POLISCOPE

The public record

VILLAGE NO 4 CDD (MARION COUNTY) · LOCALDecisions and attributed speech publishedDistrict meetings and recordsPartial coverage

Village Community Development District No. 4

Friday, May 9, 2025 · Community development district meeting record

The 30-second read

Recorded outcome

Village Community Development District No. 4

Why it matters

The official meeting record is available below. Item-level plain-language summaries are not available yet.

What happens next

No later meeting or follow-up date is stated in the reviewed record.

An official outcome record and a transcript or captions are published for this meeting.

Recorded votes

Listen to the meeting The recording is not indexed to individual votes.

10 recorded votes0 split

Split votes (0)

Every recorded vote passed unanimously.

Unanimous votes (10)

Voting yes on all of these (5)

Cliff Wieneryes
Mark Hayesyes
Cary Sternbergyes
Jim Murphyyes
Don Deakinyes

2.B. Review and Acceptance of Perpetual Utility Easement with Sumter Electric

Yes
5
No
0

3.B. Award of Request for Qualifications (RFQ) #25Q-014 Professional Architect

Yes
5
No
0

3.C. Award of Request for Qualifications (RFQ) #25Q-020 Professional Water

Yes
5
No
0

3.D. Award for Request for Qualifications # 25Q-022 Land Survey Services

Yes
5
No
0

3.E. Award for Request for Qualifications #25Q-023 Ecological, Natural Resources &

Yes
5
No
0

6.B. The Alternate Architectural Review Committee (ARC) Member

Yes
5
No
0

6.C. Architectural Review Manual Revision – Roofs

Yes
5
No
0
Yes
5
No
0

Consent Agenda

Yes
5
No
0

New Business

Yes
5
No
0

People and votes

Cary Sternberg

10 recorded votes

  1. Recorded vote

    2.B. Review and Acceptance of Perpetual Utility Easement with Sumter Electric - Voted yes on the motion “The Board approved the Minutes for the Meeting held on April 11, 2025 and approved the Acceptance of Perpetual Utility Easement with Sumter Electric Cooperative, Inc (SECO) and authorized the Chair/Vice Chair to execute the document”; the record reports passed.

    Official record
  2. Recorded vote

    3.B. Award of Request for Qualifications (RFQ) #25Q-014 Professional Architect - Voted yes on the motion “The Board awarded RFQ #25Q-014 Professional Architect Continuing Services to KP Studio Architect, P.A. for as needed services and authorized the Chair/Vice Chair to execute the Agreement”; the record reports passed.

    Official record
  3. Recorded vote

    3.C. Award of Request for Qualifications (RFQ) #25Q-020 Professional Water - Voted yes on the motion “The Board awarded RFQ #25Q-020 Professional Water Resources, Utility Operations & Utility Engineering Program Manager to Arnett Environmental, LLC dba Vikus Water for as needed services and authorized the Chair/Vice Chair to execute the Agr”; the record reports passed.

    Official record
  4. Recorded vote

    3.D. Award for Request for Qualifications # 25Q-022 Land Survey Services - Voted yes on the motion “The Board awarded RFQ #25Q-022 Land Survey Services to Clymer Farner Barley Surveying, LLC for as needed services and authorized the Chair/Vice Chair to execute the Agreement”; the record reports passed.

    Official record
  5. Recorded vote

    3.E. Award for Request for Qualifications #25Q-023 Ecological, Natural Resources & - Voted yes on the motion “The Board awarded RFQ #25Q-023 Ecological, Natural Resources & Conservation Program Management to Breedlove, Dennis & Associates, Inc for as needed services and authorized the Chair/Vice Chair execute the Agreement”; the record reports passed.

    Official record
  6. Recorded vote

    6.B. The Alternate Architectural Review Committee (ARC) Member - Voted yes on the motion “The Board reappointed Todd Turpin as the alternate Architectural Review Committee (ARC) member for Village Community Development District No. 4 for a four (4) year term that expires on May 9, 2029”; the record reports passed.

    Official record
  7. Recorded vote

    6.C. Architectural Review Manual Revision – Roofs - Voted yes on the motion “The Board approved the Architectural Review Manual revisions with the modifications discussed with an effective date of May 9, 2025”; the record reports passed.

    Official record
  8. Recorded vote

    Adjourn - Voted yes on the motion “The Board adjourned the meeting”; the record reports passed.

    Official record
  9. Recorded vote

    Consent Agenda - Voted yes on the motion “The Board took formal action on the following items: 2.C. Approval of Amendment Twelve to the Agreement 13P-017 with CH2M HILL OMI (Jacobs) for pump stations and aesthetic features for an annual increase of $415.02 and an amended base fee a”; the record reports passed.

    Official record
  10. Recorded vote

    New Business - Voted yes on the motion “The Board approved completing the drainage assessment”; the record reports passed.

    Official record
See all 10 roll calls with named votes

Transcript and record text

Closed captionsWhat was said at the meeting, transcribed Nov 7, 2026. Speech is not a decision.
  • Some speaker identities remain unresolved.

The opening of 80,256 stored characters

Everybody I'd like to call the District four Board of Supervisors meeting for May 9th, 2025 to order. Let roll call show that all of our board members are present first on the agendas, standing for the pledge to the flag, and remain standing for a moment of silence for our first responders and military personnel. The United States of America Republic Probation stand under honor individual with liberty and justice law. Thank you. Appreciate. I'd like to, excuse me, like to welcome all of our attendees. Uh, next then the agenda is public comment portion of the meeting. If you have something you wanna bring before the board or tell us something, you can step to the podium. You have three minutes. State your name and address and we will be more than happy to listen to you. So just raise your hand if you have something you wanna bring before the board. Seeing nothing, we will move on. I see we have law enforcement. You still there, right? I can't see. Okay. Uh, we're gonna call him so we can get back to duty. Alright. Hello everybody. My name's Detective Thomas Newbank. I'm the assigned detective for the Villages area at South Mary for the Marion County Sheriff's Office. Um, unfortunately our lieutenant could not be here today, so I'm here to fill in. Um, everything's been relatively smooth sailing and the district of South Marion over the last month, month and a half. We did have an uptick with some golf cart thefts from Walmart. Um, the biggest thing for you guys, make sure that if you park your golf cart, take the keys out. Don't leave valuables on your golf cart. I know it is it's habit to leave the clubs, but with the amount of money some people spend on clubs, I mean, I don't know how you could just leave it there and walk away from it. And these guys know that. Um, as far as like the traffic and stuff like that, our guys in the district are amping up the traffic enforcement. Um, they've got a double triple digit traffic enforcement for the month of April that they put up for traffic stops and UTCs and all that kind of stuff. Um, the areas right here on Buena Vista and Belmead by where we're at, um, and the Publix, they've been going through there and, and stopping people that are flowing through the stop signs and all that kind of stuff to try and make it a little bit easier for you guys on the golf carts and everybody moving around. Um, other than that, that's pretty much all we've got from the sheriff's office. Anybody have any questions for, uh, you just, you did have a fatality there on 42. We should they correct? Yes. But with, uh, in the unincorporated areas of Marion County, the Highway patrol works those. Okay, we'll, we'll show up for traffic control to make sure the scene's secure and nothing gets moved or tampered with until Highway patrol gets there. Once Highway patrol comes, then they initiate their, their traffic homicide investigation and they take the ball and they run with it. We're more for support and safety up until they get There. We do see a lot more traffic control than we've seen in a long time. Good. I'm glad. We do appreciate that. If you guys can, if you guys can tell a difference, that means the, the initiative that we're taking are working and that's what we like to hear. We need that feedback from you guys, from everybody to let us know where we need to focus our, our resources and what, what spots we need to target. Okay. Anybody in the audience have anything they want to ask? The detective would, seeing none thank you for Okay. And tell, tell lieutenant we we thank him too. Absolutely. Alright. Appreciate it guys. Thank you for coming and be safe out there. Okay, next on the agenda is the consent agenda motion to prove the consent agendas a motion to approve, approve. I do. Uh, just pardon a comment of the minute so I pull that so I can make a comment. Okay. Just let me read this first. Um, I have a, uh, motion to approve all recommended action to all matters under consent, send agenda, consider routine, and no discussion is required unless desired by a board member of the member of the public. So Jim wants to pull the minutes. I would like to pull two BI believe, just 'cause I have a question. Anybody else? If not, I'll, I'll accept the motion for two C and 2D. So moved. Second. All in favor? Aye. Aye. All opposed? Opposed? Okay. Jim, you're first. Oh, on the minutes, I just want to add for the record that, uh, uh, I don't agree a hundred percent with the, uh, description of using, um, 3 36 dash, uh, oh oh six in our case on the road. So just added to the record that I disagree with that. Okay. Synopsis that it automatically makes our roads public. Okay. And, and just for a record mark, we'll be talking about that a little later. Okay. And I, I have a question about about two b, I just don't understand where this is. If somebody could just, I mean, he gives it, he gives directions, which I have no idea where they're talking about putting this. Mike, do you know, Um, if you, if he can let him look at it and see if he can get it pulled up, and then we'll follow up with you at a later part of the meeting. Okay. Mike? It's the CCO utility Easement where they wanna put the, okay. I just was curious as to where it's gonna be located. I have questions on it as well. The, the language here, um, is a perpetual utility with CCO and with everything going on with cco, what, what does that mean? You know, what if we change our provider and so on down the road, are we locked Into to them and, and not someone else if we change a provider or what? No, this is just granting them an easement so you, it would not interfere with your desire. If you were to move, um, and let's say you wanted to do own your own poles and do solar, this would not impact that. I just wanna be sure we're not locked in. Yes, sir. Okay. As far as approving it, um, in the minutes, um, I'm, I'm all for that as Mike. Just lets me know where it is for my own knowledge. Um, so can I get a motion to approve two A and two B? So moved. I move Second. All in favor? Aye. Aye. All opposed? Seeing none. It's approved unanimously. Okay. Um, at this point in time, in the, in the, um, agenda, I'm gonna move up. We have a, um, representative here is gonna talk about the, the issue we're having down by Chatham on the, on, um, forget the name of his Glen Park. And Mike, do you wanna come up and get that started so that they can go back to work? Don't like to keep people from working? We have an engineer here, I believe. Good afternoon. Mike Harris, district Property Management. As you're aware, we did send the two estimates for the two different services for the area. Um, one of 'em was for, to do a, a study of the, the capacity of the basin there. And the other one was to look at the integrity and the functionality of the stormwater system itself. And Bruce with climber, foreigner, parley, climber foreigner barley has graciously showed up to answer any questions you guys have on the, the scope of those services and what the outcome could be. Okay. Thank you Don. I'm sure. Don I'm sure you have questions. Thank you, Mike. Thank you members of the board. I'd be happy to answer any questions you guys might have. You wanna start, Don? Well, our our concern is several and, and one of course is what are some of the options in expanding the capacity of the retention ponds that we have? And we talked at a previous meeting about the pond that, uh, is on Berwood golf course and has whole number eight and nine around it, and then the Chatham Rec Center. And, uh, it seems to me that we might be able to expand some of that area and, and the T box for whole number one is there as well. Mm-hmm. And I would hope that we could, uh, see about the feasibility of either digging deeper or digging larger, uh, with what we have there. Uh, we know we've had flooding issues with that pond even on the, uh, golf cart path coming from, um, the tee box of nine to the green. And that seemed to have gotten rectified over the years. So we have that concern. But a bigger concern for the residents is the fact that not only when we have heavy range or hurricanes, but even sometimes routine range that may be two or three inches, uh, from Arlington loop down to the lower level of homes there, the water seems to be flowing over the top of the homes themselves in the yards washing through the yards and down into the backyards of the homes that are on the lower level there. Um, the storm drains don't seem to be adequate to handle the amount of water, even with a, a couple of inches. And we have seen that flood numerous times for them, uh, even if it didn't flood on Legacy Lane. Um, although we have also had, uh, numerous incidences over the last 20 years where Legacy Lane ended up with several feet of water. Uh, and I'm not talking recent history, I'm talking about, you know, ancient history as well. And so we have concerns with that. Those people need to have relief. They should not be having the storm drains, um, not be adequate to take that kind of rain and to have it come washing up over the houses behind them and down through those yards. And, and so that's, that's one of the concerns that we have. So, so there would be two analyses that were proposed. One would be to analyze the, the inlets that you're referring to, as well as the storm pipes that are underground that convey the storm water to the pond. So we would analyze the inlet capacities and the storm pipe capacities to make sure they're adequately sized. Um, and then the second proposal would be analyzing the actual pond itself, making sure that the pond is adequately sized to handle all the runoff that's in its collective basin. Um, so that those would be the two proposals you have before you, and that would be what we would do. We would analyze all the things that you mentioned before to make sure they're all built properly. Um, I'm not an engineer, but if the pond is at a certain level and the storm drains are at what would be considered full level, but then the water gets higher than the inlets into the pond, is that water gonna flow into the pond anyway and raise the level of the, the water? Or is it going to slow that water down and that water once, once the water gets higher than the inlet, is it going to stop flowing and back up into, uh, legacy and on up onto Arlington loop? So with, without analyzing this particular system, I can't tell you what's happening here yet, but conceptually, um, if you have a, an inlet that drains to a pond, um, that the pipes, if they're sized adequately, it should drain everything to the pond. And you shouldn't have any backing up in the inlet more than what would be accepted for that. If it's a severe storm, Even after the water in the pond is higher than the inlet. So the inlet shouldn't be, or the pond shouldn't be higher than the, the inlet should be higher than the pond it's drain to. So, um, that would be part of the analysis, making sure that the inlet elevation is higher than the pond top of bank. Well, that's something then that you may need to look at because, um, that was certainly one of the more recent issues here, where the pond, the inlet was underwater already, and so it didn't, it was backing up onto legacy and onto those streets and it then it backed all the way up into Arlington and, uh, and that Arlington was flooded by several feet of water. Um, and I don't remember the, the sheet, the street that comes off and ends up in a cul-de-sac from Arlington, but it was one right above that. And, uh, so that would be a concern and, and we'd need, I guess, um, some sort of an idea of what it would take for us to raise the level of the inlets so that they can drain properly into the pond in the first place. Mm-hmm. That alone would give you several more, you know, cubic feet of water that that pond could hold without expanding the pond size itself. If, if the inlets could come in at a higher level. And what's happening now, from what I see is that yeah, gravity feeds, but it's pretty steep. And maybe if the pond had a gradual, uh, instead of a steep feed, you, you might be able to raise the storm drain a little higher, which would require digging through that easement where the storm drain is raising it up and then bear bearing it underground so that people have their normal yards still. Um, but that might be one of the things you wanna consider. I I, I don't wanna tell you how to do your job, but I'm telling you what I have observed and what I've heard from the residents, um, as being issued for them. Yes Sir. No, and observations are, are crucial. So yeah, in our analysis would be, uh, analyzing what the elevation constraints are. So if I'm not mistaken, Mike, this question's for you. What, what we're here to determine today is if we want to pay the amount of money for the study that they want to do. So, is that correct? That is correct. We wanna pay for the study that we requested. Correct. So my question to you is, would this study tell us, because I've lived here for 23 years and when I moved here, those houses weren't even here. So the underground was, so it seems that this is a problem that goes back from the very beginning. I, that that's my big concern, that we have inherited something that was not done maybe the way it should have been, and now we're, we're gonna have to pay the penalty. That's what I'm trying to get at with the study. Would that study if we agree to do it, give us that information. I don't know what we do, what we would do that after we get it, but I'm sure we could figure something out. It would give you a confirmation, number one, if the storm water system is functioning properly and give you alternatives if we wanted to do something with the basin capacity. But we've heard in the past that what could be involved in doing that type of project with the land around. Well, I understand what's involved. I just, okay. We're a, we're, we're caught between a rock and a hard place because we have residents that are suffering and this board doesn't want to suffer for the cost of what I know this thing is gonna cost. So, okay. I Does anybody else have any questions for the gentleman? Because we have to decide whether or not we want to spend this money for the, these two, there were two studies, right, Mike, for these two studies have one question. Yes, sure. Sir. Is there any possibility that the cost of that study could go further than what was projected? The studies should give you comprehensive answers, So the cost shouldn't increase. It would just be any recommendations for any remediation if necessary. That would be a cost that would Be proposed to. Okay. So what, what does this board wish to do? Somebody wanna make a motion? I, I make a motion that we proceed with the study because something needs to be done. The residents need relief. Um, I, I just have serious concerns about whether there is a solution, uh, that is going to be reasonable. Um, and, and that it's gonna be something that's, you know, financially feasible for us. Uh, I saw a ley horn study done on Morris Boulevard, and it did not address the issues. And the, the study was a, um, study in a futile possibility. There were no reasonable solutions, and they knew that before they went in with the study and, and yet a lot of money was spent on it. Okay, so you made a motion. Do I have a second? I, I just would like to clarify which study you were wanting. Was it both of them or was there a specific study that you wanted to move forward on? Well, I'm inclined to wanna split it and see what the first study would tell us, and then determine whether a second study is even gonna be worthwhile. Well, they're, they're studying two completely different things. So one of them is studying the stormwater system, and then the other one is studying the capacity of the basin. So I just, I wanna make sure that we're directing them. If, if this is where you wanna go, exactly what you're looking to accomplish. If, if your concern is the water on the resident's yard, which one of these would potentially solve that problem? That's a challenging question. Okay. Um, so without knowing what the issue is, um, so a typical rule of thumb is if you have, you know, any kind of sitting water for hours or even a day or two, it's a pipe capacity issue, which my understanding is that there is one or more inlets that are having sitting water for one or two days. If you have sitting water for a week, it is a facing package. So It, it, I don't, it's primarily one pipe coming off the cul-de-sac from Arlington loop and it it is. And so then it goes underground and it comes up and from three locations in that cul-de-sac on the lower level. So the water is running along the curbs from Arlington loop down to that cul-de-sac, which has, uh, well it, it has two on the entrance to it and then one at the end of the cul-de-sac. And but those three end up with just one pipe that's going down to the lower level. So they can't handle that because they've only got, um, two inlets from the entrance to that cul-de-sac on the upper level that feed down into the one. And that one is not able to handle everything. And then they, they come up on the three down below. Um, and then those overflow. But beyond that, because the upper ones can't handle it, the water, instead of following the curb, they're going over the curbs and over through the driveways into the ba, the front yards and then the backyards of the upper level homes. Yes, sir. And, and maybe one of the things that we should be considering is another storm drain put in so that you have 'em coming in, um, from the upper level to the lower level with more going out to the pond itself. Um, I guess I think that the, the problem, the root of the problem might be what's happening up above first. How long is the water standing in the yard? Because I, if I recall from the last, um, gentleman that we had here, he indicated that although it was an inconvenience to the residents, unless it is standing there for hours and days, it's not considered a malfunction of the system. And it is, it is, I hate to say normal, but your system is still functioning correctly as long as the water is not standing longer than a day. So I, I just wanna make sure, again, I'm, I'm not saying it's not an inconvenience to the residents and you don't wanna try to, to help them, but I would hate to see a half a million dollar project come before you for something that technically the stormwater system is functioning as it's designed. Mr. McGovern, since you're a part of this, you had your hand up. Um, I'm Anna McGovern and I live at 1 7 2 9 5 Southeast Parkland Court. And it was so serious after Milton came through. Now we had two hurricanes. Our yard was like a mudslide. I couldn't even walk in the backyard and I had to prepare it to get ready for Milton and I had to lay boards down to get into my backyard. So all of Arlington loop is draining into our neighbor's yard and it's coming over. And you could walk with me, I'll show you signs of distress. And you already are dealing with the depression stuff over at Crow Profield. This is like a 23 erosion problem, 23 years of erosion. Our next door neighbor, if you walk in their yard, you're stepping in depression. My husband's boot went right down. We're standing and standing water for at least a week after some of these storms. We built up our flail. But somebody has to do something, even if they put a storm drain in the neighbor's yard next door. I think I sent you all the pictures. Something has to be done. We're the second homeowner. And the first homeowner had already complained. They sell their house, the next door neighbors, they're the second homeowners, they sold their house or the other side. They're three homeowners. People are just selling their house. And when you read the sad story about Crow Field Avenue, that guy bought his house for 379,000. I and it went Into, I'm not trying to cut you off, we're not talking about Crow field. Keep it to the subject. We're trying, but to come to a conclusion it's the Issue. It's the same issue. I I understand it. Okay. Okay. We, we heard. Thank you. Okay. We have a, we have a motion. Is there a second? I'm just not clear on the motion. What, what is it, what we're gonna, do you want a single one? It's the motions to do one or one or both of the studies? I, I guess I it should be, or we could both either do one or Both. Correct. Okay. But Don made the motion. Okay. I think we should start with the source of the problem, which is, um, the upper level flooding down into the lower level. And then let's look at that first and then look at the additional issue if necessary, about the capacity of the pond. I think the capacity of the pond, uh, can be resolved relatively Either. Don, I, I just that you made a motion. I just want to know what your motion, the upper level. Okay. Do you, do you understand which survey is the upper Level? I, I, I do. He's referring to the conveyance system. Um, I know each of the two proposals, they're relatively the same cost. Yes. If we were designing the system, just to give you context, if we were designing the system from scratch, we would do the pond first because the pond analysis will give good information that lends itself to the second analysis. Um, whereas the second analysis done without the first one, um, you're not gonna have the pond data elevation stuff that you need in order to get the second analysis done in detail. So, um, if you had a recommendation, if you were splitting them, um, it would be the first one because that would be your pond analysis that gives you, it's called the term is tailwater, but you need that in order to really run your conveyance analysis accurately. I think the thing of elevation has been a discussion on this board for quite a while on a big concern that the elevation that was on the original, um, plats really have been exceeded, um, for whatever reason I know they have in our area, they went from plat land. Uh, I go back one street and up nine foot higher than they were when we moved in. And the developer did come out and put in black pipe in my side lawn with, uh, vs in them with the drains to drain the water out of our yard, which was basically almost coming into the house. So it is an issue as far as the pond itself is concerned. Um, you know, I also agree with that if the elevation's an issue with the pond, and I guess it's going in and digging that pond a little bit deeper so we can hold more water, but I don't know whether that water issue elevation should be part of the first study or not. What do you recommend? So my, my recommendation, if we're only gonna do one of them, would be to do the first one, which is, I believe it was titled, um, uh, drainage assessment. Um, the second one was titled, uh, stormwater Conveyance Analysis. So I, I would recommend doing the drainage assessment, which analyzes, um, what was designed and, but also more critically reviews the hydraulic data that is in that pawn itself. Carrie, you had a question? Yes, Mike, could you run me the numbers very quickly? What, What the cost of each one of these studies? So the, Lemme get my stuff. Just the second one. So, so the first one is $13,382, that is for the capacity issue. And the second one is $13,875 for the conveyance system. Thank you. I, I think I misunderstood what you were saying because I thought I heard you say one thing earlier and then in answer to, uh, his question you said something differently. I felt So are you talking about the capacity the pond is being the first study? Yes, sir. Yeah. The, there's apon capacity analysis, essentially there's apon capacity and a pipe conveyance. Um, so those are the two analyses that would be Proposed. Well, alright, I'll, I'm, I feel like we should listen to you and, and I withdraw my motion. My first motion. Okay. Before you do, mark had a question. Yeah, sir. The last gentleman that was here made it pretty clear that you cannot make that pond go any deeper because you'd be touching the water table. Is there a space there to add to it or to, to, uh, create an overflow situation? That would be part of the analysis. Uh, the aerial, it looks like there's potential space, but that would be to the district to decide what space. There's also, um, I believe that pond has some overflow conveyance to, uh, an adjacent pond in the system. Um, so part of that analysis would also be analyzing what that overflow sizing is and if that could be increasing in size. Okay. Thank you. Okay. Now you wanna make a motion, doctor? Yeah, I make a motion that we, um, do the, um, pond capacity study first and then reconsider whether we wanna go to a second study. We have a second. I'll second it. Okay. We have a motion to second? Any Other discussion? Uh, I, yeah, I wanna ask another question because there is that one pond that we just discussed, but just beyond the number one tee box, there is a second pond and I don't know how closely the related And then beyond that, there is a pond on the other side of Legacy Lane over there by Hazelwood and Arlington loops. And uh, I don't know if those two are interconnected either. So there are really three ponds in that area that might be interconnected. Uh, would that be part of this study? I believe the study was only referring to the pond that receives the Arlington loop runoff. Um, so I'd have to, the gentleman you spoke to before, I'd have to talk to him and see what it would look like to expand that, to look at the two additional ponds. Okay. We have a motion and a second. So let's call for vote. All in favor of this, uh, going ahead with the one study, aye A. Okay. You have about four, five to five to zero. Thank you. You chairman, if I may, I just want to clarify that the second study would not include any yard drainage or elevations. We are gonna go with the first study first and then Yes, sir. Depending on what comes back, we will continue. Thank you. Okay, thank you. Thank you guys. Okay, next is new business, Jennifer. Good afternoon board Jennifer Leon Norris Finance here to give you your, uh, financial overview of actuals. As of March 20, 25, year to date, your total budgeted revenues are, uh, 4,299,000 for the year. Uh, included in that amount is the budgeted maintenance assessments of 3,926,000. As of March, you received 96% of your maintenance assessments, um, which equates to 3.8 million. In April, you received another 84,000, which brings you up to 98.6% of maintenance assessments collected. Um, so that makes, uh, 59,000 left to be collected for the year. And looking back historically, um, you received a hundred percent of your assessments in June. So this seems to be normal that you, um, haven't collected, um, all the funds for the year. Um, your investment earnings are at 74,000 for the year, which is running at 32% of budget, um, budgeted income. Um, that is a 64,000 decrease from prior year. Um, you're seeing most of that volatility in your local, um, excuse me, your long-term investment portfolio due to the uncertainty of the tariffs. Um, your short-term investments, which is 85% of your portfolio, which is more stable, but you're seeing a reduction in earnings due to the Fed, uh, rate cuts. Uh, we are seeing where, where you were seeing 5.4 annualized returns, you're now seeing the norm, which is more like 4.4 annualized returns, which is still a decent return for operating expenses. District four is at 1,541,000, which is 46% of your budget. The target percentage at this time of the year, which is six months into the year, is 50%. Your utilities, um, is showing 52% as of March, but there was a lag in receiving your invoices, uh, for the month. So you do get caught up in April. Um, so I just wanted to highlight your building structure, um, maintenance, um, line item, which makes up 27% of your Med MA amended budget. Um, that is about 641,000, um, in budget for the year. Uh, some of the activity that you, um, that was expensed for the month was for liner $9,980, your tunnel. Um, B three solar conversion of 4500 cents. Painting was at 59,000, uh, 300. And your, uh, painting, which I believe is for entryway about 20,000. So the district continues to meet its reserve requirement of 2,000,333, uh, thousand, um, dollars. Uh, so in your assigned unassigned fund balance, uh, you do exceed that. So I'm here to answer any questions that you might have. Go ahead. Uh, just one, uh, relative to the, uh, approximately 4% of assessments we haven't received yet from the county, uh, assume some of that will be recovered when, uh, delinquent taxes are, uh, recovered by the county. Uh, generally what month is that? June. So June, we should be at hopefully our a hundred percent. Historically, yes, that's where you receive a hundred percent of your assessment. Anybody else have any questions for Jennifer? Thank you, Jennifer. Thank You. Next is the order of request for clarification for professional architect continuing service, Mr. Chairman? Yes. Um, and Melissa, correct me if I'm wrong, um, three B, c, d, and E are all very similar, uh, motions. Uh, and they are, um, contracts, uh, to, um, maintain or enhance our toolbox, um, that would be used on an as needed basis. Um, they involve, um, contractors, most of whom we have had a long experience with. In some cases they're just one. And, uh, I wonder if we need to do them one at a time or if there would be We We do. We do. We do. All right. I was gonna try to expedite it. I didn't know what you were trying to do. Hold on. So they all, they do all have to be voted on independently, but if you would like her to not go into as much detail on all of them since you've had a chance to review of all of it, the public has had the chance to review it on the agenda. Certainly she can do a much shortened presentation. If you would like her to, You can do the short presentation because I'm sure we're gonna approve 'em all, but we need to do it the proper way. All right, sounds good. Uh, I won't take offense to any of that at all either. So we've just heard you say it all day long and I do get to do to every single board too and I'm looking forward to it, but that's okay. Um, thank you. Good afternoon, Melissa. Shar, purchasing. Yeah, so we'll go ahead and start with the first one here, which is RFQ uh, 25 Q dash 0 1 4. For a, um, professional architect services, um, I am basically the intent of these services were to provide a firm with, um, or service or agreements with the firm who could provide architectural, um, studies, permits applications, cost estimates, uh, surveying, permitting and shop reviews. Uh, based on the evaluation and scores of a selection committee, uh, staff is requesting approval of award for RFQ 25 Q dash 0 1 4. Professional architect continuing services to KP Studios architect for as needed services. This agreement would be effective today through September 30th, 2035 with the option to renew for two five year periods. Um, and again, it was completely solicited out through the RFQ process. And I'm here if you have any questions, Any questions from the board, I'll entertain a motion. So moved. Second. All in favor? Aye. All opposed, approve unanimously. Okay, next one is requesting approval of award for RFQ 25 Q dash 0 2 0 professional water resources, utility operations and utility engineering services. Uh, these services are for utility operations and oversight consulting services, utility design services, construction engineering, capital planning consulting services, uh, based on the evaluation and scores of the selection committee, staff is requesting award for RFQ 25 Q 0 2 0 professional water resources, utility operations and utility engineering program manager to our net environmental LLC doing business as cus water for as needed services. And again, this agreement shall be awarded today with your approval through September 30th, 2035 with the option to renew 4 2 5 year period. Any discussion? Motion. So moved. Second. All in favor? Aye. Aye. All opposed? Approved. Okay. Next. Requesting approval of award for RFQ 25 Q dash 0 2 2 land survey services. Uh, the range of these services would include, um, land features, identifying, documenting existing utilities and infrastructure and analyzing collected survey data and creating accurate maps and documents. Uh, based on the selection committee's scores, staff is requesting approval of award for RFQ 25 Q dash 0 22 land survey services to climber farner barley surveying LLC for as needed services. And this agreement would alter today with your approval through September 30th, 2035 with, uh, the option to renew for two five year period. So moved. Second. All in favor? Aye. All opposed? Approve unanimously. Okay. And the last one is requesting approval of award for RFQ 25 Q dash 0 2 3 for ecological natural resources and conservation program management. These services would include oversight of subcontractor providing nuisance exotic species control of mitigation areas. Um, and uh, I like my favorite part. Response to request to assist with recovery and transport of injured wildlife. All right. Uh, after the selection committee met and scored, uh, SAP is requesting approval of award for RFQ 25 Q dash 0 2 3 ecological natural resources and comm conservation program management to breed love Dennis and Associates for as needed services for agreement to be effective today through September 30th, 2035 and the option to renew for two five year period. So moved. Approve. Second. Second. All in favor? Aye. Aye. All opposed? That's the easiest. That's for the off in any board meeting. You may be my favorite board of The month. Thank you. Yeah, thank you. Now, Mr. Chairman seemed like in some of these, uh, as we read through 'em all for the audience, we did go through a whole stack of these as we always do. Um, seemed to be some kind of overlapping of, of some of the stuff between each one of these. So does the staff just make a determination which one they want to use? Well, I, I believe as I've heard this at every other board meeting I've been to, that these are just things that are gonna be put in our toolbox if and when we need 'em. For instance, uh, t Tray Anette has been part of the villages before I moved here he is, he's actually developed everything that's happened here as far as what's in the ground. Mm-hmm. So, um, you know, there's nobody better than him to, to determine it. So it just gives him another toolbox that we don't have to go out and ask people to come in if and when we have a problem. So thank you guys. Okay. Next is supervisor comments. Start with Carrie. Carrie, you got anything? I, I, I do. And I'm going to, um, ask the other Carrie's indulgence, uh, with this, um, I, I get questions from some of our constituents about things that happened, and this is certainly not isolated to District four, but maybe you could give me some guidance so I could provide an answer. Uh, there seems to be an uproar about a number of, of of groups and clubs that have performed for the villages for years and are now being either not asked to perform or told they can't perform. Can you gimme a little bit of insight in that? 'cause I don't know what to tell them. I, I'm gonna be honest, I've seen that on, on social media. I don't know what prompted it. I don't know if there was an article in the paper that said they were no longer going to, I don't know whether they were trying to perform and were told. No, it doesn't fall under any of the district's purview, but I can certainly do some, some research and see if I can find out what prompted all of this. I've been hearing the same thing, but I, I don't know what sparked it. Okay. Yeah. A anything you could, Yeah, I'll do some, some research. Okay. Thank you Doc. Um, I have a couple of things. Um, first of all, city Works, uh, was presented to us at the a c meeting. It did come up at one of the district meetings today. And, um, I know that, or at least I hope that what they're doing with City Works is including the number of districts and I would think it would because it's part of the assets of the entire villages. And I would like to, uh, ask that we get a presentation at a meeting in the near future, um, regarding City Works and how it will, uh, benefit us as a number district and how it could be utilized, uh, by us as well. Can we get a report on that? That's up to the board. If you would like, um, staff to provide an overview on City Works, um, district one requested it, and I did ask if it could be in the summer, just because June tends to be a pretty lengthy meeting with the budget. And if that's something that as a consensus as a board you would like to do, then certainly I can have staff available to provide that overview. I, I think, I personally think it's a good idea that we understand what we paid all that money for and how we're gonna use it, but I also agree that July, maybe even August would be better when our meeting is a little shorter. That would be great. So if that's okay with the board, it's okay with me. Okay. Very good. Yes. The second thing I have, uh, I got an invitation, uh, let me, let me get to it here, um, from John Dietrich, uh, who is Vice President with the VHA and he's planning, um, a presentation of a community program on June 3rd, um, at the Mulberry Grove Recreation Center. And he invited me to come and speak. He was not very clear at the time about what he wanted me to speak on, but he also said that if I knew of anyone else that might serve as a potential speaker, um, that I should let him know about that I haven't responded to this yet. Um, we, I didn't you run one last year? Yes, please. And it was very successful, by the way, last year. Yes, it was. Uh, Carl Arps 93 40 Southeast, one 70th Humphreys Loop. Um, yes. Uh, Sean asked me as he's kind of replaced me in the Vice President's role. Um, and he's a little bit new at it, so he probably wasn't really clear. Um, we are getting it set up, I believe it'll be six in the evening, um, if, if I recall correctly. That Is correct. Okay. So we did get that squared away. Um, what we're asking for is to have somebody who can talk about a a c and, but also you are a liaison correct? With uh, Marion County? That's correct. And that is probably the real key. 'cause the focus is going to be Marion County and why is, why are we different? What's unique? And that's why we're holding it at Mulberry. Yeah. And June 3rd is a Tuesday. Yes. So, so that, you know the date. Um, but in, in addition to that, and thank you Carl, uh, in, in addition to that, um, I wanted to invite board members here maybe to, um, speak as as well instead of me or I'm willing to do it. Um, but I think someone should certainly do it. Uh, but, uh, I wanna give the rest of the supervisors here the opportunity. This, the focus is primarily with Marion County and District four and, and therefore maybe one of you would like to, uh, speak on behalf of District four and if you haven't already been invited and, and so I wanted to put that out there, um, for you to consider before I responded. Okay. Well, I cannot do it. I have a POA board meeting and that night, so, um, that's more important to me. I, and it, I have no objection where you going and doing it as long as you do it the way it needs to be done and it's important. I, I agree. Okay. The information needs to be put out. So you're going as the Marion County liaison and the a a C rep? Yes. And as a District four supervisor, Unless someone, one of the supervisors here would like to be the representative for District four as a supervisor, I, I don't see anybody raising their hand. So it looks like you're elected. Well, I would do it if the board wants me to. Um, well, I would prefer to have somebody else. I can tell you what we besides Don Do it all. I would too. I'm a rep. Okay. But if you, Jim, like me to I, so the two of you guys, that's great. Okay. As long as I have the permission from the board to talk about the board. Yes. Okay. That's exactly why I brought it here first. No, no, that's fine. Doc, anything else? Uh, now, um, can we get a copy of this, uh, for Jim to take and then you can contact him on your own. I've only got the one copy District staff is invited to the event as well. We have some representatives there. I believe we have the information and can provide it To Mr. Okay. Well he needs someone to respond back to him, so I haven't responded yet to Okay. You will respond. I, I would, I'll volunteer to get back to him. I've Got, okay. Okay. Okay. All and that's all I've got. Okay, Jim? I had two items, but, uh, we'll cover both of those, um, under all business. Okay, mark? Yeah, I'm gonna ask everybody please hear me out. Uh, these remarks are made to the supervisor. Deacon Don, your devotion to district four is unquestioned. I believe that you spend more time and any other supervisor with the reports to district courts, constituents and so on. I have always followed the time-tested rule as chief of police and deputy US marshal to a claim in public. And if discipline would call out a person, you do it in private. However, Florida of statutes prevent me from taking that action as a supervisor and we can only discuss the issue. Wait A minute, wait a minute, mark. I was getting a lot of feedback, so we all are. Yeah. Okay. Can you back up a little bit? However, Florida statute, I'll go back. Um, I have always followed the time tested rule is police chief and Deputy Lewis Marshall that we claim in public and you discipline calling out a person, you do it in private. However, Florida statutes prevent me from taking that action as a supervisor and we can only discuss issues in a called meeting venue sometime ago. District four gave you permission to hold a Q and a. You asked, you asked to do it. We got involved then as a board and decided to back away. You, you decided to continue with approval of the board. District four never gave you permission to hold a rally. And my understanding on a rally is that if you're going to do it, you have to have, there's certain statutes or certain requirements for the district to do it. Is that correct, Carrie? I I would have to verify through, through recreation Okay. As to, as to what the requirements were. Okay. Did you get permission, Dawn, from the a, a C to hold a q and A? Your rally was outside the permission granted by this board. This is, there is a difference between a Q and A and a rally. It is obviously obvious that you collaborated with Ms. Patsy Horne in your planning for the rally as she and you both issued notices in writing, announcing a q and a and then added the amenity fee rally on different dates and correspondence I wanted to attend. However, I was advised by council that I was told not to. District four has no authority to set amenity fees or to deal with amenity fee issues at its meetings. Only a a C can do that. Why was the issue of amenity freeze brought up at a question, an answer session for district four? You should have held that issue at a meeting at a different time and date and not commingle it with district four's q and A. That is why I see it being a supervisor and board of director member position has created a conflict of interest and is now being played out. I believe that one person should not hold two elected positions because it's, it's hard to separate from whom the supervisor or board board member is represented or speaking. It creates a cloudy situation to say the least. When I was a young chief of police, I attended multiple law classes and updates, including some classes given at Mark Marquette Law School. In one of those sessions, a DA from Milwaukee County stated that as Chief of police, if I was not happy with the opinion of an assistant district attorney in a case we had better be armed with case law from a legitimate service state statutes for the administrative code. To back up my objection, if not, remember that the, the district attorney has a college degree, a law degree, and is admitted to the bar and in some cases can appear before the Supreme Court to practice law. Just having an opinion is not sufficient to complain to the media or any other police chief and so on. This might be a good position for you to follow. Thank you for hearing me out. Okay. That all you have, mark. That's all I have, sir. Okay. I I only have one question. Wait a minute. Can can we get, can I get a copy of that please? Sure, Sure. Um, because I, I couldn't follow it all and because of interference and you read it so fast, I couldn't absorb it all either. Okay. Um, there's a number of comments in there that are inaccurate, so I think it's important. Yeah. Get that. Okay. I I have a question. The contractor that we have that takes care of our pods, yes. It appears they are relatively new, I think in the last couple of years. Yes. And it appears that at other districts we are having some issues with them taking care of our ponds. Are we, are we hearing at all, I mean, is there an issue with this contractor or not? I'm, I'm just curious. So the, the contractor recently asked for a very large increase in pay. Um, we were not comfortable with granting that increase. And yes, we have had con some concerns on the conditions of some of the ponds. So we are currently in the process of working with purchasing and going back out for solicitation. Um, this time rather than lumping all of the basins into one contract, we separated them out where we're wanting one contract north of 4 66. One in the project wide territory and the one in the eSport territory. Um, and hopefully we will be able to get, um, more contractors interested in it if they're a little bit more manageable areas. So that should go out this month, I believe, through purchasing this month or next month. Um, and then we will bring it back to you to award because part of that is also going to be as needed services, um, mechanical harvesting type services where for those troubled areas they can do a little bit more. Okay. So yes, I, I'm just concerned because there seems to be an issue and I want to get a top of the issue before we have the we're concerned as well. Okay. A bigger issue. So I was right to be concerned. Okay. Thank you. Um, okay. Next is, uh, Jim Investment Advisory. I know you had a meeting. Yes. Um, the meeting was held on May 6th. Um, you have a copy of the agenda there and also attached to that is, uh, the account reconciliation for all of the districts. So you can see we're sitting in there with about 400 and $490,000 sitting in there. Uh, it used to be the lowest, now we're the second lowest, so, um, so we're not the lowest one anymore. Obviously none of the investment team that we hire are, um, very comfortable with predicting anything because of tariffs and the rest of the stuff that's going on. Um, where we're really getting hurt bad is in the long term, which was a big money maker for us. And, uh, that's dropped considerably. So hopefully we'll be able to continue to bring some money in. Uh, I think we're ahead of the cost of living index, but I'm barely hanging onto that. So the only thing I would like to, uh, mention is that, um, I ask any blocker I how he was bi locating, you know, to take care of the size of the districts and, uh, he did indicate that, uh, Sean Boyle, I'm assuming he's Irish, Sean Boyle, I mean Oh, okay. For Murphy. That's what that is. But anyhow, he is now gonna sit on the committee. I did ask Ken if, um, since he had been given permission to, uh, do some things daily with short term investments as he seemed that whether that would be passed on to Sean and he assured me that it would be. So that will continue. That's really all I had. Okay. Um, multi pass discussion group is me and, um, our next meeting is in September. Um, district five has put in RPMs. Um, I, uh, I believe that it is done, that that was the last I heard that they are all installed in District five. District 12 I know was considering doing it, but after Kimberly Horn's report came out at their meeting yesterday, which I didn't attend, but I listened to it last night, they were not real happy. So I'm not quite sure which way they're gonna go. And district one today made sure that they have money in their up and coming budget to do, I assume RPMs on there. So we're making progress. We'll see. I know District nine was also interested and they have a meeting next Thursday, which I'll try to attend. So our next meeting's in September, there'll be more information coming as we get closer. Mark, um, Marion County Sheriff and yeah, Marion County Sheriff is here and the BPSD report has been furnished to all his supervisors. Okay. Do Marion County? Yes. Um, I have a couple of items. Um, one of them has to do with the fire assessments. Uh, they, um, are realizing that with everything that's been going on, that they are having difficulty, um, meeting a five year plan that they have. And they were torn between doing a yearly increase as they went along or whether they would be better off to do an increase, uh, for a five year period. The current rate is at $237. They are looking at, um, doing an, they were gonna go to two 90 and they figured out that if they, they went, they, when they said, all right, we can go with 2 37 for one more year and then four years at two 90, or they could just go right away with an average of about 2 84 and they just tied, they voted to go with 2 84, that's a 20% increase. It add, it adds up to about $47 a year annually. And, uh, so that's what the commissioners agreed to. Um, but it still has to be part of the budget approval as well. But you'll probably see it coming out on the trim notices. Um, in after June. Um, they, there was a couple of interesting, um, sidebars. One of them was that for every $1 that they invest in tourism in Marion County, they get a return of $66 back. So that's a pretty good investment for them. And, and for Marion County as a whole, uh, they did talk about the Kentucky Derby and put out a couple of facts with their chest all puffed up about that. Uh, one is that of the 19 horses that ran, 10 of them have connections with Marion County. That first and second place also are connections with Marion County and first place was sovereignty and second place was a horse called journalism. So they're, they're very pleased with the result of that. And, uh, they're showing a strong for, um, a strong, um, showing throughout the world with the Kentucky Derby. I heard, um, after the meeting that Sovereignty is not planning on running in the Preakness, so they're not going after the Triple Crown. Um, those 10 horses also all, uh, have connections with Secretariat, uh, in Heritage and with three other, uh, triple Crown winners. So that's just a sidebar of of interest. That's all I got. Okay. Um, old business. Yes sir. The first item on old business is an update on video recording your meetings and we have received all of the equipment and our scheduling training and signing up for the, um, accounts that will house these videos. We are hoping to have the first, um, video recording done at your July meeting. Okay. The second item was information on cco, which we did provide to the board on April 16th. Um, or would you like to leave CCO on your old business or is this something that you would like us to remove at this point? We, we will present the, the, um, increase in dollar amount during your budget workshop next week. Plus Ceq was sending out almost weekly Different updates on different aspects. We'll continue to provide everything, Just have a comment related to that. Um, well was also in the minutes and it had to do with a question about whether or not, uh, the, uh, residential business people were going to get, uh, an increase too. I did. Uh, okay. She's leaving. Alright. I did put a thing together and I gave all the board members a, a copy of it, but I just ran through it. Uh, I, I just took a, a bill I had, and, uh, under the old method it was $116. Uh, they raised the rates, uh, on the current stuff, about seven tenths of a cent on the, uh, overtime or the excess over a thousand watts. They raised at about, uh, a cent and a half, uh, running those two together. The increase for me for one month was $7, and, uh, calculated about 6%. And I know in the paper they talked about somewhere in the 9% range, so the residents are getting it. Uh, when I talked to the guy at seco, he didn't have any input because buried in your bill is also that dollar 15 daily rate that everybody gets. So that's added to the lump sum number you get. So he didn't have any comment to make about whether or not that dollar 15 rate was going to change. So I assume it's not all that we're gonna get some rate change. I just want to say, Gary, I I think we need to keep it on there. Okay. Um, I wasn't happy with, with the final cost for seeking both, but it's better than it would've been if we'd got the whole raise. Um, and I think we just have to wait and see how it plays out. We're gonna be paying this now forever, but some other district might come up with some other way. I, I will tell you that District seven has put out another request for bids for doing solar. I am not quite sure solar's the way that you're gonna go. So I think we should just go along and do what we have to do and see what comes out of it. We can always change at a later date. So I, I will just change it to have CCO update instead of the detail that's in there now. And then if we have updates Okay. It'll be attached. Okay. Mr. Chair? Yes. And, and Carrie, um, I thought I read somewhere in some of the news releases that this price system that they have come up with, uh, they're, they're not gonna try to do a 24 hour repair service. They're going to, um, allow themselves up to 30 days to do a repair, um, to cut part of those costs down. Is that correct? Yes, sir. Okay. So, and I agree, I think we should keep it on there. Okay. So I'm just gonna change it to a general SECO update. Yes. Number three has already been discussed and voted on. Number four is the welcome to Marion County sign. I did verify with DPM that it is still, um, It's in, it's in. Oh, it's in, it's in, it's done. We, well then we can finally remove that one from old. It's done. I saw it this morning as I was Going back. I I was there while they were putting it up yesterday. Good, good. The number five is review if district four can restrict public access behind gates. And I will turn that over to Mr. Brianis Supervisors. I, I, earlier this week I called all of you. I spoke to, most of you, left a couple of you messages that I couldn't get ahold of to let you know what the status of the memo was and why it wasn't out. So I'm still looking further into this issue. I think the general opinion last month was that if they're public roads, you can't do it. If they're private, you can, and that's still my opinion. The issue now, or the question is looking at a handful of these plats, are they actual public roads or not? The plats that I've looked at so far dedicate the roadways to the residents of certain villages. So that's a little different than dedicated to the public in general. So that's kind of what I'm looking at now. I still need to meet with district management, maybe, uh, property management as well to go over some of these plats, uh, get some clarity on some of them. But again, now the question is, is it in fact a public road if it's dedicated to the residents of a number of different villages? Jim, I know you have a question. I do. I do have some comments. Uh, um, reviewing, uh, you know, a chapter 3 16 0 0 6, um, it kind of puts it into three main categories, as you know, legal as said, and I agree with that. Uh, and one has to do with state roads, which of course doesn't affect us. Uh, one has to do with municipality roads, which of course don't affect us. And the other part has to do with everybody else, including special districts like us. Um, what isn't clear in that is when we go back to 2012 when we had the attorney's opinion on whether or not we could, uh, uh, close our gates to residence, only the opinion was then that we could. But, uh, we elected not to do that because the FEMA said if we did that, we, we were gonna get any recovery from fema. But, uh, that turned out to be kind of a joke because the recovery we got wasn't worth, uh, anything. But anyhow, along with that, the thing that's not clear in, uh, in this chapter three 16, uh, all the roads in our district, um, are built, uh, by the developer and they're reimbursed by the residents of CDD four. And, uh, elsewhere in, uh, the counties, uh, those roads are also built by the developers and re and are reimbursed by the county. So those roads then, in essence, are paid for by the taxpayers of the county. And that makes them public roads. In the case of CDD four, uh, none of those roads are reimbursed by the county. And as such, uh, we not only have to pay for the maintenance of the roads, we also have to pay for the roads themselves in our bond debt. So the thing that's still not clear in three 16 or doesn't make clear, is the fact that, um, it appears the, all the roads in, in CD four, with the exception of, uh, uh, Buena Vista, are in fact private roads as defined by, uh, three 16 and elsewhere. We wanna go. So I, I don't know where it takes us, uh, and how much time we wanna spend on it. Uh, it might be good to get a final, uh, say that says, yes, they are private roads as defined by state statutes, or they're public roads. And if they do come up and say they're public roads, then uh, I think we have some lawsuits involved whether or not we have to maintain them. 'cause if there are public roads, then like in the other counties, the counties maintain those roads. So, uh, I think you're right. Only input is up. I think, I think that's exactly where we're at. You know, Agree. Since they, Since the plat dedicated to certain residents of certain villages, does that now make them private to those residents within the villages that are referenced in the plat? Or are they public? The other issue is that bond funds are used to develop and, um, pay for these roads. And those roads are paid for through bond funds, and then the residents have to pay the bond. Yeah. That's another thing we're looking at. So again, I think we're getting there. Um, and that's kind of where we're at right now. Okay. That's, that's the issue. And everything you pointed out is accurate. Yeah, That's all I had on. Okay. Number six was to provide an update of the removal of equipment behind Calumet Postal Facility. Um, the developer did indicate that those repairs are complete and they're just waiting rainfall to fill the basin. As you know, that is not district project or property. Um, but that is what the developer has indicated. The only scary part is, and we get rain and we got another, another sinkhole, and they're gonna bring the equipment back. That's about the third sinkhole he's had in there. Uh, that's why I tell all the residents, you know, they say, oh boy, wouldn't it be nice and we can take over all those championship courses? No, you do not want that. No. No. Um, I have a question about that because that pond is growing a lot of vegetation, and when we do get a rain, um, it's still not gonna look very good. Uh, has there been any thought given to keeping that vegetation, uh, down, whether it's through hand weed whipping or some sort of mowing or, or what The, the developer has not indicated any. It's Got our pond. It looks like a weed patch. And now, and it's turning into a farm. It looks like it's, well, It's, it's not anything we have any purview over. Correct. We can call his attention to it, can we not? Yes. Would we please do that?

MINUTES OF MEETING VILLAGE COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DISTRICT NO. 4 A meeting of the Board of Supervisors of Village Community Development District No. 4 was held on Friday, May 9, 2025 at 1:30 p.m. in the Ashley Wilkes Room at the Savannah Recreation Center, 1545 Buena Vista Boulevard, The Villages Florida, 32162. Board members present and constituting a quorum: Cliff Wiener Chair Mark Hayes Vice Chair Cary Sternberg Supervisor Jim Murphy Supervisor Don Deakin Supervisor Staff Present: Carrie Duckett Deputy District Manager Mark Brionez District Counsel Bruce Brown Assistant District Manager Jennifer Liunoras Finance Director Brandy Cook Budget Director Melissa Schaar Purchasing Director Matt Armstrong Community Standards Director Mike Harris District Property Management Director Caitlyn Bessoni Executive Assistant Jennifer Farlow District Clerk Rebecca Johnson Deputy District Clerk FIRST ORDER OF BUSINESS: Call to Order 1.A. Roll Call Chair Wiener called the meeting to order at 1:30 p.m. and stated for the record that all Supervisors were present representing a quorum. 1.B. Pledge of Allegiance The Chair led the Pledge of Allegiance.

VCDD 4 – Meeting Minutes May 9, 2025 Page 2 1.C. Observation of Moment of Silence Chair Wiener led the Board and audience members in attendance in a moment of silence to observe those who have served our Country and community. 1.D. Welcome Meeting Attendees The Board welcomed all those in attendance. 1.E. Public Comments Detective Newbanks of the Marion County Sheriff’s Office (MCSO) advised that there have been a few golf cart thefts from Walmart on Hwy 441 and reminded residents to remove the keys from the carts. There has also been an increase in the number of traffic stops that the MSCO has completed in The Villages area. Supervisor Murphy inquired if there was a fatal accident on CR 42. Detective Newbanks advised that there was, but the accident fell under the Florida Highway Patrol jurisdiction. SECOND ORDER OF BUSINESS: Consent Agenda Chair Wiener advised the Board that a motion to approve the Consent Agenda is a motion to approve all recommended actions. All matters on the Consent Agenda are considered routine and no discussion is required unless desired by a Board Supervisor or a member of the public. Supervisor Murphy requested that Agenda Item 2.A. be pulled from the Consent Agenda. Chair Wiener requested that Agenda Item 2.B. be pulled from the Consent Agenda. On MOTION by Don Deakin, seconded by Mark Hayes, with all in favor, the Board took formal action on the following items: 2.C. Approval of Amendment Twelve to the Agreement 13P-017 with CH2M HILL OMI (Jacobs) for pump stations and aesthetic features for an annual increase of $415.02 and an amended base fee amount of $13,540.46 (including $2,750.00 for repairs) and authorized the Chair/Vice Chair to sign the Amendment. 2.D. Authorized Staff to advertise to hold a Public Hearing to amend and restate Chapter IV of the District's Rule for Towing. 2.A. Approval of Minutes Supervisor Murphy referred to Page 6 of the April 11, 2025 Minutes and stated that he does not agree with the opinion by Mark Brionez, District Counsel, to Florida Statute 316.006 which states that

VCDD 4 – Meeting Minutes May 9, 2025 Page 3 counties shall have the original jurisdiction over all streets and highways located within their boundaries, as it pertains to this Board’s inquiry if the Board has the ability to restrict public access behind the gates. 2.B. Review and Acceptance of Perpetual Utility Easement with Sumter Electric Cooperative, Inc (SECO) Chair Wiener requested clarification of where the easement is located. Carrie Duckett, Deputy District Manager, advised that Staff can provide the requested information. Supervisor Deakin inquired if District 4 were to change their energy provider if that would affect the Perpetual Utility Easement. Ms. Duckett advised that the Perpetual Utility Easement grants SECO an easement and has no effect on the District’s energy provider. On MOTION by Don Deakin, seconded by Cary Sternberg, with all in favor, the Board approved the Minutes for the Meeting held on April 11, 2025 and approved the Acceptance of Perpetual Utility Easement with Sumter Electric Cooperative, Inc (SECO) and authorized the Chair/Vice Chair to execute the document. THIRD ORDER OF BUSINESS: New Business Chair Wiener requested that Old Business Item #3 - Engineering costs for Arlington Loop/Parkland Court area to review drainage/pumping concerns be addressed at this time. Mike Harris, District Property Management (DPM) Director, advised that the estimate to conduct a drainage assessment of the area and provide a recommendation of possible improvements to address the drainage concerns is $13,382.00. The estimate to conduct the civil engineering evaluation project is $13,875.00. Supervisor Deakin expressed concern about the flooding of roads and yards over the years, even after a normal rainfall and inquired what options would be available if the recommendation made was to expand the capacity of the ponds. Bruce Balinside of Clymer Farner Barley stated that the first proposal is to complete an analysis of the inlets and the storm pipes to determine the inlet capacities and the storm pipe capacities. The second proposal is to complete an analysis of the pond itself to make sure it is adequately sized to handle the runoff.

VCDD 4 – Meeting Minutes May 9, 2025 Page 4 Chair Wiener stated that the flooding has been an issue for a long time, but now District 4 will be responsible for the cost to have the issue fixed. Chair Wiener inquired if the study will be able to determine if the stormwater system was properly constructed. Mr. Harris stated that the study will confirm if the stormwater system is functioning properly and will provide alternatives to change the basin capacity. Vice Chair Hayes inquired if there would be any additional costs for the studies. Mr. Balinside stated the only additional costs would be if the Board chose to proceed with a recommendation provided. Ann McGovern, Parkland Court, stated that after Hurricane Milton she was unable to walk in her yard because the water from Arlington Loop flows onto Parkland Court and the water can remain standing in the yards for a week after a storm. Mr. Balinside recommended that the pond capacity study be completed first because it will provide important information that lends itself to the second analysis. On MOTION by Don Deakin, seconded by Mark Hayes, with all in favor, the Board approved completing the drainage assessment. 3.A. Financial Statements Jennifer Liunoras, Finance Director, provided an overview of the Financial Statements as of March 31, 2025: • Total budgeted revenues year-to-date are $4,299,000 and the District has received $3.926 million in maintenance assessment revenue. As of March, the District has received 96% of the maintenance assessments to be collected with $59,000 left to be collected. • Investment earnings year-to-date are $74,000. • The expenditures are at $1,541,000, which is 46% of the budget. • The utilities is showing 52% as of March. • The Building Structure and Maintenance line item which makes up 27% of the amended budget includes $9,980 for pipe liner, $59,300 for Tunnel B3 Solar Conversion and $20,000 for painting. • The District continues to meet the reserve requirement.

VCDD 4 – Meeting Minutes May 9, 2025 Page 5 3.B. Award of Request for Qualifications (RFQ) #25Q-014 Professional Architect Continuing Services Melissa Schaar, Purchasing Director, advised that on February 11, 2025 the District issued Request for Qualifications (RFQ) #25Q-014 Professional Architect Continuing Services to include architectural and architect studies, permit applications, cost estimates and preparation of complete construction documents. This RFQ allowed for multiple firms to be awarded agreements. Seven (7) responsive submittals were received and Staff is requesting that the Board award RFP #25Q-014 to KP Studio Architect, P.A. for as needed services. The initial term of the Agreement expires on September 30, 2035 with the option to automatically renew for two (2), five (5) year periods. The Fee Schedule (Exhibit “A”) will remain fixed and firm through Fiscal Year 2025/2026 to be adjusted annually according to the Consumer Price Index for All Urban Consumers/All goods (CPI-U). On MOTION by Cary Sternberg, seconded by Don Deakin, with all in favor, the Board awarded RFQ #25Q-014 Professional Architect Continuing Services to KP Studio Architect, P.A. for as needed services and authorized the Chair/Vice Chair to execute the Agreement. 3.C. Award of Request for Qualifications (RFQ) #25Q-020 Professional Water Resources, Utility Operations & Utility Engineering Program Manager Ms. Schaar advised on February 11, 2025 the District issued Request for Qualifications (RFQ) #25Q-020 Professional Water Resources, Utility Operations & Utility Engineering Program Manager to establish Water Resource Engineering and Consulting Services for District-Owned Utilities. One responsive submittal was received and Staff is requesting that the Board award RFQ #25Q-020 to Arnett Environmental, LLC dba Vikus Water. The initial term of the Agreement expires on September 30, 2035 with the option to automatically renew for two (2), five (5) year periods. The Fee Schedule (Exhibit “A”) will remain fixed and firm through September 30, 2026 and subsequent annual adjustments shall be the 12-month percent change in the Employment Cost Index - Wages and salaries for Private industry workers in All industries and occupations.

VCDD 4 – Meeting Minutes May 9, 2025 Page 6 On MOTION by Don Deakin, seconded by Cary Sternberg, with all in favor, the Board awarded RFQ #25Q-020 Professional Water Resources, Utility Operations & Utility Engineering Program Manager to Arnett Environmental, LLC dba Vikus Water for as needed services and authorized the Chair/Vice Chair to execute the Agreement. 3.D. Award for Request for Qualifications # 25Q-022 Land Survey Services Ms. Schaar advised On February 11, 2025 the District issued Request for Qualifications (RFQ) #25Q-022 Land Survey Services to provide comprehensive surveying services. Four (4) responsive submittals were received and Staff is requesting that the Board award RFQ #25Q-022 to Clymer Farner Barley Surveying, LLC for as needed services. The initial term of the Agreement expires on September 30, 2035 with the option to renew for two (2) additional five (5) year periods. Fees will remain firm and fixed from effective date through fiscal year 25/26 and then adjusted annually according to the Consumer Price Index for All Urban Consumers/All goods (CPI-U), 12-month average, non- seasonalized. On MOTION by Don Deakin, seconded by Cary Sternberg, with all in favor, the Board awarded RFQ #25Q-022 Land Survey Services to Clymer Farner Barley Surveying, LLC for as needed services and authorized the Chair/Vice Chair to execute the Agreement. 3.E. Award for Request for Qualifications #25Q-023 Ecological, Natural Resources & Conservation Program Management Ms. Schaar advised that on February 11, 2025 the District issued Request for Qualifications (RFQ) #25Q-023 to provide environmental permitting support, oversight of subcontractors providing nuisance/exotic species control in mitigation areas and surveys for wildlife occurrences. Five (5) responsive submittals were received and Staff is requesting that the Board award RFQ #25Q-023 to Breedlove, Dennis & Associates, Inc. The initial term of the Agreement will expire on September 30, 2035 with the option to renew for two (2) additional five (5) year periods. Fees will remain firm and fixed from effective date through fiscal year 25/26 and then adjusted annually according to the Consumer Price Index for All Urban Consumers/All goods (CPI-U), 12-month average, non- seasonalized.

VCDD 4 – Meeting Minutes May 9, 2025 Page 7 On MOTION by Cary Sternberg, seconded by Don Deakin, with all in favor, the Board awarded RFQ #25Q-023 Ecological, Natural Resources & Conservation Program Management to Breedlove, Dennis & Associates, Inc for as needed services and authorized the Chair/Vice Chair execute the Agreement. FOURTH ORDER OF BUSINESS: Supervisor Comments Supervisor Sternberg advised that residents have expressed concern that resident groups are no longer able to perform at the squares. Ms. Duckett stated that performances at the squares does not fall under the District’s purview, but Staff can inquire with the Developer about the changes. Supervisor Deakin stated that a City Works presentation was made to the AAC, and requested that presentation be made to this Board also. Following concurrence of the Board, Ms. Duckett advised that the presentation would be included on the July or August agenda. Supervisor Deakin advised that he received an invitation form The Villages Homeowners Advocates (VHA) to attend a community program on June 3, 2025 at 6:00 p.m. Karl Arps, Village of Woodbury, advised that the VHA was requesting that someone attend who can speak about Amenity Authority Committee (AAC) related projects, but more importantly Supervisor Deakin was invited to attend because he is the District 4 liaison to Marion County, to assist in explaining why the Marion County portion of The Villages is unique. Supervisor Deakin inquired if one of the Supervisors would be interested in attending to represent District 4. Supervisor Murphy advised that he would attend as the representative for District 4. Vice Chair Hayes provided his appreciation of Supervisor Deakin’s dedication to the residents, but expressed concern that Supervisor Deakin held a rally in conjunction with the monthly Q&A which was not approved by this Board or the AAC. Vice Chair Hayes stated that Supervisor Deakin and resident Patsy Oburn both issued separate notices announcing the Q&A and amenity fee rally. The District 4 Board has no authority to address amenity fee related items, and Vice Chair Hayes stated that Supervisor Deakin should have addressed the amenity fee item at a separate venue and should not have been co-mingled with the District 4 Q&A. Vice Chair Hayes stated that he believes Mr. Deakin being an elected District 4 Supervisor and AAC Member has created a conflict of interest, and that one person

VCDD 4 – Meeting Minutes May 9, 2025 Page 8 should not hold two elected positions because it can become difficult to identify which entity the individual represents when addressing residents. Chair Wiener inquired if the District was experiencing an issue with the aquatic maintenance contractor. Ms. Duckett advised that the current contractor has requested an increase which Staff was not comfortable with and there have been concerns about the maintenance condition of some of the ponds. Staff has separately re-solicited the aquatic maintenance services contract for north of C$ 466, the Project Wide area and the Eastport area. FIFTH ORDER OF BUSINESS: Committee Updates 5.A. Investment Advisory Committee (IAC): Primary – Jim Murphy, Alternate – Mark Hayes Supervisor Murphy provided an overview of the District 4 investable earnings received from the IAC meeting held on May 6, 2025. 5.B. Multi-Modal Path Discussion Group (MMPDG): Cliff Wiener Chair Wiener advised that the MMPDG meeting will be held on September 23, 2025 at 2:00 p.m. at the Savannah Recreation Center. The District 5 Board has completed the installation of centerline Reflective Pavement Markers (RPM)s. 5.C. Liaison to MCSO and VPSD: Mark Hayes Vice Chair Hayes advised that the Board received a copy of The Villages Public Safety (VPSD) Department monthly report. 5.D. Liaison to MCBOCC: Don Deakin Supervisor Deakin advised the Marion County Board of County Commissioners (MCBOCC) is having difficulty meeting the five (5) year plan for the fire assessments. The current rate is $237 and the new rate will be $284. Supervisor Deakin advised that for every $1 the MCBOCC invests in tourism in Marion County there is a return of $66. SIXTH ORDER OF BUSINESS: Old Business 6.A. Old Business Status Update Ms. Duckett provided the following Old Business Status Updates:

VCDD 4 – Meeting Minutes May 9, 2025 Page 9 1. Consider video recording/live streaming meetings: Staff will begin the video recording at the July 11, 2025 meeting. 2. SECO Light pole update; Request SECO provide cost for 24-hour repair service and factors that equate to lease price: An email was forwarded to the Board on April 16, 2025. Supervisor Murphy provided an overview of the anticipated adjustments that will be made to homeowners personal SECO bills. 3. Engineering costs for Arlington Loop/Parkland Court area to review drainage/pumping concerns: This was previously discussed. 4. Provide update on “Welcome to Marion County” sign insurance claim; provide alternatives/costs for smaller sign: The sign has been installed. 5. Review if District 4 can restrict public access behind gates: Mark Brionez, District Counsel, stated that he continues to review related documents and advised that a few of the plats dedicate the roadways to the residents of certain villages, which is different that dedicated to the general public. Mr. Brionez stated the question remains if the roadways are public. Supervisor Murphy stated that Florida Statute 316.006 identifies three (3) types of roads: State, Municipality and all others including Special Districts. The District 4 roads were constructed by the Developer and the costs were reimbursed by the District 4 residents, not Marion County. Mr. Brionez stated that Supervisor Murphy is correct, and the bonds issued are being paid back by the residents of District 4. 6. Provide update of removal of equipment behind Calumet postal facility: The Developer has advised that the repairs are complete and rainfall will fill the basin. Supervisor Deakin requested that Staff contact the Developer about the vegetation that needs to be trimmed in the area. Ms. Duckett advised that Staff will contact the Developer about the concern. 7. Provide street sweeping schedule and video: An email was forwarded to the Board on April 28, 2025. 8. Depression at Storm Inlet on Crowfield Avenue (Cameron Villa): Email updates were provided on April 22, 2025 and April 30, 2025. Mr. Harris provided an overview of the timeline of the work to repair the depression. Non-VCDD No. 4 Items

VCDD 4 – Meeting Minutes May 9, 2025 Page 10 9. Provide AMR Meter-Change-out Schedule: Emails were forwarded to the Board on April 13, 2025 and April 15, 2025. Supervisor Deakin and Chair Wiener expressed concern that no notice has been provided that the meter changes would be happening. Ms. Duckett advised that Staff will look contact the contractor. 6.B. The Alternate Architectural Review Committee (ARC) Member Matt Armstrong, Community Standards Director, advised that on April 12, 2024, Todd Turpin was appointed as the Architectural Review Committee (ARC) Alternate Member to complete the remainder of the four (4) year term that expired on March 31, 2025. Mr. Turpin has indicated his desire to continue serving as the District’s Alternate Member for an additional four (4) year term that would begin on May 9, 2025. On MOTION by Cary Sternberg, seconded by Don Deakin, with all in favor, the Board reappointed Todd Turpin as the alternate Architectural Review Committee (ARC) member for Village Community Development District No. 4 for a four (4) year term that expires on May 9, 2029. 6.C. Architectural Review Manual Revision – Roofs Mr. Armstrong advised at the April 11, 2025 Board meeting, Staff presented information about re-roofing projects in Courtyard Villa units and the challenges that the ARC, residents, and contractors are facing to obtain materials because of the age of the roofs. The Board requested that Staff revise the Architectural Review Manual to assist in alleviating some of those challenges, while maintaining the integrity and design of the community. Mr. Armstrong advised that the proposed Architectural Review Manual revisions include the following: • Clarifying the metal roofing material and color requirements for Homes and Patio Villas. • Revised the roof color language to accommodate color selections that are within the hue range of the original color of the Courtyard Villa. • Alternative roofing materials include Tesla or stamped metal shingle roofs. Mr. Armstrong advised that Staff was able to obtain roofing samples so that residents have the ability to compare shingle colors and identify the manufacturers of the shingles. The samples will be

VCDD 4 – Meeting Minutes May 9, 2025 Page 11 displayed in the Community Standards Department of the District Office for residents to view. Mr. Armstrong advised that Staff recommends that the Board review the proposed revisions and provide feedback, if no revisions are necessary, approve the Architectural Review Manual revisions as presented, effective May 9, 2025. Supervisor Deakin inquired if this would include the composite rubber shingles. Mr. Armstrong advised he have to confirm. Ms. Duckett advised that another Board recommended language be included to state “Tesla or similar” to allow for other brands. Mr. Arps stated that the Board may want to consider allowing standing seam metal roofs and inquired if the incorporating multi-colored courtyard villas could be clarified that different houses can have multi-colored roofs, but one roof cannot be multi-colored. On MOTION by Cary Sternberg, seconded by Don Deakin, with all in favor, the Board approved the Architectural Review Manual revisions with the modifications discussed with an effective date of May 9, 2025. SEVENTH ORDER OF BUSINESS: Informational Items Only 7.A. Supervisor Deakin: Amenity Authority Committee After Agenda Supervisor Deakin advised that the Amenity Authority Committee (AAC) After Agenda from the May 7, 2025 meeting was provided to the Board, as information, and advised that the motion to establish an amenity fee deferral did not pass. Karen O’Farrell, Village of Piedmont, stated that she appreciated that the amenity fee deferral discussion was not moved to the beginning of the meeting for people who do not normally attend the meeting. 7.B. DPM Monthly Report The DPM Monthly Report was provided to the Board as information. 7.C. Registered Voters as of April 15, 2025 Per the Marion County Supervisor of Elections Office, the number of registered voters within Village Community Development District No. 4 as of April 15, 2025 was 7,553. 7.F. Advanced Meter Reading (AMR) Changed Out Update- April 2025 The (AMR) change out was provided to the Board as information.

VCDD 4 – Meeting Minutes May 9, 2025 Page 12 EIGHTH ORDER OF BUSINESS: District Manager Reports Ms. Duckett advised the District 4 Budget Workshop will be held on Tuesday, May 13, 2025 at 1:30 p.m. Mr. Harris provided the location of the utility easement. NINTH ORDER OF BUSINESS: District Counsel Reports There were no District Counsel Reports. TENTH ORDER OF BUSINESS: Public Comments There were no further public comments received. ELEVENTH ORDER OF BUSINESS: Adjourn The meeting was adjourned at 3:05 p.m. On MOTION by Cary Sternberg, seconded by Jim Murphy, with all in favor, the Board adjourned the meeting. Kenneth C. Blocker Cliff Wiener Secretary Chair

Showing the first 24,000 of 80,256 characters. The full document is at the source.

Everybody I'd like to call the District four Board of Supervisors meeting for May 9th, 2025 to order. Let roll call show that all of our board members are present first on the agendas, standing for the pledge to the flag, and remain standing for a moment of silence for our first responders and military personnel. The United States of America Republic Probation stand under honor individual with liberty and justice law. Thank you. Appreciate. I'd like to, excuse me, like to welcome all of our attendees. Uh, next then the agenda is public comment portion of the meeting. If you have something you wanna bring before the board or tell us something, you can step to the podium. You have three minutes. State your name and address and we will be more than happy to listen to you. So just raise your hand if you have something you wanna bring before the board. Seeing nothing, we will move on. I see we have law enforcement. You still there, right? I can't see. Okay. Uh, we're gonna call him so we can get back to duty. Alright. Hello everybody. My name's Detective Thomas Newbank. I'm the assigned detective for the Villages area at South Mary for the Marion County Sheriff's Office. Um, unfortunately our lieutenant could not be here today, so I'm here to fill in. Um, everything's been relatively smooth sailing and the district of South Marion over the last month, month and a half. We did have an uptick with some golf cart thefts from Walmart. Um, the biggest thing for you guys, make sure that if you park your golf cart, take the keys out. Don't leave valuables on your golf cart. I know it is it's habit to leave the clubs, but with the amount of money some people spend on clubs, I mean, I don't know how you could just leave it there and walk away from it. And these guys know that. Um, as far as like the traffic and stuff like that, our guys in the district are amping up the traffic enforcement. Um, they've got a double triple digit traffic enforcement for the month of April that they put up for traffic stops and UTCs and all that kind of stuff. Um, the areas right here on Buena Vista and Belmead by where we're at, um, and the Publix, they've been going through there and, and stopping people that are flowing through the stop signs and all that kind of stuff to try and make it a little bit easier for you guys on the golf carts and everybody moving around. Um, other than that, that's pretty much all we've got from the sheriff's office. Anybody have any questions for, uh, you just, you did have a fatality there on 42. We should they correct? Yes. But with, uh, in the unincorporated areas of Marion County, the Highway patrol works those. Okay, we'll, we'll show up for traffic control to make sure the scene's secure and nothing gets moved or tampered with until Highway patrol gets there. Once Highway patrol comes, then they initiate their, their traffic homicide investigation and they take the ball and they run with it. We're more for support and safety up until they get There. We do see a lot more traffic control than we've seen in a long time. Good. I'm glad. We do appreciate that. If you guys can, if you guys can tell a difference, that means the, the initiative that we're taking are working and that's what we like to hear. We need that feedback from you guys, from everybody to let us know where we need to focus our, our resources and what, what spots we need to target. Okay. Anybody in the audience have anything they want to ask? The detective would, seeing none thank you for Okay. And tell, tell lieutenant we we thank him too. Absolutely. Alright. Appreciate it guys. Thank you for coming and be safe out there. Okay, next on the agenda is the consent agenda motion to prove the consent agendas a motion to approve, approve. I do. Uh, just pardon a comment of the minute so I pull that so I can make a comment. Okay. Just let me read this first. Um, I have a, uh, motion to approve all recommended action to all matters under consent, send agenda, consider routine, and no discussion is required unless desired by a board member of the member of the public. So Jim wants to pull the minutes. I would like to pull two BI believe, just 'cause I have a question. Anybody else? If not, I'll, I'll accept the motion for two C and 2D. So moved. Second. All in favor? Aye. Aye. All opposed? Opposed? Okay. Jim, you're first. Oh, on the minutes, I just want to add for the record that, uh, uh, I don't agree a hundred percent with the, uh, description of using, um, 3 36 dash, uh, oh oh six in our case on the road. So just added to the record that I disagree with that. Okay. Synopsis that it automatically makes our roads public. Okay. And, and just for a record mark, we'll be talking about that a little later. Okay. And I, I have a question about about two b, I just don't understand where this is. If somebody could just, I mean, he gives it, he gives directions, which I have no idea where they're talking about putting this. Mike, do you know, Um, if you, if he can let him look at it and see if he can get it pulled up, and then we'll follow up with you at a later part of the meeting. Okay. Mike? It's the CCO utility Easement where they wanna put the, okay. I just was curious as to where it's gonna be located. I have questions on it as well. The, the language here, um, is a perpetual utility with CCO and with everything going on with cco, what, what does that mean? You know, what if we change our provider and so on down the road, are we locked Into to them and, and not someone else if we change a provider or what? No, this is just granting them an easement so you, it would not interfere with your desire. If you were to move, um, and let's say you wanted to do own your own poles and do solar, this would not impact that. I just wanna be sure we're not locked in. Yes, sir. Okay. As far as approving it, um, in the minutes, um, I'm, I'm all for that as Mike. Just lets me know where it is for my own knowledge. Um, so can I get a motion to approve two A and two B? So moved. I move Second. All in favor? Aye. Aye. All opposed? Seeing none. It's approved unanimously. Okay. Um, at this point in time, in the, in the, um, agenda, I'm gonna move up. We have a, um, representative here is gonna talk about the, the issue we're having down by Chatham on the, on, um, forget the name of his Glen Park. And Mike, do you wanna come up and get that started so that they can go back to work? Don't like to keep people from working? We have an engineer here, I believe. Good afternoon. Mike Harris, district Property Management. As you're aware, we did send the two estimates for the two different services for the area. Um, one of 'em was for, to do a, a study of the, the capacity of the basin there. And the other one was to look at the integrity and the functionality of the stormwater system itself. And Bruce with climber, foreigner, parley, climber foreigner barley has graciously showed up to answer any questions you guys have on the, the scope of those services and what the outcome could be. Okay. Thank you Don. I'm sure. Don I'm sure you have questions. Thank you, Mike. Thank you members of the board. I'd be happy to answer any questions you guys might have. You wanna start, Don? Well, our our concern is several and, and one of course is what are some of the options in expanding the capacity of the retention ponds that we have? And we talked at a previous meeting about the pond that, uh, is on Berwood golf course and has whole number eight and nine around it, and then the Chatham Rec Center. And, uh, it seems to me that we might be able to expand some of that area and, and the T box for whole number one is there as well. Mm-hmm. And I would hope that we could, uh, see about the feasibility of either digging deeper or digging larger, uh, with what we have there. Uh, we know we've had flooding issues with that pond even on the, uh, golf cart path coming from, um, the tee box of nine to the green. And that seemed to have gotten rectified over the years. So we have that concern. But a bigger concern for the residents is the fact that not only when we have heavy range or hurricanes, but even sometimes routine range that may be two or three inches, uh, from Arlington loop down to the lower level of homes there, the water seems to be flowing over the top of the homes themselves in the yards washing through the yards and down into the backyards of the homes that are on the lower level there. Um, the storm drains don't seem to be adequate to handle the amount of water, even with a, a couple of inches. And we have seen that flood numerous times for them, uh, even if it didn't flood on Legacy Lane. Um, although we have also had, uh, numerous incidences over the last 20 years where Legacy Lane ended up with several feet of water. Uh, and I'm not talking recent history, I'm talking about, you know, ancient history as well. And so we have concerns with that. Those people need to have relief. They should not be having the storm drains, um, not be adequate to take that kind of rain and to have it come washing up over the houses behind them and down through those yards. And, and so that's, that's one of the concerns that we have. So, so there would be two analyses that were proposed. One would be to analyze the, the inlets that you're referring to, as well as the storm pipes that are underground that convey the storm water to the pond. So we would analyze the inlet capacities and the storm pipe capacities to make sure they're adequately sized. Um, and then the second proposal would be analyzing the actual pond itself, making sure that the pond is adequately sized to handle all the runoff that's in its collective basin. Um, so that those would be the two proposals you have before you, and that would be what we would do. We would analyze all the things that you mentioned before to make sure they're all built properly. Um, I'm not an engineer, but if the pond is at a certain level and the storm drains are at what would be considered full level, but then the water gets higher than the inlets into the pond, is that water gonna flow into the pond anyway and raise the level of the, the water? Or is it going to slow that water down and that water once, once the water gets higher than the inlet, is it going to stop flowing and back up into, uh, legacy and on up onto Arlington loop? So with, without analyzing this particular system, I can't tell you what's happening here yet, but conceptually, um, if you have a, an inlet that drains to a pond, um, that the pipes, if they're sized adequately, it should drain everything to the pond. And you shouldn't have any backing up in the inlet more than what would be accepted for that. If it's a severe storm, Even after the water in the pond is higher than the inlet. So the inlet shouldn't be, or the pond shouldn't be higher than the, the inlet should be higher than the pond it's drain to. So, um, that would be part of the analysis, making sure that the inlet elevation is higher than the pond top of bank. Well, that's something then that you may need to look at because, um, that was certainly one of the more recent issues here, where the pond, the inlet was underwater already, and so it didn't, it was backing up onto legacy and onto those streets and it then it backed all the way up into Arlington and, uh, and that Arlington was flooded by several feet of water. Um, and I don't remember the, the sheet, the street that comes off and ends up in a cul-de-sac from Arlington, but it was one right above that. And, uh, so that would be a concern and, and we'd need, I guess, um, some sort of an idea of what it would take for us to raise the level of the inlets so that they can drain properly into the pond in the first place. Mm-hmm. That alone would give you several more, you know, cubic feet of water that that pond could hold without expanding the pond size itself. If, if the inlets could come in at a higher level. And what's happening now, from what I see is that yeah, gravity feeds, but it's pretty steep. And maybe if the pond had a gradual, uh, instead of a steep feed, you, you might be able to raise the storm drain a little higher, which would require digging through that easement where the storm drain is raising it up and then bear bearing it underground so that people have their normal yards still. Um, but that might be one of the things you wanna consider. I I, I don't wanna tell you how to do your job, but I'm telling you what I have observed and what I've heard from the residents, um, as being issued for them. Yes Sir. No, and observations are, are crucial. So yeah, in our analysis would be, uh, analyzing what the elevation constraints are. So if I'm not mistaken, Mike, this question's for you. What, what we're here to determine today is if we want to pay the amount of money for the study that they want to do. So, is that correct? That is correct. We wanna pay for the study that we requested. Correct. So my question to you is, would this study tell us, because I've lived here for 23 years and when I moved here, those houses weren't even here. So the underground was, so it seems that this is a problem that goes back from the very beginning. I, that that's my big concern, that we have inherited something that was not done maybe the way it should have been, and now we're, we're gonna have to pay the penalty. That's what I'm trying to get at with the study. Would that study if we agree to do it, give us that information. I don't know what we do, what we would do that after we get it, but I'm sure we could figure something out. It would give you a confirmation, number one, if the storm water system is functioning properly and give you alternatives if we wanted to do something with the basin capacity. But we've heard in the past that what could be involved in doing that type of project with the land around. Well, I understand what's involved. I just, okay. We're a, we're, we're caught between a rock and a hard place because we have residents that are suffering and this board doesn't want to suffer for the cost of what I know this thing is gonna cost. So, okay. I Does anybody else have any questions for the gentleman? Because we have to decide whether or not we want to spend this money for the, these two, there were two studies, right, Mike, for these two studies have one question. Yes, sure. Sir. Is there any possibility that the cost of that study could go further than what was projected? The studies should give you comprehensive answers, So the cost shouldn't increase. It would just be any recommendations for any remediation if necessary. That would be a cost that would Be proposed to. Okay. So what, what does this board wish to do? Somebody wanna make a motion? I, I make a motion that we proceed with the study because something needs to be done. The residents need relief. Um, I, I just have serious concerns about whether there is a solution, uh, that is going to be reasonable. Um, and, and that it's gonna be something that's, you know, financially feasible for us. Uh, I saw a ley horn study done on Morris Boulevard, and it did not address the issues. And the, the study was a, um, study in a futile possibility. There were no reasonable solutions, and they knew that before they went in with the study and, and yet a lot of money was spent on it. Okay, so you made a motion. Do I have a second? I, I just would like to clarify which study you were wanting. Was it both of them or was there a specific study that you wanted to move forward on? Well, I'm inclined to wanna split it and see what the first study would tell us, and then determine whether a second study is even gonna be worthwhile. Well, they're, they're studying two completely different things. So one of them is studying the stormwater system, and then the other one is studying the capacity of the basin. So I just, I wanna make sure that we're directing them. If, if this is where you wanna go, exactly what you're looking to accomplish. If, if your concern is the water on the resident's yard, which one of these would potentially solve that problem? That's a challenging question. Okay. Um, so without knowing what the issue is, um, so a typical rule of thumb is if you have, you know, any kind of sitting water for hours or even a day or two, it's a pipe capacity issue, which my understanding is that there is one or more inlets that are having sitting water for one or two days. If you have sitting water for a week, it is a facing package. So It, it, I don't, it's primarily one pipe coming off the cul-de-sac from Arlington loop and it it is. And so then it goes underground and it comes up and from three locations in that cul-de-sac on the lower level. So the water is running along the curbs from Arlington loop down to that cul-de-sac, which has, uh, well it, it has two on the entrance to it and then one at the end of the cul-de-sac. And but those three end up with just one pipe that's going down to the lower level. So they can't handle that because they've only got, um, two inlets from the entrance to that cul-de-sac on the upper level that feed down into the one. And that one is not able to handle everything. And then they, they come up on the three down below. Um, and then those overflow. But beyond that, because the upper ones can't handle it, the water, instead of following the curb, they're going over the curbs and over through the driveways into the ba, the front yards and then the backyards of the upper level homes. Yes, sir. And, and maybe one of the things that we should be considering is another storm drain put in so that you have 'em coming in, um, from the upper level to the lower level with more going out to the pond itself. Um, I guess I think that the, the problem, the root of the problem might be what's happening up above first. How long is the water standing in the yard? Because I, if I recall from the last, um, gentleman that we had here, he indicated that although it was an inconvenience to the residents, unless it is standing there for hours and days, it's not considered a malfunction of the system. And it is, it is, I hate to say normal, but your system is still functioning correctly as long as the water is not standing longer than a day. So I, I just wanna make sure, again, I'm, I'm not saying it's not an inconvenience to the residents and you don't wanna try to, to help them, but I would hate to see a half a million dollar project come before you for something that technically the stormwater system is functioning as it's designed. Mr. McGovern, since you're a part of this, you had your hand up. Um, I'm Anna McGovern and I live at 1 7 2 9 5 Southeast Parkland Court. And it was so serious after Milton came through. Now we had two hurricanes. Our yard was like a mudslide. I couldn't even walk in the backyard and I had to prepare it to get ready for Milton and I had to lay boards down to get into my backyard. So all of Arlington loop is draining into our neighbor's yard and it's coming over. And you could walk with me, I'll show you signs of distress. And you already are dealing with the depression stuff over at Crow Profield. This is like a 23 erosion problem, 23 years of erosion. Our next door neighbor, if you walk in their yard, you're stepping in depression. My husband's boot went right down. We're standing and standing water for at least a week after some of these storms. We built up our flail. But somebody has to do something, even if they put a storm drain in the neighbor's yard next door. I think I sent you all the pictures. Something has to be done. We're the second homeowner. And the first homeowner had already complained. They sell their house, the next door neighbors, they're the second homeowners, they sold their house or the other side. They're three homeowners. People are just selling their house. And when you read the sad story about Crow Field Avenue, that guy bought his house for 379,000. I and it went Into, I'm not trying to cut you off, we're not talking about Crow field. Keep it to the subject. We're trying, but to come to a conclusion it's the Issue. It's the same issue. I I understand it. Okay. Okay. We, we heard. Thank you. Okay. We have a, we have a motion. Is there a second? I'm just not clear on the motion. What, what is it, what we're gonna, do you want a single one? It's the motions to do one or one or both of the studies? I, I guess I it should be, or we could both either do one or Both. Correct. Okay. But Don made the motion. Okay. I think we should start with the source of the problem, which is, um, the upper level flooding down into the lower level. And then let's look at that first and then look at the additional issue if necessary, about the capacity of the pond. I think the capacity of the pond, uh, can be resolved relatively Either. Don, I, I just that you made a motion. I just want to know what your motion, the upper level. Okay. Do you, do you understand which survey is the upper Level? I, I, I do. He's referring to the conveyance system. Um, I know each of the two proposals, they're relatively the same cost. Yes. If we were designing the system, just to give you context, if we were designing the system from scratch, we would do the pond first because the pond analysis will give good information that lends itself to the second analysis. Um, whereas the second analysis done without the first one, um, you're not gonna have the pond data elevation stuff that you need in order to get the second analysis done in detail. So, um, if you had a recommendation, if you were splitting them, um, it would be the first one because that would be your pond analysis that gives you, it's called the term is tailwater, but you need that in order to really run your conveyance analysis accurately. I think the thing of elevation has been a discussion on this board for quite a while on a big concern that the elevation that was on the original, um, plats really have been exceeded, um, for whatever reason I know they have in our area, they went from plat land. Uh, I go back one street and up nine foot higher than they were when we moved in. And the developer did come out and put in black pipe in my side lawn with, uh, vs in them with the drains to drain the water out of our yard, which was basically almost coming into the house. So it is an issue as far as the pond itself is concerned. Um, you know, I also agree with that if the elevation's an issue with the pond, and I guess it's going in and digging that pond a little bit deeper so we can hold more water, but I don't know whether that water issue elevation should be part of the first study or not. What do you recommend? So my, my recommendation, if we're only gonna do one of them, would be to do the first one, which is, I believe it was titled, um, uh, drainage assessment. Um, the second one was titled, uh, stormwater Conveyance Analysis. So I, I would recommend doing the drainage assessment, which analyzes, um, what was designed and, but also more critically reviews the hydraulic data that is in that pawn itself. Carrie, you had a question? Yes, Mike, could you run me the numbers very quickly? What, What the cost of each one of these studies? So the, Lemme get my stuff. Just the second one. So, so the first one is $13,382, that is for the capacity issue. And the second one is $13,875 for the conveyance system. Thank you. I, I think I misunderstood what you were saying because I thought I heard you say one thing earlier and then in answer to, uh, his question you said something differently. I felt So are you talking about the capacity the pond is being the first study? Yes, sir. Yeah. The, there's apon capacity analysis, essentially there's apon capacity and a pipe conveyance. Um, so those are the two analyses that would be Proposed. Well, alright, I'll, I'm, I feel like we should listen to you and, and I withdraw my motion. My first motion. Okay. Before you do, mark h

Community Development District 4 Seat 1 - Cliff Wiener, Chair Seat 2 - Cary Sternberg, Supervisor Seat 3 - Jim Murphy, Supervisor Seat 4 - Mark Hayes, Vice Chair Seat 5 - Don Deakin, Supervisor May 9, 2025 at 1:30 PM Savannah Regional Recreation Center 1545 Buena Vista Blvd. The Villages, FL 32162 ____________________________________________________________________________________________ AGENDA The District encourages citizen participation in the democratic process and recognizes and protects the right of freedom of speech afforded to all. As the Board conducts the business of the District, rules of civility shall apply. District Board Supervisors, Staff members, and members of the public are to communicate respectfully. It is preferred that persons speak only when recognized by the Board Chair and, at that time, refrain from engaging in personal attacks or derogatory or offensive language. Persons who are deemed to be disruptive and negatively impact the efficient operation of the meeting shall be subject to removal after two verbal warnings. Audience Comments on all issues will be received by the Board. 1. Call to Order 1.A. Roll Call 1.B. Pledge of Allegiance 1.C. Observation of Moment of Silence 1.D. Welcome Meeting Attendees 1.E. Public Comments 2. Consent Agenda A motion to approve the Consent Agenda is a motion to approve all recommended actions. All matters on the Consent Agenda are considered routine and no discussion is required unless desired by a Board Supervisor or a Member of the Public. 2.A. Approval of Minutes 2.B. Review and Acceptance of Perpetual Utility Easement with Sumter Electric Cooperative, Inc (SECO) 2.C. Review and Approval of Amendment Twelve to Agreement 13P-017 with CH2M Hill Operations Management International, Inc. (Jacobs) for Village Community Development District No.4 Pump Stations and Aesthetic Features. 2.D. Requesting permission to advertise Amending and Restating Chapter IV of its Rule 3. New Business 3.A. Financial Statements 3.B. Award of Request for Qualifications (RFQ) Professional Architect Continuing Services 3.C. Award of Request for Qualifications (RFQ) #25Q-020 Professional Water Resources, Utility Operations & Utility Engineering Program Manager 3.D. Award of Request for Qualifications # 25Q-022 Land Survey Services 3.E. Award of Request for Qualifications # 25Q-023 Ecological, Natural Resources & Conservation Program Management

4. Supervisor Comments 5. Committee Updates 5.A. Investment Advisory Committee/Auditor Selection Committee: Primary - Jim Murphy, Alternate - Mark Hayes 5.B. Multi-Modal Path Discussion Group: Cliff Wiener 5.C. Liaison to MCSO & VPSD: Mark Hayes 5.D. Liaison to MCBOCC: Don Deakin 6. Old Business 6.A. Old Business Status Update 6.B. The Alternate Architectural Review Committee (ARC) Member 6.C. Architectural Review Manual Revision - Roofs 7. Informational Items Only 7.A. Supervisor Deakin: Amenity Authority Committee After Agenda 7.B. DPM Monthly Report 7.C. Registered Voters as of April 15, 2025 7.D. VCCDD AMR Change Out - April 2025 8. District Manager Reports 9. District Counsel Reports 10. Public Comments 11. Adjourn HOSPITALITY STEWARDSHIP INNOVATION & CREATIVITY HARD WORK NOTICE Each person who decides to appeal any action taken at these meetings is advised that person will need a record of the proceedings and that accordingly, the person may need to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceedings is made, incoming the testimony and evidence upon which such appeal is to be based. Audio recordings of Board meetings, workshops or public hearings are available for purchase per Florida Statute 119.07 through the District Clerk for $1.00 per CD requested. Any person requiring special accommodations at this meeting because of disability of physical impairment should contact the District Office at (352) 751-3939 at least five calendar days prior to the meetings.

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
Agenda packetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Action agendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Coverage and corrections

Records considered

  • Village Community Development District No. 4 (2025-05-09) — Minutes
  • Village Community Development District No. 4 (2025-05-09) — Closed Captions
  • Village Community Development District No. 4 (2025-05-09)

Not claimed by this page

  • Verified meeting decisions with item-specific public-source evidence
  • Item-level plain-language summaries are not available; this page does not infer individual agenda items.
  • Item-linked, attributed deliberation
  • A source-grounded next meeting date
  • A plain-English overview is not available.
  • Official outcomes have not been published.
  • Transcript coverage is partial.
  • Speakers have not been reliably matched to public profiles.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: 4133c48307cd196799dc72a8dada1978. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record