POLISCOPE

The public record

PITTSBURG (CONTRACOSTA COUNTY)Held · official record pendingPartial coverage

Community and Economic Development Subcommittee

Wednesday, March 12, 2025 · Government meeting record

The 30-second read

Record incomplete

Community and Economic Development Subcommittee

Why it matters

The official meeting record is available below. Item-level plain-language summaries are not available yet.

What happens next

The scheduled meeting date has passed. Minutes or an action agenda are not published in the records we hold.

This meeting date has passed and no official outcome record has been published yet. Nothing on this page is a decision.

Transcript and record text

Closed captionsWhat was said at the meeting, transcribed Aug 3, 2026. Speech is not a decision.
  • No speaker turns were supplied with this transcript.
  • This transcript has no source timestamps.
  • No speaker identities were supplied with this transcript.

This source published text without speaker turns, so speakers and timestamps are not shown.

The opening of 68,375 stored characters

Okay, this is 540 and we will get this community and economic development subcommittee started. Before we start, we are going to make a few agenda changes. Start with the economic development contract services update item number six and we are going to, if that's all right with you, Mayor, move item number five to a future agenda. So with that, item number six. Okay. Members of the subcommittee, item number six is just a very brief update in terms of looking at But in terms of two services that we had previously used in the past and Basically, it's stating that. In regards to with our agreements with the 100 companies which oversees the east bay letter and our agreement with Social Glass, which we used to create the city bids for marketplace we are recommending that we not renew these expiring contracts in that after you know months of Going over reviewing these agreements, reviewing our goals and check us where we're going and deliberation, we don't feel that these two services. Currently aligned with what we're looking to do in terms of our initiatives, goals, and objectives. As you can see right here on the report. This will obviously free up between 49,000 and 52,000 economic development funds per fiscal year over the next five years as a result. Of this recommendation and we feel that with those funds open up, it would allow for us to be able to reallocate and refocus those funds towards a lot of the priorities that we have discussed, starting with the city council workshop. And a lot of the goals and objectives that we've been going for us. So we, you know, while it's unfortunate that we have these two programs We're recommending ending these two programs. We also see it as a good opportunity that we can be able to reallocate resources to what we're what we're looking to do in terms of our our current goals and objectives that were set particularly in economic development. So… Again, that's pretty much the report and I'm happy to take any feedback or questions you have. On this recommendation. I'll just add a couple things. While both, I think, great products and both generally pretty easy to use We've just determined that glass is not made for our type of city. It's not necessarily size. It's not necessarily demographics. It's the types of businesses we have. It's a great opportunity for cities. And while there are fewer and fewer of these places that have mom and pop stores that still provide services and products to cities that we just don't have in the city of Pittsburgh. We Local stores that are going to sell us printers or paper or those types of things that glass is really targeted towards They've also kind of changed their model and I think they're looking at some larger communities and some larger buyers well they did give us a heavy discount for this past year so we could try it one more time. Just doesn't seem to be working. And I don't think that they would disagree with that. When it comes to East Bay 100, as Robert mentioned. We gave it a go. We've tried. We think we've heard the direction that we want to go. And we think that we can work with some of our local agencies like the chamber and then also just in-house with the creation of the communications division to push that out ourselves and we don't have to rely on an outside agency as much as we did. So I remember mentioning frees up a lot of money. Which right now with what we're looking at budget wise is very important and it's going to allow us to continue some of the programs that we have here in the city. Without having to spend so much money elsewhere. Appreciate that. That was really my only question was any insight. So I know we've had conversations East Bay 100, but as far as the glass architecture, that kind of thing. So for the replacement services or courses that people don't use. Does that help perform any type of endpoints, any type of criteria for how we determine what's the next thing that's successful? These two aspects or are we just going for the answer? Let's really see how that works. Yeah. Right before I answer that question, Vice Mayor. We just gave a very short update. We had two contract services, the East Bay 100, and glass commerce that we are recommending we do not renew those contracts uh Starting with glass, we gave it a go. They're a great company and they have a really good product. It's just not built for our city. It's built for a city that maybe has more small businesses that are national chains that don't have their own online stores that can connect with a government agency like ours. East Bay 100, we've talked about that at length. And we think that we have additional bandwidth in-house as well as offers from folks like the chamber to work with them to develop something. To answer your question, Commissioner. As far as replacement and like what we've learned. We learned that we need to be able to access the data better. And I think that that came to light as we were having these discussions on knowing exactly who it's going to, where they work is a little bit of a hindrance to actually be able to determine and pivot as to where we go. So that's definitely something we're going to be looking at as we replace this whether it's Looking at our own mailing list, LinkedIn, creating mailing lists from scratch, at least we'll know where those contacts are coming from. And so we are getting great response, we can focus on those. And if we're not getting great response, we can at least see, okay, well, maybe that didn't work. Maybe trying to go And seek out people from Virginia and Texas. I picked two random states Or, you know, those aren't the target markets. And so maybe we need to look more in Southern California or the peninsula where people are getting priced out. Completely made of examples, but if we have more access to the data, we'll be able to better convey to you all what we're up against and what we can do to make it better. It was more like, well, this great response that we're targeting can how do we measure whether we achieved it or not I think as we go through developing this updated plan we're going to bring some things forward, but we're going to ask you what moves the needle in your eyes. What makes you all identify with successes? We'll come up with a list of things or you know we'll have some ideas, but we definitely want your feedback Because you all are the folks that are making the decisions and providing us guidance. And so we want you to be comfortable With what success looks like. I'll let the voice might catch up a little bit. Let me know if there's any comments? So we will go. To item number one. Actually, we're going to have some public comment, which I skipped at the beginning. Any further comment? Seeing none, we'll go to item number one, ADU accelerator. So we'll turn it over to Kelsey Gunter, Associate Planner, to provide us with just a brief update. On an EU accelerator grant program. Yes, ADO Accelerator Grant Update. The City of Pittsburgh came forward the intent to apply for a grant in a total of $190,207. We took that forward to city council on December 16th last year. City Council adopted a resolution allowing staff to move forward with applying for the grant funds. And in January, staff submitted an application for the grant funding and we were awarded the grant funding in total. At the end of January and then receive that funding at the end of February. Kind of backtrack, the grant funds are to accelerate housing production and to accelerate accessory dwelling units, which is the edu within the city of Pittsburgh. State legislation has really pushed for additional housing mix of housing types, and so this funding will really allow us to expand our housing stock and to do so in a way that allows for people to age in place and people to have additional rental income on their Property. As part of the grant funding, there's two different programs that we have. Each city that is included or eligible to apply for the grant funding was awarded $50,000 for the ADU preparation of ADU plans or to improve our ADU program within the city and then based on your population estimates, we were allotted $140,406.96 as a rebate program. So to incentivize people to invest on their property. And so the rebate program I'll start with your program and then I'll jump to the AD program. The rebate program is available to all residents within the city of Pittsburgh. And there are different levels of rebates that would be available and it isn't a first come first serve basis. It is the only round of funding that we are expected to get as part of this, but if there are some who don't utilize all of their funding or Those funds may become available in the future 2026. But for now, if you don't want to restrict your property, meaning if you want to be able to rent it at whatever income level you'd like to. $15,000 is available for units less than 500 square feet. And then it goes down $10,000 for the units 501 to 750 square feet. Than 5,000 for units 751 to 1,000. And both for de-destructive and non-restricted, anything greater than 1,000 square feet is not applicable for rebates and that's because they're wanting to have smaller smaller ideas so that people are able to build more on their properties and that smaller lots are also equally as eligible. Data restricted interviews receive more money and funding than non-infected ADUs? The leadership training process is similar to the leadership processor dual units. We would be requiring requiring a contract be recorded as a regulatory agreement to restrict the amount of rent. The City of Danville, as an example, has restricted to 80% AMI. And for a minimum period of 10 years. The city has the opportunity to change that percentage, but the minimum 20 years is and as part of as part of As we move forward with accepting or with processing rebates, we will work with our team to develop a new platform ourselves as well as our current platform. In order to issue some rebates. People who are eligible for rebates are people who have their permit issued From here on out and get their certificate of occupancy within 18 months of applying or completing that foundation. What was the total amount that you could get for de-restricted? Deed restricted for units less than 500 square feet is 15,000. I'm sorry, no leadership is 7,500. 75. Awesome. And then I'll jump now to the development of the permit ready plans. That's what we plan to use the $50,000 for. I'll just say, was there any questions before we move on? I was going to ask in terms of the criteria for the dollar amount for the units per square foot is that state law or is that what we crafted? That is from Senate District 7, so yes Yes, Senator Glazer set to stand up. You said residents an out-of-town owner would not be eligible Properties within Z. So if you own a piece of property. The Sage City recognized 20 years. As opposed to the regular 55 years on rental. And yes. And so for Rena, it would count? Yeah. And that's why, oh, come on. I don't know anything else. So this was a program that was really kind of benefiting just the citizens of the city of Pittsburgh you know increase ad use and When actually Garrett brought this to me about seven months ago when it first started. I jump right on and I say, okay, we got to get our housing element done and certified. And that was one of the criteria. So once we have our housing owners certified, we were able to move forward with applying for the grant and coming to the council back in december and We were awarded the funds in late February, as Kelsey has identified. So right now we're working through just the minutia trying to get rebates Started through a seller. So what we'll do is have it online and make it a lot easier for people to submit the final paperwork. And then we'll just cross-reference it. And then we'll start. Sending out the rebate checks. So hopefully sometime we can april But we will come back to the subcommittee and provide you guys with information in regards to who's submitting and what size dwellings and is it D restricted or non-restricted? Yes, sir. Is this available to people who currently are submitting plans for EVs? Yes. And do you need a decision or direction in terms of 80% of AMR? No, uh. Yes, we really wanted to stick with what the city of Danville had well actually what we didn't want to try to mess with the numbers. It gives a little more determination. We're not trying to go outside of anything else that we want to have put together and keep it just really specific to what the um Gosh, yeah, I do like that it talks about I guess creating that database in terms of the number of folks that have been permitted as the program starts. Have we already captured since We put in our ADU prototypes and design guidelines In terms of the number of folks that have I have numbers running for last year and this year. So in terms of people using the actual ADA plans that we took forward to council last year, you actually only had three people as part of the permit process go for those. And there's only one that's actually been issued. But people are really finding that the ADU guidebook like materials have been really beneficial. And we've had 36 AD permits issued at 2024 and 19 of those were final in 2024. So that kind of gives you a timeframe. And then 2025 this year so far, we've issued only three and we've final flat lesson. Definitely thank you for that. I guess I'm trying to see now. Because only the ones that stick to the guidelines are the ones that are fast track to them. Oh, I'm sorry. I just mean when we're helping people at the public counter and giving them the guidebook. They don't have to necessarily follow the guidebook. It's more so informational So that's one part of it. And the second part of it was an actual plan so that's been developed and there's only been three of those that people have been interested in using natural plants. That sounds like the guidelines helping them. In terms of what they're trying to put together. And I think. We kind of heard the feedback when we were doing the general plan update on EDUs and trying to get a guidebook going, but give everybody some direction. So just, I guess the third one says so with the designs, the prototypes, I guess, that we have the value in that is what fast track or permitting or So the plans that we have currently Can fast track permitting, but the main benefit of it is that the property owner or homeowner doesn't have to go out to Privately hire someone to put their plans, which is a cost ranging we've seen as low as like five grand to 7,500 and up to like 15 So providing that for free for the public is something that a lot of people find. So I just want to mention something again. We did have one case, and I'm guessing that's one of the 2024 numbers Where someone has started building and i believe it was with the guidance they provided to them and then they um didn't Or setbacks and business from their labor and all of that. I just wanted to make sure that this has already been an issue that we've had There's a little bit more attention that goes to directing the public on how to build My concern for discussing them even more so after the escape planning was that we see a lot of people asking forgiveness rather than permission So it's always a concern you know first of all, when it comes to this more work to us and then everything that is downstream consequence in terms of Safety and never remove relationships and all of that. So since we already know this has happened i just wanted to make sure something you went from and no more sternly when we don't get to the public. Thank you. Is there any additional questions, we can move on to category two. We'll have Kelsey kind of highlight that real quick. The restriction on rent, is that tied only to the ADU or the whole parcel? Just the ADU. The second category that is as part of this grant that we received is $50,000 and that is to provide additional permit ready ADU plans. So what we found with the permit ready AD plants we have now, while I've mentioned that people have used them and have to reapply. It is 748 square feet and in the city of Pittsburgh, as you're all aware, there's varying lot sizes. Some people don't have the room for 740 square feet and are looking to construct something smaller. So we are. Preparing additional plans. So we're trying to get a range of footage. So there's a bigger spread for people to choose from and select from. And so that's what we're going to use the $50,000 for. And then local designer. Oh, yes. We are working with the city's building division. We have solicited local designers that work with the city pretty frequently and then we're also going to pursue preparing an RFP to receive proposals from local designers and architects alike to submit quotes to the city. So we're able to kind of see what's out there in the pool and select one or more local architects or designers to prepare the plans. Keep them on here. Yes. But if there's any more questions or there are questions answered, but if no questions, we can go. Thank you. I have a few questions. So the smaller plan, so would you start like 500 to up to the 750. Yeah, we're actually thinking even smaller. It's very like up in the air based on what we received from the architects and designers But we're thinking even something as small as like a 300 to 400 square feet. And the reason for that is because we review types of building permits that come in most frequently. And those ones that do come in more frequently are the 400 to 600 square feet kind of range. We're super sensitive. So it's really dependent on, and Garrett brought to the So when we look at fees, we have to look at fees for building permits. We want to try to keep that threshold small because the larger the house or the greater the size of the house School fees, traffic fees, impact fees. So the smaller the unit, the smaller the fees. So we want to try to reduce that as much as we can for our citizens and not have them burden with that much. And so it's generally $749 or less. It's considerably more affordable. Awesome. Any other items on this one? No, I think we covered everything. I just want to make sure yeah so yeah sorry just came to mind. Is there a restriction for one ADU per property that is going to qualify for Rehearsal that is going to qualify for the bonus or can it do like a bigger property with two three six that takes it it's a great question. So in general, each single family law is allowed to have 180 and one JEDU. But it's a good question to see if the ADU, the funding can also be used for an ADU and the JADU. I actually need to look into that. But generally. One and one are allowed. I just don't know if the funding can be used twice for the same property. I want to say no. Because of the limitations of funding, but I may be wrong. Yeah, I don't think the ADU accelerator really called out JADUs or any additional units. And usually was permitted through the state and zoning is you're allowed single family residents ADU, JDUs, and there is provisions under SB9 where you can have an SB9, but we haven't seen anything that's come through the SAS and additional SB9 unit yet. But the ADU units are really what we're focusing on here and trying to use the money for that and get that program started and get people back in here And I guess one more question from that our only residents is the individuals eligible for the program could be corporations, for example. That are now eligible for uh for the bonus and from there on if it's the same owner with multiple parcels building multiple ideas Is this something that they would qualify for? I think that's an important consideration. You know, I'm just thinking about who can benefit from nothing else I just wanted to make sure we mentioned that. I would think that that's really important especially with the limited dollars in this pie. So I had it. Hundred some thousand dollars so if there is a way to… And if you really look at it. If you use $15,000, immediately for that it's only 10 units or the most nine. So definitely that's what we'll be taking a look at when we you know receive the rebates and who can qualify and stuff like that just to make sure we're not uh So many people pushing people forward. Because at least initially we overview. The regulations assuming it's maybe silent on them we will default to one per person, regardless of how many properties they own in the city of Pittsburgh. We can provide. Periodic updates if it is very popular we more than likely will want to keep it that way if we can so we can help more and more folks. If for whatever reason the popularity is limited and we've got a pile of money that we need to expend by September 2026, we can return to you all and see if you want to open it up for folks to potentially take A second round of cash if they want to put more APs. So we'll get more definitive guidance on that to make sure if it's something we can do, but that will be our sort of preferred direction going forward. So we're going to look into it, then one more question about the rates per square footage. I would be also very interested to find out if there's anything in the legislation speaking to potentially incentivizing Based on the the ratio of the parcel that is being built upon because i don't think this puts all parts of equal footing so if you have a huge parcel and only build a tiny little idea where you can house one person It's not the same as having the same as having smaller parcel where you put a bigger idea and then you can house two people because that's like a different number of people we're housing within the same views i don't know if there's any opportunity to factor this in um as um you know how many people are um how we are able to house with that um That I use, I think also an interesting question to keep into consideration. We'll take that note. And we'll definitely take a look at it. I didn't need to have an extra word then, but if you're looking into that, it's an interesting question. Any more questions, questions? Thank you. Awesome. And moving on to developmental updates. Thank you. And… perfect and update uh also coming down as the zoning ordinance I would say is the Magna Carta distributes everything you know that distributes everything you know within the city whether it's a business whether it's a new residence you know whether it's You know. School industry everything basically the zoning ordinance controls it. Back in 2026, the city adopted a 2040 general plan and the general plan had policies and goals that needs to be implemented and the instrument to implement that is the zoning ordinance. So the city has retained placeworks a consultant to help us come up with ways to update code. As you know, our code i think Days back to 1990 something. 1998 was the last time that we did a comprehensive update. It was the last time the general plan Before this one was adopted was in 2002. So many things have happened since then. I think the iPhone has come on board. We have Airbnb we have uh uber and EV charging stations. We were 510 back then. So a lot has happened that has not been captured with our current coordinates, so we need to bring it up to… I would say the 21st century so that's part of that effort And as a result of that. We've actually initiated a few initiatives that we are trying to you know bring this code up to date. We had a kickoff TAC meeting, a technical advisory meeting back last year november and we basically uh introduced the whole effort to all the development herds at a particular time. We have coming up a joint city council planning commission session for the 17th of this month. Where we are going to introduce it and solicit feedback and direction So that's something that we're looking forward to. We have established a web page where all the information, the background has been listed and that's available for the public to go and be updated and also to provide input. We do have focus groups scheduled for May 26th. We have focus groups. I'd be made up of residence, property owners, developers, real estate professionals, community-based organizations And this last one is and we are hoping to basically engage all these segments of society to get their feedback so that we can In addition to the feedback we get from the council and the planning commission, really synthesize all the feedback and come up with a roadmap of how we're going to go forward. In addition to that, we've also posted announcements in the newspapers social media. Next dog and also the city notice parts also has information about that We are also organizing about six community outreach meetings At least many things we've basically targeted the marina as one of the locations There's also going to be another one at the pittsburgh Public Library, the senior center Los Madamus Community College, and finally the delta the elementary school So we try to target all the different areas of the city and different demographics So that everybody will have the opportunity. So included in your packet tonight there are Preliminary handouts, wrap handouts that roof prepared they are in English and Spanish. We will be providing those. And actually, we've actually been sending out notices to the different um organizations and posting them on the social media websites. But Marisa pointed out but They will be taking place, majority of those in the month of April. If somebody, and we want to have those on the weekends allow for separate weekends to try to hit different areas of the of the city. Thank you. The timeline for the whole effort is uh I'll see where you started. Somewhere in mid-2024 and we hope to complete it by early 2026. And we do have a few questions that we want to address. One of them, especially for the council and the planning commission about what is the vision for the whole town That's something that we want to look at. How can we make opening businesses more efficient What type of housing products do you want to see in the city? What types of climate commission or council applications come before you that you think maybe can be better handled in a more efficient way what type of users doing a CRM in Marina, for instance. We did a visioning for marina we identified a few things. So we just want to make sure That the council and the city council when it's on board. And then in terms of public safety what are some of the things that you want to see to create a more vibrant? City and commercial areas. And then finally, what parts of the city are utilized where you want to see you know. So these are some of the things that you know we are expecting will be touched on And when we have the workshop on Monday. We'll probably, we'll have it broken out to kind of focus sessions, those questions, and then some of the context questions Contextual questions and a development title where we talk about food trucks Airbnbs, some of the issues in regards to healthcare, childcare facilities, stuff like that. So you'll have the opportunity to kind of highlight your top five We'll take those. We'll look at those, and then we'll also during a Monday meeting, have the opportunity to And Jordan, we talked about this early, sending out a memo you should have, we can go over those questions too. So to be comprehensive, to try to really bring together Your ideas, your suggestions, and then we'll go out to the community And we'll say this is councils and the planning commission's overall top areas that we need to concern. What else in the community do we need to look at? So it's really comprehensive That we try to get everyone on board here. So we're really doing a good outreach effort to get everyone involved. Thank you again, John. So as we move forward, we'll be providing updates to this community and soliciting your feedback and input. And direction to make sure that we are moving in the right direction. So at this point, I will pause if anyone has any question, I'll be more than happy to I've raised those questions, please. I think you mentioned, you may have mentioned it. Where do we advertise that this is happening? It's on our web page and do we do like next door or anything like that? Yeah, just today I sent… the notice to the newspapers, East Bay, Contra Costa. Times and then i also posted it on next door and before coming to this meeting and then um We also have a website created that is managed by Placeworks that is also being posted on there. Between. Now and probably the next week, we're going to be printing them in English and Spanish on hard stock. And we're going to go to all the commercial centers and pass them out. We'll probably go to some of the apartments and some of the neighborhoods and drop them off just try to get the way out. We particularly going to put a lot of emphasis on our Spanish speaking community because I think You know, we've realized that even though we get away out sometimes which don't necessarily fit you know some of the content creations where they are. So we're working with one of uh stuff. I mean, who has volunteered to help us Do a more extensive outreach to the Spanish community as well. Yeah, and this will, as we've talked about in other subcommittees, this is going to be part of the annual narratives that have gotten to the part where we make the annual communication narratives just yet. We're still getting the structure together. But we talked in our first kickoff meeting that the advertisements at some point would be catching and grabbing as far as Do you live next to somebody with an illegal Airbnb? Do you want to see this happening more or you know do you want to be an Airbnb in Pittsburgh, a legal one? That kind of thing. So asking those questions that are going to hopefully get people's attention. We can also, depending on the timing, even if it's a little after when we're doing most of the outreach, we can make sure we're at car shows, some of those events and actually Wolfgang, if you can connect us with Maya Cinemas, it'd be great to get something like before movies up on the screen. I know they've reached out before. Asking about, you know, does the city have any desire to advertise so we can go through some channels like that as well One of the other highlights was cottage food operations, micro enterprise, MECOS, that's what it was. Microenterprise Home Kitchen Operation. I mean, we're going to touch on a lot of topics on Monday, but we definitely want to get your feedback. We definitely want to get direction Where should we go? What should be the biggest issues that we should look at? Narrow it down and move forward. And in terms of re-socializing the workshops on these numbers today parks are really busy this time of the year so throughout the community Well, there's you know When people are there that's That's quite a few people that you can reach. Yes. And we do have, besides the first six. Community outreach is that we have planned for between March and May. We also have three others that we hope to go back to the community and say, okay, you provided your input We basically… thought about it and discussed it with our obviously officials and consultants and this is what we've come up with so after the first draft of the code is issued We have one scheduled for July 1st. We have another one scheduled for August 27th. And then we do have another one scheduled for December 10th. So these are all kind of to get feedback loop to make sure that you don't just come one time and then you don't see us again. You're going to keep coming back to say, okay, we heard you we have implemented what you have. Or this is why we cannot do what you're asking for. There will be an ongoing engagement. Well, to help us guide our decision on Monday, is there any way to provide a separate sheet on level graphic data. Demographics yeah age gender And of the population. And at the same time the question about the housing It's hard to recommend the housing not knowing what's existing and then what other types of housing can we choose from like co-ops We don't have cocks here, so I want to say hey I want this kind of housing. There could be so many other density and where they are. I think the general plan um does get into some of those analysis That's just a separate email. Anything that would Help us guide decisions and answers to the questions I thought you were going to ask of us Monday. Jesus is too. This is just around your GIS. I was just going to grab the census. No, but we can provide that information. But before we move on, I want to the mirror, is there any additional feedback or thoughts no i think well my my thought was what you hit on sarah was more so of When I see this flyer as a general community member, I don't know what this is talking about. And that's not, it's really very And so when I see words like text amendments, ambiguous, misinterpreted. You know, it's like it's going over my head as a record. And that's why I did show with the city manager that very sentiment, right? Airbnb. That's Heights. Yeah, you know, vendors, street vending, like those are things that if I see as a community member like Oh, I get to chime in on that. Yeah, I'm tired of seeing it. And it makes me want to come to the workshop. So if possible, I would say if we can kind of rework the flyer to make it more especially going to be handed out in the community tourists like yeah it really Captures attention and really short and sweet as opposed to having to read a lot of text. So that was the only recommendation. And I get it. This process is very technical. So the NOC is not on the information per se that's here. It's just, is it digestible for the everyday community member and to give them enough to make them want to come and give their input. The other was more so I like the questions that were sent over So we're not going to necessarily dive into them right now. But I think, especially for ones as far as like you know type of projects that have come before the planning commission and the city council I don't know how easy it is if there is a table about essentially the type of decisions that have been made over the past year, two years Planning commissioners and council's office you know general plan amendments, just simple design review a permit you know overlays like to really like hone in like what are like What are you asking us to consider? And I think to refresh, because we have new Planning commissioners as well what does that mean like certain products are coming should that have been just outright permitted instead of coming to really get us in that mode and context And then I think it also would be good in that context as well to see how many Planning commission decisions were appealed and came to city council Because that's another conversation around this overall because i think that's one thing I think we're trying to find harmony between city council and Planning Commission is that, okay, this is what The statute says right and this is ultimately the guidelines that we have to work within But if they're not working, this is our opportunity to talk about that and build that cohesion between planning commission and council But as projects do come. There is fine. Like, yeah, we all agree in terms of these zoning texts and how things work. So I think it's an opportunity for that type of conversation as well. If that type of information is readily available I think that would be helpful for a table or just even if it's not ready by Monday, just something as we're continuing to have these conversations about those type of projects or what can be streamlined, like really understanding what those are. We should be able to have that information for you on Monday. Yeah. I mean, just to share my kind of share my kind of thoughts a little bit. I mean, I've been here for three years, came from a different jurisdiction And then with some of the things that jumped out to me was the fact that if you restripe the parking lot. There needs to be like planning commission not before planning commission before staff and approve if you paint your building a new color commercial building a new color If you redo your landscaping So things like that. And then, of course, there are also certain conditional use permits where The staff has the expertise to be able to handle those things right away without having to write a staff report come before the planning commission probably you know so these are some of the things that i feel like if The authorities delegated to the zoning administrator, you wouldn't have to spend so much time you know reviewing those things and um The staff also has the expertise to be able to do this even over the counter. For instance, if a commercial building wants to repaint their building a new color I think we have the expertise to be able to handle that and we don't need to come all the way to maybe the city council I think you have better things to do with your time Expected them to be determining what color your building should be. That's why he's doing this. He's the one. John, I got to get, I was like, yes. So… I know these are questions that we're definitely going to talk and touch talk about on Monday and definitely touch on over the next couple months while we're going through this process. You know, vice president. How many comments want to make sure I'm… Nope, I'm good. I'm good. My thing is around the communication so mayor talked about it with the flyer and just you know, layman terms so people can understand what we're doing and just making the materials a draw, making people curious and interested to participate. And also to add on to that, the fire that catches the attention of the attention someone in their teens is not the Stanford that is going to catch my attention so i just wanted to make sure how we acknowledge there's Different types of interests age groups within the community that, you know, and we plan on going to the uh you know the schools and stuff like that but yes definitely that's a good point uh Christian Popros. Well, I have you here, Commissioner Foster. I'm sick of it. I'm kind of jumping in here. I know it's Maurice's project, but a project that I'm working on through my school right now, engaging in youth and and community outreach, they're getting members of the youth like $100 of monopoly money and they're putting aside like Parks trees, community facilities, and then how much money does each kid want to give to each Interesting. That kind of gives them an idea. I think that's called Sims. It doesn't have to be used, but it was something that came to mind. It's a good point because, you know, 1998 was last update. What is he now 30 years later almost um who is going to benefit the most of what we design today right we're going to make sure decades from now. Experiment. I really do appreciate the mayor's concern because when I went out to distribute flyers for the housing You said… You see the blindness on people's faces. And in the same way, if you go and tell people, have you heard of the development title or development title? It's like, what are you talking about? So I think it's a balance between finding something that people really understand that they can relate to. But at the same time, making sure that it has what it needs to also appeal to People who are a little bit more savvy. Because if I go and show a little cartoon to somebody in a way that make them understand somebody who is a little bit more advanced may not take that too serious. They think it's some kind of kid's game or something like that. So I think the challenge really is for us to come up with Something that appeals to you know at a broad range of audiences and we'll take that and work on it. An infographic would be your best bet oh yeah that's good. The average reading population of fifth grade or seventh grade. So I wouldn't assume that this group of people in a higher end stuff is that big yeah yeah So is that it for good? Okay. For now. Until Monday. Till Monday. Thank you. All right, so we'll move on to item number three, the city rebrand and marketing update. I'll pass it on to George today. Good evening. We are here to present an update to the city's branding and marketing initiatives following the feedback that was provided from the City Council's workshop last month. Today we have North Star virtually to lead the discussion so Hopefully they're all… Do they want to call in? They can call in. Raised your hand of butter. Yeah. So let's go. Is allowed to talk. Anita, I think you can talk now. Okay, I think I can. Yes. Option to share. Click the little drop down to the right of share. Hand down. Okay. Click multiple And it looks like you can share your screen. Hey, there we go. I'm in too. All right. I think Anita is going to share the screen, but appreciate you guys having us on tonight. As Danae mentioned, we are here to share a little bit of an update on the creative elements from the branding process after hearing some feedback. But there may be some new voice or some new faces in the room. So just wanted to do a A really quick recap of just what the process entailed and kind of how we got here. Can you all see Anita's screen? Sam, I am not able to share, Sam. I don't know if you have that option. I'm okay. I don't either. Danae, is that possible to share or not share a screen, but give the allowance for one of us to share. It looks like you have it. You're probably not set up as panelists, just attendees. Know that they were attendees. Go over their little windows and the three dots. Go to your list of people in the meeting. Working on it. I will say this is going to be a lot easier on April 7th when we share with council because I'll actually be there in person. But I appreciate the patience tonight. I'm going to join as a parent. Of course. I mean, it's You should be able to share now, Anita. There you go. Okay. Yep. Now we're cooking. Okay. Nice. Excellent. I can share my screen. I can actually still see the screen, so we'll know what we're actually looking at. This is great. How are you doing, Sam? Nice. Yeah, I'm in. We're good to go. So thank you, everyone. All right. So as I mentioned, just to do a little bit of a recap, real quick flyby before we go into the creative. I just want to talk first how we actually uncovered the brand for Pittsburgh. Thankfully, y'all have had a very, very strong brand from the very beginning. Which has been really nice to work with. It's made its way into the community. It's appreciated. It's got strength. It's really got some really good roots. So we weren't here to overhaul anything, but just to kind of modernize the brand. And we did that by starting with research And then we moved to strategy and then into creativity and then finally into action. And the way this all kind of looks is here in this graphic that looks a little bit like an hourglass. The top half is all research, stakeholder and community education. We took all of that and boiled it down into a DNA statement, which I'll share here in a second, that says this is what Pittsburgh is and why it matters. And then from there, we started working on updating the creative and really started working on the messaging development so that over the next a few months after the April 7th council meeting, we'll really start looking at implementing this brand, how to market, how to message, how to promote Pittsburgh in the best way possible to really just help y'all stand out. And then also in the final report that we delivered, there's a bunch of brand action ideas, just how to implement the brand even further. I mentioned the research. We did a lot last year. We were there for a site visit. We did a lot of focus groups, one-on-one interviews. We surveyed the community members, we surveyed people outside of Pittsburgh to figure out what is your reputation or that outsider's perspective and how far out your general awareness goes. So we did a lot, a lot of research. It was all very intentional and thoughtful and y'all can have all the results of that research. And all of that boils down to the strategy, as I mentioned, with the DNA statement that says this is who and what Pittsburgh is. And what we came up with here, and this isn't any marketing language or even a public facing language, but rather just how we wanted to position Pittsburgh and how we wanted to think about it as we made creative decisions and especially messaging. But we came up with, for those who forge prosperity from hard work and innovation Pittsburgh, California on the southern shore of the Sacramento San Joaquin delta inspires an inherent pride that spans cultures and generations So you can build a new and enduring American enterprise. And so with that, we'll go through some creative updates based on the feedback and direction that y'all have provided. And Anita is going to take us through that. Yeah, thanks, Sam. So we did get a little bit of feedback. So we've done some updates across a variety of deliverables i think Most importantly, we did a little bit of updating to the logo as well as color palette. So we'll share that with you These are some ways that this brand could come to life in print. For a variety of audiences, so businesses, community. Visitation. So as you can see, this is a way that the brand can be used And messaged in a consistent way, but also focusing on individual audiences. And of course, the logo. We did do some color updating and you'll see that here in this logo as well. We brightened up that, well, I shouldn't say brighten we changed the orange to make it a bit more red in color. So bringing it a little more towards the red orange side versus The orangey orange that was previously here. And then we did make updates to the color palette as well. So of course we updated that orange. We also updated the yellow in the palette. It was a little golder before, so we've brought that more to a true yellow And then we also incorporated a black So that if you do want to do some cross promotions with the high school, you'll have that available in your palette As well and also can serve as an accent color in other uses. And of course, the brand standards have been updated to reflect that as well. And the brand standards will provide as a working document that really is a living document as you start to put the brand to work. You'll find other uses or ways that you might want to use the brand that you can set some guidelines around. So that even when you're looking at for example If we want to use it in a really small space and put it on a pen. What are the rules around that? You can add this to the standards document over time so that you aren't just doing one-offs and you're maintaining that consistency across time. And then we're also going to share with you, I think you may have seen a couple of these, but we've got updated brand executions, just some recommendations on some ways that the brand could come to life in everyday life in the community Of course, stationary systems are very important. So this is a look at how that might come to life for the city itself. And then perhaps customized version for economic development, again, sort of focusing on that audience, using that idea of anchored in growth. This is just a quick animation. Incorporating some of that anchored in messaging so different key attributes of the Pittsburgh community and of course the logo How that might work on some giveaways stickers and water bottles. Now that we're all carrying a water bottle everywhere. It's a good way to get the brand out into the world. And vehicles, so in this case, an example of what public works might look like. So just that door logo with public works and then anchored in service, the messaging there sort of really reinforcing that service that they're bringing to the community members. Some proposed poll banners. Again, that idea of being anchored in these core values these core ideas so innovation service fun collaboration and excellence really getting to the essence of Pittsburgh as a community. Here you can see a sample of a mock-up economic development just giveaway brochure. Again, pulling in that look that you saw up front You can see that there on the cover and then there are the brand on the inside. Potential billboard, get some of those folks to stop on by and have a little bit of fun in Pittsburgh rather than just travel on through, get them in there and see that marina and some of those wonderful assets that are available. And I believe you guys saw this one before, gateway signage. So again, this has been updated based on the feedback and the changes that we heard were desired. So you can see the updated version here. Gateway signage can be a really great way To do some placemaking. Get credit for all those wonderful assets that people see once they pass through this sign. And then here's some example wayfinding. Again, signage is a great way to get the brand out in the community and get people interacting with it and can also really be helpful to visitors as well. So that we make sure that they don't miss anything. Any of those must-seys while they're in town. So that is what we have to share the updates based on your feedback. Happy to answer questions or if you'd like to go back and look at something, happy to do that as well. Suggestions, thoughts? I like the updated colors. Based on the feedback that we gave. Because it is a Pittsburgh High School logo. So having that. I forget how you described the orange. It's a little more red orange. It's like a vibrant red orange. Well, thank you for all the work that's been done on this effort. Who like the modernization of the logo the anchored in has grown on me. Initially, I I wasn't sure, but I think just given the logo and what we're trying to communicate, I think that it does speak That's right. Yeah. The materials, I think these may just be and i or a concept or an idea or So I'm not like i don't want to be too like focused on because I thought, I feel like I've seen it before is kind of my thought when I saw it. But I do like the branding in terms of the Pittsburgh at the bottom right corner and then the anchored in messaging and then whatever the content is on the flyer, I'm sure that can be arranged. So I think overall it still does speak. In terms of the logo Appreciate the brand standards because I think that was one of the largest parts of this effort. Was just the consistency among all communications that are going out from the city and really having that brand standard. So really appreciate that. Yeah. And really overall, you know, I'm just looking forward to the execution, you know, in terms of our messaging and what we're communicating And really kind of this fresh feel. I know we're having a lot of conversations around landmarks and monuments and wayfinding signage around town so Looking forward to seeing how this rolls out and giving this fresh look to the city and what we're communicating with residents. Really appreciate the work that you all did because I know I believe it was sometime maybe last year Will you guys share some of those results about how people felt in the community, how people viewed from outside the community And that was really telling. And so looking forward to how our messaging is really going to help in that dynamic about how people feel about the city So I'll stop that. I don't have any questions just really excited that we're getting to this point. And really looking forward to the execution of this branding and marketing effort. And appreciate city staff and then all of you as well and your team. Thank you. We're really excited to see it get put to work as well. Yeah, thank you. That's our favorite part. One question for Steph before I provide any feedback. How finalized is what we're seeing today in the presentations like 11th hour already or do we have some room for back and forth on what is being presented It depends on what we're talking about for the logo and the word mark, we're really 11th hour. I mean, we're planning on taking this. To the city council on the 7th. But really, this still is kind of just that first phase. It's taking a little bit longer But when we actually get into the marketing, the mayor mentioned, you know, that specific advertisement I think that there's going to be a second phase of this and the city council has allocated us some funds that At this point, we're anticipating using to bring this out and so we can refine you know that anchor to innovation with with a very modern building in there you know that can be reworked as part of phase two as this gets executed. But we've had at this point, five or six rounds on the logo and the word mark. And so that those are I don't want to say locked in because it's all at the council's discretion but those have been fed it through and we feel very comfortable with those at this point. Yeah, that's the first time I'm saying it so i didn't want to disrupt the thought process that has been already in there just as feedback then Um i I think that just having a comfortable walk without the full color logo kind of takes away from the marriage of what we see in the current global life The water, the hills, the sun for california so that's one place where I wanted to provide feedback. Separately, the font for the Pittsburgh like the workplace where it's where So right now, just thinking about the image that we have talked about you know a place for people to work. We focus on this is where you create work jobs. More than anything else, I would have thought it would be more sleek rather than a little more clunky a little bit more cartoonish in a way, thicker lettering that we see here. So those were more my initial thoughts about it. But other than that, Anchor being i think that's right spot on. It's a lovely way to use wordplay with our logo and one of our landmarks so congratulations on that. It's really appealing to me as Something that would speak to people when they think about this work. Will be trademarked so there would not be an unauthorized use for it? It will. No, no, I definitely have one of the questions, you know, first. We didn't talk about the logo, but I do want to at least share and even allow the team to share because we We definitely had the conversations about utilizing the colors. The font as well But in terms of the colors, in terms of what that meant. In terms of how it shows up, the visibility on different users so I at least want to provide that opportunity and space. I know we've had a lot of these conversations as well. Yeah. I think it's a really good question. We talked a lot about what's the next step. How do we change that image? And I don't disagree. The colors in a lot of areas, they work quite well. And they do convey a sun and hills and the water. But as we look at what's trendy, you look at the logos in my presentation on the 8th, we showed how some of those have evolved. And while we don't want to get too caught up in the times, we want to be timeless. We're behind. We seem a little elementary with the gradients and some of those logos, which are very primary they clash or maybe they look good together in certain cases when you start to try to pour in all these different colors and you've got an advertisement for this thing that has a very clear aesthetic but then you've got this logo that has very primary colors, it doesn't work. And we surveyed Avayo who's doing the survey, Sean McCall, who's doing a lot of work downtown. And we asked them what they thought. And this conveyed to them modern. It's a little more abstract, if you will, how the sun and apologies for my voice going off. The way the sun and the hills work together. We really and we're pushing on this a little bit because we really feel confident that from an economic development perspective, selling Pittsburgh as a modern city going in that direction is very important. And so that's why we've really kind of pushed to have either a single color or that dual color logo that's a little more recognizable, a little less busy. And a little more modern. How sold are we on red and blue? Just fits in the Bay Area those are in the Bay Area predominantly gay colors. What color? Jane? Game colors. I just wanted to bring that up. Well, maybe in Southern California. I don't want to get into games. It's also red wine blue. Right, but she's also so generic it doesn't stand out because like a lot of cities, red, white, and blue so I agree with a single color. I agree with that i just Are there other… My estimation is that other estimation 90% of the time. It will be a single color because that's what's going to flash the least with these different things. As far as what we're going to put on the trucks we can continue to have that debate over the primary and secondary colors, but we felt, you know, we heard No way in New York. I know you have yellow on that. Yeah, it was a secondary color. So I'll defer to the council on on colors. So I brought it from some of the smaller businesses, not just in Old Town and others. And that was a comment that came up a lot was game colors. I'm just sharing that. I guess I saw this little orange. It definitely prints red. I mean, I didn't get the burnt orange on any of like when you look at it online or anything so if that's where we want to go, I think a different CMYK option to get closer to that but I will share. Everything else, I love that the anchored in and all. I think that's I will share the font for the Pittsburgh was actually inspiration from a chamber's old font that was used back on a poster I saw when I had lunch. So I think it's a good Mix of moving on with the times and going modern but still diving deep into what our heritage is and bringing that modernization and our history into one and moving forward. I think that it brings something you know you mix it with the with the font with the california i think it modernizes it um But yeah, it was truly inspiration from when I see it now about everyone So I think some of the chambers put some good. I find that it's a lot of chamber of covers that the mayor and I had a good conversation about innovation and Really trying to push that discussion as you know we have the Marriott photo of the park train In the new hotel and how we start maybe taking certain angles or drone shots to make sure we get more of our office and our Things that I think will change the perspective of Pittsburgh. So I actually want to raise something. Madam Vice Mayor, you had mentioned the five words that I think that. Sure. Your colleagues on the city council that sort of voice support for maybe having like five key things. And so the five we've come up with And Anita, if you can maybe go back to the slide that shows those are fun, innovation, service, excellence, and… Collaboration. Did you say service? It depends on service. Collaborate. Yeah. So, you know, if you guys have any other thoughts, I mean, we felt that those really were both spoke to the community and spoke to the businesses both existing and future. But if you have any thoughts or anything on that again There's shades of gray here on things that are really locked in and things that can change. But we did like the idea that was brought forward by the council on the eighth of having like five keys that we could really drive home, at least for the next few years. I think one of the words we have was family Okay. Put that underscore in that out. I like the words that we have because they're very they show like fortitude for us as a city So maybe one of the things that we'll work with North Star on is the mayor brought this up earlier. One of the things we really want to do because The

Page

/

2

Loading…

![](https://docs.google.com/viewerng/thumb?ds=AON1mFzHr5iU11NhNHAG34GjQn3q52SFU0B5pa7kpqcgY9bovXEweXevAnynR8G7Q4AubZXO5pMGEpeTC_oIM09uMICjzpZIqwffD2pykDpYpZhd0kwMIp1mux1Ms9yeSnRxDkUe_kPOZWetpUrP4HApyFa9DWMgxWDS87EM2m15rqC-q6FTPL_y82d6Bc-_h4jZNFdWa4OnAUDN-5qeYSW5tuttxmGFUvWvGbBNc-v7TYgP08qdkd2ZjDaGKOcN9PM51PyPYEH68UCzSOltV3aUf-xyenVE2R-7SGoYzF1ZHhrd-6wZBA0PqiY6vzXDwcj9NlbaTM8FhBg050xzCPeoExkmz6hz5g%3D%3D&ck=lantern&dsmi=unknown&authuser&w=800&webp=true&p=proj)

{"id": "", "title": "DocumentViewer.php", "mimeType": "application\\/pdf"}

## Page 1 of 2

65 Civic Avenue

Pittsburg, CA 94565

P: (925) 252-6900

F: (925) 252-4814

pittsburgca.gov

AGENDA

COMMUNITY AND ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT SUBCOMMITTEE

Wednesday, March 12, 2025

5:30 PM

City Hall

First Floor Conference Room, 4B

65 Civic Avenue

Pittsburg, CA 94565

Subcommittee Members

Jelani Killings, Mayor

Dionne Adams, Vice Mayor

Planning Commission Representatives on Land Use

Ivelina Popova, Commissioner

Elissa Robinson, Commissioner

Public Comment for Non-Agenda Items

Land Use:

1\. Accessory Dwelling Unit (ADU) Accelerator. The City has received a one-time grant of

$190,407 to establish an ADU Accelerator Program to encourage and facilitate the

construction of ADUs. Staff will provide an overview of the Program and update on staff

activities related to implementation. Subcommittee feedback requested.

2\. Development Title Update. Staff is currently undertaking a comprehensive update to the

City’s Development Code, Title 18 of the Pittsburg Municipal Code. Staff will provide an

overview of work done to date and next steps in preparation for the Joint City

Council/Planning Commission Workshop on March 17. Subcommittee feedback requested.

Economic Development:

3\. City Rebrand and Marketing Update. On February 8, 2025, during the annual City

Council Goals Workshop, staff unveiled the initial output of the Citywide rebranding and

marketing strategy. Staff will provide an update on work product and timeline for adoption.

Showing the first 24,000 of 68,375 characters. The full document is at the source.

Okay, this is 540 and we will get this community and economic development subcommittee started. Before we start, we are going to make a few agenda changes. Start with the economic development contract services update item number six and we are going to, if that's all right with you, Mayor, move item number five to a future agenda. So with that, item number six. Okay. Members of the subcommittee, item number six is just a very brief update in terms of looking at But in terms of two services that we had previously used in the past and Basically, it's stating that. In regards to with our agreements with the 100 companies which oversees the east bay letter and our agreement with Social Glass, which we used to create the city bids for marketplace we are recommending that we not renew these expiring contracts in that after you know months of Going over reviewing these agreements, reviewing our goals and check us where we're going and deliberation, we don't feel that these two services. Currently aligned with what we're looking to do in terms of our initiatives, goals, and objectives. As you can see right here on the report. This will obviously free up between 49,000 and 52,000 economic development funds per fiscal year over the next five years as a result. Of this recommendation and we feel that with those funds open up, it would allow for us to be able to reallocate and refocus those funds towards a lot of the priorities that we have discussed, starting with the city council workshop. And a lot of the goals and objectives that we've been going for us. So we, you know, while it's unfortunate that we have these two programs We're recommending ending these two programs. We also see it as a good opportunity that we can be able to reallocate resources to what we're what we're looking to do in terms of our our current goals and objectives that were set particularly in economic development. So… Again, that's pretty much the report and I'm happy to take any feedback or questions you have. On this recommendation. I'll just add a couple things. While both, I think, great products and both generally pretty easy to use We've just determined that glass is not made for our type of city. It's not necessarily size. It's not necessarily demographics. It's the types of businesses we have. It's a great opportunity for cities. And while there are fewer and fewer of these places that have mom and pop stores that still provide services and products to cities that we just don't have in the city of Pittsburgh. We Local stores that are going to sell us printers or paper or those types of things that glass is really targeted towards They've also kind of changed their model and I think they're looking at some larger communities and some larger buyers well they did give us a heavy discount for this past year so we could try it one more time. Just doesn't seem to be working. And I don't think that they would disagree with that. When it comes to East Bay 100, as Robert mentioned. We gave it a go. We've tried. We think we've heard the direction that we want to go. And we think that we can work with some of our local agencies like the chamber and then also just in-house with the creation of the communications division to push that out ourselves and we don't have to rely on an outside agency as much as we did. So I remember mentioning frees up a lot of money. Which right now with what we're looking at budget wise is very important and it's going to allow us to continue some of the programs that we have here in the city. Without having to spend so much money elsewhere. Appreciate that. That was really my only question was any insight. So I know we've had conversations East Bay 100, but as far as the glass architecture, that kind of thing. So for the replacement services or courses that people don't use. Does that help perform any type of endpoints, any type of criteria for how we determine what's the next thing that's successful? These two aspects or are we just going for the answer? Let's really see how that works. Yeah. Right before I answer that question, Vice Mayor. We just gave a very short update. We had two contract services, the East Bay 100, and glass commerce that we are recommending we do not renew those contracts uh Starting with glass, we gave it a go. They're a great company and they have a really good product. It's just not built for our city. It's built for a city that maybe has more small businesses that are national chains that don't have their own online stores that can connect with a government agency like ours. East Bay 100, we've talked about that at length. And we think that we have additional bandwidth in-house as well as offers from folks like the chamber to work with them to develop something. To answer your question, Commissioner. As far as replacement and like what we've learned. We learned that we need to be able to access the data better. And I think that that came to light as we were having these discussions on knowing exactly who it's going to, where they work is a little bit of a hindrance to actually be able to determine and pivot as to where we go. So that's definitely something we're going to be looking at as we replace this whether it's Looking at our own mailing list, LinkedIn, creating mailing lists from scratch, at least we'll know where those contacts are coming from. And so we are getting great response, we can focus on those. And if we're not getting great response, we can at least see, okay, well, maybe that didn't work. Maybe trying to go And seek out people from Virginia and Texas. I picked two random states Or, you know, those aren't the target markets. And so maybe we need to look more in Southern California or the peninsula where people are getting priced out. Completely made of examples, but if we have more access to the data, we'll be able to better convey to you all what we're up against and what we can do to make it better. It was more like, well, this great response that we're targeting can how do we measure whether we achieved it or not I think as we go through developing this updated plan we're going to bring some things forward, but we're going to ask you what moves the needle in your eyes. What makes you all identify with successes? We'll come up with a list of things or you know we'll have some ideas, but we definitely want your feedback Because you all are the folks that are making the decisions and providing us guidance. And so we want you to be comfortable With what success looks like. I'll let the voice might catch up a little bit. Let me know if there's any comments? So we will go. To item number one. Actually, we're going to have some public comment, which I skipped at the beginning. Any further comment? Seeing none, we'll go to item number one, ADU accelerator. So we'll turn it over to Kelsey Gunter, Associate Planner, to provide us with just a brief update. On an EU accelerator grant program. Yes, ADO Accelerator Grant Update. The City of Pittsburgh came forward the intent to apply for a grant in a total of $190,207. We took that forward to city council on December 16th last year. City Council adopted a resolution allowing staff to move forward with applying for the grant funds. And in January, staff submitted an application for the grant funding and we were awarded the grant funding in total. At the end of January and then receive that funding at the end of February. Kind of backtrack, the grant funds are to accelerate housing production and to accelerate accessory dwelling units, which is the edu within the city of Pittsburgh. State legislation has really pushed for additional housing mix of housing types, and so this funding will really allow us to expand our housing stock and to do so in a way that allows for people to age in place and people to have additional rental income on their Property. As part of the grant funding, there's two different programs that we have. Each city that is included or eligible to apply for the grant funding was awarded $50,000 for the ADU preparation of ADU plans or to improve our ADU program within the city and then based on your population estimates, we were allotted $140,406.96 as a rebate program. So to incentivize people to invest on their property. And so the rebate program I'll start with your program and then I'll jump to the AD program. The rebate program is available to all residents within the city of Pittsburgh. And there are different levels of rebates that would be available and it isn't a first come first serve basis. It is the only round of funding that we are expected to get as part of this, but if there are some who don't utilize all of their funding or Those funds may become available in the future 2026. But for now, if you don't want to restrict your property, meaning if you want to be able to rent it at whatever income level you'd like to. $15,000 is available for units less than 500 square feet. And then it goes down $10,000 for the units 501 to 750 square feet. Than 5,000 for units 751 to 1,000. And both for de-destructive and non-restricted, anything greater than 1,000 square feet is not applicable for rebates and that's because they're wanting to have smaller smaller ideas so that people are able to build more on their properties and that smaller lots are also equally as eligible. Data restricted interviews receive more money and funding than non-infected ADUs? The leadership training process is similar to the leadership processor dual units. We would be requiring requiring a contract be recorded as a regulatory agreement to restrict the amount of rent. The City of Danville, as an example, has restricted to 80% AMI. And for a minimum period of 10 years. The city has the opportunity to change that percentage, but the minimum 20 years is and as part of as part of As we move forward with accepting or with processing rebates, we will work with our team to develop a new platform ourselves as well as our current platform. In order to issue some rebates. People who are eligible for rebates are people who have their permit issued From here on out and get their certificate of occupancy within 18 months of applying or completing that foundation. What was the total amount that you could get for de-restricted? Deed restricted for units less than 500 square feet is 15,000. I'm sorry, no leadership is 7,500. 75. Awesome. And then I'll jump now to the development of the permit ready plans. That's what we plan to use the $50,000 for. I'll just say, was there any questions before we move on? I was going to ask in terms of the criteria for the dollar amount for the units per square foot is that state law or is that what we crafted? That is from Senate District 7, so yes Yes, Senator Glazer set to stand up. You said residents an out-of-town owner would not be eligible Properties within Z. So if you own a piece of property. The Sage City recognized 20 years. As opposed to the regular 55 years on rental. And yes. And so for Rena, it would count? Yeah. And that's why, oh, come on. I don't know anything else. So this was a program that was really kind of benefiting just the citizens of the city of Pittsburgh you know increase ad use and When actually Garrett brought this to me about seven months ago when it first started. I jump right on and I say, okay, we got to get our housing element done and certified. And that was one of the criteria. So once we have our housing owners certified, we were able to move forward with applying for the grant and coming to the council back in december and We were awarded the funds in late February, as Kelsey has identified. So right now we're working through just the minutia trying to get rebates Started through a seller. So what we'll do is have it online and make it a lot easier for people to submit the final paperwork. And then we'll just cross-reference it. And then we'll start. Sending out the rebate checks. So hopefully sometime we can april But we will come back to the subcommittee and provide you guys with information in regards to who's submitting and what size dwellings and is it D restricted or non-restricted? Yes, sir. Is this available to people who currently are submitting plans for EVs? Yes. And do you need a decision or direction in terms of 80% of AMR? No, uh. Yes, we really wanted to stick with what the city of Danville had well actually what we didn't want to try to mess with the numbers. It gives a little more determination. We're not trying to go outside of anything else that we want to have put together and keep it just really specific to what the um Gosh, yeah, I do like that it talks about I guess creating that database in terms of the number of folks that have been permitted as the program starts. Have we already captured since We put in our ADU prototypes and design guidelines In terms of the number of folks that have I have numbers running for last year and this year. So in terms of people using the actual ADA plans that we took forward to council last year, you actually only had three people as part of the permit process go for those. And there's only one that's actually been issued. But people are really finding that the ADU guidebook like materials have been really beneficial. And we've had 36 AD permits issued at 2024 and 19 of those were final in 2024. So that kind of gives you a timeframe. And then 2025 this year so far, we've issued only three and we've final flat lesson. Definitely thank you for that. I guess I'm trying to see now. Because only the ones that stick to the guidelines are the ones that are fast track to them. Oh, I'm sorry. I just mean when we're helping people at the public counter and giving them the guidebook. They don't have to necessarily follow the guidebook. It's more so informational So that's one part of it. And the second part of it was an actual plan so that's been developed and there's only been three of those that people have been interested in using natural plants. That sounds like the guidelines helping them. In terms of what they're trying to put together. And I think. We kind of heard the feedback when we were doing the general plan update on EDUs and trying to get a guidebook going, but give everybody some direction. So just, I guess the third one says so with the designs, the prototypes, I guess, that we have the value in that is what fast track or permitting or So the plans that we have currently Can fast track permitting, but the main benefit of it is that the property owner or homeowner doesn't have to go out to Privately hire someone to put their plans, which is a cost ranging we've seen as low as like five grand to 7,500 and up to like 15 So providing that for free for the public is something that a lot of people find. So I just want to mention something again. We did have one case, and I'm guessing that's one of the 2024 numbers Where someone has started building and i believe it was with the guidance they provided to them and then they um didn't Or setbacks and business from their labor and all of that. I just wanted to make sure that this has already been an issue that we've had There's a little bit more attention that goes to directing the public on how to build My concern for discussing them even more so after the escape planning was that we see a lot of people asking forgiveness rather than permission So it's always a concern you know first of all, when it comes to this more work to us and then everything that is downstream consequence in terms of Safety and never remove relationships and all of that. So since we already know this has happened i just wanted to make sure something you went from and no more sternly when we don't get to the public. Thank you. Is there any additional questions, we can move on to category two. We'll have Kelsey kind of highlight that real quick. The restriction on rent, is that tied only to the ADU or the whole parcel? Just the ADU. The second category that is as part of this grant that we received is $50,000 and that is to provide additional permit ready ADU plans. So what we found with the permit ready AD plants we have now, while I've mentioned that people have used them and have to reapply. It is 748 square feet and in the city of Pittsburgh, as you're all aware, there's varying lot sizes. Some people don't have the room for 740 square feet and are looking to construct something smaller. So we are. Preparing additional plans. So we're trying to get a range of footage. So there's a bigger spread for people to choose from and select from. And so that's what we're going to use the $50,000 for. And then local designer. Oh, yes. We are working with the city's building division. We have solicited local designers that work with the city pretty frequently and then we're also going to pursue preparing an RFP to receive proposals from local designers and architects alike to submit quotes to the city. So we're able to kind of see what's out there in the pool and select one or more local architects or designers to prepare the plans. Keep them on here. Yes. But if there's any more questions or there are questions answered, but if no questions, we can go. Thank you. I have a few questions. So the smaller plan, so would you start like 500 to up to the 750. Yeah, we're actually thinking even smaller. It's very like up in the air based on what we received from the architects and designers But we're thinking even something as small as like a 300 to 400 square feet. And the reason for that is because we review types of building permits that come in most frequently. And those ones that do come in more frequently are the 400 to 600 square feet kind of range. We're super sensitive. So it's really dependent on, and Garrett brought to the So when we look at fees, we have to look at fees for building permits. We want to try to keep that threshold small because the larger the house or the greater the size of the house School fees, traffic fees, impact fees. So the smaller the unit, the smaller the fees. So we want to try to reduce that as much as we can for our citizens and not have them burden with that much. And so it's generally $749 or less. It's considerably more affordable. Awesome. Any other items on this one? No, I think we covered everything. I just want to make sure yeah so yeah sorry just came to mind. Is there a restriction for one ADU per property that is going to qualify for Rehearsal that is going to qualify for the bonus or can it do like a bigger property with two three six that takes it it's a great question. So in general, each single family law is allowed to have 180 and one JEDU. But it's a good question to see if the ADU, the funding can also be used for an ADU and the JADU. I actually need to look into that. But generally. One and one are allowed. I just don't know if the funding can be used twice for the same property. I want to say no. Because of the limitations of funding, but I may be wrong. Yeah, I don't think the ADU accelerator really called out JADUs or any additional units. And usually was permitted through the state and zoning is you're allowed single family residents ADU, JDUs, and there is provisions under SB9 where you can have an SB9, but we haven't seen anything that's come through the SAS and additional SB9 unit yet. But the ADU units are really what we're focusing on here and trying to use the money for that and get that program started and get people back in here And I guess one more question from that our only residents is the individuals eligible for the program could be corporations, for example. That are now eligible for uh for the bonus and from there on if it's the same owner with multiple parcels building multiple ideas Is this something that they would qualify for? I think that's an important consideration. You know, I'm just thinking about who can benefit from nothing else I just wanted to make sure we mentioned that. I would think that that's really important especially with the limited dollars in this pie. So I had it. Hundred some thousand dollars so if there is a way to… And if you really look at it. If you use $15,000, immediately for that it's only 10 units or the most nine. So definitely that's what we'll be taking a look at when we you know receive the rebates and who can qualify and stuff like that just to make sure we're not uh So many people pushing people forward. Because at least initially we overview. The regulations assuming it's maybe silent on them we will default to one per person, regardless of how many properties they own in the city of Pittsburgh. We can provide. Periodic updates if it is very popular we more than likely will want to keep it that way if we can so we can help more and more folks. If for whatever reason the popularity is limited and we've got a pile of money that we need to expend by September 2026, we can return to you all and see if you want to open it up for folks to potentially take A second round of cash if they want to put more APs. So we'll get more definitive guidance on that to make sure if it's something we can do, but that will be our sort of preferred direction going forward. So we're going to look into it, then one more question about the rates per square footage. I would be also very interested to find out if there's anything in the legislation speaking to potentially incentivizing Based on the the ratio of the parcel that is being built upon because i don't think this puts all parts of equal footing so if you have a huge parcel and only build a tiny little idea where you can house one person It's not the same as having the same as having smaller parcel where you put a bigger idea and then you can house two people because that's like a different number of people we're housing within the same views i don't know if there's any opportunity to factor this in um as um you know how many people are um how we are able to house with that um That I use, I think also an interesting question to keep into consideration. We'll take that note. And we'll definitely take a look at it. I didn't need to have an extra word then, but if you're looking into that, it's an interesting question. Any more questions, questions? Thank you. Awesome. And moving on to developmental updates. Thank you. And… perfect and update uh also coming down as the zoning ordinance I would say is the Magna Carta distributes everything you know that distributes everything you know within the city whether it's a business whether it's a new residence you know whether it's You know. School industry everything basically the zoning ordinance controls it. Back in 2026, the city adopted a 2040 general plan and the general plan had policies and goals that needs to be implemented and the instrument to implement that is the zoning ordinance. So the city has retained placeworks a consultant to help us come up with ways to update code. As you know, our code i think Days back to 1990 something. 1998 was the last time that we did a comprehensive update. It was the last time the general plan Before this one was adopted was in 2002. So many things have happened since then. I think the iPhone has come on board. We have Airbnb we have uh uber and EV charging stations. We were 510 back then. So a lot has happened that has not been captured with our current coordinates, so we need to bring it up to… I would say the 21st century so that's part of that effort And as a result of that. We've actually initiated a few initiatives that we are trying to you know bring this code up to date. We had a kickoff TAC meeting, a technical advisory meeting back last year november and we basically uh introduced the whole effort to all the development herds at a particular time. We have coming up a joint city council planning commission session for the 17th of this month. Where we are going to introduce it and solicit feedback and direction So that's something that we're looking forward to. We have established a web page where all the inform

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
Agenda packetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Action agendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
MinutesNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Transcript or captionsSource recordingread transcript
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Coverage and corrections

Records considered

  • Community and Economic Development Subcommittee
  • Community and Economic Development Subcommittee — Closed Captions

Not claimed by this page

  • Verified meeting decisions with item-specific public-source evidence
  • Item-level plain-language summaries are not available; this page does not infer individual agenda items.
  • Item-linked, attributed deliberation
  • A source-grounded next meeting date
  • A plain-English overview is not available.
  • Official outcomes have not been published.
  • The available transcript has no reliable timestamps.
  • Transcript coverage is partial.
  • Speakers have not been reliably matched to public profiles.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.
  • An individual roll-call roster is not available.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: 511e8360161169dbaf079b23ad36af80. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record