POLISCOPE

The public record

REDDING (SHASTA COUNTY)Held · official record pendingPartial coverage

Aug 4, 2025 5:15 PM - Redding City Council - Special Meeting

Monday, August 4, 2025 · Government meeting record

The 30-second read

Record incomplete

Aug 4, 2025 5:15 PM - Redding City Council - Special Meeting

Why it matters

The official meeting record is available below. Item-level plain-language summaries are not available yet.

What happens next

The scheduled meeting date has passed. Minutes or an action agenda are not published in the records we hold.

This meeting date has passed and no official outcome record has been published yet. Nothing on this page is a decision.

Record text

No transcript is held for this meeting. Recording: Media

>>[ NO AUDIO ] >> We're back from closed session and there is no reportable action. We will just continue on since this is a special election or I mean, a special meeting. Yeah, no, sorry, that's tomorrow. Yeah. So, we are ready then for Julie presentation regarding the state of the Civic Auditorium. Welcome, Julie. >> Can everybody hear me, okay? >> Yes, ma'am. >> Okay. Make sure I know what I'm doing here. Good evening, Mayor Munns, members of the council, staff and the community. Tonight, I'd like to take us on a little journey to remind us of where we've been, spotlight what advanced writing has achieved, and share where we are today. 2025 marks the 55th anniversary of the Civic. From 1970, when Ray Charles headlined the grand opening, to today, the Civic has provided five decades of concerts, conventions, graduations, fundraisers, and many unforgettable moments. In the past two months alone, our little corner of the northern riverfront campus has played host to over 25,000 people for everything from Alabama and Sam Hunt on the lawn to Allison Krause and Death Cab for Cudi indoors, and of course, community staples like 3 on 3 basketball, Parson's graduation, and of course the Freedom Festival. If we turn the clock back a little bit a lot of times I hear, well, how did we get a Civic auditorium anyway? And the story for how we got ours is really a great one. The short version of which is because Carl Williams had a hundred-year vision for our city. But if you just look at more general terms, cities build venues like the Civic for two reasons. To drive economy and for a quality of life. It's dollars and meaning, an economic engine and a community heartbeat. When done right, they deliver on both and help make our community a place we all want to live. Now, as we'll all probably remember, by 2011, the Civic wasn't really delivering on either. Programming was sparse and closure was on the table. The notion of it being an economy driver was not even a consideration, but clearly it held the heartbeat of this community. Faced with possible closure, Reading showed up by the hundreds lining up to say this place matters. Still, without an economic justification, how could city leadership defend keeping it open? It's at this point in our story that advance writing enters the scene. In response to a request for proposal, advance writing was formed and came forward with a Truly unique proposition. A lease agreement where the city would retain ownership and we would become the tenant and the operator. This wasn't an economic strategy or a revitalization plan. It was a kind of triage. A lease designed to answer one question. How do we keep it open? This lease had three core objectives. The first of which was to relieve the city of a financial burden, sublease the space for Bethel's first year school program and keep the doors open to the public for a whopping 20 days a year. It was a lease for survival. Now of all we had done was check those three boxes. We would have met our contractual obligations. But that was not enough. Not for the city, our community, and not for our mission. We learned pretty early on that no one was going to invest in Redding like we would. Not an event organizer, an outside promoter, a conference broker, OVG, Live Nation, AEG, no one. If we wanted the business, we were going to have to go after it. But here's the hard part. The industries we serve all assume we have the financial backing of our city. Their pricing models and deal evaluations reflect that. They take it for granted that the programming is the loss leader. And we have General Fund or ToT allocations undergirding our operations. Even at the local level, there's a market threshold for pricing that's largely set by the hotels, the casino, and honestly how the city used to price the room. But we didn't let that stop us. Like, okay, if that's what it takes, then we found a way to navigate functioning something like a fully funded city owned venue, fronting risk, building the business, delivering results on our own again, not because we had to. It's what was required to understand what opportunities exist for this building in this market. Our work over the last 13 years has been truly transformative. We have expanded programming, we've diversified it and we realigned it to optimize economic output. And we started asking the right questions. What does impact look like? And what does sustainability require? We've come a long way from our talent buyers. First day on the job, sitting down, going through a Rolodex only to find out there was the contact information for one individual, a midget wrestling promoter. Those early days of cold calling typically started with now. Where are you calling from again? Who are you? The Reading Civic. What it was a steep learning curve and a steep acquisition curve. For the live entertainment line of business, being willing to pay an artist fee is simply the price of admission for the real conversation. What comes next is a test of our skill? Our integrity and our ability to take care of people. Early on, an agent said to us, writing is never about the money until it is. What he meant by that was for small markets, the real question is, can we make it easy for them? And are we reliable? It's about trust, and that's what we've built persistently, consistently. The feedback tells the story. Wow, you guys really know what you're doing. You made this feel like a day off. And we didn't know we could expect this in Redding. That shift didn't just happen. We earned it. All of that work has paid off on both fronts. On the economy side, in the last 12 months alone, our $6 million investment in programming and operations has resulted in over 100,000 attendees, 540 jobs supported, over 25,000 room nights. More than $315,000 contributed to TOT, $7 million in total tax revenues generated, and a total of $84.3 million in economic output. In simpler terms, for every $1 advance reading has invested, the community received a 14x return. In more recent days, conversations in the industry have started peppering lines like we're rooting for you. Your important partners, and we hope you make it. That hope you make it line, it's not casual. It speaks to the dynamics of a national landscape. In June of this year, the National Independent Venue association released the State of Live report. It's a first of its kind industry report focused on independent venues like us. The good news? In 2024, independent venues contributed more to the national GDP than beer, gaming, and the airline industries combined. The bad news? 64% of the venues that generated that GDP are struggling with profitability. Artist fees, marketing, insurance, labor costs are up across the board. Sponsorship, alcohol sales, ticket revenues are down. Consolidation and monopolistic environments are squeezing independence hard. Economic headwinds and industry shifts are affecting everyone. So clearly the volatility that advanced Redding faces in the landscape isn't unique to us. What is unique is the quality of our work. That work is so good that if we'd actually had the kind of financial backing that normal city venues do, we'd be here tonight talking about being part of that 36% that is profitable in Redding. We'd actually be talking about being standouts in that percentage because we'd still be pulling off outsized results in a smaller market with fewer resources. But that's not why we're here tonight. Tonight, we're here with just a couple of asks. The first is getting tongue tied. We're requesting the city Release the monies that were set aside for the Civic from the sale of the land to the Sheraton. And we're asking the city to reimagine its relationship with the Civic and help us build a framework for the future. Because the Civic, this building matters not just for the dollars it drives, but for the true wealth it brings and shared experiences and a sense of belonging. Thank you for your time. >> Questions, anybody? Let's move on into public comment. The city council allow up to max. Yes, of course. >> In your ask one, the release of. You can keep me on task here. If I go off. Release of funds from the Sheraton sale. Do you have what that request is going towards? Like you're asking release the funds to the Civic so that we could. >> Yeah. The ask is really about a stopgap to help us get to whatever the next conversation is going to be. Yep. >> So, can you specify and maybe city manager can clarify this further, the funds you're talking about, how much are the funds and how much is your ask from that fund and where is that fund right now? >> The Fund is about $675,000 and it's held in an equipment replacement account. >> Okay. >> Has that been account. >> Okay. >> It's not an equipment replacement. >> That's fine. >> Yeah. >> This may be just a good time to mention since it's not only for presentation, you're not able to have any action. You're not really able to debate the item or too much detail either. If you're interested, you could raise us on item 12 and ask staff to bring something back for a future meeting where we can agendize. >> Perfect. >> Okay. >> Okay. Thank you, Julie. The City Council will allocate up to a maximum of three minutes per speaker for 30 minutes total, at the beginning of the meeting for Public Comment for non-agendized matters within the City's jurisdiction. The mayor will determine the order of the speakers. If 30 minutes is not adequate to accommodate all of the individuals who have submitted their name through the electronic kiosk, the Council will trail this item to the end of the open session agenda. The remaining speakers will address the City Council at that time. It looks like we have one speaker for Robert. >> Good evening. I'd like to briefly speak on a few items. We have a budget shortfall, the need for an open house or other informal gathering where councilmember Audette can speak to the issues and make a report from public records. Seems to be in order. Seems there is disagreement and I'm confused. Her reasoning seems valid. I need to see the information clearly articulated and succinctly delivered. I suspect many others in the community would appreciate that. Frankly, I think you're allowing yourselves to be under the influence of a manipulative, opportunistic city manager who for several years have adroitly managed to have three councilmen by his side at all times. Secondly, the alternative custody facility needs to happen. Since our inept board failed to prioritize a jail, instead spending their time and resources on non-issues and conspiracy theories and choosing to fight the state on our dime. We need to support Sheriff Johnson's initiative to have a facility away from downtown. Please make this happen. Third, I'd like to thank Councilman Littell for being the only one to respond to my concerns regarding the dying off and neglect of trees within city limits. Thanks for making the palms at the park a priority. It is only a matter of time before heavy winds combined with dead fronds will cause debris to fall and with that, damage to property or God forbid, injury to residents. I mentioned and documented this a year ago and nothing's happened. Thanks for the follow up. You did follow up with me. Thanks, Mike. Lastly, for the third year in a row, I appeal to you reinstate Columbus Day, a federally recognized holiday. In Reading. The reason I got from a councilman as to why you canceled Columbus was a smokescreen and seemed disingenuous. I know we live in an area of loud revisionist activism, but I urge you to please reinstate our national holiday and don't allow politics, special interests or monetary donations to dissuade you from making the right patriotic decision. Thank you. >> Thanks for allowing me a minute. I tried to enter my name but work on the user interface out there. Hey, I'm here on behalf of my role I play at Advanced Redding. So, I joined the board, I think four or five years ago with the idea that we knew there was going to be changes in Advanced Redding. For those of you who don't know, my name is Eric Hyatt. I'm a local business person. I've founded and exited a couple successful companies and have some real estate in town. And I have a software company, so I'm a business guy. But I started on the board about four or five years ago and I really came in because we knew that that advanced writing was going to have to go through some changes. We knew that the SSM, that's the school, was going to leave eventually and we'd have to transition and figure out stuff when we came to that point. And so, we did the transition and it went really smooth and they have been out now for a little over a year, I believe. And I think things are going really well since they left. But, you know, things have changed also. And the biggest thing I think I wanted to share is I'm very familiar with the staff that operates the Civic. You know, I'm a part of the board that's an unpaid board, and I, you know, they're hustling over there. They're doing an amazing job and they're doing absolutely everything they can and they're bringing a huge value to reading. My wife and I are working really into concerts. You know, we belong to the Brit Festival. We're up in Bandit concerts. We're in Ashton. A lot for music in the South Bay. And it's super important to me and I think it's super important to our quality of life. And I think advanced reading staff just kills it in that realm. Also, economic impact is super important to me. I think it's important that reading stays relevant and I think that the Advanced Redding brings a lot of high-quality economic impact to the area. So really, I just wanted to support what they're asking for. I know it's not fun. I know it kind of stinks. I can't imagine all the things that the city council and the decisions that they have to make right now, but the alternative to this is not good. And, you know, I can do the work to shut it down, but I don't want to. And I think it's. I think that we wouldn't be asking this if it wasn't serious. And I think that's all I have. I'd be glad to answer questions. >> Appreciate it. All right, we'll move on. >> Mayor, can I just. One quick comment from the previous speaker. I respect your opinion, but I also want to express my faith in our manager that he does things with good interest of public in mind and our city council can always analyze things. >> Thank you. All right. The Consent Calendar contains items considered routine and/or which have been individually scrutinized by City Council Members and are anticipated to require no further deliberation. If a member of the public wishes to address an item on the Consent Calendar, please enter your name in the electronic kiosk located in the lobby before the Consent Calendar is considered. It shall be the prerogative of any Council Member, before the Consent Calendar is acted upon, to: (1) comment on an item; (2) respond to any public comment on an item; (3) request the record reflect an abstention or nay vote on an item; or (4) remove an item and place it on the Regular portion of the agenda for delivery of a staff report and/or an extended discussion or deliberation. All right. Do we have any? No. All right. I think motion. >> I'll make a motion to approve. >> Second. >> All right. First and a second. All in favor? >> Aye. >> Mine's not moving over here, Aaron, but I'm. >> You don't get to vote today. >> Yes, I'm in. I'm a yay. >> We are moving on. City Manager/Assistant City Manager. Consider City of Redding's response to the Shasta County Grand Jury Report regarding the Quartz Hill Subdivision Development. >> Good evening, honorable mayor and members of the council. So, as the mayor has mentioned, the item before you this evening is in regards to a Shasta grand jury report issued on 05-29-2025 titled Court SIL Subdivision development Transparent transparency. Is it clear the report stems from the city's receipt of a community development block grant, disaster recovery grant and the amount of approximately $22.6 million that was accepted by the city council in October of 2022 for the development of an approximately 112-acre city owned parcel that is to be created into single family for sale workforce housing within the grand jury report there are four findings and three recommendations. Staff agreed with two of the findings and then partially disagreed with two of the other findings. Overall, the key is that city staff is listening to the nearby residents and the community as opportunities arise and staff has also held public meetings or provided updates through email or on the city's court so project webpage. In regard to the three recommendations, staff has held two public outreach meetings one in November of 2024 and one in January of 2025. And then as council is aware we held the special meeting in March of 2025 where there was actually a project tour and staff also continues to update the city's project webpage as we progress with the project. The next public meeting will be the planning commission's consideration of the tentative map for the subdivision this week. Staff anticipates that the traffic and evacuation route comments will be submitted to the transportation consultant and the environmental studies should be completed by the end of August. Staff anticipates presenting the subdivision proposal to planning commission in October of this year. The items of concern recommendation number two are part of the of the pre development design analysis those being considered by staff and also the consultant team. The grand jury concluded that there's room for improvement by the city to address concerns of the neighbors and also concerned citizens as well as their ability to access public engagement opportunities. As noted in the city's response letter for recommendation number three. Staff anticipates developing a program or podcast by the end of this calendar year to encourage and educate citizens on how they can. They can have their voices heard in the city regarding land use and property development. City staff has drafted a grand jury response letter which is attached to your packet. This concludes my presentation and I'm available for questions. >> Thank you. >> I have no questions, but I'll make a motion to authorize the mayor to sign and send a response letter. >> I'll second. >> All in favor? >> Aye. >> I'm still frozen. >> Are you frozen, Mike? >> I'm still thinking. Yes. >> Oh, yeah. We're starting to get frozen all over the place here. >> So, do we need to roll call since we're. This thing is not functioning? >> No. She should anyway. >> No. The requirement for a roll call, at least when you have one. Verbal is fine and your rules allow you to essentially do it all at once. >> Okay. All in favor? >> Aye. >> All opposed? Restrain? Paul. 4-1, passes. >> 9.1(b). Consider City of Redding's response to the Shasta County Grand Jury Report regarding Parking. >> Good evening, honorable mayor, members of the council. Similar to Assistant City Manager Bay, I'll be presenting this evening regarding the grand jury report that we received regarding the downtown parking char. Do you have a copy? Thank you. One second, please. There we go. So, a little background here, and I'll piggyback off of some of the information that assistant city manager Bade shared. Back in May, we received our report from the grand jury based on our downtown parking. In accordance with California code 933C there shown above, we are required to respond. In total, the parking program received six findings and six recommendations. The topics generally surrounded program performance, public communication, signage and pay station visibility. Since then, staff have done a number of things, including conducting an internal review of operations. And I should mention there right alongside that one, we do constantly monitor the downtown parking program, including the signs, location and operations. So, I definitely want to make sure that relay that message as well. We also looked into each finding as well as actual program data and the field conditions. And we continued our conversation with the downtown stakeholders. And I mentioned continue because our housing division meets routinely with the downtown business group and a number of public works staff routinely attend that biweekly meeting and listen to questions and comments from that group as well as provide information. And we use that information as key indicators or KPIs, you might say, to help us determine how the program is functioning. Or it's one of our data points. A few key takeaways from the, excuse me, the grand jury report. After review, we came to the conclusion that the program is meeting its intended goals and it is being monitored regularly. However, we do recognize that updates and improvements are consistently being implemented or needed as the parking program morphs and development downtown continues to occur. You may notice in the draft letter that you have before you that each response to the findings and recommendations starts off very specifically, and that is a requirement of California code 933C, which you'll see on the slide up on the upper right-hand side. So those initial responses, although some of them may seem harsh, we are required to respond with lead our responses with one of those and I'll jump into each of those as we move on. So, I'm going to touch on the first two findings and then the one recommendation that in my opinion was really tied to the findings. The first finding really centered around what the grand jury thought was a lack of transparency regarding financial reporting. Our position or recommendation to council is that we disagree with that staff routinely track costs. We look at revenue payment trends. Staff have been before this body as well as previous councils a total of five times between 2023 to 2024. We've been talking about revenue, expenditures, costs, as well as implementing changes as development has occurred downtown. Council may recall that it was probably six months or so ago I was before you, talking about minor adjustments and tweaks that we were making to the downtown parking program in relation to the courthouse relocating. That's part of our ongoing commitment to make sure that as development continues to occur downtown that we're out there and keeping our ears and eyes open and adjusting as necessary. The second finding was similar regarding monitoring and reporting, but really centered along data or performance metrics. You might say, not necessarily the revenue side of things. But are we meeting the goals of the downtown parking program? And I'll remind council or council may recall that really one of the underlying goals or the underlying goal of the program is to have a 15% vacancy rate. So essentially an 85% turnover. And those numbers were strategically picked to ensure that there was always available parking for folks to be able to go downtown and frequent the businesses. Excuse me, and keep that turnover. Initially, when the program, the downtown parking program started, we did commission collecting that data for approximately 18 months from a vendor at the cost of roughly $30,000 a month. And so after the 18-month period was over and we were confident based on the data as well as the feedback we were receiving from the downtown business groups as well as other stakeholders and I would say really our gut as the public works department and going out and monitoring it, we did not feel like that was a prudent expense to continue at that time. However, we do want to leave the door open that as development continues to occur downtown, there may be a time to commission that data again and make sure that we're still functioning as we intended to do so. Based on those two findings, we did get a recommendation from the grand jury recommending that this body you receive quarterly updates regarding the financials and the performance of the downtown parking program. The draft response you have before you state that we will not implement that and we will continue with the trend that we have been which is roughly providing you data every six months or so. Now obviously this body can, if they like, ask for data every quarter or four months. This is your prerogative. But we felt like adequate information was being shared to both this body and the general public as well as the information that we get out through Director Many's communications teams and the communications that we do with the local business's groups and other businesses downtown. So, I'm going to move on to the other four findings and corresponding ultimately corresponding recommendations and I will jump through these ones a little bit quicker just in the essence of time. But in my opinion, findings 3 and 4 and 5 and 6 really hover around the size, the shape, the location and the color of our sign package out there. And I say it explicitly that way because it really does matter. There was a lot of thought that went into the location and the size and the shape to make sure that we were providing adequate signage for the traveling public to locate a parking stall as well as for them to be able to find the pay kiosk and or locate the signs that provide information on how to download the pay app or text the phone number park reading so they can get the one time use text message back and then go to the website. There are a number of signage standards that our signs do need to comply with. One of them is the California Manual on Uniform Traffic Control Devices. It is a mouthful, but it is referred to as the California MUTCD. In a nutshell, what that is talking about is that certain colors are reserved for certain types of signs and I think intuitively most folks are aware of that just by driving around. Typically, black on white are your regulatory signs. The one that Chief Barner and his team enforce. We have black on orange for construction zones, we have black on yellow for warning signs. And then we have the greens and blues and browns and other signs that are for more recreation and other types of non-regulatory reasons. And for that reason, we really have stuck with a color scheme because we do not want to jump out of compliance with the California MUTCD specifically on colors. Now, regarding size and location, there's more flexibility and we've taken that liberty and tried to go bigger and more than are required to make sure that we're putting adequate signs out there. But at the same time, we are careful to put too many signs out there to where we're flooding the streets with signage that folks don't have enough time to process or there becomes clutter downtown. So, there is a balance there. Now you might recall on the previous slide I mentioned that there is the continuous improvement and you will see here the picture on the top right. This is the current parking lot at California and Placer. This is one of the locations that we have had plans to bolster the parking entrance signs at and that the grand jury is ultimately recommending that we do. And we do agree with that and are in process of implementing larger parking signs at that location. So, I think that is an example of one of the things that we agree with the grand jury finding one of the other things that they noticed on. I just touch on this briefly again before we move on kiosks. The grand jury found that it was once you were in a parking lot, it was hard to locate the pay kiosk itself either because there were large vehicles in front of it and folks couldn't see it or the signs weren't readily available. So, we partially disagree with that because we feel like the kiosks are readily visible. However, there are a few locations and again this is why we partially disagree where we have gone out and raised the sign to make it higher so it's easier seen from a farther distance as well as add reflective tape and a few other things to those locations. So, I kind of let the cat out of the bag on the previous slide. But again, I'll run through a few of the recommendations and what we're doing. Recommendation two, which again these recommendations are really based on findings three through six. Recommendation two was labeling off street lots. Our response to that is this will be implemented. We're adding A number of 30 by 42 parking lot signage similar to what you see directly to the right. Recommendation three, there was a recommendation to add using air quotes, you are here maps and provide wayfinding. Similar to what you might see in a mall that would indicate where you're standing and where restrooms and entrances and certain shopping centers are. And we will not be implementing that as recommended or we're recommending that you don't do that. Because they had recommended that approximately 40 of those signs be placed. We recommend placing four of them at the existing locations that are shown on the bottom right of the slide that have already been placed at strategic locations and we'll Update those recommendations 4 and 5 again talked about improving the sign size, color and location and again, as I described or discussed a few moments ago, this will not be implemented. But that is truly because we have very little flexibility on the color. Our hands are tied to stay in compliance with the California MITCD. However, we are always looking at location improvements or making the signs larger at the same time balancing the downtown clutter. So, there will be strategic improvements there for recommendations four and five. And then finally the sixth recommendation, making kiosks more visible. We have already taken care of this. We identified a number of locations where we felt like the kiosks were a bit too hard to see and, in those locations, we've installed the signs at a higher elevation and add reflective taping and a few other minor things to improve the visibility of those signs once you are in the lot. And with that I conclude my presentation and I'm available for any questions. >> Thank you, Mr. Webb. >> I'll make a motion to approve. >> I'll second. >> All right, no more questions. >> All in favor? >> Aye. >> Motion passes 5-0. >> Thank you, Mr. Webb. And lastly, 9.2(b). Consider Market Street Manor Rehabilitation Financing Agreement. Ms. Nicole. Where's everybody going? It's not time to leave. Meeting's not over. >> Good evening, Honorable Mayor, Members of the City council. Agenda item 9.2(b) this evening pertains to the funding and corresponding rehabilitation financing agreement with Project Restoration for the redevelopment of the Market Street Manor at 2171 Market Street. Recently, the Trump administration released a policy initiative entitled Ending Crime and Disorder on American Streets. This action plan outlines a shift in federal priorities related to homelessness, mental illness and substance abuse disorders and calls for the increased funding for treatment, recovery and accountability based homeless programs. While eliminating federal support for the Housing first model. The action plan also emphasizes transitional housing approaches that promote sobriety, personal responsibility and self-sufficiency. In light of this federal policy direction as well as the State of California's current priorities, it is increasingly important to support projects aligned with these goals. City Council previously authorized staff to negotiate a $1.2 million agreement to assist in the conversion of the Market Street Manor Motel from a motel into permanent housing. Since that time, a few changes have occurred in the project structure. Funding initially anticipated for the project did not materialize and CNM Opportunities, the current property owner, has opted to restructure ownership by transferring the property to Project Restoration, a nonprofit service provider currently operating the Sober Living Transitional Housing program at the Manor that offers residents life skills training, accountability, mentorship and a strong sense of community, all aimed at supporting long term recovery and preventing relapse. Project Restoration will acquire the property from CNM opportunities for $2 million. This acquisition will be financed through a $1.1 million loan through Five Star bank and a seller carryback loan from CNM opportunities for $900,000. Staff now proposes a $1.5 million Housing and Homeless Incentive Program Fund rehab loan, an increase from the original 1.2 million previously discussed, to support the conversion of the property into permanent apartment units. The loan would carry a 1% interest rate over a 20-year term. Repayment will only be required if the project generates a positive cash flow. Understandably, Council may have concerns that the debt on the property exceeds its current appraised value. While the concern is valid, it's typical for the Housing division to take a subordinate position in income restricted housing transactions. Housing also typically assumes a higher risk in such deals, not for financial return, but to address critical community challenges, particularly those that align with federal and local priorities, such as transitional housing for homeless individuals in recovery. Staff respectfully recommends that City council approve the staff report recommendations and this concludes the presentation. I'm available for any questions. >> Thank you, Nicole. Yes, please. >> My understanding is that the seller and buyer both are related parties in this transaction. Is that correct? >> Robert Kroneck is the managing partner of CNM Opportunities as well as the CEO of Project Restoration. >> And they are second and City's third on. >> Yeah. >> TNM Opportunities has a seller carry back loan in second position at $900,000. >> I believe this is a good project and I want to see this succeed. But that does give me some concern. The City being third on the lien as well as two related parties having this transaction. The second note of 900,000. I do not know what their interest rates are. Do you know? >> Yes. The interest rates for both the first and the second are 7%. >> Okay, so that's my concern. That is that something which I don't know if other people are concerned about both parties being related and city being subordinate to their Node. >> I don't have concerns only because this has been, they've been doing this for a while and as a nonprofit, they'll get more access to grants if it's. And because they've committed to making it for the needs of those that need housing. And with all the different grants that happen, there are just different specifications from the state. So, to get that help and to actually do what the city's asking us to do, we don't have a ton of nonprofits that we can work with when it comes to housing. And that is the focus. We're trying to get people like in more permanent style housing where it's like you're renting a very small apartment essentially. And in order to convert that, they have to do a bunch of underground, like a bunch of upgrades to the plumbing that the city has required them to do. So, part of this is like we've required them to spend more. We're trying to give them a way to pay for that so that they can come up to code and it can actually function the way they want it to function. So, we've been working at this for a while, and if this is the way that it happens, then they're in a good position to do that. It's just that they're transitioning to a nonprofit where it was just a private entity doing it fully all by themselves and now it's going to balance the two. >> One other thing that we actually did in the deal was we've only, we're only going to be placing restrictions on 16 of the units, which means that the other units in the complex, if they wanted to, if they're running into a problem with cash flow, they could rent those units at market rate and they could get folks in there that have Section 8 vouchers and they would be able to have more of a positive cash flow. As it is right now, the cash flow for the project based on 98% occupancy at a fair market value of just shy of $1,000 for a studio unit, it is cash flowing for various operational costs as well as payments on the first and the second loan. So, I mean, at this point, but that also depends on the, you know, what their occupancy rate is. But there is a built-in way for them to increase cash flow through the project if they needed to. And also, another thing that we could do that we've done in the past on certain loans is we can actually record a document with recorder's office that if the first, if like say five-star bank is going into foreclosure on the first loan. We would be notified by the clerk's office that there has been an action, a foreclosure action. So, we would know if that first loan was not the payments weren't being made. >> Right. But we would still be subordinate to the second loan. That's my concern that why can we be the second and CNM Opportunities LLC can be third. >> If that's your direction and would like for us to negotiate that, we can most certainly do that. However, you know, in the past we've, we're comfortable with taking risk with these funds and then second to that our affordability covenants will actually be in first position prior to the grant deed on the property. So, we won't actually ever lose the affordability through a foreclosure action. >> Right, but the reason I'm saying is. >> You're worried about money. >> No. Not only money part, but because it's a unique transaction because the seller and buyer are related parties. That's why my personal preference and any business transaction would be that if they're related parties they should be third to the city. >> They're elected positions. >> No related because they're the same people who own the property right now and who's going to be running the nonprofit. So that's why I'm saying city should be second. My position is city should be second on the note and they can be third. >> Yeah, I'm alright the way it's written. >> Could I make one comment real quick? So, I think it's important also to note that the reason that they structured the deal this way is that the other partner that we had prior stepped out of the deal. So, the owner is bringing additional funds beyond that $750,000 that was in the previous deal, making up a gap there. And then also the city is bringing in additional funds. Prices have gone up and so I think it demonstrates the effort of the owner just to try and make this program work. This is not an easy property to manage and there's a lot of money at risk with this. And so that's why we were willing to put that owner at second position. And we know over time that our grant funded loan is going to be stronger as that project performs well. These tenants have an income from zero to $800 a month and so there's not a way to guarantee the cash flow. So that's why we structured this way. >> Yeah, I mean any other case I would have absolutely no concern just in this case because of related part. That's my concern. >> Councilmember Reserve. >> I was simply going to say that in a normal situation where we not dealing with affordable housing, I think that your concerns are completely valid. However, I think that what Mr. Bain said and what Councilmember Audette stand. And so, I will make a motion to approve. >> Sorry, Mr. Mayor, if I could just add the danger of telling the council something you all already know. I've probably annoyed Mr. Bain to no end in talking about loan position and subordination agreements. But one of the things that is of particular significance in this area is that the programs are essentially designed and they're frequently agreed to subordination of loans essentially as a form of subsidy. The idea is that the government loan program is taking a position within these transactions that is riskier than your commercial lender generally will. And that's the underlying sort of subsidy function. Just want to make sure you've got that context. Ultimately, you got to make the decisions. >> I perfectly understand that and I wouldn't have even questioned it if there was not the issue of related parties first. >> I'll second. >> All in favor? >> Aye. >> All right, all 5. >> Thank you. We shall move on. Any council travel reports we talk about? All right, seeing none. Item 12. I'll start with this one then. I think we probably have a consensus, but we'd like to see it come back for the Civic Advanced. >> Ready? >> Yeah. >> I presume with that comment you would appreciate a number of alternatives. >> So, you know, obviously you could loan it, you could give it, you could put strings on it. So, I presume the council would like to have several different options to consider. >> Yes, I would. >> Are we just going to talk about the loan? Are we also going to talk about restructuring their deal later? >> No. >> Well, the restructuring is a long-term thing, so I figured that would come back. >> It does it come back together. >> We could put that also just on the staff report. I think that that's a much bigger conversation that we probably could have that single meeting, but we could certainly, certainly put that on the staff report. So, you could have some discussion about that and decide sort of the next directions on that element as well. >> Yeah. >> Even if we could just have like what the terms are and what that is and maybe a little bit of back history. Even if we're not voting on that aspect. If we just actually understood it and had that information and then can we according to the report, you might want to have a parking charge at the Civic that might help with your cash flow. That's. There's some reason. Okay. I'm just saying. I'm just saying. Might want to start charging for parking. >> Yeah. >> Just in summary, so what we'll bring back is an element that would discuss options for the $675,000 and also ask for recommendations on next steps relative to the restructure possibility. >> Sounds good to me. >> Okay, great. Anything else? >> We had asked in the past meetings to bring back the riverfront specific plan at some point of time. And do you know the timeline for that and also for the south city park status and what the future plans are? >> Yeah. So, as far as the department's overview, we've got a schedule for once per month. The next one, which will be August 19, will be the Parks Department, and they will be talking about all thing's parks. >> Thank you. All right, we are adjourned.

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
AgendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Agenda packetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Action agendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
MinutesNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Transcript or captionsNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Recording and media

Official pages

Coverage and corrections

Records considered

  • Aug 4, 2025 5:15 PM - Redding City Council - Special Meeting — Closed Captions

Not claimed by this page

  • Verified meeting decisions with item-specific public-source evidence
  • Item-level plain-language summaries are not available; this page does not infer individual agenda items.
  • Item-linked, attributed deliberation
  • A source-grounded next meeting date
  • A plain-English overview is not available.
  • Official outcomes have not been published.
  • A transcript is not available.
  • Speakers have not been reliably matched to public profiles.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.
  • An individual roll-call roster is not available.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: 3da43f99a49a4f31019216d884a1d054. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record