POLISCOPE

The public record

GLENDALE (LOS ANGELES COUNTY)Decisions publishedPartial coverage

Design Review Board

Thursday, February 13, 2020 · Government meeting record

The 30-second read

Recorded outcome

Design Review Board

Why it matters

The official meeting record is available below. Item-level plain-language summaries are not available yet.

What happens next

No later meeting or follow-up date is stated in the reviewed record.

An official outcome record - an action agenda or minutes - is published for this meeting.

Record text

No transcript is held for this meeting. Recording: Listen to audio

M I NUTES DESIGN REVIEW BOARD MEETING - CITY OF GLENDALE February 13, 2020 Meeting called to order at 5:3 p.m. I. ROLL CALL: Present: Arzoumanian, Boyajyan, Benlian, Welch Absent: Simonian Community Development Department - Jay Platt, Kris Agardi, Brad Collin, Aileen Babakhani, Manoosh Zakarian II. REPORT REGARDING POSTING OF THE AGENDA: The agenda for this meeting was posted on or before 5 p.m. on February 6, 2020, on the bulletin board outside City Hall. Ill. ORAL COMMUNICATIONS: None IV. REVIEW CALENDAR: CHAIR PRO-TEM: Elect Benlian as chair pro-tem a) Staff Announcement: b) Design Review Cases: 1. PDR1923858 - 1226 ldlewood Road Speaking on the item: Arman Abgaryan Motion: Moved by: Seconded: Approved with conditions: (Record of Decision attached) Arzoumanian Boyajyan Vote as follows: Ayes: Noes: Absent: Abstain: Arzoumanian, Boyajyan, Benlian, Welch None Simonian None 2. PDR1920853 - 1682 Valley View Road Speaking on the item: Edward Hagobian Arsen Margossian Motion: Moved by: Seconded: Approved with conditions : (Record of Decision attached) Arzoumanian Welch Vote as follows: Ayes : Noes: Absent: Abstain : Arzoumanian, Welch , Boyajyan, Benlian None Simonian None

V. APPROVAL OF MINUTES: January 23, 2020 VI. STAFF AND BOARD BUSINESS/ DISCUSSION OF ITEMS: None VII. ADJOURNMENT: 5: 46 p.m. ~ - s ~ \J°'-V'\ i .Q.V\ I I Cl_ V\ Chairperson - Design Review Board 2

City of Glendale Community Development Department Planning Division 633 E. Broadway, Room 103 Glendale, CA 91206-4386 Tel (818) 548-2140 or (818) 548-2115 Fax (818) 240-0392 www.glendaleca .gov DESIGN REVIEW BOARD RECORD OF DE CISION Meeting Date February 13, 2020 Case No. Address PDR 1923858 1226 ldlewood Road Project Summary: Applica nt Arman Abgaryan To add a total of approximately 750 square feet to the front, side, and rear of an existing one-story, 1,201 square-foot, single-family residen_ce (built in 1937) with a new detached two-car garage on a 6,600 square- foot lot located in the R 1-1 (Low Density Residential-Floor Area Ratio District I) Zone. The project consists of removing more than 50 percent of the combined exterior walls and roof area ; therefore, the project is considered new construction, and must comply with the current zoning code . D Resian eview: Board Member Motion Second Yes No Absent Abstain Arzoumanian X X Benlian X Simonian X Boyajyan X X Welch X Totals 4 0 1 ORB Decision Approve with Conditions and Considerations Conditions: 1. Replace gravel (ground cover) along the south property line with landscape materials to comply with the zoning requirements. 2. Increase the width of the single column and base at the front porch to create a more appropriate proportion to the design. 3. Show the location of trash storage and air conditioning unit to be out of public view. Consideration: 1. Replace the proposed 6-foot-high white vinyl fence along the south property line with split-face CMU wall (facing neighbors). 2. Raise the stone veneer to sill height and use a cap stone. Analysis Site Planning: The site planning is appropriate to the site and its surroundings, as modified by any conditions, for the following reasons: • The new addition to the front, side, and rear of the existing one-story residence will not alter the site planning significantly and is appropriate to the site and its surroundings.

• The additions will not change the existing interior setbacks at the sides and will maintain the existing street front setback (26'- 6"), which is greater than the neighborhood front setback average along both sides of ldlewood Road (within 300 linear feet of the subject property). • The location of the driveway opening will not be changed; however, the existing concrete driveway will be extended to the new detached two-car garage at the rear of the property with a 90 degree turn. The location of the new two-car garage is appropriate to the site and neighborhood. • New drought-tolerant plants and trees complement the overall design. A condition of approval is added to replace the new gravel (shown on the landscape plan) along the south interior setback with landscape materials to comply with the zoning requirements. • The perimeter walls are a combination of the existing CMU walls along the north and east property line and a new white vinyl fence (proposed) along the south property line. In order to be consistent with the design and compatible with the surroundings, a consideration is added to replace the proposed 6-foot-high white vinyl fence along the south property line with split-face CMU wall (facing neighbors). Mass and Scale: The project's mass and scale are appropriate to the site and its surroundings, as modified by any conditions, for the following reasons: • The one-story addition's roof, building mass, and proportions are consistent with the existing volume of the house and surrounding neighborhood. However, a condition of approval is added to increase the width of the single column and base at the front porch to create a more appropriate proportion to the new design. • The existing roof will be replaced with a new hipped roof which integrates with the existing neighborhood context and the new additions appropriately. • The design, mass, and scale of the new two-car garage are appropriate to the design and scale of the new house. Building Design and Detailing: The project's design and detailing are appropriate to the site , as modified by any conditions, and its surroundings for the following reasons: • The project's architectural details and materials including stucco finish, stone veneer, primary steel entry door, metal gates, boxed eaves, and overall materials and textures are appropriate and reinforce the new Contemporary architectural style. • The new front entry door along with a small front porch is well integrated into the overall design. • The size, style, and placements of new windows are appropriate to the design and architectural style of the house. The windows will be white vinyl to match the existing vinyl windows. The windows throughout the house will be appropriately recessed within the walls (with wood trim and sill) and feature a combination of fixed and sliding windows. • The project does not result in any privacy impacts since no second-floor addition is added. • The color and texture of new decorative paving stone for the driveway surface within the street front setback are appropriate to the design concept. • The location of new downspouts and gutters are appropriate to the design. No locations are identified on the new plans for trash storage and air conditioning unit. Condition of approval is added to show the location of trash storage and air conditioning unit to be out of public view. The Design Review Board approves the design of projects only. Approval of a project by the Design Review Board does not constitute an approval of compliance with the Zoning Code and/or Building Code requirements. If an appeal is not filed within the 15-day appeal period of the Design Review Board decision , plans may be submitted for Building and Safety Division plan check. Prior to Building and Safety Division plan check submittal, Design Review Board approved plans must be stamped approved by Design Review Board staff. An,y changes to the approved plans may constitute returning to the Design Review Board for approval. Prior to Building and Safety Division plan check submittal, all changes in substantial conformance with approved plans by the Design Review Board must be on file with the Planning Division. Please make an appointment with the case planner for ORB stamp/sign-off prior to submitting for Building plan check. DRB Staff Member Aileen Babakhani, Case Planner

DESIGN REVIEW BOARD RECORD OF DECISION Meeting Date February 13, 2020 Case No. Address Applicant PDR 1920853 1682 Valley View Road Edward Hagobian Project Summary: To demolish the existing one-story, 1,320 square-foot, single-family residence (built in 1941) and existing detached garage, and to construct a new 5,183 square-foot, two-story single-family residence and a new attached three-car garage on a 32,670 square-foot lot in R1 R-11 (Restricted Residential- Floor Area Ratio District II) Zone . D Resian eview: Board Member Motion Second Yes No Absent Abstain Arzoumanian X X Benlian X Simonian X Boyajyan X Welch X X Totals 4 0 1 DRB Decision Approve with Conditions Conditions: 1. Comply with the conditions of Variance No. PVAR1800911. 2. Obtain required indigenous tree permit(s) and comply with all protection measures required by the City's Urban Forestry. 3. Show the location of downspouts on the elevation drawings consistent with the overall design. Analysis Site Planning: The proposed site planning is appropriate to the site and its surroundings, as modified by any conditions, for the following reasons: • The project's site planning is appropriate to the site and neighboring properties since the project will not alter the existing site planning significantly. The new house and attached three-car garage will be built on the existing flat portion of the lot (on the east portion of the uphill lot), in the almost same location of the existing house and detached garage. However, the existing flat pad will be extended to accommodate the new development, which will require an approximately 700-cubic yards of cut and 90-cubic yards of fill. The majority of the existing landform and natural terrain will remain unchanged. • The new attached garage will be accessed via the existing shared driveway from Valley View Road. The driveway currently provides vehicular access to the subject property and four other properties. Variance No. PVAR 1800911 was approved on November 20, 2018 to allow the new house to utilize the existing driveway, which is not completely located on the subject site. There is no change to the existing driveway location.

• The new house will be setback an approximately 200 feet from the street front property line and will be appropriately setback from the side and rear property lines. • The new retaining walls and deck are appropriate to the site and its surroundings. New drought tolerant plants are proposed in front of the retaining walls (deck) to minimize the visual impact of low retaining walls, which will not be more than 4'-0" in height. • There are four protected indigenous trees (three Coast Live Oak trees and one Scrub Oak tree) on the lot. Two are mature oak trees located near the existing house (northwest) and two are young trees located on the steep area of the lot, away from the existing house, towards the southwest side of the lot. All four trees are healthy trees according to the Indigenous Tree Report prepared by Arsen Margossian on April 9, 2018. In order to accommodate the proposed house, one of the mature oak trees, near the existing house and within the footprint of the new house, will be removed and replaced with four new oak trees as required by the City's Urban Forestry. Mass and Scale: The proposed mass and scale are appropriate to the site and its surroundings, as modified by any conditions, for the following reasons: • The overall proportions of the new two-story house including the second floor step backs and articulations at the elevations are in keeping with the Hillside Design Guidelines, appropriate to the site, relate to the surrounding context, and reinforce the overall architectural concept. • The overall height of the new two-story house is 35 feet, which is appropriate in the context of nearby properties, which sit at some distance from the subject property. • The second floor balconies are appropriately scaled and integrated into the overall design. • The new deck and pool are well integrated into the design and follow the existing topography. • The proposed low-pitched hipped roofs (3:12 pitch) are consistent with the overall design and neighboring buildings. Building Design and Detailing: The proposed building design and detailing are appropriate to the site , as modified by any conditions , and its surroundings for the following reasons: • The design and detailing of the new two-story house including smooth stucco wall finish, clay tile roof, stone veneer wainscot, railing, and boxed eaves are consistent with the proposed architectural style and appropriate to the surrounding area . The overall design and colors meet the intent of the Hillside Design Guidelines and blend appropriately into the surroundings. • The project's fenestration complements the architectural design and features brown color aluminum- clad wood windows with combination of casement, sliding, and fixed windows with stone sills. • The new development relates to and follows the existing natural terrain and will not create privacy issue or visual impact to its neighboring properties due to the site topography. • Retaining walls with stone veneer cladding are appropriate to the design and surroundings. • New air-conditioning unit is appropriately located out of public view. A condition of approval is added to show downspouts on the elevation drawings. The Design Review Board approves the design of projects only. Approval of a project by the Design Review Board does not constitute an approval of compliance with the Zoning Code and/or Building Code requirements. If an appeal is not filed within the 15-day appeal period of the Design Review Board decision, plans may be submitted for Building and Safety Division plan check . Prior to Building and Safety Division plan check submittal, Design Review Board approved plans must be stamped approved by Design Review Board staff. M::J. changes to the approved plans may constitute returning to the Design Review Board for approval. ..frlQ! to Building and Safety Division plan check submittal, fill changes in substantial conformance with approved plans by the Design Review Board must be on file with the Planning Division. Please make an appointment with the case planner for DRB stamp/sign-off prior to submitting for Building plan check. DRB Staff Member Aileen Babakhani, Case Planner

Thursday, February 13, 2020 at 5:00 PM

I. Roll Call: Arzoumanian, Boyajyan, Benlian, Simonian, Welch.

II. Report Regarding Posting of Agenda: The agenda for this meeting was posted on the bulletin board outside

City Hall at or before 5:00 p.m. on February 6, 2020.

III. Oral Communications: Discussion is limited to items NOT a part of this agenda. Each speaker is allowed 3

minutes. The Board may question the speaker, but there will be no debate or decision. The Board may refer the

matter to the proper department’s section for investigation/report.

IV. Review Calendar:

A. Staff Announcements

B. Design Review Cases:

DRB Case No. Address Applicant Planner Project Last Reviewed

a. PDR1923858 1226 Idlewood Rd. A. Abgaryan A. Babakhani Additions to SF -

1. DRB Record of Decision to Approve Final Project Design

Environmental Determination: Exempt from CEQA review as a Class 1 “Existing Facilities” exemption pursuant to Section

15301(e)(1) of the State CEQA Guidelines, because the proposed addition to the existing structure will not result in an increase

of more than 2,500 square feet of floor area.

b. PDR1920853 1682 Valley View Rd. E. Hagobian A. Babakhani New 2-Story SF -

1. DRB Record of Decision to Approve Final Project Design

Environmental Determination: Exempt from CEQA review as a Class 3 “New Construction or Conversion of Small Structures”

exemption pursuant to Section 15303(a) of the State CEQA Guidelines, because the project only involves the development of

one single-family residence.

V. Approval of Minutes: January 23, 2020

VI. Adjournment

NOTES:

1) PARTICIPATION: Applicants will be allotted 5 minutes to explain their projects; other interested parties will be allotted 3

minutes to speak at the discretion of the Chairperson, with a 2 minute rebuttal for the applicant. The Chairperson may alter

the order of agenda items.

2) APPEALS: There is a 15-day appeal period for decisions rendered by the Design Review Board.

3) REPORTS ONLINE: Staff reports and their respective attachments are accessible through hyperlinks in the “Agendas and

Minutes” section of the City website: www.glendaleca.gov. The case file and copies of plans may be viewed in the

Community Development Department, Municipal Service Building, Room 103.

Welcome to the meeting of the Design Review Board. Meetings are broadcast live on cable channel 6 (GTV6) and rebroadcast throughout the week;

program schedules are available by calling (818) 548-4013. DVD’s of the proceedings are available for purchase in the City Clerk’s Office. Meetings

are also archived on the City Website for viewing anytime at www.ci.glendale.ca.us/video_archives.asp. If you have any question about matters on

the agenda, or requests for assistance, please contact the Community Development Department at (818) 548-2115 during regular business hours.

PLEASE TURN OFF CELLULAR PHONES WHILE INSIDE THE HEARING ROOM.

In compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) of 1990, auxiliary hearing aids, sign language translation, and Braille transcripts are

available upon request. Assisted listening devices are available same-day upon request. At least 48 hours (or two business days) notice is required

for requests regarding sign language translation and Braille transcription services. All documents related to open session items on this agenda that

are received less than 72 hours prior to this meeting, and are public records, will be available for review in the Community Development Department,

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
Agenda packetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Action agendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Transcript or captionsNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Recording and media

Coverage and corrections

Records considered

  • Design Review Board — Minutes
  • Design Review Board

Not claimed by this page

  • Verified meeting decisions with item-specific public-source evidence
  • Item-level plain-language summaries are not available; this page does not infer individual agenda items.
  • Item-linked, attributed deliberation
  • A source-grounded next meeting date
  • A plain-English overview is not available.
  • Official outcomes have not been published.
  • A transcript is not available.
  • Speakers have not been reliably matched to public profiles.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.
  • An individual roll-call roster is not available.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: 4d618de4f8ea921cbe081c6c7ba62e8c. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record