POLISCOPE

The public record

PLANTATION (BROWARD COUNTY) · LOCALDecisions publishedPartial coverage

Affordable Housing Advisory Committee

Tuesday, January 25, 2022 · Government meeting record

The 30-second read

Recorded outcome

The newly formed Plantation Affordable Housing Advisory Committee held its first meeting to appoint leadership, set a recurring meeting schedule, and receive training on Florida's Sunshine Law. The board consists of seven members, including the Mayor and various professionals in real estate, law, and development.

Why it matters

This committee will advise the City of Plantation on affordable housing policies, which directly impacts future residential development projects and housing availability in the city.

What happens next

No later meeting or follow-up date is stated in the reviewed record.

An official outcome record - an action agenda or minutes - is published for this meeting.

Record text

No recording or transcript is held for this meeting.

AFFORDABLE HOUSING ADVISORY COMMITTEE AFFORDABLE HOUSING ADVISORY COMMITTEE CITY HALL, COUNCIL CHAMBERS 400 NW 73RD AVE PLANTATION, FLORIDA 33317 TUESDAY, JANUARY 25, 2022 Present: Katie Edwards-Walpole, Jon Auerbach, Lynn Stoner, David Weiss, Edwin Cordova, Gretchen Rovira, Rick Seraphine Mr. Weiss attended via Zoom CALL TO ORDER/ROLL CALL -- Administration Carole Morris called meeting to order at 3:33pm Carole Morris: My name is Carole Morris and I am the Assistant City Administrator and I am going to be serving as your board liaison. Today’s meeting is an organization meeting, we are going to take care of the housekeeping items. The first item on the agenda is the appointment of a chair and vice chair. The best way to do this is by starting an introduction. Introduce yourself, tell us a little about yourself and your area of expertise. Members went about the room to introduce themselves. Gretchen Rovira: I am a Plantation resident for the past 5 years. I work with the Drug Enforcement Administration as an Analyst Specialist and currently working on the opioid and fentanyl crisis that we have in the community. Rick Seraphine: I have been a Plantation resident for 20 years. I am a Building General Contractor, I have built over 30 homes and I think I can be a good asset. Edwin Cordova: I am the Housing Supervising attorney with Legal Aid of Broward County. I have been a resident since 2013. I am enjoying everything this city has given me and my family. Katie Edwards-Walpole: I lived in Plantation for 30 years, I had the privilege of serving on the Planning and Zoning Board several years ago and was elected to the State House. I was able to represent my hometown Plantation, Davie, and Sunrise in the Florida House. It was

a very eye-opening experience working and getting to know the different programs on the state level. And the things our election officials have in terms of resources and what they are able to draw down on to help these programs. Also worked with the builders and contractors in terms of incentives and how they get creative with the affordable housing options. I am here as the vocal resident appointee to the advisory board and it will be very nice to work with you all. Mayor Stoner: She is being modest; she is also an accomplished attorney for a well-established law firm named Becker & Poliakoff. Jon Auerbach: I have been a Plantation resident since 2009. I work for Stiles Corporation and my role there is a Developer. I have been active in the city for about 18 years, developing different properties. I am managing/developing the property on Peters Road. We are building 315 apartment units and we also own some retails in the city. I am happy to be here and welcomed aboard. Mayor Lynn Stoner: I am here as the elected official on the board. I have been a Plantation resident for 52 years and graduated from Plantation High. I am a general contractor, title insurance person, real estate broker all in one. My present fulltime job as the mayor of this city, which I enjoy. I am so excited to have this committee. David Weiss: I am a real estate development and an attorney as well. I’ve been in Plantation since 1988, I have been involved in developing over 3000 homes in Plantation and commercial development throughout the State of Florida and beyond. NEW BUSINESS 1. Appointment of Chair/Vice Chair Carole Morris: We have a very distinguished board and we need to come to a conclusion on a chair and vice chair for our meeting. Would you like to do a nomination or would someone like to volunteer? Mayor Stoner: I will nominate Jon for Chair and Katie for Vice Chair. Jon Auerbach: I would rather be vice chair Mayor Stoner: Do you want to be chair, Katie? Katie Edwards-Walpole: I am okay with being the Chair. Mayor Stoner: My motion is amended. Carole Morris: Amended to show Katie as chair and Jon as vice chair. Do we have a second?

Jon Auerbach: Second Moved by Lynn Stoner; seconded by Jon Auerbach to Approve Katie Edwards-Walpole as Chair and Jon Auerbach Vice Chair.. Motion Passed: 7- 0 Voting For: Katie Edwards-Walpole, Jon Auerbach, Lynn Stoner, David Weiss, Edwin Cordova, Gretchen Rovira, Rick Seraphine Voting Against: None 2. Determination of Board Meeting Dates and Times Carole Morris: The clerk’s office was suggesting the first Thursday. If that works for everyone what time of day works or you can suggest something better. We need to hear from the board, what works for all of you. Jon Auerbach: Is that monthly? Carole Morris: Yes, we may at some point not meet as frequently, but for the immediate future it would be monthly. Katie Edwards-Walpole: Can you give us an indication of the times in your experience with other boards? Is a certain time helpful, in terms of public attendance and participation? We want to make sure more people are able to attend and participate if they choose. Assistant City Attorney Morgan: "For the record my name is Quentin Morgan." I don’t necessarily think the time matters particularly with the availability of zoom and the opportunity to participate fully in the meeting. I can tell you with my experience of another Affordable Housing Advisory Committee that met in the evening, there is not much more participation than what we are experiencing right now. I think is depends on what subject matters and there is plenty of public notice provided. I think it is more important for you all to have a quorum which should drive the discussion. Katie Edwards-Walpole: Any feedback from the members for a preference of the time of day? We can designate one day per month for the clerk to keep that open for a standing meeting day. Member speaking without mic: Inaudible Katie Edwards-Walpole: Members for recording purposes, can you remember to turn on your microphone that way the clerk will be able to record it and those that are listening online will able to hear you. Jon Auerbach: Thursday afternoon is okay for me

Edwin Cordova: I would rather come at 4:30 or 5pm, if possible. Gretchen Rovira: I agree. Do you have to come during working hours or after hours? Katie Edwards-Walpole: That is at the pleasure of the board, we can reach consensus on that and work with the clerk’s office and she will handle the notices and scheduling. Rick Seraphine: Yes, 4:30pm or 5pm Katie Edwards-Walpole: Okay. Madam Clerk, I think you were looking at the first Thursday? You do want to figure the first Thursday at 4:30pm and a 2-hour time slot is that sufficient? Kia Reid: Yes Katie Edwards-Walpole: By consensus of the board first Thursday of each month 4:30 to 6:30pm. 3. Presentation by the City Attorney: Sunshine Law Carole Morris: Quentin will be with us from time to time at these meetings. We want to make sure, that everybody gets off on the right foot with an appropriate presentation about the Sunshine Law, public records and ethics issues. Quentin will present this presentation. Asst City Atty: "For the record my name is Quentin Morgan." I am the assistant city attorney for the city. I’ve been working with the city for over 20 years, and assisted with a lot of the ordinances. Has anyone had previous experience with the Sunshine Law, public record by the show of hands? See attached presentation. Katie Edwards-Walpole: As private individuals from time to time, may have members of the public request for our contact information from the clerk’s office because they have an item, they want to discuss/recommend. Is it advisable when we receive that to forward it to the clerk’s office? So, they would have a copy of that email communication or record, to archive and made available for compliance with that part of the statue? Asst City Atty: Absolutely, any email or document that you receive that is not generated by the city staff should be immediately provided to the city clerk and to Ms. Morris who is the liaison for the board. So that the city is aware and if there are any issues that relates to that particular document or email. Then we will address it immediately at that time, so you are not responsible for that document. The city clerk is the records custodian for the city and she is responsible for replying to all public record request. Does that answer your question? Katie Edwards-Walpole: Thank you Quentin, it does. As a follow-up to that, any information that we may share on social media, for example. If you share on Instagram or twitter, “Hey

I just got out of this Affordable Housing meeting and we discuss XYZ. We are getting feedback, private message or responses, would that also fall over a public record? How do you suggest we capture that and transmit to the clerk? Asst City Atty: In the last five year or so, social media archiving, record keeping from different posts you may have even though it maybe innocuous and not an issue it is still a public record. If it is made in connection with the official business of this board it will potentially be consider a public record. You need to be mindful of the things you post on social media. Katie Edwards-Walpole: Does any members are any question for the city attorney? Rick Seraphine: Regarding the conflict of interest, if I am going to be doing business with the City of Pompano. I am actively building houses for Affordable Housing for the City of Pompano. Would that be a conflict of interest? Asst City Atty: That has nothing to do with the City of Plantation. That's probably the reason why you are sitting here today because you have that experience. The city wanted to use your experience, to foster the policy that the city is going to at some point adopt. That is a great question, before there is any issues ask us any questions if you have a doubts. Katie Edwards-Walpole: The procedure to asking questions, do you recommend that be run it through the clerk office, to you directly or to the board liaison? Asst City Atty: I would recommend you route questions to the board liaison. Sunshine Public Records Ethics - 2022 Plantation Advisory Boards (00490708xC4B6A).pdf 4. Presentation by Administration on Board Duties and Expectations Carole Morris: I want to speak on 2 housekeeping details. In front of you today you have a board notebook. It is ours to take and use as a reference source or house materials. In it you have information with Quentin presentation and the Administration Board Duties and Expectation presentation. There are emails and contact information for each of you as well as for myself, city attorney and the city clerk. You have a copy of the ordinance that established this board. The ALICE report is in the board notebook, if you are not former with it you may want to spend some time and review before the next meeting. See attached presentation. Carole Morris: The next first Thursday of the month will be next week which maybe too soon, so I suggest we meet in March instead. Katie Edwards-Walpole: Those of us that are here, have made a time commitment and recognize the importance of this issue. My preference would be to take advantage of having the meeting in February. We can better understand the city programs and ordinances, have an understanding of what is currently in place, and what we are going to be working with. Having that baseline knowledge is important and a good place to begin. I suggest, we look

at demystifying and defining certain key terms that are apart of the affordable housing conversations. Terms like affordable housing, workforce housing, market unit, rent control, income restricted, density bonuses, and section 8. It is important, we have a clear base understanding of those definitions. How they relate to the city code and comp plans. This will help us to get our minds on the resources, programs and calling things appropriately, to develop certain strategies that should be first on the agenda. With the use of Planning & Zoning staff and whomever else that needs to be involved that should involve. Carole Morris: We can accomplish that but we need to make sure everyone is available and that we will have a quorum. Katie Edwards-Walpole: I will also suggest that the current Florida Rep for this area, Michael Gottlieb who has made affordable housing a priority, we should send a zoom invitation to him if he is available. To give us an update on the what going on in Tallahassee so we are aware of any potential policy changes. To our board coordinator, if you don’t mind reaching out to his office to extend an invite if he is available. If he is not available in February then he is welcome to come in March. Carole Morris: Absolutely. Katie Edwards-Walpole: I think that part is a good lengthy agenda for next meeting. Carole Morris: Okay, I will make that happen. Mayor Stoner: Members are required to attend biannual regional workshops administered under the Affordable Housing Catalyst Program. I need you to tell me what those are and where I can go. Carole Morris: Yes, so that everyone is clear this we are looking at Section 2-80(8) (G) states the city governing body member servicing on the Committee or a designee, must attend biannual regional workshops convened and administered under the Affordable Housing Catalyst Program. The mayor or one of you (designee) will need to attend. Edwin Cordova: We are here in order to accomplish something for the city. And the city has other committees/boards. How are we going to manage the same definitions and terms that was mention as a necessity for us? There are other boards that understand those definitions and have been working on the board for many years. We are just starting. Inaudible We need to base our efforts on their experience. Explain the definition, what is affordable housing? All of these concepts, we need to have the same basic understanding otherwise it’s just confusion. Asst. City Atty: That is a great question. The people that are going to be presenting the evidence and information to you are the same people that were before the other boards. You will be given the same information as far as the meaning behind certain terms. There has been a lot of activity in Tallahassee which a new statue was adopted years ago. It is a moving

process and the staff is keeping on top of that. The same people that are going to present before the CRA are the same people that will be presenting here. For clarification the chair requested to have a basic understanding for everyone so that the foundation is laid. That will be provided to them so they will have the information for you. Katie Edwards-Walpole: To clarify further within each jurisdiction as we go through Plantation codes, we are going to formulate a policy or recommendations. It is important to find out how the city have defined it? If there is no definition, we can look at why not? If there are federal/state grants, that we are going to recommend to the city and retain applications perhaps we need to include that definition to make sure the city has eligibility. There may be a definition process and procedure to comport with what comes from the state. Hopefully, identifying those things and learning what the other boards are thinking about when an applicate comes before Planning & Zoning. The applicate may have a certain amount of affordable housing units, what does that mean and how are they deciding the income criteria? Is it based on the city’s code? Is that based on certain federal and state regulations? When we are conversing, we are using the language that is in the city’s code. Asst. City Atty: I totally agree with that, you all are experts in your fields. The information that you have when you address the staff about why things are not there or why is it listed this way. I think you should change it, that would be a recommendation that you can make. The city council will take that into consideration given the appointed of you all for your expertise and your fields listed by the statue and the ordinance. The question was well taken. These meeting are happening throughout the state and county. It is important the CRA, City Council, Planning and Zoning board are all on the same page so that the city can compete and the Mayor’s and City Council policies can be carried out in a way that Affordable Housing will be affordable in the city to a degree that is acceptable. Katie Edwards-Walpole: Thank you, Mr. Morgan. February is a short month I suggest we start to look at the agenda for March meeting. Identify the various coalitions or stalk holder groups to help understand the needs, assessments or what is in the pipeline for units that maybe deem in the city. Build on the relationship with the county further partnerships and more grants Identify individuals who are seasoned that can help us do a needs assessment demographic profile Invite County Commissioner Nan Rich to come to March meeting to educate the board on what the county is doing. Jon Auerbach: Is there an opportunity to assess the existing housing spots? Carole Morris: We can add that to the agenda.

Affordable Housing Committee - pptx.pdf ALICE in Florida A Financial Hardship Study.pdf PUBLIC COMMENTS None ADJOURNMENT Meeting adjourned at 4:43pm

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
AgendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Agenda packetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Action agendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Transcript or captionsNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Coverage and corrections

Records considered

  • Affordable Housing Advisory Committee — Minutes

Not claimed by this page

  • Verified meeting decisions with item-specific public-source evidence
  • Item-level plain-language summaries are not available; this page does not infer individual agenda items.
  • Item-linked, attributed deliberation
  • A source-grounded next meeting date
  • Official outcomes have not been published.
  • A transcript is not available.
  • No audio or video recording is linked.
  • Speakers have not been reliably matched to public profiles.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.
  • An individual roll-call roster is not available.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: 3f109f176749aa102d70044d86e3eed3. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record