POLISCOPE

The public record

SOUTHGATE (LOS ANGELES COUNTY)Held · official record pendingPartial coverage

Planning Commission

Tuesday, October 1, 2024 · Government meeting record

The 30-second read

Record incomplete

Planning Commission

Why it matters

The official meeting record is available below. Item-level plain-language summaries are not available yet.

What happens next

The scheduled meeting date has passed. Minutes or an action agenda are not published in the records we hold.

This meeting date has passed and no official outcome record has been published yet. Nothing on this page is a decision.

Record text

No recording or transcript is held for this meeting.

Agenda

PLANNING COMMISSION

PLANNING COMMISSION AGENDA

Tuesday, October 1, 2024 at 6:30 p.m.

SOUTH GATE COUNCIL CHAMBERS

8650 CALIFORNIA AVENUE

SOUTH GATE, CA 90280

VIEW MEETING LIVE ONLINE AT:

HTTPS://YOUTUBE.COM/@SOUTHGATECA90280

Call To Order

Pledge of Allegiance

Roll Call

City Officials

CHAIRPERSON

COMMISSIONERS

Jimmy Ozaeta

Jenny Perez

Daisy Prieto

VICE CHAIRPERSON

Lizette Ruiz

Jovanna Laborin

Report On Posting

I, Rodrigo Pelayo, Senior Planner, certify that a true and correct copy of the foregoing meeting agenda was properly posted on September 26, 2024, seventy-two hours prior to the scheduled meeting, as required by law.

Meeting Compensation Disclosure

Pursuant to Government Code Section 54952.3: Disclosure of compensation for meeting attendance by the Planning Commission is $125.00 per meeting.

Open Session Items

1. Design Review (DR 22-03) & Variance (VAR 23-23)

Consideration for a request for approval of Design Review to allow the new construction of a 7,150 square-foot prefabricated storage building, a 1,248 square-foot prefabricated office building, including exterior site (parking lot and landscaping) improvements within an existing sodium silicate manufacturing plant; and a request for a Variance to deviate from the minimum requirements of the Zoning Code pertaining to off-street parking, landscaping, and a site perimeter wall.

Documents:

Item 1 Report 10012024.pdf

VAR 23-23_PC_ppt_10.01.24.pdf

PQ CORP PPT.pdf

Comments

At this time, members of the public and staff may address the City Planning Commission regarding any items within the subject matter jurisdiction of the Planning Commission. No action may be taken on items not listed on the agenda unless authorized by law.

AUDIENCE COMMENTS

CITY STAFF COMMENTS

PLANNING COMMISSION COMMENTS

Adjournment

In compliance with the American with Disabilities Act, if you need special assistance to participate in the Planning Commission Meetings, please contact Community Development Department.

Notification 48 hours prior to the Planning Commission Meeting will enable the City to make reasonable arrangements to assure accessibility. Any final action of the Planning Commission, on this agenda, is appealable to the City Council upon filling the request with the City Clerk prior to 5:00 pm on Tuesday, October 15, 2024.

Showing the first 24,000 of 116,481 characters. The full document is at the source.

PLANNING COMMISSION PLANNING COMMISSION AGENDA Tuesday, October 1, 2024 at 6:30 p.m. SOUTH GATE COUNCIL CHAMBERS 8650 CALIFORNIA AVENUE SOUTH GATE, CA 90280 VIEW MEETING LIVE ONLINE AT: HTTPS://YOUTUBE.COM/@SOUTHGATECA90280 Call To Order Pledge of Allegiance Roll Call City Officials CHAIRPERSON COMMISSIONERS Jimmy Ozaeta Jenny Perez Daisy Prieto VICE CHAIRPERSON Lizette Ruiz Jovanna Laborin Report On Posting I, Rodrigo Pelayo, Senior Planner, certify that a true and correct copy of the foregoing meeting agenda was properly posted on September 26, 2024, seventy-two hours prior to the scheduled meeting, as required by law. Meeting Compensation Disclosure Pursuant to Government Code Section 54952.3: Disclosure of compensation for meeting attendance by the Planning Commission is $125.00 per meeting. 1

Open Session Items 1. Design Review (DR 22-03) & Variance (VAR 23-23) Consideration for a request for approval of Design Review to allow the new construction of a 7,150 square-foot prefabricated storage building, a 1,248 square-foot prefabricated office building, including exterior site (parking lot and landscaping) improvements within an existing sodium silicate manufacturing plant; and a request for a Variance to deviate from the minimum requirements of the Zoning Code pertaining to off-street parking, landscaping, and a site perimeter wall. Documents: Item 1 Report 10012024.pdf VAR 23-23_PC_ppt_10.01.24.pdf PQ CORP PPT.pdf Comments At this time, members of the public and staff may address the City Planning Commission regarding any items within the subject matter jurisdiction of the Planning Commission. No action may be taken on items not listed on the agenda unless authorized by law. AUDIENCE COMMENTS CITY STAFF COMMENTS PLANNING COMMISSION COMMENTS Adjournment In compliance with the American with Disabilities Act, if you need special assistance to participate in the Planning Commission Meetings, please contact Community Development Department. Notification 48 hours prior to the Planning Commission Meeting will enable the City to make reasonable arrangements to assure accessibility. Any final action of the Planning Commission, on this agenda, is appealable to the City Council upon filling the request with the City Clerk prior to 5:00 pm on Tuesday, October 15, 2024. Materials related to an item on this Agenda submitted to the Planning Commission after distribution of the agenda packet are available for public inspection in the City Clerk's Office, 8650 California Avenue, South Gate, California 90280 (323) 563-9510 * fax (323) 563-5411 * www.cityofsouthgate.org. 2

City of South Gate PLANNING COMMISSION A(GENIDA IBT[TL,T[, R'odri o Pe SUBJECT: Design Review (DR 22-03) & Variance (VAR 23-23) PROJECT PROPOSAL/REQUEST: Request for approval of Design Review to allow the new construction of a 7,150 square-foot prefabricated storage building, a 1,248 square-foot prefabiicated office building, including exterior site (parking lot and landscaping) improvements within an existing sodium silicate manufacturing plant; and a request for a Vaiiance to deviate from the minimum requirements of the Zoi'iing Code pertaining to off-street parking, landscaping, and a site perimeter wall. BACKGROUND: Project Overview * General Plan Designation: Industrial * (M3, Heavy Manufacturing) * Pro.iect Location: 8401 Quartz Avenue * Assessor'sParcelNumber(s):6215-003-017 * SiteCharacteristics:Thesubjectsitemeasuresapproximately259,618squarefeet(5.96acres) and is comprised of one irregular-shaped corner parcel with double frontages. The primary frontage is along Quartz Avenue, and the secondary (rear) frontage is along Independence Avenue. The site is currently developed with a sodium silicate manufacturing plant consisting ofnumerous structures, includingmaintenance shop, a furnace building, filterroom, unloading building, exterior storage tanks and silos, and conveyor equipment. There are multiple rail spurs crossing the property, used for transport. Tlie existing buildings are similar in their exterior appearance, consisting of cornigated metal siding and gable roofs. One of the structures exhibits a combination of brick veneer base with cormgated metal siding along the wall areas above. There is a large undeveloped area at the northeasterly portion of the site. There is an existing chain link fence that spans along the westerly, southerly, and easterly frontages of the site. The site is accessible from an existing driveway located at the intersection of Quartz Avenue and Ardine Street, and a secondary gate entry along Quartz Avenue. There are underground utility and reciprocal access easements spanning from the existing driveway to an adjacent, land-locked parcel abutting to the northerly portion of the subject site. AS13772.0860893 4860-8202-7242vl 3

Planning Comtnission (DR 22-03 & VAR 23-23) - 8401 Quartz Ave. October 1, 2024 Page 2 of 17 * Surroundings: Surrounding properties include a fleet yard adjacent to tlie west, an asphalt paving materials manufactuiing plant to the north, a small office building to tlie east, and the Southern Pacific railroad south of the subject site. * Pro.iectDesciiption:Theproposalisfornewconstructionofa7,150square-footprefabiicated storage building and a 1,248 square-foot prefabricated office building. Other site improvements include paving repairs to accoini'nodate a new at-grade level parking lot, new construction of a trash enclosure, and new landscaping within the parking areas and along the easterly frontage of the subject site. * Tl'ie PQ Corporation * Design Team: Sun Engineering Services, LLC (Naresh Patel) @ Municipal Code Requirements for Design Review: Pursuant to tlie City of South Gate Municipal Code (SGMC) Chapter 11.51.060(A)(2), Design Review shall be conducted for all parcels of land fifteen thousand square feet or larger. The subject site measures approximately 5.96 acres, therefore; is subject to Design Review. * Municipal Code Requirements for a Variance: Pursuant to SGMC Chapter 11.53.020, a Variance may be granted to allow the following, where the characteristics addressed by the variance are unique to the property and not shared by adjacent parcels. The unique characteristic must pertain to tlie land itself, not to the structure, its inhabitants, or the property owners: A. A reduction or variation in setback and yard regulations; parking and/or loading regulations; height regulations; and the expansion, extension, alteration, or relocation of nonconforming buildings and uses. B. A change in the required location of accessory buildings and uses, and the designated front or frontage of the building site. C. A reduction or variation in area regulations, including limitations on the area covered by accessoiy buildings. * Required Findings for a Variance: Pursuant to SGMC Chapter 11.53.040, before a variance may be granted, the planning commission (or the city council on appeal) shall make specific findings based on the pertinent evidence of the application and conditions of the property that all of the following conditions exist in reference to the property: a. The property is subject to exceptional or extraordinary physical conditions or circumstances that do not apply generally to the property or class of use in the same zone and vicinity; AS13772.0860893 4860-8202-7242vl 4

Plai'ining Coinmission (DR 22-03 & VAR 23-23) - 8401 Quartz Ave. October 1, 2024 Page 3 of 17 b. The exceptional or extraordinary physical conditions or circumstances are a characteristic of the propeity in relation to the regulations of this title, and not a result by the applicant/property owner or any previous owner of the property. c. The variance is necessary for the preservation and enjoyment of a substantial property right possessed by other properties in the same vicinity and zone and would be denied to the property based on the application of the provisions of this title without the issuance of a variance. d. Granting the variance will not be materially detrimental to the public health, safety, or welfare, or cause adverse effect on any surrounding property orproperty improvements in the same vicinity and zone. e. Granting the variance will not confer on the applicant any special privilege that is denied by this title to any other property or class of use in the same vicinity and zone. f. Granting the variance is consistent with the intent of the general plan. ANALYSIS: Description of Site Improvements The proposed project involves new construction of a 7,150 square-foot prefabricated storage building and a 1,248 square-foot prefabricated office building at the northerly edge of the subject site. The new storage building is proposed to measure approximately 65 feet in width, 110 feet in length, and 22 feet in height. The exterior design will consist of cornugated metal siding throughout the exterior walls, two roll-up doors oriented south, window openings along the northerly fagade, and a cornigated metal gable roof design to match those of existing structures. The interior space will consist of an open floor plan (no interior partitions) to maximize the storage capacity. The proposed building elevations depict a 6-inch gap between the structures. However, the office building is proposed to be attached to the new storage building with structural grade straps and connecting braces. The structure will measure approximately 22'-8" in width, 52 feet in length, and 14 feet in height. The exterior design will incorporate engineered wood siding on the exterior walls and a flat roof design with built-up theri'noplastic polyolefin (TPO) roofing membrane. The interior configuration of the new office building will accommodate three office spaces, one conference room, a supply room, a break room, an Internet Technology (IT) room, and two restrooms. A recommended condition will require that the exposed connections between the structures be concealed with the engineered wood siding to match the material and design of the proposed office structure. The new structures are proposed to be painted in a combination of earthtone colors including tan, brown, off-white, and shades of grey. The proposed color scheme of the storage building will consist of a tan color for the exterior walls, the roof will be painted grey, and the doors will be painted brown. The office building is proposed to be painted with an off-white color with grey AS13772.0860893 4860-8202-7242vl 5

Plaiu'iing Coi'nunission (DR 22-03 & VAR 23-23) - 8401 Quaitz Ave. October 1, 2024 Page 4 of 17 trim accents. A recommended condition of approval will require that the proposed color schemes be refined by incoiporating accent colors on the storage building to enhance tlie stark appearance of the long spans of solid wall areas and the overall appearance of the structures. Furthen'nore, a condition of approval will require submittal of physical samples of tlie proposed paint color for staff review and approval. The exterior of the existing structure located at the soutlieast portion of the site exhibits some deferred maintenance, therefore, a recorni'nended condition of approval will require that said structure be repainted in a color scheme compatible witli that of tlie proposed structures to improved overall aesthetics of the site. Other site improvements include paving repairs and alterations for the creation of an at-grade level parking lot at the northwesterly portion of tlie site. The proposed parking lot will consist of thirty parking spaces. An additional twelve parking spaces are proposed to be situated tl'houghout other portions of the site. Although the plans submitted for review appear to comply with the minimum development standards and dimensions for off-street parking facilities, a recominended condition of approval will require the applicant to submit enlarged site plans of the proposed parking areas to include, but not be limited to, clear dimensions of driveway aisles, parking spaces, back-up clearances, and adjoining walkways and planters. The plans should also clearly numerate and label all parking spaces by their type (i.e. standard, compact, electric vehicles, ADA, etc.). Pursuant to SGMC Chapter 11.24.060, a minimum of 20 square feet waste/refuse storage space is required per 1,000 square feet of building area. As a result, the project is required to provide a total of 884 square feet of waste storage area. Records from the City's franchise waste hauling servicer, United Waste Services (UWS), indicate that the existing manufacturing plant has historically generated a low waste volume, averaging one pick-up (20-cubic yard container) per month. The applicant is requesting a Variance to deviate from the minimum requirement for the trash storage facilities. As such, the project proposes the construction of a new trash enclosure which will measure approximately nine feet in width and twenty-eight feet in length, and six feet in height, totaling approximately 252 square feet, approximately 632 square feet less than tlie required trash storage area. The proposed enclosure will accommodate a total of four containers: two containers (2-cubic yard capacity) for regular waste and two containers (2-cubic yard capacity) for recyclable waste. The design of the proposed enclosure will consist of concreate maso unit ("cmu") block walls witli decorative metal panel doors. Staff recommends a condition of approval requiring that the trash and recyclable waste be collected at least two times per week to ensure that trash storage facility does not overflow and that the site is maintained clean and free of visible trash or debris. Pursuant to SGMC Chapter 11.24.060, the front setback (primary frontage along Quartz Avenue) shall be at minimum, 10 feet. Furthennore, at least sixty percent of the required (primary frontage) setback area (6700 square feet) shall be landscaped. The project proposes to incorporate approximately a total of 6,964 square feet of landscaping, including new planters within the parking lot area and along the southeasterly frontage of tl'ie site. Creeping vines are also proposed to be planted along the easterly frontage of property with the intent that they grow into the existing chain link fence. A portion of an existing active railroad spur intersects the required front setback area, and as a result, approximately 6,000 square feet of landscaping is proposed to be planted within the primary frontage area. Therefore, the project will not comply the minimum requirement for landscaping. The applicant is requesting a Variance to deviate from the minimum required AS13772.0860893 4860-8202-7242vl 6

Plaru'iing Coiui'nission (DR 22-03 & VAR 23-23) - 8401 Quartz Ave. October 1, 2024 Page 5 of 17 landscaping within the front setback area. As such, the pro5ectproposes to incorporate deficient amount of landscaping within the parking lot located at tlie northerly portion of tlie site. Staff recomi'nends a condition of approval requiring tl'iat all landscape planters be constructed witli a 6- inch-tall curb to contain all the landscaping species. Except for the creeping vine planter beds, all otlier planter widths shall be not less than three feet in width to allow for adequate growth of the planting species. Another recorni'nended condition will require the submittal of a complete set of landscape plans prepared by a landscape architect for the entire property, showing the planter designs, pliotographs and schedule of plant material, planter location and metliod of automatic peri'nanent irrigation to ensure the landscape improvements consist of a drought-tolerant, high- quality design. Pursuant to SGMC Chapter 11.24.060(I), any uses or activity not contained wholly within a building shall be screened on all property lines by a minimum six-foot-high site wall or fencing and shall provide sufficient visual screening. (Landscape screening shall be provided between the site wall and the primary street frontage.). The site is currently developed a chain link fence that extends almost entirely along the perimeter of the site, therefore; the project will not incorporate a solid perimeter wall. However, the applicant is requesting a Variance to deviate from the Zoning Code requirements for screening of the entire site perimeter. The applicant proposes to incorporate creeping vines to the existing fence only along a portion of the primary frontage of the site given that the southerly, westerly, and northerly have limited-to-no-visibility from the public viewshed. A recoini'nended condition of approval will require a planter strip along the primary frontage approximately one-foot wide to allow for proper growth of the proposed creeping vines. Business Operations The existingmanufacturingplant utilizes two primai'yraw materials (sand and soda ash) to develop sodium silicate. As part typical daily operations, the sand and soda ash are delivered by truck or rail and unloaded into existing silos. The raw materials are then weighed and fed to the furnace througli conveyors and elevators and heated to fon'n sodium silicate. The silicate comes out in a liquid (molten) form and is cooled. The solid silicate is then shipped off the site as a solid or is further processed to make liquid sodium silicate. The solid products are shipped out by rail, truck, or container and the liquid products are shipped by rail, truck, or drums. In addition to the furnace, the plant operates a natural gas-fired boiler, two air compressors, and several water and sodium silicate pumps. There are conveyors and elevators to move the solid products to storage and shipping areas. There are additional tanks for liquid processing and storing liquid products. A maximum of nine employees currently works at the site at any time. Designated employees visit other plant buildings only intermittently. On-site transitions to/from various buildings are done either on foot or using forklifts or amaintenance cart. Theplant currently operates Monday through Friday, 5:00 am to 4:00 pm for approximately six months of the year. During this period a maximum of nine (9) employees work at the site. The remainer of the year the plant runs 24 hours, seven days per week. During this half of the year the plant operates with only four to five (4-5) employees per working shift. On average, there is one (1) visitor per day to this plant. AS13772.0860893 4860-8202-7242vl 7

Planning Comi'nission (DR 22-03 & VAR 23-23) - 8401 Quartz Ave. October 1, 2024 Page6ofl7 An average of five trucks enters and exit per day, for deliveries and product shipment. Trucks typically access the property through the southerly gate fronting Quartz Avenue, load or unload, and exit through the same access point. The exception to this occurs when there are train cars loading/unloading on the rail spurs, in which then trucks enter and exit through the main gate. There are no proposed changes in staff, hours of operation, nor the truck delivery/pick-up schedule as part of the proposed project. Compatibility Overall, with implementation of recoinmended conditions, the proposed buildings and the parking area improvements will be in keeping with existing structures and operations of the site and the surrounding context. Specifically, the scale of the proposed structures, cornigated metal and engineered wood-clad facades, gable roof designs and material finishes are consistent and compatible with the structures within surrounding neighborhood. In addition, the proposed parking area improvements, new landscaping, and trash storage facilities, will enhance the overall maintenance and appearance of the site and irnrnediate vicinity. Off-Street Parking Pursuant to SGMC Chapter 11.33.040, the minimum off-street parking requirement for manufacturing uses is 1 parking space per 3 employees on maximum shi'ft is required; or 1 parking space per 300 square feet of building gross floor area, whichever is greater. In addition, the minimum requirement for professional office uses is 1 parking space per 200 square feet of building gross floor area; and the minimum requirement for storage buildings is 1 parking space per 1000 square feet of building gross floor area. In accordance with the City's parking standards, a total of 135 off-street parking spaces are required for the existing manufacturing uses and proposed storage and office buildings. The parking calculations are detailed in the table below: PARKING REQUIREMENTS Parking Ratio (Manufacturing) 1 space / 300 s.f. of g.f.a Building area = 34,522 s.f.: 115.07 parking spaces (Storage) 1 space/ 1,000 s.f. of g.f.a Building area = 7,150 s.f.: 7.15 parking spaces (Office) 1 space/200 s.f. of g.f.a Building area = (existing)1308 + (new) 1,248 s.f.: 12.78 parking spaces 115.07 + 7.15 + 12.78 parking spaces = 135 parking spaces Required # of 135 parking spaces AS13772.0860893 4860-8202-7242vl 8

Plai'uiing Commission (DR 22-03 & VAR 23-23) - 8401 Quartz Ave. October 1, 2024 Page 7 of 17 parking spaces Proposed # of parking spaces 42 parking spaces Deficient # of parking spaces 93 spaces As proposed, the project would accommodate a total of 42 off-street parking spaces: thirty parking spaces will be located within tlie proposed parking lot, three parking spaces are proposed adjacent to the new office building, three additional spaces are proposed along tlie northerly edge of the existing wash room ("building 12") as depicted on the plans, four parking spaces are proposed at the westerly edge of the site, and two parking spaces are proposed in front of an office ("building 5") located near the southerly site access gate. The subject property will be deficient 93 parking spaces. The applicant is requesting a Variance to deviate from the minimum requirement for off-street parking given that the current operations consist of an average number of nine employees on-site within work shi'fts. The business operations are not expected to change; however, the new office building will increase the potential capacity of employees within work shifts. Variance Analysis In granting approval of a Variance to deviate from the minimum requirements of the Zoning Code pertaining to off-street parking, landscaping, and a site perimeter wall, the Planning Coinmission must make findings in connection with the Variance, as set forth in the SGMC. A Variance may be approved only if all of the following findings are made: A. The property is subject to exceptional or extraordinai'y physical conditions or circumstances that do not apply generally to the property or class of use in the same zone and vicinity iix that the subject site consists of a unique, irregular-sliaped parcel currently developed with a mayxufacturing plant that will remain and contains utiliffl infrastructure and reciproca[ access easements to service abutting properties that are land-locked. Furthermore, the site is adjacent to active railroad lirxes atid two railroad spurs terminate within t1ie subject site. These conditions create practical difficulties in adhering to the standard zoning requirements specifically, providing landscaping within the required setback areas and the minimum number of off-street parkirxg spaces. The existing railroad spurs and easements also occupy areas within the site where parkitig spaces would poterxtially be accommodated if they didix't exist. Based otz the curreixt business operations only nitze employees are on-site within a work shift. In arxticipation that such operations will not change because of the proposed project, the Ciffl's waste hauling servicer ([JVVS) determined that the that the existing business operations currently generate a low volume of waste; and the proposed new storage and office uses are expected to getxerate a negligible increase in waste volume. Therefore, AS13772.0860893 4860-8202-7242vl 9

Planning Coini'nission (DR 22-03 & VAR 23-23) - 8401 Quartz Ave. October 1, 2024 Page 8 of 17 compliance wit1i the minimum requiremeiits of the Zoiiing C

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Action agendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
MinutesNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Transcript or captionsNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Official pages

Coverage and corrections

Records considered

  • Planning Commission
  • Planning Commission — Packet

Not claimed by this page

  • Verified meeting decisions with item-specific public-source evidence
  • Item-level plain-language summaries are not available; this page does not infer individual agenda items.
  • Item-linked, attributed deliberation
  • A source-grounded next meeting date
  • A plain-English overview is not available.
  • Official outcomes have not been published.
  • A transcript is not available.
  • No audio or video recording is linked.
  • Speakers have not been reliably matched to public profiles.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.
  • An individual roll-call roster is not available.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: 3ac7a76b5321951e9867a99cb08086e8. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record