POLISCOPE

The public record

FREMONT (ALAMEDA COUNTY)Held · official record pendingPartial coverage

Council Meeting 2/3/26

Tuesday, February 3, 2026 · Government meeting record

The 30-second read

Record incomplete

Council Meeting 2/3/26

Why it matters

The official meeting record is available below. Item-level plain-language summaries are not available yet.

What happens next

The scheduled meeting date has passed. Minutes or an action agenda are not published in the records we hold.

This meeting date has passed and no official outcome record has been published yet. Nothing on this page is a decision.

Transcript and record text

Closed captionsWhat was said at the meeting, transcribed Aug 13, 2026. Speech is not a decision.
  • No speaker turns were supplied with this transcript.
  • This transcript has no source timestamps.
  • No speaker identities were supplied with this transcript.

This source published text without speaker turns, so speakers and timestamps are not shown.

I'D LIKE TO CALL THE FEBRUARY 3RD 2026 MEETING TO ORDER AT 7:00 P.M. I'D LIKE TO ASK VICE MAYOR SANG TO LEAD US IN THE PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE. I PLEDGE ALLEGIANCE TO THE FLA OF THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA AND TO THE REPUBLIC FOR WHICH I ONE NATION UNDER GOD, INDIVISIB WITH LIBERTY AND JUSTICE FOR AL. >> THANK YOU, VICE MAYOR. MR. CITY CLERK, IF YOU COULD TAKE THE ROLL CALL. >> COUNCILMEMBER LIU, HERE. COUNCILMEMBER SHAO IS ABSENT. COUNCILMEMBER KIM BERLIN, HERE. SAL SAL THERE ARE VACANCIES ON BOARDS AND COMMISSIONS. THE CITY CLERK'S OFFICE ACCEPTS APPLICATIONS THROUGHOUT THE YEAR. IF YOU'RE INTERESTED IN APPLYING PLEASE GO TO FREET.GOV AND VISIT THE BOARDS, COMMISSIONS AND COMMITTEES PAGE OR PLEASE CONTACT THE CITY CLERK'S OFFICE. EMAILS SUBMITTED TO THE CITY CLERK ARE COMPILED, DISTRIBUTED TO THE CITY COUNCIL AND PUBLISHED ON THE CITY'S AGENDA CENTER. AND THEY WILL BE PLACED ON FILE AND CONSIDERED PART OF THE PUBLIC RECORD. I WOULD LIKE TO ANNOUNCE THIS MEETING MAY GO ON UNTIL 11:30 P.M. THIS EVENING IF NECESSARY. WE WILL ALLOW FOR 30 MINUTES FOR ORAL COMMUNICATIONS IF THERE ARE ADDITIONAL SPEAKERS FOR ORAL COMMUNICATIONS AFTER THE INITIAL 30 MINUTES, WE WILL TAKE THOSE SPEAKERS AT THE END OF THE MEETING IF TIME REMAINS. LY NOW TURN THE MEETING OVER TO OUR CITY MANAGER FOR COMMENTS AND INTRODUCTIONS. >> GOOD EVENING TO YOU, GOOD EVENING TO MEMBERS OF THE COUNCIL. GOOD TO SEE YOU ALL THIS EVENING. ACROSS FROM THE TWO OF US WE HAVE OUR ASSISTANT CITY CLERK, DINA LEWIS, AND OUR CITY CLERK, ALBERTO QUINTANILLA. NO ANNOUNCEMENTS THIS EVENING SO I'LL TURN IT BACK OVER TO YOU, MR. MAYOR. >> Mayor Salwan: OKAY, THANK YOU. SO NEXT WE HAVE THE CONSENT CALENDAR. THE CONSENT CALENDAR WILL BE PASSED WITH ONE COUNCIL VOTE AND STAFF RECOMMENDATION WILL STAND. DOES ANY MEMBER OF THE CITY COUNCIL WISH TO REMOVE AN ITEM FROM CONSENT? VICE MAYOR ZHANG? >> Vice Mayor Zhang: I WOULD LIKE TO REMOVE 2D AND 2H FROM THE CONSENT CALENDAR. >> Mayor Salwan: MOVE 2D AND 2H. COUNCILMEMBER CAMPBELL. >> Councilmember Campbell: THANK YOU, MAYOR. I WAS GOING TO REQUEST THE SAME TWO ITEMS, PLEASE. >> Mayor Salwan: OKAY. DO WE HAVE ANY SPEAKERS FOR ANY ITEMS? >> Mr. Quintanilla: WE DO HAVE ONE FOR 2H. >> Mayor Salwan: COULD I GET A MOTION TO MOVE CONSENT WITH 2D AND 2H REMOVED. COUNCILMEMBER KIMBERLIN, MOVED BY COUNCILMEMBER KIMBERLIN, SECONDED BY COUNCILMEMBER CAMPBELL. PLEASE VOTE. >> Mayor Salwan: MOTION PASSES, SIX AYES, ONE ABSENT. OKAY. NEXT WE HAVE CEREMONIAL ITEM. WE HAVE KHLOE HALE WITH HER MOTHER, MS. TIFFANY HALE. PLEASE JOIN ME AT THE PODIUM AND I'LL BE RIGHT THERE. SHE'S A BIG GIRL NOW. SO WE HAVE THIS PROCLAMATION FOR CONGENITAL HEART DEFECT AWARENESS WEEK, WHICH IS FEBRUARY 7 TO 14, 2026. WHEREAS, THE HEALTH AND WELL-BEING OF ALL CHILDREN IN THE CITY OF FREMONT ARE OF PARAMOUNT IMPORTANCE TO OUR FAMILIES, NEIGHBORHOODS, AND COMMUNITY AS A WHOLE; AND WHEREAS, THOUSANDS OF CHILDREN ARE BORN EACH YEAR WITH BIRTH DEFECTS, INCLUDING APPROXIMATEL 40,000 CHILDREN IN THE UNITED STATES—NEARLY ONE IN EVERY 100—WHO BEGIN LIFE WITH ONE OF MORE THAN THIRTY- FIVE IDENTIFIED FORMS OF CONGENITAL HEART DEFECTS; AND WHEREAS, CONGENITAL HEART DEFECTS ARE AMONG THE MOST COMMON AND SERIOUS BIRTH DEFECTS, AND MAY BE LIFE-THREATENING DUE TO THEIR COMPLEXITY, THE LIMITATIONS OF CURRENT MEDICAL INTERVENTIONS, AND THE SCARCITY OF AVAILABLE I DONOR HEARTS; AND WHEREAS, ADVANCES IN MEDICAL RESEARCH AND CLINICAL PRACTICE HAVE LED TO I IDENTIFICATION OF THE ORIGINS AND SYMPTOMS OF CONGENITAL HEAR DEFECTS, AS WELL AS A CONTINUALLY EXPANDING RANGE OF SURGICAL AND TREATMENT OPTIONS MADE POSSIBLE THROUGH THE DEDICATED EFFORTS OF PHYSICIANS SURGEONS, SCIENTISTS, AND HEALTHCARE PROFESSIONALS; AND WHEREAS, SIGNIFICANT WORK REMAINS TO BETTER UNDERSTAND TH CAUSES OF CONGENITAL HEART DEFECTS AND TO DEVELOP EFFECTIV TREATMENTS, AND IT IS CRITICAL THAT PARENTS, CAREGIVERS, PEDIATRICIANS, AND NURSES RECOGNIZE EARLY WARNING SIGNS I NEWBORNS TO ENSURE TIMELY DIAGNOSIS AND CARE; AND WHEREAS, MANY FAMILIES WITHIN THE CITY OF FREMONT ARE DIRECTLY OR INDIRECTLY IMPACTED BY CONGENITAL HEART DEFECTS, AND THE COMMUNITY JOINS IN RECOGNIZING AND COMMENDING THE ONGOING EFFORTS OF MEDICAL PROFESSIONALS AND RESEARCHERS WHO STRIVE TO SAVE LIVES AND IMPROVE HEALTH OUTCOMES FOR CHI AND FAMILIES EVERYWHERE, AND FURTHER ACKNOWLEDGES THE MEANINGFUL ADVOCACY OF YOUNG PEOPLE LIVING WITH CONGENITAL HEART DEFECTS WHOSE VOICES, RESILIENCE, AND LEADERSHIP HELP RAISE AWARENESS, FOSTER UNDERSTANDING AND INSPIRE COMPASSION THROUGHOUT THE COMMU NOW, THEREFORE, THE CITY COUNCI OF THE CITY OF FREMONT HEREBY R FEBRUARY 7-14, 2026 AS CONGENITAL HEART DEFECT AWARENESS WEEK AND CALLS UPON ALL RESIDENTS TO OBSERVE THIS WEEK BY INCREASING AWARENESS, SUPPORTING AFFECTED FAMILIES, AND HONORING THE DEDICATED PROF WORKING TO ADVANCE PREVENTION, TREATMENT, AND CARE. SO WITH THAT, I'LL PRESENT THIS TO KHLOE. AND I'LL INVITE KHLOE TO SAY A FEW WORDS. OH, PICTURE. OKAY. HOW MANY YEARS HAVE YOU BEEN DOING THIS NOW? I'VE BEEN SEEING YOU SINCE YOU WERE SO SMALL. DO YOU REMEMBER? >> 6. >> Mayor Salwan: SIX YEARS! ALL RIGHT. TO YOU. >> HI. MY NAME IS KHLOE HALE. I AM 13 YEARS OLD. I WAS DIAGNOSED WITH A CONGENITAL HEART DEFECT ALSO CALLED A CHD AT 8 DAYS OLD. THE SHORT NAME IS TABVR. TOTAL ANOMALOUS PULMONARY VENOUS RETURN. IF THAT SOUNDS SCARY AND CONFUSING TO YOU, IMAGINE HOW IT SOUNDS AND FEELS TO ME. SPREADING AWARENESS LIKE I AM IS VERY IMPORTANT BECAUSE OF PEOPLE WHO ARE EDUCATED ON IT, KINDNESS WILL SPREAD, AND MORE PEOPLE WILL BECOME INVOLVED. OVER THE YEARS, I HAVE HAD OPPORTUNITIES TO SPREAD AWARENESS SUCH AS SHARING INFORMATION AT MY SCHOOL, CITY COUNCIL MEETINGS AND I HELP MY MOM PLAN A BIG FUN RUN TO RAISE MONEY FOR MENDING LITTLE HEARTS FOR YEARS. I HAVE ALSO TEAMED UP WITH THE ELKS LODGE TO CREATE BRAVERY BAGS FOR THE CARDIAC UNIT AT STANFORD AND UCSF, AND I SPOKE AT A LARGE GOLF TOURNAMENT FUNDRAISER. CONGENITAL HEART DEFECTS ARE THE MOST COMMON BIRTH DEFECT IN THE WORLD. 1 IN 110 PEOPLE ARE BORN WITH A CHD. THIS MEANS THAT APPROXIMATELY 1 MILLION TO 1.4 MILLION BABIES ARE BORN WITH A CHD EVERY YEAR ALL AROUND THE WORLD. WHEN A BABY IS BORN, THEIR HEART IS THE SIZE OF A WALNUT. ABOUT 25% OF BABIES BORN WITH A CHD ARE CONSIDERED CRITICAL AND REQUIRE A LIFE SAVING SURGERY BETWEEN BIRTH AND THEIR FIRST BIRTHDAY. I WAS ONLY 2 MONTHS OLD AND MY FRIEND WAS 2 MONTHS OLD WHEN WE HAD OUR SURGERY. MY NEW BABY COUSIN WAS ONLY 3 DAYS OLD FOR HIS SURGERY. THIS IS BECAUSE WE WERE BORN WITH DIFFERENT HEART DEFECTS BUT THEY WERE ALL CONSIDERED CRITICAL. ABOUT 85 TO 90% OF HEART DEFECTS HAPPEN WITHOUT A KNOWN REASON. SOME WILL NOT LIVE TO CELEBRATE THEIR FIRST BIRTHDAY. CHD IS USUALLY DIAGNOSED IN NEWBORNS, BUT MAY GO UNDETECTED AND NOT DIAGNOSED UNTIL LATER IN LIFE. EACH YEAR, 200 OR 300 NEWBORNS ARE RELEASED FROM THE HOSPITAL UNDIAGNOSED. THE DOCTORS DO NOT EVEN REALIZE I HAD A HEART DEFECT WHEN I WAS FIRST BORN. MY MOM WAS THE ONE WHO KNEW SOMETHING WAS WRONG AND DID NOT GIVE UP UNTIL SHE HAD ANSWERS. THIS IS WHY I WAS 8 DAYS OLD ONLY BEFORE BEING DIAGNOSED. MY NEW BABY C COUSIN WAS BORN IN JULY AND HIS CHD WAS DIAGNOSED WHEN MY AUNTIE WAS PREGNANT. I WAS SO -- WHEN I HEARD BUT I KNEW HE WAS GOING TO BE OKAY. OUR CHDs ARE NOT HEREDITARY AND ARE DIFFERENT. THIS IS WHY RESEARCH AND UPDATES TO TESTING IS SO IMPORTANT AND REALLY DOES SAVE LIVES. I AM VERY PROUD TO RECEIVE A PROCLAMATION FOR THIS WEEK. THANK YOU, MAYOR SALWAN, FOR CONTINUING TO SUPPORT ME AND CHD. I HOPE YOU ALL LEARNED SOMETHING NEW. THANK YOU FOR SUPPORTING CONGENITAL HEART DEFECT AWARENESS WITH ME. WE ARE BOTH 1 IN 110. WE ARE HEART WARRIORS. >> Mayor Salwan: THANK YOU VERY MUCH. WE'LL MOVE ON TO ORAL COMMUNICATIONS. THIS IS AN OPPORTUNITY FOR THE PUBLIC TO SPEAK TO THE CITY COUNCIL ON ANY ISSUE THAT IS NOT ON THE AGENDA. THE COUNCIL CANNOT TAKE ACTION, NOR RESPOND TO ITEMS THAT ARE BROUGHT UP UNDER ORAL COMMUNICATION COMMENT PERIOD. HOWEVER, THE ITEM COULD BE AGENDIZED FOR A FUTURE MEETING IF A COUNCIL MAKES REFERRAL TO STAFF FOR A REPORT BACK. WHEN SPEAKING ON BEHALF OF AN ORGANIZATION, STATE YOUR NAME OF THE ORGANIZATION THAT YOU ARE REPRESENTING. A BELL WILL RING WHEN 30 SECONDS REMAIN FOR YOU TO SUM UP YOUR COMMENTS. AND THE BELL WILL RING AGAIN WHEN THE TIME HAS ENDED. THE CITY CLARK WILL START THE TIMER FOR EACH SPEAKER. HOW MANY SPEAKERS DO WE HAVE? >> Mr. Quintanilla: WE HAVE TWO SPEAKERS. >> Mayor Salwan: FOR ORAL COMMUNICATIONS? >> Mr. Quintanilla: YES. >> Mayor Salwan: 2 MINUTES EACH. >> Mr. Quintanilla: OUR FIRST SPEAKER IS AL MINARD. >> Mayor Salwan: SIR, WE CAN'T HEAR YOU. IS IT GREEN? >> THANK YOU. GOOD EVENING, MAYOR AND CITY COUNCIL. IT'S A PLEASURE TO BE HERE ALMOST. I AM HERE BECAUSE OF THE PERRY HOUSE ON OLIVE AVENUE WAS HEARD TWICE BY THE PLANNING COMMISSION AND HAS VOTED BOTH TIMES TO DEMOLISH THE HOUSE AND PUT ADUs ON THE DOUBLE LOT. THIS HOUSE HAS NEVER BEEN -- ALTHOUGH IT'S OVER A HUNDRED YEARS OLD, BUILT BY A DISTINGUISHED FAMILY WITH A DISTINGUISHED ARCHITECT, H.A. MAT SON THAT HAD DEEP ROOTS IN THE COMMUNITY, THIS HOUSE HAS NEVER BEEN REVIEWED BY HARB, THE HISTORICAL ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW BOARD, BECAUSE SOMEONE ON THE STAFF I THINK CONSIDERED IT NOT LEGALLY HISTORIC. THIS HOUSE IS OVER A HUNDRED YEARS OLD, AND THE ONLY MODIFICATION UNDER 50 YEARS WAS CHANGING FROM WOOD SASH WINDOWS TO VINYL WINDOWS. AND I'M NOT COMPLAINING ABOUT THE STAFF OR PLANNING COMMISSION OR ANYBODY. I'M BLAMING ALL OF THE CITY COUNCIL, BECAUSE THE CITY COUNCIL APPROVES THE HIRING OF EVERYONE, APPROVES THE APPOINTMENTS OF EVERYONE TO COUNCILS AND COMMISSIONS, AND GIVES THEM DIRECTION OF WHAT THEY WANT TO DO. I THINK IT'S IMPORTANT THAT THE CITY STAFF MAKE SURE THAT HISTORIC BUILDINGS ARE REFERRED TO THE HARB BOARD FOR REVIEW BEFORE THEY GET DEMOLISHED. CITY OF FREMONT HAS CLOSED ABOUT 90 SQUARE MILES OF REAL ESTATE AND IN MY OPINION, IT IS THE MOST SIGNIFICANT SECTION OF 90 SQUARE MILES OF REAL ESTATE IN ANY COUNTY AND PROBABLY IN THE ENTIRE STATE, AND YET WE ARE DEMOLISHING IT, AND ONE OF THE THINGS THAT'S A HISTORICAL DRAW FOR BUILDINGS AND S CITIES AND HOUSES IS HISTORICAL TOURISM AND WE ARE SHOOTING OURSELF IN THE FOOT AS A CITY NOT TO PROMOTE AND PROVIDE ACCESS FOR HISTORICAL TOURISM. THANK YOU. >> Mayor Salwan: THANK YOU. >> Mr. Quintanilla: OUR NEXT SPEAKER IS AMIN SH AMSIN FOLLOWED BY KRISTEN. >> GOOD EVENING. I CAME LAST YEAR FOR THE SAME SUBJECT WITH THE FIRE HAZARD IN THE FIELD THAT CONNECTS CURTIS WITH OMAR STREET. THIS YEAR, NOW TWO TIMES, THE FIRES OCCURRED. BECAUSE THE VEGETATION IS HIGH, AND YOU CAN'T SEE WHAT HAPPENED, THERE'S HOMELESS INSIDE THE VEGETATION, YOU CAN'T SEE THEM. SO WE SEE THE SMOKE TWO TIMES, WE CALL THE FIRE TO COME TO EXTINGUISH THAT FIRE. SO AS WE HAVE NOWADAYS MORE HOMELESS, WE NEED TO DO SOLUTION. THIS VEGETATION, LAST YEAR IT SUPPOSED TO BE BREAK THE CYCLE OF THIS VEGETATION. YOU CUT THEM BEFORE THEY START MAKING SEEDS. THEN NEXT YEAR IT WILL NOT GROW BECAUSE THERE IS NO SEED THERE IN THE GROUND. SO WE NEED TO DO SOLUTION, IT'S A FIRE HAZARD NOW. THAT'S IT. >> Mayor Salwan: THANK YOU. WE CAN'T TALK ABOUT THE COMMENTS BUT YOU CAN EMAIL US OR GIVE THE INFORMATION TO ONE OF THE STAFF MEMBERS. THANK YOU, SIR. >> ALL RIGHT. THANKS. >> Mr. Quintanilla: OUR LAST SPEAKER CARD FOR THIS ITEM IS KRISTEN. >> THAT'S ME, BUT ANOTHER LADY SAID SHE FILLED OUT ONE AND I DON'T KNOW WHAT HAPPENED TO HER CARD SO PLEASE RESET MY CLOCK. PLEASE. HELLO, RESETTING OF CLOCK? OKAY. I'LL JUST TAKE AN EXTRA 10 SECONDS. I AGREE WITH THIS MAN RIGHT HERE. I CAME BACK AND FOUND OUT THAT THE CHARLIE CHAPLAIN MUSEUM OR HIS BUILDING, HIS STUDIO WAS GONE AND I'M ACTUALLY A MEMBER OF THE COMMUNITY OF ACTORS AND I WAS DEVASTATED. SO THANK YOU, SIR, FOR BRINGING THAT UP ABOUT HISTORICAL THINGS. ALSO THIS GUY MENTIONING THE HOMELESS PEOPLE, IT'S OUT OF CONTROL. THE HOMELESSNESS IS OUT OF CONTROL AND THEY ARE STEALING -- I WATCHED SOME PEOPLE STEAL TODAY, AND THE CVS PEOPLE HAD TO JUST WATCH THEM WALK OUT. SO IF YOU COULD JUST PLEASE GET THAT UNDER CONTROL. THEN THE OTHER THING THAT I WANT TO SAY IS THE TRASH. THERE IS TRASH EVERYWHERE. WHEN I GREW UP, I WAS BORN AT WASHINGTON HOSPITAL, I LIVED HERE MOST OF MY LIFE UNLESS I WAS OUT OF THE COUNTRY LIVING, BUT WHEN I CAME BACK, TRASH EVERYWHERE. COULD YOU PLEASE HIRE PEOPLE TO GO AND PICK UP THE TRASH OR DO WHAT WE USED TO DO, AND ANY KID IN JUVENILE HALL OR ANY PERSON IN THE COUNTY JAIL WILL BE PUT IN AN ORANGE VEST AND THEY WERE MEANT TO PICK UP THE TRASH. SO IF WE COULD GET THAT GOING BACK, THAT WOULD BE GREAT. AND ESPECIALLY ON THE FREEWAYS WHEN YOU'RE COMING ON TO THE FREEWAY, JUST TO THE SIDE, TRASH EVERYWHERE. WE ARE NOT A THIRD WORLD COUNTRY. THANK YOU. >> Mayor Salwan: THANK YOU. DO WE HAVE ANOTHER SPEAKER OR NOR? >> Mr. Quintanilla: NO ADDITIONAL SPEAKERS. >> Mayor Salwan: SO WITH THAT, WE WILL CLOSE THE ORAL COMMUNICATION COMMENT PERIOD. WE WILL GO TO ITEMS THAT WERE REMOVED FROM CONSENT STARTING WITH ITEM 2D. DO WE HAVE STAFF ON THOSE? SO I GUESS WE HAD VICE MAYOR ZHANG, IF YOU HAVE QUESTIONS, COMMENTS, AND THEN WE HAVE COUNCILMEMBER CAMPBELL AS WELL. I'M GOING TO CLEAR THE REQUESTS TO SPEAK AND IF THERE'S ANYBODY ELSE THAT WANTS TO ASK ANYTHING, HIT IT NOW. >> Vice Mayor Zhang: MY QUESTION IS, I HAVE RECEIVED A COMMENT FROM A COMMUNITY MEMBER, AND HE HAS SOME QUESTIONS. I THINK THAT I HAVE SIMILAR QUESTIONS, SO I WOULD LIKE THE STAFF TO RESPOND. BASICALLY ONE OF THE QUESTIONS IS, THERE ARE 13 APPLICANTS FOR THE LANDSCAPE ARCHITECT STUDIOS, AND THE STAFF HAVE INTERVIEWED THREE, AND THEN WE SELECT THREE. SO WHAT'S THE REASON WE HAVE NOT INTERVIEWED OTHER LANDSCAPE COMPANIES AND WHAT'S THE REASON? AND I THINK THERE WAS QUITE A FEW. WHETHER OUR SUPERVISION ON THE RESULT AND LOOKS LIKE WE HAVE NOT GONE INTO MEETINGS FOR THE PAST THREE MONTHS, AND DO WE HAVE ENOUGH SUPERVISION ON THOSE KIND OF A JOB? AND ALSO BASICALLY IT'S JUST TRANSPARENCY AND ACCOUNTABILITY OF THE BUDGET AND HOW WE SELECT THOSE COMPANIES. AND SAME QUESTION AS THE PERSON HAS ASKED. >> Mayor Salwan: OKAY. DID STAFF GET THE TOPICS? OKAY. >> GOOD EVENING, COUNCIL. MY NAME IS TARA, PARKS, PLANNING AND DESIGN MANAGER FOR THE CITY OF FREMONT. THANK YOU FOR YOUR QUESTION. I CAN RESPOND TO THE ONE ABOUT THE INTERVIEWS. WE HAD 18 LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURAL FIRMS SUBMIT PROPOSALS, AND THE FIRST ROUND OF SELECTION, WE LOOKED AT MULTIPLE QUALIFICATIONS, AND AFTER THE FIRST ROUND, WE DID A SPREADSHEET TAP LAITI TABULATION AND THE TOP THREE FIRMS WERE SELECTED TO SHORTLIST. AS PER OUR RFP THAT WAS PUBLISHED. STAFF HAD INTENDED TO AWARD AT LEAST THREE CONTRACTS, AND AFTER THOSE FIRST THREE, THERE WAS A BIT OF A GAP. AND THEN THE REST OF THE -- THEN THERE WERE THE REST OF THE 14 OTHER FIRMS. SO WE DECIDED TO INTERVIEW THE TOP THREE, AND THEY CHECKED ALL THE BOXES DURING THE INTERVIEW, AND WE DECIDED TO AWARD THOSE FIRMS. >> Vice Mayor Zhang: THANK YOU. SO MY FOLLOW-UP QUESTION IS, HAVE WE USED THEM IN THE PAST? ARE THEY THE SAME THREE WE HAVE USED BEFORE? >> I BELIEVE THAT PREVIOUSLY, WE HAVE USED TWO OF THEM. HOWEVER, THROUGH A DIFFERENT DEPARTMENT. I BELIEVE THAT PLANNING, NOT THROUGH THE COMMUNITY SERVICES DEPARTMENT, BUT I BELIEVE THE PLANNING DEPARTMENT PREVIOUSLY HAD CONTRACTED WITH THEM TO DO PLAN REVIEWS. >> Vice Mayor Zhang: CAN YOU ADDRESS THE ACCOUNTABILITY AND EVALUATING OF THEIR WORK AND ALSO THE PRICING? YOU KNOW, ANNUALLY? BECAUSE THIS IS A FIVE-YEAR PROJECT, RIGHT? >> WELL, SO WHAT WE'RE LOOKING FOR IS ON-CALL CONTRACTS. AND EVEN THOUGH THE AMOUNT MAY LOOK LARGE, $1.25 MILLION PER CONTRACT IS PRETTY TYPICAL FOR OUR ON-CALL DESIGN SERVICES CONTRACT FOR THE CITY. IT DOES NOT MEAN THAT THE CITY INTENDS TO AWARD UP TO THE MAXIMUM. IN FACT, IT'S PRETTY UNUSUAL THAT THE CITY WOULD AWARD TO THE MAXIMUM. IT'S JUST -- IT JUST ALLOWS FOR THAT AMOUNT TO BE AVAILABLE, AND EACH SCOPE OF WORK IS AWARDED PER TASK ORDER. SO EACH SCOPE OF WORK IS DEFINED, AND THEN AWARDED PER SCOPE. >> JUST TO ADD ON TO WHAT TARA IS SAYING, THIS IS PRETTY TYPICAL. WE DO THIS WITH MECHANICAL, PLUMBING, ELECTRICAL DESIGNS, GEOTECHNICAL, ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES. THESE ARE JUST ON-CALL CONSULTANTS THAT THE CITY USES WHEN WE'RE DOING PROJECTS AND TRYING TO DELIVER SERVICES AND GET THOSE PROJECTS OVER THE GOAL LINE. THEY'RE MANAGED WITH A -- IT'S VERY MUCH OUTLINED WHAT SERVICES THEY'RE GOING TO DELIVER, WHAT THE EXPECTATIONS ARE, AND THE COST THAT THEY WILL BE PAID FOR THEIR SERVICES. AND THEN WE ISSUE THEM A TASK ORDER THAT ONCE THEY COMPLETE THOSE SERVICES, THEY SEND IT BACK AND THAT'S HOW THEIR PAYMENT IS ISSUED. SO IT'S ALL CONTROLLED BY STAFF, IT IS NOT JUST KIND OF SAT OUT THERE, TO CLARIFY. THIS ISN'T SOMETHING THAT BOTH PUBLIC WORKS, PLANNING AND COMMUNITY SERVICES USE AND MAINTENANCE ON A REGULAR BASIS. >> Vice Mayor Zhang: THANK YOU. I HAVE REALIZED WE HAVE A SIMILAR CONTRACT JUST LIKE PUBLIC WORKS AND ET CETERA, BUT I THINK SINCE THE PUBLIC ASKED THIS QUESTION SO I WANTED TO DISCUSS PUBLICLY SO THAT WE CAN GIVE THEM THE ANSWER AND MAYBE SOME OTHER MEMBERS WOULD HAVE SIMILAR WE CANS, BUT THANK YOU. >> SURE. AND TO ANSWER THE REST OF YOUR QUESTIONS, I'LL TAKE THOSE, VICE MAYOR ZHANG. SO ON THE RECREATION COMMISSION IT IS TRUE WE DID CANCEL DECEMBER, JANUARY AND FEBRUARY. DECEMBER AND JANUARY AS WE KNOW ARE HOLIDAY MONTHS AND WE DIDN'T HAVE ANY ACTION ITEMS. WE WERE FULLY INTENDING TO DO A FEBRUARY MEETING AND THEN SOME OF THE ITEMS CHANGED SO WE ARE ALREADY PLANNING FOR A MARCH MEETING AND AN APRIL MEETING. APRIL WILL BE WHEN OUR PALM AVENUE PROJECT IS COMING FORWARD. SO IT'S JUST A MATTER OF PREFERENCE. I'M NOT SOMEONE WHO LIKES TO REALLY CALL A MEETING IF I DON'T HAVE SOMETHING SPECIFIC TO TALK ABOUT. SO WE HAVE A FULL SET OF MEETINGS MOVING FORWARD, BUT WE DIDN'T SCHEDULE THOSE MEETINGS AND WENT AHEAD AND CANCELED THEM. SO THAT'S ON THAT ITEM. AS FAR AS THE TRANSPARENCY OF THE BUDGET, ALL OF THE ITEMS THAT WOULD GO THROUGH THESE MASTER SERVICE AGREEMENTS THAT WE'RE TALKING ABOUT HAVE ALL ALREADY BEEN VETTED AND APPROVED AND RECOMMENDED BY THE RECREATION COMMISSION THROUGH THE CAPITAL IMPROVEMENT PROGRAM, AND THEN GONE TO ALL OF YOU FOR APPROVAL. SO THESE ARE -- THAT CAN WORK ON WHETHER IT'S DUSTERBERRY PARK OR PAM AVENUE PARK OR DO SPECIFIC AREAS OF LANDSCAPE SERVICES. AND WE UTILIZE THESE CONSULTANTS SO WE CAN BOTH MAXIMIZE WHEN WE HAVE STAFFING ADJUSTMENT. LET'S SAY WE HAVE A RETIREMENT OR SOMETHING CHANGES, WE DON'T WANT TO STOP A PROJECT, THEN HAVE TO GO OUT, FIND A CONSULTANT, COME BACK, THAT WOULD REALLY SLOW OUR PROJECT DOWN. OR IF WE HAVE -- RIGHT NOW WE HAVE A LOT OF PROJECTS GOING ON AND WE ALSO DON'T WANT TO GO OUT AND HIRE A BUNCH OF STAFF TO DO WORK THAT THEN EVENTUALLY IS GOING TO GO AWAY. AS WE KNOW, IMPACT FEES HAVE DECLINED AND SO WE HAVE A LOT OF PROJECTS WE'RE TRYING TO DELIVER ON AND TO MAKE SURE THAT WE CAN GET THESE GREAT COMMUNITY PROJECTS OVER THE GOAL LINE, BUT YOU KNOW, WE HAVE LIMITATIONS BASED ON THE NUMBER OF STAFF AND THESE ALLOW US BOTH TO EXPAND THE AMOUNT OF WORK WE'RE ABLE TO DO BUT ALSO THERE'S MANY THINGS THAT STAFF DON'T NECESSARILY HAVE THE QUALIFICATIONS OR THE EXPERTISE IN, SO WE CAN PICK FROM THESE CONSULTANTS, YOU KNOW, AN EXAMPLE WOULD BE MAYBE SPORTS FIELDS AND DESIGN OF SPORTS FIELDS, THAT'S A VERY SPECIFIC AREA OF EXPERTISE THAT WOULD ALLOW US TO CONSULT WITH SOMEONE TO BE ABLE TO DELIVER AND GET THAT PROJECT OVER THE GOAL LINE. >> Vice Mayor Zhang: ALL RIGHT. THANK YOU VERY MUCH. >> Mayor Salwan: COUNCILMEMBER CAMPBELL. >> Councilmember Campbell: THANK YOU. I HAD SIMILAR QUESTIONS, BUT I WANTED TO ASK A COUPLE QUESTIONS. ONE, I HEARD YOU INDICATE THAT THE COMMISSION HAD ALREADY VETTED THESE PARTICULAR CONSULTANTS. DO THEY ALWAYS HAVE TO WEIGH IN OR IS THAT TYPICAL TO HAVE THE ADVISORY BODY WEIGH IN AND THEN -- BECAUSE IT WASN'T IN THE STAFF REPORT, THAT THEY HAD WEIGHED IN. >> SO TO CLARIFY, NO, THE RECREATION COMMISSION DID NOT LOOK AT THE CONSULTANTS. THEY APPROVED THE PROJECTS THAT THE CONSULTANTS WOULD THEN BE WORKING ON AND THAT WE WOULD ISSUE TASK ORDERS FOR THEM TO DO SPECIFIC PROJECTS RELATED TO THOSE APPROVED PROJECTS THAT THEY ALREADY RECOMMENDED TO YOU AND YOU ULTIMATELY APPROVED. SO THAT MONEY IS ALREADY INCLUDED IN THAT BUDGET FOR THAT PARTICULAR PROJECT. >> Councilmember Campbell: SO JUST TO CLARIFY, THE COMMISSION, THE RECREATION COMMISSION TYPICALLY DOES NOT WEIGH IN ON CONTRACT THAT YOU -- CONSULTANTS THAT YOU'VE AWARDED CONTRACTS FOR? >> CORRECT. >> Councilmember Campbell: OKAY. SO IS IT ALSO TYPICAL THAT ONLY THREE STAFF MEMBERS WOULD WEIGH IN ON THE 18 APPLICATIONS THAT WERE SUBMITTED? >> THAT IS CORRECT AS WELL. >> Councilmember Campbell: THERE'S JUST THREE STAFF FROM YOUR STAFF THAT WOULD DO THAT? >> IT DEPENDS. SOMETIMES IT'S FROM A DIFFERENT DEPARTMENT, BUT USUALLY THREE IS ABOUT -- FOR A NON-SERVICE CONTRACT. FOR A LARGER PROJECT WHEN WE DID THE CENTRAL PARK COMMUNITY CENTER WE HAD A LARGER GROUP OF US WHO WEIGHED IN WITH DIFFERENT EXPERIENCE AND EXPERTISE BECAUSE YOU ARE AWARDING SPECIFICALLY TO THAT PROJECT. BUT FOR AN ON-SERVICE ON-CALL, THAT'S A PRETTY TYPICAL NUMBER WHEN I ACTUALLY PULLED IN RESPONSE TO LOOKING AT THIS SOME OF THE OTHER SERVICE AGREEMENTS THAT WE'VE DONE OVER THE LAST FEW YEARS AND BOTH THE AMOUNT AND AMOUNT OF REVIEWERS WAS ALL FAIRLY CONSISTENT. >> Councilmember Campbell: OKAY. AND WHAT IS IT THAT THESE THREE CONSULTANTS -- WHAT DIFFERENTIATES THEM FROM EACH OTHER? DO THEY ALL DO THE SAME THING? WILL YOU GET A DIFFERENT SET OF EXPERTISE FROM EACH OF THEM? WHEN YOU START TO LOOK AT YOUR POOL, OR ARE YOU JUST HAVING ALL THREE PROVIDE THE SAME LEVEL OF SERVICES? >> I CAN TAKE THAT QUESTION, COUNCILMEMBER. SO WE LOOK AT A FEW DIFFERENT THINGS. ALL THREE OF THE FIRMS WORK REALLY WELL WITH PUBLIC AGENCIES. WE FOUND THAT AS A COMMONALITY AND SOMETHING THAT'S VERY ATTRACTIVE TO US, BECAUSE THERE'S LESS OF A LEARNING CURVE. THEY KNOW WHAT WE NEED, AND THERE'S A LOT OF EFFICIENCY THERE. EACH FIRM WILL ALSO HAVE DIFFERENT CAPACITIES AT DIFFERENT TIMES. SO IF ONE FIRM IS BUSY, WE CAN ALWAYS PULL FROM A DIFFERENT FIRM. THEY ALSO HAVE DIFFERENT SUBCONSULTANTS, THEY ALSO HAVE DIFFERENT EXPERTISE. SO WE'RE ABLE TO PULL AND CAPITALIZE ON AN EXPERTISE OF ONE FIRM VERSUS ANOTHER. >> Councilmember Campbell: I SEE. OKAY. AND THEN SINCE THE AWARD IS 1.25 FOR ALL THREE, IT'S ANTICIPATED OVER THE FIVE YEARS, IF MY MATH IS CORRECT, IT'S GOING TO BE 3.75 OVER THE FIVE YEARS, ASSUMING WE AWARD EACH ONE OF THEM THE 1.25, CORRECT? >> IN THEORY, CORRECT, BUT KEEP IN MIND, THESE ARE DONE BY TASK ORDERS. SO WE DO THIS FOR TREES, WE DO THIS FOR A LOT OF THINGS. SO ONE CONSULTANT BASED ON THEIR AVAILABILITY, EXPERTISE, TIMING OF THE PROJECT, ONE MAY GET 50,000 IN WORK, ONE MIGHT GET 400,000 IN WORK AND ONE MIGHT GET A DIFFERENT AMOUNT. SO THERE'S NOTHING THAT SAYS THAT THEY HAVE TO GO TO THAT AMOUNT. THERE'S NOTHING -- THEY CAN DO $0. WE DON'T EVEN HAVE TO AWARD THEM ANYTHING. SO JUST TO MAKE SURE WE'RE CLEAR ON THAT. >> Councilmember Campbell: JUST ONE OTHER QUICK QUESTION. I HEARD YOU SAY THAT THERE WAS A FIRST ROUND OF THE SELECTION PROCESS, SO YOU WEEDED OUT AND YOU CAME OUT WITH, I DON'T KNOW, WHAT, 12 OR 13 LEFT? AND THEN YOU DID A SECOND ROUND? >> THERE WAS ONE ROUND. 18 REVIEWED. TO CLARIFY, THESE ARE USUALLY EXTENSIVE PROPOSALS, VERY TIME-CONSUMING. STAFF GOES THROUGH AND VETS THEM. THERE WAS DEFINITELY FROM THE REVIEW PANEL THREE TOP CONSULTANTS, WHICH WE WERE INTENDED TO REVIEW TOO. SO THEY BROUGHT THEM BACK FOR AN INITIAL MEETING AND THEN AWARD OF THOSE PARTICULAR THREE CONSULTANTS BASED ON THEIR EXPERTISE, THEIR AVAILABILITY, THEIR PRIOR EXPERIENCE, ALL OF THOSE THINGS. >> Councilmember Campbell: THOSE THINGS THAT WERE INDICATED HERE. >> AND MAKING SURE THAT THE BILLING RATE WAS REASONABLE AND EXPECTED FOR THE WORK THAT THEY'RE PROVIDING. >> Councilmember Campbell: THE BILLING RATES OF COURSE WOULD BE VERY IMPORTANT. AND THEN WERE THESE THE SAME THREE STAFF THAT WEEDED OUT ALL 18 WHO DID THE FINAL SELECTION? >> THEY WERE. >> Councilmember Campbell: THEY WERE? OKAY, GREAT. I WAS JUST ADDRESSING SOME OF THE QUESTIONS THAT WAS GIVEN TO US IN THIS THREE-PAGE DOCUMENT THAT ONE OF THE -- OUR CITIZENS SENT TO US TODAY, SO I THANK YOU FOR INDULGING ME WITH ALL OF MY QUESTIONS. >> Mayor Salwan: COUNCILMEMBER KIMBERLIN. >> Councilmember Kimberlin: MY QUESTION HAS BEEN ANSWERED. THANK YOU. >> Mayor Salwan: EXCELLENT. SO JUST LIKE A HIGH LEVEL QUESTION, I UNDERSTAND THE FLEXIBILITY THAT'S NEEDED WITH A LOT OF DIFFERENT PROJECTS. SO CAN YOU KIND OF LET US KNOW WHAT KIND OF THINGS YOU THINK YOU WILL NEED THESE CONSULTANTS FOR, WHAT SORT OF PROJECTS THAT WE'VE APPROVED THAT YOU'RE THINKING THAT THESE FUNDS WILL BE USED FOR? >> SO WHICH HAVE THE UPCOMING PALM AVENUE COMMUNITY PARK. WE'RE PARTWAY THROUGH THE CONCEPTUAL DESIGN. BUT THEN WE HAVE A WHOLE YEAR PLANNED FOR CREATING THE CONSTRUCTION DOCUMENTS FOR THE CONSTRUCTION OF THAT PROJECT. WE ALSO HAVE PACIFIC COMMONS PARK, THE SPORTS PARK THAT STILL NEEDS TO BE DESIGNED. THE BIRTH OF THESE PROJECTS ARE FULLY FUNDED AND WE JUST NEED TO EXPAND OUR CAPACITY TO BE ABLE TO DESIGN AND BUILD THOSE PARKS. AND THERE ARE OTHER SMALLER PARKS TOO. OR SMALLER PROJECTS, AND SOMETIMES WE JUST NEED EXTRA HELP FOR THOSE. >> Mayor Salwan: OKAY. >> JUST TO ADD TO THAT, AS WE KNOW, PALM AVENUE HAS ALREADY GONE TO PUBLIC PROCESS AND A CONSULTANT MIGHT JUST BE CONTRACTED TO DO THE CONSTRUCTION PLANS, FOR EXAMPLE. >> Mayor Salwan: GOT IT. EXCELLENT. SEEING NO FURTHER QUESTIONS, CAN I GET A MOTION? OH, ARE THERE ANY SPEAKERS ON THIS ITEM? >> Mr. Quintanilla: THERE ARE NO SPEAKERS. >> Mayor Salwan: COUNCILMEMBER KENG MOVES SECONDED BY COUNCILMEMBER LIU. PLEASE VOTE. MOTION PACE PASSES, SIX AYES, ONE ABSENT. THANK YOU. >> Mayor Salwan: THANK YOU. NEXT WE HAVE ITEM 2H THAT WAS PULLED? MAYBE WE CAN GET STAFF UP HERE TO ANSWER ANY QUESTIONS AND WE HAVE VICE MAYOR ZHANG WITH SOME QUESTIONS. >> Vice Mayor Zhang: YES. SO MY QUESTION IS INCREASED SERVICEFIDETELY BE HAPPY TO HAVT DISCUSSION WITH YOU DURING A BRIEFING OR AT SOME LATER TIME. >> Vice Mayor Zhang: OKAY. SO I WOULD LIKE THAT TO BE PRESENTED TO US WITH, YOU KNOW, THE PLANS AND STEPS TO ADDRESS THOSE ISSUES I MENTIONED. OKAY. THANK YOU. SO THAT'S MY QUESTION. >> Mayor Salwan: COUNCILMEMBER LIU. >> Councilmember Liu: SO I DON'T HAVE A QUESTION BUT I DO -- I JUST WANT TO SAY SOMETHING ON THIS TOPIC. THIS IS SOMETHING -- >> Mayor Salwan: LET'S DO QUESTIONS FIRST THEN WE'RE GOING TO HAVE SPEAKERS THEN COME BACK FOR COMMENTS IF THAT'S OKAY. >> Councilmember Liu: THAT'S FINE. >> Mayor Salwan: QUESTIONS. COUNCILMEMBER CAMPBELL. >> Councilmember Campbell: THANK YOU. I JUST WANTED TO UNDERSTAND, WITH THIS VETERINARIAN SERVICE THAT WE'RE USING, ARE THEY GOING TO DO THE TRAP AND RELEASE PROGRAM OR IS THIS JUST FOR EMERGENCIES AND THOSE KINDS OF THINGS FOR PETS? >> SO WE UTILIZE MANY DIFFERENT VETERINARIANS THAT HAVE DIFFERENT SPECIALTIES. SO WE DO HAVE TNR, TRAP, NEUTER, RELEASE APPOINTMENTS HAPPENING AT A DIFFERENT VETERINARIAN. SO THIS VETERINARIAN IS SPECIFICALLY FOR EMERGENCY SAME-DAY APPOINTMENTS THAT WE NEED RIGHT NOW BECAUSE WE DON'T HAVE VETERINARY STAFF IN THE SHELTER, AND THEY CAN ACCOMMODATE THOSE. YOU'RE WELCOME. >> Mayor Salwan: ANY OTHER QUESTIONS FROM COUNCIL? SEEING NONE, LET'S OPEN IT UP FOR SPEAKERS. HOW MANY SPEAKERS DO WE HAVE? >> Mr. Quintanilla: WE HAVE THREE SPEAKER CARDS. >> Mayor Salwan: THREE? OKAY. 2 MINUTES EACH. >> Mr. Quintanilla: OUR FIRST SPEAKER IS KATHY WILLIAMS FOLLOWED BY HILLARY DENEHEE. >> GOOD EVENING, MAYOR, VICE MAYOR AND COUNCIL MEMBERS. I APPRECIATE THE OPPORTUNITY TO TALK TO YOU. MY NAME IS KATHY WILLIAMS. AND I AM AFFILIATED WITH THE OHLONE HUMANE SOCIETY HERE IN FREMONT, CALIFORNIA. OHLONE HUMANE SOCIETY HAS BEEN IN OPERATION SINCE 1983, ASSISTING RESIDENTS. WE'VE BEEN TO MANY COUNCIL MEETINGS IN REGARDS TO GETTING HELP FOR TRAP, NEUTER AND RELEASES. I'D LIKE TO LET THE COUNCIL KNOW THAT THE PUBLIC IS VERY APPRECIATIVE WITH THE CHANGES THAT HAVE BEEN MADE AT THE SHELTER. STARTING WITH HAVING EXPANDED THE HOURS FROM THE PANDEMIC. THE WEBPAGE AND WEBSITE, THE POSTINGS ON NEXTDOOR, AND THE ONLINE ADOPTION PAPERWORK. IN REGARDS TO THE MONEYS THAT ARE IN QUESTION NOW GOING TO ABORN, I'M HOPING THAT SOME OF THIS WILL TRICKLE DOWN TO RESCUES AND TRAPPERS WITHIN OUR AREA. WHO ARE OUT THERE DOING TNR EVERY DAY OF THE WEEK. GENERALLY, ANYWHERE FROM 3:00 IN THE AFTERNOON UNTIL 5:00 IN THE MORNING. THIS IS CAUSING A LOT OF EXPENSES FOR THE RESCUES, BUT WE'RE DEFINITELY ENCOURAGED WITH THIS NEW FUNDING, AND I ENCOURAGE THE COUNCILMEMBERS TO POST IT -- SORRY -- TO PASS THE ITEM H. THANK YOU VERY MUCH FOR YOUR TIME THIS EVENING. >> Mayor Salwan: THANK YOU. >> Mr. Quintanilla: HILLARY DENEHEE FOLLOWED BY KRISTEN. >> HI. GOOD EVENING. IT'S GREAT TO ADDRESS THE COUNCIL THIS EVENING. AND THIS IS A VERY IMPORTANT TOPIC TO ME. MY NAME IS HILLARY. I AM THE DIRECTOR OF SPAY AND NEUTER FOR OHLONE HUMANE SOCIETY. I'VE BEEN A RESIDENT OF FREMONT FOR ABOUT 20 YEARS NOW. ALMOST HALF OF THAT VOLUNTEERING IN SOME CAPACITY WITH OHLONE HUMANE. WE WOULD REALLY LIKE TO SEE THIS KIND OF FUNDING BE MADE AVAILABLE. IT IS VERY MUCH NEEDED. THE SHELTER HAS -- TO RESPOND TO SOME OF THE COMMENTS THAT APPARENTLY HAVE TRICKLED DOWN, THE SHELTER HAS IMPROVED IMMENSELY WITHIN JUST EVEN THE LAST YEAR. WE ARE SEEING A LOT OF POSITIVE PROGRESS AND SYNERGY BETWEEN OUR RESCUE ORGANIZATION AND THE ANIMAL SHELTER. THE SHELTER HAS MADE THE HIRING PROCESS MORE EFFICIENT. THEY HAVE SOME GREAT STAFF THAT WE'RE WORKING WITH. THEY'VE EXPANDED HOURS OPEN TO THE PUBLIC TO INCREASE ADOPTIONS, YAY! GETTING THOSE ANIMALS INTO HOMES, AND ALSO REUNITING PETS WITH THEIR FAMILIES WHO ARE TRYING TO FIND THEIR LOST ANIMAL. AND THE MOST IMPORTANT TO ME IS, AND TO OHLONE, OHLONE HUMANE SOCIETY, IS WE NOW HAVE A PARTNERSHIP THAT FOR OUR RESCUE STARTED LAST JULY TO WORK ON THAT TRAP, NEUTER AND RETURN, THE TNR EFFORT, AND IT HAS BEEN JUST A FABULOUS EXPERIENCE TO FIX AND VACCINATE SO MANY MORE COMMUNITY CATS WITH THE HELP OF THE SHELTER. OUR TEAM, WE HAVE A TEAM OF UNPAID TNR VOLUNTEERS IN THE YEAR 2025, WE DID OVER 1,100 COMMUNITY CATS FIXED, AND THAT'S NOT INCLUDING THE VOUCHERS WHERE WE SUBSIDIZE INDEPENDENT TRAPPERS WHO WANT TO GET THEIR COMMUNITY CLEANED UP, AND THIS IS A COMMUNITY SERVICE. WE NEED TO SUPPORT THE SHELTER AS MUCH AS WE CAN. THANK YOU. >> Mayor Salwan: THANK YOU. >> Mr. Quintanilla: OUR FINAL SPEAKER IS KRISTEN. >> HI, YES, I AGREE WITH THESE PEOPLE BECAUSE I HAD CATS UP HERE IN MY YARD IN THE SUMMERTIME AND I CALLED ALL THE SHELTERS AND THEY SAID THAT THEY WERE FULL TO CAPACITY. AND THEY COULDN'T DO ANYTHING ABOUT IT. RECOMMENDED THAT I JUST DIDN'T FEED THEM OR LOOK AT THEM AND THEY WOULD MOVE ON. WHICH MEANS THEY WOULD GO TO SOMEBODY ELSE'S YARD. SO IT'S ABSOLUTELY IMPERATIVE THAT WE GET SOMEBODY TO COME AND COLLECT THESE CATS AND MAKE SURE THAT THEY'RE NOT REPRODUCING AT A RAPID RATE. SO THANK YOU. >> Mayor Salwan: THANK YOU. THAT CONCLUDES THE SPEAKERS. IT'S GOOD TO HEAR GENERALLY POSITIVE FEEDBACK, SO WE APPRECIATE THAT. JUST FROM A HIGH LEVEL DISCUSSION, IT SOUNDS LIKE WE HAD ORIGINALLY CONTRACTED FOR $99,000, WE'RE INCREASING BY 100,000, AND IS IT PRIMARILY LIKE FOR SICK PETS OR -- OKAY. >> YES, IT'S PRIMARILY FOR SICK AND INJURED. THERE IS A STATE LAW THAT REQUIRES US TO PROVIDE CARE TO SICK AND INJURED ANIMALS, AND THE CITY OF FREMONT, AND THAT ALSO INCLUDES UNION CITY AND NEWARK, AND AS YOU KNOW, THERE IS A VETERINARY SHORTAGE, AND FINDING A VETERINARIAN THAT CAN SEE ANIMALS THE SAME DAY HAS PROVEN TO BE A CHALLENGE AND THEY HAVE BEEN A TRUE PARTNER AND THEY HAVE EVEN DONE A LOT OF WORK WITH COMMUNITY CATS AND TNR WHEN WE'VE NEEDED APPOINTMENTS. SO THEY'VE BEEN A GREAT ASSET FOR US. >> Mayor Salwan: GREAT. ANYTHING ELSE YOU WANT TO ADDRESS BASED ON THE COMMENTS? >> NO, THERE'S NOTHING -- NOTHING ELSE EXCEPT I WOULD JUST SAY WE USE A LOT OF DIFFERENT VET VETERINARIANS, SO WE HAVE THREE EMERGENCY VETERINARIANS, WE HAVE TWO -- ONE THAT DOES HIGH VOLUME SPAY NEUTER AND WE HAVE ONE THAT DOES TNR, SO WE'RE USING AS MANY RESOURCES AS WE POSSIBLY CAN. SPREAD IT OUT. AND WE CONTINUE TO REKRE RECRUIT FOR A VET AND VET TECH SO IF ANYONE WANTS TO WORK IF HE SHELTER, APPLY. >> Mayor Salwan: THANK YOU. ALWAYS GOT TO BE SELLING. LET'S GO WITH COUNCILMEMBER LIU SINCE HE HAD A COMMENT, THEN COUNCILMEMBER KENG AFTER. >> Councilmember Liu: I JUST WANT TO ADD ON TO THAT. THIS IS SOMETHING I'VE BEEN PRETTY PASSIONATE ABOUT. I THINK OUR STAFF CAN ATTEST, WE'VE HAD MANY MEETINGS ABOUT THIS WITH ME PERSONALLY, SO I FOR ONE AM REALLY GLAD TO SEE THIS ON THE AGENDA TODAY. AND THEN I LOOK FORWARD TO SEEING ALL SORTS OF ANIMALS, BUT ESPECIALLY WITH THE CATS BECAUSE WHEN I WAS SMALLER, I HAD MY OWN CAT, I WOULD TAKE IT INTO THE VET, SHE DIDN'T LIKE IT BUT WE STILL DID IT. SO REALLY HAPPY TO SEE THIS ON THE AGENDA. THANK YOU. >> Mayor Salwan: SOME CATS DO LIKE TO GO TO THE VET. COUNCILMEMBER KENG. >> Councilmember Keng: THANK YOU. >> Mayor Salwan: NOT FERAL ONES, THOUGH. >> Councilmember Keng: IT'S REALLY GREAT TO SEE THE PROGRESS THAT WE'VE MADE SINCE A FEW YEARS AGO, I THINK WE'VE REALLY CAME A LONG WAY, AND I WANT TO ALSO APPRECIATE ALL THE COMMUNITY MEMBERS THAT HAVE BEEN WRITING US AND ADVOCATING FOR ALL THE NEEDS AT THE ANIMAL SHELTER AND YOU NEED TO KNOW THAT YOU HAVE REALLY MADE A DIFFERENCE THROUGH YOUR ADVOCACY. THANK YOU. >> Mayor Salwan: SEEING NO FURTHER COMMENTS, CAN I GET A MOTION? MOVED BY COUNCILMEMBER CAMPBELL. SECONDED BY COUNCILMEMBER LIU. PLEASE VOTE. MOTION PASSES, SIX AYES, ONE ABSENT. THANK YOU. OKAY. SO I BELIEVE THAT'S ALL -- THERE'S NO ADDITIONAL SCHEDULED ITEMS. WE DO HAVE COUNCIL REPORTS. ANYBODY HAVE COUNCIL REPORTS? COUNCILMEMBER KENG, THEN I KNOW COUNCILMEMBER ZHANG HAD A NICE WRITEUP SO WANT TO HEAR FROM HER TOO. >> Councilmember Keng: SO I REPRESENT FREMONT ON THE AVA COMMUNITY ENERGY BOARD. WHERE EACH CITY HAS A REPRESENTATIVE. AND WE DID HAVE A MEETING ON JANUARY 21ST THAT WAS A BOARD MEETING AND THEN THE LAST WEDNESDAY WE ALSO HAD A FINANCE COMMITTEE MEETING. BUT I WANT TO SHARE SOME TAKEAWAY FROM THE JANUARY 21ST MEETING. THERE IS AN UPDATE ON THE FORECAST OF YOUR 2026 PG&E BILL BECAUSE RIGHT NOW EVEN THOUGH WE'RE ON THE AVA, WHO PROCURES OUR ENERGY, BUT ALL THE CABLES AND NETWORK IS STILL UNDER PG&E, SO THEY ARE STILL DOING THE DELIVERY. SO YOUR BILL HAS A COMBINATION OF FROM THOSE TWO ENERGY AGENCIES. SO THE UPDATED BILL -- THE UPDATED 2026 BILL FOR COMPARED TO YOUR 2025 BILL, WE HAD AN ESTIMATE FORECAST THAT WAS TO HAVE A DECREASE TOTAL BILL OF 10%, AND NOW BASED ON THE AET FILING, IT WILL BE DECREASED BY 5%. WHICH IS NOT TERRIBLE NEWS BUT IT'S STILL SEEING A DECREASE. BUT MOST OF THE DECREASE IS COMING FROM THE GENERATION WHICH IS AVA, AND BECAUSE OF THE COMBINATION OF THE DELIVERY WHICH IS BY PG&E, SO THE DECREASE IS A LITTLE BIT LESS. BUT NONETHELESS, STILL A DECREASE FOR YOUR ENERGY BILLS WHICH IS GOOD ?NEWS. SO THAT'S MY REPORT. >> Mayor Salwan: THANK YOU. NEXT WE HAVE VICE MAYOR ZHANG. >> Vice Mayor Zhang: THANK YOU, MAYOR. UNDER GOVERNANCE -- JANUARY 22:00, I ATTEND THE COMMITTEE MEETING IN SACRAMENTO. THERE WAS TWO ACTION ITEMS PASSED. ONE IS THE UPDATES TO EXISTING POLICY AND GUIDING PRINCIPLES. AND THE SECOND IS LEGISLATIVE POLICY ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE IN LOCAL GOVERNMENT POLICY STATEMENT. AND THIS ONE IS THE FIRST IN ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE ADDED TO OUR POLICY. AND SO BASICALLY THE STATEMENT IS WE AS THE CALIFORNIA STATE SUPPORT A.I. IMPLEMENTATION AND THE PRACTICE, BUT ALSO WE BELIEVE THAT OVERLY RESTRICTIVE OR PRESCRIPTIVE REGULATION WOULD HINDER THE CITY'S ABILITY TO EFFECTIVELY MODERNIZE SERVICE. AND ALSO AT THE SAME TIME WE NEED TO PROTECT THE DATA AND THE PRIVACY. AND ALSO AT THE SAME TIME, AND WE INVITED A SPEAKER FROM SAN JOSÉ, THE CITY OF SAN JOSÉ, AND A.I. DEPARTMENT. SO HE TALKED ABOUT THE GOV-AI COALITION, WHICH IS A NATIONWIDE COALITION, AND THERE'S MANY MEMBERS, AND I BELIEVE THAT FREMONT IS A MEMBER OF THAT COALITION AS WELL. SO HE DISCUSSED AND DEMONSTRATED THAT A.I. REALLY HELPED THEIR CITY STAFF TO INCREASE THE EFFICIENCY OF THE WORKLOAD AND ALSO DECREASED I THINK BURNOUT, BECAUSE THEY CAN GET THEIR WORK DONE EARLY AND ALSO I THINK THEY CAN HAVE SOME TIME OFF, AND THE OTHER THING IS TO INCREASE -- BASICALLY TO FINISH WORK EARLY, SO THAT IT'S IMPROVED EFFICIENCY. AND SO BASICALLY THIS FURTHER CONFIRMS THAT A.I. IS NOT GOING TO REPLACE THE EMPLOYEES' WORK BUT FURTHER ENHANCE THE WORK QUALITY. EVEN THOUGH THE STATEMENT IS SIMPLE, AND BASICALLY IS WE SUPPORT A.I. BUT THAT'S THE FIRST STEP, SO WE WANT TO ADD A POLICY FOR A.I. IN THAT POLICY PACK AND WE WOULD ADD THAT ON, YOU KNOW, AS THE TIME GOING FORWARD. SO THAT IS MY REPORT. >> Mayor Salwan: THANK YOU. IT'S GREAT TO BE ABLE TO APPOINT YOU AS THE PRESIDENT OF THE LEAGUE. NORMALLY WE APPOINT YOU AS THE MAYOR BUT SHE WANTED TO BE ON POLICY COMMITTEE -- >> Vice Mayor Zhang: THANK YOU. MY POINT IS ACTUALLY WHEN I GAVE THEM FEEDBACK, I THOUGHT WE WOULD LIKE TO HAVE A LITTLE BIT OF DISCUSSION BEFORE THE MEETING, BECAUSE SUDDENLY WE GOT THE POLICY, LIKE APPROVE IT, SO I STILL HAD A LOT OF QUESTIONS TO ASK. >> Mayor Salwan: SOMETIMES THE FIRST MEETING, THEY ALREADY HAVE THEIR WORK AGENDA, SO THE NEXT ONE, YOU'LL BE WAY AHEAD. LET'S SEE, COUNCILMEMBER KIMBERLIN. >> Councilmember Kimberlin: THANK YOU. I AM ONE OF THE LIAISONS WITH THE FREMONT UNIFIED SCHOOL DISTRICT REPRESENTING THE CITY WITH THE SCHOOL DISTRICT ALONG WITH COUNCILMEMBER LIU, SO I'LL START AND THEN YOU FILL IN WHAT I FORGOT. WE HAD A RECENT MEETING AND THIS IS TO DO WITH WE'VE HAD SEVERAL VISITS FROM A CROSSING GUARD AND A COUPLE OTHER COMMUNITY MEMBERS WHO REALLY WANT TO BE SURE THAT WE'RE ABLE TO DELIVER THE DAYLIGHTING BILL WHICH IS AN ASSEMBLY BILL THAT HAS SOME GREAT IDEAS BUT IT DOESN'T HAVE FUNDING. SO THAT MAKES IT A LITTLE TRICKY FOR US AND WE'RE ESPECIALLY CONCERNED WITH HOW IT CREATES SAFETY AT OUR SCHOOLS AND HOW IT CREATES THE 20 FEET CLEARANCE FROM INTERSECTIONS SO THAT THE CROSSING GUARD CAN SEE, THE STUDENTS CAN SEE, AND CARS CAN SEE PEOPLE AND IT REALLY INCREASES THE SAFETY. SO WE'VE KIND OF GONE BACK AND FORTH A LITTLE BIT. A LOT OF US REALLY LIKE THE RED CURB PIECE HOWEVER THERE'S A MAINTENANCE ISSUE TO THAT AND COST TO THAT. THEN THE WAY FOR TO HAVE COMPLIANCE AND ENFORCEMENT WOULD BE FROM SIGNAGE THAT WOULD BE PLACED THERE. AND THAT ALSO HAS A COST. IT SEEMS LIKE THE TEAM, THE GROUP, THE LIAISON GROUP ISN'T SO INTERESTED ABOUT ENFORCEMENT, JUST ABOUT EDUCATION AND CREATING A SAFE ENVIRONMENT FOR THE KIDS COMING AND GOING TO SCHOOL. AND I THINK THAT'S IT FROM ME. WHAT AM I FOR GETTING, COUNCILMEMBER LIU? >> Councilmember Liu: YOU KNOW, THAT SOUNDS ABOUT RIGHT. I GUESS THE ONLY OTHER THING THAT WAS MENTIONED WAS -- IT WAS LIKE SAYING NO, WE JUST WANT TO MAKE SURE THE KIDS DON'T GET HIT BY CARS, WE'RE NOT OUT THERE TO TICKET EVERYBODY OR ANYTHING LIKE THAT, AND I THINK IT WAS ALSO MENTIONED THAT IT IS POSSIBLE FOR GROUPS OF VOLUNTEERS OR WHATEVER TO -- IF THEY WANT TO PAINT SOME CURBS RED THEMSELVES, I THINK THAT'S SOMETHING THAT CAN BE DONE. SO THAT'S SOMETHING I PERSONALLY SUPPORT AND I WOULD LOVE TO SEE EVERYBODY WHO'S ACTIVELY ENGAGED WITH OUR COMMUNITY AND WANTS TO CONTRIBUTE, I THINK THAT'S SOMETHING THAT WE CAN ALL GET TOGETHER AND DO. >> Councilmember Kimberlin: AND ONE MORE THING I THINK THAT'S REALLY IMPORTANT IS MR. LARSEN HAD LET US KNOW THAT THERE HAD BEEN SEVERAL SCHOOLS THAT HAVE BEEN ANALYZED AND LOOKED AT AND SOME SCHOOLS HAVE SOME REALLY NICE -- LIKE GLENMOOR ELEMENTARY FOR ONE HAS SOME REALLY GOOD BOLLARDS AND PAINTINGS AND IT KEEPS PEOPLE AWAY, KEEPS THE DISTANCE JUST BY THAT IMPLEMENTATION, BUT IT'S HARD TO DO THAT AT EVERY SCHOOL. SO WE'RE LOOKING AT IF THERE ARE SOME PRIORITY SCHOOLS OR ONES THAT HAVE A SPECIAL -- ESPECIALLY TROUBLING SITUATIONS THAT MAYBE WE'LL WORK WITH THE CITY AND SEE WHAT WE CAN GET DONE THERE. THANK YOU. >> Mayor Salwan: THANK YOU. ANYBODY ELSE? I GUESS I'LL JUST GIVE QUICK UPDATES ON THE ALAMEDA COUNTY TRANSPORTATION COMMISSION. WE VOTED -- WELL, THE CITY OF FREMONT WANTED TO PRIORITIZE SPEED CAMERAS, WHICH IS THESE AUTOMATED SPEED CAMERAS THAT ARE ALLOWED IN A FEW CITIES. LIKE SAN FRANCISCO, I THINK L.A., AND WE WOULD LIKE TO BE CONSIDERED AS PART OF THAT, SO WE ARE ADVOCATING FOR THAT. WE'RE ALSO ADVOCATING FOR THE IRVINGTON BART TO MAKE THAT A PRIORITY IN THE PLANS FOR FUTURE TRANSPORTATION. AND THEN I ALSO HAD THE OPPORTUNITY TO GO TO THE U.S. MAYORS' CONFERENCE. LOTS OF BIG ISSUES THAT WE FACE HERE AS WELL WERE ADDRESSED SUCH AS HOMELESSNESS, HOUSING. THE SURPRISING THING ABOUT HOUSING, I THOUGHT IT WAS JUST A COASTAL PROBLEM. BUT IT SEEMS LIKE IT'S A UNIVERSAL PROBLEM, EVEN PLACES LIKE SOUTH DAKOTA, OTHER VERY REMOTE PLACES ARE ALSO HAVING MAJOR HOUSING CHALLENGES. SO THERE ARE SOME BILLS IN THE SENATE AS WELL AS THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES ON BOTH SIDES, SO WORD IS THAT PRESIDENT TRUMP WANTS TO SIGN A HOUSING OR INFRASTRUCTURE BILL SO IT'S POSSIBLE MAYBE THAT WE'LL HAVE SOMETHING THAT CAN HELP TRANSLATE INTO MORE HOUSING ESPECIALLY MIDDLE CLASS HOUSING AND MORE LOW INCOME TAX CREDITS. AND THEN OF COURSE THERE'S LOTS OF OTHER ISSUES THAT WERE DISCUSSED BUT AGAIN, IT WAS A GOOD CONVERSATION. WE WERE ABLE TO TALK TO OUR REPRESENTATIVES AND ADVOCATE FOR WHAT WE LOOKING FOR. SO SEEING NO FURTHER COMMENTS, THAT'S IT FOR TONIGHT. THANK YOU, EVERYONE, FOR COMING OUT. HAVE A GREAT EVENING. LOOK FORWARD TO SEEING YOU NEXT WEEK.

Agenda textCouncil Meeting 2/3/26

Council Meeting 2/3/26 — Feb 3, 2026 - 07:00 PM

Showing the first 24,000 of 41,515 characters. The full document is at the source.

I'D LIKE TO CALL THE FEBRUARY 3RD 2026 MEETING TO ORDER AT 7:00 P.M. I'D LIKE TO ASK VICE MAYOR SANG TO LEAD US IN THE PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE. I PLEDGE ALLEGIANCE TO THE FLA OF THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA AND TO THE REPUBLIC FOR WHICH I ONE NATION UNDER GOD, INDIVISIB WITH LIBERTY AND JUSTICE FOR AL. >> THANK YOU, VICE MAYOR. MR. CITY CLERK, IF YOU COULD TAKE THE ROLL CALL. >> COUNCILMEMBER LIU, HERE. COUNCILMEMBER SHAO IS ABSENT. COUNCILMEMBER KIM BERLIN, HERE. SAL SAL THERE ARE VACANCIES ON BOARDS AND COMMISSIONS. THE CITY CLERK'S OFFICE ACCEPTS APPLICATIONS THROUGHOUT THE YEAR. IF YOU'RE INTERESTED IN APPLYING PLEASE GO TO FREET.GOV AND VISIT THE BOARDS, COMMISSIONS AND COMMITTEES PAGE OR PLEASE CONTACT THE CITY CLERK'S OFFICE. EMAILS SUBMITTED TO THE CITY CLERK ARE COMPILED, DISTRIBUTED TO THE CITY COUNCIL AND PUBLISHED ON THE CITY'S AGENDA CENTER. AND THEY WILL BE PLACED ON FILE AND CONSIDERED PART OF THE PUBLIC RECORD. I WOULD LIKE TO ANNOUNCE THIS MEETING MAY GO ON UNTIL 11:30 P.M. THIS EVENING IF NECESSARY. WE WILL ALLOW FOR 30 MINUTES FOR ORAL COMMUNICATIONS IF THERE ARE ADDITIONAL SPEAKERS FOR ORAL COMMUNICATIONS AFTER THE INITIAL 30 MINUTES, WE WILL TAKE THOSE SPEAKERS AT THE END OF THE MEETING IF TIME REMAINS. LY NOW TURN THE MEETING OVER TO OUR CITY MANAGER FOR COMMENTS AND INTRODUCTIONS. >> GOOD EVENING TO YOU, GOOD EVENING TO MEMBERS OF THE COUNCIL. GOOD TO SEE YOU ALL THIS EVENING. ACROSS FROM THE TWO OF US WE HAVE OUR ASSISTANT CITY CLERK, DINA LEWIS, AND OUR CITY CLERK, ALBERTO QUINTANILLA. NO ANNOUNCEMENTS THIS EVENING SO I'LL TURN IT BACK OVER TO YOU, MR. MAYOR. >> Mayor Salwan: OKAY, THANK YOU. SO NEXT WE HAVE THE CONSENT CALENDAR. THE CONSENT CALENDAR WILL BE PASSED WITH ONE COUNCIL VOTE AND STAFF RECOMMENDATION WILL STAND. DOES ANY MEMBER OF THE CITY COUNCIL WISH TO REMOVE AN ITEM FROM CONSENT? VICE MAYOR ZHANG? >> Vice Mayor Zhang: I WOULD LIKE TO REMOVE 2D AND 2H FROM THE CONSENT CALENDAR. >> Mayor Salwan: MOVE 2D AND 2H. COUNCILMEMBER CAMPBELL. >> Councilmember Campbell: THANK YOU, MAYOR. I WAS GOING TO REQUEST THE SAME TWO ITEMS, PLEASE. >> Mayor Salwan: OKAY. DO WE HAVE ANY SPEAKERS FOR ANY ITEMS? >> Mr. Quintanilla: WE DO HAVE ONE FOR 2H. >> Mayor Salwan: COULD I GET A MOTION TO MOVE CONSENT WITH 2D AND 2H REMOVED. COUNCILMEMBER KIMBERLIN, MOVED BY COUNCILMEMBER KIMBERLIN, SECONDED BY COUNCILMEMBER CAMPBELL. PLEASE VOTE. >> Mayor Salwan: MOTION PASSES, SIX AYES, ONE ABSENT. OKAY. NEXT WE HAVE CEREMONIAL ITEM. WE HAVE KHLOE HALE WITH HER MOTHER, MS. TIFFANY HALE. PLEASE JOIN ME AT THE PODIUM AND I'LL BE RIGHT THERE. SHE'S A BIG GIRL NOW. SO WE HAVE THIS PROCLAMATION FOR CONGENITAL HEART DEFECT AWARENESS WEEK, WHICH IS FEBRUARY 7 TO 14, 2026. WHEREAS, THE HEALTH AND WELL-BEING OF ALL CHILDREN IN THE CITY OF FREMONT ARE OF PARAMOUNT IMPORTANCE TO OUR FAMILIES, NEIGHBORHOODS, AND COMMUNITY AS A WHOLE; AND WHEREAS, THOUSANDS OF CHILDREN ARE BORN EACH YEAR WITH BIRTH DEFECTS, INCLUDING APPROXIMATEL 40,000 CHILDREN IN THE UNITED STATES—NEARLY ONE IN EVERY 100—WHO BEGIN LIFE WITH ONE OF MORE THAN THIRTY- FIVE IDENTIFIED FORMS OF CONGENITAL HEART DEFECTS; AND WHEREAS, CONGENITAL HEART DEFECTS ARE AMONG THE MOST COMMON AND SERIOUS BIRTH DEFECTS, AND MAY BE LIFE-THREATENING DUE TO THEIR COMPLEXITY, THE LIMITATIONS OF CURRENT MEDICAL INTERVENTIONS, AND THE SCARCITY OF AVAILABLE I DONOR HEARTS; AND WHEREAS, ADVANCES IN MEDICAL RESEARCH AND CLINICAL PRACTICE HAVE LED TO I IDENTIFICATION OF THE ORIGINS AND SYMPTOMS OF CONGENITAL HEAR DEFECTS, AS WELL AS A CONTINUALLY EXPANDING RANGE OF SURGICAL AND TREATMENT OPTIONS MADE POSSIBLE THROUGH THE DEDICATED EFFORTS OF PHYSICIANS SURGEONS, SCIENTISTS, AND HEALTHCARE PROFESSIONALS; AND WHEREAS, SIGNIFICANT WORK REMAINS TO BETTER UNDERSTAND TH CAUSES OF CONGENITAL HEART DEFECTS AND TO DEVELOP EFFECTIV TREATMENTS, AND IT IS CRITICAL THAT PARENTS, CAREGIVERS, PEDIATRICIANS, AND NURSES RECOGNIZE EARLY WARNING SIGNS I NEWBORNS TO ENSURE TIMELY DIAGNOSIS AND CARE; AND WHEREAS, MANY FAMILIES WITHIN THE CITY OF FREMONT ARE DIRECTLY OR INDIRECTLY IMPACTED BY CONGENITAL HEART DEFECTS, AND THE COMMUNITY JOINS IN RECOGNIZING AND COMMENDING THE ONGOING EFFORTS OF MEDICAL PROFESSIONALS AND RESEARCHERS WHO STRIVE TO SAVE LIVES AND IMPROVE HEALTH OUTCOMES FOR CHI AND FAMILIES EVERYWHERE, AND FURTHER ACKNOWLEDGES THE MEANINGFUL ADVOCACY OF YOUNG PEOPLE LIVING WITH CONGENITAL HEART DEFECTS WHOSE VOICES, RESILIENCE, AND LEADERSHIP HELP RAISE AWARENESS, FOSTER UNDERSTANDING AND INSPIRE COMPASSION THROUGHOUT THE COMMU NOW, THEREFORE, THE CITY COUNCI OF THE CITY OF FREMONT HEREBY R FEBRUARY 7-14, 2026 AS CONGENITAL HEART DEFECT AWARENESS WEEK AND CALLS UPON ALL RESIDENTS TO OBSERVE THIS WEEK BY INCREASING AWARENESS, SUPPORTING AFFECTED FAMILIES, AND HONORING THE DEDICATED PROF WORKING TO ADVANCE PREVENTION, TREATMENT, AND CARE. SO WITH THAT, I'LL PRESENT THIS TO KHLOE. AND I'LL INVITE KHLOE TO SAY A FEW WORDS. OH, PICTURE. OKAY. HOW MANY YEARS HAVE YOU BEEN DOING THIS NOW? I'VE BEEN SEEING YOU SINCE YOU WERE SO SMALL. DO YOU REMEMBER? >> 6. >> Mayor Salwan: SIX YEARS! ALL RIGHT. TO YOU. >> HI. MY NAME IS KHLOE HALE. I AM 13 YEARS OLD. I WAS DIAGNOSED WITH A CONGENITAL HEART DEFECT ALSO CALLED A CHD AT 8 DAYS OLD. THE SHORT NAME IS TABVR. TOTAL ANOMALOUS PULMONARY VENOUS RETURN. IF THAT SOUNDS SCARY AND CONFUSING TO YOU, IMAGINE HOW IT SOUNDS AND FEELS TO ME. SPREADING AWARENESS LIKE I AM IS VERY IMPORTANT BECAUSE OF PEOPLE WHO ARE EDUCATED ON IT, KINDNESS WILL SPREAD, AND MORE PEOPLE WILL BECOME INVOLVED. OVER THE YEARS, I HAVE HAD OPPORTUNITIES TO SPREAD AWARENESS SUCH AS SHARING INFORMATION AT MY SCHOOL, CITY COUNCIL MEETINGS AND I HELP MY MOM PLAN A BIG FUN RUN TO RAISE MONEY FOR MENDING LITTLE HEARTS FOR YEARS. I HAVE ALSO TEAMED UP WITH THE ELKS LODGE TO CREATE BRAVERY BAGS FOR THE CARDIAC UNIT AT STANFORD AND UCSF, AND I SPOKE AT A LARGE GOLF TOURNAMENT FUNDRAISER. CONGENITAL HEART DEFECTS ARE THE MOST COMMON BIRTH DEFECT IN THE WORLD. 1 IN 110 PEOPLE ARE BORN WITH A CHD. THIS MEANS THAT APPROXIMATELY 1 MILLION TO 1.4 MILLION BABIES ARE BORN WITH A CHD EVERY YEAR ALL AROUND THE WORLD. WHEN A BABY IS BORN, THEIR HEART IS THE SIZE OF A WALNUT. ABOUT 25% OF BABIES BORN WITH A CHD ARE CONSIDERED CRITICAL AND REQUIRE A LIFE SAVING SURGERY BETWEEN BIRTH AND THEIR FIRST BIRTHDAY. I WAS ONLY 2 MONTHS OLD AND MY FRIEND WAS 2 MONTHS OLD WHEN WE HAD OUR SURGERY. MY NEW BABY COUSIN WAS ONLY 3 DAYS OLD FOR HIS SURGERY. THIS IS BECAUSE WE WERE BORN WITH DIFFERENT HEART DEFECTS BUT THEY WERE ALL CONSIDERED CRITICAL. ABOUT 85 TO 90% OF HEART DEFECTS HAPPEN WITHOUT A KNOWN REASON. SOME WILL NOT LIVE TO CELEBRATE THEIR FIRST BIRTHDAY. CHD IS USUALLY DIAGNOSED IN NEWBORNS, BUT MAY GO UNDETECTED AND NOT DIAGNOSED UNTIL LATER IN LIFE. EACH YEAR, 200 OR 300 NEWBORNS ARE RELEASED FROM THE HOSPITAL UNDIAGNOSED. THE DOCTORS DO NOT EVEN REALIZE I HAD A HEART DEFECT WHEN I WAS FIRST BORN. MY MOM WAS THE ONE WHO KNEW SOMETHING WAS WRONG AND DID NOT GIVE UP UNTIL SHE HAD ANSWERS. THIS IS WHY I WAS 8 DAYS OLD ONLY BEFORE BEING DIAGNOSED. MY NEW BABY C COUSIN WAS BORN IN JULY AND HIS CHD WAS DIAGNOSED WHEN MY AUNTIE WAS PREGNANT. I WAS SO -- WHEN I HEARD BUT I KNEW HE WAS GOING TO BE OKAY. OUR CHDs ARE NOT HEREDITARY AND ARE DIFFERENT. THIS IS WHY RESEARCH AND UPDATES TO TESTING IS SO IMPORTANT AND REALLY DOES SAVE LIVES. I AM VERY PROUD TO RECEIVE A PROCLAMATION FOR THIS WEEK. THANK YOU, MAYOR SALWAN, FOR CONTINUING TO SUPPORT ME AND CHD. I HOPE YOU ALL LEARNED SOMETHING NEW. THANK YOU FOR SUPPORTING CONGENITAL HEART DEFECT AWARENESS WITH ME. WE ARE BOTH 1 IN 110. WE ARE HEART WARRIORS. >> Mayor Salwan: THANK YOU VERY MUCH. WE'LL MOVE ON TO ORAL COMMUNICATIONS. THIS IS AN OPPORTUNITY FOR THE PUBLIC TO SPEAK TO THE CITY COUNCIL ON ANY ISSUE THAT IS NOT ON THE AGENDA. THE COUNCIL CANNOT TAKE ACTION, NOR RESPOND TO ITEMS THAT ARE BROUGHT UP UNDER ORAL COMMUNICATION COMMENT PERIOD. HOWEVER, THE ITEM COULD BE AGENDIZED FOR A FUTURE MEETING IF A COUNCIL MAKES REFERRAL TO STAFF FOR A REPORT BACK. WHEN SPEAKING ON BEHALF OF AN ORGANIZATION, STATE YOUR NAME OF THE ORGANIZATION THAT YOU ARE REPRESENTING. A BELL WILL RING WHEN 30 SECONDS REMAIN FOR YOU TO SUM UP YOUR COMMENTS. AND THE BELL WILL RING AGAIN WHEN THE TIME HAS ENDED. THE CITY CLARK WILL START THE TIMER FOR EACH SPEAKER. HOW MANY SPEAKERS DO WE HAVE? >> Mr. Quintanilla: WE HAVE TWO SPEAKERS. >> Mayor Salwan: FOR ORAL COMMUNICATIONS? >> Mr. Quintanilla: YES. >> Mayor Salwan: 2 MINUTES EACH. >> Mr. Quintanilla: OUR FIRST SPEAKER IS AL MINARD. >> Mayor Salwan: SIR, WE CAN'T HEAR YOU. IS IT GREEN? >> THANK YOU. GOOD EVENING, MAYOR AND CITY COUNCIL. IT'S A PLEASURE TO BE HERE ALMOST. I AM HERE BECAUSE OF THE PERRY HOUSE ON OLIVE AVENUE WAS HEARD TWICE BY THE PLANNING COMMISSION AND HAS VOTED BOTH TIMES TO DEMOLISH THE HOUSE AND PUT ADUs ON THE DOUBLE LOT. THIS HOUSE HAS NEVER BEEN -- ALTHOUGH IT'S OVER A HUNDRED YEARS OLD, BUILT BY A DISTINGUISHED FAMILY WITH A DISTINGUISHED ARCHITECT, H.A. MAT SON THAT HAD DEEP ROOTS IN THE COMMUNITY, THIS HOUSE HAS NEVER BEEN REVIEWED BY HARB, THE HISTORICAL ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW BOARD, BECAUSE SOMEONE ON THE STAFF I THINK CONSIDERED IT NOT LEGALLY HISTORIC. THIS HOUSE IS OVER A HUNDRED YEARS OLD, AND THE ONLY MODIFICATION UNDER 50 YEARS WAS CHANGING FROM WOOD SASH WINDOWS TO VINYL WINDOWS. AND I'M NOT COMPLAINING ABOUT THE STAFF OR PLANNING COMMISSION OR ANYBODY. I'M BLAMING ALL OF THE CITY COUNCIL, BECAUSE THE CITY COUNCIL APPROVES THE HIRING OF EVERYONE, APPROVES THE APPOINTMENTS OF EVERYONE TO COUNCILS AND COMMISSIONS, AND GIVES THEM DIRECTION OF WHAT THEY WANT TO DO. I THINK IT'S IMPORTANT THAT THE CITY STAFF MAKE SURE THAT HISTORIC BUILDINGS ARE REFERRED TO THE HARB BOARD FOR REVIEW BEFORE THEY GET DEMOLISHED. CITY OF FREMONT HAS CLOSED ABOUT 90 SQUARE MILES OF REAL ESTATE AND IN MY OPINION, IT IS THE MOST SIGNIFICANT SECTION OF 90 SQUARE MILES OF REAL ESTATE IN ANY COUNTY AND PROBABLY IN THE ENTIRE STATE, AND YET WE ARE DEMOLISHING IT, AND ONE OF THE THINGS THAT'S A HISTORICAL DRAW FOR BUILDINGS AND S CITIES AND HOUSES IS HISTORICAL TOURISM AND WE ARE SHOOTING OURSELF IN THE FOOT AS A CITY NOT TO PROMOTE AND PROVIDE ACCESS FOR HISTORICAL TOURISM. THANK YOU. >> Mayor Salwan: THANK YOU. >> Mr. Quintanilla: OUR NEXT SPEAKER IS AMIN SH AMSIN FOLLOWED BY KRISTEN. >> GOOD EVENING. I CAME LAST YEAR FOR THE SAME SUBJECT WITH THE FIRE HAZARD IN THE FIELD THAT CONNECTS CURTIS WITH OMAR STREET. THIS YEAR, NOW TWO TIMES, THE FIRES OCCURRED. BECAUSE THE VEGETATION IS HIGH, AND YOU CAN'T SEE WHAT HAPPENED, THERE'S HOMELESS INSIDE THE VEGETATION, YOU CAN'T SEE THEM. SO WE SEE THE SMOKE TWO TIMES, WE CALL THE FIRE TO COME TO EXTINGUISH THAT FIRE. SO AS WE HAVE NOWADAYS MORE HOMELESS, WE NEED TO DO SOLUTION. THIS VEGETATION, LAST YEAR IT SUPPOSED TO BE BREAK THE CYCLE OF THIS VEGETATION. YOU CUT THEM BEFORE THEY START MAKING SEEDS. THEN NEXT YEAR IT WILL NOT GROW BECAUSE THERE IS NO SEED THERE IN THE GROUND. SO WE NEED TO DO SOLUTION, IT'S A FIRE HAZARD NOW. THAT'S IT. >> Mayor Salwan: THANK YOU. WE CAN'T TALK ABOUT THE COMMENTS BUT YOU CAN EMAIL US OR GIVE THE INFORMATION TO ONE OF THE STAFF MEMBERS. THANK YOU, SIR. >> ALL RIGHT. THANKS. >> Mr. Quintanilla: OUR LAST SPEAKER CARD FOR THIS ITEM IS KRISTEN. >> THAT'S ME, BUT ANOTHER LADY SAID SHE FILLED OUT ONE AND I DON'T KNOW WHAT HAPPENED TO HER CARD SO PLEASE RESET MY CLOCK. PLEASE. HELLO, RESETTING OF CLOCK? OKAY. I'LL JUST TAKE AN EXTRA 10 SECONDS. I AGREE WITH THIS MAN RIGHT HERE. I CAME BACK AND FOUND OUT THAT THE CHARLIE CHAPLAIN MUSEUM OR HIS BUILDING, HIS STUDIO WAS GONE AND I'M ACTUALLY A MEMBER OF THE COMMUNITY OF ACTORS AND I WAS DEVASTATED. SO THANK YOU, SIR, FOR BRINGING THAT UP ABOUT HISTORICAL THINGS. ALSO THIS GUY MENTIONING THE HOMELESS PEOPLE, IT'S OUT OF CONTROL. THE HOMELESSNESS IS OUT OF CONTROL AND THEY ARE STEALING -- I WATCHED SOME PEOPLE STEAL TODAY, AND THE CVS PEOPLE HAD TO JUST WATCH THEM WALK OUT. SO IF YOU COULD JUST PLEASE GET THAT UNDER CONTROL. THEN THE OTHER THING THAT I WANT TO SAY IS THE TRASH. THERE IS TRASH EVERYWHERE. WHEN I GREW UP, I WAS BORN AT WASHINGTON HOSPITAL, I LIVED HERE MOST OF MY LIFE UNLESS I WAS OUT OF THE COUNTRY LIVING, BUT WHEN I CAME BACK, TRASH EVERYWHERE. COULD YOU PLEASE HIRE PEOPLE TO GO AND PICK UP THE TRASH OR DO WHAT WE USED TO DO, AND ANY KID IN JUVENILE HALL OR ANY PERSON IN THE COUNTY JAIL WILL BE PUT IN AN ORANGE VEST AND THEY WERE MEANT TO PICK UP THE TRASH. SO IF WE COULD GET THAT GOING BACK, THAT WOULD BE GREAT. AND ESPECIALLY ON THE FREEWAYS WHEN YOU'RE COMING ON TO THE FREEWAY, JUST TO THE SIDE, TRASH EVERYWHERE. WE ARE NOT A THIRD WORLD COUNTRY. THANK YOU. >> Mayor Salwan: THANK YOU. DO WE HAVE ANOTHER SPEAKER OR NOR? >> Mr. Quintanilla: NO ADDITIONAL SPEAKERS. >> Mayor Salwan: SO WITH THAT, WE WILL CLOSE THE ORAL COMMUNICATION COMMENT PERIOD. WE WILL GO TO ITEMS THAT WERE REMOVED FROM CONSENT STARTING WITH ITEM 2D. DO WE HAVE STAFF ON THOSE? SO I GUESS WE HAD VICE MAYOR ZHANG, IF YOU HAVE QUESTIONS, COMMENTS, AND THEN WE HAVE COUNCILMEMBER CAMPBELL AS WELL. I'M GOING TO CLEAR THE REQUESTS TO SPEAK AND IF THERE'S ANYBODY ELSE THAT WANTS TO ASK ANYTHING, HIT IT NOW. >> Vice Mayor Zhang: MY QUESTION IS, I HAVE RECEIVED A COMMENT FROM A COMMUNITY MEMBER, AND HE HAS SOME QUESTIONS. I THINK THAT I HAVE SIMILAR QUESTIONS, SO I WOULD LIKE THE STAFF TO RESPOND. BASICALLY ONE OF THE QUESTIONS IS, THERE ARE 13 APPLICANTS FOR THE LANDSCAPE ARCHITECT STUDIOS, AND THE STAFF HAVE INTERVIEWED THREE, AND THEN WE SELECT THREE. SO WHAT'S THE REASON WE HAVE NOT INTERVIEWED OTHER LANDSCAPE COMPANIES AND WHAT'S THE REASON? AND I THINK THERE WAS QUITE A FEW. WHETHER OUR SUPERVISION ON THE RESULT AND LOOKS LIKE WE HAVE NOT GONE INTO MEETINGS FOR THE PAST THREE MONTHS, AND DO WE HAVE ENOUGH SUPERVISION ON THOSE KIND OF A JOB? AND ALSO BASICALLY IT'S JUST TRANSPARENCY AND ACCOUNTABILITY OF THE BUDGET AND HOW WE SELECT THOSE COMPANIES. AND SAME QUESTION AS THE PERSON HAS ASKED. >> Mayor Salwan: OKAY. DID STAFF GET THE TOPICS? OKAY. >> GOOD EVENING, COUNCIL. MY NAME IS TARA, PARKS, PLANNING AND DESIGN MANAGER FOR THE CITY OF FREMONT. THANK YOU FOR YOUR QUESTION. I CAN RESPOND TO THE ONE ABOUT THE INTERVIEWS. WE HAD 18 LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURAL FIRMS SUBMIT PROPOSALS, AND THE FIRST ROUND OF SELECTION, WE LOOKED AT MULTIPLE QUALIFICATIONS, AND AFTER THE FIRST ROUND, WE DID A SPREADSHEET TAP LAITI TABULATION AND THE TOP THREE FIRMS WERE SELECTED TO SHORTLIST. AS PER OUR RFP THAT WAS PUBLISHED. STAFF HAD INTENDED TO AWARD AT LEAST THREE CONTRACTS, AND AFTER THOSE FIRST THREE, THERE WAS A BIT OF A GAP. AND THEN THE REST OF THE -- THEN THERE WERE THE REST OF THE 14 OTHER FIRMS. SO WE DECIDED TO INTERVIEW THE TOP THREE, AND THEY CHECKED ALL THE BOXES DURING THE INTERVIEW, AND WE DECIDED TO AWARD THOSE FIRMS. >> Vice Mayor Zhang: THANK YOU. SO MY FOLLOW-UP QUESTION IS, HAVE WE USED THEM IN THE PAST? ARE THEY THE SAME THREE WE HAVE USED BEFORE? >> I BELIEVE THAT PREVIOUSLY, WE HAVE USED TWO OF THEM. HOWEVER, THROUGH A DIFFERENT DEPARTMENT. I BELIEVE THAT PLANNING, NOT THROUGH THE COMMUNITY SERVICES DEPARTMENT, BUT I BELIEVE THE PLANNING DEPARTMENT PREVIOUSLY HAD CONTRACTED WITH THEM TO DO PLAN REVIEWS. >> Vice Mayor Zhang: CAN YOU ADDRESS THE ACCOUNTABILITY AND EVALUATING OF THEIR WORK AND ALSO THE PRICING? YOU KNOW, ANNUALLY? BECAUSE THIS IS A FIVE-YEAR PROJECT, RIGHT? >> WELL, SO WHAT WE'RE LOOKING FOR IS ON-CALL CONTRACTS. AND EVEN THOUGH THE AMOUNT MAY LOOK LARGE, $1.25 MILLION PER CONTRACT IS PRETTY TYPICAL FOR OUR ON-CALL DESIGN SERVICES CONTRACT FOR THE CITY. IT DOES NOT MEAN THAT THE CITY INTENDS TO AWARD UP TO THE MAXIMUM. IN FACT, IT'S PRETTY UNUSUAL THAT THE CITY WOULD AWARD TO THE MAXIMUM. IT'S JUST -- IT JUST ALLOWS FOR THAT AMOUNT TO BE AVAILABLE, AND EACH SCOPE OF WORK IS AWARDED PER TASK ORDER. SO EACH SCOPE OF WORK IS DEFINED, AND THEN AWARDED PER SCOPE. >> JUST TO ADD ON TO WHAT TARA IS SAYING, THIS IS PRETTY TYPICAL. WE DO THIS WITH MECHANICAL, PLUMBING, ELECTRICAL DESIGNS, GEOTECHNICAL, ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES. THESE ARE JUST ON-CALL CONSULTANTS THAT THE CITY USES WHEN WE'RE DOING PROJECTS AND TRYING TO DELIVER SERVICES AND GET THOSE PROJECTS OVER THE GOAL LINE. THEY'RE MANAGED WITH A -- IT'S VERY MUCH OUTLINED WHAT SERVICES THEY'RE GOING TO DELIVER, WHAT THE EXPECTATIONS ARE, AND THE COST THAT THEY WILL BE PAID FOR THEIR SERVICES. AND THEN WE ISSUE THEM A TASK ORDER THAT ONCE THEY COMPLETE THOSE SERVICES, THEY SEND IT BACK AND THAT'S HOW THEIR PAYMENT IS ISSUED. SO IT'S ALL CONTROLLED BY STAFF, IT IS NOT JUST KIND OF SAT OUT THERE, TO CLARIFY. THIS ISN'T SOMETHING THAT BOTH PUBLIC WORKS, PLANNING AND COMMUNITY SERVICES USE AND MAINTENANCE ON A REGULAR BASIS. >> Vice Mayor Zhang: THANK YOU. I HAVE REALIZED WE HAVE A SIMILAR CONTRACT JUST LIKE PUBLIC WORKS AND ET CETERA, BUT I THINK SINCE THE PUBLIC ASKED THIS QUESTION SO I WANTED TO DISCUSS PUBLICLY SO THAT WE CAN GIVE THEM THE ANSWER AND MAYBE SOME OTHER MEMBERS WOULD HAVE SIMILAR WE CANS, BUT THANK YOU. >> SURE. AND TO ANSWER THE REST OF YOUR QUESTIONS, I'LL TAKE THOSE, VICE MAYOR ZHANG. SO ON THE RECREATION COMMISSION IT IS TRUE WE DID CANCEL DECEMBER, JANUARY AND FEBRUARY. DECEMBER AND JANUARY AS WE KNOW ARE HOLIDAY MONTHS AND WE DIDN'T HAVE ANY ACTION ITEMS. WE WERE FULLY INTENDING TO DO A FEBRUARY MEETING AND THEN SOME OF THE ITEMS CHANGED SO WE ARE ALREADY PLANNING FOR A MARCH MEETING AND AN APRIL MEETING. APRIL WILL BE WHEN OUR PALM AVENUE PROJECT IS COMING FORWARD. SO IT'S JUST A MATTER OF PREFERENCE. I'M NOT SOMEONE WHO LIKES TO REALLY CALL A MEETING IF I DON'T HAVE SOMETHING SPECIFIC TO TALK ABOUT. SO WE HAVE A FULL SET OF MEETINGS MOVING FORWARD, BUT WE DIDN'T SCHEDULE THOSE MEETINGS AND WENT AHEAD AND CANCELED THEM. SO THAT'S ON THAT ITEM. AS FAR AS THE TRANSPARENCY OF THE BUDGET, ALL OF THE ITEMS THAT WOULD GO THROUGH THESE MASTER SERVICE AGREEMENTS THAT WE'RE TALKING ABOUT HAVE ALL ALREADY BEEN VETTED AND APPROVED AND RECOMMENDED BY THE RECREATION COMMISSION THROUGH THE CAPITAL IMPROVEMENT PROGRAM, AND THEN GONE TO ALL OF YOU FOR APPROVAL. SO THESE ARE -- THAT CAN WORK ON WHETHER IT'S DUSTERBERRY PARK OR PAM AVENUE PARK OR DO SPECIFIC AREAS OF LANDSCAPE SERVICES. AND WE UTILIZE THESE CONSULTANTS SO WE CAN BOTH MAXIMIZE WHEN WE HAVE STAFFING ADJUSTMENT. LET'S SAY WE HAVE A RETIREMENT OR SOMETHING CHANGES, WE DON'T WANT TO STOP A PROJECT, THEN HAVE TO GO OUT, FIND A CONSULTANT, COME BACK, THAT WOULD REALLY SLOW OUR PROJECT DOWN. OR IF WE HAVE -- RIGHT NOW WE HAVE A LOT OF PROJECTS GOING ON AND WE ALSO DON'T WANT TO GO OUT AND HIRE A BUNCH OF STAFF TO DO WORK THAT THEN EVENTUALLY IS GOING TO GO AWAY. AS WE KNOW, IMPACT FEES HAVE DECLINED AND SO WE HAVE A LOT OF PROJECTS WE'RE TRYING TO DELIVER ON AND TO MAKE SURE THAT WE CAN GET THESE GREAT COMMUNITY PROJECTS OVER THE GOAL LINE, BUT YOU KNOW, WE HAVE LIMITATIONS BASED ON THE NUMBER OF STAFF AND THESE ALLOW US BOTH TO EXPAND THE AMOUNT OF WORK WE'RE ABLE TO DO BUT ALSO THERE'S MANY THINGS THAT STAFF DON'T NECESSARILY HAVE THE QUALIFICATIONS OR THE EXPERTISE IN, SO WE CAN PICK FROM THESE CONSULTANTS, YOU KNOW, AN EXAMPLE WOULD BE MAYBE SPORTS FIELDS AND DESIGN OF SPORTS FIELDS, THAT'S A VERY SPECIFIC AREA OF EXPERTISE THAT WOULD ALLOW US TO CONSULT WITH SOMEONE TO BE ABLE TO DELIVER AND GET THAT PROJECT OVER THE GOAL LINE. >> Vice Mayor Zhang: ALL RIGHT. THANK YOU VERY MUCH. >> Mayor Salwan: COUNCILMEMBER CAMPBELL. >> Councilmember Campbell: THANK YOU. I HAD SIMILAR QUESTIONS, BUT I WANTED TO ASK A COUPLE QUESTIONS. ONE, I HEARD YOU INDICATE THAT THE COMMISSION HAD ALREADY VETTED THESE PARTICULAR CONSULTANTS. DO THEY ALWAYS HAVE TO WEIGH IN OR IS THAT TYPICAL TO HAVE THE ADVISORY BODY WEIGH IN AND THEN -- BECAUSE IT WASN'T IN THE STAFF REPORT, THAT THEY HAD WEIGHED IN. >> SO TO CLARIFY, NO, THE RECREATION COMMISSION DID NOT LOOK AT THE CONSULTANTS. THEY APPROVED THE PROJECTS THAT THE CONSULTANTS WOULD THEN BE WORKING ON AND THAT WE WOULD ISSUE TASK ORDERS FOR THEM TO DO SPECIFIC PROJECTS RELATED TO THOSE APPROVED PROJECTS THAT THEY ALREADY RECOMMENDED TO YOU AND YOU ULTIMATELY APPROVED. SO THAT MONEY IS ALREADY INCLUDED IN THAT BUDGET FOR THAT PARTICULAR PROJECT. >> Councilmember Campbell: SO JUST TO CLARIFY, THE COMMISSION, THE RECREATION COMMISSION TYPICALLY DOES NOT WEIGH IN ON CONTRACT THAT YOU -- CONSULTANTS THAT YOU'VE AWARDED CONTRACTS FOR? >> CORRECT. >> Councilmember Campbell: OKAY. SO IS IT ALSO TYPICAL THAT ONLY THREE STAFF MEMBERS WOULD WEIGH IN ON THE 18 APPLICATIONS THAT WERE SUBMITTED? >> THAT IS CORRECT AS WELL. >> Councilmember Campbell: THERE'S JUST THREE STAFF FROM YOUR STAFF THAT WOULD DO THAT? >> IT DEPENDS. SOMETIMES IT'S FROM A DIFFERENT DEPARTMENT, BUT USUALLY THREE IS ABOUT -- FOR A NON-SERVICE CONTRACT. FOR A LARGER PROJECT WHEN WE DID THE CENTRAL PARK COMMUNITY CENTER WE HAD A LARGER GROUP OF US WHO WEIGHED IN WITH DIFFERENT EXPERIENCE AND EXPERTISE BECAUSE YOU ARE AWARDING SPECIFICALLY TO THAT PROJECT. BUT FOR AN ON-SERVICE ON-CALL, THAT'S A PRETTY TYPICAL NUMBER WHEN I ACTUALLY PULLED IN RESPONSE TO LOOKING AT THIS SOME OF THE OTHER SERVICE AGREEMENTS THAT WE'VE DONE OVER THE LAST FEW YEARS AND BOTH THE AMOUNT AND AMOUNT OF REVIEWERS WAS ALL FAIRLY CONSISTENT. >> Councilmember Campbell: OKAY. AND WHAT IS IT THAT THESE THREE CONSULTANTS -- WHAT DIFFERENTIATES THEM FROM EACH OTHER? DO THEY ALL DO THE SAME THING? WILL YOU GET A DIFFERENT SET OF EXPERTISE FROM EACH OF THEM? WHEN YOU START TO LOOK AT YOUR POOL, OR ARE YOU JUST HAVING ALL THREE PROVIDE THE SAME LEVEL OF SERVICES? >> I CAN TAKE THAT QUESTION, COUNCILMEMBER. SO WE LOOK AT A FEW DIFFERENT THINGS. ALL THREE OF THE FIRMS WORK REALLY WELL WITH PUBLIC AGENCIES. WE FOUND THAT AS A COMMONALITY AND SOMETHING THAT'S VERY ATTRACTIVE TO US, BECAUSE THERE'S LESS OF A LEARNING CURVE. THEY KNOW WHAT WE NEED, AND THERE'S A LOT OF EFFICIENCY THERE. EACH FIRM WILL ALSO HAVE DIFFERENT CAPACITIES AT DIFFERENT TIMES. SO IF ONE FIRM IS BUSY, WE CAN ALWAYS PULL FROM A DIFFERENT FIRM. THEY ALSO HAVE DIFFERENT SUBCONSULTANTS, THEY ALSO HAVE DIFFERENT EXPERTISE. SO WE'RE ABLE TO PULL AND CAPITALIZE ON AN EXPERTISE OF ONE FIRM VERSUS ANOTHER. >> Councilmember Campbell: I SEE. OKAY. AND THEN SINCE THE AWARD IS 1.25 FOR ALL THREE, IT'S ANTICIPATED OVER THE FIVE YEARS, IF MY MATH IS CORRECT, IT'S GOING TO BE 3.75 OVER THE FIVE YEARS, ASSUMING WE AWARD EACH ONE OF THEM THE 1.25, CORRECT? >> IN THEORY, CORRECT, BUT KEEP IN MIND, THESE ARE DONE BY TASK ORDERS. SO WE DO THIS FOR TREES, WE DO THIS FOR A LOT OF THINGS. SO ONE CONSULTANT BASED ON THEIR AVAILABILITY, EXPERTISE, TIMING OF THE PROJECT, ONE MAY GET 50,000 IN WORK, ONE MIGHT GET 400,000 IN WORK AND ONE MIGHT GET A DIFFERENT AMOUNT. SO THERE'S NOTHING THAT SAYS THAT THEY HAVE TO GO TO THAT AMOUNT. THERE'S NOTHING -- THEY CAN DO $0. WE DON'T EVEN HAVE TO AWARD THEM ANYTHING. SO JUST TO MAKE SURE WE'RE CLEAR ON THAT. >> Councilmember Campbell: JUST ONE OTHER QUICK QUESTION. I HEARD YOU SAY THAT THERE WAS A FIRST ROUND OF THE SELECTION PROCESS, SO YOU WEEDED OUT AND YOU CAME OUT WITH, I DON'T KNOW, WHAT, 12 OR 13 LEFT? AND THEN YOU DID A SECOND ROUND? >> THERE WAS ONE ROUND. 18 REVIEWED. TO CLARIFY, THESE ARE USUALLY EXTENSIVE PROPOSALS, VERY TIME-CONSUMING. STAFF GOES THROUGH AND VETS THEM. THERE WAS DEFINITELY FROM THE REVIEW PANEL THREE TOP CONSULTANTS, WHICH WE WERE INTENDED TO REVIEW TOO. SO THEY BROUGHT THEM BACK FOR AN INITIAL MEETING AND THEN AWARD OF THOSE PARTICULAR THREE CONSULTANTS BASED ON THEIR EXPERTISE, THEIR AVAILABILITY, THEIR PRIOR EXPERIENCE, ALL OF THOSE THINGS. >> Councilmember Campbell: THOSE THINGS THAT WERE INDICATED HERE. >> AND MAKING SURE THAT THE BILLING RATE WAS REASONABLE AND EXPECTED FOR THE WORK THAT THEY'RE PROVIDING. >> Councilmember Campbell: THE BILLING RATES OF COURSE WOULD BE VERY IMPORTANT. AND THEN WERE THESE THE SAME THREE STAFF THAT WEEDED OUT ALL 18 WHO DID THE FINAL SELECTION? >> THEY

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
AgendaNot published in the sources we holdread text
Agenda packetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Action agendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
MinutesNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Transcript or captionsSource recordingread transcript
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Recording and media

Official pages

Coverage and corrections

Records considered

  • Council Meeting 2/3/26 — Closed Captions

Not claimed by this page

  • Verified meeting decisions with item-specific public-source evidence
  • Item-level plain-language summaries are not available; this page does not infer individual agenda items.
  • Item-linked, attributed deliberation
  • A source-grounded next meeting date
  • A plain-English overview is not available.
  • Official outcomes have not been published.
  • The available transcript has no reliable timestamps.
  • Transcript coverage is partial.
  • Speakers have not been reliably matched to public profiles.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.
  • An individual roll-call roster is not available.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: 30dbf36dd21a3f6a832461008ff0c1e7. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record