POLISCOPE

The public record

WILTONMANORS (BROWARD COUNTY) · LOCALDecisions publishedPartial coverage

Regular City Commission Meeting (2024-10-08)

Tuesday, October 8, 2024 · Government meeting record

The 30-second read

Recorded outcome

Regular City Commission Meeting (2024-10-08)

Why it matters

The official meeting record is available below. Item-level plain-language summaries are not available yet.

What happens next

No later meeting or follow-up date is stated in the reviewed record.

An official outcome record - an action agenda or minutes - is published for this meeting.

Record text

No transcript is held for this meeting. Recording: Media

1 MINUTES REGULAR CITY COMMISSION MEETING Tuesday, October 8, 2024 7:00 PM – COMMISSION CHAMBERS CALL TO ORDER Mayor Scott Newton called the meeting to order at 7:00 p.m. Pledge of Allegiance Vice Mayor Mike Bracchi led the Pledge of Allegiance. ROLL CALL Assistant City Clerk Patricia Staples called the roll. Present were Mayor Scott Newton, Vice Mayor Mike Bracchi, Commissioner Chris Caputo, Commissioner Don D’Arminio, and Commissioner Paul Rolli. Also in attendance were City Manager Leigh Ann Henderson and City Attorney Kerry Ezrol. ADDITIONS / CHANGES / DELETIONS Commissioner Caputo requested that an update be provided on the Emergency Management/Utilities study, but that a similar Leisure Services study be tabled until Leisure Services Director Michelle Parks is present. Commissioner Rolli requested that both studies be tabled until the next meeting. PROCLAMATIONS LGBTQ+ History Month / The Pride Center at Equality Park Mayor Newton read a Proclamation recognizing October 2024 as LGBTQ+ History Month in Wilton Manors. He also designated Tuesday, October 8, 2024 as The Pride Center at Equality Park Day, recognizing the facility’s longstanding support of and service to the LGBTQ+ community. Robert Boo, Chief Executive Officer (CEO) of The Pride Center, accepted the Proclamation. PRESENTATION

2 Presentation of Life-Saving Awards to Officers Caleb Fonte Bernstein and Daniel Plunske Wilton Manors Police Chief Gary Blocker recognized Officers Caleb Fonte Bernstein and Daniel Plunske, who showed exceptional bravery and dedication in their response to an incident that occurred on Saturday, August 17, 2024. They responded to a report of a shooting in the city of Fort Lauderdale and identified crucial information which helped locate and treat a victim until Fire/Rescue services arrived. Chief Blocker presented the Lifesaving Awards. REPORT FROM POLICE DEPARTMENT Chief Blocker recalled that over the past two weeks, the City has experienced an increase in overnight vehicle burglaries and auto thefts. These incidents have primarily occurred in residential neighborhoods west of 6 Avenue, northeast of 6 Avenue, and west of Wilton Drive, in the Central and Westside communities. The method used by most of the criminals has been to walk certain blocks in those neighborhoods in the early morning to search for prospective vehicles. Most vehicles have been accessed by either unlocked doors or smashed windows. The Wilton Manors Police Department believes the primary motive of the thefts has been to locate key fobs left in vehicles so the vehicles can be stolen. Three of the seven auto thefts occurred using fobs left in vehicles. Detectives are actively investigating the cases, and crime analysts are working to connect these cases with others in Broward County. Two suspects have been identified in three cases and overnight patrols have been enhanced in the targeted areas. Upcoming community outreach is planned to help educate residents about this crime trend as well as how to minimize the likelihood of becoming a victim. Social media and public service announcements will be increased as well. Chief Blocker advised that due to the impending landfall of Hurricane Milton, the Police Department will double its overnight staffing beginning Wednesday, October 9, 2024 through the next day and evening. Chief Blocker requested that all present communicate these messages to other residents and increase awareness. He reminded residents to lock their vehicles at 9 p.m., remove key fobs from them and store the fobs inside their home, and never store firearms inside a vehicle. He also encouraged residents to immediately report suspicious activity either through 911 or the non- emergency number of (954)764-4357. Mayor Newton requested that Emergency Management/Utilities Director David Archacki provide an update on the hurricane and its effects. Director Archacki noted that Wilton Manors lies on the edges of Hurricane Milton and can expect 2 in. to 4 in. of rain as well as 20 to 25 mile per hour (MPH) winds through Thursday, October 10, 2024, with gusts expected up to 50 MPH. Over 6 in. of rain is anticipated throughout the coming weekend. EM/U Director Archacki advised that the City’s sewer system is at peak capacity and overflowing. He further advised that it is currently difficult to pump wastewater into the George T. Lohmeyer

3 Regional Wastewater Treatment Plant, Fort Lauderdale has sent the City six pump trucks, and the City has hired two vacuum trucks. He estimated that the City is averaging transmission of 2500 gallons per minute. The trucks will continue to pump and haul sewage to Fort Lauderdale until the City has caught up with demand and pump stations are cycling on a regular basis once more. Once this work is complete, the City will send a sanitation crew to clean drains and other areas where spills occurred. EM/U Director Archacki noted that Broward County Schools will be closed on Wednesday, October 9, 2024, and many residents are expected to be home from work as well. The County has sent an email informing the public that County operations will close at noon on Wednesday and remain closed through Thursday. Emergency Management/Utilities staff will be at work on Wednesday and will remain until the City has resumed its regular cycle of moving sewage. Commissioner D’Arminio commented that one spill occurred at 5 Avenue, and there may be a more permanent fix pending for this spill. Director Archacki replied that the City plans to install a new force main at this corner. One of the City’s civil engineers has begun the design and soil testing required prior to the installation of the new force main, which will have a larger diameter. He did not have an estimated time frame for the work, but noted that the project was approved at a previous City Commission meeting. EM/U Director Archacki also addressed the new force main at Station 11, which will help shorten the route of wastewater by four miles. The pipe has been placed beneath the canal, and staff is making open trench cuts to tie into the canal near Fort Lauderdale. Pressure testing will follow before the final connection is made to the old force main. The project is expected to be complete by December 13, 2024. Mayor Newton asked if 16 Avenue will be closed through the completion date. Director Archacki replied that restoration of the roadway will begin once all pipe is installed, which may be by the beginning of November. COMMENTS FROM THE PUBLIC At this time Mayor Newton opened public comment. Adrienne Foland, 440 NE 23 Street, suggested that Ring cameras in the vicinity of the auto break- ins and thefts could be useful to the Police Department. Jake Valentine, 1109 NW 30 Court, stated that the next election is very important for many reasons, noting that the state of Florida has made it more difficult for all citizens to vote. He noted that he has asked the City to consider providing free Circuit service on Election Day so residents can come to City Hall. The Mayor had indicated that he would look into this possibility. Mr. Valentine concluded that he would offer $1000 toward providing free Circuit service on November 5, 2024, and all forthcoming election days. With no other individuals wishing to speak at this time, Mayor Newton closed public comment.

4 CONSENT AGENDA Commissioner D’Arminio pulled Consent Resolution 2024-124 for discussion. Commissioner Caputo made a motion to approve the rest of the Consent Agenda. Commissioner Rolli seconded the motion, which prevailed by unanimous roll call vote (5-0). Approval of Minutes Minutes from the following meetings: • August 27, 2024 Regular City Commission Meeting • August 28, 2024 Commission Budget Workshop #3 • September 10, 2024 Regular City Commission Meeting Invoices Goren, Cherof, Doody & Ezrol, P.A. Items Pulled from the Consent Agenda Resolution No. 2024-124: (Leisure Services) A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF WILTON MANORS, FLORIDA, APPROVING AND AUTHORIZING THE PROPER CITY OFFICIALS OF THE CITY OF WILTON MANORS TO EXECUTE AN AGREEMENT WITH ELASTEC, INC. FOR THE PURCHASE OF A WORK BOAT AND TRAILER; PROVIDING FOR CONFLICTS; PROVIDING FOR SEVERABILITY; AND PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE. Commissioner D’Arminio made a motion to approve Resolution 2024-124. Commissioner Caputo seconded the motion. Commissioner D’Arminio noted that this Resolution approves the purchase of a boat for $88,000, and pointed out that the Resolution’s language indicates a 50% grant was previously awarded and accepted in an amount not to exceed $75,000. Later on, the Resolution also refers to the expectation of $44,000 in grant reimbursement. He requested clarification of these figures. City Manager Leigh Ann Henderson stated that a grant from the Florida Inland Navigation District (FIND) will fund 50% of the purchase. The maximum amount that FIND will reimburse the City is $75,000, which means the maximum purchase price for the boat could have been up to $150,000. Commissioner D’Arminio also addressed a recent study done on the Leisure Services Department, pointing out that the study lists maintenance responsibilities which could be shifted to a third-party contractor. These responsibilities include waterway maintenance. He asked if this was considered before the Resolution was created. City Manager Henderson replied that staff has explored the options of contractors as well as partnerships with other municipalities that own waterway cleanup vehicles; however, the City feels the purchase of a boat would still be necessary, as it would be needed for other uses in addition to maintenance.

5 The motion prevailed by unanimous roll call vote (5-0). End of Consent Agenda PUBLIC HEARINGS Ordinance No. 2024-007: (Police) (Community Development Services)(Second Reading) AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF WILTON MANORS, FLORIDA, AMENDING SECTION 21-3 “GENERAL PROHIBITIONS”; PROVIDING FOR CODIFICATION; PROVIDING FOR SEVERABILITY; PROVIDING FOR CONFLICTS; AND PROVIDING FOR AN EFFECTIVE DATE. Assistant City Clerk Staples read the Ordinance by title only. Vice Mayor Bracchi made a motion to approve Ordinance 2024-007. Commissioner Caputo seconded the motion. Community Development Services Director Roberta Moore reviewed the changes made between first and second readings of the Ordinance, which were made at the Commission’s request. These changes include: • Require a sworn affidavit of complaint from a minimum of one unrelated person residing in a separate residence, alleging the violation. • Require a time-stamped video showing evidence of the violation. CDS Director Moore continued that staff would also like to discuss the following items: • Staff requests to add the requirement of one time-stamped audio and video as evidence rather than the video alone. • Staff requests a discussion with the Commission of the potential creation of separate regulations for the hours between 10 p.m. and 6:59 a.m. and between 7 a.m. and 9:59 p.m.; draft language for this change is included in the Commissioners’ backup materials. CDS Director Moore added that she and Police Chief Blocker also spoke with representatives of the City’s Realtors Association between first and second readings of the proposed Ordinance. The proposed changes are based on those conversations. Commissioner Caputo observed that some of the Ordinance’s language is confusing, including the definition of the terms “persistent” and “continuously,” with clarification for individual interruptions. He recommended that this language be improved. At this time Mayor Newton opened the public hearing. Jake Valentine, 1109 NW 30 Court, requested that additional sounds, such as squawking or clucking, be added to the Ordinance to address noises made by pet birds. With no other individuals wishing to speak at this time, Mayor Newton closed public comment.

6 Mayor Newton asked if the term “animal noises” would include the sounds cited by Mr. Valentine. Chief Blocker confirmed that these sounds would be included, or can be added by the phrase “or otherwise vocalizes” if that is the Commission’s desire. Chief Blocker continued that there is another way to address the concern raised by Commissioner Caputo, clarifying that “the term persistently or continuously shall mean nonstop vocalizations for 20 consecutive minutes without interruptions of more than 20 seconds during the 20-minute time period.” Commissioner Caputo felt this was more consistent with the intent of the proposed Ordinance. Commissioner Caputo also addressed a line which mentioned the requirements of an affidavit and a time-stamped video, asking if these two items may come from the same individual. He also asked if the video would require a minimum duration of 20 minutes, and why both audio and video would be needed, pointing out that there is no way to verify the location of an audio. It was clarified that the intent of the proposed change was to provide video evidence with audio. Chief Blocker also clarified that the same individual may provide both the affidavit and the video. Vice Mayor Bracchi recalled that at the last public hearing on this Ordinance, Commissioners Caputo and D’Arminio had indicated their pets might regularly violate the current Ordinance. The updated Ordinance will make the filing of complaints related to dog noise more difficult. He cautioned that there may be an ethical conflict of interest due to the admitted violations, and recommended that both Commissioners consider recusing themselves from voting on the Item. Commissioner Caputo observed that the size of the class of dog owners in the City is substantial, and that neither he nor Commissioner D’Arminio constituted a sufficiently sizable presence within this class to represent a conflict. City Attorney Kerry Ezrol stated that while he can offer guidance on this issue, he is not responsible for the enforcement of Commission on Ethics requirements. He acknowledged, however, that there are existing Attorney General opinions which mention the number of others potentially affected by a law. In the case of a City-wide Ordinance, the affected class is likely to be very large. He concluded that this would be up to the individual Commissioners to decide. Vice Mayor Bracchi advised that he felt the proposed Ordinance was bad policy, and the City Commission should not regulate anomalies. He also expressed concern with how the Ordinance would be enforced, and pointed out that it could nullify any future attempts to file complaints related to dog noise. Vice Mayor Bracchi asked how much time is currently spent on the enforcement of dog-related complaints under the current Code, noting that the proposed Ordinance would change the duration of the complaint from five minutes to 20 minutes, with the clock re-starting after any break longer than 20 seconds. It was clarified that Code Compliance felt they would realistically be able to cite owners for these violations, although significant staff time may be required for the review of videos and affidavits and generation of notices of violation. The most recent such complaint took

7 approximately four to five investigative hours, based on a five-minute audio or video. Vice Mayor Bracchi addressed the 20-second gap, pointing out that this could make it more difficult to cite a dog owner. He also asked if a violation that goes before the Special Magistrate would require that Special Magistrate to listen to the entirety of video/audio evidence. Code Compliance Supervisor Abel Alberro recalled that in the most recent case, a timeline was provided for the Special Magistrate by Code Compliance, as was a portion of the video. The Special Magistrate did not listen to the entire video. Vice Mayor Bracchi noted that Special Magistrate hearings can already be lengthy processes, which would only be lengthened by the addition of cases such as these. He again cautioned that this would add a greater level of bureaucracy to the process. Vice Mayor Bracchi asked how many citations have been issued over the past two years, as well as the number of dog noise cases that have gone before the Special Magistrate within that time frame. It was clarified that six such cases were brought in 2022, with 12 in 2023. Thus far in 2024, there have been five cases. There was no knowledge of whether or not the cases involved repeat households. Five cases have gone before the Special Magistrate since 2022 and violations were affirmed. Vice Mayor Bracchi asserted that the Special Magistrate is the trier of fact in these cases and should be able to determine whether or not the Ordinance was violated without the City Commission making additional requirements. He also noted that it can be burdensome to residents to provide the additional information the proposed Ordinance would require, and felt it may increase litigation, as some residents may feel a lawsuit is their only recourse because the City did not give them other opportunities for action. Commissioner D’Arminio commented that while he did not personally perceive a dog barking for five minutes as a disturbance, he understood the use of that term in the case of a dog barking for 20 minutes. He added that he had not agreed with the previous Code and felt the proposed Ordinance is more consistent with where the Code should be. He did not feel he needed to recuse himself from voting upon the Item. Mayor Newton observed that a resident in conflict with a neighbor could encourage their dog to bark and stop them before the 20-minute time frame is reached. He asked if there is any language that could be added to address deliberate actions of this nature. City Attorney Ezrol replied that it would be difficult to prove intent before the Special Magistrate; in addition, cases before the Special Magistrate only require proof that a violation exists. Mayor Newton continued that while he felt five minutes were too short to constitute a disturbance, he also considered 20 minutes to be too long. He asked if the Ordinance could distinguish between a dog barking while playing with its owner and a dog barking continuously for another reason while the owner is not present. Vice Mayor Bracchi pointed out that it is not possible for an individual to take video on another resident’s property without a violation of privacy, but did not know how else it would be possible

8 to prove what activity is happening, such as an owner playing with a dog. He added that five minutes may be a long time for some residents to have to listen to dog noise. Commissioner Caputo stated that the 20-minute time frame is reasonable, and suggested that more flexibility be required in relation to the 20-second pause, such as a 30- or 45-second pause in barking. He felt the proposed Ordinance can streamline how these cases are addressed and reduce staff time spent on them, and added that he felt the update can lessen the possibility of harassment or inappropriate litigation by neighbors. Vice Mayor Bracchi also observed that most of the Commissioners are dog owners and may have a distinctly different view of noise from non-dog owners. It was clarified that the current Code refers to four vocalizations per minute. Vice Mayor Bracchi asked if Code Compliance finds it easier to deal with an average number of vocalizations or with certain breaks of time, reiterating that he did not want to create the need for more staff time. Supervisor Alberro replied that while the existing Ordinance made it simpler to identify the violation, the cases would still take staff time in any case. Vice Mayor Bracchi commented that he would find it easier to support the Ordinance with an average number of vocalizations. Commissioner Caputo stated, however, that he would support the Ordinance as presented with an increased number of seconds between vocalizations. Vice Mayor Bracchi added that he would be willing to support that change if there is a decrease in the total number of minutes, as he felt 20 minutes is too long. Commissioner Rolli proposed a change to 15 minutes of noise. Vice Mayor Bracchi suggested decreasing the time to 10 minutes. Mayor Newton advised that he would be supportive of 15 minutes of ongoing noise with 45-second breaks. Commissioner D’Arminio stated he would like the time to remain at 20 minutes. Vice Mayor Bracchi again expressed concern with the amount of staff time that would be dedicated to animal noise cases. Commissioner Caputo asserted that while he did not feel changing the amount of time from 15 to 20 minutes would result in significantly more or less staff time, he did believe it would avoid having staff determine whether or not an individual making a complaint is or is not telling the truth, as the burden of proof would be on the person reporting the incident and supplying the video. Commissioner Rolli indicated that he would support a change to require 15 minutes of noise. Vice Mayor Bracchi amended his earlier motion as follows: motion to approve with a change to 15 minutes of noise with 45-second breaks, including the revised definition read into the record by Chief Blocker. Chief Blocker asked if the Commission wished the Ordinance to apply on a 24-hour basis or to include separate regulations for overnight hours. Vice Mayor Bracchi suggested retaining the existing Ordinance during overnight hours, which would limit noise to no more than five minutes. There was consensus to apply the existing Ordinance, which includes five minutes of noise and an

9 average of four vocalizations, between 10 p.m. and 6:59 a.m. and apply the updated Ordinance from 7 a.m. to 9:59 p.m. The motion prevailed by a 4-1 roll call vote (Vice Mayor Bracchi dissenting). Ordinance No. 2024-010: (Community Development Services) (First Reading) AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF WILTON MANORS, FLORIDA, AMENDING THE UNIFIED LAND DEVELOPMENT REGULATIONS (“ULDR”) BY AMENDING ARTICLE 30 “URBAN CENTER MIXED-USE DISTRICTS” BY AMENDING SECTIONS 030-032 “RESIDENTIAL USES”, AND 030-040 “STANDARDS FOR LOTS AND URBAN FORM”, AMENDING THE LISTS OF GENERALIZED PERMITTED USES PROVIDING FOR CODIFICATION; PROVIDING FOR SEVERABILITY; PROVIDING FOR CONFLICTS; AND PROVIDING FOR AN EFFECTIVE DATE. Assistant City Clerk Staples read the Ordinance by title only. Commissioner Caputo made a motion to approve Ordinance 2024-010. Commissioner D’Arminio seconded the motion. CDS Director Moore provided an overview of the proposed changes, recalling that at the July 23, 2024 City Commission meeting, the Commission discussed the generalized permitted use table, as well as the percentage of office space on each major corridor. Staff compiled these changes, which are presented to the Commission tonight. The changes include the following: • Wilton Drive: change percentage of office space from 20% to 25% • Dixie Highway: change percentage of office space from 20% to 25% • Andrews Avenue: change percentage of office space from 20% to 25% CDS Director Moore addressed the table of generalized permitted uses, noting that changes to this table include: • Add permission for free-standing multi-family development to front secondary and all other streets CDS Director Moore further clarified that she would like to amend language addressing all zoning districts within the City’s Urban Center to allow free-standing multi-family frontage, as well as townhome frontage. Where the updated language refers to “free-standing multi-family fronting secondary streets and all other streets,” she recommended addition of “for properties without primary frontage” for both townhomes and multi-family developments. She listed the pages on which these amendments would need to be made. At this time Mayor Newton opened the public hearing, which he closed upon receiving no input. Commissioner D’Arminio recalled that it was the Commission’s intention to require primary streets to include mixed-use development, while secondary streets would allow residential

10 development. Director Moore confirmed that this was intended for purposes of clarification. Commissioner D’Arminio also noted that throughout Article 30, there are references to 45 ft. setbacks when abutting single-family use. He asserted that he did not believe proximity to single- family use should be a consideration, and recalled that a previous Article changed the use requirement to a zoning requirement. Commissioner D’Arminio cited the example of the pending hotel on a transit-oriented corridor (TOC) which abuts a single-family use. He cautioned that proximity should address zoning rather than use. Commissioner Caputo requested additional clarification. CDS Director Moore explained that under the Urban Center Mixed-Use District, there was a lengthy discussion of whether or not setbacks would be based on single-family use or single-family zoning. The application of use rather than zoning allowed protections to be applied for the character of single-family homes. Commissioner Caputo asked what other cities do in similar cases. CDS Director Moore replied that there is some fluctuation, depending upon the intention of the elected officials. In the case of the single-family home abutting the hotel, there were discussions which ultimately resulted in the hotel obtaining a variance; however, this was an exception, as the site was rezoned to PUD. Commissioner Caputo concluded that he was more supportive of the Arts and Entertainment District operating as such than of more single-family homes, and he would support the proposed change. Commissioner Rolli stated that the Commission spent a great deal of time drafting legislation intended to protect single-family homes and neighborhoods. With regard to use and zoning, he was not in favor of infringing upon the rights of property owners, and would not agree to base changes on zoning rather than use. He felt the existing language addressing permitted use should remain. Vice Mayor Bracchi pointed out that it is generally more difficult to change zoning than permitted use. CDS Director Moore advised that Commissioner D’Arminio’s proposal would require a similar process to change the permitted use table, as both would require public hearings before the Planning and Zoning Board as well as the City Commission. Commissioner D’Arminio explained that his suggestion addressed only the required setback. Code currently requires that developments abutting a single-family use require a 45 ft. setback. This would have limited some commercial businesses from using their outdoor space, making it more difficult to compete with other businesses which have this space. He pointed out that single-family use does not serve to accommodate the vision for the City, and suggested that the 45 ft. setback not be required if the subject parcel is not zoned to require it. If the parcel is zoned single-family, he would be supportive of following that zoning. Commissioner D’Arminio continued that recent discussion of this issue had resulted in the repeal of Article 35, which had encouraged additional density in the City’s single-family neighborhoods. He had requested this repeal with the intent of protecting single-family neighborhoods. In the

11 current case, however, he noted that the discussion now focuses on TOCs, which need more development. CDS Director Moore clarified that in the case of a business abutting a single-family residential use, it was that use of the property rather than zoning which was taken into consideration. Under existing TOC Code, single-family uses are considered with respect to setbacks. The business owner had requested a variance from the Planning and Zoning Board to relieve them of the requirement to provide a 45 ft. setback. Commissioner D’Arminio stated that requesting a variance requires a hardship, which he felt was an issue in Code that can prevent TOCs from being developed. CDS Director Moore referred to the proposed Ordinance, pointing out that rear setbacks are required to be 15 ft. or 45 ft. when abutting a single-family use. If the parcel was zoned for single- family development, that would be 15 ft. as opposed to 45 ft. She explained that there have been several conversations regarding whether or not the City wants the reduced setback or the greater setback. If the decision is based on zoning, the setback would be 15 ft., while if it continues to be based on use, the greater setback would continue to be required. Mayor Newton asked how many instances of businesses abutting single-family homes exist in the City. CDS Director Moore replied that she did not have this information on hand, as it is not part of the Ordinance proposed at tonight’s meeting. She was not certain that this issue would not need to be advertised separately from tonight’s Item. City Attorney Ezrol observed that the Commission may wish to table the first reading of the proposed Ordinance and re-advertise it for two full public hearings, depending upon the magnitude of the changes to be made. Mayor Newton reiterated that he did not have issue with requiring a 45 ft. setback when abutting a single-family residence with a use of single-family residence. He pointed out that property owners still have the option of the variance process if they wish to seek an exception. Commissioner Caputo asserted that the issue to him is the need to prove a hardship. Commissioner D’Arminio continued that the issue is a flaw in the Code with respect to the future vision for the City. Commissioner Rolli recalled that the Commission had extensive discussions regarding setbacks and abutments to single-family homes and ultimately determined current Code, which he was not in favor of changing. Commissioner Caputo advised that there should be a distinction for the small number of single- family homes abutting existing businesses, which may hinder development within very limited scenarios. Commissioner D’Arminio agreed that there should be no change to the required setbacks within single-family neighborhoods, clarifying that he was addressing anomalies with single-family use. City Attorney Ezrol noted that some changes can be made to the proposed Ordinance, as there will be another public hearing upon its second reading. Because the proposed change from a 15 ft. to a 45 ft. setback is substantial, however, he recommended advertising that issue for an additional public hearing.

12 Commissioner Caputo asked if the Item would have to be re-advertised if the data collected does not support a change. There was consensus to move forward on this basis. Director Moore estimated that she may be able to collect the necessary data before second reading, depending upon the date of that reading. It was also noted that the City may defer second reading if necessary. Vice Mayor Bracchi asked if it would be possible to bring back this issue as a discussion item between first and second reading of the Ordinance, with no vote to be taken. City Attorney Ezrol stated that the Commission may approve the Item today and defer second reading, discuss the Item further, and then determine how to proceed. If the Commission decides to make changes, the Item would be re-advertised for first reading. Vice Mayor Bracchi requested clarification of the reason the percentages of office space and ancillary uses were changed from 20% to 25%. Director Moore recalled that this was based on Commission direction. Vice Mayor Bracchi asked if the Commission felt this change was appropriate for locations such as Wilton Drive, Andrews Avenue, and Dixie Highway. He pointed out that “ancillary space” may include structures such as a gym or clubhouse directly on the street, which would not activate the pedestrian space as intended. The Commissioners discussed examples of ancillary uses and activation currently existing, as well as what the proposed changes are intended to create. Vice Mayor Bracchi recommended that on Andrews Avenue, Dixie Highway, and Wilton Drive, the first floor should be 100% street- activated; any ancillary or office uses could be placed on the second floor or facing a side street. Commissioner D’Arminio noted that part of the intent of permitting ancillary use was to provide the option of office space frontage. Vice Mayor Bracchi felt this might be appropriate on Andrews Avenue, but emphasized that Wilton Drive is activated at night, and office uses fronting onto that roadway would not be. Vice Mayor Bracchi asserted that he would like to see primary streets 100% activated, excluding ancillary uses. Commissioner D’Arminio recalled that when Code was originally passed, the requirement was for 25% commercial activation in order to provide developers with the leeway to use some of this space for offices. Commissioner Caputo advised that there may be unforeseen conditions in which 90% activation is required. Vice Mayor Bracchi suggested allowing 20% for office use and 0% for ancillary uses on the primary frontages of all three TOCs, which would prevent a building from placing a gym or clubhouse on the first floor of a structure on one of the key corridors. It was also clarified that a developer may ask for a variance, but would not be entitled to additional height. They would also have the option of requesting rezoning to PUD. Commissioner Caputo amended his motion as follows: motion to allow 20% for office use and 0% for ancillary use, with the additional changes proposed by Director Moore. The amended motion prevailed by unanimous roll call vote (5-0).

13 UNFINISHED BUSINESS Update on the Leisure Services and Emergency Management / Utilities Departmental Studies (requested by Commissioner Caputo) This Item was tabled to a later meeting. REPORTS FROM BOARDS AND ADMINISTRATIVE OFFICIALS City Manager’s Report City Manager Henderson advised that staff has received an update on its preparations for Hurricane Milton. The City will host early voting and provide vote-by-mail drop-offs at the Island City Cultural Center during the two-week early voting period. This will be one of 20 such locations in Broward County and will run from October 21 through November 3, 2024, from 7 a.m. until 7 p.m. Mayor Newton requested feedback from the Commissioners regarding the proposal to provide Circuit service free of charge to residents going to the polls. There was consensus to support the proposal by the residents to fund a portion of this service as opposed to having City staff take on this effort. City Manager Henderson advised that staff has previously worked with Circuit to extend their hours of service on Election Day. The service will begin at 7 a.m. on Election Day and the City will provide at least 300 ride vouchers for Uber and Lyft to assist residents in reaching the polls. City Attorney’s Report None. NEW BUSINESS Review certain Code Compliance Cases for potential foreclosure (requested by Commissioner Caputo) Commissioner Caputo advised that the Commissioners received a document prepared by Code Compliance staff which includes examples of properties with egregious Code violations that affect the quality of life experienced by their neighbors. Some properties have not been fully brought into compliance, while other violations recur. These properties are also located on prime corridors in which the Commission wishes to promote redevelopment, and their current liens are still accruing, some of which approach $500,000. Commissioner Caputo stated that the City should take action on these properties, which may mean establishing a policy for foreclosure. He emphasized the importance of meeting a standard, as well as considering the length of time over which the violation has occurred. He also clarified that his

14 intent was not to address homesteaded residential properties in this manner, but to take action against long-term Code violators. Mayor Newton asked the City Attorney if there must be a certain number of days before the City could pursue foreclosure. City Attorney Ezrol replied that Florida Statutes require at least 90 days after the entry of an order certifying the lien. He recalled that in prior cases, the City Attorney’s Office has worked with the City administration to review Code files and conduct title searches. In some cases, there is no equity in the property due to significant mortgages, which would make foreclosure less useful. Commissioner Caputo noted that the Commission could still take action to foreclose on the property and force the owner to sell it, potentially to a new developer. City Attorney Ezrol stated that if the City receives a judgment that is not satisfied, the property could be sold. There have been instances in which the City took ownership of the property, which they could do subject to the existing mortgage. Commissioner Rolli advised that the properties which are inhibiting the City’s economic development should be categorized separately from other properties accruing liens. He cited properties within the TOCs as an example, continuing that the Commission would need to assess whether or not foreclosure is the appropriate action. He recommended prioritizing TOC properties before moving on to the next group of non-homesteaded properties. Vice Mayor Bracchi asked if it would be permissible to categorize properties based on their location. City Attorney Ezrol confirmed that this could be done. Commissioner Caputo recommended that City staff be allowed to draft these criteria, as they are aware of the properties with owners who have been willing to make an effort or work with the City. Commissioner D’Arminio commented that the 10 largest items on the list make up over 30% of the balance, and recommended addressing those properties first. He also proposed having staff review the list based in part on whether or not the properties are in compliance, which is not noted on all listed properties. Commissioner D’Arminio continued that he did not see an incentive for property owners to pay the liens, pointing out that they are no longer being penalized if they have already come into compliance. He also clarified that the City may not foreclose on a homesteaded residence, and suggested developing a policy that could offer some level of amnesty to residents living on homesteaded properties. Vice Mayor Bracchi also advised that he did not oppose amnesty of this nature. He asked if the City may place a lien on a homesteaded property which would have to be paid off when the property is eventually sold. City Attorney Ezrol explained that the City records liens against all properties; however, under Florida Statute 162, the lien does not attach to homesteaded properties. Commissioner D’Arminio asked why no interest is charged on liens. City Attorney Ezrol replied that Florida Statutes only authorize interest when a judgment has been obtained. If no suit is filed, interest cannot be authorized. He pointed out, however, that if the Commission wishes to test

15 whether or not the City has sufficient authority to charge interest, they may adopt an Ordinance which says interest will be charged and provides a legal basis for that charge. The Ordinance would then be subject to challenge in court. Commissioner D’Arminio asked if the City has undertaken any collection efforts in the past. City Manager Henderson replied that the City has made some foreclosures, but does not involve collection agencies. Reminders are not sent to property owners, although the required notice of lien is sent. Commissioner D’Arminio reiterated that the City should develop procedures to encourage property owners to pay their liens. Commissioner Caputo advised that other cities use external services to try to collect, but have not had significant success with these efforts. He was in favor of enacting an Ordinance that charges interest, which could encourage property owners to pay before their liens accrue more significantly. There was Commission consensus to have City staff divide the list into homesteaded and non- homesteaded properties, determining priority. He was also in favor of charging interest, although he did not feel it should be the City’s top priority. This would help determine which properties should be foreclosed upon and which should be set aside for potential amnesty. City Manager requested clarification of how the properties with liens should be prioritized. Commissioner Caputo spoke in favor of bringing the list back with recommendations from Code Compliance. Commissioner D’Arminio stated again that he felt the Commission should look at the top 10 properties first, as they constitute 30% of the balance. City Manager Henderson confirmed that these would be reviewed accordingly. Request from Peter Weintraub, Esq. asking the City Commission to vacate Code liens associated with 2800 N.E. 10 Avenue. Mr. Weintraub represents the property owner, Realty Wholesalers, Inc. Commissioner Rolli noted that there are three separate Code cases related to the property at 2800 NE 10 Avenue, two of which he indicated are clear as to what had happened. He requested clarification on the third case. Code Compliance Supervisor Alberro explained that the third case for the subject property was opened on June 28, 2023. The property was sold on August 22, 2023, but had not yet been recognized under the new owner’s name according to the Broward County Property Appraiser’s Office, which requires that notice be sent to the owner listed there. In September 2023, the property was found to be in violation, and the final order was sent to the owner whose name was listed on the Property Appraiser’s website; however, Code Compliance was already in communication with the new owner, Realty Wholesalers, Inc. The new owner began addressing the violation as soon as this communication began. Supervisor Alberro advised that only one Code issue, which was related to a pool on the property, took significant time to come into compliance. This issue came into compliance in December 2023

16 after being noncompliant for 78 days. The property was also cited for work without permits, which was resolved before the target date. Supervisor Alberro confirmed that the new owner was cooperative regarding the Code cases. Commissioner Rolli observed that there were significant fines associated with the first two cases, totaling over $400,000. Fines for the third case came to $19,500, totaling $20,440 with the addition of administrative fees and staff costs. Vice Mayor Bracchi asked for additional information on the cases. City Attorney Ezrol replied that the current owner would not be legally responsible for the fines if the City did not have three liens against the property. The owner has taken the position that the liens should not have attached to a property which was purchased at a foreclosure sale. City Attorney Ezrol continued that the first two liens can be easily disposed of, as they were clearly recorded after lis pendens. That Statute states that interest in property does not attach once lis pendens is recorded. The third lien, however, was recorded after the certificate of title was issued to the new owner. City Attorney Ezrol advised that under Florida law, in cases such as this one, property owners are entitled to due process. Statute 162 includes a provision which states that in the context of voluntary conveyance from one owner to another, there is an affirmative obligation to disclose the existence of Code liens. Failure to make this disclosure results in a presumption of fraud on the part of the owner against whom the violations were charged. He pointed out, however, that this case was not a voluntary conveyance, as it was a foreclosure sale. Statute 162 also includes a provision that in the case of a voluntary conveyance, the City would be required to give the new owner a reasonable opportunity to cure the violation before bringing them in front of the Special Magistrate to certify the lien against them, based upon the notice of violation charged to the former owner. City Attorney Ezrol concluded that the practical issue in this case is that three liens are attached to the subject property, which the City cannot enforce on a legal basis, because the new owner was unaware of the liens. Had the lien landed five days earlier, the City would have enjoined as a defendant in the lawsuit and their liens would have been foreclosed. No surplus funds were generated from the sale of the property, which means the City’s liens would have been eliminated from the property. Commissioner Caputo observed that there was no reason to believe the new owner was aware of the pending liens, as they had acted reasonably to address the issues once they took possession of the property. Commissioner Caputo made a motion to remove the liens. Vice Mayor Bracchi seconded the motion. It was also noted that the subject property is currently for sale.

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
AgendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Agenda packetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Action agendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Transcript or captionsNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Recording and media

Coverage and corrections

Records considered

  • Regular City Commission Meeting (2024-10-08)

Not claimed by this page

  • Verified meeting decisions with item-specific public-source evidence
  • Item-level plain-language summaries are not available; this page does not infer individual agenda items.
  • Item-linked, attributed deliberation
  • A source-grounded next meeting date
  • A plain-English overview is not available.
  • Official outcomes have not been published.
  • A transcript is not available.
  • Speakers have not been reliably matched to public profiles.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.
  • An individual roll-call roster is not available.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: 4cb29d7a16a6d6d8ae077bc90d009405. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record