POLISCOPE

The public record

REDDING (SHASTA COUNTY)Minutes linked · not read herePartial coverage

Aug 7, 2024 5:15 PM - Redding City Council - Special Meeting

Wednesday, August 7, 2024 · Government meeting record

The 30-second read

Record incomplete

Aug 7, 2024 5:15 PM - Redding City Council - Special Meeting

Why it matters

The official meeting record is available below. Item-level plain-language summaries are not available yet.

What happens next

The scheduled meeting date has passed. Minutes or an action agenda are linked at the source, but their text is not held here.

The publisher links minutes or an action agenda for this meeting, but its text is not held here. Nothing on this page is presented as a decision; open the linked record for outcomes.

Record text

No transcript is held for this meeting. Recording: Media

>> Good evening, everybody. Can we start? 5:15. Okay. If anyone wishes to address the city council on any item considered at this meeting before or during the council's consideration of that item, please fill out a blue speaker request form located in the lighted alcoves at the back of the council chambers and submit it to the city clerk. City council will allocate up to a maximum three minutes per speaker for each agenda item. Staff are available online at city's website and in the public view binder located on the podium at the north side of the chamber. Are we gonna do the full. Okay. Yes. Let's stand for the pledge of allegiance. Are we doing. I don't know, dIAFFerent. >> I pledge allegiance to the Flag of the United States of America, and to the Republic for which it stands, one Nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. >>Stay standing. Gordon DeWitt will be our chaplain for the Redding . Police and fire departments will give the invocation. >> Would you bow with me? Our heavenly father, thank you for your presence in this room and guiding us here this evening. We're grateful for all who are present. Each of them are demonstrating a commitment to and investment in this community. Help us that our words and actions would contribute to positive outcomes for the needs of our city. We pray for our council members that you would grant them wisdom as they serve our city and its residents, and as they strive to make Redding an even more incredible place to live and work. May they not become weary in doing good, and may you provide your strength and courage to each of them. Father, bless our community and protect all of those who work to keep us safe. Pray this in your holy name. Amen. >> Roll call. [ CALLING ROLL ] >> The city council will recess to closed session to discuss the following items. At the conclusion of the closed session, open session will reconvene and reportable action, if any, will be announced. >> The city council will now meet in closed session to consider items two a and two b. Each item is described in more detail on the written agenda available at the back of the room. [ CLOSED SESSION ] >> Hi, everybody. So this is a special meeting, so we're just going to come back from closed session. Do we have any reportable action? >> No. The council met on items two A and two B and took no reportable action. >> Okay, we are going to move along to public comment. So pursuant to the Brown Act Civil council, the city council cannot take action on public comment items, which is why we don't comment on them. The city council will allocate up to a maximum of three minutes per speaker for 30 minutes total. I've got one of you, so we don't need to worry about that. Nick Gardner, come on up. >> Am I the only speaker, or you just want to get rid of me quick? >> You are the one and only. >> All right. Well, you know, Travis, last time he told us a little bit he knew about the lease for big league dreams, and I found some things that weren't quite correct. First off, big league dreams was built with a $20 million grant from the state of California. I was talking to Leonard Modi, and he's the one that told me that. And I got into it with Ken Murray, and he was lying about the amount of money Redding was going to receive from big league dreams. So Kim Neimer gave me a copy of the contract. On the first page of the contract, the first thing it said was, if this was going to go to a public vote, they weren't interested in coming. That's pretty much a red flag there. The contract was for 32 years, and the first four years were free. After that, the city of Redding would get 6% of the gross income. They started out with a $3 entrance fee, so the city of Redding 's cut from that was $0.18. That doesn't sound like much of a contract to me. But as things went along, right at the end of four years, big league dreams built a facility in Manteca. So all the Bay Area teams that were coming up here for tournaments went to Manteca. It was a lot more convenient, and the park was empty every weekend for a couple years. After that, it just set. They hired Pat Kite, and he was a city councilman at the time. I remember him up here crying that he had to get back to his family in Los Angeles, and in fact, he went to work for big league dreams as their construction consultant. His first project, I think it was Arizona, was estimated at $30 million. It overran, but big league dreams didn't bring anything to the table. Absolutely nothing. It amounted to corporate welfare, in my opinion. And when they switched from big league dreams to, well, what is it, TNC Sports, they switched their contract. And it looked to me like that was probably an effort to get out of litigation. I believe that the city of Redding should sue big league dreams for breach of contract by not keeping up our facilities. They were supposed to keep everything up and nobody oversaw it. That was a letdown on the city's part, but those things happen, and it's a too late to complain about it now. I've got that contract. If anybody wants to know anything about it, give me a call. >> Thanks, Nick. Okay, we're going to move to the consent calendar. The consent calendar contains items considered routine and or which have been individually scrutinized by the city council members and are anticipated to require no further deliberation. If a member of the public wishes to address an item on the consent calendar, please fill out a speaker request form, submit it to the city clerk before the consent calendar is considered. It shall be the prerogative of any council member before the consent calendar is acted upon to one, comment on an item. Two, respond to any public comment on that item. Three, request a record reflect an abstention or nay vote on an item. Four, to remove an item and place it on the regular portion of the agenda for delivery of a staff report and our extended discussion or deliberation. Do we have any comments? Like I said, no. Does any of the council members wish to. Councilmember Mazzeno. >> Thank you, Madam Mayor. I don't think we need to pull it. I'd just like to. I have a question about 4.5. Authorize the following actions relative to city council electric utilities fire monitoring system upgrade projects at the City of Redding power plant. The first item. Authorize $100,000 increase in in the bid schedule 5348. With BHP requiring to cover the additional work necessary to bring the power plant in compliance with local fire code. Mister Tippin, if you could expand on that. It appears that we were out of compliance and I'd like to know why. >> Yeah, so just the bottom line on the story is that the power plant staff initiated a project to upgrade some of the fire systems within the power plant. The contractor they hired submitted plans to the city. The city reviewed those plans and then when the work was completed, the assistant fire marshal did an inspection of the power plant and noticed that some other elements needed to be brought up to current codes. Pull alarms, fire strobe lights, monitoring, pressure monitoring systems, etcetera. And so what the power plant decided to do is it's best to use the current contractor we have and do a change order to get the plant fully up to code. These are some newer codes. We've owned the power plant since about 1991. And so just like everywhere else, fire department has some limited resources to do all the fire inspections. And so oftentimes like power plant doesn't get as updated, you know, in annual inspections and that sort of thing. So this is just an opportunity for us to bring this fire, the power plant, into fire code compliance. And so I think it's a smart move on their part to do it through change order instead of starting a whole new project. >> I agree. So is it safe to assume that there will be future code changes? I think that's quite common? >> Codes are updated on a periodic basis, and we have our local fire codes. And coincidentally, right now, the development services and fire department are working on our local code editions and looking at them to make sure that what we are requiring at a local fire code editions matches what our requirements should be. >> And we'll be up to speed with future code changes. >> Absolutely. >> Thank you. Thank you very much, council member Johnson. >> So my understanding on this item, Councilmember Mazzeno. Just doing, I dug into this one as well, just with staff to kind of understand it. And, you know, any remodel that we do in the city, commercial, residential, if you do one, could trigger bringing certain things up to code. So it's pretty normal those codes change. You don't have those triggers until you do another remodel. So 20 years from now, we might upgrade that same power plant and we would have to upgrade those systems. So that makes sense. The part that I was curious about, and I know there was some discussion about the fire codes being updated, looking at our local code versus the state code, and I don't know if that's generally known that there is a state fire code, and then we have the ability to lay on top of the state fire code, additional code that is kind of pertinent to our area. And those codes get developed over a course of many years, many dIAFFerent councils, fire marshals recommendations, dIAFFerent things like that. My curiosity on this particular upgrade, do we know what portion of it was state versus maybe our. >> My understanding is these are state code elements. >> Okay. >> All of them are state code. >> We have the fire chief shaking his head yes. Okay, that's great. >> I smell an item twelve coming from you soon on these things. >> Okay, no need. We're working on it. >> Okay. All right, well, that. Does anybody else want to poll or do anything on these items? Okay, so do I have a first and a motion to pass the consent calendar? >> Second. >> All right, we have a first and a second. All those in favor? Aye. Any opposed? Okay, moving forward, item 5.1. Now that we have taken one of our planning commissioners, and he is now a city council member, it leaves a position open for a planning commissioner. And so I might be holding the record on how many people I have tried to appoint as planning commissioners. I feel like we got a good one this time. So what does that say about Josh? We are, I mean, another good one this time. Another good. Obviously. Great. So I am asking for the approval of Russ Wenham to the planning commission. Do we have any public comment? >> So make sure. I would like to voice my support of Mister Russ Wenham. I've known Russ for quite some time. He has worked for consulting businesses that do quite a bit of work with the city. So I've had experience with him and just really like how he thinks. Just think he's really ethical, logical and knows this area. I think he'll be a great addition to the planning conditions. So I would love to make a motion to approve Mister Russ Wantham to the planning commission. >> I don't know him, but I like his resume, so I'm going to support him. >> Awesome. >> I obviously wanted to give him a call, talk to him. I ran into him throughout the years on various projects, but not a lot of conversation with him. But since he was going to replace me, I thought, let's have a conversation. So it was cool. But before I talked to him, I talked to a few of his competitors. He's in the civil engineering world and I wanted to just get the general sense on what they felt about him and nothing but good things about the way that he approaches projects, problem solving. And then when I got to talk to him, I go, man, it's a good thing these guys got me out of there. This is an upgrade. I really think it's going to be a huge addition to have the 40 years of experience in so many dIAFFerent levels and layers of it. And he's a collaborator. He's easy to work with, but he's okay being direct when he disagrees with something, but he does it tactfully. I think it's going to be a great addition. So I'll be supporting him. >> Thanks. Anybody else? >> I've never met him, but I talked to Mister Tippin about him and we had a good discussion. I'm in favor. >> Awesome. All right then. Do we have a motion? >> I would be happy to make a motion to appoint Mister Russ one. >> We have a first and a second. All those in favor? Aye. Any opposed? No. Awesome. All right, Russ, good luck. All right, we are going to take nine, item 9.5 e off. Director Zettel is not able to be here. He had a, I believe he had an emergency and so we'll leave it at that. But we are going to move that item to another day and we are going to go to nine six b, community service. And we're going to get an oral update regarding the status of the city of Redding sports complex. Director? Thank you. >> Good evening. So we're gonna do a quick little update about our Redding sports park, formerly known as big league dreams. So immediately after our council meeting last week, Monday the 29th, staff began reaching out to a lot of groups that showed up. We've had a lot of great conversations since then. We've actually met with eight dIAFFerent organizations, a mix of leagues, teams, tournament directors, all dIAFFerent kinds of uses. And so we've got a really good background on what the facility, how it's been run, what the teams use it for, what they pay, how that works, you know, scheduling operations, their specific needs, and we've kind of got a really good understanding of the workload of what that takes. So essentially, for things like tournaments or in house leagues, there's just dIAFFerent amounts of staffing. So we've been able to kind of get those details from not only the groups that are using the facility, but the staff on site as well. So we actually have a full list of who worked there and what they did, so we can really understand the operations out there. We've also spent a lot of time at the facility. So prior to this, we'd actually been spending time out there trying to learn everything, you know, working with those groups and doing a lot of tours and inspections and things like that, but it actually gave us a good understanding of how everything works. So now that we actually have, because we've never run the facility, we may have owned it forever, but we've never run it. So we need to really understand those systems and processes and changes that take place between soccer and hockey and whatever is going on in the building. So we've got a pretty firm understanding of that and we've met with the staff out there and we just understand general layout and systems and things like that. So we've got a pretty good insight on what a short term operation would look like and which that's, since that what we were directed to do, we're confident that there's something there. So it's given us a couple avenues to explore. So we're really able to conceptualize that right now. So since we started looking at the facilities, we're also looking at ways to make it better and more efficient in the future because we're still going to have to do that long term plan. So we're looking. We did a start of an energy audit with Reu. We've looked at ways to change up programming. We've actually asked every one of the eight groups, what are your ideas? So we're starting to do some of that market research, because no matter how that's run in the future, we're going to need to know this stuff. So it's a good chance just to check in with them and see what they think would make us the most successful, both in terms of economics and the community and what people really want out there. And since these groups travel, a lot of. We actually asked for some of these other facilities that are doing it right. So of the meetings that we've scheduled, we've kind of run through all those groups. I think they've given us really good feedback. The passion is clear with them, and they all have really good ideas. And not a single one said, you're on your own. You're going to have to figure this out. They were like, how can we help? So it was really nice to see that and the support that they have for that facility. So I think we have, like, a really good road ahead of us, especially with their support. We've actually had staff from Shasta Regional Soccer association at every meeting because they've indicated their willingness to help. So there could be a few models with their involvement. So we're still exploring that, but it was a good, another indication of support from the community and a group that's doing something similar. So, looking ahead, we're actually going to be coming back August 20 with at least another update. But we hope to have some solid options, some actionable options by then when it comes to short term operations out there. So we'll have a couple of ideas. We still have a lot of details to work out, but we'll be doing that in the coming weeks. And that's my update. >> Great. Any questions? >> This is a $64,000 question, four to six weeks before we open the doors. >> I really couldn't speculate right now until we get some direction from council, but we should have options definitely before then. >> That would be great. >> Anybody else? >> Let me phrase it another way. I think we're all just eager, right? So that's why the question, I think it's appropriate, but if on the 20th, you're gonna bring a couple of options for us to take action on or to evaluate if we make a decision going forward, do you think that those options are going to kind of be equally about the same amount of time to get the park open, or will they vary in that outcome? >> Well, certainly contracts are going to take a little longer than an in house route, but it depends on our comfort level with the decisions that we're going to make at that point. So it really would just be speculating. >> I would just add the other element that I was Debbie Downer last time is that some of that's going to be dependent on not only your willingness to spend money, but also your risk tolerance relative to insurance. Some insurance will take a while to get in place. Other insurance that we currently have, for instance, we could operate with known risk. And so the council is going to be every bit as much part of that solution in terms of when as any operation plans that the staff brings forward. >> Just to clarify, I believe Mister Tippen said known risk, not no risk. >> Any other questions, guys? Are we looking at things that can open sooner? Like the whole thing is one thing, but if the, let's just say field house for those types of activities would be easier to open than maybe a tournament. Are we looking at these things also separately, these eight dIAFFerent elements, and saying this one might be able to open sooner than this one, you know, is that also a possibility? >> Yes, there's definitely levels to it. The things that we're looking at now are what's the lowest hanging fruit that would satisfy the most people in the community, and things like practices, field house activities, tournaments. All have third parties involved that. So you're essentially offloading a lot of programming. So those seem to be the most likely routes to go down. But we're still evaluating what that means in terms of staff and cost and how we would accomplish that. >> And also just defining what open means. >> Correct. >> Open may not mean the recreational softball programs. Opening may only be availability for practice, those types of things. So, yeah, all of that is on the table and being analyzed. >> Okay. I'm just. It's not all or nothing. We're gonna be okay. That's what I wanted to know. All right, well, thank you for that update. >> Thank you. >> Appreciate it. Okay. >> Can I just say one last thing? I just want to give kudos to our staff after the last meeting, the speed at which I saw the staff move. And I'm new to this, but it felt like fastest government I've ever experienced being on the other side of the table for most of my life. So I just really appreciated the way the staff responded to everyone's voice and there was a. It became high priority. So thank you so much. >> Okay. Item 9.15 a. Consider a resolution approving the successor memorandum of understanding with the local union 1934 of International Assault association of Firefighters. >> So, good evening, my name is Kerry Kipler, and I am the personnel director, and I'm here to discuss recommendation, which would involve a successor MoU with IAFF. So to get started, I'll give you some background information on the negotiations with IAFF. We'll also talk about term and wage information that would be contingent with the successor MoU. We'll talk about some benefit modifications, the move to a new hazardous material unit model, as well as some other modifications that would be in place with this contract. And then at the very end, we'll get to the recommendation. All right, so we began negotiating with IAFF in February of 2024. In June, we reached a tentative agreement, and then in July, IAFF ratified the tentative agreement. Our current step of where we are right now is council consideration and hopefully approval of the successor MoU in the side letter agreements. And then just for those that aren't fluent in some of the verbiage that I'm using, IAFF stands for the International association of Firefighters, and so they represent our local firefighters at the city. So the proposed successor MoU would be for a three year contract term. It would begin in January of 25 and extend through December of 27. There are three wage increases associated with this contract, 5% in year one, 1% in year two, and 4% in year three. And as we get further into the presentation, we'll talk about why there's a one and a four. In addition to the wage increases, there would be some new incentive fees tied to the successor MoU. The first one would be an educational incentive, which would be effective in November of 2027. And that would allow employees to receive two and a half percent for having a, an associate of arts or science degree or having 60 semester units. The reason that it's a future effective date is we've actually tied it to changes with the firefighter classification, which would recognize non California certifying agencies, which would hopefully help us bring in a wider pool of eligible candidates. So we're excited about being able to bring in more firefighters and recognize certifications outside of California. In addition, it would include a reimbursable strike team and overhead deployment pay, so employees that are assigned to a strike team or an overhead deployment so the ink fires outside of our region. If it's reimbursable, we would provide them a 10% pay dIAFFerential, and it would just be for those deployments where we can seek reimbursement. The contract does include some benefit modifications. The first one is that starting in 2025, unit employees will increase their employee contribution to healthcare. So it's currently 15% and it'll increase to 20%. So they'll be taking on a bigger share of the contribution towards their healthcare, and then additionally they'll take on a cost sharing of the employer share of retirement cost. So in within CalPERs retirement, there are dIAFFerent tiers. And these changes for tier one and tier two would result in employees in the unit paying approximately half of their retirement costs. As a part of this agreement, we would begin the transition to a new hazardous materials unit model. So we would be looking towards moving to a Cal OES model. As a result, we would increase our hazardous materials response team from 25 employees to 33 employees. And that's because once we transition to Cal OES model, we would be responsible to respond to events outside of city limits. So we would need more staff to be able to do that. In addition, employees assigned to the would be eligible to receive a 2.5% incentive pay for possessing a special hazardous materials specialist certification. And the reason that the certification is important is it's a higher level tier. So right now, the Redding fire department is set at a level which is for technicians. Under this new model, we would be required to basically up our game and rise to the specialist level certification, and so that two and a half percent would just recognize the extra training that goes into keeping that higher level certification. The benefits of going to a Cal OES model is that we would be eligible for reimbursement on our training class directly from Cal OEs. We would have that higher level certification team. So right now, with certain events, if they happen within city limits, we have to wait for a response team. We would be able to respond with our own staff and not wait for our folks to get to us. We would be eligible to reimbursement if we are deployed regionally, which is helpful. And then also the fire department would retain local control of the team and the resources, with CalEOShelping as a funding partner. So as part of this transition to the Cal OES model, we recommend implementing these provisions via a side letter at a future council meeting once the fire department brings that Cal OES agreement for city council approval. And we would bring, we would implement via side letters with both the IAFF, which is our line staff, firefighters, as well as the Redding fire management unit as well. There are some other modifications associated with this contract, one of which is we would begin implementing a body worn camera pilot program for our fire prevention officers. This would be limited to times when they're performing law enforcement duties. So typically this would be like arson investigations. We also would add provisions to allow for the extension of probationary periods, for periods of light duty assignments, or when staff are on absences of ten or more days. The reason that this is important is when staff are on their probationary period, there are certain requirements. We want to make sure that they're ready to become a permanent firefighter. And if staff are on light duty or they're not at work, for various reasons, it limits our ability to make that determination. So that's a provision that we're excited about. We also revised the fire prevention officer class spec, and that would reflect the post peace office certification and additional certs within one year of employment. And this is tied to the fact that our fire prevention officers do perform law enforcement duties when they're performing those arson investigations. And this contract would also add a tuition reimbursement program which aligns with the programs available to the other units within the city. And one thing I just wanted to point out is the one in the 4% in year two, the reason that we wound up on a four in the last year instead of a more even spread is because of those extra Cal, the extra costs, cost sharing of the retirement provisions that those employees are taking on in that year of the agreement. And so that was at IFS request to help kind of soften that blow for them. So our recommendation is to adopt a resolution approving the successor MoU with IAFF for that three year term beginning in January of 2025 and approving amendments to the salary schedule, approving side letter agreements with IAFF immediately regarding uniform pants and tuition reimbursement program, and then approving side letter agreements with IAFF and the fire management unit regarding the transition of a CalEOS unit model, which would include the 10% incentive for the reimbursement strike team and overhead deployment pay, as well as that 2.5%. And then lastly, I just want to thank everyone who participated in this process. We worked closely with the IAFF negotiation team. We also worked closely with Redding fire management unit to get buy off for this transition of a Cal Oas Hazmat model. And we also worked closely with Gage Dungy, who was our chief labor negotiator during this process. Other any questions? >> Thanks, Kerry. We really appreciate it. A lot of hard work and it shows. So does anybody. Okay, Vice Mayor Winter? >> I don't have any questions. >> I just like to make a motion to approve staff recommendations for the MoU with IAF. >> I'll second the motion. But one thing that you didn't cover is the training that they have to take, the special training they have to take. They have to continually recertify. >> Yes. >> So that's why this two and a half percent is worth it. >> Absolutely. Initially, when we transition to that new model. And then they'll have to maintain that as well. >> All right, we have a first and a second. >> A seconded. >> All those in favor? Aye. Any opposed? None. Well done, guys. Okay, we will move to item eleven. Council travel reports. Has anybody gone to any conferences or meetings that were reimbursed at the city's expense? That was in the consent calendar. Did you want to vote dIAFFerently? Okay. No? >> I traveled, madam Mayor. I traveled to Elk Grove with one of our police captains for a calcidious function where he made a presentation on staffing and recruitment. And he did an outstanding job in the city. It was a quite well attended meeting, and he got a lot of questions and people are interested in the way we're doing it here and ready. So it was a great event. >> Great job. Thank you. Okay, item twelve. Does anybody have any suggestions for potential topics or future city council meetings? No. You sure? Okay, going once, going twice. All right, well, with that, we will adjourn. Thank you so much. [ MEETING ADJOURNED ] [ GAVEL ]

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
AgendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Agenda packetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
MinutesNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Recording and media

Coverage and corrections

Records considered

  • Aug 7, 2024 5:15 PM - Redding City Council - Special Meeting — Closed Captions
  • Aug 7, 2024 5:15 PM - Redding City Council - Special Meeting — Action Agenda

Not claimed by this page

  • Verified meeting decisions with item-specific public-source evidence
  • Item-level plain-language summaries are not available; this page does not infer individual agenda items.
  • Item-linked, attributed deliberation
  • A source-grounded next meeting date
  • A plain-English overview is not available.
  • Official outcomes have not been published.
  • A transcript is not available.
  • Speakers have not been reliably matched to public profiles.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.
  • An individual roll-call roster is not available.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: 405034d4d37165100b43a0a803187ff3. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record