POLISCOPE

The public record

DUNEDIN (PINELLAS COUNTY) · LOCALDecisions and attributed speech publishedPartial coverage

Local Planning Agency

Wednesday, August 14, 2024 · Government meeting record

The 30-second read

Recorded outcome

Local Planning Agency

Why it matters

The official meeting record is available below. Item-level plain-language summaries are not available yet.

What happens next

No later meeting or follow-up date is stated in the reviewed record.

An official outcome record and a transcript or captions are published for this meeting.

People and votes

Commissioner Jeremy Reynolds of 973 Cedarwood Avenue

1 statement

  1. Statement

    Commented on his love of Dunedin and his neighbors.

    Official record

What people said

Attributed speechA separate authority lane. Speech is evidence of what a person said, never of what the board decided.
  • The official minutes identify speakers and topics, but summarize rather than quote their exact words.

Transcript and record text

Closed captionsWhat was said at the meeting, transcribed Aug 3, 2026. Speech is not a decision.
  • No speaker turns were supplied with this transcript.
  • This transcript has no source timestamps.
  • No speaker identities were supplied with this transcript.

This source published text without speaker turns, so speakers and timestamps are not shown.

The opening of 190,206 stored characters

MEETING OF THE. [SPEAKER OFF MIC] [SPEAKER OFF MIC] THE AUGUST 14th, 2024 MEETING THE AUGUST 14th, 2024 MEETING OF THE LOCAL PLANNING AGENCY OF OF THE LOCAL PLANNING AGENCY OF THE CITY OF DUNEDIN WILL NOW THE CITY OF DUNEDIN WILL NOW COME TO ORDER. COME TO ORDER. THE LOCAL PLANNING AGENCY IS AN THE LOCAL PLANNING AGENCY IS AN ADVISORY BOARD OF CITIZENS ADVISORY BOARD OF CITIZENS APPOINTED BY THE CITY APPOINTED BY THE CITY COMMISSION. COMMISSION. THIS BOARD IS COMPRISED OF THIS BOARD IS COMPRISED OF VOLUNTEERS WHO REPRESENT THE VOLUNTEERS WHO REPRESENT THE THOUGHTS AND CONCERNS OF THE THOUGHTS AND CONCERNS OF THE COMMUNITY. COMMUNITY. THE PURPOSE OF TONIGHT'S MEETING THE PURPOSE OF TONIGHT'S MEETING IS TO MAKE RECOMMENDATIONS TO IS TO MAKE RECOMMENDATIONS TO THE CITY COMMISSION REGARDING THE CITY COMMISSION REGARDING EACH ITEM ON THE AGENDA. EACH ITEM ON THE AGENDA. ANYONE IN THE AUDIENCE WHO ANYONE IN THE AUDIENCE WHO WISHES TO GIVE TESTIMONY TO ANY WISHES TO GIVE TESTIMONY TO ANY ITEMS ON THE AGENDA WILL NEED TO ITEMS ON THE AGENDA WILL NEED TO BE SWORN IN BY THE DEPUTY CITY BE SWORN IN BY THE DEPUTY CITY CLERK. CLERK. THE SWEARING IN PROCESS WILL THE SWEARING IN PROCESS WILL OCCUR AFTER TONIGHT'S FIRST OCCUR AFTER TONIGHT'S FIRST AGENDA ITEM WHICH WILL BE AGENDA ITEM WHICH WILL BE APPROVAL OF THE MINUTES OF THE APPROVAL OF THE MINUTES OF THE LAST LOCAL PLANNING AGENCY. LAST LOCAL PLANNING AGENCY. THAT WAS A GOOD MEETING. THAT WAS A GOOD MEETING. [LAUGHTER] [LAUGHTER] CITIZENS SPEAKING ON AN AGENDA CITIZENS SPEAKING ON AN AGENDA ITEM OR DURING CITIZEN COMMENT ITEM OR DURING CITIZEN COMMENT SHALL NOT ENGAGE IN LOUD, SHALL NOT ENGAGE IN LOUD, BOISTEROUS AND/OR DISRUPTIVE BOISTEROUS AND/OR DISRUPTIVE SPEECH OR CONDUCT. SPEECH OR CONDUCT. ANY SPEAKER THAT HAS ANY SPEAKER THAT HAS CONTINUED -- ANY SPEAKER THAT CONTINUED -- ANY SPEAKER THAT HAS CONTINUED INAPPROPRIATE OR HAS CONTINUED INAPPROPRIATE OR IRRELEVANT COMMENTS WILL BE IRRELEVANT COMMENTS WILL BE REQUESTED TO RELINQUISH THE REQUESTED TO RELINQUISH THE PODIUM BY THE CHAIR. PODIUM BY THE CHAIR. PLEASE BE AWARE THAT THE LOCAL PLEASE BE AWARE THAT THE LOCAL PLANNING AGENCY IS NOT A PLANNING AGENCY IS NOT A QUASI-JUDICIAL BOARD AND, QUASI-JUDICIAL BOARD AND, THEREFORE, HAS NO FINAL THEREFORE, HAS NO FINAL DECISION-MAKING POWER. DECISION-MAKING POWER. OUR PROCEDURES, HOWEVER, ARE OUR PROCEDURES, HOWEVER, ARE STRUCTURED IN A QUASI-JUDICIAL STRUCTURED IN A QUASI-JUDICIAL MANNER FOR THE BENEFIT OF THOSE MANNER FOR THE BENEFIT OF THOSE WHO COME BEFORE IT. WHO COME BEFORE IT. TONIGHT'S FORMAT WILL BE AS TONIGHT'S FORMAT WILL BE AS FOLLOWS. FOLLOWS. I WILL INTRODUCE EACH ITEM ON I WILL INTRODUCE EACH ITEM ON THE AGENDA, AFTER WHICH THE CITY THE AGENDA, AFTER WHICH THE CITY REPRESENTATIVE WILL PRESENT REPRESENTATIVE WILL PRESENT INFORMATION ABOUT IT. INFORMATION ABOUT IT. THEREAFTER, THE MEMBERS OF THE THEREAFTER, THE MEMBERS OF THE LOCAL PLANNING AGENCY WILL ASK LOCAL PLANNING AGENCY WILL ASK QUESTIONS OF THE CITY QUESTIONS OF THE CITY REPRESENTATIVE. REPRESENTATIVE. FINALLY, ANYONE FROM THE PUBLIC FINALLY, ANYONE FROM THE PUBLIC MAY COME FORWARD. MAY COME FORWARD. THOSE FROM THE PUBLIC WISHING TO THOSE FROM THE PUBLIC WISHING TO GIVE TESTIMONY WILL APPROACH THE GIVE TESTIMONY WILL APPROACH THE DAIS, STATE THEIR NAME AND DAIS, STATE THEIR NAME AND ADDRESS, AND THEN UTILIZE THE ADDRESS, AND THEN UTILIZE THE SPEAKER'S LECTERN IN ORDER FOR SPEAKER'S LECTERN IN ORDER FOR THEIR COMMENTS TO BE RECORDED. THEIR COMMENTS TO BE RECORDED. INDIVIDUAL SPEAKERS WILL BE INDIVIDUAL SPEAKERS WILL BE LIMITED TO THREE MINUTES OF LIMITED TO THREE MINUTES OF SPEAKING TIME. SPEAKING TIME. AND WE KINDLY REQUEST THAT AND WE KINDLY REQUEST THAT SPEAKERS ARE RESPECTFUL OF THE SPEAKERS ARE RESPECTFUL OF THE COUNTDOWN CLOCK. COUNTDOWN CLOCK. UPON THE CONCLUSION OF EACH UPON THE CONCLUSION OF EACH PUBLIC HEARING, THE LOCAL PUBLIC HEARING, THE LOCAL PLANNING AGENCY WILL CONSIDER PLANNING AGENCY WILL CONSIDER THE EVIDENCE BEFORE IT AND WILL THE EVIDENCE BEFORE IT AND WILL VOTE ON THE AGENDA ITEM. VOTE ON THE AGENDA ITEM. THAT VOICE VOTE IS THE RENDITION THAT VOICE VOTE IS THE RENDITION OF THE ORDER OF THE BOARD AND OF THE ORDER OF THE BOARD AND THERE WILL BE NO WRITTEN THERE WILL BE NO WRITTEN DECISION ISSUED BY THE BOARD. DECISION ISSUED BY THE BOARD. THE FIRST ITEM ON THE AGENDA IS THE FIRST ITEM ON THE AGENDA IS TO APPROVE THE JUNE 12th AND TO APPROVE THE JUNE 12th AND JULY 29th, 2024 LPA MINUTES. JULY 29th, 2024 LPA MINUTES. ARE THERE ANY CORRECTIONS, ARE THERE ANY CORRECTIONS, ADDITIONS OR DELETIONS TO THE ADDITIONS OR DELETIONS TO THE MINUTES? MINUTES? HEARING NONE, DO I HEAR A MOTION HEARING NONE, DO I HEAR A MOTION TO ACCEPT THE MINUTES? TO ACCEPT THE MINUTES? >> SO MOVED. >> SO MOVED. >> SO MOVED. >> >> SO MOVED. >> Chair: >> SO MOVED. >> Chair: CAN >> SO MOVED. >> Chair: CAN I >> SO MOVED. >> Chair: CAN I GET >> SO MOVED. >> Chair: CAN I GET A >> SO MOVED. >> Chair: CAN I GET A SECOND? >> Chair: CAN I GET A SECOND? >> Chair: CAN I GET A SECOND? >> >> Chair: CAN I GET A SECOND? >> SECOND. >> SECOND. >> SECOND. >> >> SECOND. >> Chair: >> SECOND. >> Chair: THANK >> SECOND. >> Chair: THANK YOU. >> Chair: THANK YOU. >> Chair: THANK YOU. ALL >> Chair: THANK YOU. ALL IN >> Chair: THANK YOU. ALL IN FAVOR? ALL IN FAVOR? [AYES] [AYES] ALL OPPOSED? ALL OPPOSED? THE AYES HAVE IT. THE AYES HAVE IT. THE CLERK WILL NOW SWEAR IN ALL THE CLERK WILL NOW SWEAR IN ALL PERSONS WISHING TO SPEAK OR GIVE PERSONS WISHING TO SPEAK OR GIVE TESTIMONY TO ANY OF TONIGHT'S TESTIMONY TO ANY OF TONIGHT'S AGENDA ITEMS. AGENDA ITEMS. >> DO WE HAVE TO DO THAT? >> DO WE HAVE TO DO THAT? >> DO WE HAVE TO DO THAT? >> >> DO WE HAVE TO DO THAT? >> YOU'VE >> DO WE HAVE TO DO THAT? >> YOU'VE GOT >> DO WE HAVE TO DO THAT? >> YOU'VE GOT ONE >> DO WE HAVE TO DO THAT? >> YOU'VE GOT ONE MORE >> DO WE HAVE TO DO THAT? >> YOU'VE GOT ONE MORE SET >> DO WE HAVE TO DO THAT? >> YOU'VE GOT ONE MORE SET OF >> YOU'VE GOT ONE MORE SET OF >> YOU'VE GOT ONE MORE SET OF MINUTES >> YOU'VE GOT ONE MORE SET OF MINUTES TO >> YOU'VE GOT ONE MORE SET OF MINUTES TO APPROVE. MINUTES TO APPROVE. THE SPECIAL MEETING OF THE SPECIAL MEETING OF JULY 29th. JULY 29th. >> THAT WAS OUR SPECIAL MEETING. >> THAT WAS OUR SPECIAL MEETING. >> THAT WAS OUR SPECIAL MEETING. >> >> THAT WAS OUR SPECIAL MEETING. >> Chair: >> THAT WAS OUR SPECIAL MEETING. >> Chair: DIDN'T >> THAT WAS OUR SPECIAL MEETING. >> Chair: DIDN'T I >> THAT WAS OUR SPECIAL MEETING. >> Chair: DIDN'T I MENTION >> THAT WAS OUR SPECIAL MEETING. >> Chair: DIDN'T I MENTION THE >> Chair: DIDN'T I MENTION THE >> Chair: DIDN'T I MENTION THE 29th? 29th? >> OH, HE DID. >> OH, HE DID. >> OH, HE DID. >> >> OH, HE DID. >> Chair: >> OH, HE DID. >> Chair: JUNE >> OH, HE DID. >> Chair: JUNE 12th >> OH, HE DID. >> Chair: JUNE 12th AND >> Chair: JUNE 12th AND >> Chair: JUNE 12th AND JULY >> Chair: JUNE 12th AND JULY 29th. JULY 29th. THANK YOU VERY MUCH. THANK YOU VERY MUCH. >> I'M SORRY. >> I'M SORRY. >> I'M SORRY. [LAUGHTER] [LAUGHTER] YOU DID THEM ALL TOGETHER. YOU DID THEM ALL TOGETHER. >> Chair: I THOUGHT AM I LOSING >> Chair: I THOUGHT AM I LOSING >> Chair: I THOUGHT AM I LOSING IT >> Chair: I THOUGHT AM I LOSING IT TODAY. IT TODAY. I HAVE LOST IT BEFORE. I HAVE LOST IT BEFORE. ALL RIGHT. ALL RIGHT. SO THE CLERK WILL NOW SWEAR IN SO THE CLERK WILL NOW SWEAR IN ALL PERSONS. ALL PERSONS. >> STAND AND RAISE YOUR RIGHT >> STAND AND RAISE YOUR RIGHT >> STAND AND RAISE YOUR RIGHT HAND. HAND. DO YOU SWEAR THE TESTIMONY YOU DO YOU SWEAR THE TESTIMONY YOU ARE ABOUT TO GIVE IN THIS ARE ABOUT TO GIVE IN THIS PROCEEDING IS THE TRUTH, THE PROCEEDING IS THE TRUTH, THE WHOLE TRUTH AND NOTHING BUT THE WHOLE TRUTH AND NOTHING BUT THE TRUTH? TRUTH? [RESPONSE] [RESPONSE] >> Chair: THANK YOU. >> Chair: THANK YOU. >> Chair: THANK YOU. THE >> Chair: THANK YOU. THE SECOND >> Chair: THANK YOU. THE SECOND ITEM >> Chair: THANK YOU. THE SECOND ITEM ON >> Chair: THANK YOU. THE SECOND ITEM ON OUR >> Chair: THANK YOU. THE SECOND ITEM ON OUR AGENDA THE SECOND ITEM ON OUR AGENDA TONIGHT IS APPLICATION DR 24-04. TONIGHT IS APPLICATION DR 24-04. HAS ANYONE HAD ANY EX PARTE HAS ANYONE HAD ANY EX PARTE COMMUNICATIONS REGARDING THIS COMMUNICATIONS REGARDING THIS APPLICATION? APPLICATION? >> Chair: THANK YOU. >> Chair: THANK YOU. >> Chair: THANK YOU. HEARING >> Chair: THANK YOU. HEARING NONE, >> Chair: THANK YOU. HEARING NONE, WE >> Chair: THANK YOU. HEARING NONE, WE WILL >> Chair: THANK YOU. HEARING NONE, WE WILL HEAR >> Chair: THANK YOU. HEARING NONE, WE WILL HEAR FROM HEARING NONE, WE WILL HEAR FROM OUR CITY REPRESENTATIVE. OUR CITY REPRESENTATIVE. >> THANK YOU, MR. CHAIR. >> THANK YOU, MR. CHAIR. >> THANK YOU, MR. CHAIR. GEORGE >> THANK YOU, MR. CHAIR. GEORGE KINNEY >> THANK YOU, MR. CHAIR. GEORGE KINNEY AND >> THANK YOU, MR. CHAIR. GEORGE KINNEY AND JOSEPH GEORGE KINNEY AND JOSEPH DiPASQUA ON BEHALF OF THE DiPASQUA ON BEHALF OF THE COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DEPARTMENT. DEPARTMENT. THANK YOU FOR ALLOWING US THE THANK YOU FOR ALLOWING US THE OPPORTUNITY TO PRESENT THIS OPPORTUNITY TO PRESENT THIS EVENING TO YOU AND YOUR EVENING TO YOU AND YOUR COLLEAGUES. COLLEAGUES. THIS IS A DESIGN REVIEW REQUEST THIS IS A DESIGN REVIEW REQUEST NUMBER 24-04. NUMBER 24-04. IT IS DESIGN REVIEW APPROVAL IT IS DESIGN REVIEW APPROVAL REQUEST FOR A NEW SINGLE-FAMILY REQUEST FOR A NEW SINGLE-FAMILY REBS KNOWN AS THE WILKERSON REBS KNOWN AS THE WILKERSON RESIDENCE AT 125 EDGEWATER RESIDENCE AT 125 EDGEWATER DRIVE. DRIVE. THE OTHER THAN IS LBW WCW LLC THE OTHER THAN IS LBW WCW LLC AND THE REPRESENTATIVES OF AND THE REPRESENTATIVES OF CLIFFORD SCHOLZ AND DANIEL CLIFFORD SCHOLZ AND DANIEL SHAFFER. SHAFFER. YOU CAN SEE THE PROPERTY IN YOU CAN SEE THE PROPERTY IN QUESTION DOES HAVE AN OVERALL QUESTION DOES HAVE AN OVERALL AREA OF 1.13 ACRES OR ROUGHLY AREA OF 1.13 ACRES OR ROUGHLY 49,259 SQUARE FEET. 49,259 SQUARE FEET. IT IS COMPRISED OF SEVERAL IT IS COMPRISED OF SEVERAL DIFFERENT FLOOD ZONE CATEGORIES. DIFFERENT FLOOD ZONE CATEGORIES. HOWEVER, WHERE THE RESIDENCE IS HOWEVER, WHERE THE RESIDENCE IS PROPOSED WOULD BE OUTSIDE OF ANY PROPOSED WOULD BE OUTSIDE OF ANY FLOODPLAIN AREAS AND IN WHAT WE FLOODPLAIN AREAS AND IN WHAT WE CALL ZONE X. CALL ZONE X. THE LAN USE FOR THE PROPERTY IS THE LAN USE FOR THE PROPERTY IS RESIDENTIAL URBAN AND RECREATION RESIDENTIAL URBAN AND RECREATION OPEN SPACE. OPEN SPACE. THE ZONING DISTRICT IS THE ZONING DISTRICT IS SINGLE-FAMILY R-60. SINGLE-FAMILY R-60. AND THE EXISTING USE OF THE SITE AND THE EXISTING USE OF THE SITE IS CURRENTLY VACANT. IS CURRENTLY VACANT. FROM A PROPERTY HISTORY FROM A PROPERTY HISTORY PERSPECTIVE, THE HOME AND THE PERSPECTIVE, THE HOME AND THE OUTBUILDINGS THAT PREVIOUSLY OUTBUILDINGS THAT PREVIOUSLY OCCUPIED THIS SITE WERE OCCUPIED THIS SITE WERE DEMOLISHED EARLIER THIS YEAR SO DEMOLISHED EARLIER THIS YEAR SO THE PROPERTY IS CURRENTLY THE PROPERTY IS CURRENTLY VACANT. VACANT. TO THE RIGHT OF THIS PARTICULAR TO THE RIGHT OF THIS PARTICULAR SLIDE, YOU CAN SEE THE SURVEY OF SLIDE, YOU CAN SEE THE SURVEY OF THE PROPERTY SHOWING THE THE PROPERTY SHOWING THE BUILDINGS. BUILDINGS. AND BELOW IS ACTUALLY A GOOGLE AND BELOW IS ACTUALLY A GOOGLE IMAGE OF THE HOME THAT WAS THERE IMAGE OF THE HOME THAT WAS THERE PRIOR TO DEMOLITION. PRIOR TO DEMOLITION. THE PROJECT DESCRIPTION, THROUGH THE PROJECT DESCRIPTION, THROUGH THE REPRESENTATIVES, THE OWNERS THE REPRESENTATIVES, THE OWNERS ARE AGAIN REQUESTING DESIGN ARE AGAIN REQUESTING DESIGN REVIEW APPROVAL TO CONSTRUCT THE REVIEW APPROVAL TO CONSTRUCT THE NEW SINGLE-FAMILY HOME. NEW SINGLE-FAMILY HOME. WHAT IS KIND OF UNIQUE AND I WHAT IS KIND OF UNIQUE AND I THINK PROBABLY THE FIRST TIME THINK PROBABLY THE FIRST TIME THE BOARD HAS SEEN ONE OF THESE THE BOARD HAS SEEN ONE OF THESE PROPERTIES IN DESIGN REVIEW FORM PROPERTIES IN DESIGN REVIEW FORM BECAUSE IT IS A PROPERTY THAT IS BECAUSE IT IS A PROPERTY THAT IS IN THE SOUTH DUNEDIN OVERLAY. IN THE SOUTH DUNEDIN OVERLAY. AS PART OF THOSE PROVISIONS OF AS PART OF THOSE PROVISIONS OF THE SOUTH DUNEDIN OVERLAY, THERE THE SOUTH DUNEDIN OVERLAY, THERE IS A REQUIREMENT THAT NO NEW IS A REQUIREMENT THAT NO NEW CONSTRUCTION CAN EXCEED 60 FEET CONSTRUCTION CAN EXCEED 60 FEET IN WIDTH. IN WIDTH. AND SINCE THIS IS AN ASK FOR AND SINCE THIS IS AN ASK FOR 77.67 FEET, THAT'S THE REASON 77.67 FEET, THAT'S THE REASON THAT THE APPLICANT IS HERE TODAY THAT THE APPLICANT IS HERE TODAY TO TALK ABOUT THE NEW HOME AND TO TALK ABOUT THE NEW HOME AND ITS POSITION WITHIN THAT ITS POSITION WITHIN THAT OVERLAY. OVERLAY. VERY QUICKLY THE LAND USE PLAN VERY QUICKLY THE LAND USE PLAN EVALUATION, PRETTY CONSISTENT EVALUATION, PRETTY CONSISTENT WITH WHAT WE SEE DOWN IN THAT WITH WHAT WE SEE DOWN IN THAT PARTICULAR AREA. PARTICULAR AREA. IT'S THE RESIDENTIAL URBAN IT'S THE RESIDENTIAL URBAN CATEGORY AND, OF COURSE, IT CATEGORY AND, OF COURSE, IT WOULD PERMIT RESIDENTIAL USES. WOULD PERMIT RESIDENTIAL USES. FROM A ZONING DISTRICT FROM A ZONING DISTRICT PERSPECTIVE, AGAIN CONSISTENT PERSPECTIVE, AGAIN CONSISTENT THROUGHOUT THE AREA. THROUGHOUT THE AREA. ITS ZONING IS SINGLE-FAMILY ITS ZONING IS SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENTIAL R-60, MAXIMUM RESIDENTIAL R-60, MAXIMUM RESIDENTIAL DENSITY IS 7.5 RESIDENTIAL DENSITY IS 7.5 DWELLING UNITS -- ICE, I BACKED DWELLING UNITS -- ICE, I BACKED UP. UP. FROM A DENSITY STANDPOINT, 7.5 FROM A DENSITY STANDPOINT, 7.5 IS PERMITTED UNDER THE RU. IS PERMITTED UNDER THE RU. FROM ZONING STANDPOINT, IT IS FROM ZONING STANDPOINT, IT IS ALSO CONSISTENT AND PERMISSIBLE ALSO CONSISTENT AND PERMISSIBLE FOR SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCE TO FOR SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCE TO BE LOCATED IN THIS PARTICULAR BE LOCATED IN THIS PARTICULAR DISTRICT. DISTRICT. AND THE NEXT SLIDE THEN IS JUST AND THE NEXT SLIDE THEN IS JUST AN EVALUATION OF THE DIMENSIONAL AN EVALUATION OF THE DIMENSIONAL STANDARDS FOR THE R-60 CATEGORY. STANDARDS FOR THE R-60 CATEGORY. YOU CAN SEE ON THE LEFT ALL OF YOU CAN SEE ON THE LEFT ALL OF THOSE DIMENSIONAL STANDARDS FROM THOSE DIMENSIONAL STANDARDS FROM LOT AREA, LOT WIDTH, LOT DEPTH, LOT AREA, LOT WIDTH, LOT DEPTH, HEIGHT, FRONT SETBACK, SIDE HEIGHT, FRONT SETBACK, SIDE SETBACK AND REAR SETBACK -- THIS SETBACK AND REAR SETBACK -- THIS PARTICULAR PROPOSAL DOES MEET OR PARTICULAR PROPOSAL DOES MEET OR EXCEED ALL OF THOSE STANDARDS AS EXCEED ALL OF THOSE STANDARDS AS YOU CAN SEE THE CONFORMANCE ON YOU CAN SEE THE CONFORMANCE ON FOR EACH OF THOSE CATEGORIES. FOR EACH OF THOSE CATEGORIES. JUST VERY QUICKLY THEN, GETTING JUST VERY QUICKLY THEN, GETTING BACK TO THE SOUTH DUNEDIN BACK TO THE SOUTH DUNEDIN CHARACTER OVERLAY, BECAUSE THE CHARACTER OVERLAY, BECAUSE THE PROPERTY IS LOCATED WITHIN THAT PROPERTY IS LOCATED WITHIN THAT OVERLAY, THERE ARE ADDITIONAL OVERLAY, THERE ARE ADDITIONAL STANDARDS THAT APPLY. STANDARDS THAT APPLY. AND THAT'S WHAT THIS CHART IS AND THAT'S WHAT THIS CHART IS INTENDED TO SHOW YOU. INTENDED TO SHOW YOU. YOU MAY RECALL PROBABLY THE YOU MAY RECALL PROBABLY THE DISCUSSION ON ADOPTING THE DISCUSSION ON ADOPTING THE DAYLIGHT PLAIN, SOME ADDITIONAL DAYLIGHT PLAIN, SOME ADDITIONAL BUILDING DESIGN STANDARDS AND BUILDING DESIGN STANDARDS AND ARCHITECTURAL STYLE. ARCHITECTURAL STYLE. SO THIS CHART KIND OF OUTLAYS SO THIS CHART KIND OF OUTLAYS THIS PROPOSAL AGAINST THOSE THIS PROPOSAL AGAINST THOSE PARTICULAR STANDARDS. PARTICULAR STANDARDS. THEY DO MEET THE HEIGHT AND THEY DO MEET THE HEIGHT AND DAYLIGHT PLAIN REQUIREMENTS OF DAYLIGHT PLAIN REQUIREMENTS OF THE SOUTH OVERLAY FROM A THE SOUTH OVERLAY FROM A BUILDING DESIGN STANDPOINT, THE BUILDING DESIGN STANDPOINT, THE BUILDING ORIENTATION COMPORTS BUILDING ORIENTATION COMPORTS WITH THE OVERLAY. WITH THE OVERLAY. THE GARAGE AND CARPORT ARE THE GARAGE AND CARPORT ARE CONSISTENT WITH WHAT THE OVERLAY CONSISTENT WITH WHAT THE OVERLAY REQUIRES. REQUIRES. AND THE BUILDING ELEVATION IS AND THE BUILDING ELEVATION IS CONSISTENT. CONSISTENT. THE REASON WE ARE ACTUALLY HERE THE REASON WE ARE ACTUALLY HERE IS AGAIN FOR THAT BUILDING WIDTH IS AGAIN FOR THAT BUILDING WIDTH WHICH IS NOT TO EXCEED 60 FEET WHICH IS NOT TO EXCEED 60 FEET UNLESS YOU ENTER INTO THE DESIGN UNLESS YOU ENTER INTO THE DESIGN REVIEW PROCESS. REVIEW PROCESS. AND THEY ARE ALSO COMPLIANT WITH AND THEY ARE ALSO COMPLIANT WITH THE ARCHITECTURAL STYLE. THE ARCHITECTURAL STYLE. I'M GOING TO AT THIS POINT -- SO I'M GOING TO AT THIS POINT -- SO ONE OF THE THINGS WE WANTED TO ONE OF THE THINGS WE WANTED TO DO AS WE WORKED THROUGH THIS DO AS WE WORKED THROUGH THIS ANALYSIS WAS WE WANTED TO MAKE ANALYSIS WAS WE WANTED TO MAKE SURE WHEN WE'RE TALKING ABOUT SURE WHEN WE'RE TALKING ABOUT DESIGN REVIEW APPROVAL AND DESIGN REVIEW APPROVAL AND EXCEEDING THAT 60 FEET IN WIDTH, EXCEEDING THAT 60 FEET IN WIDTH, THAT WE ARE PERMITTING OR WE'RE THAT WE ARE PERMITTING OR WE'RE RECOMMENDING SOMETHING THAT'S RECOMMENDING SOMETHING THAT'S CONSISTENT WITH THAT CONSISTENT WITH THAT NEIGHBORHOOD FROM A NEIGHBORHOOD FROM A COMPATIBILITY STANDPOINT. COMPATIBILITY STANDPOINT. AND THAT'S WHAT I'M GOING TO ASK AND THAT'S WHAT I'M GOING TO ASK JOEY TO KIND OF WALK THROUGH JOEY TO KIND OF WALK THROUGH WHAT OUR COMPATIBILITY ANALYSIS WHAT OUR COMPATIBILITY ANALYSIS WAS AND WHAT OUR METHODOLOGY WAS AND WHAT OUR METHODOLOGY WAS. WAS. I'M SURE YOU'RE GOING TO HAVE I'M SURE YOU'RE GOING TO HAVE QUESTIONS AFTER THAT. QUESTIONS AFTER THAT. I KIND OF WANT TO TURN IT OVER I KIND OF WANT TO TURN IT OVER TO HIM AT THIS POINT TO TALK TO HIM AT THIS POINT TO TALK ABOUT HOW WE ARRIVED AT THE ABOUT HOW WE ARRIVED AT THE RECOMMENDATION THAT WE ARRIVED RECOMMENDATION THAT WE ARRIVED AT. AT. >> THANK YOU, GEORGE. >> THANK YOU, GEORGE. >> THANK YOU, GEORGE. SO >> THANK YOU, GEORGE. SO AS >> THANK YOU, GEORGE. SO AS YOU >> THANK YOU, GEORGE. SO AS YOU CAN >> THANK YOU, GEORGE. SO AS YOU CAN SEE >> THANK YOU, GEORGE. SO AS YOU CAN SEE HERE >> THANK YOU, GEORGE. SO AS YOU CAN SEE HERE ON >> THANK YOU, GEORGE. SO AS YOU CAN SEE HERE ON THE SO AS YOU CAN SEE HERE ON THE SLIDE, THAT'S SORT OF A SUMMARY SLIDE, THAT'S SORT OF A SUMMARY OF IT. OF IT. BUT IF I COULD, I'D LIKE TO JUST BUT IF I COULD, I'D LIKE TO JUST BACK UP FOR A MINUTE AND EXPLAIN BACK UP FOR A MINUTE AND EXPLAIN TO YOU WHAT OUR COMPATIBILITY TO YOU WHAT OUR COMPATIBILITY ANALYSIS INVOLVES. ANALYSIS INVOLVES. IN THIS PARTICULAR CASE, OF IN THIS PARTICULAR CASE, OF COURSE, UNDER DESIGN REVIEW WE COURSE, UNDER DESIGN REVIEW WE FOLLOW OBJECTIVE 2.9 IN OUR FOLLOW OBJECTIVE 2.9 IN OUR FUTURE LAND USE ELEMENT. FUTURE LAND USE ELEMENT. SO YOU'RE LOOKING AT PHYSICAL SO YOU'RE LOOKING AT PHYSICAL COMPATIBILITY OF THE PROPOSED COMPATIBILITY OF THE PROPOSED DEVELOPMENT OR REDEVELOPMENT DEVELOPMENT OR REDEVELOPMENT WITH THE SURROUNDING WITH THE SURROUNDING ENVIRONMENTS. ENVIRONMENTS. AND SOME OF THE THINGS YOU'RE AND SOME OF THE THINGS YOU'RE LOOKING FOR ARE HEIGHT, LOOKING FOR ARE HEIGHT, ARCHITECTURAL FEATURES OF THE ARCHITECTURAL FEATURES OF THE EXISTING STRUCTURES, HISTORIC EXISTING STRUCTURES, HISTORIC ASPECTS OF THE EXISTING ASPECTS OF THE EXISTING STRUCTURES, NATURAL FEATURES STRUCTURES, NATURAL FEATURES THAT ARE EXISTING, EXISTING LAND THAT ARE EXISTING, EXISTING LAND USES, EXISTING RESIDENTIAL USES, EXISTING RESIDENTIAL DENSITIES AND ECONOMICALLY DENSITIES AND ECONOMICALLY RELATED USES. RELATED USES. AND SO WHAT I WILL TELL YOU IS AND SO WHAT I WILL TELL YOU IS THAT, AS GEORGE MENTIONED, WHEN THAT, AS GEORGE MENTIONED, WHEN YOU LOOK OVERALL AT THE PREVIOUS YOU LOOK OVERALL AT THE PREVIOUS EVALUATIONS THAT WE DID BOTH EVALUATIONS THAT WE DID BOTH WITH THE OVERLAY DISTRICT AND WITH THE OVERLAY DISTRICT AND WITH THE ZONING DIMENSIONAL, YOU WITH THE ZONING DIMENSIONAL, YOU ESSENTIALLY HAVE HEIGHT ESSENTIALLY HAVE HEIGHT COMPATIBILITY. COMPATIBILITY. THIS IS A SINGLE-STORY THIS IS A SINGLE-STORY STRUCTURE. STRUCTURE. THE USE ITSELF AS GEORGE THE USE ITSELF AS GEORGE MENTIONS, IT'S SINGLE-FAMILY, MENTIONS, IT'S SINGLE-FAMILY, THAT'S WHAT OUR LAND USE IS. THAT'S WHAT OUR LAND USE IS. AND THAT'S WHAT YOU HAVE AND THAT'S WHAT YOU HAVE PREDOMINANTLY IN THE AREA -- IS PREDOMINANTLY IN THE AREA -- IS SINGLE-FAMILY. SINGLE-FAMILY. THERE ARE SOME TWO-FAMILY BUT THERE ARE SOME TWO-FAMILY BUT IT'S ALL REPRESENTATION. IT'S ALL REPRESENTATION. OF COURSE, THEY HAVE ALREADY OF COURSE, THEY HAVE ALREADY SELECTED ONE OF THE APPROVED SELECTED ONE OF THE APPROVED ARCHITECTURAL STYLE. ARCHITECTURAL STYLE. AND THEY HAVE MET ALL THE AND THEY HAVE MET ALL THE DIMENSIONAL STANDARDS. DIMENSIONAL STANDARDS. SO WHAT WE REALLY ARE FOCUSING SO WHAT WE REALLY ARE FOCUSING ON IS WHEN YOU LOOK AT THAT ON IS WHEN YOU LOOK AT THAT EXERCISE OF COMPATIBILITY WITH EXERCISE OF COMPATIBILITY WITH REGARD TO BUILDING WIDTH, HOW REGARD TO BUILDING WIDTH, HOW DOES THAT FIT IN WITH THE DOES THAT FIT IN WITH THE CONSISTENT THEME OF BUILDING CONSISTENT THEME OF BUILDING WIDTH THROUGHOUT THAT AREA. WIDTH THROUGHOUT THAT AREA. AND WHEN WE LOOK AT AND WHEN WE LOOK AT COMPATIBILITY, WE LOOK AT THE COMPATIBILITY, WE LOOK AT THE IMMEDIATELY SURROUNDING AREA. IMMEDIATELY SURROUNDING AREA. THAT'S HOW WE DO IT, AS YOU THAT'S HOW WE DO IT, AS YOU KNOW, WHEN WE DO ANY KIND OF KNOW, WHEN WE DO ANY KIND OF DESIGN REVIEW. DESIGN REVIEW. WITH THAT BEING SAID, WE DID WITH THAT BEING SAID, WE DID EXAMINE 34 PROPERTIES OF WHICH EXAMINE 34 PROPERTIES OF WHICH 33 OF THEM HAD BUILDINGS ON 33 OF THEM HAD BUILDINGS ON THEM, ONE BEING VACANT. THEM, ONE BEING VACANT. AND CONSISTENT WITH THE WAY THE AND CONSISTENT WITH THE WAY THE CODE IS INTENDED, WHEN YOU'RE CODE IS INTENDED, WHEN YOU'RE LOOKING AT BUILDING WIDTH, THE LOOKING AT BUILDING WIDTH, THE WAY OUR CODE READS, THIS IS THE WAY OUR CODE READS, THIS IS THE PRIMARY STRUCTURE. PRIMARY STRUCTURE. IT'S NOT A CUMULATIVE OF IT'S NOT A CUMULATIVE OF MULTIPLE BUILDINGS ON THE MULTIPLE BUILDINGS ON THE PROPERTY AND HOW THEY WOULD ADD PROPERTY AND HOW THEY WOULD ADD UP, SO TO SPEAK. UP, SO TO SPEAK. THIS IS THE PRIMARY STRUCTURE. THIS IS THE PRIMARY STRUCTURE. WHAT I WILL TELL YOU, WE DID WHAT I WILL TELL YOU, WE DID CONFIRM THAT WITH THE CITY CONFIRM THAT WITH THE CITY ATTORNEY'S OFFICE, THAT IS THE ATTORNEY'S OFFICE, THAT IS THE INTENT OF THE CODE. INTENT OF THE CODE. SO WITH THAT, WE DID EXAMINE SO WITH THAT, WE DID EXAMINE THOSE 33 PROPERTIES IMMEDIATELY THOSE 33 PROPERTIES IMMEDIATELY SURROUNDING BOTH NORTH AND SURROUNDING BOTH NORTH AND SOUTH. SOUTH. YOU'LL NOTICE WE WENT ABOUT 11 YOU'LL NOTICE WE WENT ABOUT 11 LOTS TO THE NORTH, 11 LOTS TO LOTS TO THE NORTH, 11 LOTS TO THE SOUTH AND WRAPPED AROUND THE THE SOUTH AND WRAPPED AROUND THE STRUCTURE. STRUCTURE. THAT IS THE SURROUNDING THAT IS THE SURROUNDING ENVIRONMENT, BOTH BUILT AND THEN ENVIRONMENT, BOTH BUILT AND THEN ONE VACANT. ONE VACANT. AND WHAT WE DETERMINED OUT OF AND WHAT WE DETERMINED OUT OF THOSE IS THAT 10 OF THOSE THOSE IS THAT 10 OF THOSE BUILDINGS ARE GREATER THAN BUILDINGS ARE GREATER THAN 60 FEET IN WIDTH. 60 FEET IN WIDTH. I'LL ALSO SHARE WITH YOU AND I'LL ALSO SHARE WITH YOU AND JUST FOR THE RECORD ALTHOUGH ALL JUST FOR THE RECORD ALTHOUGH ALL OF THIS IS IN THE STAFFING, WE OF THIS IS IN THE STAFFING, WE USED THE BUILDING DIAGRAMS FROM USED THE BUILDING DIAGRAMS FROM THE PROPERTY APPRAISER'S TO THE PROPERTY APPRAISER'S TO DETERMINE BUILDING WIDTH BECAUSE DETERMINE BUILDING WIDTH BECAUSE EACH BUILDING THERE'S A EACH BUILDING THERE'S A FOOTPRINT. FOOTPRINT. IT IS NOT HARD TO CALCULATE THE IT IS NOT HARD TO CALCULATE THE LINEAR LENGTH OF A BUILDING, OF LINEAR LENGTH OF A BUILDING, OF ALL EXISTING BUILDINGS. ALL EXISTING BUILDINGS. INSTEAD OF TRYING TO USE A INSTEAD OF TRYING TO USE A GOOGLE STREET VIEW AND MEASURE GOOGLE STREET VIEW AND MEASURE THINGS ON THE FLY, WE USED THE THINGS ON THE FLY, WE USED THE FOOTPRINTS FROM THE PROPERTY FOOTPRINTS FROM THE PROPERTY APPRAISER'S OFFICE. APPRAISER'S OFFICE. 10 BUILDINGS ARE GREATER THAN 6E 10 BUILDINGS ARE GREATER THAN 6E LARGEST BEING 109 FEET IN WIDTH. LARGEST BEING 109 FEET IN WIDTH. 23 BUILDINGS ARE LESS THAN 23 BUILDINGS ARE LESS THAN 60 FEET IN WIDTH BUT THE 60 FEET IN WIDTH BUT THE SMALLEST BEING 29 FEET IN WIDTH. SMALLEST BEING 29 FEET IN WIDTH. THE AVERAGE BUILDING WIDTH WHEN THE AVERAGE BUILDING WIDTH WHEN YOU TAKE ALL 33 OF THOSE YOU TAKE ALL 33 OF THOSE STRUCTURES IS ABOUT 53 FEET. STRUCTURES IS ABOUT 53 FEET. AND THE PREVIOUS HOME THAT AND THE PREVIOUS HOME THAT OCCUPIED THIS SITE WAS 63 FEET OCCUPIED THIS SITE WAS 63 FEET IN WIDTH. IN WIDTH. GOING A LITTLE FURTHER, YOU HAVE GOING A LITTLE FURTHER, YOU HAVE FIVE PROPERTIES INCLUDING THE FIVE PROPERTIES INCLUDING THE SUBJECT PROPERTY ARE LARGER THAN SUBJECT PROPERTY ARE LARGER THAN ONE ACRE, WITH AN AVERAGE LOT ONE ACRE, WITH AN AVERAGE LOT WIDTH OF 118 FEET. WIDTH OF 118 FEET. SO YOU'VE GOT A HANDFUL OF SO YOU'VE GOT A HANDFUL OF PROPERTIES THAT ARE BOTH LARGE PROPERTIES THAT ARE BOTH LARGE IN AREA AND QUITE WIDE. IN AREA AND QUITE WIDE. THEN BUILDINGS ON THOSE THEN BUILDINGS ON THOSE PROPERTIES AVERAGE ABOUT 74 FEET PROPERTIES AVERAGE ABOUT 74 FEET IN WIDTH WHERE APPROXIMATELY 63% IN WIDTH WHERE APPROXIMATELY 63% OF THE LOT WIDTH. OF THE LOT WIDTH. WHAT WE'RE TALKING ABOUT IS LOT WHAT WE'RE TALKING ABOUT IS LOT WIDTH-TO-BUILDING RATIO HERE. WIDTH-TO-BUILDING RATIO HERE. HOW MUCH MASSING DO YOU HAVE ON HOW MUCH MASSING DO YOU HAVE ON THE WIDTH OF THE LOT? THE WIDTH OF THE LOT? IT IS REALLY AN EXERCISE IN THAT IT IS REALLY AN EXERCISE IN THAT MATHEMATICAL, AN EXERCISE IN MATHEMATICAL, AN EXERCISE IN MATH. MATH. 28 PROPERTIES ARE LESS THAN 1 28 PROPERTIES ARE LESS THAN 1 ACRE WITH AVERAGE LOT WIDTH OF ACRE WITH AVERAGE LOT WIDTH OF 80 FEET. 80 FEET. AND BUILDINGS ON THOSE AND BUILDINGS ON THOSE PROPERTIES THAT ARE LESS THAN PROPERTIES THAT ARE LESS THAN ONE ACRE AVERAGED 49 FEET IN ONE ACRE AVERAGED 49 FEET IN WIDTH OR ABOUT 61% OF THE LOT WIDTH OR ABOUT 61% OF THE LOT WIDTH. WIDTH. SO YOU'VE GOT ABOUT 63% LOT SO YOU'VE GOT ABOUT 63% LOT WIDTH ON THE LARGER LOTS AND WIDTH ON THE LARGER LOTS AND ABOUT 61% ON THE SMALLER LOTS. ABOUT 61% ON THE SMALLER LOTS. BUILDINGS ON PROPERTIES -- BUILDINGS ON PROPERTIES -- EXCUSE ME. EXCUSE ME. SO THEN TO TAKE IT A STEP SO THEN TO TAKE IT A STEP FURTHER, BECAUSE DEPTH -- FURTHER, BECAUSE DEPTH -- BECAUSE AREA CAN BE DERIVED FROM BECAUSE AREA CAN BE DERIVED FROM A LOT OF THESE VERY DEEP LOTS. A LOT OF THESE VERY DEEP LOTS. WE'RE FOCUSING ON LOT WIDTH AS WE'RE FOCUSING ON LOT WIDTH AS WELL AS BUILDING WIDTH. WELL AS BUILDING WIDTH. AND THAT RATIO. AND THAT RATIO. SO WE THEN MOVED INTO THE FOLD SO WE THEN MOVED INTO THE FOLD ALL LOTS THAT ARE AT LEAST ALL LOTS THAT ARE AT LEAST 100 FEET WIDE, THE WIDER LOTS. 100 FEET WIDE, THE WIDER LOTS. AND THERE'S NINE OF THOSE. AND THERE'S NINE OF THOSE. AND THAT ARE GREATER THAN AND THAT ARE GREATER THAN 100 FEET IN WIDTH WITH AN 100 FEET IN WIDTH WITH AN AVERAGE LOT WIDTH WHEN YOU AVERAGE LOT WIDTH WHEN YOU AVERAGE THOSE NINE OF 114 FEET. AVERAGE THOSE NINE OF 114 FEET. AND BUILDINGS ON THOSE NINE LOTS AND BUILDINGS ON THOSE NINE LOTS AVERAGED 73 FEET IN WIDTH OR AVERAGED 73 FEET IN WIDTH OR APPROXIMATELY 64% OF THE AVERAGE APPROXIMATELY 64% OF THE AVERAGE LOT WIDTH. LOT WIDTH. SO WHEN YOU APPLY THOSE GUIDING SO WHEN YOU APPLY THOSE GUIDING PRINCIPLES TO THE SUBJECT PRINCIPLES TO THE SUBJECT PROPERTY WHICH IS LARGER THAN AN PROPERTY WHICH IS LARGER THAN AN ACRE AND LARGER THAN 100 FEET -- ACRE AND LARGER THAN 100 FEET -- IT'S 102 FEET WIDE AND YOU USE IT'S 102 FEET WIDE AND YOU USE THE AVERAGE BETWEEN THE LARGE THE AVERAGE BETWEEN THE LARGE LOTS OF 63 TO 64%, YOU END UP LOTS OF 63 TO 64%, YOU END UP WITH AN AVERAGE BUILDING WIDTH WITH AN AVERAGE BUILDING WIDTH ON THIS LOT USING THAT RATIO OF ON THIS LOT USING THAT RATIO OF 64.3 FEET TO 65.3 FEET. 64.3 FEET TO 65.3 FEET. YOU AVERAGE THOSE. YOU AVERAGE THOSE. 64.8 FEET. 64.8 FEET. THAT'S TAKING THE NINE LARGEST THAT'S TAKING THE NINE LARGEST LOTS AND USING THOSE AS YOUR LOTS AND USING THOSE AS YOUR BEST COMPARISON OF LOT WIDTH TO BEST COMPARISON OF LOT WIDTH TO BUILDING WIDTH RATIO. BUILDING WIDTH RATIO. AND WE HAVE JUST SIMPLY SAID AND WE HAVE JUST SIMPLY SAID ROUNDING THE 64.8 FEET TO ROUNDING THE 64.8 FEET TO 65 FEET. 65 FEET. SO THAT'S THE METHODOLOGY BEHIND SO THAT'S THE METHODOLOGY BEHIND WHY THE RECOMMENDATION IS THAT WHY THE RECOMMENDATION IS THAT GIVEN THE WIDTH OF THIS LOT, GIVEN THE WIDTH OF THIS LOT, GIVEN THE SURROUNDING BUILT GIVEN THE SURROUNDING BUILT ENVIRONMENT AND THE LOT-TO-WIDTH ENVIRONMENT AND THE LOT-TO-WIDTH RATIO FOR THOSE LARGER LOTS WITH RATIO FOR THOSE LARGER LOTS WITH GENERALLY LARGER BUILDINGS ON GENERALLY LARGER BUILDINGS ON IT, THAT'S HOW STAFF ARRIVED AT IT, THAT'S HOW STAFF ARRIVED AT THE RECOMMENDATION OF 65 FEET. THE RECOMMENDATION OF 65 FEET. >> Chair: QUESTION. >> Chair: QUESTION. >> Chair: QUESTION. WHAT >> Chair: QUESTION. WHAT WAS >> Chair: QUESTION. WHAT WAS THE >> Chair: QUESTION. WHAT WAS THE REASON >> Chair: QUESTION. WHAT WAS THE REASON FOR >> Chair: QUESTION. WHAT WAS THE REASON FOR THE WHAT WAS THE REASON FOR THE 60-FOOT LIMITATION IN THE FIRST 60-FOOT LIMITATION IN THE FIRST PLACE? PLACE? >> YEAH. >> YEAH. >> YEAH. SO >> YEAH. SO I >> YEAH. SO I THINK >> YEAH. SO I THINK IT >> YEAH. SO I THINK IT WAS >> YEAH. SO I THINK IT WAS -- >> YEAH. SO I THINK IT WAS -- THERE >> YEAH. SO I THINK IT WAS -- THERE WAS >> YEAH. SO I THINK IT WAS -- THERE WAS A SO I THINK IT WAS -- THERE WAS A DESIRE AT THE TIME -- THERE WAS DESIRE AT THE TIME -- THERE WAS A LOT OF CONVERSATION ABOUT A LOT OF CONVERSATION ABOUT LIMITING THE MASSING IN FRONT LIMITING THE MASSING IN FRONT AND MAKING SURE THERE WAS SOME AND MAKING SURE THERE WAS SOME ARCHITECTURAL STYLE. ARCHITECTURAL STYLE. AND THAT'S KIND OF THE REASON AND THAT'S KIND OF THE REASON FOR THE REAR YARD GARAGE FOR THE REAR YARD GARAGE PLACEMENT. PLACEMENT. BUT IT WAS MORE ABOUT JUST BUT IT WAS MORE ABOUT JUST MINIMIZING THE MASSING AND MINIMIZING THE MASSING AND TRYING TO MINIMIZE THE LARGER TRYING TO MINIMIZE THE LARGER FRONTAGE HOMES. FRONTAGE HOMES. IT IS PURELY MASSING. IT IS PURELY MASSING. >> Chair: WHEN WAS THAT? >> Chair: WHEN WAS THAT? >> Chair: WHEN WAS THAT? >> >> Chair: WHEN WAS THAT? >> WHEN >> Chair: WHEN WAS THAT? >> WHEN WAS >> Chair: WHEN WAS THAT? >> WHEN WAS IT >> Chair: WHEN WAS THAT? >> WHEN WAS IT ADOPTED? >> WHEN WAS IT ADOPTED? >> WHEN WAS IT ADOPTED? >> >> WHEN WAS IT ADOPTED? >> Chair: >> WHEN WAS IT ADOPTED? >> Chair: YEAH. >> Chair: YEAH. >> Chair: YEAH. [SPEAKER >> Chair: YEAH. [SPEAKER OFF >> Chair: YEAH. [SPEAKER OFF MIC] [SPEAKER OFF MIC] >> NO, IT WAS BEFORE I LEFT. >> NO, IT WAS BEFORE I LEFT. >> NO, IT WAS BEFORE I LEFT. >> >> NO, IT WAS BEFORE I LEFT. >> Chair: >> NO, IT WAS BEFORE I LEFT. >> Chair: TWO >> NO, IT WAS BEFORE I LEFT. >> Chair: TWO YEARS >> NO, IT WAS BEFORE I LEFT. >> Chair: TWO YEARS AGO? >> Chair: TWO YEARS AGO? >> Chair: TWO YEARS AGO? >> >> Chair: TWO YEARS AGO? >> YEAH. >> YEAH. >> YEAH. >> >> YEAH. >> Chair: >> YEAH. >> Chair: BUT >> YEAH. >> Chair: BUT YOU'RE >> Chair: BUT YOU'RE >> Chair: BUT YOU'RE RECOMMENDING >> Chair: BUT YOU'RE RECOMMENDING THAT >> Chair: BUT YOU'RE RECOMMENDING THAT WE >> Chair: BUT YOU'RE RECOMMENDING THAT WE IGNORE >> Chair: BUT YOU'RE RECOMMENDING THAT WE IGNORE THAT RECOMMENDING THAT WE IGNORE THAT AND SEVERAL HAVE IGNORED IT. AND SEVERAL HAVE IGNORED IT. >> SO NO. >> SO NO. >> SO NO. SO >> SO NO. SO THE >> SO NO. SO THE DESIGN >> SO NO. SO THE DESIGN REVIEW >> SO NO. SO THE DESIGN REVIEW PIECE >> SO NO. SO THE DESIGN REVIEW PIECE OF SO THE DESIGN REVIEW PIECE OF THIS IS NOT INTENDED TO LIMIT THIS IS NOT INTENDED TO LIMIT WHAT AN APPLICANT CAN DO. WHAT AN APPLICANT CAN DO. IT IS MEANT TO GET IT INTO A IT IS MEANT TO GET IT INTO A PUBLIC ENVIRONMENT FOR REVIEW. PUBLIC ENVIRONMENT FOR REVIEW. >> Chair: OKAY. >> Chair: OKAY. >> Chair: OKAY. >> >> Chair: OKAY. >> SO >> Chair: OKAY. >> SO IT'S >> Chair: OKAY. >> SO IT'S NOT >> Chair: OKAY. >> SO IT'S NOT TO >> Chair: OKAY. >> SO IT'S NOT TO SAY >> Chair: OKAY. >> SO IT'S NOT TO SAY THAT >> Chair: OKAY. >> SO IT'S NOT TO SAY THAT 65 >> Chair: OKAY. >> SO IT'S NOT TO SAY THAT 65 IS >> SO IT'S NOT TO SAY THAT 65 IS >> SO IT'S NOT TO SAY THAT 65 IS BAD. BAD. IT'S NOT TO SAY THAT WHAT THEY IT'S NOT TO SAY THAT WHAT THEY ARE PROPOSING AT 75 OR 77 IS ARE PROPOSING AT 75 OR 77 IS BAD. BAD. IT'S JUST THE IDEA WAS THAT IT'S JUST THE IDEA WAS THAT THERE NEEDED TO BE MORE PUBLIC THERE NEEDED TO BE MORE PUBLIC SCRUTINY FOR HOMES THAT STARTED SCRUTINY FOR HOMES THAT STARTED TO EVOLVE TO A STATE WHERE IT TO EVOLVE TO A STATE WHERE IT APPEARED THERE WAS MORE MASSING. APPEARED THERE WAS MORE MASSING. >> Chair: OKAY. >> Chair: OKAY. >> Chair: OKAY. >> >> Chair: OKAY. >> WELL, >> Chair: OKAY. >> WELL, IF >> Chair: OKAY. >> WELL, IF I >> Chair: OKAY. >> WELL, IF I CAN >> Chair: OKAY. >> WELL, IF I CAN ALSO >> Chair: OKAY. >> WELL, IF I CAN ALSO SAY >> WELL, IF I CAN ALSO SAY >> WELL, IF I CAN ALSO SAY SOMETHING. SOMETHING. IT WAS IN DIRECT THAT THE IT WAS IN DIRECT THAT THE LOTS -- THAT THE STRUCTURE LOTS -- THAT THE STRUCTURE SHOULD FIT THE LOT SIZE. SHOULD FIT THE LOT SIZE. SO YOU DIDN'T TAKE ONE PIECE OF SO YOU DIDN'T TAKE ONE PIECE OF PROPERTY AND TOTALLY BUILD IT PROPERTY AND TOTALLY BUILD IT OUT. OUT. AND THAT WAS THE HEART AND SOUL AND THAT WAS THE HEART AND SOUL OF THAT ORDINANCE. OF THAT ORDINANCE. >> AND TO ADD ON THAT -- THAT'S >> AND TO ADD ON THAT -- THAT'S >> AND TO ADD ON THAT -- THAT'S A >> AND TO ADD ON THAT -- THAT'S A GREAT >> AND TO ADD ON THAT -- THAT'S A GREAT POINT, >> AND TO ADD ON THAT -- THAT'S A GREAT POINT, MS. >> AND TO ADD ON THAT -- THAT'S A GREAT POINT, MS. KYNES. A GREAT POINT, MS. KYNES. AND TO ADD ON TO THAT, I THINK AND TO ADD ON TO THAT, I THINK THERE WAS A CONCERN ABOUT THERE WAS A CONCERN ABOUT AGGREGATING LOTS AS WELL. AGGREGATING LOTS AS WELL. IF YOU COULD AGGREGATE LOTS, YOU IF YOU COULD AGGREGATE LOTS, YOU COULD CONTINUE TO GET WIDER AND COULD CONTINUE TO GET WIDER AND WIDER AND WIDER. WIDER AND WIDER. THE IDEA WAS EVEN IF YOU THE IDEA WAS EVEN IF YOU AGGREGATE LOTS, THAT 60-FOOT AGGREGATE LOTS, THAT 60-FOOT BRINGS YOU BACK INTO THE IDEA. BRINGS YOU BACK INTO THE IDEA. THEN THE METHODOLOGY THAT JOEY THEN THE METHODOLOGY THAT JOEY JUST EXPLAINED HITS EXACTLY ON JUST EXPLAINED HITS EXACTLY ON THAT. THAT. NOW WE NEED TO LOOK AT THAT NOW WE NEED TO LOOK AT THAT CHARACTER OF THE AREA. CHARACTER OF THE AREA. AND WHAT IS THAT MASSING AGAINST AND WHAT IS THAT MASSING AGAINST THE FRONTAGE WIDTH? THE FRONTAGE WIDTH? AND THAT'S WHERE WE DERIVE THE AND THAT'S WHERE WE DERIVE THE PERCENTAGE. PERCENTAGE. BY LOOKING AT ALL THOSE LOTS, BY LOOKING AT ALL THOSE LOTS, WHAT WE ARRIVED AT WAS IF YOU WHAT WE ARRIVED AT WAS IF YOU BASICALLY TAKE ALL OF THOSE BASICALLY TAKE ALL OF THOSE HOMES IN THERE, ABOUT 65 FEET HOMES IN THERE, ABOUT 65 FEET FOR THE LOTS OVER AN ACRE OR 10T FOR THE LOTS OVER AN ACRE OR 10T YOU ARE SEEING OUT THERE. YOU ARE SEEING OUT THERE. >> AND THAT'S YOUR >> AND THAT'S YOUR >> AND THAT'S YOUR RECOMMENDATION? RECOMMENDATION? >> SO WE'LL GET TO THAT. >> SO WE'LL GET TO THAT. >> SO WE'LL GET TO THAT. BUT >> SO WE'LL GET TO THAT. BUT YES, >> SO WE'LL GET TO THAT. BUT YES, THAT'S >> SO WE'LL GET TO THAT. BUT YES, THAT'S ULTIMATELY >> SO WE'LL GET TO THAT. BUT YES, THAT'S ULTIMATELY OUR BUT YES, THAT'S ULTIMATELY OUR RECOMMENDATION. RECOMMENDATION. >> CAN I SEE SOME OF THE -- YOU >> CAN I SEE SOME OF THE -- YOU >> CAN I SEE SOME OF THE -- YOU GAVE >> CAN I SEE SOME OF THE -- YOU GAVE US >> CAN I SEE SOME OF THE -- YOU GAVE US ALL >> CAN I SEE SOME OF THE -- YOU GAVE US ALL THESE, >> CAN I SEE SOME OF THE -- YOU GAVE US ALL THESE, YOU >> CAN I SEE SOME OF THE -- YOU GAVE US ALL THESE, YOU KNOW >> CAN I SEE SOME OF THE -- YOU GAVE US ALL THESE, YOU KNOW -- GAVE US ALL THESE, YOU KNOW -- YOU SHOWED ALL THE HOUSES ON YOU SHOWED ALL THE HOUSES ON EDGEWATER. EDGEWATER. COULD I SEE THOSE PICTURES, COULD I SEE THOSE PICTURES, PLEASE? PLEASE? >> SO I DON'T KNOW IF I HAVE >> SO I DON'T KNOW IF I HAVE >> SO I DON'T KNOW IF I HAVE THAT >> SO I DON'T KNOW IF I HAVE THAT IN >> SO I DON'T KNOW IF I HAVE THAT IN THE >> SO I DON'T KNOW IF I HAVE THAT IN THE POWERPOINT. THAT IN THE POWERPOINT. IT SHOULD BE IN YOUR STAFFING. IT SHOULD BE IN YOUR STAFFING. >> NO, I KNOW. >> NO, I KNOW. >> NO, I KNOW. WE >> NO, I KNOW. WE READ >> NO, I KNOW. WE READ IT. WE READ IT. BUT, ONE, I MEAN I'LL JUST MOVE BUT, ONE, I MEAN I'LL JUST MOVE TO STRIKE IT BECAUSE 505 SHOULD TO STRIKE IT BECAUSE 505 SHOULD NOT HAVE BEEN INCLUDED IN THOSE NOT HAVE BEEN INCLUDED IN THOSE CALCULATIONS. CALCULATIONS. STRIKE 505. STRIKE 505. >> THAT'S THE LARGER ONE? >> THAT'S THE LARGER ONE? >> THAT'S THE LARGER ONE? >> >> THAT'S THE LARGER ONE? >> JUST >> THAT'S THE LARGER ONE? >> JUST FOR >> THAT'S THE LARGER ONE? >> JUST FOR THE >> THAT'S THE LARGER ONE? >> JUST FOR THE RECORD, >> THAT'S THE LARGER ONE? >> JUST FOR THE RECORD, THE >> JUST FOR THE RECORD, THE >> JUST FOR THE RECORD, THE ANALYSIS >> JUST FOR THE RECORD, THE ANALYSIS THAT >> JUST FOR THE RECORD, THE ANALYSIS THAT WAS >> JUST FOR THE RECORD, THE ANALYSIS THAT WAS USED >> JUST FOR THE RECORD, THE ANALYSIS THAT WAS USED FOR >> JUST FOR THE RECORD, THE ANALYSIS THAT WAS USED FOR THE ANALYSIS THAT WAS USED FOR THE RECOMMENDATION WAS THE 33 HOMES RECOMMENDATION WAS THE 33 HOMES YOU SAW ON EXHIBIT D WHICH YOU SAW ON EXHIBIT D WHICH STOPPED AT FLORIDA AVENUE. STOPPED AT FLORIDA AVENUE. >> I SAW ALL OF IT. >> I SAW ALL OF IT. >> I SAW ALL OF IT. >> >> I SAW ALL OF IT. >> IT >> I SAW ALL OF IT. >> IT DID >> I SAW ALL OF IT. >> IT DID NOT >> I SAW ALL OF IT. >> IT DID NOT GO >> I SAW ALL OF IT. >> IT DID NOT GO NORTH >> I SAW ALL OF IT. >> IT DID NOT GO NORTH OF >> IT DID NOT GO NORTH OF >> IT DID NOT GO NORTH OF FLORIDA >> IT DID NOT GO NORTH OF FLORIDA AVENUE. FLORIDA AVENUE. >> I THINK IT WOULD HAVE BEEN >> I THINK IT WOULD HAVE BEEN >> I THINK IT WOULD HAVE BEEN INTERESTING >> I THINK IT WOULD HAVE BEEN INTERESTING IF >> I THINK IT WOULD HAVE BEEN INTERESTING IF YOU >> I THINK IT WOULD HAVE BEEN INTERESTING IF YOU COULD >> I THINK IT WOULD HAVE BEEN INTERESTING IF YOU COULD HAVE INTERESTING IF YOU COULD HAVE SHOWN THEM WHAT WE SAW. SHOWN THEM WHAT WE SAW. SEE, WE GOT TO SEE THOSE AND YOU SEE, WE GOT TO SEE THOSE AND YOU PRESENTED THEM TO US, ALL THOSE PRESENTED THEM TO US, ALL THOSE PHOTOGRAPHS OF HERE'S ALL THESE PHOTOGRAPHS OF HERE'S ALL THESE HOUSES. HOUSES. BUT THEY CAN'T SEE IT. BUT THEY CAN'T SEE IT. WELL, THE AUDIENCE. WELL, THE AUDIENCE. >> RIGHT, THE PUBLIC HERE. >> RIGHT, THE PUBLIC HERE. >> RIGHT, THE PUBLIC HERE. >> >> RIGHT, THE PUBLIC HERE. >> THE >> RIGHT, THE PUBLIC HERE. >> THE PUBLIC. >> THE PUBLIC. >> THE PUBLIC. >> >> THE PUBLIC. >> OUR >> THE PUBLIC. >> OUR STAFFING >> THE PUBLIC. >> OUR STAFFING DID >> THE PUBLIC. >> OUR STAFFING DID NOT >> THE PUBLIC. >> OUR STAFFING DID NOT INCLUDE >> OUR STAFFING DID NOT INCLUDE >> OUR STAFFING DID NOT INCLUDE ANY >> OUR STAFFING DID NOT INCLUDE ANY PHOTOGRAPHS. ANY PHOTOGRAPHS. THAT MIGHT HAVE BEEN THE THAT MIGHT HAVE BEEN THE APPLICANT'S STAFFING. APPLICANT'S STAFFING. >> I SAW EVERY PHOTOGRAPH. >> I SAW EVERY PHOTOGRAPH. >> I SAW EVERY PHOTOGRAPH. THERE >> I SAW EVERY PHOTOGRAPH. THERE WAS >> I SAW EVERY PHOTOGRAPH. THERE WAS 505. THERE WAS 505. I MEAN YOU WENT RIGHT DOWN THE I MEAN YOU WENT RIGHT DOWN THE LINE. LINE. >> IT'S THEIR -- >> IT'S THEIR -- >> IT'S THEIR -- >> >> IT'S THEIR -- >> IT'S >> IT'S THEIR -- >> IT'S THE >> IT'S THEIR -- >> IT'S THE APPLICANT'S >> IT'S THE APPLICANT'S >> IT'S THE APPLICANT'S PRESENTATION? PRESENTATION? THAT'S THEIR DOCUMENTS. THAT'S THEIR DOCUMENTS. >> SO IT'S YOUR DOCUMENT. >> SO IT'S YOUR DOCUMENT. >> SO IT'S YOUR DOCUMENT. I'LL >> SO IT'S YOUR DOCUMENT. I'LL MOVE >> SO IT'S YOUR DOCUMENT. I'LL MOVE TO >> SO IT'S YOUR DOCUMENT. I'LL MOVE TO STRIKE >> SO IT'S YOUR DOCUMENT. I'LL MOVE TO STRIKE 505, >> SO IT'S YOUR DOCUMENT. I'LL MOVE TO STRIKE 505, GLADLY. I'LL MOVE TO STRIKE 505, GLADLY. >> YEAH. >> YEAH. >> YEAH. JUST >> YEAH. JUST FOR >> YEAH. JUST FOR THE >> YEAH. JUST FOR THE RECORD, >> YEAH. JUST FOR THE RECORD, FOR >> YEAH. JUST FOR THE RECORD, FOR THE JUST FOR THE RECORD, FOR THE PURPOSE OF STAFF REPORT -- NOW, PURPOSE OF STAFF REPORT -- NOW, WE DID LOOK AT THE PROPERTIES WE DID LOOK AT THE PROPERTIES NORTH. NORTH. WE DID TAKE A LOOK AT THOSE. WE DID TAKE A LOOK AT THOSE. BUT FOR THE PURPOSE OF BUT FOR THE PURPOSE OF COMPATIBILITY ANALYSIS, IT IS COMPATIBILITY ANALYSIS, IT IS THE SURROUNDING AREA. THE SURROUNDING AREA. AND FRANKLY NORTH OF FLORIDA AND FRANKLY NORTH OF FLORIDA AVENUE IS NO LONGER THE AVENUE IS NO LONGER THE SURROUNDING AREA REALLY FOR THE SURROUNDING AREA REALLY FOR THE PURPOSE. PURPOSE. AND THAT'S HOW WE CONSISTENTLY AND THAT'S HOW WE CONSISTENTLY LOOKED AT COMPATIBILITY WITH LOOKED AT COMPATIBILITY WITH REGARD TO DESIGN REVIEW, WHETHER REGARD TO DESIGN REVIEW, WHETHER IT'S THIS PROJECT -- IT'S THIS PROJECT -- >> SO YOU JUST LOOKED AT FLORIDA >> SO YOU JUST LOOKED AT FLORIDA >> SO YOU JUST LOOKED AT FLORIDA TO >> SO YOU JUST LOOKED AT FLORIDA TO ORANGEWOOD? TO ORANGEWOOD? IS THAT WHAT YOU'RE TELLING ME? IS THAT WHAT YOU'RE TELLING ME? >> WE LOOKED FROM FLORIDA NORTH, >> WE LOOKED FROM FLORIDA NORTH, >> WE LOOKED FROM FLORIDA NORTH, THE >> WE LOOKED FROM FLORIDA NORTH, THE CORNER >> WE LOOKED FROM FLORIDA NORTH, THE CORNER OF >> WE LOOKED FROM FLORIDA NORTH, THE CORNER OF FLORIDA >> WE LOOKED FROM FLORIDA NORTH, THE CORNER OF FLORIDA AND THE CORNER OF FLORIDA AND EDGEWATER DOWN TO UNION STREET. EDGEWATER DOWN TO UNION STREET. >> OKAY. >> OKAY. >> OKAY. >> >> OKAY. >> AND >> OKAY. >> AND EVERYTHING >> OKAY. >> AND EVERYTHING ALONG >> OKAY. >> AND EVERYTHING ALONG THERE >> AND EVERYTHING ALONG THERE >> AND EVERYTHING ALONG THERE AND >> AND EVERYTHING ALONG THERE AND WRAPPING >> AND EVERYTHING ALONG THERE AND WRAPPING AROUND >> AND EVERYTHING ALONG THERE AND WRAPPING AROUND THE >> AND EVERYTHING ALONG THERE AND WRAPPING AROUND THE PROPERTY AND WRAPPING AROUND THE PROPERTY AS WELL. AS WELL. WHICH I BELIEVE IS ORANGE AND WHICH I BELIEVE IS ORANGE AND CITRUS, IF I REMEMBER CORRECTLY. CITRUS, IF I REMEMBER CORRECTLY. >> OKAY. >> OKAY. >> OKAY. >> >> OKAY. >> I'VE >> OKAY. >> I'VE GOT >> OKAY. >> I'VE GOT A >> OKAY. >> I'VE GOT A QUESTION. >> I'VE GOT A QUESTION. >> I'VE GOT A QUESTION. SO >> I'VE GOT A QUESTION. SO YOUR >> I'VE GOT A QUESTION. SO YOUR RECOMMENDATION >> I'VE GOT A QUESTION. SO YOUR RECOMMENDATION IS >> I'VE GOT A QUESTION. SO YOUR RECOMMENDATION IS ABOUT SO YOUR RECOMMENDATION IS ABOUT 65% OF THE WIDTH OF THE LOT, 65% OF THE WIDTH OF THE LOT, CORRECT? CORRECT? >> 64. >> 64. >> 64. >> >> 64. >> 64.8 >> 64. >> 64.8 I >> 64. >> 64.8 I THINK >> 64. >> 64.8 I THINK IT >> 64. >> 64.8 I THINK IT WAS, >> 64. >> 64.8 I THINK IT WAS, ROUNDED >> 64.8 I THINK IT WAS, ROUNDED >> 64.8 I THINK IT WAS, ROUNDED UP >> 64.8 I THINK IT WAS, ROUNDED UP TO >> 64.8 I THINK IT WAS, ROUNDED UP TO 65. UP TO 65. >> 64%. >> 64%. >> 64%. THE >> 64%. THE NUMBER >> 64%. THE NUMBER CAME >> 64%. THE NUMBER CAME OUT >> 64%. THE NUMBER CAME OUT TO >> 64%. THE NUMBER CAME OUT TO 64.8. THE NUMBER CAME OUT TO 64.8. >> GOTCHA. >> GOTCHA. >> GOTCHA. SO >> GOTCHA. SO IF >> GOTCHA. SO IF I >> GOTCHA. SO IF I TAKE >> GOTCHA. SO IF I TAKE THE >> GOTCHA. SO IF I TAKE THE 77.67-FOOT SO IF I TAKE THE 77.67-FOOT WIDTH OF THIS DESIGN DIVIDED BY WIDTH OF THIS DESIGN DIVIDED BY THE 102, I GET ABOUT 76% WHICH THE 102, I GET ABOUT 76% WHICH IS A PRETTY SIGNIFICANT IS A PRETTY SIGNIFICANT DEVIATION FROM THE GOAL, DEVIATION FROM THE GOAL, CORRECT? CORRECT? YOU SAID OF THE NINE LOTS YOU SAID OF THE NINE LOTS THAT% CORRECT? YOU SAID OF THE NINE LOTS THAT% YOU SAID OF THE NINE LOTS THAT% ARE GREATER THAN 100 FEET, THE ARE GREATER THAN 100 FEET, THE AVERAGE WIDTH WAS 73 FEET. AVERAGE WIDTH WAS 73 FEET. IN GETTING THAT AVERAGE, HOW IN GETTING THAT AVERAGE, HOW MANY OF THOSE PROPERTIES WERE MANY OF THOSE PROPERTIES WERE APPROACHING MAYBE THAT 70% TO APPROACHING MAYBE THAT 70% TO 76% WIDTH OF PROPERTY? 76% WIDTH OF PROPERTY? BECAUSE THERE MUST BE SOME THAT BECAUSE THERE MUST BE SOME THAT ARE WIDER THAN THE 64% TO GET TO ARE WIDER THAN THE 64% TO GET TO THAT AVERAGE. THAT AVERAGE. >> BUT NOT -- YOU CANNOT TAKE >> BUT NOT -- YOU CANNOT TAKE >> BUT NOT -- YOU CANNOT TAKE INTO >> BUT NOT -- YOU CANNOT TAKE INTO CONSIDERATION >> BUT NOT -- YOU CANNOT TAKE INTO CONSIDERATION 505 >> BUT NOT -- YOU CANNOT TAKE INTO CONSIDERATION 505 BECAUSE INTO CONSIDERATION 505 BECAUSE IT WAS BUILT BEFORE -- THEY IT WAS BUILT BEFORE -- THEY ALREADY PULLED THE PERMIT AND IT ALREADY PULLED THE PERMIT AND IT WAS BUILT BEFORE THE ORDINANCE WAS BUILT BEFORE THE ORDINANCE CAME INTO PLAY. CAME INTO PLAY. IT IS BUILT PROPERTY LINE TO IT IS BUILT PROPERTY LINE TO PROPERTY LINE. PROPERTY LINE. YOU CAN LOOK AT IT. YOU CAN LOOK AT IT. >> Chair: WELL, LET THE MAN ASK >> Chair: WELL, LET THE MAN ASK >> Chair: WELL, LET THE MAN ASK HIS >> Chair: WELL, LET THE MAN ASK HIS QUESTION. HIS QUESTION. >> YEAH, SORRY. >> YEAH, SORRY. >> YEAH, SORRY. >> >> YEAH, SORRY. >> YEAH. >> YEAH. >> YEAH. I >> YEAH. I HAVE >> YEAH. I HAVE ALREADY >> YEAH. I HAVE ALREADY MADE >> YEAH. I HAVE ALREADY MADE A >> YEAH. I HAVE ALREADY MADE A MENTAL I HAVE ALREADY MADE A MENTAL NOTE DON'T COUNT 505. NOTE DON'T COUNT 505. >> SO WHAT I CAN TELL YOU, JUST >> SO WHAT I CAN TELL YOU, JUST >> SO WHAT I CAN TELL YOU, JUST LOOKING >> SO WHAT I CAN TELL YOU, JUST LOOKING AT >> SO WHAT I CAN TELL YOU, JUST LOOKING AT THE >> SO WHAT I CAN TELL YOU, JUST LOOKING AT THE TABLE >> SO WHAT I CAN TELL YOU, JUST LOOKING AT THE TABLE THAT >> SO WHAT I CAN TELL YOU, JUST LOOKING AT THE TABLE THAT WAS LOOKING AT THE TABLE THAT WAS THE SPREADSHEET THAT WAS USED TO THE SPREADSHEET THAT WAS USED TO PREPARE THIS, WE DO HAVE A PREPARE THIS, WE DO HAVE A NUMBER OF BUILDINGS -- THE NUMBER OF BUILDINGS -- THE AVERAGE AGAIN IS 64. AVERAGE AGAIN IS 64. YOU DO HAVE THE LOW BEING 50%, YOU DO HAVE THE LOW BEING 50%, THE HIGH BEING 91%. THE HIGH BEING 91%. >> OKAY. >> OKAY. >> OKAY. >> >> OKAY. >> SO >> OKAY. >> SO AGAIN, >> OKAY. >> SO AGAIN, YOU'VE >> OKAY. >> SO AGAIN, YOU'VE GOT >> OKAY. >> SO AGAIN, YOU'VE GOT -- >> OKAY. >> SO AGAIN, YOU'VE GOT -- I'LL >> SO AGAIN, YOU'VE GOT -- I'LL >> SO AGAIN, YOU'VE GOT -- I'LL JUST >> SO AGAIN, YOU'VE GOT -- I'LL JUST GIVE >> SO AGAIN, YOU'VE GOT -- I'LL JUST GIVE YOU >> SO AGAIN, YOU'VE GOT -- I'LL JUST GIVE YOU THE >> SO AGAIN, YOU'VE GOT -- I'LL JUST GIVE YOU THE NUMBERS >> SO AGAIN, YOU'VE GOT -- I'LL JUST GIVE YOU THE NUMBERS OF >> SO AGAIN, YOU'VE GOT -- I'LL JUST GIVE YOU THE NUMBERS OF THE JUST GIVE YOU THE NUMBERS OF THE NINE PROPERTIES. NINE PROPERTIES. 63%, 48%, 91%, 39%, 80%, 62%, 63%, 48%, 91%, 39%, 80%, 62%, 73%, 50% AND 73%. 73%, 50% AND 73%. >> OKAY. >> OKAY. >> OKAY. SO >> OKAY. SO FOUR >> OKAY. SO FOUR PROPERTIES >> OKAY. SO FOUR PROPERTIES ARE >> OKAY. SO FOUR PROPERTIES ARE ROUGHLY SO FOUR PROPERTIES ARE ROUGHLY THIS SAME PERCENTAGE WIDTH OF THIS SAME PERCENTAGE WIDTH OF THE PROPERTY. THE PROPERTY. OKAY. OKAY. >> Chair: ARE THERE OTHER >> Chair: ARE THERE OTHER >> Chair: ARE THERE OTHER QUESTIONS >> Chair: ARE THERE OTHER QUESTIONS OF >> Chair: ARE THERE OTHER QUESTIONS OF THE >> Chair: ARE THERE OTHER QUESTIONS OF THE STAFF? QUESTIONS OF THE STAFF? >> SO WE HAVE A COUPLE MORE >> SO WE HAVE A COUPLE MORE >> SO WE HAVE A COUPLE MORE SLIDES. SLIDES. >> Chair: PLEASE. >> Chair: PLEASE. >> Chair: PLEASE. >> >> Chair: PLEASE. >> DR. >> Chair: PLEASE. >> DR. BROOM, >> Chair: PLEASE. >> DR. BROOM, IF >> Chair: PLEASE. >> DR. BROOM, IF IT'S >> Chair: PLEASE. >> DR. BROOM, IF IT'S OKAY, >> Chair: PLEASE. >> DR. BROOM, IF IT'S OKAY, I'LL >> DR. BROOM, IF IT'S OKAY, I'LL >> DR. BROOM, IF IT'S OKAY, I'LL WALK >> DR. BROOM, IF IT'S OKAY, I'LL WALK THROUGH >> DR. BROOM, IF IT'S OKAY, I'LL WALK THROUGH THESE >> DR. BROOM, IF IT'S OKAY, I'LL WALK THROUGH THESE QUICKLY. WALK THROUGH THESE QUICKLY. I DO WANT TO GET TO THE I DO WANT TO GET TO THE RECOMMENDATION AS WELL. RECOMMENDATION AS WELL. DESIGN STANDARDS, YOU HAVE SEEN DESIGN STANDARDS, YOU HAVE SEEN THIS SEVERAL TIMES AS WE BRING THIS SEVERAL TIMES AS WE BRING DESIGN APPLICATIONS THROUGH. DESIGN APPLICATIONS THROUGH. THESE ARE THE TESTS THAT ARE THESE ARE THE TESTS THAT ARE REQUIRED AS PART OF THE REQUIRED AS PART OF THE APPLICATION PROCESS. APPLICATION PROCESS. OBVIOUSLY, THEY ARE A LITTLE BIT OBVIOUSLY, THEY ARE A LITTLE BIT MITIGATED BECAUSE THIS IS A MITIGATED BECAUSE THIS IS A SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCE VERSUS A SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCE VERSUS A LARGE COMMERCIAL PROJECT OR LARGE COMMERCIAL PROJECT OR LARGE RESIDENTIAL PROJECT. LARGE RESIDENTIAL PROJECT. HOWEVER, THEY HAVE COMPLIED WITH HOWEVER, THEY HAVE COMPLIED WITH EACH OF THOSE DESIGN REVIEW EACH OF THOSE DESIGN REVIEW STANDARDS. STANDARDS. THE DEVELOPMENT REVIEW COMMITTEE THE DEVELOPMENT REVIEW COMMITTEE DID HEAR THIS REQUEST ON MAY DID HEAR THIS REQUEST ON MAY 15th OF 2024. 15th OF 2024. ALL OF THEIR COMMENTS AND ITEMS ALL OF THEIR COMMENTS AND ITEMS HAVE BEEN ADDRESSED OR ARE HAVE BEEN ADDRESSED OR ARE ADDRESSED AS PART OF THE ADDRESSED AS PART OF THE RECOMMENDATIONS OF APPROVAL. RECOMMENDATIONS OF APPROVAL. AND THE ARCHITECTURE REVIEW AND THE ARCHITECTURE REVIEW COMMITTEE ALSO SAW THE PROJECT COMMITTEE ALSO SAW THE PROJECT AND RECOMMENDED TO THE LPA ON AND RECOMMENDED TO THE LPA ON JUNE 4, 2024. JUNE 4, 2024. A FORMAL REVIEW TOOK PLACE ON A FORMAL REVIEW TOOK PLACE ON JUNE 2, 2024 WITH THE DRC JUNE 2, 2024 WITH THE DRC UNANIMOUSLY APPROVING THE UNANIMOUSLY APPROVING THE DESIGN. DESIGN. FINALLY OUR STAFF DETERMINATION, FINALLY OUR STAFF DETERMINATION, KIND OF GETTING BACK TO THAT KIND OF GETTING BACK TO THAT METHODOLOGY AND ALL THOSE THINGS METHODOLOGY AND ALL THOSE THINGS WE SPOKE ABOUT, STAFF IS WE SPOKE ABOUT, STAFF IS RECOMMENDING DESIGN REVIEW 2024 RECOMMENDING DESIGN REVIEW 2024 FOR CONSIDERATION SUBJECT TO THE FOR CONSIDERATION SUBJECT TO THE FOLLOWING CONDITIONS. FOLLOWING CONDITIONS. THAT THE NEW SINGLE-FAMILY THAT THE NEW SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCE NOT EXCEED 65 FEET IN RESIDENCE NOT EXCEED 65 FEET IN WIDTH AT THE FRONT SETBACK LINE WIDTH AT THE FRONT SETBACK LINE FOR PHYSICAL COMPATIBILITY WITH FOR PHYSICAL COMPATIBILITY WITH THE EXISTING BUILDINGS IN THE THE EXISTING BUILDINGS IN THE SURROUNDING AREAS. SURROUNDING AREAS. AND I WOULD JUST ADD THE HOME AND I WOULD JUST ADD THE HOME THAT CAME OUT OF THERE WAS 63. THAT CAME OUT OF THERE WAS 63. SO IT WAS NOT LOST ON US THAT'S SO IT WAS NOT LOST ON US THAT'S KIND OF WHERE THAT LANDED, YOU KIND OF WHERE THAT LANDED, YOU KNOW, AS PART OF THE REVIEW. KNOW, AS PART OF THE REVIEW. NUMBER TWO, THE APPLICANT NUMBER TWO, THE APPLICANT DEVELOPER'S RESPONSE FOR MEETING DEVELOPER'S RESPONSE FOR MEETING THE MINIMUM CRITERIA OF THE LAND THE MINIMUM CRITERIA OF THE LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE FOR ACQUIRING DEVELOPMENT CODE FOR ACQUIRING ALL JURISDICTIONAL PERMITS AND ALL JURISDICTIONAL PERMITS AND APPROVALS, PRECONSTRUCTION PLANS APPROVALS, PRECONSTRUCTION PLANS SHALL BE CONSISTENT WITH THE SHALL BE CONSISTENT WITH THE DRAWINGS AND FOUR, DESIGN REVIEW DRAWINGS AND FOUR, DESIGN REVIEW APPROVAL SHALL EXPIRE IN 12 APPROVAL SHALL EXPIRE IN 12 MONTHS FROM THE DATE OF CITY MONTHS FROM THE DATE OF CITY COMMISSION DESIGN REVIEW COMMISSION DESIGN REVIEW APPROVAL UNLESS THE APPLICANT APPROVAL UNLESS THE APPLICANT OBTAINS BUILDINGS PERMITS AND OBTAINS BUILDINGS PERMITS AND THOSE ARE FAIRLY STANDARD THOSE ARE FAIRLY STANDARD CONDITIONS. CONDITIONS. WITH THAT, THAT CONCLUDES THE WITH THAT, THAT CONCLUDES THE PREPARATION AND WE'RE HAPPY TO PREPARATION AND WE'RE HAPPY TO ANSWER ANY ADDITIONAL QUESTIONS. ANSWER ANY ADDITIONAL QUESTIONS. >> I HAVE ONE. >> I HAVE ONE. >> I HAVE ONE. >> >> I HAVE ONE. >> Chair: >> I HAVE ONE. >> Chair: GO. >> Chair: GO. >> Chair: GO. >> >> Chair: GO. >> WHAT >> Chair: GO. >> WHAT IS >> Chair: GO. >> WHAT IS THE >> Chair: GO. >> WHAT IS THE -- >> Chair: GO. >> WHAT IS THE -- HOW >> Chair: GO. >> WHAT IS THE -- HOW MANY >> Chair: GO. >> WHAT IS THE -- HOW MANY FEET >> WHAT IS THE -- HOW MANY FEET >> WHAT IS THE -- HOW MANY FEET IS >> WHAT IS THE -- HOW MANY FEET IS IT >> WHAT IS THE -- HOW MANY FEET IS IT FROM >> WHAT IS THE -- HOW MANY FEET IS IT FROM THE >> WHAT IS THE -- HOW MANY FEET IS IT FROM THE PROPERTY >> WHAT IS THE -- HOW MANY FEET IS IT FROM THE PROPERTY -- >> WHAT IS THE -- HOW MANY FEET IS IT FROM THE PROPERTY -- FROM IS IT FROM THE PROPERTY -- FROM THE RIGHT-OF-WAY TO THE FRONT OF THE RIGHT-OF-WAY TO THE FRONT OF THIS BUILDING, THE HOUSE? THIS BUILDING, THE HOUSE? >> THEY ARE SET BACK A >> THEY ARE SET BACK A >> THEY ARE SET BACK A CONSIDERABLE >> THEY ARE SET BACK A CONSIDERABLE DIFFERENCE. CONSIDERABLE DIFFERENCE. >> 102, RIGHT? >> 102, RIGHT? >> 102, RIGHT? >> >> 102, RIGHT? >> I >> 102, RIGHT? >> I THINK >> 102, RIGHT? >> I THINK THAT'S >> 102, RIGHT? >> I THINK THAT'S CORRECT, >> 102, RIGHT? >> I THINK THAT'S CORRECT, YES, >> I THINK THAT'S CORRECT, YES, >> I THINK THAT'S CORRECT, YES, MA'AM. MA'AM. PART OF THAT, IT PUTS THE PART OF THAT, IT PUTS THE BUILDING OUTSIDE OF THE 100-YEAR BUILDING OUTSIDE OF THE 100-YEAR FLOODPLAIN. FLOODPLAIN. >> EXCUSE ME, ROUGHLY 110. >> EXCUSE ME, ROUGHLY 110. >> EXCUSE ME, ROUGHLY 110. >> >> EXCUSE ME, ROUGHLY 110. >> 110, >> EXCUSE ME, ROUGHLY 110. >> 110, EVEN >> EXCUSE ME, ROUGHLY 110. >> 110, EVEN BETTER. >> 110, EVEN BETTER. >> 110, EVEN BETTER. OKAY. OKAY. >> SO I JUST WANT TO CLARIFY. >> SO I JUST WANT TO CLARIFY. >> SO I JUST WANT TO CLARIFY. YOUR >> SO I JUST WANT TO CLARIFY. YOUR RECOMMENDATION >> SO I JUST WANT TO CLARIFY. YOUR RECOMMENDATION IS >> SO I JUST WANT TO CLARIFY. YOUR RECOMMENDATION IS THEY >> SO I JUST WANT TO CLARIFY. YOUR RECOMMENDATION IS THEY MEET YOUR RECOMMENDATION IS THEY MEET ALL THE CRITERIA BUT IT SHOULD ALL THE CRITERIA BUT IT SHOULD BE REDESIGNED TO FIT 65 FEET BE REDESIGNED TO FIT 65 FEET INSTEAD OF THE 77.6? INSTEAD OF THE 77.6? >> WE ARE RECOMMENDING NOT TO >> WE ARE RECOMMENDING NOT TO >> WE ARE RECOMMENDING NOT TO EXCEED >> WE ARE RECOMMENDING NOT TO EXCEED 65 >> WE ARE RECOMMENDING NOT TO EXCEED 65 FEET. EXCEED 65 FEET. >> OKAY. >> OKAY. >> OKAY. >> >> OKAY. >> Chair: >> OKAY. >> Chair: OTHER >> OKAY. >> Chair: OTHER QUESTIONS? >> Chair: OTHER QUESTIONS? >> Chair: OTHER QUESTIONS? SO, >> Chair: OTHER QUESTIONS? SO, MR. >> Chair: OTHER QUESTIONS? SO, MR. SCHOLZ >> Chair: OTHER QUESTIONS? SO, MR. SCHOLZ AND >> Chair: OTHER QUESTIONS? SO, MR. SCHOLZ AND MR. >> Chair: OTHER QUESTIONS? SO, MR. SCHOLZ AND MR. SHAFFER. SO, MR. SCHOLZ AND MR. SHAFFER. YOU WANT TO MAKE YOUR YOU WANT TO MAKE YOUR PRESENTATION, PLEASE? PRESENTATION, PLEASE? >> GOOD EVENING. >> GOOD EVENING. >> GOOD EVENING. DAVID >> GOOD EVENING. DAVID BRANDON, >> GOOD EVENING. DAVID BRANDON, BRANDON DAVID BRANDON, BRANDON CONSTRUCTION, GENERAL CONTRACTOR CONSTRUCTION, GENERAL CONTRACTOR ON THE PROJECT. ON THE PROJECT. I'LL HAVE SOME OPENING REMARKS I'LL HAVE SOME OPENING REMARKS AND THEN I'LL TURN IT OVER TO AND THEN I'LL TURN IT OVER TO OUR ARCHITECT CLIFF SCHOLZ FOR OUR ARCHITECT CLIFF SCHOLZ FOR SOME FURTHER DETAIL AND SOME SOME FURTHER DETAIL AND SOME GOOD QUESTIONS THAT YOU ALL GOOD QUESTIONS THAT YOU ALL HAVE. HAVE. SO OUR CLIENTS ARE FROM OUT OF SO OUR CLIENTS ARE FROM OUT OF STATE, DESIRE TO MOVE HERE. STATE, DESIRE TO MOVE HERE. THEY HAVE SOLD THEIR BUSINESS. THEY HAVE SOLD THEIR BUSINESS. THEIR KIDS HAVE GONE OFF TO THEIR KIDS HAVE GONE OFF TO SCHOOL. SCHOOL. AND THEY WANT TO BECOME AND THEY WANT TO BECOME FULL-TIME FLORIDA RESIDENTS. FULL-TIME FLORIDA RESIDENTS. THEY LITERALLY TRAVELED EVERY THEY LITERALLY TRAVELED EVERY COUNTY, ALL 67 COUNTIES IN THE COUNTY, ALL 67 COUNTIES IN THE STATE OF FLORIDA, SETTLED ON STATE OF FLORIDA, SETTLED ON PINELLAS, DRILLED DOWN TO PINELLAS, DRILLED DOWN TO DUNEDIN. DUNEDIN. AND THEY DROVE ALL AROUND THE AND THEY DROVE ALL AROUND THE CITY. CITY. THEY HAVE PROBABLY SEEN EVERY THEY HAVE PROBABLY SEEN EVERY HOUSE IN THE CITY OF DUNEDIN. HOUSE IN THE CITY OF DUNEDIN. THEY ARE VERY SENSITIVE TO THE THEY ARE VERY SENSITIVE TO THE ARCHITECTURAL REQUIREMENTS THAT ARCHITECTURAL REQUIREMENTS THAT THE CITY HAS AND TRYING TO KIND THE CITY HAS AND TRYING TO KIND OF PROTECT THE CHARM THAT'S IN OF PROTECT THE CHARM THAT'S IN THAT DISTRICT, WHICH IS WHY THEY THAT DISTRICT, WHICH IS WHY THEY SETTLED ON THE COTTAGE STYLE SETTLED ON THE COTTAGE STYLE ARCHITECTURE. ARCHITECTURE. AND THEY ALSO DESIRED TO KEEP IT AND THEY ALSO DESIRED TO KEEP IT ONE STORY. ONE STORY. IT'S A LOT EASIER TO MEET THESE IT'S A LOT EASIER TO MEET THESE NARROW REQUIREMENTS IF WE GO NARROW REQUIREMENTS IF WE GO MULTI-STORIES. MULTI-STORIES. BUT NOT WHEN YOU HAVE A BUT NOT WHEN YOU HAVE A SINGLE-STORY HOME. SINGLE-STORY HOME. AS THEY MENTIONED FROM STAFF, AS THEY MENTIONED FROM STAFF, IT'S A SIGNIFICANT LOT, OVER AN IT'S A SIGNIFICANT LOT, OVER AN ACRE. ACRE. SO, YOU KNOW, THE MASSING OF THE SO, YOU KNOW, THE MASSING OF THE EXISTING HOME, I WOULD EXISTING HOME, I WOULD RESPECTFULLY DISAGREE WITH THE RESPECTFULLY DISAGREE WITH THE INTERPRETATION OF STAFF. INTERPRETATION OF STAFF. IT WAS 82 FEET. IT WAS 82 FEET. IF YOU STAND ON EDGEWATER AND IF YOU STAND ON EDGEWATER AND YOU CAN SEE NORTH TO SOUTH YOU CAN SEE NORTH TO SOUTH CORNER, IT WAS 82 FEET. CORNER, IT WAS 82 FEET. THERE WAS FOUR STRUCTURES ON THERE WAS FOUR STRUCTURES ON THAT SITE THAT WE TORE DOWN. THAT SITE THAT WE TORE DOWN. THAT 82 FEET IS MEASURED CORNER THAT 82 FEET IS MEASURED CORNER TO CORNER BECAUSE THOSE TO CORNER BECAUSE THOSE OVERLAPPED. OVERLAPPED. AND IT WOULD HAVE BEEN ONE AND IT WOULD HAVE BEEN ONE STRUCTURE IF WE JUST PUT A ROOF, STRUCTURE IF WE JUST PUT A ROOF, JUST A CONNECTED WALKWAY TO ONE JUST A CONNECTED WALKWAY TO ONE OF THOSE OUTSTRUCTURES. OF THOSE OUTSTRUCTURES. AND THEN THAT'S ONE STRUCTURE. AND THEN THAT'S ONE STRUCTURE. SO IT'S KIND OF SEMANTICS TO SAY SO IT'S KIND OF SEMANTICS TO SAY IT WAS 64 FEET WIDE. IT WAS 64 FEET WIDE. IT WAS 82 FEET AS YOUR EYE SEES IT WAS 82 FEET AS YOUR EYE SEES IT FROM EDGEWATER. IT FROM EDGEWATER. WHAT WE ARE PROPOSING IS 77, WHAT WE ARE PROPOSING IS 77, 8 INCHES. 8 INCHES. ON THE FRONT SETBACK, I BELIEVE ON THE FRONT SETBACK, I BELIEVE MS. KYNES, YOU ASKED THE MS. KYNES, YOU ASKED THE QUESTION -- IT'S A GREAT QUESTION -- IT'S A GREAT QUESTION BECAUSE IT'S IN MY QUESTION BECAUSE IT'S IN MY NOTES. NOTES. WE ARE 4.48 TIMES THE REQUIRED WE ARE 4.48 TIMES THE REQUIRED FRONT SETBACK. FRONT SETBACK. 110 PLUS FEET BACK. 110 PLUS FEET BACK. SO IT IS SIGNIFICANTLY BACK OFF SO IT IS SIGNIFICANTLY BACK OFF OF EDGEWATER AND WE'RE FIVE OF EDGEWATER AND WE'RE FIVE TIMES THE REAR SETBACK. TIMES THE REAR SETBACK. SO IT'S VERY DIMINUTIVE RELATIVE SO IT'S VERY DIMINUTIVE RELATIVE TO THE OVERALL GROSS AREA OF THE TO THE OVERALL GROSS AREA OF THE SITE. SITE. ON THE COMPARISON, THE ANALYSIS ON THE COMPARISON, THE ANALYSIS THAT STAFF USED, THEY TURNED THE THAT STAFF USED, THEY TURNED THE CORNER AND WENT IN SOME BACK CORNER AND WENT IN SOME BACK STREETS. STREETS. THERE'S LOTS OVER THERE THAT ARE THERE'S LOTS OVER THERE THAT ARE 50 FEET WIDE. 50 FEET WIDE. I THINK THIS IS AN EDGEWATER I THINK THIS IS AN EDGEWATER QUESTION. QUESTION. THIS IS KIND OF THE MAIN THIS IS KIND OF THE MAIN THOROUGHFARE THROUGH THE CITY ON THOROUGHFARE THROUGH THE CITY ON THE WATERFRONT. THE WATERFRONT. SO IF WE TOOK JUST THE HOMES ON SO IF WE TOOK JUST THE HOMES ON EDGEWATER, THERE'S 23 HOMES THAT EDGEWATER, THERE'S 23 HOMES THAT ARE OVER 60 FEET WIDE. ARE OVER 60 FEET WIDE. THERE'S 21 OTHERS THAT ARE THERE'S 21 OTHERS THAT ARE 60 FEET OR LESS AND THAT 60 FEET OR LESS AND THAT INCLUDES FENWAY, A COUPLE OF INCLUDES FENWAY, A COUPLE OF CHURCHES AND THE VACANT LOTS. CHURCHES AND THE VACANT LOTS. WE DIDN'T COUNT FENWAY AS UNDER WE DIDN'T COUNT FENWAY AS UNDER 60 BUT THAT WOULD MAKE IT 24 OUT 60 BUT THAT WOULD MAKE IT 24 OUT OF THE 44 TOTAL PROPERTIES

PRESENT: ABSENT: ALSO PRESENT: CALL TO ORDER CITY OF DUNEDIN, FLORIDA LOCAL PLANNING AGENCY REGULAR MEETING OF WEDNESDAY, AUGUST 14, 2024 DUNEDIN CITY HALL - 737 LOUDEN AVENUE - 6:00 P.M. Chair Michael Broom , Vice-Chair Kevin Benjamin , Members Charlie Flatley , Paul Stanek, Deborah Kynes and Dennis Alspaugh Member Elizabeth Telford Assistant City Attorney Noah Daiker, Community Development Director George Kinney , Community Development Assistant Director Joseph DiPasqua , Business Manager Joan McHale, Community Development Project Manager Kathy Gademer, and approximately twenty-one people in the audience. Chair Broom called the August 14 , 2024, Local Planning Agency of the City of Dunedin to order at 6:00 p.m. INTRODUCTION Chair Broom stated the Local Planning Agency is an advisory board of citizens appointed by the City Commission . This board is comprised of volunteers who represent the thoughts and concerns of the community. The purpose of tonight's meeting is to make recommendations to the City Commission regarding each item on the agenda . Tonight, we will be conducting public hearings; therefore, this meeting is open to the public . Anyone in the audience who wishes to give testimony to any of the items on the agenda will need to be sworn in by the Deputy City Clerk. This swearing-in process will occur after tonight's first agenda item, which will be the approval of the minutes from the last Local Planning Agency meeting. Citizens speaking on an agenda item or during citizen comment shall not engage in loud , boisterous , and/or disruptive speech or conduct. Any speaker who has continued in inappropriate or irrelevant comments will be requested to relinquish the podium by the Chair. Please be aware that this Local Planning Agency is not a quasi-judicial board and therefore has no final decision-making power. Our procedures, however, are structured in a quasi-judicial manner for the benefit of those who come before it. Tonight's format will be as follows : he will introduce each item on the agenda, after which the City representative will present information about it. Thereafter, the members of the Local Planning Agency will respond to the City representative . Finally, anyone from the public may come forward. Those from the public wishing to give testimony will need to approach the dais, state their name and address , and utilize the speaker's lectern for their comments to be recorded. Individual speakers will be limited to 3 minutes and they kindly request speakers are respectful of the countdown clock. Upon the conclusion of each public hearing , the Local Planning Agency will consider the evidence before it and will vote on the agenda item . That voice vote is the rendition of the order of the Board and there will be NO written decision issued by the Board. 1. BUSINESS 1.a. Approval of Meeting Minutes A. June 12, 2024 LPA Meeting B. July 29, 2024 Special LPA Meeting 24-1

Regular Meeting Minutes August 14, 2024 Local Planning Agency Cha ir Broom introduced the agenda item and inquired if anyone had any corrections, additions , or deletions to the minutes. Hearing no further comments, Chair Broom asked for a motion. MOTION: Motion was made by Vice-Chair Benjamin and seconded by Mr. Alspaugh to approve the June 12, 2024, LPA Meeting Minutes and the July 29, 2024 , LPA Special Meeting minutes. VOTE: Motion carried unanimously. Chair Broom advised Ms. McHale would now swear in all persons wishing to speak to or give testimony to any of tonight's agenda items. Ms . McHale swore in Community Development Director George Kinney, Community Development Assistant Director Joseph DiPasqua, Community Development Project Manager Kathy Gademer , and all those members of the public wishing to speak . 1.b. Application DR 24-04 - Request for Design Review Approval pursuant to Section 103-32.4(B)iv of the Land Development Code (LDC) for the construction of a single-family residence within the South Dunedin Character Overlay with a width greater than sixty (60') feet at the front setback line on the property located at 125 Edgewater Drive. Chair Broom introduced the item and inquired if anyone on the Board had any ex-parte communication regard ing this application . Hearing none , at this time the Board would hear from the City representative. Staff Presentation Community Development Director Kinney shared the staff report and referenced the various exhibits , maps , and aerial views to orient the Board and the public to the location. APPLICATION INFORMATION APPLICATION NO. DR 24-04 REQUEST Design Review Approval PROJECT NAME New Single-Family Residence (Wilkerson Res idence) OWNER LBW WCW , LLC APPLICANT CMSA Scholz, Oswald and Shaffer REPRESENTATIVE Clifford M. Scholz and Daniel Shaffer PUBLIC HEARING DATES ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW COMMITTEE July 2, 2024 LOCAL PLANNING AGENCY August 14 , 2024 CITY COMMISSION September 19 , 2024 CITY COMMISSION October 17, 2024 PROPERTY INFORMATION STREET ADDRESS 125 Edgewater Drive, Dunedin, FL 34698 TAX PARCEL NO. 34-28-15-00000-330-0300 AREA 1.13 Acres (49,259 SF) LAND USE PLAN Residential Urban (RU) & Recreation/Open Space (RIOS) ZONING DISTRICT Single-Family Residential (R-60) FLOOD ZONE Zone X, Zone AE (9) , Zone AE (10) , Zone VE (11 ), Zone VE (13) EXISTING USE Vacant 24-2

Regular Meetin g Minu te s August 14 , 2024 SURR OUNDI NG ZONING & USE S ZO NI NG D ISTRICT NORTH Sing le-F am il y Residential (R-60) S OUTH Single-Fam il y Res 'dential (R-60) EAs T Sing le- F am il y Residential (R-60) W EST Ma ri ne Park (MP) PROJECT DESCRIPTI ON AND HI STO RY Local Planning Agency ExlsTI NGUS ES Res iden ti al Res iden ti al Residentia l Water Through their representatives , the property owners are requesting Design Review approval to construct a new one-story , sing le- family residence on the property . The property is located wit hin the So uth Dunedin Character Overlay and the proposed home is 77 .67 feet (77 ft . 8 in.) in width . In the over lay, bu ildings or structures that are greater than 60 feet in width require Design Rev iew approva l pursuant to the Section 103 -32 .3(B)i v of the LDC. The home and outbuildings that previously occup ied the site were demolished earlier th is year, so the property is currently vacan t. An image of the prev ious home is provi ded in the Staff Report. LAND USE PLAN EVALUATION The subject property is loca ted with in the Residential Urban (RU ) and Recreation /Open Space (RIOS ) land use plan categories . Permitted uses in RU include sing le -family resident ial. Ma xi mum residential density in RU is 7.5 dwel ling units per acre (du /a) with a maximum impe rvi ous surface rat io (ISR) of 0.65 . ZONIN G DISTRICT EVALUATION Th is sit e is located within the Single -Family Res idential (R-60) zon ing district ; the purpose of th e R-60 distri ct is to provide opportunity for the highest density considered su itable for single-family detached dwellings , offering the possibility of lower land costs while recognizing tha t R-60 lots will not accommodate large houses and accessory structures commonly found in the City. Logically , single -family res idential is a permitted use by right in R-60 pursuant to the Land Deve lopment Co de (LDC ) Use Matr ix found in Tab le 103-60 .1. Table 1 below shows lot areas and dimens ions , number of stori es, building heights , and setbacks for the R-60 district. Dimensional stand ards are found in Section 103-23. 11.3 of the LDC TAB LE 1 STANDARD PERMITTED PROPOSED CONFORMS Lot Area 6, 000 sq . ft. m in. Lot W id t h ---- Lot De~pt_h~-- Num b er o f Sto r ies Building H e ight "----- Front Setback ----- Side Setb a.ck Rea r Setback 60 ft . min . 100ft . m in . 2 stories max.. 27 ft . max. 25 ft . min . 7 .5 ft . min . 20 ft . min . 24-3 49 ,2 59 sq . ft. Yes 102 ft . Yes 46 5 ft. Yes 1 st o ry Ye·s -- ±20ft. Yes ±ll0ft. Yes 7 .8 ft . {N), 13 .S ft . {S) Ye s - - ± 1 02 ft . Yes

Regular Meeting Minutes August 14, 2024 SOUTH DUNEDIN CHARACTER OVERLAY Local Planning Agency As stated previously , this property is located within the South Dunedin Character Overlay . Fo r development in the South Dunedin Character Overlay , the following addit ional development standards and regulations also apply pursuant to Section 103-32.4 in the LDC . TABLE 2 STANDARD CONFORMS Height and Da light Pl ane Building Design inclu d ing : Bu i lding Orientat i on Garage/Carport Pl acement Bu il ding Elevati o n Maximu~i l ding Width (60 ft .) Architectural Sty le Yes Ye s Yes Yes See Note Yes Note : Buildings or structu res that are greater than 60 f eet in w i dth r eq u i re Design Review approva l. FLOODPLAIN MANAGEMENT REGULATIONS From a floodplain management standpoint , the eastern portion of the property is located within Zone X (Shaded) , which has a 0.2 percent annual chance flood hazard but is outside of the Special Flood Hazard Area (SFHA). The western portion of the property is within the SFHA and more specifically Zones AE (9), AE (10) , VE (11 ), and VE (13) . The proposed home will be constructed within Zone X . Community Development Assistant Director Di Pasqua advised: COMPATIBILITY EVALUATION Object iv e 2.9 of the Future Land Use Element requires the City to evaluate development and redevelopment as it relates to the compatibility of the surrounding land and its uses as described below. See pages 54-55 in the Comprehensive Plan for reference . Physica l compatibility of the proposed development or redevelopment with the surrounding environment shall include evaluating height issues , architectural features of the existing structures , historic aspects of the existing structures , existing natural features, existing land uses , existing residential densities , and economically-related uses. Cons istent with building width , the City Code reads that this is the primary structure , so it is not accumulative of multiple buildings on the property ; this was confirmed wi th the City Attorney 's Office that that is the intent of the Code. Staff exam ined 34 properties ; 33 of those had buildings with 1 being vacant. In summary, existing buildings in the surrounding neighborhood are mostly one and two-story single-family residential. Average building width for larger lots (>1 acre) is just over 74 feet and 49 feet for the smaller lots (<1 acre). Average building width as a percentage of average lot width for larger lots (>1 acre) is about 63 percent and 61 percent for the smaller lots (<1 acre) . Lastly , average building width as a percentage of average lot width for wider lots (>100 feet) , regardless of lot area , is about 64 percent. From the building diagrams from the Property Appraiser 's Office to determine the building widths , it was determined that 10 of those buildings are greater than 60 feet in width, the largest being 109 feet in width ; 23 buildings are less than 60 feet in width with the smallest being 29 feet in width ; and the average building width of all 33 structures is about 53 feet. The previous home that occupied this lot was 63 feet in width . There are 5 properties including the subject property larger than 1 acre with an 24-4

Regular Meeting Minutes August14 , 2024 Local Planning Agency ave rage lot width of 118 feet ; build ings on those properties average 74 feet in width or approx imately 63 % of the lot width . The focus here is lot width to bu ilding ratio , i.e. how much massing there is on the width of the lot. Twenty-eight properties are less than 1 acre with an average lot width of 80 feet , and buildings on those properties average 49 feet in width or about 61 %. There are 9 lots at least 100 feet wide with an average lot width of 114 feet , and buildings on those lots average 73 feet in width or approx imately 64% of the average lot width . App lying these guiding principles to the subject property , which is 1.13 acres in area and 102 feet in width , results in a building width of between 64 .3 feet to 65 .3 feet , the average of which is 64 .8 feet. Therefore , a one-story , single-family residence with a building width of 65 feet on th is part icular property , together with the potential development patterns in the area , would be considered compatible with the existing building heights , widths , and densities in the surrounding area and neighborhoods and is consistent with Objective 2.9 in the Future Land Use Element of the Comprehensive Plan . Board Questions In response to the question for the reason for the initial 60-foot limitation , Mr . Kinney expla ined there was much discussion about limiting the mass and making sure there was some architectural style and minimiz ing the larger homes that had that mass ive effect ; that was about two years ago . The regulations were not intended to limit but to bring it into a public environment for review ; it is not to say that 65 feet or 75 feet is bad , but there was the idea there needed to be more public scrutiny fo r homes that began to evolve to a state where there appeared to be more massing . Ms. Kynes recalled the ordinance did direct that the structure should fit the lot size so that one piece of property was not totally built out. Mr. Kinney also noted there was a concern about aggregating lots that would allow structures to get wider and wider; the idea was that even with aggregating lots, that 60 feet br ings it back to the idea and the methodology , as Mr. DiPasqua explained . It hits directly on that and now the character of the area needs to be considered and what that mass ing is against the frontage width and that is where the percentage is derived . By looking at all those lots , they arrived at about 65 feet for the lots over an acre or 100 feet in width ; that is what is being seen in the area . When Ms. Kynes suggested that 505 Edgewater Drive (the larger home) should not be used in the calculat ion, Mr. DiPasqua explained the analysis used for the recommendation was the 33 homes in Exh ibit D which stopped at Florida Avenue , not north of Florida Avenue . Ms . Kynes suggested that the exhibit should have been included for public view , not only in the agenda packet for the Board. Mr . DiPasqua noted that for the record , staff did take a look at the properties north ; however , for the purpose of compatibility analysis , it is the surrounding avenue; north of Florida Avenue is not the surrounding area . That is consistently how staff looked at compatibility with regard to the Des ign Review. The area considered was from the corner of Florida and Edgewater down to Union Street and then wrapping around the property as well , which he recalled to be Orange and Citrus . Vice-Cha ir Benjam in referred to the recommendat ion of about 65% of the width of the lot and noted that tak ing the 77.67' width of this design divided by the 102 gets about 76%, which is a fairly significant deviation from the goal ; he asked in getting that average how many of those propert ies were approaching that 70% -76% width of property , noting that there must be some wider than the 64% to get to that average . Ms . Kynes noted that 505 could not be taken into consideration because that permit was obta ined and it was built before the ordinance came into play and it is built property line to property line. Mr. DiPasqua advised that in reviewing the spreadsheet used to prepare this , for the average at 64% , 24-5

Regular Meeting Minutes August 14, 2024 the low is 50%, and the high is 91 %. DESIGN REVIEW PROCESS Local Planning Agency Design Review is required for buildings or structures located within and subject to the South Dunedin Character Overlay, erected or altered to a width greater than sixty (60) feet at the front setback line per Section 103-32.4(B)iv. The process for Design Review is set forth in Sec . 104-24.7 of the LDC and includes review by the Development Review Committee (DRC) and Architectural Review Committee (ARC) , followed by the Local Planning Agency (LPA) then two (2) public hearings before the City Commission . The purpose of the design review process is to determine the general reasonableness of the project and , while adequate information is required to make this determination, more detailed engineering submittals will still be required for infrastructure site plan approval and bu ilding permits as applicable. DESIGN REVIEW STANDARDS Mr. Kinney advised the Design Standards are the test required as part of the application process. In this case , they are somewhat mitigated because this is a single-family residence versus a large commercial or residential project; however , the applicant has complied with each of the design review standards. COMMITTEE ACTIONS DEVELOPMENT REVIEW COMMITTEE (DRC) The DRC reviewed this project on May 15 , 2024. All of the DRC comments and items have been addressed or are addressed in the conditions of approval recommended below . The notes of the May 15, 2024, DRC meeting are included as EXHIBIT F. ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW COMMITTEE (ARC) The ARC did a preliminary review of the project on June 4, 2024 . Formal review of this application took place on July 2, 2024, where the ARC unanimously approved the design of the project. The ARC meeting minutes are included as EXHIBIT G. NOTICE OF HEARINGS Per Sec . 104-12 of the LDC , this petition was noticed as follows. See EXHIBIT H for proof of public notices . • A Letter of Notice was mailed to abutting property owners within 500 feet of the subject property at least 14 days prior to the public hearings. • An informational sign was posted on the subject property at least 14 days prior to the public hearings. STAFF DETERMINATION Staff finds that Application DR 24-04 for Design Review is consistent with the applicable review criteria for approval subject to the following conditions: 1. The new single-family residence shall not exceed sixty-five (65 ') feet in width at the front setback line for physical compatibility with existing buildings in the surrounding area. Mr . Kinney noted the previous home on the lot was 63 '. 2. The applicant/developer is responsible for meeting the minimum criteria of the Land Development Code and for acquiring all other jurisdictional permits and approvals . 3. Construction plans shall be consistent with the approved Design Review plans and drawings. 4. Design Review approval shall expire in twelve (12) months from the date of City Commission Design Review approval unless the applicant obtains building permits. 24-6

Regular Meeting Minutes August 14, 2024 LIST OF EXHIBITS EXHIBIT A. EXHIBIT B. EXHIBIT C. EXHIBIT D. EXHIBIT E. EXHIBIT F. EXHIBIT G. EXHIBIT H. Staff Report Design Review Application DR 24-04 Aer ial , Land Use & Zoning Maps Map of Surrounding Properties Sustainab ility Matrix 5/15 /2023 DRC Meeting Notes 7/2/2024 ARC Meeting Minutes Public Notice Questions for Staff Local Planning Agency Ms. Kynes asked the distance from the right-of-way to the front of the structure. Mr. Kinney noted the structure is set back a considerable distance ; part of this is that it puts it out of the 100-Year Floodplain. It was noted the front setback is 110 feet. - Vice-Cha ir Benjamin noted the application meets all the criteria ; however, the staff recommendation is that it should be redesigned to fit 65 feet. Mr. Kinney acknowledged the recommendation is not to exceed 65 feet. Applicant Presentation David Brandon, Brandon Construction of 555 Palm Harbor Boulevard, Palm Harbor stated: His clients from out of state desire to move here and want to become full-time Florida residen ts. They literally traveled all 67 counties in the state , settled on Pinellas and then Dunedin. They drove all around the City and are very sensitive to the architectural requirements in protecting charm in the district , which is why they decided on the cottage-style architecture. They also desired to keep it one story . It is eas ier to meet these narrow requirements by going multi-stories , but not with a single-story home. It is a significant lot of over an acre, so the massing of the existing home was 82 feet ; there were four structures on the site they demolished. The 82 feet is measured comer to corner because those overlapped and it would have been one structure had they put in a roof with a connected walkway to one of the out structures. He commented it is sort of semantics to say it was 64 ' wide . It was 82 ' as your eye sees it from Edgewater. They are proposing 77'8 ". On the front setback , they are 4.48 times the requ ired front setback at 11 O'+. They are significantly back from Edgewater and five times the rear setback. It is very diminutive to the overall gross area of the site . On the compar ison that staff used , they turned the corner and went into some back streets ; there are lots there that are 50 ' wide. This is an Edgewater question , the main thoroughfare through the City on the waterfront. If they took just the homes on Edgewater , there are 23 homes over 60 ' wide ; 21 others are 60 ' or less and that includes Fenway , a couple of churches , and the vacant lots. They did not count Fenway as an over 60 ', which would make it 24 structures of the 44 properties. They will show they have a good and charm ing architecture , which is not overpowering to this lot. Regarding the four structures they demolished , they had a discussion early on as to whether they could renovate the house ; however , it was not economically feasible. The structure was grossly ins ignificant and nowhere near the Code . Cliff Scholz, Architects of 2724 Fruitville Road, Sarasota briefly reviewed his credentials , including having been a reg istered architect in Florida for 43 years and the work his company has done . He stated : 24-7

Regular Meeting Minutes August 14, 2024 Local Planning Agency The owners did have certain requests , part of which was a one-story house, though they had seen two-and three-story residences along Edgewater . They also wanted a Craftsman Cottage style and to take it as far back from Edgewater as was practical , which he recalled was 102 '. Part of this was to reflect the quaint appeal of Dunedin. They also wanted privacy for their pool, which brings the issue with the width. The pool is surrounded by two parts of the house. To make that work with a decent-sized pool , that is where they ended up with 77'8 ". The property is in multiple flood zones and it worked out with the owners wanting the home far back , and they were able to get into an X zone. He does differ with staff regarding the width of the "primary" residence that was demolished. The existing residence that was demolished consisted of four structures, and the distance north to south was 81 '5". This is their asse_ssment as opposed to staff determination that it was 63 ' wide . Staff mentioned to him this was a ruling from the City Attorney that only the one section of the building, which was furthest toward Edgewater , was the only primary part of these multiple structures. He disagrees in that for the existing primary structures out front, they think there was a 2-story residence , which had multiple doors on both levels . There was not vertical connection between the two floors , which leads him to believe there were three houses on this property: the ground floor , the upper floor, and the front building. He did not know why that 2-story structure should not be counted in the width of the existing structures because it was just as much a part of the primary structure as the front part. So , they are going from 81 '5" to 77'8 ". That was a very determined thing they wanted to stay under. They went through the Design Review Committee (DRC) and received some positive input , which they incorporated by changing part of the design. They also went through the Architectural Review Comm ittee (ARC) twice and were unanimously approved. When they first assessed what was happening on Edgewater , they did consider 44 residences ; however , they did not turn up Orangewood or go onto Citrus , as many of those properties are just 60 ' wide and are severely smaller than the subject property. He did not know how those would apply to the 60' maximum when the property is 60 ' wide and bound by the setbacks and not the 60 ' mark. He did not see how those could be used as comparison to properties along Edgewater . He thought their analysis of what was existing is more accurate with regard to what the visual will be driving , walking, or bicycling along Edgewater; he does not see how going around the corner has any relationship to the subject property. The Staff Report indicates it is consistent with the Code intent and he believes their evaluation of a reasonable width of 65 feet is based on opinion . There is nothing in the Codes he sees with regard to any kind of percentages ; it is all about 60 ' wide . He does think that should be changed and should be a relationship with properties O' - 50' with certain widths and setbacks; 50 ' -100'; 100'-200 ', and over 200 ' probably with an individual review. He thinks the 60 ' width is inappropriate and that there will be some issues with some of the smaller properties where they are going to max out to the side setbacks and some preordained percentage . Board Questions Vice-Cha ir Benjamin commented the fundamental question is that the City Code is okay with 65 feet ; however , the applicant's belief is that from the frontal view the former property was 82 feet, so on the sidewalk looking at it this structure will not be as big as what was there before. Mr. Scholz noted it will also be one story less. Vice-Cha ir Benjamin asked because of all the work that went into that overlay district , which was a 24-8

Regular Meeting Minutes August 14, 2024 Local Planning Agency contentious topic , if the Board makes an exception here is that setting a precedent that could compound future development in other lots in that overlay district? Also, this is a huge lot since it is so deep ; is the City limiting itself by just looking at the frontal width and not looking at the percentage of the lot the structure will actually take up? There is a lot of green space left because of the length of the lot. Mr . Kinney advised: Regarding setting a precedent , he did not believe so because getting people into th is process sort of suggests it is a unique situation and the merits are in each particular case . Staff has consistently applied this particular standard for compatibility, generally that you have to look at the surrounding area . Some of the homes behind are a little smaller ; however , as seen from the analysis , the width to lot ratio is still the same. In fact, staff took a step back and looked at th is product and where they did not look at that and went further up the road on Edgewater , tha t works to the applicant's disadvantage under staff analysis; it would require a lesser size structure . When looking at just the frontages , staff had that same question and decided to talk to the City Attorney because this is the first , and it was staff opinion that they needed to look at the primary. If there are secondary buildings that create a view ambiance , staff understands , but the focus is on the pr imary bu ild ing ; secondary buildings can come and go . Staff believed that was the intent of overlay district: to focus on those primary buildings and make sure they were not overly developed in the front. Part of that massing in the front was not only that , but then to offset the garage , which they have done 5' back in order not to create a fiat plain surface . There are many design cons iderations that went into this. Vice-Chair Benjamin noted Edgewater is a prime location for the City and the re are a unique set of lot sizes there. The only alternative would be to narrow the structure and that would be long and deep ; from a livability standpoint , that might not be desirable. He is wondering how staff is feeling about it if this is not going to set a precedent or create problems on the smaller lots in that area . Mr . Kinney responded that staff had provided their recommendation , and it is the prerogative of the Board with that information to recommend what they think is appropriate. Ms . Kynes verified with Attorney Daiker there was no conflict due to her living on Edgewater Drive . Mr. Stanek asked when the district was be ing created , was Edgewater Drive taken into cons ideration sort of separately based on the size of the lots in the rest of the overlay or the same question with lots greater than an acre? Mr. Kinney did not recall exactly ; however , he did not think the issue got that detailed , and it was more about being collectively compatible within the district ; the "daylight plane " was the hot topic. He thought one of the top reasons was that if someone has multiple lots side by side and are collectively acquiring those lots , they wanted to make sure that someone does not acquire four lots creat ing 200 feet of frontage and then a 100-foot wide house. Mr . Stanek requested an explanation of "daylight plane. " Mr . Kinney noted this application complies with the daylight plane , which is a provis ion where the massing toward the property line is limited. It creates an interior setback that you rise from and you cannot penetrate the plane with new construction that has to be more focused toward the center of the property versus impinging on the side yard . Mr . Scholz commented : With the daylight plane information , it started in Naples, Florida because the City has a significant number of smaller lots in the City and developers were building setback to setback and going two or three floors and putting adjacent properties in the shade. He does think it is a great thing and a good 24-9

Regular Meeting Minutes August 14, 2024 Local Planning Agency designer should not have an issue . Regarding the distance of measur ing 60 feet in the "primary ," which he is hearing is the most frontal of the structure , that can be a problem because if that is going to be the way it is measured , then he could have a 60-foot wide part of a house and then go back and go all the way to the setbacks . He thought that would defeat what is trying to be accomplished. Mr. Flatley commented that in looking at the drawings , it does not seem to be centered on the property and asked about the measurements on either side ; he was advised it was 13.5 feet on the south side and 7.5 feet on the north side , which is the setback . Public Hearing Chair Broom opened the public hearing . Hearing and seeing no one wishing to speak , Chair Broom closed the public hearing portion of the application . Board Comments Ms. Kynes commented she thought the arch itecture of the structure is spectacular; she likes the 110 - foot setback and consideration of the floodplain . She thought 77 feet to be out of whack; she knows Edgewater Drive. MOTION: Motion was made by Ms. Kynes and seconded by Mr . Alspaugh to recommend the City Commission approval of Application DR 24-04, Design Review Approval for the construction of a single-family residence within the South Dunedin Character Overlay for the property located at 125 Edgewater Drive with the following conditions as recommended by City staff based on the interpretation of the City Attorney 's Office : VOTE : 1. The new single-family residence shall not exceed sixty-five (65 ') feet in width at the front setback line for physical compatibility with existing buildings in the surrounding area. 2. The applicant/developer is responsible for meeting the minimum criteria of the Land Development Code and for acquiring all other jurisdictional permits and approvals . 3. Construction plans shall be consistent with the approved Design Review plans and drawings . 4. Design Review approval shall expire in twelve (12) months from the date of City Commission Design Review approval unless the applicant obtains building permits. Motion carried 4-2 with Mr. Alspaugh, Mr. Flatley, Ms. Kynes , and Chair Broom voting aye . Voting nay , Vice-Chair Benjamin and Mr. Stanek. In response to the question of the process if they design to 65 feet, Mr. Kinney commented he would say that if there are no substantial changes, it would come back directly to the Local Planning Agency ; if , for example, it went to two stories it would be a full design review. Chair Broom clarified the LPA is simply a recommendation to the City Commission and they might make a different decision . 1.c. Land Development Code (LDC) Update Kickoff Meeting with the LPA George Kinney, Community Development Director; Kathy Gademer, Community Development Project Manager; Consultant Team: Toole Design, Kendig Keast, & HDR Consultants Community Development Project Manager Gademer presented: 24-10

Regular Meeting Minutes August 14, 2024 Local Planning Agency The purpose of updating the Land Development Code (LDC) is to improve inconsistencies throughout the LDC , resolve conflicting language , and enhance readability while improving user fr iendliness with the new enCodePlus software platform. It will no longer be Municode . The enCodePlus is customer-based and user friendly , and it is an online platform that will be easy to use . The purpose of this presentation is to provide an overview of the LDC update as well as present the LPA 's role in this 2-year project , as this advisory board will be very involved . City staff will rely heavily on this Board with members who know and use the code. Ms. Gademer introduced Stefanie McQueen , HOR , who gave a brief overview of her professional credentials , including that she is a Land Use and Transportation Planner based in Tampa. She adv ised HOR is an Engineering and Architectural firm that has done work for the City previously and looks forward to working with everyone over the next couple of years. Steve Sizemore introduced himself and Rachel Booth from Kendig Keast Collaborative and adv ised : They will be working with Ms. McQueen and with Toole Design Group. He thereafter explained enCodePlus is the platform hosting the site where the update will be drafting and the City can be interacting. He reviewed the roles of Kandig Keast Collaborative and of Toole Design and HOR on the consultant team. Kandig Keast Collaborative is a mult i-disciplinary firm based out of Kansas and noted their Owner/President/CEO would be the principal in charge of the project actively involved ; he will be the Project Manager himself and Ms. Booth would the principal Assistant . However , they have other Planners who will be involved. The process is focus ing not on totally redoing everything; there are already great provisions. The key approach is to make it more consistent , remove duplications, and make it easier to use. That is not only for staff , but for applicants to find a way for it to be a single source for all the procedures and definitions , putting them in their proper place rather than having the appl icant navigate all over for similar procedures. They are not only simplifying the use of the LDC but also the interpretation , i.e . the way it is administered and enforced. This will not be changing other processes and polic ies such as the Building Code and Annexation policies. This will be working to complement those that will stay intact, and this will only be cross- referencing where appropriate and so forth. The goals of this project include modernizing the City 's already more modern code than most , part icularly in making it more user-friendly with cross references , use of graphics and tab les , and figures throughout and making it easier to interpret the standards and procedures . A key factor is implementing the Comprehensive Plan , the Strive for 2035. The City has a very deta iled set of goals and objectives throughout that document they can use to implement. In the process of making this a user-fr iendly code , they aim to reorganize it in a way that makes it logical in how the standards are aligned with each other , i.e. the uses and zoning districts and procedures , putting like things with like things , tailoring the design standards to more high-quality env ironments, and duplicating and enhancing what has been working well for the City in the Comprehensive Plan . Streamlining can mean the processes but also the way the information is accessed and making it less time-consuming for everyone . The overall objectives include : Finding ways to promote lower cost affordable housing opportunities for ex isting and future 24-11

Regular Meeting Minutes August 14, 2024 residents and giving options for households ; Local Planning Agency Look at opportunities in Dunedin for infill and redevelopment ; Reenforcing connectivity and walkable neighborhoods; Protecting natural resources and open spaces including access; Capitalizing on integrating new trends and practices in writing codes that have been identified in the Comprehensive Plan, but also that are emerging as opportunities for this process. In terms of their approach , one is finding ways to make the language as simple as possible, removing legal language that could be said in two or three words or in a graphic or table, and creating clarity and an easier way for everyone to access. Also , they will focus on implementing development-related policies , basically using the Comp Plan and adopted policies and plans to implement where appropriate, to focus on form and community character in that process . In the process, they will create value out of the application process by integrating best practices and focusing on quality neighborhoods . One size does not fit all ; the standards have to be contextual as they look to find ways to create those standards complementing the existing and desired character of neighborhoods . Understanding the local desires and what Dunedin wants to see in future development. The word module will be heard a lot; they will be drafting the LDC in three modules , three parts: Conceptually at this point: Module 1 - General Provisions and Zoning Districts and Land Use Module 2 - Development Standards Module 3 - Subdivision and Administrative They will be incorporating the existing chapters and provisions , amending and updating as needed . The restructuring of the code is done in a way of thinking of the average user accessing the code . Mr. Sizemore referred to a PowerPoint presentation and elaborated on the process and formatting of the document and the phases of the process: The integration of new Local, State , and Federal legislation; Making the process predictable for staff and applicants and decision-making government bodies . Regarding the public engagement element, it is different from something like a corridor plan or comprehens ive plan in that it is not visionary, but technical and detailed ; Mr. Sizemore advised who would be a part of the public engagement at each stage and phase of the process and each module . At the end of each module , the LPA will have the opportunity to review the draft proposal so that there are no surprises at the end of the process. There is a 2-year process mapped out for the project, which he reviewed; he noted they will be returning to the City in November for the various types of meet ings and in the meantime populating the public engagement page and beginning the diagnostics . They will also begin the annotated outline , and in the beginning of next year they will begin the drafting phase once what they have ident ified is given the go-ahead . The goal is to wrap up by the end of July 2026 . Mr . Sizemore advised on the role of the Local Planning Agency, as they are the key adv isory committee for this process ; they will be meeting with the LPA at the end of each module with the opportunity to provide feedback and ask questions and help to guide the process. Some issues to think about are what is not working in the current regulations , what should be left as is , and what should be added or 24-12

Regular Meeting Minutes August 14, 2024 Local Planning Agency removed . Also, if members have seen something implemented elsewhere , they can bring that forward as well . At the end , the LPA will be making the recommendation to the City Commission for the public hear ing process ; the City Commission will be updated through the process as well. The goal is that by the adoption phase there are no surprises , just possibly some adjustments . Board Questions Vice-Chair Benjamin asked how the public engagement will be done in a constructive way and making sure misinformation is not being spread on social media and so forth . Mr. Sizemore explained they will be working closely with Ms . Gademer and the Commun ications Department to make sure what is presented on the engagement side is accurate and consistent with what is being done . There will be misinformation and misunderstanding especially with the terminology , so they want to make sure of using language in the presentation to help guide in what is remaining the same and what is being updated. Regarding controlling how the public understands the process , they will have to see how that goes. He emphasized they are not looking to drastically change what this code does ; there is a lot working already and this will be making the information easier to use and function . Mr. Sizemore added there will be some concepts introduced, the idea being that the code is consistent with the Comprehensive Plan ; this is also to make sure the code is legally defensible and it will help promote what the community really desires. Public Input Chair Broom opened the public input. Jude Zentmeyer of 95 Milwaukee Avenue asked who is doing this work now and why they need to be replaced by another consultant group. Mr . Sizemore explained the current code is being administered by the Community Development Department Planning staff . There have been a number of amendments; they are adm inistering what has been adopted. Their role is proposing ways to update and improve the existing code. Project Manager Gademer explained this is a City Commission approved project ; they approved the contract in June and that budget was approved through the City Commiss ion process as well. Currently , the City does not have any other Land Development Code updates in terms of the entire LDC. There are ordinances making their way through the process ; this is a totally separate project for sections of the LDC . She acknowledged the contract has already been established for two years from July 2024 to July 2026 . In addition , Mr. Sizemore commented that staff has received proposals and applications and sometimes it is difficult for them to step back. For many commun ities that try to do this internally , it takes forever and there are always setbacks in the process. For something as complex as the zoning code , to step back and objectively sort it out sometimes helps to have other eyes on it. Their firm and HOR see codes from around the country and write in multiple states as well as Florida , and they have a good feel for what is functioning well across the nation. Staff could align Dunedin's code in a way that functions better , but it would be difficult unless one person is only doing that. He has seen communities attempt it internally and it is really challenging . Hearing and seeing no one else wishing to speak , Cha ir Broom closed the public input portion . Ms. Gademer explained staff will be meeting with the LPA at the end of each module as well as a few other times , including public engagement in November with the LPA and having a joint session with the LPA and the Commiss ion. The dates will be set and placed on the calendar for the Board members to know well in advance , and it will also go through the regular upload of the agenda packet. Currently , 24-13

Regular Meeting Minutes August 14, 2024 Local Planning Agency the th inking is the meet ings will be part of the normal LPA calendar meetings unless there are any objections ; they could work with Mr. Kinney and the LPA Chair. Mr. Sizemore advised the materials will be provided well in advance and they will present the big picture of those modules ; the members will have the opportunity to review ahead and be prepared with quest ions and comments . Mr . Stanek inquired about the subdivision phase . Mr . Sizemore explained they have not started the analysis part ; however, it is likely the main part they would likely do is ensure it is up to date with State regulations and is easier to access ; those probably will not be changed very much . It would be for new subdivisions , which the City is not likely to have many. 1.d. Selection of new members to Local Planning Agency Discussion and recommendation for two (2) new Alternate LPA members Mr. Alspaugh brought up the question of the Palm Harbor address for Mr. Johns , and it was noted to be the mailing address and is still in the City of Dunedin . The following candidates for vacant LPA positions were in attendance and spoke : Jude Zentmeyer of 95 Milwaukee Avenue , a resident since 2010 , commented on her interest in Dunedin as to the planning and implementation and noted she is a retired realtor and is active in various organizations and clubs in the City . She is happy with the way Dunedin has been run since she has lived here . James Johns of 2879 Deerhound Way, Palm Harbor clarified that is the mailing address which is in the City of Dunedin, and all serv ices are provided to Countrywoods by Dunedin. He has been a resident since 2019 and wants to do his part to pay it forward and contribute to the community. He does work full-time at a commercial real estate firm as an appraiser . He has a Bachelor's degree in City and Regional Planning and Master's degree in Finance. Jeremy Reynolds of 973 Cedarwood Avenue commented on his love of Dunedin and his neighbors and the need to follow the Code. Over the years , he has been a staunch citizens' advocate regarding development projects and expanded that beyond the City, having been involved in development applications and land use rights cases as a paralegal in other surrounding cities . He has been trying to get on this committee since about 2017 ; sometime during the pandemic , there was a technical issue and the date was shifted. He noted there are no certified technical criteria for qualifications for serving on the LPA. He has attended at least two LPA meetings with Dr. Broom as Chair . He is still a working paralegal. Sally Caron of 966 Douglas Avenue commented on her work in management and noted she serves on two other Dunedin committees . She has been a resident for nine years and has seen and loved the growth. She wants to be part of the City and making it better. She is on the Code Enforcement Board and the CRA Advisory Committee . Ms. McHale believes it is two , but she will check with the City Clerk regarding the regulations for the number of committees a citizen can serve on ; she advised that if th is is confirmed , Ms. Caron would have to step down from one of the committees she is currently on to serve on the LPA. Chair Broom advised there were also applications from the following who were not present. Nathalie Rivera Enchevarria Christoper Wadelin Phillip Fisher Mr . Alspaugh inquired if it is still the policy that applicants must attend at least one meeting prior to 24-14

Regular Meeting Minutes August 14 , 2024 Local Planning Agency being appointed to the LPA. Chair Broom advised his understand ing is that is tru e. Ms . McHale did not have the informat ion at this time on whether or not the other applicants have attended a meeting . Mr. Alspaugh verified with Chair Broom not knowing that would elim inate the other applications from cons iderat ion this evening. Recommendations for Alternate LPA positions: MOTION: Motion was made by Vice-Cha ir Benjamin and seconded by Mr . Flatley to recommend to the City Commission appointment of Sally Caron for the pos ition of Alternate Member 1 to the Local Planning Agency subject to clarificat ion and subsequent possible resignation from one citizen committee . VOTE: Motion carried unanimously. MOTION: Motion was made by Vice-Chair Benjamin and seconded by Mr . Alspaugh to recommend to the City Commission appointment of James Johns for the position of Alternate Member 2 to the Local Planning Agency. VOTE: Motion carried unan imously. 2. OPEN FORUM - None 3. CITIZEN INPUT - None Chair Broom advised this is the opportunity to address the Board on any item that is not on the agenda . NEXT MEETING: The next meeting of the Local Planning Agency will be on Wednesday , September 11 , 2024 , at 6:00 p.m. ADJOURN Motion made by Mr. Stanek and seconded by Vice-Chair Benjamin to adjourn passed unanimously . The meet ing adjourned at 7:40 p.m. NOTE: Dr. · ael Broom Chair , Local Planning Agency Attest: Michelle Deputy City Clerk 24-15

1 NOTICE OF PUBLIC MEETING LOCAL PLANNING AGENCY City Hall, 737 Louden Ave AUGUST 14, 2024 6:00 PM AGENDA CALL TO ORDER 1. BUSINESS 1.a. Approval of Meeting Minutes A. June 12, 2024 LPA Meeting B. July 29, 2024 Special LPA Meeting Review and approval of draft meeting minutes. EXHIBIT: A. 6/12/2024 LPA Meeting Draft Minutes EXHIBIT: B. LPA Special Minutes 07-29-24.pdf 1.b. Application DR 24-04 - Request for Design Review Approval pursuant to Section 103-32.4(B)iv of the Land Development Code (LDC) for the construction of a single-family residence within the South Dunedin Character Overlay with a width greater than sixty (60') feet at the front setback line on the property located at 125 Edgewater Drive. Staff has determined the application meets all of the applicable review criteria for a recommendation of approval with certain conditions by the Local Planning Agency (LPA) to the City Commission. EXHIBIT: A. Staff Report EXHIBIT: B. Design Review Application DR 24-04 EXHIBIT: C. Aerial, Land Use & Zoning Maps EXHIBIT: D. Map of Surrounding Properties EXHIBIT: E. Sustainability Matrix EXHIBIT: F. 5/15/2024 DRC Meeting Notes EXHIBIT: G. 7/2/2024 ARC Meeting Minutes EXHIBIT: H. Public Notices EXHIBIT: I. Staff Presentation EXHIBIT: J. Applicant's Presentation

2 1.c. Land Development Code Update Kickoff Meeting with the LPA Informational / Presentational Item: Kickoff meeting with LPA, Staff, and the Consultant Team. EXHIBIT: A. FY 2023 BPI LDC Update.pdf EXHIBIT: B. Executed GEC Task Assignment Srvc Authorization (P-2-24) Toole Design Group - LDC Update.pdf EXHIBIT: C. City Commission Work Session Mtg (6-18-24) Minutes - (Approval of Contract).pdf 1.d. Selection of new members to Local Planning Agency Discussion and Recommendation of 2 Alternate members EXHIBIT: A. LPA Applicant Packet 8.6.24.pdf 2. OPEN FORUM Opportunity for board members to discuss items not otherwise on the agenda. 3. PUBLIC INPUT Opportunity for the public to address the board members on items not otherwise on the agenda. ADJOURN If a person decides to appeal any decision made by the board, agency or commission with respect to any matter considered at such meeting or hearing, he or she will need a record of the proceedings, and for such purpose may need to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceedings is made, which record includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal is to be based, per Florida Statute 286.0105. The City of Dunedin does not discriminate on the basis of race, color, national origin, sex, religion, age, political affirmation, marital status, sexual orientation, and disabled status in employment of the provision of services. Disability Provisions: It is the policy of the City of Dunedin not to discriminate against disabled persons in employment or the provisions of services. If you have a disability that requires accommodation, please notify the ADA Coordinator 48 hours prior to the scheduled meeting at (727) 298-3043. COPIES OF THIS AND ALL COMMISSION AGENDAS ARE AVAILABLE TO THE PUBLIC AT THE OFFICE OF THE CITY CLERK, 737 LOUDEN AVENUE, ON THE MONDAY PRIOR TO THE MEETING DATE. COPIES ARE ALSO AVAILABLE ON THE CITY’S WEBSITE AT WWW.DUNEDINGOV.COM.

Showing the first 24,000 of 190,206 characters. The full document is at the source.

MEETING OF THE. [SPEAKER OFF MIC] [SPEAKER OFF MIC] THE AUGUST 14th, 2024 MEETING THE AUGUST 14th, 2024 MEETING OF THE LOCAL PLANNING AGENCY OF OF THE LOCAL PLANNING AGENCY OF THE CITY OF DUNEDIN WILL NOW THE CITY OF DUNEDIN WILL NOW COME TO ORDER. COME TO ORDER. THE LOCAL PLANNING AGENCY IS AN THE LOCAL PLANNING AGENCY IS AN ADVISORY BOARD OF CITIZENS ADVISORY BOARD OF CITIZENS APPOINTED BY THE CITY APPOINTED BY THE CITY COMMISSION. COMMISSION. THIS BOARD IS COMPRISED OF THIS BOARD IS COMPRISED OF VOLUNTEERS WHO REPRESENT THE VOLUNTEERS WHO REPRESENT THE THOUGHTS AND CONCERNS OF THE THOUGHTS AND CONCERNS OF THE COMMUNITY. COMMUNITY. THE PURPOSE OF TONIGHT'S MEETING THE PURPOSE OF TONIGHT'S MEETING IS TO MAKE RECOMMENDATIONS TO IS TO MAKE RECOMMENDATIONS TO THE CITY COMMISSION REGARDING THE CITY COMMISSION REGARDING EACH ITEM ON THE AGENDA. EACH ITEM ON THE AGENDA. ANYONE IN THE AUDIENCE WHO ANYONE IN THE AUDIENCE WHO WISHES TO GIVE TESTIMONY TO ANY WISHES TO GIVE TESTIMONY TO ANY ITEMS ON THE AGENDA WILL NEED TO ITEMS ON THE AGENDA WILL NEED TO BE SWORN IN BY THE DEPUTY CITY BE SWORN IN BY THE DEPUTY CITY CLERK. CLERK. THE SWEARING IN PROCESS WILL THE SWEARING IN PROCESS WILL OCCUR AFTER TONIGHT'S FIRST OCCUR AFTER TONIGHT'S FIRST AGENDA ITEM WHICH WILL BE AGENDA ITEM WHICH WILL BE APPROVAL OF THE MINUTES OF THE APPROVAL OF THE MINUTES OF THE LAST LOCAL PLANNING AGENCY. LAST LOCAL PLANNING AGENCY. THAT WAS A GOOD MEETING. THAT WAS A GOOD MEETING. [LAUGHTER] [LAUGHTER] CITIZENS SPEAKING ON AN AGENDA CITIZENS SPEAKING ON AN AGENDA ITEM OR DURING CITIZEN COMMENT ITEM OR DURING CITIZEN COMMENT SHALL NOT ENGAGE IN LOUD, SHALL NOT ENGAGE IN LOUD, BOISTEROUS AND/OR DISRUPTIVE BOISTEROUS AND/OR DISRUPTIVE SPEECH OR CONDUCT. SPEECH OR CONDUCT. ANY SPEAKER THAT HAS ANY SPEAKER THAT HAS CONTINUED -- ANY SPEAKER THAT CONTINUED -- ANY SPEAKER THAT HAS CONTINUED INAPPROPRIATE OR HAS CONTINUED INAPPROPRIATE OR IRRELEVANT COMMENTS WILL BE IRRELEVANT COMMENTS WILL BE REQUESTED TO RELINQUISH THE REQUESTED TO RELINQUISH THE PODIUM BY THE CHAIR. PODIUM BY THE CHAIR. PLEASE BE AWARE THAT THE LOCAL PLEASE BE AWARE THAT THE LOCAL PLANNING AGENCY IS NOT A PLANNING AGENCY IS NOT A QUASI-JUDICIAL BOARD AND, QUASI-JUDICIAL BOARD AND, THEREFORE, HAS NO FINAL THEREFORE, HAS NO FINAL DECISION-MAKING POWER. DECISION-MAKING POWER. OUR PROCEDURES, HOWEVER, ARE OUR PROCEDURES, HOWEVER, ARE STRUCTURED IN A QUASI-JUDICIAL STRUCTURED IN A QUASI-JUDICIAL MANNER FOR THE BENEFIT OF THOSE MANNER FOR THE BENEFIT OF THOSE WHO COME BEFORE IT. WHO COME BEFORE IT. TONIGHT'S FORMAT WILL BE AS TONIGHT'S FORMAT WILL BE AS FOLLOWS. FOLLOWS. I WILL INTRODUCE EACH ITEM ON I WILL INTRODUCE EACH ITEM ON THE AGENDA, AFTER WHICH THE CITY THE AGENDA, AFTER WHICH THE CITY REPRESENTATIVE WILL PRESENT REPRESENTATIVE WILL PRESENT INFORMATION ABOUT IT. INFORMATION ABOUT IT. THEREAFTER, THE MEMBERS OF THE THEREAFTER, THE MEMBERS OF THE LOCAL PLANNING AGENCY WILL ASK LOCAL PLANNING AGENCY WILL ASK QUESTIONS OF THE CITY QUESTIONS OF THE CITY REPRESENTATIVE. REPRESENTATIVE. FINALLY, ANYONE FROM THE PUBLIC FINALLY, ANYONE FROM THE PUBLIC MAY COME FORWARD. MAY COME FORWARD. THOSE FROM THE PUBLIC WISHING TO THOSE FROM THE PUBLIC WISHING TO GIVE TESTIMONY WILL APPROACH THE GIVE TESTIMONY WILL APPROACH THE DAIS, STATE THEIR NAME AND DAIS, STATE THEIR NAME AND ADDRESS, AND THEN UTILIZE THE ADDRESS, AND THEN UTILIZE THE SPEAKER'S LECTERN IN ORDER FOR SPEAKER'S LECTERN IN ORDER FOR THEIR COMMENTS TO BE RECORDED. THEIR COMMENTS TO BE RECORDED. INDIVIDUAL SPEAKERS WILL BE INDIVIDUAL SPEAKERS WILL BE LIMITED TO THREE MINUTES OF LIMITED TO THREE MINUTES OF SPEAKING TIME. SPEAKING TIME. AND WE KINDLY REQUEST THAT AND WE KINDLY REQUEST THAT SPEAKERS ARE RESPECTFUL OF THE SPEAKERS ARE RESPECTFUL OF THE COUNTDOWN CLOCK. COUNTDOWN CLOCK. UPON THE CONCLUSION OF EACH UPON THE CONCLUSION OF EACH PUBLIC HEARING, THE LOCAL PUBLIC HEARING, THE LOCAL PLANNING AGENCY WILL CONSIDER PLANNING AGENCY WILL CONSIDER THE EVIDENCE BEFORE IT AND WILL THE EVIDENCE BEFORE IT AND WILL VOTE ON THE AGENDA ITEM. VOTE ON THE AGENDA ITEM. THAT VOICE VOTE IS THE RENDITION THAT VOICE VOTE IS THE RENDITION OF THE ORDER OF THE BOARD AND OF THE ORDER OF THE BOARD AND THERE WILL BE NO WRITTEN THERE WILL BE NO WRITTEN DECISION ISSUED BY THE BOARD. DECISION ISSUED BY THE BOARD. THE FIRST ITEM ON THE AGENDA IS THE FIRST ITEM ON THE AGENDA IS TO APPROVE THE JUNE 12th AND TO APPROVE THE JUNE 12th AND JULY 29th, 2024 LPA MINUTES. JULY 29th, 2024 LPA MINUTES. ARE THERE ANY CORRECTIONS, ARE THERE ANY CORRECTIONS, ADDITIONS OR DELETIONS TO THE ADDITIONS OR DELETIONS TO THE MINUTES? MINUTES? HEARING NONE, DO I HEAR A MOTION HEARING NONE, DO I HEAR A MOTION TO ACCEPT THE MINUTES? TO ACCEPT THE MINUTES? >> SO MOVED. >> SO MOVED. >> SO MOVED. >> >> SO MOVED. >> Chair: >> SO MOVED. >> Chair: CAN >> SO MOVED. >> Chair: CAN I >> SO MOVED. >> Chair: CAN I GET >> SO MOVED. >> Chair: CAN I GET A >> SO MOVED. >> Chair: CAN I GET A SECOND? >> Chair: CAN I GET A SECOND? >> Chair: CAN I GET A SECOND? >> >> Chair: CAN I GET A SECOND? >> SECOND. >> SECOND. >> SECOND. >> >> SECOND. >> Chair: >> SECOND. >> Chair: THANK >> SECOND. >> Chair: THANK YOU. >> Chair: THANK YOU. >> Chair: THANK YOU. ALL >> Chair: THANK YOU. ALL IN >> Chair: THANK YOU. ALL IN FAVOR? ALL IN FAVOR? [AYES] [AYES] ALL OPPOSED? ALL OPPOSED? THE AYES HAVE IT. THE AYES HAVE IT. THE CLERK WILL NOW SWEAR IN ALL THE CLERK WILL NOW SWEAR IN ALL PERSONS WISHING TO SPEAK OR GIVE PERSONS WISHING TO SPEAK OR GIVE TESTIMONY TO ANY OF TONIGHT'S TESTIMONY TO ANY OF TONIGHT'S AGENDA ITEMS. AGENDA ITEMS. >> DO WE HAVE TO DO THAT? >> DO WE HAVE TO DO THAT? >> DO WE HAVE TO DO THAT? >> >> DO WE HAVE TO DO THAT? >> YOU'VE >> DO WE HAVE TO DO THAT? >> YOU'VE GOT >> DO WE HAVE TO DO THAT? >> YOU'VE GOT ONE >> DO WE HAVE TO DO THAT? >> YOU'VE GOT ONE MORE >> DO WE HAVE TO DO THAT? >> YOU'VE GOT ONE MORE SET >> DO WE HAVE TO DO THAT? >> YOU'VE GOT ONE MORE SET OF >> YOU'VE GOT ONE MORE SET OF >> YOU'VE GOT ONE MORE SET OF MINUTES >> YOU'VE GOT ONE MORE SET OF MINUTES TO >> YOU'VE GOT ONE MORE SET OF MINUTES TO APPROVE. MINUTES TO APPROVE. THE SPECIAL MEETING OF THE SPECIAL MEETING OF JULY 29th. JULY 29th. >> THAT WAS OUR SPECIAL MEETING. >> THAT WAS OUR SPECIAL MEETING. >> THAT WAS OUR SPECIAL MEETING. >> >> THAT WAS OUR SPECIAL MEETING. >> Chair: >> THAT WAS OUR SPECIAL MEETING. >> Chair: DIDN'T >> THAT WAS OUR SPECIAL MEETING. >> Chair: DIDN'T I >> THAT WAS OUR SPECIAL MEETING. >> Chair: DIDN'T I MENTION >> THAT WAS OUR SPECIAL MEETING. >> Chair: DIDN'T I MENTION THE >> Chair: DIDN'T I MENTION THE >> Chair: DIDN'T I MENTION THE 29th? 29th? >> OH, HE DID. >> OH, HE DID. >> OH, HE DID. >> >> OH, HE DID. >> Chair: >> OH, HE DID. >> Chair: JUNE >> OH, HE DID. >> Chair: JUNE 12th >> OH, HE DID. >> Chair: JUNE 12th AND >> Chair: JUNE 12th AND >> Chair: JUNE 12th AND JULY >> Chair: JUNE 12th AND JULY 29th. JULY 29th. THANK YOU VERY MUCH. THANK YOU VERY MUCH. >> I'M SORRY. >> I'M SORRY. >> I'M SORRY. [LAUGHTER] [LAUGHTER] YOU DID THEM ALL TOGETHER. YOU DID THEM ALL TOGETHER. >> Chair: I THOUGHT AM I LOSING >> Chair: I THOUGHT AM I LOSING >> Chair: I THOUGHT AM I LOSING IT >> Chair: I THOUGHT AM I LOSING IT TODAY. IT TODAY. I HAVE LOST IT BEFORE. I HAVE LOST IT BEFORE. ALL RIGHT. ALL RIGHT. SO THE CLERK WILL NOW SWEAR IN SO THE CLERK WILL NOW SWEAR IN ALL PERSONS. ALL PERSONS. >> STAND AND RAISE YOUR RIGHT >> STAND AND RAISE YOUR RIGHT >> STAND AND RAISE YOUR RIGHT HAND. HAND. DO YOU SWEAR THE TESTIMONY YOU DO YOU SWEAR THE TESTIMONY YOU ARE ABOUT TO GIVE IN THIS ARE ABOUT TO GIVE IN THIS PROCEEDING IS THE TRUTH, THE PROCEEDING IS THE TRUTH, THE WHOLE TRUTH AND NOTHING BUT THE WHOLE TRUTH AND NOTHING BUT THE TRUTH? TRUTH? [RESPONSE] [RESPONSE] >> Chair: THANK YOU. >> Chair: THANK YOU. >> Chair: THANK YOU. THE >> Chair: THANK YOU. THE SECOND >> Chair: THANK YOU. THE SECOND ITEM >> Chair: THANK YOU. THE SECOND ITEM ON >> Chair: THANK YOU. THE SECOND ITEM ON OUR >> Chair: THANK YOU. THE SECOND ITEM ON OUR AGENDA THE SECOND ITEM ON OUR AGENDA TONIGHT IS APPLICATION DR 24-04. TONIGHT IS APPLICATION DR 24-04. HAS ANYONE HAD ANY EX PARTE HAS ANYONE HAD ANY EX PARTE COMMUNICATIONS REGARDING THIS COMMUNICATIONS REGARDING THIS APPLICATION? APPLICATION? >> Chair: THANK YOU. >> Chair: THANK YOU. >> Chair: THANK YOU. HEARING >> Chair: THANK YOU. HEARING NONE, >> Chair: THANK YOU. HEARING NONE, WE >> Chair: THANK YOU. HEARING NONE, WE WILL >> Chair: THANK YOU. HEARING NONE, WE WILL HEAR >> Chair: THANK YOU. HEARING NONE, WE WILL HEAR FROM HEARING NONE, WE WILL HEAR FROM OUR CITY REPRESENTATIVE. OUR CITY REPRESENTATIVE. >> THANK YOU, MR. CHAIR. >> THANK YOU, MR. CHAIR. >> THANK YOU, MR. CHAIR. GEORGE >> THANK YOU, MR. CHAIR. GEORGE KINNEY >> THANK YOU, MR. CHAIR. GEORGE KINNEY AND >> THANK YOU, MR. CHAIR. GEORGE KINNEY AND JOSEPH GEORGE KINNEY AND JOSEPH DiPASQUA ON BEHALF OF THE DiPASQUA ON BEHALF OF THE COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DEPARTMENT. DEPARTMENT. THANK YOU FOR ALLOWING US THE THANK YOU FOR ALLOWING US THE OPPORTUNITY TO PRESENT THIS OPPORTUNITY TO PRESENT THIS EVENING TO YOU AND YOUR EVENING TO YOU AND YOUR COLLEAGUES. COLLEAGUES. THIS IS A DESIGN REVIEW REQUEST THIS IS A DESIGN REVIEW REQUEST NUMBER 24-04. NUMBER 24-04. IT IS DESIGN REVIEW APPROVAL IT IS DESIGN REVIEW APPROVAL REQUEST FOR A NEW SINGLE-FAMILY REQUEST FOR A NEW SINGLE-FAMILY REBS KNOWN AS THE WILKERSON REBS KNOWN AS THE WILKERSON RESIDENCE AT 125 EDGEWATER RESIDENCE AT 125 EDGEWATER DRIVE. DRIVE. THE OTHER THAN IS LBW WCW LLC THE OTHER THAN IS LBW WCW LLC AND THE REPRESENTATIVES OF AND THE REPRESENTATIVES OF CLIFFORD SCHOLZ AND DANIEL CLIFFORD SCHOLZ AND DANIEL SHAFFER. SHAFFER. YOU CAN SEE THE PROPERTY IN YOU CAN SEE THE PROPERTY IN QUESTION DOES HAVE AN OVERALL QUESTION DOES HAVE AN OVERALL AREA OF 1.13 ACRES OR ROUGHLY AREA OF 1.13 ACRES OR ROUGHLY 49,259 SQUARE FEET. 49,259 SQUARE FEET. IT IS COMPRISED OF SEVERAL IT IS COMPRISED OF SEVERAL DIFFERENT FLOOD ZONE CATEGORIES. DIFFERENT FLOOD ZONE CATEGORIES. HOWEVER, WHERE THE RESIDENCE IS HOWEVER, WHERE THE RESIDENCE IS PROPOSED WOULD BE OUTSIDE OF ANY PROPOSED WOULD BE OUTSIDE OF ANY FLOODPLAIN AREAS AND IN WHAT WE FLOODPLAIN AREAS AND IN WHAT WE CALL ZONE X. CALL ZONE X. THE LAN USE FOR THE PROPERTY IS THE LAN USE FOR THE PROPERTY IS RESIDENTIAL URBAN AND RECREATION RESIDENTIAL URBAN AND RECREATION OPEN SPACE. OPEN SPACE. THE ZONING DISTRICT IS THE ZONING DISTRICT IS SINGLE-FAMILY R-60. SINGLE-FAMILY R-60. AND THE EXISTING USE OF THE SITE AND THE EXISTING USE OF THE SITE IS CURRENTLY VACANT. IS CURRENTLY VACANT. FROM A PROPERTY HISTORY FROM A PROPERTY HISTORY PERSPECTIVE, THE HOME AND THE PERSPECTIVE, THE HOME AND THE OUTBUILDINGS THAT PREVIOUSLY OUTBUILDINGS THAT PREVIOUSLY OCCUPIED THIS SITE WERE OCCUPIED THIS SITE WERE DEMOLISHED EARLIER THIS YEAR SO DEMOLISHED EARLIER THIS YEAR SO THE PROPERTY IS CURRENTLY THE PROPERTY IS CURRENTLY VACANT. VACANT. TO THE RIGHT OF THIS PARTICULAR TO THE RIGHT OF THIS PARTICULAR SLIDE, YOU CAN SEE THE SURVEY OF SLIDE, YOU CAN SEE THE SURVEY OF THE PROPERTY SHOWING THE THE PROPERTY SHOWING THE BUILDINGS. BUILDINGS. AND BELOW IS ACTUALLY A GOOGLE AND BELOW IS ACTUALLY A GOOGLE IMAGE OF THE HOME THAT WAS THERE IMAGE OF THE HOME THAT WAS THERE PRIOR TO DEMOLITION. PRIOR TO DEMOLITION. THE PROJECT DESCRIPTION, THROUGH THE PROJECT DESCRIPTION, THROUGH THE REPRESENTATIVES, THE OWNERS THE REPRESENTATIVES, THE OWNERS ARE AGAIN REQUESTING DESIGN ARE AGAIN REQUESTING DESIGN REVIEW APPROVAL TO CONSTRUCT THE REVIEW APPROVAL TO CONSTRUCT THE NEW SINGLE-FAMILY HOME. NEW SINGLE-FAMILY HOME. WHAT IS KIND OF UNIQUE AND I WHAT IS KIND OF UNIQUE AND I THINK PROBABLY THE FIRST TIME THINK PROBABLY THE FIRST TIME THE BOARD HAS SEEN ONE OF THESE THE BOARD HAS SEEN ONE OF THESE PROPERTIES IN DESIGN REVIEW FORM PROPERTIES IN DESIGN REVIEW FORM BECAUSE IT IS A PROPERTY THAT IS BECAUSE IT IS A PROPERTY THAT IS IN THE SOUTH DUNEDIN OVERLAY. IN THE SOUTH DUNEDIN OVERLAY. AS PART OF THOSE PROVISIONS OF AS PART OF THOSE PROVISIONS OF THE SOUTH DUNEDIN OVERLAY, THERE THE SOUTH DUNEDIN OVERLAY, THERE IS A REQUIREMENT THAT NO NEW IS A REQUIREMENT THAT NO NEW CONSTRUCTION CAN EXCEED 60 FEET CONSTRUCTION CAN EXCEED 60 FEET IN WIDTH. IN WIDTH. AND SINCE THIS IS AN ASK FOR AND SINCE THIS IS AN ASK FOR 77.67 FEET, THAT'S THE REASON 77.67 FEET, THAT'S THE REASON THAT THE APPLICANT IS HERE TODAY THAT THE APPLICANT IS HERE TODAY TO TALK ABOUT THE NEW HOME AND TO TALK ABOUT THE NEW HOME AND ITS POSITION WITHIN THAT ITS POSITION WITHIN THAT OVERLAY. OVERLAY. VERY QUICKLY THE LAND USE PLAN VERY QUICKLY THE LAND USE PLAN EVALUATION, PRETTY CONSISTENT EVALUATION, PRETTY CONSISTENT WITH WHAT WE SEE DOWN IN THAT WITH WHAT WE SEE DOWN IN THAT PARTICULAR AREA. PARTICULAR AREA. IT'S THE RESIDENTIAL URBAN IT'S THE RESIDENTIAL URBAN CATEGORY AND, OF COURSE, IT CATEGORY AND, OF COURSE, IT WOULD PERMIT RESIDENTIAL USES. WOULD PERMIT RESIDENTIAL USES. FROM A ZONING DISTRICT FROM A ZONING DISTRICT PERSPECTIVE, AGAIN CONSISTENT PERSPECTIVE, AGAIN CONSISTENT THROUGHOUT THE AREA. THROUGHOUT THE AREA. ITS ZONING IS SINGLE-FAMILY ITS ZONING IS SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENTIAL R-60, MAXIMUM RESIDENTIAL R-60, MAXIMUM RESIDENTIAL DENSITY IS 7.5 RESIDENTIAL DENSITY IS 7.5 DWELLING UNITS -- ICE, I BACKED DWELLING UNITS -- ICE, I BACKED UP. UP. FROM A DENSITY STANDPOINT, 7.5 FROM A DENSITY STANDPOINT, 7.5 IS PERMITTED UNDER THE RU. IS PERMITTED UNDER THE RU. FROM ZONING STANDPOINT, IT IS FROM ZONING STANDPOINT, IT IS ALSO CONSISTENT AND PERMISSIBLE ALSO CONSISTENT AND PERMISSIBLE FOR SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCE TO FOR SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCE TO BE LOCATED IN THIS PARTICULAR BE LOCATED IN THIS PARTICULAR DISTRICT. DISTRICT. AND THE NEXT SLIDE THEN IS JUST AND THE NEXT SLIDE THEN IS JUST AN EVALUATION OF THE DIMENSIONAL AN EVALUATION OF THE DIMENSIONAL STANDARDS FOR THE R-60 CATEGORY. STANDARDS FOR THE R-60 CATEGORY. YOU CAN SEE ON THE LEFT ALL OF YOU CAN SEE ON THE LEFT ALL OF THOSE DIMENSIONAL STANDARDS FROM THOSE DIMENSIONAL STANDARDS FROM LOT AREA, LOT WIDTH, LOT DEPTH, LOT AREA, LOT WIDTH, LOT DEPTH, HEIGHT, FRONT SETBACK, SIDE HEIGHT, FRONT SETBACK, SIDE SETBACK AND REAR SETBACK -- THIS SETBACK AND REAR SETBACK -- THIS PARTICULAR PROPOSAL DOES MEET OR PARTICULAR PROPOSAL DOES MEET OR EXCEED ALL OF THOSE STANDARDS AS EXCEED ALL OF THOSE STANDARDS AS YOU CAN SEE THE CONFORMANCE ON YOU CAN SEE THE CONFORMANCE ON FOR EACH OF THOSE CATEGORIES. FOR EACH OF THOSE CATEGORIES. JUST VERY QUICKLY THEN, GETTING JUST VERY QUICKLY THEN, GETTING BACK TO THE SOUTH DUNEDIN BACK TO THE SOUTH DUNEDIN CHARACTER OVERLAY, BECAUSE THE CHARACTER OVERLAY, BECAUSE THE PROPERTY IS LOCATED WITHIN THAT PROPERTY IS LOCATED WITHIN THAT OVERLAY, THERE ARE ADDITIONAL OVERLAY, THERE ARE ADDITIONAL STANDARDS THAT APPLY. STANDARDS THAT APPLY. AND THAT'S WHAT THIS CHART IS AND THAT'S WHAT THIS CHART IS INTENDED TO SHOW YOU. INTENDED TO SHOW YOU. YOU MAY RECALL PROBABLY THE YOU MAY RECALL PROBABLY THE DISCUSSION ON ADOPTING THE DISCUSSION ON ADOPTING THE DAYLIGHT PLAIN, SOME ADDITIONAL DAYLIGHT PLAIN, SOME ADDITIONAL BUILDING DESIGN STANDARDS AND BUILDING DESIGN STANDARDS AND ARCHITECTURAL STYLE. ARCHITECTURAL STYLE. SO THIS CHART KIND OF OUTLAYS SO THIS CHART KIND OF OUTLAYS THIS PROPOSAL AGAINST THOSE THIS PROPOSAL AGAINST THOSE PARTICULAR STANDARDS. PARTICULAR STANDARDS. THEY DO MEET THE HEIGHT AND THEY DO MEET THE HEIGHT AND DAYLIGHT PLAIN REQUIREMENTS OF DAYLIGHT PLAIN REQUIREMENTS OF THE SOUTH OVERLAY FROM A THE SOUTH OVERLAY FROM A BUILDING DESIGN STANDPOINT, THE BUILDING DESIGN STANDPOINT, THE BUILDING ORIENTATION COMPORTS BUILDING ORIENTATION COMPORTS WITH THE OVERLAY. WITH THE OVERLAY. THE GARAGE AND CARPORT ARE THE GARAGE AND CARPORT ARE CONSISTENT WITH WHAT THE OVERLAY CONSISTENT WITH WHAT THE OVERLAY REQUIRES. REQUIRES. AND THE BUILDING ELEVATION IS AND THE BUILDING ELEVATION IS CONSISTENT. CONSISTENT. THE REASON WE ARE ACTUALLY HERE THE REASON WE ARE ACTUALLY HERE IS AGAIN FOR THAT BUILDING WIDTH IS AGAIN FOR THAT BUILDING WIDTH WHICH IS NOT TO EXCEED 60 FEET WHICH IS NOT TO EXCEED 60 FEET UNLESS YOU ENTER INTO THE DESIGN UNLESS YOU ENTER INTO THE DESIGN REVIEW PROCESS. REVIEW PROCESS. AND THEY ARE ALSO COMPLIANT WITH AND THEY ARE ALSO COMPLIANT WITH THE ARCHITECTURAL STYLE. THE ARCHITECTURAL STYLE. I'M GOING TO AT THIS POINT -- SO I'M GOING TO AT THIS POINT -- SO ONE OF THE THINGS WE WANTED TO ONE OF THE THINGS WE WANTED TO DO AS WE WORKED THROUGH THIS DO AS WE WORKED THROUGH THIS ANALYSIS WAS WE WANTED TO MAKE ANALYSIS WAS WE WANTED TO MAKE SURE WHEN WE'RE TALKING ABOUT SURE WHEN WE'RE TALKING ABOUT DESIGN REVIEW APPROVAL AND DESIGN REVIEW APPROVAL AND EXCEEDING THAT 60 FEET IN WIDTH, EXCEEDING THAT 60 FEET IN WIDTH, THAT WE ARE PERMITTING OR WE'RE THAT WE ARE PERMITTING OR WE'RE RECOMMENDING SOMETHING THAT'S RECOMMENDING SOMETHING THAT'S CONSISTENT WITH THAT CONSISTENT WITH THAT NEIGHBORHOOD FROM A NEIGHBORHOOD FROM A COMPATIBILITY STANDPOINT. COMPATIBILITY STANDPOINT. AND THAT'S WHAT I'M GOING TO ASK AND THAT'S WHAT I'M GOING TO ASK JOEY TO KIND OF WALK THROUGH JOEY TO KIND OF WALK THROUGH WHAT OUR COMPATIBILITY ANALYSIS WHAT OUR COMPATIBILITY ANALYSIS WAS AND WHAT OUR METHODOLOGY WAS AND WHAT OUR METHODOLOGY WAS. WAS. I'M SURE YOU'RE GOING TO HAVE I'M SURE YOU'RE GOING TO HAVE QUESTIONS AFTER THAT. QUESTIONS AFTER THAT. I KIND OF WANT TO TURN IT OVER I KIND OF WANT TO TURN IT OVER TO HIM AT THIS POINT TO TALK TO HIM AT THIS POINT TO TALK ABOUT HOW WE ARRIVED AT THE ABOUT HOW WE ARRIVED AT THE RECOMMENDATION THAT WE ARRIVED RECOMMENDATION THAT WE ARRIVED AT. AT. >> THANK YOU, GEORGE. >> THANK YOU, GEORGE. >> THANK YOU, GEORGE. SO >> THANK YOU, GEORGE. SO AS >> THANK YOU, GEORGE. SO AS YOU >> THANK YOU, GEORGE. SO AS YOU CAN >> THANK YOU, GEORGE. SO AS YOU CAN SEE >> THANK YOU, GEORGE. SO AS YOU CAN SEE HERE >> THANK YOU, GEORGE. SO AS YOU CAN SEE HERE ON >> THANK YOU, GEORGE. SO AS YOU CAN SEE HERE ON THE SO AS YOU CAN SEE HERE ON THE SLIDE, THAT'S SORT OF A SUMMARY SLIDE, THAT'S SORT OF A SUMMARY OF IT. OF IT. BUT IF I COULD, I'D LIKE TO JUST BUT IF I COULD, I'D LIKE TO JUST BACK UP FOR A MINUTE AND EXPLAIN BACK UP FOR A MINUTE AND EXPLAIN TO YOU WHAT OUR COMPATIBILITY TO YOU WHAT OUR COMPATIBILITY ANALYSIS INVOLVES. ANALYSIS INVOLVES. IN THIS PARTICULAR CASE, OF IN THIS PARTICULAR CASE, OF COURSE, UNDER DESIGN REVIEW WE COURSE, UNDER DESIGN REVIEW WE FOLLOW OBJECTIVE 2.9 IN OUR FOLLOW OBJECTIVE 2.9 IN OUR FUTURE LAND USE ELEMENT. FUTURE LAND USE ELEMENT. SO YOU'RE LOOKING AT PHYSICAL SO YOU'RE LOOKING AT PHYSICAL COMPATIBILITY OF THE PROPOSED COMPATIBILITY OF THE PROPOSED DEVELOPMENT OR REDEVELOPMENT DEVELOPMENT OR REDEVELOPMENT WITH THE SURROUNDING WITH THE SURROUNDING ENVIRONMENTS. ENVIRONMENTS. AND SOME OF THE THINGS YOU'RE AND SOME OF THE THINGS YOU'RE LOOKING FOR ARE HEIGHT, LOOKING FOR ARE HEIGHT, ARCHITECTURAL FEATURES OF THE ARCHITECTURAL FEATURES OF THE EXISTING STRUCTURES, HISTORIC EXISTING STRUCTURES, HISTORIC ASPECTS OF THE EXISTING ASPECTS OF THE EXISTING STRUCTURES, NATURAL FEATURES STRUCTURES, NATURAL FEATURES THAT ARE EXISTING, EXISTING LAND THAT ARE EXISTING, EXISTING LAND USES, EXISTING RESIDENTIAL USES, EXISTING RESIDENTIAL DENSITIES AND ECONOMICALLY DENSITIES AND ECONOMICALLY RELATED USES. RELATED USES. AND SO WHAT I WILL TELL YOU IS AND SO WHAT I WILL TELL YOU IS THAT, AS GEORGE MENTIONED, WHEN THAT, AS GEORGE MENTIONED, WHEN YOU LOOK OVERALL AT THE PREVIOUS YOU LOOK OVERALL AT THE PREVIOUS EVALUATIONS THAT WE DID BOTH EVALUATIONS THAT WE DID BOTH WITH THE OVERLAY DISTRICT AND WITH THE OVERLAY DISTRICT AND WITH THE ZONING DIMENSIONAL, YOU WITH THE ZONING DIMENSIONAL, YOU ESSENTIALLY HAVE HEIGHT ESSENTIALLY HAVE HEIGHT COMPATIBILITY. COMPATIBILITY. THIS IS A SINGLE-STORY THIS IS A SINGLE-STORY STRUCTURE. STRUCTURE. THE USE ITSELF AS GEORGE THE USE ITSELF AS GEORGE MENTIONS, IT'S SINGLE-FAMILY, MENTIONS, IT'S SINGLE-FAMILY, THAT'S WHAT OUR LAND USE IS. THAT'S WHAT OUR LAND USE IS. AND THAT'S WHAT YOU HAVE AND THAT'S WHAT YOU HAVE PREDOMINANTLY IN THE AREA -- IS PREDOMINANTLY IN THE AREA -- IS SINGLE-FAMILY. SINGLE-FAMILY. THERE ARE SOME TWO-FAMILY BUT THERE ARE SOME TWO-FAMILY BUT IT'S ALL REPRESENTATION. IT'S ALL REPRESENTATION. OF COURSE, THEY HAVE ALREADY OF COURSE, THEY HAVE ALREADY SELECTED ONE OF THE APPROVED SELECTED ONE OF THE APPROVED ARCHITECTURAL STYLE. ARCHITECTURAL STYLE. AND THEY HAVE MET ALL THE AND THEY HAVE MET ALL THE DIMENSIONAL STANDARDS. DIMENSIONAL STANDARDS. SO WHAT WE REALLY ARE FOCUSING SO WHAT WE REALLY ARE FOCUSING ON IS WHEN YOU LOOK AT THAT ON IS WHEN YOU LOOK AT THAT EXERCISE OF COMPATIBILITY WITH EXERCISE OF COMPATIBILITY WITH REGARD TO BUILDING WIDTH, HOW REGARD TO BUILDING WIDTH, HOW DOES THAT FIT IN WITH THE DOES THAT FIT IN WITH THE CONSISTENT THEME OF BUILDING CONSISTENT THEME OF BUILDING WIDTH THROUGHOUT THAT AREA. WIDTH THROUGHOUT THAT AREA. AND WHEN WE LOOK AT AND WHEN WE LOOK AT COMPATIBILITY, WE LOOK AT THE COMPATIBILITY, WE LOOK AT THE IMMEDIATELY SURROUNDING AREA. IMMEDIATELY SURROUNDING AREA. THAT'S HOW WE DO IT, AS YOU THAT'S HOW WE DO IT, AS YOU KNOW, WHEN WE DO ANY KIND OF KNOW, WHEN WE DO ANY KIND OF DESIGN REVIEW. DESIGN REVIEW. WITH THAT BEING SAID, WE DID WITH THAT BEING SAID, WE DID EXAMINE 34 PROPERTIES OF WHICH EXAMINE 34 PROPERTIES OF WHICH 33 OF THEM HAD BUILDINGS ON 33 OF THEM HAD BUILDINGS ON THEM, ONE BEING VACANT. THEM, ONE BEING VACANT. AND CONSISTENT WITH THE WAY THE AND CONSISTENT WITH THE WAY THE CODE IS INTENDED, WHEN YOU'RE CODE IS INTENDED, WHEN YOU'RE LOOKING AT BUILDING WIDTH, THE LOOKING AT BUILDING WIDTH, THE WAY OUR CODE READS, THIS IS THE WAY OUR CODE READS, THIS IS THE PRIMARY STRUCTURE. PRIMARY STRUCTURE. IT'S NOT A CUMULATIVE OF IT'S NOT A CUMULATIVE OF MULTIPLE BUILDINGS ON THE MULTIPLE BUILDINGS ON THE PROPERTY AND HOW THEY WOULD ADD PROPERTY AND HOW THEY WOULD ADD UP, SO TO SPEAK. UP, SO TO SPEAK. THIS IS THE PRIMARY STRUCTURE. THIS IS THE PRIMARY STRUCTURE. WHAT I WILL TELL YOU, WE DID WHAT I WILL TELL YOU, WE DID CONFIRM THAT WITH THE CITY CONFIRM THAT WITH THE CITY ATTORNEY'S OFFICE, THAT IS THE ATTORNEY'S OFFICE, THAT IS THE INTENT OF THE CODE. INTENT OF THE CODE. SO WITH THAT, WE DID EXAMINE SO WITH THAT, WE DID EXAMINE THOSE 33 PROPERTIES IMMEDIATELY THOSE 33 PROPERTIES IMMEDIATELY SURROUNDING BOTH NORTH AND SURROUNDING BOTH NORTH AND SOUTH. SOUTH. YOU'LL NOTICE WE WENT ABOUT 11 YOU'LL NOTICE WE WENT ABOUT 11 LOTS TO THE NORTH, 11 LOTS TO LOTS TO THE NORTH, 11 LOTS TO THE SOUTH AND WRAPPED AROUND THE THE SOUTH AND WRAPPED AROUND THE STRUCTURE. STRUCTURE. THAT IS THE SURROUNDING THAT IS THE SURROUNDING ENVIRONMENT, BOTH BUILT AND THEN ENVIRONMENT, BOTH BUILT AND THEN ONE VACANT. ONE VACANT. AND WHAT WE DETERMINED OUT OF AND WHAT WE DETERMINED OUT OF THOSE IS THAT 10 OF THOSE THOSE IS THAT 10 OF THOSE BUILDINGS ARE GREATER THAN BUILDINGS ARE GREATER THAN 60 FEET IN WIDTH. 60 FEET IN WIDTH. I'LL ALSO SHARE WITH YOU AND I'LL ALSO SHARE WITH YOU AND JUST FOR THE RECORD ALTHOUGH ALL JUST FOR THE RECORD ALTHOUGH ALL OF THIS IS IN THE STAFFING, WE OF THIS IS IN THE STAFFING, WE USED THE BUILDING DIAGRAMS FROM USED THE BUILDING DIAGRAMS FROM THE PROPERTY APPRAISER'S TO THE PROPERTY APPRAISER'S TO DETERMINE BUILDING WIDTH BECAUSE DETERMINE BUILDING WIDTH BECAUSE EACH BUILDING THERE'S A EACH BUILDING THERE'S A FOOTPRINT. FOOTPRINT. IT IS NOT HARD TO CALCULATE THE IT IS NOT HARD TO CALCULATE THE LINEAR LENGTH OF A BUILDING, OF LINEAR LENGTH OF A BUILDING, OF ALL EXISTING BUILDINGS. ALL EXISTING BUILDINGS. INSTEAD OF TRYING TO USE A INSTEAD OF TRYING TO USE A GOOGLE STREET VIEW AND MEASURE GOOGLE STREET VIEW AND MEASURE THINGS ON THE FLY, WE USED THE THINGS ON THE FLY, WE USED THE FOOTPRINTS FROM THE PROPERTY FOOTPRINTS FROM THE PROPERTY APPRAISER'S OFFICE. APPRAISER'S OFFICE. 10 BUILDINGS ARE GREATER THAN 6E 10 BUILDINGS ARE GREATER THAN 6E LARGEST BEING 109 FEET IN WI

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
Agenda packetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Action agendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Transcript or captionsSource recordingread transcript
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Coverage and corrections

Records considered

  • Local Planning Agency — Minutes
  • Local Planning Agency
  • Local Planning Agency — Closed Captions

Not claimed by this page

  • Verified meeting decisions with item-specific public-source evidence
  • Item-level plain-language summaries are not available; this page does not infer individual agenda items.
  • Item-linked, attributed deliberation
  • A source-grounded next meeting date
  • A plain-English overview is not available.
  • Official outcomes have not been published.
  • The available transcript has no reliable timestamps.
  • Transcript coverage is partial.
  • Speakers have not been reliably matched to public profiles.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.
  • An individual roll-call roster is not available.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: 3335b23b2bdc73926a31a959f18ca1c8. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record