POLISCOPE

The public record

STPETERSBURG (PINELLAS COUNTY) · LOCALHeld · official record pendingPartial coverage

City Council

Thursday, May 15, 2025 · Government meeting record

The 30-second read

Record incomplete

City Council

Why it matters

The official meeting record is available below. Item-level plain-language summaries are not available yet.

What happens next

The scheduled meeting date has passed. Minutes or an action agenda are not published in the records we hold.

This meeting date has passed and no official outcome record has been published yet. Nothing on this page is a decision.

Transcript and record text

Closed captionsWhat was said at the meeting, transcribed Aug 3, 2026. Speech is not a decision.
  • No speaker turns were supplied with this transcript.
  • This transcript has no source timestamps.
  • No speaker identities were supplied with this transcript.

This source published text without speaker turns, so speakers and timestamps are not shown.

The opening of 98,204 stored characters

>> Welcome to the city of St. Petersburg City Council meeting and your elected officials our mayor Ken Welch district one Council chair. Hopefully Curtis. District 2 Brendan Barber. Is to 3 Mike Harding district 4 Council vice chair, Liz said Hannah with us District 5. Deborah take Sanders. District 6 Gina Driscoll in district 7 warri Givens junior. And district day Richie Floyd. >> Good afternoon we're going to call to order the 5/15/2025 City Council meeting clerk could we please do roll call. Sanders Driscoll Ivins your floor. Curtis you're ever Artie and with us here. Okay today we will have our indication given by our very own councilmember Gina Driscoll and then please remain standing for the pledge of allegiance. >> Lord we stand here before you today full of thanks and praise for this beautiful day and for all that you have given to us here on Earth. We humbly ask for your blessing upon our city and its residents so that the same can continue to shine on all reflecting the inclusive light of your love that touches each and every one of us as we are all created by you. Today in these chambers guide our hearts and our minds in the spirit of fairness and cooperation as we conduct the business of our great city. In part your supreme wisdom upon or activities. So that we MAY serve you through our service to others and your name we pray Amen Amen. >> If the United States of America and that's what for which it stands one nation. I never got indivisible with liberty and justice for all we see it. >> Council member driskell thank you so much for that beautiful location. Okay council members we have an agenda in front of us alert a motion for approval can we have a motion and second scene is no other council members wishing to speak clerk could you please open the machine for voting. Council members please enter your votes. Seniors off PRESIDENT Council members have voted clerk please talent announce the vote MISTER Chair motion to approve the agenda passes unanimously with Council regarding absent. >> Okay. Now council members we have a consent agenda clerk do we have any comment on the consent agenda cars, MISTER Chair, okay, I'll entertain a motion for approval movements like we have a motion and a second on the consent agenda seeing is no other council members wishing to speak court could you permission for voting. Council members please and your votes seeing is all present council members voted clerk please tallying announce the vote MR. CHAIRMAN to approve the consent agenda passes unanimously with councilmember government. Ok thank you alright, we will now move into open forum clerk could you please read the rules you wish to address City Council on subjects other than public hearing a quasi-judicial items listed on the agenda. Police on alert. Only the individual wishing to speak makes on the open form she only city residents on his property. Business owners in the city or their employees MAY speak all issues discussed on open for must be limited to issues related to the city of St. Petersburg government. If you're speaking to an item on the agenda MAY only speak once during the open form when the item comes up on the agenda. Nor to provide an opportunity for all citizens to address Council. Each individual be given 3 minutes to speak and have to wish the market phone will be muted. If you MR. Addressed City Council to the zoom meeting, you must use the raise hand feature but in the app or interest are not on your phone at the time the agenda item is address. What is your turn to speak up unit next to state your name and address at the conclusion of the comments when you reach the 3 minute time limit you're muted. We all raise hands will be lowered after each agenda item regardless of the method of participation use normal rules apply including the 3 minute time limit on comments the requirement that unit presentation materials must be submitted in advance of the meeting and the rules of decorum if life of a comic. It's disrupted by violations of the rules of decorum the chair is authorized to accept public comment by alternate means including but you MAY only and we do not have any speakers chamber, no speakers. >> No speakers for open forum, then we will move right into f one resolution approving a reinstatement in second amendment to the agreement for art e l l c. We have so let's Davis. >> Yes thank you, thank you and afternoon good afternoon Celeste Davis director of arts culture and tourism. Thank you Council chaired artisan members of City Council I have a report on the extension cord request for us the sunshine city mosaic. So the timeline is Aug. 16th, the public arts Commission approved the selection of the sunshine city mosaic to be designed fabricated and installed by our autonomy which include Laura Spencer Alex Kaufman and George wrecked ish at sunset Park located at 7400 Central Avenue Saint Pete. On Apr. 12 City Council approved the $50,000 agreement with art me to install the sunshine city mosaic and there you can see how it fits into the park. On MAY 23th city pours the concrete sidewalk in preparation of the mosaic installation. On 12/20/2023. Art me ask for and was granted a 90 day extension to complete the work and submitted all required documents. On JUNE 10th Council approved an amendment to the agreement that extended the term of the agreement for an additional 8 months and 15 days. On Mar. 6 Council approved a second Amendment for completion by MAY 1st. Mar. 11th are Tommy notified the Department of arts culture and tourism that they cannot agree to the current completion timeline approved by City Council. They will need additional time to complete the sunshine city mosaic. Here I have just Come compressed timeline to show all of the actions that have been taken so far and to also show how we got to the MAY 15th request for the second amendment to the art me agreement. Here is a video. We'll show the process that art me is using to create the mosaic. I might ask the clerk for a little. Support how do I get the video. It was a time lapse that illustrated the process in the detail that was required to complete the mosaic. I have with me the members of our Tommy that will also talk about the process and the timeline. >> Good afternoon Council. My name is Laura Spencer an artist here in the city of Saint Pete born and raised and I am the designer and project manager for the sunshine city mosaic. >> I'm Alex Kaufman also an artist in St. Petersburg part of the team as well. Look when George Lucas 3rd member of the team here for the census shows so sunshine city sake. With the 3 of us we are so emerging artists I really love the city and have been working on this project since AUGUST of 2022. And has 3 emerging artist. We all work full-time jobs in the art sectors here in the city of Saint Pete, both George and Alex are employed at mgh sculpture studios, I'm a full-time freelance artist currently on leave from the mural project as we speak in fact so today we present our project to you for review and approval of our extension. As of right now we have one final section of the 172 foot long mosaic ready for assembly and ready for installation, starting JUNE 1st. This project comprises over 800 square feet and 15,000 individual pieces of tile so needless to say and has 3 emerging artist. It's a project that has been quite large in quite ambitious but we are so excited to share this love letter with the city of Saint Pete. At this time cherry we'd like to add for a. To address. The installation of the peace and to adjust the language in the agreement so that we will not have to come back again to have it reassess. Thank you. Thank you for this and bringing this item forward and thank you to the artists who have remained committed to this project. Bill what appears to be some some ups and downs. I know that often especially when you're in a larger project. It is you know difficulty anticipate. The time and also the challenges that MAY arise. Well I guess first. Could it could I ask why we why it's being requests it we defer this item. The agreement states that by MAY 15th all sections have to be completed. But after. Looking that that just cannot happen by the 15th. There's a section that has to be completed on site. There is so in the 3 minutes into parts is a section that has to be all sections have to be completed. And then the second part is for installation. The agreement has been signed but as we went over it there are some tiles that need to be actually installed on site. >> Trying to figure out because we've got this today and. I'm just a little confused because usually when an item is deferred that spread out before the City Council meeting starts. And it's discussed so I might be missing something. I decided to keep this item on the agenda of being in my district and wanting the update and to frankly I I wanted to hear the report and share some of my frustration. And that's why I kept on councilmember so I'm sorry okay to be no I and thank you Sir I think that's fair. So now that per makes sense. The other question I have actually is for the artists if we could have them come back First thanks for all you do. In your incredible contributions too our city through your work. You know big fan. Thank you so much we really appreciate that yeah and this is these are a lot it's a lot of extensions and so I just wanted to give you the opportunity to share whatever you'd like about what has brought us to this point. Absolutely so. This project is a combination of all of our collective time as well as the exclusive use of a very specific piece of equipment and that equipment equipment is a water jet which is owned by mg a sculpture studio so to give you a little background on the project were designing this large-scale mosaic those pieces are then sent to the water jet and specifically cut out of the tile you can imagine this similar to working on a stain glass project that being said this water to is owned by mj sculpture studios and so our access is limited to after mj's work hours and as long as the equipment is functional. In our very extensive timeline that is in our spec pack you can see there are some grade out dates and those dates or when the water just simply was down when and Ga wasn't cutting and we weren't able to cut as well so that put significant hindrance on the process and then of course are 2 Hurricanes. Cause quite a bit of ruckus all 3 of us had intense individual needs to help our families recover as well. Do you want to speak a little bit more to the Alex. >> You We do also understand that every time we asked for an extension it is asking for a lot and. I think truly we were. Optimistic with the timeline if we just push a little harder and a little faster. The reality we're very close for practically done with it now very minimal left. >> So you 15,000 pieces just it happens to be a lot and because this is you know a big project for us and it's in the city we live in we definitely want to promote it as well as we can just didn't want to skimp who quality know time is where you have to pull from because you know it's very specialty process we developed this process from scratch. I reached out to a lot of you know other public art mosaic people that do this and no one does it like this so. You know like you alluded to before there's ups and downs with the projects and and you know. We we wanted to get it done and we wanted to be the best quality possible. And that is that is what we're bringing and. >> Another thing to note is. We are at least the 2 of us like Laura mentioned before employed full time at the sculpture studio. We're putting anywhere from 40 to 60 hours a week. Into the studios projects and then somehow managed to do and additional 1020 30 hours. Week on the mosaic throughout the course of the last year to year and a half we've been diligently moving forward on the project and like Alex alluded to just previously we are basically in 98% cut assembled and ready for an still that's less than 2 to 2 just before as well with the stipulation of the on site installation because of the length of the sidewalk and the scope of the project. Needing to get everything done and ready beforehand and get it all ready for install. >> Basically all of it except for 2 tiny little slivers. So when the previous. Agreement amendment came back to us early MAY think was when and we saw that MAY 15th. Deadline to wrap the fabrication portion of the project. We knew we would be really close. But we felt like week just quite couldn't hit it. So then when we spoke some more it came up to have the fabrication. Completed and ready for installed by MAY 3rd. She MAY 31th. And then with the installation to be fully complete belied by JULY 31th. The 3 of us feel very strongly that that's a 100% doable we're basically ready to begin install now. There is likely mentioned. The sidewalk as the 2 long portions and then little center medallion and just by the nature of the mosaic process and the length of everything we have to leave out just a very small sections on either side of the center medallion. So that we can physically lay all of the rest of the tile including the center and then based on as Bill real dimensions once everything's in place have a handful of pieces to cut. Afterwards so we can make sure everything fits correctly there's no way all open ears if we can you know have a different way to install those last portions but you know over the length of you know say 90 feet or so on either side. Small you know small adjustments I would just be impossible to to to predict ahead of time so we need to lay. 99% of the peace in place and then take some measurements based on the gaps that exist so that the remaining pieces and get all that squared away so again we all feel very strongly by JULY 31th, which is the most recent agreement that that's a 100% doable the main stipulation was the MAY 15th thing that that was the reason we were not able to sign. The most recent agreement move. >> Okay thing get your detailed explanation gives us an inside look at just how complicated a project like this is and I applaud you for really stretching yourselves as art is to do something that's a little different. I understand that when you have that piece of equipment that water jet. I get that cause. Mark means it to you now and. Well Disney once said that anything that's doing anything worth doing is worth doing well. Sometimes that takes more time than what you planned. And so. You know I I support this because I do understand the reality of the project in the challenges that it that it can pose. At the same time, I'm really anxious to celebrate this. The complaint. >> And I mean I look forward to that. I do wonder because we're getting in the summer we're getting into rainy season. And so I do wonder if there's some merit to looking at this to ensure that this is the last extension. How do you feel about. If we were to approve this today. How confident do you feel about completion by that date. Given you know the given mother nature's going to do what she wants to do. There sure given our Florida whether we have definitely consider this heavily and the 3 of us have already discussed our installation process. The installation process we should be laying all the fence at tile all 64 sections within set in place and then we will have 2 teams of grounders come in and help to ground the mosaic as we're going so simultaneously we will be laying then grounding, we'll lay that center section before we're even done grounding. Alex will have already cut these pieces that we need to play since it too. So the entire project should be moving in a flawless manner over the course of a 3 to 5 weeks so ideally we think we should have it wrapped up in about 5 weeks. But that's why the Jenner's extension to JULY 31th is helpful to us because again if it rains that puts a damper quite literally on our ability to install it and currently in place right you have to consider this is similar to any sort of construction project if you were to lay tile in your backyard or in your home is contingents on the weather and the surface preparation so the sidewalk is ready and good to go we just need to make sure we don't get hit with one of those 5 o'clock torrential Florida. Downpours as it were right, right, and it is all of the water jet were completed at this point or. But what we need to wait until. So we have one final section that is in the process of being cut right now we've divided up the entire project into 9 different sections we are on our 9th center medallion section right now this is being cut as we speak and by the end by the MAY 31th we will have it all assembled and ready for installation JUNE 1st okay, okay, so there's no issue with that part of this point of view they confirmed she is there's a look at us traffic issue that's again something that that knock on wood as much as we can but we are full steam ahead George is actually the kind of a mechanic of the water jet so that his baby in for a try. It's the heavy cross to bear that he has to carry but she's in good shape. She's per in and we're in a good spot for cutting so I feel we feel fairly confident that we'll be able to hit our JULY 31th deadline 100%. Okay, that's that's great to hear and thank given given this site I don't really see a need for deferral but I'm interested in hearing what my colleagues and to say thank you chair. Yeah, you're welcome I it's my understanding that if we reinstate this agreement as of today they would be in the fall of the agreement because they have to be gun installation as of today. That's why they need to change the date. They need to change the need to amend the original agreement to bring the installation dates back to us because otherwise they'd have to leave here and go start installation and finished That's that's why. I got a recommendation was to different hadn't thought of that yet art yeah, the completion date in the room and the reinstated agreement is what they want the problem is is if we gave them this along with the reinstatement. They'd be in the fall as of today exactly yeah. This gives that this gives administration the opportunity to bring the whole thing back to us with the new installation date along with the JULY 31th completion deadline. And in the meantime the world here and there's less urgent if I'm as. James corden see development administrator. Thank you for the opportunity to bring this before you. It's unfortunate that we were able to show the time lapse I think you all can probably appreciate the intricacy of did all the tiles I have to be cut and put into this. One other issue and I'm looking at councilmember and it was because you know within the contract is important. We want to modify the language as it relates to the MAY 31th date because as it states currently even in this restate and I apologize for the manner in which this came about I was this was brought to my attention today. Obviously this is not the way that we would like to do things but the way that under the design and fabrication is says that all pieces would be designed and fabricated by MAY 31th and we just heard that that is not the case so we need to reword the language to make it clear that all pieces with the exception of these a few pieces that have to be done. Once we're there on site and you know look at the as built condition. So I want to make sure that the language in the agreement reflects what actually will happen. As far as the completion date the JULY 31th we actually gave 30 days more then what we were told they felt like they need it so I think we're good there. But I as has been mentioned before we want to make sure one. The agreement re-examining like what's going to happen. But also that there we can eliminate or avoid any possibility of having to bring this back we we bring it back we wanted to be the final time in the last time we talked about it is we're all they're looking at it being revealed. So part of it is just we need to make the legal language match what's actually going to happen. All right, thank you mom. >> I'm just going to say. Whoever discover this or brought it up. Last minute is never fun and it is not fun for us because someone else's emergency becomes our emergency them are stacked with this. I'm also looking at if you're bringing it back our next City Council meeting is JUNE 5th. I wanted to make sure that that is going to allow for continuation of work. I'm going present its own challenge because that's a few weeks away. And what happens in. The meantime and that could be a question for the City Attorney's Office. Right now the current. Agreements that terminated by virtue of the term ending in JANUARY. Now performance is still continuing so the way that the caseload works on that is that we're still even though that agreement technically terminated so long as the parties continue to perform we're still under the same terms and conditions of that initial agreements. So there is as I understand the desire for that performance to continue I might think a subsequent amendment can be prepared that memorializes the party's intense for the deadline to be extended until. What the parties have agreed to between the city and our economy. And so that's what will be presented and JUNE and cops awaits the new term and understanding that the parties have been performing in the absence of an agreement between JANUARY and JUNE dates and so that we have contract documents that provide a totality of of terms for performance to date and through the underperformance I apologize if that was belated but please let me know that doesn't answer your question. Well I think I followed and I understand all right and thank you. This is us such a beautiful project. I mean I can't wait to see to see it when it's finished. So let's finish. Thank you chair, thank you councilmember figs Anders. Thank you thank you first of all thank you, Haitian and I think I am well first of all I'm really confused. Because I was reading the resolution and I'm trying to figure out. We had the green scheme of the project when we went into agreement the first time right nothing has been it. Now okay, so we knew a win for when we signed on with the original date right. Okay and then we extended 8 made another extension. There was a 90 great a 90 day extension within the original agreement that are Tommy exercised. Okay. So. And I keep hearing MAY 15th MAY 15 recess MAY 15th coming from. >> The MAY 15th date is in the because it's MAY 31th that we are posing been can you. Answer them a 15 day I I I can't speak to a MAY 15th dates the the operative date that I'm aware of it is MAY 31th, but I'm looking and I keep hearing MAY 15th. What is MAY 15. Okay because I kept looking out like I don't MAY 15th and what the relevance of MAY 15 kids. I think the artist might of reference MAY 15th is when they felt that they would complete section. >> Okay so talk to me about the $50,000. How is that working. Our Tommy has received $40,000 20,000 to initiate the agreement and then 20,000 once the design was finalized. So what's outstanding is $10,000. >> So I don't I don't mind grand teen the extension. First of all let me be clear with that. But what I what I do mind is the process. In that setting precedent so I hope that we remember this when other artists are other things come to play that will provide Greece we're going to have to if we are sidestepping our own documents. This is something to meeting and I'm not sure when we found out wait. What if they don't finish by JULY 31th. >> I it would be in the photo the agreement and part of what I'm proposing is as we make this change to the language related to the fabrication we want to make sure that we're completely cleared an agreement with the artists that the JULY 31th is the absolute latest if we feel like that needs to be adjusted to ensure that we eliminate the possibility of having to come back in as for another amendment. Then we I will take that in consideration, quite frankly with the comments that were made concerning rain and other things I think it would be prudent for us to go ahead and just that day before we come back because I want to prove another extension. I was that. >> So my thing use. I agree with the extension. Not a problem with that. And we've already pay money up front but we knew where we were in for I heard a lot of certainty uncertainty. We're borrowing the weather barring the rain excuse. If we've already added those possibilities and that date of JULY 31th guests. Yes, okay, so there will be no need for us to come back after JULY 31th. There should not be but I think that it would be wise for us to adjust to date before we come back to be on JULY 31th. The original date I think the the artist would agree that they were maybe a very optimistic on the fact that things will go all as planned and they maybe didn't anticipate the the the machinery not not working in other factors because it is such an involved process which is why. Yeah I think the video the Thomas video it really kind of help you understand how involved it is. But from the original agreement I think that. The artist believed that they would be able to meet that date clearly the it was a over the optimistic goal and my plan before we come back is to bring for something that can realistically be done with no additional extensions I would agree that I also have no desire to bring additional amendments to this and we would love to see the artwork complete. Ok so when you come back if when data you look into. Thank you pastor left 31th. We have a student. I don't want to just say something right now I'd like to talk through the artist to make sure that we account for any though is there a new stipulation and the date that we approve on. >> Bringing it back if it doesn't make it that they not get the remainder of the funds how does that work. Well they can only get the funds if they complete the project so the project is not completed they won't get the final payment. Okay. All right at I was just looking at all of the extensions and was just warning about the PRESIDENT's we're setting and I just want us to use remain mindful. That this is something that was saying a precedence about because I do understand changes things happen. Okay, thank you so much for that. Thank you chair and thank you vice chair of this. Thank you well I had the one like person that had pressed a button and then you said you're going to differ which was the right call. Because this isn't ready. And so one on ones with a pie been good on this for future reference to kind of give Council an idea of what's happening and that MAY have helped kind of clear up some of the questions you had here. I know I asked for the weekend had the contract from the get-go you guys to care that you provided us the contract so that way we we understand what's going on. But I do want to say to the Argus you can not wait till the last minute when there is a b in a contract. And you want to ask for extension you did not ask for a extension on its 60 days if it's 90 days, you don't do it and then it you just don't. Neither here nor anywhere whatever other contract, you're signing you just never do that because you cannot guarantee that you're going to get that extension. And you don't have time then to do the things you do so. It's it's wise to go back figure out exactly how much time you're gonna need including the contingency time and bring us an agreement that we can all agree on without any further extensions could you've had. Ample time to do this in the problem it you have it is when you asking for extensions after the fact. You lose the other party loses faith as to what's happening. And we want to have faith that you're going to get it done. And that's the problem there has to be communication and they're everyone has to be on the same page. So that's just my $0.2 I think we spoke enough about this. Thank you chair. Okay just quickly. First. >> Brought this to me and offered to totally take it off the agenda. I wanted to keep it and so please some of the confusion is definitely on the because I wanted the opportunity to hear this and to and to speak with the artist I did have a meeting set with them and then I ended up having a 103 fever and couldn't go. But part of part of this is certainly on me with some of the confusion and and differing so so please. Grant me some grace there. Because this this is an important project I think generally and very very specifically district one so any any any grace you're willing to give please please do. So I totally agree. With both councilmember Driscoll and councilmember handle it. This is this is an awesome project and I'm so pumped to have this and district one we do not have anything like this. And it drives me bonkers to drive by and see a bear. Sidewalk in the middle of a park knowing that we've been waiting for this and so I I know it drives you nuts too. And I know that things happen. But what I look at this time table and this was the frustrating part to me and I know there it just didn't seem like there was a whole lot of backup. For almost 3 and a half months were essentially no water jet could be usable venue out another month one month later. I know that everybody has different things and you know, but it's like team not available out of town. The like when you're when it's late that's very frustrating to me. That you have jobs. Trust me I get it I have to I I totally I understand it, but also I struggled this is back to Council or by sure Hannah what's you made a commitment. We have to stick to the commitments. This has been. This has been frustrating for me. Now I want to make sure that you can complete it, I'm super excited. There is nobody will be smiling larger than me when we reveal this thing. In district one and so please do not let my frustration. Downplay how excited I am and the work that you've done and it's beautiful and all of those things I would I would echo everything councilmember Driscoll said. Like we've got we have to be better than this. And so I hope I know I learned some lessons get. So I thank you let's get the dates right. I have full faith that we're going to put a new agreement in place. And let's let's get this thing done councilmember foot. Thank you something. Thank you chair something came to mind for me shirt. You know my colleagues have already expressed frustration and excitement. The one thing I'll say about that is mosaic some of my favorite art form so I'm excited a lot for that reason and I love the park, but it's going in. Yeah I have the same frustration want to see it get across the finish line. But actually wanted to bring up. And I'm probably going to a poor job of asking this because I can't remember the terminology but this was this is not a normal public arts project correct like there's uniqueness here and that it wasn't associated with a public works and it was specifically for local artists are my MISS Remembering. So it's my understanding that the committee wanted to use local artisan emerging artists. >> Okay and then what was the funding mechanism for it was associated with the public are in the public works better the funds came out and were taken from the public are 19 oh one the public arts fund. Yeah was associated with some specific public works project because that's often how it goes down. >> No nothing in my research showed that was directly related to a specific public works project okay, okay so you know those 2 things are unique and I want to see us do more you know we've had discussions about this I want to see us get more opportunities, local artists. I want to see us look to put art in places that aren't necessarily associated with public works project. So the reasons why I brought tweaking the ordinance and which we're working on we since we're in the sunshine. We had some delays because there are some state preemption were worried about over the legislative. Legislative time session. Yes, our loss that work for a second. Although that's wrapped up now so we're gonna get back to it and hopefully we'll see it soon anyway. Ok I just wanted I just couldn't remember how unique this was because what I want to see is us move in a direction where we do more like things that focus on local artists and focus are outside of public works projects and I just wanted to make sure that there was nothing structural here going on with the way that we went about it, but it sounds to me like you know, it's just a unique situation for this piece and now that I feel comfortable knowing that that's the case so I'm not concerned about having to reassess anything in the future. I think we're on the right path. So thank you for answering those questions just want to make sure had my head wrapped around it, thank you chair, thank you. Okay legal do we need to have a specific date on the deferral or can just different the administration is ready to bring it back either on so you can bait based on your manually can establish a date certain or it can be to deferred until after a certain thing has occurred which could be administration concludes there discussions with the artist an prepares a necessary amendments okay, thank you very much council member driskell thank you can you commit to JUNE 5th. >> What does that mean we just talked to him. >> As we're talking about time so. I it sounds like there's not a whole lot to discuss and this is a few weeks away. >> But I'd like to have some certainty as to when we'll be able to get this. Brought back to us. So I would I would really like it if we can establish JUNE 5th is the return date. It's based on what's left to do the conversations that need to be had, I'm confident that we can have his back by JUNE. It's green thank you make a motion to defer this item item f one to the JUNE 5th 2025 City Council meetings I can okay. We have a motion and a second. Just quickly again council members thank you for your grace administration same to you thanks for putting up with me. And you know. I had a learning experience today too. All right. No other council members wishing speaker could you please over machine for voting. Council members please enter your votes. Councilmember Harvey seems all present council members a vote a clerk please telling announce the vote is that your motion to defer agenda item one to JUNE 5th Council passes unanimously with council member Garrett being absent. Okay we're going to move on to f to a resolution authorizing the mayor to consent approved the sale of the Portland departments. I think we've got Mark vanlue joining us. Good afternoon MR. Afternoon chair council members here today request approval of the sale of the Portland apartment project. Have a brief presentation here for you just looking at to the timeline of the sale we received notice on Feb. 10th of this year of the intent of the current owner to sell the Portland apartments. Portland is a 68 unit affordable apartment property located in downtown Saint Pete I've got some more information on that in a moment. The units are a mix of 1, 2, 3 bedroom in a restricted attendance, earning 60% or less of area median income 7 of those units are restricted to 35% or below. The buyer is a proposed buyer for this project is sunrise affordable housing group. They specialize in acquisition rehabilitation and management of affordable housing multifamily projects have experience with a light Tech projects low-income housing tax credit projects section 8 contracts project based vouchers and other affordable components designed for both families and seniors. If this when this deal closes this would be their 4th affordable housing deal in Florida and the second in Pinellas County. Terms of the sale sunrise is currently under contract to acquire the Portland in partnership with Pinellas County housing Authority whereby the housing Authority will acquire the land few simple and will ground least the project back to sunrise on a 99 year term and how that feels County housing Authority will also operate as the management agent and provide resident services to the tenants the business plan that sunrise has is to hold the property as is and within the next few years pursue a re syndication of the light Tech tax credits through tax-exempt bonds and likely through tax exempt bonds in 4% tax credits and then initiate a substantial rehabilitation of the property to preserve and extend its useful life and to extend the affordability restrictions sunrise is funding the purchase of $8 million purchase with equity from its bounds. She knew senior loan plans to assume the existing subordinate loans from the city of Saint Pete and loans given the ground lease will be leasehold mortgage. Brief timeline of the project was initiated in 2009 when the initial agreement was signed with the city. The project completed construction. I believe in 22,011. And that went online in 2018 was the first sale of the property to the current owner. In 2020 there was a transfer of membership the current ownership entity transferred principle, membership interest and that was approved by Council in 2020. And that brings us to the current sale here in 2025. You're not familiar. The project is on 3rd Avenue North just northwest of mirror Lake at 8 Street North. And this is a street level view of the building. So as associated with this one associated with the sale. The buyer requests the assignment by current owner, an assumption by the buyer of this city's ship and a half loans. Approval of the transaction that's required by the workforce housing bonus density and intensity agreement dated in 2009. The assignment by current owner of the assumption by buyer of the workforce housing bonus density and intensity agreement. The assignment by current owner, an assumption by by or that certain declaration of restrictions that were signed and recorded in 2010. The subordination of the Declaration of restrictions workforce housing bonus density intensity agreement and the ship in l half loans to the first mortgage lender the buyers attempting to assume the loan from that exists with the primary lender but if that does not go through then they will bring primary financing and extend the maturity dates of the ship and a half loans from a us first of 2045. 2 Aug. 1st of 2070. And the administration recommends approval, I'm available for questions and we also have representatives from both the current owner and the prospective buyer of the project should they be needed for answering any questions. Okay thank you vice-chair handle it. >> Thank you chair and thank you mark for the presentation. So are the attorneys here. I like to ask you some questions. >> Good afternoon and thank you for your service, my name is he Le Soir I'm with Stearns Weaver law firm we represent the buyer sunrise affordable. Thank you and so in looking at this. And so there are a lot of assignments but then you get to the subordination a portion of it. So the subordination is not just the right of repayment obviously it's covid that they have to do with other issues affordability and so on and so forth so explain to me. Yes, why does affordability have to be knocked out if there is a forklift a potential foreclosure. Why would that be a requirement. Yes, I just want to clarify the intent here. The intent isn't to wipe out the affordable restrictions on. Sunrise is acquiring the project as discussed in the presentations they planned to Tax credit recent occasion down the road in a couple years and as part of that actually additional affordable restrictions will be placed on the property. Regarding the subordination component I think there's a few different elements here so one we have the subordination of the city's current mortgage and then 2 we have 2 different restrictions that are in favor of the city affecting the property. The first being the declaration of restrictions that was it recorded and required in connection with the ship and La chance loans and the second being this density workforce housing agreement. With regard to the first the declaration of restrictions I want to highlight that the city entered a subordination agreement with the sellers current lender I think in 2020. Pursuant to which the city agreed to support any declaration of restrictions. And additionally that declaration of restrictions was amended and in that amendment. There's language expressly providing the city can sense to the subordination of that agreement to a new first mortgage. Separately I want to address the workforce housing density agreement and I want to note that further conversations have been had with buyers lender here which is key Bank and as well as with city specifically the city attorney Isabella Sobel. And the main concern for key bank with the subordination well actually with the work first density agreement is that there's language in there providing that the property cannot be transferred without the city's consent. So here. Is fine with the affordability restrictions remaining in place. Help from the city with is this provision restricting transfer of the property and the event of a foreclosure. But now I turn 2 other attorneys. >> He made a couple of points as to the density workforce agreement ended the question of restrictions and some of the issues that have arisen because they're the ear in terms of the What is our position regarding that and. And the fact that we agreed to some of that. Subordinate those declaration of restrictions previously. I want to hear about that and I hear about the workforce part. >> Hello good good afternoon Isabella so will assistant city attorney. What MS. Sawyer did her summary is is correct. I will say that the city has never explicitly subordinated any workforce bonus and temps to the agreement pursuant to article the chapter of chapter 17.5 of our code. Speaking to some of Haley's points regarding the lenders issues with it. The transfer. The transfer issues I will say this is something that came a very last minute and we looked at our code and in our code it requires city approval administrative approval approval at any transfer of title of a property that is subject to error Housing bonus density in terms of the agreement so that's something to keep in mind that we are we're bound by our code as it is written today. So are not able to to provide flexibility on that I think that we could is hospital too to contract in a way that we could still abide by our code but. That that is the situation that we're in at this time. Okay. Because. When I look at this and I see the subordination isn't the most important thing obviously if you're into it in the affordable housing spaces took an affordability in all the things in place I understand there are times that they MAY have to foreclose something and you give up to is supporting your right every payment they're all the things but everyone that goes into says space understands this and so I want to make sure that we're not doing anything that things at risk. I mean there are there were basically bargains that were made that's why they got the density the workforce, the bonuses and all the things and now we we are subordinate ing kind of everything we got. And I don't want that to disappear. Completely understand the concern and I think the main point here and what we're asking for now and what we've gotten our lender comfortable with is entering in some sort of agreement between the city and the lender by which in the event of foreclosure which hopefully doesn't happen. But in the event it does and key bank needs to take title to the property. Those workforce housing units remain as workforce, housing units. But they need the ability to take title to the property that's the security of their loan rate. So I think we have a collective you know goal and understanding and we want you've come to an agreement now I understand but. There is a little. When it comes to this and so I just want make sure that we're on the same page and obviously legal is on the same page on this but this is not typical for us is my understanding. With the density bonus agreement that's correct. So this is not typically what we do in terms of this so I just wanted to put that on the record and get your statements on the record in terms of flight. We can expect to happen with that. Yeah and and to that point. In theory if needed for clothes and that workforce housing bonus was wiped. They would actually be in violation of the zoning code because that agreement is what allowed the increase density at the property. So the lenders not even incentivize to wipe it out I think you know I just want to highlight. I appreciate that I appreciate that. We love you have anything to say on that on that point. >> I'm it's face that's correct. But. There would probably be some arguments that it's illegal nonconformity are grandfathered used at that point and I don't know how. Would we go about lopping off a couple floors to get it back and compliance that would that's an uphill battle from our standpoint as the city and enforcing them, nobody wants to be there. Nobody wants to be there that's right. Okay. Well. It's legal so good with this. I'm fine with it, but I want to make sure that we all knew where we were and got starting things on the record. Thank you. Thank you councilmember Ford, thank you. I guess kind of going off of that sales of affordable housing complexes we had discussions a year or 2 ago about them being done administratively so it's going to ask like what was so unique about this struggling to wrap my head around it. But we have that discussion a little bit. But it did look like. MISTER Van blew you are approaching the microphone so I would love to hear your thoughts on all of this as well sure and I just wanted to make. Clear that while I realize there are bigger things at play here. We need to get an understanding of what is the city's policy and procedure when it comes to the sale properties. And when it comes to the subordination especially of restrictions. This case is mitigated quite a bit by the destruction of the deal the fact that the housing Authority is going to own the property. And ground lease it to the buyer for 99 years. And obviously the housing Authority's mission in exist reason to exist is to provide affordable housing and it's their intention to provide that affordability over that 99 year period which is longer than the current restrictions would provide in addition the the workforce housing density bonus agreement that's in place provides a 4 30 years of but it allows for affordability up to a 150% of am I and ii what's propose here is a much deeper affordability over that much longer time period. So I do think in this particular case, those things are mitigated by all of that. But I do agree that we need to understand going forward what how to look at these deals and how to structure these deals and where we don't have wiggle room great hopefully that's helpful. Thank you, yeah that that is helpful and I appreciate it. You bring me some comfort knowing. Specifically around the housing Authority being involved. I only had one other thing there was a point that you had. Bullet point the you had bolded about the maturation of the ship alone and the other loan and I just wondered if you could speak to that you see in the highlighted it. Currently though those loans are actually loans are being repaid. The ownership of the Portland over the years has been a great at making those payments they paid down a significant portion of that debt that that would gone through I was 2045. I believe I had on there. Yeah, yeah, and so they're the buyers asking for those loans to be extended the maturity dates to be extended to align with the new financing for the deal. So that it works better when they do the recent occasion of the tax credits in a few years. So they would like to extend that to Aug. First of 2070. What it will mean for the city is the remaining remainder of those funds will take longer to be paid back. But it will be paid back well before the 99 year affordability period would be up. And our other terms that maintain 40 billion the While it will mean will get paid back a little bit slower it isn't going to negatively impact anything in terms of restrictions or anything. And those those or no interest loans. I think yes okay and I'm assuming the position is that. >> Allowing that as part of this overall agreement a pause it fine because we are you know there's other benefits here that we're going to receive okay, okay, yes, the so we're not in your head. Yes, all Thank you just wanted to make sure Anderson thanks. >> On it a motion for approval will chair, yes sorry if I MAY start intersect on I do believe that there's a potential here for the city to gain additional protections with respect to the affordability period. Not being subordinated the affordability period that's in the workforce housing density bonus agreement only. So it was kind of brought up by the attorney earlier I think that you know if you want to explore that we could would be happy to have that discussion with you now. >> I mean I think it's any time we can not subordinate that I think we'd like that to be a part of the discussion is that yes a couple. Just to see Julie a couple options on how to do that you could. Hold off on voting and vote later in the meeting on this gives us an opportunity to confer with the potentially give you some specific. Different language in the resolution or elsewhere. You could. Authorize our office to you can approve it as is authorize our office to have some subsequent discussions make. Any changes that improve the city's position. Either way you want to do it if you want the specifics I mean considering the public hearings you know don't start until 5 if you wanted to hold off and let us have that discussion if you want to specific language or an answer we can do it today or you just tell us go forth and conquer as long as it improves the agreement to do it whatever everyone. Council members I certainly take your feedback obviously I just our legal department to move forward in the city's best interest so the voting on it and giving them to do that or if you want to bring it back later councilmember or vice chair him with. Well I think we have the attorneys here now and making wrap it up. That's probably going to be better for all of us so I don't see what the big deal is for us to kind of the for the vote on because what happens is then they kill and things don't work out what you think your workout and at least we're all year. Maybe we can. Different little later in we've got some terrific vendors thank you and thank you for that Jacki so basically I mean agrees that I think you all have this interesting because you've heard our concerns. So if we vote on it today you still have additional conversation to bring back. 2 us in these regards or there's all different ways to do it it could just be that it doesn't come back. It provided anything that we do is improving the city's position that you're just approving it as is and then authorizing us to do that. I'd say if you ask me what typically is happened in a situation like this in the past where we have the time like we have now like councilmember handle it set. We're back you don't need to take we can just pick this back up. It's not like you have to technically different until later in the agenda. It can be a move on for now take up other business and give us that window to see what we can do. All right. Well then why do we do that will give you time to work on that will move on to f 3 and we can bring you back later on the meeting would you do you want to do that before public hearing or after. We could probably I mean we should be able to do it before we'll update you in your 9 your other business here on how long we think it might okay great. Thank you. Okay we're going to move to f 3 a resolution authorizing the mayor to accept a grant from forward Pinellas I think we have Cheryl stats, Cheryl welcome. >> If you could afternoon sheriff's tax transportation and parking management excited to be here today to present you with this opportunity. A citywide micromobility expansion feasibility study this planning study would allow us to really gain a deeper and more significant understanding of how Michael mobility programs could be expanded tip. Provide more access to scooters and bike shares and Saint Pete. The opportunities provided with support from for Pinellas they provided assistance programming in the past for their complete streets program and the city has been successful in being awarded funds for both planning and construction projects. Last year the program was repurpose Tim broaden the types of planning insistence that can be provided to the local governments but they continue to bake a $150,000 available and that category as well as up to $3 million and the construction category. They open the call for projects last fall and conducted evaluations of the applications through this spring. Recognizing the change in the program with that broad and unless focused on producing complete streets corridors staff developed an application to address a timely need for planning assistance. We've heard previously a desire to expand our micro Billy offerings outside of the downtown core and we know that the most attractive areas to do this are often are activity centers that have destinations that people would like to visit, especially via scooters and bike shares coincidentally access to activity centers was one of the key evaluation, a criteria that for Pinellas uses to consider the projects for award. So we produce the map showing this graphic here as a part of the application so you can see where the my current micro mobility service area that's really for the bike share. And we're different activity sent County wide designated activity centers are located. So you can see a little bit of overlap but not a lot. We'd like to consider the feasibility of expansion with mindful us of our existing regulations as well for scooters and bicycle use. >> The city will include a review of our existing program then planned infrastructure keeping in mind the legal status of scooter users based on state and city right city regulations. As a reminder the city's micromobility ordinance provides that they should only be operated on low-speed streets or in bike lanes they're prohibited from use on sidewalks on certain trails including at the pier and have forced parking requirements to only Park the shared devices and dedicated make mobility her house infrastructure considerations as well as destiny destination des density excuse me outside of the downtown core have been key limiting factors for why we haven't expanded access previously, it's really hard for us to and we really need to take a deep look at our connected network of facilities to make sure that they can accommodate trips to get people to and from where they want to go and a way that does so legally that they can ride on the streets where they are low seats low-speed streets where they do have bike lanes where they do have these kinds of connections and so that we're not putting destinations where they would be required to write illegally, so that's a key part of why we need to look at the infrastructure when we're thinking about where do we expand micro mobility access. >> It'll be important for us to include market considerations in our feasibility study to under the current license agreements with our micro mobility providers, the city does not subsidize the provision of these services. In fact, the scooter operators pay at the fee in exchange for the use of our right of way. So their service areas included in the agreements with opportunities to expand by mutual agreement, however, the market is seeing consolidation in recent years and operational impacts that could increase the cost of the operators could have meaningful financial impacts that should be carefully considered when developing recommendations that would modify the service area boundaries. This could be further exacerbated from Roma in Houston, the providers access programs for low-income users is increased to so having the providers at the table with us. During the course of the study will be critical to success. We don't want to change or interrupt too much of the business model that we have available to us even while we expand micro mobility access. Another key element of the study will be the review of our frozen city ordinance some of which haven't been updated in a while. I went too far sorry. I'm so excited about this I really am. >> But I'm so one key factor is and the idea of updating our relevance city ordinances again some of these haven't been updated in a very long time. For the bike ordinance wasn't up as last update in 2009. And it did was really forward thinking and establishing the framework for bike You think we update in 2009, but we didn't launch by Churchill 2016 so was a while for the technology to come up with our regulatory framework. So that was really forward thinking for us. But the ordinance the regulations in the bike ordinance do not account for e-bikes the micromobility ordinance and adopt inches in 19 is where you'll find those regulations along with the regulatory framework for scooter share. So it's worth noting too that and the legislative session earlier this year the state passed a bill that if signed into law as expected would modify the definition of micro ability. So this study is a very timely and allowing us to consider the modifications in light of that change too. At the state level. We have had some recent success in expanding bikeshare outside of the downtown core. This spring we work to develop new bike share hubs at certain public access points along the Pinellas trail. We did limit that to bikeshare given that bikes generally have a longer range of trip. Then the scooters the average scooter trip is about one 0.1 2 miles in length. Whereas the average breaks your trip is 1.8 miles o lakes was a little bit longer so that lets us to get a little further from that the core area and start serving those areas further out to the West. Today we've seen over 50 trips that these locations since they were implemented. The top 3 locations are listed here. I think it's very notable that the second-highest locations 62th Street and the and the Pinellas trail is it's the second-highest location and that has a trip since it's pretty far West and it's really into the neighborhood so I feel really good that we're providing a couple of people who must really need some good access. That lets them get better into the downtown core and probably to some employment or recreational activities. We intend to continue to monitor the use of these locations on the study will have us also the considered expand access and build upon this both geographically and with micromobility tight scooters. So the requested Council action involves the execution of a funding agreement with forward Pinellas for the study the agreement would allow the city to accept funds in the amount of a $120,000 for the study. It requires the city to use a consultant for the project his professional services have already been procured by for Pinellas it's anticipated that the funding agreement would also be presented to the for Pinellas board at their insurance JUNE meeting for their consideration and approval. Their request to Council action also includes execution of a professional services agreement with the consultant administration recommend 6 getting the professional services agreement with

Agenda textCity Council

City Council — May 15, 2025

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
AgendaNot published in the sources we holdread text
Agenda packetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Action agendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
MinutesNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Transcript or captionsSource recordingread transcript
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Recording and media

Coverage and corrections

Not claimed by this page

  • Verified meeting decisions with item-specific public-source evidence
  • Item-level plain-language summaries are not available; this page does not infer individual agenda items.
  • Item-linked, attributed deliberation
  • A source-grounded next meeting date
  • A plain-English overview is not available.
  • Official outcomes have not been published.
  • The available transcript has no reliable timestamps.
  • Transcript coverage is partial.
  • Speakers have not been reliably matched to public profiles.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.
  • An individual roll-call roster is not available.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: 35ed44c5d83f6a67e1c3c760b49f1522. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record