POLISCOPE

The public record

NAPLES (COLLIER COUNTY) · LOCALHeld · official record pendingPartial coverage

Design Review Board

Wednesday, September 25, 2024 · Government meeting record

The 30-second read

Record incomplete

The Naples Design Review Board met to discuss proposed design changes for two major development projects. The board postponed a decision on the 710 Goodlette Residences to allow the developer to address concerns regarding building aesthetics and landscaping.

Why it matters

The board's decisions determine the final appearance, landscaping, and architectural standards for significant residential and commercial developments in Naples, directly impacting neighborhood character and property aesthetics.

What happens next

The scheduled meeting date has passed. Minutes or an action agenda are not published in the records we hold.

This meeting date has passed and no official outcome record has been published yet. Nothing on this page is a decision.

Record text

No transcript is held for this meeting. Recording: Watch video

City of Naples City Council Chamber 735 Eighth Street South Naples, Florida 34102 Design Review Board Regular Meeting – September 25, 2024 – 9:01 a.m. It is noted for the record that all: 1) documentation electronically appended hereto is also contained in the file for this meeting with the City Clerk’s Office; 2) experts who testified during quasi-judicial hearings were accepted as qualified to do so in their respective fields of expertise; 3) added attachments are referenced in red as “Added Attachment”; and 4) Alternate Member duPont participated as a voting member for all items below. 1) Call to Order Chair Hruby called the meeting to order and presided. 2) Roll Call Board Members Present: Stephen Hruby, Chair Doug Haughey Luke Fredrickson, Vice Chair (left at 12:57 p.m.) Chae duPont, Alternate Member Board Members Absent: Sabrina McCabe Staff Present: Ralf Brookes, Assistant City Attorney Erica Martin, Planning Director Leslee Dulmer, Deputy Planning Director Nate Jones, Senior Planner Jeffrey Brammer, Planner II Ali Duran, Executive Assistant Presenters Present: Michael Sheeley Brian McFall Peter Shaheen Matthew Slaughter Tim McCarthy Mark McLean Patrick Trefz Others Present Linda Epstein Debbie Latiner 3) Pledge of Allegiance Member Haughey led the Pledge of Allegiance. 4) Changes to the Agenda Chair Hruby stated that the petitioner for Item 7.H asked for that item to be moved up in the agenda to ensure they make their flight. He suggested that Item 7.H be heard following Item 7.B; Members had no objections. 5) Approval of Minutes MOTION by duPont to APPROVE the August 28, 2024 meeting minutes; seconded by Fredrickson and carried 4-0 (duPont-yes, Fredrickson-yes, Haughey-yes, McCabe-absent, Hruby-yes). 2024-0828 drb minutes 6) Public Comment None. 7) Public Hearings 7.A) 20-DRB38 (Revision No. 1) - A Resolution for the Purpose of Determining Revision #1 to Final Design Review Petition 20-DRB38 to Modify the Existing Final Approval

Design Review Board Regular Meeting – September 25, 2024 – 9:01 a.m. 2 of Exterior Design, Landscaping and Other Appurtenances for 63 Luxury Apartments at the 710 Goodlette Residences Development Located at 710 Goodlette-Frank Road North, Naples, FL 34102 Owned by Sahasa Realty Corporation, and More Fully Described Herein; and Providing an Effective Date. Chair Hruby read the title of the Item. This being a quasi-judicial proceeding, Notary Public Ali Duran administered an Oath to those intending to offer testimony; all responded in the affirmative. Members then made the ex parte disclosure to the effect that each were familiar with the site and had reviewed the application. Michael Sheeley, Architect at MK Architecture, utilized an electronic presentation to overview a revision to the final design of 63 luxury apartments named 710 Goodlette Residences Development and located at 710 Goodlette-Frank Road. The revision included modifications to the exterior design, the color palette, hardscape revisions, and the addition of a fire pump room and a generator. Michael McFall, Landscape Architect at Juniper Landscaping, overviewed the revisions made to the landscape plan, noting that the height of the landscape was reduced by choosing a shorter plant palette. Chair Hruby expressed disappointment with the proposed modifications, expressing the view that the changes degraded the massing and devalued the property. Although Members agreed with replacing the asphalt with pavers, they suggested increasing the number of vehicle and electric bicycle charging stations, adding the fountain previously proposed back into the plan, reconsidering material changes that previously broke up the appearance of shear walls, reinstating the trellis on the clubhouse, including renderings displaying the roll up door, keeping the landscape in scale with the building and the luxury quality that is sought after, incorporating a push-pull rhythm on the façade by changing the roof line or using textures, correcting inconsistencies between the renderings and the elevation diagrams, accentuating the masses between the balconies and the towers, painting the back of the balcony walls a darker color, and reinstalling the stone base on both buildings. Nate Jones, Senior Planner, testified on behalf of the City and provided an overview of the staff report and the conditions contained therein. He noted that 158 letters were mailed out to adjacent neighbors and staff received phone calls questioning what was being constructed. Senior Planner Jones stated that staff reviewed the petition for a revision to the previously approved final design against the criteria provided in the Design Review Handbook and Section 2-479 of the Naples City Code and found that the proposed modifications generally met the criteria, but the original design was more compatible with the surrounding area and conformed better to the guidelines and standards set forth in design aspirations for the City. Public Comment: None. Responding to Members’ comments and the staff report, Architect Sheeley requested a continuance until the October 23, 2024 meeting to address comments presented. MOTION by Fredrickson to CONTINUE Petition 20-DRB38 (Revision No. 1) until the October 23, 2024 Design Review Board meeting; seconded by duPont and carried 4-0 (duPont-yes, Fredrickson-yes, Haughey-yes, McCabe-absent, Hruby-yes). Staff Report Resolution Application Disclosure of Interest Deed Survey Location Map Aerial Site Plan Architectural Plans- Approved Architectural Plans- Revised Color Samples- Approved Color Samples- Revised Site Rendering- Approved Site Rendering Revised- 1 Site Rendering Revised- 2 Landscape Plans- Approved Landscape Plans- Revised Lighting Plan- Approved Lighting Plan- Revised Sign Plan- Approved Sign Plan- Revised Credentials - Staff Credentials- Petitioner Public Notice Mailing Addresses Affidavit of Sign Posting

Design Review Board Regular Meeting – September 25, 2024 – 9:01 a.m. 3 Presentation (Petitioner Added Attachment) 7.B) 21-DRB11 (Revision No. 3) - A Resolution for the Purpose of Determining Revision No. 3 to Final Design Review Petition 21-DRB11, Relating to Modifications to the North side of the Building Located at 445-457 5th Avenue South on Property Owned by Colson Investments, LLC. Chair Hruby read the title of the Item. This being a quasi-judicial proceeding, Notary Public Ali Duran administered an Oath to those intending to offer testimony; all responded in the affirmative. Each Member then made the ex parte disclosure to the effect that each had visited the site and had reviewed the application. Matthew Slaughter, Owner of Colson Investments, utilized an electronic presentation to overview the third revision to the final design of a two-story commercial building named The Colson Building and located at 445-457 5th Avenue South. The revision included a request not to install awnings on the north façade. Member Haughey stated that although the awnings were not functionally necessary, he did appreciate the color they brought to an otherwise uninteresting wall. Chair Hruby suggested installing the awning over the breezeway to identify it as an entry point. Noting the photograph of the site submitted by the petitioner, Members suggested the mechanical equipment on the roof and on the side of the building be shielded from view. Deputy Planning Director Leslee Dulmer testified on behalf of the City and overviewed the staff report and the conditions contained therein. She explained to the Board that mechanical equipment is required to be screened pursuant to the Naples City Code and that she will follow up with the Building Department regarding the visible mechanical equipment on the roof and on the building façade. Deputy Planning Director Dulmer explained that staff reviewed the petition for a revision to the previously approved final design against the criteria provided in the Design Review Handbook and Section 2-479 of the Naples City Code and found that the criteria had been met. Public Comment: None. MOTION by Fredrickson to APPROVE RESOLUTION 21-DRB11 (Revision No. 3), granting final design approval as revised that day; seconded by Haughey and carried 4-0 (duPont-yes, Fredrickson-yes, Haughey-yes, McCabe-absent, Hruby-yes). Staff Memorandum Resolution Application Disclosure of Interest Aerial Site Plan Renderings and Existing Conditions Elevations Color Palette Credentials - Staff Public Notice Mailing Addresses Affidavit of Sign Posting Presentation (Petitioner Added Attachment) 21-DRB11 (Revision No. 3) - Revised Resolution, Signed (Added Attachment) It is noted for the record that Alternate Member duPont left at 10:14 a.m., during Item 7.H. 7.H) 24-DRB34 - A Resolution for the Purpose of Determining Petition 24-DRB34, Relating to Preliminary Design Review of a New Multifamily Development and Associated Amenities as Part of the Naples Beach Club Redevelopment on Property Owned by the Naples Beach Club Land Trust I, the Naples Beach Club Land Trust II and NBC Club Owner, LLC and Located at 1090 Crayton Road. Chair Hruby read the title of the Item. It is noted for the record that those intending to offer testimony were previously sworn in. Members then made the following ex parte disclosures: duPont and Haughey / familiar with the site, reviewed the application, and met with Mr. McCarthy; Hruby / met with Mr. McCarthy to discuss the presentation; and Fredrickson / familiar with the site, reviewed the application, and had a conversation with Mr. McCarthy regarding the presentation and to discuss the project. Tim McCarthy, Partner and Managing Principal at Hart Howerton, utilized an electronic presentation to overview the preliminary design of a new multifamily development and associated amenities named Golfside Residential Buildings and located at 1090 Crayton Road. He explained

Design Review Board Regular Meeting – September 25, 2024 – 9:01 a.m. 4 that in November 2018, the Board approved Petition 18-DRB52 for the preliminary design of the comprehensive redevelopment of approximately 125 acres. Member Haughey expressed concern regarding the safety of pedestrians and bicyclists due to the obscured view of the sidewalks from the egress on Gulf Shore Boulevard. Mr. McCarthy assured Member Haughey that he will follow up with the City Traffic Engineer to confirm the visibility is sufficient. Chair Hruby suggested making the window mullion pattern consistent and having the windows carry the same datum line. Deputy Planning Director Leslee Dulmer testified on behalf of the City and overviewed the staff report and the conditions contained therein. She noted an error at the bottom of page four under the Analysis section, stating that it should read “Preliminary Design Review” not “Final Design Review”. Deputy Planning Director Dulmer stated that staff reviewed the petition against the criteria provided in the Design Review Handbook and Section 2-479 of the Naples City Code and found that the plans submitted adequately addressed the criteria for preliminary review. Public Comment: None. MOTION by Haughey to APPROVE RESOLUTION 24-DRB34, granting preliminary design approval as revised that day; seconded by Fredrickson and carried 3-0 (duPont-absent, Fredrickson-yes, Haughey-yes, McCabe- absent, Hruby-yes). Staff Report Resolution Application Survey Sketch Disclosure of Interest - TRACT BE TRACT H-1 Disclosure of Interest - TRACT OS-1 Disclosure of Interest - Tract RT-1 Golfside Residences Supplemental Overview Golfside Architectural Character Overview Golfside Landscape Character Overview Architectural Plans Landscape Plans Civil Site Plans Lighting Plans Credentials - Petitioner Credentials - Staff Public Notice Mailing Addresses Affidavit of Sign Posting 7H - 24-DRB34 - Presentation (Petitioner Added Attachment) 24-DRB44 - Revised Resolution, Signed (Added Attachment) Recess from 11:00 a.m. to 11:15 a.m. It is noted for the record that the same Board Members were present when the meeting reconvened and Alternate Member duPont returned at 11:16 a.m. 7.C) 24-DRB29 - A Resolution for the Purpose of Determining Petition 24-DRB29, Relating to Final Design Review of Exterior Facade Changes on Property Owned by Neapolitan Enterprises, LLC and Located at 255 13th Avenue South. Chair Hruby read the title of the Resolution. This being a quasi-judicial proceeding, Notary Public Ali Duran administered an Oath to those intending to offer testimony; all responded in the affirmative. Members then made the following ex parte disclosures: Haughey, Fredrickson, and duPont / visited the site and reviewed the application; and Hruby / familiar with the site and reviewed the application. Mark McLean, Architect and National Director at MHK Architecture, utilized an electronic presentation to overview the final design of exterior façade changes on a structure located at 255 13th Avenue South, noting the small modifications since the preliminary hearing. Planner II Jeffrey Brammer testified on behalf of the City and overviewed the staff report. He stated that staff reviewed the petition requesting final design approval against the criteria provided in the Design Review Handbook and Section 2-479 of the Naples City Code and found that the criteria had been met. Public Comment: None. MOTION by Fredrickson to APPROVE RESOLUTION 24-DRB29, granting final design approval; seconded by Haughey and carried 4-0 (duPont-yes, Fredrickson-yes, Haughey-yes, McCabe-absent, Hruby-yes). Staff Report Resolution Application

Design Review Board Regular Meeting – September 25, 2024 – 9:01 a.m. 5 Disclosure of Interest - Property Owner Disclosure of Interest - Tenant Deed Survey Architectural Plans Credentials - Petitioner Credentials - Staff Public Notice Mailing Addresses Affidavit of Sign Posting Presentation (Petitioner Added Attachment) 24-DRB29 - Resolution, Signed (Added Attachment) 7.D) 24-DRB30 - A Resolution for the Purpose of Determining Petition 24-DRB30, Relating to Final Design Review of Exterior Facade Changes on Property Owned by Francis J. Hager Jr. and Located at 990 1st Avenue South. Chair Hruby read the title of the Resolution. It is noted for the record that those intending to offer testimony were previously sworn in. Members then made the following ex parte disclosures: Haughey, Fredrickson, and Hruby / visited the site and reviewed the application; and duPont / reviewed the application. Mark McLean, Architect and National Director at MHK Architecture, utilized an electronic presentation to overview the final design of exterior façade changes to a commercial property located at 990 1st Avenue South. He noted that the only modification will be repainting the building two shades of white. Planner II Jeffrey Brammer testified on behalf of the City and overviewed the staff report. He stated that staff reviewed the petition requesting final design approval against the criteria provided in the Design Review Handbook and Section 50-241 of the Naples City Code and found that the criteria had been met. Public Comment: None. MOTION by Haughey to APPROVE RESOLUTION 24-DRB30, granting final design approval; seconded by Fredrickson and carried 4-0 (duPont-yes, Fredrickson-yes, Haughey-yes, McCabe-absent, Hruby-yes). Staff Report Resolution Application Disclosure of Interest - Property Owner Deed Survey Architectural Plans Credentials - Petitioner Credentials - Staff Public Notice Mailing Addresses Affidavit of Sign Posting Presentation (Petitioner Added Attachment) 24-DRB30 - Resolution, Signed (Added Attachment) It is noted for the record that Alternate Member duPont left at 11:32 a.m., during Item 7.E. 7.E) 24-DRB31 - A Resolution for the Purpose of Determining Petition 24-DRB31, Relating to Final Design Review of Exterior Facade Changes on Property Owned by Naples Bay Properties, LLC and Located at 1500 5th Avenue South. Chair Hruby read the title of the Resolution. It is noted for the record that those intending to offer testimony were previously sworn in. Members then made the following ex parte disclosures: Fredrickson, Haughey, and Hruby / visited the site and reviewed the application, and duPont / familiar with the site and reviewed the application. Mark McLean, Architect and National Director at MHK Architecture, utilized an electronic presentation to overview the final design of exterior façade changes on a commercial property located at 1500 5th Avenue South. He noted that this application included outdoor dining and will be presented to the City Council for approval of the Outdoor Dining Permit. Planner II Jeffrey Brammer testified on behalf of the City and overviewed the staff report. He stated that staff reviewed the petition requesting final design approval against the criteria provided in the Design Review Handbook and in Section 50-241 of the Naples City Code and found that the criteria had been met. Public Comment: None. MOTION by Haughey to APPROVE RESOLUTION 24-DRB31, granting final design approval; seconded by Fredrickson and carried3-0 (duPont-absent, Fredrickson-yes, Haughey-yes, McCabe-absent, Hruby-absent). Staff Report Resolution Application

Design Review Board Regular Meeting – September 25, 2024 – 9:01 a.m. 6 Disclosure of Interest - Property Owner Disclosure of Interest - Business Owner Lease Agreement Memorandum of Lease Deed Architectural Plans Credentials - Petitioner Credentials - Staff Public Notice Mailing Addresses Affidavit of Sign Posting 9.23.24 24-DRB31 Staff Report 9.23.24 24-DRB31 Resolution Presentation (Petitioner Added Attachment) 24-DRB31 - Resolution, Signed (Added Attachment) It is noted for the record that Alternate Member duPont returned at 11:44am, during Item 7.F. 7.F) 24-DRB32 - A Resolution Determining Final Design Review Petition 24-DRB32 Relating to a New Two-Story Clubhouse with Recreational Amenities and Parking on the Property Located at 2900 Gordon Drive. Chair Hruby read the title of the Item. It is noted for the record that those intending to offer testimony were previously sworn in. Vice Chair Fredrickson, Member Haughey and Chair Hruby provided the ex parte disclosure that each had visited the site, reviewed the application, and had a conversation with Mr. McCarthy regarding the presentation. Tim McCarthy, Partner and Managing Principal at Hart Howerton, utilized an electronic presentation to overview the final design of a new two-story clubhouse with recreational amenities and parking called the Port Royal Club and located at 2900 Gordon Drive. Patrick Trefz, Landscape Architect at Outside Productions, provided an overview of the landscape and hardscape plans. Planning Director Erica Martin testified on behalf of the City and overviewed the staff report and the conditions contained therein. She explained that the Board was directed by City Council to determine the specific plant species that will be used to buffer the southern privacy wall. Planning Director Martin stated that staff reviewed the petition requesting final design approval against the criteria provided in the Design Review Handbook and Section 2-479 of the Naples City Code and found that the criteria had been met. Public Comment: None. MOTION by Haughey to APPROVE RESOLUTION 24-DRB32, granting final design approval as revised that day; seconded by duPont and carried 4-0 (duPont-yes, Fredrickson-yes, Haughey-yes, McCabe-absent, Hruby-yes). Staff Report Resolution Application Deed - Port Royal Beach Club Articles of Amendment Port Royal Beach Club Inc to Port Royal Club Inc Disclosure of Interest Survey Civil Plans Landscape Plans Architectural Plans Architectural Materials and 3D Renderings Signage Plan Lighting Plans Petitioners’ Credentials Planning Department Credentials Public Notice Mailing Addresses 24-DRB32 - Presentation (Petitioner Added Attachment) Turf Sample (Petitioner Added Attachment) 24-DRB32 - Revised Resolution, Signed (Added Attachment) 7.G) 24-DRB33 - A Resolution for the Purpose of Determining Petition 24-DRB33, Relating to Final Design Review of Exterior Facade Changes on Property Owned by the Barclay Condominium Building owners and located at 225 5th Avenue South. Chair Hruby read the Resolution. This being a quasi-judicial proceeding, Notary Public Ali Duran administered an Oath to those intending to offer testimony; all responded in the affirmative. Members then made the following ex parte disclosures: Haughey, Hruby, and duPont / visited the site and reviewed the application; and Fredrickson / visited the site, reviewed the application, and noted that his construction business may be awarded this project in the future. Following a brief discussion, Vice Chair Fredrickson recused himself from this item and filled out a Form 8B Memorandum of Voting Conflict for County, Municipal, and Other Local Public Officers, and left the meeting and did not return.

Design Review Board Regular Meeting – September 25, 2024 – 9:01 a.m. 7 Mark McLean, Architect and National Director at MHK Architecture, utilized an electronic presentation to overview the final design of exterior façade changes to a multi-family residential building called The Barclay Condominiums and located at 225 5th Avenue South. He noted upgrades to the railings, paint and materials palette, windows, ceiling textures, dumpster enclosure gate, doors, lighting, and porch screens. Chair Hruby suggested placing the insect screens inside the porch railings, expressing the view that it detracts from the building’s appearance. Planner II Jeffrey Brammer testified on behalf of the City and provided an overview of the staff report. He stated that 620 letters were mailed out to neighboring property owners, and no communication was received in response to those letters as of the start of the meeting that day. Deputy Planning Director Leslee Dulmer then informed the Board that an email was received throughout the day, but that the correspondent was present for public comment. Planner Brammer stated that staff reviewed the petition requesting final design approval against the criteria in the Design Review Handbook and Section 2-479 of the Naples City Code and found that the criteria had been met. Public Comment: Linda Epstein, a resident, stated that she preferred to have the railing on the interior of the screen so that it can be cleaned and that most residents had already replaced the insect screening at their own cost. She also noted that the residents had not approved the design of the door, nor had they approved replacing the railings. Ms. Epstein expressed the view that the wood embellishments on the ceilings should run opposite to what was shown and suggested a different material for the exterior walls. Debbie Latimer, Vice President of The Barclay Condominium Association, stated that the Condominium Association attempted to have residents vote on as many aspects of the project as possible and the door design was not formally determined, but options were sent out to all residents. She further stated that the Board and batten exterior façade was voted on and approved and the rhythm of the Battens will be better understood when the exterior is measured out. Architect McLean stated that he will bring back the door design to the Board should the residents decide on a design different than the glass French door presented. Following a brief discussion the Board added a condition to ensure that the Battens related to the existing window spacing when installed. MOTION by Haughey to APPROVE RESOLUTION 24-DRB33, granting final design review as revised that day; seconded by duPont and carried 3-0-1 (duPont-yes, Fredrickson-abstain, Haughey-yes, McCabe-absent, Hruby- yes). Staff Report Resolution Application Disclosure of Interest - Property Owners Survey Architectural Plans Credentials - Petitioner Credentials - Staff Public Notice Mailing Addresses Affidavit of Sign Posting Form 8B Memorandum of Voting Conflict for County, Municipal, and Other Local Public Officers (Fredrickson Added Attachment) Presentation (Petitioner Added Attachment) 24-DRB33 - Revised Resolution, Signed (Added Attachment) 8) Public Comment None. 9) Correspondence and Communication Noting that the Design Review Handbook discussion at the September 18, 2024 City Council Regular meeting was continued due to a lengthy agenda, Chair Hruby requested an update when the discussion would be rescheduled. Deputy Planning Director Leslee Dulmer stated that the discussion will be scheduled for a future workshop in November.

Design Review Board Regular Meeting – September 25, 2024 – 9:01 a.m. 8 10) Adjourn 1:29 p.m. ___________________________________ Stephen Hruby, Chair ______________________________________ Patricia L. Rambosk, City Clerk Minutes prepared by: _____________________________________ Ali Duran, Executive Assistant Minutes Approved: 10/23/2024.

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
Agenda packetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Action agendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
MinutesNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Transcript or captionsNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Recording and media

Coverage and corrections

Records considered

  • Design Review Board

Not claimed by this page

  • Verified meeting decisions with item-specific public-source evidence
  • Item-level plain-language summaries are not available; this page does not infer individual agenda items.
  • Item-linked, attributed deliberation
  • A source-grounded next meeting date
  • Official outcomes have not been published.
  • A transcript is not available.
  • Speakers have not been reliably matched to public profiles.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.
  • An individual roll-call roster is not available.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: 527de64ead54c7ec6998ee3e7d393c69. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record