POLISCOPE

The public record

PITTSBURG (CONTRACOSTA COUNTY)Decisions and attributed speech publishedPartial coverage

Planning Commission

Tuesday, February 27, 2024 · Government meeting record

The 30-second read

Recorded outcome

Planning Commission

Why it matters

The official meeting record is available below. Item-level plain-language summaries are not available yet.

What happens next

No later meeting or follow-up date is stated in the reviewed record.

An official outcome record and a transcript or captions are published for this meeting.

Transcript and record text

Closed captionsWhat was said at the meeting, transcribed Aug 3, 2026. Speech is not a decision.
  • No speaker turns were supplied with this transcript.
  • This transcript has no source timestamps.
  • No speaker identities were supplied with this transcript.

This source published text without speaker turns, so speakers and timestamps are not shown.

The opening of 67,933 stored characters

>> GOOD EVENING TO EVERYONE. THE FEBRUARY 27, 2024 REGULAR MEETING OF THE PITTSBURG PLANNING COMMISSION WILL NOW COME TO ORDER. WILL THE CLERK PLEASE CALL THE ROLE. >> ALISA ROBINSON >> PRESENT >> DONNA SMITH >> PRESENT >> SARAH FOSTER >> PRESENT >> ARLENE KOBATA >> PRESENT >> IVELINA POPOVA >> AYE. THANK YOU. AS REQUIRED BY LAW, THE AGENDA FOR THIS MEETING WAS POSTED AT CITY HALL AT LEAST 72 HOURS PRIOR TO TONIGHT'S MEETING ON FRIDAY, FEBRUARY 23rd, 2024, PLEASE LEAD US IN THE PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE. >> I PLEDGE ALLEGIANCE TO THE FLAG OF THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA AND TO THE REPUBLIC FOR WHICH IT STANDS ONE NATION UNDER GOD INDIVISIBLE WITH LIBERTY AND JUSTICE FOR ALL. >> THANK YOU, EVERYONE. MR. SECRETARY, ARE THERE ANY DELETIONS, WITHDRAWALS, OR CONTINUANCES FOR ITEMS LISTED ON THE AGENDA TONIGHT? >> GOOD EVENING. THERE ARE NO REQUESTS FOR DELETIONS, WITHDRAWALS OR CONTINUANCES TONIGHT. THANK YOU. >> THANK YOU. IF A MEMBER OF THE AUDIENCE WOULD LIKE TO SPEAK ON ANY ITEM ON THE AGENDA OR IF YOU WOULD LIKE TO ADDRESS THE COMMISSION ON A NON-AGENDA ISSUE, PLEASE FILL OUT A CITIZENS COMMENT CARD THAT CAN BE FOUND NEXT TO THE PODIUM AND HANDED TO THE CLERK. DO WE HAVE ANYONE ASKING TO SPEAK TONIGHT? >> FOR NON-AGENDA ITEMS, WE DO NOT. >> THANK YOU. IN THIS CASE I WILL CALL FOR APPROVAL OF THE CONSENT CALENDAR. DOES ANYONE ON THE COMMISSION HAVE ANY ITEMS THEY WANT PULLED FROM THE CONSENT CALENDAR TO BE CONSIDERED SEPARATELY? COMMISSIONER FOSTER? >> I MOVED TO APPROVE THE CONSENT CALENDAR. >> THANK YOU. I CAN GO AHEAD AND SECOND THE MOTION. LET'S VOTE. THE CONSENT CALENDAR IS APPROVED 5-0. THANK YOU. WE NOW COME TO THE PUBLIC HEARING PORTION OF THE AGENDA. WILL THE SECRETARY PLEASE READ THE NEXT ITEM? >> GOOD EVENING AGAIN MADAM CHAIR AND COMMISSIONERS. I WANT TO TEA THIS UP A LITTLE BIT BECAUSE WE HAVE SEEN THIS PROJECT BEFORE, AND THIS WAS BACK IN DECEMBER 12th AT THE PLANNING COMMISSION HEARING. THIS PROJECT WAS TO BE PRESENTED, AND WE RECEIVED A LATE OPPOSITION LETTER TO THE PROJECT. STAFF GRANTED THE CONTINUANCE THAT NIGHT FOR US TO COME BACK TO A LATER DATE. WE HAVE REVIEWED THE LETTER. WE HAVE ADDRESSED THE CONCERNS, AND DO NOT FEEL THERE ARE ANY CONCERNS BUT TONIGHT, THE PROJECT IS BEFORE YOU AGAIN AND WE DID RECEIVE ANOTHER LATE OPPOSITION LETTER AND WE REVIEWED THAT, TOO, SO I'M GOING TO ALLOW MAURICE TO GIVE US A PRESENTATION BUT THIS IS THE LINDE EXPANSION PROJECT. IT HAS BEEN IN EXISTENCE SINCE 1959 OF THE PROJECT AREA THEY'RE LOOKING AT EXPANDING IS A 2.5 ACRE PIECE. IT IS KIND OF THE LAST ACRE AREA OF DEVELOPMENT FOR THAT PROJECT SITE. ALSO WITH MAURICE TONIGHT IS DAN JONES, FROM OUR CH GROUP, OUR CONSULTANT THAT WORKED WITH US ON THE INITIAL STUDY. I WILL TURN IT OVER TO MAURICE AND DAN TO PROVIDE YOU WITH THE PRESENTATION. ACTUALLY, MAURICE WILL PROVIDE YOU WITH THE PRESENTATION AND IF THERE ARE ANY QUESTIONS OR CONCERNS YOU HAVE, DAN IS AVAILABLE TO ANSWER TONIGHT. >> THANK YOU. GOOD EVENING, COMMISSIONERS AND MEMBERS OF THE PUBLIC. THIS PROJECT ORIGINALLY WAS SCHEDULED TO BE HEARD DECEMBER 12th OF 2023 . THE PLANNING COMMISSION CONTINUED IT BECAUSE WE RECEIVED A LATE LETTER JUST TWO HOURS BEFORE THE HEARING. THE SAME PROJECT IS AGAIN BEFORE YOU TONIGHT FOR YOUR CONSIDERATION. THE PROPOSED PROJECT CONSISTS OF AN APPLICATION FOR USE PERMIT, DESIGN REVIEW, AND A VARIANCE TO EXPAND LINDE . IT IS THE NORTHERN CALIFORNIA INDUSTRIAL GAS MARKET, BY BUILDING A NEW PLANT AT THE CURRENTLY VACANT SITE. IT IS A 36 ACRE PARCEL. THE NEW FACILITY IS INTENDED TO EXPAND THE PRODUCTION OF LIQUID NITROGEN, OXYGEN AND ARGON. NO ADDITIONAL OR NEW PRODUCTS WOULD BE PRODUCED. THE PRODUCTS ARE STORED IN THREE LARGE TANKS AND WHEN NEEDED, THEY ARE TRANSFERRED INTO BOTH TRUCKS AND DELIVERED INTO SMALLER TANKS. CUSTOMERS ARE DIVERSE, AND THE SET OF INDUSTRIES INCLUDE HOSPITALS, FOOD PROCESSORS, ELECTRONICS, PRIMARY METALS, ENERGY, CHEMICALS AND AEROSPACE. THIS MAP SHOWS THE LINDE PLANT SIDE LOCATED AT 2000 LOVE BRIDGE ROAD WITH THE VACANT PORTION MARKED IN RED. USES INCLUDE COLUMBIA SOLAR INSTALLATION, EAGLE TIRES, MONDAY A RECYCLING, WASTE SERVICES AND OTHER INDUSTRIAL USERS. THE PROJECT HAS AN EXISTING OPERATING FACILITY AND HAS BEEN IN OPERATION FOR SEVERAL YEARS. THE CURRENT USE IS CLASSIFIED INDUSTRIAL UNDER LAND USE MAP ZONE IG, GENERAL INDUSTRIAL. MUNICIPAL CODE SECTION 18.5 4.010. THE USE PERMIT IS REQUIRED FOR HEAVY MANUFACTURING ACTIVITIES. ESTABLISHMENTS ENGAGED IN THE PRIMARY PRODUCTION OF METALS OR CHEMICAL PRODUCTS THROUGH RAW MATERIALS. PMC SECTION 15.5 4.100, DESIGN REVIEW IS ALSO REQUIRED FOR NEW CONSTRUCTION. ALSO UNDER THE SAME DMC CODE, A VARIANCE APPLICATION IS REQUIRED TO ALLOW 137 FOOT TALL TOWER WHERE A 75 FOOT MAXIMUM IS ALLOWED IN THE IG ZONE. THESE REVIEWS ARE IN RELATION TO THE EXISTING LINDE PLANT. THE INITIAL STUDY MITIGATES A NEGATIVE DECLARATION CONCLUDED THE PROJECT WOULD HAVE LESS THAN SIGNIFICANT IMPACTS WITH MITIGATIONS, AND THIS WAS SETTLED FOR PUBLIC COMMENT ON OCTOBER OF 2023. THE PROJECT IS REQUIRED TO COMPLY WITH AND RECEIVE PERMIT COVERAGE UNDER THE EAST CONTRA COSTA COUNTY HABITAT CONSERVATION PLAN, ECP FOR SHORT, AND THAT NATURAL COMMUNITY CONSERVATION PLAN, AND CCP, AND THEREFORE, A QUALIFIED BIOLOGICAL CONSULTANT FIRM WAS RETAINED TO PREPARE A PLANNING SURVEY REPORT KNOWN AS APS ARE WITH ACTION PLANS INCLUDING AVOIDING DOWNSTREAM HYDRAULIC EFFECTS THROUGH IMPLEMENTATION A STONE WATER MANAGEMENT TREATMENT CONTROLS, IMPLEMENTING MEASURES DESCRIBED IN THE ACP TO AVOID IN MINIMIZE IMPACTS TO WETLANDS AND STREAMS, WETLAND AREA AND WOODLAND SCRUB. THE IMAGE ON THE LEFT SHOWS THE LAYOUT. THE 3-D RENDITION SHOWS A REALISTIC SIMULATION OF THE PLANT , FILLING THREE TRUCKS. ACCORDING TO THE PROJECT NARRATIVE PROVIDED BY LINDE, THIS IS ONE OF THE CLEANEST PROCESSES IN HEAVY INDUSTRIAL ZONES. IN THE PROCESS, WE USE PHYSICAL CHEMISTRY TO SEPARATE THE THREE MAIN COMPONENTS 04:48:31:00OF AIR, NITROGEN, WHICH IS 78% OF AIR OXYGEN, WHICH IS 21% AND ARGON, WHICH IS 1%. BY KILLING THEM DOWN TO CRYOGENIC TEMPERATURES WHERE THE CHANGE FROM GAS TO LIQUID PHASES OCCURS. THERE IS NO COMBUSTION, CHEMICAL REACTIONS, ADDITIONAL INGREDIENTS ARE ADDED MATERIALS NEEDED TO SEPARATE THE GASES INTO THEIR PURE, ELEMENTAL FORMS. EACH PLANT CONSISTS OF THE FOLLOWING EQUIPMENT. ALL OUTDOORS. TWO MAIN AIR COMPRESSORS, TWO PURIFIER VESSELS, WHICH REMOVE MOISTURE, CARBON DIOXIDE AND OTHER GASES AND AIR, AND RETURN THEM BACK TO THE AIR. AN INDUSTRIAL CLASS CHILLER TO PRECOOL THE AIR, ONE LARGE DISTILLATION TOWER CONTAINING HEATED EXCHANGES, BOOSTER COMPRESSES --COMPRESSES, TURBINE SETS AND CRYOGENIC COLUMNS. THREE INDIVIDUAL SETS OF STORAGE TANKS FOR THE THREE PRODUCTS, INTERCONNECTING PIPES AND INSTRUMENTS INVOLVING COOLING TOWER ASSOCIATED PIPING AND HEAT EXCHANGE TO REMOVE HEAT FROM THE COMPRESSORS. THE PROJECT APPLICANT AND HIS TEAM ARE ALSO AVAILABLE TO FURTHER DISCUSS ANY FURTHER EXISTING PLANT OPERATIONS. PMC 18.5 4.120, AN INCREASE OVER THE MAXIMUM HEIGHT ALLOWANCE IS ALLOWED IN THE IL AND IG DISTRICT EQUAL TO THE NUMBER OF ADDITIONAL FEET THE STRUCTURE IS SET BACK FROM EACH PROPERTY LINE BEYOND THE MINIMUM YARD REQUIREMENTS UP TO A MAXIMUM OF 75 FEET. THE PROJECT APPLICANT IS REQUESTING A VARIANCE TO EXCEED THE PERMITTED HEIGHT LIMIT OF 75 FEET. BECAUSE OF SPECIAL CIRCUMSTANCES CONCERNING THE SUBJECT PROPERTY INCLUDING SIZE, SHAPE, TOPOGRAPHY, LOCATION AND SURROUNDINGS, STRICT APPLICATION OF THE ZONING REGULATION DEPRIVES THE PROPERTY OF PRIVILEGES ENJOYED BY OTHER PROPERTIES IN THE VICINITY IN THE SAME LAND HUGHES DISTRICT SINCE THE PROPOSED PROJECT IS AN EXTENSION OF AN EXISTING AIR SEPARATION PLANT WITH A SIMILAR TOWER FOR VENTING AND SEPARATING ESSENTIAL INDUSTRIAL AND COMMERCIAL GASES. FURTHER, THE PROJECT EXPANSION AREA IS IN APPROXIMATELY 2.5 ACRE PORTION OF A LARGER PARCEL THAT ENABLES ADEQUATE SETBACK OF MORE THAN TWO TO ONE SETBACK IN HEIGHT RATIO WITH THE PROPOSED 137 FOOT TALL RECTIFICATION CODE BOX. TOWER, WHICH IS FROM THE PROPERTY BOUNDARY. THE SITE IS RELATIVELY FLAT WITH LIMITED VEGETATION ON THE SIDE FRINGES, AND SOME WETLAND AT LIMITED EXTENT OF THE DEVELOPMENT FOOTPRINT OF THE SITE. THIS CONSTRAINS THE HORIZONTAL ORIENTATION OF THE PLANT EQUIPMENT, FORCING THEM TO BE MORE VERTICALLY STEPPED TO AVOID IMPACT ON THE WETLAND AND VEGETATION. THERE ARE SIMILAR TOWERS WITH HEIGHTS IN EXCESS OF 75 FEET AT THAT PLANT AND OTHER MANUFACTURING PLANTS AT THE IG ZONE IN THE PROJECT VICINITY AND THEREFORE, GRANTING THE HEIGHT VARIANCE WILL NOT CONSTITUTE A GRANT A SPECIAL PRIVILEGE, WHICH IS NOT GENERALLY AVAILABLE TO OTHER PROPERTY IN THE VICINITY. THE PROJECT IS REQUIRED TO COMPLY AND RECEIVE PERMIT COVERAGE OF THE CONTRA COSTA COUNTY HABITAT CONSERVATION PLAN, THE NATURAL COMMUNITY CONSERVATION PLAN AND THEREFORE A QUALIFIED BIOLOGICAL CONSULTANT FIRM WAS RETAINED TO PREPARE A SURVEY REPORT. MITIGATION MEASURES ADDRESS THE CONCERNS OF SPECIES. THE PROJECT APPLICANT HAS AGREED TO DISSIPATE IN THE PLAN AND IMPLEMENT MITIGATION MEASURES AS IDENTIFIED IN THE MITIGATION REPORTING PROGRAM TO ENSURE COMPLIANCE WITH THE PLANT. STAFF HAS RECEIVED COMMENTS FROM CALTRANS, DEPARTMENT OF TOXIC SUBSTANCE CONTROL, DTS C, AND HAS ADDRESSED ALL OF THOSE COMMENTS. ALSO, STAFF HAS RECEIVED TWO, LETTERS . BOTH WERE RECEIVED A FEW HOURS PRIOR TO HEARINGS. STAFF HAS EXHAUSTIVELY REVIEWED BOTH LETTERS AND ADDRESSED ALL THE ISSUES RAISED. CONCERNING THE COMMENTS FROM DTS C , STAFF HAS SUMMARIZED THEM BELOW. NUMBER ONE, ADDITIONAL INVESTIGATION AND SAMPLING OF SOIL IF NECESSARY SHOULD OCCUR BEFORE ANY GROUNDBREAKING ACTIVITIES COMMENCE. THE OTHER RECOMMENDATION DTSC MADE WAS IN CASE OF UNFORESEEN CONTAMINATIONS ARE DISCOVERED SHOULD ALSO BE UNDERTAKEN AND THEN FINALLY, IF THERE IS ANY IMPORTATION OF SOIL FROM SOMEWHERE ELSE, THERE SHOULD BE PROPER SAMPLING TO ENSURE THAT THE IMPORTED SOIL IS FREE FROM CONTAMINATION. STAFF'S RESPONSE TO THAT IS THAT THESE RECOMMENDATIONS HAVE BEEN INCLUDED AS CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL FOR THE PROJECT. WITH REGARD TO CALTRANS COMMENTS, THE FIRST COMMENT THEY MADE WAS THAT IF CALTRANS FACILITIES ARE IMPACTED BY THE PROJECT, THEY MUST MEET A.D.A. STANDARDS AS WELL AS MAINTAIN BICYCLE AND PEDESTRIAN ACCESS DURING CONSTRUCTION TO PROVIDE SAFE, SUSTAINABLE AND EQUITABLE TRANSPORTATION NETWORK FOR ALL USERS. THE OTHER COMMENT OR RECOMMENDATION FROM CALTRANS IS THAT ANY WORK OR TRAFFIC CONTROL THAT ENCROACHES ONTO CALTRANS' RIGHT-OF-WAY REQUIRES AN ENCROACHMENT PERMIT. STAFF'S RESPONSE AGAIN IS THAT ALTHOUGH THE PROJECT SITE IS NOT DIRECTLY ADJACENT TO STATE ROUTE HIGHWAY 4, THESE RECOMMENDATIONS HAVE BEEN INCLUDED AS CONDITIONS FOR APPROVAL TO ADDRESS THESE COMMENTS. ONTO THE COMMENTS RECEIVED FROM, STAFF HAS SUMMARIZED THEM BEFORE BELOW. ON DECEMBER 12, 2023, STAFF RECEIVED A LETTER FROM ADAMS SPIRAL, JOSEPH MENDOZA AND THEY MADE SEVERAL COMMENTS AND SO SOME KEY COMMAS HAVE BEEN COLD FROM THOSE COMMENTS AND QUOTED BELOW, SO THE FIRST ONE, STAFF IS HIGHLIGHTING THAT SUBSTANTIAL EVIDENCE SUPPORTS A FAIR ARGUMENT THAT THE PROJECT MAY RESULT IN SIGNIFICANT UNMITIGATED IMPACTS TO AIR QUALITY, HAZARDS, BIOLOGICAL RESOURCES. THE CITY MUST REPAIR --PREPARE AN ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT REPORT TO ANALYZE THIS, DISCLOSE AND MITIGATE THESE IMPACTS THAT ARE --AND DISCLOSE A LESS ENVIRONMENTALLY DAMAGING ALTERNATIVE. STAFF HAS PROVIDED COMMENTS WITH AN ANALYSIS BY DR. FOX REGARDING THE ISM D PREPARED FOR THE SUBJECT PROPERTY. NO NEW ENVIRONMENTAL CONCERNS WERE RAISED THAT WERE NOT ORIGINALLY ADDRESSED IN THE INTEREST -- INITIAL STUDY. SPECIFIC RESPONSES HAVE BEEN PROVIDED TO EACH OF THE COMMENTS THEY RAISE IN THE STAFF REPORT SUPPORTING STAFF'S DETERMINATION THAT MITIGATION MEASURES PROPOSED FOR THE PROJECT ARE SUFFICIENT TO ADDRESS ALL POTENTIAL PROJECT IMPACTS. ANOTHER KEY COMMENT ADAMS BROADWELL JOSEPH AND CARDOZA HAVE MADE A SET PHASE ONE, WHICH IS THE ENVIRONMENTAL ASSESSMENT REPORT PROVIDES SUBSTANTIAL EVIDENCE SUPPORTING A FAIR ARGUMENT THAT THE PROJECT MAY CAUSE POTENTIAL SIGNIFICANT IMPACTS DUE TO DISTURBANCE OF CONTAMINATED SOILS OR OTHER HAZARDOUS CONDITIONS THAT MAY BE PRESENT AT THE PROJECT SITE. STAFF'S RESPONSE TO THAT IS THAT THE PHASE ONE REPORT IDENTIFIED RECOGNIZABLE ENVIRONMENTAL CONDITIONS WITHIN THE GREATER PARCEL, WHICH IS WHERE THE CURRENT PLAN IS, BUT THEY WERE NOT ASSISTED WITH DITCH DREDGING [ INAUDIBLE ] AND PAST REMOVALS OF GROUND STORY TANKS WHICH EVIDENCE SUGGESTS DID NOT OCCUR ON THE PROJECT SITE , AND PAGES 27 THROUGH 29 OF THE PHASE ONE REPORT SPEAKS TO THAT, SO THE DRAFT EXPLAINS THAT WHILE 2000 LOVERIDGE ROAD MAY BE LISTED AS HAVING PREVIOUS ENVIRONMENT CONCERNS, THEY DO NOT INVOLVE THE PROPOSED PROJECT SITE PORTION OF THE PROPERTY. THE SQUIRREL WAS ASKED TO GATE EXCAVATED IN 1983, TESTED AND LANDFILLED AND THUS, THEY ARE NOT CONSIDERED A SOURCE OF CONTAMINATION TO THIS PARTICULAR SITE. ANOTHER COMMENT FROM ADAMS BROADWELL WAS THAT THE ISMD FAILS TO ADEQUATELY DISCLOSE, ANALYZE AND MITIGATE POTENTIALLY SIGNIFICANT IMPACTS TO WETLANDS AND STAFF RESPONSE TO THAT IS THAT THE PROJECT'S ENVIRONMENTAL SETTING WAS ESTABLISHED THROUGH RECONNAISSANCE LEVEL SITE ASSESSMENT BY VOLLMAR NATURAL LANDS CONSULTING IN JUNE 2023. TO FURTHER ENSURE THAT THE PROJECT AVOIDS ALL WETLANDS AND AQUATIC FEATURES, MITIGATION MEASURE BIO-6 REQUIRES A SURVEY. IN RESPONSE TO THE COMMENT MITIGATION NUMBER AGAIN, BIO-6 HAS BEEN ENHANCED TO CONTAIN SPECIFICS PERFORMANCE STANDARDS AND IDENTIFY THE TYPES OF ACTIONS THAT MAY ACHIEVE COMPLIANCE WITH PERFORMANCE STANDARDS INCLUDING REDESIGN OF THE PROJECT SITE PLAN OR TEMPORARY STAGING AREAS INCLUDING WETLANDS, COMPENSATORY MITIGATION. ADAMS BROADWELL HAS ALSO SUBMITTED AN ADDITIONAL COMMENT LETTER TODAY. NO NEW INFORMATION WAS RAISED THAT HAS NOT BEEN ADDRESSED IN THE CURRENT STUDY MITIGATION AS WELL AS THE PROGRAM. STAFF RESPONDED TO SOME OF THE KEY ISSUES THEY RAISED. ALSO, CONSULTANT DAN JONES IS AVAILABLE TO ADDRESS IT FURTHER AFTER MY PRESENTATION. ONE OF THE COMMENTS THEY RAISED HAD TO DO WITH AMBIENT AIR QUALITY . THE BIG AREA AIR QUALITY MANAGEMENT DISTRICT, AND THE CALIFORNIA AIR --IS IT RESOURCE BOARD? YES. REVIEWED THE INITIAL STUDY, AND ISMD AND DID NOT CONCLUDE THAT THE REVIEW THAT THE PROJECT WOULD HAVE ANY SIGNIFICANT IMPACT ON AIR QUALITY AND DID NOT REQUIRE ANY ADDITIONAL MITIGATION MEASURES. THE OTHER ISSUE THEY RAISE IN TODAY'S LETTERS ON-SITE ACUTE HEALTH EXPOSURES. THE APPLICANT OPERATES WITHIN THE CURRENT STANDARDS FOR OCCUPATIONAL SAFETY AND HEALTH ADMINISTRATION KNOWN AS OSHA, AND THE HEALTH RISK ASSESSMENT WAS ALSO PREPARED FOR THE PROJECT, AND REVIEWED BY THE REGULATORY AGENCIES WITH NO SPECIFIC CONCERNS RAISED. AGAIN, AS PREVIOUSLY DISCUSSED, ENVIRONMENTAL ANALYSIS PREPARED FOR THE PROJECT CONCLUDED THAT THERE WOULD NOT BE ANY SIGNIFICANT ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACTS OVER INDUCTION AND IMPLEMENTATION OF MITIGATION MONITORING AND REPORTING PROGRAM ENCLOSED AS EXHIBIT B TO THE STAFF REPORT. THE PROJECT IS NOT IN ISOLATION OF ITS SURROUNDINGS. RATHER IT IS AT AN EXISTING AIR SEPARATION PLANT WITH SIMILAR TOWERS FOR VENTING AND SEPARATING ESSENTIAL INDUSTRIAL AND COMMERCIAL GASES. THERE ARE SIMILAR TALL TOWERS AT THE LINDE PLANT AND SURROUNDINGS. THE HEIGHT VARIANCE ALLOWS THE PLANT TO INSTALL AN IMPORTANT TOWER ESSENTIALLY FOR OPERATIONS AND SIMILAR TO OTHER TOWERS IN THE VICINITY. THE PROPOSED PROJECT WOULD BE CONSISTENT WITH THE CITY ZONING ORDINANCE AND THE SITE BY EXPANDING EXISTING HEAVY MANUFACTURING OPERATION FOR THE AIR SEPARATION PLANT ALSO, THE PROPOSED EXPANSION PROMOTES AN ORDERLY DEVELOPMENT OF THE AREA BY UTILIZING A VACANT PORTION OF THE EXISTING PLANT SITE IS ZONED FOR INDUSTRIAL USE. THE PROJECT COMPLIES WITH ALL APPLICABLE USE DESIGN AND VARIANCE CRITERIA AS DETAILED IN THE STAFF REPORT, AND THE RESOLUTION. FINALLY IN CONCLUSION, STAFF IS RECOMMENDING THAT THE PLANNING COMMISSION MOVED TO ADOPT A RESOLUTION APPROVING THE USE PERMIT DESIGN REVIEW AND VARIANCE APPLICATION NUMBER 23-0046 SUBJECT TO CONDITIONS IN THE INITIAL STUDY, MITIGATED NEGATIVE DECLARATION AND MITIGATION MONITORING REPORTING PROGRAM. STAFF AND THE CONSULTANT ARE AVAILABLE TO ANSWER ANY QUESTIONS YOU MAY HAVE. THE APPLICANT IS ALSO HERE AND AVAILABLE TO PROVIDE ANY CLARIFICATION THAT MAY BE NEEDED. THANK YOU. >> THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR THE PRESENTATION. ARE THERE ANY FACTUAL QUESTIONS FROM THE COMMISSION FOR STAFF? COMMISSIONER ROBINSON. >> SO, FOR THE 2.5 ACRE PARCEL OR PORTION ON THE SITE THAT WE ARE LOOKING AT, IS THERE A PREVIOUS USE? WAS THIS A PREVIOUSLY DISTURBED SITE, OR HAS IT JUST BEEN UNTOUCHED FOR THE LAST HOWEVER MANY YEARS? >> [ INAUDIBLE ] HAS THERE BEEN A PREVIOUS USE ON THAT PIECE OF THE PARCEL? >> THROUGH THE CHAIR, THERE HAS NOT BEEN. THIS HAS BEEN UNTOUCHED. THIS SITE HAS BEEN UNDEVELOPED. >> OKAY. >> I HAVE ONE QUESTION FOR STAFF. THE ADDITIONAL COMMENTS WE RECEIVED TODAY WITH QUESTIONS, CAN YOU SUMMARIZE FOR THE PUBLIC HOW DIFFERENT THEY ARE FROM WHAT WE HAVE SEEN PREVIOUSLY, AND ADDRESSED? >> THROUGH THE CHAIR, I'M GOING TO BRIEFLY SUMMARIZE. IF WE GO BACK TO THE PRESENTATION IN REGARDS TO DISCUSSIONS REGARDING AMBIENT AIR QUALITY AND SOME OF THE ISSUES IN REGARD TO GREENHOUSE GASES AND AIR CONTAMINANTS, THOSE WERE ALREADY DISCUSSED AND ANALYZED PREVIOUSLY IN THE INITIAL STUDY. AND WHAT WE DID WAS COMPARE BOTH AND DETERMINED THAT THIS PROJECT IN THE LETTER THAT WAS RECEIVED TODAY IN THE INITIAL STUDY THAT WE PREPARED COVERED ALL OF THAT, SO WE DID NOT HAVE ANY CONCERNS BEFORE BRINGING THIS TO THE PLANNING COMMISSION TONIGHT. >> THANK YOU. IN ANY OTHER QUESTIONS FROM THE COMMISSION? COMMISSIONER FOSTER. >> GOOD EVENING. I'M TRYING TO REMEMBER WHEN I VISITED THE PLANT, WHAT IS THE SIZE OF THE BUFFER AREA? BETWEEN THE HIGHWAY IN THE NEXT NEIGHBORING PROPERTY, AND WHAT IS IN THE BUFFER AREA? >> MAURICE, IS YOUR MICROPHONE ON? >> SORRY ABOUT THAT. BASED UPON THE SITE PLAN, THERE IS A SETBACK BETWEEN THE HIGHWAY IN THE FOOTPRINT OF THE PROPOSED PROJECT OF AROUND 2300 FEET. >> WHAT IS IN THAT BUFFER? >> MOSTLY, SOME VEGETATION FOR THE MOST PART AND IN CERTAIN AREAS ARE ACTUALLY A LITTLE AARON, NOT MUCH OF ANY VEGETATION IN THOSE AREAS. THERE IS A WETLAND, AS WE ALL KNOW, AND THAT GOES ALONG A CERTAIN PORTION , SO THAT IS ALSO ANOTHER FEATURE WITHIN THAT BUFFER AREA. >> AM ALSO TRYING TO RECALL IN THIS FOLLOW-UP QUESTION, WAS THERE A BIOLOGICAL STUDY ON WILDLIFE ANYMORE THERE? >> YES. THE PSR THAT WAS CONDUCTED LOOKED AT ALL OF THE WILDLIFE, BOTH FLORA AND FAUNA, AND BASICALLY ADDRESSED THOSE IN THE MITIGATION MEASURES AS WELL AS MITIGATION MONITORING. >> DID THEY CHECK INSECTS LIKE NESTING BEES? >> I DON'T RECALL INSECTS SPECIFICALLY, BUT I THINK THEY DO HAVE PARTICULAR SPECIES THAT THEY LOOK OUT FOR, SO IF IT IS NOT ON THEIR ENDANGERED LIST OR PROTECTED SPECIES, I'M NOT SURE IF THEY'RE GOING TO TEST FOR ANY INSECT AT ALL. >> THANK YOU. >> THANK YOU. COMMISSIONER SMITH. >> THANK YOU FOR A VERY THOROUGH PRESENTATION. I APPRECIATE THAT. I PROBABLY HAVE SOME QUESTIONS HERE FOR OUR APPLICANT, BUT MAYBE THIS IS PART OF WHAT WE HAVE ALREADY UNCOVERED AND DISCOVERED. SO, TO FOLLOW UP COMMISSIONER FOSTER WITH THE TREES, WE HAVE NOT GONE TO TREES, BUT IF I CAN REMEMBER, THIS SITE, IT WAS MUDDY THAT DAY. WE HAD OUR BOOTS ON BUT THERE REALLY IS NOT ANYTHING --IT IS JUST A FIELD WITH SOME GRASS IN IT. HAS IT BEEN LOOKED AT TO POSSIBLY PUT SOME TREES ALONG THERE? NOT ONLY WOULD THAT ADD TO BEAUTIFYING THE AREA ALONG THE HIGHWAY IN THAT INDUSTRIAL AREA, BUT MAYBE WORK FOR NOISE POLLUTION. THAT IS ONE THING I DID HEAR A LOT OF NOISE THERE, AND SO THAT IS ONE QUESTION. THE VEGETATION THAT COULD BE PLANTED AROUND THAT AREA AND LOOKING AT THE SAME SLIDE YOU HAVE UP HERE, AND WONDER IF THAT WOULDN'T EVEN BE A GOOD IDEA IF WE DID THAT AND THE OTHER THING IS, IT CAME UP AND IS MENTIONED ABOUT THE ACCESS FOR BICYCLES AND PEDESTRIANS ON THE STREET. THAT AREA RIGHT THERE ALONG LOVERIDGE FIRST OF ALL IT'S REALLY HARD FOR ME TO EVEN FIND THE ENTRANCE TO IT, BUT IT LOOKS LIKE IT HAS NEVER BEEN FULLY DEVELOPED AS FAR AS THE SIDEWALK AND YOU KNOW, THE BOUNDARIES OF WHERE THE STREET ENDS IN THE GRAVEL ON THE SIDE, AND IS THE CITY -- DO WE HAVE ANY PLANS TO DO ANYTHING ABOUT THAT, TO MAKE THAT A LOT MORE ACCESSIBLE AND ALSO FOR ANYBODY WHO MAY BE WALKING THROUGH THERE? I DON'T KNOW WHERE THEY WOULD WALK THROUGH THEIR PAY THEY WOULD BE WALKING THROUGH THE GRAVEL AND THERE IS NO SIDEWALK THERE, IS THERE? >> THERE IS A SIDEWALK ALL THE WAY UP TO THE MAIN ENTRANCE WHERE THE TRUCKS GO IN BUT BEYOND THAT -- >> THERE'S NOTHING. RIGHT. >> WE ALSO HAVE A CONDITION OF APPROVAL WHERE THERE WOULD BE A LANDSCAPING BUFFER AROUND THE SITE AS PART OF THIS PROJECT. >> GOOD, BUT NOTHING SO FAR AS THE STREET IN EXCESS AND -- >> NOT THAT I KNOW OF, BUT I WILL DEFER THAT . >> THROUGH THE CHAIR, THERE IS NO SPECIFIC CONDITION FOR THAT. WHEN WE DID REVIEW THIS PROJECT WE DID REVIEW IT AS BEING A PROJECT THAT WAS ON SITE WITH THE 2.5 ACRES, MAKING SURE THEY COMPLY WITH OUR PITTSBURG MUNICIPAL CODE, THE GENERAL PLAN, AND THE MITIGATION MEASURES THAT WERE PREPARED FOR THE PROJECT, JUST TO ENSURE THAT WE COMPLY WITH CEQA AND MAKING SURE WE CAN ADDRESS ANY OF THE CONCERNS THAT WERE RAISED PREVIOUSLY IN ALL THE LETTERS IN THE INITIAL STUDY. WHAT WE DID WAS REALLY DO AN EXHAUSTIVE RESEARCH TO MAKE SURE THAT THE QUESTIONS YOU ARE ASKING IN REGARDS TO LANDSCAPING, TREES, IN REGARDS TO THE SITE ITSELF, THAT WAS ANALYZED AND PREPARED AND PUT INTO THE CONDITIONS THAT WERE APPROVED FOR THE PROJECT. >> THANK YOU. >> I WANT TO ASK WHEN CLARIFYING QUESTION. AT THIS POINT, THEY CANNOT BE CONDITIONED FURTHER THAT THERE IS DEVELOPMENT FOR THE SIDEWALK? FOR GRANTING THE PERMITS AND THE VARIANCE FOR THE PROJECT? >> THAT WOULD HAVE TO BE ESTABLISHED AS SOME SORT OF OFF-SITE IMPROVEMENT FOR NEXUS AND I DON'T SEE THAT HERE, SO I DON'T WANT TO OVERSTEP WHAT IS IN THE PITTSBURG MUNICIPAL CODE IN REGARDS TO CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL AND THE APPLICANT SO WOULD BE BETTER TO ANSWER THAT QUESTION BUT I DON'T WANT TO OVERSTEP WHAT WE HAVE HERE TONIGHT. >> THANK YOU FOR THE PRESENTATION. MY QUESTION IS REGARDING AIR QUALITY. WILL THERE BE A CONTINUAL MONITORING OF AIR QUALITY HERE AND THERE JUST TO MAKE SURE EVERYTHING IS MAINTAINED? >> THROUGH THE CHAIR I'M GOING TO ALLOW FOR OUR CONSULTANT TO ADDRESS THAT, THANK YOU. >> THANK YOU. >> YOU, THERE IS NO AIR QUALITY MONITORS AS THE OPERATION, THE AIR SEPARATION PROCESS DOES NOT EMIT ANY OPERATIONAL EMISSIONS. >> THANK YOU. >> THANKS FOR CLARIFYING. COMMISSIONER FOSTER. >> YES. AS A FORMER RESPONDER TO EMERGENCY MANAGEMENT AND BEING IN AN EMERGENCY OPERATIONS CENTER, I KNOW A LOT OF FACILITIES LIKE THIS HAVE AN EMERGENCY PLAN JUST IN CASE THERE ARE LEAKS, SO IS THERE ONE IN PLACE? >> I BELIEVE THE APPLICANT WOULD BE BETTER POSITIONED TO ANSWER THAT QUESTION, BUT I WOULD ASSUME AS AN INDUSTRY REGULATED BY OSHA, THERE HAS TO BE AN EMERGENCY PLAN IN PLACE. >> THANK YOU. >> THANK YOU SO MUCH. >> VICE-CHAIR KOBATA. >> IN REGARDS TO THE EMERGENCY PLAN, WOULD THAT BE INCLUDING A NOTIFICATION OF THE RESIDENCE AROUND THE AREA? >> PERHAPS THE APPLICANT CAN STEP FORWARD AND TELL US A LITTLE BIT ABOUT THE EMERGENCY PLAN IN PLACE. >> THANK YOU. I DO NOT SEE ANY OTHER QUESTIONS FROM THE COMMISSION IN THE QUEUE SO I WOULD LIKE TO GO AHEAD AND OPEN THE HEARING AND INVITE THE APPLICANT TO COME FORWARD. >> THERE WE GO. THANK YOU VERY MUCH, PLANNING COMMISSION, FOR YOUR TIME THIS EVENING AND FOR YOUR CONSIDERATION OF OUR PROPOSAL. MY NAME IS CHRISTIAN LUNCH. I'M THE DIRECTOR OF CAPITAL, FOR LINDE. I WAS BORN IN OAKLAND. I GRADUATED IN MECHANICAL ENGINEERING AND WAS RAISED HERE IN THE BAY AREA AND I'VE BEEN WITH LINDE FOR 30 YEARS AND AM A SUBJECT MATTER EXPERT IN THE AREA AND IT'S A PLEASURE TO BE ABLE TO ADDRESS YOU THIS EVENING. DURING THIS MEETING THE COMMISSION WILL BE DISCUSSING APPROVAL OF LINDE'S PROJECT, OAK STONE, WHICH IS A SECOND AIR SEPARATION PLANT NEXT TO OUR EXISTING UNIT. I RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR YOUR CONSIDERATION AND APPROVAL OF THIS REQUEST TO ALLOW US TO EXPAND. LINDE I S THE LARGEST INDUSTRIAL GASES COMPANY IN THE UNITED STATES , AND THE LARGEST WORLDWIDE. OUR THREE PRODUCTS, PURE OXYGEN, NITROGEN AND ARGON ARE THE MAIN PARTS OF THE AIR THAT WE ARE BREATHING RIGHT NOW, AND ARE USED IN MANY INDUSTRIES INCLUDING AEROSPACE, CHEMICALS, ELECTRONICS, REFINERIES, HEALTHCARE, FOOD AND BEVERAGE AND METALS. THERE ARE ONLY THREE OF THESE AIR SEPARATION PLANTS IN THE GREATER SAN FRANCISCO BAY AREA. THE OTHER TWO ARE IN SANTA CLARA, VACAVILLE. IN 1950 NOW -- 1959, LINDE BUILT OUR FIRST AIR SEPARATION PLAN IN AN AREA SURROUNDED BY FARMS BEHIND US. IN THE FOLLOWING 65 YEARS WE HAVE EXPANDED OUR SITE TWICE AND ADDED THE PACKAGING OF GAS CYLINDERS ALONG WITH GENERATIONS OF LOCAL EMPLOYEES IN TAXES THAT WE PAY, LINDE HAS BECOME A CRITICAL PART OF THE BAY AREA INFRASTRUCTURE. WE HAVE INVESTED OVER $150 MILLION TO SUPPORT SUPPLIES DELIVERED BY PIPELINE, BY BOAT TRAILERS AND DISTRIBUTED TO SMALLER CUSTOMERS BY CYLINDERS. IN TOTAL, THE PITTSBURG PLANT SUPPLIES SOME 33,000 CUSTOMERS THROUGHOUT THE REGION FROM FRESNO TO REDDING AND INTO NEVADA. LIKE ELECTRICITY, OR WASTEWATER TREATMENT PLANTS, WE ARE A CRITICAL UTILITY TO OUR CUSTOMERS AND ESSENTIAL TO THE LOCAL AREAS HEALTH AND SAFETY. OUR NEARBY PETROL CHEMICAL CUSTOMERS LIKE DOW, PBF AND SHELL, MARATHON OR GOLDEN EAGLE, VALERO AND PHILIPS 56 RELY ON US TO SUPPLY THEM THERE FIRE SUPPRESSING NITROGEN FROM OUR PITTSBURG PLANT BOTH BY TRUCK AND BY OUR 18 MILES OF UNDERGROUND PIPELINES TO KEEP THEIR PLANTS IN OUR NEIGHBORS SAFE. THESE PIPELINES ARE CRITICAL IN KEEPING HUNDREDS OF TINKER TRUCKS OFF THE ROADS. SOME OF OUR OXYGEN CUSTOMERS ARE HOSPITALS, AS YOU KNOW. CENTER DELTA REGIONAL CENTER IN ANTIOCH, CONTRA COSTA MEDICAL CENTERS IN MARTINEZ AND UCLA DAVIS ARE OUR CUSTOMERS. WE SUPPLY THE MAIN HOSPITAL FOR THE CITY OF FRESNO. WE ALSO SUPPLY CYLINDER GASES FOR ALL OF JOHN MUIR AND ALL OF KAISER. SAFETY IS LINDE'S HIGHEST PRIORITY IN ALL OF OUR BUSINESS AND OPERATIONS, ESPECIALLY AT OUR PLANS AND FOR OUR DRIVERS. THIS IS A CLEAN INDUSTRIAL PROCESS WITH NO TOXIC EMISSIONS OR EVEN REACTIONS. THE ONLY INPUTS ARE AIR AND ELECTRICITY , WITH WATER ADDED AS AN AUXILIARY INPUT FOR KILLING. THAT SAID, LINDE PRIORITIZES SAFETY OPERATIONS AND COMPLIANCE AS A LEADER IN SAFETY PERFORMANCE. OUR RECORDABLE INJURY RATE IS 1/8 OF THE NATIONAL INDUSTRIAL AVERAGE AND THE LAST RECORDABLE INJURY, I BELIEVE, WAS 12 YEARS AGO, SO WE HAVE BEEN INCIDENT AND ACCIDENT FREE INSIDE THE PLANT FOR 12 YEARS. THE PLANS FOR THE NEW PLANT TO INCLUDE EQUIPMENT FOR THE PRODUCTION, STORAGE AND TRUCK FILLING BUT WE UTILIZE EXISTING INFRASTRUCTURE FOR OFFICES AND CONTROL ROOMS RATHER THAN ADD NEW BUILDINGS. PROJECTS HAVE BEEN REVIEWED BY AN INDEPENDENT SEQUEL CONTRACTOR AND WAS DETERMINED TO HAVE NO NEGATIVE IMPACT ON THE ENVIRONMENT. LINDE IS SEEKING THE APPROVAL WITH PERMITTING TO EXPAND OUR SITE AND SERVE THE BAY AREA FOR DECADES TO COME. WE APPRECIATE YOUR CONSIDERATION AND APPROVAL TO ENABLE LINDE TO CONTINUE ITS UNIQUE AND BENEFICIAL OPERATIONS IN SPITSBERGEN AND I'M ABLE TO ANSWER ANY QUESTIONS YOU MAY HAVE. THANK YOU. >> THANK YOU SO MUCH. CAN I ASK FOR SOME ADVICE? ONE OF THE CUSTOMERS THE APPLICANT JUST MENTIONED IS MY EMPLOYER AND I REALIZE THAT I DIDN'T HAVE ANY PREVIOUS INFORMATION ABOUT THAT SO I WANTED TO CHECK IF THERE IS A NEED FOR ME TO EXCUSE MYSELF FROM THE REST OF THE DISCUSSION. >> THROUGH THE CHAIR, LET'S JUST TAKE A RECESS, A FIVE MINUTE RECESS AND COME BACK. THANK YOU. >> THANK YOU. >> ALL RIGHT, WE ARE READY TO PROCEED. THANK YOU FOR THE ADDITIONAL PRESENTATION. >> THANK YOU FOR YOUR INTRODUCTION, AND YOUR BACKGROUND AND YOUR LONGEVITY IN THE INDUSTRY. YOU KNOW, I UNDERSTAND THAT THIS IS AN INDUSTRIAL FACILITY THAT DEALS WITH GAS. I HAVE SEVERAL QUESTIONS. A LOT OF THE CONCERNS HERE ARE MORE CENTERED ON AIR QUALITY, BUT I WONDER, DOES WHAT YOU DO AFFECT THE GROUNDWATER? >> NO, NOT AT ALL. I GUESS I WILL DESCRIBE, IF THIS WILL HELP THE COMMISSION. WE, FOR LACK OF A BETTER TERM, AS I MENTIONED TO COMMISSIONER SMITH, WE ARE DOING MARBLE SORTING. PER 1 MILLION MARBLES OF AIR, IF YOU CAN THINK OF INDIVIDUAL MOLECULES, THERE IS 70,000 80,400 MOLECULES OF NITROGEN. 200 OXYGEN GUYS, ARGON GUYS, DEPENDING ON WHAT THE RELATIVE HUMIDITY IS, ANYWHERE FROM EIGHT OR 900 ON A DRY DATE TO 11,000 OR SO WATER GUYS. 410 CO2 GUYS AND THEN SMOG. WITH THAT THREE SMALL GASES, KRYPTON, XENON, AND NEON. OUR INDUSTRY ONLY SEPARATES OUT SIX OF THAT LIST OF 15 GASES, AND IT IS THE OXYGEN, NITROGEN AND ARGON AND FOR THE REALLY LARGE FACILITIES, KRYPTON, XEON, AND NEON AND THIS PLANT IS TOO SMALL. IT JUST DOES OXYGEN, NITROGEN AND ARGON SO WE LITERALLY USE THE PHYSICAL CHEMICAL PROPERTIES OF THE GASES AND COOL THEM DOWN TO 285 DEGREES BELOW ZERO. IN A BIG TOWER. THAT IS WHY YOU HAVE THE DISTILLATION TOWER. AT THAT POINT, THEY SEPARATE. THE OXYGEN BECOMES A LIQUID AND GOES TO THE BOTTOM. THE ARGON KIND OF STAYS IN THE CENTER. I THINK THERE IS A PICTURE IN YOUR PACKET ABOUT THE AIR SEPARATION PROCESS, AND THAT NITROGEN GOES TO THE TOP. THE SMOG THAT WE BRING IN, WE SEND BACK TO THE AIR . THERE IS NO CHEMICAL REACTIONS. WE DON'T ADD ANYTHING. THE GASES ARE ELEMENTAL IF YOU'RE AND WE ARE JUST MARBLE SORTING, TRYING TO GET THEM AS PURE AS POSSIBLE. >> A FOLLOW-UP QUESTION. I JUST HAD TO ASK THAT BECAUSE PEOPLE WILL WONDER. AS YOU SAY, YOU ARE MARBLE SORTING, AND ME WITH A LITTLE BIT OF MARITIME BACKGROUND, THIS IS IN THE CHAMBER, RIGHT? >> IT IS IN --I CALL IT A THERMOS BOTTLE, WITH CHEESE GRATERS INSIDE AND THEN AS AN OUTER CASING WHICH IS THE EXTERNAL PART OF THE TOWER. IT HAS THREE THERMOS BOTTLES WITH CHEESE GRATERS AND DISTILLATION HAPPENS INSIDE THAT. >> HOW WOULD YOU COMPARE IT TO A DOUBLE HOLD VESSEL? >> IT'S PRETTY CLOSE YEAH, IT'S PRETTY CLOSE. >> YOU, BECAUSE AT THE CHAMBER. >> WHAT WILL HAPPEN IF THE INNER VESSEL FAILS AND RELEASES GAS, PARTS OF AIR BACK, YOU WILL GET AN IMMEDIATE PRESSURE INCREASE IN THE SPACE BETWEEN THE TWO HOLES, EXACTLY, COMMISSIONER FOSTER, AND YOU WILL SEE THAT IMMEDIATE PRESSURE INCREASE AND YOU'VE GOT TO -- YOU HAVE TO DO SOMETHING ABOUT IT. IT BECOMES A SAFETY ISSUE AT THAT POINT. >> AND SO YOU DO THE DOUBLE HOLE TO PREVENT LEAKS AND ALSO FOR STRUCTURAL INTEGRITY, CORRECT? >> YES, STRUCTURAL INTEGRITY AND INSULATION. IT IS FILLED WITH PERLITE, A TYPE OF VOLCANIC ASH. IT IS MOSTLY AIR SO IT HAS THAT INTERIOR LINER TO TRY TO KEEP THE COLD INSIDE AND NOT HAVE AS MUCH HEAT TO MIGRATE INTO IT. >> I MAY HAVE OTHER QUESTIONS. I'M GOING TO LET THE OTHER COMMISSIONERS PROCEED. >> THANK YOU. COMMISSIONER SMITH IS IN THE QUEUE. >> THANK YOU VERY MUCH FOR A WONDERFUL PRESENTATION. I REALLY LEARNED A LOT. I KNOW MAURICE AND I WENT THROUGH IT TOGETHER AND ASKED A LOT OF QUESTIONS, AND YOU ARE VERY, VERY THOROUGH IN GIVING US A LOT OF INFORMATION AND I THINK I MAY HAVE SAID, YOU KNOW, I CERTAINLY HAVE SAID THIS BEFORE IN HERE, RUMORS TRAVEL FAST. YOU KNOW, WHEN I HEARD AROUND TOWN THE RUMORS THAT NO, THEY'RE GOING TO BE RELEASING THIS POISONOUS GAS, AND YOU KNOW, THAT WAS ONE OF THE THOUGHTS I HAD GOING IN THERE. THIS IS A DANGEROUS PLACE AND AFTER I LOOKED AT WHAT THE PROCESS IS, AND HOW IT HAPPENS, I REALLY WANT TO STRESS THAT IT WOULD BE WONDERFUL IF YOU COULD PUT TOGETHER SOME KIND OF WAY OF INFORMING THE PUBLIC ABOUT THIS, BECAUSE WHENEVER WE HAVE NEW INDUSTRY OR EXPANDING INDUSTRY, PEOPLE ARE SCARED AND THEY ARE SCARED BECAUSE WE HEAR THE RUMORS, BUT THEY DON'T HAVE THE TRUTH TO BE ABLE TO GIVE THEM A REAL PERSPECTIVE ON WHAT IS GOING ON, SO I KNOW I HAVE MENTIONED THAT TO YOU BEFORE. I THINK YOU GUYS NEED TO SING YOUR OWN PRAISES MORE ABOUT WHAT YOU'RE DOING BUT THAT'S JUST THE COMMENT I AM MAKING. ONE OF THE OTHER COMMENTS I HAVE YOUR IS THAT I THINK THE MOST IMPORTANT THING THAT I LEARNED FROM YOUR VISIT, NOT ONLY THE PROCESS, BUT THE FACT THAT YOU HAVE THIS LONGEVITY TO YOUR CREW, AND THEY WERE THE MOST IMPRESSIVE TO ME. YOU MENTIONED THAT YOU ARE GOING TO BE ADDING JOBS, BUT I HAVE NOT HEARD ANYTHING ABOUT IT HERE. HOW MANY JOBS, AND WHAT KIND OF TIMELINE, ASSUMING THAT THIS GOES . WHAT WOULD WE BE LOOKING AT AS FAR AS JOBS? >> THAT'S A GREAT QUESTION, AND IT WAS AN HONOR HAVING YOU AND COMMISSIONER FOSTER. I KNOW YOU CAME TO THE PLANT, TOO, AND THANK YOU VERY MUCH FOR GOING THAT EXTRA MILE TO LEARN MORE ABOUT US AND THOROUGHLY VET OUT OUR APPLICATION. SO YES. IF EVERYTHING GETS APPROVED , WE WOULD LIKE TO TRY TO BREAK GROUND HERE IN THE NEXT COUPLE OF MONTHS. IT IS ABOUT AN 18 MONTH CONSTRUCTION PROCESS . ABOUT 15 MONTHS IN, SO THIS WOULD BE NEXT SUMMER, THEREABOUTS. WE WOULD START HIRING TWO TO THREE PRODUCTION TECHNICIANS AND TECHNICIANS, ET CETERA THEN WHEN THE LOAD COMES AS HOPEFULLY WE CONTINUE TO GROW, WE WILL HIRE UPWARDS OF ANOTHER 20 DRIVERS. SOMEWHERE IN THAT RANGE, TO DELIVER THE PRODUCTS TO THE HOSPITALS AND CUSTOMERS WE TALKED ABOUT. >> OKAY, GREAT. AND ONE LAST QUESTION HERE. YOU MENTIONED THAT 1/8 OF NATIONAL ACCIDENTS. I WAS TRYING TO TAKE NOTES AS YOU WERE TALKING ABOUT THAT. WHAT KINDS OF ACCIDENTS CAN OCCUR? FIRSTLY, I BELIEVE YOU MENTIONED THAT WHEN WE WERE THERE IN PERSON ABOUT THE KINDS OF HAZARDOUS CONDITIONS YOU MIGHT COME ACROSS THERE, BUT NOT ONLY THERE, BUT CAN THEY GO OUT TO THE PUBLIC? >> THAT'S A GREAT QUESTION. BECAUSE ALL WE ARE DOING IS MARBLE SORTING, WE ARE NOT ACTUALLY CHANGING THE CHEMICAL PROPERTIES OF AIR, WE ARE JUST PUSHING THEM AROUND, OUR BODIES WERE DESIGNED FOR 20.9% OXYGEN, WHAT IS IN THE AIR, AND SO OSHA ACTUALLY MAINTAINS A LIMIT BETWEEN 19.5 AND 23.5 PERCENT OF AIR. WHEN WE GO OUTSIDE THAT RANGE THEN WE HAVE WHAT IS CONSIDERED A CONFINED SPACE AND WE'VE GOT TO GET --WE HAVE TO EVACUATE PEOPLE OUT, SO WE GENERALLY DON'T GET IN THAT WORLD. WE HAVE TO VENT ELEMENTAL NITROGEN, OXYGEN OR ARGON. ALL THOSE VENTS GO UP IN THE AIR SIMILAR TO MIXING SUGAR AND WATER OR MAKING YOUR TEA. THE ENGINEERING BEHIND IT IS ALL DISPERSION THEORY. YOU PUT SUGAR IN, YOU STIR IT UP AND IT DISAPPEARS. IF YOU DON'T PUT ENOUGH IN, IT IS WEAK. THE SAME THING APPLIES HERE.. NITROGEN OR OXYGEN OR ARGON WILL GO INTO THE AIR AND THEN IMMEDIATELY DISPERSE ITSELF, SO THE SAFETY IMPLICATIONS OF THAT ARE USUALLY MEASURED IN FEET. 10 FEET, 20 FEET. IT IS IT, AGAIN, UP IN THE AIR. IF THERE IS A LIQUID SPILL, THE LIQUID WILL CREATE A FOG BANK. THAT FOG BANK WILL GIVE YOU THE DELINEATION OF HOW FAR THE SAFETY ISSUES ARE. I'M NOT AWARE OF ANY RELEASE OF LIQUID PRODUCTS IN THE HISTORY OF THE FACILITY. IT'S NEVER HAPPENED, TO MY KNOWLEDGE . I INTERVIEWED THERE IN 1986, SO IT'S BEEN A LONG TIME. THE LAST PART IS THE PHYSICAL TOUCHING PART. IF YOU HAVE HAD A WART OR SKIN THAT THEY WANT TO BURN OFF, RIGHT? FOR PRECANCEROUS, WHATEVER STUFF, THAT IS MEDICAL GRADE NITROGEN. IT IS COMING FROM US . SO, AS YOU KNOW, THAT COLD CRYOGENIC LIQUID IS REALLY, REALLY COLD AND IT BURNS. IN THIS CASE AND THAT IS WHAT IT IS USED FOR. ITS USE TO BURN OFF THE THING THAT IS ON YOUR SKIN. IF YOU PHYSICALLY TOUCH THAT LIQUID OR A PIPE THAT HAD THAT LIQUID IN IT, IT WOULD BURN YOUR HANDS, AND THAT IS -- I JUST DESCRIBED THE THREE SAFETY ISSUES IN OUR INDUSTRY. THAT IS IT. >> CAN I JUST TAKE THAT ONE STEP FURTHER, THE FOG BANK THAT YOU DESCRIBED, YOU DESCRIBED IT WHEN WE WERE THERE. HOW FAR WOULD THAT GO? >> IT DEPENDS ON HOW MUCH LIQUID IS RELEASED. GENERALLY, IN NORMAL OPERATIONS AND AGAIN, IT DEPENDS ON HOW COLD IT IS AND IN PARTICULAR, HOW MUCH MOISTURE IS IN THE AIR SO THEY HAVE TO GET BACK DOWN TO 285 DEGREES BELOW ZERO AND THEN ONCE WE GET THERE, WE DON'T STOP. THE INSIDE OF THE BOX , COMMISSIONER FOSTER, YOU'RE TALKING ABOUT, IT ACTUALLY SHRINKS BY ALMOST TWO FEET BECAUSE THE METAL ACTUALLY GETS SMALLER, SO AS A RESULT OF THAT, THE FOG BANK THAT WOULD OCCUR IS REALLY MEASURED BY HOW COLD IT IS OUTSIDE AND HOW MUCH MOISTURE THERE IS, SO IN THE MIDDLE OF THE NIGHT IN MARCH AFTER IT RAINS, IT WILL HUG THE GROUND AND IT MIGHT GO 50 FEET OR SO , THEREABOUTS, WHEN YOU'RE FILLING A TRUCK. >> NOT MILES. IT'S JUST GOING SOME FEET AWAY IN THE AREA OF THE FACILITY? >> IT WOULD NEVER LEAVE THE PROPERTY LINE, NOT EVEN GETTING CLOSE TO LEAVING THE PROPERTY LINE, THANK YOU. >> THANKS. >> THANK YOU. >> THANK YOU. THAT WAS A REALLY GOOD EXPLANATION THE KIND OF ANSWERS MY QUESTION. I'M GOING TO ASK IT ANYWAY. SO, LOOKING AT THE PROCESS OF TAKING AIR IN, SORTING THE MARBLES AND RELEASING BACK THE SMOG OR WHATEVER OTHER ELEMENTS THAT YOU ARE RELEASING BACK INTO THE ENVIRONMENT, MY QUESTION IS CENTERED ON ENVIRONMENTAL JUSTICE BECAUSE THAT IS A FOCUS IN OUR GENERAL PLAN FOR 20 FORWARD --2040 THAT WE ARE SO CLOSE TO GETTING APPROVED, AND I WANT TO KNOW, BECAUSE ADJACENT -- NOT WITHIN THAT LITTLE BUBBLE, THE BUFFER THEY LOOK AT WHEN THEY LOOK AT IMPACTS, BUT RIGHT OUTSIDE OF THAT BUFFER ZONE IS ONE OF THE POOR IN COMMUNITIES IN PITTSBURG AND MAKING SURE THE PEOPLE THAT WAS THERE ARE NOT IMPACTED NEGATIVELY BY ANY EXPANSION THAT HAPPENS HERE, SO BRING IN THE AIR, SORTING THE MARBLES, RELEASING BACK THE SMOG. DOES THAT CHANGE THE QUALITIES, THE PERCENTAGES OF NEGATIVE ELEMENTS, THE SMOG ELEMENTS IN THE AIR THAT WOULD IMPACT ANYTHING SURROUNDING THE SITE? >> NO. TECHNICALLY, IT DOES WITHIN PROBABLY MEASURED IN FEET, BUT THEN THE SMOG WILL GO BACK AND FILL IN THE HOLES. IT IS ALL A MATRIX, RIGHT? JUST LIKE SUGAR AND WATER. IT GOES INTO A MATRIX. WITHIN FEET, IT WILL ALL GO BACK TO --AGAIN, WE'RE TALKING ABOUT PARTS PER MILLION LIKE 20 ACETYLENE MOLECULES, NOT EVEN THAT. I THINK IT IS 13. ACTUALLY, HOLD ON, I HAVE THE DATA HERE COURTESY OF THE LETTER THAT ARRIVED HERE THIS EVENING. YEAH, HYDROCARBONS, SO ACETYLENE IS 0.1 PARTS PER MILLION, SO YOU WOULD HAVE TO HAVE 2 MILLION MOLECULES OF AIR TO GET ONE MOLECULE OF ACETYLENE, FOR EXAMPLE, SO THE AMOUNT OF IMPACT TO THE AIR IS NEAR ZERO BECAUSE THERE ARE SO FEW IMPURITIES IN THE FIRST PLACE. IT'S A GREAT QUESTION, THOUGH. >> THANK YOU. >> THANK YOU. COMMISSIONER FOSTER. >> I'M BACK. I UNDERSTAND THERE IS GOING TO BE A DEMOLITION OF AN OLD BUILDING AND DOES THAT USE OBSOLETE TECHNOLOGY? AND IF BUILDING THE NEW BUILDING, WHEN THAT IS CONSTRUCTED, WILL IT BE USING MORE I WOULD SAY CURRENT TECHNOLOGY? STATE-OF-THE-ART, DOES IT EMIT LESS? IS IT AN IMPROVEMENT? >> YEAH, GREAT QUESTION. WE JUST FINISHED REPLACING OUR COOLING TOWER AT OUR SITE WITH A NEW COOLING TOWER PERMITTED THROUGH THE CITY AND EVERYTHING ELSE. ABOUT A $5 MILLION INVESTMENT. THERE ARE TWO PARTS TO THE PROCESS. THE FIRST PART IS THE SEPARATION IN THE SECOND PART IS A LIQUID FIRE. BASICALLY JUST AN AIR CONDITIONER, BUT IT IS REALLY, REALLY BIG. THE COMPRESSORS -- IT AT HOME IT IS ONE THIRD OR ONE HALF A HORSEPOWER. OUR COMPRESSORS ARE THOUSANDS OF HORSEPOWER SO IT IS THIS MASSIVE LIQUID FIRE. WE HAVE TO REMOVE THE HEAT TO GET THE AIR DOWN BELOW ZERO SO THAT HEAT GOES IN THE COOLING WATER. THAT COOLING WATER THEN GETS HOT AND GOES TO A COOLING TOWER AND THEN WE EMIT THE HEAT BACK TO THE ATMOSPHERE. THE WATER BOILS SO IF YOU DRIVE BY LEVERAGE ROAD IN THE MIDDLE OF THE NIGHT ON A COLD DAY YOU'LL SEE SMOKE COMING OFF THE COOLING TOWER AND REALLY, IT'S NOT SMOKE. IT IS STEAM AS WE ARE BOILING WATER, TAKING HEAT OUT AND JUST INCREASING THE RELATIVE HUMIDITY BY A FEW PERCENT, SO THAT COOLING TOWER WAS COMPLETED IN SEPTEMBER. WE JUST DEMOED THE OLD TOWER HERE IN JANUARY , AND WE MOVED ALL OF IT AND IT'S ALL PERMITTED AND TESTED . THAT IS WHAT YOU HAVE TO DO, AND SO THAT WORK IS ALL DONE . FOR THE NEW PLANT, BECAUSE IT IS VERY EXPENSIVE , AND POWER HERE IS OUR MAIN UTILITY INPUT, AND AS WE ALL KNOW, PG AND HE IS NOT CHEAP, SO AS A RESULT WE INCORPORATED ALL THE CURRENT ENERGY EFFICIENCY DESIGNS THAT LINDE HAS INTO THIS PLANT BECAUSE ELECTRICITY IS SO EXPENSIVE. WE WANT TO TRY TO PRODUCE IT AS EFFICIENTLY AS POSSIBLE SO YES. WE INCORPORATE BASICALLY EVERY BELL AND WHISTLE WE CAN THINK OF BECAUSE PG&E MAKES IT WORTH OUR WHILE. YOU CAN SEE THE 1979 COOLING TOWER, YOU CAN SEE THE 1999 COOLING TOWER AND THEN YOU CAN SEE THE 2023 COOLING TOWER AND SORRY, AS A MECHANICAL ENGINEER IT GOT ME A LITTLE EXCITED. YOU CAN SEE THE CHANGE IN TECHNOLOGY OVER THE GENERATIONS LITERALLY JUST LAID OUT IN FRONT OF YOU. >> AND THROUGH THE CHAIR, BAY AREA AIR QUALITY MANAGEMENT DISTRICT HEALTH RISK SIGNIFICANCE THRESHOLDS, WE REVIEWED THAT WITH THE APPLICANT AND ALONG WITH OUR CONSULTANT, MAKING SURE THAT --TRYING TO ADJUST THE EQUITY SUSTAINABILITY ISSUE, MAKING SURE THAT AN ENVIRONMENTAL JUSTICE COMPONENT, WHICH WE ARE AND AS COMMISSIONER ROBINSON TALKED ABOUT IN OUR 2040 GENERAL PLAN, IT WOULD BE CONSISTENT WITH THAT. >> THANK YOU FOR MENTIONING THAT BECAUSE I WAS GOING TO ASK ABOUT THE RELATIONSHIP WITH THE BAY AREA QUALITY MANAGEMENT, SO THANK YOU FOR ADDRESSING THAT. I STILL HAVE THE FOLLOWING QUESTION. SO, THE NEW COOLING TOWER. WHAT IS THE LIFECYCLE FOR THAT COMPARED TO THE OLD COOLING TOWER. >> IT IS NEARLY IDENTICAL. OTHER THAN -- >> HOW MANY YEARS? >> NO, DECADES. 30. IT'S MADE OUT OF FIBERGLASS AS COMPARED TO MADE OUT OF TREATED REDWOOD. THE TREATED REDWOOD BECAME HAZARDOUS MATERIALS. IT IS OUT OF FIBERGLASS, SO I UNDERSTAND IT HAS A LIFECYCLE OF AT LEAST 30 YEARS. >> AND WHEN DO YOU START RECAPITALIZING IT? YOU'RE NOT GOING TO REPLACE IT AT THE 30 YEAR MARK, ARE YOU? >> IT WILL DEPEND ON WHAT THE QUALITY IS AND WHETHER IT'S EFFICIENCY IS WORKING CORRECTLY AND IT'S SAFE. >> I WAS GOING TO ASK, WHAT IS YOUR EMERGENCY MANAGEMENT PLAN. >> WE ARE REQUIRED BY OSHA AS WELL AS CAL OSHA TO HAVE AN EMERGENCY ACTION PLAN IN PLACE. WE HAVE ABOUT 140 FACILITIES IN THE UNITED STATES. I MANAGED OUR PLANT IN NIAGARA FALLS, NEW YORK FOR FOUR YEARS. WE HAD OUR EMERGENCY ACTION PLAN THERE SO I AM INTIMATELY FAMILIAR WITH THEM BECAUSE I HAD TO MAINTAIN OURS. OUR FACILITY MANAGER WAS SITTING NEXT TO ME. THAT IS NOT HIS RESPONSIBILITY HERE FOR PITTSBURG, SO WE HAVE ONE. IT HAS TO BE REVIEWED AND UPDATED ANNUALLY, SO THE COOLING TOWER ACTUALLY CHANGED OUR FACILITY MAP AND EVACUATION PLAN, ET CETERA, BECAUSE IT IS A SITE CHANGE. WE THAT DOESN'T HAPPEN VERY OFTEN. WE REVIEW THE MANUALLY. WE HAVE ANNUAL TRAINING ON THEM AND IT IS ACTUALLY POSTED IN THE CONTROL ROOM IN THE FRONT OFFICE. I THINK THOSE ARE THE ONLY TWO LOCATIONS IN PITTSBURG BUT WE HAVE THEM IN AN ACTUAL BOOKLET IN THE CASE OF LOSS OF POWER OR WHATEVER, AND SO THAT WE CAN PHYSICALLY REFER TO THEM AND MAKE SURE WE KNOW WHAT TO DO AND IT COVERS THINGS LIKE EARTHQUAKES, FIRES, RIOTS , RELEASES. ALL THE THINGS WE'VE BEEN TALKING ABOUT. I THINK THERE ARE 13 OR 14 DIFFERENT CATEGORIES. >> A FOLLOW-ON TO THE EMERGENCY MANAGEMENT PLAN. YOU SAID TRAINING. DO YOU DO DRILLS, TABLETOP, DO YOU DO FUNCTIONAL EXERCISES? DUE TO FULL-SCALE EXERCISES AND HOW OFTEN? >> IT VARIES BY PLANT AND I DON'T KNOW SPECIFICALLY WHAT MR. CATANIA'S CURRENT AND FUTURE PLANS ARE. A LOT OF IT, TO BE HONEST, DEPENDS ON THE INTEREST OF OUR FIRST RESPONDERS THAT WE DEAL WITH, SO WHEN I WAS AT NIAGARA FALLS, WE DID AN ANNUAL PHYSICAL MAN DOWN OR VARIOUS FIRE, WHATEVER PRETEND EXERCISES WITH THE NIAGARA FALLS FIRE DEPARTMENT, AND CONTRA COSTA FIRE, WE HAVE HAD THEM ON SITE AND WE HAVE EXPRESSED OUR INTEREST TO DO DRILLS WITH THEM AND WE WOULD WELCOME THAT OPPORTUNITY IN THE FUTURE. >> GIVEN THAT THIS DOCUMENT TELLS US THERE ARE SAFETY CONCERNS FOR WORKERS, WHAT KIND OF PPE TO THE WORKERS USE AROUND THE PLANT? >> OUR REQUIREMENT IS STEEL TOED SAFETY SHOES. HIKING BOOTS AND THEN YOU'VE GOT THE STEEL TOES FOR TOE PROTECTION, LONG SLEEVES, ARMS AND LEGS, HARDHAT, SAFETY GLASSES AND HEARING PROTECTION IN AREAS THAT EXCEED 85 DB. THAT'S IT. WE ALL WEAR A PERSONAL ATMOSPHERIC MONITOR TO VERIFY THE OXYGEN CONTENT TO MAKE SURE WE ARE BETWEEN 19.5 AND 23.5 SAFETY ZONE. >> BASED ON THIS DOCUMENT, THERE IS A VOLUNTARY EMISSION REDUCTION AGREEMENT. IS THAT SOMETHING YOU HAVE CONSIDERED OR READ ABOUT? >> THROUGH THE CHAIR, I'M GOING TO STEP IN HERE REAL QUICK. THE QUESTIONS IN THE MITIGATION MEASURES HAVE BEEN ADDRESSED. THEY WOULD NOT BE SUBJECT TO THAT. THEY DON'T MEET THAT THRESHOLD . SO. >> IT'S VOLUNTARY. >> AND THEN FOR THE BUFFER, WE MENTIONED --I KNOW WHAT IS PLANTED THERE. THERE'S ACTUALLY AN INVASIVE SPECIES. THERE IS CANARY ISLAND PALM BUT I REMEMBER SAYING THAT WE'VE GOT TO WATCH OUT BECAUSE OF GOING TO MULTIPLY. SO, IS THERE A PLAN OR CONSIDERATION TO IMPROVE THAT BUFFER MORE WITH NATIVE PLANTINGS SO THAT WOULD BE A BUFFER BETWEEN THE PROPERTY IN THE HIGHWAY? ALSO, A BUFFER BETWEEN YOUR PROPERTY IN THE NEIGHBORHOODS? >> I BELIEVE AGAIN IT IS IN THE MITIGATION PLAN. WE HAVE A REQUIREMENT TO DO SOME LANDSCAPING ALONG PITTSBURG HIGHWAY AS PART OF THIS APPROVAL. >> WILL THERE BE CONTINUOUS BIOLOGICAL TESTING OR CHECKING THE WILDLIFE OR INSECTS? >> THROUGH THE CHAIR, IN THE MITIGATION MONITORING REPORTING PROGRAM THERE IS AN IMPLEMENTATION MEASURE THAT THEY HAVE TO DO CONTINUOUS MONITORING AND WHAT HAPPENED THIS ONCE THE PROJECT BEFORE CONSTRUCTION, THEY WILL HAVE A BIOLOGIST GO OUT THERE TO DO THE RECONNAISSANCE SURVEYS AND AT THAT TIME, IF THERE IS SOME ADDITIONAL MEASURES WE HAVE TO TAKE IN REGARDS TO WETLANDS OR ANY OTHER SPECIES, BUT AT THIS TIME, IT HAS BEEN DISCUSSED THAT THERE HAVE NOT BEEN ANY CONCERNS RAISED IN IN REGARD TO YOUR QUESTIONS REGARDING TREES AND PLANTINGS, DURING THE IMPROVEMENT PLANS AND CONSTRUCTION PHASE WHAT WE CAN DO AS STAFF IS MAKE SURE WE TAKE A LOOK AT THE ADDITIONAL BUFFER AND WORK WITH THE APPLICANT TO COME UP WITH SOME SPECIFICS AND AESTHETICS IN REGARD TO THE AREA ITSELF. >> YES, THANK YOU. AND PROBABLY THE BENEFIT OF PUTTING IN NATIVE PLANTS, IT IS VIRTUALLY NO MAINTENANCE FREE, SO YOU DON'T HAVE TO SHAPE IT INTO BALLS OR BOXES AND MAKE IT FANCY. IT WILL TAKE CARE OF ITSELF. >> YES, WE WOULD APPRECIATE THAT. I THINK FINDING THOSE NATIVE PLANTS THAT ARE ABLE TO HANDLE -- YOU SAW THE AREA. THERE HAVE BEEN NO TREES FOR 65 YEARS SO IT IS REALLY DRY IN THE SUMMERS, SO TRYING TO FIND THOSE NATIVE TREES IF THAT IS WHAT WE DECIDE TO DO, THAT ARE GOING TO BE ABLE TO SURVIVE IN THAT ENVIRONMENT THROUGH THE SUMMER I THINK WOULD MAKE A LOT OF SENSE AS COMPARED TO SOMETHING FOREIGN. >> LAST QUESTION. I'M GOING TO CIRCLE BACK TO THE EMERGENCY MANAGEMENT PLAN. IS THAT SOMETHING WE CAN SEE AS A COURTESY? >> THROUGH THE CHAIR, WHAT I WOULD LIKE TO DO IS IF THAT IS SOMETHING THROUGH CONCERNS, I CAN ADDRESS ADDITIONAL CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL AND WORK WITH THE APPLICANT AND PROBABLY PREPARE A MEMO TO BRING THAT BACK TO THE COMMISSION. >> YEAH. MY THOUGHTS WERE SOMETIMES I DO READ THE CONTRA COSTA COUNTY BOARD OF SUPERVISORS AGENDA, AND ONE THING THAT WAS VERY INTERESTING, THE BAY AREA MANAGEMENT QUALITY DISTRICT PROVIDED A GRANT TO THE COUNTY TO SUPPLY AIR PURIFIERS DURING WILDFIRE EVENTS, SO I WONDER IF THAT CAN BE INCORPORATED JUST IN CASE WE HAVE AN AIR QUALITY ISSUE. >> AGAIN, THROUGH THE CHAIR, PITTSBURG MUNICIPAL CODE SPECIFICALLY WE HAVE TO ADDRESS WHAT IS IN THE CODE AND WHAT YOU ARE ASKING FOR REALLY DOESN'T ESTABLISH THAT TRUE NEXUS, SO I DON'T WANT TO CONDITION A PROJECT WAS SOMETHING WE HAVE NOT EVEN LOOKED AT, AT THIS STAGE. >> ALL RIGHT, THANK YOU. >> THANK YOU. COMMISSIONER SMITH. >> THIS DOCUMENT THAT WE RECEIVED IS A HEFTY ONE, EVIDENTLY CAME IN THIS AFTERNOON OR THIS EVENING, SO WE OBVIOUSLY HAVE NOT HAD A CHANCE TO BE ABLE TO GO THROUGH IT. I DID HAVE A COUPLE QUESTIONS ABOUT INFORMATION HERE, AND I HAVE HEARD THAT THIS HAS ALL BEEN READ AND THAT IT IS ALREADY INCLUDED IN THE PLAN. THERE IS NOTHING HERE THAT IS STANDING OUT, BUT I AM LOOKING AT THE SECTION 5.1.1 ON ACCIDENTS AT EXISTING FACILITIES, AND JUST ONE THING STRUCK ME. TWO VERY SERIOUS ACCIDENTS, I'M QUOTING, INVOLVING LARGE, MANUALLY ACTUATED ISOLATION VALVES OCCURRED AT AIR SEPARATION PLANTS AND LIQUID OXYGEN SERVICE. IN BOTH INCIDENTS, THERE WERE TWO FATALITIES. LARGE MANUALLY ACTUATED ISOLATION VALVES. DO YOU USE THOSE IN YOUR FACILITY? >> MANUALLY ACTUATED? I'M LOOKING FOR THE PAGE. >> IT IS PAGE 30 OF THIS DOCUMENT. UNDER ACCIDENTS AT EXISTING FACILITIES. AND OF COURSE AT THIS POINT THEN IT IS GOING INTO DIFFERENT THINGS THAT OF CAUSE DIFFERENT ACCIDENTS AT DIFFERENT PLANTS, SIMILAR PLANTS AROUND THE WORLD'S BUT, ARE YOU -- THESE VALVES, WHEN WE WERE IN THE CONTROL ROOM I COULD SEE THAT YOU HAVE ALL OF THIS ON THE SCREEN. THESE LARGE MANUALLY ACTUATED ISOLATION VALVES, ARE PEOPLE ACTUALLY DOING THE SAME KIND OF THING THEY ARE DESCRIBING HERE? >> THEY ARE, YES. AND I HAVE DETAILS ON THAT INCIDENT THAT THEY DESCRIBED. I ACTUALLY HAVE DOCUMENTS IF WE WANT TO TALK ABOUT IT. >> THROUGH THE CHAIR, WHAT WE DID -- WE DID AN EXHAUSTIVE REVIEW AND WE DID DISCUSS SOME OF THE CONCERNS THAT WERE RAISED AGAIN IN THE COMMENT LETTERS THAT WE RECEIVED -- TWO, LETTERS RECEIVED. THE APPLICANT CAN SHINE SOME LIGHT ON SOME OF THESE QUESTIONS THAT YOU HAVE, SPECIFICALLY THIS, AND IF THERE ARE OTHER QUESTIONS THAT DO COME UP. >> THANK YOU. >> I GUESS THE FIRST PART HERE, TALKING ABOUT THE INCIDENTS IS THAT IT IS INTERESTING TO SEE THAT THEY DID NOT FIND HER PRESENT ANYTHING IN THE UNITED STATES OR EUROPE OR EVEN SOUTH AMERICA, AND THEY HAD TO ACTUALLY GO TO ASIA TO TRY TO FIND AN ISSUE. THE PARTICULAR INCIDENT THAT THEY ARE TALKING ABOUT HAPPENED AT A COMPETITORS FACILITY IN 2019 IN CHINA. CHINA OBVIOUSLY HAS, AS WE ALL KNOW, ESPECIALLY FROM AN ENVIRONMENTAL JUSTICE ARENA, IS NOT ANYWHERE NEAR BOTH IN TERMS OF SAFETY PROTOCOLS, LABOR PRACTICES AND SAFETY ISSUES. UNFORTUNATELY. I WISH THAT WAS DIFFERENT BUT BE THAT AS IT MAY, INTERESTINGLY, AFTER THIS INCIDENT OCCURRED, THEY CAME TO THE U.S. ASKING FOR HELP WITH THE INVESTIGATION AND THEY HIRED A FRIEND OF MINE, JOHN BERNARD, WHO WORKS FOR THE COMPRESSED GAS ASSOCIATION IN THE U.S. THIS IS THE ASIAN EQUIVALENT OF IT, AND HE LED THE INVESTIGATION INTO THE INCIDENT. I HAVE A COPY OF HIS REPORT. WHAT THEY DID, I CAN'T BELIEVE. BACK TO COMMISSIONER FOSTER, THIS IS VERY INTERESTING, ACTUALLY. THEY HAD A LEAK FROM THE INTERIOR KNOWS BOTTLE OF LIQUID OXYGEN, AND THAT LEAK PERMEATED INTO THE ANNULAR SPACE BETWEEN THE OUTSIDE --BETWEEN THE INNER VESSEL IN THE OUTER VESSEL. IT LASTED FOR 23 DAYS . I'M STUNNED. IT GOT SO COLD THAT IT ACTUALLY BROKE THE OUTER CASING AND LEAKED PERLITE, THAT INSULATION I WAS TALKING ABOUT, OUTSIDE AND THEY KEPT RUNNING. I'M STUNNED. ANYWAY, SO AFTER DOING THAT FOR THREE WEEKS, YEAH, THEY HAD A CATASTROPHIC EXPLOSION, AND THE PEOPLE, YOU KNOW, THERE WAS A TRAGIC INCIDENT AND OBVIOUSLY PEOPLE WERE HELD ACCOUNTABLE FOR THAT, EVEN IN CHINA, WHICH IS GOOD BUT THAT SORT OF INCIDENT WOULD NOT COULD NOT HAPPEN HERE FOR MULTIPLE REASONS. THE FIRST ONE IS THAT THE SYSTEMS THEY HAVE IN PLACE MEASURE AND MAINTAIN THE PRESSURE OF THE ANNULAR SPACE. WE HAD A WORLDWIDE OPERATIONS A IN 2010 AND THAT EQUIPMENT WAS INSTALLED AT THIS PITTSBURG PLANT IN 2011 AND I WAS ACTUALLY INVOLVED IN THAT WORK SO WE ACTUALLY HAVE AN AUTOMATED SYSTEM THAT ALARMS WHEN THE CASING PRESSURE INCREASES, SO WE ALREADY KNOW IN ADVANCE AT THE VERY BEGINNING. THE SECOND PART IS WHEN IT GETS TO YOU CAN SEE IT ON THE OUTSIDE AND YOU TEST THE INTERIOR AND FOUND OUT IN THIS CASE IT IS HIGH-PURITY OXYGEN, YOU CAN'T OPERATE. I MEAN, THAT IS JUST VERY UNSAFE IN THE THIRD PART IS OBVIOUSLY AT THE POINT WHERE IT CRACKS THE CASING AND YOU ACTUALLY HAVE GOT PERLITE LEAKING, I WAS JUST DUMBFOUNDED. SO AGAIN, IT IS FROM A DIFFERENT CONTINENT, A DIFFERENT COUNTRY. THEY DON'T FOLLOW OSHA, THEY DON'T FOLLOW CAL OSHA THEY CAN'T IMAGINE IT WOULD HAPPEN IN THE U.S. AND GIVEN THAT THEY COULDN'T FIND ANY EXAMPLES OF THIS HAPPENING IN THE U.S. OR EUROPE OR SOUTH AMERICA, YOU KNOW, I THINK THEY ARE RAISING EXAMPLES THAT ARE NOT APPLICABLE TO THE SOCIETY THAT WE LIVE IN TODAY. >> THANK YOU. >> ANY OTHER QUESTIONS FROM THE COMMISSION FOR THE APPLICANT? NO? THANK YOU SO MUCH. >> MY PLEASURE, THANK YOU. >> DO YOU AGREE TO THE CONDITIONS THAT ARE LAID OUT? >> I WILL OFFER IF ANY OF THE COMMISSIONERS THAT HAVE NOT, WOULD LIKE TO COME SEE THE SITE EVEN AFTER HOPEFULLY YOUR APPROVAL OF OUR PROJECT, AND I APPRECIATE YOUR CONSIDERATION, I'M HAPPY TO HOST YOU, ABSOLUTELY. HAPPY TO SHOW YOU AROUND AND AS COMMISSIONER SMITH MENTIONED, I THINK WE ARE DISCUSSING HOW WE CAN HELP COMMUNICATE WHO WE ARE MORE. WE'VE BEEN OUT FOR 65 YEARS. >> THANK YOU. >> COMMISSIONER SMITH, SORRY, I DID NOT SEE YOU THERE. >> THANK YOU. I'M SORRY, I HAVE ONE MORE QUESTION FOR YOU. AGAIN, THIS IS SOMETHING THAT WAS BROUGHT UP DURING OUR VISIT. YOU HAD MENTIONED, AND WE HAVE TALKED ABOUT THIS WITH OUR BIG PLAN IN THE WORKS. YOU WERE FORMERLY TEACHING OR WORKING WITH COURSES THAT LOSS OF THE DONNAS -- LAS VIDANOS TO HELP PEOPLE LEARN ABOUT YOUR BUSINESS AND I WOULD BE INTERESTED IN WHETHER YOU WOULD GO INTO THE SCHOOLS AND HELP PEOPLE LEARN ABOUT YOU KNOW, INFORMATION AND TO VOCATIONALLY MOVE THEM IN THAT DIRECTION? >> OUR PREVIOUS PLANT MANAGER A COUPLE MANAGERS AGO ACTUALLY HELP SUPPORT THE PROGRAM AT LAS VIDANOS BECAUSE A LOT OF THE FOLKS WE HEARD TODAY ARE HIGH SCHOOL GRADUATES, THEY ARE NOT COLLEGE GRADUATES AND THEY DON'T NECESSARILY NEED TO BE SO WE WOULD BE HAPPY TO -- I COULD WORK WITH MIKE AND FIGURE OUT HOW WE CAN RESTART, LOOK AT HOW WE CAN RESTART SOME SORT OF INVOLVEMENT IN HELPING PEOPLE WORK THERE. AS YOU SAW WHEN YOU WERE THERE, WE HIRE FROM LOCAL COMMUNITY. THEY'VE BEEN THERE FOR -- I THINK THE YOUNGEST ONE WAS 12 YEARS AND THAT WAS LIKE 28 YEARS. AS I MENTIONED, WE HAVE GENERATIONS OF BAY AREA FOLKS. >> THANK YOU. >> THANK YOU. >> I DON'T SEE ANY MORE QUESTIONS FROM THE COMMISSION, SO I WOULD LIKE TO INVITE MEMBERS OF THE AUDIENCE WOULD LIKE TO COME FORWARD AND SPEAK. DO WE HAVE SOMEONE WHO HAS REQUESTED TO SPEAK? >> WE DO. RICK FRANCO. GOOD EVENING, COMMISSION MEMBERS. MY NAME IS RICK FRANCO. I'M AN ATTORNEY REPRESENTING SAFER CALIFORNIA AND WE ARE HERE TONIGHT TO OPPOSE THE PROPOSED OAK STONE NORTHERN CALIFORNIA EXPANSION PROJECT. AS EXPLAINED IN THE WRITTEN COMMENTS THAT WERE SUBMITTED TODAY BY EMAIL AND BY HAND DELIVERY, THE MITIGATED DEAD [ INAUDIBLE ] FAILS TO COMPLY WITH SEQUEL. THE MND LACKS EVIDENCE TO PROVE THAT THE IMPACTS WILL BE MEDICATED TO LESS THAN SIGNIFICANT LEVELS. UNDER SEQUEL, AN EIR IS REQUIRED FOR SUBSTANTIAL EVIDENCE SUPPORTS A FAIR ARGUMENT THAT THE PROJECT COULD RESULT IN POTENTIALLY SIGNIFICANT IMPACTS. HERE ARE OUR COMMENTS TODAY, INCLUDING COMMENTS FROM AIR QUALITY AND EXPERT --HAZARD EXPERT DR. PHYLLIS FOX COMMENTING THAT THE PROJECT HAS A QUALITY ISSUES THAT WERE NOT DISCLOSED. THE MND FAILS TO REALIZE INDIRECT EMISSIONS FROM A KEY SOURCE, WHICH IS ITS USE OF ELECTRICITY. DR. FOX'S COMMENTS DEMONSTRATE THAT CERTAIN CRITERIA POLLUTANTS INCLUDING NITROGEN OXIDES AND VOLCANIC GASES, EMISSIONS FROM NATIONAL --NATURAL GAS SOURCES SUPPLYING ELECTRICITY TO THE PROGRESS WOULD BE SIGNIFICANT AND SEQUEL REQUIRES THIS TO BE DISCLOSED. IT ALSO FAILS TO DISCLOSE HEALTH RISKS TO NEARBY NEARBY MIDDLE SCHOOL STUDENTS TO DIESEL PARTICULATES DURING CONSTRUCTION. DR. FOX FOUND THE HEALTH RISKS ANALYSIS CONTAINED ERRORS WHICH DISGUISE THESE RISKS INCLUDING USING INACCURATE METEOROLOGICAL DATA FROM CONCORD AIRPORT, OVER 10 MILES AWAY, TO ANALYZE THEIR QUALITY WHEN USING LOCAL MONITORING DATA, DR. FOX CALCULATED THAT THE PROJECTS DIESEL EMISSIONS FROM CONSTRUCTION RESULT IN ELEVATED CANCER RISKS OF UP TO 20 AND 1 MILLION, WHICH IS DOUBLE THE BAY AREA AIR QUALITY MANAGEMENT DISTRICTS SIGNIFICANCE THRESHOLD AND ADDITIONAL MITIGATION IS REQUIRED TO REDUCE THE SELF RISK. BRIEFLY WITH RESPECT TO HAZARDS, DR. FOX FOUND THE AMENITY FAILS TO ADEQUATELY DESCRIBE OPERATIONAL HAZARDS ASSOCIATED WITH THE AIR SEPARATION FACILITY RESULTING FROM POLLUTANTS IN THE AMBIENT AIR INCLUDING THE EMISSIONS FROM NEARBY INDUSTRIAL FACILITIES THAT WILL THEN BE RELEASED BACK AFTER THIS PROCESS, WHICH DR. FOX NOTES CAN INCREASE THE RISK OF A CATASTROPHIC ACCIDENT. DR. FOX ALSO FOUND THE MND FELL TO ANALYZE OTHER OPERATIONAL HAZARDS INCLUDING THE PRESSURIZED GASES, CRYOGENIC TEMPERATURES, COMBUSTION, X FIX YET PROPERTIES OF NITROGEN IN THE TRANSPORT AND LOADING OF LIQUID GASES. WE URGE THE CITY TO CAREFULLY REVIEW AND CONSIDER OUR COMMENTS THAT WERE CONSIDERED --SUBMITTED TODAY AND WE REQUEST THE COMMISSION CONTINUE THE PUBLIC HEARING AND DIRECT STAFF TO PREPARE AN EIR THAT FULLY DISCLOSES, ANALYZES AND MITIGATES THE PROJECT SIGNIFICANTLY --POTENTIALLY SIGNIFICANT IMPACTS. >> THANK YOU. I DO HAVE A QUESTION FOR YOU. WE ALREADY MENTIONED IN THE BEGINNING OF THIS DISCUSSION TODAY THAT STAFF FEELS THAT MOST OF THESE QUESTIONS WERE ALREADY ADDRESSED. I WAS HOPING SINCE YOU'RE HERE TONIGHT, YOU CAN SUMMARIZE WHAT YOU THINK IS DIFFERENT FROM THE COMMENTS IN THE QUESTIONS WE HAD BEFORE, AND I WOULD ALSO LIKE TO KNOW WHY DID WE ONLY RECEIVE THE LETTER TODAY AT THIS 11th HOUR, AND WHY WASN'T IT AVAILABLE EARLIER ON? I AM ASKING , WE ALL RECEIVED THE INFORMATION ON DR. FOX'S QUALIFICATIONS. I THINK IT IS IMPRESSIVE. I THINK IT IS IMPORTANT THAT THE QUESTIONS ARE BEING RAISED BUT I WANT TO MAKE SURE WE UNDERSTAND WELL WHAT HAS CHANGED FROM THE PREVIOUS TIME TO TODAY, AND WHY THE 11th HOUR CONCERNS. THANK YOU. >> MORE THAN FAIR QUESTIONS. I'M GOING TO TRY TO ANSWER THEM. I AM HERE APPEARING FOR MY COLLEAGUE, ANDREW GRAFF, WHO HAS BEEN WORKING ON THIS PROJECT AND WORKED WITH DR. FOX AND DRAFTED THE COMMENTS THAT WERE SUBMITTED TODAY. HE IS A LAWYER FROM SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA SO I AM HERE DELIVERING HIS COMMENTS. MY UNDERSTANDING IS THAT DR. FOX DID NOT WORK WITH HIM ON THE ORIGINAL SET OF COMMENTS, AND SHE HAS DONE A NUMBER OF REVIEWS OF SORT OF UNIQUE INDUSTRIAL PROCESSES FOR US, FOR OUR CLIENTS. AND, SHE HAS IDENTIFIED, I THINK, PRIMARILY THE HEALTH RISK OF HAVING TO DO WITH CONSTRUCTION . SHE IDENTIFIED AN ISSUE THAT TO MY KNOWLEDGE, WE DID NOT SEE BEFORE, AND I THINK THAT IS TRUE OF HER COMMENTS GENERALLY. SHE REVIEWED THIS MATERIAL AND I MEAN, I DON'T WANT TO SPECULATE BECAUSE LIKE I SAID, I HAVE NOT BEEN INVOLVED WITH THIS PROJECT UNTIL LIKE IN THE LAST COUPLE OF DAYS. AND I UNDERSTAND THE DIFFICULTY WHEN YOU RECEIVE A LENGTHY COMMENT ON THE DAY OF THE HEARING. TO BE FAIR, I THINK THE STAFF REPORT FOR THIS HEARING, YOU KNOW, IT WAS FRIDAY, SO THAT'S THE BEST I CAN DO. >> THANK YOU. APPRECIATE THE FEEDBACK. >> OKAY, THANK YOU. ANYONE ELSE WHO HAS REQUESTED TO SPEAK TONIGHT? >> BRUCE OLSEN. >> THANK YOU. >> ONLY TWO MINUTES? WHAT HAPPENED TO THREE? OKAY, SORRY. GOOD EVENING, CHAIR POPOVA, COMMISSIONERS, STAFF AND FELLOW PITTSBURG RESIDENTS. I AM BRUCE ALSTON, PITTSBURG'S MR. BICYCLE. I ALSO HAVE TO SAY I AM A HOBBYIST WELDER AND I BUY MY OXYGEN, ACETYLENE, ARGON AND CARBON DIOXIDE MR. COMPRESSED IN CYLINDERS, NOT A LIQUID, FROM THE ON-SITE STORE OF THIS PROJECT, SO PERSONALLY, I HAVE NO PROBLEM WITH THE PROJECT THAT THIS ORGANIZATION WANTS TO BUILD. HOWEVER, AS A BICYCLIST, A BIGGER PLANT MEANS MORE TRUCKS. THIS PROJECT OWNER AND OPERATOR SHOULD CONTRIBUTE TO THE CONSTRUCTION OF BIKE LANES AND SIDEWALKS ON LEVERAGE ROAD. AS COMMISSIONER SMITH SAID, INFRASTRUCTURE ON LEVERAGE ROAD IS INCOMPLETE. AT MINIMUM, THE APPLICANT SHOULD INSTALL A SIDEWALK AND THE BIKE LANE ADJACENT TO THE ENTIRE FRONTAGE OF THEIR PROPERTY ON LEVERAGE ROAD. THIS IS A REASONABLE REQUEST. IN FACT, IT SHOULD HAVE BEEN A REQUIREMENT AT THE 1979 EXPANSION, SO WE ARE RUNNING A LITTLE LATE. ADDITIONALLY, THE DEVELOPER SHOULD ALSO UPGRADE AND IMPROVE THE TRAFFIC SIGNALS. REMEMBER, HE IS ADDING PERKS TO THE ROADS, ON EACH SIDE OF HIS PROJECT. THAT WOULD BE CALIFORNIA AVENUE AND THE PITTSBURG ANTIOCH HIGHWAY, AND WE WANT CROSSWALKS IN ALL FOUR QUADRANTS OF EACH TRAFFIC SIGNAL. THIS IS ALSO A REASONABLE REQUEST. THANK YOU VERY MUCH. >> THANK YOU. ANYONE ELSE REQUESTING TO SPEAK TONIGHT? >> THERE ARE NONE. >> ALL RIGHT, I WILL GO AHEAD AND CLOSE PUBLIC HEARING AND BRING THIS BACK TO THE COMMISSION FOR DELIBERATION. INITIAL THOUGHTS FROM ANYONE? COMMISSIONER FOSTER? >> THIS IS MORE OF A QUESTION FOR MR. FUNDERBURK. MR. OLSON SPOKE ABOUT THE COMMUNITY BENEFIT IDEA. I JUST WANTED TO SAY THAT IT IS NOT JUST BICYCLISTS WHO PLY THAT AREA. THERE ARE ACTUALLY PEOPLE WHO SKATE

Page

/

3

Loading…

![](https://docs.google.com/viewerng/thumb?ds=AON1mFwod9RANlzsQJtH1yEs916YoKX7KloMQI0RplnixqXb65FIp2cxG-5_cTQv26QfORPKXokHwFjzaCgsXzRsFW7BrOCzCrCHbE9qcZrGn9W-1pCt3jfLoCcCQNzBr5zXpnemOze59Kf4NXT3CJvJHoPNanhMZ3ruPLXCotKXrCCk8AtuIuCe8lHPjmJOLFzYwoPo3VDKac-PGZxYrPML8OzRCsofGKkbNgaOhMItxJbej2La1dEPIwZFwVBbqVYPxU4jWDwnfs057h9sIA8A_9xXbwhroV_vV1I6_4Sr-mxWb8fGJXY7NU0vpA8TtBFDaoVFKqkpmMe33pxmOc7GKuLyuDy1EQ%3D%3D&ck=lantern&dsmi=unknown&authuser&w=800&webp=true&p=proj)

{"id": "", "title": "DocumentViewer.php", "mimeType": "application\\/pdf"}

## Page 1 of 3

![Page 1 of 3](blob:https://docs.google.com/a788eba6-cf9f-4a0a-8839-3cccec728e1f)

## Page 2 of 3

## Page 3 of 3

![Page 3 of 3](blob:https://docs.google.com/1952514b-f0f8-4908-b5b4-ee56b83793b6)

Loading…

Copy

Add a comment

![](https://onbaseweb.pittsburgca.gov/OnBaseAgendaOnline/Images/OnBase_Logo.png)

Agenda [Agenda Packet\\ ![](https://onbaseweb.pittsburgca.gov/OnBaseAgendaOnline/Images/PDF_16x16.png)](https://onbaseweb.pittsburgca.gov/OnBaseAgendaOnline/Documents/DownloadFile/Planning_Commission_1131_Agenda_Packet_2_27_2024_7_00_00_PM.pdf?documentType=5&meetingId=1131&isAttachment=True "View Agenda Packet for Planning Commission Planning Commision on 2/27/2024 7:00:00 PM")

Switch to Accessible View

Item:

# ![](<Base64-Image-Removed>)City of Pittsburg

Planning Commission Agenda

![](<Base64-Image-Removed>)

# 02/27/2024

City Hall Council Chamber

65 Civic Avenue, Pittsburg, CA94565

Regular Meeting

7:00 P.M.

Planning Commission Members

Ivelina Popova, Chair

Arlene Kobata, Vice-Chair

Sarah Foster, Commissioner

Vacant, Commissioner

Vacant, Commissioner

Donna Smith, Commissioner

Elissa Robinson, Commissioner

Any member of the public who wishes to address the Commission should complete a Speaker’s Card, available on the public counter below the dais.Please note on the card the agenda item number, or, for items not listed on this agenda, a brief description of the issue on which you would like to address the Commission.Give the completed form to the Minutes Clerk or a staff member, who will give the card to the Commission Chair.The Chair will invite the speaker(s) to the podium at the appropriate time during the meeting.Each individual will be given three minutes to address the Commission, unless additional time is allowed as provided for spokespersons.Prior to speaking, each speaker is requested to state his or her name and business and city of residence in a clear and audible tone of voice.For items listed under the “Public Hearings” or “Commission Consideration” portions of this agenda, the public hearing or public comment period will follow a brief presentation on the item by Planning Department staff and/or the project applicant.

A decision by the Planning Commission is not final until the appeal period expires 10 calendar days after the date the decision occurred.The applicant, City Council member(s), City Manager, or any affected person may appeal the denial, approval, recommendation, or any condition of approval of an item within the 10-day appeal period.A completed appeal form and the applicable filing fee must be filed with the City Planner, 65 Civic Avenue, Pittsburg.The appeal form must include the name and address of the appellant and state the reasons for the appeal.The appeal will be set for City Council consideration and appropriate public notification given.

The Commission requests that you refrain from disruptive conduct during the meeting and that you observe the order and decorum of the Council Chamber.Please turn off or set to vibrate all cellular phones, and refrain from making personal, impertinent or slanderous remarks.Boisterous or disruptive behavior while the Commission is in session, and the display of signs in a manner that violates the rights of others or prevents others from watching or fully participating in the Planning Commission meeting is considered counterproductive and will not be tolerated, and the Commission Chair can order any person who engages in such conduct to leave the Council Chamber.

This agenda was posted in City Hall on Friday, February 23, 2024

| | | --- | | [CALL TO ORDER](https://onbaseweb.pittsburgca.gov/OnBaseAgendaOnline/Meetings/ViewMeeting?id=1131&doctype=1#) |

| | | --- | | [ROLL CALL](https://onbaseweb.pittsburgca.gov/OnBaseAgendaOnline/Meetings/ViewMeeting?id=1131&doctype=1#) |

| | | --- | | [PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE](https://onbaseweb.pittsburgca.gov/OnBaseAgendaOnline/Meetings/ViewMeeting?id=1131&doctype=1#) |

| | | --- | | [DELETIONS, WITHDRAWALS OR CONTINUANCES](https://onbaseweb.pittsburgca.gov/OnBaseAgendaOnline/Meetings/ViewMeeting?id=1131&doctype=1#) |

| | | --- | | [COMMENTS FROM THE AUDIENCE](https://onbaseweb.pittsburgca.gov/OnBaseAgendaOnline/Meetings/ViewMeeting?id=1131&doctype=1#) |

| | | --- | | [CONSENT](https://onbaseweb.pittsburgca.gov/OnBaseAgendaOnline/Meetings/ViewMeeting?id=1131&doctype=1#) |

| | | | --- | --- | | 1. | [Minutes](https://onbaseweb.pittsburgca.gov/OnBaseAgendaOnline/Meetings/ViewMeeting?id=1131&doctype=1#)<br>Minutes of February 13, 2024 |

| | | --- | | [PUBLIC HEARINGS](https://onbaseweb.pittsburgca.gov/OnBaseAgendaOnline/Meetings/ViewMeeting?id=1131&doctype=1#) |

| | | | --- | --- | | 2. | [Consideration of a Resolution Granting a Use Permit, Design Review and Variance and adoption of an Initial Study Mitigated Negative Declaration and Mitigation Monitoring Reporting Program for the Linde Inc., Oakstone Northern California Expansion Project, AP-23-0046 (UP, DR, VA)](https://onbaseweb.pittsburgca.gov/OnBaseAgendaOnline/Meetings/ViewMeeting?id=1131&doctype=1#)<br>The proposed project consists of three applications a Use Permit, Design Review and Variance application for the Oakstone Northern California Expansion Project at Linde’s existing facility located at 2000 Loveridge Road.The proposed development project will result in the expansion of its Northern California industrial gas market by building a new plant which will involve installation of an air separation unit system, including a distillation tower, heat exchanger cold box, storage tanks, air compressor and auxiliary equipment, at its existing facility. The new facility will expand Linde’s current production of liquid nitrogen, oxygen, and argon. The property is located in the Industrial General Plan Land Use classification and General Industrial Zoning District (IG). The project also includes on-site circulation improvements to provide a 25-foot drive aisle through the parcel to the project site and expansion of the existing plant on the parcel near the entry/exit on to Loveridge Road.<br>Environmental:On October 13, 2023, Staff circulated the project Mitigated Negative Declaration (MND) (Attachment 3) for a 30-day public review and comment. Comments were received from the Department of Toxic Substances Control (DTSC) and the California Department of Transportation (Caltrans). |

| | | --- | | [STAFF COMMUNICATIONS](https://onbaseweb.pittsburgca.gov/OnBaseAgendaOnline/Meetings/ViewMeeting?id=1131&doctype=1#) |

| | | --- | | [COMMITTEE REPORTS](https://onbaseweb.pittsburgca.gov/OnBaseAgendaOnline/Meetings/ViewMeeting?id=1131&doctype=1#) |

| | | --- | | [ADJOURNMENT OF PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING](https://onbaseweb.pittsburgca.gov/OnBaseAgendaOnline/Meetings/ViewMeeting?id=1131&doctype=1#) |

NOTICE TO PUBLIC

NOTICE TO THE DISABLED AND VISUALLY OR HEARING IMPAIRED

In compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act, the city of Pittsburg will provide special assistance for disabled citizens.Upon request, an agenda for any meeting shall be made available in appropriate alternative formats.The Council Chamber is equipped with sound amplifier units for use by the hearing impaired.The units operate in conjunction with the Chamber’s sound system.You may request the sound amplifier from the City Clerk for personal use during Commission meetings.If you need special assistance to participate in this meeting, or are requesting a specially formatted agenda, please contact the City Clerk at 925-252-4850.Notification 48 hours prior to the meeting will enable the city to make reasonable arrangements to ensure accessibility to this meeting or provide the requested agenda format.(28 CFR 35.102-35.104 ADA Title II)

GENERAL INFORMATION

Showing the first 24,000 of 67,933 characters. The full document is at the source.

>> GOOD EVENING TO EVERYONE. THE FEBRUARY 27, 2024 REGULAR MEETING OF THE PITTSBURG PLANNING COMMISSION WILL NOW COME TO ORDER. WILL THE CLERK PLEASE CALL THE ROLE. >> ALISA ROBINSON >> PRESENT >> DONNA SMITH >> PRESENT >> SARAH FOSTER >> PRESENT >> ARLENE KOBATA >> PRESENT >> IVELINA POPOVA >> AYE. THANK YOU. AS REQUIRED BY LAW, THE AGENDA FOR THIS MEETING WAS POSTED AT CITY HALL AT LEAST 72 HOURS PRIOR TO TONIGHT'S MEETING ON FRIDAY, FEBRUARY 23rd, 2024, PLEASE LEAD US IN THE PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE. >> I PLEDGE ALLEGIANCE TO THE FLAG OF THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA AND TO THE REPUBLIC FOR WHICH IT STANDS ONE NATION UNDER GOD INDIVISIBLE WITH LIBERTY AND JUSTICE FOR ALL. >> THANK YOU, EVERYONE. MR. SECRETARY, ARE THERE ANY DELETIONS, WITHDRAWALS, OR CONTINUANCES FOR ITEMS LISTED ON THE AGENDA TONIGHT? >> GOOD EVENING. THERE ARE NO REQUESTS FOR DELETIONS, WITHDRAWALS OR CONTINUANCES TONIGHT. THANK YOU. >> THANK YOU. IF A MEMBER OF THE AUDIENCE WOULD LIKE TO SPEAK ON ANY ITEM ON THE AGENDA OR IF YOU WOULD LIKE TO ADDRESS THE COMMISSION ON A NON-AGENDA ISSUE, PLEASE FILL OUT A CITIZENS COMMENT CARD THAT CAN BE FOUND NEXT TO THE PODIUM AND HANDED TO THE CLERK. DO WE HAVE ANYONE ASKING TO SPEAK TONIGHT? >> FOR NON-AGENDA ITEMS, WE DO NOT. >> THANK YOU. IN THIS CASE I WILL CALL FOR APPROVAL OF THE CONSENT CALENDAR. DOES ANYONE ON THE COMMISSION HAVE ANY ITEMS THEY WANT PULLED FROM THE CONSENT CALENDAR TO BE CONSIDERED SEPARATELY? COMMISSIONER FOSTER? >> I MOVED TO APPROVE THE CONSENT CALENDAR. >> THANK YOU. I CAN GO AHEAD AND SECOND THE MOTION. LET'S VOTE. THE CONSENT CALENDAR IS APPROVED 5-0. THANK YOU. WE NOW COME TO THE PUBLIC HEARING PORTION OF THE AGENDA. WILL THE SECRETARY PLEASE READ THE NEXT ITEM? >> GOOD EVENING AGAIN MADAM CHAIR AND COMMISSIONERS. I WANT TO TEA THIS UP A LITTLE BIT BECAUSE WE HAVE SEEN THIS PROJECT BEFORE, AND THIS WAS BACK IN DECEMBER 12th AT THE PLANNING COMMISSION HEARING. THIS PROJECT WAS TO BE PRESENTED, AND WE RECEIVED A LATE OPPOSITION LETTER TO THE PROJECT. STAFF GRANTED THE CONTINUANCE THAT NIGHT FOR US TO COME BACK TO A LATER DATE. WE HAVE REVIEWED THE LETTER. WE HAVE ADDRESSED THE CONCERNS, AND DO NOT FEEL THERE ARE ANY CONCERNS BUT TONIGHT, THE PROJECT IS BEFORE YOU AGAIN AND WE DID RECEIVE ANOTHER LATE OPPOSITION LETTER AND WE REVIEWED THAT, TOO, SO I'M GOING TO ALLOW MAURICE TO GIVE US A PRESENTATION BUT THIS IS THE LINDE EXPANSION PROJECT. IT HAS BEEN IN EXISTENCE SINCE 1959 OF THE PROJECT AREA THEY'RE LOOKING AT EXPANDING IS A 2.5 ACRE PIECE. IT IS KIND OF THE LAST ACRE AREA OF DEVELOPMENT FOR THAT PROJECT SITE. ALSO WITH MAURICE TONIGHT IS DAN JONES, FROM OUR CH GROUP, OUR CONSULTANT THAT WORKED WITH US ON THE INITIAL STUDY. I WILL TURN IT OVER TO MAURICE AND DAN TO PROVIDE YOU WITH THE PRESENTATION. ACTUALLY, MAURICE WILL PROVIDE YOU WITH THE PRESENTATION AND IF THERE ARE ANY QUESTIONS OR CONCERNS YOU HAVE, DAN IS AVAILABLE TO ANSWER TONIGHT. >> THANK YOU. GOOD EVENING, COMMISSIONERS AND MEMBERS OF THE PUBLIC. THIS PROJECT ORIGINALLY WAS SCHEDULED TO BE HEARD DECEMBER 12th OF 2023 . THE PLANNING COMMISSION CONTINUED IT BECAUSE WE RECEIVED A LATE LETTER JUST TWO HOURS BEFORE THE HEARING. THE SAME PROJECT IS AGAIN BEFORE YOU TONIGHT FOR YOUR CONSIDERATION. THE PROPOSED PROJECT CONSISTS OF AN APPLICATION FOR USE PERMIT, DESIGN REVIEW, AND A VARIANCE TO EXPAND LINDE . IT IS THE NORTHERN CALIFORNIA INDUSTRIAL GAS MARKET, BY BUILDING A NEW PLANT AT THE CURRENTLY VACANT SITE. IT IS A 36 ACRE PARCEL. THE NEW FACILITY IS INTENDED TO EXPAND THE PRODUCTION OF LIQUID NITROGEN, OXYGEN AND ARGON. NO ADDITIONAL OR NEW PRODUCTS WOULD BE PRODUCED. THE PRODUCTS ARE STORED IN THREE LARGE TANKS AND WHEN NEEDED, THEY ARE TRANSFERRED INTO BOTH TRUCKS AND DELIVERED INTO SMALLER TANKS. CUSTOMERS ARE DIVERSE, AND THE SET OF INDUSTRIES INCLUDE HOSPITALS, FOOD PROCESSORS, ELECTRONICS, PRIMARY METALS, ENERGY, CHEMICALS AND AEROSPACE. THIS MAP SHOWS THE LINDE PLANT SIDE LOCATED AT 2000 LOVE BRIDGE ROAD WITH THE VACANT PORTION MARKED IN RED. USES INCLUDE COLUMBIA SOLAR INSTALLATION, EAGLE TIRES, MONDAY A RECYCLING, WASTE SERVICES AND OTHER INDUSTRIAL USERS. THE PROJECT HAS AN EXISTING OPERATING FACILITY AND HAS BEEN IN OPERATION FOR SEVERAL YEARS. THE CURRENT USE IS CLASSIFIED INDUSTRIAL UNDER LAND USE MAP ZONE IG, GENERAL INDUSTRIAL. MUNICIPAL CODE SECTION 18.5 4.010. THE USE PERMIT IS REQUIRED FOR HEAVY MANUFACTURING ACTIVITIES. ESTABLISHMENTS ENGAGED IN THE PRIMARY PRODUCTION OF METALS OR CHEMICAL PRODUCTS THROUGH RAW MATERIALS. PMC SECTION 15.5 4.100, DESIGN REVIEW IS ALSO REQUIRED FOR NEW CONSTRUCTION. ALSO UNDER THE SAME DMC CODE, A VARIANCE APPLICATION IS REQUIRED TO ALLOW 137 FOOT TALL TOWER WHERE A 75 FOOT MAXIMUM IS ALLOWED IN THE IG ZONE. THESE REVIEWS ARE IN RELATION TO THE EXISTING LINDE PLANT. THE INITIAL STUDY MITIGATES A NEGATIVE DECLARATION CONCLUDED THE PROJECT WOULD HAVE LESS THAN SIGNIFICANT IMPACTS WITH MITIGATIONS, AND THIS WAS SETTLED FOR PUBLIC COMMENT ON OCTOBER OF 2023. THE PROJECT IS REQUIRED TO COMPLY WITH AND RECEIVE PERMIT COVERAGE UNDER THE EAST CONTRA COSTA COUNTY HABITAT CONSERVATION PLAN, ECP FOR SHORT, AND THAT NATURAL COMMUNITY CONSERVATION PLAN, AND CCP, AND THEREFORE, A QUALIFIED BIOLOGICAL CONSULTANT FIRM WAS RETAINED TO PREPARE A PLANNING SURVEY REPORT KNOWN AS APS ARE WITH ACTION PLANS INCLUDING AVOIDING DOWNSTREAM HYDRAULIC EFFECTS THROUGH IMPLEMENTATION A STONE WATER MANAGEMENT TREATMENT CONTROLS, IMPLEMENTING MEASURES DESCRIBED IN THE ACP TO AVOID IN MINIMIZE IMPACTS TO WETLANDS AND STREAMS, WETLAND AREA AND WOODLAND SCRUB. THE IMAGE ON THE LEFT SHOWS THE LAYOUT. THE 3-D RENDITION SHOWS A REALISTIC SIMULATION OF THE PLANT , FILLING THREE TRUCKS. ACCORDING TO THE PROJECT NARRATIVE PROVIDED BY LINDE, THIS IS ONE OF THE CLEANEST PROCESSES IN HEAVY INDUSTRIAL ZONES. IN THE PROCESS, WE USE PHYSICAL CHEMISTRY TO SEPARATE THE THREE MAIN COMPONENTS 04:48:31:00OF AIR, NITROGEN, WHICH IS 78% OF AIR OXYGEN, WHICH IS 21% AND ARGON, WHICH IS 1%. BY KILLING THEM DOWN TO CRYOGENIC TEMPERATURES WHERE THE CHANGE FROM GAS TO LIQUID PHASES OCCURS. THERE IS NO COMBUSTION, CHEMICAL REACTIONS, ADDITIONAL INGREDIENTS ARE ADDED MATERIALS NEEDED TO SEPARATE THE GASES INTO THEIR PURE, ELEMENTAL FORMS. EACH PLANT CONSISTS OF THE FOLLOWING EQUIPMENT. ALL OUTDOORS. TWO MAIN AIR COMPRESSORS, TWO PURIFIER VESSELS, WHICH REMOVE MOISTURE, CARBON DIOXIDE AND OTHER GASES AND AIR, AND RETURN THEM BACK TO THE AIR. AN INDUSTRIAL CLASS CHILLER TO PRECOOL THE AIR, ONE LARGE DISTILLATION TOWER CONTAINING HEATED EXCHANGES, BOOSTER COMPRESSES --COMPRESSES, TURBINE SETS AND CRYOGENIC COLUMNS. THREE INDIVIDUAL SETS OF STORAGE TANKS FOR THE THREE PRODUCTS, INTERCONNECTING PIPES AND INSTRUMENTS INVOLVING COOLING TOWER ASSOCIATED PIPING AND HEAT EXCHANGE TO REMOVE HEAT FROM THE COMPRESSORS. THE PROJECT APPLICANT AND HIS TEAM ARE ALSO AVAILABLE TO FURTHER DISCUSS ANY FURTHER EXISTING PLANT OPERATIONS. PMC 18.5 4.120, AN INCREASE OVER THE MAXIMUM HEIGHT ALLOWANCE IS ALLOWED IN THE IL AND IG DISTRICT EQUAL TO THE NUMBER OF ADDITIONAL FEET THE STRUCTURE IS SET BACK FROM EACH PROPERTY LINE BEYOND THE MINIMUM YARD REQUIREMENTS UP TO A MAXIMUM OF 75 FEET. THE PROJECT APPLICANT IS REQUESTING A VARIANCE TO EXCEED THE PERMITTED HEIGHT LIMIT OF 75 FEET. BECAUSE OF SPECIAL CIRCUMSTANCES CONCERNING THE SUBJECT PROPERTY INCLUDING SIZE, SHAPE, TOPOGRAPHY, LOCATION AND SURROUNDINGS, STRICT APPLICATION OF THE ZONING REGULATION DEPRIVES THE PROPERTY OF PRIVILEGES ENJOYED BY OTHER PROPERTIES IN THE VICINITY IN THE SAME LAND HUGHES DISTRICT SINCE THE PROPOSED PROJECT IS AN EXTENSION OF AN EXISTING AIR SEPARATION PLANT WITH A SIMILAR TOWER FOR VENTING AND SEPARATING ESSENTIAL INDUSTRIAL AND COMMERCIAL GASES. FURTHER, THE PROJECT EXPANSION AREA IS IN APPROXIMATELY 2.5 ACRE PORTION OF A LARGER PARCEL THAT ENABLES ADEQUATE SETBACK OF MORE THAN TWO TO ONE SETBACK IN HEIGHT RATIO WITH THE PROPOSED 137 FOOT TALL RECTIFICATION CODE BOX. TOWER, WHICH IS FROM THE PROPERTY BOUNDARY. THE SITE IS RELATIVELY FLAT WITH LIMITED VEGETATION ON THE SIDE FRINGES, AND SOME WETLAND AT LIMITED EXTENT OF THE DEVELOPMENT FOOTPRINT OF THE SITE. THIS CONSTRAINS THE HORIZONTAL ORIENTATION OF THE PLANT EQUIPMENT, FORCING THEM TO BE MORE VERTICALLY STEPPED TO AVOID IMPACT ON THE WETLAND AND VEGETATION. THERE ARE SIMILAR TOWERS WITH HEIGHTS IN EXCESS OF 75 FEET AT THAT PLANT AND OTHER MANUFACTURING PLANTS AT THE IG ZONE IN THE PROJECT VICINITY AND THEREFORE, GRANTING THE HEIGHT VARIANCE WILL NOT CONSTITUTE A GRANT A SPECIAL PRIVILEGE, WHICH IS NOT GENERALLY AVAILABLE TO OTHER PROPERTY IN THE VICINITY. THE PROJECT IS REQUIRED TO COMPLY AND RECEIVE PERMIT COVERAGE OF THE CONTRA COSTA COUNTY HABITAT CONSERVATION PLAN, THE NATURAL COMMUNITY CONSERVATION PLAN AND THEREFORE A QUALIFIED BIOLOGICAL CONSULTANT FIRM WAS RETAINED TO PREPARE A SURVEY REPORT. MITIGATION MEASURES ADDRESS THE CONCERNS OF SPECIES. THE PROJECT APPLICANT HAS AGREED TO DISSIPATE IN THE PLAN AND IMPLEMENT MITIGATION MEASURES AS IDENTIFIED IN THE MITIGATION REPORTING PROGRAM TO ENSURE COMPLIANCE WITH THE PLANT. STAFF HAS RECEIVED COMMENTS FROM CALTRANS, DEPARTMENT OF TOXIC SUBSTANCE CONTROL, DTS C, AND HAS ADDRESSED ALL OF THOSE COMMENTS. ALSO, STAFF HAS RECEIVED TWO, LETTERS . BOTH WERE RECEIVED A FEW HOURS PRIOR TO HEARINGS. STAFF HAS EXHAUSTIVELY REVIEWED BOTH LETTERS AND ADDRESSED ALL THE ISSUES RAISED. CONCERNING THE COMMENTS FROM DTS C , STAFF HAS SUMMARIZED THEM BELOW. NUMBER ONE, ADDITIONAL INVESTIGATION AND SAMPLING OF SOIL IF NECESSARY SHOULD OCCUR BEFORE ANY GROUNDBREAKING ACTIVITIES COMMENCE. THE OTHER RECOMMENDATION DTSC MADE WAS IN CASE OF UNFORESEEN CONTAMINATIONS ARE DISCOVERED SHOULD ALSO BE UNDERTAKEN AND THEN FINALLY, IF THERE IS ANY IMPORTATION OF SOIL FROM SOMEWHERE ELSE, THERE SHOULD BE PROPER SAMPLING TO ENSURE THAT THE IMPORTED SOIL IS FREE FROM CONTAMINATION. STAFF'S RESPONSE TO THAT IS THAT THESE RECOMMENDATIONS HAVE BEEN INCLUDED AS CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL FOR THE PROJECT. WITH REGARD TO CALTRANS COMMENTS, THE FIRST COMMENT THEY MADE WAS THAT IF CALTRANS FACILITIES ARE IMPACTED BY THE PROJECT, THEY MUST MEET A.D.A. STANDARDS AS WELL AS MAINTAIN BICYCLE AND PEDESTRIAN ACCESS DURING CONSTRUCTION TO PROVIDE SAFE, SUSTAINABLE AND EQUITABLE TRANSPORTATION NETWORK FOR ALL USERS. THE OTHER COMMENT OR RECOMMENDATION FROM CALTRANS IS THAT ANY WORK OR TRAFFIC CONTROL THAT ENCROACHES ONTO CALTRANS' RIGHT-OF-WAY REQUIRES AN ENCROACHMENT PERMIT. STAFF'S RESPONSE AGAIN IS THAT ALTHOUGH THE PROJECT SITE IS NOT DIRECTLY ADJACENT TO STATE ROUTE HIGHWAY 4, THESE RECOMMENDATIONS HAVE BEEN INCLUDED AS CONDITIONS FOR APPROVAL TO ADDRESS THESE COMMENTS. ONTO THE COMMENTS RECEIVED FROM, STAFF HAS SUMMARIZED THEM BEFORE BELOW. ON DECEMBER 12, 2023, STAFF RECEIVED A LETTER FROM ADAMS SPIRAL, JOSEPH MENDOZA AND THEY MADE SEVERAL COMMENTS AND SO SOME KEY COMMAS HAVE BEEN COLD FROM THOSE COMMENTS AND QUOTED BELOW, SO THE FIRST ONE, STAFF IS HIGHLIGHTING THAT SUBSTANTIAL EVIDENCE SUPPORTS A FAIR ARGUMENT THAT THE PROJECT MAY RESULT IN SIGNIFICANT UNMITIGATED IMPACTS TO AIR QUALITY, HAZARDS, BIOLOGICAL RESOURCES. THE CITY MUST REPAIR --PREPARE AN ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT REPORT TO ANALYZE THIS, DISCLOSE AND MITIGATE THESE IMPACTS THAT ARE --AND DISCLOSE A LESS ENVIRONMENTALLY DAMAGING ALTERNATIVE. STAFF HAS PROVIDED COMMENTS WITH AN ANALYSIS BY DR. FOX REGARDING THE ISM D PREPARED FOR THE SUBJECT PROPERTY. NO NEW ENVIRONMENTAL CONCERNS WERE RAISED THAT WERE NOT ORIGINALLY ADDRESSED IN THE INTEREST -- INITIAL STUDY. SPECIFIC RESPONSES HAVE BEEN PROVIDED TO EACH OF THE COMMENTS THEY RAISE IN THE STAFF REPORT SUPPORTING STAFF'S DETERMINATION THAT MITIGATION MEASURES PROPOSED FOR THE PROJECT ARE SUFFICIENT TO ADDRESS ALL POTENTIAL PROJECT IMPACTS. ANOTHER KEY COMMENT ADAMS BROADWELL JOSEPH AND CARDOZA HAVE MADE A SET PHASE ONE, WHICH IS THE ENVIRONMENTAL ASSESSMENT REPORT PROVIDES SUBSTANTIAL EVIDENCE SUPPORTING A FAIR ARGUMENT THAT THE PROJECT MAY CAUSE POTENTIAL SIGNIFICANT IMPACTS DUE TO DISTURBANCE OF CONTAMINATED SOILS OR OTHER HAZARDOUS CONDITIONS THAT MAY BE PRESENT AT THE PROJECT SITE. STAFF'S RESPONSE TO THAT IS THAT THE PHASE ONE REPORT IDENTIFIED RECOGNIZABLE ENVIRONMENTAL CONDITIONS WITHIN THE GREATER PARCEL, WHICH IS WHERE THE CURRENT PLAN IS, BUT THEY WERE NOT ASSISTED WITH DITCH DREDGING [ INAUDIBLE ] AND PAST REMOVALS OF GROUND STORY TANKS WHICH EVIDENCE SUGGESTS DID NOT OCCUR ON THE PROJECT SITE , AND PAGES 27 THROUGH 29 OF THE PHASE ONE REPORT SPEAKS TO THAT, SO THE DRAFT EXPLAINS THAT WHILE 2000 LOVERIDGE ROAD MAY BE LISTED AS HAVING PREVIOUS ENVIRONMENT CONCERNS, THEY DO NOT INVOLVE THE PROPOSED PROJECT SITE PORTION OF THE PROPERTY. THE SQUIRREL WAS ASKED TO GATE EXCAVATED IN 1983, TESTED AND LANDFILLED AND THUS, THEY ARE NOT CONSIDERED A SOURCE OF CONTAMINATION TO THIS PARTICULAR SITE. ANOTHER COMMENT FROM ADAMS BROADWELL WAS THAT THE ISMD FAILS TO ADEQUATELY DISCLOSE, ANALYZE AND MITIGATE POTENTIALLY SIGNIFICANT IMPACTS TO WETLANDS AND STAFF RESPONSE TO THAT IS THAT THE PROJECT'S ENVIRONMENTAL SETTING WAS ESTABLISHED THROUGH RECONNAISSANCE LEVEL SITE ASSESSMENT BY VOLLMAR NATURAL LANDS CONSULTING IN JUNE 2023. TO FURTHER ENSURE THAT THE PROJECT AVOIDS ALL WETLANDS AND AQUATIC FEATURES, MITIGATION MEASURE BIO-6 REQUIRES A SURVEY. IN RESPONSE TO THE COMMENT MITIGATION NUMBER AGAIN, BIO-6 HAS BEEN ENHANCED TO CONTAIN SPECIFICS PERFORMANCE STANDARDS AND IDENTIFY THE TYPES OF ACTIONS THAT MAY ACHIEVE COMPLIANCE WITH PERFORMANCE STANDARDS INCLUDING REDESIGN OF THE PROJECT SITE PLAN OR TEMPORARY STAGING AREAS INCLUDING WETLANDS, COMPENSATORY MITIGATION. ADAMS BROADWELL HAS ALSO SUBMITTED AN ADDITIONAL COMMENT LETTER TODAY. NO NEW INFORMATION WAS RAISED THAT HAS NOT BEEN ADDRESSED IN THE CURRENT STUDY MITIGATION AS WELL AS THE PROGRAM. STAFF RESPONDED TO SOME OF THE KEY ISSUES THEY RAISED. ALSO, CONSULTANT DAN JONES IS AVAILABLE TO ADDRESS IT FURTHER AFTER MY PRESENTATION. ONE OF THE COMMENTS THEY RAISED HAD TO DO WITH AMBIENT AIR QUALITY . THE BIG AREA AIR QUALITY MANAGEMENT DISTRICT, AND THE CALIFORNIA AIR --IS IT RESOURCE BOARD? YES. REVIEWED THE INITIAL STUDY, AND ISMD AND DID NOT CONCLUDE THAT THE REVIEW THAT THE PROJECT WOULD HAVE ANY SIGNIFICANT IMPACT ON AIR QUALITY AND DID NOT REQUIRE ANY ADDITIONAL MITIGATION MEASURES. THE OTHER ISSUE THEY RAISE IN TODAY'S LETTERS ON-SITE ACUTE HEALTH EXPOSURES. THE APPLICANT OPERATES WITHIN THE CURRENT STANDARDS FOR OCCUPATIONAL SAFETY AND HEALTH ADMINISTRATION KNOWN AS OSHA, AND THE HEALTH RISK ASSESSMENT WAS ALSO PREPARED FOR THE PROJECT, AND REVIEWED BY THE REGULATORY AGENCIES WITH NO SPECIFIC CONCERNS RAISED. AGAIN, AS PREVIOUSLY DISCUSSED, ENVIRONMENTAL ANALYSIS PREPARED FOR THE PROJECT CONCLUDED THAT THERE WOULD NOT BE ANY SIGNIFICANT ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACTS OVER INDUCTION AND IMPLEMENTATION OF MITIGATION MONITORING AND REPORTING PROGRAM ENCLOSED AS EXHIBIT B TO THE STAFF REPORT. THE PROJECT IS NOT IN ISOLATION OF ITS SURROUNDINGS. RATHER IT IS AT AN EXISTING AIR SEPARATION PLANT WITH SIMILAR TOWERS FOR VENTING AND SEPARATING ESSENTIAL INDUSTRIAL AND COMMERCIAL GASES. THERE ARE SIMILAR TALL TOWERS AT THE LINDE PLANT AND SURROUNDINGS. THE HEIGHT VARIANCE ALLOWS THE PLANT TO INSTALL AN IMPORTANT TOWER ESSENTIALLY FOR OPERATIONS AND SIMILAR TO OTHER TOWERS IN THE VICINITY. THE PROPOSED PROJECT WOULD BE CONSISTENT WITH THE CITY ZONING ORDINANCE AND THE SITE BY EXPANDING EXISTING HEAVY MANUFACTURING OPERATION FOR THE AIR SEPARATION PLANT ALSO, THE PROPOSED EXPANSION PROMOTES AN ORDERLY DEVELOPMENT OF THE AREA BY UTILIZING A VACANT PORTION OF THE EXISTING PLANT SITE IS ZONED FOR INDUSTRIAL USE. THE PROJECT COMPLIES WITH ALL APPLICABLE USE DESIGN AND VARIANCE CRITERIA AS DETAILED IN THE STAFF REPORT, AND THE RESOLUTION. FINALLY IN CONCLUSION, STAFF IS RECOMMENDING THAT THE PLANNING COMMISSION MOVED TO ADOPT A RESOLUTION APPROVING THE USE PERMIT DESIGN REVIEW AND VARIANCE APPLICATION NUMBER 23-0046 SUBJECT TO CONDITIONS IN THE INITIAL STUDY, MITIGATED NEGATIVE DECLARATION AND MITIGATION MONITORING REPORTING PROGRAM. STAFF AND THE CONSULTANT ARE AVAILABLE TO ANSWER ANY QUESTIONS YOU MAY HAVE. THE APPLICANT IS ALSO HERE AND AVAILABLE TO PROVIDE ANY CLARIFICATION THAT MAY BE NEEDED. THANK YOU. >> THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR THE PRESENTATION. ARE THERE ANY FACTUAL QUESTIONS FROM THE COMMISSION FOR STAFF? COMMISSIONER ROBINSON. >> SO, FOR THE 2.5 ACRE PARCEL OR PORTION ON THE SITE THAT WE ARE LOOKING AT, IS THERE A PREVIOUS USE? WAS THIS A PREVIOUSLY DISTURBED SITE, OR HAS IT JUST BEEN UNTOUCHED FOR THE LAST HOWEVER MANY YEARS? >> [ INAUDIBLE ] HAS THERE BEEN A PREVIOUS USE ON THAT PIECE OF THE PARCEL? >> THROUGH THE CHAIR, THERE HAS NOT BEEN. THIS HAS BEEN UNTOUCHED. THIS SITE HAS BEEN UNDEVELOPED. >> OKAY. >> I HAVE ONE QUESTION FOR STAFF. THE ADDITIONAL COMMENTS WE RECEIVED TODAY WITH QUESTIONS, CAN YOU SUMMARIZE FOR THE PUBLIC HOW DIFFERENT THEY ARE FROM WHAT WE HAVE SEEN PREVIOUSLY, AND ADDRESSED? >> THROUGH THE CHAIR, I'M GOING TO BRIEFLY SUMMARIZE. IF WE GO BACK TO THE PRESENTATION IN REGARDS TO DISCUSSIONS REGARDING AMBIENT AIR QUALITY AND SOME OF THE ISSUES IN REGARD TO GREENHOUSE GASES AND AIR CONTAMINANTS, THOSE WERE ALREADY DISCUSSED AND ANALYZED PREVIOUSLY IN THE INITIAL STUDY. AND WHAT WE DID WAS COMPARE BOTH AND DETERMINED THAT THIS PROJECT IN THE LETTER THAT WAS RECEIVED TODAY IN THE INITIAL STUDY THAT WE PREPARED COVERED ALL OF THAT, SO WE DID NOT HAVE ANY CONCERNS BEFORE BRINGING THIS TO THE PLANNING COMMISSION TONIGHT. >> THANK YOU. IN ANY OTHER QUESTIONS FROM THE COMMISSION? COMMISSIONER FOSTER. >> GOOD EVENING. I'M TRYING TO REMEMBER WHEN I VISITED THE PLANT, WHAT IS THE SIZE OF THE BUFFER AREA? BETWEEN THE HIGHWAY IN THE NEXT NEIGHBORING PROPERTY, AND WHAT IS IN THE BUFFER AREA? >> MAURICE, IS YOUR MICROPHONE ON? >> SORRY ABOUT THAT. BASED UPON THE SITE PLAN, THERE IS A SETBACK BETWEEN THE HIGHWAY IN THE FOOTPRINT OF THE PROPOSED PROJECT OF AROUND 2300 FEET. >> WHAT IS IN THAT BUFFER? >> MOSTLY, SOME VEGETATION FOR THE MOST PART AND IN CERTAIN AREAS ARE ACTUALLY A LITTLE AARON, NOT MUCH OF ANY VEGETATION IN THOSE AREAS. THERE IS A WETLAND, AS WE ALL KNOW, AND THAT GOES ALONG A CERTAIN PORTION , SO THAT IS ALSO ANOTHER FEATURE WITHIN THAT BUFFER AREA. >> AM ALSO TRYING TO RECALL IN THIS FOLLOW-UP QUESTION, WAS THERE A BIOLOGICAL STUDY ON WILDLIFE ANYMORE THERE? >> YES. THE PSR THAT WAS CONDUCTED LOOKED AT ALL OF THE WILDLIFE, BOTH FLORA AND FAUNA, AND BASICALLY ADDRESSED THOSE IN THE MITIGATION MEASURES AS WELL AS MITIGATION MONITORING. >> DID THEY CHECK INSECTS LIKE NESTING BEES? >> I DON'T RECALL INSECTS SPECIFICALLY, BUT I THINK THEY DO HAVE PARTICULAR SPECIES THAT THEY LOOK OUT FOR, SO IF IT IS NOT ON THEIR ENDANGERED LIST OR PROTECTED SPECIES, I'M NOT SURE IF THEY'RE GOING TO TEST FOR ANY INSECT AT ALL. >> THANK YOU. >> THANK YOU. COMMISSIONER SMITH. >> THANK YOU FOR A VERY THOROUGH PRESENTATION. I APPRECIATE THAT. I PROBABLY HAVE SOME QUESTIONS HERE FOR OUR APPLICANT, BUT MAYBE THIS IS PART OF WHAT WE HAVE ALREADY UNCOVERED AND DISCOVERED. SO, TO FOLLOW UP COMMISSIONER FOSTER WITH THE TREES, WE HAVE NOT GONE TO TREES, BUT IF I CAN REMEMBER, THIS SITE, IT WAS MUDDY THAT DAY. WE HAD OUR BOOTS ON BUT THERE REALLY IS NOT ANYTHING --IT IS JUST A FIELD WITH SOME GRASS IN IT. HAS IT BEEN LOOKED AT TO POSSIBLY PUT SOME TREES ALONG THERE? NOT ONLY WOULD THAT ADD TO BEAUTIFYING THE AREA ALONG THE HIGHWAY IN THAT INDUSTRIAL AREA, BUT MAYBE WORK FOR NOISE POLLUTION. THAT IS ONE THING I DID HEAR A LOT OF NOISE THERE, AND SO THAT IS ONE QUESTION. THE VEGETATION THAT COULD BE PLANTED AROUND THAT AREA AND LOOKING AT THE SAME SLIDE YOU HAVE UP HERE, AND WONDER IF THAT WOULDN'T EVEN BE A GOOD IDEA IF WE DID THAT AND THE OTHER THING IS, IT CAME UP AND IS MENTIONED ABOUT THE ACCESS FOR BICYCLES AND PEDESTRIANS ON THE STREET. THAT AREA RIGHT THERE ALONG LOVERIDGE FIRST OF ALL IT'S REALLY HARD FOR ME TO EVEN FIND THE ENTRANCE TO IT, BUT IT LOOKS LIKE IT HAS NEVER BEEN FULLY DEVELOPED AS FAR AS THE SIDEWALK AND YOU KNOW, THE BOUNDARIES OF WHERE THE STREET ENDS IN THE GRAVEL ON THE SIDE, AND IS THE CITY -- DO WE HAVE ANY PLANS TO DO ANYTHING ABOUT THAT, TO MAKE THAT A LOT MORE ACCESSIBLE AND ALSO FOR ANYBODY WHO MAY BE WALKING THROUGH THERE? I DON'T KNOW WHERE THEY WOULD WALK THROUGH THEIR PAY THEY WOULD BE WALKING THROUGH THE GRAVEL AND THERE IS NO SIDEWALK THERE, IS THERE? >> THERE IS A SIDEWALK ALL THE WAY UP TO THE MAIN ENTRANCE WHERE THE TRUCKS GO IN BUT BEYOND THAT -- >> THERE'S NOTHING. RIGHT. >> WE ALSO HAVE A CONDITION OF APPROVAL WHERE THERE WOULD BE A LANDSCAPING BUFFER AROUND THE SITE AS PART OF THIS PROJECT. >> GOOD, BUT NOTHING SO FAR AS THE STREET IN EXCESS AND -- >> NOT THAT I KNOW OF, BUT I WILL DEFER THAT . >> THROUGH THE CHAIR, THERE IS NO SPECIFIC CONDITION FOR THAT. WHEN WE DID REVIEW THIS PROJECT WE DID REVIEW IT AS BEING A PROJECT THAT WAS ON SITE WITH THE 2.5 ACRES, MAKING SURE THEY COMPLY WITH OUR PITTSBURG MUNICIPAL CODE, THE GENERAL PLAN, AND THE MITIGATION MEASURES THAT WERE PREPARED FOR THE PROJECT, JUST TO ENSURE THAT WE COMPLY WITH CEQA AND MAKING SURE WE CAN ADDRESS ANY OF THE CONCERNS THAT WERE RAISED PREVIOUSLY IN ALL THE LETTERS IN THE INITIAL STUDY. WHAT WE DID WAS REALLY DO AN EXHAUSTIVE RESEARCH TO MAKE SURE THAT THE QUESTIONS YOU ARE ASKING IN REGARDS TO LANDSCAPING, TREES, IN REGARDS TO THE SITE ITSELF, THAT WAS ANALYZED AND PREPARED AND PUT INTO THE CONDITIONS THAT WERE APPROVED FOR THE PROJECT. >> THANK YOU. >> I WANT TO ASK WHEN CLARIFYING QUESTION. AT THIS POINT, THEY CANNOT BE CONDITIONED FURTHER THAT THERE IS DEVELOPMENT FOR THE SIDEWALK? FOR GRANTING THE PERMITS AND THE VARIANCE FOR THE PROJECT? >> THAT WOULD HAVE TO BE ESTABLISHED AS SOME SORT OF OFF-SITE IMPROVEMENT FOR NEXUS AND I DON'T SEE THAT HERE, SO I DON'T WANT TO OVERSTEP WHAT IS IN THE PITTSBURG MUNICIPAL CODE IN REGARDS TO CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL AND THE APPLICANT SO WOULD BE BETTER TO ANSWER THAT QUESTION BUT I DON'T WANT TO OVERSTEP WHAT WE HAVE HERE TONIGHT. >> THANK YOU FOR THE PRESENTATION. MY QUESTION IS REGARDING AIR QUALITY. WILL THERE BE A CONTINUAL MONITORING OF AIR QUALITY HERE AND THERE JUST TO MAKE SURE EVERYTHING IS MAINTAINED? >> THROUGH THE CHAIR I'M GOING TO ALLOW FOR OUR CONSULTANT TO ADDRESS THAT, THANK YOU. >> THANK YOU. >> YOU, THERE IS NO AIR QUALITY MONITORS AS THE OPERATION, THE AIR SEPARATION PROCESS DOES NOT EMIT ANY OPERATIONAL EMISSIONS. >> THANK YOU. >> THANKS FOR CLARIFYING. COMMISSIONER FOSTER. >> YES. AS A FORMER RESPONDER TO EMERGENCY MANAGEMENT AND BEING IN AN EMERGENCY OPERATIONS CENTER, I KNOW A LOT OF FACILITIES LIKE THIS HAVE AN EMERGENCY PLAN JUST IN CASE THERE ARE LEAKS, SO IS THERE ONE IN PLACE? >> I BELIEVE THE APPLICANT WOULD BE BETTER POSITIONED TO ANSWER THAT QUESTION, BUT I WOULD ASSUME AS AN INDUSTRY REGULATED BY OSHA, THERE HAS TO BE AN EMERGENCY PLAN IN PLACE. >> THANK YOU. >> THANK YOU SO MUCH. >> VICE-CHAIR KOBATA. >> IN REGARDS TO THE EMERGENCY PLAN, WOULD THAT BE INCLUDING A NOTIFICATION OF THE RESIDENCE AROUND THE AREA? >> PERHAPS THE APPLICANT CAN STEP FORWARD AND TELL US A LITTLE BIT ABOUT THE EMERGENCY PLAN IN PLACE. >> THANK YOU. I DO NOT SEE ANY OTHER QUESTIONS FROM THE COMMISSION IN THE QUEUE SO I WOULD LIKE TO GO AHEAD AND OPEN THE HEARING AND INVITE THE APPLICANT TO COME FORWARD. >> THERE WE GO. THANK YOU VERY MUCH, PLANNING COMMISSION, FOR YOUR TIME THIS EVENING AND FOR YOUR CONSIDERATION OF OUR PROPOSAL. MY NAME IS CHRISTIAN LUNCH. I'M THE DIRECTOR OF CAPITAL, FOR LINDE. I WAS BORN IN OAKLAND. I GRADUATED IN MECHANICAL ENGINEERING AND WAS RAISED HERE IN THE BAY AREA AND I'VE BEEN WITH LINDE FOR 30 YEARS AND AM A SUBJECT MATTER EXPERT IN THE AREA AND IT'S A PLEASURE TO BE ABLE TO ADDRESS YOU THIS EVENING. DURING THIS MEETING THE COMMISSION WILL BE DISCUSSING APPROVAL OF LINDE'S PROJECT, OAK STONE, WHICH IS A SECOND AIR SEPARATION PLANT NEXT TO OUR EXISTING UNIT. I RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR YOUR CONSIDERATION AND APPROVA

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
Agenda packetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Action agendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Transcript or captionsSource recordingread transcript
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Coverage and corrections

Records considered

  • Planning Commission — Minutes
  • Planning Commission
  • Planning Commission — Closed Captions

Not claimed by this page

  • Verified meeting decisions with item-specific public-source evidence
  • Item-level plain-language summaries are not available; this page does not infer individual agenda items.
  • Item-linked, attributed deliberation
  • A source-grounded next meeting date
  • A plain-English overview is not available.
  • Official outcomes have not been published.
  • The available transcript has no reliable timestamps.
  • Transcript coverage is partial.
  • Speakers have not been reliably matched to public profiles.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.
  • An individual roll-call roster is not available.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: 3795b924e2ccab3929d813ed2a818ded. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record