POLISCOPE

The public record

SARASOTA (SARASOTA COUNTY) · LOCALHeld · official record pendingPartial coverage

Regular City Commission Meeting

Tuesday, February 17, 2004 · Government meeting record

The 30-second read

Record incomplete

The Sarasota City Commission met to discuss public art, city infrastructure projects, and administrative procedures. Key decisions included denying a contract for a public art installation at Lemon Avenue Plaza and approving various budget appropriations and zoning changes.

Why it matters

This meeting determined the allocation of city funds for public art, infrastructure maintenance, and community grants, while also setting new rules for how citizens can participate in future commission meetings.

What happens next

The scheduled meeting date has passed. Minutes or an action agenda are not published in the records we hold.

This meeting date has passed and no official outcome record has been published yet. Nothing on this page is a decision.

Record text

No recording or transcript is held for this meeting.

Showing the first 60,000 of 171,470 characters. The full document is at the source.

---- pages 1-40 ----

MINUTES OF THE REGULAR SARASOTA CITY COMMISSION MEETING OF FEBRUARY 17, 2004, AT 2:30 P.M.

PRESENT: Vice Mayor Richard F. Martin, Commissioners Fredd "Glossie" Atkins, Danny Bilyeu, and Mary Anne Servian, City Manager Michael A. McNees, Deputy City Auditor and Clerk Karen D. McGowan, and City Attorney Richard J. Taylor

ABSENT: Mayor Lou Ann R. Palmer and City Auditor and Clerk Billy E. Robinson

PRESIDING: Vice Mayor Martin

The meeting was called to order in accordance with Article III, Section 9(a) of the City of Sarasota Charter at 2:30 p.m.

Deputy City Auditor and Clerk McGowan gave the Invocation followed by the Pledge of Allegiance.

Vice Mayor Martin stated that Mayor Palmer was called to Tallahassee, Florida, on behalf of the City regarding possible funding for the Ed Smith Stadium and will not be in attendance.

1. CHANGES TO THE ORDERS OF THE DAY - APPROVED

Deputy City Auditor and Clerk McGowan presented the following Changes to the Orders of the Day:

A. Add Consent Agenda No. 1, Item No. IV.A.7, Approval Re: Authorize the Mayor and City Auditor and Clerk to execute a Municipal Services and Pre-Annexation Agreement between the City of Sarasota and Joseph A. and Jennifer L. Palladino for a connection to be provided to the City of Sarasota's water distribution system for a developed site located at 3005 Hawthorne Street, per the request of Technical Services Manager Haas.

B. Add Consent Agenda No. 1, Item No. IV.A.8, Approval Re: Authorize the Mayor and City Auditor and Clerk to execute a Municipal Services and Pre-Annexation Agreement between the City of Sarasota and Theresa Valenti for the purpose of obtaining potable water and sewer service for an undeveloped site located at 1806 Hansen Street, per the request of Technical Services Manager Haas.

C. Remove New Business Item No. 1, XIV.1, Discussion Re: Appeal to City Commission from decision of Planning Board regarding approval of Site Plan Application 03-SP-40 (Burns Court Villas), per the request of John Stone.

Vice Mayor Martin asked if the Commission has any objections to the Changes to the Orders of the Day. Vice Mayor Martin stated that hearing no objections, the Changes to the Orders of the Day are approved by unanimous consent.

Vice Mayor Martin asked if any Commissioner wished to remove an item from Consent Agenda No. 1 or 2.

Commissioners Servian and Bilyeu requested that Item No. IV-B-9 be removed for discussion.

Deputy City Auditor and Clerk McGowan stated that Item No. IV-B-9 concerns Resolution No. 04R-1723 to amend the City's Formal Rules of Procedure and will be considered under New Business as Agenda Item No. VII-1, which will be heard in the afternoon session.

2. CITIZENS' INPUT CONCERNING CITY TOPICS (AGENDA ITEM I)

The following people came before the Commission:

Charles Senf, 2346 Pelican Drive (34237), stated that the traffic system works well when people respect each other; that the thought seemed to tie in with the remarks for the current meeting; that a question is if the current period in history will be remembered more for Osama bin Laden or United States Attorney General John Ashcroft; that thousands of Americans are fighting and dying at the moment to bring freedom of speech to the people of Iraq; that for an elected body in America to seek to limit the right of free speech for the citizens at home is ironic; that the current Commissioners as candidates in February and March 2003 visited homes, neighborhood associations, and a variety of other public and private venues to request votes; that the importance of hearing the personal point of views and working with the neighborhood associations to obtain a fair representation of the values was stressed; that a question is what has changed.

Mr. Senf continued that to take the position of a constituent being denied the opportunity to speak to issues due to the placement on the Agenda is difficult to understand; that a question is if the disregard for the public is gleaned in the refined atmosphere of the Foundation Meetings at Michael's on East or from the developers and attorneys who are frustrated with the public's testimony; that a question is, at the next election will the constituents' opinions become more important; that perhaps other representatives will be identified who will honor each citizen and the Democratic process; that having a discussion with the Commissioners over coffee would be welcomed; that the process and the procedure limits the ability to do so; that having only three minutes to give an opinion to the Commission is difficult; that the average citizen is not prepared to do so; that the vote of the average citizen is important; that citizens should be assured of the opportunity to address the Commission; that the Commission should have the opportunity to listen.

Stan Zimmerman, 2469 Novus Street (34237), stated that all Democratic entities implement rules to govern the behavior of the government and citizens who are responsible for the Democratic institutions; that some items on the Agenda cannot be discussed under the City's rules; that Sarasota has many Sister Cities; that Sarasota really only has one mother city which is the City of Athens, Greece; that Athens was the first municipal democracy in world history; that during the Peloponnesian wars when Athens was at war and most of the young men were in service in the field, the Athenians celebrated a 100 year anniversary of the Democracy; that a coup occurred soon thereafter by the people having money and property; that developers and attorneys with economic power are the modern day counterpart; that the forces of Democracy recaptured the government of the Athens a couple of years later and decided the old rules did not work; that new rules were established; that the aftermath of the Peloponnesian wars are described in a book entitled "The Peloponnesian Wars"; that the old rules had failed to protect Democracy from subversion so the Athenians enacted legislation declaring anyone taking part in the destruction of the Democracy or holding office in a regime after the suppression of office an enemy of Athens was to be killed with impunity and personal possessions became public property; that the people were required to take an oath to uphold the law; that the law was inscribed in stone at the entrance of the Council Chamber and remained in force well into the Fourth Century.

Mr. Zimmerman continued that strong rules are important; that proposed Resolution No. 04R-1723 strips citizens of the opportunity to come speak to the Commission; that the opportunity to speak to the Commission is reduced in half; that the attorneys and developers are not restrained at all in the presentations to the Commission; that the proposed Resolution was spawned in the middle of the night and carefully slipped into the Consent Agenda where no public or Commission comment is allowed; that doing so is a subversion of Democracy or government by stealth; that the debate should be heard; that having the two Commissioners pull the Resolution off the Consent Agenda is appreciated.

Al Moore, President of the John Ringling Neighborhood Association, Member of the Barrier Island Group, 700 John Ringling Boulevard (34236), stated that the subject for discussion is a proposed inclusion of the Barrier Island Chapter in the City's Comprehensive Plan, also called the Sarasota City Plan, 1998 Edition (City's Comprehensive Plan); that the 1998 City's Comprehensive Plan sets forth principles and goals in each chapter for neighborhoods, housing, and environmental protection; that the addition of a Barrier Island Chapter is desired; that the barrier islands lie offshore from Downtown Sarasota and include Lido Key, Lido Shores, St. Armands Key, and Bird Key; that Golden Gate is a peninsula but has island characteristics; that the Town of Longboat Key is a barrier island; that the City has no jurisdiction over Longboat Key; that half of the island of Longboat Key is in Sarasota County; that the City's Comprehensive Plan includes by reference the Town of Longboat Key in the chapters on transportation and governmental coordination; that one part indicates the City in cooperation with Sarasota/Manatee Metropolitan Planning Organization (MPO) will recommend broadening the roadway and levels of service to alleviate congestion; that the contemplation of the reduction of Bayfront Drive from four to two lanes is just the opposite; that the traffic lanes are desperately needed; that the use of additional lanes stimulated the 1996 request for a Barrier Island Chapter; that the cost of eight years of imposing Florida Department of Transportation (FDOT) plans for a high bridge seems to have indicated a major misunderstanding of the growth of jobs and the taxable contribution of the barrier islands; that a preliminary draft of a Barrier Island Chapter is ready for implementation; that many island objectives always are and will be identical with the City's Comprehensive Plan; that some island situations are different; that the height of a residence should be measured from on top of a 12 or 14 feet pylon; that large, oceanfront setbacks require larger lot dimensions; that good traffic flow is vital if storm shelters are not feasible on barrier islands in the path of a Category Three hurricane; that temporary storage of vehicles Downtown prior to major storms is not permitted at this time; that emergency management personnel should persuade business owners to provide shelter for the vehicles; that the problem is insurance; however, the proposal should still be in the plan; that the opportunity to add an additional chapter is limited by time; that the matter should move forward.

3. APPROVAL RE: MINUTES OF THE EMERGENCY CITY COMMISSION MEETING OF JANUARY 16, 2004, AND THE MINUTES OF THE SPECIAL COMMISSION MEETING OF JANUARY 26, 2004 - APPROVED (AGENDA ITEMS II-1 AND 2)

MOTION: Approve the minutes of the January 16, 2004, Emergency Commission meeting. OUTCOME: Passed VOTE: Ayes 4 / Nays 0 / Absent 0 / Abstain 0 AYES: Atkins, Bilyeu, Servian, Martin NAYS: None ABSENT/ABSTAIN: None

Vice Mayor Martin asked if the Commission had any changes to the minutes of the January 26, 2004, Special Commission meeting? Vice Mayor Martin stated that hearing no changes, the minutes of the Special Commission meeting of January 26, 2004, are approved by consensus.

4. BOARD ACTIONS: REPORT RE: PUBLIC ART COMMITTEE'S REGULAR MEETING OF JANUARY 14, 2004 - RECEIVED REPORT; DENIED APPROVAL TO ENTER INTO CONTRACT WITH ARTIST BROWER HATCHER; DIRECTED THE PUBLIC ART COMMITTEE TO REVIEW PREVIOUS SUBMITTALS WITH WATER AND SEATING FEATURES (AGENDA ITEM III-1)

James Bowen, Chair, Public Art Committee, and John Burg, Chief Planner, Planning and Redevelopment Department, came before the Commission.

Mr. Bowen presented the following item from the January 14, 2004, Public Art Committee meeting:

- Public Art for the Lemon Avenue Plaza

Mr. Bowen referred to computer-generated slides of artwork by Brower Hatcher for display at the Lemon Avenue Plaza on the Chamber monitors; and stated that the call to artist process should be explained; that the process was approved by the Commission on December 12, 2002; that 182 submittals were received by February 28, 2003; that the understanding is the response was significant; that the response was pleasing and required a significant amount of work in narrowing the list by reviewing the work submitted; that 48 finalists were initially chosen, which was narrowed to 12, and then again to four; that a presentation was received by the Public Art Committee from the four finalists on January 14, 2004; that the Public Art Committee recommendation will be covered at the end of the presentation.

Mr. Bowen continued that Brower Hatcher is the artist selected from the four finalists by the Public Art Committee; that Mr. Hatcher's studies include mechanical engineering and English literature at Vanderbilt University; that Mr. Hatcher holds a Bachelor of Industrial Design from Pratt Institute in Brooklyn, New York; that graduate studies in sculpture were taught at St. Martin's School of Art in London, England; that Mr. Hatcher was head of the Sculpture Department at Bennington College in Vermont; that over 20 major commissions have been built in the last 20 years for public and corporate entities throughout the United States; that Mr. Hatcher's work has been exhibited in over 16 one-man shows and 36 group exhibitions; that Mr. Hatcher has received numerous awards, including awards from the Ford Foundation, the Sainsbury Foundation (Tate Gallery), the Guggenheim Foundation, and the National Endowment for the Arts; that Mr. Hatcher holds an Honorary Ph.D. from State University of New York (SUNY).

Mr. Bowen displayed photographs of Mr. Hatcher's work on the Chamber monitors including the Language of Whales done in 1984 which is located in Battery Park, New York; and stated that the piece has some characteristics of the proposed artwork; that another work subsequently executed is called the Prophecy of the Ancients done in 1987; that the finished work is located at the Walker Art Center in Minneapolis, Minnesota; that the artist produced a piece located at the entrance to the Herbeger Theater in Phoenix, Arizona, called Layering of Worlds which was done in 1983; that the Adirondack Guide Monument was done in 1984 and is located at SUNY in Plattburg, New York; that another sculpture is Starman which was done in 1990 and is displayed at the Wills Eye Hospital in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania; that Brainstorm was done in 2001 and is displayed at the ADC Telecom in Minneapolis, Minnesota; that Seer was done in 1994 and is displayed at Brigham Young University Museum in Provo, Utah; that El Arbor de Esperanza was done in 1995 and is displayed at Thomas Jefferson Park, New York City, New York; that Global Apex was done in 1994 and is displayed at the St. Paul Companies in St. Paul, Minnesota; that the sculpture Vortex with a canopy structure was done for the Wills Eye Hospital in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, in 2002; that the piece is especially significant because the piece is a stepping stone for the proposal for the City; that the rainwater is caught and funneled into the circular area which gives the piece the name Vortex.

Mr. Bowen stated further that the description from the artist for the artwork proposed for the Lemon Avenue Plaza is a series of canopy and support structures to cover a large portion of the designated site; that the overhead structures provide shade and partial rain protection for the public; that the support structures are stainless steel frameworks which support an array of petal-shaped powder coated elements; that the petal-like shapes overlap to catch rainwater and to allow the rainwater to fall into a catchment basin and drain through the basins; that the rain and catchment basin will become an intriguing water feature; that the support frameworks are connected overhead by a dome which supports a layer of glass elements, continues the patterns created by the petal forms, and projects the shapes, patterns, and colors onto the pavement beneath.

Mr. Bowen further stated that the sculpture will be located in the mid portion of the Lemon Avenue Mall with paving and benches around trees for the plaza space; that the actual sculpture piece will have dimensions of 24 feet, 5 inches by 45 feet, and 1 inch long; that an elevation drawing of the same piece shows five of the elements; that the overall height to the top of the elements is 10 feet, 1 inch; that the metal bowl feature is the catchment basin where water funneled through the vortex is caught and drains through the bottom of the element, which is a concrete base.

Mr. Burg stated that pragmatic issues must be addressed, the first of which is wind; that the piece will be designed for 130 mile per hour winds; that the final drawings must be stamped by a Registered Engineer; that the piece will be made of very durable finishes; that these are powder coated stainless steel and powder coated aluminum and only require hosing down occasionally; that safety and vandalism are always concerns; that the glass pieces in the central hexagon will be laminated pieces of glass with embedded wire mesh; that the piece would remain intact even if someone were to throw a rock; that the proposal was reviewed by the City's Risk Management Department which indicates no hazards were apparent; that the budget is $125,000 and is primarily for the vertical elements; that the funds come from two sources; that $68,130 is from the Public Art Fund; that $56,870 is from the developer as a requirement to meet the public art requirement for the Whole Foods Centre Market project; that funding was set aside in an escrow account with the City prior to the commencement of the project; that the remaining flatwork will come from $50,000 which is part of the Lemon Avenue Streetscape budget; that the artist has indicated the cost of the central, vertical elements and the supports will not exceed the $125,000 budgeted; that all the streetscape work in the project budget goes to the roadway near First Street and back to the alley; that Public Works has budgeted $50,000 as part of the Lemon Avenue Streetscape Project which includes brick paving, trees, tree grates, and some other elements; that the contractor, the cost estimator, and the artist should meet and develop a change order to the contract which changes the design and allows the geometry of the proposal to be rebuilt in the space within the project budget; that the geometry of the trees and grates may be different; that the exact paving and geometry of all the elements with the exception of the canopies may change as the project proceeds; that the Public Art Committee discussed the placement of the sculpture; that a major feature of the piece is that the sunlight will come through and create incredible patterns on the pavement; that the patterns on the concrete will be elaborate by themselves even if the concrete work has relatively simple geometric cuts created by the artist; that a shadow with colors will move across the pavement with the sun coming through the piece; that the placement of the seating around the pavement could change slightly while going through the process; that the canopies would remain the same.

Mr. Bowen stated that the Public Art Committee recommends the Commission authorize appropriate City Officials to negotiate and execute a contract with Mr. Hatcher for fabrication and installation of a public artwork for the Lemon Avenue Plaza for a cost to not exceed $125,000 payable from the Public Art Fund.

Commissioner Servian stated that the seating areas are not included in the proposal; that the funds for the seating would come from City funds. Mr. Burg stated that is correct.

Commissioner Servian stated that for the $125,000, the City is receiving the vertical pieces and not any of the seating.

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
Agenda packetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Action agendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
MinutesNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Transcript or captionsNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Coverage and corrections

Records considered

  • Regular City Commission Meeting

Not claimed by this page

  • Verified meeting decisions with item-specific public-source evidence
  • Item-level plain-language summaries are not available; this page does not infer individual agenda items.
  • Item-linked, attributed deliberation
  • A source-grounded next meeting date
  • Official outcomes have not been published.
  • A transcript is not available.
  • No audio or video recording is linked.
  • Speakers have not been reliably matched to public profiles.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.
  • An individual roll-call roster is not available.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: 306db0011b3dd060ba3c8ac109b2934e. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record