POLISCOPE

The public record

JUPITER (PALM BEACH COUNTY) · LOCALDecisions publishedPartial coverage

Planning and Zoning Commission Meeting

Tuesday, January 14, 2025 · Government meeting record

The 30-second read

Recorded outcome

The Jupiter Planning and Zoning Commission approved the annexation, land use map amendment, and rezoning of a 0.2-acre property at 18019 Highway A1A. The owner plans to develop a two-unit multifamily residence on the site, which is subject to future archaeological review.

Why it matters

The commission's approval allows a private property owner to proceed with annexing land into the Town of Jupiter and changing its zoning to permit a two-unit multifamily development.

What happens next

No later meeting or follow-up date is stated in the reviewed record.

An official outcome record - an action agenda or minutes - is published for this meeting.

Record text

No transcript is held for this meeting. Recording: Media

TOWN OF JUPITER PLANNING AND ZONING COMMISSION FINAL MINUTES JANUARY 14,2025 7:00 P.M.

CALL TO ORDER:

Chair Kevin Kirn called the meeting to order at 7:01 p.m.

ATTENDANCE:

Chair Kevin Kirn; Vice Chair Richard Dunning; Comm. Michael Cassatly; Comm. Beth Kelso; Comm. David Thompson; Comm. Karen Vinson; Paul Keenan, 1 $ ^{st} $ Alternate (voting member) and Cynthia Blum, 2 $ ^{nd} $ Alternate (non-voting member); Thomas Baird, Town Attorney; John Sickler, Director of Planning & Zoning; Martin Schneider, Principal Planner; Garret Watson Principal Planner; Scott Thatcher, Principal Planner and Vernisa Ayers, Secretary.

MINUTES:

Comm. Kelso moved to recommend approval of the November 12, 2024 Planning and Zoning Meeting minutes; seconded by Comm. Cassatly. Final: Motion passed unanimously, with a 7-0 vote.

SWEARING IN:

Secretary Vernisa Ayers conducted the swearing-in of witnesses for all quasi-judicial items on the agenda.

CITIZEN COMMENTS: Robert Bain, Tim Murphy, and Dawn Zangara spoke in opposition of increasing the current density to permit more residential units in Abacoa Town Center. They emphasized worries about the potential implications, costs, and maintenance issues related to this change, as well as the likelihood of future redevelopment.

REGULAR AGENDA:

A. OLD BUSINESS: None.

B. NEW BUSINESS:

1. Beyel Annexation, Future Land Use and Rezoning - Applications for a 0.2+/- acre property located at 18019 Highway A1A, to request a:

(PZ24-6133,6134,6138)

B. Future Land Use Map amendment from Palm Beach County (PBC) Commercial High with underlying Medium Residential, 5 dwelling units per acre (CH/5) to Town of Jupiter (TOJ) Inlet Village Flex; (Acting as the Local Planning Agency)

Applicant presentation: Alec Dickerson, representative of 2GHO on behalf of Venus and Mars, LLC. presented a PowerPoint presentation of the proposed project. Owner, Danny Beyel was also in attendance.

* * *

Staff presentation: Principal Planner, Martin Schneider, reviewed the staff report.

Commissioners asked questions of the Applicant and Staff:

Comm. Kelso inquired about an inconsistency, noting that a single-family home was mentioned while multifamily is noted in the staff report. Mr. Dickerson clarified that a single-family dwelling is not allowed in the Inlet Village District and the project will be a multifamily residence with two units. Comm. Kelso asked about the archaeological significance of the site and how it might affect development plans. Mr. Schneider replied that would depend on the location and quality of any findings, potentially requiring adjustments to the site plan based on the certificate to dig process. Comm. Kelso asked why the property will not be part of the Community Redevelopment Agency. Mr. Sickler mentioned there hasn't been a directive for inclusion. Comm. Kelso also questioned the staff report's reference to Inlet Village Flex (IVF) versus Inlet Village Residential (IVR) and the decision for only two residential units. Mr. Schneider clarified that their request was specifically for Inlet Village and Flex South.

Comm. Cassatly asked if combining the two abutting properties were necessary for building. Mr. Dickerson stated that this correct. Comm. Cassatly then inquired if this was a workaround for the single-family house restriction, suggesting a residential unit over the garage for the same family. Mr. Dickerson replied that the plan is for the owner to build the structure, not as a workaround. Mr. Sickler noted that these issues would be addressed in the site plan development application for the small-scale PUD. Owner, Danny Beyel, mentioned that they intended to build a second unit to rent for future income. Comm. Cassatly asked about the archaeological site and potential digging will be made in the future, and if there will be a marker related to the Celestial Railway or dating back to around 1,500 BC. Mr. Sickler noted that the Town has marked the Celestial Railroad at other development sites using pavers. Commissioner Cassatly asked about public access to uncovered artifacts if some were found. Mr. Sickler replied that access depends on the cultural resource assessment results and the Historic Resources Board's decisions on the Certificate to Dig.

Comm. Dunning asked about the next steps if the application is approved. Mr. Sickler if approved, the applicant can then proceed with the Certificate to Dig process through the Historic Resources Board, followed by site planning and a small-scale planned unit development.

Chair Kirn inquired if the Town typically assesses the removal and approval of trees based on health issues. Mr. Sickler replied that an inspection and report from a certified arborist is required. Chair Kirn inquired about traffic generation, noting the County's average 463 daily trips. Chair Kirn asked if this was the maximum? Mr. Schneider confirmed it's the cap for the highest floor area ratio. Chair Kirn mentioned that our Inlet Village traffic management tool suggests a lower cap due to the roadway capacity, limiting this property to about 35 daily trips, which would allow for roughly five multifamily units. Chair Kirn asked if Town Council has flexibility to reduce the 463. Mr. Sickler clarified that the Council has set limits or trip caps on properties for previous comprehensive plan amendment for future land use. Council has the authority to impose these limits as part of their legislative authority. Any cap established at that time must be followed when a site plan is submitted.

Comm. Thompson inquired if Mr. Beyel knew about the archaeological importance of the property. Mr. Beyel confirmed that he was aware. Comm. Thompson then asked Mr. Beyel if he was up to date on the situation with the Sperry property and what his plan would be if he faced similar challenges. Mr. Beyel responded that he is aware and if they discover anything historic while digging, they would stop all work. Comm. Thompson asked about the possibility of merging the current property with the new one that the town plans to annex, specifically asking if a Certificate to Dig would be required for the adjacent land. Mr. Beyel replied that they had already conducted some excavation. Comm. Thompson asked if that was the location where middens had been discovered. Mr. Beyel clarified that no middens were found; only an old hinge and some relatively recent pottery, were uncovered. Mr. Beyel stated that they intended to excavate the other parcel to ensure there was nothing of concern there.

Comm. Vinson inquired about any future building plans and whether this project would turn into a real multi-family or mixed-use development. Mr. Beyel responded that he did not have plans to construct anything else.

Comm. Keenan asked whether there had been any conversations regarding the resale of the parcel with any other parties. Mr. Dickerson responded that there had not been any discussions at this time.

Public Comment: None.

Deliberation by Commission: None.

Motion:

Comm. Cassatly motioned to approve the Annexation, seconded by Comm Keenan. Final: Motion passed unanimously, with a 7-0 vote.

Comm. Kelso motioned to approve the Future Land Use Map Amendment, seconded by Comm. Thompson. Final: Motion passed unanimously, with a 7-0 vote.

Comm. Vinson motioned to approve the Rezoning of the property as it stands, seconded by Comm. Cassatly. Final: Motion passed unanimously, with a 7-0 vote.

* * *

Disclosures: Comm. Vinson, Chair Kirn and Vice Chair Dunning stated that they drove by the site and spoke with staff. Commissioners Cassatly, Kelso and Blum stated that they drove by the site. Commissioners Keenan and Thompson did not have disclosures.

Applicant presentation: Craig McDonald, representative of Corporate Property Services on behalf of Wendy's restaurant presented a PowerPoint presentation of the proposed project.

Staff presentation: Principal Planner, Garret Watson, reviewed the staff report.

Commissioners asked questions of the Applicant and Staff:

Comm. Keenan asked about interior seating and overall capacity. Mr. McDonald and Mr. Watson confirmed that interior seating will have a slight decrease, with new outdoor seating added. Comm. Keenan also expressed concerns about a sealed dumpster system, to which Mr. Watson responded that it would increase costs and recalled that in 2017, the applicant requested enforcement only upon a violation, as there were no reported issues. Mr. Watson that the recommendation was to maintain Council's previous decision on the dumpster. Comm. Keenan further inquired about odor detection features. Mr. Watson explained that the dumpster, located behind the new police department, has minimal activity and is far from residential areas, reducing odor concerns.

Comm. Vinson inquired about the applicant's request to waive the decorative lighting payments. Mr. McDonald clarified that the Wendy's owner willing to bury power lines, landscape, provide a 25-foot public access easement, and install sidewalks. Mr. McDonald stated that he would like to have further discussions with staff before this goes to Council about waiving the lighting. Mr. Watson noted that decorative street lighting is usually included with underground utilities to replace the existing wood poles with decorative poles, and has been a standard condition since 2012. Comm. Vinson then inquired if passing the application would include the lighting as proposed, to which Mr. Watson affirmed related to condition 7B in Exhibit 1 on page 2-13.

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
AgendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Agenda packetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Action agendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Transcript or captionsNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Recording and media

Coverage and corrections

Records considered

  • Planning and Zoning Commission Meeting (2025-01-14)

Not claimed by this page

  • Verified meeting decisions with item-specific public-source evidence
  • Item-level plain-language summaries are not available; this page does not infer individual agenda items.
  • Item-linked, attributed deliberation
  • A source-grounded next meeting date
  • Official outcomes have not been published.
  • A transcript is not available.
  • Speakers have not been reliably matched to public profiles.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.
  • An individual roll-call roster is not available.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: 34735d4010170bb3316a6956fe2d6605. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record