POLISCOPE

The public record

NAPLES (COLLIER COUNTY) · LOCALHeld · official record pendingPartial coverage

Code Enforcement Board

Thursday, October 24, 2024 · Government meeting record

The 30-second read

Record incomplete

The Naples Code Enforcement Board met to review property maintenance violations and permit issues. The board continued two cases to January 2025 and finalized a fine for an unpermitted interior alteration.

Why it matters

Property owners in Naples face potential fines and legal liens if they fail to maintain their properties or obtain required building permits, as demonstrated by the board's decision to impose an $8,750 fine on a local property owner.

What happens next

The scheduled meeting date has passed. Minutes or an action agenda are not published in the records we hold.

This meeting date has passed and no official outcome record has been published yet. Nothing on this page is a decision.

Record text

No transcript is held for this meeting. Recording: Watch video

City of Naples City Council Chamber 735 Eighth Street South Naples, Florida 34102 Code Enforcement Board Meeting – October 24, 2024 – 2:00 p.m. It is noted for the record that: 1) all documentation electronically appended hereto is also contained in the file for this meeting in the City Clerk’s Office; 2) Notary Public Ali Duran administered an oath to those intending to offer testimony and all responded in the affirmative; 3) all experts who testified during quasi-judicial proceedings were accepted as qualified to do so in their respective fields of expertise; and 4) all added attachments are referenced in red as “Added Attachment”. 1) Call to Order Chair Krol called the meeting to order. 2) Roll Call Members Present: John Krol, Chair Michael Faucett Nicholas Spahr, Vice Chair Maria Mair Members Absent: Steven Greenwald Richard Landuyt Sophia Abbott, Alternate Member Gregory Jarrett, Alternate Member Staff Present: Ralf Brookes, Assistant City Attorney Robert Eschenfelder, Board Attorney Thomas Tucker, Deputy Building Official William Quinsey, Code Compliance Manager Matthew Ramos, Code Compliance Officer Ali Duran, Executive Assistant Others Present Timothy Gammons Rick Jackson Cynthia Shivamber Frank Ferri Mike Depaola 3) Pledge of Allegiance Chair Krol led the Pledge of Allegiance. 4) Approval of Minutes MOTION by Spahr to APPROVE the May 23, 2024 meeting minutes; seconded by Mair and carried 4-0 (Greenwald-absent, Faucett-yes, Landuyt-absent, Mair-yes, Spahr-yes, Krol-yes). May 23, 2024 Code Enforcement Board Meeting Minutes 5) Additions / Deletions / Corrections to Agenda / Motion to Accept Agenda Code Compliance Manager William Quinsey requested to remove Items 7.4 and 7.6 from the agenda due to the lack of proper hearing notification as a result of Hurricanes Helene and Milton. MOTION by Spahr to SET the Agenda subject to removing Items 7.4 and 7.6 from the agenda; seconded by Mair and carried 4-0 (Abbott-absent, Greenwald-absent, Jarrett-absent, Faucett-yes, Landuyt-absent, Mair-yes, Spahr-yes, Krol-yes). 6) Staff Comments

Code Enforcement Board Meeting – October 24, 2024 – 2:00 p.m. 2 Code Compliance Manager William Quinsey introduced and welcomed Robert Eschenfelder, the new Code Enforcement Board Attorney. Timothy Gammons, respondent for Item 7.6, then stated that he received a notice for this hearing and requested that his case be placed back on the agenda. Assistant City Attorney Ralf Brookes announced that the item will be added back into the Agenda. Docket 7.1) Case No. CEVEG202301729 - IMPOSITION OF FINES; OWNER: COASTLAND CENTER LLC; REGISTERED AGENT: CORPPORATION SERVICE COMPANY; LOCATION: 1700 9TH STREET N; VIOLATION: Sec. 16-285. - Residential and commercial property maintenance. Chair Krol read the title of the item. Code Compliance Manager William Quinsey testified on behalf of the City. The following individuals represented the respondent: Rick Jackson, General Manager at Brookfield Properties; and Cynthia Shivamber, Attorney at McKenna, McCausland & Murphy, P.A. Original Violation: Section 16-285(b)(27) Failure to maintain landscape plan standards in accordance with Ordinance 2016-13864. Required Action: The landscaping at Coastland Mall must be maintained to standards in submitted landscape plan, Ordinance 2016-13684. Remove dead landscape materials and replace them with materials as shown in landscape plan. MOTION by Spahr to CONTINUE Case No. CEVEG202301729 to the January 23, 2025 meeting; seconded by Faucett and carried 4-0 (Abbott-absent, Greenwald-absent, Jarrett-absent, Faucett-yes, Landuyt-absent, Mair-yes, Spahr-yes, Krol-yes). EXHIBIT A - Notice of Hearing - Imposition of Fines-Liens EXHIBIT B - Imposition of Fines-Liens - Proof of Mailing EXHIBIT C - Code Enforcement Board Order - January 25, 2024 Meeting EXHIBIT D - Notice of Violation. EXHIBIT E - Affidavit of Non-Compliance EXHIBIT F - Affidavit of Personal Service EXHIBIT G - City Hall Posting Affidavit Presentation (Staff Added Attachment) 7.2) Case No. CEPM202400990 - IMPOSITION OF FINES; OWNER: SHRI AND VICTORIA PERSAUD; LOCATION: 687 BOUGAINVILLEA ROAD; VIOLATION: Sec. 16-285. - Residential and commercial property maintenance. Chair Krol read the title of the item. The following individuals testified on behalf of the City: Code Compliance Manager William Quinsey and Deputy Building Official Thomas Tucker. Original Violation: Exterior surfaces on structure in disrepair. Required Action: Repair and restore exterior surfaces. Facia along the roofline is deteriorating. Peeling paint is prohibited. Remove all the peeling paint. Repaint and restore with protective treatment. MOTION by Faucett to CONTINUE Case No. CEPM202400990 to the January 23, 2025 meeting; seconded by Mair and carried 4-0 (Abbott-absent, Greenwald-absent, Jarrett-absent, Faucett-yes, Landuyt-absent, Mair-yes, Spahr-yes, Krol-yes). EXHIBIT A - Notice of Hearing - Imposition of Fines-Liens EXHIBIT B - Notice of Hearing - Imposition of Fines-Liens - Proof of Mailing EXHIBIT C - Affidavit of Non-Compliance EXHIBIT D - Code Enforcement Board Order - May 23, 2024 Meeting

Code Enforcement Board Meeting – October 24, 2024 – 2:00 p.m. 3 EXHIBIT E - Notice of Violation EXHIBIT F - Affidavit of Posting at Property EXHIBIT G - Picture of Posting at Property EXHIBIT H - City Hall Posting Affidavit Presentation (Staff Added Attachment) 7.3) Case No. CEZONE202301879 - IMPOSITION OF FINES; OWNER: FRANK FERRI; LOCATION: 2011 GULF SHORE BOULEVARD NORTH UNIT 36; VIOLATION: Sec. 16- 112. - Florida Building Code adopted; amendments and Sec. 16-52. - Permit fees. Chair Krol read the title of the Item. The following individuals testified on behalf of the City: Code Compliance Manager William Quinsey and Deputy Building Official Thomas Tucker. Owner Frank Ferri testified as the respondent. Original Violation: Interior addition/alteration work without a permit. “Required Action: Apply for and obtain Multi-Family Addition/Alteration Permit as required by stop work order issued on October 26, 2023.” MOTION by Mair to IMPOSE a reduced fine of $8,750.00. Motion failed due to lack of a second. The following motion was then proffered. MOTION by Spahr to FIND that the violation in Case No. CEZONE20231879 has been corrected; and to IMPOSE a reduced fine of $12,937.50 to be paid within 14 days. Should the fine not be paid in the allotted timeframe, an imposition order against the property for the original amount of $17,250.00 will be filed with the Collier County Clerk of Court; seconded by Mair and FAILED 3-1 (Abbott-absent, Greenwald-absent, Jarrett-absent, Faucett-no, Landuyt-absent, Mair-yes, Spahr-yes, Krol-yes). MOTION by Mair to FIND that the violation in Case No. CEZONE202301879 has been corrected; and to IMPOSE a reduced fine of $8,750.00 to be paid within 14 days. Should the fine not be paid in the allotted timeframe, an imposition order against the property for the original amount of $17,250.00 will be filed with the Collier County Clerk of Court; seconded by Faucett and carried 4-0 (Abbott-absent, Greenwald-absent, Jarrett-absent, Faucett-yes, Landuyt-absent, Mair-yes, Spahr-yes, Krol-yes). EXHIBIT A - Notice of Hearing Imposition of Fines EXHIBIT B - Notice of Hearing Imposition of Fines - Proof of Mailing EXHIBIT C - Email Notice to Owner EXHIBIT D - Affidavit of Compliance EXHIBIT E - Code Enforcement Board Order - May 23, 2024 Meeting EXHIBIT F - Notice of Violation EXHIBIT G - City Hall Posting Affidavit Presentation (Staff Added Attachment) 7.4) Case No. CEPM202400646 - OWNER: R&C LLC; REGISTERED AGENT: CLENCY LEE- YOW; LOCATION: 1507 MUREX DRIVE; VIOLATION: Sec. 16-289. - Unsightly conditions. Removed from the agenda (See Item 5). EXHIBIT A - Notice of Violation EXHIBIT B - Notice of Violation - Proof of Mailing EXHIBIT C - Notice of Violation - Returned Mail EXHIBIT D - Notice of Hearing EXHIBIT E - Notice of Hearing - Proof of Mailing EXHIBIT F - City Hall Posting Affidavit EXHIBIT G - Picture of Property (1) EXHIBIT H - Picture of Property (2) EXHIBIT I - Picture of Property (3) 7.5) Case No. CEZONE202400011 - OWNER: DAVID MCELRATH; LOCATION: 900 8TH AVENUE SOUTH; VIOLATION: Sec. 16-112. - Florida Building Code adopted; amendments and Sec. 16-52. - Permit fees.

Code Enforcement Board Meeting – October 24, 2024 – 2:00 p.m. 4 Chair Krol read the title of the item. The following individuals testified on behalf of the City: Code Compliance Manager William Quinsey and Deputy Building Official Thomas Tucker. Violation: Interior addition/alteration work without a permit. Required Action: Apply for and obtain a Multi-Family Addition/Alteration Permit as required by stop work order that was issued on December 20, 2023. MOTION by Mair in Case No. CEPM202400646 to FIND based upon the testimony and evidence presented, that: 1) the conditions described by the Code Compliance Manager, in the Notice of Violation and at this hearing, existed on the date(s), and at the time(s) and place alleged; 2) the conditions described constitute a violation of Section 16-112. – Florida Building Code adopted; and Section 16-52. – Permit Fees; of the Naples City Code. The motion was seconded by Faucett and carried 4-0 (Abbott-absent, Greenwald- absent, Jarrett-absent, Faucett-yes, Landuyt-absent, Mair-yes, Spahr-yes, Krol-yes). MOTION by Mair in Case No. CEPM202400646 to FIND that this Board, having considered the gravity of the violation, the efforts (if any) to comply, and any other relevant violations, order the respondent to correct the violation within 90 days of the date of the rendition of this order to correct, and if the violation is not corrected within such a period of time, a fine of $250 be imposed for each day thereafter that the violation has not been corrected. The Board reserves jurisdiction to consider further evidence as to whether the violation has been corrected. The motion was seconded by Faucett and carried 4-0 (Abbott-absent, Greenwald-absent, Jarrett-absent, Faucett-yes, Landuyt- absent, Mair-yes, Spahr-yes, Krol-yes). EXHIBIT A - Notice of Violation EXHIBIT B - Notice of Violation - Proof of Mailing EXHIBIT C - Notice of Violation - Returned Mail EXHIBIT D - Notice of Hearing EXHIBIT E - Notice of Hearing - Proof of Mailing EXHIBIT F - Affidavit of Posting at Property EXHIBIT G -Picture of Posting at Property EXHIBIT H - City Hall Posting Affidavit EXHIBIT I - Stop Work Order EXHIBIT J - Permit Determination EXHIBIT K - Case Report EXHIBIT L - Picture of Property Presentation (Staff Added Attachment) 7.6) Case No. CERENT202401861 - RECURRING VIOLATION; OWNER: TIMOTHY & TETYANA GAMMONS; LOCATION: 438 17TH AVENUE SOUTH; VIOLATION: Sec. 58- 171 - District purpose., Sec. 58-172. - Uses permitted., Sec. 44-8. - Definitions. Transient lodging facility. Title read by Chair Krol. Code Compliance Manager William Quinsey stated that staff requested to withdraw the case, noting that the violation was brought to compliance previously. Code Compliance Manager Quinsey explained to the respondent that should a similar violation occur again, that it will be considered a recurring violation and addressed as such. EXHIBIT A - Notice of Hearing Recurring Violation EXHIBIT B - Notice of Hearing Recurring Violation - Proof of Mailing EXHIBIT C - City Hall Posting Affidavit EXHIBIT D - Original Notice of Violation EXHIBIT E - VRBO Advertisement In Violation 07-11-2024 EXHIBIT F - VRBO Booking Page 07-11-2024 EXHIBIT G - VRBO Advertisement in Compliance 08-05-2024 EXHIBIT H - VRBO Advertisement in Compliance 09-18-2024 Presentation (Staff Added Attachment)

Code Enforcement Board Meeting – October 24, 2024 – 2:00 p.m. 5 7.7) Case No. CEPM202402480 - OWNER: SURINDER S CHANDOK; LOCATION: 1555 BLUE POINT AVENUE; VIOLATION: Sec. 16-289. Unsightly conditions. Title read by Chair Krol. The following individuals testified on behalf of the City: Code Compliance Manager William Quinsey and Code Compliance Officer Matthew Ramos. Michael DePaola, Property Manager at Premier Property Management, represented the respondent. Violation: Discarded furniture and household appliances in visible yard areas. Property exteriors with trash, litter, debris, packing boxes, lumber and construction material. Garbage and trash containers are stored in a manner that is visible from the street. Required Action: Remove all trash, broken appliances, and maintain clean and sanitary property. MOTION by Mair in Case No. CEPM202402480, to FIND, based upon the testimony and evidence presented, that 1) the conditions described by the Code Compliance Officer, in the Notice of Violation and at this hearing, existed on the date(s), and at the time(s) and place alleged; and 2) the conditions described constitute a violation of Section 16-289. – Unsightly Conditions of the Naples City Code. The motion was seconded by Faucett and carried 4-0 (Abbott-absent, Greenwald-absent, Jarrett-absent, Faucett- yes, Landuyt-absent, Mair-yes, Spahr-yes, Krol-yes). MOTION by Mair to ORDER that no fine be imposed due to the violation being corrected; seconded by Spahr and carried 4-0 (Abbott-absent, Greenwald- absent, Jarrett-absent, Faucett-yes, Landuyt-absent, Mair-yes, Spahr-yes, Krol-yes). EXHIBIT A - Notice of Violation EXHIBIT B - Notice of Violation - Proof of Mailing EXHIBIT C - Notice of Hearing EXHIBIT D - Notice of Hearing - Proof of Mailing EXHIBIT E - City Hall Posting Affidavit EXHIBIT F - Picture of Property - 9-18-2024 EXHIBIT G - Picture of Property - 9-18-2024 - Bulk in ROW EXHIBIT H - Picture of Property - 9-18-2024 - Bed Frame EXHIBIT I - Picture of Property - 9-28-2024 - Bulk in ROW EXHIBIT J - Picture of Property - 9-28-2024 - Bed frame EXHIBIT K - Picture of Property - 9-28-2024 - Common Area EXHIBIT L - Picture of Property - 10-16-2024 - Bulk in ROW Presentation (Staff Added Attachment) Exhibit M (Staff Added Attachment) Exhibit N (Staff Added Attachment) 8) Next Meeting Date: January 23, 2025 9) Adjournment 4:31 p.m. ___________________________________ John Krol, Chair _____________________________________ Patricia L. Rambosk, City Clerk Minutes Prepared by: _____________________________________ Ali Duran, Executive Assistant Minutes Approved:01/23/2025.

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
Agenda packetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Action agendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
MinutesNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Transcript or captionsNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Recording and media

Coverage and corrections

Records considered

  • Code Enforcement Board

Not claimed by this page

  • Verified meeting decisions with item-specific public-source evidence
  • Item-level plain-language summaries are not available; this page does not infer individual agenda items.
  • Item-linked, attributed deliberation
  • A source-grounded next meeting date
  • Official outcomes have not been published.
  • A transcript is not available.
  • Speakers have not been reliably matched to public profiles.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.
  • An individual roll-call roster is not available.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: 465df42607b9505f2abd1c92065f09ed. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record