POLISCOPE

The public record

WALNUTCREEK (CONTRACOSTA COUNTY)Held · official record pendingPartial coverage

Design Review Commission

Wednesday, November 19, 2008 · Government meeting record

The 30-second read

Record incomplete

Design Review Commission

Why it matters

The official meeting record is available below. Item-level plain-language summaries are not available yet.

What happens next

The scheduled meeting date has passed. Minutes or an action agenda are not published in the records we hold.

This meeting date has passed and no official outcome record has been published yet. Nothing on this page is a decision.

Record text

No recording or transcript is held for this meeting.

WALNUT CREEK DESIGN REVIEW COMMISSION November 19, 2008 7:00pm Regular Meeting Minutes City Hall, Council Chamber 1666 North Main Street, Walnut Creek COMMISSIONERS: Chair Joseph Gorny Vice Chair Brian Kilian Sanjiv Bhandari Dorothy McDonald 1. OPENING Roll Call: All Commissioners were present, except Mark Lopez 2. PUBLIC COMMUNICATION Carol Clark, Planning Department Secretary, presented a commendation and gift to Bonnie Alcatraz, Minutes Clerk, for her outstanding work as minutes clerk to the Planning and Transportation Commissions during the months of September and October. 3. CONSENT CALENDAR a. Approve minutes of October 29, 2008 Motion by Kilian, second by Gorny AYES: Kilian, Gorny ABSENT: Lopez ABSTAIN: Bhandari, McDonald 4. PUBLIC HEARINGS a. NORDSTROM EXPANSION – DESIGN REVIEW – APPLICATION NO. Y08-083 - PUBLIC HEARING for Design Review for a 18,410 square-foot expansion to the existing Nordstrom store, including interior and exterior remodeling, enclosure of outdoor space, second story addition, entryways, signs, and landscaping at 1200 Broadway Plaza. APN: 183-380-010 and 183-380-011. ZONING: Pedestrian Retail Steven Buckley, Senior Planner, provided a summary of the staff report, noting that there are issues with the signage and staff concerns regarding materials proposed for the rooftop screening and materials along the ramps. John Bierly, architect, reported on revisions that were made based on comments of the Design Review Commission at a previous hearing. The Commissioners asked questions of the Staff and applicant team regarding lighting and background colors of signage, location of seismic retrofitting, tree removal, replacement tree size, and a bench as an Art element. Chair Gorny opened the Public Hearing. The following member of the public spoke: Primo Facchini, representing the Walnut Creek Historical Society: encouraged the Commission to assist the developers in implementing this application to modernize the building. Chair Gorny closed the Public Hearing. The Commissioners commented on the project as follows:

Design Review Commission November 19, 2008 Minutes Page 2 of 5 Commissioner Gorny: Agrees with the proposed setbacks; reduce the East signage from five-foot letters to four-foot letters; agrees with the 35 foot signage on the South elevation; reduce the projecting blade sign from 25 feet to 22 feet. Likes the larger window at corner. Suggested that the sidewalk width reduction should be studied more. The sand-blasted cast-concrete ramp walls are fine. Agrees that more attention is needed to landscaping to screen the mechanical back side of the building, but as this is not new construction, he does not believe that the street elevations need to be redesigned. Commissioner Kilian: Does not agree with the blade sign as it is out of character with the building; suggests further reduction in the east and south facing signage; does not agree with removing the liquid amber trees; more trees need to be added to soften the hard surfaces. He is okay with the removal of the two trees that require approval. He suggested a 12 inch cutout to plant vines to soften the wall. Trees need to be in 60 inch boxes. Landscaping is needed on the loading dock area such as vines. The landscape area is okay, but the amount and size need to be upgraded. The ramp walls could have a softer look with a different material, landscaping or it could be an art wall. Not in agreement that the benches being an “Art” element. The pavers could enhance the area where the “Art” benches would be located. Add screen walls and landscaping to reduce the impact of the loading dock. Commissioner Bhandari: Nordstrom is a good tenant and their plans are an enhancement to the City’s retail arena. He has no problems with the signage as only one sign can be seen at a time from the pedestrian viewpoint. He understands Commissioner Kilian’s concern with the blade sign, but with any future building in the area, the blade sign may be only one visible from Mt. Diablo Boulevard. The north elevation needs a larger tree species by the entry. The new pedestrian area needs to integrate more smoothly with the existing area. The paver materials should continue all the way to the crossing and all the way to the new entry. Agrees that having the wider sidewalk would be best. The ramp walls are fine. “Art” benches can be attractive if done properly. Would like to see a more elaborate roof plan with details such as color and patterns. The mechanical equipment screen could be more integrated in the building. Suggested coloring the masonry to break up the massing and enhance the surfaces, such as two-tones or banding. Commissioner McDonald: The brackets on the blade sign are very prominent. Supportive of “Art” benches similar to what another center has installed. Chair Gorny summarized that this application needs to be continued with the applicant addressing the following issues: blade sign, landscape plans, tree replacements, vine pockets (or similar) on walls, sidewalk paver pattern width, ramp walls to relate to other improvements, public art location is further studied with the landscape plans, roof details, east elevation landscaping, It was agreed that the streetscape with showroom window and north elevation entrance are acceptable. b. PARKVIEW CONDOMINIUMS – SUBDIVISION, ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW, VARIANCE, TREE REMOVAL, TREE DRIP LINE ENCROACHMENT, DESIGN REVIEW: APPLICATION NO. Y08-042. PUBLIC HEARING to review a proposal to construct an 8-unit, 45-foot condo complex with at-grade garage parking on 0.27-acre parcel at 1665 Carmel Drive. APN 178-290-008. ZONING: Multi-Family Residential (M-1).

Design Review Commission November 19, 2008 Minutes Page 3 of 5 Ethan Bindernagel, Associate Planner, provided the staff report. David Bogstad, applicant, showed a drawing describing the view of the building from the library site. The Commissioners asked questions of Staff and the applicant regarding handicap parking, future health of the major tree, location of stair tower, and the lobby window. Ms. Walker commented that under the current tree ordinance, the bonding period is three years and if the tree is significantly declining health, the bond could be extended. If the tree is healthy after three years, the bond is removed. Staff and Commissioners discussed the practicality of monitoring the tree. Chair Gorny opened the Public Hearing. There were no speakers and Chair Gorny closed the Public Hearing. The Commissioners commented on the project as follows: Commissioner Bhandari: It would be nice to incorporate the next door property with this project site; design is impressive; extra design effort on the top two floors’ back elevation; create more interest in balconies so they are not the same; add trellis and plantings to hide cars from the sidewalk view; break up the continuous metal panels. Commissioner McDonald: Seven-foot front setback is fine; building architecture is attractive; the main tree is not attractive; likes the improved design and the expanded bike storage. Commissioner Kilian: Screening in front has been removed in the plans and should be included; balconies as shown are fine; is not in favor of the handicap parking located at the front of the site. Chair Gorny: noted that the architect had emailed copies of the design to him sometime ago; setback is fine; unit size is good; removal of the elevator cap would be good; integration of new sidewalk with neighboring frontage; use instead of painting stripes to delineate the handicap parking space; architecture could use more attention, especially towards the top; alternate the metal pattern or texture. Motion by Bhandari, second by McDonald, to move application Y08-099 forward to the Planning Commission, with a positive recommendation. AYES: Bhandari, McDonald, Kilian, Gorny c. LEGACY YGNACIO CENTER 2 (2033 NORTH MAIN STREET) - DESIGN REVIEW APPLICATION NO. Y08-087 - PUBLIC HEARING on a proposal to construct a 743 square foot lobby addition within the existing building footprint. ZONING: OC, Office Commercial. Sam Knutson, Assistant Planner, provided a summary of the staff report, noting he had provided the Commissioners with a supplemental packet with landscaping plans. The Commissioners asked questions of the Staff and applicant team regarding tandem spaces, reflective pool shape, glass wall, removal of storage space, landscape planters, banding. Chair

Design Review Commission November 19, 2008 Minutes Page 4 of 5 Gorny suggested that the corner design was constrictive so that pedestrians would need to walk a longer distance around. Chair Gorny opened the Public Hearing. The following member of the public spoke: Primo Facchini: Asked if the applicant was covering the building’s “dryvit” with stucco; agrees with Chair Gorny regarding the corner design as people are used to walking through the corner. Chair Gorny closed the Public Hearing. The Commissioners commented on the project as follows: Commissioner Kilian: Likes the design and the corner design; place planters where needed to create a design and not just to have a certain square footage of landscaping. Commissioner Bhandari: Likes the change in color, the contemporary design, and larger lobby; shape of pool does not belong to the circulation pattern and suggested cropping the corner; the distance between the glass wall and the planter appears to be tight. Commissioner McDonald: Attractive design; agrees with grouping the planters; agrees with reshaping the pool. Chair Gorny: Agrees with the plan to remove the balcony and changing of material that is compatible with the building behind to it; the design rectangle is not integrated with the architecture; street access is more important than the size of the lobby; not a positive addition to the street; does not support project. Motion by Kilian, second by Bhandari to approve Application Y08-087 with additional conditions: maintain 6-8 foot width by changing the shape of the reflective pool or by modifying the wing wall; planters situated in front of columns or other appropriate locations. AYES: Kilian, Bhandari, McDonald NOES: Gorny ABSENT: Lopez d. ATRIA VALLEY VIEW - DESIGN REVIEW, APPLICATION NO. Y08-106. PUBLIC HEARING to review a proposal to remodel the existing structure and upgrade landscaping onsite at 1228 Rossmoor Parkway (APN). ZONING: Planned Development (PD-656). Ethan Bindernagel, Associate Planner, provided the staff report. Matt Windsor, Applicant, reported that an arborist report was obtained and 23 trees are to be removed, none are highly protected species. Project is working towards LEED (Leadership in Energy and Environmental Design) certification. The Commissioners asked questions of Staff and the applicant regarding dark colors, size of trellis, sidewalk replacement, balcony railings, service area, mechanical screening, signage and stonework.

Design Review Commission November 19, 2008 Minutes Page 5 of 5 Commissioner Kilian stated that the applicant will need to resubmit a new landscaping plan as the one presented was too complicated to read. Chair Gorny opened the Public Hearing. There were no speakers and Chair Gorny closed the Public Hearing. The Commissioners commented on the project as follows: Chair Gorny: Likes the project, colors, and architecture; appreciates the updating of the older building; detailing and lighting needs to be well done. Commissioner Kilian: Colors are too dark for the shaded, north side creating a gloomy area; wood elements are too thin, suggested metal or heavier wood; likes the general direction; native plants are woody, so use some ornamentals. Commissioner McDonald: Likes the direction the project is going. Commissioner Bhandari: Currently there is not enough signage; colors are a little too dark; building is segmented into three parts and suggested using tone on tone, complimentary colors; do not repeat all aspects; removing overhang will be an improvement. 5. COMMISSION CONSIDERATIONS None 6. CORRESPONDENCE None 7. STAFF’S BRIEF ANNOUNCMENTS OR BRIEF REPORTS ON HIS OR HER ACTIVITIES Victoria Walker announced that she will be the interim Planning Manager and secretary to the Planning Commission. Scott Harriman will be interim Assistant Planning Manager and serve as Secretary to the Design Review Commission. Ken Nodder will serve as the staff person to the Sign Subcommittee. 8. COMMISSIONERS’ BRIEF ANNOUNCMENTS OR BRIEF REPORTS ON HIS OR HER ACTIVITIES Commissioner Kilian noted that a senior housing project on Mt. Diablo Boulevard has a new white background sign face. Ms. Walker commented that Code Enforcement is checking on the signage. The new Ace Hardware store has installed their conforming sign. Commissioner Bhandari reported that there is an upcoming event, New Partners for Smart Growth in January in New Mexico. 9. ADJOURNMENT Chair Gorny adjourned the meeting at 10:18 p.m. to the next meeting, December 3, 2008. /s/ VICTORIA WALKER, Secretary Approved 1/7/09 Walnut Creek Design Review Commission

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
Agenda packetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Action agendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
MinutesNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Transcript or captionsNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Official pages

Coverage and corrections

Records considered

  • Design Review Commission

Not claimed by this page

  • Verified meeting decisions with item-specific public-source evidence
  • Item-level plain-language summaries are not available; this page does not infer individual agenda items.
  • Item-linked, attributed deliberation
  • A source-grounded next meeting date
  • A plain-English overview is not available.
  • Official outcomes have not been published.
  • A transcript is not available.
  • No audio or video recording is linked.
  • Speakers have not been reliably matched to public profiles.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.
  • An individual roll-call roster is not available.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: 389d994f41ef0a71f4a5df538a5b8ab3. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record