POLISCOPE

The public record

NAPLES (COLLIER COUNTY) · LOCALDecisions publishedPartial coverage

City Council Workshop Meeting

Monday, January 13, 2025 · Government meeting record

The 30-second read

Recorded outcome

The Naples City Council held a workshop meeting to discuss the implementation of the state's 'Live Local Act' regarding affordable housing and to review new digital public record tools. Residents also provided public comments on concerns including airport noise, recent aircraft incidents, local flooding, and opposition to the Naples Pride Festival.

Why it matters

The Council began the process of setting local development standards and approval procedures for affordable housing projects under Florida's Live Local Act, which will dictate future residential density and building requirements in the city.

What happens next

No later meeting or follow-up date is stated in the reviewed record.

An official outcome record - an action agenda or minutes - is published for this meeting.

Record text

No transcript is held for this meeting. Recording: Watch video

City of Naples City Council Chamber 735 Eighth Street South Naples, Florida 34102 City Council Workshop Meeting – January 13, 2025 – 8:33 a.m. It is noted for the record that all: 1) documentation electronically appended hereto is also contained in the file for this meeting with the City Clerk’s Office; and 2) added attachments are referenced in red as “ADDED ATTACHMENT”. 1) CALL TO ORDER AND ROLL CALL City Council Members Present: Teresa Lee Heitmann, Mayor Berne Barton Terry Hutchison, Vice Mayor Ray Christman Bill Kramer Linda Penniman Beth Petrunoff Staff Present: Jay Boodheshwar, City Manager Patricia Rambosk, City Clerk Gary Young, Deputy City Manager / Chief Finance Officer Matthew McConnell, City Attorney Robert Middleton, Public Works Director Erica Martin, Planning Director Chad Merritt, Parks, Recreation, and Facilities Director Dan Ohrenstein, City Engineer Michelle Baines, Public Works Deputy Director Ali Duran, Executive Assistant Natalie Hardman, Natural Resources Manager Charlotte Loewel, Human Resources Director Russell Thomas, Employee / Labor Relations Manager Jessica Rosenberg, Deputy City Clerk Others Present: Linda Oberhaus Dan O’Berski Wynn Watkins Mary Alger Bob Bernardi Vicki Brotherton Frank Cerveny Teddy Collins Pamela Cunningham Cody Davis Andrew DeLong Janet Ferry Ritchie Gillespie Julianne Jones Jay Kohlhagen Laura Koster Small Vicky Lindsay Eileen Lowry Maria Mair Cindy Mayo Suzanne McDonald James Rosenberger Mary Tatigian Alberto Torres Ronda Burns Katie Walker Kevin Williams Mary Young Amy Adiutori Cynthia Deshields Ellin Goetz John Remington Peter Van Arsdale 2) PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE Council Member Christman led in the Pledge of Allegiance. 3) SET AGENDA (ADD OR REMOVE ITEMS) City Manager Jay Boodheshwar said there were no changes to the agenda and announced that there were two time-certain Items scheduled that day, Item 6.C at 10:00 a.m., a presentation on the Live Local Act, and Item 7.A at 12:30 p.m., an Executive Session related to ongoing labor negotiations.

City Council Workshop Meeting – January 13, 2025 – 8:33 a.m. 2 MOTION by Hutchison to SET AGENDA; seconded by Petrunoff and unanimously carried, all members present and voting (Barton-yes, Christman-yes, Hutchison-yes, Kramer-yes, Penniman-yes, Petrunoff-yes, Heitmann-yes). 4) ANNOUNCEMENTS AND PRESENTATIONS 4.A) REV. DR. MARTIN LUTHER KING JR. PRAYER BREAKFAST PROCLAMATION. Mayor Heitmann read a Proclamation declaring January 17, 2025, as the Trinity Life Foundation Reverend Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. Prayer Breakfast Day, presenting it to Wynn Watkins and Ronda Burns. Mr. Watkins expressed his gratitude with words of thanks. 4.B) HUMAN TRAFFICKING AWARENESS MONTH PROCLAMATION. Mayor Heitmann read a proclamation proclaiming the month of January as Human Trafficking Awareness Month, presenting it to Linda Oberhaus from the Shelter for Abused Women and Children. Ms. Oberhaus offered brief remarks to convey her appreciation. 4.C) DEMONSTRATION OF LASERFICHE SEARCH TOOL (CONTINUED FROM THE DECEMBER 9, 2024 CITY COUNCIL WORKSHOP). City Clerk Patricia Rambosk provided an overview of LaserFiche, a new searchable online library. She explained that this electronic records management system is a powerful tool capable of locating documents through full-text search, document or folder names. She noted that LaserFiche is publicly accessible via the City’s Homepage under the Public Records tab. City Clerk Rambosk highlighted the benefits of LaserFiche, including preventing record loss, saving storage space, streamlining document management and enabling faster and easier access to records. She noted that the library consists of searchable records, starting in 1925, including meeting minutes, resolutions and ordinances for City Council and all boards and committees. She expressed gratitude to her staff for setting up the LaserFiche platform in-house without the assistance of outside consultants. City Clerk Rambosk then provided a live demonstration of the LaserFiche interface on the City of Naples public website overviewing how to access and search records. In response to Mayor Heitmann, City Clerk Rambosk said she would work with each department starting with Human Resources to begin expanding LaserFiche throughout the City. Agenda Memorandum Laserfiche User Instructions 5) PUBLIC COMMENTS The following spoke in opposition to approval of the Naples Pride Festival; Mary Alger, Teddy Collins, Laura Koster Small, Pamela Cunningham, Cindy Mayo, Vicki Brotherton, Suzanne McDonald, Cody Davis, Andrew DeLong, Katie Walker, Julianne Jones, Vicky Lindsay, Kevin Williams, James Rosenberger, and Ritchie Gillespie. Jay Kohlhagen claimed that the non-profit status of the Naples Pride organization was suspended. Bob Bernardi, a 5th Avenue South resident, expressed concern regarding car, truck, and motorcycle noise, loud vehicle radios, and low flying jets in his neighborhood. Maria Mair voiced concerns about safety at the Naples Airport, citing three recent aircraft incidents. Mary Tatigian, a County resident living in the path of incoming aircraft to Naples Airport, discussed the physical health impacts caused by aircraft noise pollution. Eileen Lowry raised questions about the New Year’s early morning aircraft crash at the Naples Airport. She advocated for increased local control over airport operations to improve safety and reduce aircraft noise. Mary Young, President of the Old Naples Association, expressed concern about the weather conditions and lack of precautions that contributed to the New Year’s early morning aircraft crash at Naples Airport. She called for a thorough investigation and appropriate accountability. Frank Cerveny, a resident of Gulf Shore Boulevard South, expressed concern regarding recent flooding in his neighborhood. He spoke about the City’s responsibilities to maintain stormwater systems to

City Council Workshop Meeting – January 13, 2025 – 8:33 a.m. 3 prevent flooding. Janet Young, past President and current board member of the Old Naples Association, presented the results of her organization’s Annual Survey. She highlighted that overdevelopment ranked as the top concern among members, followed by issues such as green space, clean water, traffic, and noise. Ms. Young noted that survey respondents felt the City often acts too slowly on pressing issues but expressed appreciation for the City’s respect for the Charter Height Amendment, as well as City Council’s accessibility and communication with residents. The survey also revealed that members desired more strictly managed growth and development, regulation of transient lodging, control over traffic influx from the County, improvements to beach ends, and enhanced debris cleanup efforts. Wynn Watkins and Alberto Torez were not present when called. Handout (ADDED ATTACHMENT / D. Adan and J. Kohlhagen) Recess: 10:23 a.m. to 10:36 a.m. It is noted for the record that the same Council Members were present when the meeting reconvened. 6) DISCUSSION ITEMS 6.C) DISCUSSION RELATED TO THE CITY OF NAPLES ADMINISTRATIVE PROCESS FOR THE IMPLEMENTATION OF CS/SB 328 "LIVE LOCAL ACT". (10:00 A.M. TIME CERTAIN). City Manager Jay Boodheshwar introduced the item, followed by Planning Director Erica Martin, who used an electronic presentation to provide an overview of Florida CS/SB328, the Live Local Act, highlighting its key provisions. Dan O’Berski, Real Estate Advisor at Trinity Commercial Group, clarified the qualifying income levels for affordable housing under CS/SB328. Planning Director Martin shared the two action items for City Council to consider that day: 1) determine applicable development standards for affordable housing; and 2) determine an administrative approval process for affordable housing. Real Estate Advisor O’Berski spoke about methods to address potential challenges to the City’s development standards, specifically limits on unit floor areas, units per acre limits, parking requirements, required setbacks, maximum lot coverage, and building height limits. He stated that the strategies he offered would be used as an alternative strategy for potential developers in lieu of the Live Local Act. Mayor Heitmann remarked that while the Live Local Act was designed to assist municipalities in addressing affordable housing, it ultimately acts as an obstacle to those efforts. She asked if the State regulations preempt local comprehensive plans and zoning regulations. In response, City Attorney Matthew McConnell advised that the City’s Charter and Comprehensive Plan trump the Live Local Act. City Attorney McConnell clarified that, under the Live Local Act, building heights cannot be restricted to less than the tallest allowable height within a one-mile radius of the proposed development. Vice Mayor Hutchison emphasized the importance of City Council thoroughly understanding the broader implications of density and height regulations across the community. He also raised concerns about the Live Local Acts requirement for administrative approval of affordable housing developments. In response, City Attorney McConnell clarified that the City Councils role that day was to determine how potential workforce developments would advance through the site plan process. He stressed the urgency of swift action, cautioning that once a site, such as the proposed Stillwater Cove, is developed, it would no longer be subject to future City Council decisions. He suggested that information related to new development standards and approval process be uploaded to the City’s website as soon as possible. Real Estate Advisor O’Berski clarified that the City has jurisdictional authority over any assets it owns. Council Member Christman suggested that the Live Local Act represents the States response to local resistance to affordable housing initiatives. Acknowledging the City’s delayed response to the Act, he advocated for immediate compliance to meet its requirements. He further proposed that City Council focus on creating a process to promote high-quality affordable housing in the

City Council Workshop Meeting – January 13, 2025 – 8:33 a.m. 4 future. Planning Director Martin said she would provide Council Members with examples of how other municipalities have handled affordable housing regulations. She added that Collier County has had its provisions in place for a few months. Responding to Council Member Barton, Planning Director Martin explained that the Live Local Act requires affordable housing development requests to be approved administratively through the site plan process. However, it is up to City Council to establish the specifics of that process, which may incorporate the City’s R3-12 Multifamily District standards, excluding height and parking exemptions, she said. Noting that developers using the Live Local Act are eligible for state tax credits, Council Member Barton proposed that the City consider offering comparable tax incentives to encourage developers to choose the local alternative development standards. Addressing concerns from Council Members, Real Estate Advisor O’Berski explained that developers compliance with development standards is monitored using Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) standards. However, he acknowledged uncertainty regarding which entity is responsible for auditing the properties. He committed to investigating how the County conducts audits and reporting his findings back to staff. Vice Mayor Hutchison proposed that the guidance provided to staff regarding the Live Local Act take the most conservative approach. Summarizing the discussion, City Attorney McConnell stated that staff is directed to apply the R3-12 multifamily zoning district standards and require a site plan review for affordable housing applicants under the Live Local Act. Mayor Heitmann then proffered the following consensus, Consensus to direct staff to move forward with the administrative process and the development standards based on R3-12 Multifamily District standards. Planning Director Martin added that the two changes discussed that day were allowing smaller floor areas and implementing a sliding scale for parking allotments based on the size of the unit. Mayor Heitmann and Council Member Petrunoff expressed disagreement with the changes. Agenda Memorandum Summary Points - Florida CS-CS-SB 328 Affordable Housing City of Naples Affordable Housing Regulations - Code of Ordinances Section 56-82 CS-CS-SB 328 Text Map Depicting the Percentage of the City Zoned Commercial or Industrial O’Berski Email - Live Local Projects Presentation 6.D) DISCUSSION REGARDING PROCESS AND TIMING FOR THE REPLACEMENT OF CAMBIER PARK PLAYGROUND. City Manager Jay Boodheshwar introduced the agenda item and offered a brief overview of efforts to replace the Cambier Park Playground, noting that many earlier plans have been delayed due to hurricanes. Chad Merritt, Parks, Recreation, and Facilities Director, followed with an electronic presentation highlighting that the playground equipment has a typical life expectancy of 20 years. The current structure, primarily made of wood, is approximately 30 years old, he noted. He explained that while staff has performed extensive basic repairs over the years, they are not equipped to address the significant structural repairs that are now required. He then detailed playground replacement efforts to date which include conceptional designs, public meetings to gather insights, establishment of a website that provides public information and a public survey that has generated over 200 responses. Director Merritt continued his presentation by highlighting conceptual renderings of the proposed replacement playground, alongside photographs highlighting defects in existing playground structures. He also offered a recommended scope of work which includes the demolition of existing playground, and the design, furnishing and installation of new playground equipment.

City Council Workshop Meeting – January 13, 2025 – 8:33 a.m. 5 Public Comments: John Remington, who helped build the playground 30 years ago, inquired about the accessibility features and design process for the new playground. Ellin Goetz provided a historical overview of the playground and agreed that the equipment needed to be replaced. Noting that Leathers and Associates had been the contractor for the original playground and highlighting other popular playgrounds in the area designed by the firm, she encouraged the City to consider utilizing their services for the new Cambier Park playground. Similarly, Peter VanArsdale, a former City Council Member and another contributor to the original playground project, advocated for the involvement of Leathers and Associates, emphasizing the importance of creating a unique design. Amy Adiutori declined to speak when called. Cynthia Deshields was not present when called. Vice Mayor Hutchison inquired about donor recognition options for the new playground and advocated for an unconventional design that incorporates sensory engagement activities. Director Merritt emphasized the importance of moving forward with a sense of urgency. Council Member Christman agreed that the playground needed to be replaced but expressed uncertainty about the path forward. He asked for clarification on the role of the Community Services Advisory Board (CSAB) in the project and the procurement process for selecting a vendor. Council Member Barton recommended that, to streamline the process, only design/build firms be considered, highlighting Leathers and Associates as a potential candidate. He also urged the immediate removal of any playground elements that pose safety risks. Director Merritt confirmed that Leathers and Associates would be contacted but noted that if the firm is either uninterested in the project or unable to meet the City’s standards, the CSAB would be consulted on the selection of an alternative firm. Mayor Heitmann emphasized the importance of gathering additional community input, while Council Member Petrunoff highlighted the need to incorporate positive elements from the existing playground into the new design. Ms. Goetz shared insights from Leathers and Associates, noting that the company offers three types of build models: Community, Contractor, and Hybrid. City Attorney Matthew McConnell estimated that City Council’s role in the playground replacement process would take approximately nine to 12 months. He emphasized that, in the meantime, any unsafe materials on the playground should be removed promptly. City Attorney McConnell clarified that City Councils direction is for staff to solicit a Request for Proposal (RFP) from design firms, which would include conceptual drawings. Director Merritt noted that community input has been considered during staff’s efforts to ensure the playground meets current safety standards, uses appropriate materials, and is inclusive. In response, Council Member Barton emphasized that it is the City Councils responsibility to establish the safety criteria for the project, wi th design firms being evaluated based on their ability to adhere to these standards. Once a firm is selected, he added, public input on the design can be considered. Council Member Kramer suggested that public input could be gathered during a CSAB meeting. City Manager Boodheshwar recommended drafting the RFP first, followed by inviting the public to a CSAB meeting to gather their feedback. Agenda Memorandum Cambier Park Playground Project Presentation 7) NEW BUSINESS 7.A) LABOR NEGOTIATIONS EXECUTIVE SESSION (12:30 P.M. TIME CERTAIN). City Manager Jay Boodheshwar announced an Executive Session to discuss labor relations and collective bargaining strategies. Executive Session: 1:16 p.m. to 2:46 p.m. It is noted for the record that the same Council Members were present when the meeting reconvened. Agenda Memorandum 6.A) DISCUSSION AND DIRECTION OF CITY COUNCIL TO PROCEED WITH AMENDING THE CODE OF ORDINANCES TO UTILIZE THE COLLIER COUNTY CLERK OF COURTS WEBSITE FOR PUBLISHING LEGAL NOTICES, RATHER THAN THE NEWSPAPER, AS PERMITTED BY SECTION 50.0311 OF THE FLORIDA STATUTES.

City Council Workshop Meeting – January 13, 2025 – 8:33 a.m. 6 City Clerk Patricia Rambosk introduced the item, a request for direction from City Council to move forward with amending the Code of Ordinances to allow the use of the Collier County Clerk of Courts website for publishing Legal Notices instead of the newspaper. She explained that House Bill 7049 amended Chapter 50 of the Florida Statutes, permitting municipalities to publish required Legal Notices on a “publicly accessible website” as outlined in Section 50.0311. She noted that while legal notices are still being published in the local newspaper, they have also been appearing on the Collier County Clerk of Courts website since July 2024. City Clerk Rambosk then proffered an electronic presentation demonstrating how to navigate the City of Naples website and the Collier County Clerk of Courts website to locate the City’s legal notices. She also reviewed the requirements and benefits of using this website, highlighting features such as the ability to subscribe to notices, quicker access to affidavits of publication, cost savings, reduced staff time, a longer publication period, and improved readability. She revealed that the cost to publish the legal notices in the Naples Daily News the previous three fiscal years was $170,000, which did not include staff time. Council Members expressed their support for the request. In response to Council Member Kramer, City Clerk Rambosk outlined several methods available to notify the public to ensure accessibility and awareness, including the City’s newsletter and running a notification ad in the Naples Daily News for six months. Agenda Memorandum Presentation 6.B) UPDATE ON INTEGRATED WATER RESOURCES PLANNING ACTIVITIES & DISCUSSION ON CITY’S WATER AND WASTEWATER SERVICE AREAS. City Manager Jay Boodheshwar introduced the agenda item, explaining that the presentation would be divided into two parts: the first providing informational context and the second addressing stormwater sewer infrastructure located outside the City limits. Public Works Director Robert Middleton provided an overview of the Integrated Water Resources Plan (IWRP), which was updated in 2022. Following his remarks, Public Works Deputy Director Michelle Baines proffered an electronic presentation highlighting conclusions and recommendations from the 2022 IWRP and updates to the City’s potable water system, the wastewater collection system, and the reclaimed water system. Public Works Director Middleton explained that the Southwest Florida Water Management District (SFWMD) typically issues five-year water use permits. However, after the implementation of the IWRP, Naples became the first city in the state to be awarded a 20-year permit. He highlighted that the adoption of the IWRP, along with the expansion of the reclaimed water system, led to a 20 to 25 percent reduction in water demand within the City, a significant achievement that earned Naples the extended permit. Furthermore, following the 2022 update to the IWRP, the State granted Naples an additional 10-year permit extension in February 2024, he noted. In response to Council Members’ concerns, Public Works Director Middleton asserted that Naples is at no risk of running out of water. In addition, he stated that since Golden Gate Estates residents draw their water from a different water supply, their actions do not affect Naples’ water supply. Public Works Deputy Director Baines continued the presentation by providing an overview and details of City/County interlocal agreements, which date back to 1977 and include 11 amendments. She then presented maps outlining the boundaries of the City’s Wastewater Service Area and Water Service Area. She explained that the City’s Wastewater Service Area includes limited areas outside the City, covering 16.4 square miles and serving 9,000 accounts. In contrast, the City’s Water Service Area extends significantly east of the City limits, encompassing 29 square miles and serving 18,435 accounts.

City Council Workshop Meeting – January 13, 2025 – 8:33 a.m. 7 Public Works Deputy Director Baines provided an overview of the Utility Review Process for County projects within the City’s potable water service area. She emphasized that the City’s submittal requirements are the same for projects located inside or outside City limits, and County projects intending to use the City’s potable water cannot proceed without City utility approval. She also highlighted upcoming challenges, including finite resources, aging infrastructure, increasing regulatory requirements, and the need to adapt to climate change. Mayor Heitmann concluded by underscoring the importance of establishing a fair and equitable system for impact fees, managing the City’s water resources collaboratively and gaining a clearer understanding of the costs associated with producing water. She also stressed the need to determine how impact fees will fund infrastructure for future water supplies, establish annual agreements for impact fees, promote sustainable water practices between the City and County and work with the County to secure State and Federal grants. Agenda Memorandum Presentation Integrated Water Resources Plan Update - Presentation (March 22, 2022 City Council Regular Meeting) Integrated Water Resources Plan Update - Recap and Discussion (May 31, 2022 City Council Regular Meeting) Integrated Water Resources Plan Update - Final Report (Prepared by AECOM, Dated August 04, 2022) City of Naples Water and Wastewater Service Interlocal Service Boundary Agreement and Accord and Satisfaction (Dated February 24, 2009) City of Naples Ordinance No. 2698 (First Reading - June 15, 1977; Adopted at Second Reading - July 6, 1977) City of Naples Ordinance No. 2699 (First Reading - June 15, 1977; Adopted at Second Reading - July 6, 1977) 6.E) UPDATE ON 2024-2025 RESILIENCY AND ADAPTATION PROJECTS. City Manager Jay Boodheshwar introduced the agenda item. Natural Resources Manager Natalie Hardman provided an update on resilience initiatives during the first six months following the approval of the City’s Adaptation Plan. Utilizing an electronic presentation, she highlighted efforts aimed at enhancing resiliency in Naples. Natural Resources Manager Hardman noted that City Council approved funding of four projects in September 2024 and one budget item for this year, which include: 1) creating a business case for a resilience study; 2) developing climate resilience outreach materials; 3) performing summer hot spot thermal analysis; 4) taking inventory of seawalls and updating the Seawall Height Ordinance and 5) working on a Watershed Master Plan. She then listed strategy initiatives with resilience components that were led by other City Departments in 2024, which include: 1) a Comprehensive Plan Update (Planning Department); 2) a new street sweeper (Stormwater Division); 3) development of the Wastewater Master Plan (Utilities Division); 4) the Wastewater Lift Station Project (Utilities Division); 5) the Coastal Storm Outfalls Consolidation Project (Stormwater Division); and 6) the Multi-basin Prioritization Project (Stormwater Division). Natural Resources Manager Hardman then listed coordination and collaboration strategies initiated in 2024, which include: 1) expanding coordination with the County for regional flood protection; 2) coordinating with Florida Power and Light to harden electrical infrastructure; 3) assessing opportunities for natural based solutions; 4) developing a vehicle storm relocation program; 5) researching pilot projects for dune revegetation; 6) coordinating dune revegetation efforts with Collier County and beach renourishment and expanding dune revegetation projects with Florida Gulf Coast University; and 7) continuing coordination efforts with the Army Corps of Engineers (USACE) regarding the Collier Storm Risk Management (CSRM) Study, which may produce resilience initiatives in vulnerable neighborhoods. She concluded by outlining upcoming

City Council Workshop Meeting – January 13, 2025 – 8:33 a.m. 8 strategies, which include continuing to apply for grants and other forms of funding for projects based on availability of funds and deadlines of funding sources. In addition, she noted that as studies and prioritization projects are completed, the information should be leveraged for development of defined capital projects, engineering design of capital projects and policy development and implementation. Council Member Christman emphasized the importance of a comprehensive resiliency plan and identified the State of Florida as the most logical funding source for its implementation. He suggested that Naples examine resiliency plans from East Coast communities, noting that those areas have greater resources and more experience addressing these challenges. In response, Natural Resources Manager Hardman offered an overview of business strategies to implement resiliency and adaptation projects. Vice Mayor Hutchison suggested prioritizing beach cleanup efforts before the County begins planting on the dunes. In response to Mayor Heitmann, Natural Resources Manager Hardman detailed efforts within City departments to promote resiliency efforts. Agenda Memorandum Naples Resilience Efforts First 6 Months 6.F) DISCUSSION AND DIRECTION REGARDING PRIORITIZATION OF THE DESIGN AND CONSTRUCTION OF MULTI-BASIN AND BASIN 4 STORMWATER PROJECTS Public Works Director Robert Middleton reviewed the agenda memorandum, noting that an item for approval of additional funding for Kimley-Horn & Associates to provide professional engineering services for the Multi-Basin Implementation Plan is scheduled for the January 15, 2025, Regular City Council meeting. City Engineer Dan Ohrenstein delivered an electronic presentation outlining the Multi-Basin Stormwater Assessment and the Basin 4 Assessment. He discussed project goals and objectives, shared model recommendations and analysis, and provided examples of proposed improvements. City Engineer Ohrenstein also reviewed alternate analysis approaches and considerations. He then highlighted key findings from both existing conditions and long-range analyses and the engineer’s opinion of probable costs for all five areas, which amounted to $591.4 million. He summarized the final recommendations that included: 1) developing a more detailed implementation plan and funding strategy leveraging information from the study; 2) implementing short-term proposed improvements; 3) evaluating proposed projects early in the design process to understand their individual effectiveness and eligibility for grant funding; and 4) performing feasibility studies of existing and proposed pump stations to determine details of a proposed design. City Engineer Ohrenstein provided an overview of the Basin 4 Assessment identifying key issues with the current system. He explained that the conveyance system is not interconnected with roads often functioning as storage and conveyance instead of swales and pipes. He noted that many pipe outfalls are undersized, some catch basins are at grade and inefficient at collecting water, and driveways and sump systems are obstructing flow. He presented various improvement scenarios and their estimated costs, emphasizing that a higher level of service can be achieved through a gravity or pumped system. He suggested that existing infrastructure needs to be upgraded, the conveyance system must be connected to outfalls and outfalls and pipes need to be enlarged to meet service-level goals. He further explained that the overall cost depends on sea level rise projections, service level criteria, system storage capacity, and water quality treatment. He suggested funding the project through a Stormwater millage rate increase dedicated to stormwater and climate resilience initiatives. Council Member Penniman suggested increasing the pipe size and introducing pump systems to all stormwater sub-basins. Council Member Christman suggested prioritizing Basin 4 due to extensive flooding in that area.

City Council Workshop Meeting – January 13, 2025 – 8:33 a.m. 9 Public Comment: Frank Cerveny, a resident of Gulf Shore Boulevard South, voiced concerns about the flooding in his neighborhood. He explained that his residence has experienced flooding from recent hurricanes as well as normal rain events and suggested replacing the 12-inch stormwater pipes in Basin 4 with 48-inch or even 72-inch pipes. He also cautioned against new development over the existing pipes, which could complicate future replacements. In response, Mayor Heitmann directed staff to contact Mr. Cerveny and provide recommendations on how his concerns will be addressed. Public Works Director Middleton concluded the presentation by explaining that its purpose was to inform City Council about the necessary work and to recommend prioritizing and consolidating the studies. He noted that the item on the January 15, 2025, agenda would involve deciding whether to advance the Kimley-Horn & Associates study to the next phase. Agenda Memorandum Combined Program Presentation Multi-Basin Plan Final Report KHA Basin 4 Final Report AECOM Resolution KH Implementation Plan Task Order Recess: 5:45 p.m. to 5:52 p.m. It is noted for the record that the same Council Members were present when the meeting reconvened. 6.G) DISCUSSION REGARDING THE APPOINTMENT OF AN INTERIM CITY MANAGER AND PERMANENT CITY MANAGER. City Manager Jay Boodheshwar briefly reviewed the agenda memorandum. Mayor Heitmann expressed a preference for appointing a full-time City Manager rather than an interim one. She recommended current Deputy City Manager/CFO Finance Director Gary Young for the position, highlighting his qualifications and suggesting that his term aligns with the three years remaining in her mayoral term. Council Members voiced their support for Deputy City Manager Young, emphasizing his qualifications and suitability for the role. Deputy City Manager Gary Young expressed his gratitude for being considered for the City Manager position and outlined several ongoing projects he was eager to see through to completion during the next three years of his planned term. He also stated that, upon his appointment, he would hire an interim Finance Director to fill his current role. Mayor Heitmann announced that a contract for Deputy City Manager Young would be presented to City Council at the January 15, 2025 meeting. If approved, Mr. Young would sign the contract and be sworn in at the February 5, 2025, City Council meeting. City Manager Boodheshwar expressed his support for Deputy City Manager Young and assured that he would facilitate a smooth transition. He noted that the contract might not be ready in time for the January 15th meeting but stated that Deputy City Manager Young could sign a contract at the February 5, 2025, City Council meeting that would be retroactive to February 1, 2025. City Manager Boodheshwar noted that he would not be in attendance at the February 5, 2025 meeting and suggested that a motion be proffered at the January 15, 2025, meeting to announce the City Manager appointment. The motion would serve to bridge the gap between the two meetings, he said. Agenda Memorandum 8) PUBLIC COMMENTS 9) COMMUNICATIONS FROM THE MAYOR, CITY COUNCIL, AND STAFF Council Member Christman expressed interest in participating in the January 20, 2025, Martin Luther King Jr. Parade and Celebration. He requested information for himself and other Council Members. In addition, he asked for updates on the 1st Avenue South Parking Garage, and on condominium inspections.

City Council Workshop Meeting – January 13, 2025 – 8:33 a.m. 10 Council Member Petrunoff announced that a Tiger Dam demonstration is scheduled for Thursday, January 16, 2025, at 10:30 a.m. at the City of Naples Fire Rescue Station #1. She explained that Tiger Dam is a perimeter flood protection system capable of extending to 32 feet. She also announced a meeting later that day at 2:00 p.m. at the Norris Community Center with the Fire Department and Building Department to discuss flood panels and other flood protection devices, inviting other Council Members to attend. In response, City Attorney Matthew McConnell advised that if more than one Council Member plans to attend, a public notice must be published through the City Clerk’s office. Council Member Petrunoff expressed concern over the number of events held at City Parks. In addition, she suggested that the City Clerk schedule public training sessions for utilizing LaserFiche. Regarding the City’s Priority List, she proposed temporarily removing lower-priority items to maintain focus on higher-priority initiatives. She also voiced concern about the lack of discussion on the Basin Stormwater Projects earlier that day, citing the length of the meeting as a limiting factor. To address this going forward, she suggested scheduling only one agenda item per department on future agendas to allow for more in-depth discussions. Additionally, Council Member Petrunoff raised concerns about after-curfew flights at Naples Airport, referencing a flight incident at 1:30 a.m. on January 1, 2025. While acknowledging that the City cannot regulate flights, she suggested closing the airport parking lot after the voluntary curfew to discourage after-curfew flights. In response, Mayor Heitmann suggested that City Council appeal to the Naples Airport Authority for more information on the incident. Vice Mayor Hutchison emphasized the need to refocus on City priorities and sought clarification on the rollout of the LaserFiche program. He also addressed the importance of staff support for security at special events within the City and highlighted the need to prioritize funding options for resiliency initiatives. Mayor Heitmann expressed concern about restoring grass areas, trees, and seawalls following the replacement of reclaimed water lines along the beach between Central Avenue and South Golf Drive. 10) ADJOURNMENT 6:43 p.m. _______________________ Teresa Lee Heitmann, Mayor ______________________________ Patricia L. Rambosk, City Clerk Meeting clerked by: ________________________________ Jessica R. Rosenberg, Deputy City Clerk Minutes prepared by: Dave Horton, Executive Assistant Minutes Approved: 2/20/2025.

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
AgendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Agenda packetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Action agendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Transcript or captionsNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Recording and media

Coverage and corrections

Records considered

  • City Council Workshop Meeting — Minutes

Not claimed by this page

  • Verified meeting decisions with item-specific public-source evidence
  • Item-level plain-language summaries are not available; this page does not infer individual agenda items.
  • Item-linked, attributed deliberation
  • A source-grounded next meeting date
  • Official outcomes have not been published.
  • A transcript is not available.
  • Speakers have not been reliably matched to public profiles.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.
  • An individual roll-call roster is not available.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: 3408b6b2fa5de774d2e40775e81238a3. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record