POLISCOPE

The public record

BREVARD COUNTY · LOCALDecisions publishedPartial coverage

Brevard County Board of County Commissioners

Tuesday, March 12, 2024 · County government meeting record

The 30-second read

Recorded outcome

Resolution recognizing March 2024 as Bleeding Disorders Awareness Month

The Brevard County Board of County Commissioners held a regular meeting to approve past minutes, adopt resolutions recognizing local awareness months and community organizations, and clarify a park agreement. The board officially recognized Bleeding Disorders Awareness Month, Florida Surveyors & Mappers Week, and the GFWC Viera Woman’s Club.

Why it matters

Residents can see how their local government allocates time for community recognition and manages public infrastructure agreements.

What happens next

No later meeting or follow-up date is stated in the reviewed record.

An official outcome record - an action agenda or minutes - is published for this meeting.

Captured actions

32

Recorded outcomes

31

Source artifacts

1

What changed

Other key decisions

31 captured items have a publicly linked outcome. These 5 are the clearest resident summaries in the record.

Search all 32 meeting actions
  • Item E.1.

    Resolution recognizing March 2024 as Bleeding Disorders Awareness Month

    Moved by Rita Pritchett · Seconded by Rob Feltner

    approved - Chair Steele read aloud, and the Board adopted Resolution No. 24-018, proclaiming the month of March 2024 as Bleeding Disorders Awareness Month. Samantha Nazario, Bleeding Foundation of Florida, stated this is their sixth year in partnership with the Board; retired Commissioner Curt Smith was the first Commissioner to ever bestow this proclamation upon them; his predecessor, former Commissioner Kristine Zonka, and now District 4; she is a mother of a son with a bleeding disorder; her son, Tyler, is 24 years old, and is a student Eastern Florida State College; and his medication and medical costs for the year can be upwards of one-half a million dollars to a million dollars. She went on to say one dose of medication is $16,000; they were just in Washington last week advocating for Senate Bill (SB) 228 in the State of Florida; another one of their wonderful co-sponsors and community supporters, Bill Posey, is the co-sponsor of House Bill (HB) 830, for the Federal Bill; and the Bill they are trying to pass is called the Help Co-Pay Bill. She noted what that Bill does is it allows every dollar that comes out of a person’s pocket go towards his or her out-of-pocket expenses for the year instead of disappearing into what they call the insurance abyss; she is sure everybody in this room pays a co-pay if they have insurance; what they learned to do in 2018 was to circumvent the previous law that stated that every dollar out of a person’s pocket went towards their out-of-pocket; and they decided to say if there was any assistance from Pharma, or anything else of that nature, a person would still owe his or her out-of-pocket, so for example, they would take her $25,000 worth of assistance, and in May they would say she was still responsible for the $5,000 out-of-pocket. She stated she is lucky enough that Tyler is not severe, he has a mild Von Willebrand disease; but in severe cases, their medication is $16,000 a dose; that could be two times a day, three times a day, to seven times a week; that could be anywhere, as she said earlier, from one-half a million to a million dollars a year medical coverage; thanks to the ACH, children like her son and other patients are covered, and are no longer uninsurable as they would have been in the past; and if a person does not know what a bleeding disorder is, to please Google the Bleeding Disorder Foundation of Florida, or the National Bleeding Disorder Foundation and educate themselves. She explained one or two percent of the population of the United States of America is undiagnosed with a bleeding disorder, and does not know until it is entirely too late; in the State of Florida they have 6,000 patients, and 433 of those patients call Brevard County home, including administrators, staff, and a lot of the kids here; she expressed her appreciation to Brevard County for continuing its partnership with them; and she stated she looks forward to continuing it for as long as she can.
  • Item E.2.

    Resolution, RE: Florida Surveyors & Mappers Week in Brevard County

    Moved by Rob Feltner · Seconded by Tom Goodson

    approved - Commissioner Feltner read aloud, and the Board adopted Resolution No. 24-019, recognizing March 17 - 23, 2024, as Florida Surveyors & Mappers Week in Brevard County.
  • Item E.3.

    Resolution acknowledging GFWC Viera Woman’s Club

    Moved by Rob Feltner · Seconded by Rita Pritchett

    approved - Commissioner Feltner read aloud, and the Board adopted Resolution No. 24-020, recognizing General Federation of Women’s Club (GFWC) Viera Woman’s Club, an April 8, 2024, as Turn Compassion into Action Day in Brevard County.
  • Item F.1.

    Committee Appointments RE: Public School Facility Planning and Concurrency Interlocal Agreement

    Moved by Rob Feltner · Seconded by Rita Pritchett

    approved - The Board appointed Keith Neterer as the County’s representative to the Educational Facilities Impact Fee Benefit District Committee and Educational Facilities Capital Outlay Committee, and appointed Jeffrey King and Naomi Adkins-Hicks as alternates.
  • Item F.2.

    Final Plat and Contract Approval, Re: Christian Commons Developer: Plumosa Investment Partners, LLC District 2

    Moved by Rob Feltner · Seconded by Rita Pritchett

    approved - The Board, in accordance with Section 62-2841(i) and Section 62-2844, granted final plat approval; and authorized the Chair to sign the final plat and Subdivision Infrastructure Contract for Christian Commons, Developer: Plumosa Investment Partner, LLC, subject to minor engineering changes, as applicable, and developer responsible for obtaining all other necessary jurisdictional permits.

Recorded votes

7 recorded votes0 split

Split votes (0)

Every recorded vote passed unanimously.

Unanimous votes (7)

Voting yes on all of these (5)

Pritchettyes
Goodsonyes
Tobiayes
Feltneryes
Steeleyes
passed

Agreement with Drown Zero for Drown Zero Stations

passed

Brevard County Space Coast Area Transit PTASP Update 2023

passed

Brevard Zoo Linear Park Agreement

passed

Committee Appointments RE: Public School Facility Planning

passed

Final Plat and Contract Approval, Re: Christian Commons

passed

Financing options for Environmentally Endangered Lands (EEL) Program

passed

Transportation Impact Fee Technical Advisory Committee Funding

Money

People and votes

Rita Pritchett

County Commissioner

Open person dossier

3 motions · 19 seconds · 7 recorded votes

  1. MotionItem E.1.

    Resolution recognizing March 2024 as Bleeding Disorders Awareness Month - Moved the recorded motion.

    Official record
  2. SecondItem E.3.

    Resolution acknowledging GFWC Viera Woman’s Club - Seconded the recorded motion.

    Official record
  3. SecondItem F.1.

    Committee Appointments RE: Public School Facility Planning and Concurrency Interlocal Agreement - Seconded the recorded motion.

    Official record
  4. SecondItem F.2.

    Final Plat and Contract Approval, Re: Christian Commons Developer: Plumosa Investment Partners, LLC District 2 - Seconded the recorded motion.

    Official record
  5. SecondItem F.3.

    Approval RE: Transportation Impact Fee Technical Advisory Committee for the North Mainland Benefit District Project Funding Recommendations (Districts 1 and 2) - Seconded the recorded motion.

    Official record
  6. SecondItem F.4.

    Approval, Re: Donation of Right of Way by Warranty Deed from West Malabar Properties, L.L.C. for the Benefit of the DR Horton Signalization Plans at the lntersection of Minton Road and Hield Road - District 5. - Seconded the recorded motion.

    Official record
  7. SecondItem F.5.

    Approval, Re: Donation of Utility Easement from Merritt Island Lodge No. 2073 Loyal Order of Moose, Inc. for the Armen Groves Subdivision - District 2. - Seconded the recorded motion.

    Official record
  8. SecondItem F.6.

    Approval, Re: Dedication of Roadway, Drainage, Utility and Sidewalk Easement from Tootie's Grocery, LLC and Dedication of Right of Way by Warranty Deed from 2354 Talmadge Drive, LLC Related to Phase 1 and 2 of Site Plan Number 21SP00005 - District 1. - Seconded the recorded motion.

    Official record
  9. SecondItem F.7.

    Approval, Re: Dedication of Right of Way by Quit Claim Deed from Mike Erdman Motors, Inc. and Plumosa Investment Partners, LLC Related to the Christian Commons Plat - District 2. - Seconded the recorded motion.

    Official record
  10. SecondItem F.8.

    Approval, Re: Dedication of Drainage Easement from Epler Park, LLC for the Epler Commercial Park Project - District 5. - Seconded the recorded motion.

    Official record
  11. SecondItem F.10.

    Approval; RE: Authorization to explore financing options for Environmentally Endangered Lands (EEL) Program capital improvements and equipment, land acquisition and land acquisition services. - Seconded the recorded motion.

    Official record
  12. SecondItem F.11.

    Approval, Re: Brevard County Space Coast Area Transit Public Transportation Agency Safety Plan (PTASP) Update 2023. - Seconded the recorded motion.

    Official record
  13. SecondItem F.12.

    Board Approval: Agreement Between Brevard County Board of County Commissioners and Drown Zero for Provision, Maintenance, and Supply of Drown Zero Stations. - Seconded the recorded motion.

    Official record
  14. MotionItem H.1.

    Interlocal Agreement to Transfer James Road Extension to City of Cocoa - Moved the recorded motion.

    Official record
  15. SecondItem F.13.

    Acceptance and Approval of Internal Audit Reports - Seconded the recorded motion.

    Official record
  16. SecondItem F.14.

    Appointment(s) / Reappointment(s) - Seconded the recorded motion.

    Official record
  17. SecondItem F.15.

    Bill Folder - Seconded the recorded motion.

    Official record
  18. MotionItem G.2.

    Petition to Vacate, Re: Public Rights-of-ways - Virginia Avenue & Maple Street - “June Park Addition No. 3” Plat Book 4, Page 74 - Melbourne - Andrew W. Powshok - District 5 - Moved the recorded motion.

    Official record
  19. SecondItem I.2.

    Approval, Re: Resolution and Maintenance Maps for Rockledge Drive Right-of-Way (four section maps) from U.S. Highway 1 to 1851 Rockledge Drive located in unincorporated Brevard County - District 2. - Seconded the recorded motion.

    Official record
  20. SecondItem I.6.

    Legislative Intent and Permission to Advertise an Ordinance Amending Chapter 74, Article VI, Section 74-102, Brevard County Code of Ordinances, Pertaining to Sexual Offenders and Sexual Predators. - Seconded the recorded motion.

    Official record
  21. Second

    Approval; Re: Brevard Zoo Linear Park Agreement with the East Coast Zoological Society, Inc. (District 4) - Seconded the recorded motion.

    Official record
  22. SecondItem I.5.

    Permission to Advertise, Re: Request for Proposal (RFP) for State Lobbying Services - Seconded the recorded motion.

    Official record
  23. Recorded vote

    Agreement with Drown Zero for Drown Zero Stations - Voted yes on the motion “Approve and execute agreement for provision, maintenance, and supply of Drown Zero stations.”; the record reports passed.

  24. Recorded vote

    Brevard County Space Coast Area Transit PTASP Update 2023 - Voted yes on the motion “Approve and execute the update to the Public Transportation Agency Safety Plan.”; the record reports passed.

  25. Recorded vote

    Brevard Zoo Linear Park Agreement - Voted yes on the motion “Approve and authorize the Chair to execute the Brevard Zoo Linear Park Agreement.”; the record reports passed.

  26. Recorded vote

    Committee Appointments RE: Public School Facility Planning - Voted yes on the motion “Appoint Keith Neterer as representative and Jeffrey King and Naomi Adkins-Hicks as alternates to the Educational Facilities committees.”; the record reports passed.

  27. Recorded vote

    Final Plat and Contract Approval, Re: Christian Commons - Voted yes on the motion “Grant final plat approval and authorize Chair to sign plat and infrastructure contract.”; the record reports passed.

  28. Recorded vote

    Financing options for Environmentally Endangered Lands (EEL) Program - Voted yes on the motion “Authorize staff to research financing for $3.2M in capital improvements and $3M for land acquisition.”; the record reports passed.

  29. Recorded vote

    Transportation Impact Fee Technical Advisory Committee Funding - Voted yes on the motion “Approve disbursement of $3,099,586 and reallocation of $330,463 for North Mainland Benefit District projects.”; the record reports passed.

See all 7 roll calls with named votes

Record text

No recording or transcript is held for this meeting.

Showing the first 60,000 of 105,541 characters. The full document is at the source.

Tuesday, March 12, 2024 5:00 PM Brevard County Board of County Commissioners 2725 Judge Fran Jamieson Way Viera, FL 32940 Commission Chambers Minutes Regular March 12, 2024 Rollcall Commissioner District 1 Rita Pritchett, Commissioner District 2 Tom Goodson, Commissioner District 3 John Tobia, Commissioner District 4 Rob Feltner, and Commissioner District 5 Jason Steele Present: A. CALL TO ORDER 5:01 PM C. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE Commissioner Goodson led the assembly in the Pledge of Allegiance. D. MINUTES FOR APPROVAL The Board approved the January 23, 2024, Regular Meeting, February 1, 2024, Zoning Meeting, and February 6, 2024, Regular Meeting Minutes. Result: APPROVED Mover: Tom Goodson Seconder: John Tobia Ayes: Pritchett, Goodson, Tobia, Feltner, and Steele E.1. Resolution recognizing March 2024 as Bleeding Disorders Awareness Month Chair Steele read aloud, and the Board adopted Resolution No. 24-018, proclaiming the month of March 2024 as Bleeding Disorders Awareness Month. Samantha Nazario, Bleeding Foundation of Florida, stated this is their sixth year in partnership with the Board; retired Commissioner Curt Smith was the first Commissioner to ever bestow this proclamation upon them; his predecessor, former Commissioner Kristine Zonka, and now District 4; she is a mother of a son with a bleeding disorder; her son, Tyler, is 24 years old, and is a student Eastern Florida State College; and his medication and medical costs for the year can be upwards of one-half a million dollars to a million dollars. She went on to say one dose of medication is $16,000; they were just in Washington last week advocating for Senate Bill (SB) 228 in the State of Florida; another one of their wonderful co-sponsors and community supporters, Bill Posey, is the co-sponsor of House Bill (HB) 830, for the Federal Bill; and the Bill they are trying to pass is called the Help Co-Pay Bill. She noted what that Bill does is it allows every dollar that comes out of a person’s pocket go towards his or her out-of-pocket expenses for the year instead of disappearing into what they call the insurance abyss; she is sure everybody in this room pays a co-pay if they have insurance; what they learned to do in 2018 was to circumvent the previous law that stated that every dollar out of a person’s pocket went towards their out-of-pocket; and they decided to say if there was any assistance from Pharma, or anything else of that nature, a person would still owe his or her out-of-pocket, so for example, they would take her $25,000 worth of assistance, and in May they would say she was still responsible for the $5,000 out-of-pocket. She stated she is lucky enough that Tyler is not severe, he has a mild Von Willebrand disease; but in severe cases, their medication is $16,000 a dose; that could be two times a day, three times a day, to seven times a week; that could be anywhere, as she said earlier, from one-half a million to a million dollars a year medical coverage; thanks to the ACH, children like her son and other patients are covered, and are no longer uninsurable as they would have been in the past; and if a person does not know what a bleeding disorder is, to please Google the Bleeding Disorder Foundation of Florida, or the National Bleeding Disorder Foundation and educate themselves. She explained one or two percent of the population of the United States of America is undiagnosed with a bleeding disorder, and does not know until it is entirely too late; in the State of Florida they have 6,000 Page 1 of 31 March 12, 2024 patients, and 433 of those patients call Brevard County home, including administrators, staff, and a lot of the kids here; she expressed her appreciation to Brevard County for continuing its partnership with them; and she stated she looks forward to continuing it for as long as she can. Result: ADOPTED Mover: Rita Pritchett Seconder: Rob Feltner Ayes: Pritchett, Goodson, Tobia, Feltner, and Steele E.2. Resolution, RE: Florida Surveyors & Mappers Week in Brevard County Commissioner Feltner read aloud, and the Board adopted Resolution No. 24-019, recognizing March 17 - 23, 2024, as Florida Surveyors & Mappers Week in Brevard County. Result: ADOPTED Mover: Rob Feltner Seconder: Tom Goodson Ayes: Pritchett, Goodson, Tobia, Feltner, and Steele Tony Vitale, Survey Staff Specialist, Survey and Mapper, expressed his appreciation to all of the local surveyors in Brevard County for all of the great work that they do, supporting the community with all of the new development happening for the past 30 years that he has been here; he advised he also wanted to thank the County’s staff, County Surveyor, Mike Sweeney, Amber Holley, Vacating Specialist, and all of the other great people in their office; they always do a great job; and he cannot wait until next year, and do it all over again. E.3. Resolution acknowledging GFWC Viera Woman’s Club Commissioner Feltner read aloud, and the Board adopted Resolution No. 24-020, recognizing General Federation of Women’s Club (GFWC) Viera Woman’s Club, an April 8, 2024, as Turn Compassion into Action Day in Brevard County. Result: ADOPTED Mover: Rob Feltner Seconder: Rita Pritchett Ayes: Pritchett, Goodson, Tobia, Feltner, and Steele Kam Gates, President of GFWC Viera Woman’s Club, expressed her appreciation to the Board for the Resolution; she stated together, with their community, they make a difference one interaction at a time as they turn compassion into action; Viera Woman’s Club has served the Brevard County community for 20 years with inspiring hard work, dedication, and selfless groups of women working together on a variety of community service projects and programs; and their members proudly utilize their time and talents to meet specific needs for numerous non-profit organizations in Brevard County and beyond. She went on to say in 2023, their club volunteered 13,364 hours, and their projects were 89; they donated $29,318; in kind donations was $9,282; and along with past presidents and members, it is with sincere gratitude that she accepts the Resolution on behalf of the GFWC Viera Woman’s Club. F.9. Approval; Re: Brevard Zoo Linear Park Agreement with the East Coast Zoological Society, Inc. (District 4) Sandra Sullivan stated her comment is about Brevard County Parks and Recreation taking over the Zoo, Zip Line portion; when searching for that property on the Property Appraiser’s website, Page 2 of 31 March 12, 2024 and a person searches for that property, the Zip Line is within that property that is owned by the Zoo; she asked if any of the Board Members have Zip Lined in there, because she has; and she stated a person is literally Zip Lining over the monkeys and different areas, and literally in the Zoo. She continued by saying it would be really nice to hear from the Board why, they as taxpayers, are taking over the running of a portion of the Zoo, because this is a really odd Agenda Item. Commissioner Tobia pointed out by reading the Item, it is pretty clear as it says Linear Park; a Zip Line is a straight line, so he gets where the misunderstanding is, but it has nothing to do with the Zip Line; and if Ms. Sullivan had read a little bit further, it is the walkway that is called Linear Park, so it is not anywhere near the Zip Line. He noted the Parks and Recreation Director, he believes, will say the same information; he would not mind taking over the Zip Line part, it is a money-making thing; but unfortunately, that is not it. Mary Ellen Donner, Parks and Recreation Director, advised she is here to answer any questions from the Board. Commissioner Tobia asked if this transfer would be Linear Park as it says in the outline, or will it be the Zip Line facility. Ms. Donner responded it is not the Zip Line facility, it is 2.8 miles of the Linear Park. F.1. Committee Appointments RE: Public School Facility Planning and Concurrency Interlocal Agreement The Board appointed Keith Neterer as the County’s representative to the Educational Facilities Impact Fee Benefit District Committee and Educational Facilities Capital Outlay Committee, and appointed Jeffrey King and Naomi Adkins-Hicks as alternates. Result: APPROVED Mover: Rob Feltner Seconder: Rita Pritchett F.2. Final Plat and Contract Approval, Re: Christian Commons Developer: Plumosa Investment Partners, LLC District 2 The Board, in accordance with Section 62-2841(i) and Section 62-2844, granted final plat approval; and authorized the Chair to sign the final plat and Subdivision Infrastructure Contract for Christian Commons, Developer: Plumosa Investment Partner, LLC, subject to minor engineering changes, as applicable, and developer responsible for obtaining all other necessary jurisdictional permits. Result: APPROVED Mover: Rob Feltner Seconder: Rita Pritchett F.3. Approval RE: Transportation Impact Fee Technical Advisory Committee for the North Mainland Benefit District Project Funding Recommendations (Districts 1 and 2) The Board approved disbursement of $3,099.586 and the reallocation of $330,463 in Transportation Impact Fees in accordance with the recommendations prepared by the Transportation Impact Fee Technical Advisory Committee for the North Mainland Benefit District, which appropriates a total of $3,430,049; and authorized the Budget Office to execute any Budget Change Requests necessary for implementing these appropriations. Page 3 of 31 March 12, 2024 Result: APPROVED Mover: Rob Feltner Seconder: Rita Pritchett F.4. Approval, Re: Donation of Right of Way by Warranty Deed from West Malabar Properties, L.L.C. for the Benefit of the DR Horton Signalization Plans at the lntersection of Minton Road and Hield Road - District 5. The Board approved and accepted the donation of right-of-way by Warranty Deed from West Malabar properties, LLC for the benefit of DR Horton Signalization Plans at the intersection of Minton Road and Hield Road. Result: APPROVED Mover: Rob Feltner Seconder: Rita Pritchett F.5. Approval, Re: Donation of Utility Easement from Merritt Island Lodge No. 2073 Loyal Order of Moose, Inc. for the Armen Groves Subdivision - District 2. The Board approved and accepted the donation of Utility Easement from Merritt Island Lodge No. 2073, Loyal Order of the Moose, Inc. for the Armen Groves Subdivision. Result: APPROVED Mover: John Tobia Seconder: Rita Pritchett F.6. Approval, Re: Dedication of Roadway, Drainage, Utility and Sidewalk Easement from Tootie's Grocery, LLC and Dedication of Right of Way by Warranty Deed from 2354 Talmadge Drive, LLC Related to Phase 1 and 2 of Site Plan Number 21SP00005 - District 1. The Board approved and accepted the dedication of Roadway, Drainage, Utility, and Sidewalk Easement from Tootie’s Grocery, LLC; and approved and accepted the right-of-way by Warranty Deed from 2354 Talmadge Drive, LLC related to Phase 1 and 2 of Site Plan Number 21SP00005. Result: APPROVED Mover: Rob Feltner Seconder: Rita Pritchett F.7. Approval, Re: Dedication of Right of Way by Quit Claim Deed from Mike Erdman Motors, Inc. and Plumosa Investment Partners, LLC Related to the Christian Commons Plat - District 2. The Board approved and accepted the dedication of right-of-way by Quit Claim Deed from Mike Erdman Motors, Inc. and Plumosa Investment Partners, LLC related to the Christian Commons Plat. Result: APPROVED Mover: Rob Feltner Seconder: Rita Pritchett F.8. Approval, Re: Dedication of Drainage Easement from Epler Park, LLC for the Epler Commercial Park Project - District 5. The Board approved and accepted the dedication of Drainage Easement from Epler Park, LLC for the Epler Commercial Park Project. Page 4 of 31 March 12, 2024 Result: APPROVED Mover: Rob Feltner Seconder: Rita Pritchett Approval; Re: Brevard Zoo Linear Park Agreement with the East Coast Zoological Society, Inc. (District 4) The Board approved and authorized the Chair to execute the Brevard Zoo Linear Park Agreement with the East Coast Zoological Society, Inc. Result: APPROVED Mover: Rob Feltner Seconder: Rita Pritchett F.10. Approval; RE: Authorization to explore financing options for Environmentally Endangered Lands (EEL) Program capital improvements and equipment, land acquisition and land acquisition services. The Board authorized staff to research and implement the most efficient and cost-effective financing options for the following: to fund, not to exceed $3.2 million aggregate principal amount for capital improvements and equipment to improve and maintain existing facilities and conservation lands, and to fund, not to exceed $3 million aggregate principal amount for the initial land acquisition of additional conservation lands with specific focus on lands that directly benefit the Indian River Lagoon and St. Johns River; and begin the Request for Proposal (RFP) process to seek qualified applicants with demonstrated expertise and success in conservation land real estate acquisition and bring the best qualified applicant(s) back to the Board for consideration. Result: APPROVED Mover: Rob Feltner Seconder: Rita Pritchett F.11. Approval, Re: Brevard County Space Coast Area Transit Public Transportation Agency Safety Plan (PTASP) Update 2023. The Board approved and executed the update to Brevard County Space Coast Area Transit Public Transportation Safety (PTASP) 2023. Result: APPROVED Mover: Rob Feltner Seconder: Rita Pritchett F.12. Board Approval: Agreement Between Brevard County Board of County Commissioners and Drown Zero for Provision, Maintenance, and Supply of Drown Zero Stations. The Board approved and executed the Agreement between Brevard County Board of County Commissioners and Drown Zero for provision, maintenance, and supply of Drown Zero stations; and delegated the County Manager approval authority, as appropriate and necessary, for any administrative actions, extension, amendments, or Budget Change Requests as required. Result: APPROVED Mover: Rob Feltner Seconder: Rita Pritchett Page 5 of 31 March 12, 2024 F.13. Acceptance and Approval of Internal Audit Reports The Board acknowledged and approved the Internal Auditor’s Reports. Result: APPROVED Mover: Rob Feltner Seconder: Rita Pritchett F.14. Appointment(s) / Reappointment(s) The Board appointed/reappointed Larry Brown to the Diamond Square CRA (Cocoa), with term expiring March 24, 2028; Frank Catino to the Marine Advisory Council, with term expiring December 31, 2025; and Terri Friedlander and Vincent Grillo as alternates to Transportation Planning Organization (TPO) Citizens Advisory Committee, with terms expiring December 31, 2024. Result: APPROVED Mover: Rob Feltner Seconder: Rita Pritchett F.15. Bill Folder The Board acknowledged receipt of the Bill Folder. Result: APPROVED Mover: Rob Feltner Seconder: Rita Pritchett G.1. Request for Public Interest Determination (PID) for the Marker 99 restaurant, formerly known as Captain Katana’s, Inc., to allow an approximately 122 square foot deck expansion, exceedance of 30 percent impervious areas within the surface water protection buffer (Buffer), and an exception to the Natural Resources Management (NRM) stormwater management requirement. (District 4) Chair Steele called for a public hearing to consider a Public Interest Determination (PID) for the Marker 99 Restaurant, formerly known as Captain Katana’s, Inc., allowing an approximately 122 square foot deck expansion, exceedance of 30 percent impervious areas within the surface water protection buffer, and an exception to the Natural Resources Management (NRM) stormwater management requirement (Tax Account Numbers 2611662 and 2611664). Amanda Elmore, Planning and Development Deputy Director, advised she was present for any questions the Board may have. There being no comments or objections, the Board considered and approved Option 1, approving a PID as presented, including all mitigating site plan provision by Monroe Engineering, Inc. on behalf of IR Tiki 2, LLC for Marker 99 Restaurant and Tiki Bar at 4263 North Highway 1, Melbourne. Result: APPROVED Mover: Rob Feltner Seconder: John Tobia Ayes: Pritchett, Goodson, Tobia, Feltner, and Steele G.2. Petition to Vacate, Re: Public Rights-of-ways - Virginia Avenue & Maple Street - “June Park Addition No. 3” Plat Book 4, Page 74 - Melbourne - Andrew W. Page 6 of 31 March 12, 2024 Powshok - District 5 Chair Steele called for a public hearing to consider petition to vacate a portion of public rights-of-way in plat June Park Addition No. 3, Melbourne, as petitioned by Andrew Powshok. Marian Huston stated she wants to let the Board know she is not here alone, she has other community members with her in the audience, she is just the speaker for tonight; they are opposed to allowing this to happen, because it is going to tear up private roads; it is going to interfere with the safety of their children in their neighborhood; they were not notified that this was something that was going to occur when they purchased in this neighborhood; and they are a gated, private street, they pay for the roadway and their walkway, and this plat that they are going to have access to, they have the options to do well water, to do septic, which would not require them to then tear into their roadway, and to disrupt their community. She continued by saying they also have an option to utilize other means of getting access to this property, which she believes may be government property that they can access this property from, and these so-called paper roads that they can also utilize rather than coming through a private neighborhood; this is also a property that sits between two bodies of water, and it also houses a lot of wildlife; there has been Eagles resting up there; they have Gopher Turtles nesting there; and there are also Sand Hill Cranes. She asked the Board to take into consideration to make sure that is safe for the wildlife as well. Commissioner Goodson asked what the purpose of this is, and could someone give the Board a better understanding of what is trying to be accomplished. Marc Bernath, Public Works Director, replied this is a request to vacate by Mr. Powshok; from a staff perspective, they are reviewing the vacating request, and then proposing that to the Board; this particular owner is looking to add water, sewer, and then to ultimately annex the property into the City of West Melbourne; as noted, there are several objections; but there is an ingress/egress easement granted across the private roads by the developer; and this is not part of the platted subdivision. Commissioner Goodson asked if the Board does approve it, will that all be attached to the resolution that he has to do those things. Mr. Bernath responded the resolution is specific to the vacating. Commissioner Goodson asked if the comments Mr. Bernath made will be in that resolution. Mr. Bernath responded affirmatively. Chair Steele explained he sat through the briefing in regards to this and he asked several questions; he understands the residents’ concerns; but apparently, this lot was not included in the original subdivision in the first place; and he asked Mr. Bernath if that is correct. Mr. Bernath replied that is correct. Chair Steele pointed out it is kind of sitting out there in the middle of no place; it needs to be done if Mr. Powshok is going to connect the sewer, water, and all of those other issues; that is what he heard at the briefing; and he is fine with it. There being no further comments or objections, the Board adopted Resolution No. 24-021, Page 7 of 31 March 12, 2024 vacating a portion of two public rights-of-way in plat of June Park Addition No. 3, Melbourne, as petitioned by Andrew Powshok. Result: ADOPTED Mover: Rita Pritchett Seconder: John Tobia Ayes: Pritchett, Goodson, Tobia, Feltner, and Steele H.1. Interlocal Agreement to Transfer James Road Extension to City of Cocoa Morris Richardson, County Attorney, explained this is one more piece of the 2007 Settlement Agreement between the County, the City of Cocoa, and several developers who own the properties at the northeastern and southeastern intersections of I-95 and State Road (SR) 528; this one is specific to the southeastern portion; that Agreement provided access to the development on the southeast, which is now known as the Windward Preserve Subdivision, located entirely within the City of Cocoa, that they would have an access across James Road; the developer had applied to Brevard County for a permit to construct an extension of James Road, west of Friday Road, where it currently ends for access to that subdivision; and because it is only going to serve a subdivision within the City of Cocoa and Cocoa residents, everyone agreed that Cocoa should ultimately have the maintenance responsibility for that James Road extension, so this is an agreement that is going to transfer the segment of James Road west of Friday Road to I-95 to the City of Cocoa for construction of that roadway. He went on to say the County will maintain ownership and control of the 50-foot drainage right-of-way south of that segment; the County will still have permit authority for the discharge into that right-of-way; this agreement does not give authority to discharge into that right-of-way; they would still have to go through all permitting for drainage and things like that; and he is happy to answer any questions. Rick Heffelfinger commented he is kind of surprised to see the interlocal agreement, and the fact that the permit closed; he has a public records request in that is almost a month old now; he was going to try to figure out what was going on, because he was concerned about the water; he heard now that the County Attorney said the County has not permitted any water into the James Canal; he hopes that is true; he wanted to verify that for himself by getting records; and one month later, he does not have records. He noted he has put in written questions to Public Works he guesses about if there is a water permit special; he asked how the permit closed; he stated the last he heard, it had to be determined if it was going to be a public or private road; he asked if it is a public or a private road, because somebody threw signs up that say ‘No Trespassing’; and he pointed out, as far as he knows, it is still a public road. He advised he would love for someone to answer that; no one even wanted to go down there a file a Code complaint that somebody put illegally-placed signs on Brevard County right-of-way without a permit; the County wants to charge him for public records requests, that is fine; but he asked why the County does not collect some fines that are due; the Commissioners have no idea how many emails he went through to try to get a response on that; somebody tried to, and he believes it was the developer or the owner, to intimidate the citizens, because they have been down there watching what they are doing; it turns out there is an Eagle on the property; and he asked who would have guessed. He asked if it is a public road and can he go down there; he stated last he heard, he could; he asked whose idea was it to say it was private property; he remarked great job defending Brevard County residents, the Board is holding the line for them; there is a single-point exit for a crap-load of houses; he asked if the County did a safety inspection of that intersection; the permit was supposed to have questions from the County from one of the engineers about how that intersection was going to be improved; and he stated he does not know because nobody gave him his public records. He stated he hopes Page 8 of 31 March 12, 2024 the County has a good answer, because when he gets his public records, he is going to make sure it did a thorough job; he thinks this whole thing is stinky, stinky; he is trying to do his due diligence and he cannot get records; he does not get answers to any questions; nobody enforces Code Enforcement about a sign trying to intimidate the citizens; he asked if this what he expects from his County Commission and his government; and Marc Bernath is the Director, and is he here today. He mentioned Mr. Bernath was the only one who reached out and said the County will have them remove the signs; he asked if it had to escalate to that; he noted he is trying to make sure the County is doing it right, and he will continue; but so far, the County is non-cooperative, and he is disappointed. Commissioner Pritchett asked Mr. Heffelfinger how long ago he put public records requests in. Mr. Heffelfinger asked if she wants him to go through the questions. Commissioner Pritchett replied no, if he will just tell her the date; she is going to ask questions and see if there was a hang up, and check what is going on; and she asked again how long ago he made the request. Mr. Heffelfinger advised he has it here somewhere; and he has more paperwork than the Board does. Commissioner Pritchett stated if he will just let her know, she will take a peek and see. Mr. Heffelfinger pointed out he was supposed to have them earlier this week, but there were multiple questions that were not answered; and he asked if there is a water variance of some kind. Commissioner Tobia explained that a question and a public records request are two different things; and a question requires maybe engineering to get involved. Mr. Heffelfinger asked if she is an engineer in Public Works. Commissioner Tobia noted a public record is something that already exists; he does not know when Mr. Heffelfinger put it in; but he pretty much can guarantee if he put in something that already exists . . . Mr. Heffelfinger advised put in and paid for, the County already cashed his check; and it was $147. Commissioner Tobia explained a couple of the Commissioners will get on this; but to be clear, a question and a public records request are two different things. Mr. Heffelfinger asked what about requesting in an email, who manages that. Commissioner Tobia commented that is not a public record. Mr. Heffelfinger asked who answers the questions; and he never got an answer. Commissioner Tobia remarked he does not know what the question was and where that would be directed; but the County is under State Statute when it comes to the timely return of public records; questions could require a whole bunch of stuff to be answered, figures to be done, and engineering to happen; and that is completely different. He stated he just wants Mr. Heffelfinger Page 9 of 31 March 12, 2024 to be very clear that a public record is a document that already exists; staff does a pretty good darned job in getting those turned around exceedingly quickly, because it is work that does not have to be done other than gathering information and putting it together, unless it has to be redacted or something like that; he does not know what the request is; but those cannot be used interchangeably. He reiterated that questions and public records are different; he and Commissioner Pritchett will look into that; and if it was paid for, it will be looked into, and an answer will be given. Mr. Heffelfinger stated he expects his four hours worth, putting that together for that permit. Sandra Sullivan commented as stated by the County Attorney, there was a court-ordered Stipulated Agreement with some terms and one of them pertaining to Friday Road was traffic- calming; in the Stipulated Agreement it specifies a meeting with the people who live there to put input into where that traffic-calming should go; this is a little bit different Commission, but some of them were here back with Rockledge trees drive; and there was a public meeting held with the Commissioner to take that feedback. She went on to say there are quite a few issues pertaining with these, as referred to as Commissioner Rita, as the Brightline development north and south of SR 528 and I-95; there are a number of things; related to this, she would ask the Board to hold off on a motion until that public meeting is held, to get the input and answer the questions that the community has pertaining both to the Canaveral Groves and this one, especially since the statement was made that no decision was made on the Angelica Road thoroughfare to an urban development from a rural development; and she reiterated the request is for a meeting for these people that live in these communities. The Board approved an Interlocal Agreement transferring to the City of Cocoa the road right-of-way, maintenance, and associated functional responsibilities for James Road, west of Friday Road, to I-95; and authorized the chair to sign the Interlocal Agreement and associated County Deed. Result: APPROVED Mover: Rita Pritchett Seconder: John Tobia Ayes: Pritchett, Goodson, Tobia, Feltner, and Steele I.1. Appeal Request Re: Appeal to Denied Sidewalk Waiver for Storsafe of Rockledge (23WV00020) (22SP00038)(District 2) Cole Oliver, Attorney for the applicant, stated this is an appeal for denial of a sidewalk waiver; his client owns the property; it was a former Harbor Groves site on the intersection of Barnes Boulevard and US 1; they are in the process of developing a self-storage facility there; the client has requested a waiver from the requirement to install a sidewalk; and in lieu of a total waiver, they have requested from staff a waiver to an assessment agreement whereby they would agree to pay for and build a sidewalk at a future date when the County is connecting the rest of the sidewalks. He continued by saying there are very limited sidewalks within that area; he thinks the only ones he can remember are the ones right at the intersection where it is crossing over US 1 where the railroad was that Brightline put in; by going north, he does not believe there is another sidewalk for a couple of miles; and by moving south, there is a couple of sporadic pieces. He commented specifically, a parcel of his client's land just south of there, the County entered into a similar sidewalk assessment agreement along US 1, 18 months ago; the reasons behind this sidewalk request is it is really not going anywhere, and instead of being a sidewalk, it is kind of a side stand; the client has had issues with people that come onto the property and setup shop, start selling t-shirts, and other trespassing activities; and with a Page 10 of 31 March 12, 2024 storage facility, they want to keep it safe. He stated they believe having a sidewalk there that connects to nothing else would be a safety issue for their customers coming and going from the facility; with that, he is here for any questions the Board may have; and he respectfully requests the assessment agreement. Commissioner Goodson stated right now for a six-inch, five-foot wide sidewalk, they are going for $9.25 a foot; what he does not understand about the developer is a sidewalk was there on the beginning of initial plans all the way through permitting; sometimes a person has to be first; but at the same token, he is more in tune to a bond placed on the land that would guarantee that the County could either go to the bond if the developer sold or did not want to build, and have a guarantee the County would have it; and if a person understands anything about construction, there is always the first that has to go in. He went on by saying that Mr. Oliver is absolutely correct, the nearest sidewalk is on Park Avenue going north; the next nearest is over the railroad tracks on Barnes Boulevard, which goes nowhere; it might be 75 feet; he found out from staff that it is hard to get these people, and it is no reflection on Mr. Oliver, the developers, to put a sidewalk in, because everything he hears about plans is the bitch about a sidewalk, so the County is either going to change the variances or do something to guarantee; they put up a two-year maintenance bond if he is not mistaken; and he asked staff if that is correct. Tad Calkins, Planning and Development Director, replied a performance bond is required for things that are built in a right-of-way; and then the maintenance of that work is required by a maintenance bond. Commissioner Goodson asked if that is a two-year maintenance bond. Mr. Calkins responded yes, that is correct. Commissioner Goodson mentioned then the County has the option to point out the faults and then the builder has to correct those faults before it is accepted by the County; and he asked if that is correct. Mr. Calkins responded affirmatively. Commissioner Goodson remarked he does not understand why the owner wants to postpone this, because things could go up; right now at 800 feet, five-foot wide times $9.25 is somewhere around $45,000, so everyone wants to save money; that is the last thing to do before landscaping is the sidewalk; and he is all for a bond, not for a variance. Commissioner Tobia asked for a little leeway, as he has a few questions; he stated Commissioner Goodson may be a little afraid because the two of them may be on the same side; he is sorry he did not get in touch with Mr. Oliver before today; these are things that could probably have been answered behind the scenes; but Mr. Oliver did not reach out to him. He went on to say clearly, Mr. Oliver is aware of Section 62-2956(b)(2), Brevard County Code of Ordinances, which requires the developer to, “provide sidewalks adjacent to the roadway abutting their project.” Mr. Oliver advised he is. Commissioner Tobia explained Commissioner Goodson did a good job; and he asked if that was there prior to this land being purchased. Mr. Oliver responded yes. Page 11 of 31 March 12, 2024 Commissioner Tobia asked when the site plan was created, when the requirements were outlined that was just gone over regarding the Brevard County Code of Ordinances, were they in place at that time. Mr. Oliver replied he would agree. Commissioner Tobia stated Section 62-2956, goes on to say “requirements can be waived administratively in areas where it can be demonstrated by the applicant that there is no current or future need for sidewalks in the immediate area;” staff has shown actually the contrary of that is true; the site is within 800 feet of the intersection of US 1 and Barnes Boulevard, and there is a high priority for sidewalks near major intersections; in fact, Space Coast Transportation Planning Organization (TPO) designated this corridor as a priority for improvements for pedestrians and bicyclists; and there are residential neighbors lands abutting this site. He asked if Mr. Oliver believes Planning and Development, Space Coast TPO, and Public Works are all incorrect. Mr. Oliver responded no, he would not say they are all incorrect. Commissioner Tobia remarked neither would he; he advised in a 2022 study by Smart Growth America, Brevard County was ranked the 12th most dangerous area in the country for pedestrian safety based on death per capita; there were 93 pedestrian deaths in Brevard County within this five-year span; according to Vehicular Data Management Company, Geotab, the Florida section of US Highway 1 is the most dangerous road in the County with 1,079 injuries over the course of a 10-year period; and the US Department of Transportation goes on to say that roadways without sidewalks are more than twice as likely to have pedestrian crashes as ones without. He asked how concerned Mr. Oliver’s client is with pedestrian safety. Mr. Oliver replied he would say they are very concerned, but their position is when the sidewalk would go anywhere else, they are agreeing to connect it, and he does not see that the limited stretch as 800 feet is. Commissioner Tobia pointed out, as Commissioner Goodson said, somebody has to be first; the applicant owns the parcel just to the south, which would require approximately 900 linear feet of sidewalk to be installed; and if this request is approved, would Mr. Oliver expect the applicant, the one he is working for, to request the same waiver for the parcel that would be coming up. Mr. Oliver responded he does not know the answer to that one to be honest; but he would suspect they would if it is not going any further. Commissioner Tobia stated he appreciates Mr. Oliver’s honesty; the developer knew this requirement when they purchased, when they started developing; pedestrian safety should be the highest priority; this is where he gets into, and he has no qualms for Mr. Oliver, but the County is comprised of highly-educated, experienced, and qualified staff who make well-informed decisions; when builders and developers do not get the answers they want, it should not be the policymakers, the County Commissioners, that override the decisions of staff; again, he does not blame Mr. Oliver; but he is very concerned if the Board votes for this waiver, it will start an ugly precedent; and people do not have to trust him on that, they heard Mr. Oliver say he will ask for the very same thing on the adjacent property. He went on to say he likes the idea of the bond that Commissioner Goodson mentioned, but he does not even think the Board should do that; he thinks the Board should just require the sidewalks to be built all together, as Page 12 of 31 March 12, 2024 Commissioner Goodson mentioned; this is not a big cost; the developer just probably made a financial decision and said he could get an attorney up here for $4,000, $5,000, or $10,000, and just say a sidewalk costs $40,000, and they will build it and sell it in two years; and by that time, the sidewalk will be someone else’s problem. He commented he does not belabor the issue, but he thinks this waiver should be denied. Motion by Commissioner Tobia to deny the approval of the appeal requested by Storage of Rockledge, LLC, regarding the administration denial of waiver 23WV00020. Motion died due to lack of a second. Commissioner Goodson asked if Commissioner Tobia is not for the bond either. Commissioner Tobia replied between he and Commissioner Goodson, that is his fallback; he would rather them build that as a condition, but if the votes are not there, he does have fallback motion; he would be more than willing to do that; but he does not want to show that card right now. Commissioner Goodson mentioned if Commissioner Tobia knows anything about, and he and staff are very knowledgeable, the worst thing a person can have on a job is a sidewalk, as far as maintaining the sidewalk; watching the people that park on it, that drive over it, and do not drive in the driveway, so there is some consideration there that a developer needs time to get their security in place; but he is for the bond, he is not for the variance; he just wanted Commissioner Tobia to know that sidewalks are a pain; he is glad that they are there; and the applicant needs to be the first. Commissioner Pritchett expressed her appreciation to Mr. Oliver for being such a good sport; she noted he is such a nice person and he has her respect; she will be voting with the Commissioner of the District on this; in her District, she makes everybody build the sidewalks; if Commissioner Goodson had done it different, she would understand as it is his area; and she reiterated whatever Commissioner Goodson chooses to do, she will be with him. Mr. Oliver explained to Commissioner Tobia’s point, he does understand; the appeal, not wanting to overturn staff with each one of these, as they come through, either way; but his client is in a position where, literally, just down the road they own a piece that is very similarly situation in which this assessment agreement was granted; he was not involved with that application so he does not know the details of it; but it is 6400 US 1. Commissioner Tobia stated the Board did not make that decision, staff made this decision. Mr. Oliver advised that is correct. Commissioner Tobia pointed out he trusts staff; staff made that decision to grant that; but he is asking for something different; and he likes the decision made previously, but not on this decision. Mr. Oliver noted on a different piece of property; he asked what the criteria is for applying for an assessment agreement and having consistent application of that at the staff level; he stated they do not know that; he is not picking on anyone here; maybe to the Board’s point of somebody has got to build it; and maybe he can bridge the gap between everyone. He continued by saying if they can agree to the bond with the bond being tied to a specific date; when the development of the southern portion that connects it to the intersection, that whole Page 13 of 31 March 12, 2024 piece, because what they are going to deal with is this developer is going to build this first piece, and at some point somebody is going to build that second piece; they are going to be in that process of are they tearing up that sidewalk, breaking that sidewalk, or maintaining that sidewalk with the next piece that comes in; that might be two years after that maintenance bond has expired; and then it is going to be the County in the middle of dealing with it, so he believes his client will respectfully agree to a performance bond to Commissioner Goodson’s point if it can be tied to the total development of that parcel, which would then tie it within 800 feet of the intersection. Commissioner Tobia inquired if Mr. Oliver had any idea how long that would take. Mr. Oliver replied he would respectfully tie it to a timeframe that the Board can agree to. Chair Steele passed the gavel to Vice Chair Pritchett. Chair Steele advised after hearing this at the briefing, he thinks that everyone over there at the table would say he was one of the guys who said he wanted a bond, he wanted something, and he wanted a bond to see that it is going to be paid; he happened to be going to Titusville today and stopped by the property; he built a lot of subdivisions in his life and put some sidewalks in himself; he can tell everyone exactly what is going to happen if the County puts that sidewalk in now, it is going to be 800 feet with the sidewalk, with dirt this way and dirt that way; people will be driving over it with concrete trucks and will demolish the sidewalk; and in a year’s time, it will have to be redone. He advised he would like to see the Board go with a bond on it; he would like to at least get everybody in-line with knowing it will be built at some point in time; but it is really ugly out there; and to put a sidewalk in the middle of nowhere, with dirt on both sides of it, makes no sense to him. Vice Chair Pritchett passed the gavel back to Chair Steele. Commissioner Goodson asked the County Attorney if a bond is approved tonight on this property, can staff fix the bond on a timeframe, and tie it to the land, so before they sell, somebody has to make good on the bond. Morris Richardson, County Attorney, responded it can be done; and it can be tied to a short developer’s agreement specific to the sidewalk, and then the County would secure performance of that with a bond. Commissioner Goodson asked if the Board should pass that, would the bond be for a year or two years; and could the time be set to whatever the County wanted on the bond. Attorney Richardson replied the County could; the Board may want to do five years, with a provision that if staff deems it necessary prior to that, then they construct it when the County requires, but at a minimum, if it has not been required by five years, sometime before that it will be constructed. Commissioner Goodson commented he definitely does not want to make it five years, because he can see a one-year bond, and then at the Board’s discretion to say build it, or at the Board’s discretion to renew it for another year; five years is way too long; he drove the property many times; today, what was funny about it, when a person got up to Dunkin Donuts, there are sidewalks; but there are seven bicycles riding in the road, so people do not always use the sidewalk, they should, but sometimes they have the bike lane and all that. Page 14 of 31 March 12, 2024 Motion by Commissioner Goodson to propose the bond to the developer for a period of one year, with an extension of a year, and that is it, or it could be worded if there is development on either end that warrants it, then the bond could be called due at any time. Motion died due to lack of a second. Commissioner Tobia asked if he could expand on Commissioner Goodson’s motion. Commissioner Goodson replied sure. Commissioner Tobia pointed out this motion came from the County Attorney’s Office; he asked the County Attorney to do this; and he changed one thing, and that was the five years down to one, so everything else he got from the County Attorney’s Office. Commissioner Goodson advised he is fine with the motion, as long as staff is fine with it. Mr. Calkins stated if that is what the Board wishes to do. Chair Steele stated the Commissioners had this same discussion in a briefing, and it went on for about the same amount of time as it has here; and pretty much, the bond is going to be the answer to it. Attorney Richardson stated he wanted to make one point of clarification; and he asked if the County Manager is authorized to make the decision on whether or not to extend that bond for one year, or does the Board want to see that back. Commissioner Goodson advised he would say the County Manager, or his designee. Commissioner Tobia stated he agrees. The Board approved the appeal request by Storsafe of Rockledge, LLC, regarding the administrative denial of Waiver 23WV00020, subject to the developer’s entry into an agreement in a form acceptable to staff and the County Attorney, providing for the construction of the sidewalk when there is a current need, but no more than one year from today’s date; authorized the developer shall post a one-year surety performance bond in the amount of 110 percent of the estimated construction costs of the sidewalk based on an estimate certified by a professional engineer and determined by staff to be sufficient; authorized there shall be one extension to the one-year bond period to be approved by the County Manager or his designee; authorized the County Manager, or his designee, to execute the developer’s agreement on behalf of the County, and to take such action to require the sidewalks to be installed as may be necessary, including forfeiture of the bond if the developer fails to install the improvements as required. Result: APPROVED Mover: John Tobia Seconder: Tom Goodson Ayes: Pritchett, Goodson, Tobia, Feltner, and Steele Commissioner Goodson mentioned he would like to propose to the Board that it direct staff to clean up the variance laws, or whatever, so this issue does not have to be fought every time; if the County goes through approving plans, then it should have a good variance, or no variance, and put the bond in it so the Board does not have to fight this battle every time. Page 15 of 31 March 12, 2024 Frank Abbate, County Manager, stated staff is going to bring that ordinance back to the Board with that proposed modification in it at a future meeting. I.2. Approval, Re: Resolution and Maintenance Maps for Rockledge Drive Right-of-Way (four section maps) from U.S. Highway 1 to 1851 Rockledge Drive located in unincorporated Brevard County - District 2. Sandra Sullivan explained just like the Brightline, this is another one of the shenanigans that was very difficult for this community; she helped work on this with this community; she was at the community meeting that was held, so this seems to be moving forward to the paving, et cetera; in all of those meetings, the community was told they needed to cut down 67 trees for this project in order to repave the road; what she found out was on the Lagoon Plan, which was planned for sewer, so following up they asked if the road was being repaved because sewer was being put in; and the answer was yes, but they were not told. She went on to say this is the part about not engaging the people, so the people agreed to vote to pay taxes for projects for the Save the Lagoon; then when there is a project where this road, those trees, serve a purpose of holding the banks and holding the road from washing out, has been notified by National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) as being federally recognized as having a lot of resiliency issues with potential flooding from surge events; it just seems like the Board is not listening to the will of the people when it comes to projects; a lot of people had petitions with thousands of signatures on it; and more than 100 people filled this room. She noted they voted for the Lagoon tax; a lot of these people on this road already have advanced septic; the County is going to ask the people to vote again for the Lagoon tax; the County is still just moving ahead with a project with planning for Rockledge Drive to take down the trees that are important to them; and it is part of their quality of life and why they live there. Kirk Rummelhoff expressed his appreciation to the Board for allowing him to speak; he stated he was here a couple of years ago speaking on the same subject; unfortunately, he is back to talk about it again; the decision that has been made in the past regarding the trees on Rockledge Drive has been to leave the trees as they are; that was a decision that was made, he believes, a couple of years back; and that is currently being revisited with a proposal to cut some of the trees down, or trim them down. He continued by saying he does not see any change in the issues that existed a couple of years ago when the decision to leave the trees there was made; the will of the people certainly has not changed in that period of time; he is supposing that perhaps that there is a different viewpoint in the minds of the new Commissioners; he respects that; nonetheless, it is his hope that when the rubber meets the road and a decision needs to be made on this, that the Commissioners will abide by the wisdom of the decision that was made a couple of years ago, to leave the trees as they are, and to protect this particular aspect of Rockledge Drive, which is very singular; and it is part of the legacy of Rockledge Drive. J. Christy Wilson, III, Attorney, on behalf of Rockledge Drive Tree Coalition, stated he has a couple of things he wants to share with the Board in the time allotted; the Board is being asked to approve a maintenance map tonight; that maintenance map, it can be debated about the amount of ownership, but it gives the County ownership of something it has not claimed ownership to before, including private property that has been maintained; it flies in the face, it is in strict tension with Article 10, Section 6A, of the Florida Constitution, which guarantees that no private property will be taken except for public purpose and with full compensation paid to each owner; and the Board needs to look at that very carefully, as there is a Statute of Limitations in this case, because the County did not build this roadway. He went on to say if the County can prove it maintained it continually for a period of seven years, then it can take these rights, today until the Board makes that decision, belong to the adjacent owners; he asked the Board to Page 16 of 31 March 12, 2024 consider this very carefully; he asked the County Attorney for the staff report, which he sent him; included in the staff report is an affidavit from someone from Road and Bridge, one of the County’s staff; and he said the County has maintained this road for seven years. He asked what has the County done, and where are the records; he noted as a matter of inquiry, the Board at least owes the citizens the time spent looking at those maintenance maps to see what exactly has been done, rather than taking the affidavit saying the County maintained this, because they have a serious contest with staff about that; he has requested, he has filed a public information request today with the County; he apologizes for the late filing; but they only learned of this meeting on Thursday; and he has asked the County to provide him copies of all of the work it has done, job orders, who did it, and when it was done, because that is all relevant here. He advised he wants to underscore the importance of Rockledge Drive; and he asked if he can have a brief moment. Chair Steele replied no, but he will give him five seconds. Mr. Wilson pointed out Rockledge Drive is a scenic highway; these trees are specimen trees; the County has a Code that is 500 pages long dealing with trees; and it prohibits the destruction of specimen trees. Doug Simon commented he has been here before trying to save the historical live Oaks and their canopies on Rockledge Drive; everyone has sort of gotten to where he is already; Mr. Wilson kind of hit the points he has written down; Mr. Rummelhoff hit some points; and former Commissioner Smith said two or three years ago, he has a letter from him where he said the County gives up, it was not his fault, and he is leaving the trees alone. He stated he was forwarded an email, which Marc Bernath, Public Works Director, Brevard County, sent out Thursday; in the email it stated that he wants to use Florida Statute 95.361, which is an adverse possession Statute, covering Rockledge Drive pavement; he called the Public Works office, and he has never gotten a straight answer; he inquired what the reason is for wanting to do this tonight, this resolution, and maintenance maps for Rockledge Drive; he advised they called it right-of-way, which really is only the pavement; Rockledge Drive does not have a right-of-way, it does not have easements; and it is the old US 1 from the year 1900 or something like that. He mentioned he really just wanted to get an answer, which he has not gotten; he asked what the purpose is of this adverse possession; is it to control the road to make sure the State does not still have their hands on it, or to do a land grab; and he stated he would like to get a straight answer, that is all, nothing crazy. Chair Steele asked Mr. Simon to email his questions to him, and he will get it to the right person. Carole Pope stated they are concerned up and down the drive about the precedent that is being set with this request tonight; she really does not understand it; when she pulled the information up on the County website, this is the information that comes up; she showed the Board a copy of the information; and she noted a person really cannot determine how it is affecting their property. She asked the Board that it delay this tonight and let the County hold a meeting, or at least make these maps available to the public, to the homeowners, so they can actually see how their land is being affected; she pointed out the print is so small a person cannot read it; she has been driving up and down that road for 50 years, many times a week; she has never seen a County maintenance vehicle out there doing any type of maintenance at all; she knows the County or the city does not maintain the roads in Rockledge; and that is one thing to consider. She asked the Board again to consider delaying this, because the residents really cannot understand how this affects anybody up and down the road there, and what this really means; she stated they are concerned about the issues that have been taking place on Page 17 of 31 March 12, 2024 Rockledge Drive with the County’s attitude towards the street; she asked if this is a County vendetta against Rockledge Drive particularly, because there are many side streets that lead into Rockledge Drive; they have trees; usually they have low-hanging branches; and there has not been this type of tree-trimming requests or right-of-way requests. She explained they do not see that on any other streets; she asked what is going on with Rockledge Drive; she stated it is very concerning to everybody on Rockledge Drive; and she expressed her appreciation to the Board for its time. Commissioner Pritchett asked if staff can answer the questions on this for the maintenance, what type of maintenance the County is looking to do with this. Marc Bernath, Public Works Director, explained first of all, it is important to note that the County has been maintaining the road since the late 1970’s and 1980’s based on the available records, depending on which segments were turned over to the County by Florida Department of Transportation (FDOT) at the time; that includes road maintenance, drainage, and landscaping; this is nothing the County is taking that it does not already have based on Florida Statute; the County has been maintaining it more than the past seven years; and as such, this is enumerating and documenting what the County already owns as far as boundaries on Rockledge Drive. Commissioner Pritchett inquired if this is going to set forth any different things the County is about to do here soon. Frank Abbate, County Manager, replied that is not part of what the maintenance maps are; this is just establishing, confirming the ownership; that is a separate issue; and that will come back to the Board as a separate resolution in the future. Commissioner Pritchett remarked that is what she thought, and she wanted to clarify that. Morris Richardson, County Attorney, advised this, respectfully, does not have the affect described by the attorney; the vesting of the title under the Statute occurs when the prescription period under the Statute is met, so that was satisfied in the case of Rockledge Drive a long time ago; what the maintenance map does is visually depicts and lends clarity to what has been maintained for the required period in time, which under the Statute, title is already vested in the County; it is filed in its prima facie evidence of that maintenance; but it is not an action tonight; it does not means if the County takes this action, parts of the road suddenly belong to the County that did not before; and that has already been established by that continual maintenance over time. Commissioner Goodson stated he has no heartburn about this issue; if the County owns it, it owns it; everybody needs to understand that; he has been here 65 years; and he has seen a lot of work on Rockledge Drive. Chair Steele remarked the County was not going to go out and start cutting down trees or anything of that nature at this particular point in time; and he asked Mr. Bernath if that was correct. Mr. Bernath replied that is correct, this has nothing to do with the trees. Chair Steele asked if nothing will be done like that without public notice. Mr. Bernath replied that is correct. Page 18 of 31 March 12, 2024 The Board approved and adopted Resolution No. 24-022; approved each of the four (4) Rockledge Drive maintenance maps (collectively referred to as the Rockledge Drive Maintenance Map); approved any other documentation to effectuate the maintenance map process, including, but not limited to, addressing any issues with or scrivener’s errors on said maps; and 4) authorized staff to record the Resolution and the Rockledge Drive Maintenance Map. Result: ADOPTED Mover: Tom Goodson Seconder: Rita Pritchett Ayes: Pritchett, Goodson, Tobia, Feltner, and Steele I.4. Permission to Advertise, Re: Request for Proposals (RFP) for financial Auditor Services, Appointment a Board Representative, and Auditor Selection Committee The Board approved issuance of a Request for Proposals (RFP) to solicit an auditor to conduct the County’s annual financial audit pursuant to Section 218.39, Florida Statutes; established an Auditor Selection Committee, as required by Section 218.391(2)(a), Florida Statutes, composed of Office of the Clerk of Courts, Office of the Property Appraiser, Office of the Sheriff, Office of the Supervisor of Elections, Office of the Tax Collector, and Commissioner Pritchett as the member of the Board of County Commissioners, or their respective designees; and authorized Central Services staff to convene and assist the Auditor Selection Committee through the solicitation process and their recommendation to the Board. Result: APPROVED Mover: Rob Feltner Ayes: Pritchett, Goodson, Tobia, Feltner, and Stee

All meeting actions

Source coverage incomplete

32 meeting items captured. The published sources do not prove this is the complete docket.

Showing 12 of 32

Browse by category32 actions
  • Agenda item D.Other meeting itemsapproved - The Board approved the January 23, 2024, Regular Meeting, February 1, 2024, Zoning Meeting, and February 6, 2024, Regular Meeting Minutes.

    MINUTES FOR APPROVAL

    Department: MINUTES FOR APPROVAL

  • Agenda item E.1.Resolutionsapproved - Chair Steele read aloud, and the Board adopted Resolution No. 24-018, proclaiming the month of March 2024 as Bleeding Disorders Awareness Month. Samantha Nazario, Bleeding Foundation of Florida, stated this is their sixth year in partnership with the Board; retired Commissioner Curt Smith was the first Commissioner to ever bestow this proclamation upon them; his predecessor, former Commissioner Kristine Zonka, and now District 4; she is a mother of a son with a bleeding disorder; her son, Tyler, is 24 years old, and is a student Eastern Florida State College; and his medication and medical costs for the year can be upwards of one-half a million dollars to a million dollars. She went on to say one dose of medication is $16,000; they were just in Washington last week advocating for Senate Bill (SB) 228 in the State of Florida; another one of their wonderful co-sponsors and community supporters, Bill Posey, is the co-sponsor of House Bill (HB) 830, for the Federal Bill; and the Bill they are trying to pass is called the Help Co-Pay Bill. She noted what that Bill does is it allows every dollar that comes out of a person’s pocket go towards his or her out-of-pocket expenses for the year instead of disappearing into what they call the insurance abyss; she is sure everybody in this room pays a co-pay if they have insurance; what they learned to do in 2018 was to circumvent the previous law that stated that every dollar out of a person’s pocket went towards their out-of-pocket; and they decided to say if there was any assistance from Pharma, or anything else of that nature, a person would still owe his or her out-of-pocket, so for example, they would take her $25,000 worth of assistance, and in May they would say she was still responsible for the $5,000 out-of-pocket. She stated she is lucky enough that Tyler is not severe, he has a mild Von Willebrand disease; but in severe cases, their medication is $16,000 a dose; that could be two times a day, three times a day, to seven times a week; that could be anywhere, as she said earlier, from one-half a million to a million dollars a year medical coverage; thanks to the ACH, children like her son and other patients are covered, and are no longer uninsurable as they would have been in the past; and if a person does not know what a bleeding disorder is, to please Google the Bleeding Disorder Foundation of Florida, or the National Bleeding Disorder Foundation and educate themselves. She explained one or two percent of the population of the United States of America is undiagnosed with a bleeding disorder, and does not know until it is entirely too late; in the State of Florida they have 6,000 patients, and 433 of those patients call Brevard County home, including administrators, staff, and a lot of the kids here; she expressed her appreciation to Brevard County for continuing its partnership with them; and she stated she looks forward to continuing it for as long as she can.

    Resolution recognizing March 2024 as Bleeding Disorders Awareness Month

    $16,000

  • Agenda item E.2.Resolutionsapproved - Commissioner Feltner read aloud, and the Board adopted Resolution No. 24-019, recognizing March 17 - 23, 2024, as Florida Surveyors & Mappers Week in Brevard County.

    Resolution, RE: Florida Surveyors & Mappers Week in Brevard County

  • Agenda item E.3.Resolutionsapproved - Commissioner Feltner read aloud, and the Board adopted Resolution No. 24-020, recognizing General Federation of Women’s Club (GFWC) Viera Woman’s Club, an April 8, 2024, as Turn Compassion into Action Day in Brevard County.

    Resolution acknowledging GFWC Viera Woman’s Club

  • Agenda item F.1.Land useapproved - The Board appointed Keith Neterer as the County’s representative to the Educational Facilities Impact Fee Benefit District Committee and Educational Facilities Capital Outlay Committee, and appointed Jeffrey King and Naomi Adkins-Hicks as alternates.

    Committee Appointments RE: Public School Facility Planning and Concurrency Interlocal Agreement

  • Agenda item F.2.Contractsapproved - The Board, in accordance with Section 62-2841(i) and Section 62-2844, granted final plat approval; and authorized the Chair to sign the final plat and Subdivision Infrastructure Contract for Christian Commons, Developer: Plumosa Investment Partner, LLC, subject to minor engineering changes, as applicable, and developer responsible for obtaining all other necessary jurisdictional permits.

    Final Plat and Contract Approval, Re: Christian Commons Developer: Plumosa Investment Partners, LLC District 2

  • Agenda item F.3.Budget and financeapproved - The Board approved disbursement of $3,099.586 and the reallocation of $330,463 in Transportation Impact Fees in accordance with the recommendations prepared by the Transportation Impact Fee Technical Advisory Committee for the North Mainland Benefit District, which appropriates a total of $3,430,049; and authorized the Budget Office to execute any Budget Change Requests necessary for implementing these appropriations.

    Approval RE: Transportation Impact Fee Technical Advisory Committee for the North Mainland Benefit District Project Funding Recommendations (Districts 1 and 2)

    $3,099.58

  • Agenda item F.4.Budget and financeapproved - The Board approved and accepted the donation of right-of-way by Warranty Deed from West Malabar properties, LLC for the benefit of DR Horton Signalization Plans at the intersection of Minton Road and Hield Road.

    Approval, Re: Donation of Right of Way by Warranty Deed from West Malabar Properties, L.L.C. for the Benefit of the DR Horton Signalization Plans at the lntersection of Minton Road and Hield Road - District 5.

  • Agenda item F.5.Other meeting itemsapproved - The Board approved and accepted the donation of Utility Easement from Merritt Island Lodge No. 2073, Loyal Order of the Moose, Inc. for the Armen Groves Subdivision.

    Approval, Re: Donation of Utility Easement from Merritt Island Lodge No. 2073 Loyal Order of Moose, Inc. for the Armen Groves Subdivision - District 2.

  • Agenda item F.6.Budget and financeapproved - The Board approved and accepted the dedication of Roadway, Drainage, Utility, and Sidewalk Easement from Tootie’s Grocery, LLC; and approved and accepted the right-of-way by Warranty Deed from 2354 Talmadge Drive, LLC related to Phase 1 and 2 of Site Plan Number 21SP00005.

    Approval, Re: Dedication of Roadway, Drainage, Utility and Sidewalk Easement from Tootie's Grocery, LLC and Dedication of Right of Way by Warranty Deed from 2354 Talmadge Drive, LLC Related to Phase 1 and 2 of Site Plan Number 21SP00005 - District 1.

  • Agenda item F.7.Other meeting itemsapproved - The Board approved and accepted the dedication of right-of-way by Quit Claim Deed from Mike Erdman Motors, Inc. and Plumosa Investment Partners, LLC related to the Christian Commons Plat.

    Approval, Re: Dedication of Right of Way by Quit Claim Deed from Mike Erdman Motors, Inc. and Plumosa Investment Partners, LLC Related to the Christian Commons Plat - District 2.

  • Agenda item F.8.Other meeting itemsapproved - The Board approved and accepted the dedication of Drainage Easement from Epler Park, LLC for the Epler Commercial Park Project.

    Approval, Re: Dedication of Drainage Easement from Epler Park, LLC for the Epler Commercial Park Project - District 5.

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
AgendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Agenda packetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Action agendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Transcript or captionsNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Official pages

Coverage and corrections

Records considered

  • Brevard County Board of County Commissioners — Minutes

Not claimed by this page

  • Item-level plain-language summaries are not available; this page does not infer individual agenda items.
  • Item-linked, attributed deliberation
  • A source-grounded next meeting date
  • A transcript is not available.
  • No audio or video recording is linked.
  • Speakers have not been reliably matched to public profiles.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: 50f7d806c2b3ce6c7de12f7251c44d2e. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record