POLISCOPE

The public record

ST. LUCIE COUNTY · LOCALDecisions and attributed speech publishedPartial coverage

BOCC Informal Meeting

Tuesday, January 14, 2025 · Government meeting record

The 30-second read

Recorded outcome

The St. Lucie County Board of County Commissioners discussed a potential pilot program to adjust meeting start times to avoid late-night sessions and reviewed a draft ordinance to restructure the Planning and Zoning Commission. No final decisions were made on either item during this informal session.

Why it matters

Residents may see changes to when public hearings are held and how development projects are reviewed if the Board adopts these proposed scheduling and structural reforms.

What happens next

No later meeting or follow-up date is stated in the reviewed record.

Official minutes publish outcomes and identify speakers and the topics they addressed.

People and votes

Commissioner Commissioner Leet

2 statements

  1. Statement

    Commented on the importance of strategic appointments to the Planning and Zoning.

    Official record
  2. Statement

    Commented on traffic, taxes, and roads being a top priority, and agreed with the.

    Official record

What people said

Attributed speechA separate authority lane. Speech is evidence of what a person said, never of what the board decided.
  • The official minutes identify speakers and topics, but summarize rather than quote their exact words.

Record text

No recording or transcript is held for this meeting.

BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS ST. LUCIE COUNTY, FLORIDA Informal Meeting January 14, 2025 Convened: 9:00 AM Adjourned: 11:42 AM 1. CALL TO ORDER - JAMIE FOWLER, CHAIR BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS The meeting was called to order at 9:00 AM by Chair Jamie Fowler, District No. 4. Present Commissioner Jamie Fowler District 4, Commissioner Larry Leet District 2, Commissioner James Clasby District 1, Commissioner Erin Lowry District 3, Commissioner Cathy Townsend District 5 Also Present Dan McIntyre, County Attorney George Landry, County Administrator Mayte Santamaria, Deputy County Administrator Jason Davis, Deputy County Administrator Benjamin Balcer, Planning & Development Services Director Monica Graziani, Building & Code Regulation Manager Mayte Santamaria, Deputy County Administrator Jennifer Hill, OMB & Budget Director Patrick Dayan, Public Works Director Katrina Slay, Executive Aide to County Administration/Agenda Coordinator Sydney Halleran, Agenda Coordinator Vera Smith, Deputy Clerk Recording Secretary 2. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE 3. DISCUSSION ITEMS The order of the agenda items has been modified. A. Pilot Program for Adjusted Board of County Commissioners Scheduled Meeting Time George Landry, County Administrator, presented to the Board a proposed Pilot Program for adjusting the Board of County Commissioners meeting times to better accommodate public feedback and engagement and in alignment with the Strategic Plan objective of Community Trust. The intent is not to avoid night meetings but to address feedback regarding meetings going past 11 pm, midnight, or 1 am. The current meeting schedule includes the first Tuesday at 6 pm, the second Tuesday at 9 am, and the third Tuesday at 9 am. Most public interest items are discussed on the first Tuesday, leading to a long agenda. The second and third Tuesday meetings mainly cover routine business with less public input. The goal is to make

BOCC Informal Meeting Tuesday, January 14, 2025 9:00 AM 2 | P a g e meetings more efficient and accessible to the public. Staff suggested a 6-month pilot program to gauge feedback from residents while implementing changes. The first and third Tuesday meetings would start at 2 pm, with the agenda rearranged to place public hearings last. The regular items would be set in front of public hearings to avoid meetings running into the evening. If the agenda is lengthy, the Board could consider recessing at 5 pm for a break and resuming at 6 pm for another public comment period. The Board could choose to keep certain public hearings on the first Tuesday at 6 pm based on residents’ feedback. Special meetings could be set up for specific items, ensuring transparency and public awareness. The informal meeting at 9 am on the second Tuesday could be moved to the third Tuesday to allow more time for agenda preparation. During the pilot program, feedback from residents and the Board would be gathered to decide on future changes. Staff suggested another option to start the first Tuesday meeting at 3 pm, with the agenda rearranged similarly to the 2 pm proposal. The third Tuesday meeting would remain at 9 am, and the second Tuesday would remain as is. A third option was suggested to limit meetings to 12 per year, avoiding late-night sessions, but this would reduce the number of public opportunities. The feedback from residents has been positive regarding the current late afternoon and evening meeting times. The goal is to avoid scheduling meetings at times that are inconvenient for the public. Staff recommended approval of the 6-month pilot program starting at the first meeting in February, with the understanding that the program can be terminated and the meeting schedule adjusted further or returned to the original schedule at any time based on feedback from the community. Chair Fowler expressed concern regarding the unfairness of late-night meetings for both Board members and staff, suggesting a more equitable process. She mentioned moving meetings up would force people to take time off work, which could negatively impact their jobs and businesses. She highlighted the importance of serving the public and ensuring that meetings are accessible to all residents. Commissioner Leet advised he is in favor of the start time of 3 pm for meetings, and the pilot program, but his main goal is to increase public input and make it easier for them to attend the meetings without taking time off of work. Commissioner Clasby expressed his concern regarding the time duration of night meetings and suggested having a hard end time of 11 pm for meetings, even if it means resuming the next day. Commissioner Townsend commented on the meeting times and mentioned that many people affected by projects are not self-employed and have limited flexibility in their schedules, and the importance of advertising meetings accurately to avoid confusion. She suggested splitting public hearings across multiple meetings to avoid overloading any single meeting. Also, suggested having special meetings for controversial items to keep regular meetings manageable and considering a Wednesday meeting for additional public hearings. Commissioner Lowry suggested a compromise of starting meetings at 5 pm instead of 6 pm. The Board and staff discussed splitting public hearings across multiple meetings and ensuring adequate notice for public participation. They also discussed the importance of not rushing through items and the need for better scheduling to accommodate long meetings, flexibility in scheduling, public convenience,

BOCC Informal Meeting Tuesday, January 14, 2025 9:00 AM 3 | P a g e meeting start times, length of staff presentation, Planning & Zoning meetings, Board preparation before meetings, public comment, and a backup plan for continuing discussions on the next day if necessary. Mayte Santamaria, the Deputy County Administrator, informed the Board that meeting notices need to be advertised at least 10 to 15 days in advance. If the Wednesday after the first Tuesday meeting is considered it could be included in the notification that the Tuesday meeting is expected to end by 11 pm. However, if all agenda items have not been addressed by that time, the meeting may continue until Wednesday. Mr. Landry suggested that staff could schedule the Wednesday meeting at 6 PM for the first Tuesday of the month. This time could be added to the Board's schedule as well. Constituents could be informed promptly during the Tuesday meeting. This item was for discussion only no consensus was made. C. Planning and Zoning Commission Membership Composition Mayte Santamaria, the Deputy County Administrator, presented to the Board a draft ordinance that proposes changes to the Planning and Zoning Board. The Board has expressed an interest in more involvement earlier in the development review process. The Board of County Commissioners could designate itself as the local planning agency, as provided in Florida statute section 163.3174. The current Planning and Zoning Board serves as the local planning agency. It consists of a seven-member citizen- appointed Board with no specific eligibility criteria, including one School Board District Member as an ex officio member, as required by statute. The proposed drafted ordinance incorporates the Board of County Commissioners to sit as the five members of the Planning and Zoning Board with two at-large appointments and continue to have one School Board District Member as an ex officio member, as required by statute. In October 2023, under the direction of the previous Board the Planning and Zoning Board was reduced from nine appointed members to seven appointed members. If the Board consisted of seven members the majority would be four members which may cause a tie. In October 2023, a five- member quorum requirement was discussed. Also, the proposed changes consider expertise and knowledge in the development realm considered for the two at-large appointees. The proposed changes aim to allow the Board to be more involved in the development process earlier, allowing an opportunity to guide both staff and the development community. Staff requested the BOCC provide directions on processing Land Development Code amendments to adjust the Planning and Zoning Commission membership. Commissioner Clasby commented that he is opposed to the amendment, the process takes citizens out of the process of being part of the Planning and Zoning Commission. He discussed viewing the Planning and Zoning meetings online and the preparation he does before meetings. He also mentioned the benefits of a citizen-led government. Chair Fowler mentioned the disconnect in the process with single-family homes to ensure an equitable process for all stakeholders, the importance of community input, and the value of appointing passionate individuals to the Board.

BOCC Informal Meeting Tuesday, January 14, 2025 9:00 AM 4 | P a g e Commissioner Lowry commented on the benefits of appointing a community member to the Planning and Zoning Board and the value of community and public involvement. She advised the current system works well. Commissioner Leet commented on the importance of strategic appointments to the Planning and Zoning Commission, and the need to monitor all appointees to ensure they align with the Board's goals and values. He likes the idea of having the Board involved from the very beginning. Commissioner Townsend commented and advised she disagreed with the changes and the importance of not using the Planning and Zoning Commission for political agendas. She also commented on the enforcement of the two-term limit for committee members. She also mentioned the current system works well and does not need to change. The Board and staff discussed the terms and limits of Planning and Zoning members, and communication with the members to ensure alignment with their goals. After discussion, the Board reached a consensus to maintain the Planning and Zoning Commission as it is. B. Code Enforcement Discussion Monica Graziani, Building & Code Regulation Manager, and Benjamin Balcer, Planning & Development Services Director, presented this item to the Board to discuss Code Enforcement’s current standards, practices, and the process of violations leading to liens on the property. The program is governed by Chapter 162, of the Florida statutes, and the County code of ordinances. The division's goal of compliance is to promote public safety and the welfare of the citizens and the environment of the County. The division is a response-based program, which operates based on citizen complaints and has an 85% compliance rate on code cases annually. The division currently employs four full-time code officers, two vacancies, two full- time contractor licensing investigators, two office assistants, and one code supervisor. The short-staffed division is actively recruiting to fill the two code officer positions. All officers and licensing investigators can obtain certifications through the Florida Association of Code Enforcement (F.A.C.E.). In 2020, the division was the first to adopt performance metrics to monitor their services. The key metrics include the time to turn around a case and the number of cases handled by code officers. Four officers are covering the entire unincorporated County. Typical violations include overgrowth, trash, debris, abandoned vehicles, work without permits, operating a business without zoning compliance, outdoor storage, and vegetation removal without a permit. The largest number of violations last year were caused by building without a permit, with 356 cases. The division uses a response-based approach to address a wide range of concerns from citizens. Complaints may be received by email, phone call, or through the county webpage. A new law implemented in 2021 requires complainants to provide their name and address, which can cause fear of retaliation. Anonymous complaints can be accepted if there is an imminent threat to the environment, such as a failed sewage system or an unsecured swimming pool. The division has the authority to secure and place costs on abandoned properties if the owner does not address the issue. In the code compliance activity for the last year there were over 2,200 cases and on 13% made it to the Code Board. The inspection process advised that inspections are typically windshield inspections from the road, officers cannot enter the property without permission and cannot go down private roads. The division sweeps entire streets to avoid accusations of selective enforcement. Violation notices are typically given for 14 days, with extensions possible if the owner requests them, and can be up to 30 days with 60 days at the most. The process from the initial notice to the Board can take 90 to 120 days, and failure to abate a

BOCC Informal Meeting Tuesday, January 14, 2025 9:00 AM 5 | P a g e violation can result in a fines hearing. The Code Enforcement Board (CEB) is governed by Chapter 162, of the Florida statutes and consists of seven volunteer citizens appointed by the BOCC with three-year terms, the at-large appointments are limited to two terms and cannot serve more than six. The members are a mix of professionals such as architects, engineers, contractors, subcontractors, and realtors. The Board meets the first Wednesday of each month at 9:00 am lasting up to 5 hours. The Board has the authority to determine if a violation exists, levy and reduce fines, and often allow extensions with 64% of cases being kicked down the road. Failure to abate a violation can result in a daily fine ($250/$500 for repeat violations), and failure to correct the violation leads to a lien on the property for 20 years, capped at $5,000 for residential, and $10,000 for commercial. Severe violations can be higher at the direction of the Boards direction. If the violation is abated, the applicant may request the fine be reduced by up to 75% at the monthly Code Board meeting. Another option for reduction is the lien amnesty program which started in 2017 and offers a 90% reduction if the property owner complies. Staff sends a notice to every property owner with an outstanding lien, notifying them of the upcoming program offered annually from April 1 st through July. There have been 270 participants and $185,000 in collected liens. The division also conducts neighborhood sweeps, solid waste coordination, and a sea turtle program, with a new dashboard for tracking sea turtle nesting data. The division also handles the collection of outstanding liens and abandoned property issues. The sea turtle program runs from March through November, with surveys and beach monitoring for nesting. The division is requesting the Board to consider converting to a proactive approach, using a special magistrate to hear code enforcement violations, and the consideration of increasing daily fines and maximum fines for particularly non-residential properties. Staff requested direction and input on current and recommended operational procedures of the County's Code Enforcement Division. Commissioner Townsend stated that she is not interested in making any changes. She is open to allowing commercial items to go before the magistrate and not the Code Board while keeping residential with the Code Board. Commissioner Clasby stated that he agreed with Commissioner Townsend and highlighted the importance of citizen involvement and the fairness of notifying individuals about foreclosures. He commented on the appointment of Board members, and the comparison of daily fines with surrounding counties. He expressed concern regarding the difficulty of verifying the authenticity of anonymous complaints, the potential for misuse, and the effectiveness of the "no anonymous" policy. Commissioner Leet expressed concern regarding anonymous complaints, suggesting they are often retaliatory in helping those in need, the issue of repeat violators, and the need for a more proactive approach to enforcement. Commissioner Lowry expressed concern regarding fines for commercial businesses for major violations. Chair Fowler stated she supports the idea of a special magistrate for commercial code enforcement and mentioned the need for leniency towards residents. She expressed concern about property violations being passed on to new owners and the need for consistent enforcement.

BOCC Informal Meeting Tuesday, January 14, 2025 9:00 AM 6 | P a g e Commissioner Clasby expressed concerns about moving away from citizen involvement in code enforcement and the potential for administrative overreach. Commissioner Townsend mentioned a property cannot be sold to another owner unless liens/fines are removed and approved by Code enforcement for a clear title. All property must be in compliance before being sold legally. Ms. Graziani, agreed with Commissioner Townsend and clarified if a lien has been filed in the public record and the property has been sold it is tagged onto that property and would need to be settled before the sale. However, if they are going through the enforcement process the fine/lien has not been recorded into the public record but the Board may have found them in violation. The property could transfer ownership in that time frame and there is no lien yet with the violation and the process starts again and the notice will go to the new owner. The new owner would be stuck with the violation and getting it abated. The Board and staff discussed the mechanisms for handling anonymous complaints, challenges of ensuring compliance, limitations for repeat violators, the impact of anonymous complaints on property values, separating commercial and residential code enforcement, changes to the policy, consistent enforcement, maximum fines, and the process of handling property liens. Upon completion of the discussion, a consensus was made to continue researching surrounding areas, the best approach to code enforcement and bring the item back for discussion. Commissioner Clasby mentioned his willingness to volunteer as an auxiliary code enforcement officer if necessary. D. Visioning and FY 26 Budget Priorities - CONTINUED FROM 12/10/24 INFORMAL MEETING George Landry, the County Administrator, presented an updated discussion to the Board regarding the components of strategic planning and budgeting. The initial strategic plan was established during 2018- 2019, starting with five goals that were later expanded to six. The Board engaged a third-party strategic planning specialist to develop a framework for setting priorities. A comprehensive public survey was conducted to gather input on community needs and preferences. Multiple workshops were held to refine the goals and priorities, involving both staff and the public. The strategic plan includes six main goals: Fostering Community Trust, Resilient Infrastructure, Thriving Community, Advance Opportunity, Health & Safety, and Environmental Stewardship. The current priorities include Workforce/Affordable Housing, Air & Seaport Development, Infrastructure (Water, Sewer, Stormwater), Natural Environment, Balancing Impacts of Development, Economic Development, Community Engagement & Messaging, County Government Campus/Assessment, Medical Examiner’s Office and Water Quality. The Board previously discussed refining some of the priorities, particularly in the areas of Roads and other Infrastructure, and adjusting the priorities based on their current needs. The budget cycle is about to begin, with capital priorities starting soon and operational budget discussions scheduled for March. The final budget for FY 25-26 will be presented in July, incorporating the discussed priorities. The budget priorities are based on community input from a recent survey, with Affordable Housing being the top community concern. Staff suggested the Board consider any additional priorities or adjustments to the titles of existing priorities as they move forward with the budget process. The Board requested that the discussion be revisited for further consideration.

BOCC Informal Meeting Tuesday, January 14, 2025 9:00 AM 7 | P a g e Chair Fowler commented on her research of other municipalities' priorities. She mentioned it may not make sense to have the County Government Campus, and the Medical Examiner’s Office, listed separately but they are still priorities. She agrees they should be taken off and listed under Infrastructure and Facilities. She expressed the need to get the Medical Examiner’s office completed and the need for the Government Campus to consolidate offices. She suggested adding technology as a theme across all strategic plans and needs to be listed. Also, a need to update community surveys to reflect current priorities, with a focus on Parks and Recreation. She also suggested adding Roads to the priorities list. Commissioner Clasby commented that the surveys are not a good idea, but public input is important. He mentioned the need to include growth management and roads to the priorities and the need for clear Board decisions on high-level priorities. He expressed the need for increased roadway resurfacing, currently at 13 miles per year, and suggested a target of 50 miles per year, the need for a neighborhood resurfacing program, and revisiting franchise fees to ensure adequate road maintenance. Commissioner Townsend commented and advised Infrastructure includes water, sewer, and stormwater. She mentioned the Medical Examiner office falls under all four counties (Martin, Okeechobee, Indian River, St. Lucie) and is funded by each, so it should be a standalone item. She advised Infrastructure should remain as is and facilities should be a stand-alone item. She suggests reactivating the Airport Authority Board to provide oversight and engage the community and expressed the need for a Humane Society Board to ensure resident involvement and oversight. Commissioner Leet commented on traffic, taxes, and roads being a top priority, and agreed with the need for Boards to provide a broader perspective and engage the community. He also mentioned the need for additional tax revenue, entertainment, growth, and a visionary approach that includes both short-term and long-term goals. Commissioner Lowry commented on the strategic priorities and changes over the years. She also mentioned the need for different ways to generate revenue. Chair Fowler suggested adding Roads to the priorities list. She also mentioned keeping the Medical Examiner's office a stand-alone priority and including the Government Campus with Facilities. She mentioned the Boards involvement in the budget process. Commissioner Clasby clarified his mention of roads as a priority. He is not suggesting maintaining the current budget and adding more funds for roads. His suggestion is to create a flat budget and reprioritize existing funds for Public Works, and Road & Bridge for roads. He also suggested exploring other revenue generation methods, such as negotiating contracts and utilizing franchise fees. Jennifer Hill, OMB Director, commented and explained the internal process of department budget submissions, audits, and reviews, leading to workshops with the Board for final decisions. She mentioned the workshops in July involve detailed discussions with departments and the Board to finalize the budget based on revenue streams and priorities. She advised the strategic plan is designed as a 20-year plan with long-term goals, while the objectives, priorities, and action items are adjusted yearly.

BOCC Informal Meeting Tuesday, January 14, 2025 9:00 AM 8 | P a g e Patrick Dayan, Public Works Director, updated the Board on the pavement management plan, which will be presented to the Board in an informal meeting in March or April, focusing on data-driven analysis and strategic planning for road maintenance. The Board and staff discussed public surveys, reorganizing the priorities, roads, infrastructure maintenance, the quality of County roads, stormwater management, rearrangement of the budget process, legislative authority, design of the strategic plan/priorities, growth, additional revenue/tax revenue, and visionary approach that includes both short-term and long-term goals. The implementation of deep restrictions on the sale of facilities to protect historic downtown Fort Pierce. Also, the possibility of having a separate advisory board or committee focusing on identifying and evaluating revenue generation opportunities for the County. Mayte Santamaria, Deputy County Administrator summarized the priorities based on the Board's discussion with Infrastructure including Roads within its category, rather than the County Government Campus Assessment of the possibility of changing to Facilities and Operational Efficiency and it falls under that category, maintaining Medical Examiner, potentially changing Balancing Impacts of Development to Growth Management & Balancing Impacts, Natural Environment, Airport & Seaport Development, Economic Development & Monitoring, a new category of Fiscal Responsibility & Revenue Generation, Community Engagement & Messaging, Water Quality & Stewardship, and Affordable Housing & Workforce Housing. This item will be brought back to the Board. 4. ADJOURNMENT With no other information to be brought for consideration before the Board, the meeting was adjourned at 11:42 AM. Please note: Final minutes are recorded in the official minute books filed with the Clerk of the Circuit Court and Comptroller, which are available for inspection upon request.

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
AgendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Agenda packetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Action agendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Transcript or captionsNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Coverage and corrections

Records considered

  • BOCC Informal Meeting (2025-01-14)

Not claimed by this page

  • Verified meeting decisions with item-specific public-source evidence
  • Item-level plain-language summaries are not available; this page does not infer individual agenda items.
  • Item-linked, attributed deliberation
  • A source-grounded next meeting date
  • Official outcomes have not been published.
  • A transcript is not available.
  • No audio or video recording is linked.
  • Speakers have not been reliably matched to public profiles.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.
  • An individual roll-call roster is not available.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: 52a22180e6f4c550ec138692eaf997a0. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record