POLISCOPE

The public record

SARASOTA (SARASOTA COUNTY) · LOCALDecisions and attributed speech publishedPartial coverage

Planning Board/Local Planning Agency Regular Meeting

Wednesday, February 11, 2026 · Government meeting record

The 30-second read

Recorded outcome

CHANGES TO THE ORDER OF THE DAY

Why it matters

This item is supported by a public source record.

What happens next

No later meeting or follow-up date is stated in the reviewed record.

An official outcome record and a transcript or captions are published for this meeting.

Captured actions

4

Recorded outcomes

0

Source artifacts

3

Transcript and record text

Closed captionsWhat was said at the meeting, transcribed Sep 20, 2026. Speech is not a decision.
  • No speaker turns were supplied with this transcript.
  • This transcript has no source timestamps.
  • No speaker identities were supplied with this transcript.

This source published text without speaker turns, so speakers and timestamps are not shown.

The opening of 72,445 stored characters

for a company? Yes. >> Mister president Mister Yes, Mister Clermont there. Mister Christie. Yes, for this tournament yes. Any changes to the order of the day or less for changes to go to the day. One topic and urchins and pledge of allegiance. Led the United States of America and to the for which it stands. One nation under God, with liberty and justice for all. All right. And that brings us to. When you on the Okay. conduct. We may disagree but we will be respectful to one another. We will direct all comments to issues. We will not engage in personal attacks. sorry. I'm struggling to this paper that does And this is not source keeping too. It is quasi judicial Sorry. All right. We're going to open the public and request judicial and that brings us to the applicant and we'll ask the parte attorney. I will get fine. want to run through the cause is just procedures and then we'll get to the oath after that. Because you just hearing is a slightly more formal hearing that a legislative public hearing. >> There are parties to it just hearing the parties, including applicant, the city and anyone who has applied for it received affect a person's status under the city's. Criteria, its code parties may proffer evidence, testimony, expert testimony and documentary evidence parties have the opportunity to cross examine opposing parties in the present. In closing rebuttal argument. The decision of the planning board and a quasi judicial hearing must be based on the competent, substantial evidence in the record and the board must apply the appropriate standards review in the zoning code relating to the type of approval requested. At the beginning of the public hearing. Board members indicate if they've had any ex parte communications on the matter, which is contact with any parties outside of the public hearing today. So at this point, I will now ask the board members if they had ex parte communications on this matter. Kristi I have not. >> I met with city staff. Okay. Thank And you have in your quest protected persons status. >> We give me a second. We had one person. Apply. And that Mary Martha, Great House Gentile. She present. They're so okay. >> So will skip defected. Persons can and then suggested time limits for each partition. >> The applicant. Has requested 20 minutes. That's with the board, which is 5 minutes of the usual. 15, I didn't know. I thought it >> asked for now 50's get I take you up on for you. Haha. All right. We'll go. Get requested 15 minutes 15 minutes part because they're doing consensus 15 minutes. All And we've already done and that opens it up to the applicant. >> And now I would just one come before the board today, too. Rise and raise your right hand for the these where or affirm that the testimony evidence or factual representations, you're about to give a present to the plane board this 11th day of February 2020 cents are truthful. ? ? >> All right. Keep was results for the record. Did you open the public hearing that OK, Good afternoon. My name is Jeff weather the president and CEO of Harbor. >> Craig Kimmel partner with Psr. Thanks, Joe Freeman. Freeman Consulting. Job in a civil engineer. Kimley-horn Matt Dunn landscape architect coming on. I have the overhead. Please. I think we're all familiar with the property Plymouth Harbor. It's been here since 1966, I believe. This is the property here. It's about 16.5, 9 acres. You can there's John Ringling Boulevard. There is a Sarasota Bay. What I like to do first, though, before I get into this too much is have Judge Jeff weather had just give a bro prefer what's Plymouth Harbor? All right, again, good afternoon, everybody >> so Plymouth Harbor is a continuing care retirement community licensed by the state of Florida, which means that we provide housing and services to older adults, independent living home care. Memory care, assisted living and skilled nursing facility. Kind of all in one community. We've been serving the community since in January. We celebrate it. The 60th anniversary of our first resident moving in. We are a not for profit organization founded by Reverend John Whitney me. You know, I'm from First Congregational Church here in town and we have been with a not for profit volunteer board. Over 60 years. We currently have 215 independent living residences and that will kind of come into play here a little bit they're well known in the community. We have a 250 people on our waitlist. 50% of the people who currently move into Plymouth Harbor move into a smaller apartment than the one that they choose and then move later, which is very disruptive for somebody average age of injuries. 81. Only 20% of our independent living units become available every year. So kind of a typical a wait list for somebody who wants a two-bedroom apartment somewhere between 5 and 8 years. Again, we have 250 people on that waitlist. And as we look to explore this expansion, we have a list of about 250 households said yes, this is something that they strongly want to consider. So. Thank you for the time. Great. Thank you, Jeff. >> So we have a 2 petitions in front of you right now. Today. This is the future land use map. It's a rezoning and we have the site proffered site plan. The property there, purple. That's Plymouth Harbor actually it Metropolitan Regional number 3 in the comp plan. Land use plan. And it's implementing zone district in the plan is Rmf 5. So that's what we're doing. We're requesting the arm 5 zone district. What's interesting is that currently, of course, the tower that's theirs completely nonconforming because MCI zoning, which is the existing zoning, has a 35 foot height limit. So obviously, this is going to be reducing the nonconformities. that's a good thing. So now I'm going to have Craig Kimmel, the architect kind of go through me, put up the same plane. First here's a site plan. >> So good A little bit about the project itself. One of the things that were we're really looking at is the the only available land really that's that's left on this property to build on its current at great parking with some covered structures. There. Just person control. So that is basically that rectangle is the location of the site. The project does extend of cross the that road that creates a connection to the existing building. It's very important in in senior living to to create continuity also to to kind of reduce the U.S. and them between the existing and proposed bridging that and really trying to create unification of the entire campus is is really inherently part of what we're doing. There's also some improvements that are taking place at the front. And talk a little bit about that as we go this image just kind of gives you a sense of of the existing and proposed the tower obviously is existing everything on the image to the right of that is existing as well. And colonies space, which is that 3 story just to the left of the towers existing. What we're proposing is is basically a 3 story parking garage that replaces the existing parking and provides parking for the proposed 151 independent living apartment residents. And then on top of that 8 stories of of independent living apartments that that fits within the Arma 5 requirements that are defined as as Joe mentioned in this change of zone. So that's that's kind of the the overview as it relates to the the front of the building. One of the things that has always been kind of part of what me Plymouth Harbor, kind of special was this arrangement from the front entry in. But it was a boulevard and that created some real safety concerns. And that was identified by staff. And as a result, we've really reinvented the front door to still be symmetrical about the front porch share and the tower and recognizing that the entry to the new building is kind of secondary to that but through that process, we've been able to really develop and add parking both surface at this structured parking underneath the building to accommodate us. The needs of growth of the campus. Just a little bit about kind of the architecture we wanted to be complimentary to the air and respectful to the original architecture. It also didn't want to necessarily be a So so we really wanted the building to have a base of middle and top much like the existing building does Kerry the colors forward, which is primarily white. But there's also some some unity, gray colors that the kind of get a common dated in different areas within the building and and then kind of work from there with with really the this offset between parking and building as a plaza amenity space for the Both on the on on both sides of the building really is as we start looking and then the bridge element is the is is a dining and fitness and auditorium space specifically for the residents of Plymouth Harbor and that is kind of that element that allows that kind of activity between the new and the existing. Great. Thank you. >> Okay. and this just in case. So Craig the arm at 5 zoning is the last 25 maker. When we do this edition, we end up that 24 point. >> To 3 units per acre. So within that the high we could go up to 90 But we're a little bit. I think we're at an actual very close right here. again, as I mentioned, revive rezoning. We've we've reduced the nonconformity. So that's a good thing. So I'm going to go through that reviewed the rezoning review criteria right now. Number one is the proposed change country to the future land use plan, as I've mentioned, are mystified as implementing zoning district. Compatibility with existing land use patterns. This really is the land use patterns in area, quite frankly. So it's just expanding on the existing property. Creation of an isolated district. Know it's the implementing zone district. Population density Dewey over Texas system, sewer, water and all that. All of those have been concurrency the signed off on that. chant where the changing conditions have caused this mean as you can tell they they have a way this I mean, so this is an obvious expansion for them to meet that need. Will there be a drainage problem created by know and sometimes you hear Joe is here. If you have any questions about that. reduce the flow of air and light. You can see it's still a very open campus. It's not going have any impact on that. Whether the change will be a deterrent to improvement for the adjacent area. Know the end of this investment and know what the cost of this is, but it's significant investment. It's going in here. It will just encourage people to keep upgrading their facilities properties. granted special privileges versus public welfare. No, we follow that. We follow the process. And again, there's major need for senior housing in this sector. And so this will be helping solving that problem. Is that out of scale with the need to the neighborhood you can see a lower project and the existing tower. So we think we think it's compatible. Is it impossible to find other properties? Again, that's really not applicable. This is what they own and they're expanding on their own property. Lansky now into the site plan We've met all the landscaping requirements again. Matt from Kimley-horn is here. If you have specific questions about that. Now there was a a there is a should say lift station on the property. This is kind of an interesting. Twist to this project. There is a list station on the property. And it's hard to see right there. But and there was a pipe that went to that list station. So we came in and we ended up having to going to be required to remove that pipe because it shouldn't be there. It was a pipe to drain into the the station. I guess again, Joe can explain more. But then the lift station itself. It's inside a property. So we needed to get a variance from a setback. From our new building to that. And we did get the variance. Granted, it's a 27 foot. 45 4.5 inch. Variance from my front yard setback. This created from the list station property. So again, it just in that we could relocate to the station that was not going to be possible. So as a result of that variances, of course, we meet all the requirements. Now, the other interesting thing on the traffic study that was done. We agreed to kind of coordinate and work with Florida Department of Transportation on investigating whether or not a pedestrian cross can occur in this area. I know there's a specific name for the type a crosswalk, but again, Joe is here to talk about that will do the studies. We'll see if the DOT wants to do this. And if they do, we've agreed to do it. So quickly. The review criteria, proposed plan in content standards of the district. We need all the requirements. This is day whether on balance a proposed development lay out a compatible with the plan. Is it's been positioned on the site very well. And action strategy. 3.5 states. If we meet all the zoning code requirements, we're considered to be consistent with the comprehensive plan. Number 3 is as the required information they provided. It has. We wouldn't be here for one, whether there are ways to change the configuration to make it less impactful on the surrounding area. Again, I think that the entrance and that whole concept of how the entrance works, it's it's pretty dramatic. And I think it's it's really well done. Thank at the overhead again. It's very well. That's going to be a very pleasing entrance for the the Hole Scylla t. Do we make adequate provisions for pedestrian access? We're not changing the access. Does the plan make adequate provisions for parking and loading? They'll be 590 spaces and a new parking over 700 total for the entire property. as we said, we're working to if they want to cross walk across Lee Boulevard. So that's setting a minute before he left pretty deal. We're here to answer any and a side project and the beautiful addition, there's a lot of people want to move in. This. Thank you. home. I have a couple of. Rand of sorts of questions. I'd like to start with. Can anyone give me the history of why you had to acquire a small piece of property from the city? Yeah. Is that related to the list? that that wasn't pie. talking about. >> So once it got removed, we're having to remove it having that property. There made no sense the city didn't need more and it would have created more setback issues from this property line. So the city said we don't need you want to buy. So we went through the appraisal process and the city commission agreed to sell it. Okay. Good. And and I saw in materials that there's a that's been that sale has been completed. Is that correct? The clothes going to be in later this month? All right. Good because it looked fresh. Yeah. So it's it's all done. And Mister Appleby is here. >> Yeah, it's it's it's under contract. And it's supposed to March 3rd of March, we're in. We're in contact with the with the for mishandling. The closing soaking the seems to be moving forward. I just wanted to to make sure because it looked to me like the plan is contingent on that. definitely So you're not going to have any no. >> We're not have any issues with that. That's going to happen. >> And you know, and and in reality to put context that strip of land, I think 9 out of 10 times would have been easement probably that the That would be So it's it's little atypical that the so you know, it's pretty simple reason bus pretty. And it's yes, owns. >> I went out there. So, you know, real estate law, House really I was surprised. It was easement. Yeah. I'm sure you were I have a question conductivity are describing. can just correct. So a couple questions about that. here's this beautiful thing behind existing building. I believe they call the rookery yes. >> And I didn't see any Khan activity on the plans for people with the new building to be able to >> access that easily. The most wonderfully to explain to us how this, you know, looking at sea 502, and the other things that you for other things you put out that. Make it look like it would be hard for people that it's absolutely stunning back there. And I really it really is. And so I just wanted to understand what your thinking was about how people access that So the connection point actually between the existing and the new is really pretty. >> Pretty much just that one corner and right at that one quarter, we have 2 elevators that basically go from grade all the way up to the just in this Here it right on the corner. And so from there, you can literally walk out the corner of the existing building and you're right there at the Rotary. Okay, great. >> And I this I couldn't figure out what was on C 502. Is this in the upper right corner of of the site plan? Is this the FDOT crosswalk? Yes. If you are thinking about it. What's the logic behind that? Just go see the other side town when there's a stop over The bus stop. Okay. Could certainly get it. And then my final for you guys is about the Banyan tree that in front of the East building. That's not going to be touched, right? That's a beautiful that's being removed. Yeah, that's >> Yeah. The the live oak is stay. That's the one that's closest to the front existing workers share. But on the other side of canyon is removed. That's right where we're making that that connection. I wondered about that. has the Take a look at tree. >> technically, it's invasive for the city's code so we don't OK, but I liked it thank you. The maintenance people aren't so thrilled about it. And especially now. Thank you much. Thank you. Thank you. Thanks, everybody. >> My questions or the director of the facility. You said that your nonprofit course you are. That doesn't mean you serve the poor, correct? >> We do have a assistance program for residents who have exhausted their funds. >> I I know that your lovely organization that did answer my question. That was that was not my question. You want to try again? so no, we tend to serve a more affluent population, correct? Your of the population that you serve our wealthy, elderly people retirement, correct? Yes. All right. With respect to to parking you're adding 500 and 90 total parking spaces, correct? It's going to have 590 and there were removing some parking spaces. So but >> understood but but the idea is that you're going to have 590 additional parking spaces with a total for everything in the development of 700. True, correct? All right. So between the parking garage, the 24 existing surface parking spaces that are going to remain the 38 surface parking spaces that are proposed that equals the total number, correct? Yes, alright, whether there are some parking spaces under the existing building as well. >> The existing building, you mean the tower the East Jordan and also the Northwest not specifically under the tower, exactly, but but to either side of understood. So. Just so we're clear the total parking spaces for the entire development of 700 trip. Yes, okay. 790 790. Okay. Great. Thank you. That's 590 parking spaces for the new development and 110 for the existing. That right. I guess you could look at that with our 20200 for the decision, right? I'm asking, have you guys look at the plant? It's it's all. Well, it's a it's all for the whole campus. Okay. Yeah. I'm not sure that really doesn't nation between the existing in the new in terms of parking. Okay. Bruce part, Mister Franklin talked about reducing the nonconformity in. This is, of course, hailed in your documents in the city's reported as a great thing, reducing the nonconformity. want to talk a little bit some questions related to the nonconformity. site consists of most the property is most of the small barrier island. Correct? Joel? All right. It's he's my twin brother. I Haha. >> It's part of the barrier island system. I guess you could say yeah, it's it's most of a small barrier island, right? Okay. I I wouldn't call it a barrier island because the barrier island. On the other side of across I'm not I'm not. And and you know, expert okay. All right. it's a an island portion and there's water something else surrounding right? I mean that that's what it looks like when I look at it. Yes, really an island. But maybe I guess if you look across the street but never going So the existing nonconformity relates to the historic tower. Current other things, correct it all as this story tower. 24 Stuart, when it's 260 years. Something as a 25, I'm sorry. it's 200 plus yet 200 plus, but about 260 some Okay. That's very high for that area. Correct? Oh, yeah. Yeah. So it's a it's a crazy high toll tower. They wouldn't be there. But for this historical anomaly, right? Yeah, it was done before zoning exist. Yeah. Exactly. We want it done. 66 the original? Yeah. you know, after zoning n, you know, sort of proper planning, which we're all in favor of good, common sense planning if if good common sense planning had been in place at the time, that never would have been constructed fair. Well, again, you know, height of the building never would right to you. I mean, let's be honest that you never would have gotten Bill right now. Let's say created downtown core downtown bayfront. I don't ever want We can. I mean, we can agree, right? There are buildings now that are taller than Okay. And we get your job to quibble. I guess you want to quibble, but no, I don't know what your point is. Okay. My point is that building is a very a significant historical anomaly in the development of the area Okay. We can agree on a legal nonconforming use, correct? On conforming structure. Absolutely. that's a represents a significant not only height, nonconforming height, but intensity of development in that particular area to agree. Density is. It's not really a change in density. I'm not asking about the current be that this thing that existing building was well below the maximum density allowed in the MCI District. Okay. with respect to the a change in the Sony there are 2 real, much of the zoning is similar right? There are really 2 issues in terms of the change in zoning. One is the max building coverage, which is essentially massing right? Yeah, OK? So increase of 10% of the amount of massing by virtue of the change in zoning OK, yes, yes, okay. So and then the height. The existing heights, 35 feet under a and C district, right? Correct. Okay. In the propose own district, it's 90 feet and we're proposing to go up to the full 90 feet, correct. arrest of party great. which was my next point. The you talk about 90 feet is the building height. But of course not. That's not the actual building height. If you have a normal, no person. Who went out to the site and they said helped holes that building. They would say it's 115 feet toll, right? Correct. Correct. Okay. And that's because you're measuring the 90 foot building height from the top of the 3 story parking garage. True. Correct. Her so the proposed development, the site plan and the rezone represents a significant increase in the density in the massing on that site. Fair. What does the site's not fully developed right? I really yes or no. It's an increase in in density intensity under that compared to existing. Yes, okay. All right. I think that's it does go my questions. Thank you very Thank Yes, I appreciate the renderings. We don't always get the more and more we're getting them. But it does kind of help that vision. You know, this is a kind of top-down review site plan. >> The zoning it's nice to be able to see what you're proposing just kind of helps the whole picture. I don't know that anybody here. Not me is old enough to remember when this building was I've just always wondered. And this is just more comment. That was questions that we have answer. What in the world, the city people think when this building was being built in 66, he's a beloved building. 25 stories now would create a look, you push so that that time really been something most people just thought. Well, it's way out there. You know, so that, you have you ever heard what the reaction was to the at that time? Because, you know, we all drive but now says part of the landscape of seen in forever right? But yeah, so I think, you know, it's an anomaly start. The anomalies using it will remain that. So even if we changed the zoning and still taller than what would know that a lot. So, you know, it's it. And then so anyway. So I get to a question. I think it probably should. He just after 7. And I asked myself questions, including the question and answer period it you answer this already. my first question was what needed the community is being fulfilled here because, of course, we have to weigh the balance of what is a benefit to the community versus what is the downside of having a larger, massive and intensive development on the site. as mentioned something about the wait times and all of that. But is this something that's citywide or region-wide where there's a problem where everybody who is who development properties like this is has long wait times as as you across our country, you know, 10,000 people a day are turning 65. Yeah. And people are living longer study by the National Investment counsel. >> What I think 2 years ago indicated to meet all of the need for senior living. United States is already 35,000 units short. In our market study shows that. If the expansion goes and Erickson property in Lakewood Ranch, an all of that. Everything in Sarasota County that's being developed. We will still only serve about 2%, the age and income qualified. Clientele in our area. Yes. So there does seem to be a pretty strong need across the segment. >> Mister really got to the point about how this is a little bit affluent crowd. from is there going to accomplished and see anything in this year for maybe lower income or that or this was just going part of their program. No, okay. Just injures and back to again about the parking. I'm still not quite clear because I saw in there is on site on site. Record Park is for 24. company that was just for the new but then there's 590 being built in there when it was 790 seems like an awful lot of parking spaces. And you know, I don't like impervious surfaces is necessary to have this much parking so 190 you. It's in the again. So funny because last had a community workshop. I was talking about a project meeting code. You're not provide enough park the Every time I come up here, even provide too much or not enough or whatever. So. >> They're used to it then. there's no other option, we don't have parking. We've got a problem on this site because you're going park John. We will know just seemed like the might and lot and allies that they know how go ahead. >> If you go out there during the day, you'll see people are parking grass and they're trying to find any stitch of parking available anywhere. So so part of the this parking count that we've looked at. Campus, why takes that into consideration? So so that's that's really where the? >> Where that demand meat came from in reality than we actually expanded the parking one bay through the design process because there was a feeling we weren't going to provide enough. so this is really a of a need kind of assessment that we do to determined the parking. >> I would I if I could just chime in. One factor may be different from a typical residential building is where a very staff intensive. Operation. So for our current 380 residents, we have about 320 team members. probably 11560 day shift kind of through the night. And so and these typical cars. these are typical apartment buildings where it is not all that great right? >> Yeah. Okay. Understand. this is just a and a quibble. But with that is I just wonder what's going on. The roof of the round going up. There's like 30 feet tall. Cooling towers cooling towers. Yeah. As everyone knows that requires such cooling towers and so tall. a stone, the size will work. We're building done. It's underneath them, which is a structural frame that comes up off the roof so that the roof can be. >> Re done in the future without having to impact the towers themselves. And then on top of that, basically we have the towers and there are there are 3 cells and that and and so so, yeah, yes, that is that is the size of the tower. We also didn't win impact that beautiful rectory area and behind. So those cooling towers would have been just a big barrier. To block that in understand. One last question. I'm usually we do hear from them. A neighboring property. In this case, the neighboring property is the original tower. How have the who live in their politically on the corner facing this of the receive this idea because also they're going to be losing some of their sideline. Yeah, it's been a very mixed reaction we've had some folks who just given the age of our population, there's there's a set of people who say this is going to open in 2030. Likely not to impact me. And then there are some who are saying I get that the need and the impact to the community. So. supportive of it. And there there's a group who would prefer to not go through the disruption. And we try to be very accommodating accommodating to each of those groups. As we plan forward. Always a challenge, OK? Thank you. Okay. So to follow up a mystery as point. think that building it's it's 115 feet doesn't minutes tell his own. so I think it >> make for some kind of seems like it's over the top of it. it does meet all the criteria to that about when you're making. I think the architecture, I want to commend you on that. I think it's that the thankful some Smith building, I think it's highly regarded among local architect. It's a really nice example architecture on here. It's dumping 6 telling us what time is the city of all. The definitely went down tonight. But I think that the that the design a sympathetic to the original tower and it's really nice it complements it nicely. I think even even the scout components that think it's it's well done. Well, considered. I also appreciate the set of the grand recipes that then and I also do like that. But I understand. >> And the cooling tower. I didn't pick up on that. It is really tall. Isn't acting like a central energy plant to the existing tower or is that it's it's tied to the central plant of of the existing But all of these to the 3 towers that will be on the roof are all serving this new Bill. Okay. And that's what was required a is that sorry I misspeak. There are 2 towers on the new building that are serving that. that's there, too. There are 3 cell towers or 3 free tower cells on that serve the existing building. And those are those are in their own structure back closer to the river in. And when we study that, well, if we could add 2 more cells back there, but it really starts to restrict access and you to the rookery. And we're concerned about that. So that was really what drove the decision to move the towers system. Yeah, the energy plan for the building today. The tower on great. Here it is. Yeah. Okay. Okay. that staying put your not. it's storage underneath because of the flood >> Okay. Got you. I thought it was large because you're trying to accommodate of ice so it get. Adding 2 more hours to that structure really became restrictive in terms of how >> that structure was going to the view by by everyone in the share of >> And then let's see the You're calling out public art along the railing elevation for the building 300 Lang public. Can you kind of talk more about what you planning to do that we're not quite sure yet. We we have met with Sierra Coleman to to start initial conversations about how the art Republic are requirement. >> Could be applied to the screening of the garage in the front, which really route from the stair tower on either side out to the front corner and across the front face, it would be on the second and 3rd floor of the of the actual garage, the thinking being that the first floor is primarily going to landscape So really looking at that thing being on those upper 2 floors. Beyond that, I don't think that we've really gotten into artist or the specifics of the screen other than I think there's a desire maybe to do something with a bird motifs that ties back to the >> Okay. See as like a heart that are not yes, perforated screen. Yes, it would be art of some surprise when the rent I That's it. >> Might act as the screen as well. But right now we're assuming that the screening requirements and needs zoning is not the art that that's being applied behind it that the art is being applied in front. If the art meets that criteria, we may be able to use the art as the screen We're not assuming that right now. >> It's nice and then I guess question I have again, to Mister this point about the mass of the building and the future build out. Is this is this kind of your final stage? Where would you go from here? This is this is it? This your vaccine out. >> I mean, we're max lot coverage. We're getting close to density limitations. So so really in in practicality, there's really nowhere else to go. I mean, there's a possibility that you could imagine growing vertically over the 3 story pieces of the building. But the thing, the cost some of these parking needs are going to really limit that has a future growth possible. Okay. This I took your turn as a cause. And >> I had parking concerns as well. But those have been addressed and just to piggyback off the last. >> Talking point. If my math is right, you guys are still capable of building. 46, more was that actually considered? It sounds like it might have been, but that's address previously. So I I don't think we ever consider building more. came in with a waitlist and this is a needs-based decisions. So why wasn't? >> It is not density kind of explored. >> I think the the density as we had. It had a defined originally. We were looking at trying to get 9 stories into the 90 feet. And and we recognize that that was creating some of the same bill ceiling, height limitations that are in the existing building structure. And we wanted to this new product to differentiate a little bit in terms of product. And so we went to 8 stories which gave us a little bit more Florida floor, height in the in that building in doing so that footprint spread out. And so we've never really tried to extend that density beyond that one. 50 target. I think we're one 51 right now. Because it just felt like that was kind of the right number based on the size of the garage and the amount of parking we can get on the site to meet the needs of of Plymouth Harbor. If we tried to get that full density on there, I think it would. It would start compromising use for the existing apartments and and as well as because it would force the building to the denser or we would need to start looking to put things on top of the existing building, which has its own complications. And we really didn't ever pursue. Looking at that. And you said the parking on the right away from the parcel is currently a problem. But it's not a problem. >> For your employees, are that just a problem? Because other people are parking. parking there that you said that that's currently being excess. Yeah. Our our residents guess. >> Okay. it is it is nobody property related uses not nobody got all on related. Okay. And then last but not least probably not relevant. But if I recall correctly back in. >> August or September, we were here on the yacht Club next are doing some construction right up against breathe estimates of construction. We had discussions. Any issues there. They're real co-operative. >> Yeah, they're very The architect is one of our board members. So, you know, we're in collaboration with You know, we've gotten their model of of their expansion. We've we've included that in some of the Larry Bird and I'm not concerned about that. >> what they've done kind of is complementary to what we're doing and really, I think their expansion of parking is is adjacent to our parking. So right. >> In fact, we'd like to not have the whole the setbacks, their budget, but we because there's a there's a parcel line. So so they're they're meeting the setback for meeting the setbacks but it's kind of. I don't say wasted space, but it's a little bit of a lost opportunity because it's part the party. >> Okay. Thinking over the course just on the question, I did have one more thing and that was a gentleman from heart. You know, it's a variance of environmentally sensitive area. Obviously, I just wanted comment on home. This storm watersheds currently on that side versus what will be done now that will have this larger building. is going to work better. We improving the situation. >> so we're meeting that improvement requirements and also the redevelopment requirement. Cry tears for treatment with water management district looking at the site as a whole currently portions of the just discharged directly out to the Bay with the new system. We're going to be kind of rerouting not and it will be going to a treatment of all Pryor's. I don't need the treatment criteria and the treatment elevations and then anything above that will discharge out. All right. Thank you. just a couple of follow-ups. Public are. You can make a contribution or you can put the building. >> And do I take it from your comments that your intent is whether or not you can use art as screening? You will. Put on the building. That is the intent. Okay. They are would be on the building. Yes. All right. Good. And I just wanted to follow up a little bit. Took a look at your 2020 to 9.90. And at that time, if I recall correctly, you had 413 employees listed on the 9.90. Have you reduced employment hat? From the harbor? Is that been a reduction in census? Because as he said 3.80, today, 3.81, if I heard you correctly, sir. Yeah, 3.20. Yeah. want thank yeah. 320 full-time employees. When you people who were kind of part time is needed. That number grows up. I was. Just trying to take the number of people who would typically be there on any given day, OK, I also noticed follow up on Mister Giuliani's comments a little bit that you reported in 2022, something like 16 million dollars in prepayments or initiation fees. Is that? That? Is that how you serve your clients? They paint initiation fee, club. I'm just trying to understand your Yeah. were actually licenses and insurance product people when they move in the paint and a front entrance fee. The gets escrow to take help offset their future. Health care costs and to guarantee placement and they run out of funds theirs? There's the Pullman eat to assist with that coming in 2022, we're coming out of COVID where there was a period of time where people were not moving into the community. So 2022 kind of the build back year. Because we had inventory that. Became vacant during COVID that we filled. But yes, our our model is an entrance fee model on the front side. refundable over a period of time or earned by the community. If the residency is of a certain least. Covers capital costs. I know this is probably irrelevant, but I just have to ask the question. So what you sell his insurance contract? In the eyes of the state of Florida? Yes, thank you, All right. Thank you very much. Appreciate that. It was another Thank you very much. just isn't so. >> Good afternoon for club stirs certified planner Acting Development review chief planner. They have been sworn. The subject. Property is approximately 16.5 million acres of a blunt and submerged lands and is owned by Plymouth Harbor. The property is located at 700 John Ringling Boulevard between Saint Armands Key to the West and very key to the east. The property is currently zoned medical charitable institutional, MCI, with the future land use classification of metropolitan regional number 3. The properties to the north across John Ringling Boulevard, zoned residential, multiple family for with a future land use classification of multiple family, medium density and the property to the East Zone Office regional district with the future land use classification of community office, institutional and the property is located within the coastal islands, overly. The subject. Property currently contains senior living units and assisted living facilities with Associated Accessory uses the applicant is requesting a rezone and site plan approval to change the zoning of the property from the MCI zone districts to the RNA, 5 Stone District. And I want to reiterate that this is the only implementing zone district for the Metropolitan Regional number 3 future land use. The applicant is requesting the rezone to reduce existing nonconformities and to construct a new building addition and approximately 5.2, 5 acre portion of the northeast corner of the property. The new building will replace an existing surface parking lot with 3 levels of structured parking containing a total of 590 parking spaces and the stories of multifamily residential containing approximately 151 independent senior living dwelling units. Vehicular access is proposed to remain from John Ringling Boulevard. The proposed development is compliant with all development standards of the zoning code, including high parking in loading and setback requirements. There are a total of 200 trees on the subject. Property and 77 are proposed to be removed. Of the 77 trees proposed to be removed. 9 do not require mitigation, including 3 dead trees to Rika Palms pygmy date. Palm Senecal deep on a Banyan tree and queen com. The 68 remaining palms proposed to be removed, require medication in mitigation is proposed with 25 palms and 49 3 inch caliper trees which exceeds minimum mitigation requirements required by code. All existing drink. Grand trees are proposed to be preserved and the applicant has met all interior landscape requirements for parking lots and all requirements for perimeter and parking lot landscape. Buffers. The application received full Development Review committee signed off January 5th 2026, a community workshop was held in September. 30th 2024. with 5 members of the public in attendance. discussion focused on the proposed height of the new building roof treatment to reduce he impacts areas within the building and development review process for a reason with the site plan. An initial transportation concurrency analysis in track traffic circulation review was completed which to deem the development. Not to mention this. So traffic impact analysis was completed and all comments just the proposed site plan complies with all applicable sections of the zoning code and staff recommends approval with the conditions as outlined in the staff report. And I'm happy to answer any questions. >> Thank you, Mister House. After new this I have a question about the traffic concurrent. He now says he just reading your report that all comments were addressed. And I'm really interested me in the standard for of you talking about a number 5 proposed development, traffic circulation. And this is, you know, I'm still relatively do with this. But the way I looked at. Item 5 on Page, 52 of the report. It looked to me like there's 86% increase in PM trips. And so when the staff report says all comments were didn't see any comments addressing this particular increase, which I think is pretty large. And it's a it's a big it's a big increase. Going from 80. 44 in the quarter. 82 and a half. Just in line us a little bit on how staff dealt with. A magnitude of this and what and specifically what comments for that standard were raised and addressed. >> So in the initial review, the project is not deemed him in There was going to be a traffic reviewing that was completed. Transportation Concurrency is reviewed by assistant city engineer. And so she has reviewed it. The completed the traffic study and address comments of that traffic study. And so she was able to sign off and development Review Committee V for that project. >> Can want I don't want to belabor it. But it didn't raise any question in any part of staff's review that. Pm trips were going to re be raised on average about 86%. That's not a for a level of service. The room. >> So I think what Rebecca saying is that's reviewed by the assistant city engineer. So the document that's in here is just the initial review that triggers the traffic study. The full traffic study is not in the backup material is done by outside 3rd party entity. But it sent back to the assistant city engineer to review. So if there were comments brought up by that study, she verifies in her review of the site plan that those comments have been addressed. And then those comments are about impacts on the right of way. So that would have looked at impacts on like John Ringling from the increase in peak pm hour trips and she felt in her opinion as a subject matter expert that been addressed by the site plan. Yeah, I'm still Miss Christie >> this is the report that triggered the site plan. Yet we're at site plan that triggered the study. I should say yes. Yeah, we're it site. Plan review. Where were? Going to review positively or negatively. The site plan, right? So I hear your explanation as well. We weep hunted. I know you haven't, but I'm searching for work. We know that there may be a lot of increased traffic, but we're not looking at it now at site plan time. >> No, that's not what I meant. So they look at it as a result of the traffic study in that traffic study would come back and say you need to add a turn lane or you need to add a traffic light or things like that. And that would have been been required as a part of the site plan and that's been completed. The traffic study has been completed. >> And so its impact on the site I'm getting confused. Sorry, it's week mind. I know that you guys all have this cold and I'm the one who doesn't. >> What I'm trying to understand is where have we county site plan for what is was initially determined to be an 86% increase in PM side trips. >> Let me see if I can pull up the traffic study and I can tell you what the requirements of the traffic study were, there might not have been anything triggered by the traffic study like adding a turn later, adding a traffic light. There might not have been anything triggered answers. Nowhere. You know where you think. Oh, I don't mean to be difficult about this, but it's a big number. Big change. >> I understand I'm just not a traffic engineer said oh, but the traffic engineers did do a traffic study and then review that traffic study and whatever was required for that traffic study has been incorporated into the site plan. For example, one thing that came out if that was the potential conversation of a crosswalk along John Ringling to a bus stop. So that's just going pull West there. Yes, going west. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. I was wondering about the bus stop. I I'm not trying to be difficult. I just don't. It's a big number. Big changes. Our raise flags. I'm not feeling that I'm not getting the feeling that. We've addressed this particular thing in the site plan. You're saying it would have them future perfect addressed and site plan. But I don't see where it had to have been for the assistant city engineer to sign off and the RC for this. Okay. Thank you. Miss Webster. chilly. I have no questions for the city to scream. You know, we talked about this leave yesterday, but I'm going to and yes, some of questions the same. So it's on the public record. The implementing for the future land use. We run into this a number of times and I was just kind of like unexplained because it's kind of this gray area, just a side of being able to do something by right? >> Because it is foreseen. This intensity is for scene. You just described a little bit about that a little further because what you know, and I remember, Michael, have one says to set up is what are we doing here? If we can't say no to this, I just want to make sure we can. >> So the future land use. I have up on the overhead. The future land use is Metropolitan Regional Information, Paula, to regional say 3, which is what this one is, the only zone district for that future land uses are in a 5. And so this is from the zoning code and it has the future land uses. And then what the implementing zone districts are. So currently the MCI zone district is not implementing for this site. And so it's, you know, the future vision for the city that the land use and ultimately the zone districts are the implementing zoning districts for each property. And so for this one, really the only zone district for this site is are in a 5. >> I didn't I just want explain for everybody. I'm not trying to my hand and I'm against it necessarily. I'm just saying I want to make sure we all got together here today for a reason kind of just as you're talk about that point for second or ask a question. So I think Mister, your question to her, what it was essentially. >> Do we have to vote for this? Because are 5 is that's kind of what is option? Okay. Well, okay. So an EV to look at and that's okay. So that that's that question. And that answer is troubling to me, right? Because we're not, you know, AI bots up here, right where representatives of the public and it's our job to scrutinize things. And you have a particular mechanism for doing that. council explained it to us at the beginning right what he said is what we're supposed to do is too. Is to take the competent, substantial evidence, right? That's that's coming in from the record and to apply that to be a clickable standards, right? That's our job, OK? We don't have to vote. Yes, we do have shackles on and says we have to approve this project. That's insane. Okay. We do not. Let's be really clear about what that's what I was here. I would look at the evidence the confidence stachel evidence in the record and we look at each one of those criteria on the 2 separate issues we're looking at one of them is the is the is other plan, right? So if they all have different criteria, right? And it's I think it's 7 for one. And it's it's it's a lesser number for the other. So I don't want us to get confused about that. No, I don't either. That was the point of my question. Maybe you didn't make that point clear enough. >> Is that we do have things to debate. Here is not a matter of this is just settled before we got here we do have points to consider on this is not a matter of well, this is implementing zone that is going out. comes to us the only implementing zoning district so it seems to me with this kind of lay down and I don't think should be. So in my opinion, that's often what were fed. Yeah. Yeah. All weigh in on that because this has come up before and >> you know, my my stance has been. As as prior board discuss to. Yeah, I mean, if you if you had to vote yes, then why would we be here? Sure. however, does need to be taken into account that when there is. A property that is currently in a knot before me. So they're trying to rezone and there's literally only one of the many zone that they can rizzotti to then be in compliance. That has to be taken into account and that's kind of special circumstance. It. So yeah, I'm not telling you. You have to you're legally required to. approve this rezone his you. That's not accurate. But it would also be foolish to ignore the. that. That's that that that this is literally the only I think they can rezone, too. So I told them they can rezone. There could be legal indications of that. Well, they have requirements. >> And with this, I have to make the requirement to have to read all of the They selected all that I look by Foreman does writing get Exactly. That was my point. They can ask sure it's not necessarily that we deliver. >> Yet there was one other point I just want to make is on Page 14 and it is it the reduction of light and there? And here it myself pretty fortunate hear the voice of the proposed change, we will not seriously reduce the flow of light and air to adjacent areas that stated as a fact. But it's fairly you know, it's a big building. So I I would just like to know how did you determine with such certitude that the proposed change will not seriously reduce the flow of light and air to Jason areas. What's the standard? >> Sure, the standards that we mainly use our setback requirements and height requirements by the code and they are in compliance with both of those standards. >> Okay. So if you know the building could be quite large as long as it meets these. Requirements. You feel as though because it does change late there for the people. Ordinarily Jason to it does change it for the people who are trying to enjoy the yacht club next door. So, you know, from their point of view them as well. Setbacks are great, but its toll taking away my sunset or whatever might be Okay. That's more of a Thank you. So thank you, and mistress. It. >> Just to piggyback off that I mean, obviously that would be a different analysis are fact or if they were seeking variances because then they are not meeting the setback or other things even if the neighbor complained, you know, I wasn't a question. My question is when property is not being subdivided, what constitutes a unit with respect to the density for the zoning like where how does the city consider something unit? What defines it? What variability is there on it? Just to kind of get back to my questions about the fair to maximize the density on the site. Like what? From the city's perspective and looking at the site plan, what makes something a unit within this building that we can definitively say they will be 151. Is it the amenities in particular spaces and how it's constructed? What what makes something Well, think the unit again dominated, but like in the traditional sense of like a site plan, our, you know, creating lots and every lot's going have a home or creating condo units. That's obviously a unit. But not subdivided. The property here. So how do we define the units with respect to knowing that their building? 151 on top of the existing 215. >> Doing unit is defined in our code. So we use that Second, look this up and just I can read Yeah. I think it's going looking for somebody to come to summarize for any building or portion thereof designed occupied or intended for occupancy as a complete independent living facility for the exclusive use of one family, including permanent full provisions for sleeping eating cooking and sanitation. So then they would have to have some variability or flexibility with respect to size. It's the >> It's based on the kitchen. And then we do have a different calculation for assisted living facilities and things like that. That not be protection. Okay. And is that a clickable? Yes. And so we have calculated that as well that okay. Think that's it. I appreciate education. I don't have any questions. Thank you very much. We're going to have public comments that's one public I'm Tom Duncan, Tom Duncan here. Come on down to the table. And then just give it a second because he's going to be using an interpreter. Okay, no problem. We're going to as the gentleman been sworn in, we're here is not it was there he didn't. are also in need of break. Would we be able do? We have One on one second say. >> Jake, So we'll have to come to >> Bring your computer. It can bring. whatever you Sorry. >> are all others to read pretty sure. I did not see the yellows for you. And sir, have you been sworn that right there is that. >> Do you swear or affirm that the testimony and evidence are about to give to play more during this hearing held this 11th day of February 2026 is truthful. >> guess just speak into the mic. >> are going republic. Carry Okay. I have a permit partner >> women are. >> Yeah. about One or and I did that for at the R D Department traffic call from Kamala you're a crop. The guard year created at more parking more ordered that can be that. >> The they did indicate the applicant that they were going to do that it was necessary and pay for it. We can. We can ask we'll ask the applicant directly. >> you to probably a long you're going cross country that are harder. The company the car you to do it. garbage. You can turn page. You not talk. >> Understood. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you, sir. And that was it for public comments, correct? Okay. All right. So now we're back to the applicant for rebuttal. Can please have the applicant? I get city? I'm so you know, the city doesn't have a ? 2 issues that we're talking about traffic. ? Joe, here. Going explain increase in traffic. >> Sure, I'll start with I'm not an expert to speak on traffic all. I have reports I'm going just trying to explain it briefly, but I just want to put that out there. So looking at the traffic study, it says there's an increase of 38.2, 5 trips, which is greater than one percent on the roadway. But one percent on the roadway is around. 29.2 trips. So we're looking at less than 2% increase on the roadway. Which is much different than this. >> So when you're done with regard to what you're saying, the way they look at the traffic impacts is do we degrade the level service below that which causes a need for offsite improvements. And the study show we did not the one thing they did want was this crosswalk. can cross walk. I mean, Plymouth Harbor, been there for years and years. And they've talked about traffic lights, etcetera, etcetera, and the DOT says it doesn't warrant that it's a dot road so we don't control it. We've agreed that we will install that if the DOT approved, it will install that crosswalk and bill and pay for. And the even though it's on the West side, the idea is that let's say someone is coming to work. Work at Plymouth Harbor. They take the bus and would cross over that gentleman there that spoke. It sounds like they they go and take the take. The trolley may be to Saint Armands Circle loops around and goes all the way downtown. So it's warranted. The permit. We'll definitely pay for. But back you. I hear you. >> But I don't agree with that analysis of the numbers because 29 point to as one percent of that capacity of the road to your argument is you're increasing it just slightly from one percent capacity. I'm looking at the absolute number of additional trips, right? And have denied that they're more. 35 additional pmp car trips. 38. 0.2, 5.30. I'm looking at them in an hour. I understand. I just think that there's that you can use numbers to make something smaller or make something bigger, right. And that really doesn't matter to me, at least in my analysis of this, I'm not a traffic engineer either. I'm not even a very good driver somewhat. I would say Figure out your increase an arbitrary percentage is different from looking at the absolute number. And so that's where that's all we will we different? I understand your I understand I just I would suggest that you asked the city now to have their traffic people at all your meetings. >> Because the methodology for doing the studies, we don't make it up. I know it's set and it's set by professional traffic engineers. So you need to have someone here. Because we don't even get that. We don't get to comment on the study. Mister write the check. We pay for. And that said, I hear you and you can probably tell from my comments to the city that I wanted that explanation from the traffic people, not from someone downstream of them who wasn't privy to the to the knowledge. So I I completely agree with you, sir. It is a minor impact year. I will tell Thank you, Mister Lee. I had no questions. Thank you, Mister No questions. call people back on that while we're talking about it, the traffic has never been part of the 14 criteria that comes up constantly. This has been brought around over, never never going to brought somebody here. And we ignore the expert analysis. What's the point that it is something we're supposed to consider and it is utility utility. It's part of the, you know, impact. It's significant. You know. >> Some of this in the standard

| CITY OF SARASOTA Development Review Division Development Services Department MINUTES OF THE REGULAR MEETING OF THE PLANNING BOARD/LOCAL PLANNING AGENCY FEBRUARY 11,2026 at 1:30 p.m. in the Sarasota City Commission Chambers | | | --- | --- | | Planning Board Members Present: | Chair Shane LaMay,Vice Chair Douglas Christy,PB Member Dan Clermont,PB Member Dan Deleo,PB Member Alex Neihaus | | Planning Board Members Absent: | | | Staff Members Present: | John Shamsey,Deputy City Attorney Alison Christie,AICP,General Manager,Development Services Rebecca Webster,AICP,Acting Development Review Chief Planner Miles Larsen,Manager,Public Broadcasting John Nopper,Coordinator,Public Broadcasting Amanda Cisneros,Development Review Coordinator,Development Services |

## I. CALL MEETING TO ORDER AND ROLL CALL

1:30 p.m.

Chair Shane LaMay called the meeting to order. Alison Christie (acting as the Planning Board's Secretary) called the roll.

## II. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE

## III. CHANGES TO THE ORDER OF THE DAY

None.

## IV. LAND USE ADMINISTRATION PUBLIC HEARINGS

NOTICE TO THE PUBLIC: At this time anyone wishing to speak to take an oath. (Time limitations will be established by the

at the following public hearings will be required Planning Board.)

## A. Reading of the Pledge of Conduct

Chair LaMay read the Pledge of Conduct. In Quasi-Judicial procedures and asked the Be communications.

Reputy City Attorney Shamsey explained the Board Members to disclose ex-parte

## B. Quasi-Judicial

1. Plymouth Harbor New Building (700 John Ringling Blvd): Rezone with Site Plan Application Nos. 25-SP-01 and 25-RE-01 request for Rezone with Site Plan approval to construct an 8-story multi-family residential building constructed over a three-level parking structure on the $ \\pm 1 6. 5 9 $ -acre subject property.The new building will contain

* * *

151 residential senior living dwelling units, amenity areas, and support facilities. The site is currently zoned Medical Charitable Institutional (MCI) with a Future Land Use Classification of Metropolitan/Regional #3. The Applicant has proposed a rezone to Residential Multiple Family 5 (RMF-F), an implementing Zone District of the Future Land Use Classification. Access is proposed to remain from John Ringling Blvd. No attainable units are proposed.

(Rebecca Webster, AICP, Acting Development Review Chief Planner, Development Services)

## Applicant presentation:

Jeff Weatherhead, Craig Kimmel, Joel Freedman, Joe Bena, and Matt Dunn presented to the dias. Mr. Freedman provided the location and property size. Mr. Weatherhead discussed what Plymouth Harbor is and the intake process. Mr. Freedman discussed the Zoning. Mr. Kimmell discussed the existing buildings, the location of the proposed building, and connection between the existing building and proposed. Mr. Kimmell provided details on the proposed parking and independent living apartments. Mr. Freedman spoke to the Criteria for Rezones, the Standards for Review and explained why a Variance was requested.

PB Member Neihaus posed questions regarding purchasing a piece of property from the City of Sarasota, connectivity to property amenities, pedestrian crosswalks and tree removal. Mr. Freedman, Mr. Weatherhead and Mr. Dunn spoke to the questions.

PB Member Deleo posed questions regarding average income base. Mr. Weatherhead spoke to the question. PB Member Deleo posed questions regarding parking. Mr. Freedman spoke to the questions. PB Member Deleo posed questions regarding the location, height of the current building, zoning, and review process during the existing buildings proposal. PB Member Deleo also posed questions regarding the proposed building. Mr. Freedman spoke to the questions.

PB Member Clermont spoke to the proposed project. PB Member Clermont posed a questions regarding the need for the proposed addition, accommodation for lower income residents, parking, and building design. Mr. Weatherhead, Mr. Freedman, and Mr. Kimmel spoke to the questions.

Chair LaMay spoke to the proposed request. Chair LaMay posed questions regarding the cooling towers, Public Art and future development. Mr. Kimmel spoke to the questions.

Vice Chair Christy posed questions regarding maximum density and building design. Mr. Kimmel spoke to the questions.

PB Member Clermont posed a question regarding stormwater. Mr. Bena spoke to the question.

* * *

PB Member Neihaus posed questions regarding Public Art current employment, and initiation fees. Mr. Weatherhead spoke to the questions.

## Staff Presentation:

Rebecca Webster, AICP, Acting Development Review Chief Planner, Development Services presented and discussed the location, zoning, abutting properties, parking, number of dwelling units and noted that the proposed development is compliant. Ms. Webster briefly discussed tree removal and mitigation. Ms. Webster also noted that the application meets all Standards for Review and Staff recommends approval to City Commission.

PB Member Neihaus posed questions regarding traffic. Ms. Webster spoke to the questions. Ms. Christie provided clarification regarding the Traffic Study and the review process. PB Member Neihaus continued to pose questions regarding the study. Ms. Christie spoke to the questions.

PB Member Clermont posed a question regarding the zone district and Future Land Use Classification. Ms. Webster spoke to the question.

PB Member Deleo spoke to the proposed zoning. Deputy City Attorney Shamsey provided clarification regarding Rezoning and Future Land Use Classifications and compatibility.

PB Member Clermont posed a question regarding the proposed Standards for light and air flow. Ms. Webster spoke to the question.

Vice Chair Christy posed questions regarding density, zoning, and Dwelling Units. Ms. Webster spoke to the questions. Ms. Christie clarified the definition of Dwelling Units.

## Affected Persons:

Input received by Tom Duncan.

## Citizen Input:

No citizen input.

## Staff Rebuttal:

Planning Board/Local Planning Agency Regular Meeting

Planning Board/Local Planning Agency Regular Meeting

AGENDA

February 11, 2026 - 01:00 P.M. City Hall Commission Chambers

Notice of Meeting Click Here to View Notice of Meeting

I.

CALL MEETING TO ORDER AND ROLL CALL

II.

PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE

III.

CHANGES TO THE ORDER OF THE DAY

IV.

LAND USE ADMINISTRATION PUBLIC HEARINGS NOTICE TO THE PUBLIC: At this time anyone wishing to speak at the following public hearings will be required to take an oath. (Time limitations will be established by the Planning Board.)

NOTICE TO THE PUBLIC: At this time anyone wishing to speak at the following public hearings will be required to take an oath. (Time limitations will be established by the Planning Board.)

A.

Quasi-Judicial

1.

Plymouth Harbor New Building (700 John Ringling Blvd): Rezone with Site Plan Application Nos. 25-SP-01 and 25-RE-01 request for Rezone with Site Plan approval to construct an 8-story multi-family residential building constructed over a three-level parking structure on the ±16.59-acre subject property. The new building will contain 151 residential senior living dwelling units, amenity areas, and support facilities. The site is currently zoned Medical Charitable Institutional (MCI) with a Future Land Use Classification of Metropolitan/Regional #3. The Applicant has proposed a rezone to Residential Multiple Family 5 (RMF-F), an implementing Zone District of the Future Land Use Classification. Access is proposed to remain from John Ringling Blvd. No attainable units are proposed. Rebecca Webster, AICP, Acting Development Review Chief Planner, Development Services)

Click Here to View Staff Report

Click Here to View Site Plan

Applicant Presentation

Click Here to View Applicant Presentation

V.

CITIZEN?S INPUT NOTICE TO THE PUBLIC: At this time Citizens may address the Planning Board on topics of concern. Items which have been previously discussed at Public Hearings may not be addressed at this time. (A maximum 5-minute time limit.)

NOTICE TO THE PUBLIC: At this time Citizens may address the Planning Board on topics of concern. Items which have been previously discussed at Public Hearings may not be addressed at this time. (A maximum 5-minute time limit.)

VI.

APPROVAL OF MINUTES

1.

January 14, 2026

Click Here to View Draft Minutes

VII.

PRESENTATION OF TOPICS BY STAFF Items presented are informational only (no action taken).  Any issue presented that may require future action will be placed on the next available agenda for discussion.

VIII.

PRESENTATION OF TOPICS BY PLANNING BOARD Items presented are informational only (no action taken).  Any issue presented that may require future action will be placed on the next available agenda for discussion.

IX.

ADJOURNMENT Note: The City?s Website address is sarasotafl.gov. Select the meeting under ?Meetings/Agendas/Video? from the Main Web Page to view agendas, videos of meetings, and minutes.

Notice to Public

Speaker Sheets Click Here to View Speaker Sheets

Showing the first 24,000 of 72,445 characters. The full document is at the source.

for a company? Yes. >> Mister president Mister Yes, Mister Clermont there. Mister Christie. Yes, for this tournament yes. Any changes to the order of the day or less for changes to go to the day. One topic and urchins and pledge of allegiance. Led the United States of America and to the for which it stands. One nation under God, with liberty and justice for all. All right. And that brings us to. When you on the Okay. conduct. We may disagree but we will be respectful to one another. We will direct all comments to issues. We will not engage in personal attacks. sorry. I'm struggling to this paper that does And this is not source keeping too. It is quasi judicial Sorry. All right. We're going to open the public and request judicial and that brings us to the applicant and we'll ask the parte attorney. I will get fine. want to run through the cause is just procedures and then we'll get to the oath after that. Because you just hearing is a slightly more formal hearing that a legislative public hearing. >> There are parties to it just hearing the parties, including applicant, the city and anyone who has applied for it received affect a person's status under the city's. Criteria, its code parties may proffer evidence, testimony, expert testimony and documentary evidence parties have the opportunity to cross examine opposing parties in the present. In closing rebuttal argument. The decision of the planning board and a quasi judicial hearing must be based on the competent, substantial evidence in the record and the board must apply the appropriate standards review in the zoning code relating to the type of approval requested. At the beginning of the public hearing. Board members indicate if they've had any ex parte communications on the matter, which is contact with any parties outside of the public hearing today. So at this point, I will now ask the board members if they had ex parte communications on this matter. Kristi I have not. >> I met with city staff. Okay. Thank And you have in your quest protected persons status. >> We give me a second. We had one person. Apply. And that Mary Martha, Great House Gentile. She present. They're so okay. >> So will skip defected. Persons can and then suggested time limits for each partition. >> The applicant. Has requested 20 minutes. That's with the board, which is 5 minutes of the usual. 15, I didn't know. I thought it >> asked for now 50's get I take you up on for you. Haha. All right. We'll go. Get requested 15 minutes 15 minutes part because they're doing consensus 15 minutes. All And we've already done and that opens it up to the applicant. >> And now I would just one come before the board today, too. Rise and raise your right hand for the these where or affirm that the testimony evidence or factual representations, you're about to give a present to the plane board this 11th day of February 2020 cents are truthful. ? ? >> All right. Keep was results for the record. Did you open the public hearing that OK, Good afternoon. My name is Jeff weather the president and CEO of Harbor. >> Craig Kimmel partner with Psr. Thanks, Joe Freeman. Freeman Consulting. Job in a civil engineer. Kimley-horn Matt Dunn landscape architect coming on. I have the overhead. Please. I think we're all familiar with the property Plymouth Harbor. It's been here since 1966, I believe. This is the property here. It's about 16.5, 9 acres. You can there's John Ringling Boulevard. There is a Sarasota Bay. What I like to do first, though, before I get into this too much is have Judge Jeff weather had just give a bro prefer what's Plymouth Harbor? All right, again, good afternoon, everybody >> so Plymouth Harbor is a continuing care retirement community licensed by the state of Florida, which means that we provide housing and services to older adults, independent living home care. Memory care, assisted living and skilled nursing facility. Kind of all in one community. We've been serving the community since in January. We celebrate it. The 60th anniversary of our first resident moving in. We are a not for profit organization founded by Reverend John Whitney me. You know, I'm from First Congregational Church here in town and we have been with a not for profit volunteer board. Over 60 years. We currently have 215 independent living residences and that will kind of come into play here a little bit they're well known in the community. We have a 250 people on our waitlist. 50% of the people who currently move into Plymouth Harbor move into a smaller apartment than the one that they choose and then move later, which is very disruptive for somebody average age of injuries. 81. Only 20% of our independent living units become available every year. So kind of a typical a wait list for somebody who wants a two-bedroom apartment somewhere between 5 and 8 years. Again, we have 250 people on that waitlist. And as we look to explore this expansion, we have a list of about 250 households said yes, this is something that they strongly want to consider. So. Thank you for the time. Great. Thank you, Jeff. >> So we have a 2 petitions in front of you right now. Today. This is the future land use map. It's a rezoning and we have the site proffered site plan. The property there, purple. That's Plymouth Harbor actually it Metropolitan Regional number 3 in the comp plan. Land use plan. And it's implementing zone district in the plan is Rmf 5. So that's what we're doing. We're requesting the arm 5 zone district. What's interesting is that currently, of course, the tower that's theirs completely nonconforming because MCI zoning, which is the existing zoning, has a 35 foot height limit. So obviously, this is going to be reducing the nonconformities. that's a good thing. So now I'm going to have Craig Kimmel, the architect kind of go through me, put up the same plane. First here's a site plan. >> So good A little bit about the project itself. One of the things that were we're really looking at is the the only available land really that's that's left on this property to build on its current at great parking with some covered structures. There. Just person control. So that is basically that rectangle is the location of the site. The project does extend of cross the that road that creates a connection to the existing building. It's very important in in senior living to to create continuity also to to kind of reduce the U.S. and them between the existing and proposed bridging that and really trying to create unification of the entire campus is is really inherently part of what we're doing. There's also some improvements that are taking place at the front. And talk a little bit about that as we go this image just kind of gives you a sense of of the existing and proposed the tower obviously is existing everything on the image to the right of that is existing as well. And colonies space, which is that 3 story just to the left of the towers existing. What we're proposing is is basically a 3 story parking garage that replaces the existing parking and provides parking for the proposed 151 independent living apartment residents. And then on top of that 8 stories of of independent living apartments that that fits within the Arma 5 requirements that are defined as as Joe mentioned in this change of zone. So that's that's kind of the the overview as it relates to the the front of the building. One of the things that has always been kind of part of what me Plymouth Harbor, kind of special was this arrangement from the front entry in. But it was a boulevard and that created some real safety concerns. And that was identified by staff. And as a result, we've really reinvented the front door to still be symmetrical about the front porch share and the tower and recognizing that the entry to the new building is kind of secondary to that but through that process, we've been able to really develop and add parking both surface at this structured parking underneath the building to accommodate us. The needs of growth of the campus. Just a little bit about kind of the architecture we wanted to be complimentary to the air and respectful to the original architecture. It also didn't want to necessarily be a So so we really wanted the building to have a base of middle and top much like the existing building does Kerry the colors forward, which is primarily white. But there's also some some unity, gray colors that the kind of get a common dated in different areas within the building and and then kind of work from there with with really the this offset between parking and building as a plaza amenity space for the Both on the on on both sides of the building really is as we start looking and then the bridge element is the is is a dining and fitness and auditorium space specifically for the residents of Plymouth Harbor and that is kind of that element that allows that kind of activity between the new and the existing. Great. Thank you. >> Okay. and this just in case. So Craig the arm at 5 zoning is the last 25 maker. When we do this edition, we end up that 24 point. >> To 3 units per acre. So within that the high we could go up to 90 But we're a little bit. I think we're at an actual very close right here. again, as I mentioned, revive rezoning. We've we've reduced the nonconformity. So that's a good thing. So I'm going to go through that reviewed the rezoning review criteria right now. Number one is the proposed change country to the future land use plan, as I've mentioned, are mystified as implementing zoning district. Compatibility with existing land use patterns. This really is the land use patterns in area, quite frankly. So it's just expanding on the existing property. Creation of an isolated district. Know it's the implementing zone district. Population density Dewey over Texas system, sewer, water and all that. All of those have been concurrency the signed off on that. chant where the changing conditions have caused this mean as you can tell they they have a way this I mean, so this is an obvious expansion for them to meet that need. Will there be a drainage problem created by know and sometimes you hear Joe is here. If you have any questions about that. reduce the flow of air and light. You can see it's still a very open campus. It's not going have any impact on that. Whether the change will be a deterrent to improvement for the adjacent area. Know the end of this investment and know what the cost of this is, but it's significant investment. It's going in here. It will just encourage people to keep upgrading their facilities properties. granted special privileges versus public welfare. No, we follow that. We follow the process. And again, there's major need for senior housing in this sector. And so this will be helping solving that problem. Is that out of scale with the need to the neighborhood you can see a lower project and the existing tower. So we think we think it's compatible. Is it impossible to find other properties? Again, that's really not applicable. This is what they own and they're expanding on their own property. Lansky now into the site plan We've met all the landscaping requirements again. Matt from Kimley-horn is here. If you have specific questions about that. Now there was a a there is a should say lift station on the property. This is kind of an interesting. Twist to this project. There is a list station on the property. And it's hard to see right there. But and there was a pipe that went to that list station. So we came in and we ended up having to going to be required to remove that pipe because it shouldn't be there. It was a pipe to drain into the the station. I guess again, Joe can explain more. But then the lift station itself. It's inside a property. So we needed to get a variance from a setback. From our new building to that. And we did get the variance. Granted, it's a 27 foot. 45 4.5 inch. Variance from my front yard setback. This created from the list station property. So again, it just in that we could relocate to the station that was not going to be possible. So as a result of that variances, of course, we meet all the requirements. Now, the other interesting thing on the traffic study that was done. We agreed to kind of coordinate and work with Florida Department of Transportation on investigating whether or not a pedestrian cross can occur in this area. I know there's a specific name for the type a crosswalk, but again, Joe is here to talk about that will do the studies. We'll see if the DOT wants to do this. And if they do, we've agreed to do it. So quickly. The review criteria, proposed plan in content standards of the district. We need all the requirements. This is day whether on balance a proposed development lay out a compatible with the plan. Is it's been positioned on the site very well. And action strategy. 3.5 states. If we meet all the zoning code requirements, we're considered to be consistent with the comprehensive plan. Number 3 is as the required information they provided. It has. We wouldn't be here for one, whether there are ways to change the configuration to make it less impactful on the surrounding area. Again, I think that the entrance and that whole concept of how the entrance works, it's it's pretty dramatic. And I think it's it's really well done. Thank at the overhead again. It's very well. That's going to be a very pleasing entrance for the the Hole Scylla t. Do we make adequate provisions for pedestrian access? We're not changing the access. Does the plan make adequate provisions for parking and loading? They'll be 590 spaces and a new parking over 700 total for the entire property. as we said, we're working to if they want to cross walk across Lee Boulevard. So that's setting a minute before he left pretty deal. We're here to answer any and a side project and the beautiful addition, there's a lot of people want to move in. This. Thank you. home. I have a couple of. Rand of sorts of questions. I'd like to start with. Can anyone give me the history of why you had to acquire a small piece of property from the city? Yeah. Is that related to the list? that that wasn't pie. talking about. >> So once it got removed, we're having to remove it having that property. There made no sense the city didn't need more and it would have created more setback issues from this property line. So the city said we don't need you want to buy. So we went through the appraisal process and the city commission agreed to sell it. Okay. Good. And and I saw in materials that there's a that's been that sale has been completed. Is that correct? The clothes going to be in later this month? All right. Good because it looked fresh. Yeah. So it's it's all done. And Mister Appleby is here. >> Yeah, it's it's it's under contract. And it's supposed to March 3rd of March, we're in. We're in contact with the with the for mishandling. The closing soaking the seems to be moving forward. I just wanted to to make sure because it looked to me like the plan is contingent on that. definitely So you're not going to have any no. >> We're not have any issues with that. That's going to happen. >> And you know, and and in reality to put context that strip of land, I think 9 out of 10 times would have been easement probably that the That would be So it's it's little atypical that the so you know, it's pretty simple reason bus pretty. And it's yes, owns. >> I went out there. So, you know, real estate law, House really I was surprised. It was easement. Yeah. I'm sure you were I have a question conductivity are describing. can just correct. So a couple questions about that. here's this beautiful thing behind existing building. I believe they call the rookery yes. >> And I didn't see any Khan activity on the plans for people with the new building to be able to >> access that easily. The most wonderfully to explain to us how this, you know, looking at sea 502, and the other things that you for other things you put out that. Make it look like it would be hard for people that it's absolutely stunning back there. And I really it really is. And so I just wanted to understand what your thinking was about how people access that So the connection point actually between the existing and the new is really pretty. >> Pretty much just that one corner and right at that one quarter, we have 2 elevators that basically go from grade all the way up to the just in this Here it right on the corner. And so from there, you can literally walk out the corner of the existing building and you're right there at the Rotary. Okay, great. >> And I this I couldn't figure out what was on C 502. Is this in the upper right corner of of the site plan? Is this the FDOT crosswalk? Yes. If you are thinking about it. What's the logic behind that? Just go see the other side town when there's a stop over The bus stop. Okay. Could certainly get it. And then my final for you guys is about the Banyan tree that in front of the East building. That's not going to be touched, right? That's a beautiful that's being removed. Yeah, that's >> Yeah. The the live oak is stay. That's the one that's closest to the front existing workers share. But on the other side of canyon is removed. That's right where we're making that that connection. I wondered about that. has the Take a look at tree. >> technically, it's invasive for the city's code so we don't OK, but I liked it thank you. The maintenance people aren't so thrilled about it. And especially now. Thank you much. Thank you. Thank you. Thanks, everybody. >> My questions or the director of the facility. You said that your nonprofit course you are. That doesn't mean you serve the poor, correct? >> We do have a assistance program for residents who have exhausted their funds. >> I I know that your lovely organization that did answer my question. That was that was not my question. You want to try again? so no, we tend to serve a more affluent population, correct? Your of the population that you serve our wealthy, elderly people retirement, correct? Yes. All right. With respect to to parking you're adding 500 and 90 total parking spaces, correct? It's going to have 590 and there were removing some parking spaces. So but >> understood but but the idea is that you're going to have 590 additional parking spaces with a total for everything in the development of 700. True, correct? All right. So between the parking garage, the 24 existing surface parking spaces that are going to remain the 38 surface parking spaces that are proposed that equals the total number, correct? Yes, alright, whether there are some parking spaces under the existing building as well. >> The existing building, you mean the tower the East Jordan and also the Northwest not specifically under the tower, exactly, but but to either side of understood. So. Just so we're clear the total parking spaces for the entire development of 700 trip. Yes, okay. 790 790. Okay. Great. Thank you. That's 590 parking spaces for the new development and 110 for the existing. That right. I guess you could look at that with our 20200 for the decision, right? I'm asking, have you guys look at the plant? It's it's all. Well, it's a it's all for the whole campus. Okay. Yeah. I'm not sure that really doesn't nation between the existing in the new in terms of parking. Okay. Bruce part, Mister Franklin talked about reducing the nonconformity in. This is, of course, hailed in your documents in the city's reported as a great thing, reducing the nonconformity. want to talk a little bit some questions related to the nonconformity. site consists of most the property is most of the small barrier island. Correct? Joel? All right. It's he's my twin brother. I Haha. >> It's part of the barrier island system. I guess you could say yeah, it's it's most of a small barrier island, right? Okay. I I wouldn't call it a barrier island because the barrier island. On the other side of across I'm not I'm not. And and you know, expert okay. All right. it's a an island portion and there's water something else surrounding right? I mean that that's what it looks like when I look at it. Yes, really an island. But maybe I guess if you look across the street but never going So the existing nonconformity relates to the historic tower. Current other things, correct it all as this story tower. 24 Stuart, when it's 260 years. Something as a 25, I'm sorry. it's 200 plus yet 200 plus, but about 260 some Okay. That's very high for that area. Correct? Oh, yeah. Yeah. So it's a it's a crazy high toll tower. They wouldn't be there. But for this historical anomaly, right? Yeah, it was done before zoning exist. Yeah. Exactly. We want it done. 66 the original? Yeah. you know, after zoning n, you know, sort of proper planning, which we're all in favor of good, common sense planning if if good common sense planning had been in place at the time, that never would have been constructed fair. Well, again, you know, height of the building never would right to you. I mean, let's be honest that you never would have gotten Bill right now. Let's say created downtown core downtown bayfront. I don't ever want We can. I mean, we can agree, right? There are buildings now that are taller than Okay. And we get your job to quibble. I guess you want to quibble, but no, I don't know what your point is. Okay. My point is that building is a very a significant historical anomaly in the development of the area Okay. We can agree on a legal nonconforming use, correct? On conforming structure. Absolutely. that's a represents a significant not only height, nonconforming height, but intensity of development in that particular area to agree. Density is. It's not really a change in density. I'm not asking about the current be that this thing that existing building was well below the maximum density allowed in the MCI District. Okay. with respect to the a change in the Sony there are 2 real, much of the zoning is similar right? There are really 2 issues in terms of the change in zoning. One is the max building coverage, which is essentially massing right? Yeah, OK? So increase of 10% of the amount of massing by virtue of the change in zoning OK, yes, yes, okay. So and then the height. The existing heights, 35 feet under a and C district, right? Correct. Okay. In the propose own district, it's 90 feet and we're proposing to go up to the full 90 feet, correct. arrest of party great. which was my next point. The you talk about 90 feet is the building height. But of course not. That's not the actual building height. If you have a normal, no person. Who went out to the site and they said helped holes that building. They would say it's 115 feet toll, right? Correct. Correct. Okay. And that's because you're measuring the 90 foot building height from the top of the 3 story parking garage. True. Correct. Her so the proposed development, the site plan and the rezone represents a significant increase in the density in the massing on that site. Fair. What does the site's not fully developed right? I really yes or no. It's an increase in in density intensity under that compared to existing. Yes, okay. All right. I think that's it does go my questions. Thank you very Thank Yes, I appreciate the renderings. We don't always get the more and more we're getting them. But it does kind of help that vision. You know, this is a kind of top-down review site plan. >> The zoning it's nice to be able to see what you're proposing just kind of helps the whole picture. I don't know that anybody here. Not me is old enough to remember when this building was I've just always wondered. And this is just more comment. That was questions that we have answer. What in the world, the city people think when this building was being built in 66, he's a beloved building. 25 stories now would create a look, you push so that that time really been something most people just thought. Well, it's way out there. You know, so that, you have you ever heard what the reaction was

All meeting actions

Source coverage incomplete

4 meeting items captured. The published sources do not prove this is the complete docket.

Showing 4 of 4

Browse by category4 actions

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
Agenda packetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Action agendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Transcript or captionsSource recordingread transcript
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Coverage and corrections

Records considered

  • Planning Board/Local Planning Agency Regular Meeting — Minutes
  • Planning Board/Local Planning Agency Regular Meeting
  • Planning Board/Local Planning Agency Regular Meeting — Closed Captions

Not claimed by this page

  • Item-linked, attributed deliberation
  • A source-grounded next meeting date
  • A plain-English overview is not available.
  • Official outcomes have not been published.
  • The available transcript has no reliable timestamps.
  • Transcript coverage is partial.
  • Speakers have not been reliably matched to public profiles.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.
  • An individual roll-call roster is not available.
  • Low-grade, ungraded, procedural, or superseded items remain in the complete agenda inventory rather than the meeting digest.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: 4e04c71136b392008351dc9b22de59a5. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record