POLISCOPE

The public record

PUNTAGORDA (CHARLOTTE COUNTY) · LOCALHeld · official record pendingPartial coverage

Board of Zoning Appeals

Monday, November 24, 2025 · Government meeting record

The 30-second read

Record incomplete

The Punta Gorda Board of Zoning Appeals will meet to review two variance requests for property developments. The board will consider a proposal for an outdoor entertainment venue at 126 E Olympia Avenue and a setback variance for a home addition at 959 Messina Drive.

Why it matters

The board's decisions on these variance requests will determine whether specific property owners are permitted to proceed with construction projects that do not currently meet city code requirements.

What happens next

The scheduled meeting date has passed. Minutes or an action agenda are not published in the records we hold.

This meeting date has passed and no official outcome record has been published yet. Nothing on this page is a decision.

Record text

No recording or transcript is held for this meeting.

Robert C Sifrit, Chair Patrice Petrik, Board Member Heather Knuffke, Board Member Toni Gray, Board Member John Reynders, Board Member Charles V Lewis, Board Member James Wilton, Board Member CALL TO ORDER Roll Call Pledge of Allegiance Announcements Next Meeting PUBLIC COMMENTS Anyone wishing to address the Board of Zoning Appeals on any subject may do so at the appropriate time during the meeting. Those who choose to speak must state their name for the record. Each person will be allowed to speak up to a maximum of three minutes. 1. APPROVAL OF MINUTES 1.a September 22, 2025, Meeting Minutes. 2. LEGISLATIVE PUBLIC HEARINGS 3. QUASI-JUDICIAL PUBLIC HEARINGS 3.a V-04-2025 - 126 E Olympia Avenue 3.b V-06-2025 - 959 Messina Drive 4. REGULAR AGENDA STAFF COMMENTS MEMBER COMMENTS BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS AGENDA 120 LAISHLEY COURT, UNIT 111, PUNTA GORDA, FLORIDA 33950 NOVEMBER 24, 2025, 2:00 PM 1

ADJOURNMENT If any person decides to appeal any matter considered at this meeting, he or she may need a record of the proceedings, and for such purpose he or she may need to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceedings is made, which record includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal is to be based. In accordance with the Americans with Disabilities Act and Florida Statute 286.26, the location of this public hearing is accessible to persons with disabilities. If you are a person with disability who needs any accommodation in order to participate in this proceeding, you are entitled, at no cost to you, to the provision of certain assistance. Interpreters for the hearing impaired (TTY 941-575-5013) or non-English speaking citizens, and any other special accommodations can be requested by contacting the Human Resources Manager/Non-Discrimination Coordinator whose address is 326 W. Marion Avenue, Punta Gorda, FL 33950, whose telephone number is (941) 575-3371, and whose email address is humres@cityofpuntagordafl.com, at least two (2) calendars days prior to the meeting. 2

Title: September 22, 2025, Meeting Minutes. Funds: Not applicable Recommended Action: For approval. Summary: September 22, 2025, Meeting Minutes. Department/Division: City Clerk BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS CITY OF PUNTA GORDA 11/24/2025 APPROVAL OF MINUTES EXHIBITS: 1. September 22, 2025, Minutes 3

CITY OF PUNTA GORDA, FLORIDA BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS MEETING MINUTES SEPTEMBER 22, 2025, 9:00 A.M. 120 LAISHLEY COURT PUNTA GORDA, FL 33950 MEMBERS PRESENT: Robert Sifrit, Chair Toni Gray, Heather Knuffke, Charles Lewis, Patrice Petrik, John Reynders, James Wilton CITY STAFF PRESENT: Rachel Barry, Zoning Official; Interim City Attorney Leskovich; Deputy City Clerk Falkner; Alexandra Friend, Board Recorder CALL TO ORDER Chair Sifrit called the meeting to order at 2:00 p.m., followed by the Pledge of Allegiance. PUBLIC COMMENTS There were none. 1) APPROVAL OF MINUTES 1.a July 28, 2025, Meeting Minutes. Exhibits: Cover Page July 28, 2025, Minutes Member Lewis MOVED to approve the July 28, 2025, minutes, SECONDED by Member Reynders. MOTION CARRIED UNANIMOUSLY. 2) LEGISLATIVE PUBLIC HEARINGS There were none. 3) QUASI-JUDICIAL PUBLIC HEARINGS Alexandra Friend, Board Recorder, swore in all participants. 3.a V-03-2025 - A request by Carlos H. Reyes, as the authorized applicant on behalf of Open Concept Developers, LLC, property owner, pursuant to Chapter 26, Section 16.10, Punta Gorda Code, for a 10-foot setback reduction to allow a 15- foot rear yard setback instead of the required 25 feet for a proposed multi-family development. Exhibits: Cover Page V-03-2025 BZA Staff Report V-03-2025 Application V-03-2025 Site Plan 4

Rachel Barry, Zoning Official, reviewed the request for variance, explaining the criteria for burden of persuasion. Chair Sifrit questioned if there had been other setback reduction requests in the area of the subject property. Rachel Barry replied in the negative. Member Lewis questioned if the property was subject to the deed restrictions of Burnt Store Isles. Rachel Barry replied with uncertainty, noting staff did not enforce same. Carlos Reyes, applicant, reviewed the timeline of the project thus far, providing a presentation on same. He played audio from his Design Studio meeting with staff, drawing attention to the setback requirements being explained as 15 feet. Member Lewis questioned if the applicant had permission to record the meeting. Carlos Reyes replied affirmatively. Rachel Barry explained Design Studio meetings were recorded and considered public records. Carlos Reyes stated a redesign of the development would be costly, requesting the Board consider the impacts of the misinformation on the project. He reviewed ways the economic environment had impacted the project, noting property values in the City had significantly decreased since the project began. Member Lewis indicated the Burnt Store Isles Home Owners’ Association (HOA) had not approved the applicant's request for development. Carlos Lewis stated they were not aware they needed the approval of the HOA. Member Knuffke inquired as to the discrepancy in the information shared with the applicant regarding setback requirements. Interim City Attorney Leskovich stated the City was not opposed to granting the variance, noting any issues with the HOA requirements were not within the purview of the City. He stated the City could be liable if the applicant demonstrated they had experienced undue harm due to relying on information provided by the City. Ms. Knuffke spoke in favor of recommending approval for the variance based on the extraordinary circumstance criterion, opining the variance would not cause harm to the surrounding neighborhood. Member Lewis spoke against the variance request, opining same would set a precedent. Chair Sifrit opened the floor for public comment, calling 3 times for same. Joseph Comeaux, San Rocco Court, spoke in favor of allowing the variance, noting he lived near the subject property. Member Wilton MOVED to close the public hearing, SECONDED by Member Knuffke. MOTION CARRIED UNANIMOUSLY. Member Reynders MOVED to recommend approval of the request for variance, SECONDED by Member Knuffke. AYE: Gray, Knuffke, Petrik, Sifrit, Reynders, Wilton NAY: Lewis MOTION CARRIED. 4) REGULAR AGENDA There were no items. 5

STAFF COMMENTS There were none. MEMBER COMMENTS There were none. ADJOURNMENT The meeting adjourned at 3:12 p.m.Chair Board Recorder 6

Title: V-04-2025 - 126 E Olympia Avenue Funds: Recommended Action: For Board of Zoning Appeals review and recommendation to the City Council Summary: A request by Veronica Martin of TDM Consulting, Inc., as the Authorized Agent on behalf of David Fry, Applicant, authorized by 126 E Olympia Ave., LLC, Property Owner, for a variance pursuant to Chapter 26, Section 16.10, Punta Gorda Code, from multiple sections of Chapter 26, Punta Gorda Code, pertaining to design requirements to allow the construction of an outdoor entertainment venue on an approximate 0.50- acre portion of the property located at 126 E Olympia Avenue, Punta Gorda, Florida 33950. The applicant is requesting a variance from Sections 3.9(g)(7), 3.9(g)(9), 3.9(e)(2), 3.9(e)(3), 3.9(e)(4), 7.4(a)(2), 7.4(a)(4), 7.4(d)(8), 7.4(d)(9), and 7.4(d)(11). Department/Division: Urban Design BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS CITY OF PUNTA GORDA 11/24/2025 QUASI-JUDICIAL PUBLIC HEARINGS EXHIBITS: 1. Application 2. BZA Staff Report 3. Site Plan 7

8

9

10

11

NARRATIVE OF PROPOSED REDEVELOPMENT The Applicant, David Fry, is proposing to redevelop a portion of 126 E. Olympia Avenue in downtown Punta Gorda into a commercial establishment that includes food trucks and entertainment. Mr. Fry has a contract for purchase with the current property owner, 126 E Olympia Ave, LLC. A Lot Split is currently under review by staff (LOT-03-2025). The property was originally developed as the Bank of America office building with associated parking. The site has a future land use classification of City Center and a zoning district of Traditional Punta Gorda, Downtown Core (TPG -DC). Section 3.9 of the Land Development Regulations encourages the redevelopment and expansion of the traditional town center with a broad array of uses including shops, restaurants, services, work places, civic, educational and religious facilities, and high density housing. It is expected that the City Center District will expand over time to meet the growth in demand for downtown facilities and services. That is the intent of the proposed redevelopment – to convert an old, seldom used parking lot into a commercial enterprise to serve the downtown district. The proposed use (similar to a restaurant with outdoor dining and outdoor entertainment) is permitted per Land Development Regulation Section 3.9(a)(16) - “Any such other uses which are similar to those listed as deemed appropriate in the district by the Zoning Official” and Section 3.9(b) Permitted Accessory Uses. The proposed development will include a 6’ high opaque wall/fence on all sides as shown on the Site Plan. This will not only provide privacy, but will increase compatibility with adjacent land uses. The location is not within 200 feet of property located within a residential district or within 200 feet from an NR District boundary. In addition, all structures are located towards the perimeter of the lot. The anticipated hours of operation will be the same as Bay Street Yard in downtown Fort Myers. With the exception of special events and holidays, the hours of operation are as follows: • Sunday: 11 am – 10 pm • Monday: 4 pm – 12 am • Tuesday: Closed • Wednesday: Closed • Thursday: 4 pm – 12 am • Friday and Saturday: 11 am – 2 am As stated above, the applicant is proposing two (2) mobile food trucks on-site, which are permitted in the City Center zoning district. The vendors will be required to obtain all required 12

Page 2 of 4 licensing and permits prior to operating on site. This is consistent with Section 4.4 – Amusement Facilities, 4.24 – Outdoor Recreation, Section 4.29 – Recreational Facilities, and Section 4.40 – Mobile Food Dispensing Vehicles. VARIANCE REQUEST The Applicant is requesting a total of four (4) Variances. (1) Variance from LDR Section 3.9(g)(4) - Development Standards, which requires a minimum rear setback requirement of 20 feet. The Applicant is requesting a 0-foot setback to the rear, abutting Herald Court. (2) Variance from LDR Section 3.9(g)(7) – Development Standards, which requires the frontage build-out to be 70% of the street face. Request to permit the proposed 6’ high opaque wall along E. Olympia Avenue to meet this requirement in lieu of the building façade. (3) Variance from LDR Section 3.9(g)(9) – Development Standards, which requires a minimum height of 2 stories, 26 feet above BFE. Request to permit a minimum height of 1 story, 20 feet above BFE. (4) Variance from LDR Section 3.9(e)(2) – General Requirements, which requires an arcade, shopfront, stoop, forecourt, or dooryard frontage. Request to permit a Front Lawn type frontage along E. Olympia Avenue. VARIANCE CRITERIA 1. That special conditions or circumstances exist which are particular to the size and characteristics of the land, structure or building involved and which are not applicable to other lands, structures or buildings in the same zoning district. The proposed redevelopment for the intended use doesn’t fit neatly into a pre-determined use category. It’s “similar” to several other uses permitted in the City Center zoning district, including restaurant with outdoor seating and outdoor recreational facility. The actual development is located behind a 6’ high opaque wall/fence with all activity and structures located inside for privacy and compatibility with adjacent land uses. The applicant is proposing to use shipping containers for the buildings, including the bar, restrooms, etc. The site is a remnant of the parking lot for the Bank of America office building. The site is surrounded by E. Olympia Avenue to the south, Herald Court to the north, an alley to the west, and an existing parking lot to the east. The site is constrained by the fact that it’s limited in size to only 21,769 square feet without the ability to acquire additional land. In addition, the frontage types permitted in the City Center zoning district are more conducive to traditional commercial development; however, aren’t compatible with the proposed development. In addition, as previously mentioned, the applicant intends to use shipping containers for the structures, which are limited to one-story in height. The special conditions and/or circumstances of the site and proposed use are particular to this specific lot; however, the limitation on use categories is the same for the City Center zoning district. 2. The strict and literal enforcement of the zoning regulations would create an undue hardship as distinguished from a mere inconvenience on the property owners. Physical 13

Page 3 of 4 handicaps or disability of the applicant and other considerations may be considered where relevant to the request. The strict application of the zoning regulations creates a hardship on the applicant. It isn’t possible to acquire additional land to increase the rear setback; the nature of the development prohibits a 70% frontage build-out; the nature of the development doesn’t fit into the approved frontage types; and doesn’t promote a 2-story building. As mentioned previously, the site is small in size with only 104.60 feet of frontage on E. Olympia Avenue, 136.60 feet of frontage on Herald Court, 183.34 feet on the west side along the alley, and 180.53 feet along the east property line. In addition, this is a redevelopment of what would be considered an infill lot. The Applicant is burdened by the application of the code requirements, and the strict application would prevent the redevelopment of the site for the proposed use. 3. That such hardship is not shared generally by other properties in the same zoning district and in the same vicinity. Please see the narrative above. The hardship is not generally shared by other properties in the same zoning district in the same vicinity. 4. The granting of the variance would not be injurious to or incompatible with contiguous uses, the surrounding neighborhood or otherwise detrimental to the public welfare. The surrounding neighborhood consists of streets and commercial uses, including an automotive and maintenance repair shop west of the alley, the Bank of America office building and associated parking east of the site, a large parking lot south of E. Olympia Avenue, and a shopping plaza north of the site. There aren’t any residential uses nearby. The Site Plan shows the property surrounded by a 6’ high opaque wall/fence to add privacy to the development and increase compatibility with the surrounding neighborhood. In addition, the venue has limited timeframes, especially during the week nights. Granting of the variances will not be injurious to or incompatible with the abutting uses, the surrounding neighborhood or otherwise detrimental to the public welfare. 5. That the variance requested is the minimum modification of the regulation at issue that will afford relief. The proposed Variances are the minimum modification of the regulations at issue that will afford relief. As stated, the land on all four sides is currently developed so the applicant cannot acquire additional land to meet the rear setback requirements and the permitted frontage types aren’t compatible with the proposed use. 6. The condition giving rise to the requested variance has not been created by any person presently having an interest in the property and/or the conditions cannot reasonably be corrected or avoided by the applicant. The Variance requests are not due to a hardship created by the Applicant. The current Land Development Code doesn’t provide regulations specific to the proposed use; however, does provide a mechanism for Variances from regulations to permit flexibility in design. Strict compliance with the code regulations 14

Page 4 of 4 7. The variance requested does not involve any use which is prohibited in the district where the property is located. Please see the narrative above. The proposed use isn’t a specific listed use in the Land Development Regulations; however, LDR Section 3.9(a)(16) permits the Zoning Official to permit similar uses. The proposed use is similar to restaurants with outdoor seating and outdoor recreation facilities. 8. Please explain in detail how this variance request is consistent with the City of Punta Gorda Comprehensive Plan. Pursuant to Future Land Use Element Goal 1.1, it is the intent of the City to continue to create a lively, economically viable, pedestrian oriented town with a publicly accessible waterfront, healthy neighborhoods, and a high quality of community character. The proposed development is a unique mix of food and entertainment in the heart of the City, which meets the intent of Goal 1.1. Pursuant to Future Land Use Element Policy 1.1.10.2, the City of Punta Gorda will encourage infill development within the city by maintaining a high level of urban services, by cooperating with the private sector in promoting the city to traditional retiree populations, by promoting other forms of economic growth, and by maintaining land development regulations that facility the sensitive integration of new development in older urban areas. The site is located in the City Center and public services and infrastructure are already in place. The proposed redevelopment of a parking lot that is no longer needed with a vibrant new development meets the intent of Policy 1.1.10.2. The site has a future land use classification of Traditional Punta Gorda – Downtown, which is a mixed-use category with a description of “intended to be developed in a pedestrian oriented manner consistent with the historic pattern. A mix of retail, dining, offices and multi-family residential are permitted. The location, in the downtown core, is ideal for the proposed development; however, it isn’t possible to provide a “mix” of uses with the proposed uses. The “mix of uses” intended by the TPC – DC future land use classification is a result of the 2019 Citywide Master Plan, which was intended to provide greater flexibility in the mix of uses and development patterns accommodated in the City’s non-residential use areas. 15

V-04-2025 Staff Report Board of Zoning Appeals - November 24, 2025 | City Council - December 3, 2025 Page 1 of 17 VARIANCE STAFF REPORT TO: Punta Gorda Board of Zoning Appeals (BZA) City Council (CC) FROM: Rachel Barry, Zoning Official BZA HEARING DATE: November 24, 2025 CC HEARING DATE: December 3, 2025 RE: V-04-2025 – Olympia Avenue Yard Applicant Request: V-04-2025: A request by Veronica Martin of TDM Consulting, Inc., as the Authorized Agent on behalf of David Fry, Applicant, authorized by 126 E Olympia Ave., LLC, Property Owner, for a variance pursuant to Chapter 26, Section 16.10, Punta Gorda Code, from multiple sections of Chapter 26, Punta Gorda Code, pertaining to design requirements to allow the construction of an outdoor entertainment venue on an approximate 0.50-acre portion of the property located at 126 E Olympia Avenue, Punta Gorda, Florida 33950. The applicant is requesting a variance from Sections 3.9(g)(7), 3.9(g)(9), 3.9(e)(2), 3.9(e)(3), 3.9(e)(4), 7.4(a)(2), 7.4(a)(4), 7.4(d)(8), 7.4(d)(9), and 7.4(d)(11). Hearing Minutes and Board Recommendation(s): At the filing of this application, the property subject to this application was included as a portion of the parcel addressed as 126 E Olympia Avenue, Punta Gorda, Florida 33950, otherwise identified by the Charlotte County Property Appraiser as parcel 412306331010, which is listed on the Florida Master Site File. Pursuant to Section 3.14(i) of Chapter 26, Land Development Regulations, Punta Gorda Code, the City of Punta Gorda Historic Preservation Advisory Board (HPAB) heard the request on October 23, 2025. HPAB recommended approval of the request, 6- 1. Following the public hearing, the BZA shall forward the proposed variance to the City Council together with its recommendation and a statement setting forth its reasons for such recommendation. Due to the timing of hearing dates, the Agenda for the City Council meeting will be published prior to the BZA meeting. All additional information, including the BZA’s recommendation, will be provided immediately following the BZA meeting. Supplemental Material/Issue Analysis Report: As mentioned above, at the filing of this application and advertising for the public hearing, the subject property was included as a portion of the parcel addressed as 126 E Olympia Avenue, Punta Gorda, Florida 33950, otherwise identified by the Charlotte County Property Appraiser as 16

V-04-2025 Staff Report Board of Zoning Appeals - November 24, 2025 | City Council - December 3, 2025 Page 2 of 17 parcel 412306331010. Prior to the filing of this application, the parent parcel owner, 126 E Olympia Ave., LLC, authorized the prospective buyer, David Fry, to apply for a Lot Split Application to obtain a separate parcel number for the approximate 0.50-acre area that Mr. Fry was under contract to purchase. The property being more specifically described as all of Lots 18 and 19 and the southwesterly five (5) feet of Lot 20, all in Block 34, City of Punta Gorda, Florida, according to the Plat thereof as recorded in Plat Book 1, Page 21, of the Public Records of Charlotte County, Florida; and more accurately depicted on the survey included in Exhibit 6 of this staff report. The lot split is now updated on the Charlotte County Property Appraiser’s GIS Map, and the separated portion of the property that is subject to this request is now known as parcel 412306331011. The sale was finalized and a warranty deed recorded on November 12, 2025, instrument number 3587021; the property owner is now listed as PG Yard Land, LLC, of which David Fry is listed as the Manger and Registered Agent. The applicant is requesting a variance from multiple sections of Chapter 26, Land Development Regulations (LDRs), Punta Gorda Code, to allow the construction of a new entertainment venue to be known as the Olympia Avenue Yard. The property is located within the City Center zoning district, as regulated by Section 3.9, LDRs, and is located within the Downtown Commercial Historic District Overlay. The subject property is not listed on the Florida Master Site File and is therefore not subject to Certificate of Appropriateness requirements. The application describes the proposed development as a commercial establishment that includes food trucks and entertainment, along with beverage service. The property is located within the City Center zoning district which allows bars and food trucks as uses permitted with conditions, and allows outdoor dining as a permitted accessory use; the proposed outdoor entertainment is allowed so long as it is accessory to and customarily incidental and subordinate to the permitted principal use as a bar establishment. Section 4.7, LDRs, outlines the conditions for bars and nightclubs. The two conditions are: (1) the establishment is not permitted within 300 feet of a one- or two-family dwelling unit, church, or other civic use building; and (2) parking is allowed to be provided off-site. The property and proposed development comply with both conditions. Additionally, the property is not located within 200 feet of a Neighborhood Residential zoning district boundary, as is prohibited by Section 3.9, LDRs. Section 4.40, LDRs, outlines the conditions for food trucks, also referred to as “mobile food dispensing vehicles”. Subsection (b)(1) notes food trucks are permitted on developed property within the City Center district. Developing the property in compliance with the conditions in Section 4.7, LDRs, will in turn allow the food truck(s) on the property, subject to all conditions in Section 4.40, LDRs. The proposed development is unique in style and design, and does not align with certain architectural guidelines or development requirements of the LDRs. A rendering of the proposed development is included as Exhibit 9 of this staff report. Review of the application shows a predominately open-air, covered, bar establishment with outdoor entertainment, seating areas, and food trucks, as well as restroom facilities, an office, and storage. There appear to be no site- built enclosed buildings proposed in the project. The Applicant is requesting relief from the following Sections of the LDRs: Section 3.9, City Center • Subsection (e), General Requirements o Paragraph (2) – requires the front of a structure to comply with arcade, shopfront, stoop, forecourt, or dooryard frontage definition. The structures in the proposed development are modified shipping containers, and are not used as an entrance into the establishment. The structures will be set back from the main 17

V-04-2025 Staff Report Board of Zoning Appeals - November 24, 2025 | City Council - December 3, 2025 Page 3 of 17 entrance; however, they do not serve as the façade that is the intended subject of this requirement. Having no façade or building entrance into the establishment, the development as proposed would not comply with this requirement. o Paragraph (3) – requires the structure to comply with specific architectural styles This requirement references architectural styles detailed in Section 7.3, LDRs. The development as proposed would not fall within any of the categories listed in Section 7.3, LDRs. o Paragraph (4) – requires the structure to comply with building principles where applicable by use This requirement references the building principles detailed in Section 7.4, LDRs. Additional information regarding the applicable portions of Section 7.4 is listed below. • Subsection (g), Development Standards o Paragraph (7) – requires a minimum 70% frontage build-out along the primary street The proposed development, being mostly open-air space, would not comply with this requirement. The applicant has proposed decorative fencing, landscaping, and other architectural features along the entirety of the primary street frontage. o Paragraph (9) – requires a minimum height of two (2) stories and 26 feet above base flood elevation (BFE) The open-air nature of the proposed development, utilizing modified containers, would not comply with this requirement. Section 7.4, Building Principles • Subsection (a), General Building Principles o Paragraph (2) – requires structures to be built architecturally compatible with adjacent buildings through several options, including, but not limited to, spacing, setbacks, exterior materials, and scale. The adjacent buildings are each unique in their respective architectural designs. The proposed development is located next to the Bank of America building – a four-story building constructed in 1960 in the Mid-Century Modern style; across an alleyway behind Greg’s Automotive repair shop – a one-story building constructed in 1947 in the Commercial Vernacular style; and across an alleyway behind the H.W. Smith Building – a one-story building constructed in 1926 in the Mission Revival style. The applicant has proposed a design that is not architecturally similar to adjacent buildings, and would not comply with this requirement. o Paragraph (4) – requires the primary entrance of the structure to be on the front façade of the building. There being no primary structure, there is no façade in which to incorporate a primary entrance. The primary entrance into the proposed development is located on E Olympia Avenue, where the applicant has proposed decorative fencing, landscaping, and other architectural elements. • Subsection (d), Shopfront and Workplace Principles [mixed use] o Paragraph (8) – requires all equipment be located in the side yard and screened from off- site view, rooftop equipment to be enclosed in material that matches the building, and no mechanical equipment may be mounted of the building façade visible from public right-of- way or adjacent properties. The applicant is requesting a variance from this requirement. 18

V-04-2025 Staff Report Board of Zoning Appeals - November 24, 2025 | City Council - December 3, 2025 Page 4 of 17 o Paragraph (9) – requires building walls be made of brick, concrete, stucco, stone, marble, or similar materials. The applicant is proposing to utilize modified shipping containers to serve as the structures on the property; however, the containers do not have modified exterior cladding other than paint. o Paragraph (11) – requires the first floor of street level building façades to be a minimum 50% windows. There being no street level building facade, the proposed development would not meet this requirement. Section 16.10, Application for Variance, LDRs. (a) Application. Veronica Martin of TDM Consulting, Inc., as the Authorized Agent for David Fry, Applicant authorized by Kim Devine, listed on Sunbiz.org as the Registered Agent for 126 E Olympia Ave., LLC, Property Owner, has filed an application for a variance with the Urban Design Department. Since the filing of this application, the parent parcel was split, and the area subject to this application is now owned by PG Yard Land, LLC, for which David Fry is listed as the Manager and Registered Agent. (b) Approval Criteria. No variance shall be approved unless all of the following statements are true with respect to the subject property: (1) That special conditions or circumstances exist which are particular to the size and characteristics of the land, structure or building involved which are not applicable to other lands, structures or buildings in the same zoning district. This criterion is true with respect to the subject property. The proposed structures are unique in design, which is a special condition that does not apply to other structures or buildings in the same zoning district. (2) The strict and literal enforcement of the zoning regulations would create an undue hardship as distinguished from a mere inconvenience on the property owners. Physical handicaps or disability of the applicant and other considerations may be considered where relevant to the request. This criterion is true with respect to the subject property. The Applicant developed a similar project in Fort Myers, known as The Bay Street Yard, which is designed in the same manner as the proposed development. The strict and literal enforcement of the zoning regulations would cause the applicant to redesign the proposed project, eliminating continuity between multiple business locations. (3) That such hardship is not shared generally by other properties in the same zoning district and in the same vicinity. This criterion is true with the respect to the subject property. Staff is not aware of any other property or property owner in the vicinity or zoning district that share the hardship. 19

V-04-2025 Staff Report Board of Zoning Appeals - November 24, 2025 | City Council - December 3, 2025 Page 5 of 17 (4) The granting of the variance would not be injurious to or incompatible with contiguous uses, the surrounding neighborhood or otherwise detrimental to the public welfare. This criterion is true with respect to the subject property. The only area contiguous to the property is the remaining portion of the parent parcel, which contains the vacant Bank of America building. Granting the variance would not be injurious or incompatible with the contiguous use. The property is located in downtown Punta Gorda near several other food and beverage establishments; granting the variance would not be injurious or incompatible with the uses in the surrounding neighborhood. Granting the variance may not be compatible with the architecture and design of the surrounding neighborhood, but could be made compatible through proper landscaping. (5) That the variance requested is the minimum modification of the regulation at issue that will afford relief. This criterion is partially true with respect to the subject property. Theoretically, the development could be redesigned to place a container at the front of the property to act as the primary entrance, however, doing so may retract from the visual aesthetics in comparison to the proposed entrance design. The containers could theoretically be redesigned to have appropriate cladding. Additionally, the application does not propose a solution or remedy for equipment screening; complete reduction of screening requirements may not be necessary, and screening the equipment may be feasible. (6) The condition giving rise to the requested variance has not been created by any person presently having an interest in the property and/or the conditions cannot reasonably be corrected or avoided by the applicant. This criterion may not be wholly true with respect to the subject property. The Applicant and any other person presently having an interest in the property were not involved with the creation or adoption of the LDRs, which outline all of the requirements for design and development. However, the Applicant has proposed a design that does not comply with the LDRs. A redesign may theoretically be possible, but would affect the Applicant’s business model/branding and may not be reasonable. (7) The variance requested does not involve any use which is prohibited in the district where the property is located. This criterion is true with respect to the subject property. A bar establishment and food trucks are uses permitted with conditions in the City Center District, and the outdoor entertainment is permitted as an accessory to the bar establishment. (8) The requested variance is consistent with the City of Punta Gorda Comprehensive Plan. This criterion is true with respect to the subject property. The following Goals, Objectives, and Policies of the Future Land Use Element, City of Punta Gorda 2045 Comprehensive Plan, support the requested variance: Goal 1.1: The long term end toward which land use programs and activities are ultimately directed is the orderly growth and development of Punta Gorda in a high quality environment. Over the next planning period, it is the intent of the City to 20

V-04-2025 Staff Report Board of Zoning Appeals - November 24, 2025 | City Council - December 3, 2025 Page 6 of 17 continue to create a lively, economically viable, pedestrian oriented town with a publicly accessible waterfront, healthy neighborhoods, and a high quality of community character Objective 1.1.3: The City of Punta Gorda is committed to the redevelopment and renewal of blighted areas, and the prevention of blight in other areas through the following policies: Policy 1.1.3.6: The City will ensure that local historic and neighborhood conservation district requirements do not impose additional and/or excessive development barriers on key infill and redevelopment opportunity sites. Objective 1.1.10: Punta Gorda will discourage urban sprawl by controlling the extension of urban facilities and services to non-urban areas and by encouraging urban infill development. Policy 1.1.10.2: Punta Gorda will encourage infill development within the city by maintaining a high level of urban services, by cooperating with the private sector in promoting economic growth, and by maintaining land development regulations that facilitate the sensitive integration of new development in older urban areas. Objective 1.1.14: Punta Gorda will maintain a Future Land Use Map and land use classification system that provides for the distribution, extent, and location of a variety of land uses. Policy 1.1.14.2: Downtown lands encompass the traditional commercial core of the city; therefore, they feature the most intense retail and office space allowances, combined with an encouragement of vertically integrated mixed-use development. These areas shall be developed: a. In a pedestrian-oriented manner consistent with the existing and historic pattern . (c) Burden of Persuasion. […] The applicant shall be required to demonstrate that the granting of a variance will alleviate a clearly demonstrable hardship approaching confiscation as distinguished from a special privilege or convenience sought by the applicant or that strict application of the ordinance would effectively prohibit or unreasonably restrict reasonable use of the property by reason of any one of the following: (1) Exceptional narrowness, shallowness, size or shape of a specific piece of property at the time of enactment of this Ordinance. (2) Exceptional topographic conditions or other extraordinary and exceptional situation or condition of such property. (3) The condition situation or development of property immediately adjacent to the subject property. The applicant has indicated a hardship; however, the hardship is not due to the size, shape, or topography of the property, or due to any situation or development immediately adjacent to the property. (d) Public Hearing. The application for variance is scheduled for public hearing before the Punta Gorda Board of Zoning Appeals (BZA) on Monday, November 24, 2025, and before the City Council on Wednesday, December 3, 2025. 21

V-04-2025 Staff Report Board of Zoning Appeals - November 24, 2025 | City Council - December 3, 2025 Page 7 of 17 (e) BZA Review and Recommendation. Following the public hearing, the BZA shall forward the proposed variance to the City Council together with its recommendation and a statement setting forth its reasons for such recommendation. Due to the timing of hearing dates, the Agenda for the City Council meeting will be published prior to the BZA meeting. All additional information, including the BZA’s recommendation, will be provided immediately following the BZA meeting. Summary of Findings Finding #1: The property is located in the City Center zoning district. The applicant’s proposed development does not include any uses that are prohibited in this district, and the proposed development is compatible with surrounding uses. Finding #2: The design and style of the proposed development do not align with the architectural styles the City has prioritized for development in the downtown area. The design may not be compatible with the design found throughout the surrounding area, but could be made compatible through proper and sufficient landscaping. Finding #3: Section 7.5, LDRs, states in part, “Major variation to building façade requirements due to unique building use requirements may be approved by the City Council, provided the overall pedestrian nature of the street is maintained in accordance with all other standards.” Finding #4: The LDRs provide avenues to seek relief from development regulations through a variance application, outlined in Section 16.10 of the LDRs. Finding #5: Section 16.10(b), LDRs, lists eight (8) approval criteria. Six (6) have been found to be true with respect to the subject property, and two (2) have been found to be partially true with respect to the subject property. Staff Recommendation: If this request, V-04-2025, is approved, Staff recommends the following conditions of approval: 1. The approved variance shall be valid for the current property owner, David Fry of PG Yard Land, LLC, and shall expire two (2) years after the date of approval unless a valid building permit has been issued through the City of Punta Gorda Building Department. 2. The Applicant’s project shall adhere to the design as shown in the rendering included as Exhibit 9 of this staff report. 3. The Applicant shall construct decorative fencing and provide adequate landscaping along a minimum of 70% of the front property line. 4. The Applicant shall install adequate landscaping to the highest extent possible to screen equipment. 5. The Applicant shall ensure that all structures are painted and maintained in a proper manner, and any fading areas, scratches, peeling, or otherwise, will be immediately addressed and corrected. Attachments: Exhibit 1 – Location Map Exhibit 2 – Subject Property Map Exhibit 3 – Zoning Map Exhibit 4 – Historic District Overlay Map 22

V-04-2025 Staff Report Board of Zoning Appeals - November 24, 2025 | City Council - December 3, 2025 Page 8 of 17 Exhibit 5 – Future Land Use Map Exhibit 6 – Survey Exhibit 7 – Site Plan Overlaid on Map Exhibit 8 – Site Plan Exhibit 9 – Renderings of Front Entrance (The remainder of this page intentionally left blank) 23

V-04-2025 Staff Report Board of Zoning Appeals - November 24, 2025 | City Council - December 3, 2025 Page 9 of 17 Exhibit 1: 24

V-04-2025 Staff Report Board of Zoning Appeals - November 24, 2025 | City Council - December 3, 2025 Page 10 of 17 Exhibit 2: 25

V-04-2025 Staff Report Board of Zoning Appeals - November 24, 2025 | City Council - December 3, 2025 Page 11 of 17 Exhibit 3: 26

V-04-2025 Staff Report Board of Zoning Appeals - November 24, 2025 | City Council - December 3, 2025 Page 12 of 17 Exhibit 4: 27

V-04-2025 Staff Report Board of Zoning Appeals - November 24, 2025 | City Council - December 3, 2025 Page 13 of 17 Exhibit 5: 28

V-04-2025 Staff Report Board of Zoning Appeals - November 24, 2025 | City Council - December 3, 2025 Page 14 of 17 Exhibit 6: 29

V-04-2025 Staff Report Board of Zoning Appeals - November 24, 2025 | City Council - December 3, 2025 Page 15 of 17 Exhibit 7: 30

V-04-2025 Staff Report Board of Zoning Appeals - November 24, 2025 | City Council - December 3, 2025 Page 16 of 17 Exhibit 8: Site Plan Provided by Applicant 31

V-04-2025 Staff Report Board of Zoning Appeals - November 24, 2025 | City Council - December 3, 2025 Page 17 of 17 Exhibit 9: Renderings Provided by Applicant 32

33

Title: V-06-2025 - 959 Messina Drive Funds: Recommended Action: For Board of Zoning Appeals review and recommendation to the City Council Summary: A request by Michael Simone, property owner, for a variance from minimum setback requirements pursuant to Chapter 26, Section 16.10, Punta Gorda Code, to allow a 6.8-foot side yard setback for a partially constructed addition, instead of the required 7.5-foot setback, as is required by Chapter 26, Section 3.4, Punta Gorda Code, at 959 Messina Dr., Punta Gorda, Florida 33950. Department/Division: Urban Design BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS CITY OF PUNTA GORDA 11/24/2025 QUASI-JUDICIAL PUBLIC HEARINGS EXHIBITS: 1. Application 2. BZA Staff Report 3. Site Plan 34

35

36

37

38

39

40

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
AgendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Action agendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
MinutesNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Transcript or captionsNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Coverage and corrections

Records considered

  • Board of Zoning Appeals — Packet

Not claimed by this page

  • Verified meeting decisions with item-specific public-source evidence
  • Item-level plain-language summaries are not available; this page does not infer individual agenda items.
  • Item-linked, attributed deliberation
  • A source-grounded next meeting date
  • Official outcomes have not been published.
  • A transcript is not available.
  • No audio or video recording is linked.
  • Speakers have not been reliably matched to public profiles.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.
  • An individual roll-call roster is not available.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: 3b9995e246f0601c63f5e340b19c764f. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record