POLISCOPE

The public record

DUNEDIN (PINELLAS COUNTY) · LOCALDecisions and attributed speech publishedPartial coverage

City Commission Work Session

Tuesday, December 17, 2024 · Government meeting record

The 30-second read

Recorded outcome

CITY COMMISSION WORK SESSION

Why it matters

The official meeting record is available below. Item-level plain-language summaries are not available yet.

What happens next

No later meeting or follow-up date is stated in the reviewed record.

An official outcome record and a transcript or captions are published for this meeting.

People and votes

MAYOR FREANEY

The reviewed record lists this person as present but does not attribute a motion, statement, or individual vote to them.

Transcript and record text

Closed captionsWhat was said at the meeting, transcribed Aug 3, 2026. Speech is not a decision.
  • Some speaker identities remain unresolved.

The opening of 403,396 stored characters

>> MAYOR >> MAYOR FREANEY: >> GOOD >> GOOD MORNING, >> GOOD MORNING, WELCOME >> GOOD MORNING, WELCOME TO >> GOOD MORNING, WELCOME TO DECEMBER >> GOOD MORNING, WELCOME TO DECEMBER 17th, WELCOME TO DECEMBER 17th, 2024, CITY COMMISSION WORK 2024, CITY COMMISSION WORK SESSION. SESSION. LIKE TO CALL THIS MEETING TO LIKE TO CALL THIS MEETING TO ORDER, SO I'LL OFFICIALLY POUND ORDER, SO I'LL OFFICIALLY POUND THE GAVEL AGAIN. THE GAVEL AGAIN. AND WE'RE GOING TO START WITH AND WE'RE GOING TO START WITH JEN, COULD YOU LEAD US IN THE JEN, COULD YOU LEAD US IN THE PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE. [PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE] [PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE] >> MAYOR FREANEY: WELL, I AM >> WELL, I AM >> WELL, I AM GOING >> WELL, I AM GOING TO >> WELL, I AM GOING TO SAY, >> WELL, I AM GOING TO SAY, CITY >> WELL, I AM GOING TO SAY, CITY MANAGER, >> WELL, I AM GOING TO SAY, CITY MANAGER, IT'S GOING TO SAY, CITY MANAGER, IT'S NICE TO SEE YOU FOLLOWED HOLIDAY NICE TO SEE YOU FOLLOWED HOLIDAY TRADITION AND GAVE US VERY LIGHT TRADITION AND GAVE US VERY LIGHT ITEMS, NO READING, NO HARD WORK ITEMS, NO READING, NO HARD WORK AT THE HOLIDAYS. AT THE HOLIDAYS. >> [OFF MIC] >> [OFF MIC] >> [OFF MIC] >> >> [OFF MIC] >> MAYOR >> [OFF MIC] >> MAYOR FREANEY: >> [OFF MIC] >> MAYOR FREANEY: OBVIOUSLY >> OBVIOUSLY >> OBVIOUSLY THAT'S >> OBVIOUSLY THAT'S A >> OBVIOUSLY THAT'S A JOKE. THAT'S A JOKE. OKAY, WELL WE DON'T HAVE ANY OKAY, WELL WE DON'T HAVE ANY PRESENTATIONS TODAY, SO I'M PRESENTATIONS TODAY, SO I'M GOING TO GO RIGHT TO CITIZENS GOING TO GO RIGHT TO CITIZENS INPUT. INPUT. DOES ANYONE IN THE AUDIENCE WISH DOES ANYONE IN THE AUDIENCE WISH TO SPEAK ON A TOPIC THAT IS NOT TO SPEAK ON A TOPIC THAT IS NOT ON THE AGENDA? ON THE AGENDA? IF SO, YOU CAN COME FORWARD NOW. IF SO, YOU CAN COME FORWARD NOW. OKAY, I GUESS FATHER BOB IS HERE OKAY, I GUESS FATHER BOB IS HERE FOR SOMETHING ON THE AGENDA. FOR SOMETHING ON THE AGENDA. HERE WE GO. HERE WE GO. ALREADY LEARNED SOMETHING TODAY. ALREADY LEARNED SOMETHING TODAY. SO SEEING NO ONE COMING FORWARD, SO SEEING NO ONE COMING FORWARD, I WILL CLOSE SITGENS IN-- I WILL CLOSE SITGENS IN-- CITIZENS INPUT. CITIZENS INPUT. OKAY, WE'RE GOING TO GO TO THE OKAY, WE'RE GOING TO GO TO THE CONSENT AGENDA, SO JUST READING CONSENT AGENDA, SO JUST READING THROUGH ON CONSENT AGENDA, WE THROUGH ON CONSENT AGENDA, WE HAVE APPROVAL OF MINUTES FOR HAVE APPROVAL OF MINUTES FOR 8/21/24, 10/1/24, 10/3/24, AND 8/21/24, 10/1/24, 10/3/24, AND 10/8/24, AND BOARD AND COMMITTEE 10/8/24, AND BOARD AND COMMITTEE APPOINTMENTS, WE HAVE SERVICE APPOINTMENTS, WE HAVE SERVICE AUTHORIZATION FOR KIMLEY-HORN AUTHORIZATION FOR KIMLEY-HORN AND ASSOCIATES TO UPDATE THE AND ASSOCIATES TO UPDATE THE CITYWIDE MULTIMODAL CITYWIDE MULTIMODAL TRANSPORTATION MASTER PLAN, TRANSPORTATION MASTER PLAN, BICYCLE PEDESTRIAN MASTER PLAN. BICYCLE PEDESTRIAN MASTER PLAN. WE HAVE ADDENDUM NUMBER 3 FOR WE HAVE ADDENDUM NUMBER 3 FOR BIDDING AND CONSTRUCTION PHASE, BIDDING AND CONSTRUCTION PHASE, PROFESSIONAL SERVICES TO THE PROFESSIONAL SERVICES TO THE CONTRACT WITH McKIM & CREED CONTRACT WITH McKIM & CREED INC. FOR LIFT STATION NUMBER 32 INC. FOR LIFT STATION NUMBER 32 REBUILD, NOT TO EXCEED REBUILD, NOT TO EXCEED $101,178 AND I BELIEVE THAT'S $101,178 AND I BELIEVE THAT'S IT. IT. IS THERE ANYBODY ELSE ON THE IS THERE ANYBODY ELSE ON THE CONSENT AGENDA THAT SOMEONE LIKE CONSENT AGENDA THAT SOMEONE LIKE TO BE PULLED? TO BE PULLED? >> I WOULD LIKE TO PULL ITEM 2C. >> I WOULD LIKE TO PULL ITEM 2C. >> I WOULD LIKE TO PULL ITEM 2C. >> >> I WOULD LIKE TO PULL ITEM 2C. >> O. >> O. >> O. >> >> O. >> MAYOR >> O. >> MAYOR FREANEY: >> O. >> MAYOR FREANEY: OKAY, >> O. >> MAYOR FREANEY: OKAY, SO >> O. >> MAYOR FREANEY: OKAY, SO ITEM >> OKAY, SO ITEM >> OKAY, SO ITEM 2C. 2C. >> I WOULD LIKE TO PULL ITEM 2D. >> I WOULD LIKE TO PULL ITEM 2D. >> I WOULD LIKE TO PULL ITEM 2D. >> >> I WOULD LIKE TO PULL ITEM 2D. >> MAYOR >> I WOULD LIKE TO PULL ITEM 2D. >> MAYOR FREANEY: >> I WOULD LIKE TO PULL ITEM 2D. >> MAYOR FREANEY: 2D. >> 2D. >> 2D. >> >> 2D. >> YES, >> 2D. >> YES, MA'AM. >> YES, MA'AM. >> YES, MA'AM. >> >> YES, MA'AM. >> MAYOR >> YES, MA'AM. >> MAYOR FREANEY: >> YES, MA'AM. >> MAYOR FREANEY: OKAY. >> OKAY. >> OKAY. ALL >> OKAY. ALL RIGHT >> OKAY. ALL RIGHT SO >> OKAY. ALL RIGHT SO PULLING >> OKAY. ALL RIGHT SO PULLING THOSE >> OKAY. ALL RIGHT SO PULLING THOSE OUT, ALL RIGHT SO PULLING THOSE OUT, IF I COULD GET A MOTION FOR THE IF I COULD GET A MOTION FOR THE ITEMS OF THE MINUTES AND THE ITEMS OF THE MINUTES AND THE BOARD AND COMMITTEE BOARD AND COMMITTEE APPOINTMENTS. APPOINTMENTS. >> SO MOVED. >> SO MOVED. >> SO MOVED. >> >> SO MOVED. >> SECOND. >> SECOND. >> SECOND. >> >> SECOND. >> MAYOR >> SECOND. >> MAYOR FREANEY: >> SECOND. >> MAYOR FREANEY: OKAY, >> SECOND. >> MAYOR FREANEY: OKAY, I >> SECOND. >> MAYOR FREANEY: OKAY, I HAVE >> OKAY, I HAVE >> OKAY, I HAVE COMMISSIONER >> OKAY, I HAVE COMMISSIONER GOW >> OKAY, I HAVE COMMISSIONER GOW AND COMMISSIONER GOW AND COMMISSIONER WALKER. COMMISSIONER WALKER. AND I'M SORRY VICE MAYOR GOW, AND I'M SORRY VICE MAYOR GOW, AND OKAY. AND OKAY. ANY PUBLIC INPUT ON ANY OF THE ANY PUBLIC INPUT ON ANY OF THE CONSENT ITEMS? CONSENT ITEMS? DO YOU HAVE ANYTHING? DO YOU HAVE ANYTHING? COME FORWARD NOW. COME FORWARD NOW. SEEING NO ONE, CLOSE THAT AND SEEING NO ONE, CLOSE THAT AND ALL IN FAVOR OF THE CONSENT ALL IN FAVOR OF THE CONSENT AGENDA. AGENDA. >> AYE. >> AYE. >> AYE. >> >> AYE. >> AYE. >> AYE. >> AYE. >> >> AYE. >> ANY >> AYE. >> ANY NAYS? >> ANY NAYS? >> ANY NAYS? OKAY >> ANY NAYS? OKAY AND >> ANY NAYS? OKAY AND THAT >> ANY NAYS? OKAY AND THAT MOTION >> ANY NAYS? OKAY AND THAT MOTION PASSES OKAY AND THAT MOTION PASSES UNANIMOUSLY. UNANIMOUSLY. OKAY, SO LET'S GO BACK TO THE OKAY, SO LET'S GO BACK TO THE BICYCLE PEDESTRIAN MASTER PLAN, BICYCLE PEDESTRIAN MASTER PLAN, AND I BELIEVE COMMISSIONER AND I BELIEVE COMMISSIONER SANDBERGEN YOU PULLED THAT. SANDBERGEN YOU PULLED THAT. DO YOU HAVE A QUESTION, WOULD DO YOU HAVE A QUESTION, WOULD YOU LIKE A PRESENTATION? YOU LIKE A PRESENTATION? WHAT WOULD YOU LIKE? WHAT WOULD YOU LIKE? >> I GUESS I WOULD LIKE A LITTLE >> I GUESS I WOULD LIKE A LITTLE >> I GUESS I WOULD LIKE A LITTLE MORE >> I GUESS I WOULD LIKE A LITTLE MORE CLARIFICATION. MORE CLARIFICATION. >> MAYOR FREANEY: SO A LITTLE >> SO A LITTLE >> SO A LITTLE OVERVIEW >> SO A LITTLE OVERVIEW OR >> SO A LITTLE OVERVIEW OR SOMETHING >> SO A LITTLE OVERVIEW OR SOMETHING OR >> SO A LITTLE OVERVIEW OR SOMETHING OR JUST >> SO A LITTLE OVERVIEW OR SOMETHING OR JUST -- OVERVIEW OR SOMETHING OR JUST -- >> YEAH, I THINK IT'S THE COST >> YEAH, I THINK IT'S THE COST >> YEAH, I THINK IT'S THE COST AND >> YEAH, I THINK IT'S THE COST AND WHERE >> YEAH, I THINK IT'S THE COST AND WHERE THE >> YEAH, I THINK IT'S THE COST AND WHERE THE MONEY'S >> YEAH, I THINK IT'S THE COST AND WHERE THE MONEY'S GOING AND WHERE THE MONEY'S GOING TOWARDS. TOWARDS. I WOULD LIKE A LITTLE BETTER I WOULD LIKE A LITTLE BETTER EXPLANATION. EXPLANATION. >> GEORGIA, MAYOR, VICE MAYOR, >> GEORGIA, MAYOR, VICE MAYOR, >> GEORGIA, MAYOR, VICE MAYOR, COMMISSIONERS, >> GEORGIA, MAYOR, VICE MAYOR, COMMISSIONERS, GEORGE >> GEORGIA, MAYOR, VICE MAYOR, COMMISSIONERS, GEORGE KINNEY >> GEORGIA, MAYOR, VICE MAYOR, COMMISSIONERS, GEORGE KINNEY AND COMMISSIONERS, GEORGE KINNEY AND CATHY MATMER. CATHY MATMER. THIS WAS A BUSINESS PLAN THIS WAS A BUSINESS PLAN COMMISSIONSATIVE THAT CAME COMMISSIONSATIVE THAT CAME THROUGH THE BUDGET PROCESS LAST THROUGH THE BUDGET PROCESS LAST YEAR. YEAR. WE BASICALLY HAVE A 2011 BIKE WE BASICALLY HAVE A 2011 BIKE PED PLAN SO IT'S QUITE DATED, PED PLAN SO IT'S QUITE DATED, QUITE OLD. QUITE OLD. IT DOES NOT NECESSARILY INCLUDE IT DOES NOT NECESSARILY INCLUDE ANY POLICIES, GOALS, ACTION ANY POLICIES, GOALS, ACTION ITEMS, CONTINGENCIES OR ITEMS, CONTINGENCIES OR ANYTHING. ANYTHING. THE GOAL WAS TO TAKE THAT PLAN, THE GOAL WAS TO TAKE THAT PLAN, CREATE A ROBUST PLAN, INCLUDE CREATE A ROBUST PLAN, INCLUDE SOME STRATEGIES, SOME ACTIONS, SOME STRATEGIES, SOME ACTIONS, SOME MOBILITY STRATEGIES, SOME SOME MOBILITY STRATEGIES, SOME MAPPING ITEMS, AND THEN NORMT MAPPING ITEMS, AND THEN NORMT THAT BACK INTO THE MULTIMODAL THAT BACK INTO THE MULTIMODAL TRANSPORTATION PLAN DHRX WHICH TRANSPORTATION PLAN DHRX WHICH WAS APPROVED BY THE COMMISSION WAS APPROVED BY THE COMMISSION IN 2021. IN 2021. I HAVE THE CONSULTANT HERE IF I HAVE THE CONSULTANT HERE IF IT'S FROM FROM KIMLEY-HORN AND IT'S FROM FROM KIMLEY-HORN AND THEY HAVE PUT TOGETHER THE SCOPE THEY HAVE PUT TOGETHER THE SCOPE THAT WENT TOGETHER WITH THAT THAT WENT TOGETHER WITH THAT BUSINESS PLAN INITIATIVE AND BUSINESS PLAN INITIATIVE AND THEY CAN SPEAK TO ANY OF THE THEY CAN SPEAK TO ANY OF THE ITEMS THAT THEY'RE PERFORMING AS ITEMS THAT THEY'RE PERFORMING AS PART OF THAT SCOPE IF YOU WOULD PART OF THAT SCOPE IF YOU WOULD LIKE SOME MORE DETAIL ON IT. LIKE SOME MORE DETAIL ON IT. >> I THINK I MAYBE GET A LITTLE >> I THINK I MAYBE GET A LITTLE >> I THINK I MAYBE GET A LITTLE HUNG >> I THINK I MAYBE GET A LITTLE HUNG UP >> I THINK I MAYBE GET A LITTLE HUNG UP ON >> I THINK I MAYBE GET A LITTLE HUNG UP ON SEEING >> I THINK I MAYBE GET A LITTLE HUNG UP ON SEEING THE >> I THINK I MAYBE GET A LITTLE HUNG UP ON SEEING THE BICYCLE HUNG UP ON SEEING THE BICYCLE ACTIVITY DOWNTOWN AND THEREFORE ACTIVITY DOWNTOWN AND THEREFORE I'VE NOT GIVEN ENOUGH THOUGHT TO I'VE NOT GIVEN ENOUGH THOUGHT TO THE SURROUNDING PARTS OF TOWN, THE SURROUNDING PARTS OF TOWN, SO I SEE LARGE AMOUNTS OF MONEY SO I SEE LARGE AMOUNTS OF MONEY AND THINGS SEEM TO BE WORKING AND THINGS SEEM TO BE WORKING QUITE WELL FOR BICYCLE TRAFFIC. QUITE WELL FOR BICYCLE TRAFFIC. I KNOW IT WAS TAKES INTO I KNOW IT WAS TAKES INTO CONSIDERATION ON THE SKINNER CONSIDERATION ON THE SKINNER PROJECT, AND I DON'T KNOW, MAYBE PROJECT, AND I DON'T KNOW, MAYBE IF YOU COULD JUST. IF YOU COULD JUST. >> SO THIS WOULD BE A CITYWIDE >> SO THIS WOULD BE A CITYWIDE >> SO THIS WOULD BE A CITYWIDE PLAN. PLAN. SO IT WOULDN'T BE LIMITED TO THE SO IT WOULDN'T BE LIMITED TO THE DOWNTOWN AND WE WOULD LEE DOWNTOWN AND WE WOULD LEE BOOKING AT FACILITIES ALL AROUND BOOKING AT FACILITIES ALL AROUND OUR DOWNTOWN. OUR DOWNTOWN. WE WOULD BE LOOKING AT GAPS, WE WOULD BE LOOKING AT GAPS, CONNECTIONS, SAFE ROUTES TO CONNECTIONS, SAFE ROUTES TO SCHOOL POSSIBILITIES, SO IT'S SCHOOL POSSIBILITIES, SO IT'S REALLY GOING TO BE A REALLY GOING TO BE A COMPREHENSIVE LOOK AT WHERE OUR COMPREHENSIVE LOOK AT WHERE OUR OPPORTUNITIES ARE TO PROVIDE OPPORTUNITIES ARE TO PROVIDE SAFE BIKE ROUTES. SAFE BIKE ROUTES. >> WITH A FOCUS ON SAFETY YOU >> WITH A FOCUS ON SAFETY YOU >> WITH A FOCUS ON SAFETY YOU SAID? SAID? >> ABSOLUTELY. >> ABSOLUTELY. >> ABSOLUTELY. >> >> ABSOLUTELY. >> OKAY. >> OKAY. >> OKAY. THEN >> OKAY. THEN I'M >> OKAY. THEN I'M SATISFIED >> OKAY. THEN I'M SATISFIED WITH >> OKAY. THEN I'M SATISFIED WITH WHAT THEN I'M SATISFIED WITH WHAT I'VE HEARD. I'VE HEARD. THANK YOU. THANK YOU. >> ANYONE ELSE HAVE QUESTIONS? >> ANYONE ELSE HAVE QUESTIONS? >> ANYONE ELSE HAVE QUESTIONS? COMMISSIONER >> ANYONE ELSE HAVE QUESTIONS? COMMISSIONER WALKER. COMMISSIONER WALKER. >> SO THE MASTER PLAN ITSELF, >> SO THE MASTER PLAN ITSELF, >> SO THE MASTER PLAN ITSELF, LET >> SO THE MASTER PLAN ITSELF, LET ME >> SO THE MASTER PLAN ITSELF, LET ME SEE >> SO THE MASTER PLAN ITSELF, LET ME SEE IF >> SO THE MASTER PLAN ITSELF, LET ME SEE IF I'VE >> SO THE MASTER PLAN ITSELF, LET ME SEE IF I'VE GOT >> SO THE MASTER PLAN ITSELF, LET ME SEE IF I'VE GOT THIS LET ME SEE IF I'VE GOT THIS CLEAR. CLEAR. SO WHAT WE'RE DOING RIGHT NOW SO WHAT WE'RE DOING RIGHT NOW ISING ON BASICALLY THE SERVICE ISING ON BASICALLY THE SERVICE A2K3WR5E789, IS THAT CORRECT? A2K3WR5E789, IS THAT CORRECT? >> CORRECT. >> CORRECT. >> CORRECT. >> >> CORRECT. >> AND >> CORRECT. >> AND CAN >> CORRECT. >> AND CAN YOU >> CORRECT. >> AND CAN YOU JUST >> CORRECT. >> AND CAN YOU JUST SUMMARIZE, >> CORRECT. >> AND CAN YOU JUST SUMMARIZE, I >> AND CAN YOU JUST SUMMARIZE, I >> AND CAN YOU JUST SUMMARIZE, I DON'T >> AND CAN YOU JUST SUMMARIZE, I DON'T KNOW >> AND CAN YOU JUST SUMMARIZE, I DON'T KNOW TO >> AND CAN YOU JUST SUMMARIZE, I DON'T KNOW TO HOLD >> AND CAN YOU JUST SUMMARIZE, I DON'T KNOW TO HOLD THIS >> AND CAN YOU JUST SUMMARIZE, I DON'T KNOW TO HOLD THIS UP, >> AND CAN YOU JUST SUMMARIZE, I DON'T KNOW TO HOLD THIS UP, BUT DON'T KNOW TO HOLD THIS UP, BUT JUST SUMMARIZE WHAT IS IT IN THE JUST SUMMARIZE WHAT IS IT IN THE MASTER PLAN THAT SPECIFICALLY MASTER PLAN THAT SPECIFICALLY THAT SPECIFICALLY WAS LACKING TO THAT SPECIFICALLY WAS LACKING TO GET TO THIS POINT. GET TO THIS POINT. >> SO THE CURRENT PLAN, >> SO THE CURRENT PLAN, >> SO THE CURRENT PLAN, COMMISSIONERS, >> SO THE CURRENT PLAN, COMMISSIONERS, KIND >> SO THE CURRENT PLAN, COMMISSIONERS, KIND OF >> SO THE CURRENT PLAN, COMMISSIONERS, KIND OF SITS COMMISSIONERS, KIND OF SITS ALONE. ALONE. IT'S NOT EMBEDDED IN THE IT'S NOT EMBEDDED IN THE MULTIMODAL TRANSPORTATION PLAN, MULTIMODAL TRANSPORTATION PLAN, AND THAT CURRENT PLAN DOESN'T -- AND THAT CURRENT PLAN DOESN'T -- WE HAVE NOTHING IN IT. WE HAVE NOTHING IN IT. IT'S REALLY BARE BONE. IT'S REALLY BARE BONE. THERE IS NO STRATEGIES, THERE THERE IS NO STRATEGIES, THERE ARE NO POLICY. ARE NO POLICY. THERE IS NO ACTIONS. THERE IS NO ACTIONS. THERE ARE NO GOALS SO THE IDEA THERE ARE NO GOALS SO THE IDEA IS TO MOVE THAT CURRENT PLAN IS TO MOVE THAT CURRENT PLAN INTO YOUR CURRENT 2021 INTO YOUR CURRENT 2021 MULTIMODAL MASTER PLAN AND MULTIMODAL MASTER PLAN AND CREATE ALL OF THAT AS PART OF CREATE ALL OF THAT AS PART OF THE PLAN SET FOR THE MULTIMODAL THE PLAN SET FOR THE MULTIMODAL PLAN. PLAN. >> OKAY SO THIS IS TO MAKE IT >> OKAY SO THIS IS TO MAKE IT >> OKAY SO THIS IS TO MAKE IT CONSISTENT >> OKAY SO THIS IS TO MAKE IT CONSISTENT WITH >> OKAY SO THIS IS TO MAKE IT CONSISTENT WITH BEING >> OKAY SO THIS IS TO MAKE IT CONSISTENT WITH BEING A >> OKAY SO THIS IS TO MAKE IT CONSISTENT WITH BEING A MORE CONSISTENT WITH BEING A MORE BIKEABLE AND WALKABLE CITY. BIKEABLE AND WALKABLE CITY. >> ABSOLUTELY. >> ABSOLUTELY. >> ABSOLUTELY. >> >> ABSOLUTELY. >> OKAY, >> ABSOLUTELY. >> OKAY, THANK >> ABSOLUTELY. >> OKAY, THANK YOU. >> OKAY, THANK YOU. >> OKAY, THANK YOU. >> >> OKAY, THANK YOU. >> MAYOR >> OKAY, THANK YOU. >> MAYOR FREANEY: >> OKAY, THANK YOU. >> MAYOR FREANEY: COMMISSIONER >> COMMISSIONER >> COMMISSIONER DUGARD, >> COMMISSIONER DUGARD, DID >> COMMISSIONER DUGARD, DID YOU >> COMMISSIONER DUGARD, DID YOU HAVE >> COMMISSIONER DUGARD, DID YOU HAVE SOMETHING? DUGARD, DID YOU HAVE SOMETHING? >> THANK YOU. >> THANK YOU. >> THANK YOU. I >> THANK YOU. I HAVE >> THANK YOU. I HAVE SOME >> THANK YOU. I HAVE SOME DATA >> THANK YOU. I HAVE SOME DATA THAT >> THANK YOU. I HAVE SOME DATA THAT I I HAVE SOME DATA THAT I GENERATED DURING MY EFFORTS TO GENERATED DURING MY EFFORTS TO GET IN THIS CHAIR THAT INDICATES GET IN THIS CHAIR THAT INDICATES THERE'S A CONCERN OF SAFETY, THERE'S A CONCERN OF SAFETY, PARTICULARLY ON THE TRAIL. PARTICULARLY ON THE TRAIL. THE PINELLAS TRAIL. THE PINELLAS TRAIL. WE DO NOT CONTROL AS YOU KNOW WE DO NOT CONTROL AS YOU KNOW THE PINELLAS TRAIL SO HOW WILL THE PINELLAS TRAIL SO HOW WILL WE ADDRESS THAT INABILITY TO WE ADDRESS THAT INABILITY TO CONTROL THE TRAIL AND THEN CONTROL THE TRAIL AND THEN INTEGRATE THAT INTO CREATING A INTEGRATE THAT INTO CREATING A GREATER SENSE OF SAFETY TRAIL? GREATER SENSE OF SAFETY TRAIL? >> MAYBE HAVE KIMLEY-HORN COME >> MAYBE HAVE KIMLEY-HORN COME >> MAYBE HAVE KIMLEY-HORN COME UP >> MAYBE HAVE KIMLEY-HORN COME UP AND >> MAYBE HAVE KIMLEY-HORN COME UP AND TALK >> MAYBE HAVE KIMLEY-HORN COME UP AND TALK ABOUT >> MAYBE HAVE KIMLEY-HORN COME UP AND TALK ABOUT SOME >> MAYBE HAVE KIMLEY-HORN COME UP AND TALK ABOUT SOME OF >> MAYBE HAVE KIMLEY-HORN COME UP AND TALK ABOUT SOME OF THE UP AND TALK ABOUT SOME OF THE STRATEGIES THEY'RE THINKING STRATEGIES THEY'RE THINKING ABOUT REAL QUICK. ABOUT REAL QUICK. >> THANKS, GEORGE, GOOD MORNING, >> THANKS, GEORGE, GOOD MORNING, >> THANKS, GEORGE, GOOD MORNING, MEMBERS >> THANKS, GEORGE, GOOD MORNING, MEMBERS OF >> THANKS, GEORGE, GOOD MORNING, MEMBERS OF THE >> THANKS, GEORGE, GOOD MORNING, MEMBERS OF THE COMMISSION. MEMBERS OF THE COMMISSION. JARED SNYDER WITH KIMLEY-HORN. JARED SNYDER WITH KIMLEY-HORN. I LEAD OUR PRACTICE HERE IN THIS I LEAD OUR PRACTICE HERE IN THIS COUNTY. COUNTY. THAT'S WHAT MOST OF THE PLANS THAT'S WHAT MOST OF THE PLANS ARE DEALING WITH ARE ARE DEALING WITH ARE PARTNERSHIPS SO WE WOULD DEAL, PARTNERSHIPS SO WE WOULD DEAL, WE WOULD WORK WITH FORWARD WE WOULD WORK WITH FORWARD PINELLAS, PINELLAS COUNTY, AND PINELLAS, PINELLAS COUNTY, AND FDOT AS PART OF THIS PLAN TO FDOT AS PART OF THIS PLAN TO CREATE THOSE STRATEGIES AND CREATE THOSE STRATEGIES AND RECOMMENDATIONS THAT GEORGE IS RECOMMENDATIONS THAT GEORGE IS TALKING ABOUT. TALKING ABOUT. >> I LOOK FORWARD TO READING >> I LOOK FORWARD TO READING >> I LOOK FORWARD TO READING THAT. THAT. >> MAYOR FREANEY: OKAY. >> OKAY. >> OKAY. ANYTHING >> OKAY. ANYTHING ELSE? ANYTHING ELSE? IS VICE MAYOR? IS VICE MAYOR? >> HOW LONG DO YOU PLAN -- HOW >> HOW LONG DO YOU PLAN -- HOW >> HOW LONG DO YOU PLAN -- HOW LONG >> HOW LONG DO YOU PLAN -- HOW LONG DO >> HOW LONG DO YOU PLAN -- HOW LONG DO YOU >> HOW LONG DO YOU PLAN -- HOW LONG DO YOU THINK >> HOW LONG DO YOU PLAN -- HOW LONG DO YOU THINK THIS >> HOW LONG DO YOU PLAN -- HOW LONG DO YOU THINK THIS IS >> HOW LONG DO YOU PLAN -- HOW LONG DO YOU THINK THIS IS GOING LONG DO YOU THINK THIS IS GOING TO TAKE BEFORE IT COMES BEFORE TO TAKE BEFORE IT COMES BEFORE US? US? >> WE'VE GOT SEVERAL CHECK-INS. >> WE'VE GOT SEVERAL CHECK-INS. >> WE'VE GOT SEVERAL CHECK-INS. THE >> WE'VE GOT SEVERAL CHECK-INS. THE FULL >> WE'VE GOT SEVERAL CHECK-INS. THE FULL SCHEDULE >> WE'VE GOT SEVERAL CHECK-INS. THE FULL SCHEDULE I >> WE'VE GOT SEVERAL CHECK-INS. THE FULL SCHEDULE I BELIEVE >> WE'VE GOT SEVERAL CHECK-INS. THE FULL SCHEDULE I BELIEVE IS THE FULL SCHEDULE I BELIEVE IS AROUND -- SIX MONTHS TOTAL BUT AROUND -- SIX MONTHS TOTAL BUT YEAH FOUR TO SIX WE WOULD COME YEAH FOUR TO SIX WE WOULD COME AND SEE Y'ALL. AND SEE Y'ALL. >> LOOKING FORWARD TO IT. >> LOOKING FORWARD TO IT. >> LOOKING FORWARD TO IT. >> >> LOOKING FORWARD TO IT. >> I >> LOOKING FORWARD TO IT. >> I GUESS >> LOOKING FORWARD TO IT. >> I GUESS WHEN >> LOOKING FORWARD TO IT. >> I GUESS WHEN I >> LOOKING FORWARD TO IT. >> I GUESS WHEN I THINK >> LOOKING FORWARD TO IT. >> I GUESS WHEN I THINK ABOUT >> I GUESS WHEN I THINK ABOUT >> I GUESS WHEN I THINK ABOUT BIKE >> I GUESS WHEN I THINK ABOUT BIKE SAFETY, >> I GUESS WHEN I THINK ABOUT BIKE SAFETY, I >> I GUESS WHEN I THINK ABOUT BIKE SAFETY, I RECENTLY >> I GUESS WHEN I THINK ABOUT BIKE SAFETY, I RECENTLY SAW >> I GUESS WHEN I THINK ABOUT BIKE SAFETY, I RECENTLY SAW A BIKE SAFETY, I RECENTLY SAW A COMMERCIAL FOR AN ELECTRIC BIKE COMMERCIAL FOR AN ELECTRIC BIKE THAT WILL TOP OUT AT 42 MILES AN THAT WILL TOP OUT AT 42 MILES AN HOUR. HOUR. THAT'S A FAR CRY FROM A LITTLE THAT'S A FAR CRY FROM A LITTLE BOY OR GIRL WITH THEIR TRAINING BOY OR GIRL WITH THEIR TRAINING WHEELS ON TRYING TO BE, YOU WHEELS ON TRYING TO BE, YOU KNOW, ENJOY THEIR DAY DOWNTOWN KNOW, ENJOY THEIR DAY DOWNTOWN DUNEDIN. DUNEDIN. SO I MEAN, I FEEL LIKE I KNOW SO I MEAN, I FEEL LIKE I KNOW WHERE THIS IS GOING, BUT JUST WHERE THIS IS GOING, BUT JUST WANT TO MAKE SURE WE SPEND THE WANT TO MAKE SURE WE SPEND THE CITY'S MONEY PROPERLY AND GET CITY'S MONEY PROPERLY AND GET THE MOST WE CAN FOR IT. THE MOST WE CAN FOR IT. >> I DID SHARE WITH THE CITY >> I DID SHARE WITH THE CITY >> I DID SHARE WITH THE CITY MANAGER. MANAGER. I THOUGHT IN THE FUTURE WHEN WE I THOUGHT IN THE FUTURE WHEN WE HAVE ONE OF THESE HAVING A LINK HAVE ONE OF THESE HAVING A LINK IMMEDIATELY TO THE MULTIMODAL IMMEDIATELY TO THE MULTIMODAL AND TO THE 2011 BIKE PLAN, SO AND TO THE 2011 BIKE PLAN, SO THAT ESPECIALLY NEW THAT ESPECIALLY NEW COMMISSIONERS CAN IMMEDIATELY COMMISSIONERS CAN IMMEDIATELY REFERENCE, YOU KNOW, WHAT IT IS, REFERENCE, YOU KNOW, WHAT IT IS, BECAUSE I MEAN THERE ARE BECAUSE I MEAN THERE ARE SIGNIFICANT DOCUMENTS. SIGNIFICANT DOCUMENTS. >> ABSOLUTELY. >> ABSOLUTELY. >> ABSOLUTELY. YOU >> ABSOLUTELY. YOU KNOW, >> ABSOLUTELY. YOU KNOW, OUR >> ABSOLUTELY. YOU KNOW, OUR COMMUNICATIONS YOU KNOW, OUR COMMUNICATIONS TEAM DOES A GREAT JOB OF TEAM DOES A GREAT JOB OF CREATING PAGES FOR THESE PPI CREATING PAGES FOR THESE PPI PROJECTS SO WE'LL ABSOLUTELY -- PROJECTS SO WE'LL ABSOLUTELY -- YOU KNOW, WE'LL HAVE THAT LINK YOU KNOW, WE'LL HAVE THAT LINK TO OUR COMMUNICATIONS TEAM AS TO OUR COMMUNICATIONS TEAM AS WELL AS ON OUR OWN WEB SITE WELL AS ON OUR OWN WEB SITE OBVIOUSLY, SO. OBVIOUSLY, SO. >> MAYOR, MAY I? >> MAYOR, MAY I? >> MAYOR, MAY I? WE'LL >> MAYOR, MAY I? WE'LL HAVE >> MAYOR, MAY I? WE'LL HAVE THAT >> MAYOR, MAY I? WE'LL HAVE THAT LINKED >> MAYOR, MAY I? WE'LL HAVE THAT LINKED TO >> MAYOR, MAY I? WE'LL HAVE THAT LINKED TO YOU WE'LL HAVE THAT LINKED TO YOU THIS MORNING. THIS MORNING. >> THAT WOULD BE GREAT. >> THAT WOULD BE GREAT. >> THAT WOULD BE GREAT. I >> THAT WOULD BE GREAT. I JUST >> THAT WOULD BE GREAT. I JUST THINK >> THAT WOULD BE GREAT. I JUST THINK THEY'RE >> THAT WOULD BE GREAT. I JUST THINK THEY'RE GOOD I JUST THINK THEY'RE GOOD REFERENCE DOCUMENTS, AND IT'S REFERENCE DOCUMENTS, AND IT'S HARD TO VOTE ON SOMETHING NEW HARD TO VOTE ON SOMETHING NEW AND FEEL LIKE YOU'RE NOT WASTING AND FEEL LIKE YOU'RE NOT WASTING MONEY WITHOUT SEEING WHAT'S BEEN MONEY WITHOUT SEEING WHAT'S BEEN DONE BEFORE. DONE BEFORE. OKAY. OKAY. SO I'LL JUST DO A VOICE VOTE ON SO I'LL JUST DO A VOICE VOTE ON THIS. THIS. ALL IN FAVOR. ALL IN FAVOR. ANY OPPOSED? ANY OPPOSED? OKAY. OKAY. MOTION CARRIES UNANIMOUSLY. MOTION CARRIES UNANIMOUSLY. >> I NEED -- >> I NEED -- >> I NEED -- >> >> I NEED -- >> SORY? >> SORY? >> SORY? >> >> SORY? >> I >> SORY? >> I DIDN'T >> SORY? >> I DIDN'T GET >> SORY? >> I DIDN'T GET A >> SORY? >> I DIDN'T GET A MOTION. >> I DIDN'T GET A MOTION. >> I DIDN'T GET A MOTION. >> >> I DIDN'T GET A MOTION. >> OH, >> I DIDN'T GET A MOTION. >> OH, SORRY. >> OH, SORRY. >> OH, SORRY. YOU'RE >> OH, SORRY. YOU'RE ABSOLUTELY >> OH, SORRY. YOU'RE ABSOLUTELY RIGHT. YOU'RE ABSOLUTELY RIGHT. SO I GUESS FIRST I NEED A MOTION SO I GUESS FIRST I NEED A MOTION TO APPROVE. TO APPROVE. >> SO MOVED. >> SO MOVED. >> SO MOVED. >> >> SO MOVED. >> SECOND. >> SECOND. >> SECOND. >> >> SECOND. >> DID >> SECOND. >> DID YOU >> SECOND. >> DID YOU ASK >> SECOND. >> DID YOU ASK FOR >> SECOND. >> DID YOU ASK FOR CITIZEN >> DID YOU ASK FOR CITIZEN >> DID YOU ASK FOR CITIZEN INPUT. INPUT. >> I DID NOT. >> I DID NOT. >> I DID NOT. OKAY. OKAY. GOOD. GOOD. EVERYBODY'S KEEPING ME HONEST EVERYBODY'S KEEPING ME HONEST TODAY. TODAY. ANY CITIZEN INPUT ON THIS ITEM? ANY CITIZEN INPUT ON THIS ITEM? COME FORWARD NOW. COME FORWARD NOW. OKAY. OKAY. SEEING NONE, NOW I WILL ASK FOR SEEING NONE, NOW I WILL ASK FOR A VOICE VOTE. A VOICE VOTE. ALL IN FAVOR. ALL IN FAVOR. OKAY, NO NAYS, AND I WILL SAY OKAY, NO NAYS, AND I WILL SAY THE MOTION PASSES UNANIMOUSLY. THE MOTION PASSES UNANIMOUSLY. THANK YOU. THANK YOU. OKAY. OKAY. LET'S GET THIS NEXT ONE GOOD. LET'S GET THIS NEXT ONE GOOD. SO I THINK COMMISSIONER WALKER, SO I THINK COMMISSIONER WALKER, YOU PULLED THE BIDDING ON THE YOU PULLED THE BIDDING ON THE LIFT STATION 32 REBUILD, SO. LIFT STATION 32 REBUILD, SO. >> YES, MA'AM, THANK YOU. >> YES, MA'AM, THANK YOU. >> YES, MA'AM, THANK YOU. >> >> YES, MA'AM, THANK YOU. >> DO >> YES, MA'AM, THANK YOU. >> DO YOU >> YES, MA'AM, THANK YOU. >> DO YOU WANT >> YES, MA'AM, THANK YOU. >> DO YOU WANT A >> YES, MA'AM, THANK YOU. >> DO YOU WANT A PRESENTATION >> YES, MA'AM, THANK YOU. >> DO YOU WANT A PRESENTATION OR >> DO YOU WANT A PRESENTATION OR >> DO YOU WANT A PRESENTATION OR JUST. JUST. >> NO, THIS IS JUST A QUESTION. >> NO, THIS IS JUST A QUESTION. >> NO, THIS IS JUST A QUESTION. DURING >> NO, THIS IS JUST A QUESTION. DURING OUR >> NO, THIS IS JUST A QUESTION. DURING OUR BRIEFINS >> NO, THIS IS JUST A QUESTION. DURING OUR BRIEFINS YESTERDAY, DURING OUR BRIEFINS YESTERDAY, THE REASON WE DO THIS, RIGHT, THE REASON WE DO THIS, RIGHT, FOR THE LIFT STATIONS IS BECAUSE FOR THE LIFT STATIONS IS BECAUSE WE DON'T HAVE THE IN-HOUSE WE DON'T HAVE THE IN-HOUSE EXPERTISE TO DO ALL THE BID EXPERTISE TO DO ALL THE BID DOCUMENTS AND REVIEW THE DOCUMENTS AND REVIEW THE DRAWINGS AND SUCH. DRAWINGS AND SUCH. IS THAT -- IS THAT -- >> CORRECT. >> CORRECT. >> CORRECT. GOOD >> CORRECT. GOOD MORNING, >> CORRECT. GOOD MORNING, MADAM >> CORRECT. GOOD MORNING, MADAM MAYOR, >> CORRECT. GOOD MORNING, MADAM MAYOR, VICE GOOD MORNING, MADAM MAYOR, VICE MAYOR, AND COMMISSIONERS. MAYOR, AND COMMISSIONERS. JORGE QUINTAS, DEPUTY CITY JORGE QUINTAS, DEPUTY CITY MANAGER. WE ARE GOING DO OUR BET MANAGER. WE ARE GOING DO OUR BET TO ANSWER THE QUESTIONS NORMALLY TO ANSWER THE QUESTIONS NORMALLY ALEX WOULD. ALEX WOULD. HE IS NOT FEELING WELL TODAY BUT HE IS NOT FEELING WELL TODAY BUT TO YOUR PARTICULAR QUESTION, TO YOUR PARTICULAR QUESTION, THIS PARTICULAR PROJECT WE THIS PARTICULAR PROJECT WE ACTUALLY -- WE HIRED McKIM & ACTUALLY -- WE HIRED McKIM & CREED TO DO QUITE A BIT OF CREED TO DO QUITE A BIT OF ANALYSIS NOT ONLY ON LIFT ANALYSIS NOT ONLY ON LIFT STATION 32 BUT LIFT STATION 20 STATION 32 BUT LIFT STATION 20 AND THEY WERE PRETTY HEAVILY AND THEY WERE PRETTY HEAVILY INVOLVED AS ENGINEER OF RECORD INVOLVED AS ENGINEER OF RECORD IN BOTH OF THOSE PROJECTS. IN BOTH OF THOSE PROJECTS. WE HAD DIFFERENT SCENARIOS WHERE WE HAD DIFFERENT SCENARIOS WHERE WE LOOKED AT DIFFERENT SITING WE LOOKED AT DIFFERENT SITING LOCATIONS, DIFFERENT LOCATIONS, DIFFERENT CONSTRUCTABILITY CONCERNS, SO CONSTRUCTABILITY CONCERNS, SO THIS ONE IS SPECIFIC AS THE ITEM THIS ONE IS SPECIFIC AS THE ITEM INDICATES, IT'S AN ADDENDMENT TO INDICATES, IT'S AN ADDENDMENT TO THE WORK EFFORT THAT THEY HAVE THE WORK EFFORT THAT THEY HAVE BEEN PROVIDING AT LIFT STATION BEEN PROVIDING AT LIFT STATION 32 AND THIS IS SPECIFIC TO THE 32 AND THIS IS SPECIFIC TO THE CONSTRUCTION ADMINISTRATION CONSTRUCTION ADMINISTRATION PORTION OF WHEN THAT PROJECT PORTION OF WHEN THAT PROJECT GOES TO CONSTRUCTION AND SINCE GOES TO CONSTRUCTION AND SINCE THEY ARE ENGINEER OF RECORD THEY THEY ARE ENGINEER OF RECORD THEY HAVE TO CERTIFY THAT THOSE HAVE TO CERTIFY THAT THOSE ELEMENTS OF THE PROJECT THAT ELEMENTS OF THE PROJECT THAT WERE CONSTRUCTED BY THE AWARDED WERE CONSTRUCTED BY THE AWARDED CONTRACTOR WILL IN FACT MEET CONTRACTOR WILL IN FACT MEET THOSE PERMIT CRITERIA AND THE THOSE PERMIT CRITERIA AND THE DESIGN CRITERIA. DESIGN CRITERIA. >> OKAY, SO THIS IS ALSO SOME >> OKAY, SO THIS IS ALSO SOME >> OKAY, SO THIS IS ALSO SOME ELEMENT >> OKAY, SO THIS IS ALSO SOME ELEMENT OF >> OKAY, SO THIS IS ALSO SOME ELEMENT OF SUBJECT >> OKAY, SO THIS IS ALSO SOME ELEMENT OF SUBJECT MATTER ELEMENT OF SUBJECT MATTER EXPERTISE OF THE AREA AND THE EXPERTISE OF THE AREA AND THE ACTUAL LIFT STATION, RIGHT? ACTUAL LIFT STATION, RIGHT? >> CORRECT. >> CORRECT. >> CORRECT. CORRECT. CORRECT. >> YEAH, AND I'M JUST CURIOUS, >> YEAH, AND I'M JUST CURIOUS, >> YEAH, AND I'M JUST CURIOUS, THIS >> YEAH, AND I'M JUST CURIOUS, THIS IS >> YEAH, AND I'M JUST CURIOUS, THIS IS PROBABLY >> YEAH, AND I'M JUST CURIOUS, THIS IS PROBABLY A >> YEAH, AND I'M JUST CURIOUS, THIS IS PROBABLY A TOPIC >> YEAH, AND I'M JUST CURIOUS, THIS IS PROBABLY A TOPIC FOR THIS IS PROBABLY A TOPIC FOR DISCUSSION WHEN WE START GETTING DISCUSSION WHEN WE START GETTING INTO BUDGET, BUT YOU KNOW, IN AN INTO BUDGET, BUT YOU KNOW, IN AN IDEAL WORLD, WHAT WOULD A PERSON IDEAL WORLD, WHAT WOULD A PERSON THAT COULD ACCOMPLISH THAT KIND THAT COULD ACCOMPLISH THAT KIND OF STUFF DO BECAUSE YOU KNOW IT OF STUFF DO BECAUSE YOU KNOW IT SEEMS TO ME THAT THAT WOULD BE SEEMS TO ME THAT THAT WOULD BE SOMETHING WE'D WANT IN HOUSE, SOMETHING WE'D WANT IN HOUSE, RIGHT? RIGHT? >> CORRECT, AND WE'VE, YOU KNOW, >> CORRECT, AND WE'VE, YOU KNOW, >> CORRECT, AND WE'VE, YOU KNOW, I'LL >> CORRECT, AND WE'VE, YOU KNOW, I'LL LET >> CORRECT, AND WE'VE, YOU KNOW, I'LL LET CLAY >> CORRECT, AND WE'VE, YOU KNOW, I'LL LET CLAY ELABORATE >> CORRECT, AND WE'VE, YOU KNOW, I'LL LET CLAY ELABORATE SOME, I'LL LET CLAY ELABORATE SOME, BUT WE FILLED SOME CRITICAL BUT WE FILLED SOME CRITICAL VACANCIES THAT WE'VE HAD IN VACANCIES THAT WE'VE HAD IN ENGINEERING IF YOU RECALL WE'VE ENGINEERING IF YOU RECALL WE'VE HAD SOME OF THOSE VACANCIES FOR HAD SOME OF THOSE VACANCIES FOR SOMETIMES WELL OVER A COUPLE, SOMETIMES WELL OVER A COUPLE, TWO, THREE YEARS. TWO, THREE YEARS. THESE PROJECTS HAVE BEEN UNDER THESE PROJECTS HAVE BEEN UNDER DESIGN FOR QUITE SOMETIME. DESIGN FOR QUITE SOMETIME. THEY WERE BOTH WHAT ARE CALLED THEY WERE BOTH WHAT ARE CALLED HMGP GRANTS, HAZARD MITIGATION HMGP GRANTS, HAZARD MITIGATION GRANT PROGRAM FUNDED PROJECTS. GRANT PROGRAM FUNDED PROJECTS. THOSE WERE ACTUALLY AS A RESULT THOSE WERE ACTUALLY AS A RESULT OF HURRICANE IRMA IF YOU WANT TO OF HURRICANE IRMA IF YOU WANT TO BELIEVE THAT. BELIEVE THAT. SO WE'VE BEEN DEALING WITH THE SO WE'VE BEEN DEALING WITH THE DEPARTMENT OF ENVIRONMENTAL FDEM DEPARTMENT OF ENVIRONMENTAL FDEM ON THE ADMINISTRATION OF BOTH OF ON THE ADMINISTRATION OF BOTH OF THOSE GRANTS, WE ACTUALLY USED? THOSE GRANTS, WE ACTUALLY USED? OF THAT FUNDING FOR THE DESIGN OF THAT FUNDING FOR THE DESIGN AND PROPERTY ACQUISITION ON LIFT AND PROPERTY ACQUISITION ON LIFT STATION 20 AND AS WELL ON THIS STATION 20 AND AS WELL ON THIS PROJECT. PROJECT. SO WE'VE BEEN ABLE TO ADVANCE SO WE'VE BEEN ABLE TO ADVANCE PROJECTS AT BOTH OF THESE PROJECTS AT BOTH OF THESE STATIONS WHICH WERE IMPACTED STATIONS WHICH WERE IMPACTED DURING IRMA AND OBVIOUSLY WE DURING IRMA AND OBVIOUSLY WE WANT TO MITIGATE ANY FUTURE WANT TO MITIGATE ANY FUTURE CONCERNS, LIFT STATION 32 IS CONCERNS, LIFT STATION 32 IS ALSO THE RECEIVING LIFT STATION ALSO THE RECEIVING LIFT STATION FOR THE LOFTY PINE PROJECT IF FOR THE LOFTY PINE PROJECT IF YOU KNOW THAT'S THE YOU KNOW THAT'S THE UNINCORPORATED PROJECT THAT WE UNINCORPORATED PROJECT THAT WE GOT FUNDING ALSO FROM THE STATE GOT FUNDING ALSO FROM THE STATE AND THE COUNTY TO DO THE GRAVITY AND THE COUNTY TO DO THE GRAVITY SEWER EXPANSION IN THAT LOFTY SEWER EXPANSION IN THAT LOFTY PINE UNINCORPORATED AREA OF PINE UNINCORPORATED AREA OF DUNEDIN. DUNEDIN. AND SO THOSE FLOWS ALL COME TO AND SO THOSE FLOWS ALL COME TO THE LIFT STATION 32 AS WELL. THE LIFT STATION 32 AS WELL. >> OKAY. >> OKAY. >> OKAY. >> >> OKAY. >> AND >> OKAY. >> AND TO >> OKAY. >> AND TO EXPAND >> OKAY. >> AND TO EXPAND ON >> OKAY. >> AND TO EXPAND ON THAT >> OKAY. >> AND TO EXPAND ON THAT A >> AND TO EXPAND ON THAT A >> AND TO EXPAND ON THAT A LITTLE >> AND TO EXPAND ON THAT A LITTLE BIT >> AND TO EXPAND ON THAT A LITTLE BIT MORE, >> AND TO EXPAND ON THAT A LITTLE BIT MORE, WITH >> AND TO EXPAND ON THAT A LITTLE BIT MORE, WITH THE LITTLE BIT MORE, WITH THE ADDITION OF ADDITIONAL STAFF, WE ADDITION OF ADDITIONAL STAFF, WE HAVE ANOTHER HIRE WE'RE HOPING HAVE ANOTHER HIRE WE'RE HOPING TO GET ON HERE IN THE NEXT TO GET ON HERE IN THE NEXT COUPLE OF DAYS. COUPLE OF DAYS. WE'LL START TO BRING ON SOME OF WE'LL START TO BRING ON SOME OF THE SMALLER DESIGN WORK AND IN THE SMALLER DESIGN WORK AND IN HOUSE WE CAN TAKE CARE OF AND HOUSE WE CAN TAKE CARE OF AND TRY TO SAVE SOME FEES ON DESIGN. TRY TO SAVE SOME FEES ON DESIGN. >> OKAY, YEAH, SO TO KIND OF SUM >> OKAY, YEAH, SO TO KIND OF SUM >> OKAY, YEAH, SO TO KIND OF SUM IT >> OKAY, YEAH, SO TO KIND OF SUM IT UP, >> OKAY, YEAH, SO TO KIND OF SUM IT UP, WE'RE >> OKAY, YEAH, SO TO KIND OF SUM IT UP, WE'RE LOOKING >> OKAY, YEAH, SO TO KIND OF SUM IT UP, WE'RE LOOKING FOR >> OKAY, YEAH, SO TO KIND OF SUM IT UP, WE'RE LOOKING FOR A >> OKAY, YEAH, SO TO KIND OF SUM IT UP, WE'RE LOOKING FOR A VERY IT UP, WE'RE LOOKING FOR A VERY SPECIALIZED SKILL SET. SPECIALIZED SKILL SET. >> YEAH, THIS ONE, IF I'M >> YEAH, THIS ONE, IF I'M >> YEAH, THIS ONE, IF I'M CORRECT, >> YEAH, THIS ONE, IF I'M CORRECT, WE'RE >> YEAH, THIS ONE, IF I'M CORRECT, WE'RE TRYING >> YEAH, THIS ONE, IF I'M CORRECT, WE'RE TRYING TO >> YEAH, THIS ONE, IF I'M CORRECT, WE'RE TRYING TO MODEL CORRECT, WE'RE TRYING TO MODEL SOME OF THE FLOWS COMING TO THE SOME OF THE FLOWS COMING TO THE STATION AND A FEW OTHER THINGS STATION AND A FEW OTHER THINGS SO IT'S STUFF THAT -- SO IT'S STUFF THAT -- >> BRINGING MODELING INTO, >> BRINGING MODELING INTO, >> BRINGING MODELING INTO, MODELING >> BRINGING MODELING INTO, MODELING SIMULATION >> BRINGING MODELING INTO, MODELING SIMULATION INTO >> BRINGING MODELING INTO, MODELING SIMULATION INTO -- MODELING SIMULATION INTO -- >> INTO WASTEWATER ALSO. >> INTO WASTEWATER ALSO. >> INTO WASTEWATER ALSO. >> >> INTO WASTEWATER ALSO. >> OH, >> INTO WASTEWATER ALSO. >> OH, MY >> INTO WASTEWATER ALSO. >> OH, MY GOD, >> INTO WASTEWATER ALSO. >> OH, MY GOD, YOU'RE >> INTO WASTEWATER ALSO. >> OH, MY GOD, YOU'RE TALKING >> INTO WASTEWATER ALSO. >> OH, MY GOD, YOU'RE TALKING MY >> OH, MY GOD, YOU'RE TALKING MY >> OH, MY GOD, YOU'RE TALKING MY LANGUAGE. LANGUAGE. [LAUGHTER] [LAUGHTER] >> THAT'S ALL I TALK ABOUT IT >> THAT'S ALL I TALK ABOUT IT >> THAT'S ALL I TALK ABOUT IT SEEMS >> THAT'S ALL I TALK ABOUT IT SEEMS LIKE. SEEMS LIKE. >> THAT WAS PART OF THE EFFORT >> THAT WAS PART OF THE EFFORT >> THAT WAS PART OF THE EFFORT ON >> THAT WAS PART OF THE EFFORT ON BOTH >> THAT WAS PART OF THE EFFORT ON BOTH OF >> THAT WAS PART OF THE EFFORT ON BOTH OF THESE >> THAT WAS PART OF THE EFFORT ON BOTH OF THESE WAS >> THAT WAS PART OF THE EFFORT ON BOTH OF THESE WAS MODELING ON BOTH OF THESE WAS MODELING AND MAKING SURE THAT THE NEW AND MAKING SURE THAT THE NEW STATION COULD HANDLE THE FUTURE STATION COULD HANDLE THE FUTURE FLOWS. FLOWS. >> YES. >> YES. >> YES. >> >> YES. >> ALL >> YES. >> ALL RIGHT. >> ALL RIGHT. >> ALL RIGHT. GO >> ALL RIGHT. GO FORWARD, >> ALL RIGHT. GO FORWARD, DO >> ALL RIGHT. GO FORWARD, DO GOOD >> ALL RIGHT. GO FORWARD, DO GOOD THINGS. GO FORWARD, DO GOOD THINGS. THANK YOU. THANK YOU. >> THANK YOU. >> THANK YOU. >> THANK YOU. >> >> THANK YOU. >> MAYOR, >> THANK YOU. >> MAYOR, MAY >> THANK YOU. >> MAYOR, MAY I? >> MAYOR, MAY I? >> MAYOR, MAY I? WE >> MAYOR, MAY I? WE HAD >> MAYOR, MAY I? WE HAD A >> MAYOR, MAY I? WE HAD A LOT >> MAYOR, MAY I? WE HAD A LOT OF >> MAYOR, MAY I? WE HAD A LOT OF VACANCIES >> MAYOR, MAY I? WE HAD A LOT OF VACANCIES IN WE HAD A LOT OF VACANCIES IN ENGINEERING AND WE WEREN'T ABLE ENGINEERING AND WE WEREN'T ABLE TO MOVIE LOT OF PROJECTS ALONG TO MOVIE LOT OF PROJECTS ALONG EVEN TO SCOPE OUT BIDDING EVEN TO SCOPE OUT BIDDING DOCUMENTS AND CONSTRUCTION DOCUMENTS AND CONSTRUCTION DOCUMENTS AS WE FILL THOSE DOCUMENTS AS WE FILL THOSE POSITIONS NOW WE'RE ABLE TO MOVE POSITIONS NOW WE'RE ABLE TO MOVE FORWARD A LOT OF THOSE PROJECTS FORWARD A LOT OF THOSE PROJECTS WHICH IS WHY WE'RE YOU'RE SEEING WHICH IS WHY WE'RE YOU'RE SEEING PHYSICALLY OUT IN THE FIELD AND PHYSICALLY OUT IN THE FIELD AND THE BOARD OF FINANCE COMMENTED THE BOARD OF FINANCE COMMENTED ABOUT YOU KNOW WE HADN'T BEEN ABOUT YOU KNOW WE HADN'T BEEN SPENDING OUR CAPITAL DOLLARS AND SPENDING OUR CAPITAL DOLLARS AND WE ARE. WE ARE. BUT YOU KNOW THIS IS THE REASON BUT YOU KNOW THIS IS THE REASON WHY WE'RE ABLE TO MOVE THESE WHY WE'RE ABLE TO MOVE THESE PROJECTS ALONG FARTHER NOW, AND PROJECTS ALONG FARTHER NOW, AND PEOPLE ARE ASKING WHY ALL THE PEOPLE ARE ASKING WHY ALL THE ROADS ARE BEING TORN UP. ROADS ARE BEING TORN UP. IT'S BECAUSE THAT'S CRITICAL IT'S BECAUSE THAT'S CRITICAL INFRASTRUCTURE IS BEING PUT IN INFRASTRUCTURE IS BEING PUT IN PLACE NOW BECAUSE WE HAVE THE PLACE NOW BECAUSE WE HAVE THE STAFF. STAFF. >> THANK YOU, JENNIFER, >> THANK YOU, JENNIFER, >> THANK YOU, JENNIFER, APPRECIATE >> THANK YOU, JENNIFER, APPRECIATE THAT. APPRECIATE THAT. COOL. COOL. ANY, ANYBODY ELSE HAVE ANY, ANYBODY ELSE HAVE QUESTIONS, COMMISSIONER DUGARD, QUESTIONS, COMMISSIONER DUGARD, ANYTHING? ANYTHING? >> YEAH, THANK YOU. >> YEAH, THANK YOU. >> YEAH, THANK YOU. I'M >> YEAH, THANK YOU. I'M VERY >> YEAH, THANK YOU. I'M VERY LITTLE >> YEAH, THANK YOU. I'M VERY LITTLE I >> YEAH, THANK YOU. I'M VERY LITTLE I HAD >> YEAH, THANK YOU. I'M VERY LITTLE I HAD NO I'M VERY LITTLE I HAD NO OPPOSITION TO THIS PARTICULAR OPPOSITION TO THIS PARTICULAR ACTION. ACTION. HOWEVER, I THINK ABOUT THE HOWEVER, I THINK ABOUT THE CONTEXT ISSUE AND TWO NEW CONTEXT ISSUE AND TWO NEW COMMISSIONERS BEING ASKED TO COMMISSIONERS BEING ASKED TO VOTE ON SUCH ITEMS WITHOUT VOTE ON SUCH ITEMS WITHOUT CONTEXT FOR THE WHOLE SYSTEM. CONTEXT FOR THE WHOLE SYSTEM. AT SOME POINT IN THE FUTURE I AT SOME POINT IN THE FUTURE I WOULD LIKE A BRIEFING TO GIVE ME WOULD LIKE A BRIEFING TO GIVE ME CONTEXTUAL VIEW OF THE SYSTEM CONTEXTUAL VIEW OF THE SYSTEM WHERE WE THINK OUR WEAK LINKS WHERE WE THINK OUR WEAK LINKS ARE, OUR HIGH FRICTION AREAS, ARE, OUR HIGH FRICTION AREAS, I'D LIKE JUST TO GET A GENERAL I'D LIKE JUST TO GET A GENERAL OVERVIEW BECAUSE THE ISSUE ASK OVERVIEW BECAUSE THE ISSUE ASK TOO IMPORTANT. TOO IMPORTANT. >> YEAH, I KNOW THAT WE'VE GOT >> YEAH, I KNOW THAT WE'VE GOT >> YEAH, I KNOW THAT WE'VE GOT SOME >> YEAH, I KNOW THAT WE'VE GOT SOME TOURS >> YEAH, I KNOW THAT WE'VE GOT SOME TOURS PLANNED >> YEAH, I KNOW THAT WE'VE GOT SOME TOURS PLANNED FOR >> YEAH, I KNOW THAT WE'VE GOT SOME TOURS PLANNED FOR YOURSELF SOME TOURS PLANNED FOR YOURSELF AND COMMISSIONER SANDBERGEN IN AND COMMISSIONER SANDBERGEN IN THE NEW YEAR AND WE'RE GOING TO THE NEW YEAR AND WE'RE GOING TO VISIT IN DIFFERENT OF THE VISIT IN DIFFERENT OF THE OPERATIONAL UNITS, SO OBVIOUSLY OPERATIONAL UNITS, SO OBVIOUSLY WHEN WE GO TO THE COLLECTIONS WHEN WE GO TO THE COLLECTIONS GROUP, WE'RE GOING TO ELABORATE GROUP, WE'RE GOING TO ELABORATE ON THAT BUT WE HAVE 44 LIFT ON THAT BUT WE HAVE 44 LIFT STATIONS THROUGHOUT THE CITY STATIONS THROUGHOUT THE CITY THAT WE HAVE TO MAINTAIN, AND THAT WE HAVE TO MAINTAIN, AND SOME HAVE PRETTY SUBSTANTIAL SOME HAVE PRETTY SUBSTANTIAL FLOWS AS YOU RECALL DURING THE FLOWS AS YOU RECALL DURING THE CONVERSATIONS RELATED TO NORTH CONVERSATIONS RELATED TO NORTH DOUGLAS THAT'S LIFT STATION 8 DOUGLAS THAT'S LIFT STATION 8 THAT TAKES UP ENORMOUS AMOUNT OF THAT TAKES UP ENORMOUS AMOUNT OF FLOW FROM THE NORTH PART OF THE FLOW FROM THE NORTH PART OF THE CITY. CITY. SO. SO. >> IT IS WITH MIXED THOUGHTS >> IT IS WITH MIXED THOUGHTS >> IT IS WITH MIXED THOUGHTS THAT >> IT IS WITH MIXED THOUGHTS THAT I >> IT IS WITH MIXED THOUGHTS THAT I LOOK >> IT IS WITH MIXED THOUGHTS THAT I LOOK FORWARD >> IT IS WITH MIXED THOUGHTS THAT I LOOK FORWARD TO >> IT IS WITH MIXED THOUGHTS THAT I LOOK FORWARD TO THAT. THAT I LOOK FORWARD TO THAT. [LAUGHTER] [LAUGHTER] >> YOUR NUMBER TWO IS OUR NUMBER >> YOUR NUMBER TWO IS OUR NUMBER >> YOUR NUMBER TWO IS OUR NUMBER ONE, >> YOUR NUMBER TWO IS OUR NUMBER ONE, SIR. ONE, SIR. >> KEY WORD IS FLOW. >> KEY WORD IS FLOW. >> KEY WORD IS FLOW. OKAY. OKAY. ANYTHING ON THIS SIDE, VICE ANYTHING ON THIS SIDE, VICE MAYOR, ANY QUESTIONS? MAYOR, ANY QUESTIONS? >> NO, MA'AM, I'M FINE. >> NO, MA'AM, I'M FINE. >> NO, MA'AM, I'M FINE. >> >> NO, MA'AM, I'M FINE. >> MAYOR >> NO, MA'AM, I'M FINE. >> MAYOR FREANEY: >> NO, MA'AM, I'M FINE. >> MAYOR FREANEY: COMMISSIONER >> COMMISSIONER >> COMMISSIONER SANDBERGEN? SANDBERGEN? OKAY SO DO I HAVE A MOTION TO OKAY SO DO I HAVE A MOTION TO APPROVE THE BIDDING AND APPROVE THE BIDDING AND CONSTRUCTION? CONSTRUCTION? >> SO MOVED. >> SO MOVED. >> SO MOVED. >> >> SO MOVED. >> MAYOR >> SO MOVED. >> MAYOR FREANEY: >> SO MOVED. >> MAYOR FREANEY: OKAY, >> SO MOVED. >> MAYOR FREANEY: OKAY, ANY >> OKAY, ANY >> OKAY, ANY CITIZEN >> OKAY, ANY CITIZEN INPUT? CITIZEN INPUT? ANYONE WISH TO SPEAK ON THIS ANYONE WISH TO SPEAK ON THIS ITEM? ITEM? SEEING NO ONE, OKAY, I WILL SEEING NO ONE, OKAY, I WILL CLOSE THAT. CLOSE THAT. AND ASK FOR ALL IN FAVOR. AND ASK FOR ALL IN FAVOR. AND THAT MOTION PASSES AND THAT MOTION PASSES UNANIMOUSLY. UNANIMOUSLY. OKAY, WE'LL KNEE OUR ACTION OKAY, WE'LL KNEE OUR ACTION ITEMS AND THE -- GO TO OUR ITEMS AND THE -- GO TO OUR ACTION ITEMS AND THE FIRST ITEM ACTION ITEMS AND THE FIRST ITEM IS FREEBEE FLEX ROUTE ANNUAL IS FREEBEE FLEX ROUTE ANNUAL CONTRACT 12/22/2024 THROUGH CONTRACT 12/22/2024 THROUGH 12/21/2025. 12/21/2025. >> GEORGE KINNEY. >> GEORGE KINNEY. >> GEORGE KINNEY. WHAT >> GEORGE KINNEY. WHAT WE >> GEORGE KINNEY. WHAT WE WANT >> GEORGE KINNEY. WHAT WE WANT TO >> GEORGE KINNEY. WHAT WE WANT TO DO >> GEORGE KINNEY. WHAT WE WANT TO DO FOR >> GEORGE KINNEY. WHAT WE WANT TO DO FOR THIS WHAT WE WANT TO DO FOR THIS PARTICULAR PRESENTATION IS TURN PARTICULAR PRESENTATION IS TURN IT OVER TO JASON SPIEGEL THE CEO IT OVER TO JASON SPIEGEL THE CEO OF FREEBEE. OF FREEBEE. THEN KIND OF WALK THROUGH KIND THEN KIND OF WALK THROUGH KIND OF PART AND PARCEL TO OUR OF PART AND PARCEL TO OUR RECOMMENDATION TO YOU ALL, BUT I RECOMMENDATION TO YOU ALL, BUT I WOULD LIKE TO RESERVE THE WOULD LIKE TO RESERVE THE OPPORTUNITY TO COME BACK TO YOU OPPORTUNITY TO COME BACK TO YOU AT THE END AND SUMMARIZE OUR AT THE END AND SUMMARIZE OUR RECOMMENDATION WHERE YOU KNOW RECOMMENDATION WHERE YOU KNOW AFTER YOU'VE ASKED YOUR AFTER YOU'VE ASKED YOUR QUESTIONS OF JAYS FN THAT'S OKAY QUESTIONS OF JAYS FN THAT'S OKAY WITH THE MAYOR AND THE WITH THE MAYOR AND THE COMMISSION. COMMISSION. >> THAT'D BE GREAT, THANK YOU. >> THAT'D BE GREAT, THANK YOU. >> THAT'D BE GREAT, THANK YOU. >> >> THAT'D BE GREAT, THANK YOU. >> SO >> THAT'D BE GREAT, THANK YOU. >> SO WITH >> THAT'D BE GREAT, THANK YOU. >> SO WITH THAT >> THAT'D BE GREAT, THANK YOU. >> SO WITH THAT I >> THAT'D BE GREAT, THANK YOU. >> SO WITH THAT I WILL >> THAT'D BE GREAT, THANK YOU. >> SO WITH THAT I WILL TURN >> THAT'D BE GREAT, THANK YOU. >> SO WITH THAT I WILL TURN IT >> SO WITH THAT I WILL TURN IT >> SO WITH THAT I WILL TURN IT OVER >> SO WITH THAT I WILL TURN IT OVER TO >> SO WITH THAT I WILL TURN IT OVER TO JASON. OVER TO JASON. >> GOOD MORNING, EVERYBODY. >> GOOD MORNING, EVERYBODY. >> GOOD MORNING, EVERYBODY. EXCUSE >> GOOD MORNING, EVERYBODY. EXCUSE ME >> GOOD MORNING, EVERYBODY. EXCUSE ME VOICE. EXCUSE ME VOICE. I'M JUST GETTING OVER A PRETTY I'M JUST GETTING OVER A PRETTY BAD COLD SO IF I SCRATCH A BAD COLD SO IF I SCRATCH A LITTLE BIT, JUST BARE WITH ME. LITTLE BIT, JUST BARE WITH ME. BUT GREAT TO SEE EVERYBODY BUT GREAT TO SEE EVERYBODY AGAIN. AGAIN. CONGRATULATIONS, MADAM MAY, CONGRATULATIONS, MADAM MAY, CONGRATULATIONS TO THE TWO NEW CONGRATULATIONS TO THE TWO NEW COMMISSIONERS. COMMISSIONERS. I'M JASON SEGAL, ONE OF THE I'M JASON SEGAL, ONE OF THE MANAGING PARTNERS HERE AT MANAGING PARTNERS HERE AT FREEBIE. FREEBIE. KIND OF LOOKING BACK AT THE DATA KIND OF LOOKING BACK AT THE DATA AND THE TAKEAWAYS WE LOOK AT AND THE TAKEAWAYS WE LOOK AT THIS PROGRAM AS A REALLY BIG THIS PROGRAM AS A REALLY BIG SUCCESS, AND THE BIG TAKEAWAY IS SUCCESS, AND THE BIG TAKEAWAY IS NOT ONLY HOW SUCCESSFUL IT IS IN NOT ONLY HOW SUCCESSFUL IT IS IN TERMS OF RIDERSHIP DATA BUT THIS TERMS OF RIDERSHIP DATA BUT THIS HAS BEEN A REALLY BIG BENEFIT TO HAS BEEN A REALLY BIG BENEFIT TO EVERY STAKEHOLDERS IN THIS EVERY STAKEHOLDERS IN THIS COMMUNITY. COMMUNITY. WE'RE TALKING ABOUT RESIDENTS, WE'RE TALKING ABOUT RESIDENTS, THE VISITORS, THE WORKERS, THE THE VISITORS, THE WORKERS, THE LOCAL BUSINESSES, THE SENIOR LOCAL BUSINESSES, THE SENIOR COMMUNITY OVER AT THE MESE. COMMUNITY OVER AT THE MESE. EVERYBODY HAS BEEN ABLE TO EVERYBODY HAS BEEN ABLE TO BENEFIT FROM TO THIS PROGRAM. BENEFIT FROM TO THIS PROGRAM. IT'S NOT SPECIFIC TO ONE IT'S NOT SPECIFIC TO ONE SPECIFIC GROUP, DEMOGRAPHIC. SPECIFIC GROUP, DEMOGRAPHIC. EVERYBODY HAS BEEN TAKING EVERYBODY HAS BEEN TAKING ADVANTAGE OF THAT AND AGAIN IT'S ADVANTAGE OF THAT AND AGAIN IT'S BEEN A VERY SUCCESSFUL BEEN A VERY SUCCESSFUL IMPLEMENTATION TO THE POINT IMPLEMENTATION TO THE POINT WHERE YOUR NEIGHBORING WHERE YOUR NEIGHBORING COMMUNITIES, THE ELECTED COMMUNITIES, THE ELECTED OFFICIALS ARE COMING HERE TO OFFICIALS ARE COMING HERE TO DUNEDIN, THEY'RE LOOKING AT THE DUNEDIN, THEY'RE LOOKING AT THE PROGRAM, THEY'RE USING THE PROGRAM, THEY'RE USING THE SERVICE AND NOW THEY WANT TO SERVICE AND NOW THEY WANT TO IMPLEMENT THE SAME EXACT SERVICE IMPLEMENT THE SAME EXACT SERVICE THAT YOU GUYS HAVE IMPLEMENTED, THAT YOU GUYS HAVE IMPLEMENTED, AND THEY'RE DOWNTOWNS AND IN AND THEY'RE DOWNTOWNS AND IN THEIR COMMUNITIES. THEIR COMMUNITIES. AND THIS ISN'T FREEBEE GOING TO AND THIS ISN'T FREEBEE GOING TO THEM TRYING TO SELL THEM ON A THEM TRYING TO SELL THEM ON A NEW PROGRAM. NEW PROGRAM. THE ONLY REASON WE'VE BEEN ABLE THE ONLY REASON WE'VE BEEN ABLE TO FIND OUT ABOUT THIS IS TO FIND OUT ABOUT THIS IS BECAUSE THERE'S BEEN ARTICLES BECAUSE THERE'S BEEN ARTICLES WRITTEN IN THE NEWSPAPERS MOST WRITTEN IN THE NEWSPAPERS MOST RECENTLY FROM TARPON SPRINGS, RECENTLY FROM TARPON SPRINGS, PLANT CITY, ET CETERA, AND IT PLANT CITY, ET CETERA, AND IT REALLY GOES TO SHOW HOW YOU GUYS REALLY GOES TO SHOW HOW YOU GUYS ARE, YOU KNOW, REALLY SHOWN THAT ARE, YOU KNOW, REALLY SHOWN THAT YOU GUYS ARE A LEADER WHEN IT YOU GUYS ARE A LEADER WHEN IT COMES TO TRANSPORTATION, COMES TO TRANSPORTATION, INNOVATIVE MOBILITY, ET CETERA INNOVATIVE MOBILITY, ET CETERA THERE, SO AGAIN WE'RE GOING TO THERE, SO AGAIN WE'RE GOING TO TAKE A QUICK HISTORY OF THE TAKE A QUICK HISTORY OF THE PROGRAM. PROGRAM. WE'RE GOING TOG THROUGH THE DATA WE'RE GOING TOG THROUGH THE DATA OVER THE LAST YEAR, THE FIXED OVER THE LAST YEAR, THE FIXED ROUTE DATA, THE LAST 90 DAYS ROUTE DATA, THE LAST 90 DAYS DURING THE FLEX PROGRAM PILOT, DURING THE FLEX PROGRAM PILOT, THE COMPARISON THERE, AND THEN THE COMPARISON THERE, AND THEN TALK ABOUT SOME RECOMMENDATIONS TALK ABOUT SOME RECOMMENDATIONS THAT WE HAVE TO CONTINUE TO THAT WE HAVE TO CONTINUE TO ENHANCE THE PROGRAM AS WE GO ENHANCE THE PROGRAM AS WE GO INTO YEAR TWO THERE. INTO YEAR TWO THERE. SO JUST AGAIN GOING BACK TO THE SO JUST AGAIN GOING BACK TO THE GOALS, YOU KNOW, WHAT WAS THE GOALS, YOU KNOW, WHAT WAS THE OBJECTIVE OF THIS PROGRAM AND IT OBJECTIVE OF THIS PROGRAM AND IT WAS REALLY TO INTRODUCE AN WAS REALLY TO INTRODUCE AN INNOVATIVE TURN KEY INNOVATIVE TURN KEY TRANSPORTATION SOLUTION THAT TRANSPORTATION SOLUTION THAT SERVES ALL THE RESIDENTS, THE SERVES ALL THE RESIDENTS, THE VISITORS, THE BUSINESS VISITORS, THE BUSINESS EMPLOYEES, BY PROVIDING EMPLOYEES, BY PROVIDING CONNECTIVITY TO EVERYTHING THAT CONNECTIVITY TO EVERYTHING THAT DUNEDIN HAS TO OFFER. DUNEDIN HAS TO OFFER. SPECIFICALLY WITHIN DOWNTOWN SPECIFICALLY WITHIN DOWNTOWN DUNEDIN THERE. DUNEDIN THERE. GOALS HELP REDUCE TRAFFIC GOALS HELP REDUCE TRAFFIC CONGESTION, FREE UP SOME OF THE CONGESTION, FREE UP SOME OF THE LIMITED PARKING AVAILABILITY, LIMITED PARKING AVAILABILITY, ALLOW RESIDENTS THAT LIVE WITHIN ALLOW RESIDENTS THAT LIVE WITHIN AN AREA NOT HAVING TO TAKE OUT AN AREA NOT HAVING TO TAKE OUT THEIR PERSONAL VEHICLE TO COME THEIR PERSONAL VEHICLE TO COME AND EXPLORE DOWNTOWN, PROVIDE A AND EXPLORE DOWNTOWN, PROVIDE A CONVENIENT PARK ONCE OPPORTUNITY CONVENIENT PARK ONCE OPPORTUNITY FOR PEOPLE THAT DO DECIDE TO FOR PEOPLE THAT DO DECIDE TO DRIVE THEIR CAR INTO DOWNTOWN DRIVE THEIR CAR INTO DOWNTOWN HERE AND NOT HAVE TO CONTINUE TO HERE AND NOT HAVE TO CONTINUE TO TAKE IT OUT TO MOVE AROUND TAKE IT OUT TO MOVE AROUND DOWNTOWN TO FREQUENT THE DOWNTOWN TO FREQUENT THE DIFFERENT BUSINESSES AND SHOPS. DIFFERENT BUSINESSES AND SHOPS. DECREASE CARBON EMISSION BY DECREASE CARBON EMISSION BY USING 100% ELECTRIC VEHICLES. USING 100% ELECTRIC VEHICLES. SUPPORTING THE OBVIOUSLY THE SUPPORTING THE OBVIOUSLY THE BLUE JAYS DURING SPRING TRAINING BLUE JAYS DURING SPRING TRAINING SEASON WHEN YOU GUYS HAVE A HUGE SEASON WHEN YOU GUYS HAVE A HUGE INFLUX OF VISITORS THAT COME INFLUX OF VISITORS THAT COME INTO THE AREA THERE AND THEN INTO THE AREA THERE AND THEN ULTIMATELY CONTINUE TO HELP ULTIMATELY CONTINUE TO HELP TRANSFORM THE CITY OF DUNEDIN TO TRANSFORM THE CITY OF DUNEDIN TO THE PLACE WHERE YOU CAN COME THE PLACE WHERE YOU CAN COME LIVE, WORK, AND PLAY AND NOT LIVE, WORK, AND PLAY AND NOT NEED TO OWN A PERSONAL VEHICLE NEED TO OWN A PERSONAL VEHICLE THERE. THERE. SO IN EARLY 2023 THE CITY PUT SO IN EARLY 2023 THE CITY PUT OUT AN RFP TO OPERATE A DOWNTOWN OUT AN RFP TO OPERATE A DOWNTOWN LOOPER PROGRAM THROUGH A LOOPER PROGRAM THROUGH A SIX-MONTH PILOT THIS WAS AWARDED SIX-MONTH PILOT THIS WAS AWARDED TO FREEBEE AND WE LAUNCHED THE TO FREEBEE AND WE LAUNCHED THE PROGRAM IN NOVEMBER 2023 WITH PROGRAM IN NOVEMBER 2023 WITH THREE VEHICLES THAT WERE IN THREE VEHICLES THAT WERE IN SERVICE. SERVICE. WE ALSO HAD A FOURTH VEHICLE WE ALSO HAD A FOURTH VEHICLE THAT WAS ON STANDBY FOR ADA THAT WAS ON STANDBY FOR ADA ACCESSIBILITY AND THE SERVICE ACCESSIBILITY AND THE SERVICE STARTED AS A THURSDAY THROUGH STARTED AS A THURSDAY THROUGH SUNDAY PROGRAM. SUNDAY PROGRAM. THURSDAY IT WAS 11:00 A.M. TO THURSDAY IT WAS 11:00 A.M. TO 10:00 P.M., FRIDAY AND SATURDAY 10:00 P.M., FRIDAY AND SATURDAY 11:00 A.M. TO 12:00 A.M., AND 11:00 A.M. TO 12:00 A.M., AND THEN SUNDAY FROM 11:00 A.M. TO THEN SUNDAY FROM 11:00 A.M. TO 7:00 P.M. 7:00 P.M. DURING THIS INITIAL SUCCESS OF DURING THIS INITIAL SUCCESS OF THE SIX MONTHS, THE PILOT WAS THE SIX MONTHS, THE PILOT WAS EXTEND UNDER TO THE OFFSEASON EXTEND UNDER TO THE OFFSEASON AND AFTER SPRING TRAINING SCALED AND AFTER SPRING TRAINING SCALED DOWN TO TWO VEHICLES. DOWN TO TWO VEHICLES. WE LIMITED THE AMOUNT OF HOURS WE LIMITED THE AMOUNT OF HOURS OF OPERATION STILL OPERATING OF OPERATION STILL OPERATING THURSDAY THROUGH SUNDAY, BUT IT THURSDAY THROUGH SUNDAY, BUT IT WENT FROM ABOUT I THINK IT WAS WENT FROM ABOUT I THINK IT WAS ABOUT 45 HOURS DOWN TO 35 HOURS ABOUT 45 HOURS DOWN TO 35 HOURS PER VEHICLE. PER VEHICLE. THURSDAY FROM 3:00 P.M. TO THURSDAY FROM 3:00 P.M. TO 10:00 P.M., FRIDAY 3:00 TO 10:00 P.M., FRIDAY 3:00 TO MIDNIGHT, SATURDAY 11:00 TO 12 MIDNIGHT, SATURDAY 11:00 TO 12 MIDNIGHT AND SUNDAY FROM MIDNIGHT AND SUNDAY FROM 11:00 A.M. TO 7:00 P.M. 11:00 A.M. TO 7:00 P.M. AND MORE RECENTLY IN SEPTEMBER AND MORE RECENTLY IN SEPTEMBER OF THIS YEAR, AS YOU KNOW THE OF THIS YEAR, AS YOU KNOW THE SUMMER RIDERSHIP REALLY KIND OF SUMMER RIDERSHIP REALLY KIND OF SLOWED, WE LOOKED AT KIND OF SLOWED, WE LOOKED AT KIND OF INOVATIVE WAYS ON HOW DO WE INOVATIVE WAYS ON HOW DO WE BOOST RIDERSHIP, HOW DO WE GET BOOST RIDERSHIP, HOW DO WE GET RESIDENTS TO COME INTO IT RESIDENTS TO COME INTO IT DOWNTOWN WITHOUT HAVING TO TAKE DOWNTOWN WITHOUT HAVING TO TAKE THEIR CAR. THEIR CAR. WE LAUNCHED A 90-DAY FLEX WE LAUNCHED A 90-DAY FLEX PROGRAM REALLY AGAIN TRYING TO PROGRAM REALLY AGAIN TRYING TO CREATE A REALLY CONVENIENT CAR CREATE A REALLY CONVENIENT CAR FREE ENVIRONMENT WITHIN THE CITY FREE ENVIRONMENT WITHIN THE CITY OF DUNEDIN. OF DUNEDIN. THIS WAS THE ROUTES DURING YOU THIS WAS THE ROUTES DURING YOU KNOW WHEN WE HAD THE FIXED KNOW WHEN WE HAD THE FIXED ROUTE, THE ONE ON THE LEFT IS ROUTE, THE ONE ON THE LEFT IS THE OFFSEASON ROUTE SO THAT IS THE OFFSEASON ROUTE SO THAT IS WHEN SPRING TRAINING WAS NOT -- WHEN SPRING TRAINING WAS NOT -- WAS NOT IN SEASON THERE. WAS NOT IN SEASON THERE. AND THEN THE ROUTE ON THE AND THEN THE ROUTE ON THE RIGHT-HAND SIDE YOU SEE IT RIGHT-HAND SIDE YOU SEE IT ACTUALLY GOES TO TD BALLPARK ACTUALLY GOES TO TD BALLPARK DURING THE SPRING TRAINING DURING THE SPRING TRAINING MONTHS, AND AGAIN, BOTH OF THOSE MONTHS, AND AGAIN, BOTH OF THOSE ROUTES, YOU KNOW REALLY ROUTES, YOU KNOW REALLY DEFINITELY PROVED TO DRIVE HIGH DEFINITELY PROVED TO DRIVE HIGH RIDERSHIP DURING THOSE MONTHS. RIDERSHIP DURING THOSE MONTHS. AND THEN ESPECIALLY DURING THE AND THEN ESPECIALLY DURING THE SPRING TRAINING WE HAD REALLY SPRING TRAINING WE HAD REALLY MASSIVE RIDERSHIP THERE. MASSIVE RIDERSHIP THERE. SO THIS RIDERSHIP ENCOMPASSES SO THIS RIDERSHIP ENCOMPASSES THE FIRST YEAR SO FROM THE FIRST YEAR SO FROM NOVEMBER 1st TO NOVEMBER 1st TO OCTOBER 31st. OCTOBER 31st. THAT'S WHAT THIS DATA RIGHT HERE THAT'S WHAT THIS DATA RIGHT HERE ON THIS PAGE IS SHOWING. ON THIS PAGE IS SHOWING. AGAIN A LITTLE OVER 13,000 AGAIN A LITTLE OVER 13,000 PASSENGERS BASICALLY AVERAGING PASSENGERS BASICALLY AVERAGING ABOUT 2 1/2 PASSENGERS PER RIDE ABOUT 2 1/2 PASSENGERS PER RIDE SO YOU'RE GETTING A LOT OF SO YOU'RE GETTING A LOT OF SHARED RIDES TOGETHER. SHARED RIDES TOGETHER. YOU KNOW, IT LEANED A LITTLE BIT YOU KNOW, IT LEANED A LITTLE BIT MORE FEMALE VERSUS MALE. MORE FEMALE VERSUS MALE. IN TERMS OF APP VERSUS FLAGDOWN, IN TERMS OF APP VERSUS FLAGDOWN, 41 TO 59%. 41 TO 59%. AND WHEN WE FIRST LAUNCHED THIS AND WHEN WE FIRST LAUNCHED THIS PROGRAM, I THINK WHEN WE FIRST PROGRAM, I THINK WHEN WE FIRST DID OUR SIX-MONTH UPDATE IT WAS DID OUR SIX-MONTH UPDATE IT WAS ONLY ABOUT 25, 30% APP USAGE AND ONLY ABOUT 25, 30% APP USAGE AND THE REST WAS FLAGDOWN SO A LOT THE REST WAS FLAGDOWN SO A LOT MORE PEOPLE WERE ACTUALLY USING MORE PEOPLE WERE ACTUALLY USING THE APP TO USE THE SERVICE THERE THE APP TO USE THE SERVICE THERE AND THEN WHEN YOU LOOK AT THE AND THEN WHEN YOU LOOK AT THE DEMOGRAPHICS OF THE RIDERS, DEMOGRAPHICS OF THE RIDERS, AGAIN APP ONLY BECAUSE WE'RE NOT AGAIN APP ONLY BECAUSE WE'RE NOT COLLECTING THAT SPECIFIC DATA COLLECTING THAT SPECIFIC DATA THROUGH FLAGDOWNS OR THROUGH THE THROUGH FLAGDOWNS OR THROUGH THE FIXED ROUTE. FIXED ROUTE. OVER 71% OF YOUR RIDERS WERE OVER 71% OF YOUR RIDERS WERE AGES OVER 51. AGES OVER 51. 15% WERE BETWEEN 35 AND 50 AND 15% WERE BETWEEN 35 AND 50 AND ABOUT 13% WERE BETWEEN 21 AND ABOUT 13% WERE BETWEEN 21 AND 34. 34. SO WHERE WERE PEOPLE RIDING? SO WHERE WERE PEOPLE RIDING? AGAIN, THIS WAS MOSTLY AGAIN, THIS WAS MOSTLY CENTRALIZED WITHIN THE DOWNTOWN CENTRALIZED WITHIN THE DOWNTOWN CORE. CORE. THEN AGAIN DURING THIS NEXT THEN AGAIN DURING THIS NEXT PROGRAM IT WAS DESIGNED TO DRIVE PROGRAM IT WAS DESIGNED TO DRIVE TRAFFIC TO AND FROM THE DOWNTOWN TRAFFIC TO AND FROM THE DOWNTOWN CORE. CORE. SO PEOPLE WERE FREQUENTING THE SO PEOPLE WERE FREQUENTING THE RESTAURANTS, THE BARS, ALL THE RESTAURANTS, THE BARS, ALL THE SHOPPING IN THE AREA, HOTELS SHOPPING IN THE AREA, HOTELS WERE OBVIOUSLY A BIG HOT SPOT WERE OBVIOUSLY A BIG HOT SPOT WITH THE VISITORS USING THE WITH THE VISITORS USING THE SERVICE. SERVICE. THE MARINA IS A HUGE HOT SPOT. THE MARINA IS A HUGE HOT SPOT. THE TD BALLPARK DURING SPRING THE TD BALLPARK DURING SPRING TRAINING SEASON, THE HOSPITAL, A TRAINING SEASON, THE HOSPITAL, A LOT OF THE WORKERS WERE USING IT LOT OF THE WORKERS WERE USING IT TO GET DOWNTOWN FOR LUNCH AND TO GET DOWNTOWN FOR LUNCH AND THEN MEASE. THEN MEASE. THEY'VE BEEN A HUGE, HUGE THEY'VE BEEN A HUGE, HUGE ADVOCATE OF THE PROGRAM. ADVOCATE OF THE PROGRAM. THEY'VE BEEN USING IT SINCE DAY THEY'VE BEEN USING IT SINCE DAY 1. 1. THEY CONTINUE TO USE THE SERVICE THEY CONTINUE TO USE THE SERVICE THERE AND IT'S BIB A REALLY, THERE AND IT'S BIB A REALLY, REALLY GREAT TO YOU KNOW REALLY GREAT TO YOU KNOW CONTINUE TO GIVE THEM THAT CONTINUE TO GIVE THEM THAT QUALITY OF LIFE TO GET THEM OUT QUALITY OF LIFE TO GET THEM OUT OF THE BUILDING THERE INTO THE OF THE BUILDING THERE INTO THE COMMUNITY TO BE ABLE TO COMMUNITY TO BE ABLE TO EXPERIENCE EVERYTHING DUNEDIN EXPERIENCE EVERYTHING DUNEDIN HAS TO OFFER. HAS TO OFFER. ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT. ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT. AGAIN, YOU KNOW WE'RE USING 100% AGAIN, YOU KNOW WE'RE USING 100% ELECTRIC VEHICLES. ELECTRIC VEHICLES. SO THROUGH THAT FIRST YEAR OF SO THROUGH THAT FIRST YEAR OF THE PILOT PROGRAM, WE HAD OVER THE PILOT PROGRAM, WE HAD OVER 18,000 MILES THAT THESE VEHICLES 18,000 MILES THAT THESE VEHICLES TRAVELED AND WE HAVE A TRAVELED AND WE HAVE A CALCULATION THAT WE USE THAT IS CALCULATION THAT WE USE THAT IS THROUGH THE EPA THAT IS ABLE TO THROUGH THE EPA THAT IS ABLE TO TRANSLATE BASED ON USING TRANSLATE BASED ON USING ELECTRIC VEHICLESS VERSUS GAS, ELECTRIC VEHICLESS VERSUS GAS, HOW MUCH CO2 HAS BEEN BEEN ABLE HOW MUCH CO2 HAS BEEN BEEN ABLE TO HAVE TO BE REDUCED WITHIN THE TO HAVE TO BE REDUCED WITHIN THE CITY HERE AND IT'S ABOUT 7.1 CITY HERE AND IT'S ABOUT 7.1 METRIC TONS AND FOR FOLKS THAT METRIC TONS AND FOR FOLKS THAT DO USE THE APP, ON THAT RIDE DO USE THE APP, ON THAT RIDE RECEIPT AFTER THE RIDE EMAIL AND RECEIPT AFTER THE RIDE EMAIL AND EVEN IN THE APP ITSELF YOU EVEN IN THE APP ITSELF YOU ACTUALLY CAN SEE ON A PER RIDE ACTUALLY CAN SEE ON A PER RIDE BASIS HOW MUCH CO2 YOU ARE BASIS HOW MUCH CO2 YOU ARE PREVENTING BY USING THE SERVICE PREVENTING BY USING THE SERVICE RATHER THAN USING THE GAS RATHER THAN USING THE GAS VEHICLE THERE AND IT'S SOMETHING VEHICLE THERE AND IT'S SOMETHING A LOT OF OUR RIDERS CONTINUE TO A LOT OF OUR RIDERS CONTINUE TO TRACK ALONG THE WAY THERE. TRACK ALONG THE WAY THERE. SO SUMMERTIME, YOU KNOW. SO SUMMERTIME, YOU KNOW. SUMMERTIME YOU KNOW AS WE SUMMERTIME YOU KNOW AS WE CONTINUE TO OPERAT THE FIXED CONTINUE TO OPERAT THE FIXED ROUTE DURING THE SUMMER, IT WAS ROUTE DURING THE SUMMER, IT WAS REALLY, REALLY SLOW. REALLY, REALLY SLOW. AND HAD RITERSHIP WAS LOW, AND HAD RITERSHIP WAS LOW, SPECIFICALLY COMPARED TO YOU SPECIFICALLY COMPARED TO YOU KNOW, MANY OF THE OTHER MONTHS KNOW, MANY OF THE OTHER MONTHS WHEN WE WERE OPERATING THIS, SO WHEN WE WERE OPERATING THIS, SO DE SEPTEMBER MEETIC WE CAME IN DE SEPTEMBER MEETIC WE CAME IN HERE AND PROPOSED TRANSITIONING HERE AND PROPOSED TRANSITIONING FROM FIXED ROUTE CIRCULATOR TO A FROM FIXED ROUTE CIRCULATOR TO A ON DEMAND. ON DEMAND. THIS WAS TO BOOST OFFPEAK THIS WAS TO BOOST OFFPEAK RIDERSHIP, PROVIDE ECONOMIC RIDERSHIP, PROVIDE ECONOMIC SUPPORT FOR THE LOCAL BUSINESSES SUPPORT FOR THE LOCAL BUSINESSES TO HELP RESIDENTS COME INTO THE TO HELP RESIDENTS COME INTO THE DOWNTOWN CORE AND REALLY ENHANCE DOWNTOWN CORE AND REALLY ENHANCE LIFE FOR THE RESIDENTS. LIFE FOR THE RESIDENTS. IT WAS REALLY, REALLY CENTERED IT WAS REALLY, REALLY CENTERED AROUND THAT. AROUND THAT. SO IT WAS APPROVED ON THE SO IT WAS APPROVED ON THE SEPTEMBER 19th MEETING. SEPTEMBER 19th MEETING. IT TENDED TO LAUNCH ON IT TENDED TO LAUNCH ON SEPTEMBER 26th BUT SEPTEMBER 26th BUT UNFORTUNATELY WE HAD HURRICANE UNFORTUNATELY WE HAD HURRICANE HELENE SO WE WERE NOT ABLE TO HELENE SO WE WERE NOT ABLE TO LAUNCH THAT UNTIL LAUNCH THAT UNTIL OCTOBER 3rd AND THEN WE HAD OCTOBER 3rd AND THEN WE HAD ANOTHER HURRICANE SO OFFICIALLY ANOTHER HURRICANE SO OFFICIALLY WE DID LAUNCH IT IN OCTOBER BUT WE DID LAUNCH IT IN OCTOBER BUT YOU KNOW WE HAD BUMPS ALONG THE YOU KNOW WE HAD BUMPS ALONG THE ROAD THERE AS WE STARTED TO ROLL ROAD THERE AS WE STARTED TO ROLL OUT THE PROGRAM BUT I THINK YOU OUT THE PROGRAM BUT I THINK YOU KNOW FROM THE RESULTS IN THE KNOW FROM THE RESULTS IN THE RIDERSHIP THAT WE'RE ABLE TO SEE RIDERSHIP THAT WE'RE ABLE TO SEE IT REALLY KIND OF SPEAKS TO THE IT REALLY KIND OF SPEAKS TO THE SUCCESS OF THIS ON DEMAND FLEX SUCCESS OF THIS ON DEMAND FLEX TYPE PROGRAM. TYPE PROGRAM. SO EVEN WITH YOU KNOW HURRICANE SO EVEN WITH YOU KNOW HURRICANE MILTON RIGHT IN THE BEGINNING OF MILTON RIGHT IN THE BEGINNING OF OCTOBER THERE, THE FLEX PROGRAM OCTOBER THERE, THE FLEX PROGRAM WAS ABLE TO INCREASE RIDERSHIP WAS ABLE TO INCREASE RIDERSHIP BASICALLY COMPARING SEPTEMBER BASICALLY COMPARING SEPTEMBER THE MONTH PRIOR FROM US THE MONTH PRIOR FROM US LAUNCHING THAT TO OCTOBER. LAUNCHING THAT TO OCTOBER. IT WAS A 68% IF CREASE. IT WAS A 68% IF CREASE. I MEAN, THAT'S -- INCREASE. I MEAN, THAT'S -- INCREASE. THAT'S MASSIVE INCREASE THERE. THAT'S MASSIVE INCREASE THERE. AND THEN WHEN YOU COMPARE AND THEN WHEN YOU COMPARE OCTOBER TO NOVEMBER BASICALLY OCTOBER TO NOVEMBER BASICALLY TWO FULL MONTHS OF SERVICE TWO FULL MONTHS OF SERVICE COMPARED TO THE PRIOR TWO COMPARED TO THE PRIOR TWO MONTHS, AUGUST, SEPTEMBER, IT MONTHS, AUGUST, SEPTEMBER, IT WAS A 75% INCREASE. WAS A 75% INCREASE. AND THEN NOVEMBER WAS ACTUALLY AND THEN NOVEMBER WAS ACTUALLY THE FIRST MONTH WE WERE ABLE TO THE FIRST MONTH WE WERE ABLE TO LOOK AT YEAR OVER YEAR LOOK AT YEAR OVER YEAR COMPARISONS. COMPARISONS. AND IN 2023 WE WERE OPERATING AND IN 2023 WE WERE

Showing the first 60,000 of 67,195 characters. The full document is at the source.

PRESENT: City Commission: Also Present: CALL TO ORDER DUNEDIN, FLORIDA MINUTES OF THE CITY COMMISSION WORK SESSION DECEMBER 17, 2024 CIT HALL, 737 LOUDEN AVENUE 9:00 A.M. Mayor Maureen "Moe" Freaney, Vice Mayor Jeff Gow, Commissioners Tom Dugard, Steven Sandbergen, and Robert Walker City Manager Jennifer Bramley, City Attorney Jennifer Cowan, City Clerk Rebecca Schlichter, Deputy City Manager Jorge Quintas, Finance Director Les Tyler, Community Development Director George Kinney, Engineer & Assistant Director Utilities & Engineering Clay Watkins, Community Development Project Manager Kathy Gademer, Community Development Planner II Frances Leong Sharp and approximately nine people in the audience. Mayor Freaney called the December 17, 2024, Work Session to order at 9:00 a.m. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE City Attorney Cowan led the Pledge of Allegiance. 1. PRESENTATIONS - None CITIZEN INPUT Mayor Freaney advised now was the time for anyone who wished to speak on a topic that is not already on the agenda. Seeing and hearing no one wishing to speak, Mayor Freaney moved to the next agenda item. 2. CONSENT AGENDA 2.a. Approve the Minutes for the: A. 8/21/2024 Special Meeting B. 10/1/2024 Work Session C. 10/3/2024 Regular Meeting D. 10/8/2024 Emergency Meeting 2.b. Board and Committee Appointments A. Arts and Culture Advisory Committee -Move Ashley Haynes from an alternate to a partial regular term ending 4/1/2026 B. Causeway & lntercoastal Waterway Committee -Move Ron Matuska from an alternate to a partial regular term ending 6/1/2027 C. Public Safety Committee -Reappoint James Hughes to a regular term ending 1/1/2028 D. Social Services Committee -Move Linda Diana from an alternate to a partial regular term ending 5/1/2027 -Move William Couchenour from an alternate to a partial regular term ending 5/1/2027 -Appoint Don Urbahn to a partial regular term ending 5/1/2026 -Appoint Sydney Marks to a partial regular term ending 5/1/2026 2.c. Service Authorization for Kimley Horn and Associates, Inc to update the Citywide Multimodal Transportation Master Plan / Bicycle Pedestrian Master Plan. 2.d. Addendum No. 3 for Bidding and Construction Phase Professional Services to the contract with McKim & Creed, Inc., for Lift Station #32 Rebuild, Not to Exceed (NTE) $101,178. MOTION: Motion was made by Vice Mayor Gow and seconded by Commissioner Walker to approve the Consent Agenda except items 2.c. and 2.d. 24-1

Work Session Minutes December 17, 2024 Public Input Dunedin City Commission Mayor Freaney opened public input on any Consent item. Hearing and seeing no one wishing to speak, Mayor Freaney closed the public input. VOTE: Motion carried unanimously. ITEMS PULLED FROM THE CONSENT AGENDA· 2.c. Service Authorization for Kimley Horn and Associates, Inc to update the Citywide Multimodal Transportation Master Plan/Bicycle Pedestrian Master Plan. Community Development Director Kinney advised: This item is in relation to a Business Plan Initiative that came through the budget process last year. Currently, the City has a 2011 Bicycle/Pedestrian Master Plan that does not necessarily include any policies, goals, action items, contingencies, and so forth. The goal here was to take that plan and create a robust plan including some strategies and actions, mobility strategies, and mapping items to incorporate that back into the Multimodal Master Transportation Plan approved by the Commission in 2021. The representative from Kimley-Horn was present to answer any questions on the scope for that Business Plan Initiative. Commission Questions/Comments Commissioner Sandbergen expressed concern regarding the amount of funding when he has observed that things seem to be working well with the bicycle traffic. Mr. Kinney explained this would be a Citywide plan and would not be limited to the downtown including looking at gaps, connections, and safe routes to school possibilities. It would be a comprehensive look at opportunities to provide safe routes for bikes and pedestrians. In response to the question from Commissioner Walker, Mr. Kinney explained the 2011 Bicycle/Pedestrian Master Plan currently stands alone, as it is not embedded in the Multimodal Master Transportation Plan; it is very bare-bones with no strategies, policies, actions, or goals. Commissioner Dugard commented regarding the concerns for safety, particularly for the Pinellas Trail which the City does not control, and asked how that inability will be addressed to integrate that into a greater sense of safety. Mr. Schneider with Kimley Horn noted the good question and explained both plans are dealing with a partnership with Forward Pinellas, Pinellas County, and FOOT as far as a plan to create those recommendations and strategies Mr. Kinney talked about. Vice Mayor Gow asked the timeline for the update to come before the Commission; Mr. Schneider recalled it was four to six months. MOTION: Motion was made by Commissioner Dugard and seconded by Vice Mayor Gow to approve Consent Agenda item 2.c. Public Input Mayor Freaney opened public input on any Consent item. Hearing and seeing no one wishing to speak, Mayor Freaney closed the public input. · VOTE: Motion carried unanimously. 2.d. Addendum No. 3 for Bidding and Construction Phase Professional Services to the contract with McKim & Creed, Inc., for Lift Station #32 Rebuild, Not to Exceed (NTE) $101,178. Commissioner Walker clarified with Deputy City Manager Quintas the reason for this item is that the City does not have the in-house expertise to do all the bid documents and review the drawings and so forth. 24-2

Work Session Minutes December 17, 2024 Dunedin City Commission Deputy City Manager Quintas provided additional information regarding the previous work with McKim & Creed, Inc. and noted this item is an addendum to the work they have been providing on Lift Station #32 specific to the construction/administration portion when the project goes to construction. Since they are Engineer of Record, they have to certify that those elements of the project constructed by the awarded contractor will meet the permit and design criteria. Discussion ensued regarding the vacancies in Engineering; some have been filled in relation to some of the projects that have been under design for quite some time, and explanation of funding resources that included grants was provided. MOTION: Motion was made by Commissioner Walker and seconded by Commissioner Dugard to approve Consent Agenda item 2.d. Public Input Mayor Freaney opened public input on any Consent item. Hearing and seeing no one wishing to speak, Mayor Freaney closed the public input. VOTE: Motion carried unanimously. 3. ACTION ITEMS 3.a. Freebee Flex Route Annual Contract 12/22/2024 through 12/21/2025 Staff Presentation Community Development Director Kinney introduced Jason Spiegel, BeeFree, LLC Managing Partner, who provided the presentation as follows: It is now past the 1-year mark on the Dunedin Freebee Loop Pilot Program, which they look at as being a big success. The biggest takeaway they believe is they have been able to demonstrate through the program, not only the success in terms of ridership data and so forth, that it has been a benefit to every stakeholder in the community, including residents, visitors, workers, local businesses, the senior community at Mease, and everyone who has been able to benefit from the program. The benefits have not been segmented to one specific demographic. It has been a very successful implementation to the point of elected officials from surrounding communities coming to Dunedin to look at the program and using the service and wanting to implement the same type of service in their communities. Mr. Speigel continued with the presentation covering the data for the past year including the Fixed Route and the 90-day Flex Pilot Program comparison and recommendations to continue to enhance the program going into year two. He thereafter referred to the PowerPoint presentation Service Enhancement Recommendation, Exhibit D, attached to the staffing memo covering the following topics: Program Goals Objectives City of Dunedin Goals Program History In early 2023, Freebee was awarded RFP #23-1217 to operate the Downtown Looper through a 6-month pilot program. The service launched in November 2023 with three vehicles running on the following schedule: Thursday: 11 AM - 10 PM Friday & Saturday: 11 AM - 12 AM Sunday: 11 AM - 7 PM 24-3

Work Session Minutes December 17, 2024 Dunedin City Commission Following the program's initial success, the pilot was extended into the off-season after Spring Training. During this period, the service scaled down to two vehicles operating on a modified schedule: Thursday: 3 PM - 10 PM Friday: 3 PM - 12 AM Saturday: 11 AM - 12 AM Sunday: 11 AM - 7 PM In September 2024, as summer ridership slowed, we launched a 90-day pilot to evaluate the feasibility of an on-demand flex service aimed at providing residents with a convenient, car-free option to access downtown. Fixed Route - Graphics/Maps - Page 4 Off-Season Route In-Season Route Ridership - Graphic - Page 5 Data for the various types of ridership November 1, 2023 - October 31, 2024 Economic Impact - Graphic/Map - Page 6 Where are people riding? Mostly within the downtown core During the select program, it was designed to drive traffic to and from the downtown core Environmental Impact - Details - Page 7 100% Electric Vehicles Summertime Ridership Challenges - Page 8 During the summer months, ridership in the Downtown Core is significantly lower compared to the busier in-season period. To address this, Freebee proposed transitioning from a fixed-route circulator to an on-demand flex model. The primary objectives were to: o Boost off-peak ridership o Provide economic support for local businesses o Enhance the quality of life for residents The Commission approved the pilot program at the September 19th meeting, with an intended launch date of September 26th. However, the program's rollout was delayed until the weekend of October 3rd due to Hurricane Helene. Flex vs. Fixed Route Comparison - Page 9 Despite also facing challenges from Hurricane Milton in October, the Flex program achieved an impressive 68% increase in ridership compared to the previous month. When comparing October and November ridership to the two months prior to the Flex service launch, we saw an increase of over 75%. November provided the first opportunity to compare year-over-year data, revealing: o In 2023: 3 cars operational o In 2024: 2 cars operational, 25% fewer service hours o Despite these reductions, ridership per vehicle increased by an outstanding 21 % 24-4

Work Session Minutes December 17, 2024 Dunedin City Commission Mr. Spiegel noted the service was not meant to take people from house to house or to the grocery store; it is to get people to come into the downtown not using a vehicle; reduce traffic; and spend money at local businesses. Mr. Spiegel commented he thought there could have been much more in terms of marketing the program for getting it out to more residents; as they continue to grow the program, it will continue to drive month over month. There were approximately 13,000 passengers in the first year and they believe with the flex program in year two, it will reach 20,000 to 25,000 passengers, even with reduced service with 2 vehicles. Flex Statistics - Graphic/Map - Page 10 Data for passengers; wait time; user satisfaction; car trips prevented; and percentage of rides started or ended outside the Downtown Core. Data is for October and November and one weekend in December. Data shows this was a very successful implementation of the flex program. Moving Forward - Page 11 Based on the success of the service during its first year and the data collected, we propose the following recommendation: Service Delivery: Option 1: (Recommended Option): On-Demand Service Year Round o *Fixed Route during Spring Training Game Days Option 2: Fixed Route During Peak Season, On-Demand During Non-Peak Option 3: Fixed Route Year Round Mr. Spiegel explained this year would cost less than last year due to having more data and understanding the months when three vehicles are not needed. Peak Service Hours between January 16th through April 14th utilizing three (3) vehicles with hours of operation were as follows: Thursday: 11 am - 10pm Friday/Saturday: 11 am - 12am Sunday: 11 am - 7pm Non-Peak Service Hours between April 15th through January 15th utilizing two (2) Vehicles with hours of operation were as follows: Thursdays - 5pm to 10pm Fridays - 3pm to 12am Saturdays - 11 am to 12am Sundays - 11 am to 7pm Maximum Cost: $219,000 *Opportunity to be reduced under $200,000 with advertising subsidy revenue with Commission direction. The Blue Jays already want to advertise during the month of March, and other advertisers have been reaching out throughout the entire year. Cost Recovery - Page 12 Advertising Sponsorships: Partnering with businesses to display advertisements on the vehicles or in the vehicles to generate additional revenue. 24-5

Work Session Minutes December 17, 2024 Dunedin City Commission Revenue from advertising sponsorships can help offset operational costs. Advertising sponsorship can come from local, regional , and national brands. Grant Opportunities: In-house grant team with extensive experience identifying and assisting our partners in applying for competitive grants 2025 FOOT Grants: Service Development Program+ Innovative Service Staff Presentation Community Development Director Kinney advised Freebee does have a dashboard that collects all the data, which is available to the City to access with Mr. Spiegel's help. He thereafter provided information on the reasons for the staff recommendation: Staff is in line with recommending the flex program, believing that it will reach more Dunedin residents and assure personal vehicle use and that people outside the downtown will have the advantage of using the system if it is positioned as a flex program. Regarding the vehicle miles traveled and the associated carbon emission reduction, which translates into both environmental and real cost savings, it is consistent with the City's Sustainability & Resiliency Policies and Goals. Reduction in the amount of fuel used, vehicle maintenance costs, and traffic congestion. The Looper is consistent with the goals of both the Comprehensive Plan and the Multimodal Transportation Plan as it offers first and last mile micro-mobility options and connects public parking locations and fills gaps to transit stops, schools, and parks. There are opportunities for the Looper to integrate with other potential or future micro solutions including ride-share and bike-share programs if the City decides to move forward with that in the future. The recommendation includes this 1-year contract before the Commission, which is set up such that after a year, the Commission would have the opportunity to extend the contract for four additional 1- year periods. The 1-year contract provides the opportunity for staff to reevaluate the service and bring it to the Commission. There are FOOT grants available, and if approved, staff will aggressively pursue those. The grants are matched at 50% assuming available funding. There will be the ability for future grants as the service continues to grow should the City decide to go in that direction. Additionally, on the funding side, there is an opportunity to recapture some costs through advertising, which would be an item for discussion . There is no app or credit card necessarily needed for those concerned about those items. The service can simply be hailed. The system offers services to no vehicle households and provides service to assisted living facilities in the program area. This service offers ADA service and the ability to service special events. There are possibly some economic development opportunities for some type of outreach for any opportunities to bring costs down. Staff is recommending approval of the contract before the Commission. Questions for Staff Vice Mayor Gow clarified with Mr. Kinney with this 1-year contract, the labels such as "pilot program" are no longer being used. Vice Mayor Gow also clarified on a general basis the 1-year options for this service is more about review and making any changes versus not going forward with the service. 24-6

Work Session Minutes December 17, 2024 Dunedin City Commission Vice Mayor Gow addressed the issue of economic benefit to the downtown with the use of taxpayer dollars, and Mr. Spiegel responded that would be an equation that would have to be done. They do have the data that could be translated to "dollars per head" that shows an economic impact, which is a big part of this program; he elaborated on the various benefits to the downtown businesses, to the City, and to the riders. Mr. Spiegel emphasized their service is not the be-all and end-all solution to economic benefit, but they are a part of it playing a role in driving additional business. Vice Mayor Gow noted the service area remaining as it was for the pilot, which he thought to be too small; he thought a great opportunity was being missed in terms of north Dunedin. Mr. Spiegel explained the number of vehicles play a role in the service area, as does providing a high level of service with people not waiting too long for a ride with a maximum of 15 minutes; possibly there could be an expansion of the flex program based on the data of 6.5 minutes wait time; the City has the ability to make changes, which are easy and at no cost. Vice Mayor Gow expressed disappointment regarding the advertising aspect not moving forward. Mr. Spiegel noted the direction to this point has been to leave the vehicles without advertising in that first year; it would be up to the Commission to give the direction on that revenue sharing, and there are multiple ways of advertising; currently there is free advertising on the app for any local businesses. How the advertising is handled is at the discretion of the City as to the City or BeeFree in terms of the structure. Commissioner Sandbergen inquired if there were any arrangements with the downtown businesses to transport their employees, noting the City encourages them to park away from downtown and maybe not right in front of the shops or restaurants. Mr. Spiegel explained there is no direct program with specific businesses, and he explained the goal is to make sure all the businesses are educated that they have this resource and that they should continue to educate their employees on the service. BeeFree has someone who goes door-to-door to the businesses, and they are provided flyers and marketing materials. Mr. Kinney noted Bee Free also works with the hotels in the area for their guests to be aware of the option. In response to the question from Commissioner Sandbergen and his comments regarding the golf club, Mr. Spiegel commented he thought there is opportunity to expand the outer zone. Mr. Spiegel explained their drivers are local residents and know about the community; they are aware of special events and so forth and they do a tremendous job. The drivers are employees who are paid livable wages and healthcare benefits; they are not independent contractors. Riders are not expected to tip the drivers; the goal is to make sure the drivers make as much money as possible. However, if they are going above and beyond providing great service and someone hands them a tip, that is okay; they are not allowed to solicit tips. The expectation is that it is a free ride. Commissioner Walker referred to the maps on pages 5, 9, and 10 and Mr. Spiegel reviewed the data on those pages. Commissioner Walker recalled that at the last addendum to the contract, he had asked for data on the impact to local business and also requested a proforma for the advertising dollars if the Commission elected to go that route. He explained his disappointment was in not hearing anything about impact to local business, for example Local Tiki Rides, which provides on-demand service. Mr. Spiegel recalled that City Manager Bramley had indicated there was a meeting with Tiki Rides and they put together a full comparison and data of that service. Mr. Kinney advised regarding the meeting with the owners of Tiki Rides, who provided portions of their business model and there was a comparison. Tiki Rides is a singular gas-powered vehicle; it is typically rented out in a charter fashion versus being able to be called on-demand. His understanding was there are three sets of team drivers, and on occasion the service would be disrupted for vacations and so forth. 24-7

Work Session Minutes December 17, 2024 Dunedin City Commission What was seen was they garner most of their rides sort of outside the service area shown here, and it was not necessarily a downtown destination, which he thought could be outside the municipality. As they looked from that perspective, the thinking was that those were two different services providing two different opportunities. City Manager Bramley added to the discussion regarding Tiki Rides , noting the documents they provided which were attached to the agenda item , except for their budget for when this was previously brought to the Commission. There would be an impact on Tiki Rides; it is a share of the market. Staff thought that their geofence is more expansive than Freebee , so there would not be a huge impact on their service ; they were not able to exactly quantify that impact. Commissioner Walker verified with Mr. Spiegel that only one of the vehicles is equipped for ADA ; that is an extra that is fully wheelchair-accessible . The request is done similar to the other vehicles; riders can request for that vehicle through the app or by calling to request additional service . If it is a waving-down situation, the driver will explain he will be right back and switch vehicles and come right back to accommodate them. Commissioner Walker inquired regarding the possibil ity of advertising and the staff recommendation to seemingly keep the 50/50 revenue share. Mr. Spiegel stated it is a lot of work; they have a full dedicated team that has contact with all the agencies and businesses ; however, if the City wanted to take that on , they would be amenable to amend ing that contract. Commissioner Walker commented regarding the comments of reducing the cost, which is to the General Fund , and he expressed concern for the amount. Mr. Spiegel explained the figure was based on an estimated $40,000 worth of advertising through the year at minimum . Mr. Kinney explained regarding grants; those can be up to three years. Mr. Spiege l explained the City has to submit for the grant ; BeeFree has an in-house grant writing team that works hand-in-hand with many of their municipalities; they are familiar with these grants and what needs to be included. Mr. Spiegel explained regarding the businesses that there are endorsements , and there was no survey. They have an economic development team in the City monthly, which is meeting with local businesses and helping with ads, promotions, and so forth; that is done consistently throughout the year. Commissioner Dugard verified with Mr. Kinney that ARPA funded this program for the initial six-month pilot. Commissioner Dugard requested the data for the number of Dunedin residents who have downloaded the app. Mr. Spiegel will provide that at a later date, noting City staff has been provided with a data dashboard with access to all the data and they can add that specific information to the dashboard to be available at all times. Commissioner Dugard inquired regarding increasing capacity in re lation to the success of the program, and Mr. Sp iegel elaborated on various ways they can work with the City to reduce wait times. In response to the question from Commissioner Dugard, Mr. Spiegel explained these vehicles do not have air conditioning ; they have been providing the service for 12 years in Florida, and in the beginning it was a novelty, and in many areas, they have proved that on-demand select service is a much more efficient way to move people than fixed-route ; in other areas , fixed-route makes more sense . Mayor Freaney referred to past discussions including comments that the City is taking on the job of the Pinellas Suncoast Transit Authority (PSTA) with General Fund money and the question of whether or not that is what the City should be doing. Mr . Kinney responded he thought this is the next step to what the City gets from PSTA. PSTA has a fixed route that goes to certain fi xed stations ; if they are not convenient for the ridership, then they are stuck or 24-8

Work Session Minutes December 17, 2024 Dunedin City Commission they are not taking that route. This provides the option of coming off the bus station and hailing the Freebee or using the app to get to their destination in more convenient way. This is giving more personal service in that last piece of a destination. Local drivers are an important aspect. Mr. Speigel gave the example of the St. Pete Beach experience eliminating the fixed-route system and the success of Freebee. It comes down to the community and what the residents want. Mayor Freaney noted the question of why the City would do this for free on the government funding versus everyone just using something like Uber. Mr. Kinney spoke to the Uber question, noting that is usually for longer trips and the pick-up time will be more than 4 to 6 minutes and there will be a cost. He does not know that business model; however, he thought that would be younger ridership, probably not senior citizens and those on fixed incomes. He thought there was more advantage with this first and last mile service not found with less personal and more expensive Uber-type trips. Mr. Speigel emphasized the importance of public transit and the totally different type of service with different types of customers. Freebee provides a public transit service that operates in a very innovative way that actually drives high ridership. Mr. Kinney advised regarding grants; should the amount asked not be granted, staff will come back to the Commission for review; staff will constantly be looking at it. Mayor Freaney expressed concern regarding the advertising on the vehicles as to the types of companies and so forth. Mr. Spiegel explained the Commission would have approval on the client and the creative advertising before it would be put on the vehicle; that is how they work with all the cities. Mayor Freaney asked whether there are any limits if there is an agreement to do advertising; are there any issues of free speech to consider once the City provides advertising in terms of control of what is or is not allowed on the vehicle? City Attorney Cowan stated there would be some restrictions and she would want to research that more in the specific context. In response to the question from Mayor Freaney about ADA accessibility other than wheelchairs, Mr. Speigel explained most foldable walkers and even foldable wheelchairs will fit on the regular vehicles, but the ADA vehicle is available and staff is fully trained to provide that type of service. Mr. Dugard asked should the Commission decide not to move forward with this contract, who would be most likely to complain about the loss of the service, tourists or residents? Mr. Speigel thought it would be a little from everyone and that what they have seen over the years is every stakeholder using the service. Public Input Mayor Freaney opened the item to public input. Tiffany Potter - Tiki Rides stated she thought there was a misunderstanding with the meeting with the City they had in that they assumed Tiki Rides is a Charter business, which is not what they do. They started out offering rides in Dunedin without a fee on the weekends; they ran Friday, Saturday, and Sunday; they then took off Sunday because there were no riders. Then they did Thursday, Friday, and Saturday, and they had to drop Thursday for the lack of riders, so they run Friday and Saturday. Charters are a side business during the week; typically, they do not do those on the weekend unless it is during the summer. Their main service was to provide people covering the Dunedin zip code transport to downtown, but they will take people anywhere in Dunedin. Charters are not their main business . They have been hurt by Freebee coming into town; the flex route obviously more than the fixed route because in downtown Dunedin, it is pretty walkable. They don't get calls from the Fenway anymore except on big groups like weddings or from Bon Appetit, like they used to get constantly. They have survived. 24-9

Work Session Minutes December 17, 2024 Dunedin City Commission Father Bob Swick commented with regard to Freebee, he thought they had done a fine job and welcomed them to the community. He hopes the Commission is comfortable with recognizing this as a good asset to the community, in particular to the residents who are confined with Mease being an example. Hearing and seeing no one else wishing to speak, Mayor Freaney closed the public input. Commission Comments Commissioner Walker made the following comments: He did not like the deal as currently written. It would be more palatable if it did not include on-demand service. He does not particularly like the other two options , which gives the appearance of painting the City into a corner; however, if they are choosing, it would be for Option 2, which provides the on-demand service in off-peak season. There are several other things he is uncomfortable with. He would have liked to have heard the Freebee services were complimentary to what the local business is providing. Regarding economic impact being measured through ridership, it is a good metric, but he talked to five businesses and not one could say they saw any impact with regard to the Freebee operation. From a business perspective, the numbers might be there and might be something that can be measured; however, they were not available for this hearing. As part of the deal, he is uncomfortable with the expense and more so as a General Fund expense. After experiencing two historic hurricanes and dealing with substantial damage and people out of their homes, he noted this is $219,000 out of the General Fund. In reference to the PSTA, he sits on the Board and knows their service to Dunedin; the City's spend on that is minimal, so people are getting to the downtown through public transportation. Also, there is Uber and Lyft. He owns one car and a golf cart; Uber and Lyft are his third option and they do have ADA. The optic of this is that the City is subsidizing a business that is not a local business to deliver a service that is detrimental to local business. He has two caveats in summary of what he does believe; he would like to take the on-demand out knowing about the Mease Life ridership that is part of the fixed route, not the on-demand. The other component is the ADA compliance. He has struggled from day one and he does not like the deal the way it is structured and thinks there are things that can make the deal better. Commissioner Dugard made the following comments: He too struggled with this decision for a number of reasons; he sees its prospects and potential and an added feature to the community that makes a better host to tourists and visitors. He also sees the competitive issue with the local business. He does see that transportation is in a revolution right now in almost all forms. For him, it gets down to the dollars and cents; he agreed the City will probably reprioritize a number of things in the next few years because of the devastation experienced, which he thought might take priority over these types of projects; however, that is unknown at this time. He is not sure this is the highest priority at this time. Vice Mayor Gow made the following comments: With PSTA , the City does pay for the Ferry service and the Jolley Trolley; even though those are PSTA transportation modes, they are above what the taxpayers are paying for public transit. He thought that whether or not this is a business that PSTA should be providing remains to be seen; it is not currently 24-10

Work Session Minutes December 17, 2024 Dunedin City Commission in their business model. PSTA is in the middle of a culture change as well, as he thinks society is, and he wonders how PSTA will react to micro-transit. There does need to be a measure of economic impact somehow because it is about dollars and cents. It is difficult if it cannot be done with the Looper service; with the on-demand, it can be extrapolated to road maintenance, environmental impacts with the reduction of car emissions and so forth, and any money the City can save residents there is not necessarily saving, but the opportunity to spend in the downtown. He sees it as a transfer of funds; the City pays for this to give residents the opportunity to spend that money they would spend otherwise. In terms of the culture change, no one knows where it will end up. The challenge he has always had with the Looper is that the downtown has always been walkable and the City has been proud of that. Then it is offering free rides and people do want a ride; it's a free ride. He goes to his concerns for discouraging people getting exercise. He noted the health insurance companies offering discounts for exercise. He does understand with the on-demand there has to be a destination point. He does question the wait time and how that is being measured. If he understood correctly, the flex time would not be done during Spring Training because there is more business downtown for the Looper service; he would like to see somehow not getting rid of that on- demand service. To him, that is the meat on the bone that validates everything else. At this time, he is in support because of the on-demand and it is a change in culture. The residents need to be allowed the time to understand the benefits of leaving their car at home. This is an opportunity to show it is not true we have to have a car. We are still trying to find out where it is going with the multimodal transportation and it is not anti-car; it is giving people options. The more the citizens are given the opportunity to choose their own methods of mobility, the better off the community is as whole. He wished to strongly focus on the on-demand and measurement. Commissioner Sandbergen related his personal positive experience with the Freebee and made the following comments: He does have a problem with neighboring subdivisions and communities that do not get the benefit of the Freebee while they are being asked to help pay for something specified to such a small geographical part of town. He thought it would be good to be able to get to Publix or the golf club or Community Center in the routes. He wished there was a way to include the entire community. Today he was not sure of his feeling for the future of the Freebee. Mayor Freaney made the following comments: The original goal was to help downtown parking and she has had concerns about the looper aspect, although she has liked the on-demand piece. She thinks there have been some additional benefits, including for Mease Life; however, she related her experience meeting some ladies who were just going to ride around, which was not part of the goal. But it is Dunedin and the quality of life and people who otherwise would not be able to get out. She agrees with wanting to expand citywide; however, there should be baby steps, noting that it is General Fund money and not just ARPA, which is of concern with huge other demands with basic infrastructure and other important projects. She does agree with understanding the impact to the businesses in the City in terms of economic impact; she was surprised there were not more businesses in attendance as there were previously, who were very positive about the service. 24-11

Work Session Minutes December 17, 2024 Dunedin City Commission She referred to comments regarding safety and the many uses in that regard. Tiki Rides does an awesome job. She does think there is room for both and expressed appreciation for some of the loss to Tiki Rides. This item was bid to talk about availability, how many vehicles, ADA accessibility and so forth; many things were included in the bid. She is also uncomfortable about the expense now that it has moved to the General Fund; getting the grant is critical to getting it down to $110,000 and possible other ways to offset the cost. In her mind, this is still a pilot, an ongoing experiment, and they are continuing to learn and grow and understand. Included is not having a negative effect on the General Fund by this, which is just a piece of the puzzle and going back to the original goal of parking issues and the extremely high cost of parking spaces. She personally thinks getting the grant and bringing it down to $110 ,000 is a reasonable amount of money to continue the experiment for another year and to continue to data mine to have a better understanding of all the numbers, impacts on business, and so forth to determine if the cost/benefit really is there. She does support this on the basis of keeping the experiment going for a year and learning about solving the original problem that will save much more than $100,000. She thinks it is in sync with the Comprehensive Plan and Sustainability efforts and lnclusivity. MOTION: Motion was made by Vice Mayor Gow and seconded by Commissioner Dugard to approve the Freebee Flex Route Annual Contract (Exhibit A). Vice Mayor Gow and Commissioner Dugard reiterated their previous comments, concerns, and support or lack of support for the motion. Commissioner Walker suggested an amendment to the motion to remove the on-demand piece out of the contract; six months of payment with a caveat that in six months the Commission decides based on the status of the grant and have a clear projection on the economic impact and advertising. In response to the question from Mayor Freaney, City Attorney Cowan reviewed the contract, noting it says the City has the right at any time without cause to provide 90 days advance notice of intent to terminate. Vice Mayor Gow agreed to amend his motion continuing to include on-demand; he could not support just the Looper service; and if possible, if the grant is not awarded. it comes back to the Commission. Commissioner Walker could not support those amendments. Vice Mayor Gow let his motion stand. Commissioner Sandbergen stated his lack of support because of not knowing whether or not the grant will be awarded and when if so. He verified the current contract is up in December. Mayor Freaney commented the cost of not continuing the experiment is greater than the cost to stop it, and then to restart is too expensive. She agreed the grant is important; however, clearly in the contract there is the ability to change if it is not awarded and give the 90-day notice. VOTE: Motion carried 3-2 with Commissioners Dugard and Gow and Mayor Freaney voting aye. Voting nay : Commissioners Sandbergen and Walker. Commission Consensus: The Commission gave direction to staff to research the advertising aspect of the Freebee as a revenue source to be brought back under City Manager 's Update. BREAK approx. 11: 10 A.M. - 11 :25 A.M. As a new Commissioner, Commissioner Dugard declared during the break he commented to a colleague that next year they would be tougher on this item. 24-12

Work Session Minutes December 17, 2024 3.b. The proposed agenda for January 7, 2025, Work Session Dunedin City Commission Mayor Freaney inquired if there were any changes to the January 7, 2025, Work Session agenda. MOTION: Motion was made by Commissioner Sandbergen and seconded by Commissioner Walker to approve the proposed agenda for the January 7, 2025, Work Session. VOTE: Motion carried unanimously. 4. WORKSHOP ITEMS 4.a. Historic Preservation Ordinance Update and Certificate of Appropriateness (COA) Matrix Update Staff Presentation Community Development Planner II Sharp referred to a PowerPoint presentation and advised: This item is an update to the Historic Preservation Ordinance and the Certificate of Appropriateness (COA) for feedback, comments, and direction from the City Commission. Historic preservation in the City goes back to 2003 through 2015; there were discussions indicating the interest from the community for a historic preservation program to be put in place. The timeline indicates the results of a workshop with direction from the Commission to move forward with a new ordinance, and then up to 2018 there is the ordinance in place today. From 2019 to the present, after the ordinance was adopted as well as the COA matrix afterwards, a few applications have come forward for the landmark designation as well as more work and projects done by the Historic Preservation Advisory Committee (HPAC). One of the things brought forward was the suggestion to update the ordinance for more clarity and a thought to potentially create a district and more clear language into the ordinance to be more user-friendly. Blair Knighting with Kimley-Horn and Associates advised: They have been working on this for a while with quite a few workshops with the HPAC to understand what they wanted from this ordinance, which was not tailored for Dunedin and not how Dunedin typically does their noticing. They wanted to rewrite the ordinance to make sure it was easy and user-friendly. The current ordinance has the Commission approving a lot of aspects with a lot of work. What they heard was to take some of that from the Commission and put it on City staff and the HPAC. They rewrote the approval matrix for the COA to be clearer as to who reviews what; also, they made an easy flow chart and updated the actual ordinance. A significant action in light of the matrix is giving more decision-making capabilities on the HPAC, removing them as an advisory committee to become the Historic Preservation Committee (HPC) and being a decision maker, not just advisory. They also added definitions due to some confusion, including what a landmark is and what a landmark site is. An example is the Marina could be the landmark site versus a landmark that would be the whole parcel. They added the ability to have a Historic District, which the City did not have previously. Many municipalities throughout the state have local historic districts, which was an ask of the HPAC. The notice requirement was updated because it was not very clear and did not follow the procedures as rezoning and so forth. The landmark designation process was cleaned up in terms of housekeeping items. They also included a requirement that COAs require a pre-application with staff. They wanted to talk about the matrix, there is staff review, HPAC review, and the City Commission is essentially reviewing demolition, landmarks, and so forth. 24-13

Work Session Minutes December 17, 2024 Dunedin City Commission They wanted to add language for mitigation for when a property is not a landmark, clarifying that language due to some prominent demolitions seen recently. They wanted to make sure they were not stopping demolition but mitigating by taking pictures, documenting the building, etc.; the Commission has the ability to direct staff or HPAC to do that. Flow charts shown indicate a simple way for staff and the applicant to understand the process more clearly than just reading the ordinance. Ms. Knighting commented these are tools in the toolbox; adding historic districts to the ordinance might be new, which is essentially a tool for preservation and does not have to be activated or used. If the ordinance change is supported, there is that tool, for which there is none currently . Commission questions, comments, and concerns were addressed to include: To come up with the methodology for the GOA Matrix, Kimley-Horn worked with the HPAC to determine what they were comfortable approving and reviewing. St. Pete Beach has an approval matrix very similar that was used. They also wanted to be sure big-ticket items like landmarks and demolitions still come to the Commission, but keep the minutiae in with staff and the HPAC being the subject matter experts. Ms. Sharp provided an explanation of the Certificate of Appropriateness (GOA) in relation to improvements to homes with a historic designation. Concern for many questions associated with the designation of Historic Districts. Benefits of historic designation currently were addressed. Ms. Knighting explained the responsibilities of structures within a historic district that are not designated historic. She also provided details of requirements for becoming a historic district and gave an example. A historic district has to be contiguous, and usually it is the majority of the buildings within it that are contributing. Ms. Knighting spoke regarding the National Parks Service/Department of the Interior standards. Ms. Knighting explained regarding the phasing as shown in the PowerPoint and the surveys done. Concerns were expressed regarding moving forward for protecting the rights of homeowners and making sure the Commission is protecting those rights while at the same time protecting historic structures like the Kellogg Mansion, which was lost. Ms. Knighting explained the mortgage documents and deed restrictions at the time of purchase provide the information on the local historic district. It should be a disclosure from the real estate agent as well. Also, some municipalities check the Property Appraiser every 30 days and send out letters to new homeowners regarding being in a historic district, so that can be a process change to ensure those notices go out. Regarding the HPAC going to a decision-making committee, the HPC would have the review of the GOA rather than the City Commission; there is also a staff review that does not rise to the level of the HPC. Ms. Sharp explained the COAs were coming before the Commission, and after each approval the Commission asked when the ordinance was going to change because those were issues that could be reviewed by staff, so the change was in response to the Commission direction. The historical and cultural perspective was noted, as well as the economic factors of historic designations or historic districts. Significant concern was expressed regarding affordability and the market pressure on homes, especially for the working class in Dunedin. The question was posed as to the demographic of the homes in the historic districts, which Ms. Knighting addressed by providing examples and noting the diversity can still be preserved. 24-14

Work Session Minutes December 17, 2024 Dunedin City Commission In terms of the members of the committee, the qualifications are listed in the resolution; the Commission appoints the members, which would continue. Concern was expressed that the Commission review, though burdensome for the homeowner for the COA, is a level of protection for the rest of the community having the Commission approval. Discussion ensued with an explanation of the "Contiguous" and "Contributing" and "Non-Contiguous" structures in terms of a street that is a historic district that has newer homes, for example a pocket of new townhomes. Currently in the ordinance, the 60% is for private ownership, and in commercial and multifamily the designation is 100%, which can be a topic of discussion and at the discretion of the Commission. City Attorney Cowan explained in residential districts, the only permissible use is residential whereas in some other districts surveyed, those could have a commercial use or a multifamily use. The thought was not to restrict which use in commercial or multifamily and becoming a historic district without all of the owners being in agreement. Discussion ensued regarding these issues. It was clarified regarding what would be the HPC approving the COA; that is looking only at the exterior alterations. It was noted there needed to be clarification in the matrix regarding for the non-contributing that staff can review the COAs for the checks and balances in a historic district in terms of a non-contributing doing something out of scale with the rest of the neighborhood. That is in terms of rebuilding or a remodel. It was noted to begin the process it could be someone in the neighborhood, the City Manager, or the HPC with the question of being more grassroots and not forcing the issue unless there is some unique reason. Ms. Knighting explained the importance of being grassroots and first having community buy-in, and that is usually how it works; however, there are always situations that might come up and there should be the ability in those unique situations that are really important to the culture and heritage of the City to protect those. Public Input Mayor Freaney opened the item to public input. Deborah Kynes, Chair of HPAC commented: This has been a two-year process and this comes to the Commission first as a workshop, not straight to the Local Planning Agency (LPA) and then the Commission. It is complex and there can be clarifications, discussion, and compromise. The actual goal is to add new tools and make the COA much more amenable and user-friendly. She questioned if the Commission really wanted requests to come to the dais, for example to replace a fence with a historical looking fence. Some things should be handled by staff and then some would come to the HPAC/HPC; it could always go on to the Commission for checks and balances; there are many included in the proposal with the assistance of City Attorney Cowan protecting the interest of the Commission. In bringing the new historic districts in, they are trying to do the next right thing and to do it correctly with full participation, citizen input, and beginning with the Commission. Regarding the COAs, they also looked at Fernandina Beach. Vinnie Luisi, City Historian commented: The intent with this is to be completely transparent to everyone. They are not trying to have someone buy a home and then take their personal interests in their home away. They are here to instruct people 24-15

Work Session Minutes December 17, 2024 Dunedin City Commission as to what they are trying to do, to explain what is in the document. The website will also be there to help explain what it is all about. The intent is not to take over a community and make sure it becomes historic for the needs of the City or the people individually who want that; it is to provide the interest of saving Dunedin's history, but also working with the members and homeowners in that community. Ryan Saunders of 250 Lyndhurst Street commented: He lives in a 1940s historic house and they are interested in restoring it and maintaining it. His most notable concern is hearing about this being voluntary; however, Section 111-1.7 Designation of Local Historic Districts grants the HPC and City Manager the ability to designate a historic district without the 60% rule. It was said there is a reason to do that sometimes; however, that is someone telling him what they can do with his house and what he can do, and it also affects affordability within that area. Section 111-1. 7- D.8. outlines restrictive policies occurring homeowners in historic districts to undergo that COA process before making any property changes. He might be in that 40% that did not want to be in a historic district or the City Commission or City Manager said they were going to make him in a historic district, and now he is responsible to go through a COA process for anything that is going to be showing on the curb level of his home. He thinks about the vulnerability to hurricanes; these regulations pose a lot of risk to homeowners aiming to strengthen their homes against future homes and undertake that post-disaster repair. That cost is going to be exponentially higher in a historic district. This is why he thinks it is placing unnecessary administrative burdens on the HPC, the committee's part of this; this time-consuming review process will be at the time when people are at their worst, which is after a storm. Many of the homes in the City were affected by floods that are shown in this phasing of the historic districts. He thinks it is important to consider a process that keeps some of these code changes, but to get rid of the historic district, which he thinks is not needed as a unilateral authority that is going to be given to the HPC that does not require that 60% to regulate these districts without the homeowner's approval. The program really should remain generally voluntary. He had more questions he would leave with the City Clerk for the Commission. Paul Gionis of 159 Beltrees Street commented: He bought a 1939 Bungalow and he loves old houses and does not like changing them. They wanted a new house that looked old, ready for hurricanes, and fit the style. He referred to the portions of Section 111-1. 7 that goes around the 60% requirement for homeowners; For applications initiated by property owners in a residential historic district, a petition signed by at least 60% of the property owners within the proposed historic district must accompany an application. It does not say anything about the HPC, which did not happen by accident. Whoever drafted it for whatever reason was so the public could not have a say in what happens to their homes. He expressed concern for the situation with the hurricanes and needing for example new windows, but someone may not like the new windows. There is a section addressing there is no need for the COA if it is a life-threatening situation. He will send emails and support with documentation to the Commission and provide his legal analysis. An eComment was submitted by Ryan Saunders: regarding Document A ... 111-1. 7 reads: The process may be initiated by aproperty owner within the proposed district, by the HPC, or by the City Manager. For applications initiated by property owners in 24-16

Work Session Minutes December 17, 2024 Dunedin City Commission a residential historic district, a petition signed by at least 60% of the property owners within the proposed historic district must accompany an application. For applications initiated by property owners in a multi-family or commercial historic district, a petition signed by all the property owners within the proposed historic district must accompany an application. This currently reads that ONLY applications submitted by property owners will require 60% of property owners to sign. If this is initiated by the HPC or City Manager that is NOT required. My understanding from the meeting with the HPC on 12112 is that this is a mistake and it is the intention of the HPC is to ensure the 60% property owner approval applies as well to HPC or City Manager initiated applications as well. An eComment was submitted by Ryan Saunders: During the HPC meeting on December 12 it was stated that any home inside of a history district would not have to follow the rules, unless they applied for their individual house to be included, however the language today does not reflect that it states .. . Any ordinance designating a historic district shall set forth the historic district design regulations that apply to the historic district. These regulations would then become the Historic District Design Regulations for that historic district. Modifications to any structure within the designated historic district shall follow the GOA procedures in Sec. 111. 1. 8 below. My understanding from the meeting December 12 is that this is a mistake and it is NOT the intention of the HPC to apply restrictions to every home, only those that apply. Can this be corrected to reflect the intentions of the HPC Please see all questions provided to the HPC on Dec 12 and Dec 13. Hearing and seeing no one else wishing to speak, Mayor Freaney closed the public input. Response to Public Input Regarding repairs in a historic district in the situation of storms and the recent waiver of the City's waiver of the 5-year look back for the FEMA 50% rule: Ms. Knighting explained in the ordinance right now, if it is repair and maintenance, there does not have to be a COA as long as it is shown that it is just a repair. She thought State statutes protect the homeowner highly after a storm in terms of building permits; however, she was not sure and will research to answer that question. Staff having the ability to review many of these issues helps the homeowner. In response to the questions from Commissioner Sandbergen at this time, Ms. Sharp related some reasons why a homeowner would want to be part of a historic district and why not; she went through the process and clarification of the COA application by the individual homeowner, not a neighbor, City Manager or HPC, which would only be for a historic district; the City Commission has the final vote. City Manager Bramley explained City staff would be looking for consensus direction should the Commission want anything in the ordinance to be modified or brought back for consideration. Commission Additional Summary Comments Commissioners reiterated their comments and concerns as previously stated and requested the following: More information on historic districts with structures destroyed/damaged by a hurricane. Give consideration of property rights concerns and possibly going too far, and the suggestion that there has to be a threshold more than a majority opinion and for the City to not be unilaterally making this type of impactful decision. Address concerns regarding neighbors by a vote of 60% telling other neighbors what they can and cannot do in this type of issue. Information on the economic impact on the housing market/community as whole by a historic district in another part of the City. Recommendation for a change in the language, for example, for "Non-Contributing," Non-Participating might be better 24-17

Work Session Minutes December 17, 2024 Dunedin City Commission City Manager Bramley explained moving forward would be going before the Local Planning Agency (LPA} and then first reading of an ordinance before the City Commission. She thought staff would have to caucus and bring something back to the Commission as far as the bar discussed and talk with the HPAC. It is an important enough point to make sure of the Commission's buy-in before moving to the LPA. 4.b. Eligible ARPA City Projects/Initiatives Update Staff Presentation Finance Director Tyler advised that Ryan Vergara, Senior Fiscal Advisor with Witt O'Brien's, a consultant the City has worked with on the ARPA Fund, was attending via Zoom to answer any questions. He noted on April 16, 2024, staff presented an ARPA Update to the Commission, and this is a follow-up to that discussion as to where the projects are today and moving forward. He thereafter referred to the PowerPoint presentation, American Rescue Plan Act (ARPA) Update, Exhibit D attached to the staffing memo. American Rescue Plan Act (ARPA) Overview • Signed into law March 11, 2021 • $1.9 Trillion aid package that provides financial aid to families, governments, businesses, schools, non- profits & others impacted by COVID-19 public health crisis, including: • $350 Billion for State and Local Governments Fiscal Recovery Fund State & Local Governments Fiscal Recovery Fund: Overview • Title IX- Committee on Finance (Dept. of Treasury) • Subtitle M - Coronavirus State and Local Fiscal Recovery Fund • Provides $350 billion for state and local governments • Cities and Counties: $130.2 billion • Pinellas County: $189.3 million allocation • City of Dunedin: $18.3 million allocation • Grant funding will be released in two payments: • First payment was October 2021 - $9.145 Million • Second payment was August 2022 - $9.145 Million • Funds must be incurred/obligated by December 31, 2024; December 31, 2026 is the period of performance end date - deadlin

1. PRESENTATIONS 2. CONSENT AGENDA 2.a Approve the Minutes for the: A. 8/21/2024 Special Meeting B. 10/1/2024 Work Session C. 10/3/2024 Regular Meeting D. 10/8/2024 Emergency Meeting 2.b Board and Committee Appointments NOTICE OF PUBLIC MEETING CITY COMMISSION WORK SESSION DUNEDIN CITY HALL, 737 LOUDEN AVENUE DECEMBER 17, 2024 9:00 AM AGENDA CALL TO ORDER PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE CITIZEN INPUT Staff recommends to approve the minutes for the meetings identified above. EXHIBIT: A. 08-21-24 SM Minutes.pdf EXHIBIT: B. 10-01-24 WS Minutes.pdf EXHIBIT: C. 10-03-24 RM Minutes.pdf EXHIBIT: D. 10-08-24 EM Minutes.pdf A. Arts and Culture Advisory Committee - Move Ashley Haynes from an alternate to a partial regular term ending 4/1/2026 B. Causeway & Intercoastal Waterway Committee - Move Ron Matuska from an alternate to a partial regular term ending 6/1/2027 C. Public Safety Committee - Reappoint James Hughes to a regular term ending 1/1/2028 D. Social Services Committee - Move Linda Diana from an alternate to a partial regular term ending 5/1/2027 - Move William Couchenour from an alternate to a partial regular term ending 5/1/2027 - Appoint Don Urbahn to a partial regular term ending 5/1/2026 - Appoint Sydney Marks to a partial regular term ending 5/1/2026 EXHIBIT: A. ACAC Roster.pdf EXHIBIT: B. CCWC Roster.pdf EXHIBIT: C. PSC Roster.pdf 1

2.c Service Authorization for Kimley Horn and Associates, Inc to update the Citywide Multimodal Transportation Master Plan / Bicycle Pedestrian Master Plan. 2.d Addendum No. 3 for Bidding and Construction Phase Professional Services to the contract with McKim & Creed, Inc., for Lift Station #32 Rebuild, Not to Exceed (NTE) $101,178. 3. ACTION ITEMS 3.a Freebee Flex Route Annual Contract 12/22/2024 through 12/21/2025 3.b The proposed agenda for the January 7, 2025, Commission Meeting. 4. WORKSHOP ITEMS 4.a Historic Preservation Ordinance Update and Certificate of Appropriateness (COA) EXHIBIT: D. SSC Applicant Packet.pdf Staff recommends authorizing Deputy City Manager Quintas to execute Service Authorization M-1-25 with Kimley-Horn and Associates, Inc. for updates to the Citywide Multimodal Transportation Master Plan / Bicycle Pedestrian Master Plan at a not-to-exceed cost of $75,000.00. EXHIBIT: A. Kimley-Horn Service Authorization M-1-25 Bike Ped Master Plan.pdf EXHIBIT: B. FY 2025 BPI Bike Ped Master Plan.pdf EXHIBIT: C. fy-2025-adopted-budget Bike - Ped $75000.pdf EXHIBIT: D. 2024 1206 Finance Memo to CM re KH.pdf Approval of Addendum No. 3 to the agreement with McKim & Creed, Inc., of Clearwater, FL, for Bidding and Construction Phase Professional Services related to the Lift Station #32 Rebuild Project, in an amount NTE $101,178. EXHIBIT: A. LS 20 & LS 32 Rebuild WO - Addendum No. 3.pdf EXHIBIT: B. LS 20 & LS 32 McKim and Creed Scope and Fee.pdf EXHIBIT: C. LS 20 & LS 32 Rebuild WO - Addendum No. 1.pdf EXHIBIT: D. LS 20 & LS 32 Rebuild WO - Adendum No. 2.pdf EXHIBIT: E. Planning Contract No. H0415 between Dept of Emergency Mgmt & Dunedin EXHIBIT: F. Construction Contract No. H1109 between Dept of Emergency Mgmt & Dunedin Recommend City Commission to approve the Freebee Flex Route Annual Contract (Exhibit A). EXHIBIT: A. 2024 1210 Annual Freebee Contract.pdf EXHIBIT: B. 2024-2025 Beefree COI for Dunedin.pdf EXHIBIT: C. Geo Fenced Service Area Contract Graphic.pdf EXHIBIT: D. Freebee and Dunedin Comparison Report.pdf EXHIBIT: E. Executed 1st, 2nd, 3rd, 4th, and 5th Contract Amendments.pdf EXHIBIT: F. Previous Freebee Loop Budget Impacts.pdf EXHIBIT: G. Freebee Background and City Commission Past Actions.pdf Staff recommends approving the proposed agenda for the January 7, 2025, Commission Meeting. EXHIBIT: A. January 7, 2025 Proposed Agenda.pdf 2

Matrix Update 4.b Eligible ARPA City Projects/Initiatives Update City Commission to discuss, comment and provide direction on whether to move forward with the proposed draft ordinance and COA matrix update for adoption process. EXHIBIT: A. Draft Historic Preservation Ordinance with Blackline EXHIBIT: B. Draft COA Matrix.pdf EXHIBIT: C. Ordinance Review Committee Report 12-14-2021.pdf EXHIBIT: D. City Commission Workshop Meeting Minutes 10-27-2015.pdf EXHIBIT: E. City Commission Workshop Minutes 10-17-2017.pdf EXHIBIT: F. City Commission Meeting Minutes 9-20-2018.pdf EXHIBIT: G. City Commission Meeting Minutes 10-4-2018.pdf EXHIBIT: H. City Commission Meeting Minutes 8-22-2019.pdf EXHIBIT: I. City Commission Meeting Minutes 9-5-2019.pdf EXHIBIT: J. Historic Preservation Advisory Committee Meeting Minutes 4.15.2022.pdf EXHIBIT: K. Historic Preservation Advisory Committee Meeting Minutes 8.10.2023.pdf EXHIBIT: L. Historic Preservation Advisory Committee Meeting Minutes 12.9.2021.pdf EXHIBIT: M. April 18, 2023 City Commission Work Session Minutes.pdf EXHIBIT: N. Historic Preservaiton Advisory Committee Meeting Minutes 5.12.2022.pdf EXHIBIT: O. Historic Preservation Adviosry Committee Meeting Minutes 3.10.2022.pdf EXHIBIT: P. Historic Preservation Advisory Committee Meeting Minutes 1.13.2022.pdf EXHIBIT: Q. Historic Preservation Advisory Committee Meeting Minutes 4.13.2023.pdf EXHIBIT: R. Historic Preservation Advisory Committee Workshop Minutes 8.11.2022.pdf EXHIBIT: S. Historic Preservation Advisory Committee Workshop Minutes 1.12.2023.pdf EXHIBIT: T. Historic Preservation Advisory Committee Training Workshop Minutes 1.7.2022.pdf EXHIBIT: U. Historic Preservation Advisory Committee Workshop Minutes 3.8.2023.pdf EXHIBIT: V. Historic Preservation Advisory Committee Workshop Minutes 7.13.2023.pdf EXHIBIT: W. Historic Preservation Advisory Committee 2022 Annual Report.pdf EXHIBIT: X. Historic Preservation Advisory Committee Annual Report 2023- 2024.pdf EXHIBIT: Y. Historic Preservation Advisory Committee Annual Report 2023.pdf Topic for Discussion EXHIBIT: A. City Projects To Date.pdf EXHIBIT: B. ARPA Project Descriptions.pdf EXHIBIT: C. ARPA Transfer to General Fund EXHIBIT: D. ARPA Presentation.pdf 3

5. INFORMATIONAL ITEMS 5.a Commission Discussion 5.b City Clerk's Update 5.c City Manager's Update 5.d City Attorney's Update 5.e Commission Comments 6. DUNEDIN PUBLIC PARTICIPATION & DECORUM RULES The Commission share topics of concerns or future issues they wish to address. City Clerk's Update City Manager's Update EXHIBIT: A. CM Update Report November 2024.pdf EXHIBIT: B. CM Update Report December 2024.pdf City Attorney's Update The Commission shares events attended, announcements, liaison updates, etc. ADJOURN MEETING Note: Please put cell phones and pagers on silent or vibrate during the meeting. This meeting is televised; therefore, you may appear on TV at any time. Public Appearance: CITIZEN INPUT is for comments from members of the audience regarding items not listed on the agenda for this meeting (please give name and address and limit all comments to a maximum of three minutes). AS FOR ITEMS ON THE AGENDA individual speakers are limited to a maximum of three minutes. A Representative of a group consisting of 5 individuals who are present during the meeting may speak on behalf of the group for up to 10 minutes at the Chair’s discretion. To do so, the individuals must have waived their time to the representative by providing their name and address on the back of the comment card. Appeals: Per Florida Statute 286.0105 - If a person decides to appeal any decision made by the board, agency, or commission with respect to any matter considered at such meeting or hearing, he or she will need a record of the proceedings, and that, for such purpose, he or she may need to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceedings is made, which record includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal is to be based. Disability Provisions: It is the policy of the City of Dunedin not to discriminate against disabled persons in employment or the provisions of services. If you have a disability that requires accommodation, please notify the ADA Coordinator 48 hours prior to the scheduled meeting at (727) 298-3043. COPIES OF THIS AND ALL COMMISSION AGENDAS ARE AVAILABLE TO THE PUBLIC AT THE OFFICE OF THE CITY CLERK, 737 LOUDEN AVENUE, ON THE MONDAY PRIOR 4

TO THE MEETING DATE. COPIES ARE ALSO AVAILABLE ON THE CITY’S WEBSITE AT WWW.DUNEDINGOV.COM. 5

Showing the first 24,000 of 403,396 characters. The full document is at the source.

>> MAYOR >> MAYOR FREANEY: >> GOOD >> GOOD MORNING, >> GOOD MORNING, WELCOME >> GOOD MORNING, WELCOME TO >> GOOD MORNING, WELCOME TO DECEMBER >> GOOD MORNING, WELCOME TO DECEMBER 17th, WELCOME TO DECEMBER 17th, 2024, CITY COMMISSION WORK 2024, CITY COMMISSION WORK SESSION. SESSION. LIKE TO CALL THIS MEETING TO LIKE TO CALL THIS MEETING TO ORDER, SO I'LL OFFICIALLY POUND ORDER, SO I'LL OFFICIALLY POUND THE GAVEL AGAIN. THE GAVEL AGAIN. AND WE'RE GOING TO START WITH AND WE'RE GOING TO START WITH JEN, COULD YOU LEAD US IN THE JEN, COULD YOU LEAD US IN THE PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE. [PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE] [PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE] >> MAYOR FREANEY: WELL, I AM >> WELL, I AM >> WELL, I AM GOING >> WELL, I AM GOING TO >> WELL, I AM GOING TO SAY, >> WELL, I AM GOING TO SAY, CITY >> WELL, I AM GOING TO SAY, CITY MANAGER, >> WELL, I AM GOING TO SAY, CITY MANAGER, IT'S GOING TO SAY, CITY MANAGER, IT'S NICE TO SEE YOU FOLLOWED HOLIDAY NICE TO SEE YOU FOLLOWED HOLIDAY TRADITION AND GAVE US VERY LIGHT TRADITION AND GAVE US VERY LIGHT ITEMS, NO READING, NO HARD WORK ITEMS, NO READING, NO HARD WORK AT THE HOLIDAYS. AT THE HOLIDAYS. >> [OFF MIC] >> [OFF MIC] >> [OFF MIC] >> >> [OFF MIC] >> MAYOR >> [OFF MIC] >> MAYOR FREANEY: >> [OFF MIC] >> MAYOR FREANEY: OBVIOUSLY >> OBVIOUSLY >> OBVIOUSLY THAT'S >> OBVIOUSLY THAT'S A >> OBVIOUSLY THAT'S A JOKE. THAT'S A JOKE. OKAY, WELL WE DON'T HAVE ANY OKAY, WELL WE DON'T HAVE ANY PRESENTATIONS TODAY, SO I'M PRESENTATIONS TODAY, SO I'M GOING TO GO RIGHT TO CITIZENS GOING TO GO RIGHT TO CITIZENS INPUT. INPUT. DOES ANYONE IN THE AUDIENCE WISH DOES ANYONE IN THE AUDIENCE WISH TO SPEAK ON A TOPIC THAT IS NOT TO SPEAK ON A TOPIC THAT IS NOT ON THE AGENDA? ON THE AGENDA? IF SO, YOU CAN COME FORWARD NOW. IF SO, YOU CAN COME FORWARD NOW. OKAY, I GUESS FATHER BOB IS HERE OKAY, I GUESS FATHER BOB IS HERE FOR SOMETHING ON THE AGENDA. FOR SOMETHING ON THE AGENDA. HERE WE GO. HERE WE GO. ALREADY LEARNED SOMETHING TODAY. ALREADY LEARNED SOMETHING TODAY. SO SEEING NO ONE COMING FORWARD, SO SEEING NO ONE COMING FORWARD, I WILL CLOSE SITGENS IN-- I WILL CLOSE SITGENS IN-- CITIZENS INPUT. CITIZENS INPUT. OKAY, WE'RE GOING TO GO TO THE OKAY, WE'RE GOING TO GO TO THE CONSENT AGENDA, SO JUST READING CONSENT AGENDA, SO JUST READING THROUGH ON CONSENT AGENDA, WE THROUGH ON CONSENT AGENDA, WE HAVE APPROVAL OF MINUTES FOR HAVE APPROVAL OF MINUTES FOR 8/21/24, 10/1/24, 10/3/24, AND 8/21/24, 10/1/24, 10/3/24, AND 10/8/24, AND BOARD AND COMMITTEE 10/8/24, AND BOARD AND COMMITTEE APPOINTMENTS, WE HAVE SERVICE APPOINTMENTS, WE HAVE SERVICE AUTHORIZATION FOR KIMLEY-HORN AUTHORIZATION FOR KIMLEY-HORN AND ASSOCIATES TO UPDATE THE AND ASSOCIATES TO UPDATE THE CITYWIDE MULTIMODAL CITYWIDE MULTIMODAL TRANSPORTATION MASTER PLAN, TRANSPORTATION MASTER PLAN, BICYCLE PEDESTRIAN MASTER PLAN. BICYCLE PEDESTRIAN MASTER PLAN. WE HAVE ADDENDUM NUMBER 3 FOR WE HAVE ADDENDUM NUMBER 3 FOR BIDDING AND CONSTRUCTION PHASE, BIDDING AND CONSTRUCTION PHASE, PROFESSIONAL SERVICES TO THE PROFESSIONAL SERVICES TO THE CONTRACT WITH McKIM & CREED CONTRACT WITH McKIM & CREED INC. FOR LIFT STATION NUMBER 32 INC. FOR LIFT STATION NUMBER 32 REBUILD, NOT TO EXCEED REBUILD, NOT TO EXCEED $101,178 AND I BELIEVE THAT'S $101,178 AND I BELIEVE THAT'S IT. IT. IS THERE ANYBODY ELSE ON THE IS THERE ANYBODY ELSE ON THE CONSENT AGENDA THAT SOMEONE LIKE CONSENT AGENDA THAT SOMEONE LIKE TO BE PULLED? TO BE PULLED? >> I WOULD LIKE TO PULL ITEM 2C. >> I WOULD LIKE TO PULL ITEM 2C. >> I WOULD LIKE TO PULL ITEM 2C. >> >> I WOULD LIKE TO PULL ITEM 2C. >> O. >> O. >> O. >> >> O. >> MAYOR >> O. >> MAYOR FREANEY: >> O. >> MAYOR FREANEY: OKAY, >> O. >> MAYOR FREANEY: OKAY, SO >> O. >> MAYOR FREANEY: OKAY, SO ITEM >> OKAY, SO ITEM >> OKAY, SO ITEM 2C. 2C. >> I WOULD LIKE TO PULL ITEM 2D. >> I WOULD LIKE TO PULL ITEM 2D. >> I WOULD LIKE TO PULL ITEM 2D. >> >> I WOULD LIKE TO PULL ITEM 2D. >> MAYOR >> I WOULD LIKE TO PULL ITEM 2D. >> MAYOR FREANEY: >> I WOULD LIKE TO PULL ITEM 2D. >> MAYOR FREANEY: 2D. >> 2D. >> 2D. >> >> 2D. >> YES, >> 2D. >> YES, MA'AM. >> YES, MA'AM. >> YES, MA'AM. >> >> YES, MA'AM. >> MAYOR >> YES, MA'AM. >> MAYOR FREANEY: >> YES, MA'AM. >> MAYOR FREANEY: OKAY. >> OKAY. >> OKAY. ALL >> OKAY. ALL RIGHT >> OKAY. ALL RIGHT SO >> OKAY. ALL RIGHT SO PULLING >> OKAY. ALL RIGHT SO PULLING THOSE >> OKAY. ALL RIGHT SO PULLING THOSE OUT, ALL RIGHT SO PULLING THOSE OUT, IF I COULD GET A MOTION FOR THE IF I COULD GET A MOTION FOR THE ITEMS OF THE MINUTES AND THE ITEMS OF THE MINUTES AND THE BOARD AND COMMITTEE BOARD AND COMMITTEE APPOINTMENTS. APPOINTMENTS. >> SO MOVED. >> SO MOVED. >> SO MOVED. >> >> SO MOVED. >> SECOND. >> SECOND. >> SECOND. >> >> SECOND. >> MAYOR >> SECOND. >> MAYOR FREANEY: >> SECOND. >> MAYOR FREANEY: OKAY, >> SECOND. >> MAYOR FREANEY: OKAY, I >> SECOND. >> MAYOR FREANEY: OKAY, I HAVE >> OKAY, I HAVE >> OKAY, I HAVE COMMISSIONER >> OKAY, I HAVE COMMISSIONER GOW >> OKAY, I HAVE COMMISSIONER GOW AND COMMISSIONER GOW AND COMMISSIONER WALKER. COMMISSIONER WALKER. AND I'M SORRY VICE MAYOR GOW, AND I'M SORRY VICE MAYOR GOW, AND OKAY. AND OKAY. ANY PUBLIC INPUT ON ANY OF THE ANY PUBLIC INPUT ON ANY OF THE CONSENT ITEMS? CONSENT ITEMS? DO YOU HAVE ANYTHING? DO YOU HAVE ANYTHING? COME FORWARD NOW. COME FORWARD NOW. SEEING NO ONE, CLOSE THAT AND SEEING NO ONE, CLOSE THAT AND ALL IN FAVOR OF THE CONSENT ALL IN FAVOR OF THE CONSENT AGENDA. AGENDA. >> AYE. >> AYE. >> AYE. >> >> AYE. >> AYE. >> AYE. >> AYE. >> >> AYE. >> ANY >> AYE. >> ANY NAYS? >> ANY NAYS? >> ANY NAYS? OKAY >> ANY NAYS? OKAY AND >> ANY NAYS? OKAY AND THAT >> ANY NAYS? OKAY AND THAT MOTION >> ANY NAYS? OKAY AND THAT MOTION PASSES OKAY AND THAT MOTION PASSES UNANIMOUSLY. UNANIMOUSLY. OKAY, SO LET'S GO BACK TO THE OKAY, SO LET'S GO BACK TO THE BICYCLE PEDESTRIAN MASTER PLAN, BICYCLE PEDESTRIAN MASTER PLAN, AND I BELIEVE COMMISSIONER AND I BELIEVE COMMISSIONER SANDBERGEN YOU PULLED THAT. SANDBERGEN YOU PULLED THAT. DO YOU HAVE A QUESTION, WOULD DO YOU HAVE A QUESTION, WOULD YOU LIKE A PRESENTATION? YOU LIKE A PRESENTATION? WHAT WOULD YOU LIKE? WHAT WOULD YOU LIKE? >> I GUESS I WOULD LIKE A LITTLE >> I GUESS I WOULD LIKE A LITTLE >> I GUESS I WOULD LIKE A LITTLE MORE >> I GUESS I WOULD LIKE A LITTLE MORE CLARIFICATION. MORE CLARIFICATION. >> MAYOR FREANEY: SO A LITTLE >> SO A LITTLE >> SO A LITTLE OVERVIEW >> SO A LITTLE OVERVIEW OR >> SO A LITTLE OVERVIEW OR SOMETHING >> SO A LITTLE OVERVIEW OR SOMETHING OR >> SO A LITTLE OVERVIEW OR SOMETHING OR JUST >> SO A LITTLE OVERVIEW OR SOMETHING OR JUST -- OVERVIEW OR SOMETHING OR JUST -- >> YEAH, I THINK IT'S THE COST >> YEAH, I THINK IT'S THE COST >> YEAH, I THINK IT'S THE COST AND >> YEAH, I THINK IT'S THE COST AND WHERE >> YEAH, I THINK IT'S THE COST AND WHERE THE >> YEAH, I THINK IT'S THE COST AND WHERE THE MONEY'S >> YEAH, I THINK IT'S THE COST AND WHERE THE MONEY'S GOING AND WHERE THE MONEY'S GOING TOWARDS. TOWARDS. I WOULD LIKE A LITTLE BETTER I WOULD LIKE A LITTLE BETTER EXPLANATION. EXPLANATION. >> GEORGIA, MAYOR, VICE MAYOR, >> GEORGIA, MAYOR, VICE MAYOR, >> GEORGIA, MAYOR, VICE MAYOR, COMMISSIONERS, >> GEORGIA, MAYOR, VICE MAYOR, COMMISSIONERS, GEORGE >> GEORGIA, MAYOR, VICE MAYOR, COMMISSIONERS, GEORGE KINNEY >> GEORGIA, MAYOR, VICE MAYOR, COMMISSIONERS, GEORGE KINNEY AND COMMISSIONERS, GEORGE KINNEY AND CATHY MATMER. CATHY MATMER. THIS WAS A BUSINESS PLAN THIS WAS A BUSINESS PLAN COMMISSIONSATIVE THAT CAME COMMISSIONSATIVE THAT CAME THROUGH THE BUDGET PROCESS LAST THROUGH THE BUDGET PROCESS LAST YEAR. YEAR. WE BASICALLY HAVE A 2011 BIKE WE BASICALLY HAVE A 2011 BIKE PED PLAN SO IT'S QUITE DATED, PED PLAN SO IT'S QUITE DATED, QUITE OLD. QUITE OLD. IT DOES NOT NECESSARILY INCLUDE IT DOES NOT NECESSARILY INCLUDE ANY POLICIES, GOALS, ACTION ANY POLICIES, GOALS, ACTION ITEMS, CONTINGENCIES OR ITEMS, CONTINGENCIES OR ANYTHING. ANYTHING. THE GOAL WAS TO TAKE THAT PLAN, THE GOAL WAS TO TAKE THAT PLAN, CREATE A ROBUST PLAN, INCLUDE CREATE A ROBUST PLAN, INCLUDE SOME STRATEGIES, SOME ACTIONS, SOME STRATEGIES, SOME ACTIONS, SOME MOBILITY STRATEGIES, SOME SOME MOBILITY STRATEGIES, SOME MAPPING ITEMS, AND THEN NORMT MAPPING ITEMS, AND THEN NORMT THAT BACK INTO THE MULTIMODAL THAT BACK INTO THE MULTIMODAL TRANSPORTATION PLAN DHRX WHICH TRANSPORTATION PLAN DHRX WHICH WAS APPROVED BY THE COMMISSION WAS APPROVED BY THE COMMISSION IN 2021. IN 2021. I HAVE THE CONSULTANT HERE IF I HAVE THE CONSULTANT HERE IF IT'S FROM FROM KIMLEY-HORN AND IT'S FROM FROM KIMLEY-HORN AND THEY HAVE PUT TOGETHER THE SCOPE THEY HAVE PUT TOGETHER THE SCOPE THAT WENT TOGETHER WITH THAT THAT WENT TOGETHER WITH THAT BUSINESS PLAN INITIATIVE AND BUSINESS PLAN INITIATIVE AND THEY CAN SPEAK TO ANY OF THE THEY CAN SPEAK TO ANY OF THE ITEMS THAT THEY'RE PERFORMING AS ITEMS THAT THEY'RE PERFORMING AS PART OF THAT SCOPE IF YOU WOULD PART OF THAT SCOPE IF YOU WOULD LIKE SOME MORE DETAIL ON IT. LIKE SOME MORE DETAIL ON IT. >> I THINK I MAYBE GET A LITTLE >> I THINK I MAYBE GET A LITTLE >> I THINK I MAYBE GET A LITTLE HUNG >> I THINK I MAYBE GET A LITTLE HUNG UP >> I THINK I MAYBE GET A LITTLE HUNG UP ON >> I THINK I MAYBE GET A LITTLE HUNG UP ON SEEING >> I THINK I MAYBE GET A LITTLE HUNG UP ON SEEING THE >> I THINK I MAYBE GET A LITTLE HUNG UP ON SEEING THE BICYCLE HUNG UP ON SEEING THE BICYCLE ACTIVITY DOWNTOWN AND THEREFORE ACTIVITY DOWNTOWN AND THEREFORE I'VE NOT GIVEN ENOUGH THOUGHT TO I'VE NOT GIVEN ENOUGH THOUGHT TO THE SURROUNDING PARTS OF TOWN, THE SURROUNDING PARTS OF TOWN, SO I SEE LARGE AMOUNTS OF MONEY SO I SEE LARGE AMOUNTS OF MONEY AND THINGS SEEM TO BE WORKING AND THINGS SEEM TO BE WORKING QUITE WELL FOR BICYCLE TRAFFIC. QUITE WELL FOR BICYCLE TRAFFIC. I KNOW IT WAS TAKES INTO I KNOW IT WAS TAKES INTO CONSIDERATION ON THE SKINNER CONSIDERATION ON THE SKINNER PROJECT, AND I DON'T KNOW, MAYBE PROJECT, AND I DON'T KNOW, MAYBE IF YOU COULD JUST. IF YOU COULD JUST. >> SO THIS WOULD BE A CITYWIDE >> SO THIS WOULD BE A CITYWIDE >> SO THIS WOULD BE A CITYWIDE PLAN. PLAN. SO IT WOULDN'T BE LIMITED TO THE SO IT WOULDN'T BE LIMITED TO THE DOWNTOWN AND WE WOULD LEE DOWNTOWN AND WE WOULD LEE BOOKING AT FACILITIES ALL AROUND BOOKING AT FACILITIES ALL AROUND OUR DOWNTOWN. OUR DOWNTOWN. WE WOULD BE LOOKING AT GAPS, WE WOULD BE LOOKING AT GAPS, CONNECTIONS, SAFE ROUTES TO CONNECTIONS, SAFE ROUTES TO SCHOOL POSSIBILITIES, SO IT'S SCHOOL POSSIBILITIES, SO IT'S REALLY GOING TO BE A REALLY GOING TO BE A COMPREHENSIVE LOOK AT WHERE OUR COMPREHENSIVE LOOK AT WHERE OUR OPPORTUNITIES ARE TO PROVIDE OPPORTUNITIES ARE TO PROVIDE SAFE BIKE ROUTES. SAFE BIKE ROUTES. >> WITH A FOCUS ON SAFETY YOU >> WITH A FOCUS ON SAFETY YOU >> WITH A FOCUS ON SAFETY YOU SAID? SAID? >> ABSOLUTELY. >> ABSOLUTELY. >> ABSOLUTELY. >> >> ABSOLUTELY. >> OKAY. >> OKAY. >> OKAY. THEN >> OKAY. THEN I'M >> OKAY. THEN I'M SATISFIED >> OKAY. THEN I'M SATISFIED WITH >> OKAY. THEN I'M SATISFIED WITH WHAT THEN I'M SATISFIED WITH WHAT I'VE HEARD. I'VE HEARD. THANK YOU. THANK YOU. >> ANYONE ELSE HAVE QUESTIONS? >> ANYONE ELSE HAVE QUESTIONS? >> ANYONE ELSE HAVE QUESTIONS? COMMISSIONER >> ANYONE ELSE HAVE QUESTIONS? COMMISSIONER WALKER. COMMISSIONER WALKER. >> SO THE MASTER PLAN ITSELF, >> SO THE MASTER PLAN ITSELF, >> SO THE MASTER PLAN ITSELF, LET >> SO THE MASTER PLAN ITSELF, LET ME >> SO THE MASTER PLAN ITSELF, LET ME SEE >> SO THE MASTER PLAN ITSELF, LET ME SEE IF >> SO THE MASTER PLAN ITSELF, LET ME SEE IF I'VE >> SO THE MASTER PLAN ITSELF, LET ME SEE IF I'VE GOT >> SO THE MASTER PLAN ITSELF, LET ME SEE IF I'VE GOT THIS LET ME SEE IF I'VE GOT THIS CLEAR. CLEAR. SO WHAT WE'RE DOING RIGHT NOW SO WHAT WE'RE DOING RIGHT NOW ISING ON BASICALLY THE SERVICE ISING ON BASICALLY THE SERVICE A2K3WR5E789, IS THAT CORRECT? A2K3WR5E789, IS THAT CORRECT? >> CORRECT. >> CORRECT. >> CORRECT. >> >> CORRECT. >> AND >> CORRECT. >> AND CAN >> CORRECT. >> AND CAN YOU >> CORRECT. >> AND CAN YOU JUST >> CORRECT. >> AND CAN YOU JUST SUMMARIZE, >> CORRECT. >> AND CAN YOU JUST SUMMARIZE, I >> AND CAN YOU JUST SUMMARIZE, I >> AND CAN YOU JUST SUMMARIZE, I DON'T >> AND CAN YOU JUST SUMMARIZE, I DON'T KNOW >> AND CAN YOU JUST SUMMARIZE, I DON'T KNOW TO >> AND CAN YOU JUST SUMMARIZE, I DON'T KNOW TO HOLD >> AND CAN YOU JUST SUMMARIZE, I DON'T KNOW TO HOLD THIS >> AND CAN YOU JUST SUMMARIZE, I DON'T KNOW TO HOLD THIS UP, >> AND CAN YOU JUST SUMMARIZE, I DON'T KNOW TO HOLD THIS UP, BUT DON'T KNOW TO HOLD THIS UP, BUT JUST SUMMARIZE WHAT IS IT IN THE JUST SUMMARIZE WHAT IS IT IN THE MASTER PLAN THAT SPECIFICALLY MASTER PLAN THAT SPECIFICALLY THAT SPECIFICALLY WAS LACKING TO THAT SPECIFICALLY WAS LACKING TO GET TO THIS POINT. GET TO THIS POINT. >> SO THE CURRENT PLAN, >> SO THE CURRENT PLAN, >> SO THE CURRENT PLAN, COMMISSIONERS, >> SO THE CURRENT PLAN, COMMISSIONERS, KIND >> SO THE CURRENT PLAN, COMMISSIONERS, KIND OF >> SO THE CURRENT PLAN, COMMISSIONERS, KIND OF SITS COMMISSIONERS, KIND OF SITS ALONE. ALONE. IT'S NOT EMBEDDED IN THE IT'S NOT EMBEDDED IN THE MULTIMODAL TRANSPORTATION PLAN, MULTIMODAL TRANSPORTATION PLAN, AND THAT CURRENT PLAN DOESN'T -- AND THAT CURRENT PLAN DOESN'T -- WE HAVE NOTHING IN IT. WE HAVE NOTHING IN IT. IT'S REALLY BARE BONE. IT'S REALLY BARE BONE. THERE IS NO STRATEGIES, THERE THERE IS NO STRATEGIES, THERE ARE NO POLICY. ARE NO POLICY. THERE IS NO ACTIONS. THERE IS NO ACTIONS. THERE ARE NO GOALS SO THE IDEA THERE ARE NO GOALS SO THE IDEA IS TO MOVE THAT CURRENT PLAN IS TO MOVE THAT CURRENT PLAN INTO YOUR CURRENT 2021 INTO YOUR CURRENT 2021 MULTIMODAL MASTER PLAN AND MULTIMODAL MASTER PLAN AND CREATE ALL OF THAT AS PART OF CREATE ALL OF THAT AS PART OF THE PLAN SET FOR THE MULTIMODAL THE PLAN SET FOR THE MULTIMODAL PLAN. PLAN. >> OKAY SO THIS IS TO MAKE IT >> OKAY SO THIS IS TO MAKE IT >> OKAY SO THIS IS TO MAKE IT CONSISTENT >> OKAY SO THIS IS TO MAKE IT CONSISTENT WITH >> OKAY SO THIS IS TO MAKE IT CONSISTENT WITH BEING >> OKAY SO THIS IS TO MAKE IT CONSISTENT WITH BEING A >> OKAY SO THIS IS TO MAKE IT CONSISTENT WITH BEING A MORE CONSISTENT WITH BEING A MORE BIKEABLE AND WALKABLE CITY. BIKEABLE AND WALKABLE CITY. >> ABSOLUTELY. >> ABSOLUTELY. >> ABSOLUTELY. >> >> ABSOLUTELY. >> OKAY, >> ABSOLUTELY. >> OKAY, THANK >> ABSOLUTELY. >> OKAY, THANK YOU. >> OKAY, THANK YOU. >> OKAY, THANK YOU. >> >> OKAY, THANK YOU. >> MAYOR >> OKAY, THANK YOU. >> MAYOR FREANEY: >> OKAY, THANK YOU. >> MAYOR FREANEY: COMMISSIONER >> COMMISSIONER >> COMMISSIONER DUGARD, >> COMMISSIONER DUGARD, DID >> COMMISSIONER DUGARD, DID YOU >> COMMISSIONER DUGARD, DID YOU HAVE >> COMMISSIONER DUGARD, DID YOU HAVE SOMETHING? DUGARD, DID YOU HAVE SOMETHING? >> THANK YOU. >> THANK YOU. >> THANK YOU. I >> THANK YOU. I HAVE >> THANK YOU. I HAVE SOME >> THANK YOU. I HAVE SOME DATA >> THANK YOU. I HAVE SOME DATA THAT >> THANK YOU. I HAVE SOME DATA THAT I I HAVE SOME DATA THAT I GENERATED DURING MY EFFORTS TO GENERATED DURING MY EFFORTS TO GET IN THIS CHAIR THAT INDICATES GET IN THIS CHAIR THAT INDICATES THERE'S A CONCERN OF SAFETY, THERE'S A CONCERN OF SAFETY, PARTICULARLY ON THE TRAIL. PARTICULARLY ON THE TRAIL. THE PINELLAS TRAIL. THE PINELLAS TRAIL. WE DO NOT CONTROL AS YOU KNOW WE DO NOT CONTROL AS YOU KNOW THE PINELLAS TRAIL SO HOW WILL THE PINELLAS TRAIL SO HOW WILL WE ADDRESS THAT INABILITY TO WE ADDRESS THAT INABILITY TO CONTROL THE TRAIL AND THEN CONTROL THE TRAIL AND THEN INTEGRATE THAT INTO CREATING A INTEGRATE THAT INTO CREATING A GREATER SENSE OF SAFETY TRAIL? GREATER SENSE OF SAFETY TRAIL? >> MAYBE HAVE KIMLEY-HORN COME >> MAYBE HAVE KIMLEY-HORN COME >> MAYBE HAVE KIMLEY-HORN COME UP >> MAYBE HAVE KIMLEY-HORN COME UP AND >> MAYBE HAVE KIMLEY-HORN COME UP AND TALK >> MAYBE HAVE KIMLEY-HORN COME UP AND TALK ABOUT >> MAYBE HAVE KIMLEY-HORN COME UP AND TALK ABOUT SOME >> MAYBE HAVE KIMLEY-HORN COME UP AND TALK ABOUT SOME OF >> MAYBE HAVE KIMLEY-HORN COME UP AND TALK ABOUT SOME OF THE UP AND TALK ABOUT SOME OF THE STRATEGIES THEY'RE THINKING STRATEGIES THEY'RE THINKING ABOUT REAL QUICK. ABOUT REAL QUICK. >> THANKS, GEORGE, GOOD MORNING, >> THANKS, GEORGE, GOOD MORNING, >> THANKS, GEORGE, GOOD MORNING, MEMBERS >> THANKS, GEORGE, GOOD MORNING, MEMBERS OF >> THANKS, GEORGE, GOOD MORNING, MEMBERS OF THE >> THANKS, GEORGE, GOOD MORNING, MEMBERS OF THE COMMISSION. MEMBERS OF THE COMMISSION. JARED SNYDER WITH KIMLEY-HORN. JARED SNYDER WITH KIMLEY-HORN. I LEAD OUR PRACTICE HERE IN THIS I LEAD OUR PRACTICE HERE IN THIS COUNTY. COUNTY. THAT'S WHAT MOST OF THE PLANS THAT'S WHAT MOST OF THE PLANS ARE DEALING WITH ARE ARE DEALING WITH ARE PARTNERSHIPS SO WE WOULD DEAL, PARTNERSHIPS SO WE WOULD DEAL, WE WOULD WORK WITH FORWARD WE WOULD WORK WITH FORWARD PINELLAS, PINELLAS COUNTY, AND PINELLAS, PINELLAS COUNTY, AND FDOT AS PART OF THIS PLAN TO FDOT AS PART OF THIS PLAN TO CREATE THOSE STRATEGIES AND CREATE THOSE STRATEGIES AND RECOMMENDATIONS THAT GEORGE IS RECOMMENDATIONS THAT GEORGE IS TALKING ABOUT. TALKING ABOUT. >> I LOOK FORWARD TO READING >> I LOOK FORWARD TO READING >> I LOOK FORWARD TO READING THAT. THAT. >> MAYOR FREANEY: OKAY. >> OKAY. >> OKAY. ANYTHING >> OKAY. ANYTHING ELSE? ANYTHING ELSE? IS VICE MAYOR? IS VICE MAYOR? >> HOW LONG DO YOU PLAN -- HOW >> HOW LONG DO YOU PLAN -- HOW >> HOW LONG DO YOU PLAN -- HOW LONG >> HOW LONG DO YOU PLAN -- HOW LONG DO >> HOW LONG DO YOU PLAN -- HOW LONG DO YOU >> HOW LONG DO YOU PLAN -- HOW LONG DO YOU THINK >> HOW LONG DO YOU PLAN -- HOW LONG DO YOU THINK THIS >> HOW LONG DO YOU PLAN -- HOW LONG DO YOU THINK THIS IS >> HOW LONG DO YOU PLAN -- HOW LONG DO YOU THINK THIS IS GOING LONG DO YOU THINK THIS IS GOING TO TAKE BEFORE IT COMES BEFORE TO TAKE BEFORE IT COMES BEFORE US? US? >> WE'VE GOT SEVERAL CHECK-INS. >> WE'VE GOT SEVERAL CHECK-INS. >> WE'VE GOT SEVERAL CHECK-INS. THE >> WE'VE GOT SEVERAL CHECK-INS. THE FULL >> WE'VE GOT SEVERAL CHECK-INS. THE FULL SCHEDULE >> WE'VE GOT SEVERAL CHECK-INS. THE FULL SCHEDULE I >> WE'VE GOT SEVERAL CHECK-INS. THE FULL SCHEDULE I BELIEVE >> WE'VE GOT SEVERAL CHECK-INS. THE FULL SCHEDULE I BELIEVE IS THE FULL SCHEDULE I BELIEVE IS AROUND -- SIX MONTHS TOTAL BUT AROUND -- SIX MONTHS TOTAL BUT YEAH FOUR TO SIX WE WOULD COME YEAH FOUR TO SIX WE WOULD COME AND SEE Y'ALL. AND SEE Y'ALL. >> LOOKING FORWARD TO IT. >> LOOKING FORWARD TO IT. >> LOOKING FORWARD TO IT. >> >> LOOKING FORWARD TO IT. >> I >> LOOKING FORWARD TO IT. >> I GUESS >> LOOKING FORWARD TO IT. >> I GUESS WHEN >> LOOKING FORWARD TO IT. >> I GUESS WHEN I >> LOOKING FORWARD TO IT. >> I GUESS WHEN I THINK >> LOOKING FORWARD TO IT. >> I GUESS WHEN I THINK ABOUT >> I GUESS WHEN I THINK ABOUT >> I GUESS WHEN I THINK ABOUT BIKE >> I GUESS WHEN I THINK ABOUT BIKE SAFETY, >> I GUESS WHEN I THINK ABOUT BIKE SAFETY, I >> I GUESS WHEN I THINK ABOUT BIKE SAFETY, I RECENTLY >> I GUESS WHEN I THINK ABOUT BIKE SAFETY, I RECENTLY SAW >> I GUESS WHEN I THINK ABOUT BIKE SAFETY, I RECENTLY SAW A BIKE SAFETY, I RECENTLY SAW A COMMERCIAL FOR AN ELECTRIC BIKE COMMERCIAL FOR AN ELECTRIC BIKE THAT WILL TOP OUT AT 42 MILES AN THAT WILL TOP OUT AT 42 MILES AN HOUR. HOUR. THAT'S A FAR CRY FROM A LITTLE THAT'S A FAR CRY FROM A LITTLE BOY OR GIRL WITH THEIR TRAINING BOY OR GIRL WITH THEIR TRAINING WHEELS ON TRYING TO BE, YOU WHEELS ON TRYING TO BE, YOU KNOW, ENJOY THEIR DAY DOWNTOWN KNOW, ENJOY THEIR DAY DOWNTOWN DUNEDIN. DUNEDIN. SO I MEAN, I FEEL LIKE I KNOW SO I MEAN, I FEEL LIKE I KNOW WHERE THIS IS GOING, BUT JUST WHERE THIS IS GOING, BUT JUST WANT TO MAKE SURE WE SPEND THE WANT TO MAKE SURE WE SPEND THE CITY'S MONEY PROPERLY AND GET CITY'S MONEY PROPERLY AND GET THE MOST WE CAN FOR IT. THE MOST WE CAN FOR IT. >> I DID SHARE WITH THE CITY >> I DID SHARE WITH THE CITY >> I DID SHARE WITH THE CITY MANAGER. MANAGER. I THOUGHT IN THE FUTURE WHEN WE I THOUGHT IN THE FUTURE WHEN WE HAVE ONE OF THESE HAVING A LINK HAVE ONE OF THESE HAVING A LINK IMMEDIATELY TO THE MULTIMODAL IMMEDIATELY TO THE MULTIMODAL AND TO THE 2011 BIKE PLAN, SO AND TO THE 2011 BIKE PLAN, SO THAT ESPECIALLY NEW THAT ESPECIALLY NEW COMMISSIONERS CAN IMMEDIATELY COMMISSIONERS CAN IMMEDIATELY REFERENCE, YOU KNOW, WHAT IT IS, REFERENCE, YOU KNOW, WHAT IT IS, BECAUSE I MEAN THERE ARE BECAUSE I MEAN THERE ARE SIGNIFICANT DOCUMENTS. SIGNIFICANT DOCUMENTS. >> ABSOLUTELY. >> ABSOLUTELY. >> ABSOLUTELY. YOU >> ABSOLUTELY. YOU KNOW, >> ABSOLUTELY. YOU KNOW, OUR >> ABSOLUTELY. YOU KNOW, OUR COMMUNICATIONS YOU KNOW, OUR COMMUNICATIONS TEAM DOES A GREAT JOB OF TEAM DOES A GREAT JOB OF CREATING PAGES FOR THESE PPI CREATING PAGES FOR THESE PPI PROJECTS SO WE'LL ABSOLUTELY -- PROJECTS SO WE'LL ABSOLUTELY -- YOU KNOW, WE'LL HAVE THAT LINK YOU KNOW, WE'LL HAVE THAT LINK TO OUR COMMUNICATIONS TEAM AS TO OUR COMMUNICATIONS TEAM AS WELL AS ON OUR OWN WEB SITE WELL AS ON OUR OWN WEB SITE OBVIOUSLY, SO. OBVIOUSLY, SO. >> MAYOR, MAY I? >> MAYOR, MAY I? >> MAYOR, MAY I? WE'LL >> MAYOR, MAY I? WE'LL HAVE >> MAYOR, MAY I? WE'LL HAVE THAT >> MAYOR, MAY I? WE'LL HAVE THAT LINKED >> MAYOR, MAY I? WE'LL HAVE THAT LINKED TO >> MAYOR, MAY I? WE'LL HAVE THAT LINKED TO YOU WE'LL HAVE THAT LINKED TO YOU THIS MORNING. THIS MORNING. >> THAT WOULD BE GREAT. >> THAT WOULD BE GREAT. >> THAT WOULD BE GREAT. I >> THAT WOULD BE GREAT. I JUST >> THAT WOULD BE GREAT. I JUST THINK >> THAT WOULD BE GREAT. I JUST THINK THEY'RE >> THAT WOULD BE GREAT. I JUST THINK THEY'RE GOOD I JUST THINK THEY'RE GOOD REFERENCE DOCUMENTS, AND IT'S REFERENCE DOCUMENTS, AND IT'S HARD TO VOTE ON SOMETHING NEW HARD TO VOTE ON SOMETHING NEW AND FEEL LIKE YOU'RE NOT WASTING AND FEEL LIKE YOU'RE NOT WASTING MONEY WITHOUT SEEING WHAT'S BEEN MONEY WITHOUT SEEING WHAT'S BEEN DONE BEFORE. DONE BEFORE. OKAY. OKAY. SO I'LL JUST DO A VOICE VOTE ON SO I'LL JUST DO A VOICE VOTE ON THIS. THIS. ALL IN FAVOR. ALL IN FAVOR. ANY OPPOSED? ANY OPPOSED? OKAY. OKAY. MOTION CARRIES UNANIMOUSLY. MOTION CARRIES UNANIMOUSLY. >> I NEED -- >> I NEED -- >> I NEED -- >> >> I NEED -- >> SORY? >> SORY? >> SORY? >> >> SORY? >> I >> SORY? >> I DIDN'T >> SORY? >> I DIDN'T GET >> SORY? >> I DIDN'T GET A >> SORY? >> I DIDN'T GET A MOTION. >> I DIDN'T GET A MOTION. >> I DIDN'T GET A MOTION. >> >> I DIDN'T GET A MOTION. >> OH, >> I DIDN'T GET A MOTION. >> OH, SORRY. >> OH, SORRY. >> OH, SORRY. YOU'RE >> OH, SORRY. YOU'RE ABSOLUTELY >> OH, SORRY. YOU'RE ABSOLUTELY RIGHT. YOU'RE ABSOLUTELY RIGHT. SO I GUESS FIRST I NEED A MOTION SO I GUESS FIRST I NEED A MOTION TO APPROVE. TO APPROVE. >> SO MOVED. >> SO MOVED. >> SO MOVED. >> >> SO MOVED. >> SECOND. >> SECOND. >> SECOND. >> >> SECOND. >> DID >> SECOND. >> DID YOU >> SECOND. >> DID YOU ASK >> SECOND. >> DID YOU ASK FOR >> SECOND. >> DID YOU ASK FOR CITIZEN >> DID YOU ASK FOR CITIZEN >> DID YOU ASK FOR CITIZEN INPUT. INPUT. >> I DID NOT. >> I DID NOT. >> I DID NOT. OKAY. OKAY. GOOD. GOOD. EVERYBODY'S KEEPING ME HONEST EVERYBODY'S KEEPING ME HONEST TODAY. TODAY. ANY CITIZEN INPUT ON THIS ITEM? ANY CITIZEN INPUT ON THIS ITEM? COME FORWARD NOW. COME FORWARD NOW. OKAY. OKAY. SEEING NONE, NOW I WILL ASK FOR SEEING NONE, NOW I WILL ASK FOR A VOICE VOTE. A VOICE VOTE. ALL IN FAVOR. ALL IN FAVOR. OKAY, NO NAYS, AND I WILL SAY OKAY, NO NAYS, AND I WILL SAY THE MOTION PASSES UNANIMOUSLY. THE MOTION PASSES UNANIMOUSLY. THANK YOU. THANK YOU. OKAY. OKAY. LET'S GET THIS NEXT ONE GOOD. LET'S GET THIS NEXT ONE GOOD. SO I THINK COMMISSIONER WALKER, SO I THINK COMMISSIONER WALKER, YOU PULLED THE BIDDING ON THE YOU PULLED THE BIDDING ON THE LIFT STATION 32 REBUILD, SO. LIFT STATION 32 REBUILD, SO. >> YES, MA'AM, THANK YOU. >> YES, MA'AM, THANK YOU. >> YES, MA'AM, THANK YOU. >> >> YES, MA'AM, THANK YOU. >> DO >> YES, MA'AM, THANK YOU. >> DO YOU >> YES, MA'AM, THANK YOU. >> DO YOU WANT >> YES, MA'AM, THANK YOU. >> DO YOU WANT A >> YES, MA'AM, THANK YOU. >> DO YOU WANT A PRESENTATION >> YES, MA'AM, THANK YOU. >> DO YOU WANT A PRESENTATION OR >> DO YOU WANT A PRESENTATION OR >> DO YOU WANT A PRESENTATION OR JUST. JUST. >> NO, THIS IS JUST A QUESTION. >> NO, THIS IS JUST A QUESTION. >> NO, THIS IS JUST A QUESTION. DURING >> NO, THIS IS JUST A QUESTION. DURING OUR >> NO, THIS IS JUST A QUESTION.

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
Agenda packetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Action agendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Transcript or captionsSource recordingread transcript
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Coverage and corrections

Records considered

  • CITY COMMISSION WORK SESSION — Minutes
  • CITY COMMISSION WORK SESSION
  • CITY COMMISSION WORK SESSION — Closed Captions

Not claimed by this page

  • Verified meeting decisions with item-specific public-source evidence
  • Item-level plain-language summaries are not available; this page does not infer individual agenda items.
  • Item-linked, attributed deliberation
  • A source-grounded next meeting date
  • A plain-English overview is not available.
  • Official outcomes have not been published.
  • Transcript coverage is partial.
  • Speakers have not been reliably matched to public profiles.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.
  • An individual roll-call roster is not available.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: 459fa3617e60a62eee3761dd7d8c5c69. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record