POLISCOPE

The public record

DADECITY (PASCO COUNTY) · LOCALHeld · official record pendingPartial coverage

Planning Board - 06 Aug 2025

Wednesday, August 6, 2025 · Government meeting record

The 30-second read

Record incomplete

The Dade City Planning Board will meet on August 6, 2025, to review land-use and zoning changes for two properties. The agenda includes proposals for a 2.66-acre site associated with First Baptist Church and a 0.60-acre site on Fort King Road.

Why it matters

The board will vote on land-use and zoning changes that determine what types of buildings and activities are permitted on specific properties in Dade City, which directly impacts local development and property rights.

What happens next

The scheduled meeting date has passed. Minutes or an action agenda are not published in the records we hold.

This meeting date has passed and no official outcome record has been published yet. Nothing on this page is a decision.

Record text

No recording or transcript is held for this meeting.

Planning Board - 06 Aug 2025. Location: City Hall - Commission Chambers. Time: 05:30 PM. Agenda: Planning Board - 06 Aug 2025 - Agenda - Html Planning Board Agenda City Hall - Commission Chambers Wednesday, August 6, 2025, 5:30 PM PROUD Heritage | PROMISING Future PLANNING BOARD Chair Michael Stout Vice Chair Kim Barker Board Member Davis Henley Board Member Lisa Simon Board Member [vacant] Board Member Vickie Levings Board Member Johnathan McKeen-Chaff School Board Member Chris Williams CITY OFFICIALS Catherine Ralston, Director, Community and Economic Development Evis Bushi, Deputy Director, Community and Economic Development Isaiah Hollinshead, Planner II Craig Hanson, Planner I Patrick Brackins, City Attorney Page A. MEETING PROCEDURES The Planning Board will be meeting in person. As an alternate option, the public may observe virtually. The virtual meeting will be in “watch/listen mode” only; no public comments will be taken virtually. To join the virtual meeting by computer or smart device: https://teams.microsoft.com/l/meetup-join/19%3ameeting_NmY3NjZlMzAtZGJmNy00ZDMxLWFkMjctY2Q1MjEzNmNkM2Vk%40thread.v2/0?context=%7b%22Tid%22%3a%2293e30c94-d7e7-4a24-a77e-f78f00386b17%22%2c%22Oid%22%3a%221fc5964e-efc3-40e8-9b13-1b5e8fb7e76a%22%7d This virtual meeting will be hosted via Microsoft Teams Town Hall. A Microsoft Teams account will not be required to join. Public Comment : If you are present in the Commission Chambers, you will be limited to three minutes to make your comments as is the usual rule of procedure for Planning Board meetings, except for matters heard in a quasi-judicial capacity. Public comments will not be taken virtually. Submission of Presentations: For security purposes, the City cannot accept jump drives or other USB devices. Please contact the City Clerk for more information. B. CALL TO ORDER B.1. Pledge of Allegiance. B.2. Roll Call C. PUBLIC COMMENTS D. APPROVAL OF MINUTES D.1. Draft minutes - July 02, 2025 Planning Board Planning Board - 02 Jul 2025 - Minutes 6 - 20 E. OLD BUSINESS F. NEW BUSINESS F.1. Small Scale Comprehensive Plan Amendment - First Baptist Church ORDINANCE 2025-08 AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY OF DADE CITY, FLORIDA, AMENDING THE CITY OF DADE CITY COMPREHENSIVE PLAN, PROVIDING FOR A SMALL SCALE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN AMENDMENT TO THE FUTURE LAND USE MAP, RELATIVE TO CERTAIN REAL PROPERTY, CONTAINING APPROXIMATELY ±2.66 ACRES, LOCATED ON THE SOUTH SIDE OF MERIDIAN AVENUE, AND MORE SPECIFICALLY DESCRIBED IN THIS ORDINANCE, FROM DADE CITY’S LOW DENSITY RESIDENTIAL (LDR) DESIGNATION TO DADE CITY’S RESIDENTIAL OFFICE (RO) DESIGNATION, PROVIDING FOR LEGISLATIVE FINDINGS AND INTENT, CONFLICTS, SEVERABILITY, AND AN EFFECTIVE DATE. First Baptist Church FLU Ordinance 2025-08 Staff Report Attachment A - Ordinance 2025-08 - FLU Amendment - First Baptist Church Attachment B - Application - First Baptist Church Attachment C - Affidavit of Publishing 21 - 51 F.2. Zoning Amendment - First Baptist Church ORDINANCE 2025-09 AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY OF DADE CITY, FLORIDA AMENDING THE CITY OF DADE CITY OFFICIAL ZONING MAP TO CHANGE THE ZONING DISTRICT ON CERTAIN REAL PROPERTY, APPROXIMATELY ±2.66 ACRES IN SIZE, GENERALLY LOCATED ON THE SOUTH SIDE OF MERIDIAN AVENUE, AND MORE SPECIFICALLY DESCRIBED IN THIS ORDINANCE, FROM DADE CITY’S RESIDENTIAL SINGLE FAMILY 2 (RS-2) DISTRICT TO DADE CITY’S RESIDENTIAL INSTITUTIONAL OFFICE (RIO) DISTRICT, IN ACCORDANCE WITH THE PROVISIONS OF SECTION 166.041 OF THE FLORIDA STATUTES AND THE DADE CITY LAND DEVELOPMENT REGULATIONS; PROVIDING FOR LEGISLATIVE FINDINGS AND INTENT, CONFLICTS, SEVERABILITY AND AN EFFECTIVE DATE. First Baptist Church Zoning Amendment Ordinance 2025-09 Staff Report Attachment A - Ordinance 2025-09 - Zoning Amendment - First Baptist Church Attachment B - Application - First Baptist Church Attachment C - Affidavit of Publishing 52 - 86 F.3. Annexation Petition - Marlu Lane ORDINANCE 2025-05 AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY OF DADE CITY, FLORIDA, ANNEXING APPROXIMATELY ±0.60 ACRES INTO THE CORPORATE LIMITS OF THE CITY PURSUANT TO THE REQUEST OF THE OWNERS OF SUCH LANDS AND IN ACCORDANCE WITH SECTION 171.044 OF THE FLORIDA STATUTES; PROVIDING FOR LEGISLATIVE FINDINGS; PROVIDING FOR ANNEXATION; PROVIDING FOR ADMINISTRATIVE ACTIONS, CONFLICTS, SEVERABILITY, CODIFICATION AND AN EFFECTIVE DATE. Marlu Lane Annexation Ordinance 2025-05 Staff Report Attachment A - Ordinance 2025-05 - Annexation - Marlu Lane Attachment B - Application - Marlu Lane Attachment C - Affidavit of Publishing 87 - 106 F.4. Small Scale Comprehensive Plan Amendment - Marlu Lane ORDINANCE 2025-06 AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY OF DADE CITY, FLORIDA, AMENDING THE CITY OF DADE CITY COMPREHENSIVE PLAN, PROVIDING FOR A SMALL SCALE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN AMENDMENT TO THE FUTURE LAND USE MAP, RELATIVE TO CERTAIN REAL PROPERTY, CONTAINING APPROXIMATELY ±0.60 ACRES, LOCATED ON THE EAST SIDE OF FORT KING ROAD, AND MORE SPECIFICALLY DESCRIBED IN THIS ORDINANCE, FROM PASCO COUNTY’S RESIDENTIAL (RES-6) DESIGNATION TO DADE CITY’S PUBLIC / SEMI-PUBLIC (P-SP) DESIGNATION; PROVIDING FOR LEGISLATIVE FINDINGS AND INTENT, CONFLICTS, SEVERABILITY, AND AN EFFECTIVE DATE. Marlu Lane FLU Ordinance 2025-06 Staff Report Attachment A - Ordinance 2025-06 - FLU Amendment - Marlu Lane Attachment B - Application - Marlu Lane Attachment C - Affidavit of Publishing 107 - 130 F.5. Zoning Amendment - Marlu Lane ORDINANCE 2025-07 AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY OF DADE CITY, FLORIDA AMENDING THE CITY OF DADE CITY OFFICIAL ZONING MAP TO CHANGE THE ZONING DISTRICT ON CERTAIN REAL PROPERTY, APPROXIMATELY ±0.60 ACRES IN SIZE, GENERALLY LOCATED ON THE EAST SIDE OF FORT KING ROAD, AND MORE SPECIFICALLY DESCRIBED IN THIS ORDINANCE, FROM PASCO COUNTY’S RESIDENTIAL 3 (R3) DISTRICT TO DADE CITY’S RESIDENTIAL INSTITUTIONAL OFFICE (RIO) DISTRICT, IN ACCORDANCE WITH THE PROVISIONS OF SECTION 166.041 OF THE FLORIDA STATUTES AND THE DADE CITY LAND DEVELOPMENT REGULATIONS; PROVIDING FOR LEGISLATIVE FINDINGS AND INTENT, CONFLICTS, SEVERABILITY AND AN EFFECTIVE DATE. Marlu Lane Zoning Amendment Ordinance 2025-07 Staff Report Attachment A - Ordinance 2025-07 - Zoning Amendment - Marlu Lane Attachment B - Application - Marlu Lane Attachment C - Affidavit of Publishing 131 - 156 G. MEMBER COMMENTS H. ADJOURNMENT Next Meeting - September 3, 2025 I. FOOTER TEXT NOTE: ONE OR MORE CITY COMMISSIONERS, PLANNING BOARD OR HISTORIC BOARD MEMBERS MAY BE PRESENT AT THIS MEETING AND MAY PARTICIPATE ADDRESSING THE BOARD: Any person desiring to address the Board shall secure the permission of the Presiding Officer to do so. MANNER OF ADDRESSING THE BOARD: TIME LIMIT: Each person addressing the Board shall step up to the podium, shall give their name and address in an audible tone of voice for the records, and unless further time is requested and granted by the Board shall limit the address to three minutes . All remarks shall be made to the Board as a body and not to any member thereof. No person other than the person having the floor and the Board shall be allowed to enter into any discussion either directly or through a Board Member without the permission of the Presiding Officer. No question shall be asked a Board Member except through the Presiding Officer. APPEALS: Any person desiring to appeal any decision made by the Planning Board with respect to any matter considered at any meeting or hearing will need a record of the proceedings and may need to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceedings is made which includes the testimony and evidence upon with the appeal is based. DISABILITY: If you are a person with a disability who needs any accommodation in order to participate in this proceeding, you are entitled at no cost to you to the provision of certain assistance within two (2) working days of your receipt of this notice. Please contact the Dade City Clerk’s office, P.O. Box 1355, Dade City, FL 33526-1355; (352) 523-5052 for further assistance and information. Document: Planning Board - 06 Aug 2025 - Minutes - Html Planning Board Minutes City Hall - Commission Chambers Wednesday, August 6, 2025, 5:30 PM PROUD Heritage | PROMISING Future Members Present Chair Michael Stout Vice Chair Kim Barker Board Member Davis Henley Board Member Johnathan McKeen-Chaff School Board Member Chris Williams Staff Present Community & Economic Development Director Catherine Ralston Deputy Community & Economic Development Director Evis Bushi Planner II Isaiah Hollinshead GIS Planner I Craig Hanson City Attorney Patrick Brackins Members Absent/Regrets Board Member Lisa Simon Board Member Vickie Levings A. MEETING PROCEDURES B. CALL TO ORDER Chair Stout called the meeting to order at 5:31 P.M. B.1. Pledge of Allegiance. B.2. Roll Call All members were present except Board Members Simon and Levings. C. PUBLIC COMMENTS There were no public comments. D. APPROVAL OF MINUTES D.1. Draft minutes - July 02, 2025 Planning Board Moved by Board Member McKeen-Chaff, seconded by School Board Member Williams. Motion to approve the minutes. Motion approved unanimously. E. OLD BUSINESS F. NEW BUSINESS F.1. Small Scale Comprehensive Plan Amendment - First Baptist Church ORDINANCE 2025-08 AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY OF DADE CITY, FLORIDA, AMENDING THE CITY OF DADE CITY COMPREHENSIVE PLAN, PROVIDING FOR A SMALL SCALE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN AMENDMENT TO THE FUTURE LAND USE MAP, RELATIVE TO CERTAIN REAL PROPERTY, CONTAINING APPROXIMATELY ±2.66 ACRES, LOCATED ON THE SOUTH SIDE OF MERIDIAN AVENUE, AND MORE SPECIFICALLY DESCRIBED IN THIS ORDINANCE, FROM DADE CITY’S LOW DENSITY RESIDENTIAL (LDR) DESIGNATION TO DADE CITY’S RESIDENTIAL OFFICE (RO) DESIGNATION, PROVIDING FOR LEGISLATIVE FINDINGS AND INTENT, CONFLICTS, SEVERABILITY, AND AN EFFECTIVE DATE. Community and Economic Development Director Catherine Ralston explained staff will conduct one presentation on items F1 and F2. City Attorney Patrick Brackins swore in staff and affected parties. Deputy Community and Economic Development Director Evis Bushi presented the background information about the requests and history on the Church property. Chair Stout asked if the board should open up to public comment. City Attorney Patrick Brackins said the board could do both — ask the applicant questions and later open it up to public comment. Chair Stout asked the applicant if, were the property to be rezoned, there would be nothing to guarantee the Church would not be torn down, and that the new zoning would remain on the property. Deputy Community and Economic Development Director Evis Bushi affirmed that statement. Chair Stout stated that one of the criteria to move forward with the rezoning — criteria number 7, surrounding zoning compatibility — was in question. He asked staff how they reached the conclusion that the one adjacent parcel, which is brown (RIO) and currently used as a residence (League of Pastors), met that criteria. He noted that this did not seem to be a completely different change. Deputy Community and Economic Development Director Evis Bushi explained that because RIO zoning is adjacent to the specific parcel — which has been in the RIO district since the 1990s — and because to the southwest also contains the Middle School, it is not considered spot zoning. Chair Stout rebutted that it seemed spottish, and asked if that house had ever been used for anything other than a residence. Board Member McKeen-Chaff mentioned the bed and breakfast (the yellow house) on the corner of Meridian and 14th. Chair Stout noted that, at this point, the property is not designated historic, and there is nothing in the application suggesting what might be built. He stated that this amendment would effectively put the cart before the horse, as the City has not been offered any indication of what the applicant intends to construct, and he is therefore hesitant to support the comprehensive plan amendment. Community and Economic Development Director Catherine Ralston announced that the applicant was present and had wanted a determination of the zoning prior to the closing of the due diligence period. She stated this makes the property less financially feasible and invited him to the stage. Vice Chair Barker asked her to repeat what she had said about what the RIO zoning does not include. Community and Economic Development Director Catherine Ralston stated that, under current RIO zoning, single-family use is not allowed, but it is allowed under RS-2. She clarified that the request before the board was to move forward with allowing the RIO zoning district, but that this was not the item before them tonight. Vice Chair Barker confirmed that there are 290 parcels not conforming in the RIO zoning district. City Attorney Patrick Brackins clarified that the current residential use is legal and may continue without being subject to code enforcement. Vice Chair Barker asked if the use was grandfathered in, and City Attorney Patrick Brackins confirmed it is legal non-conforming. Steve Smith, 37547 Church, said he bought a third house on the same city block, and this would be the fourth. He stated that he has a Church that rents from him at One Pasco Center, 40,000 square feet, and there is a need for office space. He expressed a desire to use the sanctuary as it is for weddings and funerals, explaining details of his business plans from day one of moving in — placing one business into the Meridian house and another holding services on Wednesday nights, as well as hosting events for weddings, funerals, and baptisms. Steve Smith spoke of his plans for his daughter moving back; she is musical, and he envisioned concerts. He said he is motivated to save the Church, and explained family motivations of wanting his daughter to take the house. He added that he may move back in to the neighborhood after 24 years. Steve Smith further explained the Church building has a kitchen suitable for weddings, and he plans to hold weddings, entertainment events, and cook meals there, keeping that kitchen and updating it further. He said he plans to run his businesses and had not known that he would have to wait 23 years to apply for historic designation (when the building turns 100 years old). He stated he has since learned that this rule no longer applies. City Attorney Patrick Brackins probed about the application for historic board designation. Community and Economic Development Director Catherine Ralston stated that once the application is complete, it can be processed by the historic board, which meets once a quarter. She added they could call a special meeting for something like this hearing. City Attorney Patrick Brackins asked the applicant if it was his intent to register the building on the historic register. Steve Smith replied yes and said he had just learned about the process and had thought he had to wait 23 years. City Attorney Patrick Brackins noted that the comprehensive plan process takes longer, and asked if he would be willing to commit to the historic board. Steve Smith spoke about the “crazy amount” of work to be done, including upgrades. He said 90–95% of the walls are rated good for fire, with 8-inch walls, but adding sprinklers would be a big expense. He wanted to maintain a positive cash flow. City Attorney Patrick Brackins asked if being listed as a historic structure would require sprinklers. Steve Smith said no, but stated that to run a business, due diligence is needed as long as he knows it is viable. He described the walls as thick like a bomb shelter. He mentioned he has been on the block for 25 years, has trademarked “Church Street Christmas,” and is all in when it comes to keeping something nice for the community. Chair Stout asked if the First Baptist Church building is a contributing structure to the historic district. Community and Economic Development Director Catherine Ralston explained that it is not. When the Church Street Historic District was nominated for the National Register of Historic Places, the building at 37511 Church was listed as non-contributing, but this was done in the late 1990s. She stated that thirty years later, the Historic Board could make the case the building is contributing, but it is still not on the list, and the property owner would need to apply for its designation. Chair Stout asked the pleasure of the board and called for comments from the public. Board Member Henley mentioned there are multiple rooms in the hallway wing and whether there were any plans for that particular part. Steve Smith elaborated that he has no plans for it now. He said he has been through all those rooms and it feels like a hospital, wishing there were signs for which way to go. He stated he has no desire to tear down the 8-inch-thick walls and sees the space as mostly office space. He touted the 5,000-square-foot sanctuary space, and plans to run his business, as well as his daughter’s and son-in-law’s businesses, out of the building. He added that he has friends with businesses and discussed the computer and server upgrades. Steve Smith stated he does not intend to get rich off the building, and wants his daughter to move back and have grandkids here. He said he does not plan on tearing down walls and that, if it is not making money, it must at least cover the bills. He added that he is creative enough to fit the right tenant into the space. Board Member McKeen-Chaff asked if his intent was to use this as a playing card to allow his daughter and grandkids to move back, but what would happen if they did not and it no longer made sense to keep the building. Board Member McKeen-Chaff inquired what would happen if a health company wants to buy the property, and there was more discussion on potential plans in the future. Steve Smith described his property on the lake and talked about his daughter living on the lake. He said he could run his business from anywhere. He added that enough is being built in Florida and so many people are moving here that he believes there will always be positive cash flow. Board Member McKeen-Chaff asked the applicant if he had done significant due diligence on office space numbers in and around Dade City. Steve Smith replied that his business alone would make more than needed to keep the place open, and he is not worried about having to find other tenants. He said he could hold weddings and funerals and expand the music program. He noted the Church has had concerts before, and said he is not going anywhere and he does not want the Church to go anywhere. Steve Smith stated he is not worried about his viability. Chair Stout realized that Steve Smith had mentioned an expensive sprinkler system and asked if he had investigated whether the building contained asbestos and galvanized pipes. Steve Smith mentioned that Simpson had done some asbestos removal. He said he was told by the pastor that as long as walls were not being torn apart, the building could continue to operate. If changes were required, he would seal off the area and hire proper professionals to handle possible asbestos removal. Chair Stout stated that his concern was that if the property were to be converted into office space with a collection of smaller rooms, most business models would require some kind of changes. He expressed concern that once the costs of improvements, asbestos removal, and repiping the building were considered, the financial feasibility might be impacted. He noted that while nobody expected Steve Smith to take a huge loss, if the City rezoned the property, someone else might be able to make it work if he did not. Steve Smith stated that he knew he could make it work, and there was further discussion about a lake in a subdivision, a 1031 exchange, and his lack of concern over the viability of the business. Chair Stout noted that, as Board Member McKeen-Chaff had mentioned earlier, the property could potentially be used for a hospital, mental health center, or rehab center, and that the type of zoning proposed caused anxiety amongst nearby residents. Steve Smith stated that he agreed with those concerns but knew where his heart is. He said he had moved to the area after getting married and discussed his children wanting to play on Church Street, the Church Street Christmas event he created, and how this venture would be a great thing for his daughter. He compared the charm of Dade City to a Mayberry on steroids, and stated his family would not live anywhere else. Board Member McKeen-Chaff asked what kind of business he planned to operate. Steve Smith explained his ventures at One Pasco Center, noting that it was fully rented out, and there was further discussion on his business ventures. There was discussion on Withlacoochee River Electric requirements. Board Member McKeen-Chaff again asked what kind of business he intended to operate. Steve Smith explained his concept of a franchise program targeting the college market with beverage products. Board Member McKeen-Chaff asked what that meant in terms of functionality, instructing him to be vague. Steve Smith talked about his vitamins and antioxidant business idea. Board Member McKeen-Chaff asked if the business was currently operational. Steve Smith explained that things had been changing with dyes, and that he could not spend enough time on it while traveling the world. He claimed that Coca-Cola and Pepsi were bidding on it and gave details on relaunching the program, noting that money would not be an issue. He added that he would soon be building homes on the lake and could pay for whatever was needed to operate the business. Board Member McKeen-Chaff asked if he had done development in real estate before. Steve Smith said no, but noted that it had taken him 24 years to get property platted. He provided further background details on his businesses. Chair Stout asked if there were any more questions and suggested opening it up to public comment. Gordon Larkin, the next-door neighbor of 37441 Church Avenue, explained that 37438 Church, the adjacent property, had been rezoned a long time ago when there were not many options with the City. He spoke about the Modley House, which dated from the early 1900s to the 1970s and had been converted into apartments. He provided details on the history of the property’s transition to single-family and then to a bed and breakfast, referencing the property appraiser. Gordon Larkin questioned how RS-2 zoning could be compared to RIO zoning, stating that RIO was not intended for commercial property. He said that while he was not opposed to the property hosting events, he was concerned about what else could be allowed under RIO zoning. He asked what would stop the neighboring property from undergoing similar changes. He stated that if a zoning application could not be found that would limit and restrict the use to something more comparable, in his opinion RIO would be a bad decision. Gordon Larkin urged caution of the board, to be careful not to lose the charm in our town. He expressed that he did not want someone telling him what he could not do with his property, and that the proposed change would affect the value of Church Avenue. He said people would not want to live there, ownership could change, and the decision could affect his property value and quality of life. Board Member McKeen-Chaff asked Gordon Larkin how many years he had been a contractor. Gordon Larkin replied that he had been a contractor for over 40 years — longer than Board Member McKeen-Chaff had been alive. Board Member McKeen-Chaff noted that Mr. Larkin knew a thing or two about the building and asked if he had assessed it or been consulted on repairs. Gordon Larkin said he had not assessed it. Board Member McKeen-Chaff asked if he was familiar with whether the Church needed a roof, would soon need air conditioning, required sprinklers, or had windows that needed replacement, and what a rough cost estimate might be. Gordon Larkin said he did not want to throw around numbers, as that was the applicant’s business, but that it would cost a lot of money. He mentioned parking limitations, the size of the auditorium, and the kitchen area, and said that if the building were used to its full capacity, there would never be enough parking. He expressed concern about the potential for seven-days-a-week parking issues, noting that a church works well when people park only once a week. Ava Larkin, 37814 Howard Avenue, spoke on behalf of Ray Battle, 37603 Church Avenue, regarding his stance on keeping the zoning as it is. She stated that the City had declared Church Street to be historical and that it should remain that way. She noted that even if the property was not on the historic register, the surrounding properties were. She said the property had historical relevance, with Mr. Battle’s family name chiseled on the stone as well as being among the founding pioneers. She stated that it was not just a building but an institution. She described Church Street Christmas as our own little Mecca and emphasized its importance to the community. Ava Larkin stated that while the building might not sell immediately, someone else could eventually purchase it and therefore the sale should not be rushed. She said there should be a group of Christians to stand firm and uphold traditions on its grounds, as they have since it was erected. Having lived on Church Street, she expressed that she knew parking was an issue, mentioning that the four-way stop sign is often run, creating safety concerns for daily activities and pedestrians. Most importantly, Ava Larkin felt the downtown should be protected, stating that it felt as though it was being taken away, and urged preservation of the community by thinking about the future, not just the present. E Knight a Vietnam veteran, living at 37522 Church Avenue across the street from the property, stated he had known Mr. Smith for over twenty years and that it had been a pleasure having a church nearby. He said he did not have anything else to add and that the questions already asked reflected his own concerns, particularly those raised by Mr. Larkin regarding parking. He stated he would soon be 82 years old and was not sure if Mr. Smith could complete all his plans in his time remaining. He described Church Street as home, recalling how he and his family moved in during Thanksgiving and the Church Street Christmas holiday events were taking place, including a contest. He stated that the event was something special to the City and that Mr. Smith had always participated. Cynthia Giokas, 37540 Church Avenue, stated she had lived there for three years as of April, having moved from Wesley Chapel where she had witnessed firsthand the changes brought by new businesses. She said Dade City had always been small, southern, and tight-knit, and that she bought on Church Street without expecting significant change. She said she had nothing against Steve Smith personally but opposed the rezoning. She expressed concern that the 2.6-acre property could be developed with 20 homes per acre, attached housing, or other high-density projects, which would affect property values and change the character of the historic district. She acknowledged that Mr. Smith had good ideas, including a theatrical-type school, and noted that RS-2 zoning already allows for a neighborhood recreation center, which could accommodate large spaces, workshops, classrooms, or theatrics. She said such uses could be done under the current category and that, as far as office use, Mr. Smith would figure that out himself. Cynthia Giokas concern was what might happen in five years if the property were grandfathered in. She questioned the impact on single-family homes, noting that the street was brick and already had school-related traffic requiring adjustments. She said the brick road could not handle much more traffic. She stated she was thoroughly against the rezoning and worried about the state of the street if it were approved. She read from the comprehensive plan, noting that Dade City’s low-density residential designation is intended to create a quiet, spacious environment and peaceful residential setting with more privacy. She expressed fear that the change would move the area toward high-density zoning, allowing townhomes and apartments, and urged the board to take this into consideration. Karla Shelton, 37604 Church Avenue, stated she did not have much to add after what had already been said. She said that even if Mr. Smith was able to make the project work, there was no guarantee about the property’s future 5, 10, or 15 years from now. She stated that her family was not going anywhere and did not want the community to change because it was part of their identity. Karla Shelton urged the board to look at the outer parts of Dade City, noting that they no longer looked as they once had, but emphasized that this did not mean the inner part of the City had to change. She said her comments applied not just to Mr. Smith but to any future owner. Ray Battle, 37603 Church Avenue, stated that the town had declared Church Street historic and questioned why anyone would want to change that or tear it down. Steve Smith stated that he had no problem with making the property historic. City Attorney Patrick Brackins explained the conditional use provision for a gathering place of 200 or more people. Steve Smith said he is not buying it as a nonprofit church. Board Member McKeen-Chaff said the conditional use will not change, noting that churches rent out all the time. Steve Smith said he was not a church, but they would rent from him. Board Member McKeen-Chaff asked for legal counsel. City Attorney Patrick Brackins read the conditional uses permitted in RS-2. Board Member McKeen-Chaff asked how many employees there would be, and there was discussion on hypothetical plans. Steve Smith said he could not give a number because he was still working on the business. Board Member McKeen-Chaff asked City Attorney Patrick Brackins if they were allowed to give a variance for the office. City Attorney Patrick Brackins said no, it’s not before the board. He said he is not in the planning department and the requirements are very specific. Applicants seeking to change the code would require a discussion of the applicability of conditional use and rezoning to all properties. School Board Member Williams asked if that would be a conditional use, prompting discussion on what’s conditional. Community and Economic Development Director Catherine Ralston differentiated offices from business services, explaining that the church use is a separate business entity and cannot be considered the same as an office entity. This prompted discussion on ancillary uses and business uses. City Attorney Patrick Brackins stated that for RS-1 and RS-2, none of the applicant’s requests are permissible. Board Member McKeen-Chaff asked if Steve Smith could come back to the board later for a variance. Community and Economic Development Director Catherine Ralston said no, that is for building and development standards such as setbacks, not for use changes. She explained how variances are intended for sites with physical limitations. City Attorney Patrick Brackins added that variances require a hardship, not simply “I want this.” Community and Economic Development Director Catherine Ralston said a change in use would require a change to the zoning code, which would apply to all RS-2 properties throughout the city. Steve Smith asked, once designated historic, would he be prevented from tearing it down. If he wanted to open up a wall, would that be allowed. Community and Economic Development Director Catherine Ralston said interior modifications could be made, and exterior changes would go to the historic board. Chair Stout noted that the process to petition the historic board is voluntary and can be withdrawn by the owner. Community and Economic Development Director Catherine Ralston said she believed a property could be removed from the historic register and demolished. Chair Stout said a future owner could withdraw the designation, referencing a church in Tampa (at Hillsborough and Nebraska in Seminole Heights) that was removed from the register and torn down for a hospital. Historic designation does not guarantee the structure will remain. Community and Economic Development Director Catherine Ralston reiterated that the zoning does not guarantee protection from demolition. Chair Stout agreed, noting that maintenance over time will be a challenge for any owner. Steve Smith spoke about the building’s interior: walls, drywall strips, industrial electrical work, limited bathrooms and running water. He is still doing due diligence but thinks the building is worth saving, even though others wanted to tear it down. Vice Chair Barker asked how long the building has been on the market. Steve Smith said it had been on and off the market for years. Ever since Discover Church built its new facility on County Road 52, the property has had various plans, but deals fell through due to market conditions or lack of fit. He said the Church feels he is the right fit. School Board Member Williams said that as a member of First Baptist, the building has been for sale for at least three years. Chair Stout asked about the motion. City Attorney Patrick Brackins explained that any motion must include a stated reason for supporting or denying the zoning change. Denials cannot be arbitrary; they must be fairly debatable, based on evidence, and consistent with surrounding neighborhood character. He noted that RIO is not consistent with LDR is a permissible example. Board Member McKeen-Chaff moved to deny based on testimony that it is not consistent with the surrounding area. Chair Stout asked for a second. Vice Chair Barker said more discussion was needed. Chair Stout withdrew Board Member McKeen-Chaff’s motion. Vice Chair Barker said she appreciated everyone’s comments and loves Church Street Christmas. She said this property on a main thoroughfare presents a quandary. While it could work as a community center or school, she was not convinced by the petitioner. She noted that the building has been for sale for a long time and times have changed. She worried about the possibility of condos or offices replacing it. She would prefer something that adds character and value, but based on what she’s heard, she leans against approval. Steve Smith attempted to respond, but Chair Stout said the board had moved past that. There was further discussion on hypthetical development numbers. Board Member McKeen-Chaff said the city has the authority to say no if a project doesn’t align with the Comprehensive Plan. No one wants to see the building torn down, but much is allowed under RIO. Board Member McKeen-Chaff said that 90% of businesses fail, and if so it would probably be bought up by a large commercial or medical operation such as AdventHealth, which he believes would effectively ruin the drive into downtown. He said he takes the testimony from neighbors such as Mr. Larkin very seriously, someone who is knowledgeable on the the neighboring property, and the context of RIO as a zoning designation that fits within the community. He said if then proposed business venture fails, the property is large enough to be viable for what could become a large-scale commercial or medical operation, which is not desirable. City Attorney Patrick Brackins asked if his comment meant the comp plan was inconsistent with the character of the area. School Board Member Williams said that based on Steve Smith’s testimony, it will take a lot of money to preserve the building. Without action, the highest bidder could tear it down, so perhaps office space is the best position. Board Member McKeen-Chaff said allowing the change because a higher bidder might do the same is not a strong reason. City Attorney Patrick Brackins noted that Steve Smith would voluntarily apply for historic designation to support his application. School Board Member Williams said that shows he wants to preserve it. Board Member McKeen-Chaff said that in 20 years, someone could still tear it down. School Board Member Williams replied that there are no guarantees in life, and another church could do the same thing. Board Member McKeen-Chaff asked if changing to RO would be consistent. School Board Member Williams reminded him that the board cannot offer a conditional use permit for office space, and the applicant’s goal is to preserve the building. City Attorney Patrick Brackins said School Board Member Williams’s statement was correct: based on the applicant’s testimony, he wants to preserve the church, but needs the office space, and the only way to get that is through RIO zoning. Chair Stout said he hates that First Baptist Church left the building and left the community with this issue. School Board Member Williams agreed, noting that the church had to make a difficult decision to move. Chair Stout said that rezoning could allow the owner to walk away, and future uses under different zonings may still not be consistent. Vice Chair Barker confirmed whether the board’s decision was binding or advisory. City Attorney Patrick Brackins said it was binding for the planning board but still goes to the City Commission. The minutes from tonight will be part of the record but do not bind the commission. Chair Stout closed discussion and asked for a motion. Board Member McKeen-Chaff moved to deny based on inconsistency. Chair Stout said he has never had to pass the gavel. City Attorney Patrick Brackins instructed him to pass it to the Vice Chair, who then seconded the motion to deny. Vice Chair Barker asked if there was any further discussion before city staff took the motion. Moved by Board Member McKeen-Chaff, seconded by Chair Stout. Motion to deny Comprehensive Plan Amendment based on inconsistency with surrounding neighborhood. FOR: Stout, Barker, and McKeen-Chaff AGAINST: Henley and Williams ABSENT: Simon and Levings CARRIED. Motion approved 3-2, with Board Member Henley and School Board Member Williams voting to deny. F.2. Zoning Amendment - First Baptist Church ORDINANCE 2025-09 AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY OF DADE CITY, FLORIDA AMENDING THE CITY OF DADE CITY OFFICIAL ZONING MAP TO CHANGE THE ZONING DISTRICT ON CERTAIN REAL PROPERTY, APPROXIMATELY ±2.66 ACRES IN SIZE, GENERALLY LOCATED ON THE SOUTH SIDE OF MERIDIAN AVENUE, AND MORE SPECIFICALLY DESCRIBED IN THIS ORDINANCE, FROM DADE CITY’S RESIDENTIAL SINGLE FAMILY 2 (RS-2) DISTRICT TO DADE CITY’S RESIDENTIAL INSTITUTIONAL OFFICE (RIO) DISTRICT, IN ACCORDANCE WITH THE PROVISIONS OF SECTION 166.041 OF THE FLORIDA STATUTES AND THE DADE CITY LAND DEVELOPMENT REGULATIONS; PROVIDING FOR LEGISLATIVE FINDINGS AND INTENT, CONFLICTS, SEVERABILITY AND AN EFFECTIVE DATE. Moved by Board Member McKeen-Chaff, seconded by Chair Stout. Motion to deny Zoning Amendment to RIO, based on it not being consistent with the current Low Density Residential future land use designation. FOR: Stout, Barker, and McKeen-Chaff AGAINST: Henley and Williams ABSENT: Simon and Levings CARRIED. Motion approved 3-2, with Board Member Henley and School Board Member Williams voting to deny. F.3. Annexation Petition - Marlu Lane ORDINANCE 2025-05 AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY OF DADE CITY, FLORIDA, ANNEXING APPROXIMATELY ±0.60 ACRES INTO THE CORPORATE LIMITS OF THE CITY PURSUANT TO THE REQUEST OF THE OWNERS OF SUCH LANDS AND IN ACCORDANCE WITH SECTION 171.044 OF THE FLORIDA STATUTES; PROVIDING FOR LEGISLATIVE FINDINGS; PROVIDING FOR ANNEXATION; PROVIDING FOR ADMINISTRATIVE ACTIONS, CONFLICTS, SEVERABILITY, CODIFICATION AND AN EFFECTIVE DATE. City Attorney Patrick Brackins administered the oath to staff and applicants and provided background context, noting that the City is also the applicant in this case. Deputy Community and Economic Development Director Evis Bushi presented the item. City Attorney Patrick Brackins elaborated on the limited scope of information available to the board at this tim

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
AgendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Agenda packetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Action agendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
MinutesNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Transcript or captionsNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Official pages

Coverage and corrections

Records considered

  • Planning Board - 06 Aug 2025 (2025-08-06)

Not claimed by this page

  • Verified meeting decisions with item-specific public-source evidence
  • Item-level plain-language summaries are not available; this page does not infer individual agenda items.
  • Item-linked, attributed deliberation
  • A source-grounded next meeting date
  • Official outcomes have not been published.
  • A transcript is not available.
  • No audio or video recording is linked.
  • Speakers have not been reliably matched to public profiles.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.
  • An individual roll-call roster is not available.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: 448221f590d6017705a9ebb1aae8be31. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record