POLISCOPE

The public record

PASADENA (LOS ANGELES COUNTY)Held · official record pendingPartial coverage

City Council Meeting: October 13, 2026 (Audio Description)

Tuesday, October 13, 2026 · Government meeting record

The 30-second read

Record incomplete

City Council Meeting: October 13, 2026 (Audio Description)

Why it matters

The official meeting record is available below. Item-level plain-language summaries are not available yet.

What happens next

The scheduled meeting date has passed. Minutes or an action agenda are not published in the records we hold.

This meeting date has passed and no official outcome record has been published yet. Nothing on this page is a decision.

Transcript and record text

Closed captionsWhat was said at the meeting, transcribed Oct 17, 2026. Speech is not a decision.
  • No speaker turns were supplied with this transcript.
  • This transcript has no source timestamps.
  • No speaker identities were supplied with this transcript.

This source published text without speaker turns, so speakers and timestamps are not shown.

The opening of 158,089 stored characters

[AD] Council members face the audience from a curved dais. [CC] Recording in progress. [AD] Council members face the audience from a curved dais. [CC] Mayor and council, we are live. Thank you, Mr. Clerk. Good afternoon, everyone. Welcome to the October 13th, 2026 meeting of the Pasadena City Council. The council, well, we'll start with the recalling of the roll. Council Member Cole. Council Member Hampton is not here. Council Member Jones. Here. Council Member Lyon. Here. Councilor Madison here counselor Masuda here vice mayor Rivas here mayor Bordeaux here. There's a quorum the council president. Thank you and I'll ask miss Rivas to lead us in the Pledge of Allegiance [AD] Council members and audience rise for the Pledge of Allegiance. [AD] Council members and audience sit down. [AD] Mayor Gordo walks from the dais to the podium for ceremonial matters. Okay, if I could ask our city attorney Our chief assistant city prosecutor Tim Wellman and Linda Alessandra O'Fray and Tunisia O'Fray from Shepherd's Door as [CC] well as Alessandra Marinelli [AD] Honorees join Mayor Gordo at the podium. [CC] well as Alessandra Marinelli [AD] Honorees join Mayor Gordo at the podium. [CC] from Peace Over Violence to [CC] from Peace Over Violence to join me. And we also have a representative from our Pasadena Police Department, Dean Bistrofeld. Thank you. So colleagues, you all know that this is Domestic Violence Awareness Month. Nearly one in three women and four men in our country have suffered physical violence by an intimate partner. And domestic violence impacts people of every age, ethnicity, nationality, and economic status and belief. And these crimes are often perpetrated in what we consider the safest of places, our homes. And so it's important for us to recognize that domestic violence is not acceptable in anyone's home against anyone, whether it's in our city of Pasadena or beyond. And so it's in that spirit that we reaffirm as a city, its dedication to providing a community where no one suffers the pain and hardship caused by domestic violence. And on behalf of the City Council, I do hereby proclaim October, 2026 as Domestic Violence Awareness Month and would like to present a commendation to peace over violence. [CC] Ms. Marinelli, [AD] Mayor Gordo presents a proclamation to Alessandra Marinelli. [CC] Ms. Marinelli, [AD] Mayor Gordo presents a proclamation to Alessandra Marinelli. [CC] thank you for your work in this area [CC] thank you for your work in this area in our community. And also to Tunisia O'Fray, who also has a tremendous history here in Pasadena [CC] and working on this issue. [AD] Mayor Gordo presents a proclamation to Tunisia O'Fray. [CC] and working on this issue. [AD] Mayor Gordo presents a proclamation to Tunisia O'Fray. [CC] So thank you to both of you, [AD] Mayor Gordo presents a proclamation to Tunisia O'Fray. [CC] your supporters and for your work. [CC] your supporters and for your work. And of course, I would be remiss if I didn't think our own staff within the city prosecutor's office as well as our police department and city attorney. I think you all for your work. I would just note that these organizations have been working with the city prosecutor's office with the police department as resources available to victims of domestic violence. And they are a place to go. We also have victim witness advocate who is a coordinator as well. So we want to thank those organizations for all that they do in working with us to protect those in the city of Pasadena. And of course Chief Harris is also here. Thank you Chief for your efforts. [AD] The group poses for a photo. at the time. Thank you for what you do. Thank you for working with us. Thank you, Mayor. Now the city manager has a an announcement that is sad and we should all join in our best wishes to a family the family of a city employee. Yeah, thank you, Mayor. It's with sadness that I informed the council and the community tonight regarding the recent passing of one of our city employees, her name Nancy Defoya Gutierrez. Nancy began her service with the city in 2008 as a Community Service Rep 2 in Human Services and Recreation Department, and then was reclassified in 2017 to Community Service Rep 3 in the department, which you may now known as Parks, Rec, and Community Services. After serving the city for 16 years in PRCS, she was promoted Program Coordinator 1 in the Rent Stabilization Department, and I she was the first employee of the rent stabilization department outside of the acting director. And that's where she served until her passing. So Nancy will truly be missed. Excuse me, she was a dedicated employee. Wow, this is hard. A dedicated employee of 18 years. So our thoughts and prayers are with her and her family during this difficult time. Thank you, Mr. City Manager. And for those of us who had the honor and privilege of working with Nancy, as I did, we join in your comments. And of course, we'll adjourn in memory of Nancy and we'll send a letter to her family as is our custom. Mr. Jones. Thanks, Mayor. And it is extremely sad news. As we know, Nancy worked at the JRCC and I've seen her there and so I just my thoughts and prayers go out to her family and so our city employees as well because you know when you work with somebody they become your family essentially too. Well said. Okay so we will adjourn as requested by the city manager. And then mayor if I could just comment before we get into the agenda I believe item 10 the Tefer hearing is gonna be canceled. That's correct so if you are here for item 10 or you're in for item 10, the TEFRA hearing on Colorado Boulevard. That item is pulled from the agenda and will not be heard, but you can still remain tuned in if you like. Next, we'll, oh, I did want to invite all of you tomorrow morning, Pastor Kerwin Manning will be here and is celebrating his service and I will join him. So that's at 10 a.m. tomorrow here at the Rotunda City Hall if you're around and available. With that, we will turn to public comment for matters not on the agenda. How many cards, Mr. Clerk? We have currently seven cards. I would also note that we did get a speaker card for item number 10, and it's from P.A. Brown. So I would just say to Mr. Brown, oh, and we're not going to be taking item 10. The public hearing is being canceled. So if you would like to speak on that item, maybe do it during public comment on matters not on the agenda, since it's being canceled. OK, I will call Sonia Burns, Eric Su, Renee Gonzalez, Danny Clash, Anthony Edson, Howard Tan, and then Greg Hedrick, and then P.A. Brown and Erica Foy, I think is going to be doing that. Ms. Byrne, welcome. If you heard your name, [CC] please form a line in the center aisle so that we can get through public comment. Ms. Byrne? [AD] Public speaker Sonia Bernt approaches the podium. [CC] please form a line in the center aisle so that we can get through public comment. Ms. Byrne? [CC] please form a line in the center aisle so that we can get through public comment. Ms. Byrne? Thank you. Good evening. I have two issues. First, at the September 29th council meeting, council member Hampton asked housing staff Poe, when the city runs out of motel vouchers, will the council be notified? Staff stated, quote, we can certainly notify you guys when that happens, unquote. However, at the August 5th HHP meeting, housing staff had already acknowledged they don't have enough vouchers and that they have not notified the council as it previously requested. staff said with 300 persons sleeping on the street they can always use more vouchers assistant city manager page said that the policy regarding notifying council when motel vouchers run out quote it's not clear we need to have a discussion unquote so no there aren't nearly enough motel vouchers and this needs to be agendized urgently secondly at the CPOC meeting last week chief Harris gave a detailed PowerPoint on PPD activities for the first six months of this year, except as to homelessness, zero data was presented. Chief Harris briefly discussed some changes in enforcement. The new community impact team will handle all quality of life issues. He said, quote, we need to address, quote, the community's request, unquote, but he gave no information on how the codes will be enforced. We have over 300 unsheltered folks who sleep on the street and have no bathrooms to relieve themselves. Back in September 2024, the council and the community were assured that there would be no change in enforcement of codes related to or unhoused notwithstanding the Grants Pass case unless and until the council makes that change. We've been given no data on how PPD is handling issues related to homelessness. Please agendize the topic of PPD enforcement of these issues and instruct PPD to provide specific data on how violations are being handled. Thank you. Thank you Eric Sue followed by Renee Gonzales then Danny Clash then Anthony Edson if Mr. [CC] Gonzales and Mr. Clash and Mr. Edson could please line up. Go ahead. [AD] Public speaker Eric Su approaches the podium. [CC] Gonzales and Mr. Clash and Mr. Edson could please line up. Go ahead. [CC] Thank you Mr. Sue. Hi I live on Fair Oaks and Esther Street and recently the specific plan was approved there. I believe that MHCH will be proposing $20,000 allocated to sidewalk improvements in the area, and I'd like to voice my support for that allocation in light of Rick Cole's previous comments about actually implementing the plan and getting things done rather than having it remain as a piece of paper. And I'd also like to sincerely thank you all for approving the plan. I believe it will improve my neighborhood. Thank you. [CC] Thank you, Mr. Su. [AD] Public speaker Rene Gonzalez approaches the podium. [CC] Thank you, Mr. Su. [AD] Public speaker Rene Gonzalez approaches the podium. [CC] Mr. Gonzalez, welcome. Thank you, Mayor Gordo. Honorable members of the Council, October 14 is National Sister Cities Day, commemorating President Eisenhower's birthday and honoring his global peace vision in the 1956 White House Conference on Citizen Diplomacy and People-to-People Relationships. Seventy years later, as the Latin Heritage Month ends on October 15, Pasadena has no Latin American sister city flags on these chambers, despite generations of Latin American families helping build our city. For me, the absence of a Mexican flag is a painful reminder of Pasadena's history of discrimination, redlining, exclusion, and poor representation. After three years of civic dedication, completing the formal Guanajuato sister city proposal process and placing our trust elected officials we feel deeply disappointed and betrayed. That broken trust has even discouraged some of our members and dedicated volunteers from participating in civic affairs. Yet we remain hopeful that we can all change this narrative. Today I respectfully request that this Council supports an October 14, 2027, Pasadena Sister City Day Proclamation or Resolution, and began to work with Sister Cities International California representatives to restore trust, citizen diplomacy and advance or formal Guanajuato Sister City affiliation with no further delays, personal ego or politics. We may hopefully celebrate next year's Latin Heritage Month with a Mexican flag proudly display in these chambers. Thank you for your attention. May God bless the future Children of Pasadena and peace throughout the world. Thank you. Danny Clash, Mr Gonzalez. Just so you're aware, we we I recently recognized exchanged communications with the mayor of Guanajuato. We are now a friendship city. Um, and the flag has been ordered and will be displayed appropriately. Thank you. Mayor, excuse me, but I just have to state my disagreement with what you just said and for reasons that I think we've discussed before. And I hope that we do move forward to formally offer through the powers vested only in the City Council, not in the mayor, not in any one of us, that the City Council exercise its power to extend an invitation to Guanajuato to be a sister city. It's far, far beyond the time where we should have already done that. The authority to recognize friendship cities is is with the mayor is my understanding. That's incorrect, Mayor. But I don't want to debate it now. And I don't want to be impertinent here. But it's the sister city organization that changed the rules to authorize the mayor to do that is and has been operating unlawfully because they're not in good standing under California law and mr. Gonzalez has formed a new organization which lawfully this council could consider the application of Guanajuato because they picked up the work that had already been done and again I think everyone knows how I feel about that we disagree I respect your opinion but well it's a fact that it's the mayor of the city has always had the authority to recognize friendship cities I've recognized a number of them but we can read it and it's not on the agenda it's not on the agenda so brief response can we agendize it for a discussion mayor let's let's let's see how this goes next Danny Clash is not here okay moving on to Anthony Edson then Howard Tan, Anthony Edson, are you here? Howard Tan. [AD] Public speaker Howard Tan approaches the podium. Evening Mayor, council members, and the city staff. My name is Howard Tan. Having recently concluded my service as residents, having recently concluded my service as commissioner on the Parks and Rec creation and community service commission. I want to thank the council and the city for the privilege to serve our community. I am speaking tonight as a concerned Pasadena citizen and community steward regarding the ongoing situation with the Rose Bowl Riders, an 80 year old institution currently facing eviction. The fundamental issue before us is a breakdown in our communication and a lack of open dialogue between the city and key stakeholders. Rigid demands and closed processes have created an avoidable crisis that threatens a long standing community asset. As stewards of our public spaces and community programming, the city bears responsibility to maintain a proactive, transparent engagement with the groups and residents directly impacted by its decisions. This affects our youth, our community, and the broader character of Pasadena. Community assets that take decades of grassroots doerships to build can be dismantled overnight when administrative processes replace genuine collaboration. I urge you tonight or anytime, deposit eviction proceedings, direct staff to engage in transparent, good faith dialogue and work collaboratively towards a workable resolution. Thank you for your time, leadership and service to the community. Jill Shook followed by Chico Dilly Udengwu, then Erica Foy, then P.A. Brown, then Greg Hedrick. Is Jill Shook here? And she's not online? Okay. Chico Dilly Udengwu, I thought I saw you, there you are. [AD] A public speaker approaches the podium. [CC] Two minutes, go ahead. Good evening Mayor and City Council. Could you bring the microphone down a little bit? Right away, thank you. I'm here again to request to file a missing person report for my son, Michael C. Ogbodo and Uzamaka R. Ogbodo. I've requested to speak to some of the members of the police department and the mayor. In addition to the missing person report for my two kids, I'm also requesting to four incident reports, the one that happened on the two, on 5-26-26 and 5-27-26, 12-16-25, and 12-15-25. The incident that happened on June 5th, 2022, and June 6th, 2022, where I was transferred to Linwood Jail and released to return to claim my property. And my property and the documents with the basis of which I was removed from my home, missing from my property. And also, my SIM card, both of them were missing. I didn't realize it until late. Now, for the past 11 years, I've been coming here in and out for the experiences that I've encountered in the city. I have to pause for you guys to give me a response because the issue of my son and my daughter is urgent. Thank you. Thank you, ma'am. Yes, next speaker. Ma'am, it's not our, we are forbidden by law from engaging in a discussion for something that's not on the agenda. Okay. We would refer you back to the police department. But that's what I've been going on. Ma'am, thank you. Erica Foy. May I would like that to be agendized. Thank you ma'am. Agendized. We cannot agendize personal matters. No it's not personal matters. Ma'am thank you. Ma'am we want to be fair to everyone please. Next speaker. Erica Foy. [AD] Public speaker Erica Foy approaches the podium. Good evening mayor and council members. Tonight you were supposedly going to be asked to authorize 42 million dollars in tax exempt bond financing for 144 apartments at 2000 East Colorado. Your resolution asks you to find that this financing is in the public interest for the public benefit. I have several questions I'd like council to ask staff. First, why approve financing before the design commission completes its review? Maybe you decided, maybe you changed your mind since you're not hearing it tonight. But we're looking at 78 foot building where the usual height limit is 39 feet, Significantly reduced open space, only 64 parking spaces for 144 apartments and concerns about massing blank walls and long facades. Have those concerns been addressed? I hope so. Second, will this property pay property taxes or qualify for an exemption? If exempt, how much revenue would Pasadena otherwise receive? Third, tomorrow's housing committee reports identifies 4,160 apartments in our development pipeline, including 1,525 affordable units. Shouldn't we be keeping a running total of how much potential property tax revenue we're giving up? We don't build affordable housing in a bubble, and it isn't free. These buildings need fire protection, police, streets, and other city services. Are we comparing those costs with the revenue they generate? We're asking residents to consider another tax for our fire stations? Are we placing more pressure on existing taxpayers with tax exemptions? I think many of us have reached our limit on being asked for more money. When Council declares something in the public interest and for the public benefit, shouldn't we look at the impact on the entire city, not just the number of affordable units? Thank you very much. Thank you. PA [CC] Brown. Mr. Brown. Thank you Mayor. Good evening Council members. I have a [AD] Public speaker P.A. Brown approaches the podium. [CC] Brown. Mr. Brown. Thank you Mayor. Good evening Council members. I have a [CC] Brown. Mr. Brown. Thank you Mayor. Good evening Council members. I have a 2000 East Colorado project This is a very important project 143 rental units 100% affordable housing along East Colorado a part of this city that needs more Multifamily housing it could bring greater vitality to the area more more people for business More students for the schools and I will note that the schools that serve What will be this building if it if it goes forward are significantly under capacity so they need more students and this project would bring them more students. Approving the resolution that you were going to vote on tonight but hopefully we'll consider another time is exactly the right thing to do. The city should be doing everything possible in its power to facilitate these type of projects, fast-tracking or removing bureaucratic requirements and taking the action that needs to be done so they can be billed. Second thing I just wanted to mention this evening is Governor Newsom, as you all know, signed into law last week the plug-in solar bill. This plug-in solar legislation promises great possibilities for those in apartments or condos in Pasadena. And I hope PWP can encourage implementation of plug-in solar by residents as soon as possible. Thank you. So Danny Clash, Anthony Edson, Jill Shook are not in the room. We'll go to Greg Hedrick. Oh, sorry. Who's here? Please come forward. [AD] Public speaker Anthony Edson approaches the podium. Mr. Edson. I'll ring a bell when you have 30 seconds left. You have two minutes. Go ahead. Thank you. Good evening. My name is Anthony Edson. I'm joined tonight by my mother, Jerry Edson, and I'm following up on the email that was sent to you all last week about Pasadena's fair return process. Rent control is only constitutional when owners have a working path to a fair return. Fair return is the line between lawful regulation and regulatory taking. In my opinion, Pasadena does not have a working path. I say that as the first owner Pasadena to win a fair return petition. The hearing officer found our building entitled to an upward adjustment. However, more than 400 days after we filed that adjustment has not been able to be implemented. Why? Because the city is working with broken tools and a broken process. So let's start with the tools. Every petition runs through the city's worksheet model. The model currently posted on the city's website does not comply with the city's regulations. Then the process, and this was what happened to my case. Four days before the 60-day decision, my case was continued. The clock was restarted. When my decision came, it contained basic arithmetic errors, the kind that a simple review would have caught. But the only way to fix them is filing appeal. We filed an appeal that said unscheduled for months. We first were told that there was a meeting room that needed to be scheduled. Then we were told that the board needed more workshops unfair return. Now measure H took effect in December of 22. We are nearly in 2027 and the body that decides these appeals and still needs workshops to understand them. Only after I wrote to this body, did I actually get an appeal date. Each step may be defensible on its own, but together they amount to an indefinite delay and none of this is new. The delay hurts the tenants to while case drags on continuances, errors and repeated hearings, tenants live with uncertainties about what their will be and a timely accurate process serves everyone. I ask for three things an enforceable deadlines with decisions and appeals a way to correct clear math errors without a month's long appeals and a worksheet that actually applies the regulations as written. Measure H is constitutional not because fair return exists on paper. Sir your time has expired. Thank you. Jill Shook I see steaming into the room and then Greg Hedrick who will be participating [CC] online. Ms. Shook, [AD] Public speaker Jill Shook approaches the podium. [CC] online. Ms. Shook, welcome. Welcome, thank you. Someone named Danny Clash will be here very shortly. He also has a public comment and we're both part of the public art team to help identify the Black Legacy District and we come here to thank you for supporting the Black Legacy District. There's a lot of joy going on right now about the decision you all made. So I also am thinking about what I've heard our mayor say many times about being the center of the universe. And there's actually some of that kind of coming true in terms of an article as a result of the decision you made last week. It came out with a group called By Black. It's an amazing article. I made copies for you. [CC] And so it's gone nationwide, and so I have copies to give you now. [AD] Jill Shook holds up a printed article. [CC] And so it's gone nationwide, and so I have copies to give you now. [AD] Jill Shook holds up a printed article. [CC] It features Loretta, who spoke last week, and how she came from Phoenix as a little [CC] It features Loretta, who spoke last week, and how she came from Phoenix as a little girl to visit her dad here, and just the pride that she had when she could come here and see people that look like her, that own businesses, lawyers, doctors, all kinds of folks that made her believe she could be and do anything. And so I think that this is just a huge first step, not only for the Black legacy district, but I hope to see a Latino district. I hope to see an Armenian district. We really need to celebrate the beautiful cultures of this city. But we can't do this without funding. I know Tyrone talked about the importance of funding. So we'd love to be able to have banners up as you recommended by the Black History Parade. We need at least 20,000 to begin to move that forward. So I'm hoping you can agendize that and see if you can find somewhere that we can make this happen. But I'm proud of you and I thank you. Thank you. Thank you, Ms. Schuch. Greg Hedrick. [AD] Public Speaker Greg Hedrick participates remotely. Next speaker. He's online. Oh, he's online, okay. Is he in the meeting? Mr. Hedrick, you're muted. Can you hear me now? Yes, go ahead. Okay, give me two seconds. I'm here tonight to speak about the Rose Bowl writers. The Rose Bowl writer board has repeatedly requested a meeting with the city leadership. Not one meeting has been scheduled. City officials and city employees have found time to communicate with individuals advocating for a removal, but the city has not found time to meet with the leadership of the Rose Bowl writers as they have The city has acknowledged possessions of disclosable records, but we're still waiting for them. You can terminate an 80-year-old institution, but you can't find the time to face the people affected. What exactly is so hard about having a conversation? And here's what makes this extraordinary. We're all right here, right now in the room. No scheduling conflicts, no unanswered emails, and no excuses. Will you guys commit to setting a meeting tonight before we all leave? Is your public comment done? Thank you. Yeah, I asked a question. Thank you. We are prohibited by law from engaging with the public on matters not properly on the agenda. That completes public comment on matters not on the agenda. Okay. With that, let's move on to the consent calendar. We have a speaker card on item one. we have a speaker card on item four and I know council member Jones is recused on item six mayor did you have a I'm sorry there's the there's an operating budget amendment that's item five oh it's eight item eight so if we can hold item from a sweep motion. Well we have to hold one four six and eight from the sweep motion. Okay why don't we do public comment on all of them. Okay that's fine. And we'll go we'll do that. All right sounds good. Item one is Igor Schumach. Item four is Sonia Berndt for the consent calendar. [CC] Igor Schumach? Yes. Okay [AD] Public Speaker Igor Schumach participates remotely. [CC] Igor Schumach? Yes. Okay [AD] Public Speaker Igor Schumach participates remotely. [CC] oh you're online go ahead. Hi I was reading the staff report and I do not [CC] oh you're online go ahead. Hi I was reading the staff report and I do not see two critical things indicated in it. At the bottom of page one, it states that although the contractor outsource is contractually responsible for completing the cable removal and replacement, the team, the power delivery team, field personnel indicated substantial operational risks if the contract is unable to complete the work as planned. But there is no indication if the contractor is financially responsible for the delay. And if so, to what degree? So in other words, my question, will the contractor be financially responsible for the cost of this rental? And later on, it states that the rental could be a maximum period up to 12 months. So my second question is, will the equipment be rented for all 12 months at once or on a monthly basis and see how long that's needed? And if so, what is the incentives for the contractor to complete the work as soon as possible, if the city will swallow the cost of the necessary equipment rental. Thank you. [AD] Public Speaker Sonia Burns. [CC] Thank you. [AD] Public Speaker Sonia Burns. [CC] Next speaker. Sonia Burns. On number four. I don't oppose this agenda item, but a short discussion of the history of this project is in order. So hopefully, we don't ever dump enormous funds and delay a lot of time into one affordable housing project again. Way back in December 2020, the city entered into exclusive negotiations with National Corps for a development and lease agreement, the key terms of which were approved in November 2022. At that time, the estimated total cost of the project was just under $63 million. Less than seven months ago, the estimated total cost was $83.1 million, and now it's jumped to $87.8 million, with a per-unit cost of $878,000. Why the extra 25 million? Only 48 of the 100 units will be set aside for seniors experiencing homelessness. Completion of construction is not expected until the end of 2028. As of the 2026 homeless count, we had 577 unhoused persons, 322 of which have no shelter at all. If the city commits to any more affordable housing projects like this one, we will never even make a dent in our homelessness crisis. The city must pursue cheaper housing models like modular housing. Also, I was informed recently that converting existing motels, hotels to housing would cost less than $300,000 per unit. Our unsheltered residents cannot wait years and years for the city to create the affordable housing needed to take them off the street. Many suffer from serious chronic illness and our own housing staff has described life on the street as, quote, very unsafe, unquote. Please provide keen oversight of this project until it's finished. Also, please urgently pursue quicker, less costly affordable housing models for a city. Other cities are doing it. We don't have to wait and have this huge amount of money. I mean, it's not city money. I mean, we have some loans. This is another $2.7 some million of home funding. We can do it much cheaper. Thank you. Thank you, Ms. Spur. That completes public comment on the consent calendar. I'm just double checking at the bottom here. Yeah, that completes public comment on the consent calendar. So we need a sweet motion for everything except for six and eight. Sweet motion on the consent calendar with the exception of six and eight made by Mr. Masuda, seconded by Mr. Lyon. Are there any objections? I'm not, I don't object. I did that just a comment okay very briefly and I appreciate I don't know if your microphones on let's think it is oh it is okay I appreciate miss burnt on being here and advocating for you know housing regularly it means a lot I do I would like to see agenda item at the homeless housing and what is your new planning thank you it's a lot it's a lot but but I mean you guys got a lot of work you know ahead of you and for the whole entire community in the city and so I know that this is near dear to all of us but 80 use for residents if a resident wants to house someone for for an average person to build a DU or their existing garage, it may cost 80,000 to 120,000. And Ms. Berner's 100% right. There are other models out here that are a lot less expensive and why we're still going a million dollars per unit or $800,000 per unit. When there are residents out here that would happily house someone if the city is helping finance the building of their ADU. I know that we already do a program similar to this, but maybe we need to expand on that program. We can certainly look at the issue of ADUs and the status of various options because the state, the state has changed quite a bit in the area of ADUs so we'll agendize. And not just ADUs, but all other modular homes, containers, etc. Yeah, thank you. Thank you. So we'll definitely, it's a good suggestion from Ms. Burke and you, Councilman so we'll we'll take it up okay so we have a motion in a second to approve all consent items except for items eight six and eight okay item six any objections item six no no any objections to the motion thank you see you no objections thank you no no item six item six okay so out of an In abundance of caution, I will recuse myself from item six because this includes my direct employer at LA County Public Works, thank you. Okay, Mr. Jones will step out and is now out of the room. Is there a motion on item six? So moved. Seconded by Mr. Lyons, seconded by Mr. Hampton. Are there any objections? Seeing none, the matter is approved. Mr. Jones comes back. As it relates to item eight, I'm asking that we bifurcate or separate an issue for a separate motion. It includes item eight is the amendment to our capital improvement program and it includes a lighting district in which I own a home and so it's been my practice to recuse on that very specific item And so I will recuse myself for the Raymond Avenue Lighting District. So they'll vote on the one that you're the area that you're recused from first. OK, and then I'll make a motion for the item minus the Raymond. No, he needs to. OK, you need to take that one up first. Yeah, well, yeah, you want to you want to be here for that. Well, he wants to be here for the item. The recusal has to go first. But they have to vote on his recusal first. OK. So I'll hand it over to Ms. Riegel. All right. Hold on a second. So the mayor is now recused and leaving at 6.42. So we need a motion for just. I'll move the recommendation on this specific item that the mayor's recused. The Raymond. I'll second. On the lighting. The Raymond what? Oh, lighting. What number is it in the staff report? The records. Number eight. There's a lot of things about lighting here. I think we need to have staff. It's five million dollars that has already been budgeted in the capital budget for the Raymond Avenue undergrounding project. It's project number four on project four. Yeah, so it's agenda item eight sub four in the staff report, right? Thank you. So we have a motion and a second. Any objections? I just have one question, Vice Mayor, for staff. Are all of these recommendations organic from the staff? To call. Yes. OK, great. Thank you. Thanks, Vice Mayor. Any objections? Seeing none, the item passes. Bring the mayor back in. So the mayor can return on the rest. The mayor can return. Thank you. Make the motion on the rest of the item. Second. Seconded by Mr. Hampton. okay then moved remaining by mr. Hampton it was second it was made by vice mayor Revis seconded by mr. Hampton thank you to approve the rest of the recommendations except for the item for okay I don't think you we need to so we call roll no call vote are there any objections are there any objections I thought you were asking for a roll call vote. It was not. Mr. Clerk, there's every. You're gonna make me turn red now, thanks. Just once a meeting. Yeah. Are there any objections? Seeing none, the matter's approved, and the clerk agrees. And the clerk agrees, and with a red face. You wanna go to the ordinance and do that quickly before that? Okay, so we have an ordinance, item 12. This is an uncautified ordinance of the City of Pasadena, exempting qualifying Eaton fire repairs from construction tax. This was initially introduced by Council Member Hampton. This is the second reading to adopt. Council Member Cole? Yes. Council Member Hampton? Council Member Jones? Yes. Council Member Lyon? Yes. Council Member Masson? Yes. Council Member Masuda? Yes. Vice Mayor Rivas? Yes. Mayor Gordo? Yes. The ordinance is adopted unanimously. Thank you. And just again, item 10, the tougher hearing has canceled and will be re-noticed. So now we are moving on to item 11, which is surface type selection for Villa Park and Robinson Park athletic fields. And we have 25 speaker cards for this item. [CC] Just letting the council know. [AD] Staff member Koko Panosian approaches the podium. [CC] Just letting the council know. Good evening, Mayor Gordo, members of council, Koko Panosian representing the parks recreation community services department. We are here today to ask you to approve the recommendation finding this item categorically exempt from CEQA because it is an existing facility and it is a replacement. We're also asking you, recommending that you approve the replacement of the existing two artificial turf fields at Villa Park and Robinson Park with advanced artificial turf systems, ones that have, that reduce, remove PFAS from manufacturing and they're also with natural infill. In addition, we're asking you to direct staff to continue to evaluate natural grass for future renovation projects. What we found in our conversation with other agencies that public agencies as well as school districts continue to rely on artificial turf for uses, such as soccer and football, that are very heavy uses. Yet they maintain a very healthy inventory of natural grass fields. So is the case with us. So with this recommendation, we are not establishing a policy city-wide just focusing on these two fields. We have a very healthy 20 fields, natural fields, that we will maintain. And this little pilot that we intend to is going to help us improve the quality of those fields for our users. Brief background, we have 22 athletic fields, two of them are official turf, one at Villa, one at Robinson. They were both installed approximately during 2009, 2011. Both were replaced 2017 and 18 under warranty. And the Villa Park one is currently funded through our capital projects, fiscal year 26, 27 capital projects. Robinson Park is also nearing its end of life, yet it is not funded. Couple of meetings we've attended with the Municipal Services Committee, one was back in March and one in June. During those meetings we had a very healthy discussion. The committee members had quite a few questions, and we're back to try and address all of those and seeking council's approval to move this project forward. Just to touch back also on the reasons why these fills were replaced on gone to artificial turf in the first place were four reasons. One, it was to reduce field downtime. It is to increase playability of the fields. It was to lower operational costs. And lastly, just to see reduction in undesired activity in the park. And we believe those are all prevalent issues that we continue to face at the moment. So let's look at the three service options. Council asked us to do an evaluation of these committee members, asked us to do an evaluation, include the hybrid grass as part of the evaluation. For natural grass, as it sounds, it is living grass, as such requires watering, mowing, fertilization. It is the coolest surface that you are going to find and natural attraction, especially if it's well maintained. It will require very heavy water usage. And it has, of all the comparisons to all of them, has the highest need for maintenance. As far as the closure during construction, for natural grass you're facing about a four to six month closure for the construction. And regularly, annually, we would have to shut down the field for three months for renovation as the impact of the activities will essentially destroy the grass will require to be shut down to be safe and reinvigorate again. For hybrid grass it's essentially the same as natural grass but it has little synthetic fibers that are tufted into the grass into a mesh netting. It plays like it's grass but it actually has a durability of the artificial turf. It's maintenance however the one thing to note with this as you continue to mow the grass you essentially start mowing some of the fibers the plastic fibers along with it thus in our conversation with the Rose Bowl staff when they experienced this they'd have to be bagged and disposed of properly at a landfill it cannot be used as green waste because of the fibers being reduced the synthetic fibers being cut along with it and we do not have a lot of information on this the closure timeline for renovation has not been established, we don't have a lot of information. We'll touch on that in the next couple of screens. And for artificial turf fields, they are synthetic fibers. The proposal is to use the organic infill materials. It is consistent surface, playing surface, but it gets a lot hotter than natural grass and the hybrid grass. Because it's plastic, it is going to see much higher temperatures as you play. The rubberized products that we currently have are a lot more higher than the natural infill. The fact that they're natural, they tend to be about 20% to 30% cooler than the rub rise, yet still higher than the natural grass. It requires minimal water. It is to keep the moisture within the field. Because it's natural, the moisture helps keep it cooler. But no comparison to living grass. And there will be no mowing or irrigation. And as far as maintenance goes, it's the lowest impact maintenance required. For the construction timeline, artificial turf, you're looking at a two to three month shutdown for the construction. and we don't anticipate any closures for renovation because it is grooming that we do a couple of times a year and that grooming can be done within the morning hours without impacting any activity. I want to extend my gratitude to our partners over at the Rose Bowl. They accepted us a couple of months back. We sat down and talked to their team about the hybrid reinforced product that they had. It was during the FIFA, the club world cup that was done last year. and FIFA came in and installed it for them. They do not, the estimates that we have for the costs are from a Palo Alto field, which was the closest we came to finding some information on a hybrid product. It is not very common in municipalities, especially in the US. Hybrid is used in European fields, very professional fields, because it's very costly to not only install, according to Rolls-Royce staff, it may be the same cost to renovate every time you have to address renovation for it, because they have to be tufted yet again. And the equipment, according to Roseville, came from Europe, so you're shipping the equipment and the material from Europe to be able to do the job. The City of Palo Alto did a recent study, similar to what we're doing right now, comparing the three, and based on their analysis of looking at the hybrid artificial turf and the natural grass, the City Council there directed their staff to proceed with artificial turf. as I lost my screen as we talked about a potential test pilot during the meetings we've held with the committees and even you know at this dais there been a lot of questions about how about trying different types of varieties of seed and that's what we'd like to do we like to dedicate this picture is the Villa Park multi-purpose field this is the open turf area that we use for athletics originally designed as open turf because the because of the demand that we have many of our facilities if it has open turf air like this is currently being used for athletics and sporting events. We like to take 25,000 square feet of this property, spill it into four, and then test four different types of varieties of seed to see which one is going to hold up. They're all going to get the same level of irrigation, maintenance, and mowing, fertilizing. And we're looking for, within a two-year time frame, having to do it a couple of times, to just do a comparison on how they establish, how they wear, the recovery, how fast they tear, and what type of resource each one is requiring an allocation of to see it through. Within a couple years, we'll be able to narrow it down to the best quality of seed for our 20 natural fields to be renovating annually. In looking at the life cycle cost comparison, we took the annual maintenance and renovation, and we added 3% escalation to it, figured it over a 10-year timeframe. We did the 10-year timeframe, Because if you look at the artificial turf in 10 years, roughly 8 to 10 years is the life cycle of an artificial turf. In 10 years, it has to be replaced. And there is an added cost for that replacement. Overall, if you look at it, natural grass, while it has the higher annual maintenance compared to artificial turf, it has a higher cost for regular annual maintenance. Overall, in a 10-year time frame, the fact that it doesn't have the $1.2 million re-renovation of the materials, it is estimated at 1.5 million dollars over 10 years. And on artificial turf, the fact that we have the 1.2 million capital that needs to be re-implemented in 10 years, that cost is looking at 2.4 million over two years. Now the hybrid, these are estimates, we had to take the study conducted by Palo Alto and configured their field size and factored in with our Villa Parks turf at 72,000 square feet, narrowed just the annual maintenance on that we do not have information on renovation based on my conversation with the Rose Bowl staff they believe it is the same as the initial initial installation cost which is estimated at two point two million dollars for a field of this size so based on those factors alone and not including renovation annual renovation that is estimated at two point eight million dollars cost per time of hour I believe council member Jones had asked at the last MSC meeting what does it cost for each one of these products if we do a comparison on and per our field we based it off of a prime time availability we consider pride town is 4 p.m. to 10 p.m. during the weekdays and saturday's open to close seven to ten for in for artificial turf that equates to about three thousand one or 20 hours for these fields specifically because they have lights fields that don't have lights actually add to much lower playability because in the winter time, you're not gonna get much playing time in the evenings. For artificial turf, it equates to 3,000 one or 20 hours. Break it divided by the cost for maintaining that facility. Maintenance and renovation factors only, not the capital. Wanna make sure we clarified that this does not include the capital investment, just maintenance and renovation. The per hour cost to play on artificial turf is $5.34. natural grass because of the shutdown of the three months for the renovation we've deducted that percentage from the available hours it is two thousand three hundred forty hours available for play and that breaks down to sixteen dollars and fifteen cents I will also note that the natural grass fields we have not factored in any closures for rainy days nor have we factored any closures for like extreme heat days this is just straightforward these are available hours if you're able to play every hour that is available these the cost per hour playability. And for the hybrid grass, we wanted to factor in a number to do a comparison, but this number still does not include any of the renovation costs that we don't know what they are, and still higher than both of the other products materials. On the side of the environmental and heat considerations, I want to extend my gratitude to our partners over at Public Health. Director Manuel Cormona is also here to address. They're helping us determine and draft a guideline for outdoor activity. And this is going to be applying to both natural grass and artificial turf fields. And it is looking to align with CIF and to use the wet bulb globe temperature, the WIBGIT. I'm calling it a WIBGIT, so he can explain better. We're looking at using that criteria to determine playability. And that will be consistent with CIF in a lot of schools. It would set the hydration, duration, and cancellation and thresholds for all of our activities within the parks. Taking each one individually, natural grass, it's in the name. It doesn't have any synthetic materials. It is natural, it doesn't have any PFAS because there's no synthetic components. PFAS has been one of the factors that we've heard a lot from community and council members as to concern related to environmental impacts. Heat, natural grass is gonna be the coolest of all the products that we've seen. And as long as it is, you know healthy and it's been irrigated it'll remain cool and then mitigation factors if it's higher temperatures doesn't really quite meet the threshold of cancellation as typically teams do now they'll add some additional hydration breaks to the process and You know regular irrigating and hydration could potentially mitigate some of the heat elements For the hybrid it is natural yet also the synthetic materials in there So the fiber composition of the fibers for the synthetic, we would have to ask the manufacturer to provide more information to see if it does contain PFAS. For heat, it is somewhat similar to natural grass. I would expect it to be a little warmer because it has some synthetic materials in there. But similarly, for mitigation, likely irrigation and hydration breaks can mitigate higher level of temperatures that doesn't result in a closure or cancellation of games. And for artificial turf fields, It is made of synthetic materials, and our proposal going forth is to use natural infill like cork, sand, coconut husks, olive pits. It's a combination of natural products that we can use as an infill. There are manufacturers that currently manufacture this product with no PFAS in there, and they can have third-party certifications of the product that doesn't have the PFAS. We just have to make sure that it is part of the scope, and they have to provide the proof, as well as comply with all applicable laws related to that. Heat, no question about it. Artificial turf is going to be warmer than the natural grass. Although, as we said earlier, the rubberized infill materials are a lot more significantly hotter than this particular product with the natural infill. It does keep it cooler, yet still warmer than grass. And for heat mitigation, once we develop the guidelines, we will follow that, whatever you come up with working with public health. But we'll definitely need some cooling, which is having to, in really extreme warm days, that doesn't meet the threshold for cancellation, maybe putting some irrigation, about four or five minutes of it, to kind of wet the material to keep it moist. And moisture being, keeps it cooler. And additional hydration breaks and likely scheduling changes could be anywhere from shifting schedules and or canceling games. Committee members also directed us to go back to POSD and the rules, we'll then talk to them about field availability to see what else we can add to the mix. In our conversations, it was pretty clear evident that there is limited availability. They have their own programs, and the challenge is a structured lead program that cannot be accommodated at these fields. They might be able to give us a day or so here and there to have an activity, but if you're looking at a structured programming that might be, well, it will be impacted by going to a natural grass, they're not able to accommodate. So the closures that are scheduled will require us to look at the entire season in the program and make some adjustments. Those adjustments could include having to play on weekends, Sundays especially. Right now they don't play on Sundays. Maybe look at shorter seasons. That's one option to consider. Additional games per week, and as a coach I can tell you one week they One game a week is the ideal model, but we'd have to sit down and have a conversation with the leagues that if we want To have a number of games to accommodate it. It's gonna have to be two games a week. Maybe one practice in two games There is a lot to kind of work out and depending on the direction we'd have to sit down with our partners and all of our users and determine how best to move that forward and We we do know that we have field constraints because the demand we're not able to meet the demand right now they kind of create the seasons that we have. Practically every season has every field used with very limited ability for us to even go in and do maintenance currently on our existing natural grass fields. Thus the artificial turf fields were developed and constructed about 15 years ago. As far as fiscal impact I want to note we erroneously in the document the agenda report the fiscal impact says nine hundred seventy five thousand dollars adopted. That's wrong That actually was the cost of the artificial turf. Council adopted the fiscal year 27 CIP with $1.125 million appropriated to this project. And at the time, the thinking was if council decides to go artificial turf, this will cover that cost. If council decides to go with natural grass, this will cover that cost. So if you pick either one of those, there will be no additional impact because it is budgeted. Only the time if you direct us to proceed with the hybrid option, And then there will be need for additional appropriation because those costs are higher than what's budgeted. And just wanna highlight that Robinson Park is currently not funded and would have to come back at a later date to ask for capital project appropriation for that. That concludes my presentation. I'd be happy to answer questions. Thank you, Mr. Pinozian, Mr. Lyon. Thank you, thanks for the presentation and for, we've been through a few iterations of this now. a couple of questions first why why are we estimating a 10-year lifespan for artificial turf because we've only gotten eight years out of it twice now in two different cycles are the materials changing has it improved good question councilmember Lyon experience my experience has been properly maintained they can give you 10-year lifespan we are now going into the ninth year at Villa Park might be able to get away just by the end of this That's the nine years. The average is between eight and ten and we believe with the proper maintenance We can get ten years out of it my prior experience with it. We've gotten ten years and I believe it is doable That's what we're estimating a ten-year replacement cycle in the program itself But at this point we're into pretty severe erosion of the materials, right? That is correct I was my land the currently we might be able to get one more season out of this field and If we don't move forward with the project we might end up having to do some shutdowns and cancellations sometime next year, later in the year. And so what is the proper maintenance? What does it look like? Do we have to add infill along the way? Adding infill is one of the factors. So part of it is to make sure you sweep. And it's essentially a grooming where you lift the fibers up a little bit. It's equipment that comes with the price that we've estimated, comes with the equipment. You drive it over the turf, lifts up the blades, and it shuffles the material, the infill back. What it does is it keeps the blade standing and if the blades are standing and not compressed down Compressed you're gonna keep hitting it with the cleats is gonna tear up faster So if you continue the maintenance options the way we have it laid out right now It will last longer because that first and the products are made more durable than in the past Manufacturers have you know improved on the product year after year So that's those are one of the reasons as well And what about compaction about the soil and the and the infill do we do we is there a way to sort of? compact because over time it gets really packed. Yes actually that's part of the renovation council member line we identify right now probably initially no more than two times would be necessary a year to bring in a technician a specialist that does the grooming that really fluffs it back up and it creates it so it's basically similar to what it was when it was first installed so yes it does get compaction and couple of times a year which we call the renovation for artificial turf will address that as we move Okay, and then for the one park it artificial turf is roughly a million dollars more expensive than natural grass first for Villa Park Robinson Park is Larger space. Yeah, Robinson Park is essentially twice the size of Villa Park and as such Robinson Park estimates if we went with artificial turf at Robinson Park Same concept over 10 year period you're looking at three point one million dollars including maintenance and annual renovations. And for natural grass, that would be about $2.8 million over a ten-year timeline. So I wanted to ask you about those numbers. Because you're only assuming a 700,000 increase for artificial, but a 1.3 million increase for grass. That doesn't, how does that, it seems they would be proportional between the two. So why is it such a bigger leap for grass at Robinson? You know, I don't have detail. This was that pull this together for me last second based on taking the formula of the size and that's how they figured it out So I think it is possible. There's something off in the math. It could be in the natural grass one I can't pinpoint right now councilmember Lane because it yeah, it's a it you're coming out really close to the same price Yeah, but but but a big leap part of that part of the for the natural It will be because because it is a larger facility if you look at the annual maintenance cost is significantly higher than 10 years scale. That actually, the maintenance and renovation of those are much higher scale-wise. And at Villa Park, there's a big lawn space next to, there's big open grass space next to the field, right? This is it, sir. This is that open space that we use for all of our activities, special events happen here, as well as constant soccer play and other athletic programming. [CC] This is separate from the turf. [AD] Slide displays an aerial photograph of the Villa Parke field pilot. [CC] This is separate from the turf. [AD] Slide displays an aerial photograph of the Villa Parke field pilot. [CC] This is the open space you're referring to, sir. [AD] Slide displays an aerial photograph of the Villa Parke field pilot. [CC] We use it regularly. [CC] We use it regularly. And it's schedulable too, or is it already scheduled? We currently schedule it to its full extent. If you look at the pattern on this, this is a picture from June of 2025. So this had already gone through a renovation sometime between November and January of the year, we do that annually, and by June this is what it looks like. So what this would dictate is we'll have to play, this is June, so we still have the fall programming of 7-7 soccer, it'll impact it more, come November it'll look worse. The compaction alone is, there's a risk. The compacted grass fields, when you fall, there's higher potential for injuries. So we'd have to renovate it annually, and this is that particular field, sir. OK, so in the end, what it comes down to then is the potentially three months less of play on grass than on turf. That is correct. And we're looking at roughly $1 million for those three months. So that helps me kind of sort it out. I mean, I know, Councilman Lai, last time the question was also asked about, well, can we do sod? Absolutely. If we did sod, we'd probably save probably a month on the other end, because sod already comes established. Part of the challenge with seed, it's going to take you three to four weeks for the seed to actually start popping and looking like it's grass again, greening things up. But if you come on too soon after you've seeded, the play is going to destroy it. So all the effort, resources you put into it, it's gonna be, essentially, it's not gonna be worth it because a couple months has been finished. And what does SOD cost look like, compared to? SOD will probably be about 100,000 plus per facility. And I'll give you an example. The 25,000 square foot area that we discussed doing the pilot study, we asked for an estimate from a contractor. They gave us an estimate of $125,000 to take that out, bring in four different products, the SOD materials to lay down. So it can be much costlier. So SOD will probably add $100,000 a year to the renovation. But if we but but would also add play it would add an extra month of play So ten years a million dollars, you're back to the same But grass and without having yeah, you know I had one way in our water system, which we didn't talk a

Untitled 1

To access staff reports, please download and install Adobe Reader at the link below http://www.adobe.com/products/acrobat/readstep2.html

To comply with the Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990, Assistive Listening Devices are available at all Pasadena City Council meetings. Assistive Listening headphones and neck loops can be checked out at the desk of the Sergeant-at-Arms, located inside the City Council Chambers.

Language translation services are available for this meeting by calling (626) 744-4124 at least 24 hours in advance.

Habrá servicio de interpretación disponible para éstas juntas llamando al

(626) 744-4124 por lo menos con 24 horas de anticipación .

Meetings are broadcast live on CHARTER CABLE Channel 3 and rebroadcast daily;

call (626)794-8585 for schedule.

PUBLIC COMMENT INSTRUCTIONS

INSTRUCCIONES PARA COMENTARIOS PÚBLICOS

TO VIEW THE CITY COUNCIL USING LIVESTREAM AND OTHER METHODS PLEASE CLICK ON ONE OF THE FOLLOWING OPTIONS:

WWW.PASADENAMEDIA.ORG

HTTPS://WWW.YOUTUBE.COM/@PASADENAMEDIATV/STREAMS

CITYOFPASADENA.NET/CCZOOM

WWW.CITYOFPASADENA.NET/COMMISSIONS/AGENDAS

AGENDA

CITY COUNCIL AND

THE SUCCESSOR AGENCY TO THE

PASADENA COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT COMMISSION

OCTOBER 13, 2026

Closed Session: 5:00 P.M.

Public Meeting: 6:00 P.M.

Council Chamber, Pasadena City Hall

100 North Garfield Avenue, Room S249

Note to public: Please see separate Closed Session Special Meeting agenda scheduled to begin at 4:30 p.m.

The City Council may take action on any item listed on this agenda as it deems appropriate following consideration and discussion of the matter.

CLOSED SESSION – 5:00 P.M.

A.

CITY COUNCIL CONFERENCE WITH REAL PROPERTY NEGOTIATORS pursuant to Government Code Section 54956.8

Property Locations: 230 Wigmore Drive, 180 W. Glenarm Avenue, 1175 Pasadena Avenue, and 163 State Street

Agency Negotiator: Matthew Hawkesworth, Interim City Manager

Negotiating Party: Bryan Wong, Chief Executive Officer, San Gabriel Valley Habitat for Humanity

Under negotiation: Price and Terms of Payment

B. CITY COUNCIL CONFERENCE WITH LEGAL COUNSEL regarding pending litigation pursuant to Government Code Section 54956.9(d)(1)

Name of Case: City of Pasadena v. Varda, Inc., et al.

Los Angeles County Superior Court Case No. 25NNCV01992

C. CITY COUNCIL CONFERENCE WITH LABOR NEGOTIATORS pursuant to Government Code Section 54957.6

Agency Designated Representatives: Matthew Hawkesworth and Tiffany Jacobs-Quinn

Employee Organization: International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers (IBEW)

D. CITY COUNCIL CONFERENCE regarding public employee performance evaluation pursuant to Government Code Section 54957(b)(1)

Showing the first 24,000 of 158,089 characters. The full document is at the source.

[AD] Council members face the audience from a curved dais. [CC] Recording in progress. [AD] Council members face the audience from a curved dais. [CC] Mayor and council, we are live. Thank you, Mr. Clerk. Good afternoon, everyone. Welcome to the October 13th, 2026 meeting of the Pasadena City Council. The council, well, we'll start with the recalling of the roll. Council Member Cole. Council Member Hampton is not here. Council Member Jones. Here. Council Member Lyon. Here. Councilor Madison here counselor Masuda here vice mayor Rivas here mayor Bordeaux here. There's a quorum the council president. Thank you and I'll ask miss Rivas to lead us in the Pledge of Allegiance [AD] Council members and audience rise for the Pledge of Allegiance. [AD] Council members and audience sit down. [AD] Mayor Gordo walks from the dais to the podium for ceremonial matters. Okay, if I could ask our city attorney Our chief assistant city prosecutor Tim Wellman and Linda Alessandra O'Fray and Tunisia O'Fray from Shepherd's Door as [CC] well as Alessandra Marinelli [AD] Honorees join Mayor Gordo at the podium. [CC] well as Alessandra Marinelli [AD] Honorees join Mayor Gordo at the podium. [CC] from Peace Over Violence to [CC] from Peace Over Violence to join me. And we also have a representative from our Pasadena Police Department, Dean Bistrofeld. Thank you. So colleagues, you all know that this is Domestic Violence Awareness Month. Nearly one in three women and four men in our country have suffered physical violence by an intimate partner. And domestic violence impacts people of every age, ethnicity, nationality, and economic status and belief. And these crimes are often perpetrated in what we consider the safest of places, our homes. And so it's important for us to recognize that domestic violence is not acceptable in anyone's home against anyone, whether it's in our city of Pasadena or beyond. And so it's in that spirit that we reaffirm as a city, its dedication to providing a community where no one suffers the pain and hardship caused by domestic violence. And on behalf of the City Council, I do hereby proclaim October, 2026 as Domestic Violence Awareness Month and would like to present a commendation to peace over violence. [CC] Ms. Marinelli, [AD] Mayor Gordo presents a proclamation to Alessandra Marinelli. [CC] Ms. Marinelli, [AD] Mayor Gordo presents a proclamation to Alessandra Marinelli. [CC] thank you for your work in this area [CC] thank you for your work in this area in our community. And also to Tunisia O'Fray, who also has a tremendous history here in Pasadena [CC] and working on this issue. [AD] Mayor Gordo presents a proclamation to Tunisia O'Fray. [CC] and working on this issue. [AD] Mayor Gordo presents a proclamation to Tunisia O'Fray. [CC] So thank you to both of you, [AD] Mayor Gordo presents a proclamation to Tunisia O'Fray. [CC] your supporters and for your work. [CC] your supporters and for your work. And of course, I would be remiss if I didn't think our own staff within the city prosecutor's office as well as our police department and city attorney. I think you all for your work. I would just note that these organizations have been working with the city prosecutor's office with the police department as resources available to victims of domestic violence. And they are a place to go. We also have victim witness advocate who is a coordinator as well. So we want to thank those organizations for all that they do in working with us to protect those in the city of Pasadena. And of course Chief Harris is also here. Thank you Chief for your efforts. [AD] The group poses for a photo. at the time. Thank you for what you do. Thank you for working with us. Thank you, Mayor. Now the city manager has a an announcement that is sad and we should all join in our best wishes to a family the family of a city employee. Yeah, thank you, Mayor. It's with sadness that I informed the council and the community tonight regarding the recent passing of one of our city employees, her name Nancy Defoya Gutierrez. Nancy began her service with the city in 2008 as a Community Service Rep 2 in Human Services and Recreation Department, and then was reclassified in 2017 to Community Service Rep 3 in the department, which you may now known as Parks, Rec, and Community Services. After serving the city for 16 years in PRCS, she was promoted Program Coordinator 1 in the Rent Stabilization Department, and I she was the first employee of the rent stabilization department outside of the acting director. And that's where she served until her passing. So Nancy will truly be missed. Excuse me, she was a dedicated employee. Wow, this is hard. A dedicated employee of 18 years. So our thoughts and prayers are with her and her family during this difficult time. Thank you, Mr. City Manager. And for those of us who had the honor and privilege of working with Nancy, as I did, we join in your comments. And of course, we'll adjourn in memory of Nancy and we'll send a letter to her family as is our custom. Mr. Jones. Thanks, Mayor. And it is extremely sad news. As we know, Nancy worked at the JRCC and I've seen her there and so I just my thoughts and prayers go out to her family and so our city employees as well because you know when you work with somebody they become your family essentially too. Well said. Okay so we will adjourn as requested by the city manager. And then mayor if I could just comment before we get into the agenda I believe item 10 the Tefer hearing is gonna be canceled. That's correct so if you are here for item 10 or you're in for item 10, the TEFRA hearing on Colorado Boulevard. That item is pulled from the agenda and will not be heard, but you can still remain tuned in if you like. Next, we'll, oh, I did want to invite all of you tomorrow morning, Pastor Kerwin Manning will be here and is celebrating his service and I will join him. So that's at 10 a.m. tomorrow here at the Rotunda City Hall if you're around and available. With that, we will turn to public comment for matters not on the agenda. How many cards, Mr. Clerk? We have currently seven cards. I would also note that we did get a speaker card for item number 10, and it's from P.A. Brown. So I would just say to Mr. Brown, oh, and we're not going to be taking item 10. The public hearing is being canceled. So if you would like to speak on that item, maybe do it during public comment on matters not on the agenda, since it's being canceled. OK, I will call Sonia Burns, Eric Su, Renee Gonzalez, Danny Clash, Anthony Edson, Howard Tan, and then Greg Hedrick, and then P.A. Brown and Erica Foy, I think is going to be doing that. Ms. Byrne, welcome. If you heard your name, [CC] please form a line in the center aisle so that we can get through public comment. Ms. Byrne? [AD] Public speaker Sonia Bernt approaches the podium. [CC] please form a line in the center aisle so that we can get through public comment. Ms. Byrne? [CC] please form a line in the center aisle so that we can get through public comment. Ms. Byrne? Thank you. Good evening. I have two issues. First, at the September 29th council meeting, council member Hampton asked housing staff Poe, when the city runs out of motel vouchers, will the council be notified? Staff stated, quote, we can certainly notify you guys when that happens, unquote. However, at the August 5th HHP meeting, housing staff had already acknowledged they don't have enough vouchers and that they have not notified the council as it previously requested. staff said with 300 persons sleeping on the street they can always use more vouchers assistant city manager page said that the policy regarding notifying council when motel vouchers run out quote it's not clear we need to have a discussion unquote so no there aren't nearly enough motel vouchers and this needs to be agendized urgently secondly at the CPOC meeting last week chief Harris gave a detailed PowerPoint on PPD activities for the first six months of this year, except as to homelessness, zero data was presented. Chief Harris briefly discussed some changes in enforcement. The new community impact team will handle all quality of life issues. He said, quote, we need to address, quote, the community's request, unquote, but he gave no information on how the codes will be enforced. We have over 300 unsheltered folks who sleep on the street and have no bathrooms to relieve themselves. Back in September 2024, the council and the community were assured that there would be no change in enforcement of codes related to or unhoused notwithstanding the Grants Pass case unless and until the council makes that change. We've been given no data on how PPD is handling issues related to homelessness. Please agendize the topic of PPD enforcement of these issues and instruct PPD to provide specific data on how violations are being handled. Thank you. Thank you Eric Sue followed by Renee Gonzales then Danny Clash then Anthony Edson if Mr. [CC] Gonzales and Mr. Clash and Mr. Edson could please line up. Go ahead. [AD] Public speaker Eric Su approaches the podium. [CC] Gonzales and Mr. Clash and Mr. Edson could please line up. Go ahead. [CC] Thank you Mr. Sue. Hi I live on Fair Oaks and Esther Street and recently the specific plan was approved there. I believe that MHCH will be proposing $20,000 allocated to sidewalk improvements in the area, and I'd like to voice my support for that allocation in light of Rick Cole's previous comments about actually implementing the plan and getting things done rather than having it remain as a piece of paper. And I'd also like to sincerely thank you all for approving the plan. I believe it will improve my neighborhood. Thank you. [CC] Thank you, Mr. Su. [AD] Public speaker Rene Gonzalez approaches the podium. [CC] Thank you, Mr. Su. [AD] Public speaker Rene Gonzalez approaches the podium. [CC] Mr. Gonzalez, welcome. Thank you, Mayor Gordo. Honorable members of the Council, October 14 is National Sister Cities Day, commemorating President Eisenhower's birthday and honoring his global peace vision in the 1956 White House Conference on Citizen Diplomacy and People-to-People Relationships. Seventy years later, as the Latin Heritage Month ends on October 15, Pasadena has no Latin American sister city flags on these chambers, despite generations of Latin American families helping build our city. For me, the absence of a Mexican flag is a painful reminder of Pasadena's history of discrimination, redlining, exclusion, and poor representation. After three years of civic dedication, completing the formal Guanajuato sister city proposal process and placing our trust elected officials we feel deeply disappointed and betrayed. That broken trust has even discouraged some of our members and dedicated volunteers from participating in civic affairs. Yet we remain hopeful that we can all change this narrative. Today I respectfully request that this Council supports an October 14, 2027, Pasadena Sister City Day Proclamation or Resolution, and began to work with Sister Cities International California representatives to restore trust, citizen diplomacy and advance or formal Guanajuato Sister City affiliation with no further delays, personal ego or politics. We may hopefully celebrate next year's Latin Heritage Month with a Mexican flag proudly display in these chambers. Thank you for your attention. May God bless the future Children of Pasadena and peace throughout the world. Thank you. Danny Clash, Mr Gonzalez. Just so you're aware, we we I recently recognized exchanged communications with the mayor of Guanajuato. We are now a friendship city. Um, and the flag has been ordered and will be displayed appropriately. Thank you. Mayor, excuse me, but I just have to state my disagreement with what you just said and for reasons that I think we've discussed before. And I hope that we do move forward to formally offer through the powers vested only in the City Council, not in the mayor, not in any one of us, that the City Council exercise its power to extend an invitation to Guanajuato to be a sister city. It's far, far beyond the time where we should have already done that. The authority to recognize friendship cities is is with the mayor is my understanding. That's incorrect, Mayor. But I don't want to debate it now. And I don't want to be impertinent here. But it's the sister city organization that changed the rules to authorize the mayor to do that is and has been operating unlawfully because they're not in good standing under California law and mr. Gonzalez has formed a new organization which lawfully this council could consider the application of Guanajuato because they picked up the work that had already been done and again I think everyone knows how I feel about that we disagree I respect your opinion but well it's a fact that it's the mayor of the city has always had the authority to recognize friendship cities I've recognized a number of them but we can read it and it's not on the agenda it's not on the agenda so brief response can we agendize it for a discussion mayor let's let's let's see how this goes next Danny Clash is not here okay moving on to Anthony Edson then Howard Tan, Anthony Edson, are you here? Howard Tan. [AD] Public speaker Howard Tan approaches the podium. Evening Mayor, council members, and the city staff. My name is Howard Tan. Having recently concluded my service as residents, having recently concluded my service as commissioner on the Parks and Rec creation and community service commission. I want to thank the council and the city for the privilege to serve our community. I am speaking tonight as a concerned Pasadena citizen and community steward regarding the ongoing situation with the Rose Bowl Riders, an 80 year old institution currently facing eviction. The fundamental issue before us is a breakdown in our communication and a lack of open dialogue between the city and key stakeholders. Rigid demands and closed processes have created an avoidable crisis that threatens a long standing community asset. As stewards of our public spaces and community programming, the city bears responsibility to maintain a proactive, transparent engagement with the groups and residents directly impacted by its decisions. This affects our youth, our community, and the broader character of Pasadena. Community assets that take decades of grassroots doerships to build can be dismantled overnight when administrative processes replace genuine collaboration. I urge you tonight or anytime, deposit eviction proceedings, direct staff to engage in transparent, good faith dialogue and work collaboratively towards a workable resolution. Thank you for your time, leadership and service to the community. Jill Shook followed by Chico Dilly Udengwu, then Erica Foy, then P.A. Brown, then Greg Hedrick. Is Jill Shook here? And she's not online? Okay. Chico Dilly Udengwu, I thought I saw you, there you are. [AD] A public speaker approaches the podium. [CC] Two minutes, go ahead. Good evening Mayor and City Council. Could you bring the microphone down a little bit? Right away, thank you. I'm here again to request to file a missing person report for my son, Michael C. Ogbodo and Uzamaka R. Ogbodo. I've requested to speak to some of the members of the police department and the mayor. In addition to the missing person report for my two kids, I'm also requesting to four incident reports, the one that happened on the two, on 5-26-26 and 5-27-26, 12-16-25, and 12-15-25. The incident that happened on June 5th, 2022, and June 6th, 2022, where I was transferred to Linwood Jail and released to return to claim my property. And my property and the documents with the basis of which I was removed from my home, missing from my property. And also, my SIM card, both of them were missing. I didn't realize it until late. Now, for the past 11 years, I've been coming here in and out for the experiences that I've encountered in the city. I have to pause for you guys to give me a response because the issue of my son and my daughter is urgent. Thank you. Thank you, ma'am. Yes, next speaker. Ma'am, it's not our, we are forbidden by law from engaging in a discussion for something that's not on the agenda. Okay. We would refer you back to the police department. But that's what I've been going on. Ma'am, thank you. Erica Foy. May I would like that to be agendized. Thank you ma'am. Agendized. We cannot agendize personal matters. No it's not personal matters. Ma'am thank you. Ma'am we want to be fair to everyone please. Next speaker. Erica Foy. [AD] Public speaker Erica Foy approaches the podium. Good evening mayor and council members. Tonight you were supposedly going to be asked to authorize 42 million dollars in tax exempt bond financing for 144 apartments at 2000 East Colorado. Your resolution asks you to find that this financing is in the public interest for the public benefit. I have several questions I'd like council to ask staff. First, why approve financing before the design commission completes its review? Maybe you decided, maybe you changed your mind since you're not hearing it tonight. But we're looking at 78 foot building where the usual height limit is 39 feet, Significantly reduced open space, only 64 parking spaces for 144 apartments and concerns about massing blank walls and long facades. Have those concerns been addressed? I hope so. Second, will this property pay property taxes or qualify for an exemption? If exempt, how much revenue would Pasadena otherwise receive? Third, tomorrow's housing committee reports identifies 4,160 apartments in our development pipeline, including 1,525 affordable units. Shouldn't we be keeping a running total of how much potential property tax revenue we're giving up? We don't build affordable housing in a bubble, and it isn't free. These buildings need fire protection, police, streets, and other city services. Are we comparing those costs with the revenue they generate? We're asking residents to consider another tax for our fire stations? Are we placing more pressure on existing taxpayers with tax exemptions? I think many of us have reached our limit on being asked for more money. When Council declares something in the public interest and for the public benefit, shouldn't we look at the impact on the entire city, not just the number of affordable units? Thank you very much. Thank you. PA [CC] Brown. Mr. Brown. Thank you Mayor. Good evening Council members. I have a [AD] Public speaker P.A. Brown approaches the podium. [CC] Brown. Mr. Brown. Thank you Mayor. Good evening Council members. I have a [CC] Brown. Mr. Brown. Thank you Mayor. Good evening Council members. I have a 2000 East Colorado project This is a very important project 143 rental units 100% affordable housing along East Colorado a part of this city that needs more Multifamily housing it could bring greater vitality to the area more more people for business More students for the schools and I will note that the schools that serve What will be this building if it if it goes forward are significantly under capacity so they need more students and this project would bring them more students. Approving the resolution that you were going to vote on tonight but hopefully we'll consider another time is exactly the right thing to do. The city should be doing everything possible in its power to facilitate these type of projects, fast-tracking or removing bureaucratic requirements and taking the action that needs to be done so they can be billed. Second thing I just wanted to mention this evening is Governor Newsom, as you all know, signed into law last week the plug-in solar bill. This plug-in solar legislation promises great possibilities for those in apartments or condos in Pasadena. And I hope PWP can encourage implementation of plug-in solar by residents as soon as possible. Thank you. So Danny Clash, Anthony Edson, Jill Shook are not in the room. We'll go to Greg Hedrick. Oh, sorry. Who's here? Please come forward. [AD] Public speaker Anthony Edson approaches the podium. Mr. Edson. I'll ring a bell when you have 30 seconds left. You have two minutes. Go ahead. Thank you. Good evening. My name is Anthony Edson. I'm joined tonight by my mother, Jerry Edson, and I'm following up on the email that was sent to you all last week about Pasadena's fair return process. Rent control is only constitutional when owners have a working path to a fair return. Fair return is the line between lawful regulation and regulatory taking. In my opinion, Pasadena does not have a working path. I say that as the first owner Pasadena to win a fair return petition. The hearing officer found our building entitled to an upward adjustment. However, more than 400 days after we filed that adjustment has not been able to be implemented. Why? Because the city is working with broken tools and a broken process. So let's start with the tools. Every petition runs through the city's worksheet model. The model currently posted on the city's website does not comply with the city's regulations. Then the process, and this was what happened to my case. Four days before the 60-day decision, my case was continued. The clock was restarted. When my decision came, it contained basic arithmetic errors, the kind that a simple review would have caught. But the only way to fix them is filing appeal. We filed an appeal that said unscheduled for months. We first were told that there was a meeting room that needed to be scheduled. Then we were told that the board needed more workshops unfair return. Now measure H took effect in December of 22. We are nearly in 2027 and the body that decides these appeals and still needs workshops to understand them. Only after I wrote to this body, did I actually get an appeal date. Each step may be defensible on its own, but together they amount to an indefinite delay and none of this is new. The delay hurts the tenants to while case drags on continuances, errors and repeated hearings, tenants live with uncertainties about what their will be and a timely accurate process serves everyone. I ask for three things an enforceable deadlines with decisions and appeals a way to correct clear math errors without a month's long appeals and a worksheet that actually applies the regulations as written. Measure H is constitutional not because fair return exists on paper. Sir your time has expired. Thank you. Jill Shook I see steaming into the room and then Greg Hedrick who will be participating [CC] online. Ms. Shook, [AD] Public speaker Jill Shook approaches the podium. [CC] online. Ms. Shook, welcome. Welcome, thank you. Someone named Danny Clash will be here very shortly. He also has a public comment and we're both part of the public art team to help identify the Black Legacy District and we come here to thank you for supporting the Black Legacy District. There's a lot of joy going on right now about the decision you all made. So I also am thinking about what I've heard our mayor say many times about being the center of the universe. And there's actually some of that kind of coming true in terms of an article as a result of the decision you made last week. It came out with a group called By Black. It's an amazing article. I made copies for you. [CC] And so it's gone nationwide, and so I have copies to give you now. [AD] Jill Shook holds up a printed article. [CC] And so it's gone nationwide, and so I have copies to give you now. [AD] Jill Shook holds up a printed article. [CC] It features Loretta, who spoke last week, and how she came from Phoenix as a little [CC] It features Loretta, who spoke last week, and how she came from Phoenix as a little girl to visit her dad here, and just the pride that she had when she could come here and see people that look like her, that own businesses, lawyers, doctors, all kinds of folks that made her believe she could be and do anything. And so I think that this is just a huge first

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
Agenda packetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Action agendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
MinutesNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Transcript or captionsSource recordingread transcript
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Coverage and corrections

Records considered

  • City Council Meeting: October 13, 2026 (Audio Description)
  • City Council Meeting: October 13, 2026 (Audio Description) — Closed Captions

Not claimed by this page

  • Verified meeting decisions with item-specific public-source evidence
  • Item-level plain-language summaries are not available; this page does not infer individual agenda items.
  • Item-linked, attributed deliberation
  • A source-grounded next meeting date
  • A plain-English overview is not available.
  • Official outcomes have not been published.
  • The available transcript has no reliable timestamps.
  • Transcript coverage is partial.
  • Speakers have not been reliably matched to public profiles.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.
  • An individual roll-call roster is not available.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: 33d333755ba202769b1cd5c764660bb5. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record