POLISCOPE

The public record

SARASOTA (SARASOTA COUNTY) · LOCALDecisions and attributed speech publishedPartial coverage

Firefighters' Pension Plan Board of Trustees Regular Meeting

Wednesday, September 24, 2025 · Government meeting record

The 30-second read

Recorded outcome

Firefighters' Pension Plan Board of Trustees Regular Meeting

Why it matters

This page inventories the meeting agenda; the available analyses do not establish a headline decision.

What happens next

No later meeting or follow-up date is stated in the reviewed record.

An official outcome record and a transcript or captions are published for this meeting.

Captured actions

11

Recorded outcomes

0

Source artifacts

3

Transcript and record text

Closed captionsWhat was said at the meeting, transcribed Sep 20, 2026. Speech is not a decision.
  • No speaker turns were supplied with this transcript.
  • This transcript has no source timestamps.
  • No speaker identities were supplied with this transcript.

This source published text without speaker turns, so speakers and timestamps are not shown.

I all stunned that the view. >> I know we're actually going to do thing all we can I can spare. Thank like the kind that normally keepers. I like the kind that are normally like cross you know, keep keep ? ? ? ? ? >> I'm like I hope that works out for you. She's with. Where is. I ? She or take care ? both her mom and he went to Alzheimer's and her mom was told to take care of her. Her she was out for like 4 years. ? ? ? ? Just up for us this year. ? All the time. ? And this got to find job. And you never work a day in your life. you. Call it okay. ? ? Q A me. >> The order. Good morning. Everyone will call me and order for the firefighters. Pension Plan Board of trustees regular meeting for today. September 24th. First on the agenda is the Pledge of Allegiance. Can we turn that over to you? Treasure. Great. Yes. Police need. >> fine. ? >> Thank you very much. And then the pledge of civility. Would you like to do that today, Chuck, I would love to. We may disagree, but we will be respectful to one another. We will direct all comments to issues. We will not engage in personal attacks. Thank you for shot. Next. As roll call will turn it over not to be left out. That. >> Thank Chair Hartley President Vice Chair Joseph President, Secretary Treasurer Trustee, Snow present this team assurance present. >> Public input, no cards for today. >> I didn't think I >> I recognize 3 of 4. So I wanted to make Alright, approval of the minutes will turn to 6 0.1 in the agenda as the minutes for firefighter pension plan. Our meeting from July 23rd. I did review them last night. The only thing I wanted to ask was on. Page 4.95. I might as owned out, but in the if you count, the motion passed unanimously go down one to 3 under chair Hartley. Mister Owens made a statement that. Large cap growth managers more focused on race, mad, but then returned. However, evaluating portfolio has less risk. You remember him saying that Peters and in was that on the recording? We would have >> Go back and shake that. Just to verify many view, one is to weaken, pull off a proven the minutes and bring them back if you want. But >> I'm only asking me because I'm going to get to it later in the investment. And the investment. We're moving. 20% of growth down to 10. Because the corps, which was one of the things that brought up was corps was more value. The manager we packed. I just want to be able to factually say whether that reduced the risk in our portfolio. When I'm talking to. Retirees. >> We have to go. Listen. Yeah. Okay. end. >> I'm willing to approve it as is I just want to make. I want to verify, but I can I'll just put it on. The agenda are not on the agenda. I'll just put my notes to ask. Greystone. They come in next month. Okay. All right. I just wondered if anybody heard him say that I just know. >> like, go back and listen. >> That's the only thing I had to bring up in the notes that. I wanted to ask about anybody, see anything or any questions. Chair will entertain a motion that for the adoption of the minutes from July 23rd 2025 are a pension meeting. I make a motion to adopt the Motion on the tables been moved and second for the adoption of the minutes for July 23rd, there's no other discussion. Do a roll call for approval? >> Chair Hartley? Yes, vice chair Joseph. Yeah. Secretary Treasurer, Greg's trustee. Snow. Yes. Esteem a >> Very good. move on then to our first investment performance review under a number 7 0st step is Lazard. We'll turn it over to Michael Powers and Frank's because Idol. Good morning. Glad to hear you had a good flight without delay. normally we. After we ask you to introduce yourself to the mikes, remind everybody that we usually give you 15 minutes and then we might have some questions at the end. thanks for coming morning. >> We tried to stay in our usual hotel, the Hyatt, but apparently they were no longer taking reservations. You're going to have to we are in the West, which is very close to here. we can absolutely do the 15 minute version. We have all kinds of versions. >> And whatever questions you have, please, you know, interrupt. try and stick to the high Frank spells I've been at as of this month. 28 years or since I have brown hair. my powers makes me look like a rookie. He's on the portfolio side of things and has been here since the first trade was made of That's a 35. Like 35 years. I started in >> all right. So that is another way of saying we've seen a lot of different markets. This one's been particularly unusual over the last several years starting with COVID but I the best news I have is that your international portfolio is finally outperforming by a large margin. The U.S. and that's been a long time coming. We've been talking about how undervalued international stocks are relative the U.S. and that has just continued for well over a decade. it's been kind of frustrating as a that has 2 thirds of its assets and global and international portfolios. And one of the reasons for that was the U.S. dollar extremely strong, which has a U.S. investor her to you in terms of your returns. That has been the opposite this this international stocks have solid earnings and they've done extremely well. So your portfolio is up. Just this is through a 2nd quarter. But the up-to-date numbers close to 20% year to date. And that's, you know, we're only in September the 2nd quarter itself was incredibly strong And if you had said to me, we're going to be up 10 or 11%. You know, in a quarter like that. That is unsustainable for a whole year. But we seem to be, you know, kind of cruising along and it still substantially head of the U.S. then the bad news is we're the benchmark this year. and it's for a couple reasons. The primary one is it's a very high quality portfolio. And for those of you who might have been around we presented originally was that we focus on very high quality stocks very financially productive load at sustainable earnings and we try and buy them at reasonable prices. So generally speaking, this is a blue chip portfolio. That's true of both the developed portion and the emerging market portion. If you remember, we have 2 pieces to this puzzle and we allocate to the emerging markets portfolio in order to get exposure there we went through a period in the emerging markets world where low quality stocks outperform high quality stocks. Stocks, which is not the norm, but happens periodically bite huge margins. And I mean that certain periods, 2030, 40%, it was impossible to have a high quality portfolio, an outperform. It was almost the reverse like the better quality of the company bought the worse. It did relatively speaking. But that resolved itself and then for a period of time, the emerging markets piece was a drag on the overall portfolio. If you remember that was that was keeping back the developed portion of the portfolio that reversed itself and the emerging market portfolios has outperform stanch Ali, over the last 5 years. Now east, we're seeing this on the develop. Side were low. Quality is outperforming high quality by substantial margins. So it's been tough. Sledding. The good news is that that differential is narrowing and we're starting to see the portfolio look better relative to the the index. Michael, did that cause you to drift at all to the lower quality? >> You know, we're now know we've you know, as Frank said. >> We're looking for good businesses. Good management's that with that regard, highly the output of the efforts of the management, the business they make a high level of return on capital. I literally put in the first raid on the slick portfolios back in 93 and and, you know, ever since then, we've never had a time when our return on equity return on Capital Profar wasn't higher than broad market, right? So that meant that includes today. So there's, you know. we in terms of quality, we tend to have and we do today less indebtedness of our portfolio companies than the marketplace by meaningful amount. We also often grow earnings faster than Broad-market both trailing and forward looking true today. And so, you know, again about the earnings, the profitability, the how the how the business is capitalized. All those are, you know, check, check, check, quality quality quality. And we don't want to pay rias reasonable valuation you know, there there are times when lower performs. Some of that are a lot of that kind of thing can be attributed to all the massive stimulus that's been present. I think I'm sure said that in these meetings before when when you have so much stimulus, both monetary in terms of interest rates being lower, historically low, we're a fiscal stimulus where the government is running big budget deficit is to try to, you know, be be fiscally stimulative that can of, you know, help, though, the more marginal company more than it helps the bigger, stronger, you know, better capitalize business. And so. You know, that's been going on and I think today in terms of quality what we'll see this in a minute. You have a situation where the quality and of this of the opportunity said is looking quite cheap relative to the hole. universe. And, you know, that's kind of like trying to hold a beach ball underwater at some point at that pops up and you know, I we're actually beginning to see that this month. Today we're quality. However, you define it is performing. And so are we. >> So are the international tariffs affecting the higher quality? Yes, yes, they are. the think of it. That, you know, France's we owe a lot of stocks in Europe and and in Europe, the the bigger companies that tend to be higher return companies are generally the net exporters back to the dollar. Smaller companies tend to be more domestically focused and and our big exporting businesses have have had a negative sort of hit from the tariffs. I think it's both tariffs and also this year, as Frank mention, the U.S. dollar has been notably we commute. It's down 8, 9, 9.10%, year to date. And so these big multinational exporters that we own in Europe are are selling into both the tariff headwind at times and that her picture changes like from day to day week to week in terms of a lot of turf is threatened. Then there's always meetings and negotiations in the lot of the tariff is really a negotiating posture and then they wind up with something much more benign at the end. And so initially the shock of the tariffs, I think hurt are bigger. Exporting companies more than it did the smaller companies. And so that was definitely a headwind. And so, yeah, the tariff has has never hurt us so far. Not this month, but but this year, the no question. >> But I would add that longer term stronger companies are able to tolerate that better than we write you know, even, you know, a smaller company that's in the export business is just not going to have the kind of margins that can afford additional costs. So what we're trying to do it's our job to go company, the company and determine how much they're affected by the tariffs depending on what their export ing, you know where they're exporting it to see. You could have a company in Europe that exports nothing to the U.S.. But does a lot of export into the emerging market countries, for So we need to figure out the the IT individual impact. It's not it's not a broad picture. You know. So in some cases, I probably said this in the past, a strong dollar can help certain companies and hurt certain companies. You know, in the same country just because of what they do and where they sell to. >> The tariffs are part of mention the asset class international has done great this year. Just everything you want. I mean, we've been waiting, you know, 15 years for this and we're getting it in spades now. And so he started out in January one with cheap stocks, meaning quite low valuations. You particularly relative to the U.S. alternative. And you also had very expensive U.S. dollar cheap other currencies. So, yeah, chief stocks and cheap currencies both historically cheap in terms of the level of valuation and a lot happened this year. That caused, you know, our our stocks, international stocks in general, the earnings have been good and they've been good in the U.S. as well. But, you know, the in terms of what we're we're here to talk about earnings of done beautifully and and so But but all these sort of macro events have have caused people to sort of shine a light on international international is doing a lot of self-help and Europe, Japan, Korea and some other places kind just recently about, you know, the the U.S. I understand is, you know, America first, but that's causing a lot of other countries and regions to say, you know, we have to be more self reliant. We don't want to be the we can't be the younger brother junior partner to the U.S. really going to do for ourselves. Now we've got to get our defense in order. We got to spend there. We've got to get our infrastructure in order so our economy can function well. We've got to deregulate, so economy can function well. Other words look more like what we're used to here. And so as the margin that's been a positive factor for international stocks to do well and the tariff thing has helped us in terms of absolute return. But Curtis, on a relative basis, if you can follow that distinction, yeah. So. I've been concerned about international with the real thing going on. >> Yeah, the Cle. So there's a lot of a lot of moving parts. But but, you know, we're sitting here with the, you know, almost 20% his 19.4 4 was a number I got this morning. And hallelujah. You know, you know, whatever return assumption you have for the for the plan. I'm sure that's way, way above that. And it's and it's, you know, lots above the S and P which is in low teens. And there were a little so thick. So, you know, it is the international assets are really working this year, both stocks and, you know, the share prices and the currency is helping. And so still today, because our earnings have been good. Stock prices have been good, but they've been moving like the earnings. And so they haven't really gotten much more expensive, whereas in the U.S., particularly in the big cap stuff. You have a lot of multiple expansion, or valuation. Expansions and evaluation got higher and higher. And so you still have today, chief stock, cheap currencies internationally you know, sort of good fundamentals and a lot of self-help happening in a lot of places. And so I think there's a there's a good fighting chance that your international S a switch and perform so well for you now for 3 quarters of the year that can continue on into next year and and hopefully will be on. So when you think I can quote you on that. I'm good with You probably just you know, along those lines, you know, we've been talking for several years now about. But the fact that that these low valuations make no sense. >> The currency weakness, you know, as well beyond what it should be. It's like a coiled spring, right? So there's just more more potential being built up as the U.S. keep outperforming outperforming outperforming. So now what we see is a year when all the news is about how tough it is for international stocks and they're all performing. They have just they just have so much gas in the tank. You know, based on the fact that they've been so undervalued for a period of time, we have a chart here was just looking for it. But it showed, you know how you know is us earnings were drifting down. The valuations were going up, which doesn't make a whole lot of sense and how the international earnings were going up and the valuations were drifting down. So was the really the reverse of what you would expect longer term? And a lot of times these things return to their longer term pattern. But we have we have a tendency to look at them kind of small vacuum right? When you look over the broad picture. Before this us, how performance for good, solid 10 years international outperformed this is before we came in here in the first place. But a lot of the reasons international got attention as it was outperforming the U.S. consistently year after year. You know, there's a lot of opportunity out outside the U.S. but that we went through this U.S. exceptionalism, period. When you just couldn't beat it. All right. And then the stimulus made it worse, right? So it's just propped up the whole market in a way that made it impossible for for other markets to to compete fairly. So what happens is, again, a lot of potential gets built them. You know, that never gets realize. So we still have a very undervalued portfolio. International stocks are still undervalued currencies. You know, we are still cheap. All right. That which tells us there's a lot more upside and we're finding, you know, when when things are unnaturally cheap to assess the relative value manager, their bargains, right. So we see really good earnings and return on equity, you know, but but cheap valuations. So to us, you know, if you have patients and you buy it, you know, and you wait, it pays off over time. I think the quality, the quality aspect of the opportunity said we're we're position is also, I think, poised to. >> really have a you know, a good relative run. If you turn to Page 16, I think this is a good illustration. And keep the very brief. But it's that the 2 bars so far to the left, which pays you say total quality factor. Looks got it. Yeah, I forget that. Sometimes we send it to. You comes out a little different than our physical book. But what that shows us from from 2014 to 2020 it shows that quality the higher we stocks this, which is one way to define quality outperform low. we stocks return on equity by over 5% per year per year for that period per year. You'd expect something like that. Yeah. The better companies that's that's closer to the long term. You know, Norm, I'm not going to go the chart below that because I find very confusing. But then to the bar to the right. Shows that from 2020 so halfway through this year was the complete opposite. So high quality outperform underperformed, low quality by over 5% per year for for more than 4 years. So that the bar on the left us much more the longer term. Norm, you would expect quality outperform low quality, right? But what we're seeing here is we've been through this period now. You know, we see it lessening and we know that it's more likely long-term to to a premium of quality over low quality. The that the only thing I'll say about that, the next chart on Page 17 is the average outperformance per year. And this goes back since 1998. is about 1.6% per year. There was going to have those periods when it goes back and forth again, the times I might have, you know, when interest rates are really low, it helps indebted companies, right? You borrow money at really low interest rates. You look better if you're borrowing money at much higher interest rate, you're you're paying off your debt. You could much finance and lower your interest in meaningful. You typically get a credit rating upgrade. The stock goes up. Doesn't mean all of a sudden year the greatest business right up the little red dot on the left shows you basically how much of an outlier, you know, the June 2025. Number. It was the second worst period for quality since 1998. All right. That being said, we're still seeing, you know, lots of opportunity. I would turn one more page on looking at the clock as I know. Yes, that 15 minutes. I think this might be the most important page in the book about this quality thing we've been talking about. This is a. >> 25 year timeline and it's believe it or not, this That's Europe, Australia, far that's a very commonly used. The international index that there is an EV quality version. And again, the 3 components of the quality are high return on Capital High return equity low indebtedness and steadiness of earnings. Those are the 3 components that make up this quality index. If you compare that to the regular the fee for over this 25 years, what what you see there is when that wigley blue line is heading down and gets below the red dotted line. That means that low quality is outperforming. And when you see the green line, that means that that has turned and now the quality aspect of the market is starting to perform. And so look at these prior periods. When you have such a big run of quality, underperforming the regular in the next. You know, you see it 3 to 4 period in sort 5. You saw it in about 2013 17. And now just recently. >> Way down on the chart in the lower right. You see where we are today. That implies to me that you have a lot of bounce-back potential to get that green line of performing going forward again, I'm I'm going to teach community. I keep wanting to say this expression of a strict trying to hold a beach ball underwater? You know, it wants to come up. And I think that's what you have over on the far right. So I think quality, which is us. Can have a good relative run. We've this so much more we could talk about. But I think those are the big points we wanted to make. I hope we're able to communicate effectively. >> So >> if I look at Page 19, which is our performance summary, your explanation for why are gross and that is below the index's because of the lower quality run and were higher quality. You're a higher quality manager with less risk. >> Yes, the I would I think that's a fair statement. >> Any other reasons. >> There's always a few stocks here and there that that's always the So there's also the tariff thing we talked about a little bit that we tend to be positioned in the high quality European exporters that are selling a lot stuff into the dollar. And with the weakening dollar and >> you know, and those companies bearing the brunt of the tariffs for for a moment that that ended. I was part of that as well. But I think the quality thing was something that's been present for, you know, for even into 5 years now. >> I would say this and trustees correct me if I'm around because I'm going to paraphrase Greystone a little bit. Obviously they've been keeping an eye on Lazard. Yeah, I'm asked a few quarters. I remember him saying that he's looking for a higher quality run and that's where you got catch up. >> Right. That's what that's what Page 18 is all about. Those. >> Yeah, you know that we've we've we've had the negative of the green line down in our hopefully poised the lowest point on the page. >> To spring up with the performing line. >> I just want to tag on what question was that the reason you don't make the bench where you have hit the benchmark was because of high quality. And you mentioned are performing and you mentioned you're not going to change. We're not going to change that. Now. I just want think that's what you're hired. As for that's what people hire us for. >> And we're going to keep doing that. No changes in ownership decision makers. You know, the team is intact. Right team this team is We did hire a new CEO of the asset Management piece. He came from Alliance Bernstein and we we literally announced that. >> A week and a half ago, he'll start sometime in December. When are less CEO retired 3 years ago. The CFO of the overall company took over as CEO of Asset Management. They came from the investment banking side. This person you know. Investment person, so to speak, which we think is, you know, really positive. And he's, you know, got a great reputation. And frankly, we didn't know he was available. So his name is Chris whole been and will at the end of the year. And you might even see him at something because he likes to get out and talk talk to clients. He doesn't manage the portfolio, but he will manage the the investment side of the business as well as our side of the business and in terms of ownership were publicly held company on the near Thank you very We do. Thanks for the and I was. >> Obviously had some question about it and you covered those. Appreciate it. Thanks. Have a good trip home. Thank you. Appreciate what you guys do. Thank you. All right. Moving on, move on to 7.2, our presentation from Renaissance Investments. Their performance as of June, 30th will turn it over. Michael. Michael, is this your first time here? I can't Can't remember seeing it We my memory is not as good as it used to be. anyway, my Disney. welcomes. Good to have you. Thank you. So same thing 15 minutes and about. I normally don't interrupt. So I asked questions at the end? ? House, a What we're gloating right all right. I like to start by thanking the board for the opportunity to present today and the confidence you have placed in Renaissance. >> I'm Mike partner and portfolio manager for Renaissance is international strategy. I just give a real quick background on that from team in located in Cincinnati, Ohio, about 3.6 billion in assets under management. What about 400 million is in the international strategy? turn the page investment team here. There's one change to mention over the past year. That's the job earning who was the Co portfolio manager with me did retire at the end of 2024, that was a change that we had previously announced almost 2 years ago. Now I'm just ensuring a smooth transition acso. One change the investment team but no changes the investment process. We are guard manager. So we're looking for high quality companies with good earnings growth rates, but also checking to make sure they traded attractive valuations. And find these companies, we utilize a 2 step investment process. The first step is the quantitative process where we have a 13 factor model that scores and ranks all the stocks within universe from every move on to the second step, which is running a fundamental analysis on just the top 20% of stocks in those rankings. And that's ultimately where the decision is made, whether or not to buy stock. I don't know what pretty quickly. Any questions about that before going to performance. got skip ahead here a little bit to page 7. The trailing performance summary. So you can see in Michael Franken You know, very good last from an absolute perspective, 15 and a half percent for the portfolio through 6.30, very strong absolute We were lagging the acquiesce us over the past m very happy to report that we've had a very good 3rd quarter so far up about 10% on an absolute basis. And ahead of the act us by about 3%. So one you're back at the U.S.. 3 in 5, both the head of the acquisition takes us. Tenure is still This is due in large part to the market leadership that we saw from 2017 through the 3rd quarter of 2020, we saw the most expensive stocks have some significant Outperformance was a huge had one for our relative performance weekend at a very low allocation to those expensive stocks and Charlie got asked Joe, you did too about changing strategies. You know, 3 to 4 years of pretty significant underperformance for us during that time period. One of the real strengths about our process overall process is the process and it puts guardrails on the overall process doesn't allow for that style drift. So, you know, we could have said. Valuation factors just do not work anymore. And the lighting so badly. But our overall process just doesn't allow for that style drift. That's that was that 3 in 5. You're bouncing back here since that period of outperformance. There. Also taking a deeper dive into the past years. Performing Striver is here to page 8 from a sector perspective. Industrials been strong sector for us for a number of years. Now. All right. Here helping some of our airspace in the fence. Names. So names like be Rolls-Royce helping from the pickup. and I defense spending within Europe. One thing to note is that we did end up selling our position Rolls Royce purely based on a valuation. We still really like the company. But the stock is now trading at over 4 times price to sales and never been above 2 times by sales. That's a stop in a very long trading Even 20 times, never been about 15 times. So just do it after a very strong multi run for that stock, that the valuation became to stretch for us. Consumer discretionary, another positive. All right. Here are helped by some of our Chinese tech So names like They had been underperforming for for a number of years undergoing investment period. However, they're starting to see the V a the fruits of that labor now are at their core. E-commerce operations have returned to growth. Cloud computing segment is seeing a celebration of growth and then sentiment is really improved in that name to do to reports they have developed an AI chip that can compete with That stock's been a very good performer for us and has continued here in the 3rd quarter as well. The big thorn in our side for the last several years has been financials. We were hurt by both are underway to financials and then also stock selection within financials. And the big reason for this is just our lack of exposure to the European banking sector. It's been one of the strongest performing industries in the international over the past 3 years. It's returned about 190%. So about 3% relative had want our performance. One thing that was that we did into that space in the 2nd quarter bike race, which is a Greek bank. They're being helped by the improvement in the Greek back or pictures. So double digit longer expected for the bank when we bought it, price-to-book was below one time. So a nice mix of good growth and attractive valuations for us. Some performance drivers from a country perspective on Page 9, a UK was a strong country for us again goes back to the Aerospace and segment within those country. Singapore, another positive here were helped by FLEX, which Singapore-based electronic manufacturing services provider. What liked about that company was there are shifting their focus from so for a long time, they're essentially just, you know, building phone. So very commoditized product. Are they start to do more in the design and development started to shift their focus more towards AI hardware sets a higher growth, higher margin opportunity that's caused the stock to rewrite. And then on the downside, Ireland, we're here by icon, which is a contract research essentially the companies that do the clinical testing for pharmaceutical companies. You've seen a big decrease in spending from both big pharma and biotech companies. Just given all the uncertainties within the industry, things like a potential am FM policies that tariffs and then just the whole, you know, RFK be in charge of HHS. Kind of what that means for the future of drugs. That's a name that we sold out. Just given the fact we don't think that uncertainty is going stop anytime soon. So went through a lot of names are quickly. Any questions about performance. What is Marshall Islands? Marshall Islands was tanker company that we So a lot of those tanker companies are going to you that Marshall Islands there, just random countries that get a sign that don't relate. I mean, much in terms of country down South Okay. Let's get to have to be here to Page 11. The sector allocation. So Industrials are largest sector way and overweight and within Industrials, right largest theme in the portfolio, which is electrification. So names like Prison E which is in advanced cable, Schneider Electric and the talks which are left school equipment, manufacturers. All these companies should benefit from a couple of things. So the first being that there's a lot of countries that need to update their aging power You've seen very strong infrastructure spending in the U.S. which is likely to continue. Now you're seeing a pickup in infrastructure spending in Europe as well. And they're also being helped by a growth kicker from AI in the massive amounts of electricity that require so seeing a lot of good growth drivers really look at this is more of a growth market rather than just a a quick flip up and growth. So area, we're very positive on. Infotech generally a higher weight that the we've pulled back our exposure bit. So 2 of auto and industrial names. names like Renaissance and fitting in Stone, I XP but just pull back our exposure to semiconductors a bit. Still a slight overweight, about 8% for the benchmark at about 6% out. And the financials mentioned underweight there, but a very large way within the portfolio. Sheriff second largest weigh in the highest. What we've been the financials over 10 years now. But within financials tend to favor the emerging market banks over the European banks. Those emerging market can grow independent of what interest rates do generally are serving underbanked populations. So that's names like I see. I see I out of Bank Indonesia and the North Bay out of Mexico. From a regional perspective on Page 12, Western Europe, largest way for us. A UK is the country way within Western Europe, but about 12%. But very diversified exposure there with 11 countries represented. Kind of like Mike said before, you know, these tend to be multinational companies that we own. So the actual revenue exposure to Western Europe about 25% versus the roughly 47%. You see so much more multinational companies within Western Europe. North America region that we've increased our exposure to this is both because we decreased our Canadian exposure. If you go back to 2020, we're about 15% currently only on one name there and then more recently decreased our Mexican exposure. But both those countries really rely on the so any changes to trade policies. They're starting to renegotiate the USMCA could be very bad for those countries. But right at the names we sold or much company specific issues rather than accurate, prevent. And the big under way for U.S. Asia, Pacific. So within Asia, Pacific Garner weights are Australia at about India, about 3% that counts for the bulk of that 7%. There largest single country within the entire portfolio is Japan about 14%. And it's a country that we've had some significant exposure to over the last several years, but did start to decrease our exposure about a year ago. Japanese equities admin been a very strong multi runs. The valuations were quite as attractive as we like. So starting point back, our exposure there went to about 9% the end of the year, but then started to ramp that back up to the current 14%. And within Japan, there are making it kind of changed over the longtime longest time. We've been focused on companies that would benefit from that weekend. However, we think the yen weakness is likely ending here so focusing instead on companies they get some sort of revenue from within Inflation steadily been above 2% in Japan's. That's going to put pressure on the Bank Japan to continue to increase interest rates. And Trump administration really does not like when one of the country's devalue their currencies to get a gain, a competitive advantage. So likely to put pressure on the Japanese to and that they and appreciation that we've seen. Last country mentioned It's been a swing factor for us. We've been as high as 20% back in 2020 steadily decreased our exposure there to about 7% a year ago. But then we did start to increase our exposure. That was because we we saw the Chinese government becoming more serious about stimulating the economy and wasn't just their traditional, you know, build-out capacity where they already have overcapacity in the industrial space. But it was more focused on consumption and consumer demand, which likes about names like JD Dot Com, which is an e-commerce operator of benefiting from the for appliances, where the government and introduce the trading So companies like that that going to benefit more from that. One thing that that was that back in April, we did sell 2 we've seen. We have been seeing increase reports that U.S. was looking to delist Chinese ADRs from us the reports new SEC chairman and some senators are making a push for this. So we look at the portfolio essentially just said any stocks that don't have a primary or secondary listing in Hong Kong, we're just going to sell our worry was that if there was a sudden announcement for the listing, there were not be, you know, incremental buyer there. I'm sorry, concerned with what happens if that does happen. So just said, you know, we like these companies were just going to sell them and that kind of impact are our experience back in 2022 and we saw a Russian stocks prior to the invasion. Those stocks ended up going to 0. So just want to be prudent time, get some risk management on his knee. And even though we like them. So that's the portfolio. If you have any questions there. Trustees, any questions. It not. In fact down couple charred siding on here for you guys want me to times up on. Yeah, I want to talk a little bit about to try Yeah. Okay. Page 13 year. So Mike and Frank, mentioned this little bit, but International's had its best to quarter run since the rebound from the global financial Back it up over 15 years ago. Now. And the real positive fears that its last now 3 quarters where, you know, we've seen some false positives in the past. You've seen, you know, really strong quarter on a relative basis for international, but winds the next quarter. So the fact that, you know, you really strong performance in the 1st quarter, performance for the 2nd quarter. And even though international sliding slightly still can keeping up with us here in the 3rd quarter, we think is very positive. But the big question here is can this be sustained and a big reason we think it can be is So if you look at Page 14 and you can see that a huge disconnect emerged over the past 15 years from the consistent outperformance of U.S. stocks versus international equities. You can see back 15 years ago U.S. international essentially traded at parity now at the end of 2024 international trading, a 40% discount to those U.S. A massive, massive disconnect emerge. This struggle little bit here so far this year, but still sitting about 35% discount. So, you know, still by historical standards, a massive dis get disconnect, even with performance of international so far this year really doesn't make sense to us. If you look at expected earnings growth in 2026, both U.S. and international stocks are expected to return her to grow about 12 or 13%. Their earnings. So what you're getting is a huge discount with much higher growth in international markets right now. So we think that's the biggest rivalry we're finally starting to see that that discount start to unwind. Blast are on here today is really important. Is page 16, which is the dollar, which is a big driver of, you know, returns on both sides here. So the top chart just as the dollar over the past year, you can see since the beginning of the year, the dollar has been depreciating a I its worst 1st half of the year and over 30 years, dollars down about 11%. So pretty huge move. It feels like been a nice boost. International returns for us base. Investors like yourself. But if you look at the bottom chart that shows the past 30 years, you can see even though that move is felt really big so far this year, it's actually not huge in terms overall charge, especially when you look at the dollar's performance since 2008, when you saw pretty steady appreciation of the dollar, which is a huge had won 2 international returns here for the past 15 or so years. So the question here is, you know, where does the dollar go government? And we think the dollars likely a man during a period of sustained weakness. Yeah, there's several factors working against that. The one big thing working for the dollar, though, is that it is still the reserve currency of the world. Unlikely to stop. The judge is no other currency that can take that over. Several factors working. It's a dollar would be. Trump administration really wants to decrease the trade deficit. One of the easiest ways you can do that is to allow your currency to depreciate weekend helps to boost your competitiveness of your exports and a global scale that would help them then decrease that trade deficit, which is a big old. The Trump administration. Another thing is, you know, the unpredictable policies from Washington right now are leading to sell off to the dollar. So whether it's trade policy, whether it's putting the revenge attacks in the reconciliation bill that, you know, was pulled out but still hurt sentiment towards the dollar decreases the demand for the U.S. is a destination for capital. That hurts, too. And the big thing that would be if if fed independence is lost, which seems very unlikely still. But if that is lost, you can be left with a very politicized fed artificially low interest rates, which should put more downward pressure on the dollar which for you mean, you know, a nice boost to a nice tailwind for returns. I'm going for here for U.S. based international investors John, of clear it up and offer for outlook. They're happy to. Answer any questions here. And question buddy. Perfect Arshay your review. Thank you coming in today. Thank you all very much. >> All right. We'll turn it over now to 0.1 presentation and discussion the adoption of a revised investment policy statement. ? ? And I want to ask you on that. I think it says a 0.1, but it's 9.1 of the presentation right? Yeah. Okay. I threw me off for saying I'm like I know I looked at it and okay. First, I don't know if everybody had a chance to review it or not, we talked about again the last month. Some of the changes based on are going to a core manager. But Pedro, I wanted to ask you about. ? The statement in here. That's been added in the investment policies for. countries of Sudan. Or that participated a boycott of Israel. That's new to me. So I wanted to ask about it. Sure. So >> taking a step back. So if if you recall about I guess 2012 so over well, over a decade ago to they enacted this protecting Florida's Investments Act. essentially what that did was it required divestiture of public assets certain companies that were seen to do business with Sudan. And I of a sea red because of the political discourse that was taking in Sudan because of the At that point in and unfortunately is as it continues over the course of the past 12, 13 years. That has also been expanded to include other countries such as Cuba, North Korea. And in China to a certain extent as well. And then most recently as of July, 1st of this year 2025, it also includes companies that are seen as anti Israel or that boycott Israel, although that is not defined in the ironically enough the state Board administration. Was originally charged with Oversight administration of this law. And that continues. And so they it is charged with. All of the diligence and publishing a list on a quarterly basis of all of these quote, unquote, scrutinized companies, right or prohibited investments, essential. All right. So if you're on this list that the SBA publishes on a quarterly basis then. Either you cannot purchase that security directly with public assets or if you own it. And this company is is put on prohibited list. You must divest, you know, within a reasonable time, right? I think we give ourselves about a year to to divest from that security. if you recall couple years ago, there was a big movement by the state to focus investments only on the CUNY area factors, Which this this seems to go against. But nonetheless, here we are, right. So that's why the language has been included as part of the Addendums to invest a policy statement. Technically we were already complying with it because again, we cited the statute. so this was an amendment to that statute. But we just thought it was it would be it would be a little more precise. That just includes specific language just as we had already right And that is you just read. So just to include the new language to to reflect this New Amendment. This most recent amendment as part of the part of the state. >> And you've legally all the the statements, the investment policy and then all the manager contract. Yes, sir. And if I'm correct the highlighted areas on Page 3, 5, the investment. statement is change based on our change to the core manager change in the percentage is? >> Correct. I think that was the discussion you guys had at last meeting. I believe it where you are. You kind of adjusted the target allocation. The ranges and then there's some some changes too. I think I saw some benchmarks. And the name of one of your managers changed as well from a to hedge Hudson some sort. A Hudson edge investment partners. Instead of H G K. And that's that's those are all changes that were made. Just want to make sure. So, yes, we've we reviewed Everything is in order. And from our perspective. So we were the it really we would certainly final adoption. Anybody have any questions? There's no further discussion. Chair will entertain a motion adopted changes to the statement of our investment policy goals and guidelines as well as the >> individual contracts. excuse me. Make the motion. And second. OK? Motion on the table has been moved and second and there's no further discussion will take a roll call. Vote. >> Share Hartley. Yes. Vice chair Joseph. Yes, secretary Treasurer Griggs Stay snow, just resting. All right. Very good. >> Thank you for that. Will move on. Then to the presentation is cush quick question? Sure enough. Now is the time or waiting get to the end and ask me, but I just want to go back. To the last meeting. We discussed the core manager. We have actually looked at bringing 2 on. I don't know if we want to go back to Scott and see if there's additional core manager, something maybe that helps too. Get this style. Back online, more to where we are. But, you know, it's my understanding that the court will go either way. So it's not a. But I don't know if we still want to look at another core manager. I think that was. Where main thoughts were originally to go to 2 with one growth in one value. I just want to keep it out there in case we still want do that and see what everybody else's opinion to our. Anybody want to respond. My opinion with I want to wait and see how they did. I was obviously concerned and expressed that there are a little weighted toward value. And that's why when I saw in the minutes that that's going to be less risk force. >> I want to see if that's true. Ask God about it, Owens, but also to be honest with you, I had a meeting with. retirement group. Yeah, and I want to. Does the get into this? And second is the city. >> GE or police plan have the any of the international money in an index instead of a manager. The recall. What you on the spot. But >> Milan and >> okay. I would have to find I get you I don't know of him. Yeah, because if you look at both the books. And this is obviously a gray stones coming in next month. The index, if you are. So the fire, the firefighters, he's a great both. Yeah. The firefighters have some index funds and they talk about some of the money that's being safe. So I just want to find out. With underperformance that we've seen if we're going to make a change. I'd like to at least pick his brain about an index fund because I know both of these are on his watch. Basically that he was concerned about underperformance for in the long term. So I just wondered. >> And I I can can you will answer correct answer to all of mobile, I don't know. How quickly do you want to see want right now want to look into yes, something ask a Mexican and I know the index fund has a cost to it, too. It's not like you just throw in the index and it doesn't like our managers have a cost basis point. I know your pain. The index managers as well. So because it offset some of that, I don't know. It's a it's a much lower cost of this Yeah, it is. And then that's going to mean and we've seen a lot of it going to be a whole discussion in terms of passive versus active man. exactly. No. I know we've had. you know, it's been. >> It's been discussed before. So maybe that's that that could be a good opportunity to to put some couple that with your active management. But again, that's that's for grace to the kind of well, part of it. Yeah. I mean, we look at I look at Renaissance. We've had them for 17 years. >> So I think every so often you need to review this as a board. So you feel good about are we doing due diligence? Are we doing the best we can for the fund is there is a time to make a path of active change. So. That's where I was at with that because I just look at both of the indexes and think. Is it time? I don't that's just my Very few 110%. Scott your wisdom to know I'm I'm fine with >> Okay. I'm fine check. >> I know you'll know you listen. And then >> the mail that he But yet it >> go ahead for the record. Good Morning Board of Trustees. Anthony Fair. See your pension analysts sent a message was listening internally other payroll. The things going on with the city. But the answers now. Just for the record, the police pension, he's had a core holding since 1998. And an American funds. A mutual fund. That's lable for anyone to take place and but as it reviewed the minutes as well, Mister Owens did present the index. as an option yet in case. that. Thank you. >> All Anything else? Oh, yeah. No, no, no, hope we answered enough. Alright, turned over to a point, too. presentation to City Commission. This I was look we can talk >> So we actually have our first forward presenting to the commission on October, the 6th. >> I'll have a better idea of what is expected and what they're asking for. As of right now, the back of those prison is the board of Adjustment who will be meeting with the commission. They just put their previous report. For the last fiscal year. And then when this current fiscal year issue is safe and then they also do like updated board report with like, you know, how many means everybody's been to, you know, the usual so. Just for the record are meeting is the first meeting March. >> Like for the chair to print, present to the commission. If you can't as the vice chairman of that, the method that is the trickle down the road, everybody March >> Next year, yes, that's not No March 1st. >> That's the that's the old this >> am I looking at the It's the first Monday in March. Because this is the old calendar. We haven't put out the new commission town. Yeah, that's what don't look at that yet. We typically put out the new commission count in November, first, money and market to see the first Monday Looking now Kmart you are. >> And all of that that that's had that rain break. That's the outlook right now. It's the first second. Them are second, I be able to make make that have a better After meeting. >> We're going to tell my wife. >> Well, they originally had his own will. I can say they is my office today. Rizzo. You had do schedule than but dead pointed out that this that month and those in January a rare in this kind of a bad month with conference. all it can still so the push to March. So we are march. The second. Okay. >> He's looking at this. I was praying was going to be in October. not going to work. This is just a sick. We used to do this sudden a regular annually. I favor and do it right. I mean, I used to come. I know he actually was And in grey. So here. We did. We all know we need come up and >> when we come together collectively and then we need kind of, you know, speak for 5. Yes, a couple minutes to to the commission. They would typically ask questions. 9 times out of 10. It was definitely the It was either to, you know, to to the actuary, for the most part and or investments. But nothing's going to be in that in that I really don't at the. >> We are doing it will be only going to 7 minutes for a presentation from the board of Everybody. Right? Okay. So we're trying to be sure and sleet don't know if I just if you guys wanted. I'm happy to come again or, you know, whatever you need. >> Yeah, I honestly page, I don't. >> Anticipated be in this series we'll see how long this lesson my pain. >> Haha. >> We funded we are what we're. >> And just the basics. Keep it simple. back to rain returns. That is and yes, 100%. Like I said at the October have a better idea of kind of what to expect. Okay. And then I can kind of report that to you all and we can figure that will staff will help put together. Okay only 7 minutes, you can talk for 7 minutes. >> Ewing all. 7 minutes. She tells the I couldn't talk more than 7 have to take the whole time allotted to lie >> So that can walk in a room and talk for >> So this this is the day was going on there. Thank you. New business. 9.1 which no, it's not 9.1. So I think we just make state 9, it is okay. Alright, proposed audit services for physical year ending September 30th. I take it your Daniel Anderson. >> Nice to see you. You. Good morning. Fair. Malden Jenkins. >> Hope everyone still well this morning, not brief presentation, really? You know, we're right towards the plans fiscal year. And so it's time to talk about audit season a little bit. I know that gives dead in her team. A lot excitement >> everyone's excited about the other. So what we've got to engagement letters for you here to review the first one is the general plan. >> Annual audit that's required in accordance with the statutes. No real significant change in the audit standards. No real significant change in accounting pronouncements that will affect the plan. So it should be, you know, just another kind of coming in here. You know, I like to look at these type of audit has really to audits. One were actually or during the activity that you had. You know, we do valuation testing on your investments. That's pretty much your entire balance sheet. The second OT is really a compliance audit. We're selecting samples and recalculating contributions that were made, you know, by the participants, recalculating benefit payments that were made, ensuring that they were in accordance with all of the required a plan provisions. So that's all really nothing in it different except we're coming in with fresh eyes looking fresh samples and reevaluating everything for 2025 fiscal year. The second OT engagement letter is in regards to the allocation of the net pension liability between the city and the county to this will be the last year that we're performing this audit due to how the inner local agreement expired in the contributions from the county ended. But really it into the 2020 for fiscal year and this audit is kind of going in and just saying, okay, kind of the whole liability is going to fall on the city's books going forward. So we're just coming in testing those allocations issuing a final report to say at this point that liability is 100%, the responsibility of the city and not the county that audit is paid for by the so that's not going to be paid for by the It's just obviously, you know, your plans. So we're presenting that engagement letter to you guys as well. >> How how do in the past how to house the bill sent to the county and have they responded that they would cover the cost. >> we invoice the county directly. And then they kind of pay it pass back. You know, obviously from their funds either you can make sure that space. Initial process perfect. >> So you need us to adopt the got these for signature, correct? Correct. Anybody have any questions about the letters. I They're standard a little different font than they've been in the past. I like >> like the new fund. I marketing teams always looking for fresh ways to reports and our our engagement letters. haha chair entertain the option of the engagement letters. >> We're going to both the one that I do both. I make a motion that we adopt both engagement letter Smith moment in Jenkins. >> Can I just ask that question? And that that I saw the just to check with Devon Staff. The fee was 14,500. I just want to confirm. That's that's correct. >> Why I think it's to 14, 14 to 40 to 50. I'm sorry. I the that's correct. The county's is 7500 correct? Okay. That's an increase of about 3.6% for the audit. >> did we do the motion? yes, it was the first in a second. >> First saying, Jumped in and If there's no further discussion will do a roll call, vote. hardly >> Just Secretary treasurer agree us. Trustee, Snow. Yes, trustee Yes. >> Final question for you or you move into the new office on the 7th floor at Northern Trust. >> I will not I was actually probably going over there tomorrow. I'll be here for the other 2 board meetings in kind of go take a look at it. I think they said the end of October is when it should be finalized is looking nice jumping in there. So, yeah, I've heard good things. >> papers done excellently in there. >> Haha. >> I know a guy that did it. All right. >> Thanks. Thank you. That's going to be the close to home. Pedro turning matters. lot on the agenda today. Guys know nothing really to report on, which is always >> Thank you guys for having me. Appreciate my seeing I think really they want to show was that boycott Israel language that we spoke about already. So no need to go into that again. Some upcoming of education opportunity Appts coming up. I think about 2 weeks or so, maybe a little up in. It's it's not next week the following week. I think it up in Jacksonville and put a taxable beach because technically so if anybody's going to be see that and if not, there's the winter school, which will be at the end of January. That's a little bit closer. I guess that's in Orlando. If anybody has time of the counties, that might be a good one to go to as well. With an oath. >> That's nice. All >> No, no further questions for you. Pedro will go other matters. Turn it over to you, dad, for the >> budget analysis at the June 30th. >> Yes, this is as of June, are there any questions about any of the specific line items? The total expenses are right at about 75%. Which is good. We're good. Yeah. No questions. In conjunction with that. The next item is the check register for the time period. Are there any questions about any of those expenditures? Moving right the next item is the proposed regular meeting schedule for 2026. These are all on Wednesday. Same time. Are there any questions or concerns about any of those dates? You see there? >> The general membership meeting again is set February and March March. Okay. The March meeting. Okay. No questions. Worse. 25th yes. Would make sure we get that out. second. Yes. The Yeah. >> And then the final document you have is the asset allocation. As of September. The 12th, this is after we've done our cash needs analysis and to make payroll for pension. There are no questions. That's all I have. >> No questions. Administrative leave, everybody staff and putting all the good numbers together the minutes. Everything. Thank you for your. I know those been extensive. The last few meetings. Any matters by any other trustees. ? What earn. >> That's a 1000 is got to be ready. That's a wreck.

# MINUTES OF THE CITY OF SARASOTA FIREFIGHTERS’ PENSION PLAN BOARD OF TRUSTEES REGULAR MEETING OF SEPTEMBER 24, 2025

Present: Chair Michael Hartley, Vice Chair Charles Joseph, Secretary/Treasurer Shayla Griggs, Trustee Scott Snow, and Trustee Heather Mushrush.

Others: Attorney Pedro Herrera, Pension Plans Administrator Debra Martin, Senior Pension Analyst Anthony Ferrer, and Pension Specialist Peter Gottlieb.

Absent: None.

## 1. CALL MEETING TO ORDER:

## Presenter(s): Chair Hartley

Chair Hartley called the City of Sarasota (City), Firefighters’ Pension Plan (Plan) Board of Trustees Regular meeting to order at 9:00 a.m.

## 2. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE:

Present(s): Secretary/Treasurer Griggs.

Secretary/Treasurer Griggs led the Board and meeting attendees in the Pledge of Allegiance.

## 3. PLEDGE OF CIVILITY:

Present(s): Chair Hartley.

Vice Chair Joseph stated for the record, “We may disagree, but we will be respectful to one another. We will direct all comments to issues. We will not engage in personal attacks.”

## 4. ROLL CALL:

Present(s): Debra Martin, Pension Plans Administrator.

Pension Plans Administrator Martin called roll; all trustees were present.

## 5. PUBLIC INPUT:

None.

## 6. APPROVAL OF MINUTES:

6.1. Approval Re: Minutes of the Firefighters’ Pension Plan Board of Trustees Regular Meeting of July 23, 2025.

Present(s): Chair Hartley

Chair Hartley asked Pension Administration if page 495 of the minutes accurately reflected the comments of Scott Owens of Graystone Consulting (Graystone), who asserted that a value-leaning portfolio would have less risk. Secretary/Treasurer Griggs, Pension Plans Administrator Martin, and Pension Specialist Gottlieb advised they would need to review the meeting video before confirming and the Board may delay approving the minutes if it believed the minutes were inaccurate. Chair Hartley advised that he does not question the accuracy of the minutes, however he intends to rely on the comment when he discusses with retirees the portfolio reallocation to include a core holding.

---

Vice Chair Joseph made a motion to approve the minutes of the Regular, July 23, 2025, meeting; Trustee Mushrush seconded the motion.

The motion passed unanimously (5-0).

## 7. INVESTMENT PERFORMANCE REVIEW:

7.1. Presentation and Discussion Re: Lazard Asset Management, Performance Review as of June 30, 2025.

Presenter(s): Michael Powers, Senior Advisor, Portfolio Manager/Analyst; Frank Sposato, Director; Lazard Asset Management.

Michael Powers and Frank Sposato of Lazard Asset Management (Lazard) appeared before the Board and introduced themselves.

Attorney Herrera joined the meeting at 9:05 a.m.

Mr. Sposato explained that the Plan is invested in Lazard’s International Equity strategy, and it has significantly outperformed domestic equities in 2025. The portfolio’s absolute, year-to-date return is close to 20%; the portfolio leads domestic equities but trails its benchmark because the portfolio is higher quality, has lower debt, and more sustainable earnings than its benchmark. He noted there are 2 components to the portfolio: high quality versus low quality, and emerging markets and developed markets. There have been aberrant periods in emerging markets when low quality stocks outperformed high quality, by as much as 30% and 40%; during these periods, the portfolio lags on a relative basis. That has since corrected, and the emerging markets portion of the portfolio has outperformed over the last 5 years. Now a similar environment exists on the developed market side where low quality is outperforming high quality by substantial margins. In the current environment, the spread between low and high quality is narrowing, and the portfolio is catching up to the index.

To Chair Hartley’s questions, Mr. Powers advised that throughout the market cycles described by Mr. Sposato, Lazard has not drifted away from high quality companies with low debt and reasonable valuations. He explained that large-scale stimulus, such as what many governments provided during the COVID-19 pandemic, generally helps low quality companies in the short term far more than the established, stable, high-quality companies Lazard favors. While the portfolio is disadvantaged in this type of environment, high-quality companies’ stock prices also tend to fall which creates investment opportunities; as the stimulus ends the high-quality stock prices will rise, which is currently being seen in the portfolio. He discussed how the United States’ threats and applications of tariffs have been a headwind for the portfolio. Many of the portfolio’s bigger, high-return European companies tend to be net exporters to the US while smaller companies are already domestically focused and tariffs have generally hit those larger companies harder. Further, the US Dollar is down in 2025, almost 10% year to date, which additionally hurts the portfolio. He noted that many of the threats of tariffs have been far worse than the tariff amounts finally imposed. Mr. Sposato added that, despite tariff’s impact, higher quality companies are better able to withstand the burden of tariffs than smaller, low-quality companies, although the impact must be made on a company-by-company basis.

Mr. Powers and Mr. Sposato discussed international equity performance in 2025 relative to domestics, and how the US policy of “America First” has caused other countries to take similar positions of self-investment; this has boosted international equities more than domestics such that the portfolio is outperforming on an absolute basis and relative to domestic equities but underperforming its benchmark. International stock prices and earnings have been moving up similarly in 2025, while domestic equities, especially in large cap, have seen significant valuation expansions, meaning international equities remain attractively priced, with favorable currency values, and in promising local environments. Lazard is hopeful this environment will continue into 2026 and beyond. International equity’s attractive valuations and favorable currency rates, counterintuitively, had not been leading to better relative performance, and the domestics’ outperformance only added to international equities’ “gas in the tank,” that is now driving outperformance. Prior to the most recent period of domestic exceptionalism, international equities had been consistently outperforming domestics for a decade. Lazard believes that both the portfolio and the broader international equity asset class remain undervalued and therefore significant potential remains for continued outperformance. Page 16 of the materials shows that within the MSCI EAFE benchmark, from January 1, 2015, through September

---

30, 2020, high quality stocks, or those with high returns on equity (ROE), outperformed low-quality or low ROE stocks by more than 5% from year to year, which is to be expected. From October 1, 2020, through June 30, 2025, low-quality outperformed high-quality by more than 5% from year-to-year. This trend appears to be reversing back to the norm. The average outperformance, going back to 1998, is approximately 1.6% per year. On the page titled Quality Factor, Mr. Powers reminded the Board that the 3 components of “quality” are high ROE, low debt, and steadiness of earnings, and noted that the blue line trending down shows when low-quality is outperforming high-quality, and the green line trending up shows when low-quality outperforms high-quality; the rate as of June 2025 suggests strong potential for high-quality to again outperform.

To Chair Hartley’s question, in reference to the Performance Summary, Mr. Powers confirmed that, generally, the portfolio’s Gross and Net underperformance is due to the portfolio’s bias towards high quality when low quality was outperforming, although tariffs have also played a role.

To Vice Chair Joseph’s question, Mr. Powers reiterated the portfolio’s commitment to high quality stocks.

To Chair Hartley’s question, Mr. Powers and Mr. Sposato explained that there have been no changes to the investment team, although Lazard has hired Chris Hogbin, formerly of AllianceBernstein, as CEO of Asset Management. Mr. Hogbin will start in December 2025, and succeeds CFO and acting CEO Evan Russo, who will move into an advisory role.

The Board thanked Mr. Sposato and Mr. Powers for their presentation.

7.2. Presentation and Discussion Re: Renaissance Investments, Performance Review as of June 30, 2025.

Firefighters' Pension Plan Board of Trustees Regular Meeting

FIREFIGHTERS' PENSION PLAN BOARD OF TRUSTEES REGULAR MEETING

08:45 a.m. September 24, 2025

MEETING NOTICE AND PUBLISHED AGENDA

Click to View the Meeting Notice and Final Published Agenda.

1.

CALL MEETING TO ORDER: Presenter(s): Chair Hartley.

2.

PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE: Presenter(s): Secretary/Treasurer Griggs.

3.

PLEDGE OF CIVILITY: Presenter(s): Chair Hartley.

"We may disagree, but we will be respectful of one another. We will direct all comments to issues. We will not engage in personal attacks."

4.

ROLL CALL: Presenter(s): Debra Martin, Pension Plans Administrator.

5.

PUBLIC INPUT:

6.

APPROVAL OF THE MINUTES:

6.1.

Approval Re: Minutes of the Firefighters' Pension Plan Board of Trustees Regular Meeting of July 23, 2025. Presenter(s): Chair Hartley.

Click to View Backup Materials.

7.

INVESTMENT PERFORMANCE REVIEW:

7.1.

Presentation and Discussion Re: Lazard Asset Management, Performance Review as of June 30, 2025. Presenter(s): Michael Powers, Senior Advisor, Portfolio Manager/Analyst; Frank Sposato, Director; Lazard Asset Management.

Click to View Backup Materials.

7.2.

Presentation and Discussion Re: Renaissance Investments, Performance Review as of June 30, 2025. Presenter(s): Michael J. Streitmarter, CFA, Partner, Portfolio Manager, Renaissance Investments.

Click to View Backup Materials.

8.

UNFINISHED BUSINESS:

8.1.

Presentation and Discussion Re: Adoption of Revised Investment Policy Statement. Presenter(s): Chair Hartley.

Click to View Backup Materials.

8.2.

Presentation and Discussion Re: Board Presentations to City Commission. Presenter(s): Secretary Griggs.

Click to View Backup Materials.

9.

NEW BUSINESS:

9.1.

Showing the first 24,000 of 59,006 characters. The full document is at the source.

I all stunned that the view. >> I know we're actually going to do thing all we can I can spare. Thank like the kind that normally keepers. I like the kind that are normally like cross you know, keep keep ? ? ? ? ? >> I'm like I hope that works out for you. She's with. Where is. I ? She or take care ? both her mom and he went to Alzheimer's and her mom was told to take care of her. Her she was out for like 4 years. ? ? ? ? Just up for us this year. ? All the time. ? And this got to find job. And you never work a day in your life. you. Call it okay. ? ? Q A me. >> The order. Good morning. Everyone will call me and order for the firefighters. Pension Plan Board of trustees regular meeting for today. September 24th. First on the agenda is the Pledge of Allegiance. Can we turn that over to you? Treasure. Great. Yes. Police need. >> fine. ? >> Thank you very much. And then the pledge of civility. Would you like to do that today, Chuck, I would love to. We may disagree, but we will be respectful to one another. We will direct all comments to issues. We will not engage in personal attacks. Thank you for shot. Next. As roll call will turn it over not to be left out. That. >> Thank Chair Hartley President Vice Chair Joseph President, Secretary Treasurer Trustee, Snow present this team assurance present. >> Public input, no cards for today. >> I didn't think I >> I recognize 3 of 4. So I wanted to make Alright, approval of the minutes will turn to 6 0.1 in the agenda as the minutes for firefighter pension plan. Our meeting from July 23rd. I did review them last night. The only thing I wanted to ask was on. Page 4.95. I might as owned out, but in the if you count, the motion passed unanimously go down one to 3 under chair Hartley. Mister Owens made a statement that. Large cap growth managers more focused on race, mad, but then returned. However, evaluating portfolio has less risk. You remember him saying that Peters and in was that on the recording? We would have >> Go back and shake that. Just to verify many view, one is to weaken, pull off a proven the minutes and bring them back if you want. But >> I'm only asking me because I'm going to get to it later in the investment. And the investment. We're moving. 20% of growth down to 10. Because the corps, which was one of the things that brought up was corps was more value. The manager we packed. I just want to be able to factually say whether that reduced the risk in our portfolio. When I'm talking to. Retirees. >> We have to go. Listen. Yeah. Okay. end. >> I'm willing to approve it as is I just want to make. I want to verify, but I can I'll just put it on. The agenda are not on the agenda. I'll just put my notes to ask. Greystone. They come in next month. Okay. All right. I just wondered if anybody heard him say that I just know. >> like, go back and listen. >> That's the only thing I had to bring up in the notes that. I wanted to ask about anybody, see anything or any questions. Chair will entertain a motion that for the adoption of the minutes from July 23rd 2025 are a pension meeting. I make a motion to adopt the Motion on the tables been moved and second for the adoption of the minutes for July 23rd, there's no other discussion. Do a roll call for approval? >> Chair Hartley? Yes, vice chair Joseph. Yeah. Secretary Treasurer, Greg's trustee. Snow. Yes. Esteem a >> Very good. move on then to our first investment performance review under a number 7 0st step is Lazard. We'll turn it over to Michael Powers and Frank's because Idol. Good morning. Glad to hear you had a good flight without delay. normally we. After we ask you to introduce yourself to the mikes, remind everybody that we usually give you 15 minutes and then we might have some questions at the end. thanks for coming morning. >> We tried to stay in our usual hotel, the Hyatt, but apparently they were no longer taking reservations. You're going to have to we are in the West, which is very close to here. we can absolutely do the 15 minute version. We have all kinds of versions. >> And whatever questions you have, please, you know, interrupt. try and stick to the high Frank spells I've been at as of this month. 28 years or since I have brown hair. my powers makes me look like a rookie. He's on the portfolio side of things and has been here since the first trade was made of That's a 35. Like 35 years. I started in >> all right. So that is another way of saying we've seen a lot of different markets. This one's been particularly unusual over the last several years starting with COVID but I the best news I have is that your international portfolio is finally outperforming by a large margin. The U.S. and that's been a long time coming. We've been talking about how undervalued international stocks are relative the U.S. and that has just continued for well over a decade. it's been kind of frustrating as a that has 2 thirds of its assets and global and international portfolios. And one of the reasons for that was the U.S. dollar extremely strong, which has a U.S. investor her to you in terms of your returns. That has been the opposite this this international stocks have solid earnings and they've done extremely well. So your portfolio is up. Just this is through a 2nd quarter. But the up-to-date numbers close to 20% year to date. And that's, you know, we're only in September the 2nd quarter itself was incredibly strong And if you had said to me, we're going to be up 10 or 11%. You know, in a quarter like that. That is unsustainable for a whole year. But we seem to be, you know, kind of cruising along and it still substantially head of the U.S. then the bad news is we're the benchmark this year. and it's for a couple reasons. The primary one is it's a very high quality portfolio. And for those of you who might have been around we presented originally was that we focus on very high quality stocks very financially productive load at sustainable earnings and we try and buy them at reasonable prices. So generally speaking, this is a blue chip portfolio. That's true of both the developed portion and the emerging market portion. If you remember, we have 2 pieces to this puzzle and we allocate to the emerging markets portfolio in order to get exposure there we went through a period in the emerging markets world where low quality stocks outperform high quality stocks. Stocks, which is not the norm, but happens periodically bite huge margins. And I mean that certain periods, 2030, 40%, it was impossible to have a high quality portfolio, an outperform. It was almost the reverse like the better quality of the company bought the worse. It did relatively speaking. But that resolved itself and then for a period of time, the emerging markets piece was a drag on the overall portfolio. If you remember that was that was keeping back the developed portion of the portfolio that reversed itself and the emerging market portfolios has outperform stanch Ali, over the last 5 years. Now east, we're seeing this on the develop. Side were low. Quality is outperforming high quality by substantial margins. So it's been tough. Sledding. The good news is that that differential is narrowing and we're starting to see the portfolio look better relative to the the index. Michael, did that cause you to drift at all to the lower quality? >> You know, we're now know we've you know, as Frank said. >> We're looking for good businesses. Good management's that with that regard, highly the output of the efforts of the management, the business they make a high level of return on capital. I literally put in the first raid on the slick portfolios back in 93 and and, you know, ever since then, we've never had a time when our return on equity return on Capital Profar wasn't higher than broad market, right? So that meant that includes today. So there's, you know. we in terms of quality, we tend to have and we do today less indebtedness of our portfolio companies than the marketplace by meaningful amount. We also often grow earnings faster than Broad-market both trailing and forward looking true today. And so, you know, again about the earnings, the profitability, the how the how the business is capitalized. All those are, you know, check, check, check, quality quality quality. And we don't want to pay rias reasonable valuation you know, there there are times when lower performs. Some of that are a lot of that kind of thing can be attributed to all the massive stimulus that's been present. I think I'm sure said that in these meetings before when when you have so much stimulus, both monetary in terms of interest rates being lower, historically low, we're a fiscal stimulus where the government is running big budget deficit is to try to, you know, be be fiscally stimulative that can of, you know, help, though, the more marginal company more than it helps the bigger, stronger, you know, better capitalize business. And so. You know, that's been going on and I think today in terms of quality what we'll see this in a minute. You have a situation where the quality and of this of the opportunity said is looking quite cheap relative to the hole. universe. And, you know, that's kind of like trying to hold a beach ball underwater at some point at that pops up and you know, I we're actually beginning to see that this month. Today we're quality. However, you define it is performing. And so are we. >> So are the international tariffs affecting the higher quality? Yes, yes, they are. the think of it. That, you know, France's we owe a lot of stocks in Europe and and in Europe, the the bigger companies that tend to be higher return companies are generally the net exporters back to the dollar. Smaller companies tend to be more domestically focused and and our big exporting businesses have have had a negative sort of hit from the tariffs. I think it's both tariffs and also this year, as Frank mention, the U.S. dollar has been notably we commute. It's down 8, 9, 9.10%, year to date. And so these big multinational exporters that we own in Europe are are selling into both the tariff headwind at times and that her picture changes like from day to day week to week in terms of a lot of turf is threatened. Then there's always meetings and negotiations in the lot of the tariff is really a negotiating posture and then they wind up with something much more benign at the end. And so initially the shock of the tariffs, I think hurt are bigger. Exporting companies more than it did the smaller companies. And so that was definitely a headwind. And so, yeah, the tariff has has never hurt us so far. Not this month, but but this year, the no question. >> But I would add that longer term stronger companies are able to tolerate that better than we write you know, even, you know, a smaller company that's in the export business is just not going to have the kind of margins that can afford additional costs. So what we're trying to do it's our job to go company, the company and determine how much they're affected by the tariffs depending on what their export ing, you know where they're exporting it to see. You could have a company in Europe that exports nothing to the U.S.. But does a lot of export into the emerging market countries, for So we need to figure out the the IT individual impact. It's not it's not a broad picture. You know. So in some cases, I probably said this in the past, a strong dollar can help certain companies and hurt certain companies. You know, in the same country just because of what they do and where they sell to. >> The tariffs are part of mention the asset class international has done great this year. Just everything you want. I mean, we've been waiting, you know, 15 years for this and we're getting it in spades now. And so he started out in January one with cheap stocks, meaning quite low valuations. You particularly relative to the U.S. alternative. And you also had very expensive U.S. dollar cheap other currencies. So, yeah, chief stocks and cheap currencies both historically cheap in terms of the level of valuation and a lot happened this year. That caused, you know, our our stocks, international stocks in general, the earnings have been good and they've been good in the U.S. as well. But, you know, the in terms of what we're we're here to talk about earnings of done beautifully and and so But but all these sort of macro events have have caused people to sort of shine a light on international international is doing a lot of self-help and Europe, Japan, Korea and some other places kind just recently about, you know, the the U.S. I understand is, you know, America first, but that's causing a lot of other countries and regions to say, you know, we have to be more self reliant. We don't want to be the we can't be the younger brother junior partner to the U.S. really going to do for ourselves. Now we've got to get our defense in order. We got to spend there. We've got to get our infrastructure in order so our economy can function well. We've got to deregulate, so economy can function well. Other words look more like what we're used to here. And so as the margin that's been a positive factor for international stocks to do well and the tariff thing has helped us in terms of absolute return. But Curtis, on a relative basis, if you can follow that distinction, yeah. So. I've been concerned about international with the real thing going on. >> Yeah, the Cle. So there's a lot of a lot of moving parts. But but, you know, we're sitting here with the, you know, almost 20% his 19.4 4 was a number I got this morning. And hallelujah. You know, you know, whatever return assumption you have for the for the plan. I'm sure that's way, way above that. And it's and it's, you know, lots above the S and P which is in low teens. And there were a little so thick. So, you know, it is the international assets are really working this year, both stocks and, you know, the share prices and the currency is helping. And so still today, because our earnings have been good. Stock prices have been good, but they've been moving like the earnings. And so they haven't really gotten much more expensive, whereas in the U.S., particularly in the big cap stuff. You have a lot of multiple expansion, or valuation. Expansions and evaluation got higher and higher. And so you still have today, chief stock, cheap currencies internationally you know, sort of good fundamentals and a lot of self-help happening in a lot of places. And so I think there's a there's a good fighting chance that your international S a switch and perform so well for you now for 3 quarters of the year that can continue on into next year and and hopefully will be on. So when you think I can quote you on that. I'm good with You probably just you know, along those lines, you know, we've been talking for several years now about. But the fact that that these low valuations make no sense. >> The currency weakness, you know, as well beyond what it should be. It's like a coiled spring, right? So there's just more more potential being built up as the U.S. keep outperforming outperforming outperforming. So now what we see is a year when all the news is about how tough it is for international stocks and they're all performing. They have just they just have so much gas in the tank. You know, based on the fact that they've been so undervalued for a period of time, we have a chart here was just looking for it. But it showed, you know how you know is us earnings were drifting down. The valuations were going up, which doesn't make a whole lot of sense and how the international earnings were going up and the valuations were drifting down. So was the really the reverse of what you would expect longer term? And a lot of times these things return to their longer term pattern. But we have we have a tendency to look at them kind of small vacuum right? When you look over the broad picture. Before this us, how performance for good, solid 10 years international outperformed this is before we came in here in the first place. But a lot of the reasons international got attention as it was outperforming the U.S. consistently year after year. You know, there's a lot of opportunity out outside the U.S. but that we went through this U.S. exceptionalism, period. When you just couldn't beat it. All right. And then the stimulus made it worse, right? So it's just propped up the whole market in a way that made it impossible for for other markets to to compete fairly. So what happens is, again, a lot of potential gets built them. You know, that never gets realize. So we still have a very undervalued portfolio. International stocks are still undervalued currencies. You know, we are still cheap. All right. That which tells us there's a lot more upside and we're finding, you know, when when things are unnaturally cheap to assess the relative value manager, their bargains, right. So we see really good earnings and return on equity, you know, but but cheap valuations. So to us, you know, if you have patients and you buy it, you know, and you wait, it pays off over time. I think the quality, the quality aspect of the opportunity said we're we're position is also, I think, poised to. >> really have a you know, a good relative run. If you turn to Page 16, I think this is a good illustration. And keep the very brief. But it's that the 2 bars so far to the left, which pays you say total quality factor. Looks got it. Yeah, I forget that. Sometimes we send it to. You comes out a little different than our physical book. But what that shows us from from 2014 to 2020 it shows that quality the higher we stocks this, which is one way to define quality outperform low. we stocks return on equity by over 5% per year per year for that period per year. You'd expect something like that. Yeah. The better companies that's that's closer to the long term. You know, Norm, I'm not going to go the chart below that because I find very confusing. But then to the bar to the right. Shows that from 2020 so halfway through this year was the complete opposite. So high quality outperform underperformed, low quality by over 5% per year for for more than 4 years. So that the bar on the left us much more the longer term. Norm, you would expect quality outperform low quality, right? But what we're seeing here is we've been through this period now. You know, we see it lessening and we know that it's more likely long-term to to a premium of quality over low quality. The that the only thing I'll say about that, the next chart on Page 17 is the average outperformance per year. And this goes back since 1998. is about 1.6% per year. There was going to have those periods when it goes back and forth again, the times I might have, you know, when interest rates are really low, it helps indebted companies, right? You borrow money at really low interest rates. You look better if you're borrowing money at much higher interest rate, you're you're paying off your debt. You could much finance and lower your interest in meaningful. You typically get a credit rating upgrade. The stock goes up. Doesn't mean all of a sudden year the greatest business right up the little red dot on the left shows you basically how much of an outlier, you know, the June 2025. Number. It was the second worst period for quality since 1998. All right. That being said, we're still seeing, you know, lots of opportunity. I would turn one more page on looking at the clock as I know. Yes, that 15 minutes. I think this might be the most important page in the book about this quality thing we've been talking about. This is a. >> 25 year timeline and it's believe it or not, this That's Europe, Australia, far that's a very commonly used. The international index that there is an EV quality version. And again, the 3 components of the quality are high return on Capital High return equity low indebtedness and steadiness of earnings. Those are the 3 components that make up this quality index. If you compare that to the regular the fee for over this 25 years, what what you see there is when that wigley blue line is heading down and gets below the red dotted line. That means that low quality is outperforming. And when you see the green line, that means that that has turned and now the quality aspect of the market is starting to perform. And so look at these prior periods. When you have such a big run of quality, underperforming the regular in the next. You know, you see it 3 to 4 period in sort 5. You saw it in about 2013 17. And now just recently. >> Way down on the chart in the lower right. You see where we are today. That implies to me that you have a lot of bounce-back potential to get that green line of performing going forward again, I'm I'm going to teach community. I keep wanting to say this expression of a strict trying to hold a beach ball underwater? You know, it wants to come up. And I think that's what you have over on the far right. So I think quality, which is us. Can have a good relative run. We've this so much more we could talk about. But I think those are the big points we wanted to make. I hope we're able to communicate effectively. >> So >> if I look at Page 19, which is our performance summary, your explanation for why are gross and that is below the index's because of the lower quality run and were higher quality. You're a higher quality manager with less risk. >> Yes, the I would I think that's a fair statement. >> Any other reasons. >> There's always a few stocks here and there that that's always the So there's also the tariff thing we talked about a little bit that we tend to be positioned in the high quality European exporters that are selling a lot stuff into the dollar. And with the weakening dollar and >> you know, and those companies bearing the brunt of the tariffs for for a moment that that ended. I was part of that as well. But I think the quality thing was something that's been present for, you know, for even into 5 years now. >> I would say this and trustees correct me if I'm around because I'm going to paraphrase Greystone a little bit. Obviously they've been keeping an eye on Lazard. Yeah, I'm asked a few quarters. I remember him saying that he's looking for a higher quality run and that's where you got catch up. >> Right. That's what that's what Page 18 is all about. Those. >> Yeah, you know that we've we've we've had the negative of the green line down in our hopefully poised the lowest point on the page. >> To spring up with the performing line. >> I just want to tag on what question was that the reason you don't make the bench where you have hit the benchmark was because of high quality. And you mentioned are performing and you mentioned you're not going to change. We're not going to change that. Now. I just want think that's what you're hired. As for that's what people hire us for. >> And we're going to keep doing that. No changes in ownership decision makers. You know, the team is intact. Right team this team is We did hire a new CEO of the asset Management piece. He came from Alliance Bernstein and we we literally announced that. >> A week and a half ago, he'll start sometime in December. When are less CEO retired 3 years ago. The CFO of the overall company took over as CEO of Asset Management. They came from the investment banking side. This person you know. Investment person, so to speak, which we think is, you know, really positive. And he's, you know, got a great reputation. And frankly, we didn't know he was available. So his name is Chris whole been and will at the end of the year. And you might even see him at something because he likes to get out and talk talk to clients. He doesn't manage the portfolio, but he will manage the the investment side of the business as well as our side of the business and in terms of ownership were publicly held company on the near Thank you very We do. Thanks for the and I was. >> Obviously had some question about it and you covered those. Apprec

All meeting actions

Source coverage incomplete

11 meeting items captured. The published sources do not prove this is the complete docket.

Showing 11 of 11

Browse by category11 actions

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
Agenda packetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Action agendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Transcript or captionsSource recordingread transcript
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Coverage and corrections

Records considered

  • Firefighters' Pension Plan Board of Trustees Regular Meeting — Minutes
  • Firefighters' Pension Plan Board of Trustees Regular Meeting
  • Firefighters' Pension Plan Board of Trustees Regular Meeting — Closed Captions

Not claimed by this page

  • Verified meeting decisions with item-specific public-source evidence
  • A medium- or high-grade, non-procedural agenda-item analysis for the meeting digest
  • Item-linked, attributed deliberation
  • A source-grounded next meeting date
  • A plain-English overview is not available.
  • Official outcomes have not been published.
  • The available transcript has no reliable timestamps.
  • Transcript coverage is partial.
  • Speakers have not been reliably matched to public profiles.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.
  • An individual roll-call roster is not available.
  • Low-grade, ungraded, procedural, or superseded items remain in the complete agenda inventory rather than the meeting digest.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: 3e0f4a8ffa0719b69296205b92548a55. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record