POLISCOPE

The public record

LEE COUNTY SCHOOLS · LOCALDecisions publishedPartial coverage

School Board Quasi-Judicial Hearing Agenda 11:00 AM

Tuesday, November 4, 2025 · School board meeting record

The 30-second read

AI summary

What the board considered

The Lee County School Board held a quasi-judicial hearing to address the employment status of four district employees. The board voted to terminate one employee and suspend three others without pay pending further administrative hearings.

Why it matters

The board's decisions directly impact the employment status and compensation of four district staff members, effective November 4, 2025.

What happens next

No later meeting or follow-up date is stated in the reviewed record.

An official outcome record - an action agenda or minutes - is published for this meeting.

Recorded votes

5 recorded votes0 split

Split votes (0)

Every recorded vote passed unanimously.

A. Order of Business (1)

Voting yes on all of these (7)

Samuel Fisheryes
Melisa Giovannelliyes
William Ribbleyes
Debbie Jordanyes
Armor Personsyes
Jada Flemingyes
Vanessa Chavianoyes

Approval of the Agenda as the Order of Business.

Yes
7
No
0
Absent
0

B. Superintendent's Recommendation (4)

Voting yes on all of these (7)

Samuel Fisheryes
Melisa Giovannelliyes
William Ribbleyes
Debbie Jordanyes
Armor Personsyes
Jada Flemingyes
Vanessa Chavianoyes

1. Petition for Termination of Nuria Acuna

Yes
7
No
0
Absent
0

2. Petition for Termination of Jose Villafane

Yes
7
No
0
Absent
0

3. Petition for Termination of Mariah Roller

Yes
7
No
0
Absent
0

4. Petition for Termination of Brooke Wold

Yes
7
No
0
Absent
0

School district

People and votes

Armor Persons

School Board Member

Open person dossier

5 recorded votes

  1. Recorded voteItem A.2

    Approval of the Agenda as the Order of Business. - Voted yes; the record reports passed.

    Official record
  2. Recorded voteItem B.1

    1. Petition for Termination of Nuria Acuna - Voted yes on the motion “Approval of the suspension of Nuria Acuna without pay and benefits pending the outcome of the DOAH hearing, effective November 4, 2025.”; the record reports passed.

    Official record
  3. Recorded voteItem B.2

    2. Petition for Termination of Jose Villafane - Voted yes on the motion “Approval of the termination of Jose Villafane's employment with the School District of Lee County, effective November 4, 2025.”; the record reports passed.

    Official record
  4. Recorded voteItem B.3

    3. Petition for Termination of Mariah Roller - Voted yes on the motion “Approval of the suspension of Mariah Roller without pay and benefits pending the outcome of the DOAH hearing, effective November 4, 2025.”; the record reports passed.

    Official record
  5. Recorded voteItem B.4

    4. Petition for Termination of Brooke Wold - Voted yes on the motion “Approval of the suspension of Brooke Wold without pay and benefits pending the outcome of the DOAH hearing, effective November 4, 2025.”; the record reports passed.

    Official record
See all 5 roll calls with named votes

Record text

No recording or transcript is held for this meeting.

3 Tuesday, November 4, 2025 School Board Quasi-Judicial Hearing Agenda 11:00 AM Lee County Public Education Center 2855 Colonial Blvd. Fort Myers, Florida 33966-1012 (239) 334-1102 www.leeschools.net A. Order of Business Subject 1. Call to Order - Melisa W. Giovannelli, Presiding Board Member Meeting Nov 4, 2025 - School Board Quasi-Judicial Hearing Agenda 11:00 AM Category A. Order of Business Type Information, Procedural File Attachments Subject 2. Approval of the Agenda as the Order of Business. Meeting Nov 4, 2025 - School Board Quasi-Judicial Hearing Agenda 11:00 AM Category A. Order of Business Type Action, Procedural Recommended Action Approval of the Agenda as the Order of Business. File Attachments Motion & Voting Approval of the Agenda as the Order of Business. Motion by Debbie Jordan, second by Vanessa Chaviano. Final Resolution: Motion Carried Yea: Samuel Fisher, Melisa Giovannelli, William Ribble, Debbie Jordan, Armor Persons, Jada Fleming, Vanessa Chaviano B. Superintendent's Recommendation Subject 1. 1. Petition for Termination of Nuria Acuna Meeting Nov 4, 2025 - School Board Quasi-Judicial Hearing Agenda 11:00 AM Category B. Superintendent's Recommendation Type Action Fiscal Impact No Budgeted No Budget Source There is no fiscal impact to the District for this approval. Recommended Action Approval of the suspension of Nuria Acuna without pay and benefits pending the outcome of the DOAH hearing, effective November 4, 2025. Attached is the petition outlining the grounds for Nuria Acuna's termination of employment. The petition was served on September 15, 2025. There are 7 PDF attachments. [Contact Person: Kathy Dupuy-Bruno, Esq., B.C.S. School Board Attorney and General Counsel] File Attachments 2025.09.10 Petition for Termination.pdf (751 KB) 2025.09.16 Return of Service.pdf (12 KB) Rule 6A-5.056.pdf (122 KB) Board Policy 3210.pdf (140 KB) Board Policy 3210.pdf (140 KB) Board Policy 3139.pdf (93 KB) Acuna - Proposed Final Order.pdf (125 KB) Motion & Voting Approval of the suspension of Nuria Acuna without pay and benefits pending the outcome of the DOAH hearing, effective November 4, 2025. Motion by Armor Persons, second by William Ribble. Final Resolution: Motion Carried Yea: Samuel Fisher, Melisa Giovannelli, William Ribble, Debbie Jordan, Armor Persons, Jada Fleming, Vanessa Chaviano Subject 2. 2. Petition for Termination of Jose Villafane Meeting Nov 4, 2025 - School Board Quasi-Judicial Hearing Agenda 11:00 AM Category B. Superintendent's Recommendation Type Action Fiscal Impact No Budgeted No Budget Source There is no fiscal impact to the District for this approval. Recommended Action Approval of the termination of Jose Villafane's employment with the School District of Lee County, effective November 4, 2025. Attached is the petition outlining the grounds for Jose Villafane's termination of employment. After multiple attempts to personally serve Mr. Villafane, the petition was posted on his door and mailed to him via regular mail. There are 8 PDF attachments. [Contact Person: Kathy Dupuy-Bruno, Esq., B.C.S. School Board Attorney and General Counsel] File Attachments Rule 6A-5.056.pdf (122 KB) Board Policy 4210.pdf (128 KB) Board Policy 4120.pdf (126 KB) Board Policy 4210.01.pdf (139 KB) SPALC - Article 6 – Working Conditions.pdf (290 KB) 2025.09.29 Petition re Villafane.pdf (762 KB) 2025.10.09 Return of Service.pdf (264 KB) Villafane - Proposed Final Order.pdf (125 KB) Motion & Voting Approval of the termination of Jose Villafane's employment with the School District of Lee County, effective November 4, 2025. Motion by William Ribble, second by Vanessa Chaviano. Final Resolution: Motion Carried Yea: Samuel Fisher, Melisa Giovannelli, William Ribble, Debbie Jordan, Armor Persons, Jada Fleming, Vanessa Chaviano Subject 3. 3. Petition for Termination of Mariah Roller Meeting Nov 4, 2025 - School Board Quasi-Judicial Hearing Agenda 11:00 AM Category B. Superintendent's Recommendation Type Action Fiscal Impact No Budgeted No Budget Source There is no fiscal impact to the District for this approval. Recommended Action Approval of the suspension of Mariah Roller without pay and benefits pending the outcome of the DOAH hearing, effective November 4, 2025. Attached is the petition outlining the grounds for Mariah Roller's termination of employment. The petition was served on October 15, 2025. There are 12 PDF attachments. [Contact Person: Kathy Dupuy-Bruno, Esq., B.C.S. School Board Attorney and General Counsel] File Attachments 6A-10.081.pdf (130 KB) Rule 6A-5.056.pdf (122 KB) Board Policy 3139.pdf (93 KB) Board Policy 3210.01.pdf (139 KB) Board Policy 3210.pdf (140 KB) Board Policy 3231.pdf (97 KB) Board Policy 7544.pdf (171 KB) 2025.10.06 Petition re Roller.pdf (828 KB) 2025.10.12 Return of Service.pdf (9 KB) 2025.10.16 Return of Service.pdf (288 KB) 2025.10.23 Letter of Representation & Request for DOAH.pdf (78 KB) 2025.10.28 Proposed Final Order re Roller.pdf (125 KB) Motion & Voting Approval of the suspension of Mariah Roller without pay and benefits pending the outcome of the DOAH hearing, effective November 4, 2025. Motion by Samuel Fisher, second by Vanessa Chaviano. Final Resolution: Motion Carried Yea: Samuel Fisher, Melisa Giovannelli, William Ribble, Debbie Jordan, Armor Persons, Jada Fleming, Vanessa Chaviano Subject 4. 4. Petition for Termination of Brooke Wold Meeting Nov 4, 2025 - School Board Quasi-Judicial Hearing Agenda 11:00 AM Category B. Superintendent's Recommendation Type Action Fiscal Impact No Budgeted No Budget Source There is no fiscal impact to the District for this approval. Recommended Action Approval of the suspension of Brooke Wold without pay and benefits pending the outcome of the DOAH hearing, effective November 4, 2025. Attached is the petition outlining the grounds for Brooke Wold's termination of employment. The petition was served on October 14, 2025. There are 11 PDF attachments. [Contact Person: Kathy Dupuy-Bruno, Esq., B.C.S. School Board Attorney and General Counsel] File Attachments 2025.10.06 Petition re Wold.pdf (619 KB) 6A-10.081.pdf (130 KB) Rule 6A-5.056.pdf (122 KB) Board Policy 3139.pdf (93 KB) Board Policy 3210.01.pdf (139 KB) Board Policy 3210.pdf (140 KB) Board Policy 3231.pdf (97 KB) Board Policy 7544.pdf (171 KB) 2025.10.14 Return of Service.pdf (315 KB) 2025.10.20 Letter of Representation & Request for DOAH.pdf (80 KB) 2025.10.28 Proposed Final Order re Wold.pdf (126 KB) Motion & Voting Approval of the suspension of Brooke Wold without pay and benefits pending the outcome of the DOAH hearing, effective November 4, 2025. Motion by William Ribble, second by Jada Fleming. Final Resolution: Motion Carried Yea: Samuel Fisher, Melisa Giovannelli, William Ribble, Debbie Jordan, Armor Persons, Jada Fleming, Vanessa Chaviano C. Adjournment

Sources and limits

This meeting has been held, but no source-backed decision record is available yet. Agenda items remain proposals.

Not claimed by this page

  • No agenda facet is available for a complete inventory of planned business.
  • No packet or attachment facet is available for supporting materials.
  • Item-level plain-language summaries are not available; this page does not infer individual agenda items.

Canonical record: 4c06f78399d7b1fd69647583af9938bb. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record