POLISCOPE

The public record

MARTINEZ (CONTRACOSTA COUNTY)Decisions and attributed speech publishedPartial coverage

Planning Commission

Tuesday, April 9, 2024 · Government meeting record

The 30-second read

Recorded outcome

Planning Commission

Why it matters

The official meeting record is available below. Item-level plain-language summaries are not available yet.

What happens next

No later meeting or follow-up date is stated in the reviewed record.

An official outcome record and a transcript or captions are published for this meeting.

Record text

No transcript is held for this meeting. Recording: Media

Action Minutes Planning Commission Regular Meeting Tuesday, April 9, 2024 at 7:00 p.m. Via Video/Teleconference Page 1 of 5 * Full details are available via audio/video recording on our website. Microsoft Internet Explorer browser is recommended for video-viewing compatibility or enable Adobe Flash on your default browser. Commissioners on Video Conference City Staff on Video Conference Chair Sean Trambley Vice Chair Tracey Casella Commissioner Jonathan Bash Commissioner Joseph Evans Commissioner Susan Gustofson Commissioner Rochelle Johnson Commissioner Jason Martin Commissioner John Klopp (Alternate) Present Excused Present Present Excused Absent Present Present Michael P. Cass, Planning Manager Daniel Gordon, Associate Planner Dee Dee Fendley, Administrative Aide III Call to Order Meeting called to order at 7:00 p.m. Public Comment (01:26 in video) None Consent Calendar (01:51 in video) 1. Approval of the January 23, 2024 Planning Commission Action Minutes Speakers: None Public Comment: None Closing Comments: None Motion to: Approve Motion by: Commissioner Bash Seconded By: Commissioner Klopp Motion passed 5-0 Sean Trambley Aye Susan Gustofson Excused Tracey Casella Excused Rochelle Johnson Absent Jonathan Bash Aye Jason Martin Aye Joseph Evans Aye John Klopp (Alternate) Aye Regular Items (02:38 in video) 2. Conduct a public hearing and adopt Resolution No. 24-02, recommending that the City Council adopt an Ordinance Approving a Zoning Map and Zoning Text Amendment to amend the Martinez Municipal Code by: 1) comprehensively updating the permitted and conditionally permitted uses for the Commercial, Industrial, Research and Development, and Professional and Administrative zoning districts; 2) amending Chapter 22.04 (Definitions) to remove the

Planning Commission Action Minutes Tuesday, April 9, 2024 Page 2 of 5 individual numbering and add definitions consistent with the updated uses; 3) amending Chapters 22.14 (PA Professional and Administrative Office Districts), 22.15 (C Commercial Districts), and 22.18 (I Industrial Districts) by revising setback and building separation standards to be consistent with other zoning districts; 4) amending Chapters 22.15 (RD Research and Development Districts) and 22.18 (I Industrial Districts) by modifying development standards to incentivize industrial development and establishing performance standards; 5) repealing Chapter 22.30 (U Undesignated Districts); 6) adding Chapter 22.31 (Temporary Use Permits) to regulate temporary uses, such as mobile vendors; 7) Revising Section 22.36.060 (Parking – Industrial Uses) to reduce industrial parking requirements; 8) revising Chapter 22.43 (Accessory Dwelling Units and Junior Accessory Dwelling Units) to comply with State law and clarify existing regulations; 9) revising Chapter 22.08 (District Designations) to be consistent with the elimination of the TC Thoroughfare Commercial, CR Commercial Recreation, CI Controlled Industrial, and U Undesignated zoning districts; 10) approving a Zoning Map Amendment: for 45 parcels zoned TC/NC Thoroughfare Commercial/Neighborhood Commercial to NC Neighborhood Commercial; for six parcels zoned TC Thoroughfare Commercial to NC Neighborhood Commercial; for four parcels zoned CR Commercial Recreation to NC Neighborhood Commercial; for 11 parcels zoned M-29 Multifamily to R- 1.5 Residential; for 12 parcels zoned PA/CI Professional and Administrative/Controlled Industrial to PA/RD Professional and Administrative/ Research and Development; for 14 parcels zoned RB Retail Business to NC Neighborhood Commercial; and for one parcel zoned ECD/CI Environmental Conservation District/Controlled Industrial to ECD/SC Environmental Conservation District/Service Commercial; 11) approving a Zoning Map Amendment to rezone all parcels zoned U Undesignated to appropriate zoning designations consistent with the General Plan; and 12) other minor revisions. Speakers: • Daniel Gordon, Associate Planner, gave a presentation outlining the project. • Commissioner Martin asked for clarification of a “legal parking space” regarding food trucks (mobile vendors). He confirmed that current, vacant properties do not have to activate their storefronts and the proposed regulations would only apply to properties requesting a planning entitlement. Commissioner Martin asked who would be responsible for obtaining the temporary use permit. • Chair Trambley confirmed that food trucks using legal parking spaces would need to pay the parking fees while occupying these spaces. He asked if the update to food truck regulations was bringing the City into compliance with State law. • Commissioner Klopp asked if the updates would change the process for approval of Conditional Use Permits. He inquired about the process for controversial uses. Public Comment: • Dennis Boettcher stated that Five Suns Brewing is the most impacted business at this time. He supports the proposed food

Planning Commission Action Minutes Tuesday, April 9, 2024 Page 3 of 5 truck regulations. He asked for information regarding the process for obtaining a Temporary Use Permit. He asked if the City has received any feedback from current food truck operators in Martinez. Closing Comments: • Commissioner Bash suggested that the time the food trucks are allowed to operate be extended beyond 10:00 p.m., given that people may be drinking alcoholic beverages and food options late in the evening may be beneficial from a safety standpoint. • Planning Manager Cass suggested reconsideration of the permitted hours could occur when the Noise Ordinance is updated. Motion to: Adopt Resolution No. 24-02, recommending that the City Council adopt an Ordinance Approving a Zoning Map and Zoning Text Amendment to amend the Martinez Municipal Code by: 1) comprehensively updating the permitted and conditionally permitted uses for the Commercial, Industrial, Research and Development, and Professional and Administrative zoning districts; 2) amending Chapter 22.04 (Definitions) to remove the individual numbering and add definitions consistent with the updated uses; 3) amending Chapters 22.14 (PA Professional and Administrative Office Districts), 22.15 (C Commercial Districts), and 22.18 (I Industrial Districts) by revising setback and building separation standards to be consistent with other zoning districts; 4) amending Chapters 22.15 (RD Research and Development Districts) and 22.18 (I Industrial Districts) by modifying development standards to incentivize industrial development and establishing performance standards; 5) repealing Chapter 22.30 (U Undesignated Districts); 6) adding Chapter 22.31 (Temporary Use Permits) to regulate temporary uses, such as mobile vendors; 7) Revising Section 22.36.060 (Parking – Industrial Uses) to reduce industrial parking requirements; 8) revising Chapter 22.43 (Accessory Dwelling Units and Junior Accessory Dwelling Units) to comply with State law and clarify existing regulations; 9) revising Chapter 22.08 (District Designations) to be consistent with the elimination of the TC Thoroughfare Commercial, CR Commercial Recreation, CI Controlled Industrial, and U Undesignated zoning districts; 10) approving a Zoning Map Amendment: for 45 parcels zoned TC/NC Thoroughfare Commercial/Neighborhood Commercial to NC Neighborhood Commercial; for six parcels zoned TC Thoroughfare Commercial to NC Neighborhood Commercial; for four parcels zoned CR Commercial Recreation to NC Neighborhood Commercial; for 11 parcels zoned M-29 Multifamily to R-1.5 Residential; for 12 parcels zoned PA/CI Professional and Administrative/Controlled Industrial to PA/RD Professional and Administrative/ Research and Development;

Planning Commission Action Minutes Tuesday, April 9, 2024 Page 4 of 5 for 14 parcels zoned RB Retail Business to NC Neighborhood Commercial; and for one parcel zoned ECD/CI Environmental Conservation District/Controlled Industrial to ECD/SC Environmental Conservation District/Service Commercial; 11) approving a Zoning Map Amendment to rezone all parcels zoned U Undesignated to appropriate zoning designations consistent with the General Plan; and 12) other minor revisions. Motion by: Commissioner Martin Seconded By: Commissioner Bash Motion passed 5-0 Sean Trambley Aye Susan Gustofson Excused Tracey Casella Excused Rochelle Johnson Absent Jonathan Bash Aye Jason Martin Aye Joseph Evans Aye John Klopp (Alternate) Aye Commission Items (43:13 in video) Comments/ Updates None Planning Manager Items (43:21 in video) Comments/ Updates Planning Manager Cass provided the following updates: • The City resubmitted the Revised Adopted Housing Element to the Department of Housing and Community Development (“HCD”) for certification. The City Council also approved a revised and restated Resolution. There will be a 60-day review period by HCD. • Early in 2024, the City Council approved amendments to the City’s cannabis regulations. • The City’s Waterfront Marina Trust Land Use Plan was approved by the City Council in March and has been submitted to the State Lands Commission for final approval. • The Housing Element Annual Progress report was brought forward at the last City Council meeting. The report was encouraging as the City issued building permits for 88 dwelling units in 2023. • The City Council also approved the Universal Design Regulations which deal with accessibility requirements for new residential construction. • The regulations for all-electric construction approved by the City Council in late 2022 have been eliminated and will not be enforced by the City. • The following two items will be up for consideration soon:  Density bonus regulations to comply with State law  Update of the Growth Management Element of the General Plan

Planning Commission Action Minutes Tuesday, April 9, 2024 Page 5 of 5 Communications (51:05 in video) Comments/ Updates None Adjournment (51:23 in video) Chair Trambley adjourned the meeting at 7:51 p.m. Sean Trambley, Chair Dee Dee Fendley, Administrative Aide III

Transcript or captions textPlanning Commission — Closed Captions

Showing the first 24,000 of 36,465 characters. The full document is at the source.

>> IT EVENING, EVERYBODY. I PLEDGE ALLEGIANCE IT IS TUESDAY, APRIL 9th. 7:00. LET'S CALL THIS SESSION TO ORDER. WE WILL START WITH THE PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE. >> TO THE FLAG OF THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA AND TO THE REPUBLIC FOR WHICH IT STANDS ONE NATION UNDER GOD INDIVISIBLE WITH LIBERTY AND JUSTICE FOR ALL. >> JONATHAN BASH? JOSEPH EVANS? SUSAN GUSTOFSON IS EXCUSED. ROCHELLE JOHNSON? JASON MARTIN? >> THANK YOU. WE WILL CONTINUE . AS YOUR APPOINTED GOVERNING BOARD WE WILL TREAT EACH OTHER IN THE PUBLIC WITH PATIENT, STABILITY, THE SAME BEHAVIOR FOR MARTINEZ IN THE COMMUNITY. THIS INCLUDES RESPECT FOR EVERYONE'S FIRST AMENDMENT RIGHT TO VOICE THEIR OPINION ON MATTERS WITHIN THE JURISDICTION EVEN IF THAT OPINION IS DIFFERENT FROM OUR OWN. THE DECISIONS WILL ME --TONIGHT WILL BE NOT FOR PERSONAL GAIN. WE WILL THEN OPEN PUBLIC COMMENT FOR ITEMS NOT LISTED ON THE AGENDA. PUBLIC COMMENT IS LIMITED TO JURISDICTION OF THE PLANNING COMMISSION AND NOT ITEMS LISTED ELSEWHERE IN THE AGENDA. WE HAVE ANY PUBLIC COMMENT? ANY IN THE DIGITAL SPACE? >> THERE ARE NO HANDS RAISED. WE WILL CLOSE THE CONSENT CALENDAR. WE ONLY HAVE ONE ITEM TO APPROVE THE ACTION MINUTES ON JANUARY 23rd, 2020 FOURTH. EDITS, QUESTIONS, REVISIONS? IF NOT, CAN I HAVE THE MOTION? >> I WILL MOVE TO APPROVE THE PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING ACTION MINUTES DATED JANUARY 23rd, 2024. >> SECOND. >> PLEASE RECORD THE VOTE. >> SEAN TRAMBLEY? JONATHAN BASH? JOSEPH EVANS? JASON MARTIN? THE MOTION PASSES. >> THANK YOU. WE WILL MOVE ON FROM THE CONSENT CALENDAR TO THE REGULAR ITEMS. SINCE IT IS SUCH A LONG ONE I WILL SAY IS LISTED ON THE AGENDA AND THEN WE WILL MOVE OVER TO A STAFF PRESENTATION. THANK YOU, DANIEL. >> THANK YOU. GOOD EVENING MEMBERS OF THE PLANNING COMMISSION. I WILL WAIT FOR THAT TO LOAD REAL QUICK. ASSOCIATE PLANNER DAN GORDON. I'M HERE TO PRESENT TO YOU THE PROPOSED ZONING TEXT AND ZONING MAP AMENDMENTS. THE FULL TITLE I WILL PRECLUDE IN THE RECOMMENDATION AT THE END. WHAT IS BEING PROPOSED TONIGHT, THE PRIMARY GOAL OF THIS FAIRLY LENGTHY ORDINANCE IS TO COMPREHENSIVELY UPDATE THE PERMITTED AND CONDITIONALLY PERMITTED USES IN THE COVE. SEVERAL OTHER ITEMS HAVE BEEN INCLUDED IN THIS EFFORT. THESE INCLUDE NEW AND REVISED DEFINITIONS PRIMARILY REFLECTING THOSE NEW USES THAT YOU WILL SEE. THE INCLUSION OF INDUSTRIAL ZONING INCENTIVES A CHAPTER ON TEMPORARY USE PERMIT, NEW REGULATIONS IN THAT CHAPTER. SOME CHANGES TO A DU REGULATIONS. REZONING OF 98 PARCELS THROUGHOUT THE CITY AND OTHER CHANGES. FIRST, LET'S COVER A LITTLE BIT ABOUT WHY THESE CHANGES ARE NECESSARY RIGHT NOW. THE FIRST IS THAT THE MUNICIPAL CODE WAS LAST COMPREHENSIVELY UPDATED IN 1975. MOST OF THE USES THAT ARE LISTED ARE NOT GESTATED BUT DOWNRIGHT ARCHAIC. I WILL JUST LIST A FEW OF MY FAVORITES TO ILLUSTRATE THIS POINT. THE CODE SPECIFICALLY LISTS THE FOLLOWING USES, MESSENGER OFFICES, TELEPHONE EXCHANGES, ADDRESS STORIES. I'M NOT SURE WHAT THAT IS. TELEGRAPH OFFICES AND MY PERSONAL FAVORITE, ICE STORAGE SHED. WHY THIS IS PROBLEMATIC IS MARTINEZ HAS PREMISES ZONING. ONLY USES LISTED IN THE ZONE ARE ALLOWED TO OPERATE MARTINEZ. WE HAVE A SITUATION WHERE THE USE IS COMMON PLACE 50 YEARS AGO ARE RESTRICTING BUSINESSES THAT THEY CAN AND CAN'T HAVE THROUGHOUT THE CITY. THE SECOND REASON IS THE HOUSING ELEMENT. THE HOUSING ELEMENT NEEDS THE CITY TO COMPLETE SEVERAL PROGRAMS BY THE END OF THIS YEAR. THESE PLANS ARE REFLECTED IN THE WORK PLAN. THESE REVISIONS ACCOMPLISH THE FOLLOWING TASKS FROM THAT WORKPLAN. TASKS 28 IS TO UPDATE ACCESSORY DRILLING UNIT REGULATIONS UPDATE FOOD TRUCK REGULATIONS. ESTABLISH INDUSTRIAL ZONING INCENTIVES AND TASK 41, UPDATE THE PERMITTED USES. THE THIRD REASON FOR THESE PROVISIONS IS CONSISTENCY AND EASE-OF-USE. THERE IS A LOT OF OVERLY COMPLICATED TERMINOLOGY AND FREEZING. THIS A LOT MORE USER FRIENDLY LANGUAGE. LAST COMMITTEE EVOLVING NEEDS OF THE COMMUNITY. THIS GOES HAND IN HAND WITH THE ARCHAIC MARTINEZ IS READY TO TAKE ADVANTAGE OF NEW BUSINESSES AND EMERGING TECHNOLOGIES AND NOT BEING STUCK IN THE PAST. SO, LET'S DIVE INTO THE PROPOSED CHANGES. FIRST IS THE UPDATE TO THE PERMITTED AND CONDITIONAL USES PROPOSES FROM A VERY LONG LIST OF VERY SPECIFIC USES TO A CATEGORY-BASED APPROACH. FOR INTERESTED, DRY CLEANING AND PET CLEANING, THEY WILL BE UNDER PERSONAL SERVICES. THIS PROVIDES MORE FLEXIBILITY AND HELPS FUTURE CODED THE ZONE WITH NEW TYPES OF BUSINESSES. NEW AND REVISED DEFINITIONS ARE INCLUDED IN THIS UPDATE. PRIMARILY THESE REFLECT THE NEW USE CATEGORIES THAT ARE BEING ESTABLISHED. FOR INSTANCE, PERSONAL SERVICES, PROFESSIONAL SERVICES, THAT KIND OF THING. SOME DEFINITIONS WERE REVISED FOR THE STAKE OF CLARITY LANGUAGE AND MODERNIZATION. ADDITIONALLY, WE WILL BE REMOVING ALL OF THE NUMBERING THAT IS ASSOCIATED WITH THE DEFINITION SINCE IT WAS A BURDEN ON STAFF. WE HAVE TO UPDATE THE NUMBERING ANYTIME WE WANTED TO ADD A NEW DEFINITION. WE WILL BE REMOVING THEM TO FOLLOW THAT PRACTICE. THIS IS A LIST OF ALL THE DEFINITIONS THAT HAVE BEEN INCLUDED. I WILL COLLECT SOME OF THESE CATEGORIES. FOR EXAMPLE, WE WILL ADD NEW CATEGORIES LIKE CRAFTSMANSHIP ESTABLISHMENT THAT WOULD COVER EVERYTHING FROM WOODWORKING TO STONE MASONRY TO CLASS WORKING. FINANCIAL INSTITUTION, PERSONAL SERVICES, PROFESSIONAL SERVICES, PUBLIC ENTERTAINMENT VALUE AND WHOLESALE ESTABLISHMENT. NEXT UP IS THE NEW CHAPTER ON TEMPORARY USE PERMITS. TEMPORARY USE PERMITS DIFFER FROM CONDITIONAL USE PERMITS THAT YOU ARE FAMILIAR WITH. THEY DON'T RUN WITH THE LAND, THEY ARE TIME-LIMITED THEY ARE PROCESSED ADMINISTRATIVE RATHER THAN A PUBLIC HEARING OFFICE. THEY MAKE A LOT OF SENSE WHEN YOU ARE PERMITTING TRANSIENT USES LIKE CHRISTMAS TREE LIGHTS OR OTHER USES WITH REGULAR REINSPECTION ON AN ANNUAL OR SHORTER BASIS. ONE OF THE MAIN REASONS WHY WE ARE RECOMMENDING THE TEMPORARY USE PERMIT CHAPTER IS ACTUALLY TWO FOLD. IT IS GOOD PRACTICE TO HAVE THIS AND SECOND IS THE CITY COUNCIL ENDORSED USING TEMPORARY USE PERMIT AS A FRAMEWORK TO REGULATE THE TRUCKS THROUGHOUT THE CITY WITH THE STUDY SESSION IN FEBRUARY. CITY COUNCIL ALSO ENDORSED SOME FURTHER REGULATIONS FOR SPECIFICALLY FOOD TRUCKS AT THAT MEETING. I WILL COVER THAT NOW. THE PREFERRED TERMINOLOGY FOR FOOD TRUCKS IS A MOBILE VENDOR FOR THE USE OF THE PUBLIC LISTENING TO MY I WILL USE THE FOOD TRUCK TERM BECAUSE THAT IS WHAT PEOPLE UNDERSTAND. THE FURTHER REGULATIONS THAT WOULD APPLY TO FOOD TRUCKS ARE THESE. THE APPROVAL OF THE PROPERTY OWNER, LOCAL PERMITS, SECURITY AND DISPLAY MARTINEZ CITY BUSINESS LICENSE. POINT OF SALES FOR ALL SALES TAX GENERATED IN CITY LIMITS. MINIMIZING THE NOISE FROM ANY GENERATORS THAT MAY BE PRESENT AND TO LIMIT OPERATIONS NOT INCLUDING MONDAYS AND TUESDAYS ON THE RESTAURANTS IN THE CITIES ARE CLOSED. I WILL JUST TOUCH BRIEFLY ON FOOD TRUCKS THAT OPERATE IN THE PUBLIC RIGHT-OF-WAY. ESSENTIALLY THE CITY CANNOT PROHIBIT THE TRUCKS FROM OPERATING IN LEGAL PUBLIC PARKING SPACES ON THE STREET. DUE TO THE VEHICLE CODE AND CASE LAW. HOWEVER, THE CITY CAN IMPOSE TIME PLACEMENT RESTRICTIONS IN LEGAL PARKING SPACES IF THEY HAVE HEALTH AND SAFETY RATIONALE. DID ENDORSED SEVERAL OF THESE RESTRICTIONS AND PROPOSING THEM TONIGHT. THESE INCLUDE RESTRICTING HOURS OF OPERATION FROM SYNAGOGUE M TO 10:00 P.M. WASTE RECEPTACLE AND OFF FOR SOLID WASTE. PROHIBITION FROM OPERATING ON THE STREET OVER 35 MILES AN HOUR FOR PEDESTRIAN SAFETY. IF IT IS PART IN A SPOT FOR LONGER THAN TWO HOURS TWO ADDITIONAL IMPOSES ON THEM. SEPARATION FROM ANY OTHER FOOD TRUCK PARKED IN A PARKING SPACE. THEY WOULD NEED TO BE WITHIN 200 FEET OF A READILY AVAILABLE RESTROOM FACILITY. THE NEXT CHANGE, SETBACKS AND BUILDING SEPARATION REQUIREMENTS. THIS WAS INCLUDED IN THE CODE CLEANUP AND REVIEW LAST YEAR. ESSENTIALLY IT WOULD MOVE THE CITY FROM USING A COMPLICATED EQUATION TO COMPLICATING SETBACKS IN SEPARATION REQUIREMENTS AND MOVED TO A MUCH EASIER TO USE TABLE. WE HAVE ALREADY DONE THIS FOR RESIDENTIAL DISTRICTS, LAST YEAR. THIS WHAT A SPRING CONSISTENCY. >> AS PART IS THE UPDATE TO THE USES, STAFF IS ALSO PROPOSING INCLUDING A SECTION ON PERFORMANCE STANDARDS. THIS JUST REFLECTS THE REALITY IN THOSE TWO DISTRICTS WITH THE POTENTIAL PROPOSED GREATER IMPACTS ON RESIDENTIAL OR COMMERCIAL DISTRICTS. THEY WILL REGULATE NOISE, VIBRATION, ACTIVITY, ELECTRICAL MATERIAL. AIR POLLUTION, ODORS, GASES LIQUID CONTAMINANTS AND HAZARDOUS MATERIALS. PERFORMANCE STANDARDS DIFFER FROM --THEY REQUIRE CONDITIONS WITH THE CONDITION OF A PROPERTY IN PERFORMANCE STANDARD REGULATE --SPEAKING OF REQUIRED CONDITIONS, IN THE COMMERCIAL DISTRICT CHAPTER THERE WERE MULTIPLE DUPLICATE SECTIONS. REQUIRED CONDITIONS THAT STAFF IS PROPOSING TO CONDENSE AND SIMPLIFY INTO A NEW SECTION WITH THE REQUIREMENTS. NOTHING MUCH IS CHANGING AND THAT, IT IS JUST CONDENSING THEM. THERE IS ONE NEW CHANGE AS PART OF THIS IT WILL BE A REQUIREMENT FOR ANYONE SEEKING PLANNING WITH GROUND-FLOOR FRONTAGE OF ANY TENANT SPACE IN THE CENTRAL COMMERCIAL DISTRICT BY PROVIDING VISUAL DISPLAY AS THIS WOULD HELP MORE VIBRANT FEELING DOWNTOWN. THIS APPLIES TO ALL COMMERCIAL USES BUT NON-RETAIL USES LIKE RESTAURANTS OR NARROW SALONS HAVING A TRANSPARENT FRONTAGE WHERE YOU CAN SEE THE ACTIVITY GOING ON. THE CITY COUNCIL HELD A SPECIAL STUDY SESSION LAST MONTH TO DISCUSS INDUSTRIAL ZONING INCENTIVES IN ORDER TO INCENTIVIZE THROUGHOUT THE CITY. SEVERAL CONDITIONS IN THE CODE TO BE ABLE TO DO THIS. THESE INCLUDED A DECREASE IN THE MINIMUM SETBACKS FOR THE RMD AND INDUSTRIAL DISTRICTS TO 10 FEET FOR THE FRONT YARD AND ZERO FEET FOR THE REAR AND SIDE YARDS. GREATER SETBACKS WOULD BE REQUIRED. ALSO, THE INCREASE IN THE PERMITTED RATIO FROM 0.4 TO 2.0. A REDUCTION IN REQUIRED FRONT YARD LANDSCAPING FROM 100% OF THE FRONT YARD TO 50% OF THE FRONT YARD. IT WOULD ALLOW FOR GREATER FLOOR AREA TO SHOW. ALL OF THESE REVISIONS HAVE BEEN ACCEPTED IN FRONT OF YOU TONIGHT. THE COMMUNITY BENEFIT FROM THIS PROGRAM. THESE WILL HAVE TO BE INCLUDED IN A LATER EFFORT AS THEY REQUIRE A GENERAL PLAN AMENDMENT. JUST TO ILLUSTRATE THE POINT OF HOW RESTRICTIVE SOME OF THE CURRENT DEVELOPMENT STANDARDS ARE, I HAVE GOT SOME DIAGRAMS FOR YOU TONIGHT. FIRST IS A PARCEL OF THE HEAVY INDUSTRIAL DISTRICT. YOU CAN SEE IT HERE IN GREEN. TWO PARCELS BUT WE ARE TREATING IT AS ONE TONIGHT. AND THEN IN THE NEXT SLIDE YOU CAN SEE THE AREA THAT THEY WOULD BE ABLE TO DEVELOP BASED ON CURRENT SETBACK REQUIREMENTS. THEY WOULD BE SEVERELY RESTRICTED. SIMILARLY, THIS IS A PARCEL OUT LINED IN GREEN. THE INDUSTRIAL DISTRICT IN THE NEXT SLIDE YOU WILL BE ABLE TO SEE THE AREA THAT THEY WILL BE ABLE TO DEVELOP YOUR NOT AS A PROTECTED AS INDUSTRIAL, BUT THE CURRENT ELEMENT DOESN'T COMPLY WITH THESE REQUIREMENTS, WHICH IS THE CASE FOR A LOT OF OUR PROPERTIES IN HIGH INDUSTRIAL. IT MAKES SENSE TO REDUCE THESE STANDARDS IN THESE INSTANCES BECAUSE IT IS SURROUNDED BY OTHER INDUSTRIAL USES. COMING TO A PARCEL LIKE THIS, MUCH LESS USE THAN THE 1970s WHEN THESE STANDARDS WERE INSTITUTED. WE ARE NOT EXPECTING TO GET FOUNDRY IN THESE AREAS. PROBABLY BE A DATA CENTER OR A SEMI CONDUCTOR. STAFF REVIEWED ALL OF THE YOUTH IS IN THE CODE. WE ALSO REVIEWED THE ZONING DISTRICTS AND DETERMINED THAT SEVERAL OF THEM COULD POTENTIALLY BE ELIMINATED. THESE INCLUDE COMMERCIAL RECREATION, CONTROLLED INDUSTRIAL AND UNDESIGNATED ZONING DISTRICTS. I WILL GO THROUGH THOSE BRIEFLY. THE COMMERCIAL DISTRICT ONLY APPLIES TO THE COMMERCIAL STRETCH BETWEEN HIGHWAY 4 AND THE HIGH SCHOOL AND THREE PARCELS ON ARNOLD DRIVE. THE DISTRICTS ALLOWED OVER THIS COMMERCIAL DISTRICT WERE MORTUARIES, VEHICLE SALES AND REPAIR, PUBLIC ENTERTAINMENT LIKE BOWLING ALLEYS AND VETERINARIANS OFFICES. REALLY LIMITED CONDITIONS TO THE NEIGHBORHOOD COMMERCIAL ZONING DISTRICT. AS EXTRA USES ARE PREPARED TO BE INCLUDED IN THE DISTRICT FOR PROPERTIES ALONG MAJOR THOROUGHFARE. NONE OF THOSE USES ARE IN THOSE PARCELS THAT ARE BEING REZONED. THEY WILL STILL BE PERMITTED UNDER THE NONMAJOR DISTRICT. NEXT, THE COMMERCIAL RECREATION DISTRICT. THIS IS A STRANGE ONE THAT ONLY APPLIED TO FOUR PARCELS NEAR ROAD AND CENTER AVENUE. NONE OF THE PARCELS HAS AN OF NEWS -- ACTIVE USE. COUNTY OFFICES, MOVIE THEATER. SO, THESE PARCELS ARE PROPOSED TO BE REZONED TO NEIGHBORHOOD COMMERCIAL. NEXT, THE CONTROLLED INDUSTRIAL ZONING DISTRICT. THIS IS ORIENTED TO AGRICULTURAL USES LIKE HORTICULTURE AND VITICULTURE. THE ONLY AREA WAS A COLLECTION OF BUSINESS PARKS OFF ARNOLD DRIVE AND IT IS A STORAGE FACILITY OFF OF MEARS STATION ROAD. POTENTIALLY WE BELIEVE THAT THE CONTROLLED INDUSTRIAL DISTRICT WAS ESTABLISHED WHEN THESE WERE ORCHARDS BACK IN THE 1970s. THEY NO LONGER ARE. THE PARCELS HAVE A MIXED ZONING DESIGNATION OF PROFESSIONAL ADMINISTRATIVE. THEY ARE PROPOSED TO BE REZONED TO PROFESSIONAL ADMINISTRATIVE AND RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT. THE STORAGE FACILITY IS CURRENTLY ZONED ENVIRONMENTAL CONSERVATION DISTRICT/INDUSTRIAL AND WE ARE PROPOSING THAT IT BE ZONED ENVIRONMENTAL/COMMERCIAL. THE UNDESIGNATED ZONING DISTRICT WAS PREVIOUSLY USED AS A HOLDING ZONE FOR PARCELS WHICH THE CITY ANNEXES BUT DOES NOT SIMULTANEOUSLY REZONE. IT HAS NOT BEEN USED FOR THIS PURPOSE AND TO DO SO WOULD NOT BE THE PRACTICE. SEVERAL PARCELS HAVE MAINTAINED THE DESIGNATION OF UNSUNG ATTIC UNDESIGNATED. THESE ARE PARCELS THAT WILL BE REZONED WITH THE PLAN. GOING FORWARD, ANNEXATION AND REZONING OF PARCELS WOULD BE CONDUCTED CONCURRENTLY. ADDITIONALLY, SEVERAL PARCELS WITH DESIGNATIONS FROM THE COUNTY AND WE ARE ALSO PROPOSING THEM TO BE REZONED. THESE INCLUDE ALL PARCELS THAT ARE RETAIL BUSINESS. THOSE WOULD BE REZONED TO NEIGHBORHOOD COMMERCIAL. M 29 WOULD BE OUR 1.5 MULTIFAMILY USAGE. YOU CAN SEE HERE, THE EXISTING ZONING OF THESE PARCELS UNLESS THEY ARE BEING REZONED AS OUTLINED IN RED. THIS IS THE EXISTING ZONING. THE NEXT SLIDE IS ONCE THE REZONING IS COMPLETE. LIVING ON. LAST YEAR'S LEGISLATIVE SESSION IN CALIFORNIA SAW SEVERAL LAWS PASSED. THEY REQUIRE US TO UPDATE OUR REGULATIONS. USING A CONDOMINIUM PLAN. IT EXTENDS THE PROHIBITION OF OCCUPANCY REQUIREMENTS. ADOPT PREAPPROVED WITH A 30 DAY REQUIREMENT FOR ANY APPLICATION UTILIZING THESE PLANS OR UTILIZING ANY OTHER PREAPPROVED EDU PLANS. IN ADDITION, WHEN FURTHER CHANGE FROM STAFF IS RECOMMENDING TONIGHT IS RELATED TO ROOFTOP BALCONIES AND DECKS. TO BE BUILT CLOSER TO PROPERTY LINES ORIGINALLY INTENDED, WHICH IMPOSED A PRIVACY IMPACT. STAFF IS RECOMMENDING TONIGHT TO REQUIRE DECKS AND BALCONIES. TO CONFORM TO THE SETBACK REQUIREMENTS REQUIRED OF A PRIMARY DWELLING TO MINIMIZE. THERE WERE SEVERAL OTHER MINOR CHANGES INCLUDED IN THIS PACKAGE OF REVISIONS TONIGHT THESE INCLUDE THE CONTINUED REMOVAL OF REFERENCES TO MORE ADJUSTMENTS AS THE FUNCTIONS OF THAT BODY HAVE BEEN CLAIMED. 22.08, DESIGNATIONS CONSISTENT WITH ZONING DISTRICTS. UPDATES TO THE PURPOSES FOR SOME OF THE AFFECTED ZONING DISTRICTS TO MODERNIZE THE CURRENT REALITY OF BUSINESSES IN THAT ENVIRONMENT. SIMPLIFICATION AND CLARIFICATION OF THE USE PERMIT FINDINGS FOR BARS. THE ABILITY FOR MASSAGE BUSINESS USE PERMIT TO BE BROUGHT BEFORE THE ZONING ADMINISTRATOR INSTEAD OF DIRECTLY TO YOU HERE AT THE PLANNING COMMISSION. THE ADDITION FOR TABLES FOR SETBACKS, HEIGHT AND OTHER REQUIREMENTS FOR EASE-OF-USE. SO, THE FULL RECOMMENDATION FOR THE PLANNING COMMISSION TONIGHT IS TO CONDUCT A PUBLIC HEARING AND ADOPT RESOLUTION 24-02 RECOMMENDING THAT THE CITY COUNCIL ADOPT AN ORDINANCE PROVING A ZONING MAP AND ZONING TEXT A MOMENT TO AMEND THE BARNSTABLE CODE BY COMPREHENSIVELY UPDATING THE CONDITIONAL USES FOR THE COMMERCIAL, INDUSTRIAL, RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT AND PROFESSIONAL AND MINISTER OF ZONING DISTRICTS. TWO, AMENDING AND I DEFINITIONS CONSISTENT WITH THE UPDATED USES. AMENDING CHAPTERS 2214, PROFESSIONAL INDUSTRY OF OFFICE DISTRICTS. 22.15, SEE COMMERCIAL DISTRICTS AND 22.18, INDUSTRIAL DISTRICTS BY REVISING SETBACK AND BUILDING SEPARATION CENTERS TO BE CONSISTENT WITH OTHER DISTRICTS. FOUR, AMENDING CHAPTERS 22.15, RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT DISTRICTS. BY MODIFYING DEVELOPMENT STANDARDS TO INCENTIVE FIVE DEVELOPMENT AND ESTABLISHING PERFORMANCE OF THEIR MERITS. REPEALING CHAPTER 2.30, UNDESIGNATED DISTRICTS. ADDING CHAPTER 2303 ONE TWO REGULATE USES LIKE MOBILE VENDORS. REVISING SECTION 22 136.060, PARKING INDUSTRIAL USES TO INDUCE INDUSTRIAL PARKING REQUIREMENTS. REVISING CHAPTER 22.43, ACCESSORY DWELLING UNIT AND JUNIOR ACCESSORY DWELLING UNITS TO CLARIFY WITH EXISTING REGULATIONS. REVISING 22.0 TO BE CONSISTENT WITH THE LIMITATION OF THE COMMERCIAL, CR COMMERCIAL RECREATION, CI, CONTROLLED INDUSTRIAL, UNDESIGNATED DISTRICTS. APPEARED IN THE ZONING MAP AMENDMENT FOR 45 PARCELS FROM NEIGHBORHOOD COMMERCIAL TO NEIGHBORHOOD COMMERCIAL. FOUR PARCELS FROM COMMERCIAL RECREATION TO NEIGHBORHOOD COMMERCIAL. 11 PARCELS, ZONED MULTI FAMILY TO RESIDENTIAL. FOR 12 PARCELS, ZONED PROFESSIONAL AND ADMINISTRATIVE/CONTROLLED INDUSTRIAL TO RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT. 14 PARCELS OWNED RETAIL BUSINESS TO COMMERCIAL AND ONE PARCEL ZONED ENVIRONMENTAL CONSERVATION INDUSTRIAL WITH SERVICE COMMERCIAL. APPROVING A ZONING MAP AMENDMENT TO --APPROPRIATE ZONING DESIGNATIONS WITH THE GENERAL PLAN AND 12. OTHER MINOR REVISIONS. SO, THE NEXT STEPS FOR THIS ORDINANCE WOULD BE TO TWO READINGS AT THE CITY COUNCIL IN MAY. IF APPROVED, IT WILL BECOME EFFECTIVE ON JUNE 15th. SO, THANK YOU VERY MUCH FOR YOUR ATTENTION AND WITH THAT I WELCOME ANY QUESTIONS YOU MAY HAVE. >> VERY THOROUGH, THANK YOU VERY MUCH FOR THAT. SEEMS LIKE THESE ARE A LONG ANTICIPATED NEEDED REVISIONS IN UPDATE TO THE ZONING CODES AND PROCEDURES THROUGHOUT THE CITY. SOMETHING YOU BEEN WORKING VERY HARD ON. WITH THAT I WILL OPEN UP QUESTIONS FROM THE PLANNING COMMISSION THAT WE WILL MOVE TO PUBLIC COMMENT AND BRING IT BACK TO THE DAIS FOR DISCUSSION AND EMOTION. WITH THAT, ANY QUESTIONS FOR THE STAFF? >> FIRST WITH THE FOOD TRUCKS, LEGAL PARKING SPACES, I'M ASSUMING THAT REFERS TO AN ACTUAL PHYSICAL PARKING SPOT ON THE STREET OR THE PARKING LOT WERE NOT JUST WHERE A TRUCK IS PARKED. >> THAT IS CORRECT. IT WOULD HAVE TO BE A CONSTRUCTED LEGAL PARKING SPACE THAT IS DESIGNATED. >> THE OTHER ONE OF THE FRONTAGES , THE BEAUTIFICATION OF THOSE, THAT WOULD BE WHEN IT IS GOING THROUGH THE ENTITLEMENT A STOREFRONT EMPTY BUILDING TODAY WOULD HAVE TO BEAUTIFY THEIR SPACE? >> THAT IS CORRECT. >> THINK YOU. >> ON THE LEGAL PARKING SPOT, THEY WOULD BE REQUIRED TO PAY FOR THEIR PARKING THAT THEY ARE OCCUPYING. >> INDEED, THEY WOULD. >> DOES THIS CHANGE THE PROCESS FOR HOW CONDITIONAL USE PERMITS ARE APPROVED OR ARE WE JUST CHANGING THE LANGUAGE FOR THE CATEGORY? >> IT WILL NOT CHANGE THE PROCESS FOR CONDITIONAL USE PURPOSES OTHER THAN LIMITED USES. FOR I MENTIONED MASSAGE PARLORS DON'T HAVE TO GO TO THE PLANNING COMMISSION THEY CAN GO TO THE ZONING ADMINISTRATOR. THE GENERAL PROCESS, NO. >> HOW ABOUT SOME OF THE OTHER MORE CONTROVERSIAL TOPICS? THE FIREARMS DEALERS, IT CAME UP SEVERAL YEARS AGO. >> DEPENDING ON THE CONTROVERSIAL NATURE OF THE USE, IT WOULD STILL BE BROUGHT TO THE PLANNING COMMISSION FOR FULL PUBLIC HEARING. >> SO THAT WOULD STILL BE? >> YES. >> REGARDING THE FOOD TRUCKS GIVEN THAT IT IS REGULATED UNDER THE CALIFORNIA VEHICLE CODE, THEY ARE CURRENTLY LEGAL AND ABLE TO PARK AND BE DOWNTOWN ANYWHERE ELSE AS IT ALREADY IS. SO HOW MUCH OF A CHANGE IS THIS? OR IS THIS BRINGING US IN LINE WITH STATE REGULATIONS? >> BRING US IN LINE WITH STATE REGULATIONS. THEY HAVE BEEN IN MARTINEZ FOR SEVERAL YEARS NOW, THERE IS SOMETHING --NOTHING STOPPING THEM FROM OPERATING IN THE CITY. >> MAKE IT A CORE ELEMENT OF OUR ECONOMIC STRATEGY, IS IT? WE WOULD LIKE TO WORK WITH THE ASSISTING BUSINESSES WITH CREATIVE WAYS TO USE FOOD TRUCKS ON THEIR PRIVATE PROPERTIES FOR SPECIAL EVENTS AND THAT KIND OF THING BUT IT DOES OPEN UP THAT OPPORTUNITY FOR PRIVATE PROPERTY SINCE CURRENTLY WE DO PROHIBIT FOOD TRUCKS ON PRIVATE PROPERTY IN THE DOWNTOWN AREA. BUT NO, IT IS NOT A LARGE-SCALE CHANGE. >> WE PROHIBIT THEM ON PRIVATE PROPERTY? >> WE PROHIBIT THEM ON PRIVATE PROPERTY IN THE DOWNTOWN. >> OKAY. ARE THERE EXCEPTIONS TO THAT? >> THERE ARE NO EXCEPTIONS TO THAT, BUT THE CITY COUNCIL DID CHOOSE TO NOT ENFORCE THAT PARTICULAR ORDINANCE SEVERAL YEARS AGO. >> WITH THAT BE SOMETHING THAT IS GOING TO BE ENFORCED GOING FORWARD. >> KNOW. THIS WOULD ELIMINATE THAT. >> VERY GOOD. >> FAIR ENOUGH. OKAY. SPECIFICALLY FOR PRIVATE PROPERTY. >> EXCELLENT. GOT YOU. PERFECT. THANK YOU FOR THE CLARIFICATION. NO FURTHER QUESTIONS? MAYBE EMOTION? VERY GOOD. WE WILL MOVE TO PUBLIC COMMENT. I AM NOT SEEING ANYONE IN THE ROOM FOR IN PERSON, AND. DO WE HAVE ANYONE ONLINE THAT WISHES TO SPEAK? YOU WILL HAVE THREE MINUTES AND THE FLOOR IS YOURS. >> WE DO HAVE DENNIS. YOU CAN UNMUTE AND HE CAN. YOU HAVE THREE MINUTES . >> I JUST WANT TO VISIT THE FOOD TRUCKS. I THINK IT IS GOOD TO GET THINGS UPDATED AS SOME OF THOSE THINGS COME FROM A LONG TIME AGO. FROM WHAT I HEAR YOU WILL NEED A TWO U.P. PERMIT. WHAT IS THE PROCESS FOR ATP PERMIT? HOW MUCH DOES THAT COST OR WHAT IS THE ELIGIBILITY FOR THAT? ARE YOU ABLE TO ANSWER THAT QUESTION? >> CAN I DIRECT THAT QUESTION THE STAFF? >> STAFF CANNOT ANSWER THE QUESTION THAT WE WOULD LIKE THEM TO RESOLVE AND WE CAN ANSWER THE QUESTION. >> THAT WAS MY FIRST QUESTION IS JUST A LITTLE BIT OF INSIGHT ONTO HOW SOME OF THE EXISTING VENDORS THAT MIGHT BE SERVICING THE COMMUNITY, WHAT THEY MIGHT BE ABLE TO EXPECT GOING FORWARD. IS THERE A FEE FOR THE PERMIT, IS THERE A CERTAIN REGULATION THAT IS NEW TO THEM? MY MAJOR CONCERN IS I DON'T WANT TO MAKE ANYTHING TOO DIFFICULT FOR THEM. I DON'T WANT TO MAKE IT HARDER FOR PEOPLE TO COME TO MARTINEZ. I WANT TO MAKE IT EASIER FOR THEM TO COME TO MARTINEZ. THE OTHER QUESTION I HAVE, ARE THERE ANY FOOD TRUCKS IF IT IS PRIMAVERA OR SOME OF THE PARTNERS TO THE EVENTS OR FARMERS MARKET TYPE STUFF. HAVE WE GOTTEN ANY FEEDBACK FROM PEOPLE, SPECIFICALLY WITHIN THE INDUSTRY THAT DO THIS KIND OF THING? I WOULD BE INTERESTED TO KIND OF SEE OR KIND OF WANT TO KNOW THAT THAT WE ARE NOT MAKING TOO MANY REGULATIONS WITHOUT ALSO INVOLVING INDUSTRY THAT DIRECTLY IMPACTS IS KIND OF MY CONCERN. FROM MOST OF WHAT I READ IT MAKES A LOT OF SENSE I THINK. NOT CHANGING A BUNCH OF THINGS. BUT I DO WANT TO MAKE SURE THAT IT DOESN'T MAKE IT ANY HARDER FOR PARTNERS TO COME HERE AND HELP US, THAT'S ALL. I THINK THAT IS THE END MY COMMENT. THANK YOU. >> THANK YOU, DENNIS. WE CAN ANSWER THE QUESTION AND CONTINUE WITH PUBLIC COMMENT INTO THOSE QUESTIONS AFTER PUBLIC COMMENT. >> WE CAN ANSWER NOW IF YOU SO CHOOSE. >> THE APPLICATION PROCESS TO GET A TEMP OR USE PERMIT IS VERY STRAIGHTFORWARD, VERY SIMPLE. YOU WOULD FILL OUT OUR STANDARD PLANNING APPLICATION. YOU CAN FIND ON THE WEBSITE. THERE IS ALREADY A SECTION. THERE IS A SECTION FOR TEMPORARY USE PERMIT ON THE A NARRATIVE OF WHAT YOU ARE PLANNING COMMITTEES OF WE, HOURS OF OPERATION, WHAT SORT OF OFFERINGS. THAT KIND OF THING. WILL COME BACK TO STAFF AND WE WILL REVIEW IT AND IT WILL MOST LIKELY BE APPROVED IN STAFF LEVEL. THERE IS A FEE ASSOCIATED WITH IT FOR THE YEARLY TEMPORARY USE PERMIT, $450 FEE. THERE IS ALSO A RENEWAL FEE THAT IS LESS YOUR $225 RENEWAL FEE AS LONG AS THERE ARE NO CHANGES TO THE FOOD TRUCK. >> WHO WOULD HAVE TO APPLY FOR THAT? WOULD IT BE THE BUSINESS COMMITTEE FOOD TRUCK? THE PROPERTY OWNER? >> THE APPROVAL OR THE THE PROPERTY OWNER QUESTION MARK FROM THE BUSINESS AS THE FOOD TRUCK >> THEY WOULD HAVE TO APPROVE THE FOOD TRUCK. >> OKAY. IN THIS CASE IT WOULD NOT BE WHEREVER THE FOOD TRUCK IS THAT IS ON-SITE. >> BUT I WOULD LIKE TO ADD TO THAT IS TYPICALLY, THAT WOULD BE THE PROCESS, BUT I THINK STAFF IS WILLING TO WORK WITH PROPERTY OWNERS, FOR INSTANCE, THEY HAVE MULTIPLE FOOD TRUCKS THAT THEY WORK WITH BUT IT IS THE SAME CIRCUMSTANCES THAT ARE THERE. SO I COULD FOR IT WOULD BE THE SAME CIRCUMSTANCES THAT WOULD COME UP. AND THOSE WOULD BE COMFORTABLE PROCESSING ONE APPLICATION. ANY FOOD TRUCKS IN THAT PARTICULAR LOCATION. >> IT WOULD HAVE TO BE SEPARATE FOR EVERY FOOD TRUCK. IF THEY ARE HAVING IT ROTATING IT SEEMS TO BE A LOT OF ADMINISTRATIVE BURDEN, NOT JUST ON THE APPLICANT, BUT STAFF AS WELL

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
AgendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Agenda packetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Action agendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Recording and media

Coverage and corrections

Records considered

  • Planning Commission — Minutes
  • Planning Commission — Closed Captions

Not claimed by this page

  • Verified meeting decisions with item-specific public-source evidence
  • Item-level plain-language summaries are not available; this page does not infer individual agenda items.
  • Item-linked, attributed deliberation
  • A source-grounded next meeting date
  • A plain-English overview is not available.
  • Official outcomes have not been published.
  • A transcript is not available.
  • Speakers have not been reliably matched to public profiles.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.
  • An individual roll-call roster is not available.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: 4df147a69f67d4e890492ce49428cd56. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record