POLISCOPE

The public record

STPETERSBURG (PINELLAS COUNTY) · LOCALHeld · official record pendingPartial coverage

City Council

Thursday, September 28, 2023 · Government meeting record

The 30-second read

Record incomplete

City Council

Why it matters

The official meeting record is available below. Item-level plain-language summaries are not available yet.

What happens next

The scheduled meeting date has passed. Minutes or an action agenda are not published in the records we hold.

This meeting date has passed and no official outcome record has been published yet. Nothing on this page is a decision.

Record text

No transcript is held for this meeting. Recording: Watch video

Showing the first 60,000 of 154,935 characters. The full document is at the source.

Welcome to the city of St. Petersburg City Council meeting and your elected officials our mayor Ken Welch district one hopefully Curtis. >> District 2 Council chair Randy Gabbert district 3 and not marry. His pick 4 with that kind of way. 5 and Council vice chair Debra big spenders. Gina Driscoll. John Muhammad. And district day Richie Floyd. >> Good afternoon, everyone we will call to order the Sept. 28th 2023 City Council meeting beginning with roll call play service. You're after you're married here and what air unders hear comment here Lloyd here and we will begin our meeting this afternoon with an indication that is going to be given by councilmember public Curtis and following that we will do the pledge of allegiance please all rise. >> If you join me in bow your head. Blessed is the man that does not walk with the wicked whose delight is in the law of the Lord. He is like the tree planted by water. Lord I ask your blessing today as fall begins. We ask you to continue to nurture and protect us please bless our city employees and first responders they are the lifeblood of our city that enables us all to serve all those that need it. Plus our mayor and administration continue to lead them with your bright light. Plus this Council and all who join us today. Guide our decisions through your eyes, not ours. Lord please continue to bless this great city from our businesses to our neighbors and from are most fortunate to our most needy. Please lighten the load of our residents that most need it. We especially lift up our neighborhoods and residents affected by Hurricane ideal ya bring them peace and sustain to stay in them through this difficult time. Please keep our police and firefighters safe in your care as they are on the front lines of protecting us every day. We're a city that that is diverse and beautiful. We continue to let our light shine everywhere and lead us to protect that light for all of our citizens. It is my prayer today that this body continues to put people over politics that we do not do not forget the past. But also we do not move too quickly through the present and do not overlook are abundant future. Let us be that tree that is planted by water tiong and healthy able to serve and provide shade this is the day the Lord has made. Let us rejoice and be glad Amen in. >> Donations to the flag. The United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under GOD indivisible with Liberty. >> Thank you councilmember guard us it is a beautiful invocation alright council members we have an agenda before us today we do have a couple of changes. So we are going to be moving item c-one to reports item c b 14 to reports and then adding cra item 3 so with those changes, I'll entertain a motion for approval approve on that. And we have a motion and a second team seeing no requests to speak clerk please open the machine for voting. Council members enter your votes. Saying all council members voted clerk please telling announce the vote. MADAM Chair motion to approve the agenda passes unanimously. >> ok and next we have our consent agenda. Any cards on the consent agenda. MADAM Chair, and there's no one's of okay council members and the emotion. And we have a motion and a second saying their request to speak on the consent agenda clerk please open the machine for voting. Council members in your votes. Seeing all council members voted clerk please telling announce the vote. And chair motion to approve the consent agenda passes unanimously. Ok and at this time before we move on I want to go ahead and turn it over to our city attorney, Jackie Cove large to introduce the newest member of our team. Thank you MADAM On on your consent agenda. You just confirm the appointment of Sarah Walker. She's the newest member of our team she's going to be focused on doing a lot of transactional work which mccall was very excited to And serve recently passed the bar exam so that was reason enough to to celebrate. Because of her initiative to actually started as a legal intern, I mentioned this earlier a lot of times Otter. Law students will graduate take a break after they passed the bar exam and then wait for the results are want to get started early. So she's been an intern for a few weeks and will start as an assistant city. Attorney tomorrow, we're happy to report that we appreciate your confirmation. Absolutely welcome Sarah. Thank you for joining the team and we're looking forward to working with you. Thank you would you like to say anything. >> I'm it's been a pleasure to be here. It's been wonderful working with everyone so far and I'm so excited to get snow all of you and get to help you out with anything that comes up absolutely thank you, thank you, Jackie future. All right well now we will go ahead and move into our open form clerk please read the rules. >> If you wish to address to the Council on subjects other than public hearing or judicial items listed on the agenda please sign up with the clerk. Only the individual wishing to speak MAY signed the open form she. Only city residents owners of property business owners in the city for their employees MAY speak. All issues discussed and open for must be limited to issues related to the city of St. Petersburg government. If you're speaking to an item on the agenda you MAY only speak once during the open for him or when it comes up on the agenda. In order to provide an opportunity for all citizens to address Council each individual be given 3 minutes to speak and after which the market from will be muted. If you missed or just City Council to the zoom meeting you must use the raise hand feature button in the zoom app we're interest are 9 on your phone at the time the agenda item is address. When it's your turn to speak, you'll be unmuted annex to state your name and address. At the conclusion of the comments are when you reach the 3 minute limit you'll be muted. All raise hands will be Lord after each agenda item regardless of the method of participation used normal rules apply including the 3 minute time limit on comments. The requirement that any presentation materials must be submitted in advance of the meeting and the rules of decorum we fly public comment is disrupted by violations of the rules of decorum the chairs authorized to accept public comment by alternate means including by email only and MADAM Chair we do have. Speaker in the chamber, and one Fate Mark faith please go to the podium state your name and address for the record. You have 2 minutes to address City Council. >> Well, I anybody here markieff 302nd Avenue Southeast I'm here to discuss or mention. Privatization privatization of city projects. We recently went through a situation. The city was pleading poverty. And couldn't handle the reservation, they renovations necessary the marina and we're exploring possibilities privatized my views on the matter and the local newspapers and on video. My second point is you turn it around and want to get another Millstone around our neck of this sports fan you these things never deliver. Please do the due diligence a look at the studies. They don't deliver the panacea is people don't come to Saint Pete to view our Marine it's not on their bucket list. 7 years from now we're going to be right back here. He already had to implode the arena down with the Dali is because it was a turn into a turkey. We're having a problem the white elephant with a truck that Trump now you're going to be right back here in 7 to 10 years, you'll have all moved on to bigger and better things and the taxpayers in the saddle that white elephant. Police don't get taxpayer money involved this pushing back on the private people if it's such a red hot business deal, they'll be panting to get involved. Let them raise the funds build it maintain and operate it give them some tax breaks or other incentives but do not put another Millstone around their necks and around the taxpayers next. And chairman speakers name is Bruce missing. Bruce wants to enter into the meeting space please unmute yourself state your name and address for the record and you have 2 minutes to address City Council. >> Yes, my name is Bruce gnesen away the 2.53 sunlit coat drive Northeast in Saint Pete. I want to speak to the issue of legal counsel for people facing evictions which I understand is on your agenda today. I hope very very strongly that you're going to support this. It's a very very important issue you're do if you can do this you're doing something for the renters in Saint Pete and it's been a rough time for renters and they deserve something but beyond that even it's it will be beneficial the city as a whole studies have shown again and again that whenever there's lawyers involved on both sides much less likely that eviction even occurs in the first place if something gets worked out a payment schedule gets worked out. And yeah evictions and then all the consequent problems of homelessness and cost to the city for taking care of homeless people everything else are also taken care of. So I strongly urge you all to vote in favor of this legal counsel for people facing evictions which is coming up. I'm fairly confident you will be passing those that want to thank you for doing so. Thank you. And that's the final speaker worsens one more. >> Warren Willie him. Once you into meeting space please state your name and address for the record you have to be minister addressed City Council. Hey were unwilling him 3 to 4, 5 Jackson Street North 3, 3, 7, 4, I'm here also to express my support for supplying legal counsel to those that are being In the South the it's a great step towards making it less one-sided thank you. I know speaker that. Okay we will go ahead and close it before. And at this time we're recess. The City Council will convene as the cra and take up item cra too. We are joined by economic development officer George Smith and the topic will be community law program to offer pro bono eviction and provide assistance to residents of the South St. Petersburg cra hello. Good afternoon, MADAM Chair. Council members George Smith economic and workforce development. Thank you for this opportunity to present this request to you today. City administration is requesting that the agency recommends and City Council approves the agreement with community law program to provide pro bono, legal services to South Petersburg cra residents who are facing eviction and to provide probate services to clear title to homes that MAY be in the name of deceased persons and to allocate $300,000 through the South St. Petersburg community redevelopment area tax increment financing funds. Community law program is a 5 oh one c 3 non-profit corporation that provides free civil legal services, 2 financial financially eligible residents and qualified nonprofit. Well, it is a shuns in Pinellas County. Eviction prevention program. Well, the fight too is designed to provide services to individuals that are facing eviction it is not limited to act an eviction complaint has been filed. All when the notice has been provided indicating that tenants MAY be displaced. War Tenet fears and eviction MAY be imminent due to the inability to pay. Also it is not restricted to household income. And we'll provide legal advice to the tenants. Now the service will be to negotiate a voluntary payment schedule and relocation agreements to draft an fao p dings in court represent tennis throughout formal eviction proceedings. Very important that they help to mitigate any harsh consequences. The vixens record. Additional services will be related to probate assistance. We've been able to determine that property appraiser has shown it yet 348 state property parcels and the South St. Petersburg cra services will include again pro bono legal services to clear title. Homes that MAY be in the name of the seas persons to draft fau pleadings in court. This program will restrict applicants household income to less than a 120%. Am I. So that gives you an indication of the location of the estate properties throughout the cre. The agreement with community law program stipulation following that 95,000 dolls will be yeah Mark used to hire a full-time attorney Warrick Whitman to provide eviction prevention services to tenants that reside within the boundaries of the cra an additional $5,000 will be available for court fees and costs for represented individuals. They're important to note the funding will not be use for payment of back rent or payment into the court's registry. Well probate assistance $200,000 be allocated. 2 hot her knees and staff assistance of fund existing positions to provide the probate assistance to individuals to pay court fees and costs 2 reasonable careful costs and other necessary cost to clear titles. Administrative supervisory and management reporting services we're not exceed 5% of the total Grant amount. So again we're requesting that the agency recommends and the City Council approves the agreement with community law program to provide pro bono legal services to South St. Petersburg cre residents who are facing eviction and to provide probate services to clear title to homes that MAY be in the name. A deceased person's and to allocate $300,000 through South St. Petersburg some community redevelopment area tax increment financing funds. Now we should be join to leave that MS. Kinley Rodgers. Oh yes, yes, he's here. Executive director of community law program and city attorney Brad tenant is also available to assist with any questions that you MAY have. Thank you. Thank you. MISTER Smith alright councilmember Floyd thank I first want to thank administration for both of the things covered in the resolution other crilly creative solutions to some of the problems that we're facing particularly in the area and the cra. It's great that we can make our residents lives a little You know there wasn't everything that I'd hoped for in Vick shun prevention stuff but it's a great first step in a program. That push forward tenants rights when we're limited on a lot of other legal ways I will enthusiastically be voting yes on move approval as well second. All right, let's go ahead and go to public comment. >> MADAM Chair, we have 2 speakers. The Kerry in I believe is James. Fees go to I the podium state your name and address for the record you have 2 minutes to address City Council. Nick Carey temps Street North. Yeah, I just want to speak and support of Thank you to City Council and the administration for moving it to this point this feels like a great first step in the right first step considering the highest number of evictions happen in South Saint Pete. And so often when we talk about solutions to the housing crisis we're going through a lot of those solutions are 5.10 years down the road and this is something we can do to help renters right now and so I'm I'm very much in support of this and helping people avoid the harm of evictions and I hope that you'll pass it. >> James get her for 5 one to 7th Avenue North. I'd like to thank you all for supporting this and I'd like to specifically thank you for supporting it with any income or other means test. When someone is facing eviction and they don't have representation that's the test right there. So and I hope that this could also demonstrate to landlords across the entire city that we all have to abide by the same laws. Thank you. >> Dylan Danes please go to the podium state your name and address for the record you have 2 minutes to address City Council. >> My name is Dylan Dame's I 1, 2, 0, 0, on doctor mlk junior should North unity. I wasn't here in support of these steps towards tenant protections. I think it's a really important step for us and it's something that the verge for for the past couple years. I remember a conversation that I had with us. A lady that was helping us with one of our events and she believed in the long term solutions in the fives. The 5 to 10 years solutions, but one thing that she kept going was a she needed help now shifted back and forth between hotels because of price gouging and it's something that I hold very closely to the center of the work that we do and I'm glad that we're taking a step to do some put some fires out so thank you Council. >> That was our final speaker speaker so k councilmember might marry. Thank you MADAM Chair and thank you for the presentation MISTER Smith so I. We have some big concerns about Back in FEBRUARY of this year we had and our youth and family Services meeting a report on evictions and. We found out in that meeting that there were 821 evictions in the city of St. Petersburg in 90% of them were for nonpayment of rent. He also was a breakdown of where the evictions occur. And 75% of them happened outside of the South St. Petersburg cre. The other data that was shared with us was of the average pass rent that was due was a over $3100. I have some concerns about the legality of And I want to talk I've got some questions for legal. And let me just start right because this seems to me to be against the 14th Amendment. The equal protection. Well also how to how do we we have an ordinance that helps people in a certain amount of the city and doesn't help people in other parts of the city. Sure absolutely so. Florida statute in a in a billing. The creation of cra's provides that the funding from cr series is the tax increment financing. So this is money from the people that is spent particular to this area. So in so far into the difference between general funds which would be from taxpayers across the city state statute specifically allows us to take money from tax increment financing from a certain geographic area and put it back into that geographic area. >> Does the cra allow us to expend funds for purposes like like this. Like like this this before us. Yes. So it has to be pursuant to a rcr a plan and I we've got deferred administration. But I believe the discussion was prevention of homelessness and. Encouraging home ownership being 2 points that are encouraged under our plan and so far as both of these are focused on that then it would be consistent with the general. State statute and now of course tough the for to George regarding and the specifics of our plan and if I got anything wrong. That is accurate is all right into a reduction of homelessness and creation of homeownership opportunities. And one thing that we recognize set as result of the services that will offering. It will be able to mitigate any negative consequences. A relative to any fiction. And that's one of the any fiction going on their credit report you will because if we able to Council with those who are facing evictions and get to the point that it does not show up on their credit report, then that would put them in a better position to minimize homelessness as well as the better candidate for home ownership. I mean let me go back to 2 legal. With I have in front of attorney general's opinion that addresses. A similar type situation and it's. Attorney general 3040. In the conclusion. It says however grants to entities that promote tourism and economic development as well as nonprofits providing socially benefit programs would be out outside the scope of the community redevelopment act. >> Councilmember Mike mayor I would say that we were not made of whereof this opinion and I mean more than 5 minutes ago that being said the opinion it's off is related to festivals or Street parties. So it a quick review of this it appears that that statement would be taken off contacts in light of what this opinion is related to. It also talk about. But it's with it. Is related to the expenditure of funds for festivals are Street parties from what we can say and we're happy to read this more thoroughly and report back at the end of the questions but we're not saying that that appears to be apples to apples comparison. Okay. Well. So my my concerns first are constitutional concerns and then there's this. If you get get beyond the 14th Concerns that I have this attorney opinion and then just the fact of the city taking sides in a landlord tenant relationship. That seems like it's tipping the scales and it's not fair for landlords can you can you address that MISTER 10. >> This was discussed at a committee meeting in the context of some of the new preemptions related landlord tenant so in this circumstance, our opinion would be that the provision of legal services only seeks to ensure that the law is followed so if there is not a case for example of someone, those rent and they're not able to pay it. The landlord is follow the law and there's not a defense to eviction they didn't pay the rent and really And it's some of out leave to administration explain in more detail. But part of in drafting the agreement was to make it clear that it's not just for fighting evictions in court. The reality is there's some just hard discussions to be had with people to say that we can go to court. There's no defense and the reality is from that perspective if we can help you avoid the eviction then it's better for preventing homelessness the idea being is having an eviction on your record is problematic when seeking further. Accommodations with that in mind the idea is if you can't eat if someone's followed the law there's no cause of action and our agreement with community law in no way tries to have them expand beyond that you follow the law try to help people. You know if the law is followed but not to help people where there's not a cause of action they would be have the same restrictions we have as far as not bring 5th frivolous claims and seeking to make arguments that are in bad faith and so that having done this. As an agency for a while. I believe that's why administration selected them to go forward and continue that work in the same capacity along the lines of you trying to help people just to make sure the last followed it's the last followed the help to them is not to go to court necessarily try to delay its to tell them. What the law is and what options they have and that hopefully that kind of gets it what you are we were asking. >> Well I if I'm a landlord in and I know that a tenant that he's behind on the has an attorney there I'm going to want to hire an attorney also so I put it reporting burdens on a landlord in this case. So. Potentially a yes so in so far any rental is owned by a corporation that would be required to have a landlord are required to have an attorney anyway. So if they cannot represent themselves in court. It's an organization. So it would be the only people who might be required to get an attorney would be the the landlord but they're not required to as you pointed out if the other person as attorney they might feel obligated to but only the entity would be obligated to because they can't represent themselves. Can you can you share with And that that just kind of gets to fundamental fair fairness and in my opinion and I'm thinking about the mom and mom and pop landlords that we are. Rent and they still have bills to pay they still have to pay the mortgage still to pay proper insurance. People and they're on there. On their property. Utilities as this goes on, can you talk about. Any sort of delays if somebody has an attorney and you're going to go to court would dis delay the process. And I'm going to actually step in here and then maybe assistant city attorney could add in, but I'm going to refresh our memory of the conversation that happened in committee. The majority of these cases never go to court. The attorneys actually are helping both the landlord and the tenant in most cases negotiate a longer tail for them too. Get out of the home and find other housing. So there's a lot of other outcomes besides going to court they go to court very few cases and are providing support on the front and this was something that was actually supported. By many of the landlords that we worked with as a way to help them. Have better outcomes in the end where tenants are not staying in the property drawing out the process and negotiating those outcomes in the process and again I'm going to remind you that this is something that the city funded during covid so we have a track record using the same agency in the past and. The Bay Area apartment Association actually was a part of that project and was very thankful for the work that community law program did as well as the tenants keeping them from becoming homeless. So you mention that very few cases these cases go to court. 821. Evictions and I can you give us any specific said Lake County. How many of 21 ended up. I have to go back and pull up what we presented to you at the committee level. But. I couldn't think of the cases that we worked on one at the homeless leadership alliance and maybe 3 in hundreds went to court. The the examples that were provided in your committee materials were presented directly from community law program so I have to go pull those up and look at them. >> just to follow up and my question to 2 Council. What is that your question is there something in attorney can do to delay versus right. So there's nothing an attorney could do that the individual tenant could not do. So while attorney could file a motion to determine the amount of rent if there's a dispute in that regard. The tenant can do the same thing. So obviously the lawyer being more experience in this regard is more likely to know what the options are a tenant can do do the same motion and make the same argument for the court. Councilmember Justin. Thank you. >> Regarding the prue based services we've got 2 parts here. I wish they were being brought forward is to separate agreements and that one I'm I'm very supportive of out of on The map with the the estates that are in probate the shared in the presentation. 60 of those are in my district. This is to me. This one's a no-brainer helping people to get out of their situation so that they can mean to have ownership of that family property is important and I think that that definitely aligns with the mission of the South St. Petersburg cra and the affordable homeownership program. >> I want to know, I'm a little bit more about community law program. I'm quite familiar with the organization, but. Are they they're currently doing some work with the city already right. That is correct and I think can be best if the second director answer any specific questions who is here. If you don't mind him, yeah I would just like everyone to have a brief explanation of what we're already doing with this organization. We're good. >> Afternoon everyone number 2 storm. The community while program has been working for receiving funding from the city of St. Petersburg MAY of 2021. Those funds were. Federal funds that were passed through this city of St. Petersburg we utilize those funds to assist. Tenants at risk of and as. Amy. >> We worked with the homeless leadership alliance and with other partners to. Help them negotiate settlements and 2. Work. Use utilizing mediators help mediations with both the tenant and landlord also representing on the rare occasions that there was a legal basis to. While an appearance in court. >> All right, thank you and those are that funding and all of that was more related to. The pandemic right that was it sort of grew out of that right yes grab that. So you tell us how how soon that was in a different time we had a lot of people struggling on on all ends. And I'm very grateful for the work that you started doing at that time tell me how this is tell us how this and this one is different. >> Well this is different in the sense that the tenants that we'll be able to serve. Are. Those that reside in the cra area and they don't have to a financial impact from covid. There and there's no income requirement and there is requirements for documentation that is sometimes. Posed a burden for some folks particularly with the expedited nature eviction cases. And then prior to I mean prior to the pandemic prior to receiving funding from the city. We for years we have tenants facing eviction as well as. Assist with probate matters. So. All right great, thank you so much I would say if if this looked a little bit more like I can be supportive of it I do George I do have some concerns about. The fact that we don't have any income restrictions on this. I think that when we are looking at. Giving someone a hand up. And when we're trying to. Engage with a with a nonprofit in a situation like this. I think we need to be looking at helping our most vulnerable residents. And to not have any kind of an income cap. This even if it was a 120%. I could feel more comfortable with it. But it I want to especially our South Saint peace Erie dollars with programs. I'm like this to really be targeted to the people who need it the most. Now having said that councilmember Mohnton Arie I'm just mentioned something 70 5% of the evictions in the number that was present in the committee meeting are actually. Residents of the residents that live outside of this housing so. I was I had hopes that we would come up with something that was citywide because we have renters who need help everywhere and rather than having this so nearly focus team, one part of our city but then with no income restrictions. I wonder what were the dollars look like if we weren't using Siri dollars. If we made a citywide and then had some kind of an income cap to ensure that we are truly helping people who cannot a Ford to do this on their own. And some are just go up. I think maybe quite a bit of time has passed and she will discuss this. You previously asked us to pilot this in the cra took almost a year and a negotiate that contract. So this is the pilot program you have money in your budget to do the citywide once the pilot gets off the ground. The plan is to bring the forward something that would affect the whole city. But this is something you all approved in asked us to move forward almost a year ago and it's taken us a year to negotiate that contract and get those details nailed down so the citywide program is coming but we wanted to first make good on the promise of what was. Budgeted in your Siri budget last year which included this conversation around a cra program. Well, 75% of evictions take place outside of the cra the series also a small area of the city there is a significant number the highest zip codes where there are evictions do take place in the cra which is what the intention was behind bringing forward a cra program. You will spend much more money rehousing people her evicted. 3 the programs and this was a homeless prevention strategy that was specific to the zip codes where we see the highest eviction rates. In my conversations with. Some staff and and with and some members of the community who are passionate about this. I've been. It's quite clear that I wanted to see income restrictions on this so that it's truly helping those who need it the most when I have some reservations about including. Nonpayment of rent is being acceptable unless there is some kind of. Criteria that goes with that it seems that that could leave things open maybe some it's a misuse of the funds. So I I'm not really happy about that bad. The biggest thing for me is that income requirement. I worry that especially with that in place that we're not going to be able to take this city-wide. It's it's just going to cover too many people and we saw what happened in Tampa when they tried to do some rental assistance. They ran out of money immediately. Immediately. I want us to be the city that does it right. I have too many and that to me this just doesn't help enough people and I'd rather have us. Go back in and try Improve this is that it benefits more people that's that's where I met with this right now. Thank you. Well you do understand believe that this is not rental assistance that. So the funding that we have set aside for this program is basically to provide assistance to those tenants those residents who find themselves with and could be the case in ability to make rental payments and and we want to assist them to move on to the next step without causing long-term harm. If that is possible and the intent is again too and minimize. The number of people that now or septic to homelessness because in the the credit report impact of any eviction it's one thing you know would like to really focus on because once an eviction is on the credit report, it makes extremely difficult for them to get housing in any other place. So this is assistance too and provide information to those individuals who find themselves in. In situation to him possibly have experienced before. It doesn't minimize responsibility obligation for them to pay their rent that's not what this is about it's about providing additional services and in summation that they made many did not even realize existed. And that's the focus of this what this program. That's a vice chair fix Sanders. You know as they say if you want to keep them in their place keep the magic hated. As I listen. 2 the argument against providing information. Let us remind each other that poverty happened before covid so the fact that we're actually here. >> Having a discussion about providing information to help those that otherwise would not have it. Discourages me and what our intent to help all constituents, looks like. I think legal actually clarified that. We are in our boundaries and the dollars for this comes from the tif funds that are actually accumulated by those that live in the same cre in which we're live looking to serve. I remember so many times on different topics that were not concerning certain categories that we trusted ministries we know administration would need is wrong until he gets a certain topics in certain pieces of our population. When we talk about 10 is versus landlords let's look at the balance of scale. When we talk about those relationships. I don't think that this. Prices has anything against landlords with this to help the tenets understand what the air resources and what their opportunities are. When we talk about city why we're ok with pilots on everything else and I guess my issue is how we cheer up and justice. How we pick and choose who deserves to be served. How we look ad in provide stipulations on educating and providing what is Israel by when we take those taxpayers dollars when we asked for those bows we don't ask them for the income statement and they give you 2 as we do ask them for their address. And this there in our districts. So I just wanted to interject by Saint. It is in our accountability to educate all one of our sentences and I didn't understand these dollars to be used to pave a grant. I don't understand these dollars for anyone else to benefit from the fact that community long he's been here. Serving our community for many years not to question their credibility because we're trying to serve it really was serving somewhere else we have those same questions. So I'm just going to go ahead in just put it out there, i've never seen such a struggle. To say no. Versus taking was in front of us. What is even able to us to do what it is that we want to do and you know we have our we have our pause is about certain things we do and I understand you know the legalities of it. But is is the Foster said we had this conversation and this is what we asked to bring forth. Now if we had converse and we have we have some second thoughts I wish we would have been able to work. There was out prior too but I am fully wholeheartedly going to support the fact that either we keep them in our homes in their homes today. We're going to be complaining because they add a bus stops tomorrow. They they're going to be in our way they're going to be occupying innocent eyesore on our streets. I would prefer to have people in their own homes. Home ownership is key. Land is in a gusty. So I kind of want us to just remember. This is home ownership is an American jury rather somebody is Wherever the case MAY be. Let us continue to remember why we are here and those dollars I don't think the legal would have instructed us to do anything incorrectly. I don't think I'm in a stray shun would have. I do know this some of us have a little bit more experiences with homelessness and there's a big difference in perspectives on that. So I think you MISTER Smith for your presentation. I thank you for came to speak on behalf of making sure that when it rains. It doesn't pour. but in us to provide opportunity to those that would normally not have access to that information I think is is kudos for I applied as warnings to just educate those that need that information and down again thank you for bringing this forward thank you chair. Council member Hannah what's thank you chair. And thank you for the presentation. >> Well first of all my biggest concern last time we had this conversation obviously was the issue I don't want this to be about litigation. I want this to be about. Preventing. The actions. I want to make sure this is about negotiation. And that was part of the reason we have the conversation about that pain back Grant in court registry and all that stuff because then you're into the litigation around and then you're off to the races, I'm very happy that that's not part of it. So. The fact that it's a pilot is another reason that I'm fine with this because some of the issues that were raised. In the agreement you're supposed to be some really detailed reporting correct. In terms of what the outcomes are and that's meant which is reporting that we're going to see that some point to figure out if this works or not what who's using it. Is it people all right the people that are you know 80% and mising people above 120% we will have that information to deal with. So you know the fact we talked about. The pilot cre as as as a right way to do this. Yeah that's the way I'm looking at this issue. I do want to give legal the opportunity because no attorney likes. As we've all been in court we've been given that case right before hearing. In terms of being given something to look at right before hearings I just want to give legal an opportunity to kind of cover. The attorney general. Decision I look at I think it's distinguishable in terms of what you said, but I just that now that you probably had more of an opportunity to look at it can you provide us a little bit more detail. >> Jump in the first thing I would point out is you know even how it's titled the community redevelopment promotional activities. It kind of jumps out I agree with you councilmember mountain area that it talks about something else other than festivals or Street parties. But it's all taken in contacts saying kind of won one 2nd so it's hard to tell the extent to which they're interrelated the thing that I would point out is there's really no there's nothing in here to me that indicates this is an evaluation of a program similar to the one before you today. And the only phrase in here is the one that you mention providing socially beneficial programs. But it's taken in contacts with promoting tourism and economic development. So I don't see we don't see any other opinions that reference this socially beneficial programs or any other reference to this opinion at so there just doesn't seem enough here based on the research that has previously been done by our office. There doesn't appear to be enough yurt to change our opinion that a program like this is within the scope that okay so. And in terms of the cre. >> Program and the community redevelopment plan how is it was set up and with the Bulls part of that program I just want to make clear. It's your opinion that this fits within the goals of the summary program has written legally. Yes, okay, ok well, thank you that's all my questions. All right it's been a lively to say the least I mean I remember very clearly the committee conversation that we had a a year ago now I remember there being some concern but I don't remember this level but concerns so to be honest. I'm a little surprised that we're having this link they have a conversation today. I see here that some of the concerns that were dressed in that committee you did clearly address in the negotiation with our community law program partner I remember when you know this program was created during the funding that we had at the federal level and that came through a lot of collaboration a lot of cooperation with stakeholders overwhelming support at that point in time and now here we are talking about the cra the area of the greatest need in our city and now we're having all of this concern. So quite frankly, I'm a little disappointed that we're having this much concern but it is my hopes that it will pass today I completely support this program I support it as a pilot. I look forward to us having continued conversation about what it looks like going forward for a citywide program because it does need to be citywide. When we talk about means testing for me. The means testing has been done by doing it in the cra with a pilot program because when I go and look at census data for the cra. And these are rough numbers. So don't quote me on them, there's a great Web site that I use a lot for census data since this reporter dot org. And it looks to me like about the income in those zip codes is about $31,000 that right there is a means test as far as I'm concerned. 20% of people in this cra live below the poverty line. 38% of children live below the poverty line. 14% of seniors live below the poverty line that is the means testing. So. And let's just be honest. I mean we're talking about only a 3rd of the funding even going to that particular portion of the program. Now we talk about the other two-thirds of the 200,000 that to me is an issue that we have struggled with for a very long time. We have talked about generational home ownership and the challenges around that in specifically the cra for years and now we have a way to help people be able to get out from underneath that and maintain homeownership which is also a critical part of the affordable housing work that we do. >> So. I'm a little baffled by. The concerns that are being brought up today that I haven't really heard as much cry for in the past I asked. I'm hopeful that we can move this forward and that we can utilize this pilot program to make a citywide program even better. But I'm very happy with the work that staff has done and very happy for the partnership that we have with the community law program and really you know MISTER Rogers I thank you for your partnership and your continued advocacy for people and just hope that we can continue to move forward and doing what's right for the residents that we serve. So thank you. I councilmember might marry. Thank you MADAM Chair. So. >> Jackie I did want to circle back to this attorney general opinion and you have that in in front of you. On the on the first page we're in the paragraph where it says in sum. The sec second sentence there Sardi's a council member. It's the so on the first page. There's a a summation says in sum and then the second sentence there. I just don't understand. How you can make the conclusion that this. Carries out the purposes of the community redevelopment act. So maybe I'll jump in. >> Generally the cra going back to the foundation people in place based help and this circumstance. It is people base help and this goes to some of the original things that were done in the cra was job assistance and training this fits into that category as far as the you know what under the cra plan and under the cre statute is being done that being said the kind of the core crux of our discussion regarding this phrase is job promotion I think could be obviously considered equally a socially beneficial program. So in that context some things we know have been approved for cre uses to promote people end up being that you fit into what Austin's we not a specifically defined phrase and the attorney general pin. According according we were looking at the context of the entire attorney general compete opinion the ones that referenced and you know other approved programs for the cra and pointing to well this is what category it fits in generally its broad interpretation is what we're allowed to do in cra and deferring to the legislative act and there have been significant changes since his opinion was given there have court cases new cra programs and the combination of all that leads us to believe that the phrase socially beneficial program is not meant to be all encompassing. All right, I'll leave it there, thank you. And we have a motion second. Clerk please a punishing for voting. Council members in your votes. Seeing all council members voted quickly stallion announce the vote. MADAM Chair motion to approve agenda item cra to pass a 62 we councilmembers Driscoll and want to marry voting no council members thick Sanders Floyd gabbard guard is Mohammed voting. Yes. Move on now to item c or e 3 in our local agreement between the city and community Redevelopment agency MISTER Smith, this is your item as well I believe. >> Haha no it's not all right. Thank Hello how are you Welcome. Before you today and the county issue finance reporting issue. As you know we have this city and the cra the account as you know there are certain items that are funded from the cra but executed through the city such as using silly city employees services such accounting and finance reporting perspective we have to put them in the right place. Right now as you probably know as we would meet present the city's financial statements, we present 2 different ones, the cities and then we have a separately issued cra audit that is a relatively new requirement. You know from this from a recent changes in the state statute for the cra so as part of that separate audit, there are certain items that we have to include in that report. If we don't have an inner local agreement in place that tells us how we allocate that appropriately. For pensions does the cra have to report the city's pension plans. So this agreement spells out those accounting details. Okay, so. I'm here and can ask any questions but what we're trying to do is make sure all of this is paper correctly in accordance with state regulations gaz these etcetera so. Again this is a I get a matter that is. >> All 5, 2, Second. All right, we have a motion a second seeing their request to speak clerk Lisa punishing preventing. Council members any of us. They all council members a vote a clerk please telling announce the vote. Motion to approve agenda item cra 3 passes unanimously. >> All right, thank you thank you so much. We will now adjourned as the cra and reconvene the City Council and item f one. Entertain a motion for approval saying all right. We have a motion a second seeing no further request to speak clerk please a punishing for voting. Council members in your vote saying all council members a vote a clerk please tell me announce the vote. Motion to approve agenda item f one passes 62 week council members Driscoll an mot much in their voting know councilmember speak Sanders Floyd Gabbert guard is Hannah was Mohammed voting. Yes. All right, we will now go to item that was pulled from consent, it is now item f 3 our inner local agreement between the city and community redevelopment which we just did All right, we have a motion and a second clerk please open machine for voting. Council members in your boat seeing all council members a vote a clerk please tell ya Nance the vote. Want you to approve agenda an ef 3 passes unanimously. All right in our next report item is also are pulled from a consent and it is now f 2 which is a license agreement between the city and h m s ferries and we're joined by transportation and parking management director, Evan Murray. Good afternoon Council. Thank you for the opportunity to bring this to you today. I will go ahead and use the opportunity to go over the council but also provide an update. Since been a couple of weeks and so have been submitted. Item before you is the resolution to approve a license agreement between hms ferries and the city of St. Petersburg to use one of 2 locations. In Saint Pete port war the North yeah base and operate the cross Bay ferry service for the next 2 seasons. As a reminder about to enter the 3rd. Year of a four-year agreement to provide these services. This year service increases the length of the season from 8 months to 9 with service to continue through JUNE of next summer. The final year of the existing agreement requires year-round service from OCTOBER of 2024 through SEPTEMBER of 2025 and since a national Ferry season began in NOVEMBER of 36. And we have seen steadily increasing ridership with the exception of during the height of the covid pandemic we've also seen the public subsidy. The ferry decrease from an initial cost of $350,000 for 6 months of service to this year city contribution of 202,500 for 9 months of service. The reason city Council is being asked to pervert approved to license agreements, he's an order that we have the operational flexibility to either the port or the Basin. So currently we do not hold a valid permit from the Army Corps of Engineers that meets the needs of the ferry. Specifically we were recently notified that there's a strict limit a 3 trips per day. This legacy languages from initial permit application made in 36. We're not allowed to offset those Too at trips on the weekend and operate your weekday trips. This requirement operating from the North face and I would mean that on an average weekend. They're be hundreds of passengers wishing to make the trip. The normally turned away to bit due to being sold out. Additionally the core advised that due to changes in federal requirements of crude in the last year. The longest extension the permit that they that they could provide as 6 months and the season is 9. Since the final decision are rendered by the court earlier this month. Staff has been working diligently on a new permit. That we will submit a plan to summit next week. And if that permits this would allow North Basin for up to 3 more years so we don't have the anywhere in tools. It's possible. It's a new permit would be ready before the end of this season, but conservative we're probably looking at finishing out the season at the port and then moving to the north face and next year. So while the port location has disadvantages of not to the disadvantage of not being a cent relocated, there's a North face and it does have certain attributes similar to we're even better than the North Bay, some locations. For example of that identified a surface parking lot. Immediately adjacent to the dock and location. This large enough to fit most or all the vehicles that people drive downtown and the parking well for this parking for free and no daily time on that. That will result in reduced parking demand. The downtown core including the pier lots which are often we do reach capacity on we. Or flow parking opportunities exist along 8 Avenue Southeast. The closest liver trolley stop to the port is an approximately 1000 foot walk. And that stops them from the hangar restaurant. By contrast the walk from the north based on location to the loop or stop near the pier entrance is also a 1000 feet. Unfortunately summer last year. The vessels been there's large seas and the Atlantic. It's been I unable to make the trip down to Boston and should be arriving by now but it is not. So it's a mess is monitoring the weather and hopes that the vessel will be able to arrive next week and then commit service shortly thereafter. So as soon as we have a start date confirmed. There's a media alert ready to go out from the city's marketing team. Hms marketing team. We'll let everybody know when the first day of service is make sure but knows where it operates from. A final note is that in the budget being considered by City Council tonight. There's $250,000 included for designing a permanent commercial dock that would accommodate the ferry and other vessels down time. We still need to identify construction funding excuse me. But the administration is committed identifying a permanent solution for the ferry dock that would be centrally located and not involve using temporary ducks with that will be happy to answer any questions and request approval. Alright council member driskell. Thank you. Thank you for that I update we've been through quite a lot recent times trying to get this figured out and I really appreciate all the work that that you and others have done to get us here. I'm an imperfect fix that a fix nonetheless. We always knew that the temporary permit 4. The North Basin was just that it was temporary and we finally got called on it. It was temporary because the permanent Ferry dock was supposed to be part of the new pier. The new pier was constructed without that. And so then be began. My request and and many conversations about getting that bill. You mentioned this we're working on it now where where are we in how many years do you think we're going to have to use the port. >> Where the North yacht Basin or some other temporary spot until we've got something permanent so we don't have to worry about this anymore. So the funding that would be approved tonight what is likely sufficient to complete design on the permanent location that process takes about a year and funding we need to be identified for construction probably in the following year's budget. Either through city funds or other funds. I mean construction could take one or 2 years so we're probably looking at 2 to 3 years from now would An estimate of when we could have the. >> And you guys are working and getting the permit ring new on getting so that we can get back to them in the North Basin. We're asking for a 3 year permit in the past. They were they would only issue we're at a time. Haven't said yes or no to the longer term. You feel like 3 years will be sufficient. Yeah, okay. >> In the meantime we have to use that we're going to use the port, I'm glad we have something. I want everyone to know that you did have conversations with the folks who operate the looper Charlie to try to get it stop either moved or added right at that spot just too make it as easy as possible. That was declined. And I'm not happy about it. We should be better partners than that. And I'm seeing that collectively. At least we have one that's nearby. So the only thing remaining is my crewmen bility are you going to have scooters e-bikes nearby. So that folks who want to use that can how about the ferry and onto and a bike or a scooter. Absolutely yes. And you do you have the spot picked out I mean since the ferries late getting here we've got time to really make this as welcoming as possible. Because it is less than ideal. I I want to dress and. And do everything that we can have it ready not still be getting things in place. When he gets here. >> They will be there the day that the vessel operates and we know where the pedestrians will exit the port and we will put it in a place that they can't MISS It. >> I'm going to get with you as a follow-up hopefully we'll get this passed and then we can. Make sure that this is good lead. Our city has been has been. Supportive of this Ferry. You know since day one and it's not easy to get. 2 cities and 2 counties to all agree on something now we're down to 3 of those pitching in. But we're still at it and I just appreciate your perseverance and that of the administration to keep this going because we know that this type of waterborne transportation is it incredibly important to the future of the whole region really. I appreciate all that you've done. I look forward to voting for this. Thank you. Council member Mary thank you MADAM Chair, thank you for the. >> This this is important to to all of us. Especially to the residents of St. Petersburg coming we take great pride in our you know we're from and we want that too always look good in that the temporary dock that we've had for the ferry. It's just that it's been a temporary dock that it's just been going on for for a long time. And. We need just to set a higher standard and paper something on the on the waterfront so I look forward to getting this study done and then building a permanent for the ferry and any any other ships we MAY be bringing to a St. Petersburg. Can you talk about that so that the Doc is going to be removed can you talk about defense and the chaos that's that's out there what's going to be the status of that the payment booth will move to the port. So that won't be there anymore. The fencing is there for a couple reasons one is that Utilities and the fencing either needs to stay or be replaced with something else. Okay. But hasn't been determined yet, but we we won't be able. We don't want to remove some of the things that are there that we need like the water and electric. That makes sense I I just want to again that that was a temporary. Yeah, I'm I'm I want to just like I said before set a high bar for for anything on our. Our waterfront. So let me just understand this we're waiting on the Corps of Engineers to make a decision. The ferries. We're probably going to be operating out of the port 4. This this season when but they MAY be coming back to the north yacht Basin. For the next 2 seasons. Except for they would not issue a renewal. So we have to submit a brand new application that we're planning on submitting next week. So we're partnered with the Hillsborough County. Yes Hillsborough is the lead agency and we have a partnership. Remember Tampa Hillsborough in Saint Pete and then we have a separate agreement with Pinellas County where there still providing funding but not at some of those other partners, okay is there any sort do they have any say on where we operate that the peer out of is that in the agreement. The agreement is far from their parents that puts the onus on hms to work with the city's 2. A secure location. So what we're doing is consistent with the the agreement we've had meetings with all the partners in the last couple months and everybody knows what's happening. Okay all right very good. Thank you for the afternoon. >> Before we vote Evan, I just want to thank you. Were you know just always continuing to push be creative stay on top of our ferry service because it has not been easy by any means. The number of conversations that we've had over the years about how we can you know continue to make sure that we have ferry service. I can't probably couldn't even count them if I had to so I just want to thank you personally because it is such an important I had the privilege of serving for a very long time on the waterborne Transportation committee with forward Pinellas and having me where this work a community surrounded by water. So not to have. Waterborne transportation as part of our multi-modal system really would be a travesty and so I'm so glad that we continue to persevere had a lot of obstacles in the way. Still a few more obstacles before we have that permanent year-round but we're almost there. And so I'm just I'm such a fan of the ferry for so many there's such a vision for what it can be and what it should be and just thank you. Thank you for the residents that enjoy it and just thank you for me personally. All right we have a motion second. Seeing no further request to speak clerk please a punishing for voting. Council members and your votes. Saying all council members voted clerk please tell him not to vote. MADAM Chair motion to approve agenda item f 2 passes unanimously. All right very good. Thank you MISTER Murray. All right and we will now go to our new business item item g one councilmember point. >> Thank you I

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
AgendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Agenda packetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Action agendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
MinutesNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Transcript or captionsNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Recording and media

Coverage and corrections

Records considered

  • City Council — Closed Captions

Not claimed by this page

  • Verified meeting decisions with item-specific public-source evidence
  • Item-level plain-language summaries are not available; this page does not infer individual agenda items.
  • Item-linked, attributed deliberation
  • A source-grounded next meeting date
  • A plain-English overview is not available.
  • Official outcomes have not been published.
  • A transcript is not available.
  • Speakers have not been reliably matched to public profiles.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.
  • An individual roll-call roster is not available.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: 5314e15f69ed94b9a39aeeaa74f5919a. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record