POLISCOPE

The public record

NAPLES (COLLIER COUNTY) · LOCALDecisions publishedPartial coverage

City Council Workshop Meeting

Monday, March 17, 2025 · Government meeting record

The 30-second read

Recorded outcome

The Naples City Council reviewed a proposed $49 million Florida Department of Transportation (FDOT) project to replace aging stormwater drainage systems along U.S. 41 between Golden Gate Parkway and 5th Avenue South. The project is currently funded only for design, with construction tentatively scheduled for fiscal year 2029.

Why it matters

Residents and businesses along the U.S. 41 corridor face potential future construction disruptions and infrastructure changes, with the city currently coordinating with FDOT to address flooding concerns and project timelines.

What happens next

No later meeting or follow-up date is stated in the reviewed record.

An official outcome record - an action agenda or minutes - is published for this meeting.

Record text

No transcript is held for this meeting. Recording: Watch video

City of Naples City Council Chamber 735 Eighth Street South Naples, Florida 34102 City Council Workshop Meeting – March 17, 2025 – 8:32 a.m. It is noted for the record that all: 1) documentation electronically appended hereto is also contained in the file for this meeting with the City Clerk’s Office; 2) experts who testified during quasi-judicial hearings were accepted as qualified to do so in their respective fields of expertise; and 3) added attachments are referenced in red as “ADDED ATTACHMENT”. 1) CALL TO ORDER AND ROLL CALL City Council Members Present Teresa Heitmann, Mayor Terry Hutchison, Vice Mayor Staff Present: Gary Young, City Manager Patricia Rambosk, City Clerk Andrew Dickman, Assistant City Attorney Dave Rivera, Traffic Operations Supervisor Charlotte Loewel, Human Resources Director Russell Thomas, Employee and Labor Relations Mgr. Others Present: Eileen Lowry Lori Raleigh Jeffrey Jones Wayne Gaither Richard Matthews Berne Barton Ray Christman Bill Kramer (via Zoom, left at 12:42 p.m.) Linda Penniman Beth Petrunoff Matthew McConnell, City Attorney Robert Middleton, Public Works Dir. Erica Martin, Planning Director Alison Bickett, Deputy City Engineer Ciro Dominguez, Police Chief Jessica Hernandez, Deputy City Clerk Laura DeJohn Chrissy Fisher Carolyn Usher Leigh Anne King Erin Deady 2) PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE Council Member Petrunoff led the Pledge of Allegiance. 3) SET AGENDA City Manager Gary Young stated that there were no changes to the agenda but noted Time Certain Item 7.A (Executive Session regarding Labor Relations and Collective Bargaining) at 12:30 p.m. MOTION by Petrunoff to SET AGENDA; seconded by Christman and unanimously carried, all members present and voting (Barton-yes, Christman-yes, Hutchison-yes, Kramer-yes, Penniman-yes, Petrunoff-yes, Heitmann-yes). 4) ANNOUNCEMENTS AND PRESENTATIONS None. 5) PUBLIC COMMENT None. 6) DISCUSSION ITEMS 6.A) Presentation from the Florida Department of Transportation (FDOT) Relating to the Proposed Stormwater Drainage Project along the State Roadway System between Golden Gate Parkway and 5th Avenue South.

City Council Workshop Meeting – March 17, 2025 – 8:32 a.m. 2 Roll call votes by Council Members are recorded in random order, pursuant to City Council policy. City Manager Gary Young introduced the item. Deputy City Engineer Alison Bickett provided a brief background on the stormwater collection and conveyance system under U.S. 41 between Golden Gate Parkway and 5th Avenue South, noting that the system was reaching the end of its useful life. She summarized the history of collaboration between the City and the Florida Department of Transportation (FDOT) on potential improvements, including previous discussions on reducing vehicular lanes, which were ultimately dismissed due to concerns regarding the potential diversion of vehicular traffic through residential neighborhoods and additional vehicular congestion on U.S. 41. She referenced FDOT’s prior commitment to incorporating findings from the 41-10 Master Plan and the City’s Pedestrian and Bicycle Plan before engaging the community on potential mobility changes. Deputy City Engineer Bickett noted that on March 10, 2023, FDOT confirmed that the lane reduction would not move forward but that improvements to bike and pedestrian infrastructure along the east-west corridor would be considered. She reported that at the April 19, 2023, City Council Meeting, FDOT provided an update on efforts to amend the FY24 Work Program to include a Project Development and Environmental (PD&E) Study, with concurrent design for stormwater drainage improvements along U.S. 41. Given the urgency of addressing stormwater infrastructure needs, she explained that FDOT has removed the PD&E study for broader mobility enhancements and will move forward with necessary drainage improvements while maintaining the current roadway design. Jeffrey Jones, Project Management Engineer at FDOT, utilized an electronic presentation to review FDOT’s proposed Stormwater Drainage Improvement Project along the State Roadway System between Golden Gate Parkway and 5th Avenue South, which included: project boundaries; scope of work; the estimated cost of construction at $49 million, which is currently unfunded for construction costs; project phases; coordination requirements with City staff; the traffic Management Plan; a survey of the current drainage system; noise, traffic, access, and landscaping impacts; and the project’s timeline, noting that the construction is planned to commence in FY 2029. Mayor Heitmann expressed concern regarding the delayed timeline for construction, emphasizing the urgent need for stormwater improvements. She specifically referenced ongoing flooding issues between 10th Street and 12th Street and raised concerns that FDOT’s proposed improvements could potentially disrupt a planned project once they are completed. She encouraged FDOT to coordinate with the planned project to ensure both projects occur concurrently, minimizing disruptions and improving efficiency. Later in the meeting, Vice Mayor Hutchison also requested that the project be coordinated with stormwater management improvements related to the Naples Beach Hotel and major special events and that emergency contingencies be planned in case of a major storm event. During discussion, FDOT representatives responded to questions and provided clarifications on various aspects of the project. FDOT Engineer Jones stated that the project would address undulations in the roadway system by replacing the main line and installing new pavement. He also clarified that the project was currently funded for design only. Wayne Gaither, Southwest Area Office Director at FDOT, said that FDOT will continue to identify funding opportunities and would keep staff apprised of updates. FDOT Southwest Director Gaither noted that funding for FDOT projects is approved through the Department’s Work Program, which functions similarly to the City’s Capital Improvement Plan. In response to Council Member Petrunoff, Deputy Engineer Bickett stated that Jimmy P’s expansion into the rights-of-way was an agreement between FDOT and the restaurant owner. FDOT Engineer Jones confirmed that the project is not proposing any expansion of roadway or changes to the rights-of-ways. Vice Mayor Hutchison then presented a rendering depicting a damaged stormwater drain at U.S. 41 and South Golf Drive. FDOT Engineer Jones confirmed responsibility for repairing a damaged stormwater drain at U.S. 41 and South Golf Drive, adding that the repair would be reconstructed

City Council Workshop Meeting – March 17, 2025 – 8:32 a.m. 3 Roll call votes by Council Members are recorded in random order, pursuant to City Council policy. to meet current State standards. Traffic Operations Supervisor Dave Rivera stated that FDOT’s subcontractor had already been contacted to address the issue. FDOT Southwest Director Gaither confirmed that although the proposed plan is to reinstall landscaping like-for-like, the District would work with City staff regarding potential modifications. He also stated that he would work with staff to avoid delays between the stormwater improvements and subsequent landscaping improvements. FDOT Engineer Jones confirmed that FDOT had already began discussions with the District’s Landscape Architect. He also confirmed that the project will not include rights-of-way work but will include repair to curbs and driveways along U.S. 41 only if necessary. FDOT Southwest Director Gaither stated that FDOT had requested its asset management group to analyze current roadway conditions along U.S. 41. The analysis identified four locations between Golden Gate Parkway and 5th Avenue South in need of infrastructure improvements where initial repairs had been made; however, further repairs to the roadbed are still required. He stated that additionally, two locations north of Golden Gate Parkway have been identified, and repairs at those sites will soon be made. Traffic Operations Supervisor Rivera and Deputy Engineer Bicket confirmed that FDOT had made efforts to make improvements at the request of staff on a case-by-case basis. City Council discussed the urgency of the project and its desire to prioritize the proposed project as well as future roadway improvements to U.S 41. City Council also raised the possibility of staff contacting the City’s lobbyist to advocate for accelerating the project timeline, securing State funding, and integrating the project with planned roadway improvements for U.S. 41. FDOT Southwest Director Gaither expressed the District’s preference to first discuss advocacy efforts with staff to ensure alignment with project goals. He emphasized FDOT’s commitment to completing the project and highlighted the importance of finalizing the design phase before allocating construction funds to prevent potential funding issues if design changes occur. Council Members questioned whether the project could be bifurcated by lining the outfall pipes that need to be repaired rather than replacing them and then repaving the road at a later time. FDOT Engineer Jones stated that FDOT had not yet evaluated whether the existing outfall pipes could be lined rather than replaced. Public Works Director Robert Middleton explained that relining outfall pipes would be an adequate temporary solution for necessary repairs but recommended that the pipes be fully replaced as part of the overall project design. Traffic Operations Supervisor Rivera stated that the section of outfall pipe at 6th Avenue North was relined over 10 years ago. He noted that the pipes can be relined; however, it does not remove the void already there, which will cause overlaying asphalt to settle over time. FDOT Engineer Jones added that relining a pipe reduces its capacity and noted he was not aware of any instance where an outfall pipe had been lined a second time. FDOT Southwest Director Gaither reiterated that the purpose of this project is not to make repairs but to replace the aging system, and he assured City Council that the District would work with staff to ensure that necessary repairs are made in the meantime. FDOT Southwest Director Gaither expressed his position that the system needed to be replaced. In response, Council Member Petrunoff asked that he evaluate all available options with City staff before finalizing that determination. In response to City Manager Gary Young, FDOT Southwest Director Gaither confirmed that the new system is planned to have a lifespan of 40 to 50 years. FDOT Southwest Director Gaither stated that he would report back to City Council regarding the number of vehicles traveling on U.S. 41 between Golden Gate Parkway and 5th Avenue South each day. He confirmed that roadway calculations play a significant role in determining a projects priority and will be evaluated as part of this project. FDOT Engineer Jones said he anticipated being able to provide significantly more updates relating to the project within 12 months. Deputy Engineer Bickett added that she had already

City Council Workshop Meeting – March 17, 2025 – 8:32 a.m. 4 Roll call votes by Council Members are recorded in random order, pursuant to City Council policy. been in discussions with FDOT about scheduling meetings between staff and would keep City Council informed of the project timeline. City Manager Young requested to be included in future meetings with the project team City Council also expressed concern about water quality and resiliency and requested that consideration be given to addressing this issue as part of the project. FDOT Southwest Director Gaither expressed the District’s commitment to advancing the project. He noted that funding could be obtained through the Metropolitan Planning Organization (MPO) and State grants. Agenda Memorandum Resolution 2018-14134 FDOT Presentation US 41 and South Golf Drive Photograph (Staff/Added Attachment) 6.B) Receive Presentation from the Florida Department of Transportation (FDOT) and Provide Feedback on Proposed Roadway Modifications along the State Roadway System of US-41 between the Intersections of 9th Street South and Goodlette Frank Roadway. Deputy City Engineer Alison Bickett provided an overview of background information related to the proposed redevelopment project located between 6th Avenue South and 5th Avenue South, bounded by 9th Street South and 11th Street South, excluding the property west of 900 5th Avenue South. She explained that the project, previously referred to as the “M Development” and now known as “The Avenue,” has been under consideration for several years. As part of the site plan review process, she noted that a Traffic Impact Study (TIS) was required and submitted by the petitioner’s consultant, Trebilcock Consulting Solutions, and reviewed by the Florida Department of Transportation (FDOT). According to the information reviewed, the reports identified both existing and anticipated traffic deficiencies in the surrounding roadway network. Deputy Engineer Bickett shared that discussions had taken place between the Streets Division and FDOT, including a virtual meeting, to address concerns and explore possible solutions. She noted that the project has evolved over time and was ultimately modified through conditions identified in a Settlement Agreement. She further explained that FDOT conducted an independent analysis of traffic conditions and evaluated design alternatives presented by the petitioner’s consultant, including detailed microsimulation modeling of nearby intersections. She referenced a coordination meeting held on February 4, 2025, which included representatives from Davidson Engineering, Trebilcock Consulting Solutions, the Streets Division, and FDOT. She noted that during that meeting, FDOT presented updated analysis and modeling results with potential design options, after which staff requested that the design alternatives be presented to the City Council. Richard Matthews, Transportation Engineer at VIBEngineering and Consultant for FDOT, explained that the scope of FDOT’s Transportation Alternatives Analysis for “The Avenue” development included the intersections of U.S. 41 and 3rd Avenue South, the four corners (U.S. 41 and 9th Street South), U.S. 41 and 10th Avenue North, and U.S. 41 and Goodlette-Frank Road. He used an electronic presentation to review existing conditions at the four intersections; major traffic movement areas; vehicle counts during peak hours and causes of traffic congestion. He noted that the current pedestrian crossing at 10th Street South disrupts the signal at 10th Avenue North when activated by a pedestrian crossing, causing it to no longer maintain the same cycle length as the surrounding signals, thus leading to traffic congestion. Transportation Engineer Matthews continued the presentation to review current conditions combined with The Avenue’s project conditions, highlighting the projected traffic volume for the development at 125 vehicles each hour turning left at 10th Street South. He stated that this would increase traffic queuing, especially in the left turn lane. He provided various modeling data, including a comparison of current and combined travel time, noting multiple traffic deficiencies. Transportation Engineer Matthews then reviewed FDOT’s proposed changes and data modeling, which included: 1) creating a westbound left-turn lane at the four corners intersection. He explained that adding another left-turn lane into the City would help relieve some demand from the existing left-turn

City Council Workshop Meeting – March 17, 2025 – 8:32 a.m. 5 Roll call votes by Council Members are recorded in random order, pursuant to City Council policy. lane, estimating that 15 percent of traffic demand would benefit from the proposed change; and 2) converting the through-lane to a right-turn lane, creating two right-turn lanes on 10th Street South. He explained that this change would allow for clearing twice as much traffic on green, alleviating congestion leaving the City, and would also prevent the traffic signal from going out of sync with surrounding traffic signals when the pedestrian crossing at 10th Street South is activated. He presented four scenarios to be considered: 1) existing conditions; 2) existing conditions combined with the project conditions; 3) Alternative Option One, which includes FDOT’s two proposed changes; and 4) Alternative Option Two, which includes only the creation of two right-turn lanes on 10th Street South. He provided various modeling data, including a comparison of travel times and video simulations for Alternative Options One and Two, along with the advantages and disadvantages of each option. During the discussion, City Council expressed concern that Alternative Option Two could lead to drivers diverting traffic by making a right turn onto U.S. 41, then a left onto Goodlette-Frank Road, and subsequently turning onto 3rd Avenue South or other avenue streets, which could negatively impact residential neighborhoods. The Council also noted that the existing 10th Street South through-lane connects traffic to the Design District and could have a negative impact on other intersections throughout the City. Vice Mayor Hutchison stated that although there is a no left turn sign at the intersection of U.S. 41 and 10th Street South heading north, he observed travelers making a left turn to access 5th Avenue North. He suggested installing an island at that intersection to prevent left turns. Transportation Engineer Matthews confirmed that both proposed right-turn lanes on 10th Street South would be signalized with Alternative Option One. Council Member Penniman inquired whether the far right turn lane could be changed to an at-will turn lane, allowing travelers to turn right when it is safe to do so, rather than waiting for the signal. Transportation Engineer Matthews stated that it was possible and that one of his earlier models had shown the far right-turn lane as an at-will right turn. However, he noted that one of the challenges with that option is that vehicles in the left right-turn lane can sometimes cause congestion by attempting to slide into the at-will turn lane when both turn lanes are not in sync. He said FDOT determined that it would be safer for the dual right lanes to operate in sync and for the right-turn lane to have a “no turn on red” sign. Transportation Engineer Matthews responded to questions regarding the developer’s Traffic Impact Study (TIS). He stated that the Traffic Engineer for the project used a less precise analysis software program, which resulted in deficiencies with the proposed alternatives. He explained that FDOT decided to use its own modeling program to gather more detailed traffic projections and ensure that any proposed changes are implementable. Traffic Operations Supervisor Dave Rivera stated that the developer proposed eliminating one of the west-bound through lanes on 10th Street South to create two left-turn lanes. He noted that he had expressed strong opposition to this proposal, as it would cause major traffic congestion for vehicles traveling west on U.S. 41. Traffic Operations Supervisor Rivera said he recommended adding a left-turn lane at 9th Street South as an alternative. He said this would allow traffic needing to access the development’s site to do so without causing congestion at the intersection of U.S. 41 and 10th Street South. Deputy City Engineer Bickett and Traffic Operations Supervisor Rivera responded to questions regarding future plans to reroute Golden Gate Parkway traffic, and the elimination of a right-turn lane onto 11th Street South from U.S. 41. City Council expressed additional concerns throughout the discussion regarding Golden Gate Parkway traffic, truck routes for 5th Avenue South, bicycle and pedestrian traffic, and traffic affected by future development of the Davis-triangle area.

City Council Workshop Meeting – March 17, 2025 – 8:32 a.m. 6 Roll call votes by Council Members are recorded in random order, pursuant to City Council policy. Council Member Christman questioned whether The Avenue was responsible for making its site accessible without negatively impacting traffic or if it was also responsible for addressing a broader traffic problem. Deputy City Engineer Bickett explained that while there are existing deficiencies in the surrounding roadway that the City would need to address, the developer is responsible for making improvements necessary to accommodate the additional trips the project will add to the roadway. She noted that part of the development’s conditions of approval requires that staff be satisfied with the traffic plan and that the developer address the necessary improvements. She further stated that if City Council decided not to approve any changes to the existing roadway network, The Avenue’s plan would still be considered satisfactory. Transportation Engineer Matthews expressed hope that all parties could agree on an alternative option but emphasized that, since the project impacts the State’s roadway network, FDOT would have some influence over the final decision. Deputy Engineer Bickett suggested selecting Alternative Option Two and evaluating the dual right-turn lanes at a later time. Transportation Engineer Matthews stated that FDOT was agreeable with Alternative Option Two. In response to Council Member Petrunoff, Deputy Engineer Bickett stated that the City previously evaluated creating a roundabout at the four corners intersection; however, that option was determined to be unsafe. Public Comment: None. Mayor Heitmann, Vice Mayor Hutchison, and Council Members Christman, Petrunoff, and Penniman agreed that Alternative Option One is an unsatisfactory option; Council Member Kramer expressed a preference for Alternative Option One; and Council Member Barton stated that he was inclined to allow staff’s expert opinion to determine the most appropriate option. Ensuing further discussions, City Manager Young received a consensus to consider Alternative Option Two as a possible solution and to have further discussions regarding Alternative Option One before finalizing a decision to bring back to City Council for final approval. Agenda Memorandum Presentation Recess: 11:27 a.m. to 11:38 a.m. It is noted for the record that: 1) the same Council Members were present when the meeting reconvened; and 2) Mayor Heitmann announced at 12:42 p.m. that Council Member Kramer left the meeting during the discussion of Item 6.C below. 6.C) Kick-off Presentation by Johnson Engineering on the Elective Changes to the City of Naples Comprehensive Plan. Planning Director Erica Martin provided a brief background on the item, noting that City Council approved an agreement between Johnson Engineering, Inc. and the City of Naples for professional services to complete the update of the City of Naples Comprehensive Plan. Laura DeJohn, Principal at Johnson Engineering, introduced the team. Chrissy Fisher, Principal Planner at Johnson Engineering, provided a brief overview of Comprehensive Planning, Statutory requirements, additional optional elements, a brief background of the City’s Comprehensive Plan and Vision Plan, the project’s schedule and seven phases, and driving themes/goals of the project. Carolyn Usher, Office Manager and Contract Coordinator at CMA Outreach, provided an overview of the project’s public outreach and community engagement plan. She explained that the plan is designed to assess community needs through a series of public meetings and small group discussions focused on topics such as parking, transportation, and traffic. She stated that participation would be encouraged through various outreach methods including flyers, postcards, questionnaires, phone calls, social media, and the development of a project webpage. She noted that the website is now live and accessible to the public, and individuals can sign up on the site to receive project updates. Later in the meeting, Planner Fisher provided the following website

City Council Workshop Meeting – March 17, 2025 – 8:32 a.m. 7 Roll call votes by Council Members are recorded in random order, pursuant to City Council policy. and email that the public can access and sign up for updates on the Project: website: www.Naples2045.com; and email: info@Naples2045.com. Leigh Anne King, Director at Clarion Associates, LLC, stated that her firm would focus on evaluating the City’s Vision Plan with an emphasis on Future Land Use and Community Character. She explained that the goal is to work collaboratively with the City and community to develop policies that align with the Vision Plan and help preserve the character of the community. She also noted that the process would begin with a review of the City’s established character areas and coordination with CMA Outreach to assess resident concerns related to community character. Ms. King stated that the firm would then evaluate the City’s Future Land Use Map (FLUM) and Comprehensive Plan policies to determine possible modifications that would address concerns obtained through the feedback process and define policies and strategies for redevelopment. Erin Deady, Attorney and Planner at Erin Deady, P.A., stated that her firm would focus on resiliency planning efforts. She emphasized the importance of establishing policies that support resiliency to strengthen eligibility for grant opportunities, including those available through the State’s Always Ready legislation. Attorney Deady explained that such policies would involve updating Level of Service (LOS) standards for road elevation, drainage, and infrastructure improvements based on current data, as well as considering land acquisition strategies and incorporating flexibility in development or design criteria to account for the unique risks of different areas. During the discussion, Planner Fisher confirmed that community engagement efforts would begin prior to the upcoming hurricane season and noted that the project timeline includes some flexibility to accommodate any unforeseen delays. She explained that the team had a meeting scheduled with staff and would finalize the public engagement plan within the next few weeks. City Council emphasized the importance of ensuring that feedback is primarily collected from City residents. Questions were also raised about how the survey process would prevent multiple submissions from a single individual to maintain the integrity of the results. Contract Coordinator Usher stated that if conducted electronically, the survey could be configured to allow only one submission per IP address; however, she noted that this method would not prevent individuals from using another computer to submit additional responses. Contract Coordinator Usher added that, alternatively, surveys could be mailed, allowing responses to be linked to specific addresses, and noted that typically two surveys are sent per household. She also confirmed that surveys can be coded by neighborhood to allow for the collection of neighborhood-specific feedback, and that the comment form on the project website prompts respondents to identify the neighborhood in which they reside. Suggestions were made to include follow-up questions for low scores in specific areas to gather more detailed information, incorporate demographic questions such as age and housing type, and utilize a variety of outreach methods to ensure broad and representative community participation. City Council suggested that the use of ACUNE modeling data could be a valuable support tool for evaluating resiliency policies. Throughout discussion, City Council Members highlighted high area priorities which included resiliency, permits, growth management, residents’ concerns relating to Naples Airport, lot coverage, and stormwater. Attorney Deady provided additional information regarding the State’s Always Ready legislation, explaining that it offers financial assistance in two forms: planning dollars for conducting vulnerability assessments; and adaptation plans, and grants for capital improvement projects. She noted that, since the City has recently approved an adaptation plan, it is now eligible to pursue financial assistance for capital improvement projects for up to 50 percent of the cost. Attorney Deady also confirmed that funding could be obtained by establishing a Municipal Service Benefit Unit (MSBU) Program. Mayor Heitmann received consensus from Council Members that the City is fundamentally a residential community impacted by tourism and that Comprehensive Plan priorities should be

City Council Workshop Meeting – March 17, 2025 – 8:32 a.m. 8 Roll call votes by Council Members are recorded in random order, pursuant to City Council policy. focused primarily on serving the needs of residents. Mayor Heitmann stated that it may be more efficient for the City Council to review an early draft of the Comprehensive Plan with the Planning Advisory Board (PAB) during a joint meeting rather than having it be presented to the PAB separately for any recommended changes. Planner Fisher confirmed that the team would review the PAB-recommended changes to the Comprehensive Plan that were not incorporated in the current Plan. Planner Fisher stated that Conservation and Coastal Management are currently combined as one element in the Comprehensive Plan; however, following discussions with staff, it is likely that the two will be separated in the update, resulting in a total of 12 elements in the revised Comprehensive Plan. Vice Mayor Hutchison reviewed several comments submitted via email to City Council and staff regarding the Comprehensive Plan Update, highlighting a request for the scope of work to include a three-dimensional (3D) model illustrating maximum build-out based on current Comprehensive Plan policies and the City’s Code of Ordinances. Mayor Heitmann noted that City Council had previously asked the former City Manager to pursue 3D modeling and requested that City Manager Gary Young follow up on the matter. Following further discussion on 3D scenario modeling, a consensus was reached to authorize City Manager Young to discuss the possibility of adding it to Johnson Engineering’s scope of work. Public Comment: Eileen Lowry was not present when called. Lori Raleigh commented that, over time, the integrity of the City’s Code of Ordinances has been diminished due to a weakening of the Comprehensive Plan. She requested that Johnson Engineering review an earlier version of the Comprehensive Plan that contained over 700 pages, in comparison to the current 200-page version, and consider amendments that would restore content aimed at strengthening policy protections. She also noted a disconnect between the FLUM and current zoning regulations. Planning Director Martin outlined the process for updating zoning regulations, emphasizing that updating the Comprehensive Plan is a critical step to ensure that future code revisions are guided by the policies established within the Plan. Mayor Heitmann stated her preference to address certain incentives in zoning districts prior to updating the Comprehensive Plan. City Manager Young stated that he would meet with Planning Director Martin to review incentives of the D- Downtown District and overlay districts and would provide that information to City Council. Agenda Memorandum Presentation Correspondence (J. Migliara/Added Attachment) 7) NEW BUSINESS 7.A) Executive Session - Labor Relations and Collective Bargaining Strategy. Mayor Heitmann announced that City Council would enter into Executive Session. The following individuals were in attendance during the Executive Session: Mayor Heitmann, Vice Mayor Hutchison; City Council Members Barton, Christman, Penniman, and Petrunoff; City Manager Gary Young; City Attorney Matthew McConnell; Human Resources Director Charlotte Loewel; Police Chief Ciro Dominguez; and Employee and Labor Relations Manager Russell Thomas. Executive Session: 12:41 p.m. to 1:38 p.m. It is noted for the record that the same Council Members were present when the meeting reconvened. No action announced. Agenda Memorandum 8) PUBLIC COMMENTS None. 9) COMMUNICATIONS FROM THE MAYOR, CITY COUNCIL, AND STAFF Council Member Penniman presented a letter signed by Metropolitan Planning Organization (MPO) Chair Dan Kowal in support of House Bill 501, which prohibits the use of handheld cell phones while driving. She suggested that City Council also submit a similar letter to Representative Robinson. Council Members agreed, and City Manager Gary Young stated that

City Council Workshop Meeting – March 17, 2025 – 8:32 a.m. 9 Roll call votes by Council Members are recorded in random order, pursuant to City Council policy. staff would draft the letter and include it in the agenda item related to a Resolution approving the Council’s support of the proposed State legislation, which would be considered at the April 2, 2025 City Council Regular Meeting. Council Member Barton requested that staff be diligent with outreach communications regarding flood panels, suggesting that a direct link be included in community newsletters. In response to Council Member Petrunoff, City Attorney Matthew McConnell stated that a temporary injunction was issued in regard to Florida’s recently enacted law that required municipal elected officials to submit a Form 6 Financial disclosure. He noted that the case is still open and in the event the injunction is lifted, Council Members would need to immediately submit the required form. City Attorney McConnell stated that he receives updates and would keep Council Members informed on the matter. Council Member Petrunoff inquired as to whether the City Council could take any action to discourage candidates from accepting donations from political action committees. Mayor Heitmann responded that City Council would need to seek legal advice to determine if such action would be permissible. Council Member Petrunoff addressed the 30,000 square-foot jet center that began construction at the airport, noting that upon conducting research on the project, she could not locate meeting minutes reflecting when the project was approved by City Council. Council Member Petrunoff stated that she would like the Naples Airport Authority (NAA) Executive Director to provide information on when the project was approved. Mayor Heitmann stated that the issue had been brought to her attention and that she contacted staff to find out more information. City Manager Young stated that he, along with the City Attorney and Mayor Heitmann, met with residents on the topic. He asserted that the language governing the Utilization Plan since 1998, as well as Council’s previous actions, is relevant to the issue and holds standing. He noted that he had a meeting scheduled with NAA Executive Director Chris Rozansky on March 21, 2025, to discuss the matter and that he planned to schedule a City Council discussion on it at an upcoming meeting. City Attorney McConnell advised that the Airport’s first request would likely be to extend the lease and stated he would be happy to begin discussions with airport representatives to evaluate potential lease extension terms, if directed by Council. Mayor Heitmann expressed the view that Council should first discuss the Utilization Plan before authorizing the City Manager to proceed with those discussions. Council Members discussed several airport topics and City Attorney McConnell suggested that the discussion relating to the Utilization Plan be a broader discussion on airport-related matters to address multiple topics. City Manager Young reviewed upcoming agenda items and agreed to schedule the airport discussion for the April 17, 2025 City Council Meeting, with an update to be provided at the April 2, 2025 meeting. Ensuing further discussion, Vice Mayor Hutchison received a consensus to direct the City Clerk to provide meeting minutes regarding the approval of the jet center. City Attorney McConnell requested a consensus to work with the Code Compliance Department to purchase noise equipment to assist him in creating a general noise ordinance and to work on amending fees for short-term rental violations. Mayor Heitmann asked for additional information regarding this request and City Attorney McConnell stated that he would work with the City Manager to bring a formal request to City Council. City Clerk Patricia Rambosk stated that she received a request to add an email communication to the record for Item 6.C. In response to City Attorney McConnell, she explained that resident Joe Migliara made the request because he was unable to attend the meeting to provide public comment. Consensus reached to add Joe Migliara’s email correspondence to the record for Item 6.C.

City Council Workshop Meeting – March 17, 2025 – 8:32 a.m. 10 Roll call votes by Council Members are recorded in random order, pursuant to City Council policy. Mayor Heitmann requested that the City Manager evaluate staff’s process for reviewing Traffic Impact Statements (TIS) for developments. Correspondence (Penniman/Added Attachment) 10) ADJOURNMENT 3:10 p.m. ____________________________ Teresa Lee Heitmann, Mayor ______________________________ Patricia L. Rambosk, City Clerk Minutes by: _______________________________ Jessica Hernandez, Deputy City Clerk Minutes Approved: 4/2/2025.

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
AgendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Agenda packetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Action agendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Transcript or captionsNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Recording and media

Coverage and corrections

Records considered

  • City Council Workshop Meeting — Minutes

Not claimed by this page

  • Verified meeting decisions with item-specific public-source evidence
  • Item-level plain-language summaries are not available; this page does not infer individual agenda items.
  • Item-linked, attributed deliberation
  • A source-grounded next meeting date
  • Official outcomes have not been published.
  • A transcript is not available.
  • Speakers have not been reliably matched to public profiles.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.
  • An individual roll-call roster is not available.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: 4dc9871673d1938f27afc54b43f18e1c. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record