POLISCOPE

The public record

STPETERSBURG (PINELLAS COUNTY) · LOCALHeld · official record pendingPartial coverage

City Council

Thursday, February 3, 2022 · Government meeting record

The 30-second read

Record incomplete

City Council

Why it matters

The official meeting record is available below. Item-level plain-language summaries are not available yet.

What happens next

The scheduled meeting date has passed. Minutes or an action agenda are not published in the records we hold.

This meeting date has passed and no official outcome record has been published yet. Nothing on this page is a decision.

Transcript and record text

Closed captionsWhat was said at the meeting, transcribed Aug 3, 2026. Speech is not a decision.
  • No speaker turns were supplied with this transcript.
  • This transcript has no source timestamps.
  • No speaker identities were supplied with this transcript.

This source published text without speaker turns, so speakers and timestamps are not shown.

The opening of 85,126 stored characters

>> Welcome to the city of St. Petersburg City Council meeting and your elected officials our mayor Ken Welch district one hopefully burdis district 2 Council vice chair Brandi Gabbert district 3 and not marry. He's worked for with that kind of way. Deborah big Sanders. And Council chair Gina Driscoll district 7 Lisa Wheeler Bowman. And district day Richie Floyd. >> City Council. Whether clerk please start with the roll call emmert Martin narey and what's here fix Sanders. Driscoll you're really Bowman Floyd year or does here. >> We will have our indication today followed by a moment of silence and then the pledge of allegiance. Joining us today for in vacation is pastor. Is that reverend Bob beamon's missing Grandma from maximo Presbyterian Church that morning. Thank you for joining us. Can everyone please stand. >> Gracious and loving GOD. Thank you for the gift of life on this brand new day. Thank you for walking along with us. This positive for Cody is. Lately these been dimic infused years have been quite weary. Help us to overcome the pandemic can get well soon. When we celebrate black history. We thank you for opening a new and historic chopped up. You know a city of St. Petersburg. Thank you for this new administration and at City Hall. We pray for a a mistake in Welsh the 7th of the people with an acute listening year. Full of love and compassion. Granting wisdom to make decisions that will impact a beautiful city and gracious people. We pray for this city Council. Including those new as well as those who have been out on the block for a while. Bless them with compassion and hearts. So that the policies they approve and implement. We'll make life for all people in Saint Peter's book. A little better. Help And the City Council to work together for the sake of the people's business. Like role was in the same boat. MAY they wrote together. In the same direction. And made that direction leads to the well-being of all of people. You know city. Both residents and visitors. Did GOD bless now we pray. The work which City Council has to do today. Each work continue to make Ellis it is stronger. More peaceful. In full of justice for all of your people. We pray for all these things trusting you and knowing that you are a balloon to help us do the right thing on these matches. We ask all this in your holy name. Amen. >> If everyone to please remain standing for a moment of silence to honor the life and service of officer David Crawford. End of watch Feb. 21th. 2011. Council members. We have an agenda before us all entertain a motion for approval. We'll prove them and we have a motion in the second to approve the agenda. But the current PRESIDENT Mission for voting. Council members please. Seeing that a PRESIDENT Council members have voted will the clerk please telling announced the votes. MADAM Chair, the motion to approve the agenda passes unanimously with councilmember gambhir being absent. Next on her agenda is the approval of our consent agenda. We have a motion to second to approve the consent agenda. I'm seeing that requests for public comment from City Council members of that clerk please open the machine for voting. Council members please enter your votes. Thing that a PRESIDENT Council members have voted for the clicks a stallion announced the votes. MADAM Chair, the motion to approve the consent agenda passes unanimously with council member Garrett being absent. Thank you will need to open do we have any speakers this morning. We do go ahead and read the rules. Open form if you wish to address City Council and subjects or public hearing because it is your items listed on the agenda please sign up with the clerk. Only the individual wishing to speak MAY signed the open forum seat only city residents owners of property, business owners in the city or their employees MAY speak. All you see is discussed and are open for must be limited to issues related to the city of St. Petersburg government. If you're speaking to an item on the agenda. You MAY only speak wants during the open forum. When the item comes up on the agenda in order to provide an opportunity for all citizens to address Council. Each individual will be given 3 minutes to speak and after which the microphone will be muted. If you wish to address to the council through the zoom meeting, you must use the race and feature but in the app our interest are 9 on your phone at the time the agenda item is addressed. When it is your turn to speak you'll be on you did an axis state your name and address at the conclusion of your comments or when you reach the 3 minute time limit you will be muted all raised hands will be lowered after each agenda item regardless of the method of participation use normal rules apply, including the 3 minute time limit on comments. The requirement that any presentation materials must be submitted in advance of the meeting and the rules of decorum if live public comment is disrupted by violations of the rules of decorum this year's authorized to accept public comment. My art and it means including e-mail only. >> MADAM Chair, we have no however, there are members and chamber we're going to call you to talk to a time to go to the podium. Once you name is Khan is your time to speak please state your name and address for the record and you have 3 minutes to address City Council. MADAM Chair, the first 2 speakers are Peter Clarke into Wayne Virgin's. >> Peter addresses 2, 9, 5, 0, Pinellas Bailey South. I am the PRESIDENT And founder of Tampa Bay watch. And we appreciate the opportunity come before you this morning and talk about the Tampa Bay watch discovery center as well as our new eco both the discovery. Tampa Bay watch celebrating 29 years of habitat restoration, education and community outreach programs for the Tampa Bay estuary. We organize between 8 10,000 community volunteers a year. To participate in a restoration projects and out and tear Verde and a good year were able to bring about 3500 kids to go through our education programs out there. And because of the success of the education programs out there. We wanted to play a role in downtown St. Petersburg in grower education outreach which we are able to do when we signed an agreement with the city of St. Petersburg to develop a new facility and the. The new St. Petersburg pier. Which ultimately became the discovery center. We've been participating all along with the pier use committee in the peer education advisory team to help design educational outreach opportunities along the Petersburg waterfront. With the addition of the discovery center really gave us a new platform near the communities that we wanted to reach as interior Verde we have a eco both that takes classrooms of kids out on the water. Many of them actually the majority of the schools that visit the terra Verde facility. Our title one schools. A lot of these are kids that have never been on the water before. This is the really their first opportunity to see the Tampa Bay Ussery many of the things that we take for granted. And because of the success of the classroom bowed out and tear Verde we have always planned on including an eco vessel as part of our discovery center operations activities in downtown Saint Pete. The new eco boat is able to provide a platform for a couple of different things were able to take the kids out on the water. During the morning sessions and then do eco tours in the afternoon with the community. The discovery center is all about telling the story of the Tampa Bay estuary in the eco boat gets us that platform to extended out into the water itself. With that I would like to introduce tween Virgin it. He opened up to the discovery center 2 years ago. As our executive director and because of his success. We have elevated him to the ceo position of Tampa Bay watch he's going to speak toward downtown operations as well as the discovery boat. Thank you still have 10 seconds left. >> And go good morning Thank you all for your service appreciate you taking time to hear from us this Please state your name and address for the rest, I'm sorry to waver work address $3,000 by the way South. Thank you. As Peter mentioned I've been with Tampa Bay watch for a few years open the discovery center. Eco vessel eco tour was always part of our plans that was part of our initial lease with the city that we would open this up. And the reason we speak to this morning as of the talking about that is I just want to clarify the truth and I'm glad that we had MISTER Offer a blessing this morning because I think there are a lot of I know there are a lot of misstatements that were made back at the DECEMBER meeting and we just want to make sure that you hear the facts. The facts are that this is discussion between the tenant that's on satisfied with having competition down at the pier. The fact is that we began service down there as you plan to from understand back in 36. So this is this is nothing new. We are consistently in line with our mission. As a nonprofit, and that means that we are educating. We have educators out on every tour of some of our staff that are here from the boat, most of them advanced degrees and not bachelor's degrees. In marine Sciences, good. They're about education there about teaching. So this is something that we've done in addition to all of the research that we've added the research was not part of our initial plan with the city but it is something we've added to that includes 7 different programs that we're doing right now that we are sharing a working in collaboration with Eckerd College and Noah and the estuary program and fwc that's just one of the benefits or bring because it ties back to our mission. On the factual side. Some of the misstatements that were made that I just want to clarify with each of you is there is nothing that we're doing that is inconsistent with our mission. We're not breaking any rules any laws any violations related to the lease. That's just not true. We were not asked to leave the public slip. We were docked. We asked to go to a commercial slip for several reasons, including the fact that we could provide better signage and then we would have to move our boat. Twice a day from the temporary slips. There's nothing illegal immoral or inconsistent with the lease that we signed with the city of St. Petersburg. So I think one of the other misstatements that we've heard was that we were subsidized by the city. We are not subsidized by the city. We cover all of our own expenses down there. In addition to the cam utility fees tenant improvements in interior building repairs and maintenance which all of the tenants at the pier are paying for. We also have and invested over $1.3 million towards improvements to the building and the exhibit tree in the interior. The discussion on our winter wonderland tour. It was ridiculous. We were doing comparisons educationally to polar animals versus estuary animals. All we did this but holiday lights on the boat and put a name on it nothing inconsistent there and lastly one of the folks that spoke said they were a board member of ours MISTER Labadie. >> He is not. Thank you for your time this morning. Thank u next 2 speakers please. MISTER Speaker, the man of Medan fair been saying and Bill waters please state your name and address for the record and you have 3 minutes to address City Council. As everybody doing. So my name is captain Christian open channel of the 5515 pine circle Avenue Northeast. Ask your permission to tell a little story day about a city. And offer profit competing with a small business. So forth generation, Saint Pete native lives here has worked his whole life and it's been part of corporate America enjoys his job but not really fulfilling him. During a worldwide pandemic shutdown he takes a huge risk gets his captain's license purchases, a 41 foot catamaran. And a 29 year-old Dolphin tours in sightseeing business. The captain hires a marine biologist to shift the focus to education add even more value to the tour and does outreach to children the community. The captain market says business in the city appearing in shows getting several million views about 7 several million views online. So 10 months after purchasing the business the city places and not for profit, but a 44 foot catamaran on a dock behind Doc Ford's designated for recreational boats. The Army Corps of Engineers approved one vessel designated as a floating classroom. The captain spoke of concern he would be loose significant business but the city officials said not to worry. There are no private charters in the vessels designated for educational program only tied to the classroom and the building that they give him for $10 year subsidize $10 here have you want to say it the not for profit begins advertising sunset tours, ghost tours, polar express tumors winter wonderland tours all kinds of events which had nothing to do with education clearly ignoring the agreement they've had with the city and the Army Corps engineers into their benefactors in addition the not for profit vessels acting as a standalone business advertising you can sign up online without even visiting the center, but the city gave to them in good faith for $10 a year. The captain e-mails and speaks in front of City Council asked persistent. The city agreed this not for profit has broken their lease as I was told verbally by the city manager. But response by rewarding them. The city puts them ahead of 20 to small businesses on a frozen waitlist 22 businesses that have paid to be on this weightless. Not for profit re brands, the boat makes even more aggressive business approach marking Dolphin birds mimicking the captain's route to her times all the while drastically under cutting all the commercial businesses in the marina being subsidized by the city. They do pay further $800 a month or so lease. The leader of the nonprofit who is your partner is irritated makes legal threats to 2 of my friends that your boy better calm down and stop making these claims or we've got lawyers and deep pockets. So if the cap if the captain. So gravely broke his agreement least without the city and went out of bounds of education Dolphin tours what would happen to him. So how is this story going and how are you good justify. Remaining in competition business with the captain, how much longer does he have to put his trust in you to stand behind small business and do something how much longer will his choice is to go out of business sells assets or hire a lawyer. I'm going to fall miley's if Tampa Bay watchful as early as I see nothing wrong. As a matter of fact they have things that can be days you all right. Speaker please. >> bill 21 by a grant. I really just want to come out today to show follow-up I've been sort of supporting I was here at the last meeting with Tampa Bay water we had a conversation I was here in DECEMBER have sort of heard the arguments. I listen to the other captains that we're here at the last meeting who were jumped to put a commercial vessel in front of theirs where they have been on a waiting list for many years, I'm a local captain I think it's pretty sad. As it was pointed out by and attorney last meeting this doesn't pass the smell test. You know education classroom is suddenly placed in a recreational dock. But then it becomes more commercial right on that edge. Suddenly they're moved. They state they were moved on their own whatever they're suddenly moved, jumping a wait list and now they are absolutely doing Dolphin tours in sightseeing and parties and everything fun. Plus their advertising at the pier, you know how is that fair to any of the other businesses that are on that strip they're only allowed to advertise right there in their space yet. These guys are able to do it I just I think Tampa Bay watch is great. I'm not arguing what they do with their mission. You know, I've been a local and a resident and supported them for years and indirectly even don't donated to them. But I just think it just as a common odd sudden mix-up of how they were out there, acting as a business and then suddenly jumping over. Our small business owner and now they're directly next to them competing and advertising that they're doing the exact same thing and under under cutting all their prices I've been on the water and they're literally following right behind Christian right behind that they're both doing the exact same route you know that seems again a little fishy doesn't pass the smell test so I'm very interested to hear from the marina and and go through that. Lee's I've looked at it in You know the city doesn't owe them anything once they leave that recreational that spot at the recreation dock. And it was after a certain number of days we didn't owe them a commercial slip. So if they decide to be commercial they should be in line with the other 22 individuals and you heard from them last time those other captains that were literally jumped to put them in front. Of them have been on a wait list for quite some time so looking forward I hope you guys follow up I wanted to be fair for everyone. I don't think that one large non business or profit should be able to trample on small businesses here in this town and look forward to that comment. Thank you. >> The next speaker, MADAM Chair. Mark some of those key in because Ken Grimes please state your name and address for the record and you have 3 minutes to address City Council. A City MARCH similar scheme in 1900 bright waters Boulevard on the board of Tampa Bay watch. You know. I think the last 2 speakers again just showed how you can come up here and to say about anything you would and I would hope you don't take that as fact it's kind of sad to the state of affairs here. You have to realize too that we're not the only ones that have an ego boat. You have Mote that has an eco both the charges people to go out and have a educational experience. You have the clear Aquarium that also does the same as well as the Florida aquarium. So all these things are not something that we created we look at other successful organizations try to see what they did better serve the community and that's all we're trying to do a Tampa Bay watch. I think we followed every I know we have we talked many of the people on the other side and accusations that were threatening them is outrageous. All we want to do is really compromise and figure out a way to solve this. So that that's that's what that's what we're here to talk about today really defend what Tampa Bay's mission is I've been on the board for about 10 years now, it's upsetting you know they hear things like this and people trying to threaten a group that's done some great things for our city and we've always followed the period. So with that thank you. >> Please state your name and address for the record. Hi my name is Ken I live at one oh one Bayshore drive. Islip for. >> I'm a been a local resident for a long time I know many of you has a long time not for profit board member and PRESIDENT. I executive for an aviation company which becomes important in a minute just really wanted to make a 3 main One is well and I drive for the Dolphin 2 were paired off and were occasionally. So they're both these organizations are great organizations and great companies. The Tampa my companies doing a leadership retreat and I suggested they do they contact Tampa Bay to do some sort of team building building lobster pots those sort of things I'm in a very important mission. And I also suggested they go on the pier golf increases. As a group as well to do that activity. So both organizations are great I'm in the aviation business and how we aggressively compete and put somebody out of business is this it's a simple playbook we get ourselves next to them at a I think somebody here is from aviation so you'll know this to be true. We get ourselves next to them and again and we matched their roots and then we slashed the price is 30. 33% are charged 33% less than them. And it's really awful thing to do, but it's a way to put somebody out of business right. And so that's what's happened here. You know Tampa Bay watch Bo, somehow I asked to be on the commercial waiting list and I was denied that right. So I wanted to give historic downtown tours which many of you know I can do a really good job and do a lot for the city. I was denied a slip and yet Tampa Bay watch was. He was evicted pain taxpayer was evicted they were put in the slip at the gate right next to peer Dolphin cruises and then paired off increases Tampa Bay watch has the sign board you know one of the sandwich board matching the the roots in times of the pier Dolphin cruises and then slashed in charges much less. There's all kinds of other in consistencies that I mean Tampa Bay watch is a not for profit compete with a commercial business. Poor guy trying to feed his family to be honest with you. They can advertise on the pier which paired off increases can so there's all kinds of things that are you know wrong here. The really the last thing is really headed. How do we get here and how did the city's sort of be complacent in this I would look if I was on the commission would look for you know where the conflict lies because but these people are good people how did this happen how did that person get evicted how did they get put in there how did the city not facilitate this paired off a cruise is the taxpayer of the city and needs the city's protection. Not you know. And Tampa Bay watch doesn't pay you. Next to speakers please. I will speak to final speakers name is Chris Wiggins please state your name and address for the record. You have 3 minutes to address City Council. My name's Chris Wiggins >> fishing charter business Saint Pete and I've been trying to think you could you give your address please what was that could you give your address for the record please. Addresses 6535 12 Street North. Thank you Florida. 3, 3, 7, 0, 2, So I don't a private charter business name I put my name on the list. Over 2 years ago my question is how the Tampa Bay watch and other businesses could go above me on that list. I put money into have a commercial slip down there and I've never heard another word. And other businesses are. Cutting ahead of everybody on that list. That's I just don't understand that part. Thank you so much. Thank you what's become chair. They're in private error we're in front. Please state your name and address for the record and you have 3 minutes to address City Council good morning council members my name is Mary and private era Renfro I live at 7.29 Santa Maria drive-in tier a birdie and I'm a longtime member of the board of directors of Tampa Bay watch as well as previous past chair. I'm here this morning to support Tampa Bay watch and to again dispel the misinformation and I use that word timely. That is being presented to the board in public forum. Regarding this nonprofit organization. This organization. Its mission is to restore preserve and protect Tampa Bay. We do this through our projects and we do this through education to help. Attract volunteers for the new MISS Projects that this organization does all around Tampa Bay to help improve the water quality and protect the shorelines of Tampa Bay. As well create a next-generation of stewards to continue this work. We worked intimately with multiple organizations from around the Tampa Bay area to address all of the issues as they arise with reference to having a negative impact on this. Those 2 area which is a testament of a positive turn around in a body of water that decades ago severely polluted and this I know because I have lived here since I was 3 years old in 1963 my family moved here and so I'm quite aware of the change and the quality of the water the seagrass beds and the shorelines here and the impact that they have it negatively And what Tampa Bay watch along with other organizations has done to turn that around as well as municipalities we also work with municipalities work with pet projects that they want to create to help improve the shoreline in their community and the water quality in their community as well. I have been intimately involved as the previous chair with the Tampa Bay watch discovery Center. And the echo vest so. That was a part of the project I oversaw that as chair of the board and I want to let you know that this echo vessel was always on plans with the city the city was well aware of it it is an education vehicle that was used. As an extension of our programming just as we do in tier Bertie the reason that the boat was not put into service sooner was the fact that construction at the pier was pushed back as well as creation of the docks for where the vessel would be more and the vessel would have been in operation sooner had it not been for construction delay. Thank you. Thank you so much. >> Thank you we'll go ahead and close open Thank you to all who took the time to speak today. Go next to new ordinances and she won. >> The one proposed ordinance 1141 be an ordinance approving a vacation of Davenport Avenue Northeast from pursing Street Northeast 2 Eastern terminus of Davenport Avenue Northeast. And a vacation of pine Street Northeast from 64th Avenue Northeast to the southern terminus of pine Street Northeast, setting forth conditions for the vacations to become effective and providing an effective date. The public for this item is Feb. 17th, MADAM Chair, we have no heart. All right. Thank you. Thing that they're in a request to speak I'll entertain a motion for approval. Approval. We have a motion in a second. The discussion saying there's no requests for discussion with the clerk please open the machine for voting. Members please enter your votes. Seeing PRESIDENT Council members have voted for the clerk please tallying announced the votes. MADAM Chair, the motion to approve the agenda item g one passes unanimously with council member Garrett being absent. Thank you. Our next item is item. G 2. To propose ordinance 7.50 dash ale an ordinance amending the future land use map of the comprehensive plan for the city of St. Petersburg Florida. I change in the future land use map designation for a 0.3 9 acre property located at 15 oh one 5th Avenue north from planned redevelopment so that's residential pr dash r the planned redevelopment desk mixed use pr Das im you providing for repeal of conflicting ordinances and provisions thereof and providing an effective date the public hearing is Feb. 17th. And we have no carts for this item. All right. Thank you. >> Since there are 2 ordinances with this if you would like you to read them both at the same time a vote on both up together that's up to you. Yes, I would prefer that thank you. The to be the proposed ordinance 7.80 dash z. An ordinance amending the official zoning map of the city of St. Petersburg Florida by changing the official zoning map designation for a 0.3 9 acre parcel located at 15 oh one 5th Avenue north from neighborhood traditional dash 2 in t dash 2 2 corridor residential traditional dash one crt dash one providing for repeal of conflicting ordinances and provisions thereof and providing an effective date the public hearing for this item is also Feb. 17th. And we have no speakers. All right, thank you. And it looks like we have no requests to speak at this time saw entertain a motion for approval. Some of second. We have a motion in a second for approval of All right g 2 a and b seeing that there are no requests for discussion with the clerk please open the machine for voting. Council members please enter your votes, seeing that all present council members have voted the clerk please telling announced the votes. I'm sure the motion to approve the agenda items, Ga 2 and b passes unanimously with councilmember Gabbert being absent all right. Thank you, that's all for new ordinances today will go next to reports with item e to our Tampa Bay watch update. MADAM Chair members of Council. MISTER Chris Leicester city development. And informational report. You've heard from the and so far. But I want to make sure to. Share some of the comments that were made across multiple open forums in DECEMBER and JANUARY. A 100% of those were from Christian open shine or supporters of peer Dolphin cruises a Marine attendant and members of the public that support them. So this comments were all in regards to another tenant at the marina Tampa Bay watch an implied that there involving in unfair business practices. They have an unfair competitive advantage. And ball. Those statements are not correct like to provide a foundation to help with facts history and context for the record. Tampa Bay watch is a 5 oh one c 3 as you well know nonprofit focused on protecting the Tampa Bay estuary for 29 years in 42 years ago the city received a proposal from Tampa Bay watched operate the education station at this new Saint Pete pier that this timeline is important. The pier building was originally. It was selected to do educational use. But originally Council and staff discussed should be a commercial use should be an ice cream shop should generate revenue to help support the subsidy the pier. But a very direct and specific direction was laid out by Council and administration to make it a building that could support education. So Tampa Bay's watches proposal outlined ways to introduce visitors and locals to develop a deeper connection with our Tampa Bay estuary. Including labs. What classroom indoor educational space with tanks rotating exhibits. School field trips many other activities. That was all just for the building. Very importantly in the 36 proposal. They stated with clarity that they would purchase and manage an echo vessel as part of the Saint Pete Marina Elise was signed in 38 with Tampa Bay watch that reflected on this. Giving them a first right of refusal to utilize the slip at the newly formed courtesy docks at no cost. And if if that happened they could proceed as they did. So all that is history. Tampa Bay's. Echo vessel. Was to take the public out on Tampa Bay. Not just for dauphin to her but for additional educational experiences. Including but not limited to no permitted while bottle nose Dolphin dorsal identification opportunistic wild bottlenose Dolphin dorsal identification. Our trawl data collection. That was identified Cajun and data collection. Water quality testing data shared with other agencies as well school field trips many other activities, some of which you MAY have just heard about every one of those they have an educator on board as noted in the prior comments. So they're fulfilling their mission as outlined many years ago the city of Saint Pete. So we're here to repeated criticisms from Tampa Bay and from pier Dolphin cruises specifically Christian ovation was launched several complaints and we've listened very carefully. The quickest reappeared often cruises as has then explain to previously as the vessels been in operation. The pair dauphin cruise vessel since the 1980's under different ownership group. Bunch and Partners purchased the business in 2020. And again in our operations in the Saint Pete Marina in a commercial slip in SEPTEMBER of 2020. And they were granted ultimately a 3 year agreement in MARCH of 2021. So all this is relatively new to the marina. In terms of the new business. The first complaints from this tenants we're a guard to actually not Tampa Bay watch but a taking what that's all operating out of the marina. Many complaints, facts emails etc. Staff provided background information on what was going on there and that that operation is a permitted use a permit being issued by the Parks Department. Yet the complaints were a pretty extraordinary based on that vessel in complaints regarding Tampa Bay watch followed. And they included. As noted the location was 2 prominent that that courtesy docks it was the first one I remember hearing. It was too visible. The visibility, the marketing of having that big vessel right outside of Doc. Ford's was unacceptable. Tampa Bay. Watch didn't pay rent. Another complaint. And that's allowed as per their lease agreement in 38. Tampa Bay watch wasn't doing education at the vessel. i find that offensive, that's a statement that's been made and repeated in front of you. The city of subsidizing Tampa Bay watch. And this was the one really I focused on from the beginning was in this is in conversations, Christian oversized effectively if you're operating like a commercial tenant they should be a commercial Tenet. Now on the subject just about members of the public reiterated the same statements and concerns it's all documented in the record. So for clarity yes, Tampa Bay watch is a nonprofit. The city doesn't discriminate on a marina vessel based on what their business formation us. Yes, Tampa Bay watch did not pay rent at the courtesy docks when they were there as per the prior agreement with the city of Saint Pete going back to 38. 38 is long before and shine decided to purchase the dis the paired off increases. The city is not subsidizing Tampa Bay watch that's been discussed, I would concur with the what I don't recall they were made with but. I do not pay rent to the discovery center. And they didn't pay rent to the courtesy docks and they were moved to the new docks whether or not pay rent that commercial tax. Tampa Bay watch is doing education as there's a dedicated educator educator. On every cruise and it's also important to note that Tampa Bay watches vessel. We have been on our radar screen since 36. As a pending tenant it wasn't necessary to put them on the waitlist at the time granted because they had a dedicated slip at the courtesy docks which we had relentless complaints about to begin with. I think paired off increases. So there's a monocle timeline of how we got to where we are. Anyhow as Tampa Bay watch couldn't Park overnight at the courtesy docks. It was actually beneficial to the city as well. The permit restriction restricted overnight parking at the courtesy taxes beneficial to the city as well to move them into a marina slip them, I just heard somebody mention We have terminated the tenant. To free up a slip for them, absolutely false. Once again. This is where the the fact and fiction has to be clearly laid out. We asked Tampa Bay watch would you consider being rent paying tenant in a commercial space where they didn't have to pay rent before. They need to do this that would satisfy the original request of pure often cruises if they're going to operate in a commercial way they should be a commercial way. Though they were operating as an educational vessel all along. And that would level the competition playing field in Tampa Bay watch agreed. They said ok we're happy to do that. There is a wait list for commercial tenants at the marina absolutely true. And the city moved Tampa Bay watch up on that waitlist and this is a permissible administrative action. When circumstances dictate doesn't happen often, but it can be done. And we did it, public content comments on the subject have been heartfelt and at times emotional. Running a Marine I like running a business is not for the faint of heart. So there's risk and opportunity. The city works hard to provide a fair and equitable playing field for all businesses it interacts with it often cruises been afforded a unique opportunity even given a 3 year term. Most tenants overwhelming amount of 1650 tenants in the marina there's only 2 that have three-year terms. One of those is now appeared often cruises I stood up before this body, a couple years ago to ask for that to give them a glide path to get their business going. So was happy to do it at the time and so only of 14 commercial tenants there's only 2 have three-year terms as those who like to in the marina with multi year terms. You're often crews should be commended on their efforts to relaunch that business. Tampa Bay watches mission also is protecting Tampa Bay estuary as you know, confess it has been a part of that plan since 36. So the city agreed in this vision which is vetted very publicly. Well in advance of MISTER Lynch shane's decision to get into the business at the marina. There is no secret that this was coming. So reasonable adjustments have been made moving them into a commercial space making them pay rent. On an equal footing with everybody as much for appearances, frankly as anything else because they were operating in complete compliance with their prior lease at the courtesy docks. They did it. Here we are today. And again those adjustments were made and no further action is recommended at this time gladly answer questions as you desire. All right, thank Okay too. >> Council members wishing to speak first will be council member it's. >> When I was watching the meeting back. If you're the people in the contract. There's no to 50 fall. So my question to the attorney for the city is if Tampa Bay in the fall of any of its contract. A lot of patients to the City. Council member based on obviously legal doesn't always have firsthand information of everything you caring at those facilities. We however we have had multiple conversations with administration based on the information provided to us were not aware of any default in any agreement. >> Okay have a amended the leaves. The council approved. In a minute. Was One time and that had to do with tenant improvements when the pier was under construction. So that it was Let me get that. Back in MAY of 39 and predominantly ahead do with pre-construction activities based on. Kind of control of how the the tenant improvements were going to occur at the time. >> Right no amendments relevant to this issue. >> We see in here. About the status. The Tampa Bay as the non profit. And as a result they can engage uncertainty. I think that's one of the most enduring misconceptions about nonprofits is that they're prohibited from engaging activity similar to other businesses. So to give an example think about the ymca. You can have a gym membership. It competes against chance. Think about not profit hospitals. We have one right here in the city. The anthonys hospital. It competes with profit profit off. Think about the American Red Cross. You can go on the walmart website right now and see 600 products that are marketed were American Red Cross. Well that's a American right. And I see this because I know it was part of the whole conversation I don't want to get 5 tracked about the issues because it's easy to get sidetracked. There's nowhere. The Internal Revenue Service. If there is such a provision, that's why these businesses kind of threw that in the issue is whether or not it goes to the mission of the organization. So you know the difference between an on it is that. The post in order to the benefit of the private individual or shareholders of anything life. The relationship with Tampa Bay watch from everything I understand materialize because there was a need and Saint Pete pier to have an organization provide educational services it provides that pier. This is part of the vision of the pier, it sounds like it was something the mayor. The previous mayor wanted a City Council asked for and my understanding is that camp a Baywatch step forward and provided a proposal. With providing that service. And then there was opportunity by the way in the newspaper for others to come forward and provides it services and they were the only ones that stepped up and did and that resulted into a contract. And in that contract. There were provisions that we're talking about whether this let you know the get a slip for the eagle torso and so forth and that was something that was negotiated at the time with the city. While nonprofits could be dependent. If there's something that violate the contract signed I'm sharing of this because in terms of me all the relevant fact that I've been that we needed. This is an administrative issue. And there is nothing in terms of City Council at the City Council's purview that we can do. In terms of to Cannon's having issues with each other on different parts of their businesses. It can even be private civil matters and that's a completely separate issue but I just want to share my thoughts and how i am the issue. What some of the other comments were made from thank you so much all right, thank you. Councilmember months nary thank thank you MADAM Chair. Thank you. Everyone that's spoke on this issue and MISTER Blaster thank you for the update. So the. I've I've stated this before that the pier is the most studied piece to real estate and Saint Petersburg's history. Proud to be a part of it. Yes, yes, I know. We did have a lot of gray here when we started working on the pier. So the first peer task force started its work back in 2009 finished a year and a half later in 2010. And we had to multiple recommendations, one was for a Marine discovery center. Going back to that a task force and task force was started under mayor Baker. When that work was completed. The next to Mir mayors, each had a. They MAY have had separate names. But the fact that we had education component at out at the pier was important too. The 3 different administrations and the 3 community groups that that got together and worked on this. So I'm seeing as being very consistent with what the vision was starting. Starting back when. Mayor Baker was an office in the 20 people that served on original your task force. I I agree with council member Hannah what's talked about that seems to me like we're getting into an area that's not under that purview of City This is had missed rate of. Issue I do have just a couple questions and I want to I want to hear a little more about the. The waiting list and there are some allegations 22 people on the waiting list. And that the a Tampa Bay watch vessel. Kind of jump the line can discuss that a little bit further there's a waiting list >> We MAY have discussed in the It in the next iteration of the marina which you know undetermined at this point but but commercial slips and we'd like to add to the inventory of commercial slips, theirs about 14 commercial tenants today. There is a wait list. That's about 2122 people on it and there's some categories sometimes times to tied to both size by example in one of the DECEMBER meetings, the gentleman came up and spoke to getting jump to run the it is sounds concerning. But it turns out he has a 65 foot boat which we're not going to slip anyhow so. There there are other issues at the end of the day. There are circumstances this happens occasionally at the airport as well where we have a long waiting list for airplanes hangers et cetera t hangers it could be tied to any number of factors but once again. Really getting told in a relentless fashion. How unfair things were and this tenants if there operating in a it could be educational, but they want to be more than that they should be a commercial tenant and frankly we listened. Also Sat., so we moved them above that's again permissible for men to invest Raiders and then a straight of perspective. It also satisfied something on the marina side as well as the permit. There are restrictions in the permit for the courtesy docks about 25 just do. South of the Doc Ford's area. And the restriction is that you can't. Birth there overnight. So the vessel would have to move constantly. And so that obviously lends itself to better being a commercial time the other. The other side of it was I had no idea didn't think Tampa Bay watch Frankly agree that would be a good idea because they were by right by contract. Available to stay at the courtesy docks at no charge that was laid out. Back in 38. This is history to it and the administrative decision was made to advance them above some other waitlist the tenets. Was anybody evicted. That is absolutely false. >> We keep track could be because of the educational component, I know there's and MISTER Clark talk teaching programs and coming to. Participate too weak to city keep track who how many paying customers are paying for a ticket on the Tampa Bay watches. Festival versus how many people are not paying because they're part of a classroom. That's a great question. We don't have we are not tracking that at the moment I am Some of them are behind me right now that they be happy to share that information I'd like to I'd be happy to suffer if you all can send an email. The big. Good good to know because I do know a percentage of your. Passengers that you carry your not you're not making any money on them. Because of the educational component. So I think that's going to do it for for my questions I I am a big. Proponent for for Tampa Bay watch. I know when he was in office. A Tampa Bay a priority and if you go down to their facility on. Because it was a priority for for Tampa Bay watch. Our city values education and we have we value our environment. I value the work the Tampa Bay watch does too educate and help inform. People about the environment that saw all around us so. Thank you for answering my questions and I'll leave it right there man I'm sure thank you council member girgis thank you chair. I just have a couple of quick questions and really there for. For clarity for me and I think kind of like my colleagues just I think to be set out loud can you can you walk me through the difference in the ability for Tampa Bay watch to market compared to other commercial tenants that are docked on the pier. So as a commercial tenant which a Tampa Bay watch now on an equal footing. Would fall under the standard operating procedures and guidelines that every Tenet shares so the signage. Allowable should be equivalent. Obviously people their vessel. How however they choose et cetera and market, the of that floating mechanism but in terms of the physical asset that we control there's dedicated sign zones. This is another one of the public comments was the Tampa Bay watch as a sign and well frankly so this paired off increases and a frame signed as so again that I think just added to the cloud uncertainty presented to you primarily in DECEMBER. But the rules are uniform as as commercial tenants year. Everyone's the Regardless of what rent your thing you have the same rules and regulations. Now that a frame sign that's on the sidewalk next to the doctors that directly on the pier. So there's 2 yeah that's a good question. There's a Tampa Bay watch Putting a sign and that by right they have the ability to put a sign out at the education station eco tours at these times. And I that may have been the problematic item. qqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqq`qqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqq`qqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqq >> Anything that administration would consider. When did you ask Tampa Bay watch to remove the a frame sign from the discovery center. I'm sure that's just totally curiosity has probably within the last month, the management company Colliers done that for okay. Just just my opinion, but I think the try to avoid things in the future. Some signs that are shouldn't be there but are being allowed. I love the uniform part and then I feel like we've got a lot we got away from that a little bit but. I think we should try to be as uniform as possible. And then there was a question about. A city man MISTER Green maybe this is a question for city manager stating that they have broken their lease. You know anything about that. No council member not that we have a city manager but right now I I have not participated in any conversation. With any of the parties. MISTER Bill Lester. From the administration with both the Tampa Bay walk in don't increase. I cannot speak to that question exact okay, thank you. And then this this is my last question how much of this. MISTER Blitzer, do you think Being exacerbated because of proximity to each other. Being right next to each other. A good question I I I'm not sure. You know the there is not another location to move either vessel and the insurer. Without. Disrupting another tenants business and we certainly could ask another you know we can query another tenant is that an option for you to relocate we are happy to do that. Again. Really are attempting to make sure that it is a fair playing field for all. And simultaneously not mandating are dictating. In the operation what the rates should be what your routes should be right that's just business you do what you need to to fulfill your mission. So it isn't an option probably. To relocate It's not without Some challenges, I'm happy to look at that as as an and maybe to not necessarily philosophical point but is it a problem and to that have similar activities I I don't know if I'd call similar, but it's close enough there. Touring vessels. Scott let's leave it at that are close to each other. You know, I look at this I look at them original charter sly look at the marina and I see other businesses that you know they have similar I I would not argue that you know to broke brokerages next to each other similar they're not touring vessels but there are other publicly accessible vessels kind of all in a row and for context for all of counsel I you know didn't show map but this all takes along Bayshore Boulevard wrapping around frescoes to the east along the main pier out so that's basically the commercial zone of the pier today until we rework the pier and in the marina part of me. You want to read to the pier going to be. >> been there done Well Chris I appreciate all your hard work. I know. I know you're trying to work the problem I just appreciate it very much. Yeah for for Council. I don't think I need to speak too You know I want the best for every one of my tenants peer Dolphin cruises is a is a tenet of my no different than Tampa Bay watch. And we've got a lot of in the city underneath the enterprise facilities umbrella which I'm responsible for so we work very hard to find the equitable solutions the things we we have in appeared off increases we've had a challenge with this one and part of it whatever we attempt to do I feel that the goal post moved so we're trying to get to the finish line I believe that they want to get to that place also we're continue to work it. But at this juncture there is additional action that I would recommend other than as you just noted, we can explore possibly swapping some spaces. I appreciate Chris. Thank you chair. All right, thank you councilmember fig Sanders. Thank you so much here I definitely appreciate the Of everyone that what this forward into our attention because a lot of times we don't know what we don't know. And you know I want to thank you MISTER For kind of having that conversation to educate me on how some of the pier. Operations who work in and again when it was first brought to our attention the first thing came to my mind was how deep in the weeds does city Council get into private enterprise and different businesses and I think we were attached because the pier is a city project. The The city does have its hands in a lot of the operations as to what happens. On the piano and so I agree with the fact that. If you want to often tours are phenomenal. My son's family just went on a tour or not have the cutest little videos of my granddaughter seeing the Dolphins come out of the order they loved it. I appreciate what Tampa Bay. Watch is also doing for our community so I'm hoping with us now having this open dialogue that we're able to come to resolve my one comment to this and I was glad to hear the term equitable used. In feedback. I did ask since the city is still attached to the educational piece of it to provide me some references of the students said benefit from these tours and the list that i have received is impressive. But I am going to ask if we can include and I I don't have any right to ask anyone in regards to the operational choices that they choose to provide the services to but to consider providing some of the other opportunities for some of our title one schools, I'm looking at the ones then have access to the pier location is only one in South Saint Pete. So I just want to know that if the city is supporting which we do and we will. There we also continue to look at some of our projects with a more equitable and and providing some of the occupation, some of these opportunities to some of our other very. He's urging students that in other words are the terms would not have access to this because they're both beautiful prone programs and projects and I'm going to ask both to consider providing some additional opportunities to those schools and students that would normally have the opportunity to enjoy something is says. Thank you chair. Thank you councilmember Floyd. >> Thank you I just couple of quick questions just to get some so in Tampa Bay watch is a an initial agreement with the city was there. Talk eco tours involved in that first agreement. Okay when when was that. >> The agreement was ultimately executed by a approved by the council executed by the mehr in the year 38. And the eco tours are clearly and the right to have a slip. At no charge. But the conversation on eco tours began in 36. As council member Mary noted the desire for something along these lines was a clearly stated by the pier to advisory tax task force in their final years before that so it's been it's a long conversation on the subject. Okay >> when did peer Dolphin tours become a tenant at at the marina. I believe that they became a I think they purchase a business and ultimately became a under this off and how we started month to month commercial In the and the 20 20 in OCTOBER. Transferring into a 3 year agreement in MARCH of 2021. Okay what do they have to wait on the wait list to become a tenant at the marina pier Dolphin tours. That's a good question honestly don't remember the answer to that one okay. I think I'll leave it there, thank you for the information. >> And that there are no other requests at this go ahead and thank you so much for the the update and for the clarification that's it's been needed Since the DECEMBER meeting. When you started to discuss. Moving was there consideration given to possibly allowing an exception to the overnight rule at the original location. Rather than moving it. No we did not. Feel that that was a worthy process challenging and lengthy the permit was very explicit 25 slips with no overnight. Capability because they were dedicated as transit slips and the permit was amended to allow Tampa Bay watch to be there. So you had one. Vessel Tampa Bay watch and then 24 slips but all of them had to abide by the original rules and we didn't even consider going back for a permit modification for overnight stay at that location and. Frankly didn't really suit the marina in the not withstanding the fact that they're operating completely within their under the agreement. Operationally for the marina. It was easier really to keep the commercial tenants together. And as noted previously it is satisfied if their commercial they should be commercial. So but that we achieved the objective yet we're here today. So. >> Because it just seems like if there is a little bit of distance like physical distance between the 2 vessels that I hear that a little better councilmember girders as well and has a look at if there's an alternative there. If I could interject one thing for councilmember flooded to backtrack they were not on the just as life think through because they tenants that have been sold in the boat had to get rebuilt. To put back into service. So they had a slip there that being peer Dolphin cruises so sorry about sort of toggle between the 2 of us want to make sure that the record was accurate. Yeah, no thank you for and getting good following up on that one. So we have we have to agreements here to leases that are that are not alike we're not talking apples to apples here because they Tampa Bay watch vessel is tied to the discovery center center agreement and always has been whereas they. The other vessel is our our standard commercial lease for the marina. Marina yes that that said though for clarity the agreement. There's a progression if I can take a moment. Often a tenants will start with what we call a commercial agreement and that's often administratively approved and then they will have a license agreement there's a commercial tenants the good Ol license agreement which is the council consent agenda approval, generally. The exception being when we do multiyear agreements 2 in the marina today, one of them appeared often cruises 3 year agreements. And so there's of the commercial slips. Commercial agreements summer license agreements and some are 3 year agreements now so it is staff's intention bring forward to Council downstream. To to make the agreements uniform. So they they and for us as a city. It allows us the opportunity you know it just that deputies language things of that nature. So that made making sure that they're all identical, by example when peer Dolphin cruises started I believe they were under a commercial. A standard commercial agreement before they transferred to a license agreement. So again. Not particularly interesting. But the just sort of the factual process on how things work and how we intend streamline in a uniform way. >> Because we have the discovery center involved as well, you know that. Sort of makes it it makes it hard for a lot of folks to understand. Why why some things are different for Tampa Bay watch. When it comes to the vessel because it is tied to the discovery Center in a way. Not that that's wrong. It's just that sometimes it looks like some folks have to have different rules than others. Yeah, and that can that can create some banks in some in some cases. Well and again that the commercial rules and guidelines are uniform. And so that was part of the you know while while not technically necessary the objective of a for lack of a better term leveling the playing field. So the rules even the rent is the same. More or less for the 2 vessels that we're talking about today. There is a tie back to the discovery center out at the pier. There doesn't really need to be and with the. Being a commercial tenant and so in a that was very specific and you have to remember back in the day when when we talk about all this was was that prayer very complicated because we hadn't even finish the design of the pier. All right so right there are a lot of unknowns and so the language that allowed them a right to a boat slip was very generic and hopeful that we would if that project even done in a construction. You know that that we could financially afford to do. >> Right and and under the agreement as it is the

Agenda textCity Council

City Council — February 3, 2022

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
AgendaNot published in the sources we holdread text
Agenda packetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Action agendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
MinutesNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Transcript or captionsSource recordingread transcript
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Recording and media

Coverage and corrections

Not claimed by this page

  • Verified meeting decisions with item-specific public-source evidence
  • Item-level plain-language summaries are not available; this page does not infer individual agenda items.
  • Item-linked, attributed deliberation
  • A source-grounded next meeting date
  • A plain-English overview is not available.
  • Official outcomes have not been published.
  • The available transcript has no reliable timestamps.
  • Transcript coverage is partial.
  • Speakers have not been reliably matched to public profiles.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.
  • An individual roll-call roster is not available.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: 4d071bc4ae28b8ad8867df7619b73f85. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record