POLISCOPE

The public record

MIAMI-DADE COUNTY · LOCALHeld · official record pendingPartial coverage

Board of County Commissioners - Part 2

Tuesday, July 20, 2021 · County government meeting record

The 30-second read

Record incomplete

Board of County Commissioners - Part 2

Why it matters

The official meeting record is available below. Item-level plain-language summaries are not available yet.

What happens next

The scheduled meeting date has passed. Minutes or an action agenda are not published in the records we hold.

This meeting date has passed and no official outcome record has been published yet. Nothing on this page is a decision.

Record text

No transcript is held for this meeting. Recording: Media

Showing the first 60,000 of 265,801 characters. The full document is at the source.

that it's cool too. >> Good morning MR. CHAIRMAN and members bit of my name is Josc) Smith and I am a 55 year resident of Miami-Dade. I live in Normandy Shores and I used to serve on the city commission. I served for two terms and I'm currently the chair of the oversight committee of residents that would like you all to support the item five ee, which is on your agenda and approve the creation of this redevelopment agency. I'm also here to remind. >> One minute MR. Smith is this a public hearing item because if it is. >> Five ee as a public hearing. >> We will call you during public and. >> Thank you, sir. >> Myself as well? >> 5v, absolutely. No we have Ron (Name?). Is this five e also? >> Marvin Ramsey. Good morning my name is Marvin Ramsey and my address is 326 ne. 1/52 Street Miami, Florida 33162. I'm currently the PRESIDENT Of Biscayne Gardens Civic Association representing approximately 35 or 36,000 residents in the area. Just lke to say that we do have a concern with the five percent traffic, the residence of Biscayne Gardens strongly believed if not changed or amended we will be forced to deal with non-(Word?) Vehicles adding to our system. Thank you. >> Thank you very much. If we could all take this opportunity to silence our cell phones and put them on vibrate that would be great. Thank you all for reminding me to also put it on vibrate here also. Commissioner Higgins I know yours is not on vibrate. So MR. Book Father of Senator Brett your retinas. >> MR. CHAIRMAN before I start we have three homeless trustees items on the agenda is there anyway you like me to take the items? >> No particular order. Christ let me start than if that's okay with 10 87, which are the renewals under the food and beverage tax. CHAIRMAN And members of the commission, in the 26 1/2 years of the trust existence the trust has never done a bid waiver. To the best of my regulation there's only been one instance where we have come to the commission and asked the commission to extend the contract beyond its period of existence and that was approximately 15 years ago. It was a partial extension of a contract when a provider decided to pull out we needed to get a new provider and and so that is the only other time we have done an extension. I need nt tell all of you what a challenging time it has been during covid for te trust and our providers. We are coming to ask you to extend these areements one additional year beyond the three-year term of its contract for continuity purposes. If we do not extend we run the risk of people being displaced. We run the risk of providers not moving forward. We hve run the risk that we will bid it and get less beds, less units than what we currently have no because we all know cost of providing services and housing has increased. This ensures continuity of care for purposes that have been expensing homelessness. Many of which who came into our continuum during quarantine and isolation program, the hotel program as many of you identify. We have got the eviction moratorium expiring 11 days from today. The challenges that we will meet are significant. Let me remind you, 584 emergency shelter beds, three Hunter Nate units of permanent housing with supportive services, 1500 indoor mils a month, almost prevention and assistance, street outreach for 600. >> Just so you know I think we got that one. I know these items were waived. So if you could go to the next one. >> MR. CHAIRMAN on 14 a 15 if I could, which is a priority of this kind of question during the last session the legislator. $562,000 Of specialized money to provide rich housing and the spport services for what we consider to be the high flyers. The most difficult in the community. Never been a time of greater significance when we sought the money it was with a clear understanding that Camilla's house would operate the program in a set-aside facility within the Camillus poperty. It is a big deal to us. They have dedicated staff, dedicated programming. It is around-the-clock support services. Crisis unit issues, and the light. It is not terribly difficult, it is passed to the state of a preparation, which we have been successful in achieving during the last legislator. Third item that we have is 14 a 24 . I want to take a minute to think director Lou for the partnership that we find at the homeless trust that we have today with public housing department. >> Please take two seconds to think him and 15 seconds to wrap it up. >> If we do not by an adult living facility where we have been housing senior citizens throughout the pandemic we will be putting elderly people into a state of homelessness. Period. End of story. If no capacity to house the myriad of seniors. We took 185 of them out of our shelters and put them into isolation and quarantine. It took almost 300 off the streets we have been housing these individuals. We do not have housing if we do not buy this building. Public housing director found this first $5 million, which does not give us all the way there, but it gets us pretty close. Let me just remind you, we tested over 22,000 individuals. We vaccinated almost 2500, our positivity rate has been 1.2 percent because our providers and their staff and the homeless trust staff have risked their lives to save the people that we are trying to protect with this preparation. >> Thank you. That was the last of the cards for reasonable opportunity to be heard. It is officially the longest reasonable opportunity to be heard since we have been on the days together Commissioner Jenny. They heard the CHAIRMAN Would not be here and they all signed up. Last meeting. Right no we are going to set the agenda, right? And maturity are MR. Turney? We have one more? >> Yes, sir. >> We have one more. It is a lot. >> Never say never. >> Your name and address. >> My name is (Name?) And my address is 3328 Northwest 53rd Sreet Miami, Florida 33 142. Kenny commissioners I come here to speak against 1026 is increase of price of affordable housing in Miami Dade -- and so-called housing advocates to represent the benefits of raising the cost of infill housing. Here's one fact that they cannot reboot. The first item you need in the homelessness process is the bank's pequalification letter. Imagine a working class family going into a bank post pandemic to secure a $300,000 bank approval loan. If you are a single parent you can forget about it. The (Word?) That the model cdc consulted for the information estimated that to get a $300,000 prequalification letter you have to be making $67,000 a year. Either as an individual or as a couple. With my last minute I just have to say this about this item. We have been fighting this item since APRIL 9,2019 and as for myself if this item passes I will be alright. If you pass this item you will be alright. Most of the people in this room will be alright, but we hve people in our county who cannot afford to come to these meetings, who cannot afford to take the day off. If we pass increase of affordable housing they will not be alright. You MAY never see them and you MAY never have to encounter them for they MAY never confront you. They don't have time to come here and confront you, but keep that in your mind. They will not be alright. Okay thank you for your time. >> Thank you. >> Good morning Brenda (Name?) 1436 (Name?) Street. Good money to commissioners and mayor. Just have a quick question. Are we going to continue helping seniors with the section 8 programs because we have received so many complaints about seniors trying to get some information and they are not able to do it. Want to see if it is possible to see if it is possible to find out what is going on. For Commissioner Higgins just a question. -- We've been receiving a lot of phone calls on the radio complaining about them not being served and the boss is not picking them up. I really appreciate if you could look into it because the senior centers, the one in h Street and eighth seven Avenue they have been lacking in picking up. We are concerned about it. Thank you. >> Thank you. Reasonable opportunity is no closed for MADAM Attorney. >> Yes MR. Chair there are a few plural luminary matters. Item 2b two. Senator Garcia poses item. Af one. Commissioner Cohen Higgins and Commissioner Regalado are adding their names to the pole list and vice CHAIRMAN Gilbert is releasing his pull of the siding. That is item 8 of one. Af two Commissioner Cohen Higgins adds her name to the pole list. 8f6. Commissioner Higgins adds this item to the pole list. Eight f7 and supplement vice CHAIRMAN Gilbert and Commissioner Higgins and Commissioner Regalado are pulling this item. Nine a one. Commissioner Regalado is releasing her poll of this item and the administration has asked for deferral of data. With the setting of the agenda this item will be deferred. Tenant a five. Commissioner Mcghee is assuming sponsorship of this item and is requesting deferral to know date certain. 11 a five, vice CHAIRMAN Gilbert releases this item. He was the only drink 24 Commissioner. Item -- she was the only polling Commissioner Peter Peter 14 a six Commissioner -- Cohen Higgins and Commissioner Mcghee add their names to the poll list. 14 a 16 and at supplement Commissioner Martinez is polling this item. 14 a 20 this is an ordinance for first rating so I will read 14 a 20 with the first reading items. 14 a 23. Senator Garcia holds this item. 14 a 24 is a public hearing item. This item will be taken up with the other public hearing items and MR. Vice chair I have some request to (Word?) This item for discussion. 15 b1, commissioners Regalado, Sosa, and Heyman are releasing this item. There were no other polling commissioners. I also have some request for cosponsorship. 11 a 13, Senator Garcia wishes to be listed as the cosponsor. He also wishes to be listed as a cosponsor on items 14 a one and 14 a six. Item -- listed as cosponsors. 14 a 20 Commissioner Mcghee wishes to be listed as a cosponsor. Senator Garcia, and Commissioner Martinez wish to be listed as cosponsors. The items to be considered at today's meetings will be those listed in the Pinto final agenda with the additions, dferrals, and (Word?) Noted in the memorandum, and te items I mentioned the Commissioner will approve this by a single vote by excepting the agenda on except first rating. Public ordinances, ordinances set for second reading, items 18 a one, and 11 a 10 those are commercial service -- voted on separately and are not on your poll lst under section 14 advisory board appointments, which is your item 15 d1 and it supplement there is a ballot for the appointment of members to the County Public Library advisory board. I believe a ballad has been or will be distributed. The following poll items. Item 1 e-two, site one e-two we did. Item two b2, eight e four, 8f1, 8f six, eight f7, and it supplement, 8g1, 8g two, 8g3, 8g4, 8j two, 8j four, eight and five, eight and six, eight -- 14 a one, 14 a two, 14 a five, 1487, 14 89, 14 810, 14 811, 14 812, 14 eight 1314 a 14, 14 a 16, 14 817 and settlement, 14 a 18, 14 819, 14 820, which is the first reading item and i will read those with the first rating speed 14 821, 14 822, 14 a 23, 14 a 24, which is a public hearing item, which will be taken up at the time of the other public hearing items are taken unpaid 14 825, 14 a 26, 14 827, 14 828, and 14 a 29. MR. Chair a motion to set the order is on the agenda. >> MR. Chair. >> Yes Commissioner. I would like to add 11 813 to the pole list for final amendment that I would like to offer a commission. >> I thought everything was on the poll list, but okay. >> MR. Chair if I can I would like to release 8j2 and cosponsor it, please. >> That sounds good to me. >> MR. Chair I pulled item eight f6 because the department needs to make a small man and nobody has approved it. If you'd like the department to read it no it could be approved with the setting of the agenda. Mohammed are you available? >> Thank you Commissioner good morning everyone and chair. No I am (Name?). On item eight f6 it is to remove all references to group two, which would be awarded a later date. The fiscal impact for the five-year term is reduced by $350,000 for $80 to 12,000,472 dollars. -- Of 12,000,047 dollars. It is amended to remove the seb preference and the local preference and will apply the price offered by the local renter is higher than the allotted preference to the local firm. The table is amended to correct second growth to reflect the second responder ppe is only awarded group 3. Page 5 resolution title and the second paragraph, any reference to group 2 is deleted. Amount is reduced by $350,000 for $80 for $12,000,472. Thank you. >> Okay. Show that men excepted together. Commissioner Monestime would you like to read yours into the record? >> Thank you MR. Chair. I want to say thank you to Commissioner Mcghee for sponsoring this item upon the request of some of the constituents that we both represent. Both in the district and this district I would like to offer an amendment to remove numerical item four and five and change number 624 and if the amendment is accepted I would like to ask that I cosponsor this item with him if he allows me. >> Thank you and thank you to my colleague. Commissioner monitoring without a question. I have except both of yur request to cosponsor along with the amendments to this (Word?). >> That is in the last "whereas" clause. > Thank you show the iem amended and list Commissioner Monestime as a cosponsor. >> MR. Chair. >> Okay. Commissioner Heyman. >> Thank you MR. Chair. If it is appropriate at this time we have a lot of 14s that have not been pulled and if we could enter those as moving I would be happy to move them when we set the agenda. >> Absolutely (Indiscernible). >> MR. Chair. >> Yes. >> Who is speaking? Commissioner Sosa how are you? > Hi I am a little bit better. Thank you for asking. MR. Chair I would like to ask if you allow me to release item 14 a 13. I was the only person who trained 26 the item. I would like to afford the rule for 14 a seven. >> 1404 14 a seven. MADAM Attorney do you have that? >> Thank you. So Commissioner Heyman are going to move all the love them and we will get the agenda set. Just so we know how this will work. Anytime you want to release something you are the only pulling person that is always in order. That is always in order and we are going to do a heartbreak at 1:00 P.M. For lunch. From 1:00 P.M. To 2:00 P.M. We will be at lunch break. It's also vice Chair we also received word that Commissioner Regalado would like to release items ag two, ag three, and ag four. >> Yes. >> 1487 has been for day ruled. Would you like to read the four teams that have not been pulled. >> I want to make sure Commissioner Higgins is good. You good? >> Yes, sir. Have a motion on an item to change the public hearing date for an item to SEPTEMBER 1. I could read that no if we are willing to do that. >> Yes. >> I think the county attorney has the motion to be read. This is an item we will see it zoning, but because of the committee cancellations last week we were able to do the public hearing so this will move to SEPTEMBER 1. Are you ready to read that or do you want me to read it. Thank you, Jerry. Higgins motion is to set the public hearing for road closing petition p9 seven d1 on the board of County commissioners meeting on SEPTEMBER 1, 2021 at 9:30 A.M. In the Stephen p Clark center in the commission chambers -- of general situation in the county at least two weeks prior to such date. >> Thank you MR. Chair. >> So that will be approved with the agenda? Okay. >> Yes with the setting of agenda. >> With the setting of agenda, okay. Just so we know how this is running in Siebel and peta I have the members appearing virtually and on the screen in front of me and I see Commissioner Sosa has raised her hand. Commissioner Regalado was reckless first. >> Since Commissioner Sosa for day ruled my item I wanted to ask the Google rep resented us, to tell the Google representatives that are here that were available for your questions that they can go home. Sorry, folks. We were really excited about getting that done today, but I guess that will not happen. Then I also have a motion similar to Commissioner Higgins to move something to the SEPTEMBER 1. This is legislator number 211306 an ordinance that I'm sponsoring pertaining to the board's rules of procedure. As adopted on first reading on JUNE 2, 2021, board meeting as item for e and was scheduled for public hearing blithely JULY 14 CHAIRMAN's Council on policy meeting as item 1g2 because the meeting was canceled I would like to request that the county attorney read a motion to set the public hearing for this item at the SEPTEMBER 1, 2021 board meeting. >> MADAM Attorney. >> Yes, sir. That would be legislator number 211 306, which was the ordinance that Commissioner Regalado had referred to it relating to boards of rules and procedure that apply when a municipality adopts a position on a board or committee agenda item. Commissioner Regalado is moving to suspend the item for acne review so the second reading of such ordinance could be held at the SEPTEMBER 1, 2021 board of county commissioner meeting. >> That will be approved with the setting of agenda. >> Yes, sir. Want to go to the items that will be aproved? Sorry Commissioner so set your reckless. >> Thank MR. Chair. I will follow my colleagues. On ledger start 2109 98 and ordinance that I sponsored pertaining to for hired mower vehicles was adopted as item for age at the MAY 4, 2021 board meeting and was scheduled for public hearing as item 1 g1 at the JUNE 8 2021 transportation and planning committee and as item 1 g2 at the JULY 13, 2021 transportation mobility planning committee because both committees meetings were canceled I would like to request that the county attorney read my motion related to setting the public hearing for this item as of SEPTEMBER 1, 2021 or meeting and I thank you for this opportunity. >> Thank you Commissioner Sosa. MADAM Attorney. >> Yes sir. Commissioner Sosa since the rules and procedure requiring -- 210 998 and ordinance related to for to hire vehicles. -- Set ordinance at the SEPTEMBER 1, 2021 board of County commissioners meeting. MR. Vice Chair Commissioner Heyman has a similar motion that she has requested that we just read. Commissioner Heyman is moving to suspend the rules of procedure requiring committee review as to legislator to 11 518 and ordinance relating to the independent civilian panel. Further moves to set the public hearing and second reading for set ordinance at the SEPTEMBER 1, 2021 board of County commissioners meeting. MR. Chair would you like me to read what items are left on the 66.0304(11)(A) List? >> What is on the poll list or not on the pll list? >> Which list is shorter? Process of illumination. Go ahead. >> I think the 223 is shorter. >> To b2. >> 8b4, 8f1, 8f2, 8f7 and a supplement, eight g1, eight j2, eight l2, eight and one, 8m6, 1186, 11 a11. -- 14 a 11 has been pulled,-14 a5 was pulled, 1486 was not polled, 1487 was for day ruled. -- And 11 were not pulled. 14 a 12, 13, and 14 were nt pulled. 15 was not polled, 16 was, 17, 18, 19 or not. 14 a 20 is the first item. 14 a 21 and 14 a 22 were not pulled. 14 a 23 has a pulling Commissioner.- -Which will take up with the others. 14 a 25, 26, 27, 20, and 29 have not been 66.0304(11)(A) Six. Would you like me to read the ones that have been polled so the board knows? >> Yes. >> I show 14 a three, five, 14 a 16 and a supplement, 14 a 20, 14 a 21, 14 a 23 and publican. Those are the only four teams that remain once the motion is approved with the setting of the agenda as stated by Commissioner Heyman. >> Okay I think they are trying to hand you another motion to read right now behind you. >> I don't have another one do I? >> While-Viola. I'm sorry Commissioner Martinez I did not see her hand. I apologize Commissioner Martinez. >> Took a bead -- I refuse the item and I was the only 66.0304(11)(A) For Cmmissioner on it. >> 14 a six show released good thank you Commissioner Martinez. >> Yes vice Chair Gilbert has another motion. Is moving to suspend the rules of procedure requiring committee review as to adjust our item number 211 752, which was item 1g2 on the 715 21 cio agenda, which was canceled. Further moves to set the public hearing and second reading for set ordinance at the SEPTEMBER 1 2121 board of County commissioners meeting. >> Thank you. Did you get Commissioner Martinez comments regarding-he was the only one Commissioner his release of 14 a six. I believe there's a motion to move the agenda. As been moved by Commissioner Heyman. It has been seconded by Commissioner Mcghee paid. Show the agenda set. >> MR. Vice PRESIDENT Would you like to do the first readings? For a is related to workforce housing in the incorporated areas mending -- of the code providing farming as parties to enter into Interlocal agreements with the county to participate in the counties workforce housing deponent program. Mending capter 30 3e and excreting sections 33 eight 18. 33 I 18, 30 3k 17. Authorizing to defer all impact fees for workforce housing -- subject to conditions making technical changes providing several buddy in the code and an effective date. 4b is a and ordinance related to the -- and establishment of a trust fund for such districts. Grading chapter 20 1b article 4 of the code. Creating trail district, which is generally bounded by Miami international import by primitive road on 57th Avenue. Stepper Creek canal on the -- the Palmetto Expressway on the west. Providing for legislative intent findings and purpose grading definitions establishing a trust fund for the district and providing for the funding of such trust fund from certain countywide funds. -- Inclusion and code repeal, and an effective date. Farsi is a ordinance crating Westchester information Center district advisory board providing for purpose composition and duties of the board and other related matters providing severability and inclusion in the code and an effective date. 40 is an ordinance reviewing issue meant from the mighty Dade County Florida Commissioner notes and one of more serious and aggregate printable amount not to exceed $200 million as any at one time and -- of improvements to seek -- including paying commercial paper notes -- authorizing the mayor or Mayor's designee to obtain proposals for selection of crucial paper dealers and payer agents and providers in connection with theproviding severability exclusion from the code and an effective date. 4e has been deferred. 4f is related to the Medicaid hospital program crating article 4 and chapter 18 of the code and enforcement of the ministry payment for the nonfederal share of Medicaid and Medicaid managed care payments paid to benefit existing and newly licensed properties identifying services to be provided providing for severability inclusion in the code and an efective date and 14 a 20 is an ordinance related to the rules and procedure of the Board of County commissioners amending two- one of the code revising rule 505 of the Board's rules providing that agenda items related to the disposition of County owned Robbie MAY only be sponsored by a county commissioner and whose -- exceptions, making technical and conforming changes, finding severability and inclusion in the code and an effective date. Those are your first reading items. >> Move and block. >> It has been moved. >> The terrible second. We need to call role in that? Peter called the role. >> Commissioner Cohen Higgins. >> For. >> Commissioner Garcia. >> I. Hardemon. >> For. >> Commissioner Heyman. >> Commissioner Higgins. >> Commissioner Martinez. >> I. >> Commissioner Mcghee. >> I. Monestime. >> Yes. >> Commissioner Janet. Commissioner Sosa. >> Yes. >> Commissioner Souto. >> Yes. >> Vice CHAIRMAN Gilbert. >> Yes. >> CHAIRMAN Diaz. >> Yes. >> Passes unanimously. >> MR. Chair there are aviation items and they require a super vote and they are not on your list. They are 11 a one and 11 a 10. -- >> By the Higgins one moved and one segment. Thank you all. That needs to be a roll call vote. >> No these are both resolutions. >> Those in favor signify by saying I paid those opposed? Showed that adopted. >> The next item was 11 a 10" I hear a motion by Higgins and the second by the chair. I'm writing this none, all in favor signify by Seeing Eye. Those opposed? >> Show that adopted. I know that we have an item that-can we take five a as a public hearing. >> Yes, sir. >> If we can move to five a.- -Joint deponent boundary, joint municipality boundary change request. Amending sections 20-3.1 and 20-five of the code and Miami Dade County, Florida printing the filing and consideration of proposed boundary changes under certain circumstances and providing for procedures providing severability, inclusion in the code, and the effective date. It is a public imputed. >> Publicly on this item is open and I have, oh well I have a lot of cards. First person I will call is Mayor jc (Name?). JUNE 3 come on down. The next person is Albert Gomez and after that is going to be Nicholas Durand, and after that is going to be smebody who had bad handwriting. Miguel (Name?). >> Good morning MR. Chair, MR. Visor, and chairs of the commission. MADAM Mayor for the opportunity to be here with you today. I am here on this item that is in front of you asking that the item be voted down and the vote "no" for the following reasons. I will not get into specifics. I have spoken to most of you about this, but there are four things that are very important and decide the future of this body and the process. Number one a changing of the rules of the game in the middle of the game is never a good public policy. This item would change the rules of the game and that draws out application for two areas west of the. Mall would become no and void by changing the rules much after the drought has been applied. Number two of the due process for the residence of the city of Dorado the stage will certainly be denied by changing the rules of the game in the middle of the game. That includes me as a resident of the city of (Name?). It is not fair, but it is in fact the process, there due process. Number three the businesses in that area that MAY have a reason our voice her opinion as to why not this area should go to, should stay in the county and should go to Sweetwater will no be limited in their ability to express himself because the choice when it comes to front of you decides who passes will be limited to only two options and I remind you the pab is recommended deferral until JUNE 28 was for Peter finally it's not good public policy. I know that you are in a difficult position. I know there MAY be an argument about the urban deponent, but this has nothing to do with a certain speed this ordinance simile has to do with illuminating the opportunity of a municipality that has applied for an accession in the middle of the process, which is a fairly unfair so I will ask you one more time in the words of the early movie from Spike Lee to do the right ting. I will do-as you to do the right thing. Don't allow the rules of the game to be changed in the middle of the process because it is bad for public policy and I is bad for me this potties, it is better for the county, and it is bad for the governing buddy. I will ask you to do the right thing and be fair and vote no on this item because it impacts the due process of the residence of one of your municipalities that I happen to represent and live in and that is unfair. I ask you to do the right thing and vote note tere. Will ask you to do the right thing because the business community pays taxes and when they talk about annexation they should have a say in this process. They should be able to be heard as to where they want to stay in the county, go to 66.0304(11)(A) Five, or go to another minutes potty. >> I will ask you to do the right thing and bring this to a close. >> Finally I will ask you to do the right thing and vote no because it is not good public policy been it is AUGUST body, which is doing a fantastic job. I've been able to sit on boards with most of you and I know, you have always done te right thing so I ask you to vote no on this agenda item five a. >> Thank you Mayor. >> Albert Gomez 3566 Vista court and with businesses in 2250 102nd Avenue JUNE 25 Florida paid for over 30+ years I have had a business in what no is Douros. I have also been very supportive of industry with a balance on conservation. Obviously I spend all my after hours and conservation. I spend my working hours building industry. So effectively I stated that I was there before it was Douros because we have to look at precedent. When I say precedent, if it was put into law, if it is the rule of the land we have to honor those things more. We are living in a time of variance. Everything gets a variance and approved outside of code. I have seen it day in and day out in Miami-Dade County and altering this potties within it. Everything gets done through variance. If we look at champagne towers that was a variance. Everything is done through variance and if we take a look at it we looked at the urban development boundary. That shouldn't be changed other than with an act of GOD. It is there for a reason. Secondly if we look at who was there first, I believe Sweetwater was there. I have a business and Douros so the reality is I cannot wait to collaborate with the mayor of Chen something. There's nothing more I would love to do than that. That said I think with the reality of the push to annex lands beyond the urban deponent boundary and not honoring that urban deponent boundary, regardless of who wants it. If it is for conservation, great. If it is to develop it I say, no we need to protect our urban deponent boundary. >> My address is 9660 Northwest (Word?) Street. The coalition would like to support it support for 48, and a l two. Would like to give special -- Fort introducing this-would enable the Dade County to better safeguard its agricultural land. >> This is the public hearing on five a? Keep it to five a. In the urban development boundaries are an essential tool for sustaining urban sprawl and helps infill and redevelopment. The county should look for ways to improve these initiatives to preserve land outside of the urban develop and boundary Street and surrounding the county with a buffer of violence and wetlands will not only prove water quality. It will help protect us from storm surge, recharge our aquifer, and allows to move water into these areas when larger flooding occurs. As the most sustainable thing we can do. And owners laugh at the value offered per unit of limpid how can we make land acquisition programs more attractive so this option is exercised. Between no and the second reading we would love to bring storm with you on ways to improve the program so it's exercise and more land is protected. So getting onto five a. We also think it's important to have it -- the candy should have a 30 outside of the udp consistent with the -- 2015 report on annexation and incorporation. It states that the udp is important to a fort Miami-Dade County for defining urban service, proof texting since of land and land use limitations. Because of the importance the consultant Rick mended the annexation of areas outside of the udb not be permitted in order to maintain county control over sch areas. Speaking personally these are the sorts of programs and policies that I want to see for the future Miami-Dade County. As lifelong resident. >> Thank you very much. >> Thank you. >> Already MR. CHAIRMAN, commissioners, members of the separate my name is Miguel Deas and I a an attorney at Custer 600 brickle Avenue Miami, floater. I'm here on behalf of the city of Jensen team. We are here to oppose item %a which was crafted to -- and private Douros of his due process rights to have its annexation application heard under the code rules, which are the roles in which Duros applied almost 7 months ago. The timeline and a specific substantive changes proposed an item 5a leave no doubt that the proposed ordinance before you was tailored specifically to ufairly disqualify Douros's annexation. Let's talk about the timeline. On SEPTEMBER 24, 2020 Sweetwater filed an application to annex the area in question paid quickly and two months later it was before the bcc on SEPTEMBER 19 and it was quickly set to the pa before Allison and recognition. Douros filed on DECEMBER 21, 2020 and it was told by the clerk in writing that their application would be before the bcc for referral to the planning advisory board on JANUARY 20 and mysteriously and never made the agenda of JANUARY 28 despite numerous requests. Douros's annexation application was not agenda for the County commission in fiber, March, APRIL. Finally it was agenda on MAY 4 and to Douros's surprise it was aso there along with an item that is before you today, 5a, which in essence does golf eyes Douros and makes its application no. What does 5a do? It craves continuity that disqualifies him something. Every application that yu approve before including Sweetwater's application of the dolphin Mall area that was annexed in 2010 defined contiguity and use contiguity as connecting at a corner. Both Douros and Sweetwater's application under current law are contiguous at exactly its the same way by connecting at corners and touching occurrence. Douros is at 25th Street and Sweetwater is at 12. This ordinance before you changes that and makes Douros's noncontiguous and allows Sweetwater application to remain contiguous, remain contiguous by crating an artificial standard. Counting of the area between Northwest Hall Street and Northwest 25th Street as a common boundary even though there is a c2 canal in there. I ask you to do the right thing, allow Douros and the affected people in the area. >> Thank you cards due process and an oportunity to be heard under the rules of the game that were in place. Thank you. >> Think is much. >> Thank you. Your time is up. >> Thank you, take care. >> (Name?). I MAY have messed that up. Digna, Armando (Name?), Christian (Name?), and Laberto Spagato. That is the next four. >> Good morning. MR. CHAIRMAN and Vice CHAIRMAN And commissioners it is an honor for me to be here among all of you and I am here for you to please to listen to our call on the -- on the COUNCILMAN Of the city of Douros. My address is 401 northwest. 53rd Street Douros, Florida 30166. So we are here to request to ask you to please submit what the mayor was mentioning to please vote against 5a. Our residents of the city of Douros are very concerned because this is an application that was submitted on DECEMBER, the city of Douros. I told personally by the Chair that it would be placed on the agenda in JANUARY. JANUARY, fabric, MARCH, and it came up to you on MAY on the pab on MAY. At that time, at the same time it was placed in a resolution to make changes on the boundaries. So for us as an affair for the residents of the city of Douros that are application has been among one the delay for it to be presented among the pab, and at the same time the application on the resolution that is made by the Chair, that represent our district. Something that should be fair and should be partial because at the end of the day he is representing all of us. So we are asking you to please look into it and to support our community. As you can see it is not being represented fairly by our Chair that is at the same time our Commissioner. >> That is all I have to say. >> Thank you. >> Good morning my name is Armando (Name?). -- 1017 3166. I'm here to read a statement on behalf of COUNCILWOMAN Claudia (Name?) With the city of Douros, who we have disputed copies for your reference. It reads as follows. As a resident and elected representative of the residents of the city of Douros I thank you for allowing me this opportunity to respectively stress my opposition to agenda item 5a and encourage you to vote no on the item. I consider that the intent to redefine the term of contiguity in this ordinance, while there are competing applications for annexation of the same area is untimely, unfounded, and unfair. I would like to leave on record at several points that relate to this ordinance. Number one, as a point of reference in 2010 when Sweetwater requested to annex an area that includes the dolphin Mall, officials promised residents that their taxes would be lowered. When in fact their millage rate, their millage rate was raised. Number two we are no home to over 70,000 residents in the city of Douros, with one of the largest and most diverse minority communities in the state of Florida. Comprised of multicultural and multigenerational households. Thirdly the city of Jen 17 department including our police and the public works department are highly reliable, responsive, accessible, and significantly contribute towards a superb quality of life to our residents and businesses. Fourth there are 295 property owners in the annexation area such as Telemundo and Home Depot and as our exhibits to mistreat the mjority of these businesses do not want to be incorporated into the city of Sweetwater because their taxes would be raised approximately 107 percent. In spirit of fairness their voices should be heard. To this end I reiterate my rquest to vote no today on the proposed ordinance or at least to be amended to only be applied prospectively to future applications filed after effective date for boundary changes. >> Good morning MR. CHAIRMAN and get money commissioners my name is (Name?) And my address is 9482 northwest. 49 consenting Lane Jen something. I have lived in a Douros for 24 years after working 40 years for an American organization and living in six countries. I came to a point in my life where I got an opportunity to leave. The first choice was the United States and the second choice was the city of Douros. The reason we choose to live here is the respect for the rule of law. Being originally from Argentina I will refer to sucker. I have a good friend of mine who is a good reporter who says Argentina is the only place where in the game you can change the rules after it has started. I said no way. When unfortunately today here I am facing this same situation. There is a change of a role in a game that has already changed -started. That does not speak well about good governors and respect for the rule of law. All we are asking, and I'm asking as a residence is fair treatment. Fair treatment. When you do these changes you are damaging not only one case, you are damaging the reputation we have built over the year. Respect the law and don't change the rules. The summary comes here and I'm an advisor to many investors. The one thing Leo says is, the good news is that the rules are set to be followed and respected. Don't expect a game change in the middle of the game. So I kindly ask of you, and I know many of you have been very kind to us, that you reject this proposal because it has a long-term effect on the good governors of Miami-Dade County. Thank you very much. >> (Applause). >> Good afternoon. Good morning Board of commissioners it is a pleasure to be here. I'm here to speak against the item as well. My name is Christian (Name?) And I grew up in Rapides I've been living there for 15 years. My address is 8401 northwest. 53rd Terrace Douros, Florida 33136. I'm here to speak against the item because as many have mentioned before me I think it is very reasonable and fair for the opinion of the local businesses and the land owners in the area to be heard something that is not happening right now rather than changing the rules of the game in terms of ambiguity and qualification I think applications should be considered based on the basis of what they can offer to the residence and business owners in this case. Thank you. >> Thank you. Oscar (Name?), (Name?) Bailey, Miguel (Name?), Miranda Lopez. >> Good morning MR. Chair and commissioners, and MADAM Mayor Peter thank you for giving me the oportunity I am Oscar (Name?) Council member for the city of Douros. 5323 w. (Name?). I'm also here in opposition to this item for the simple reason of fairness. As you know back in the year 2010, 2011 the city of Sweetwater annexed the area called dolphin Mall and at the time it was represented by our current Commissioner. The area is located close to a mile away from Sweetwater. Clear and not contiguous to the city of Sweetwater like the rule says today. Today this item changes the rules, just qualifying our city of Douros, which is contiguous to the area. I urge you t vote and give Douros a chance to be treated equally and fairly. Thank you so much. >> Thank you. >> Good morning my name is Claudia Bailey and I'm a resident of Jen something 9990 51st Lane three 17a. First and foremost CHAIRMAN, vice Chair and commission thank you very much for your service. I know this is hard work and I am most appreciative as a voter for a long time. I'm here against this item and I am urging you to vote no. You do not change the rules paid you don't move the goalpost in the middle of the game so your favorite team wins. You don't do that. This is supposed to be a fair and equitable process. I expect as a voter fair and equity from all of you, transparency. You do not move the goalpost in the middle of the game so that your favorite team can win. Thank you, vote no. >> Think you. >> Good morning commissioners. -On behalf of the water-city of two other. This ordinance that provide some guidelines for annexations is simply long overdue. At first the ordinance provides in order to annex an area the petitioning city must have at least 500 feet of contiguity with the area. This is not a novel concept. In fact flow to statute 171 requires municipalities and all other 66 counties in our great state to have significant contiguity to petition for annexation. The only reason this requirement is not applicable to Miami-Dade County to date is because we are home rule County and we get to set our own rules, which is what you're doing right now. The second significant thing it does is private annexation of areas outside of the udb, important to your policy paid on suddenly aware that you have been lobbied by the other meanest body that seeks to annex land that is not contiguous to its boundaries. So to be cleared they filed an application that they knew made no planning sense and was contrary to the states public policy and the message to you has been that it it is not fair to impose these guidelines no and that they should be allowed to proceed with the petition that would be prohibited by law in every other county in this state. I will respectfully cement you from a public policy perspective the issue is not whether it helps or hinders any given municipality at any given point in time. The proper analysis is simply this: do the guidelines further, sound public policy and respectfully there is no question that they do. In terms of timing, they have four application pending right no*untran17* does paid other cities have other applications for naked if you file-follow the logic that you should not change the rules midstream you would never be able to legislate any change to chapter 20 because they are always pending annexation petition. On behalf of the city of Sweetwater we urge you for your support and thank you for your time. >> Thank you. >> (Applause). >> So just so we ae clear about how we applaud. If you really like something and someone says something that gets your juices flowing. You do this. You just smile. If you don't like it you do this and you just frown and we know you don't like it. So we are going to refrain from clapping. Thank you. >> Good morning Vice CHAIRMAN Gilbert and Goodman commissioners. City of Sweetwater and first and foremost what I would like to do is have the opportunity to explain where the process enact annexation we are. -- Application back in 2013 after the application itself was stalled for over two years in 2015 we asked the district Commissioner Diaz to please give us the opportunity to told this application so we can amend the maps because at the present time the original application was presented part of the areas in the map that we submitted did a pass a udb and an understanding at the time that County policy did not accept applications or would not take applications to pass the udb paid as well as address other issues like contiguity and everything that we did meet at the time. Then we told the application in 2015, we resubmit the maps. >> Just one second-which application he speaking? >> This very same application that was resubmit it before the county in AUGUST. It was originally submitted-I want to spend the process why we are here. So we told the application and we submitted in AUGUST 2020 almost up to the day after we cement the application Douros cements a request asking for annexation we submit. Four days later they cement the same evocation before the County. After having discussions with CHAIRMAN Diaz I sling to him that we understand that the policies are in place within the county, but they have never been codified they really should be fair for all applications. Same way that you cannot pass the gentle, you cannot annex an area going through the udb. The policy was always that you don't contemplate to annexation policies for the same area at the same time. So we do support the fact that this annexation amendment to the annexation ordinance is being sponsored at the time because what it does is actually makes it an even playing field for everybody. Make sure that you complete one annexation obligation and the other, not simultaneously like it is at this time. There were issues that were discussed aout contiguity paid there is absolutely no contiguity in the other annexation application that was presented by Douros. As those who have been before me has said, what we are urging you. >> Thank you for much. >> Good legislation entered policy. Thank you. >> No we have Raffaella (Name?), Yvette Gonzales, Brenda (Name?), and Joe Reed Junior. >> Good morning MR. CHAIRMAN and MR. Vice CHAIRMAN, MADAME Mayor, and members of the commission paid my name is Ralph (Name?) The Mayor's Chief of Staff and city manager of Sweetwater with address 500 s. 105 Sweetwater, Florida. I am speaking in favor of item 5a and I'm here to ask you in considering 5a to do the right thing. Doing the right thing is supporting what is good public policy. The requirement of cntiguity is a standard that is accepted throughout the entire state and the vast majority of jurisdictions throughout the contribute there's a rationale for this. If you do not have contiguity then nothing would stop for example adventure for wanting to annex land outside of homestead or flow to sitting wanting to annex land by West Miami. It becomes incredible he difficult at that point to set planning standards and it becomes infinitely difficult at that point, especially for jurisdictions who have their own utilities to even serve the utilities properly or administer the utilities properly and it becomes increasingly difficult to provide fire and police services when you are scattered throughout the entire county. Especially when you are talking about cities that really, for the most part will ultimately end up lacking the resources of the county, which is able to do it. It simply does not make sense from a planning perspective to require, to permit rstrictions to verse another jurisdiction and allow them to provide -- no apparently listening to my colleagues and the city of Douros, the purpose has been this whole Douros and Sweetwater issue. That's not the case. Good public policy is not Douros versus Sweetwater. Good public policy is passing 5a and for that I think you and I urge support of 5a. >> Thank you. >> Commissioners good morning and thank you for the opportunity to, as you consider your vote on agenda item 5a. I'm here in hopes that you will consider voting against this particular item. My name is Yvette (Name?) And I'm a resident of the city action something and my address is 10532 northwest. 46th Terrace I'm also the PRESIDENT Of an organization called the Douros community coalition. We made efforts to Connecticut with you all over the last three weeks and order to try to hone in on some of what the issues are and some of the concerns that shush if you understand what this proposal comes from and what it becomes is in the short-term you know it reminds due process and number two the office usurping two cities in the same district have applied to annex the same area. The rules have applied-the rows that have applied to annexing this particular area have existed for years and there has been some comment about the fact that Sweetwater submitted this a long time ago. Why is it that no after Douros has ended their application suddenly there is a concern about what contiguity means. The roles of the process are being changed after the process has begun without any substantive notice to anyone or any tue debate on the matter. This item has been removed from committees at least once and it is moving through this process incredibly fast without proper consideration. I'm referring to a change in the definition of what it means to be contiguous. By definition that again has been on te books in our county for decades. By voting yes on item 5a you're sending a message to your constituents and the rest of the canopied says to Miami-Dade that it's okay for the commission to change the rules without true notice and opportunity to be heard and assessed. It sends a message that it's okay to forgo the rules of process. It sends a message that the presentation free from conflict of interest is not a party to this mission. It sends a message that merit at best a second to politics. I feel strongly that all of you have the fortitude and the calibrated moral compass to acknowledge when the proposal before you does not present good governance. This message with his speed and trajectory is thoughtless and hasty. It is unfair and it is bad precedent. Above all it says to my neighbors in action something that you are okay with us fending for ourselves and search for someone to -- it says that it's okay for you all as constituents to be pitted against constituents without a neutral voice to call the shots. We are not being represented here. I call you just for today to be my representative. >> Thank you MS. Gonzales (Name?) That is time. Whiskey morning Brenda (Name?). I'm in favor of 5a and the reason is because when we talk about the lack of directness and a lot of the regulation that we have in the county we were not thinking about Sweetwater or Douros. When all of these were being set up the county was thinking about the rest of the areas of the county. It was not a specifically for, to put two cities against each other and the CHAIRMAN Was thinking about what city is better for me or not. This was set up before that and we have to think about the rest of the county that is not just the city of Douros and the city of Sweetwater. Those are the reasons you have to kind of think about it outside the box. Not just about two cities that want a piece of land to see who will pay taxes for the city, but the reason it was done, it was to establish the rest of the county to be in order sometimes it is not going to be easy. One side is always going to lose and one side will always win, but in this case this 5a was directed to just do complement of a lot of regulation that we have that it was missing. At least until all the meetings that we went to and we heard about it it was never in our conversation about against Douros or in favor to Sweetwater Oregon Sweetwater, in favor of Douros. So I want to make sure that I see my support for 5a. >> Thank you very much. That is all the speaker cards that we have for item 5a. Are there any other speakers or public comments on item 5a? See no other we will close public comment on JUNE 13 and I will return the gavel to our treatment. >> Thank you Commissioner Higgins. We are now, Commissioner Deas-CHAIRMAN Are you there? >> Yes I'm here. >> Okay there you go. >> Thank you MR. CHAIRMAN. It is interesting -- as we know as policy setters that unfortunately there is one side the benefits and another side that does not benefit. This is where we are working on this. One of the things that I did was always to do the right thing and that's what we continue to do here at this particular ordinance. When I first started as Chair I stated that the process had to be clear and precise over everything that we did. I was going to look into finding every angle of process that we could improve and make sure that it was seamless and we have done this with countless things, not only myself, but my colleagues have stepped up and done a lot to improve the processes the best way possible. If you see what is happening in the particular issue that shush the fairness is to avoid ambiguity to take place. The fairness is to have a city while after another city to try to stop their annexation by leveraging in a different area. Contiguity is something that is extremely important and it is stated as law and the other 66 counties and we go by. That's what we do when we look into processing our applications and deal with them in making sure that we look at every angle of that application. Contiguity is important and we stated when these processes take place. We also state that they cannot go in the urban boundary line. Example, city of Sweetwater as stated by the mayor and the attorneys had filed before and they were told after they were filed that they cannot continue because it was in the urban boundary areas and it took a long time for them and that was seven years ago when that process started. So they filed it, they returned the application when they replied again that they would have the money to move forward. So they did. So in process this has been done properly, but the issue is this is not the only application that is taking place in Dade County. There are many applications taking place. There is a four city agreement that has taken place in some cities want to take over other city areas and so on. There is a lot of different opinions being taken place when it comes to annexation and corporations, but this is why we try to clarify things and why we have them for a long time and this is what this ordinance does. It clarifies it anyway where note you cannot continue and go into an urban boundary area and no you have to be contiguous in your filing of that particular area. So let's be clear. Where is the non-fairness if you are not contiguous you are looking to go into or skip over the urban boundary area. It is not allowed then what is the problem? Whether this is done now or this is done later, or this would have been done before. It is still the right thing. We cannot proceed forward. The laws are there and our policies are there. So what this des is it codifies reality of what we go by. In this case I urge the city of Douros, I apologize because this is the right thing to do. You could say it is fairness on your part because you want to have your particular way of doing it and you know what, that is fine and this is a democracy, but this is also city law. When I was asked a long time ago to help create the city of Douros a lot of people told me, no it is not right, they cannot have all of those ridges, they cannot be that big, that city could not be done paid we fought hard to make the city of Douros and incorporate the city of Douros. Listen because it's not fair, it is not going to be right, and there was a lot of opposition, but I move forward and still covered Douros and I helped them from every angle that I possibly could in my tensor of being the Commissioner of the district did so much so that I got word from the city attentively. Don't say that I don't care about the city of Douros because I care a lot about the city of Douros, but I care about the other cities in my district and Dade County. I care about the fairness for a city that has so much, so much, and a different city that is struggling to get to the same place in every way I can. Applied ended their situation early on and also did it properly and when it wasn't properly their application had to be taken back and started again. This is not about the application this is about this ordinance to make sure that the right thing is done. Not oly now, but always. This is why I stand so much behind this ordinance because I think process has to be over everything. When they say that it's not fair because they should all be fair. Was it fair when the city in this case of Sweetwater was not allowed to move forward? Because their application went into the urban boundary area they had to redo it? These are the kinds of things that shush I know I have been accused and I know I saw the signs put up in the city of Chen something. There's never been a sign on any city in the that shush in this case the city of Douros said it was unfair to the 70,000 citizens of the city of Douros, which was very sad to see, but that is fine, that is politics. When you are saying that a certain city is taking over and it is going to be 100 or 200 percent than another city don't try to full people by saying things that are not true. Legislation is legislation in the right thing is doing things like this my colleagues to make sure that when you are facing an annexation in your area or have faced in annexation in your area and these rules are in place so that you won't have the mess that I am basically dealing with in my district today. So I ask for your support in doing the right thing which has been stated all along and making sure that this ordinance, which is simply following our process, codifying, following state law and doing what is correct and codifying at in our code once and for 5w d]Y y+Mv= h" jh-#En]_ w=}u-@mr p! $ @@ o8 < &@ -*  #v 3v #v#v#v #v#v+v+v+v+v#v#v#v#v!V#v#v#v#v#v#v#v+v#v!V#v#v#v#v +v+v #v 1v !V3v#v +v1v #v 3v3v #v#v 3v #v 1v pppppppppppppppppppppp````````aaaaaa``a``````````````````````````pppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppp```aa`a`aa``pppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppp`pppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppp

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
AgendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Agenda packetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Action agendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
MinutesNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Transcript or captionsNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Recording and media

Official pages

Coverage and corrections

Records considered

  • Board of County Commissioners - Part 2 — Closed Captions

Not claimed by this page

  • Verified meeting decisions with item-specific public-source evidence
  • Item-level plain-language summaries are not available; this page does not infer individual agenda items.
  • Item-linked, attributed deliberation
  • A source-grounded next meeting date
  • A plain-English overview is not available.
  • Official outcomes have not been published.
  • A transcript is not available.
  • Speakers have not been reliably matched to public profiles.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.
  • An individual roll-call roster is not available.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: 3968a663e7c14501b48b8b7b9d771b81. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record