POLISCOPE

The public record

DADECITY (PASCO COUNTY) · LOCALHeld · official record pendingPartial coverage

Planning Board - 04 Sep 2024

Wednesday, September 4, 2024 · Government meeting record

The 30-second read

Record incomplete

The Dade City Planning Board approved three residential fence variances and recommended approval for the Summit View 1 Phase 2A development project. The board also discussed concerns regarding long-standing development agreements and the oversight of dirt removal processes.

Why it matters

The board's decisions directly impact property owners' ability to install privacy fences and advance a major residential development project that has been subject to long-term settlement agreements.

What happens next

The scheduled meeting date has passed. Minutes or an action agenda are not published in the records we hold.

This meeting date has passed and no official outcome record has been published yet. Nothing on this page is a decision.

Record text

No recording or transcript is held for this meeting.

Planning Board - 04 Sep 2024. Location: City Hall - Commission Chambers. Time: 05:30 PM. Agenda: Planning Board - 04 Sep 2024 - Agenda - Html Planning Board Agenda City Hall - Commission Chambers Wednesday, September 4, 2024, 5:30 PM PROUD Heritage | PROMISING Future PLANNING BOARD Chair Jere Ferguson Vice Chair Jordon Frier Board Member Davis Henley Board Member Keeley Karatinos Board Member Lisa Simon Board Member Michael Stout Board Member Kim Barker School Board Member Chris Williams CITY OFFICIALS Evis Bushi, Interim Community and Economic Development Director Isaiah Hollinshead, Planner II Craig Hanson, Planner I Patrick Brackins, City Attorney Page A. MEETING PROCEDURES The Planning Board will be meeting in person. As an alternate option, the public may observe virtually. The virtual meeting will be in “watch/listen mode” only; no public comments will be taken virtually. To join the Zoom Meeting by computer or smart device https://us06web.zoom.us/j/81089794043?pwd=gT68GaBvSbbmzeR9qGMYczUiXfehM5.1 To join by phone, dial: 1 929 205 6099 Meeting ID: 810 8979 4043 Passcode: 179418 One Tap Mobile: +13052241968,,81249375653#,,,,*836702# Public Comment : If you are present in the Commission Chambers, you will be limited to three minutes to make your comments as is the usual rule of procedure for Planning Board meetings, except for matters heard in a quasi-judicial capacity. Public comments will not be taken virtually. B. CALL TO ORDER B.1. Pledge of Allegiance. B.2. Roll Call C. PUBLIC COMMENTS D. APPROVAL OF MINUTES D.1. 07 August 2024 - Planning Board Minutes Planning Board - 07 Aug 2024 - Minutes Draft 4 - 11 E. OLD BUSINESS F. NEW BUSINESS F.1. Dutton Variance - 6' Privacy Fence on a Corner Lot Dutton Variance Staff Report Attachment A - Dutton Variance Application 12 - 29 F.2. Ruiz Variance - 6' Privacy Fence on a Corner Lot Ruiz Variance Staff Report Attachment A - Ruiz Variance Application 30 - 52 F.3. Valez Variance - 6' Privacy Fence on a Corner Lot Valez Variance Staff Report Attachment A - Valez Variance Application 53 - 69 F.4. Summit View 1 Phase 2A - Preliminary Plan Summit View 1 Phase 2A August 7, 2024 Summary Memo Summit View 2A Preliminary Plat Agenda Memo Attachment A - Summit View 1 Phase 2A Signed and Sealed Preliminary Plat Attachment B - 2005-0905 Ordinance Rezoning-PUD Summit View Attachment C - Agreement 2018-13 - Summit View Settlement Agreement Attachment D - Ordinance 2020-23 Substantial Modification Attachment E - Summit View layout October 1, 2020 70 - 169 G. MEMBER COMMENTS H. ADJOURNMENT I. FOOTER TEXT NOTE: ONE OR MORE CITY COMMISSIONERS, PLANNING BOARD OR HISTORIC BOARD MEMBERS MAY BE PRESENT AT THIS MEETING AND MAY PARTICIPATE ADDRESSING THE BOARD: Any person desiring to address the Board shall secure the permission of the Presiding Officer to do so. MANNER OF ADDRESSING THE BOARD: TIME LIMIT: Each person addressing the Board shall step up to the podium, shall give their name and address in an audible tone of voice for the records, and unless further time is requested and granted by the Board shall limit the address to three minutes . All remarks shall be made to the Board as a body and not to any member thereof. No person other than the person having the floor and the Board shall be allowed to enter into any discussion either directly or through a Board Member without the permission of the Presiding Officer. No question shall be asked a Board Member except through the Presiding Officer. APPEALS: Any person desiring to appeal any decision made by the Planning Board with respect to any matter considered at any meeting or hearing will need a record of the proceedings and may need to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceedings is made which includes the testimony and evidence upon with the appeal is based. DISABILITY: If you are a person with a disability who needs any accommodation in order to participate in this proceeding, you are entitled at no cost to you to the provision of certain assistance within two (2) working days of your receipt of this notice. Please contact the Dade City Clerk’s office, P.O. Box 1355, Dade City, FL 33526-1355; (352) 523-5052 for further assistance and information. Document: Planning Board - 04 Sep 2024 - Minutes - Html Planning Board Minutes City Hall - Commission Chambers Wednesday, September 4, 2024, 5:30 PM PROUD Heritage | PROMISING Future Members Present Chair Jere Ferguson Vice-Chair Jordon Frier Board Member Lisa Simon Board Member Kim Barker School Board Member Chris Williams Staff Present Community & Economic Development Interim Director Evis Bushi GIS Planner I Craig Hanson City Attorney Patrick Brackins Members Absent/Regrets Board Member Davis Henley Board Member Keeley Karatinos Board Member Michael Stout A. MEETING PROCEDURES B. CALL TO ORDER Chair Ferguson called the meeting to order at 5:33 PM. B.1. Pledge of Allegiance. B.2. Roll Call C. PUBLIC COMMENTS D. APPROVAL OF MINUTES Chris Williams stated a correction from the August Planning Board Meeting minutes; he was present at the previous meeting and marked absent. D.1. 07 August 2024 - Planning Board Minutes Moved by School Board Member Williams, seconded by Vice-Chair Frier. Motion to approve the minutes with the correction stated by Chris Williams. E. OLD BUSINESS F. NEW BUSINESS City Attorney Andrew Hand swore in anyone offering testimony on the quasi-judicial hearing. F.1. Dutton Variance - 6' Privacy Fence on a Corner Lot Community and Economic Development Interim Director Evis Bushi provided background information on the variance. Chair Ferguson opened the floor for questions and public comment. Mary McKnight, of 36210 St Joe Road, expressed concerns regarding the HOA regulations in Abbey Glen. She stated that the HOA documents specify where fences can be placed and that fences are generally discouraged unless they enhance the property. She noted that shrubs and hedges are preferred, and the documents outline specific standards regarding fence height, materials, and other elements. Mary McKnight asked if the approval being discussed would override the HOA documents and the implications on a corner lot. Community and Economic Development Interim Director Evis Bushi responded, stating that the proposed action complies with Dade City standards. Mary McKnight then asked for confirmation that the applicant is not overriding HOA requirements. City Attorney Andrew Hand said the applicant can discuss if they wish. Chair Ferguson asked if the applicant would respond. Robbie Dutton, 13212 Waterford Castle Drive, stated that they had previously spoken with the HOA, which approved their plan. He mentioned that under the current plan 90% of the side of the house would still be visible, and the fence would be placed far from the stop sign. Vice Chair Frier confirmed that the HOA had approved the plan, and Mr. Dutton reiterated that the HOA had instructed him to obtain a variance and a City permit. Chair Ferguson noted that similar fences, including one that spans the length of the house, had been approved in the past. Board Member Barker inquired whether the HOA’s architectural review board had provided written approval. Mr. Dutton confirmed that they had received approval via email. Board Member Barker suggested that it might be helpful for the board to request a copy of the email for review to better understand the process and to include HOA approval documentation in future applications. Vice Chair Frier added that, regardless of HOA approval, the board is solely focused on completing Dade City's variance process. City Attorney Andrew Hand clarified that the criteria for granting variances are strictly governed by Dade City regulations. While it is beneficial for the applicant to provide HOA documentation, it is not relevant and holds no bearing on the board's decision-making process. Moved by Vice-Chair Frier, seconded by Board Member Barker. Motion to approve the Variance. Motion approves unanimously. Board Member Barker raised the question of whether the HOA testimony would be sufficient for City purposes. City Attorney Andrew Hand explained that while the applicant is free to provide HOA documentation, it is not necessary for a variance. The applicant’s sworn testimony regarding HOA approval is sufficient without the need for physical documentation. Vice Chair Frier added that the HOA is awaiting Dade City's approval on this matter. There was further discussion regarding HOA procedures. City Attorney Andrew Hand noted that he was not familiar with the specific procedures of this neighborhood's HOA without reviewing their documents. Chair Ferguson emphasized that the board should not alter its standards moving forward. F.2. Ruiz Variance - 6' Privacy Fence on a Corner Lot Community and Economic Development Interim Director Evis Bushi provided background information on the variance. Chair Ferguson opened the floor for questions and public comment. Samuel Mercano Ruiz, 12910 Ogden Glade Road, stated that he had submitted his fence proposal to the HOA, which approved it with the condition that the fence must be constructed 6 inches above the ground. Moved by Vice-Chair Frier, seconded by Board Member Barker. Motion to approve the Variance. Motion approves unanimously. F.3. Valez Variance - 6' Privacy Fence on a Corner Lot Community and Economic Development Interim Director Evis Bushi provided background information on the variance. Chair Ferguson opened the floor for questions and public comment. Moved by Board Member Barker, seconded by Vice-Chair Frier. Motion to approve the Variance. Motion approves unanimously. F.4. m Summit View 1 Phase 2A - Preliminary Plan Community and Economic Development Interim Director Evis Bushi read the ordinance background information. Chair Ferguson thanked Dade City staff for addressing questions from the previous hearing. Board Member Barker also thanked City Attorney Patrick Brackins for providing an email that outlined the project’s history. She highlighted that the current staff was not involved when the project initially began and expressed increased confidence in decision-making, given that the Land Development Regulations (LDR) process has since changed. Mary McKnight, 36210 St Joe Road, presented a chart from the development documents and raised concerns regarding dirt removal from the property and the timetable for future development. She cited figures stating that 450,000 cubic yards of dirt were to be removed within 18 months from August 31, 2018. Mary McKnight noted that according to the applicant's previous testimony, over a million cubic yards had already been removed and the removal process was ongoing. She inquired whether the applicant is required to track how much dirt is being removed and asked who is responsible for overseeing this process. Chair Ferguson advised that members of the public could bring such issues before the Commission, and noted that the details raised were not on the agenda for tonight's meeting. City Attorney Andrew Hand concurred with this statement. Board Member Simon expressed a desire for stronger sunset provisions, stating that continuing to honor entitlements that are over 20 years old is concerning. She hoped Dade City would move away from this practice in the future. City Attorney Andrew Hand advised the board to focus on the relevant information for the current meeting. He commented while longer sunset provisions were typical in the past, jurisdictions have generally moved toward shorter time periods with sunset provisions now commonly set at 5-7 years instead of 20 years. Chair Ferguson added that he would like to see a more concrete rule on sunset provisions, as well as clearer regulations regarding cut-and-fill and other issues discussed recently, though he acknowledged these topics were not relevant to tonight's agenda. Simone Savino of Stearns Weaver Miller, 401 Jackson Street, Tampa, spoke on behalf of the applicant. She thanked the board, staff and the public for their patience and emphasized that she was available to address questions and concerns regarding the age of the project. She assured the board that the applicant’s actions are guided by the settlement agreement and all relevant regulations. School Board Member Chris Williams requested an answer regarding the dirt removal and the timeframe for completion. Simone Savino explained that the settlement agreement included in the packet has gone through the State review process. She stated that all dirt removal is properly documented by the property owner, and that it is a controlled and regulated process, not done recklessly. She confirmed that the project is on track with state permits and that the process is dictated by the settlement agreement. Board Member Simon asked when the appropriate time would be to address these concerns. She expressed frustration, noting that it seems like a "bait and switch" situation with developers and questioned how state permits could be approved while Dade City has not yet addressed the issue. She mentioned that the development agreement had originally included limitations on how much dirt could be removed. City Attorney Andrew Hand responded by stating that, according to the settlement agreement, there are mechanisms to enforce the conditions related to fill. He added that the permitting process involves multiple layers, including state water management district permits, which can create timing and procedural complexities. He explained that local government faces a gauntlet of timing that is not always aligned with state processes. Board Member Simon asked who is responsible for follow-up, noting that Dade City used to have an engineer on staff. She expressed frustration, saying that the City sets stipulations but does not follow up, allowing developers to act without oversight. Community and Economic Development Interim Director Evis Bushi explained that Public Works teams are responsible for follow-up, and project managers frequently visit sites. She offered to find out how many times per week they visit specific projects. Simone Savino added that there are numerous permits involved at the state level, as well as Pasco County right-of-way permits, and that the mass grading plan is part of the settlement agreement. Board Member Simon questioned where the disconnect lies between the amount of dirt Dade City allows for removal and the actual dirt being removed. There were further questions about the details of the settlement agreement. Simone Savino explained that focusing on specific details without considering the broader complexities of the development might lead to misunderstandings. Board Member Simon reiterated her concern that stipulations are not being followed and asked when these issues would be addressed. The board then moved into a discussion on project approval. Chair Ferguson asked the City Attorney if the Planning Board has the authority to recommend approval of the project while requesting a review of the City's role in permitting "cut-and-fill" and other compliance matters, seeking clarification on when such decisions would be appropriate. City Attorney Andrew Hand advised this would be a comment for staff, noting that while he wouldn’t speak on this settlement agreement, any violation of the agreement that might delay the review process is outside the purview of the advisory board. However, this does not mean that such issues will go unaddressed. Chair Ferguson asked for guidance on Florida’s Sunshine Laws, specifically whether the board can communicate with City Commission members or staff. City Attorney Andrew Hand clarified that direct communication about upcoming agenda items is allowed if it is disclosed to avoid violating Sunshine Laws. Chair Ferguson sought further clarification on what the board is authorized to do, asking whether they could place concerns on record, communicate with staff, or disclose conversations with the City Commission to ensure compliance. City Attorney Andrew Hand confirmed that this approach is acceptable and that board members can also attend City Commission meetings. Chair Ferguson then commented that the upcoming workshops are intended for such discussions and wrapped up the conversation, looking to the board for a motion to move forward. Moved by Board Member Barker, seconded by Vice-Chair Frier Motion to recommend approval. Motion approved unanimously. G. MEMBER COMMENTS Chair Ferguson encouraged everyone to attend the upcoming workshop, highlighting its importance in shaping the future of Dade City. Board Member Barker expressed her wish that the current sentiment could be made retroactive, though acknowledging that it can't be. She added that she was pleased to be part of both the workshop and the Comprehensive Plan development process. There was also discussion about potential dates for the next workshop. Chair Ferguson emphasized that public comment is welcome throughout the workshop and mentioned the availability of an online community input survey. H. ADJOURNMENT Chair Ferguson adjourned the meeting at 6:20 PM. I. FOOTER TEXT

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
AgendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Agenda packetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Action agendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
MinutesNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Transcript or captionsNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Official pages

Coverage and corrections

Records considered

  • Planning Board - 04 Sep 2024 (2024-09-04)

Not claimed by this page

  • Verified meeting decisions with item-specific public-source evidence
  • Item-level plain-language summaries are not available; this page does not infer individual agenda items.
  • Item-linked, attributed deliberation
  • A source-grounded next meeting date
  • Official outcomes have not been published.
  • A transcript is not available.
  • No audio or video recording is linked.
  • Speakers have not been reliably matched to public profiles.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.
  • An individual roll-call roster is not available.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: 466c6b1990b84a6c3f6d41bb62b48703. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record