POLISCOPE

The public record

PIEDMONT (ALAMEDA COUNTY)Decisions publishedPartial coverage

Planning Commission Meeting

Monday, January 8, 2024 · Government meeting record

The 30-second read

Recorded outcome

Planning Commission Meeting

Why it matters

The official meeting record is available below. Item-level plain-language summaries are not available yet.

What happens next

No later meeting or follow-up date is stated in the reviewed record.

An official outcome record - an action agenda or minutes - is published for this meeting.

Record text

No recording or transcript is held for this meeting.

Showing the first 60,000 of 100,705 characters. The full document is at the source.

1 PIEDMONT PLANNING COMMISSION Regular Meeting Minutes for Monday, January 8, 2024 A Regular Session of the Piedmont Planning Commission was held on Monday, January 8, 2024, both in person and via ZOOM teleconference, in accordance with Government Code Section 54953. The agenda for this meeting was posted for public inspection on December 21, 2023, in accordance with the General Code Section 54954.2 (a). CALL TO ORDER Chair Douglas Strout called the meeting to order at 5:32 p.m. A break was taken from 7:27 p.m. until 7:54 p.m. ROLL CALL Present: Commissioners Rani Batra, Aradhana Jajodia, Julie Ortiz, Wayne Rowland, Douglas Strout, and Justin Zucker Staff: Planning & Building Director Kevin Jackson, Senior Planner Pierce Macdonald, Associate Planner Gopika Nair, Assistant Planner Steven Lizzarago, Assistant Planner Joshua Muller, and Administrative Assistant Mark Enea, Deputy City Attorney Deepa Sharma PUBLIC FORUM There was no public testimony. REGULAR SESSION The Commission considered the following items of regular business: APPROVAL OF MINUTES Resolution 01-PL-24 RESOLVED, that the Planning Commission approves as presented its meeting minutes of the December 11, 2023, regular meeting of the Planning Commission. Moved by Jajodia, Seconded by Zucker Ayes: Batra, Jajodia, Rowland, Strout, Zucker Noes: None Absent: None CONSENT CALENDAR By procedural motion, the Commission placed the following application on the Consent Calendar as noted: • 546 Blair Avenue, DRPC2023-029 (Design Review Permit) Resolution 02-PL-24 RESOLVED, that the Planning Commission approves the Consent Calendar as noted. Moved by Batra, Seconded by Jajodia Ayes: Batra, Jajodia, Rowland, Strout, Zucker Noes: None Absent: None At the end of the meeting, the following Resolution was approved adopting the Consent Calendar item. Design Review, 546 Blair Avenue, DRPC2023-029 Resolution 023-DRPC-29 WHEREAS, the Property Owners are requesting permission to install a new pool and renovate existing landscape and hardscape within the rear yard, which construction requires a design review permit, and WHEREAS, after reviewing the application, plans, and any and all testimony and documentation submitted in connection with such application and after visiting the subject property, the Piedmont Planning Commission finds that the project is categorically exempt under the California Environmental Quality Act, CEQA, pursuant to CEQA Guidelines Section 15303, Class 3 (e), New Construction or

Planning Commission Minutes January 8, 2024 2 Conversion of Small Structures and 15304, Class 4 (b), Minor Alterations to Land, and the project was consistent with General Plan policies and programs; and WHEREAS, regarding the design review permit, the Planning Commission finds that, as conditioned, the project is consistent with General Plan policies and programs, and the proposal, as conditioned, does conform to the criteria and standards of Section 17.66.060 of the Piedmont City Code as follows: 1. The proposed design is consistent with the City's General Plan and Piedmont Design Guidelines. The following building features are consistent with the original architecture and neighborhood development including the plant material, the fence and accessory structure design, and the hardscape color and material. 2. The design has little or no effect on neighboring properties' existing views, privacy, and access to direct and indirect light because the distance between the project and neighboring homes is appropriate. There is sufficient vegetative screening. The topographical differences are appropriate to preserve privacy, views and light. 3. The proposed design does not adversely affect pedestrian or vehicular safety because the project does not modify vehicular safety conditions, and the new hardscape and pathways should improve pedestrian safety. 4. As conditioned, the application complies with the following Design Review Guidelines and General Plan policies and programs: Site Design 3.08, 3.09, 3.11, 3.12, 3.13, Building Design: General 4.04, 4.05, and Design: Single Family Residential 5.04. 5. The project is consistent with General Plan policies and programs, including the land use element, housing element, and design and preservation element, including: Design and Preservation Element Policy 29.2 (Landscape Design), Design and Preservation Element Policy 29.4 (Maintenance Privacy), Design and Preservation Element Policy 29.5 (Fence and Wall Design), Design and Preservation Element Policy 29.6 (Retaining Walls), and Design and Preservation Element Policy 29.8 (Exterior Lighting). RESOLVED, that based on the findings and facts set forth heretofore, the Piedmont Planning Commission approves the variances and design review permit applications for the construction at 546 Blair Avenue, Piedmont, California, in accordance with the plans and specifications on file with the City, subject to the following conditions: 1. Approved Plan Set. The approved plans are those submitted on December 27, 2023, after notices to neighbors were mailed and the application was available for public review. 2. Sound. The proposed mechanical equipment shall meet the sound requirements of a maximum 50 decibels (dBA) at the nearest property line as proscribed in Building Code Section 8.02.020 EE. Any modifications in order to meet the sound requirements including a sound barrier or an enclosure are subject to staff review and approval. 3. Defense of Legal Challenges. The Property Owner shall indemnify, defend and hold harmless the City, its Council, Planning Commission, advisory boards, officers, employees, consultants and agents (hereinafter “City”) from any claim, action or proceeding (hereinafter “Proceeding”) brought against the City to attack, set aside, void or annul the City‘s actions regarding any development or land use permit, application, license, denial, approval or authorization, including, but not limited to, variances, use permits, developments plans, specific plans, general plan

Planning Commission Minutes January 8, 2024 3 amendments, zoning amendments, approvals and certifications pursuant to the California Environmental Quality Act, and/or any mitigation monitoring program, or brought against the City due to actions or omissions in any way connected to the Property Owner’s project (“Challenge”). City may, but is not obligated to, defend such Challenge as City, in its sole discretion, determines appropriate, all at Property Owner’s sole cost and expense. This indemnification shall include, but not be limited to, damages, fees and/or costs awarded against the City, if any, and costs of suit, attorney’s fees and other costs, liabilities and expenses incurred in connection with such proceeding whether incurred by the Property Owner, City, and/or parties initiating or bringing such Proceeding. If the Property Owner is required to defend the City as set forth above, the City shall retain the right to select the counsel who shall defend the City. Per Government Code Section 66474.9, the City shall promptly notify Property Owner of any Proceeding and shall cooperate fully in the defense. 4. Encroachment Permit. Before the issuance of a building permit, the Property Owner shall apply for a revocable encroachment permit to allow for the construction within the sewer easement. 5. Sewer Main Condition and Repair. City records indicate that City storm and sewer mains and associated easement(s) may be located near the proposed construction next to the south property line. Prior to the issuance of a building permit, the Property Owner shall submit a revised copy of the survey prepared by Monumental Land Surveying to show sewer manhole covers and any easements. Said easements and manhole covers shall also be shown on the building permit drawings. The applicant shall also work with City staff to verify the location and depth of the storm and sanitary sewer mains. In addition, the City shall videotape the existing sanitary and storm sewer mains to assess their pre-construction condition in order to make a determination as to whether any repairs to or replacement of the sewer main is required prior to the commencement of excavation and/or construction. (The City is responsible for the cost of the main line, and the property owner for costs of the lateral.) As part of the final inspection the same sanitary and storm sewer lines shall be inspected as required by the Director of Public Works, who shall also determine if the sewer lines were damaged as a result of the construction and therefore must be repaired at the applicant's expense. The applicant is responsible to locate their private sewer lateral and note such location on the building permit drawings. 6. Stormwater Design. The California Regional Water Quality Control Board requires all projects, or a combination of related projects, that create and/or replace 2,500 square feet or more of impervious surface to comply with Provision C.3.i of the Municipal Regional Stormwater NPDES Permit. As required by the Chief Building Official, the Property Owner shall verify the total area of impervious surface to be created and/or replaced within the scope of this project, or this project combined with other related projects and/or permits and incorporate the site design measure(s) required under Provision C.3.i into the plans submitted for a building permit. Copies of the Municipal Regional Stormwater Permit are available from the Piedmont Public Works Department and on-line at cleanwaterprogram.org. 7. Final Landscape Plan. Before issuance of a building permit, the Property Owner shall submit for staff review and approval a Final Landscape Plan that shows trees proposed for retention. The final plan shall comply with City Code Division 17.34 and Section 17.33.30 and shall not propose plants near the driveway that could obscure visibility of pedestrians on the sidewalk or vehicles on the street from drivers backing out of the driveway. Upon the determination of the Director, minor differences in the number, size and/or species of vegetation between those shown on the approved landscape plan and those installed at the time of final

Planning Commission Minutes January 8, 2024 4 inspection that do not involve an increase in hardscape or structure coverage may be subject to staff review and approval. Significant differences between the vegetation installed at the time of final inspection and vegetation shown on the approved landscape plan are subject to a design review permit. 8. Construction Management Plan. The Property Owner shall develop a comprehensive Construction Management Plan. The Construction Management Plan shall identify the point(s) for access to the property for construction and address noise, vibrations, traffic control, parking, debris removal, dust control, sanitary facilities, site safety security emergency access, and other potential construction impacts, as well as other details involving the means and methods of completing the Project, including the construction route. The City Building Official has the authority to require modifications and amendments to the Construction Management Plan as deemed necessary throughout the course of the Project and until the Final Inspection. a. Construction Site Control of Stormwater. The California Regional Water Quality Control Board requires all projects that disturb the site to comply with Provision C.6 of the San Francisco Bay Regional Stormwater NPDES Permit in order to prevent construction site discharges of pollutants and other regulated materials during construction. As required by the Chief Building Official and prior to the issuance of a building permit, the Applicant shall develop and submit a construction stormwater management plan as part of the Construction Management Plan to achieve timely and effective compliance with Provision C.6. Permit Provision C.6.c.ii provides sources for site specific, and seasonally- and phase-appropriate, effective Best Management Practices (BMPs) that may be incorporated into the stormwater management plan. Copies of the Municipal Regional Stormwater Permit are available from the Piedmont Public Works Department and on-line at cleanwaterprogram.org. 9. Construction Completion Schedule. Work on the Project, once begun, shall be promptly executed with continuous good faith and reasonable progress. Since timely completion of this Project is of the essence, the Applicant shall submit for approval a Construction Completion Schedule, which will specify, in detail, the duration and percentage of the project as a whole for each phase. a. The Construction Completion Schedule with associated construction values for each benchmark shall set forth completion dates for the following benchmarks as needed: i) Completion of Excavation; ii) Completion of Retaining Walls; iii) Completion of Foundation; iv) Completion of Rough Framing; v) Completion of Electrical; vi) Completion of Plumbing; vii) Completion of Mechanical; viii) Completion of Fire Sprinklers; ix) Completion of Home; x) Completion of Hardscaping and Landscaping; and any further construction benchmarks and conditions of occupancy as may be determined by the Director of Planning and Building. b. Before the Project begins, the Director of Planning and Building shall make a determination as to the reasonableness of the proposed completion dates applicable to the Project, and that determination shall constitute the Approved Construction Completion Schedule and be binding on the Applicant. The City may, at the Applicant’s sole cost, engage the services of a consultant to review the proposed Construction Completion Schedule and, to the extent the period allocated for any work appears unjustifiable, recommend to the Director of Planning and Building a reasonable completion date for any benchmark. c. In the event of a change in scope of the Project that would alter the benchmarks dates set forth in the Approved Construction Completion Schedule, or in the event the Applicant fails to meet a benchmark set forth in the Approved Construction Completion Schedule, the Applicant shall

Planning Commission Minutes January 8, 2024 5 immediately submit a request to amend the Approved Construction Completion Schedule to the Director of Planning and Building. The request to amend shall be accompanied by a new proposed Construction Completion Schedule in compliance with subsection (a) of this condition of approval and the Director of Planning and Building shall evaluate the proposed amendments to the Approved Construction Completion Schedule in accordance with subsection (b) of this condition of approval. d. The failure of the Applicant to comply with the Approved Construction Completion Schedule, or any amendments to it approved in conformance with subsection (d) of this condition of approval, shall constitute a nuisance under the City of Piedmont City Code (“City Code”). The failure of the Applicant to comply with the Approved Construction Completion Schedule may result in the City pursuing administrative citations pursuant to Chapter 1 of the City Code, nuisance abatement pursuant to Chapter 6 of the City Code, or any other remedy available to the City under the law. Additionally, if the Applicant fails to comply with the Approved Construction Completion Schedule, the Director of Planning and Building, at his or her sole discretion, may make a claim against the Property Owner’s Site Security, if one is required, in order to complete the benchmark. The Director of Planning and Building, at his or her sole discretion, may refer the application to the Planning Commission for public review and direction. 10. California’s Water Efficient Landscape Ordinance: Property Owner shall comply with the requirements of California’s Model Water Efficient Landscape Ordinance that went into effect December 1, 2015, by submitting the following required information to the Building Department: a.) Landscape Documentation Package that includes the following 6 items: i) Project Information; ii) Water Efficient Landscape Worksheet; iii) Soil Management Report; iv) Landscape Design Plan; v) Irrigation Design Plan; and vi) Grading Design Plan. The Landscape Documentation Package is subject to staff review and approval before the issuance of a building permit. b.) Once a building permit has been issued, the Property Owner shall submit a copy of the Water Efficient Landscape Worksheet, to the local water purveyor, East Bay Municipal Utility District. c.) After completion of work, the Property Owner shall submit to the City and East Bay Municipal Utility District a Certificate of Completion, including an irrigation schedule, an irrigation maintenance schedule, and an irrigation audit report. The City may approve or deny the Certificate of Completion. Moved by Rowland, Seconded by Zucker Ayes: Batra, Jajodia, Rowland, Strout, Zucker Noes: None Absent: None Abstain: None REGULAR CALENDAR The Commission considered the following items as part of Regular Calendar: Study Session - Forthcoming General Plan Amendments, Draft Zoning Ordinance Amendment, and Draft Environmental Impact Report for Piedmont’s Housing Element Implementation Project In addition to providing the Commission a written report, Planning & Building Director Kevin Jackson Senior Planner Pierce Macdonald, and Associate Planner Gopika Nair presented a slide presentation to review draft amendments to the Piedmont General Plan and City Code Chapter 17, Planning and Land Use (Zoning Ordinance) that implement key programs from Piedmont’s adopted 6th Cycle Housing Element for the 2023-2031 term (Housing Element), implement the State laws that are already enacted, and clarify text. The study session also included a discussion about the Draft Environmental Impact Report (DEIR) prepared for the Housing Element Implementation project.

Planning Commission Minutes January 8, 2024 6 . Associate Planner Gopika Nair presented slides describing the proposals in detail and noted the Draft EIR was published on November 3, 2023. The Draft EIR is a program EIR. The public comment period ended on December 18, 2023, and a total of 16 comments were received. The final EIR and responses to public comment will be published by January 16, 2024. State law requires consistency within the elements of the General Plan, including the Housing Element, and consistency between the City’s General Plan and the Zoning Ordinance. To accomplish this, draft amendments were prepared for the Land Use, Environmental Hazards, Transportation, Design and Preservation, Community Services and Facilities, Natural Resources and Sustainability, and Parks, Recreation, and Open Space Elements. The draft amendments were published on the City’s Piedmontishome.org website on December 6, 2023. Study sessions were held on December 11, and December 18, 2023, which included public engagement. The proposed revisions to the Zoning Ordinance are limited to changes required by Housing Element programs and changes necessary for conformance with State law, and best practices to ensure consistency throughout the Zoning Ordinance. Revisions to Division 17.02: Title; Intent; City Charter. Revised section: 17.02.010. The proposed revisions are recommended by staff to provide consistency with the Housing Element and to reflect the City’s goal of welcoming more and diverse housing types as specified in the Housing Element. The proposed updates to the zoning revisions are designed to implement the City’s goals specified in this section. Revisions to Zone D: Commercial and Mixed Use. Revised section: 17.26.030. Following discussions at the December 18, 2023, City Council study session, staff proposes to eliminate language that calls out fueling station, EV charging station and minor auto servicing as conditional uses allowed in Zone D because said revisions are not a Housing Element program requirement. Revisions to Development Regulations in All Zones. Revised sections: 17.20.040.C, 17.22.040.D, 17.24.040.C, 17.26.040.E and 17.28.040.C. Following the discussions at the December 11, 2023, Planning Commission study session and consistent with the program requirements and program intent, staff has prepared proposed revisions to the sections that implement Housing Element program 1.E requirements in all zones. The revision primarily clarifies that construction of an ADU would be required when a new single-family residence is proposed on a vacant lot or when a remodel of an existing single-family residence is proposed where 70% or more of structure is demolished, unless the remodel or reconstruction is required due to a natural disaster. This reconstruction or remodel due to a natural disaster must remain at the same or similar square footage to not trigger the ADU construction requirement. Following discussions regarding SB 330, staff proposes additional development standards applicable to Zone C and Zone D for multi-family housing concurrent with the proposed increase in permitted residential density. The proposed amendments to the Zoning Code would implement a unit type mix standard for multi-family development, including co-housing and excluding senior and disabled housing types. The unit type mix requirement specifies that 50% of the new units proposed in new multi-family development must provide a minimum of two bedrooms. Exceptions are permitted for developments in which

Planning Commission Minutes January 8, 2024 7 100% of the units are deed-restricted affordable to households earning very low incomes (50% or less of the area median income or AMI) for 55 years. Following the discussions at the December 18, 2023, City Council study session and consistent with Housing Element program requirements, staff proposes to specify a deed restriction period of 55 years or more to the commercial waiver offered to a 100% affordable residential development. To meet the program requirements of Housing Element Program 1.R, staff proposes that a floor area ratio requirement be added for non-residential uses in Zone D and a minimum density of 20 dwelling units per acre be added for multifamily residential development or similar group residential uses in Zone D. Revisions to New Division 17.54 Urban Lot Splits and Two-Unit Housing Developments. Revised section: 17.54.010, 17.54.020. Staff proposes to add language to explicitly state that SB 9 development is allowed in zones A and E only. Revisions to Division 17.90 Definitions; Measurements. Revised sections: 17.90.010 and 17.90.020. Staff proposes to add the definition for the term “demolished.” Staff also proposes to add clarification for the terms: dwelling units per acre and net lot area under the Measurements section. Revisions to Division 17.67 Ministerial Design Review Permits. Staff proposes revisions that allow ministerial design review of development projects that meet the State’s eligibility criteria in addition to eligibility under SB 35. For example, applications submitted under SB 6 and AB 2011. The next step includes a special meeting of the Planning Commission on Monday, January 29, 2024, during which and in conformance with City Code section 17.72.040, the Commission will hold a public hearing to consider a recommendation to the City Council regarding the amendments to the General Plan and Zoning Ordinance and a related Environmental Impact Report (EIR). Comments on the proposed amendments to the General Plan and City Code and on the EIR, can be made by emailing Senior Planner Pierce Macdonald at pmacdonald@piedmont.ca.gov and Associate Planner Gopika Nair at gnair@piedmont.ca.gov. Commissioners Jajodia asked about the ministerial design review approval authority and is the “no notice” requirement state mandated? She also asked if there are any notifications for ministerial applications. Director Jackson responded that ministerial means there is no public hearing so there are no notifications. Commissioner Rowland asked if it would be an exception to the requirement of construction of an ADU if a home is damaged or destroyed by natural disaster. He also asked if a definition exists for what is considered a natural disaster. Director Jackson responded that yes that is an exception, and the definition would be the “common sense term” for natural disaster. Commissioner Zucker asked about the Zone D requirement for ground floor commercial retail and the uses. He stated this does not appear to be an objective standard but a more subjective standard.

Planning Commission Minutes January 8, 2024 8 There was no public testimony received. Study Session – Moraga Canyon Specific Plan Planning & Building Director Kevin Jackson stated that staff and JZMK Partners will provide a report and presentation on the status of the preparation of a Moraga Canyon Specific Plan (MCSP) and discuss the Commission’s priorities and concerns. Andrew Watkins, representing JZMK Partners, presented that the MCSP is a program of the certified 6 th Cycle Housing Element, that accommodates 132 new housing units, and includes recreation uses and the Public Works Corporation Yard. Planning work began in September 2023 to be completed by the end of 2024, and the affordable housing program is expected to secure Alameda County Measure A-1 (2016) funding. A ”Specific Plan” is a comprehensive, action-oriented planning and zoning document for a defined geographic area. Specific Plans bridge the gap between the general policy-oriented language of a city’s “Specific Plan” by providing detailed criteria for the development of specific sites. The MCSP will study all City-owned land in Moraga Canyon, including Blair Park Open Space, Coaches Field, Kennelly Skate Park, and the City’s Public Works Corporation Yard. The end goal is to create a detailed plan for how to incorporate 132 units of new housing, 60 of which would be reserved for households with lower incomes; maintain, replace and improve existing City facilities (Corp Yard), open space, and recreational amenities; and improve traffic as well as pedestrian, bicycle and wildfire safety. The Moraga Canyon Specific Plan Community Survey ran from September 20 to October 20, 2023. More than 1,100 community members participated in the survey. The survey included questions about which benefits of the MCSP are most important, how often do people visit Moraga Canyon, and what qualities of Moraga Canyon were valued the most. Andrew Watkins described the existing site conditions and preliminary concepts for the specific plan. He noted that some site improvements that can be utilized in any plan include better mobility, recreation, public works, and housing. Ease of access to the site is important for mobility and a signalized control at the Red Rock Road intersection would improve access. Possible recreation improvements include new sports fields, parking, and a skate area. Public Works would improve their facilities and space. Housing includes the 132 units. The market-rate and affordable housing project needs to operate somewhat independently. Mr. Watkins continued that the specific plan options considered the walk-up, the wrap, and the podium building types. The podium building type was chosen because it uses land efficiently. Mr. Watkins described slides showing each of four land use options. Option 1 would include housing development in Blair Park open space, preserve and expand Coaches Field, preserve the Corporation Yard, improve pedestrian and bicyclist safety and access, and increase parking and transit access. Option 2 would include combining public recreation on Blair Park open space, minor impacts to the Corporation Yard, increase parking and transit access, improve pedestrian and bicyclist safety and access, and multiple development sites on Coaches Field side with common open space amenity. Option 3 would move the Corporation Yard to Blair Park Open Space, improve the soccer field and skate park, increase parking and transit access, improve pedestrian and bicyclist safety and access, facilitate hillside housing development, and avoid infrastructure relocation. Option 4 would include preserve Blair Park Open Space, improving the soccer field and skate spot, with under-field parking, increasing transit access, improving pedestrian safety and access, as well as

Planning Commission Minutes January 8, 2024 9 hillside housing development, avoiding infrastructure relocation, and connecting open space along Moraga Ave. A feasibility study is currently underway. The feasibility study will assess the development feasibility of the MCSP Area given the proposed program, current market values, and infrastructure and development costs. The fiscal study evaluates ongoing, annual impacts of the MCSP at buildout to the City’s General Fund. The feasibility study considers the residual land value (RLV) values (sales prices and capitalized rents) minus development costs (horizontal infrastructure and vertical construction). RLV identifies supportable land value and is used to assess gaps in feasibility. The fiscal study for the annual General Fund impact reviews key City documents, such as the FY 2023-2024 budget (adopted). It estimates revenues including property tax, property tax in-lieu of VLF, property transfer tax, parcel tax, rental tax, and other revenues. It estimates expenditures in coordination with departments on anticipated expenditures given new service population from 132 new housing units. Further feasibility analysis will include refining programmatic assumption across alternatives, Residual Land Value analysis, and exploring financing mechanisms to defray infrastructure costs and improve project development feasibility. The November 30, 2023, workshop’s key themes included: • Attendees were generally supportive of housing in Moraga Canyon • Concern for meaningful combination of market-rate and affordable housing • Questions regarding alternative placement of the two single-family homes • Traffic and pedestrian and cyclist safety • Traffic calming and congestion smoothing measures along Moraga Avenue • Hiking trail(s) addition received positive feedback • Preservation of Coaches Field and Blair Park Open Space recreation areas is a priority for many residents • Option 4 received the most comments, with praise for the preservation of open space in the Canyon. Some comments questioned the financial viability and impact of building the playfield atop a garage structure. Commissioner discussed the traffic analysis, options to preserve the Corporation Yard, improvements to the Corporation Yard buildings, road widening where the new housing units are located by the Corporation Yard in Option 2, a plan for a visual separation. Commissioners discussed protections for bicyclists from cars, and analysis of bottlenecks on Moraga Avenue for ingress and Commissioners requested information and development assumptions for the market-rate and affordable housing, such as is there a parking podium underneath, and requested more detail regarding the infrastructure impacts ratings table included in the presentation slides. Mr. Watkins responded that a traffic analysis is part of the Specific Plan. He noted that where the Corporation Yard is preserved in its existing location, there are not plans to make improvements to the buildings. Yes, a new scope would need to be added if a build new scenario is needed for the Corporation Yard in its existing location. Mr. Watkins explained that there will be some widening of certain areas of Moraga Avenue. The Specific Plan concept anticipates that there will be visual separation, such as vegetation etc., between the Corporation Yard and residential units. In addition, there will be bicyclist roadway striping on the uphill bike lane only, and the traffic consultants will study more details on that. The Specific Plan concept mitigates parking podiums are underneath the housing. Mr. Watkins noted that the impact 4 score for option 4 was due to the big impact of the parking garage. He noted that in general, the options with housing closer to Moraga Avenue would have a small

Planning Commission Minutes January 8, 2024 10 advantage for fire risk. H also noted that there has not been a study for the useful life of the existing facilities in the Corporation Yard. Public testimony was received from: Ralph Catalano Pam Hirtzer, Liz Lummis O’Neil, Julie Waters, Irene Cheng, Kirk Peterson, Marj Blackwell and Andy Madeira stated their concerns about the project, which included safety and traffic hazards along Moraga Avenue and crossing it, the segregation of housing units, escape routes during a wildfire, parking, privacy impacts from the proposed hiking trail, the impacts from the proposed single-family housing at Maxwelton Road and Abbott Way, the detouring of traffic during construction, the architectural character of the development, the lack of detailed costs and public funding, Piedmont’s moral imperative to develop affordable housing the impediment public infrastructure improvements present to the development of affordable housing, and the availability of public funding sources to build affordable housing. Chair Strout stated that it would be beneficial to choose an optimal plan, if the utilities impact matrix could be expanded. Some concerns are access to site, parking, traffic impact, constructability, number of phases of construction, future growth potential, Corporate Yard (stay the same or add cost to the scope), green space, and acoustics. Commissioner Batra stated all these steps help to visualize what the project could look like. She noted that safety and public funds could be determining factors in an option being chosen. She asked if options should be narrowed at this point, or should they all be left in play? Commissioner Zucker stated that if there are aspects of the proposals that are not permitted, they shouldn’t be considered because it would be a waste of time. In regard to public financing and viability, there have been issues with things being built in a certain timeline within the 6 th Cycle. Things need to be lined up in order to get the housing Piedmont needs in the 6 th Cycle. Director Jackson stated the next step is to hear the particular concerns with any of the options that are relevant to the Commission and Council. The next public City Council study session will be held on January 22, 2024. The City Council may give some direction on how to proceed to develop a draft of the Moraga Canyon Specific Plan. Commissioner Zucker asked about Option 2. Mr. Watkins stated that the idea is to understand the site’s potential for residential buildings. Commissioner Batra stated it’s important to integrate different income levels and it should be a principle of any of the options that get finalized. Mr. Watkins stated the cost analysis will be provided at the City Council meeting. Commissioner Rowland stated housing is based on the needs of the consumer of housing. The needs could be very different for affordable housing residents versus fair market residents. Mr. Rowland suggested the City focus on the needs of the actual resident, and what is best for them. Design Review, 139 Lexford Road, DRPC2023-018 The Property Owners are requesting permission to construct a new 4,573-square-foot single-family residence on an existing vacant lot in Zone A. The new residence is proposed to be four levels with three bedrooms, two bathrooms, a half bath, a ceramic tile roof, dining room, kitchen, family room, office, laundry room, elevator, and

Planning Commission Minutes January 8, 2024 11 conforming two-car garage. A front terrace is proposed at the upper level, and patios are proposed at the rear of the house. A proposed landscape plan has been submitted with retaining walls, stairs, walkways, and exterior lighting. The application proposes retaining walls greater than 30 inches in the front setback. Public testimony was received from: Kirk Peterson, architect, stated that the design is a step up the hill and an interesting composition due to the site and height limit. There is a need for an elevator. Previous approvals listed conditions with many measures. The project is feasible. In response to Commissioner questions, Mr. Peterson stated that this design is only different from previous versions on the one side where the setback is increased by 1 foot, that the house is a little bit smaller, that the elevator made it harder to minimize excavation, that the drainage for the site is typical, and that the project did not previously get constructed because of financial requirements and then a divorce. Willis Yu, Property Owner, stated that he has developed multiple single-family residences on hilly sites and understands what is at stake for this project. He also stated he is open to considering reasonable and relevant suggestions, and that the construction of the residence will follow the professional guidance of qualified engineers. Testimony was received from adjacent and nearby neighbors, including Stuwart Block, Eileen White, Michael Gardner, Reza Bazargani, Bonnie Wang, Shari Fujii, Feng Nathan Pan, Anuraag Kansal, Christopher Van Gundy, Bob Stanley, and Richard Wang, stated that although they are supportive of the project and the prospect of a new family in the neighborhood and the overall design and aesthetic qualities of the proposed residence, they have significant concerns with the proposed construction methods, the geotechnical characteristics of the hillside, protections for neighboring properties and the hillside, and the conditions of approval for the application (specifically the omission of conditions included for previously approved projects at this site). Additional testimony was received from Denay Hillbrandt-Buddy who stated she has concerns about damaged trees where the garage is proposed, the nature of the construction relative to the easement present, and protection for her clients at 145 Lexford Road. Director Jackson explained the Commission’s role in regard to the requirement of bonds as a condition of approval. He also noted that the standards for approval for the proposed construction are provided in City Code 17.66.060. Commissioner Rowland stated there wasn’t any objections to the design of the project, and that construction concerns will be addressed during the building permit phase. Commissioner Batra commended all speakers for the tenor of the discussion but stated she thought additional protections for neighbor’ properties was warranted and is open to suggestions. Commissioner Zucker commended all the speakers. He stated that development is possible on steeply sloped properties, and across the board, speakers were supportive of the project, they are open to adding another house, but they want it to be built responsibly. The builder is responsible with a track record of building on sites of this nature. The concerns that were raised are building permit issues not design issues. It’s consistent with the General Plan. The City has identified this site to be developed. This is an approvable design. He reiterated some conditions of approval that are already in

Planning Commission Minutes January 8, 2024 12 place. He noted a quote by Alan Kropp, a geotechnical engineer whose analysis of the project was included with the public comments, stating that the site is viable for development. Commissioner Jajodia stated the design is within the zoning code requirements. The design is appropriate for building on the challenging slope. She supports the project from a design review perspective. The conditions of approvals address some of the speaker’s concerns. Commissioner Rowland stated the project meets the design review guidelines. He supports the project. It’s a brave project. He understands the neighbor’s concerns. With proper conditions, concerns are addressed, and becomes an approved design. Chair Strout commended Commissioners Jajodia and Zucker for going through the conditions of approval, and that the project appears to be a buildable design. He supports the project. Resolution 018-DRPC-23 WHEREAS, the Property Owners are requesting to construct a new 4,573-square-foot single-family residence on an existing vacant lot in Zone A. The new residence is proposed to be four levels with three bedrooms, two bathrooms, a half bath, a ceramic tile roof, dining room, kitchen, family room, office, laundry room, elevator, and conforming two-car garage. A front terrace is proposed at the upper level, and patios are proposed at the rear of the house. A proposed landscape plan has been submitted with retaining walls, stairs, walkways, and exterior lighting. The application proposes retaining walls greater than 30 inches in the front setback, which construction requires a design review permit, and WHEREAS, after reviewing the application, plans, and any and all testimony and documentation submitted in connection with such application and after visiting the subject property, the Piedmont Planning Commission finds that the project is categorically exempt under the California Environmental Quality Act, CEQA, pursuant to CEQA Guidelines Section 15303, Class 3 (a), New Construction or Conversion of Small Structures because the project proposes a new single-family residence, and there is substantial evidence in the record that none of the exceptions to the exemptions in Sections 15302 are present, and Section 15304, Class 4 (b), Minor Alterations to Land because the project proposes new landscaping; and WHEREAS, regarding the design review permit, the Planning Commission finds that, as conditioned, the project is consistent with General Plan policies and programs, including the recent Housing Element update, and the proposal, as conditioned, does conform to the criteria and standards of Section 17.66.060 of the Piedmont City Code as follows: 1. The proposed design is consistent with the City's General Plan and Piedmont Design Guidelines. The following building features are consistent with the original architecture and neighborhood development including the wall material, the building articulation, the roof form, the roof material, stepping of the building into the slope, the window and door material, the fenestration pattern, the eave overhang design and dimension, the guardrail material, and the relationship of the proposed residence to the site, to existing topography, and to neighboring residences including the locations of driveways. 2. The design has little or no effect on neighboring properties' existing views, privacy, and access to direct and indirect light because the distance between the project and neighboring homes is appropriate. The view is not a significant view. There is

Planning Commission Minutes January 8, 2024 13 sufficient vegetative screening. The topographical differences are appropriate to preserve privacy, views and light as exemplified by the slope and trees. The height of the project has been kept as low as possible and tucks into the slope wherever possible. 3. The proposed design does not adversely affect pedestrian or vehicular safety because the project maintains adequate visibility for entering and exiting the driveway and adjacent driveways are comment in Piedmont. The new handrails and on-grade steps should facilitate pedestrian safety. The separation between the proposed driveway and the pedestrian path of travel on the property and in the public right-of- way is safe and appropriate because the project includes both the construction of a sidewalk along the frontage on Lexford Road and pedestrian access that is distinct from the garage access. 4. As conditioned, the application complies with the following Design Review Guidelines and General Plan policies and programs: Site Design 3.03, 3.05, 3:08, 3.09, 3.11, 3.12, 3.13, Building Design: General 4.01, 4.02, 4.03, 4.04, 4.05, and Design: Single Family Residential 5.01, 5.02, 5.04. 5. The project is consistent with General Plan policies and programs, including the land use element, housing element, and design and preservation element, including: Design and Preservation Element Policy 18.4 (Soil and Geologic Reports), Design and Preservation Element Policy 22.1 (Noise Insulation for New Development), Design and Preservation Element Policy 22.2 (Noise Reduction Measures), Design and Preservation Element Policy 28.1 (Scale, Height, and Bulk Compatibility), Design and Preservation Element Policy 28.2 (Style Compatibility), Design and Preservation Element Policy 28.4 (Setback Consistency), Design and Preservation Element Policy 28.5 (Garages, Decks, and Porches), Design and Preservation Element Policy 28.6 (Exterior Materials), Design and Preservation Element Policy 28.7 (Hillside Home Design), Design and Preservation Element Policy 28.8 (Acoustical and Visual Privacy), Design and Preservation Policy 28.12 (Creativity and Innovation), Design and Preservation Element Policy 29.1 (Conserving Residential Yards), Design and Preservation Element Policy 29.2 (Landscape Design), Design and Preservation Element Policy 29.3 (Front Yard Enclosures), Design and Preservation Element Policy 29.4 (Maintaining Privacy), Design and Preservation Element Policy 29.5 (Fence and Wall Design), Design and Preservation Element Policy 29.6 (Retaining Walls), Design and Preservation Element Policy 29.7 (Driveway and Parking Location), Design and Preservation Element Policy 29.8 (Exterior Lighting), and Design and Preservation Element Policy 29.9 (Sight Obstructions). RESOLVED, that based on the findings and facts set forth heretofore, the Piedmont Planning Commission approves the variances and design review permit applications for the construction at 139 Lexford Road, Piedmont, California, in accordance with the plans and specifications on file with the City, subject to the following conditions: 1. Window and Door Material. As specified in the plans, the building material for the new windows and doors shall be aluminum. 2. Window Color Scheme. All the windows on the house shall have a consistent color scheme. 3. Window Recess. All new windows shall be recessed 3 inches from the exterior wall to the face of window sash in order to maintain consistency with the proposed Mediterranean style architecture, as required by the City’s Design Guidelines and Standards and Window Replacement Policy. Window details shall be submitted for review and approval at the time of building permit application. 4. Exterior Lighting. All new exterior light fixtures surface-mounted to walls and ceilings shall be downward directed with an opaque or translucent shade that

Planning Commission Minutes January 8, 2024 14 completely covers the light bulb. 5. Sound. The proposed air conditioning unit shall meet the sound requirements of a maximum 50 decibels (dBA) at the nearest property line as proscribed in Building Code Section 8.02.020 EE. Any modifications in order to meet the sound requirements including a sound barrier or an enclosure are subject to staff review and approval. 6. Garage Door. To facilitate vehicular access, the garage door shall be motorized. If design modifications are required to accomplish this, those modifications shall be subject to staff review. In addition and in compliance with California Health and Safety Code Section 19892, an automatic garage door opener for the garage door(s) shall have a battery backup function that is design to operate when activated in the event of an electrical outage. 7. Contractor’s General Liability Insurance. To ensure that the contractor doing work in the City will be responsible for damages caused by the work to City property or to neighboring property, the Property Owner shall require all contractors performing work on the Project to maintain General Liability Insurance for protection from claims for damages because of bodily injury, including death, and claims for damages, other than to the contractor’s work itself, to property which may arise out of or result from the contractor’s operations. Such insurance shall be written for not less than $2,000,000 per occurrence. The insurance shall include an endorsement requiring 10 days prior notice to the City if the insurance is to be cancelled or changed, and Property Owner shall immediately arrange for substitute insurance coverage. If the contractor’s insurance carrier states in writing that it is unable to provide the required endorsement, Property Owner shall be responsible for providing the City with the required notice if the insurance is to be cancelled or changed. Property Owner’s failure to provide such notice shall constitute grounds for revocation of the City’s design review approval and/or permit. If the Property Owner does not have a general contractor, the Property Owner shall maintain property insurance and coverage for contractors, which is substantially equivalent to the contractor's requirement of this section. 8. Modifications to Conditions. The City may impose modifications to Conditions of Approval #7, #22, and #25 in the event such modification is necessary in the opinion of the Director of Planning & Building in consultation with the City Attorney. 9. C&D Compliance. Compliance with Section 9.04 of the Municipal Code, which governs the recycling of construction and demolition debris, is required for all phases of this project. 10. Double Trailer Truck Prohibition. To reduce potential damage to the streets and to avoid traffic hazards on narrow curving city streets, no double trailers shall be used as part of the Project. 11. Defense of Legal Challenges. The Property Owner shall indemnify, defend and hold harmless the City, its Council, Planning Commission, advisory boards, officers, employees, consultants and agents (hereinafter “City”) from any claim, action or proceeding (hereinafter “Proceeding”) brought against the City to attack, set aside, void or annul the City‘s actions regarding any development or land use permit, application, license, denial, approval or authorization, including, but not limited to, variances, use permits, developments plans, specific plans, general plan amendments, zoning amendments, approvals and certifications pursuant to the California Environmental Quality Act, and/or any mitigation monitoring program, or brought against the City due to actions or omissions in any way connected to the Property Owner’s project (“Challenge”). City may, but is not obligated to, defend such Challenge as City, in its sole discretion, determines appropriate, all

Planning Commission Minutes January 8, 2024 15 at Property Owner’s sole cost and expense. This indemnification shall include, but not be limited to, damages, fees and/or costs awarded against the City, if any, and costs of suit, attorney’s fees and other costs, liabilities and expenses incurred in connection with such proceeding whether incurred by the Property Owner, City, and/or parties initiating or bringing such Proceeding. If the Property Owner is required to defend the City as set forth above, the City shall retain the right to select the counsel who shall defend the City. Per Government Code Section 66474.9, the City shall promptly notify Property Owner of any Proceeding and shall cooperate fully in the defense. 12. Setback from Property Line Verification. Prior to foundation inspection, the applicant shall submit to the Building Official written verification by a licensed land surveyor stating that the construction is located at the setback dimension from North, East, and South property lines as shown on the approved plans. The intent is to verify that the approved features are constructed at the approved dimension from the property lines. 13. Building Height and Floor Level Verification. Prior to foundation and frame inspections, the applicant shall provide the Building Official written verification by a licensed land surveyor stating that the floor levels and roof of the new structure are constructed at the approved heights above grade. 14. Encroachment Permit. Before the issuance of a building permit, the Property Owner shall apply for an encroachment permit to allow for the construction within the public right-of-way. 15. Sewer Main Condition and Repair. City records indicate that City storm and sewer mains and associated easement(s) may be located near the proposed construction next to the east property line. Prior to the issuance of a building permit, the Property Owner shall submit a revised copy of the survey prepared by Moran Engineering to show sewer manhole covers and any easements. Said easements and manhole covers shall also be shown on the building permit drawings. The applicant shall also work with City staff to verify the location and depth of the storm and sanitary sewer mains. In addition, the City shall videotape the existing sanitary and storm sewer mains to assess their pre-construction condition in order to make a determination as to whether any repairs to or replacement of the sewer main is required prior to the commencement of excavation and/or construction. (The City is responsible for the cost of the main line, and the property owner for costs of the lateral.) As part of the final inspection the same sanitary and storm sewer lines shall be inspected as required by the Director of Public Works, who shall also determine if the sewer lines were damaged as a result of the construction and therefore must be repaired at the applicant's expense. The applicant is responsible to locate their private sewer lateral and note such location on the building permit drawings. 16. Stormwater Design. The California Regional Water Quality Control Board requires all projects, or a combination of related projects, that create and/or replace 2,500 square feet or more of impervious surface to comply with Provision C.3.i of the Municipal Regional Stormwater NPDES Permit. As required by the Chief Building Official, the Property Owner shall verify the total area of impervious surface to be created and/or replaced within the scope of this project, or this project combined with other related projects and/or permits, and incorporate the site design measure(s) required under Provision C.3.i into the plans submitted for a building permit. Copies of the Municipal Regional Stormwater Permit are available from the Piedmont Public Works Department and on-line at cleanwaterprogram.org. 17. Final Landscape Plan. Before issuance of a building permit, the Property Owner shall submit for staff review and approval a Final Landscape Plan that shows trees

Planning Commission Minutes January 8, 2024 16 proposed for retention. The final plan shall comply with City Code Division 17.34 and Section 17.33.30 and shall not propose plants near the driveway that could obscure visibility of pedestrians on the sidewalk or vehicles on the street from drivers backing out of the driveway. Upon the determination of the Director, minor differences in the number, size and/or species of vegetation between those shown on the approved landscape plan and those installed at the time of final inspection that do not involve an increase in hardscape or structure coverage may be subject to staff review and approval. Significant differences between the vegetation installed at the time of final inspection and vegetation shown on the approved landscape plan are subject to a design review permit. 18. Arborist’s Report and Certified Tree Preservation Plan. Before the issuance of a building permit, the Property Owner shall submit an Arborist’s Report and Certified Tree Preservation Plan that includes tree preservation measures to preserve the existing Oak trees in the upper left portion of the property and the Eucalyptus trees along the east property line. The tree preservation measures shall be on the appropriate sheets of the construction plans. The arborist shall be on- site during critical construction activities, including initial and final grading, to ensure the protection of the existing trees that are intended to be retained. The arborist shall document in writing and with photographs the tree protection measures used during these critical construction phases. If some trees have been compromised, mitigation measures must be specified in writing, and implementation certified by the Project Arborist. Trees proposed for removal shall have an in-lieu replacement tree planted elsewhere on the property, which shall be shown on the final landscape plan. Replacement tree size is subject to staff review and shall be commensurate with the size and numbers of trees to be removed. They shall generally be a minimum of 24" box size. Before the Final Inspection, the Arborist shall file a report to the City certifying that all tree preservation measures as recommended have been implemented to his/her satisfaction and that all retained trees have not been compromised by the construction. 19. Foundation/Shoring/Excavation Plan. The Property Owner shall submit foundation, excavation, and shoring plans prepared by a licensed civil or structural engineer that fully address issues of site shoring, fencing and hillside security issues. The plans shall not require any trespassing or intruding into neighboring properties (without prior written consent), and shall mitigate against any subsidence or other damage to neighboring properties. Such plans shall incorporate as appropriate the recommendations of the Property Owner’s geotechnical engineer and the City’s geotechnical consultant and shall be subject to approval by the City Engineer and the Chief Building Official. 20. Geotechnical Report and Review. The Property Owner shall submit a report prepared by a geotechnical engineer of the Property Owner’s choice that fully assesses the existing site conditions, and addresses all issues regarding excavation and grading, foundations and their construction, drainage, retaining wall systems, periodic on-site observations, and other related items involving the Project. a. Peer Review. The City, at the Property Owner’s sole expense, shall retain an independent geotechnical consultant to perform a peer-review of the Property Owner’s geotechnical report and advise the City in connection with the Property Owner’s proposals. The City Engineer shall select this independent geotechnical consultant, whose services shall be provided for the sole benefit of the City and whose reports and recommendations can be relied upon only by the City. The independent geotechnical consultant shall also review the building plans during the permit approval process, and may provide periodic on-site observations during excavation and construction of the foundations as deemed necessary by the City Engineer. The Property Owner shall provide

Planning Commission Minutes January 8, 2024 17 payment for this at the time of the Building Permit submittal. 21. Sound and Vibration Mitigation Plan and Review. As required by the Director of Public Works, the Property Owner shall submit a plan prepared by a licensed engineer of the Property Owner’s choice that fully assesses the existing site conditions for the mitigation and monitoring of vibration and decibel levels at the Project during construction (including being periodically present at the construction site during excavation and foundation work). If, in the Engineer’s sole discretion, such monitoring indicates that the sound or vibration levels exceed those anticipated in the Property Owner’s Construction Management Plan and/or the Sound and Vibration Mitigation Plan, all work on the Project may be immediately stopped by the City and may not resume until the City Engineer is fully assured that the sound and vibration transmissions generated by work on the Project can be maintained at or below a reasonable level and duration. a. Peer Review. The City, at the Property Owner’s sole expense, shall retain an independent engineering consultant to perform a peer-review of the Property Owner’s Sound and Vibration Mitigation Plan and advise t

1 City of Piedmont Planning Commission Agenda - REVISED Monday, January 8, 2024 5:30 p.m. City Council Chambers, 120 Vista Avenue, Piedmont, CA Piedmont Planning Commission meetings are conducted in person at City Hall Council Chambers. As a courtesy, and technology permitting, members of the public may participate virtually. However, the City cannot guarantee that the public’s access to teleconferencing technology will be uninterrupted, and technical difficulties may occur from time to time. Please see the end of the agenda for information on how to participate virtually. Call to Order Roll Call Public Forum Persons wishing to address the Planning Commission regarding items not on the agenda may do so during the Public Forum. In order for all speakers to be heard, the Commission normally limits individuals’ comments to 3 minutes. Disclosure of ex parte communications and identification of conflicts of interest Regular Agenda 1. Approval of minutes for the December 11, 2023, regular meeting of the Planning Commission. 2. Removal of Applications from Regular Session to Consent Calendar. Applications that receive unanimous Planning Commission approval by consent will be placed on the Consent Calendar prior to consideration of the remaining applications on the Regular Session agenda. 3. STUDY SESSION - FORTHCOMING GENERAL PLAN AMENDMENTS, DRAFT ZONING ORDINANCE AMENDMENTS, AND DRAFT ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT REPORT FOR PIEDMONT’S HOUSING ELEMENT IMPLEMENTATION PROJECT This agenda item is a study session to introduce and review draft amendments to the Piedmont General Plan and City Code Chapter 17, Planning and Land Use (Zoning Ordinance) that implement key programs from Piedmont’s adopted 6th Cycle Housing Element for the 2023-2031 term (Housing Element), implement the State laws that are already enacted, and clarify text. The study session includes a discussion about the Draft Environmental Impact Report (DEIR) prepared for the Housing Element Implementation project. This is an informational item only.

2 4. STUDY SESSION – MORAGA CANYON SPECIFIC PLAN This agenda item is a study session for the preparation of a Moraga Canyon Specific Plan (MCSP). Staff and JMZK Consultants will provide a report and presentation on the status of the preparation of a MCSP and entertain a discussion about the Commission’s priorities and concerns. 5. DESIGN REVIEW 139 Lexford Road DRPC2023-018 The application proposes to construct a new 4,573-square-foot single-family residence on an existing vacant lot in Zone A. The new residence is proposed to be four levels with three bedrooms, two bathrooms, a half bath, a ceramic tile roof, dining room, kitchen, family room, office, laundry room, elevator, and conforming two-car garage. A front terrace is proposed at the upper level, and patios are proposed at the rear of the house. A proposed landscape plan has been submitted with retaining walls, stairs, walkways, and exterior lighting. The application proposes retaining walls greater than 30 inches in the front setback. CEQA Determination: The project is categorically exempt under the California Environmental Quality Act, pursuant to CEQA Guidelines Section 15303, Class 3 (a), New Construction or Conversion of Small Structures and Section 15304, Class 4(b), Minor Alterations to Land. 6. VARIANCE AND FENCE AND WALL DESIGN REVIEW 1 Croydon Circle VAR2023-010 and DRFW2023-005 The applications propose to construct new retaining walls and fencing within the 20-foot street yard setback along St. James Drive and make various hardscape and landscape improvements. A variance is required in order to construct a patio within the 20-foot street yard setback. CEQA Determination: The project is categorically exempt under the California Environmental Quality Act, pursuant to CEQA Guidelines Section 15303, Class 3 (e), New Construction or Conversion of Small Structures. 7. DESIGN REVIEW 546 Blair Avenue DRPC2023-029 This application proposes to install a new pool and renovate existing landscape and hardscape within the rear yard. CEQA Determination: The project is categorically exempt under the California Environmental Quality Act, pursuant to CEQA Guidelines Sections 15303, Class 3 (e), New Construction or Conversion of Small Structures and 15304, Class 4 (b), Minor Alterations to Land. 8. DESIGN REVIEW 480 Wildwood Avenue DRPC2023-030 This application proposes to construct a 673 square foot two-level addition at the rear of the home, construct new windows and doors, reconfigure the interior layout, and make various exterior and interior modifications. CEQA Determination: The project is categorically exempt under the California Environmental Quality Act, pursuant to CEQA Guidelines Section 15301, Class 1 (e), Existing Structures.

3 Adjourn Members of the public may participate in the meeting virtually in the following ways: • Computer or smart phone: Click on https://piedmont-ca-gov.zoom.us/j/81433792168 • Telephone: Dial (669) 900-9128 and enter webinar/meeting number 814 3379 2168 To comment using the Zoom platform, click the “Raise Your Hand” button to request to speak when public comment is being taken. You will be asked to unmute yourself when it is your turn to make your comment. After the allotted time, you will then be re-muted. If you are dialing in by telephone, dial *9 to request to speak and *6 to unmute yourself when called. The meeting is also available for life and archived viewing on the City’s website at https://piedmont.ca.gov/government/meeting_videos as well as on KCOM TV, Comcast Channel 27 or AT&T UVerse Channel 99. Agenda Item Material The materials for the agenda items listed above are available for review upon request by contacting Planning & Building Director Kevin Jackson at kjackson@piedmont.ca.gov. A response will be provided during regular business hours 8:30 a.m. to 5 p.m. Monday through Thursday. Procedural Notes 1. The Planning Commission welcomes you to its meeting which is regularly scheduled for the second Monday of each month. Your interest and participation are encouraged and appreciated. Members of the public will have an opportunity to be heard during the public portion of a hearing. While it is not mandatory, you are requested to give your name and address, comments and/or questions. In order that all interested parties have an opportunity to speak, please limit your comments to the specific subject under discussion. Time limitations are generally three minutes but shall be at the discretion of the Chairperson. You are not required to give your name and address, but doing so makes the meeting more efficient, enables the recording secretary to properly attribute comments in the meeting minutes, and will enable the City to send future notices concerning this application if there are any. 2. Applications are generally scheduled in the order in which they were submitted, but the Planning Commission reserves the right to change the order of applications on the agenda or change items from one calendar to the other without further notice. Each applicant is advised that if her or his representative is not present to speak to this application, her or his application may be acted upon and possibly denied. This meeting is required to end at or before 11:30 p.m. unless a majority of the Commission votes to continue the meeting. If your item has not been heard prior to the 11:30 p.m. deadline, your item may be continued to a future meeting. 3. APPEAL - Any decision of the Planning Commission pursuant to Chapter 17 of the Piedmont City Code may be appealed by any interested party within ten (10) days to the City Council in accordance with the procedure set forth in Division 17.78, Appeals; Calls for review. 4. The Planning Commission may take a dinner break at approximately 7:00 pm. Any member of the public who needs accommodations should email the City Clerk at cityclerk@piedmont.ca.gov or call (510) 420- 3040 who will make their best efforts to provide reasonable accommodations to provide as much accessibility as possible while also maintaining public safety in accordance with the City procedure for resolving reasonable accommodation requests. Information about reasonable accommodations is available on the City website at https://piedmont.ca.gov. [28 CFR 35.102-35.104 ADA Title II] In accordance with G.C. Sec. 54954.2 (a) this notice, and agenda were posted on the City Hall bulletin board and also in the Piedmont Police Department on December 21, 2023. The revised notice and agenda were posted on December 27, 2023

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
Agenda packetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Action agendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Transcript or captionsNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Coverage and corrections

Records considered

  • Planning Commission Meeting — Minutes
  • Planning Commission Meeting

Not claimed by this page

  • Verified meeting decisions with item-specific public-source evidence
  • Item-level plain-language summaries are not available; this page does not infer individual agenda items.
  • Item-linked, attributed deliberation
  • A source-grounded next meeting date
  • A plain-English overview is not available.
  • Official outcomes have not been published.
  • A transcript is not available.
  • No audio or video recording is linked.
  • Speakers have not been reliably matched to public profiles.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.
  • An individual roll-call roster is not available.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: 42baa9a59a3ff63ffacbea96954e19e6. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record