POLISCOPE

The public record

DAVIS (SACRAMENTO COUNTY)Held · official record pendingPartial coverage

City Council

Tuesday, December 12, 2023 · Government meeting record

The 30-second read

Record incomplete

City Council

Why it matters

The official meeting record is available below. Item-level plain-language summaries are not available yet.

What happens next

The scheduled meeting date has passed. Minutes or an action agenda are not published in the records we hold.

This meeting date has passed and no official outcome record has been published yet. Nothing on this page is a decision.

Transcript and record text

Closed captionsWhat was said at the meeting, transcribed Aug 3, 2026. Speech is not a decision.
  • No speaker turns were supplied with this transcript.
  • This transcript has no source timestamps.
  • No speaker identities were supplied with this transcript.

This source published text without speaker turns, so speakers and timestamps are not shown.

The opening of 261,206 stored characters

function here on 73. First of all sounds Hansel distance from this mission hustlas is for its setting versus welcome to community 12th, 2023 meeting of the Davis City Council before we begin I do want to share a note from our fire marshal as you can see. We do have a Packed house tonight. We are at maximum capacity as you can imagine if there there are any empty sats next to you, please raise your hand so that folks can fill up any empty seats. Anyone standing needs to please keep the exit doors. As clear and no sitting on the ground as it's a tripping Hazard and blocks exit Pathways. And also I gather that these aisles on the sides are icky exit route the need to be cleared. So I think not an issue on this side potentially on this side, but we are we are at capacity as you know, there's overflow folks in the lobby and in the conference room as well. And when we do get to public comment, we're going to ask, you know, just from a pure space usage standpoint. That folks are courteous about kind of once they speak making room for others to come and speak. I believe that's it on the capacity piece. Okay, so welcome everybody. It is a very nice to see so many folks here, and I hope you came in. Peace. So I will note that all city council members are here. S that that is purposes of roll call at this time. i will ask whether any changes are to be made to the agenda. Otherwise, I'll entertain a motion to approve the agenda. So moved it's been moved by Josh. Is there a second second second and by Donna any discussion on the motion? I'll call for a vote all in favor. Please. Say aye aye aye. Any opposed hearing none that passes unanimously we agenda so item one on the agenda is city manager brief announcements. That's item one a I'll give it to you Mike. Yeah, thank you very much mayor city council you do. You mean tonight actually do not have any announcements so you can get straight to your next items. Thank you. Thank you. Mike item one be city council brief announcements and liaison reports from various two by two meetings commission's boards or other juror interjurisdictional assignments. Does have any reports like that? Seeing none item 10 c city council indication of intent to pull items from our consent calendar for dscussion any items at this time that council members wish to pull from consent? I don't want you to pull anything, but if time allows I'd like to just make a brief comment on consent items c. Okay. We have to remind me when it comes up. Thank you. So with that, we'll move on now to item two. So this is general public comment for items that are not on our agenda the resolution village farms the mayor and vice mayor for next year are three regular items. Each of those items will have their own dedicated public comment period so this is for items that are not on the agenda because we have such a packed house. I am going to close public 7:30 if there's still folks. This is just for general public comment again, not for the items that are on the agenda. So I will open public comment and welcome our first speaker. Good evening, mayor Arnold and counsel. Thank you very much for hearing me again. They just relax Alan Hirsch. I'm here because I support all people but I particularly support science and I'm concerned about science. Acknowledged in the Middle East and particularly because the Middle East climate change the temperatures are rising twice as fast as the rest of the world twice as fast unless we Act here in Davis to address greenhouse gases that protect our climate action plan the land the mend of milk and honey the land the levantine palestine-israel, whatever you call it. It's going to be less inhabitable and have people will die from heat Stones by the end of the century. That's all the have a I have a story here little handout that talks about all this thing. We need to protect our climate plan for all the people for the entire world and for us to think that we can drive more. I'm on the freeway by widening the freeway to put more greenhouse gases in there. It's it in are air-conditioned cars, but people in the Middle East do not ever conditioning die and suffer in the pain is not appropriate. Last night before the environmental impact was could study was even completed decision was made to basically widen the freeway put more greenhouse gases in the air and even Caltrans even what's flawed analysis which attracts distance it District chair that executive or said she couldn't defend headed cannot be mitigated. They're still doing it short-term thinking. We that's climate Injustice that basically we cn drive and Davis we can so we can take a little five or six minutes and we destroy the climate and other places in the world. So thank you very mch. Please consider it. Please consider the resolution that you will commit in this resolution to address climate change to thank you very much. Thank you Alan. I will note at this time that our practice is to ensure that we have that folks feel safe and speaking. We do ask that folks not clap or whatever. The opposite of clap would be boo or something like that when there's a speaker just so that everyone feels as though they have safe. Space to speak of course the exception to that is when we're maybe giving kid an award or something like that. We love to clap for that but that's not what I'm talking about. So again, lots o new faces I think so. I like remind folks of sort of our practice. Are there any other members of the public that wish to make public comment on items not on our agenda? I'm not seeing any there's anyone in the back. That's not a little make it up front. Please indicate that but I'm not Seeing or hearing any do we have a pre-recorded general public comment? I believe we do. There's the kind of woman speaking on the item to General Public comment all of my comments at the meeting are being made the individual. So in this general public comment, I wanted to speak broadly about the need to Center the most marginalized and those who are most harmed by oppression and exploitation and there are a lot of different systems of Oppression from capitalism to ableism to white supremacy to colonialism to patriarchy that is heteronormativity, too. All sorts of different inching systems and structures that benefit certain groups at the of others and all of these systems need to be challenged and need to be dismantled and there are different ways to do that and there are different ways to do that at different levels of Oppression because some oppression is interpersonal but a lot of Oppression and especially some of the most Insidious oppression the type that is the most harmful, and yet the hardest to detect for members of dominant groups to do with the system's themselves and the institutions. So the way that Society is structured and the way that we are socialized to think about certain groups in different ways than we think about other purposes. So all of this needs to be incorporated into our analyses All of these systems and how best to work against them. So for instance a few years ago during the picnic day five when a group of undercover police assaulted and then arrested a group of young black and brown people at City Council meetings when we were discussing. The incident white supremacy was brought up as a system of Oppression and a lot of council members did not understand that. This That is referring to the underlying structures and institutions and not necessarily their personal feelings or actions. Yes. Yeah public comment for consent as well. Hi, my name is hi, my name is Todd Adelman and I'm from South Davis. This first comment is for the consent calendar item be designation of locations as restricted areas for the purposes of removing yard material pile collection service. Well, first of all any time we put tree material in the in the bike lane in most other places in the street were essentially weaponizing though. The trees against people riding bikes, but the overall problem is that there's no equity and ownership of living things. We have a funnel fundamental misunderstanding arboreal Eco systems also known as trees and until we work that out and come up with a different understanding. Which we teach ourselves and we teach our children. We're not going to solve things like we flowers or with leaf blowers with animals bees and so on which are part of trees and of course trees being half under grout. So at the very minimum, hope that this is brought out of calendar to this. Why we need to do signage and places where leaf piles are already illegal, and w're enforcement is basically completely useless importantly. Thanks very much. Okay, and that was our last of our general public comments, So I will close general public comment. Bring it back to the for for our consent calendar. This is item number three matters listed under the consent calendar considered routine non-controversial and and are approved typically all together. So after hearing public comment or their items that folks Wish to pull the additional items Donna I dd remember you had a comment on one of the concerns. Thank you ver Al and I'll just comment very briefly. And because I think this is relevant to everyone who's here tonight well item c on the consent calendar was our proposed legislative platform for the coming year where we as representatives of counsel seek different changes in the the law that we think would make it better allow us to better serve the community and one of the bills that is referenced in there is assembly Bill 817 which didn't progress during last year's legislative session. But which would allow ow, certain advisory bodies not this body city council, but the many advisory committees that we have and other entities have to meet virtually even in a post covid world and it can be a very if this if we can encourage this bill to move through the legislative process, I think it will go a long way to making public participation more inclusive more Equitable particularly in some of these large rural counties where it's become extremely difficult for individuals to travel to attend meetings in person. So I just wanted to highlight light that that is one of the bills that we are going to be working on as part of our platform. Great. Thank you, Donna and thank you for your on the subcommittee for the lgislative platform any other comments on the consent calendar? Otherwise, I'll entertain a motion to approve the consent calendar. It's been moved by Gloria. Is there a second I'll second consecutive by bapu any further discussion. Hearing none. I'll call for a vote all in favor. Please. Say aye hi any opposed hearing none on passes unanimously? Okay. So with we move on now to number for this is the item I believe most folks are here for this is a proposed resolution calling for peace in Israel. And Gaza. I don't believe we have a staff report on this. Correct Okay, so Before we go to public comment on this I did want to take just an opportunity first to thank everyone here everyone who be listening at home for the very thoughtful feedback. We've received thus fr on the proposed resolution, and I think it's worth sharing a bit of at least my thinking on how we arrived at the draft that is in front of us currently. I'll start by noting that that the feedback we've gotten so far has has as I seen it almost universally been about what is not contained in the resolution rather than what is in it. I'm not surprised by this the language itself that's in the resolution has received support while being criticized by folks on both sides of this charge debate as not being enough and I want to say that is fair criticism. It's not enough. I don't know that anything we could put forward would be enough and I know that words are not enough. I've we've received a lot of proposed additional language. I can speak only for myself that my thinking in the language that exists currently is it was an attempt at finding consensus and I think there is value in finding where we can all agree. I know we are very good at finding where we disagree but suppose I have concerns about where that gets us in trying to find common ground and that the mere quest for consensus in some cases can be seen itself as acquiescing to one side or another in a debate. And so I am fully prepared to be called naive on this point, but I believe there's value in finding where we can all agree in this case. About us the universal value human life and it's need for protection and that these are consensus principles identified in the draft resolution that if followed would it's would in fact result in an end to the violence and that the suggestion additions are are thoughtful and rooted in an Earnest desire for for greater peace and less suffering, but that potentially move us away from Consensus and this resolution is certainly not enough. It's not enough to satisfy everyone or probably anyone and it's I know my mindset was intentionally hpeful and future-focused. I suppose I remain convinced that the path forward for Humanity is to find where we can agree rather than finding where we disagree and if I'm alone on this, I'm okay with that a few notes about tonight. Went through a couple of them, but I figured I would mention a few it's clear that will have a lot of public comment. Can I get maybe a show of hands of who is anticipate is planning to speak tonight? We have a packed agenda already. So I'm making the determination that we will have 1 and 1/2 minutes per public commenter. I expect a diverse group of public commenters and sometimes filled with passion. We appreciate the value of free speech and at the council we listen to all. Voices we do not screen our public comments. I expect we'll hear voices of people personally touched by this harrowing violence that is occurring half a world away. I will ask in the name of of colorants that audience members do not applaud or respond so that everyone feels safe and nobody feels intimidated from sharing their feelings and thoughts. I will give an opportunity for first to my colleague Gloria with whom I worked on this draft as we have it if you have anything you want to add? I'm going to save some of my comments for after a public comment and when we have a discussion the resolution, but I just want to thank you for your comments. And I want to thank everyone who is you know, this is going to take a little while and a thank you for coming and for those of you who are willing to you know, stand through all of this. It's obvious that. It's always difficult to be in the position of having to navigate these highly emotional issues and nothing can be more emotionally than watching Humanity, especially children maimed and killed when this conflict started we were asked for statement condemning the atrocities Hamas had inflicted and continues to inflict by holding hostages. Through the mayor we responded with a statement because although week directly affect a lot of the policies that happen outside of our purview. I believe that one of I think we all believe that one of the most important roles of City leadership is to commiserate and respond to the hurt and pain. It's Community feels As elected officials we have grieved and MARCH together. I see a lot of you out there that have marched with and reflected with our words the concerns of the community. Sometimes is we're experiencing today holding that space with the community becomes So I've read many emails. I was reading them right up until we came in today and spoken to several individuals and have heard the varying ideas. Of what this resolution means to them My question to myself has been what is the purpose of this resolution? Will this resolution increase the likelihood of our national leaders responding in a certain way to the issue will this resolution signal to our community that we stand against the of innocent civilians in Gaza will this resolution signal to our community that we believe the state of Israel should be left abandoned and defenseless here. Iris attack from my conversations, all of these beliefs are held by different members of our community. As a person and timidly involved and part of marginalized groups. I know what it feels like to be overlooked and unheard I know it's important to stop and deeply listen and try to understand also know that no matter the language and it in this resolution people will feel unheard even if what we are ultimately saying is that we believe that no one below that no one deserves to be murdered in their homes. I also know that I Council are not fit to speak on the on foreign matters. I know that we care deeply about our community. i know that no one wants a continuation of armed combat in Israel Gaza or any of the more than 100 places that are currently in the middle of wars. So the purpose of putting out this resolution for m was to let my community know that I see you all of you that I believe this assault on Gaza should end just as I felt the attack by Hamas and Israel should have never happened. Lastly we received an email from the human relations commission, and I don't know if anyone is here from the human relations commission. And I was I want to thank them for attempting to reach out to community and be a sounding board for them and for reminding us that this process occurred in 2009. Was There almost word for word. The resolution was let's put out and it had the exact effect back in 2009 that there were this division that there was this Division and the community and as I mentioned I think that after public comment i will have more to say Thank you, Gloria two other of the council wish to make any comments at this time or o do you wanna move it quick just very quickly. I'll make more comments after hearing public comment, but I just want to say for many of you. It MAY be the first time that you're commenting at city council. I know that for many of us. It's not so easy to be speaking in public in front of Siddharth. Crowd and it's all that much more difficult when emotionally charged and you know that there's others in the audience who passionately disagree with you. So I'd like to say that this is a safe space. So when you come up, whatever you're feeling you're safe here, you're free here and we'll support you so too. The time you need to be done within the not to clear it out there, but take a breath and and and say what's in your heart. Thank you papa that's nicely said in a good note to remember anyone else. Would you want to go to public comment? Okay, the last thing I'll mention of a pure logistic piece is that we hope that maybe as folks are lining up that that line be only about 10 people long and then we can kind of cycle. I know it's it's a packed out. So it's going to be a little bit in negotiating the space here, but I think I think we can all do it and we're not. Make sure that that whoever wants to speak is given an opportunity. So with that I will open public comment on this item will start with folks who are here in the room with us. Welcome. Hi, I wish to quickly review why it's so important for the city of Davis to act as a voice for basic human rights as it did in 1978 divesting from the apartheid government of South Africa and support a real cease fire. Now if it's a gory says the cd Now would not dvest from South Africa because as gory as suggest, we don't really know anything about International Affairs that's that is for the city to, you know, be decisive on and create create a new phase. But I think that the current draft of the resolution reads too many constituents with whom I've spoken as a kind of a generic liberal bromide we hear you we feel your pain and something like all lives matter in the face of racist violence, but I feel that this killing o gazans cannot plausibly be seen as a reasonable military response or a targeted operation to remove Hamas. But is instead an attempted ethnic cleansing that even if you read the New York Times regularly, they've talked about what qualifies as a genocide and what I think many people in the community who have family there are experiencing as a genocide before their eyes and I feel actually it's a somewhat disturbing. Sort of Act of privilege and remoteness to just kind of give them a pat on the head But say we really can't do anything else except. Hope things get better. Thank you. Thank you to the public commenter. Welcome. Hello. My name is Jennifer and I come before you to this evening to urge the council to be more explicit and calling for a permanent unconditional ceasefire in this The resolution should demand the return of all hostages and and to Israel's occupation of the occupied territories and urge the federal government immediately direct substantive humanitarian. Aid to meet the needs of gaza's population. Some MAY ask why the city of Davis has any business and Gain. In a local Global Affairs, but as residents of Davis we are part of the larger World our local community contains individuals from Palestine and Israel those representing multiple Faith groups to whom the recently on Friday, of course, the United States made what I think is a tragic decision by voting against the un resolution for a permanent ceasefire and a virile Benoit the executive director of Doctors Without Borders for the U.S. Made in I think very powerful statement saying by vetoing this revolute resolution the U.S. Stands alone in casting it to vote against humanity and continues The U.S. Veto makes it complicit in the Carnage in Ian, I am sensitive the lessons of history and I feel compelled to learn from them and not repeat the mistakes of the past when individuals communities and governments turn a blind eye to Human Rights catastrophes Like we're seeing in Gaza now it's corrosive and Lee told destroying having lost extended families to genocide some 80 years ago. I cannot sit by and see it done again in My Name by Israel a government. That is dehumanize those. And well-being. It has unjustly held in its hands for more than 75 years. Thank you your friendship when we say It means never again for anyone welcome. First of all, I just want to say thank you for trying to use this as an opportunity to actually bring our community together on a very hard topic and I want to say we don't really know each other. Well, I'm Rabbi best Wallner and I speak as one of the two rabbis of congregation bait hovering spiritual home to over 300 families and the only synagogue in Yolo County and like many in this room. My completely shattered on OCTOBER 7th and has continued to shatter each day since every week from our Pulpit. We pray for peace and name the unimaginable suffering and Terror occurring in what is supposed to be a holy land those murdered by terrorists those taken hostage and those innocent civilians in Gaza. Gaza who have no control over the decisions of their leaders, but must face the horrible and irreversible consequences the GOD. I believe in cries at the deaths of the innocent no religion or nationality always. Last month with news of a ceasefire and the return of many of the hostages. I felt like I could take a real breath for the first time since OCTOBER 7th and this month I mourned when that ceasefire eded, but I am not a politician. I'm not a diplomat and I'm not a general. I am a rabbi here to serve my community and Yolo County and that is the lens they speak from every member of our congregation. I've spoken to wants to see peace for all people in the Middle East. Yes, they MAY hold many and varying opinions on how we get there I'm not here to say which of their views is right and which is wrong and only here to recognize a name the pain that this debate is having on our community. Your time is up. I'm just going to finish this one thing because I know other people got to go. But I hope and pray that this moment encourages us to have more hard conversations as a community not in the context of a city council meeting but in talking to our neighbors in organizing opportunities to actually know one another it is the only to prevent hate from taking root. Thank you. Thank you. Welcome. My name is Bart of topkis. I'm your Arnold and council members. I would like to address the actual resolution and perhaps consider. Have you considered some changes the first paragraph where it says, the Davis City Council hears and feels deeply the pain of this community called by violence in Israel and Gaza. We add Russia and Ukraine the uyghurs? Who are a Muslim? Already in China are suffering right now the people in Afghanistan Central African Republic of Ethiopia, Libya Mali Somalia South Sudan and Syria, they are suffering and they're being killed third paragraph where it says where is violence is already claimed the lives of many to include all those other people whose lives are being claimed in in China and elsewhere in the world. The fifth paragraph where you urge the international organizations where you talk about them. I would like to City urge the Red Cross to visit our american-israeli and other abduct people who have been abducted. We don't know what's happening to them. We don't know if they're alive. We don't know if they're dead the Red Cross needs Where's the government of the United States hold immense power to save Israeli and Palestinian lives also the lives of all the others. At the end where you have mutual respect for international law including for American citizens held by Russia unjustly. Will you call for peace I call for peace for all conflicts all regions. So the resolution should be for peace in all places in the world. Thank you. Thank you Vera. Welcome. I just wanted to note something that happened today the un General Assembly voted to demand an imediate humanitarian ceasefire with 153 countries voting. Yes PRESIDENT Biden. Also today said Israel is starting to lose support by indiscriminate bombing laza ads Israel. Also cannot say no. To a Palestinian State. Why is the city of Davis Davis not keeping up with the momentum and the waking up of the world. We are a country that Prides ourselves on freedom for all and this country seems to be conditional and only four members of a fraternity and exclusive Freedom. It's not inclusive. The if city of Davis is not being Progressive with this resolution, or is it or independently thinking and the current version that you have proof? So and as you each vote, yes, it'll prove that on each of you make the appropriate edits and make this a real ceasefire resolution. It's not that complicated And as you mention Gaza you completely neglect the West Bank Hamas does not control the It's bank. So why are people being consistently arrested there? Why our homes being rated? Why are children being taken? You asked yourselves? Why in the hostage exchange has these Palestinian hostages because there are Palestinian hostages being released our children. Why is Israel holding so many children and women it was altered and children Woman released. These are things that you need to take it because it as you research your research properly both sites. Thank you to the public commenter. Welcome. Hello week. I shared the story of Rheem. Is her grandfather holding her dead body. He called her the sole of his soul the un secretary-general called Gaza a graveyard for children. I am Palestinian, but you need not be Palestinian to care. Just human. i implore you to include a clear call fr a ceasefire. It is critical to end the cycle of violence on both sides of this conflict continued violence will do nothing to safety again speaking up against the acts of the government is not a condemnation of a people or a faith and I want to be clear that I hold the lives of the hostages and the killed and injured Israelis dear in my heart too. We can hold space and compassion for both what I did not speak of last week though of was love. One of you once said in a campaign speech that it was a risk to use the word in politics. It is precisely is precisely what we need more in governing and fear is the greatest enemy of love here today by some that killing is the only way to secure safety or that cease-fires anti-semitic it will be easy for you. Yu for fear to take over. Please keep your minds and your hearts open love not continued violence is the root solution is the only way I am Palestinian in my husband is Jewish. We both have family in the region our children are born of a love that most would call impossible love makes it possible to see all innocent humans as beautiful Miracles that deserve freely and in peace love is the force to get to get behind. So please do your part to ensure that love wins for all. Of and your Humanity. Thank you. Welcome. Hello city council members mayor Arnold and community members. I'm a Lebanese student at uc Davis and two weeks ago. I received a text from my 14 year old cousin saline and the text read are we going to die? One of my cousin's text me. I'm scared we have nowhere to go. And I reply by lying to them and telling them that I'm sure that everything will be okay because they are young and I don't want them to worry. I'd tell them I'm doing everything I can here to stop the violence and then I called my dad and I ask him for guidance the way they asked it of me. I asked him Baba. How is everyone doing and he lies to me the way lied to them and I tell him bubba. This is not normal. Please tell me what's going on and he tells me that. Half of my hometown has fled due to the bombings. He says this is like before when I was a child and I fled as I watched the war planes bomb my best friend's family down the street. I asked him about my mother who has lived through five Wars and over 20 years of occupation and he tells me that she refuses to leave our home despite the bombing because she would rather die then leave and never be able to return I urge you to let your Humanity. Lead you to not just call for empty piece, but for a ceasefire that will end this violence. Thank you. Thank you. I'm a Plestinian and proud Palestinian student at uc Davis. I've and seen aggression at the hands of Israel since the age of 8 when I watched my own father be detained at an Israeli checkpoint. I went to my first protest at the age of 94 Palestine screaming for my freedom and for people to Value me as a child as a Palestinian child at the age of 10. I learned that my cousin me lad was murdered in the West Bank. He was murdered. He was martyred. He was shot by Israeli forces when he was only 16 at the age of 11. I learned that my uncle had been wrongly in prison and faced torture with no trial or charge at the age of 15. My grandfather passed away. Was my biggest hero and fought in the neck ba were Israeli forces dmolished. My family's Village at the age of 18. I was denied entry into Palestine se m family, which I did every summer at the age of 20. I worked in refugee camps throughout Nablus in Palestine. Not what I was there this summer because there was bombed. I had my freedom of movement stripped from me through checkpoints living under occupation. I was harassed at checkpoints entering Palestine caring children whose mothers were being stripped searched at the age of 21. I was in Palestine with Israeli forces raided Janine, I am still 21 and now experience the murder of 42 extended family members and Gaza. There are some Yen 15 members buttery and 15 numbers. Oh GOD labib 12 members. My grandfather's last ties to his mother's was murdered along side 14 other family members my uncle sister along with all her children and grandchildren their bodies still not recovered my aunt sister along with her children and grandchildren one sole survivor a ten-year-old little girl and we only found out because mod says a journalist in the gods the got to post since all communication has been cut off twenty thousand Palestinians have been married 25 thousand children are left orphaned. 86 journalists have been murdered mosques churches un schools and hospitals have been bombed. I'm not asking you t pity me. I'm not asking you to rebuild my family's Village. I'm not asking you to end Decades of colonisation or occupation. I'm asking for you to call for a permanent ceasefire with unrestricted entry of humanitarian assistance in 2000. I've been begging the world to Value My Life along with my Palestinian brothers and sisters. I'm a proud Palestinian and I will forever talk about Palestine. We demand an immediate ceasefire you. I'm so sorry for your loss. I'm a doctor. I'm a neurologist. I'm here to say that it's not okay to bomb hospitals. It's not to bomb ambulances is not okay to bomb doctors. It's not okay to bomb nurses. It's not okay to bomb children. You cannot win a war by killing children at this is not how you win a war by bombing innocent children you do not win. This is not a In for Humanity, this is a loss for Humanity at every point And anyone who stands for killing children. What kind of I'm tired of trying to prove the humanity of my brothers and sisters in Palestine. No, I'm not posting it, but I'm tired of trying to prove that. You know what their blood is just like anyone elses blood in this room. Why is the blood of a child a Palestinian child worth less than anyone else? His blood why why is the bombing of children? Okay, it's never okay, and this government is complicit in crime and tey are killing children left and right and anyone who supports genocide of children is no longer a human in my eyes. I'm tired of trying to prove other by Humanity. I'm tired of considering you as human if you allow the genocide of children. Welcome. Hi, u, I thought you said this is why is asking for peace controversial. Criticizing war crimes controversial house criticizing murdering children controversial every five minutes a person who has killed of those killed about 41% our children 25 percent are women on average one child is killed and who are injured every ten the war in turning Gaza into a graveyard. Good for children according to the un secretary-general. Thank you. for your public comment. Welcome. Thank you. Councilmembers. I'm a name is Dylan a resident of North Daviess. I remember the police accountability commission and a candidate for city council. I as I was thinking about what I was going to say this evening, I've been reflecting a lot on a saying popularize I think by Minnesota congresswoman ilhan Omar and it's if your freedom relies on my oppression, the neither one of us are free. I don't think anyone who's spoken before me. Anyone who's going to speak this evening Anyone in this room the reality that the people of you'll Jewish people around the world have the right to live in Freedom and security. I think the problem comes when we see that the people of Gaza have that rght to the people of the West Bank have that right to the people of the goal. On Heights have that right to to live in Peace and Freedom and security. We are relying on y'all are elected Council your voice in defense of our values of inclusion of Human Rights a resolution that calls for a permanent peace in this region of the world has to do just that it has to call for a true permanent. Peace and that starts with a ceasefire a ceasefire. Has There to be called for explicitly if that's what we want if we want a permanent. Peace. We need to say that you know with our full chest is the the young people say these days. I hope that this Council calls for that ceasefire, and I hope that y'all stand up for our values. Thank you. Thank you Dylan. Hello, everyone. I am a Davis resident. My name is Nathan or I'd like to start off this comment by stating clearly that I stand against all forms of islamophobia anti-Semitism and persecution of oppressed peoples according to U.S. Campaign for Palestinian rights the people of Davis final nine hundred nineteen thousand one hundred fifty eight federal tax dollars to Israel's weapons committing genocide in plus I sine right now money. We desperately need to keep in our community for our people's needs instead. We send that money to fund unforgivable by silence now tonight before these public comments. It was stated that words cannot be enough though. It's no stretch to say that the word ceasefire is certainly a start Israel is actively violating articles of the un convention on genocide. The United States itself is guilty of committing genocide by providing the bombs that have killed at least eighteen thousand Palestinians since seventh over seven thousand seven hundred of those killed were children, 1.9 million Palestinians have been displaced over 2 million face famine because of the is Israeli genocide and Siege last Friday 13 countries of the un Security Council voted for a resolution for a ceasefire a resolution sponsored by ninety seven other countries only the United States vetoed it counsel. You must stand with us on the right side of history and you will stand with the majority of the world when you resolve a ceasefire in Gaza. Palestine will be free. T the public commenter mock-ups. I'm actually not sure what we're doing here this situation of public comment. MAY I MAY I ask a question? Are yu you produced a resolution? Are you prepared to change it hear from some of it's quite clear what we're doing, so we're not the brown Act is very specific about us engaging in a back and forth during public comment. So if you will allow to ask your question, and then we will respond in all the public comment is done to any questions that get asked during public on that Josh that question. Now you're prepared to change it. Say that it is within our purview as the council to make edits to the resolution. Yes. Okay, but I'm not gonna be the last of the back and forth. You know that that will have to be the last of the responses back to the public comment. I don't want to run afoul of of the state law in terms of public comment. So any other questions you have will answer the in public comment. Any other question, I have your wood one. We will answer at the end of public comment of all of the public comment and I will answer any that are proposed during public comment. Well, I think it's rather clear that most of the people you're hearing from at a minimum are asking for a ceasefire and an immediate ceasefire that she's fine. Now I think is quite clearly the majority. Preity opinion if that is important to you as our Representatives, I think that that change should be made there are all sorts of other issues which you will hear about you, and I'm not really happy by one of the companies saying that is try and get it exactly. That you want to get a common opinion or a consensus really this massacre has been going on now for two months, believe it or not. It's amazing that it's been months and every is not every day. It's every our people have been cured so a ceasefire now. Is what is required? Thank you. Thank you for the public comment. I'll apologize to our City attorney if Ineed her anxious welcoming. My name is Molly and I'm a beauty was gsa in times of Crisis people. Look to the other ship for thank the city council for bringing forth a resolution calling for peace in Israel and Gaza the uc Davis gsa also passed a boycott divestment sanction resolution on DECEMBER 6th, which will be shared with our University leadership during the discussion many students shared stories of teir families have been lost in the conflict and the Discrimination that they're facing. Is your themselves today's proposed resolution is also step towards recognition of those sufferings the resolution states that the U.S. Government holds power to save Israeli and Palestinian lives. I urge the resolution that's also for your Senators a up and representatives ask for a permanent ceasefire not that sanctions against are profiting from the occupation of Palestine. And divestment and allowing only aid for these of humanitarian purposes are about the strategies to deter for the loss of human life and international relations and doesn't thank you. Thank you welcome. Hello. Hello cty council. Student at uc Davis and I like many others here believe the resolution was nowhere near what we what was needed or required for standing with Humanity or Justice placing the search for consensus in your own words over human right to existence in peace without occupation is not the right answer whatsoever. Palestinians are being killed en masse by the Israeli army with our money and you put nothing to condemn that Slaughter by them. Nothing t stand in solidarity is with Palestinians threw their struggle resoluti places violence at some random occurrence, and that does nothing to name te constant 75 years of Israeli genocide and ethnic cleansing of Palestinians. No condemnation. Nothing the city of Davis will like to ride on the coattails of condemning apartheid South Africa, but nothing is being said to condemn the apartheid going on right now in the state of Israel. You can can you can hold to that achievement from years ago, but that means nothing if you do nothing now a ceasefire was a bare minimum call from every from constituents and you did not deliver whatsoever. You can look around the room both during this meeting and last meeting with the dozens of posters for a ceasefire and that word did not come in your resolution. Once I urge the council to revise and make the correct edits that meat that I and others before me here have said Thank you. Thank you. MISS Jenny, I was named after my great-grandmother Jenny scaped hungrier than the same time sister. You lishka was gassed and Aschwitz alongside her four-year-old son, Michel. I held one of Michelle's shoes once and I wept because that shoe looked so much like the children's shoes. I have found in the desert while carrying gallons of water along the U.S. Mexico the children back in her deserts and our prisons in the children who died in the Holocaust and the children being slaughtered and Palestine are all connected how many children have to die senselessly painfully? Violently before we can gather the courage to see that none of us are free until all of us are free. This is not a complicated issue. The state of Israel has murdered tortured dehumanized and oppressed Palestinians for over 70 years wielding the power of the richest most bloodthirsty nation in the world cease fire now say it clearly it is the bare minimum ceasefire now. Thank you. Jenny. Welcome. Thank you council members. What's happening now in Gaza is indeed a tragedy. It's a tragedy that was caused by the Despicable vile terrorist actions of Hamas on OCTOBER 7th from which many in the Jewish Community are still reeling with horror and fear. Even in this room is is a t-shirt that says honor our Martyrs that statement appeared days after the OCTOBER 7th Massacre on the Davis Campus the martyrs that is being referenced. Here are the Hamas terrorists we are afraid. I asked the counsel not to pass this or any other resolution regarding Israel and Gaza. We will have no effect on the International Community the purpose of forcing this resolution council and of this discussion is to create division in our community And in that it is being spectacularly successful. I know that there are people here that genuinely believe that a ceasefire will bring peace. Tey are wrong. The only hope for peace is to eliminate Hamas and to bring the hostages home. Thank you. Thank you. I was here last week. My name is Annie. I'm proudly Jewish Igrew up here. I've lived almost my life here, and I'm going to ask you to vote for a resolution for a permanent ceasefire with the word ceasefire in it. Just as Davis spoke out about South Africa apartheid. The least you can do is use the will see d Spire as the Jewish physician Gabor mate who is a holocaust Survivor States quote. How was it possible? How could the world have left? Such Horrors happen? And and what shall do? We Ordinary People i pray we can listen to our hearts. My heart tells me that never again is not a tribal slogan Not the murdered that the murder of my grandparents in Auschwitz does not justify te ongoing dispossession of the Palestinians that just it is true. Peace are not tribal prerogative, 's that Israel's right to defend itself on arguable and principle does not validate, Mass killing. I'm asking you to be brave to stand for what is right to agree with what the United Nations General Assembly. Said Bleah today and to give children in both Israel and Palestine and a chance. It is with my Jewish values that I'm here today ask you to acknowledge that the only long lasting solution is not and never will be violence ceasefire now use the language. Thank you. Thank you Annie. Welcome. Hello. My name is Mae. Ngao Desmond. I was born and raised in Davis. I live here now with my 7 month old son. And until recently. Well, I also have family in Israel ad friends from Palestinian territories. Not been to any vigils for Israel that have mod also condemned the loss of innocent lives in Gaza one does not go without the other we need to stand for peace. But right now isn't it time while Hamas is still in power while Hamas is still? Saying Well that they will repeat OCTOBER 7th. I've second a third a fourth time until Israel no longer stands That is not the time to call for ceasefire. Consider the impact that this resolution has on the members of your on the Israelis. The Jews the Arabs the Plestinians the Muslims w all need to learn to live together in peace. There are lts of people coming into this community from outside who seek to divide us who seek to breed hate and to free to fear we need to do our part not these senseless. Resolutions don't have any impact except to divide. Thank you. Thank you my own. Welcome. Hi. Good evening. My name is Naomi and I have lived in this community almost my entire life, and I want to start off by thanking yu for recognizing concern over the resolution that's already led to pain and Discord with within our community and doing your best to get it into a place where we can have common I'm also thankful that the proposed resolution contem going to condemns the anti-semitic and Islam islamophobic attacks in our community which have been on the rise since the terror attack that Hamas carried out on OCTOBER 7th in Israel. I agree that violence has claimed the lives of too many Israelis and too many Palestinians and I pray for a long lasting peace with that prayer in my heart. I ask respectfully that the city council rejects calls to add language into the resolution regarding an immediate ceasefire Cease fire only supports a situation were Hamas remains in power where it will continue to attack Israel will in turn only further endanger Palestinians in Gaza as Israel tries to defend itself against these inevitable attacks yt. I continue to see people in this community supporting Hamas by Framing the attack on OCTOBER 7th as Justified resistance and echoing other Hamas rhetoric and I want to ask them. Do they think that supporting extremist violence serve when Hamas either directly or explicitly in reality? It only serves to further entrench and strengthen the most destructive and extreme voices o both sides of this conflict and icreases the death spiral of violence. I asked instead that these people lend their voices to the voices of piece on both sides and moderate voices think you know me what time's up. Thank you. Thank you. My name is Karan Levy while your intentions MAY be honorable. I find this effort at a resolution misguided you actually believe that it avoids carries any weight in the global Arena when you can't bring local anti-Semitism will stop when you see the faculty threatened Jews and are allowed to hold emergency teach-ins during which Israel is referred to as gentle cycle and racist called. A mass protests during which Jewish students are threatened when anti-semitic faculty remain employed and anti-semitic students are not expelled hide behind the First Amendment which does not protect hate speech when I alone face an aggressive mob of protesters last Friday, they refused to condemn Hamas and screamed from The River To The Sea intifada Revolution. There is only one solution. In front of the downtown Starbucks and police did not show up until they moved to another location and then asked me in a me questions like did I offense at what was being built which is the did not bother to follow them up and allow them to scream for the destruction of my people in another part of town. You can't make juice feel safe here, but you want to dictate the to those facing physical harm on a daily basis how to handle being attacked by a terrorist organization. You just partita. MR. Arnold. Have you ever shot in a bomb shelter told your best that amaze us with your last conversation? She should know you loved her watch that your teenage daughter is slaughtered in front of you your grandmother abducted hauled on the back of a motorcycle watched your friends rate set on fire tortured. Waited for abducted loved ones to be freed. You are out of their league get your house in order here. Thank you covering. Welcome. Hi. My name is Leah. I live and work in Davis. I look around this room and I see so much intense pain the division and despair for what for a resolution that no matter how it is written. It will not impact peace in the Middle East for a resolution that no matter how it is written. And it will not have any impact on Hamas or Israel's action for a resolution that no matter how it is written as long as it is focused on the Middle East and not here in Davis group of us will feel like winners and another group will feel like losers with one group feeling seen powerful and righteous and the other abandoned vulnerable and wronged. So while a resolution on the Middle East will make no impact on the stated goal of Peace in the Middle East. What it will do is so Division and harm the community right here again for what in this small close-knit community. We have an opportunity dialogue Foster empathy to build Bridges to create Community can be that we want to live in that's what this Council should be focused on However if this Council proceeds with the I you Didn't ask to consider this? Yes the death and destruction in horror that is going on I Palestine and Israel must stop. But the fastest emotion during weight islands is to demand the Hamas lay down their weapons hostages surrender those advocating for a ceasefire without Hamas surrendering or dooming the region to repeat this violence over and over. Again, you don't have to take my word for it. You can take a mosses word. They have said loud and clear that they will repeat the horrors of OCTOBER 7th again, and again, they want a permanent border a permanent war on Israel's border. I want peace you want peace, but Hamas explicitly does not want peace. no Pathway to peace with moss and power. So thank you for not calling for an ill-advised ceasefire that leadership from across the The political Spectrum no is useless even in the short term, but I hope that you look again at this resolution and think for what thank you Lea your answer create epathy build Bridges increased civil discourse Foster dialogue right here I Davis that is resolution worthy of this Council. Thank you Leah. Just a moment. I'll remind folks. I think the beginning of public comment folks were really ensuring that we kept sort of a didn't do the clapping and all that and it's gone on the desire to show support is completely natural, but I know that it also has the effect of making this a less safe filled the space for folks so I really To emphasize how important it is that we allow space for folks to speak that. Welcome mayor and council members. Thank you. My name is Sherry blobski. I'm a Davis resident some of you might recognize me because I've stood before you to advocate fr the rights of people who are unhealthy and for emergency winter shelter, which has been kind of mine and something I've supported in the community. So I would say that that's part of what brings me here tonight. Eight that I with respect. I fear that we're wandering into the terrain. That's not really belonging to the Davis when you have so many local issues to be focusing on so with that if we must pass a resolution, I support the draft that you currently have. Thank you. Thank you Sherry welcome. Good evening Council. My name is Scott Stewart will and Glory. I've been thinking for writing the solution. I have made it clear that it does need to have ceasefire in it I have been accused of being someone wo proves of Hamas that is not correct. What is correct is that in? The balance gave us has a books that people pay attention to? People have been telling you that somehow Davis is irrelevant or today of us doesn't know what it's doing or somehow you are dispossessed up your own minds. Me, Believe that's not true. I know all of the here needs to step forward. Look at the what is being said by your key. People are saying that the people who are speaking for ceasefire somehow. Not belonging that they're trying to divide us quite the opposite like the opposite. The reason I'm here is because I've watched this conflict for 50 years reason I'm here is because it is finally gone much too far online on our conscience. We need to cease fire then we can dialogue. Cease fire works both sides stop the shooting ask our government to cease fire. Thank you. Thank you Scott. My name is Amir: I've been a resident of Davis for the past 15 years on OCTOBER 7 Hamas launched an unprecedented genocidal terror attack targeted. These are civilians mainly women infants children adults and the elderly Hamas intentionally and systematically murdered raped and tortured. Israeli civilian resulting in the killing of more than 1,200 people 240 Tina and complete Devastation of entire civilian communities. The Gaza Strip has been under the de facto governing authority of Hamachi since 2007. And in that capacity Hamas waged war against the state of Israel Hamas its founding Charter that hit and I quote strive to raise the banner of Allah over every inch of Palestine that Israel will continue to exist until Islam. Oh obliterated and that the day of judgment will not come about until Muslim fight Jews and killed on OCTOBER 7th Hamas show the entire world that they mean every word that they say as long as Hamas is radical Islamic ideology rules gather. There can be no long lasting peace. Basically Hamas made a decision to attack Israel knowing that Israel will Strike Back come back embedded its military force with instant civilian population within schools hospitals and Moss. Asks, Hamas is sacrificing doesn't level lives as a strategy in what world has Sovereign entity attack a different one and then ask for a ceasefire as an exit strategy Hamas as a sovereign in Gaza can end this terrible War tomorrow. Throw by itself and releasing the hostages. How much was the one to bring this misery upon gotta come up with one that can end it it is a composite responsibility if the city of Davis is truly concerned about parthian live together. We should all call Hamas to take responsibility surrender itself and release the hostages. Thank you. Thank you mayor. Thank you. Well, I'm afraid I'm gonna be a bit repetitive. So try not fault me for that. Let's start off with thank you for this opportunity to address the Davis City Council. I believe that the Davis City Council is well meeting and sincere proposing this resolution. Your goal is to propose a statement that appears neutral and will unite people. Unfortunately, I believe you are wrong on both counts. You appear to not understand that any position that leaves a moss in control of Gaza is a disaster for all in the area Arabs and Jews if you are serious about adopting the resolution that is more platitudes and we'll would result in an immediate ceasefire there need be only two Provisions number one immediate return of all hostages. Remember to Hamas must surrender and be rendered ineffective. Why? A-maz is a terrorist barbaric organization that if they have the ability promises to commit more 7 s in the future leave them in their Charter or must clearly states that they are dedicated to obliterating Israel and killing Jews believe them. Hamas opposes a two-state solution which I've supported for 60 years blieve them of moss by have by hiding almost civilians uses gazans as human Shields and does not allow them to leave areas of conflict inflate numbers of casualties both real and imagined for propaganda purposes while the dcc resolution contains many noble sentiments if you want to say something Beyond platitudes take a position that matters. Is there a truthful person who believes that Hamas will comply any of the resolutions provisions it is dangerous to mislead people so division is better to say nothing than to promote the naive and dangerous position. Thank you. Welcome mayor on Old members of the council. Who can you hear me? Okay with the mask. My name I Alan Brown. Ski, Davis has been my home since 1981. I mean the Jew I served as a member of the board of congregation at half of rain fr several terms. I've also served as PRESIDENT And Vice PRESIDENT I've experienced anti-semitic hatred drected at Jews in Israel since I was a young child in the early 1950s cake red down with Israel, but I'm just for the Arabs were scrawled on the walls of the neighborhood where children played and this hatred has continued throughout my entire life from childhood to adopt. I fear that te optionally ad fuel to the fire of this hatred and I'm very relieved that it does not do so. It's hard to know what to say in these tragic times filled with death fear horror morning and anger. I find myself Torn Between Two core normally realities in tension with each other. First. The terror group Hamas is dedicated to the extermination of the Jews in Israel. So that the entire Middle East JUNE ride empty Jews after the massacre of OCTOBER 7th. We know that this is their plan of action as well as their rhetoric. A ceasefire that leaves a Motz and places we implicitly Deacon don't like Toby seventh Massacre and invite future acts of savagery. Second second the death and suffering in Gaza cannot continue on evade. It must stop. It's an unacceptable non-combatants. I support the council's resolution as it is written because it reflects these brutal realities by calling for an end to violence and Terror against Jews Plestinians and Israelis. Thank you for your time. Thank you. you. Hi, my name is Josh livni and like many people here. This conflict is personal in 1906 grandfather's family the Holograms and arrived in Palestine. They were early zionists founders of Tel Aviv My father flew the Israel after the 67 War volunteering for every year to support the country. I remember visiting my brother who is studying in Jerusalem during the second intifada. His regular side is cafeteria. I see when to is Market. They were all hit by Suicide bombings. I saw firsthand the results and disappointment that prevailed the horrific attacks on OCTOBER 7 were orders of magnitude worse. It's hard to imagine the trauma fear and anger. They have bought but I also know that Israel's policies across the occupied territories by strategically counterproductive. I know some members of our community here tonight are advocating to continue the solder in Gaza. Arguing that the disproportionate civilian death toll will be worth it to eliminate Hamas. Een if it were possible remove cannot and inhumane violence, and it's not by creating even more trauma in this act of Revenge Israel is not securing peace for the future. So just continuing to possibilities that have failed to give you the safe in Israel fueling the next generation of resonance in violence Hamas is a symptom of this violence. And Israel is doing Hamas has work for them. As a diaspora to who wishes peace and security for Israel, I be

Agenda textCity Council

Page 1 of 4 CITY OF DAVIS CITY COUNCIL AGENDA COMMUNITY CHAMBERS, 23 RUSSELL BOULEVARD, DAVIS, CA 95616 TUESDAY, DECEMBER 12, 2023 6:30 P.M. Members of the City Council: Will Arnold, Mayor Josh Chapman, Vice Mayor Donna Neville Gloria Partida Mike Webb, City Manager Bapu Vaitla Inder Khalsa, City Attorney PLEASE NOTE – The numerical order of items on this agenda is for convenience of reference; times listed are estimates. Items may be taken out of order upon request of the Mayor or Coun- cil Members. A 4/5 vote of the Council is required to begin consideration of a new item of busi- ness after 11:30 p.m. Roll Call Approval of Agenda Item 1 6:30 A. City Manager Brief Announcements B. City Council Brief Announcements and Liaison Reports from Various 2x2 Meet- ings and Commission/Board/Inter-jurisdictional Assignments C. City Council Indication of Intent to Pull Item(s) from the Consent Calendar for Discussion Item 2 6:40 Public Comments The Public Comments section is for the City Council to receive comments; except for brief ques- tions for clarification, no discussion or action may be taken on any item that is not listed on the agenda. Public comment may be continued to the end of the meeting if the time allotted for public comment expires. IN PERSON PUBLIC COMMENTS: Any member of the public may address the City Council on matters not listed on this agenda, or on matters listed on the consent calendar. If possible, citizens should reserve their comments for regular matters listed on this agenda until the time the item is consid- ered by the Council. Speakers will be asked to line up at the podium and state their name for the record. Comments are limited to no more than 2 minutes per speaker. WRITTEN AND VOICEMAIL PUBLIC COMMENTS: 1. Submit written public comments to CityCouncilMembers@cityofdavis.org. Emails are distributed to City Council and staff. To ensure the City Council has the opportunity to review information prior to the meeting, send emails by 3:00 p.m. on the meeting date.12-12-23 City Council MeetingAgenda - 1

Davis City Council Agenda December 12, 2023 Page 2 of 4 2. Submit comments by voicemail prior to the meeting: Call the city’s dedicated phone line (530) 757-5693 to leave a voicemail message for public comment. Staff will play comments during the appropriate agenda item. Comments will be accepted from 12:00 noon until 4:00 p.m. on the day of the meeting. Voicemail public comments will not be accepted after 4:00 p.m. Speakers will be limited to no more than two minutes. Note: You must leave a separate voicemail for each item you wish to comment on. Please indicate your name and which item you are speaking about. Item 3 Consent Calendar 6:55 All matters listed under the Consent Calendar are considered routine and non-controversial, require no discussion and are expected to have unanimous Council support and may be enacted by the Council in one motion in the form listed below. There will be no separate discussion of these items; however, before the Council votes on the motion to adopt, members of the Council, staff, or the public may request that specific items be removed from the Consent Calendar for separate discus- sion and action. Item(s) removed will be discussed later in the meeting as time permits. A. Memorandum of Understanding (MOU) Amendment: Tree Davis Work with the City of Davis (Public Works Utilities & Operations Director Stan Gryczko/Urban Forestry Program Supervisor) Recommendation: Resolution Authorizing the City Manager to Execute Amendment No. 1 to the Memorandum of Understanding with Tree Davis B. Designation of Locations as “Restricted Areas” for the Purposes of Removing Yard Material Pile Collection Service (Public Works Utilities & Operations Di- rector Stan Gryczko/Deputy Director Adrienne Heinig) Recommendation: 1. Approve Resolution Designating Locations as “Restricted Areas” for the Purposes of Removing Yard Material Pile Collection Service 2. Direct staff to notify the impacted areas via written notice of the designation as a “restricted area” and removal of yard material pile collection service C. 2024 City Council Legislative Platform (Council Legislative Subcommittee—Ar- nold & Neville/City Manager Mike Webb) Recommendation: Approve Resolution Authorizing the Adoption of a 2024 Legislative Platform D. Surveillance Technology: Replacement Body-Worn Cameras/In Car Cameras (Police Chief Darren Pytel/Deputy Police Chief Todd Henry/Deputy Director of Police Services Jean Lyon) Recommendation: Informational. The Police Department is submitting this informational staff report on consent calendar at least 30 days prior to asking the City Council to hold a public hearing for the purchase of replacement body- worn cameras (BWC) and in-car cameras (an integrated system) because the current cameras have reached their end-of-life.12-12-23 City Council MeetingAgenda - 2

Davis City Council Agenda December 12, 2023 Page 3 of 4 E. Commission Minutes: Open Space and Habitat Commission Meeting of Sep- tember 11, 2023 Recommendation: Informational Regular Calendar *See above instructions for public comments* Item 4 7:00 Proposed Resolution Calling for Peace in Israel and Gaza (Council Subcommit- tee—Arnold & Partida) Recommendation: Approve Resolution Calling for Peace in Israel and Gaza Item 5 8:00 Village Farms Davis Environmental Impact Report (EIR) Alternatives Review (Community Development Director Sherri Metzker/Principal Planner Dara Dung- worth) Recommendation: Review the proposed draft EIR alternative concepts and pro- vide direction to modify one or more of the EIR alternatives, if needed. Item 6 8:45 Designation of Mayor and Vice Mayor for Calendar Year 2024 (City Manager Mike Webb) Recommendation: 1. Designate a member of City Council to serve as Mayor for calendar year 2024. 2. Designate a member of City Council to serve as Vice Mayor for calendar year 2024. Item 7 8:50 A. AB 1234 Reporting of Meetings Attended at City Expense B. City Council Long Range Calendar. The calendar is a fluid working document used to support efficient and effective meetings and is subject to change. At this time, Council may request items be placed on a future meeting agenda Adjournment. The foregoing agenda for the December 12, 2023 meeting of the Davis City Council was delivered to each Councilmember and posted on the outside public bulletin board at City Hall, 23 Russell Boulevard on De- cember 8, 2023, and made available to the public during normal business hours. Meetings may be viewed online. They are live streamed and archived meetings are available for review at http://cityofdavis.org/city-hall/city-council/city-council-meetings/meeting-videos. Meetings are also televised live on City of Davis Government Channel 16 (available to those who subscribe to cable television) and replayed at the following times: Wednesday at 9:00 a.m.; Thursday at 7:00 a.m., 1:00 p.m. and 7:00 p.m.; and Saturday at 1:00 p.m. Closed captions are available for televised meetings - to view, activate captions on your viewing device.12-12-23 City Council MeetingAgenda - 3

Davis City Council Agenda December 12, 2023 Page 4 of 4 If you have any questions regarding televised meetings or the Government Channel in general, please call 530-757-5667. General Notes:  By request, alternative agenda document formats are available to persons with disabilities. To arrange an alternative agenda document format or to arrange aid or services to modify or accommodate per- sons with a disability to participate in a public meeting, contact the City Clerk by calling 530-757-5648 (voice) or 530-757-5666 (TDD).  Staff recommendations are guidelines to the City Council. On any item, the Council may take action which varies from that recommended by staff.  The City does not transcribe its proceedings. Anyone who desires a verbatim record of this meeting should arrange for a court reporter or for other acceptable means of recordation. Such arrangements will be at the sole expense of the individual requesting the recordation.  For questions about this agenda, call the City Clerk’s Office 530-757-5648 or email Clerkweb@cityofda- vis.org.12-12-23 City Council MeetingAgenda - 4

Showing the first 24,000 of 261,206 characters. The full document is at the source.

function here on 73. First of all sounds Hansel distance from this mission hustlas is for its setting versus welcome to community 12th, 2023 meeting of the Davis City Council before we begin I do want to share a note from our fire marshal as you can see. We do have a Packed house tonight. We are at maximum capacity as you can imagine if there there are any empty sats next to you, please raise your hand so that folks can fill up any empty seats. Anyone standing needs to please keep the exit doors. As clear and no sitting on the ground as it's a tripping Hazard and blocks exit Pathways. And also I gather that these aisles on the sides are icky exit route the need to be cleared. So I think not an issue on this side potentially on this side, but we are we are at capacity as you know, there's overflow folks in the lobby and in the conference room as well. And when we do get to public comment, we're going to ask, you know, just from a pure space usage standpoint. That folks are courteous about kind of once they speak making room for others to come and speak. I believe that's it on the capacity piece. Okay, so welcome everybody. It is a very nice to see so many folks here, and I hope you came in. Peace. So I will note that all city council members are here. S that that is purposes of roll call at this time. i will ask whether any changes are to be made to the agenda. Otherwise, I'll entertain a motion to approve the agenda. So moved it's been moved by Josh. Is there a second second second and by Donna any discussion on the motion? I'll call for a vote all in favor. Please. Say aye aye aye. Any opposed hearing none that passes unanimously we agenda so item one on the agenda is city manager brief announcements. That's item one a I'll give it to you Mike. Yeah, thank you very much mayor city council you do. You mean tonight actually do not have any announcements so you can get straight to your next items. Thank you. Thank you. Mike item one be city council brief announcements and liaison reports from various two by two meetings commission's boards or other juror interjurisdictional assignments. Does have any reports like that? Seeing none item 10 c city council indication of intent to pull items from our consent calendar for dscussion any items at this time that council members wish to pull from consent? I don't want you to pull anything, but if time allows I'd like to just make a brief comment on consent items c. Okay. We have to remind me when it comes up. Thank you. So with that, we'll move on now to item two. So this is general public comment for items that are not on our agenda the resolution village farms the mayor and vice mayor for next year are three regular items. Each of those items will have their own dedicated public comment period so this is for items that are not on the agenda because we have such a packed house. I am going to close public 7:30 if there's still folks. This is just for general public comment again, not for the items that are on the agenda. So I will open public comment and welcome our first speaker. Good evening, mayor Arnold and counsel. Thank you very much for hearing me again. They just relax Alan Hirsch. I'm here because I support all people but I particularly support science and I'm concerned about science. Acknowledged in the Middle East and particularly because the Middle East climate change the temperatures are rising twice as fast as the rest of the world twice as fast unless we Act here in Davis to address greenhouse gases that protect our climate action plan the land the mend of milk and honey the land the levantine palestine-israel, whatever you call it. It's going to be less inhabitable and have people will die from heat Stones by the end of the century. That's all the have a I have a story here little handout that talks about all this thing. We need to protect our climate plan for all the people for the entire world and for us to think that we can drive more. I'm on the freeway by widening the freeway to put more greenhouse gases in there. It's it in are air-conditioned cars, but people in the Middle East do not ever conditioning die and suffer in the pain is not appropriate. Last night before the environmental impact was could study was even completed decision was made to basically widen the freeway put more greenhouse gases in the air and even Caltrans even what's flawed analysis which attracts distance it District chair that executive or said she couldn't defend headed cannot be mitigated. They're still doing it short-term thinking. We that's climate Injustice that basically we cn drive and Davis we can so we can take a little five or six minutes and we destroy the climate and other places in the world. So thank you very mch. Please consider it. Please consider the resolution that you will commit in this resolution to address climate change to thank you very much. Thank you Alan. I will note at this time that our practice is to ensure that we have that folks feel safe and speaking. We do ask that folks not clap or whatever. The opposite of clap would be boo or something like that when there's a speaker just so that everyone feels as though they have safe. Space to speak of course the exception to that is when we're maybe giving kid an award or something like that. We love to clap for that but that's not what I'm talking about. So again, lots o new faces I think so. I like remind folks of sort of our practice. Are there any other members of the public that wish to make public comment on items not on our agenda? I'm not seeing any there's anyone in the back. That's not a little make it up front. Please indicate that but I'm not Seeing or hearing any do we have a pre-recorded general public comment? I believe we do. There's the kind of woman speaking on the item to General Public comment all of my comments at the meeting are being made the individual. So in this general public comment, I wanted to speak broadly about the need to Center the most marginalized and those who are most harmed by oppression and exploitation and there are a lot of different systems of Oppression from capitalism to ableism to white supremacy to colonialism to patriarchy that is heteronormativity, too. All sorts of different inching systems and structures that benefit certain groups at the of others and all of these systems need to be challenged and need to be dismantled and there are different ways to do that and there are different ways to do that at different levels of Oppression because some oppression is interpersonal but a lot of Oppression and especially some of the most Insidious oppression the type that is the most harmful, and yet the hardest to detect for members of dominant groups to do with the system's themselves and the institutions. So the way that Society is structured and the way that we are socialized to think about certain groups in different ways than we think about other purposes. So all of this needs to be incorporated into our analyses All of these systems and how best to work against them. So for instance a few years ago during the picnic day five when a group of undercover police assaulted and then arrested a group of young black and brown people at City Council meetings when we were discussing. The incident white supremacy was brought up as a system of Oppression and a lot of council members did not understand that. This That is referring to the underlying structures and institutions and not necessarily their personal feelings or actions. Yes. Yeah public comment for consent as well. Hi, my name is hi, my name is Todd Adelman and I'm from South Davis. This first comment is for the consent calendar item be designation of locations as restricted areas for the purposes of removing yard material pile collection service. Well, first of all any time we put tree material in the in the bike lane in most other places in the street were essentially weaponizing though. The trees against people riding bikes, but the overall problem is that there's no equity and ownership of living things. We have a funnel fundamental misunderstanding arboreal Eco systems also known as trees and until we work that out and come up with a different understanding. Which we teach ourselves and we teach our children. We're not going to solve things like we flowers or with leaf blowers with animals bees and so on which are part of trees and of course trees being half under grout. So at the very minimum, hope that this is brought out of calendar to this. Why we need to do signage and places where leaf piles are already illegal, and w're enforcement is basically completely useless importantly. Thanks very much. Okay, and that was our last of our general public comments, So I will close general public comment. Bring it back to the for for our consent calendar. This is item number three matters listed under the consent calendar considered routine non-controversial and and are approved typically all together. So after hearing public comment or their items that folks Wish to pull the additional items Donna I dd remember you had a comment on one of the concerns. Thank you ver Al and I'll just comment very briefly. And because I think this is relevant to everyone who's here tonight well item c on the consent calendar was our proposed legislative platform for the coming year where we as representatives of counsel seek different changes in the the law that we think would make it better allow us to better serve the community and one of the bills that is referenced in there is assembly Bill 817 which didn't progress during last year's legislative session. But which would allow ow, certain advisory bodies not this body city council, but the many advisory committees that we have and other entities have to meet virtually even in a post covid world and it can be a very if this if we can encourage this bill to move through the legislative process, I think it will go a long way to making public participation more inclusive more Equitable particularly in some of these large rural counties where it's become extremely difficult for individuals to travel to attend meetings in person. So I just wanted to highlight light that that is one of the bills that we are going to be working on as part of our platform. Great. Thank you, Donna and thank you for your on the subcommittee for the lgislative platform any other comments on the consent calendar? Otherwise, I'll entertain a motion to approve the consent calendar. It's been moved by Gloria. Is there a second I'll second consecutive by bapu any further discussion. Hearing none. I'll call for a vote all in favor. Please. Say aye hi any opposed hearing none on passes unanimously? Okay. So with we move on now to number for this is the item I believe most folks are here for this is a proposed resolution calling for peace in Israel. And Gaza. I don't believe we have a staff report on this. Correct Okay, so Before we go to public comment on this I did want to take just an opportunity first to thank everyone here everyone who be listening at home for the very thoughtful feedback. We've received thus fr on the proposed resolution, and I think it's worth sharing a bit of at least my thinking on how we arrived at the draft that is in front of us currently. I'll start by noting that that the feedback we've gotten so far has has as I seen it almost universally been about what is not contained in the resolution rather than what is in it. I'm not surprised by this the language itself that's in the resolution has received support while being criticized by folks on both sides of this charge debate as not being enough and I want to say that is fair criticism. It's not enough. I don't know that anything we could put forward would be enough and I know that words are not enough. I've we've received a lot of proposed additional language. I can speak only for myself that my thinking in the language that exists currently is it was an attempt at finding consensus and I think there is value in finding where we can all agree. I know we are very good at finding where we disagree but suppose I have concerns about where that gets us in trying to find common ground and that the mere quest for consensus in some cases can be seen itself as acquiescing to one side or another in a debate. And so I am fully prepared to be called naive on this point, but I believe there's value in finding where we can all agree in this case. About us the universal value human life and it's need for protection and that these are consensus principles identified in the draft resolution that if followed would it's would in fact result in an end to the violence and that the suggestion additions are are thoughtful and rooted in an Earnest desire for for greater peace and less suffering, but that potentially move us away from Consensus and this resolution is certainly not enough. It's not enough to satisfy everyone or probably anyone and it's I know my mindset was intentionally hpeful and future-focused. I suppose I remain convinced that the path forward for Humanity is to find where we can agree rather than finding where we disagree and if I'm alone on this, I'm okay with that a few notes about tonight. Went through a couple of them, but I figured I would mention a few it's clear that will have a lot of public comment. Can I get maybe a show of hands of who is anticipate is planning to speak tonight? We have a packed agenda already. So I'm making the determination that we will have 1 and 1/2 minutes per public commenter. I expect a diverse group of public commenters and sometimes filled with passion. We appreciate the value of free speech and at the council we listen to all. Voices we do not screen our public comments. I expect we'll hear voices of people personally touched by this harrowing violence that is occurring half a world away. I will ask in the name of of colorants that audience members do not applaud or respond so that everyone feels safe and nobody feels intimidated from sharing their feelings and thoughts. I will give an opportunity for first to my colleague Gloria with whom I worked on this draft as we have it if you have anything you want to add? I'm going to save some of my comments for after a public comment and when we have a discussion the resolution, but I just want to thank you for your comments. And I want to thank everyone who is you know, this is going to take a little while and a thank you for coming and for those of you who are willing to you know, stand through all of this. It's obvious that. It's always difficult to be in the position of having to navigate these highly emotional issues and nothing can be more emotionally than watching Humanity, especially children maimed and killed when this conflict started we were asked for statement condemning the atrocities Hamas had inflicted and continues to inflict by holding hostages. Through the mayor we responded with a statement because although week directly affect a lot of the policies that happen outside of our purview. I believe that one of I think we all believe that one of the most important roles of City leadership is to commiserate and respond to the hurt and pain. It's Community feels As elected officials we have grieved and MARCH together. I see a lot of you out there that have marched with and reflected with our words the concerns of the community. Sometimes is we're experiencing today holding that space with the community becomes So I've read many emails. I was reading them right up until we came in today and spoken to several individuals and have heard the varying ideas. Of what this resolution means to them My question to myself has been what is the purpose of this resolution? Will this resolution increase the likelihood of our national leaders responding in a certain way to the issue will this resolution signal to our community that we stand against the of innocent civilians in Gaza will this resolution signal to our community that we believe the state of Israel should be left abandoned and defenseless here. Iris attack from my conversations, all of these beliefs are held by different members of our community. As a person and timidly involved and part of marginalized groups. I know what it feels like to be overlooked and unheard I know it's important to stop and deeply listen and try to understand also know that no matter the language and it in this resolution people will feel unheard even if what we are ultimately saying is that we believe that no one below that no one deserves to be murdered in their homes. I also know that I Council are not fit to speak on the on foreign matters. I know that we care deeply about our community. i know that no one wants a continuation of armed combat in Israel Gaza or any of the more than 100 places that are currently in the middle of wars. So the purpose of putting out this resolution for m was to let my community know that I see you all of you that I believe this assault on Gaza should end just as I felt the attack by Hamas and Israel should have never happened. Lastly we received an email from the human relations commission, and I don't know if anyone is here from the human relations commission. And I was I want to thank them for attempting to reach out to community and be a sounding board for them and for reminding us that this process occurred in 2009. Was There almost word for word. The resolution was let's put out and it had the exact effect back in 2009 that there were this division that there was this Division and the community and as I mentioned I think that after public comment i will have more to say Thank you, Gloria two other of the council wish to make any comments at this time or o do you wanna move it quick just very quickly. I'll make more comments after hearing public comment, but I just want to say for many of you. It MAY be the first time that you're commenting at city council. I know that for many of us. It's not so easy to be speaking in public in front of Siddharth. Crowd and it's all that much more difficult when emotionally charged and you know that there's others in the audience who passionately disagree with you. So I'd like to say that this is a safe space. So when you come up, whatever you're feeling you're safe here, you're free here and we'll support you so too. The time you need to be done within the not to clear it out there, but take a breath and and and say what's in your heart. Thank you papa that's nicely said in a good note to remember anyone else. Would you want to go to public comment? Okay, the last thing I'll mention of a pure logistic piece is that we hope that maybe as folks are lining up that that line be only about 10 people long and then we can kind of cycle. I know it's it's a packed out. So it's going to be a little bit in negotiating the space here, but I think I think we can all do it and we're not. Make sure that that whoever wants to speak is given an opportunity. So with that I will open public comment on this item will start with folks who are here in the room with us. Welcome. Hi, I wish to quickly review why it's so important for the city of Davis to act as a voice for basic human rights as it did in 1978 divesting from the apartheid government of South Africa and support a real cease fire. Now if it's a gory says the cd Now would not dvest from South Africa because as gory as suggest, we don't really know anything about International Affairs that's that is for the city to, you know, be decisive on and create create a new phase. But I think that the current draft of the resolution reads too many constituents with whom I've spoken as a kind of a generic liberal bromide we hear you we feel your pain and something like all lives matter in the face of racist violence, but I feel that this killing o gazans cannot plausibly be seen as a reasonable military response or a targeted operation to remove Hamas. But is instead an attempted ethnic cleansing that even if you read the New York Times regularly, they've talked about what qualifies as a genocide and what I think many people in the community who have family there are experiencing as a genocide before their eyes and I feel actually it's a somewhat disturbing. Sort of Act of privilege and remoteness to just kind of give them a pat on the head But say we really can't do anything else except. Hope things get better. Thank you. Thank you to the public commenter. Welcome. Hello. My name is Jennifer and I come before you to this evening to urge the council to be more explicit and calling for a permanent unconditional ceasefire in this The resolution should demand the return of all hostages and and to Israel's occupation of the occupied territories and urge the federal government immediately direct substantive humanitarian. Aid to meet the needs of gaza's population. Some MAY ask why the city of Davis has any business and Gain. In a local Global Affairs, but as residents of Davis we are part of the larger World our local community contains individuals from Palestine and Israel those representing multiple Faith groups to whom the recently on Friday, of course, the United States made what I think is a tragic decision by voting against the un resolution for a permanent ceasefire and a virile Benoit the executive director of Doctors Without Borders for the U.S. Made in I think very powerful statement saying by vetoing this revolute resolution the U.S. Stands alone in casting it to vote against humanity and continues The U.S. Veto makes it complicit in the Carnage in Ian, I am sensitive the lessons of history and I feel compelled to learn from them and not repeat the mistakes of the past when individuals communities and governments turn a blind eye to Human Rights catastrophes Like we're seeing in Gaza now it's corrosive and Lee told destroying having lost extended families to genocide some 80 years ago. I cannot sit by and see it done again in My Name by Israel a government. That is dehumanize those. And well-being. It has unjustly held in its hands for more than 75 years. Thank you your friendship when we say It means never again for anyone welcome. First of all, I just want to say thank you for trying to use this as an opportunity to actually bring our community together on a very hard topic and I want to say we don't really know each other. Well, I'm Rabbi best Wallner and I speak as one of the two rabbis of congregation bait hovering spiritual home to over 300 families and the only synagogue in Yolo County and like many in this room. My completely shattered on OCTOBER 7th and has continued to shatter each day since every week from our Pulpit. We pray for peace and name the unimaginable suffering and Terror occurring in what is supposed to be a holy land those murdered by terrorists those taken hostage and those innocent civilians in Gaza. Gaza who have no control over the decisions of their leaders, but must face the horrible and irreversible consequences the GOD. I believe in cries at the deaths of the innocent no religion or nationality always. Last month with news of a ceasefire and the return of many of the hostages. I felt like I could take a real breath for the first time since OCTOBER 7th and this month I mourned when that ceasefire eded, but I am not a politician. I'm not a diplomat and I'm not a general. I am a rabbi here to serve my community and Yolo County and that is the lens they speak from every member of our congregation. I've spoken to wants to see peace for all people in the Middle East. Yes, they MAY hold many and varying opinions on how we get there I'm not here to say which of their views is right and which is wrong and only here to recognize a name the pain that this debate is having on our community. Your time is up. I'm just going to finish this one thing because I know other people got to go. But I hope and pray that this moment encourages us to have more hard conversations as a community not in the context of a city council mee

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
Agenda packetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Action agendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
MinutesNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Transcript or captionsSource recordread transcript
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Coverage and corrections

Records considered

  • City Council
  • City Council — Closed Captions

Not claimed by this page

  • Verified meeting decisions with item-specific public-source evidence
  • Item-level plain-language summaries are not available; this page does not infer individual agenda items.
  • Item-linked, attributed deliberation
  • A source-grounded next meeting date
  • A plain-English overview is not available.
  • Official outcomes have not been published.
  • The available transcript has no reliable timestamps.
  • Transcript coverage is partial.
  • No audio or video recording is linked.
  • Speakers have not been reliably matched to public profiles.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.
  • An individual roll-call roster is not available.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: 42ffef62e8f3832544f754582476607a. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record