POLISCOPE

The public record

NAPLES (COLLIER COUNTY) · LOCALHeld · official record pendingPartial coverage

City Council Workshop Meeting

Monday, April 14, 2025 · Government meeting record

The 30-second read

Record incomplete

The Naples City Council held a workshop to interview candidates for various city advisory boards and review a new pavement management plan. The council also heard public concerns regarding flooding in the Swan Lake community and noise levels from airport jet traffic.

Why it matters

The city is planning a $1,452,000 road resurfacing program for 2025 and is evaluating feedback on airport noise and local flood mitigation, which directly impacts infrastructure spending and resident quality of life.

What happens next

The scheduled meeting date has passed. Minutes or an action agenda are not published in the records we hold.

This meeting date has passed and no official outcome record has been published yet. Nothing on this page is a decision.

Record text

No transcript is held for this meeting. Recording: Watch video

City of Naples City Council Chamber 735 Eighth Street South Naples, Florida 34102 City Council Workshop Meeting – April 14, 2025 – 8:31 a.m. It is noted for the record that all: 1) documentation electronically appended hereto is also contained in the file for this meeting with the City Clerk’s Office; and 2) added attachments are referenced in red as “ADDED ATTACHMENT”. 1) CALL TO ORDER AND ROLL CALL City Council Members Present: Teresa Lee Heitmann, Mayor Berne Barton (left Zoom at 1:09 p.m.) Terry Hutchison, Vice Mayor Ray Christman Bill Kramer Linda Penniman Beth Petrunoff Staff Present: Gary Young, City Manager Matthew McConnell, City Attorney Patricia Rambosk, City Clerk Erica Martin, Planning Director Robert Middleton, Public Works Director Ciro Dominguez, Police Chief Chad Merritt, Parks, Recreation, and Facilities Director Phillip Pennington, Fire Chief Alison Bickett, Deputy City Engineer David Rivera, Traffic Operations Sup. Danielle Futia, Special Events/Marketing Supervisor Ali Duran, Executive Assistant George Yilmaz, Critical Infrastructure Director Jessica Rosenberg, Deputy City Clerk Others Present: Lisa Koches Mary Young Paul Koches Frank Verpoorten John Nulsen Joseph Burke Alan Parker Christopher Shucart Janet Ferry Daniel Barone Maria Mair Garey Cooper Patrick Coughlan Gregory Fowler Joshua Hildebrand 2) PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE Mayor Heitmann led in the Pledge of Allegiance. Following the Pledge of Allegiance, Mayor Heitmann spoke in remembrance of Patricia Barton, Council Member Barton’s mother who had recently passed away, after which followed a moment of silence in her honor. 3) SET AGENDA (Add or Remove Items) City Manager Gary Young stated that there were no changes to the agenda. He, however, explained that there were two supplements to provide additional and/or revised information relative to Item 5.A, the board interviews, and Item 6.A regarding the Naples Airport Site Plan and Utilization Plan Project Review. Mayor Heitmann noted for the record that Council Member Barton would leave the meeting at 10:00 a.m. after which he would join by Zoom.

City Council Workshop Meeting – April 14, 2025 – 8:31 a.m. 2 MOTION by Penniman to SET AGENDA; seconded by Christman and unanimously carried, all members present and voting (Barton-yes, Christman-yes, Hutchison-yes, Kramer-yes, Penniman-yes, Petrunoff-yes, Heitmann-yes). 4) PUBLIC COMMENTS Lisa Koches ceded her time to Paul Koches. Noting that he represented the Swan Lake community, Mr. Koches distributed the handout below. He explained that a large amount of rainwater flows from the watershed into Swan Lake, diminishing its capacity to serve its purpose primarily as a retention pond. He added that the installation of improper size backflow check valves has restricted outflows and further increased the significant flooding risk. Mayor Heitmann said the City Manager will follow up on this issue. In closing, Mr. Koches expressed disappointment that a colleague visiting the construction site and engaging in polite dialog had been detained and cited by Naples police officers with disorderly conduct. He later said his colleague was acquitted and the case was dismissed. John Nulsen asked that Council address airport noise, saying that it was so disruptive that he and his family could not hold a conversation on the deck of their home in Old Naples. Alan Parker provided data from February and March of that year regarding jet departures from the airport, noting there were flights above Old Naples every one to four minutes for hours with noise levels of 80 to 100 decibels. He expressed doubt that the City would curtail increased jet operations and suggested that it warn potential buyers and visitors of the noise and pollution problem. Swan Lake Flood Mitigation Handout (ADDED ATTACHMENT / P. Koches) 5) BOARDS AND COMMITTEES 5.A) INTERVIEW ONE APPLICANT FOR THE COLLIER COUNTY COASTAL ADVISORY COMMITTEE, TWO APPLICANTS FOR THE COMMUNITY REDEVELOPMENT AGENCY ADVISORY BOARD, AND FOUR APPLICANTS FOR THE PLANNING ADVISORY BOARD (SUPPLEMENT 1/REVISED ITEM). City Clerk Patricia Rambosk began the interview process with the Collier County Coastal Advisory Committee (CCCAC), noting that Scott Schulz, who will be interviewed for the Planning Advisory Board, had withdrawn his application for the CCCAC. City Council then interviewed current CCCAC Member Joseph Burke. City Clerk Rambosk continued with the Community Redevelopment Agency Advisory Board (CRAAB), noting that applicant Christopher Aglio had withdrawn his application. City Council then interviewed current alternate member Christopher Shucart for a Regular term. It is noted for the record that Council Member Barton left the Council Chamber at 10:29 a.m. whereupon he started participating via Zoom. City Clerk Rambosk continued with the Planning Advisory Board (PAB) noting that alternate member Daniel Barone had applied for a Regular term after the packet was submitted to City Council, and that his application was therefore provided in the first supplement. City Council then interviewed Mr. Barone, followed by new applicant Garey Cooper, current member Patrick Coughlan, and new applicant Gregory Fowler. At the conclusion, City Clerk Rambosk explained that PAB applicant Schultz would be interviewed at the April 16, 2025 Regular Meeting just prior to the appointments. Agenda Memorandum Coastal Advisory - Joseph Burke Application Coastal Advisory - Scott Schultz Application Collier County Coastal Advisory Committee Code CRAAB - Christopher Aglio Application CRAAB - Christopher Shucart Application CRAAB Code PAB - Garey Cooper Application PAB - Patrick Coughlan Application PAB - Gregory Fowler Application PAB - Scott Schultz Application PAB Code Additional PAB Applicant Agenda Memorandum (Supplement 1) PAB - Daniel Barone Application (Supplement 1)

City Council Workshop Meeting – April 14, 2025 – 8:31 a.m. 3 Recess: 10:58 a.m. to 11:13 a.m. It is noted for the record that all Council Members were present when the meeting reconvened except Council Member Barton who was participating via Zoom. 6) DISCUSSION ITEMS 6.A) RECEIVE THE PRESENTATION ON THE PAVEMENT MANAGEMENT PLAN FROM JOHNSON ENGINEERING AND PROVIDE FEEDBACK ON THE PROGRAM PRIORITIZATION AND PAVEMENT SERVICE CYCLE. City Manager Gary Young welcomed George Yilmaz, the City’s new Critical Infrastructure Director, who has joined the Public Works Department. Robert Middleton, Public Works Director, reviewed the agenda memorandum which provided the history and background of this project. He asked that City Council provide feedback after the presentation to enable the department to prioritize current year resurfacing improvements. Joshua Hildebrand, Transportation Engineer with Johnson Engineering, proffered an electronic presentation which outlined the project background, goals and objectives, timeline, field assessments and pavement condition index (PCI) ratings, examples of PCI ratings, depictions of pavement conditions, field assessments and development of PCI ratings, pavement coring and analysis, and field assessment results. He then detailed the PCI results and analysis which he summarized as follows: 33.80 miles in good condition, 68.90 miles in satisfactory condition, 10.17 miles in fair condition, and 0.23 miles in poor condition. Overall, this indicates the City is in the satisfactory range, which he said was a testament to the City’s rehabilitation strategy and funding allocated to this effort. Engineer Hildebrand then reviewed rehabilitation strategies, the incorporation of preferred and prohibited truck routes into the recommendations, the City’s proposed 2025 resurfacing program which contained the 13 worst roadway segments totaling $1,452,000, and budget considerations. At that point, he outlined the next steps which he described as receiving Council’s input, adopting the 2025 resurfacing program in June of that year, considering a long-range total resurfacing program, beginning the implementation of that year’s program, and considering a policy to evaluate and improve alleyways. In response to City Council, Engineer Hildebrand affirmed that his team does have methods to increase pavement in corridors that will experience heavier loading due to truck traffic. To address resiliency, he explained that raising and strengthening the roadway is a strategy. Public Works Director Middleton added that if a roadway needed to be rebuilt, staff would consider stormwater and any other relevant factors and raise it as needed contingent on the overall design. He added that the program under consideration will be used for 25 years and will be updated every five years to ensure that funds are being spent wisely based on the conditions of the roads. David Rivera, Traffic Operations Supervisor, said raising roads is a major construction project and explained some of the associated challenges such as impacts to driveways and valley gutters. In further discussion, Engineer Hildebrand said the assessment was strictly a ranking of the current condition of the asphalt. Mr. Rivera added that staff asked Engineer Hildebrand not to assess certain roadways such as Gulf Shore Boulevard or 1st Avenue South, as they were already scheduled to be included in upcoming projects. Deputy City Engineer Alison Bickett said Johnson Engineering has created a GIS document that depicts core sample locations and rankings which the City can use for future project needs and prioritization. Shen then referenced recent building permit applications, noting that she asks developers for resurfacing especially if a project creates a significant amount of impact or is adjacent to a commercial property, and suggested implementing this as a policy. Deputy City Engineer Bickett then said that although staff have been prioritizing the roadway system, there have been requests to restore alleyways. In response to City Council, Public Works Director Middleton said staff have been budgeting a certain dollar amount annually and then repairing what it can based on that amount. Engineer Hildebrand confirmed that $51 million would be the cost this year to resurface every road in the

City Council Workshop Meeting – April 14, 2025 – 8:31 a.m. 4 City. Supervisor Rivera asserted that $1.5 million has been budgeted for this year and $1 million for next year. City Manager Young reported that this is a large increase from past years. He also noted the importance of ensuring there are no conflicts with projects arising from the basin assessment and determining the amount it would take to raise those roads in poor and fair categories to a satisfactory condition. Council Member Christman noted the difficulty in resolving the issue of truck traffic, saying the City has a very limited capacity. He also said the City should treat alleys in large commercial areas as streets in terms of their maintenance as part of the overall pavement resurfacing plan. City Manager Young said the poor and fair roads could be addressed in the first two years of the five-year plan; those roads currently in satisfactory condition could be re-evaluated starting in the third year, noting their potential to worsen. In response to Council Member Penniman, City Manager Young said the City has no street impact fees. Instead, the City has an interlocal agreement whereby all fees collected are remitted to Collier County except for $200,000. City Attorney Matthew McConnell affirmed that the City cannot use impact fees for repairs and maintenance and suggested adding a broader discussion on impact fees to a future workshop. City Council expressed its agreement with the plan as presented. In further discussion, Deputy City Engineer Bickett confirmed that the analysis included only five commercial alleyways for future expansion of the plan. Engineer Hildebrand said he would present additional information on them as well as conceptual costs when he returns to City Council in June. Agenda Memorandum Presentation Recess: 12:39 p.m. to 1:09 p.m. It is noted for the record that all Council Members were present when the meeting reconvened except Council Member Barton who left Zoom at that time and did not return for the remainder of the meeting. 6.B) NAPLES AIRPORT SITE PLAN AND UTILIZATION PLAN PROJECT REVIEW AND DISCUSSION (SUPPLEMENT 2/REVISED ITEM) City Manager Gary Young stated that there had been discussions at the last several Council Meetings regarding the Jet Center hangar at the Naples Airport, and that this item was being presented to offer information on the timelines and approvals related to the Airport Site Plan and Airport Utilization Plan. Planning Director Erica Martin proffered an electronic presentation that included Objective 7 of the Comprehensive Plan which addresses the management of the airport, the Airport Utilization Plan, which is reviewed through the site plan review process, Resolution 98-8151 which approved the 1998 Airport Utilization Plan, the 2003 Update, and the 2006 Update which was reviewed but not approved by City Council. Planning Director Martin pointed out that the 2006 Update is the first time the subject property had been identified for a new site-specific development. She then continued with the 2010 Update, when the property was identified for a new site-specific development under the category of “non-specific hangar development” and the 2013 Update, which depicts the property the same as in the 2010 Update. In response to Vice Mayor Hutchison, Planning Director Martin affirmed that there are inconsistencies on how features on these Updates are labeled and depicted. Several Council Members noted the ambiguity in deciphering the shaded areas of the sites and the resultant confusion and asserted the importance of determining a better process in the future. Planning Director Martin then presented the 2016 Update where there are areas shown as approved site- specific development, new site-specific development, and future development. Council Member Petrunoff said the City Council did not review or approve the Jet Center. Planning Director Martin said individual projects are not presented to City Council. She added that the most recently approved Updates, including the current 2021 Update, indicate a site marked for new hangar development with no specificity. Council Member Petrunoff pointed out that during the review of the 2021 Update, Council had specified that there be no new hangars.

City Council Workshop Meeting – April 14, 2025 – 8:31 a.m. 5 Planning Director Martin, however, explained that the Update had depicted previously approved site-specific development. At that point, Planning Director Martin continued with the presentation to review the 2018 Update, the 2021 Update, and Resolution 2021-14744 which removed two new site-specific projects. She also reviewed the Jet Center plans and staff reports presented to the Design Review Board (DRB) for preliminary design approval in 2021 and final approval in 2022, and the existing and proposed site plan diagrams of the new Jet Center Hangar and FBO (Fixed Base Operations). In response to City Council, City Attorney Matthew McConnell confirmed that the Airport is building the Jet Center within the parameters of its building permit which was approved by the DRB. Vice Mayor Hutchson questioned whether there was a remedy if the City discovered that there was a mistake in the approval process. City Attorney McConnell said cities are obligated to enforce their codes; for example, a city may need to revoke a building permit if it was found to have been granted in error. He added that there is a difference, however, between having questions and actually making a mistake. He recommended that the City update its processes to require more clarity in its submissions and incorporating them into the Code. In response to Council Member Penniman, Planning Director Martin pointed out that there are project areas depicted on the plans presented to the DRB which do not align with the leased areas or the taxiways, and that this makes enforcement difficult. Mayor Heitmann said there are inaccuracies in the documents that the airport submitted, which she finds unacceptable. She added that the City should determine how to pause this project until there is clarity. Mayor Heitmann added that the community has expressed its plea for relief from increased airport noise, and said the project does not comport with the City’s Vision Statement or Comprehensive Plan. Vice Mayor Hutchison noted non-specificity in the documents and said that Council would have never knowingly approved construction of the hangar. Council Member Christman said he believed the process to approve airport-related utilization plans and the projects within them has been ineffectual. He however said that since 2006, the property has been identified for a site-specific purpose and approved by City Council. The project has now been granted permits and is under construction. Council Member Christman therefore expressed doubt that Council could reverse its decision and instead suggested asking staff to draft recommendations on a different set of processes. Council Member Kramer concurred and predicted that the City would face liability if it tried to stop the Jet Center from being built. City Attorney McConnell expressed doubt that there was any legal remedy for the City to stop the project. In response to City Council, he said that, pursuant to the Code, the updates are to be presented periodically, and that Council may now wish to establish a specified timeframe going forward. Council Member Petrunoff recommended that the Airport present a draft update after the upcoming summer. Public Comment: Maria Mair, expressed amazement and disappointment over the construction of a new 30,000 square foot hangar which she said signaled a commitment to continued growth of the private jet industry and increased airport activity. She added that staff had presented documents that day that the public could not find and asked where they had been stored. Expressing disagreement with the City Attorney, Ms. Mair said the City should revoke the permit as it had been approved without full and clear information. Janet Ferry, representing the Old Naples Association, said that back to the 2003 Update, the past Councils have been thoughtful and thorough in their questions about what was on the Plan, and should have been presented with clear and concise information by the Airport. She added that during the 2021 Update process, Council had made it clear the City wanted no new hangars and therefore questioned whether this direction to the Airport should have been reflected on that graphic. In closing, she said the Jet Center project site-specific building has always been shown as detached. Mary Young, representing the Old Naples Association, expressed appreciation to the City for

City Council Workshop Meeting – April 14, 2025 – 8:31 a.m. 6 conducting this discussion. Referencing the site plan diagram, she said it appears the Jet Center hangar which had always been shown as unchanging and detached, now stretches approximately 10,000 square feet into an unapproved area and questioned whether there was a legal right to do so. Mayor Heitmann said she believed this project needs further investigation and received the below consensus. Majority consensus to pause this project until all outstanding questions are answered (Kramer and Christman dissenting and Barton absent). City Manager Young detailed the entire approval process for the 2021 Update and asked the Council to provide direction. Vice Mayor Hutchison said there should be no temporary certificate of occupancy, certificate of occupancy, nor incremental progress on hangar construction due to inconsistencies with project specifics in the 2021 Update in relation to the Jet Center. He added that the project is not consistent with direction from City Council to not construct new hangars in the north quadrant. Referring to Ms. Young’s question, Council Member Kramer said he received confirmation from the City Attorney that the airport was building the project within the parameters of its permit in the correct location. He therefore said he was not willing to expose the City to liability. Noting that the DRB was considering the Jet Center without Council’s knowledge, Mayor Heitmann stressed the importance of changing the operation of the City’s advisory boards to ensure greater transparency. Council Member Christman said regardless of its intentions and discussions with the Airport regarding growth, Council approved this project which has been properly permitted. He therefore advocated moving forward rather than pursuing litigation in this matter. City Attorney McConnell said he needed some time, noting that he did not foresee any options at that point to stop this project. Majority consensus to direct the City Attorney to present advice at the May 21, 2025 Regular Meeting regarding any action the City may take to pause the Naples Airport Authority Jet Center Project. (Kramer and Christman dissenting and Barton absent). Recess: 3:36 p.m. to 3:50 p.m. It is noted for the record that the same Council Members were present when the meeting reconvened. Council Member Penniman said upon recent research of cities about the same size as Naples, she had found that City Councils always had the final approval of projects and therefore recommended amending the current process which she described as flawed. Agenda Memorandum NAA Discussion - Presentation 22-DRB41 DRB Submittal - Final DRB Application 22-DRB41 DRB Submittal - Lease Agreement 22-DRB41 DRB Submittal - Disclosure of Interest 22-DRB41 DRB Submittal - Architectural Plans 22-DRB41 DRB Submittal - Landscape Plans 22-DRB41 DRB Submittal - Petitioner’s Credentials 22-DRB41 DRB Submittal - MHK Presentation 22-DRB41 DRB Packet - 2021 Airport Utilization Plan Resolution 2003-10081 (Supplement 1) 2003 Approved Utilization Plan (Supplement 1) 2006 Agenda Memo - Presented and No Action Taken (Supplement 1) 2006 Proposed Utilization Plan - No Action Taken (Supplement 1) 2006-0510 PAB Meeting Minutes (Supplement 1) 2006-0607 City Council Meeting Minutes (Supplement 1) 2006-0612 City Council Meeting Minutes (Supplement 1) 2006-0614 City Council Meeting Minutes (Supplement 1)

City Council Workshop Meeting – April 14, 2025 – 8:31 a.m. 7 2010-12689 Resolution with Utilization Plan (Supplement 1) 2011-12861 Resolution with Utilization Plan (Supplement 1) Resolution 2013-13259 (Supplement 1) 2013 Utilization Plan (Supplement 1) Resolution 2016-13875 (Supplement 1) 2016 Approved Utilization Plan (Supplement 1) 2018-14168 Resolution with Utilization Plan (Supplement 1) 2021-14744 Resolution with Utilization Plan (Supplement 1) REVISED NAA Discussion Presentation (Supplement 1/Revised Presentation) REVISED 2021-14744 Resolution with Utilization Plan Official Clerk Record (Supplement 2/Revised Attachment) 6.C) SPECIAL EVENT UPDATE - PRESENTATION AND DISCUSSION City Manager Gary Young briefly introduced this item noting staff would require direction regarding a new contract for fireworks events. Chad Merritt, Parks, Recreation, and Facilities Director, proffered an electronic presentation that included the Special Event Committee, examples of special events, the current special event application process, criteria requiring City Council approval, current challenges, and top event attendances such as the Christmas Parade and the July 4th Parade and Fireworks. He continued with the various questions staff are currently considering, for example, whether the event has a positive or negative impact on the community and whether it benefits a local organization. At that point, he reviewed some recommendations such as allowing staff to deny any submittal not meeting the deadlines, allowing administrative approval for low-impact events, implementing a penalty for violations to the permits, determining a limit for special events in public spaces, and determining venue limitations as each site has unique features and layouts. Director Merritt presented six options for the City to consider before approving event requests in public spaces; 1) only allow events by non-profits in public spaces; 2) only allow events by non- profits, based in the corporate city limits of Naples in public spaces; 3) only allow events by non- profits, based in Collier County in public spaces; 4) allow non-profits and for profits, based in the Corporate City Limits of Naples in public spaces; 5) only allow events by organizations in Collier County in public spaces; 6) maintain the status quo that includes no guidelines on who can have events. He defined public spaces as parks, streets, beach, and areas maintained by the City and open to the public. While reviewing the Events Calendar, Director Merritt highlighted the concerning number of days with multiple events scheduled, noting that these place an increased strain on City resources and open space areas. He then addressed safety concerns for events in public spaces, noting that Cambier Park remains open and vulnerable. He suggested installing bollards around the park to prevent vehicle intrusions. Director Merritt proposed a 120-day deadline for submitting applications for high-impact events, 90 days for moderate-impact events, and 60 days for low-impact events, which may be approved administratively. He then shared an event grading scale used to determine whether an event should be classified as high, medium, or low impact. Director Merritt detailed staffing challenges and provided a breakdown of hours accumulated by police while working off-duty at events in 2025. He also gave an overview of the impacts that Special Events have on Cambier Park. He then shared proposed measures for consideration to limit the number of Art Fairs held per month. Vice Mayor Hutchison emphasized the need for staff to deny event submittals that do not meet deadlines, adequately address safety concerns, or follow the manual guidelines. He also

City Council Workshop Meeting – April 14, 2025 – 8:31 a.m. 8 expressed support for reducing the number of events held annually and underscored the importance of safety measures during events, including the installation of bollards. Council Member Kramer asserted that event rules must be applied and enforced equally. He stated that requiring event sponsors to be Naples residents would effectively reduce the number of events. In addition, he emphasized that closing streets for events should be a rare occurrence. Council Member Christman requested an update on usage of the Norris Center following the opening of the Gulfshore Playhouse. To assist in limiting the number of events, Council Member Petrunoff suggested approving only those that provide meaningful value to Naples residents. In response, City Attorney Matthew McConnell cautioned that any restrictions or guidelines applied by staff must remain content neutral. Director Merritt stated that the two most challenging issues related to special events are handling applications submitted after deadlines and ensuring event safety. Council Member Kramer suggested implementing a cap on the number of events and gradually reducing that number over time. City Attorney McConnell opined that if event applications are submitted on time and meet the established criteria, the City will be required to accept them. He added that the City cannot show favoritism in the approval process; however, he proposed that the criteria could be revised to possibly include a requirement that events be compatible with the surrounding neighborhood. In response to Council Member Penniman, Director Merritt stated that, due to safety concerns, he has been working on relocating running and walking events to Baker Park. Danielle Futia, Special Events/Marketing Supervisor, explained that nearly all events scheduled from November through April are considered grandfathered events, having taken place for over twenty years and holding the first right to reserve their annual dates. Mayor Heitmann suggested using security guards in place of police officers during special events to help alleviate the demand on Naples Police Department resources. Director Merritt expressed concern about past instances where late event applications were denied, only for the event sponsors to appeal to City Council, which then approved the events. He noted that once a late application is approved, others use that precedent to justify their own tardiness. Noting past inconsistencies in the acceptance of late special event applications, Council Member Kramer and City Attorney McConnell emphasized the need for strict adherence to deadlines. Mayor Heitmann expressed concern about the closure of the Cambier Park Softball Field for special events. She also stated that events that require street closures or hinder access to residents’ driveways need to be reduced. Council Member Christman expressed the opinion that the overbooking of special events is primarily an issue from January through March with limited special events scheduled in the offseason. In response, Director Merritt stated that he encourages offseason events; however, event sponsors are often reluctant to proceed if their organizations do not benefit. Consensus to direct the Parks, Recreation, and Facilities Director to strictly enforce the special events rules and application deadline. In addition, the Parks, Recreation, and Facilities Director is directed to address multiple events on weekends which strain City resources. In response to Council Member Kramer, Director Merritt said he would provide clarification regarding which event sponsors are local organizations and which are not. In response to Council Member Petrunoff, Supervisor Futia and Director Merritt explained how site plans are utilized in the special event application process. Public Comment: Frank Verpoorten, Executive Director of the Naples Art Institute, spoke about the successful Art Fair season. Regarding the potential elimination of street closures during events, Mr. Verpoorten requested that Park Street remain closed during Art Fairs in Cambier Park,

City Council Workshop Meeting – April 14, 2025 – 8:31 a.m. 9 as the closure is a big part of the event’s success and allows Art Fairs to stay within the park rather than its former location on 5th Avenue South. Director Merritt provided an update on firework events in the City, noting that the contract with Zambelli Fireworks is set to expire on September 30, 2025. He added that the July 4, 2025 show has already been approved and is covered under the current contract. Going forward, he stated that a decision is needed on whether to put future fireworks event sponsorships out to bid or to continue with Zambelli by utilizing another municipality’s existing contract. In addition, he stated that a decision is needed regarding the number of fireworks shows the City desires, as well as the size and location of those shows. Police Chief Ciro Dominguez spoke about traffic challenges his department faces during and after the Fireworks Show. He added that challenges related to New Year’s Eve celebrations throughout the City create additional difficulties during the Fireworks Show. In response to Mayor Heitmann’s earlier comments regarding the use of security guards instead of police officers for special events, Police Chief Dominguez explained that police officers are better equipped to address modern security challenges and that their communication systems enable a coordinated response to incidents. In response to Council Member Kramer, Police Chief Dominguez explained that, even with the additional presence of County deputies, there is still insufficient law enforcement coverage for the Fireworks Show on New Year’s Eve. Citing safety concerns, Council Member Kramer expressed opposition to the New Year’s Eve Fireworks Show, and instead touted the County Drone Show at Paradise Coast Sports Complex. Council Member Christman stated that he received a letter signed by numerous Naples homeowner association presidents expressing support for fireworks shows. He also questioned why the early evening fireworks show conflicted with the later New Year’s Eve celebrations throughout the City. In response, Police Chief Dominguez stated that he had sufficient staff to police the New Year’s Eve Fireworks Show; however, the officers’ other duties would be neglected during that time. Vice Mayor Hutchison expressed support for Police Chief Dominguez’s recommendation and stated his opposition to the New Year’s Eve Fireworks, while voicing support for the July 4th Fireworks. In response to Council Member Petrunoff, Police Chief Dominguez suggested that if the City decided to host New Year’s fireworks, it might consider holding the show on the weekend following January 1st. Fire Chief Phillip Pennington stated that ensuring accessibility for emergency vehicles is the primary concern during major events such as fireworks shows. Public Comment: Mary Young, President of the Old Naples Association, spoke in favor of minimizing the impact of the New Year’s Eve Fireworks Show by having homeowner associations sponsor the event and scheduling it on January 1st. Consensus to direct the Parks, Recreation, and Facilities Director to schedule the New Year’s Fireworks on either January 1st, or a day or more thereafter. Vice Mayor Hutchison expressed support for the consensus but opposed relinquishing sole authority over the New Year’s Fireworks Show to homeowner associations. In response, City Manager Young clarified that while he would consult with homeowner association presidents, final decisions would remain with the City Council. Agenda Memorandum Special Event Update - Presentation 2025 Special Event Calendar 2024 Special Events Organizer/Event Status List Resolution 2024-15458 - Zambelli Agreement

City Council Workshop Meeting – April 14, 2025 – 8:31 a.m. 10 6.D) A DISCUSSION ON CURRENT NAMING RIGHTS POLICY ESTABLISHED BY RESOLUTION 08-12283. This item was continued. Agenda Memorandum Resolution 08-12283 - Naming Rights Policy (Amended) Resolution - 00-8854 - Naming Rights 7) NEW BUSINESS 7.A) ANNOUNCEMENT OF AN EXECUTIVE SESSION ON MAY 7, 2025 - KELLERHOUSE, PRICILLA JOY V. CITY OF NAPLES, ET. AL., 20TH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT, CASE NO. 23- CA-000446 IN AND FOR COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA. City Attorney Matthew McConnell said this item was no longer required. Agenda Memorandum Public Notice 7.B) ANNOUNCEMENT OF AN EXECUTIVE SESSION ON MAY 21, 2025 - WALTER, ROBERT V. CITY OF NAPLES, 20TH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT COURT, CASE NO. 23-CA- 001074 IN AND FOR COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA. City Attorney Matthew McConnell read the public notice of a request to schedule an Executive Session on May 21, 2025, at 12:30 p.m. for the purpose of providing advice and discussing settlement negotiations and litigation expenditures related to Walter Robert v. City of Naples, Case Number 23-CA-001074. Agenda Memorandum Public Notice 7.C) ANNOUNCEMENT OF AN EXECUTIVE SESSION ON MAY 21, 2025 - BARNICLE, DONNA V. CITY OF NAPLES, 20TH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT, CASE NO. 23-CA-001425, 20TH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT, IN AND FOR COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA. City Attorney Matthew McConnell read the public notice of a request to schedule an Executive Session on May 21, 2025, at 1:30 p.m. or immediately following the previously announced Executive Session, for the purpose of providing advice and discussing settlement negotiations and litigation expenditures related to Barnicle Donna v. City of Naples, Case Number 23-CA- 001425. Agenda Memorandum Public Notice 8) PUBLIC COMMENTS None. 9) COMMUNICATIONS FROM THE MAYOR, CITY COUNCIL, AND STAFF Noting discussions at the meeting that day, Council Member Penniman recommended that the City work together with the Presidents Council when making difficult decisions that affect the citizens. She then suggested creating a new ordinance that requires that all new public parking lots be pervious. With respect to Item 4, Public Comments, Council Member Christman said he had spoken to Paul Koches about the issues he raised regarding Swan Lake . He said he believed the best course of action would be for the City Manager and the appropriate staff to follow up with Mr. Koches and his colleagues to determine what should be done prior to the start of rainy season. City Manager Gary Young said he, Public Works Director Robert Middleton, and Critical Infrastructure Director George Yilmaz are working on that issue, will perform a site visit the next day, April 17, 2025, and will later report back to City Council. Council Member Christman then said he had met with Mr. and Mrs. George Merriman of Royal Harbor the prior week at their request. They have for the past year had a barge stationed in the water just outside their home and have questioned the available legal remedies. He said he hoped staff can give this matter some attention. Council Member Petrunoff expressed her appreciation to City Manager Young for responding to the many issues raised by City Council in the short time since he was appointed City Manager. With respect to Swan Lake residents, she explained that they would like the City to take action prior to hurricane season and are requesting a procedure regarding the weir boards and a determination on whether the wrong size backflow check valves had been installed.

City Council Workshop Meeting – April 14, 2025 – 8:31 a.m. 11 Council Member Petrunoff also expressed thanks to City Council for its patience and its input regarding the Naples Airport discussion under Item 6.B, noting that this issue is of great importance to the business community as well as the residents. With regard to the Swan Lake issue, Vice Mayor Hutchison noted the importance of using stand- by pumps to alleviate any flooding that might occur in the residences. He then addressed Item 6.A regarding the Pavement Management Plan, and said he agreed with the necessity of raising the elevation of roads at the opportune time. Vice Mayor Hutchison then read information regarding House Bill 337 enacted in 2021 which specifies the limit that a local government can raise impact fees and noted the merit of understanding the City’s rights in that regard. City Manager Young said he planned a workshop discussion of that issue in September or October. In response to Mayor Heitmann, City Manager Young explained that there may be a supplement for the April 16, 2025 Regular Council Meeting to add an amendment to the legal services agreement with the Dickman Law Firm that would allow it to participate with the Comprehensive Plan update and expand its services for certain litigation against the City. 10) ADJOURNMENT 6:28 p.m. _______________________ Teresa Lee Heitmann, Mayor ______________________________ Patricia L. Rambosk, City Clerk Meeting clerked by: ________________________________ Jessica R. Rosenberg, Deputy City Clerk Minutes prepared by: Dave Horton, Executive Assistant and Jessica R. Rosenberg, Deputy City Clerk Minutes Approved: ___________5/21/2025

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
Agenda packetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Action agendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
MinutesNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Transcript or captionsNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Recording and media

Coverage and corrections

Records considered

  • City Council Workshop Meeting

Not claimed by this page

  • Verified meeting decisions with item-specific public-source evidence
  • Item-level plain-language summaries are not available; this page does not infer individual agenda items.
  • Item-linked, attributed deliberation
  • A source-grounded next meeting date
  • Official outcomes have not been published.
  • A transcript is not available.
  • Speakers have not been reliably matched to public profiles.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.
  • An individual roll-call roster is not available.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: 4383d49ffe0d11a3e25c6beae4a3442c. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record