POLISCOPE

The public record

PUNTAGORDA (CHARLOTTE COUNTY) · LOCALDecisions publishedPartial coverage

Historic Preservation Advisory Board

Thursday, June 26, 2025 · Government meeting record

The 30-second read

Recorded outcome

Historic Preservation Advisory Board

Why it matters

The official meeting record is available below. Item-level plain-language summaries are not available yet.

What happens next

No later meeting or follow-up date is stated in the reviewed record.

An official outcome record - an action agenda or minutes - is published for this meeting.

Record text

No recording or transcript is held for this meeting.

CITY OF PUNTA GORDA, FLORIDA HISTORIC PRESERVATION ADVISORY BOARD MEETING MINUTES JUNE 26, 2025, 9:00 A.M. 120 LAISHLEY COURT PUNTA GORDA, FL 33950 MEMBERS PRESENT: David Perry, Chair Teresa Desguin, Dawn Goode, Beth Magnin, Charles Noble, Lucille Ponte, Stephen Valdes CITY STAFF PRESENT: Rachel Barry, Zoning Official; Hank Flores, Urban Design Manager; Alexandra Friend, Board Recorder CALL TO ORDER Mr. Perry called the meeting to order at 9:04 a.m., followed by the Pledge of Allegiance. PUBLIC COMMENTS Ms. Nancy Johnson spoke about the A.C. Freeman House, recalling multiple organizations meeting with the Board to discuss options for same. She noted an inventory was taken for the contents of the A.C. Freeman House, stating she would provide same to the Board. 1) APPROVAL OF MINUTES 1.a May 22, 2025, Meeting Minutes. Exhibits: Cover Page May 22, 2025, Minutes Mr. Noble MOVED to approve the May 22, 2025, minutes, SECONDED by Ms. Ponte. MOTION CARRIED UNANIMOUSLY. 2) CERTIFICATES OF APPROPRIATENESS 2.a CA-25-2025 - 509 Palm Avenue, Demolition - Action Required Exhibits: Cover Page 1 - CA-25-2025 - 509 Palm Avenue_A MEM_HPAB.pdf 2 - CA-25-2025 - 509 Palm Avenue - Application.pdf 3 - PRC.pdf 4 - CA-25-2025 - 509 Palm Avenue - Analysis.pdf 5 - CA-25-2025 - 509 Palm Avenue - Current Pictures.pdf 6 - Streetview 1.pdf 7 - Streetview 2.pdf Mr. Hank Flores, Urban Design Manager, reviewed the application for demolition, noting staff recommended approval of same.

Ms. Ponte questioned if the homeowner had explored opportunities to salvage the home. Mr. Adam Riley, LTD Contracting, replied affirmatively, noting the damage to the home was extensive from the past 3 hurricanes. NOTE: Ms. Magnin left the dais at 9:11 a.m. Ms. Goode stated the property was adjacent to her own, disclosing ex parte communications and a site visit. She expressed concern that there was a home identical to this structure that was being restored. She suggested the home may be repairable, acknowledging the interiors of the twin structures may not be in similar condition. She expressed empathy for the struggle of the homeowner, questioning how the Board could justify approving a request for demolition when an identical structure was being restored. NOTE: Ms. Magnin returned to the dais at 9:14 a.m. Mr. Riley questioned if an engineering report was provided for the other property. Ms. Goode replied with uncertainty, expressing a desire to create a fair environment for all requests. Mr. Riley stated the property owner had been displaced from their home for 2 years, opining all the vacant properties were not beneficial to the City. He stated the condition of the home called for demolition as opposed to preservation. Ms. Goode suggested the neighboring properties would flood more frequently if the home were rebuilt at a higher elevation. Mr. Riley stated a stem wall would be used which allowed for proper drainage. Ms. Goode questioned if stem walls were allowed for new builds in the City. Mr. Riley opined the only way for homeowners to avoid future flooding in the City was to elevate. Mr. Noble opined the burden on the resident should be considered. Ms. Desguin disclosed a site visit, stating it appeared no work had been done in the home since Hurricane Ian, opining the demolition request was due to neglect. Mr. Riley stated the property owner was limited to actions they could take after Hurricane Ian due to their insurance provider. Ms. Goode opined the Board should not consider property owners’ fiscal situations when the goal was historic preservation. Mr. Riley opined the Board should consider the effect that vacant structures and residents living in RVs on their properties could have on property values within the City. He stated the foundation of the home would have to be fixed and all the historic elements would be replaced with newer materials if the property were repaired, opining it would not keep its historic significance either way. Note: Mr. Noble left the dais at 9:27 a.m. Ms. Magnin inquired whether the home could be moved. Mr. Riley replied he had experience with moving homes; however, this home was not a good candidate for same. Ms. Goode questioned how much it cost to have a home moved. Mr. Riley replied with uncertainty. NOTE: Mr. Noble returned to the dais at 9:30 a.m.

Ms. Ponte noted declining the request would only lead to an 18-month delay, questioning the benefit of subjecting the property owner to same. She recalled previous demolition requests denied by the Board had been due to an engineering analysis not being provided, opining it was not within the Board’s purview to argue with the stance of professionals. Mr. Valdes stated the Historic District should be a beautiful and welcoming area, opining he would prefer to see a new home with a historic look than a vacant home that was an eyesore. Ms. Ponte MOVED to recommend approval of the application, SECONDED by Mr. Noble. AYE: Magnin, Noble, Perry, Ponte, Valdes NAY: Goode, Desguin MOTION CARRIED. Ms. Goode cited her reason for a nay vote was due to the twin structure that was being restored. Ms. Desguin cited her reason for a nay vote was due to her considering this demolition request to be based on neglect. 2.b CA-36-2025 - 124 McGregor Street, Windows and Doors - Action Required Exhibits: Cover Page 1 - CA-36-2025 - 124 McGregor Street_MEM_HPAB.pdf 2 - CA-36-2025 - 124 McGregor Street - Application.pdf 3 - CA-36-2025 - 124 McGregor Street - Specifications.pdf 4 - PRC.pdf 5 - Streetview 1.pdf 6 - Streetview 2.pdf Mr. Flores reviewed the application for window and door replacements, noting staff recommended approval of same. Ms. Desguin MOVED to recommend approval of the application, SECONDED by Ms. Goode. MOTION CARRIED UNANIMOUSLY. 2.c CA - 28-2025 457 W Virginia Avenue - Windows and Doors Exhibits: Cover Page 1 - CA-28-2025_457 West Virginia Avenue_AMEM_HPAB.pdf 2 - CA-28-2025 - 457 West Virginia - Application.pdf 3 - PRC.pdf 4 -Q Streetview 1.pdf 5 -R Streetview 2.pdf 6 - Streetview 3.pdf Mr. Flores reviewed the application for window and door replacements, noting staff recommended approval of same. Ms. Desguin MOVED to recommend approval of the application, SECONDED by Ms. Ponte. MOTION CARRIED UNANIMOUSLY.

2.d CA-29-2025 - 314 Tamiami Trail, Sign - Action Required Exhibits: Cover Page 1 - CA-29-2025_314 Tamiami Trail_MEM_HPAB.pdf 2 - CA-29-2025 - 314 Tamiami Trail - Application.pdf 3 - Signage Documents.pdf 4 - PRC.pdf 5 - Streetview 1.pdf 6 - Streetview 2.pdf Mr. Flores reviewed the application for proposed signage, noting staff recommended approval of same. Ms. Ponte MOVED to recommend approval of the application, SECONDED by Ms. Desguin. MOTION CARRIED UNANIMOUSLY. 2.e CA-30-2025 - 515 Palm Avenue, Exterior Door - Action Required Exhibits: Cover Page 1 - CA-30-2025_515 Palm Avenue_MEM_HPAB.pdf 2 - CA-30-2025 - 515 Palm Avenue - Application.pdf 3 - PRC.pdf 4 - Streetview 1.pdf 5 - Streetview 2.pdf Mr. Flores reviewed the application for exterior door replacement, noting staff recommended approval of same. Ms. Goode MOVED to recommend approval of the application, SECONDED by Ms. Magnin. MOTION CARRIED UNANIMOUSLY. 2.f CA-31-2025 - 512 East Marion Avenue, Door - Action Required Exhibits: Cover Page 1 - CA-31-2025_512 East Marion Avenue_MEM_HPAB.pdf 2 - CA-31-2025 - 512 East Marion Avenue - Application.pdf 3 - PRC.pdf 4 - Warranty Deed.pdf 5 - Window Specifications.pdf 6 - Window Placement.pdf 7 - Streetview 1.pdf Mr. Flores reviewed the application for window replacement, noting staff recommended approval of same. Ms. Ponte confirmed with Mr. Flores that the door replacement for this agenda item was in error. Mr. Noble MOVED to recommend approval of the application, SECONDED by Ms. Desguin. MOTION CARRIED UNANIMOUSLY. 2.g CA-33-2025 - 221 Durance Street, Roof - Action Required

Exhibits: Cover Page 1 - CA-33-2025_221 Durrance Street_MEM_HPAB.pdf 2 - CA-33-2025 - 221 Durrance Street - Application.pdf 3 - PRC.pdf 4 - CA-33-2025 - 221 Durrance Street - Specifications.pdf 5 - Streetview 1.pdf 6 - Streetview 2.pdf Mr. Flores reviewed the application for roof replacement, noting staff recommended approval of same. Ms. Magnin MOVED to recommend approval of the application, SECONDED by Mr. Noble. MOTION CARRIED UNANIMOUSLY. 2.h CA-34-2025 - 301 W Marion Avenue, Door - Action Required Exhibits: Cover Page 1 - CA-34-2025_301 West Marion Avenue_MEM_HPAB.pdf 2 - CA-34-2025 - 301 West Marion Avenue - Application.pdf 3 - CA-34-2025 - 301 West Marion Avenue - Specifications.pdf 4 - CA-34-2025 - Warranty Deed.pdf 4 - Streetview 1.pdf 5 - Streetview 2.pdf 6 - Streetview 3.pdf 7 - Streetview 4.pdf Mr. Flores reviewed the application for stair and landscaping upgrades and removal of 2 nonstructural walls, noting staff recommended approval of same. Ms. Ponte MOVED to recommend approval of the application, SECONDED by Ms. Magnin. MOTION CARRIED UNANIMOUSLY. 2.i CA-35-2025 - 322 East Grace Street, Demo - Action Required Exhibits: Cover Page 1 - CA-35-2025 - 322 East_Grace_Street_MEM_HPAB.pdf 2 - CA-35-2025 - 322 East Grace Street - Application.pdf 3 - CA-35-2025 - 322 East Grace Street - Structural Report.pdf 4 - PRC.pdf 5 - Streetview 1.pdf 6 - Streetview 2.pdf Mr. Flores reviewed the application for demolition, noting staff recommended approval of same. He stated the property was currently under Code Compliance action. Ms. Goode disclosed a site visit to the location, questioning how long the property had been vacant. Mr. Flores replied with uncertainty. Ms. Desguin disclosed a site visit, noting the property appeared to be in severe disrepair.

Ms. Goode MOVED to recommend approval of the application, SECONDED by Ms. Desguin. MOTION CARRIED UNANIMOUSLY. 2.j CA-37-2025 - 311 Goldstein Street, Demo - Action Required Exhibits: Cover Page 1 - CA-37-2025 - 311 Goldstein Street_MEM_HPAB.pdf 2 - CA-37-2025 - 311 Goldstein Street - Application.pdf 3 - PRC.pdf 4 - CA-37-2025 - 311 Goldstein Street - Structural Report.pdf 5 - Streetview 1.pdf 6 - Streetview 2.pdf Mr. Flores reviewed the application for demolition, noting staff recommended approval of same. Ms. Desguin disclosed a site visit, noting it appeared work had begun in the structure, questioning why the property owner was now requesting to demolish the structure. Ms. Magnin questioned if the home was a candidate for the Elevate Florida program, asking if the property owner had applied for same. Mr. Flores noted the property would be eligible; however, he was unsure if they had applied for same. Ms. Goode questioned if the property was occupied. Mr. Flores replied in the negative. Ms. Ponte questioned if the property owner had considered other options for preserving the home. Ms. Goode noted historic homes were not affected by the 50% rule. She recalled a Certificate of Appropriateness had been issued for demolition, noting an individual purchased the home and wished to preserve it. She disclosed a site visit and emphasized her concerns regarding making decisions based on property owners’ fiscal situations. She opined residents should not purchase homes in the historic district if they were not willing to put money into preserving same. Mr. Perry suggested the applicant being present would provide the Board with more clarity during their decision making. Ms. Magnin suggested the Certificate Of appropriateness be postponed until the property owner could appear to answer the Board's questions. Ms. Ponte MOVED to table the application until the July 24, 2025, meeting, SECONDED by Mr. Valdes. MOTION CARRIED UNANIMOUSLY. 2.k CA-38-2025 - 409 West Ann Street, Windows - Action Required Exhibits: Cover Page 1 - CA-38-2025 - 409 West Ann Street_MEM_HPAB.pdf 2 - CA-38-2025 - 409 West Ann Street - Application.pdf 3 - CA-38-2025 - Warranty Deed.pdf 4 - PRC.pdf 5 - Specifications.pdf 6 - Streetview 1.pdf

Mr. Flores reviewed the application for window replacements, noting staff recommended approval of same. Mr. Valdes MOVED to recommend approval of the application, SECONDED by Ms. Ponte. MOTION CARRIED UNANIMOUSLY. 2.l CA-39-2025 - 410 West Grace St, Windows - Action Required Exhibits: Cover Page 1 - CA-39-2025 - 410 West Grace Street_MEM_HPAB.pdf 2 - CA-39-2025 - 410 West Grace Street - Application.pdf 3 - PRC.pdf 3 - Warranty Deed.pdf 5 - Specifications.pdf Mr. Flores reviewed the application for window replacement, noting staff recommended approval of same. Ms. Goode MOVED to recommend approval of the application, SECONDED by Mr. Noble. MOTION CARRIED UNANIMOUSLY. 3) GENERAL BUSINESS Ms. Danielle Berhel, Senior Project Manager, stated there had been no updates since the joint meeting with City Council. She noted staff provided City Council a cost estimate for City Hall which was $3.4 million, noting the actual cost would likely increase due to the increase in construction costs. She further stated a draft lease had been prepared for the Charlotte Desoto Building Industry Association (CDBIA) to handle the donations of time and materials which would cost roughly $400,000. STAFF COMMENTS Ms. Rachel Barry, Zoning Official, noted a report had been generated regarding demolition permits that had been applied for since the recent hurricanes. MEMBER COMMENTS Ms. Ponte thanked City Clerk Welch for reading her comments into the record at the joint meeting that she was unable to attend. Ms. Desguin spoke in favor of the proposed history walk at Ponce De Leon park, suggesting same could be used in other City parks. Mr. Noble thanked Ms. Nancy Johnson for her efforts in historic preservation. He then thanked Ms. Ponte for encouraging him to reach out to TEAM Punta Gorda regarding the preservation of the Calostimucu statue. Ms. Desguin questioned if TEAM Punta Gorda was currently involved in the A.C Freeman House. Ms. Goode recalled applicants of Elevate Florida needing a letter, providing a copy of the letter sent by staff for same. She opined the letter provided was not sufficient. She then read a proposed drafted letter into the record, opining same was a more accurate reflection of the Board's desire to support those who applied for Elevate Florida. She suggested Mr. Perry,

Mayor Lux, and Interim City Manager Reichert should sign same, noting the letters would have to be sent by July 1, 2025. Ms. Ponte questioned if the intent of the letter was to provide it to property owners. Ms. Goode replied affirmatively, noting property owners could then provide same to Elevate Florida. Mr. Noble MOVED to recommend the use of the proposed letter, SECONDED by Ms. Ponte. MOTION CARRIED UNANIMOUSLY. ADJOURNMENT The meeting adjourned at 10:25 a.m.Chair Board Recorder

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
AgendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Agenda packetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Action agendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Transcript or captionsNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Coverage and corrections

Records considered

  • Historic Preservation Advisory Board — Minutes

Not claimed by this page

  • Verified meeting decisions with item-specific public-source evidence
  • Item-level plain-language summaries are not available; this page does not infer individual agenda items.
  • Item-linked, attributed deliberation
  • A source-grounded next meeting date
  • A plain-English overview is not available.
  • Official outcomes have not been published.
  • A transcript is not available.
  • No audio or video recording is linked.
  • Speakers have not been reliably matched to public profiles.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.
  • An individual roll-call roster is not available.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: 3c4ca9d9bcad8f41f4d42a190209570f. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record