POLISCOPE

The public record

SOUTHPASADENA (LOS ANGELES COUNTY)Held · official record pendingPartial coverage

Additional Documents

Wednesday, January 15, 2025 · Government meeting record

The 30-second read

Record incomplete

Additional Documents

Why it matters

The official meeting record is available below. Item-level plain-language summaries are not available yet.

What happens next

The scheduled meeting date has passed. Minutes or an action agenda are not published in the records we hold.

This meeting date has passed and no official outcome record has been published yet. Nothing on this page is a decision.

Record text

No recording or transcript is held for this meeting.

CITY OF SOUTH PASADENA

ADDITIONAL DOCUMENTS

WEDNESDAY, JANUARY 15, 2025 AT 7:00 PM

ADDITIONAL DOCUMENTS

Additional Documents to the January 15, 2025 City Council Meetings. The attached

documents include submitted written public comments and amendments to the agenda.

Submit by no later than 12:00 p.m., on the day of the City Council meeting. Correspondence

received after this time will be distributed the following business day.

ADDITIONAL DOCUMENTS TO THE JANUARY 15, 2025 CITY COUNCIL MEETINGS

General Public Comments

Public Comment on Agenda Item 5

Public Comment on Item 10

Public Comment on Item 13

1

Showing the first 24,000 of 29,384 characters. The full document is at the source.

CITY OF SOUTH PASADENA ADDITIONAL DOCUMENTS WEDNESDAY, JANUARY 15, 2025 AT 7:00 PM ADDITIONAL DOCUMENTS Additional Documents to the January 15, 2025 City Council Meetings. The attached documents include submitted written public comments and amendments to the agenda. Submit by no later than 12:00 p.m., on the day of the City Council meeting. Correspondence received after this time will be distributed the following business day. ADDITIONAL DOCUMENTS TO THE JANUARY 15, 2025 CITY COUNCIL MEETINGS General Public Comments Public Comment on Agenda Item 5 Public Comment on Item 10 Public Comment on Item 13 1

From: Yvonne LaRose To: City Council Public Comment Subject: Public Comment: Lessons on Harmonious Community Life Date: Tuesday, January 14, 2025 8:46:07 PM CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the City of South Pasadena. Do not click links or open attachments unless you recognize the sender and know the content is safe. CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the City of South Pasadena. Do not click links or open attachments unless you recognize the sender and know the content is safe. We are here. It's 2025 and we're one week away from the commencement of the new Administration. Expressions of shock and anxiety about what is to come, dread of enduring an autocratic regime have become a whisper of yesterdays. Because of COVID and now the wind and fire storms, we are immersed in real-life lessons about building healthy, supportive, inclusive communities in this city. We need to continue these real-life lessons as the fires and winds die down to memories of what brought us together. Some examples of our having a community include things like : messages sent to neighbors as far away as 2 to 5 blocks asking, "Are you okay?" and "Do you need anything." The implied message was, "I care about you." Neighbors who voluntarily retrieving trash barrels hurled up and down streets, away from their homes. For me it included my presence on social media as my recruiting, HR, and journalism colleagues began to demand that I inform them about my status and whether I am safe. It was astounding to venture out to attend to business matters on Thursday and Friday. At each business and government location, the employees were present, dressed and groomed appropriately with a smile and a calm disposition. Their focus was on rendering flawless service to each patron. The realization that each one of those employees (including first responders) no doubt left home where the winds had torn apart their environment. Many probably also live in one of the fire zones yet they did not allow those personal concerns to interfere with their primary work focus - serving their patrons with dignity. And the two even more personal examples of community came when it was time to cross the street on Fair Oaks. A man wearing a mask and I traversed first from the east side of the avenue to the west together. We conversed with one another about various things, especially the length of time it took for the light to change. On reaching our destinations, we parted company, glad for the sake of a companion for that part of our path. I sat at Shakers to read a book while waiting for my transportation. When it was time to leave, a woman probably 10 years my senior held the door open for me. The irony is I should have been giving her that courtesy. We chatted about the memories Shakers represented for us as well as other commonalities we shared. We became friends because of that brief encounter and were glad of the meeting. 2

Then there was the incident at the post office on Friday. Business handled, it was time to descend the stairs. A man who is also at least 10 years my senior offered to tote my walker down the steps for me. The offer had to be declined because of a phone call but another person made a similar offer and actually carried the walker down both flights of steps. Just holding the door by a senior underscored the fact that being a senior citizen does not mean you're useless. It means you have value to be contributed to your community and that value should be recognized and respected. So our emergency events hold valuable life lessons for us on how to survive the next four years. Respect and value the talents of others, no matter the age, ethnicity, or status. Those talents can be of great benefit if they are properly used and not allowed to decay. Treat others with respect. While they may be ranting at the moment, it's important to realize the emergency is probably impacting them to a greater degree than you. Keep a calm head; be understanding. Check in with your neighbors - the ones next door and the ones at a distance. They are an extended family that we call Our Community. They are a source of security. Viva Yvonne LaRose, CAC Organization Development Consultant: Diversity/Title VII, Harassment, Ethics 3

From: Anne Bagasao To: City Council Public Comment Cc: Anne Bagasao; Casey Dukes Subject: General Public Comment Open Session Council Meeting 1-15-25 Date: Wednesday, January 15, 2025 11:05:56 AM Attachments: SPTU Letter to the City Council Re_ Rent Freeze.pdf CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the City of South Pasadena. Do not click links or open attachments unless you recognize the sender and know the content is safe. CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the City of South Pasadena. Do not click links or open attachments unless you recognize the sender and know the content is safe. Dear City Clerk: On behalf of South Pasadena Tenants Union, please include the attached as a written General Comment for the abovementioned meeting. Thank you. I will also send from my personal email to ensure delivery. Best, Anne Bagasao 4

Subject: Urgent Action Needed: Implement a Rent Freeze and Tenant Protections Now Dear South Pasadena City Council, The City of South Pasadena must act immediately to implement a rent freeze. In July 2024, the Council directed staff to prepare a report on a rent freeze to protect tenants while the City fulfills its commitments outlined in the Housing Element certified by the California Department of Housing and Community Development (HCD). Despite this directive, no action was ever taken. The time for delay is over—we need a rent freeze now. Price gouging in the wake of disasters is unacceptable and requires immediate action. A rent freeze is a simple, effective measure that could be enacted without delay. Will this Council step up and do what is right for our community? We also need an eviction moratorium to prevent landlords from displacing tenants to exploit the current crisis for financial gain. For years, South Pasadena residents have asked this Council to adopt an increased relocation fee ordinance. This critical measure, also included in the Housing Element, has been ignored for too long. If residents are forced out of their homes by investor landlords or profiteering agents seeking to replace them with fire victims desperate for housing, how will they survive on a relocation fee of just one month’s rent? Where are they expected to go? Should families pitch tents in Garfield Park? Should parents uproot their children from our school district? This is both a health and economic crisis, much like the challenges we faced during COVID-19. Tens of thousands of people are newly homeless, and many more who have lost income are at risk of joining them. South Pasadena must implement robust homelessness prevention measures now. The community cannot wait months for debate or inaction. We urge you to protect South Pasadena residents with a rent freeze, an eviction moratorium, and increased relocation fees without delay. Our community is counting on your leadership in this critical moment. South Pasadena Tenants Union and South Pasadena residents 5

Megan Aaron Tim Aaron Cathy Abbey Amielynn Abellera Lindsay Adams Rilla Alexander Steve Alexander Angelo Angeles Alexander Aquino-Kaljakin Sepand Ardeshir Bree Arnall Hazard Anne Bagasao Nicholas Bain Heidi Barnett Nick Barnett Marcus Batista William Beasley Matthew Bennett Richard Blake Heather Bland Sheri Borrego Britany Brodeur Julianne Bull Denise Burciaga Greg Burns Jody Butts Ana Camacho Ricardo Casas Bianca Ciebrant Anastasia Coon Danelle Courtice David Courtice Kathrine Cruz Lula Cummings Leesa Dang Valerie de la Rosa Susan Delgadillo Rigoberto Delgadillo Grace Dennis Casey Dukes Jason Dukes Scott Dukes Denise Durrett Patti Emery Jolynn Enz Russell Farmarco Nicole Farmarco Salik Farooqi Rachael Faught Kathrin Ford Roberto Fuentes Stephany Gamez Jessica Gerhardt Cameron Gibson Paul Goetz Joseph Grijalva Wendy Gutschow Amber Haley Rachel Hamilton Alec Hamilton Vector Hasting Aidan Howard-Rede Ella Hushagen Phung Huynh Arend Jessurun Jazmin Joyce Laura Kieffer Alice Kim Tina Kistinger Jessica Klier Aileen Kutaka Caitlin Lainoff Lana Le Therese A. Le Veque Kimberly Leung-Earley Sergio Leyva Maria Angelicon Mapue Esmeralda Marcial Viri Mata Yuka Matsuyama Christine Mauer Sean McCullough Debra McCurdy Kathleen McLaughlin Michael Mesker Arianna Messmer Kimberly Ming Rhonda Mitchell Michael Mizgalski Mireya Naranjo Thank Nguyen Michael Noe Kimber Norquest Joanne Nuckols Roxy Ortiz Dean Peterson Denise Philley Hazel Portillo Fiona Purdon Karina Ramirez Erica Rede Sarah Rodman Phoenix Rodman Abraham Romwro Philip Rowland Tess Ryan Loresa Salazar Kim Seltzer Michael Serrano Delaine Shane Genevieve Sigala Laura Sorenson Kristen Swift Nick Taylor Nany Thenard Judith H. Trout Vanessa Valencia Gabriela Valle Melanie Wagner Kate Wilson Camila Zagarra Michael Zahn Priscilla Zaragoza Manuel Zaragoza 6

From: Elizabeth Anne Bagasao To: City Council Public Comment Subject: Fw: General Public Comment Open Session Council Meeting 1-15-25 Date: Wednesday, January 15, 2025 11:06:27 AM Attachments: SPTU Letter to the City Council Re_ Rent Freeze.pdf CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the City of South Pasadena. Do not click links or open attachments unless you recognize the sender and know the content is safe. CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the City of South Pasadena. Do not click links or open attachments unless you recognize the sender and know the content is safe. Thank you! Anne From: Anne Bagasao <SPTenantsUnion@outlook.com> Sent: Wednesday, January 15, 2025 11:05 AM To: ccpubliccomment@southpasadenaca.gov <ccpubliccomment@southpasadenaca.gov> Cc: Elizabeth Anne Bagasao <eabagasao@hotmail.com>; Casey Dukes <caseydukes@gmail.com> Subject: General Public Comment Open Session Council Meeting 1-15-25 Dear City Clerk: On behalf of South Pasadena Tenants Union, please include the attached as a written General Comment for the abovementioned meeting. Thank you. I will also send from my personal email to ensure delivery. Best, Anne Bagasao 7

Subject: Urgent Action Needed: Implement a Rent Freeze and Tenant Protections Now Dear South Pasadena City Council, The City of South Pasadena must act immediately to implement a rent freeze. In July 2024, the Council directed staff to prepare a report on a rent freeze to protect tenants while the City fulfills its commitments outlined in the Housing Element certified by the California Department of Housing and Community Development (HCD). Despite this directive, no action was ever taken. The time for delay is over—we need a rent freeze now. Price gouging in the wake of disasters is unacceptable and requires immediate action. A rent freeze is a simple, effective measure that could be enacted without delay. Will this Council step up and do what is right for our community? We also need an eviction moratorium to prevent landlords from displacing tenants to exploit the current crisis for financial gain. For years, South Pasadena residents have asked this Council to adopt an increased relocation fee ordinance. This critical measure, also included in the Housing Element, has been ignored for too long. If residents are forced out of their homes by investor landlords or profiteering agents seeking to replace them with fire victims desperate for housing, how will they survive on a relocation fee of just one month’s rent? Where are they expected to go? Should families pitch tents in Garfield Park? Should parents uproot their children from our school district? This is both a health and economic crisis, much like the challenges we faced during COVID-19. Tens of thousands of people are newly homeless, and many more who have lost income are at risk of joining them. South Pasadena must implement robust homelessness prevention measures now. The community cannot wait months for debate or inaction. We urge you to protect South Pasadena residents with a rent freeze, an eviction moratorium, and increased relocation fees without delay. Our community is counting on your leadership in this critical moment. South Pasadena Tenants Union and South Pasadena residents 8

Megan Aaron Tim Aaron Cathy Abbey Amielynn Abellera Lindsay Adams Rilla Alexander Steve Alexander Angelo Angeles Alexander Aquino-Kaljakin Sepand Ardeshir Bree Arnall Hazard Anne Bagasao Nicholas Bain Heidi Barnett Nick Barnett Marcus Batista William Beasley Matthew Bennett Richard Blake Heather Bland Sheri Borrego Britany Brodeur Julianne Bull Denise Burciaga Greg Burns Jody Butts Ana Camacho Ricardo Casas Bianca Ciebrant Anastasia Coon Danelle Courtice David Courtice Kathrine Cruz Lula Cummings Leesa Dang Valerie de la Rosa Susan Delgadillo Rigoberto Delgadillo Grace Dennis Casey Dukes Jason Dukes Scott Dukes Denise Durrett Patti Emery Jolynn Enz Russell Farmarco Nicole Farmarco Salik Farooqi Rachael Faught Kathrin Ford Roberto Fuentes Stephany Gamez Jessica Gerhardt Cameron Gibson Paul Goetz Joseph Grijalva Wendy Gutschow Amber Haley Rachel Hamilton Alec Hamilton Vector Hasting Aidan Howard-Rede Ella Hushagen Phung Huynh Arend Jessurun Jazmin Joyce Laura Kieffer Alice Kim Tina Kistinger Jessica Klier Aileen Kutaka Caitlin Lainoff Lana Le Therese A. Le Veque Kimberly Leung-Earley Sergio Leyva Maria Angelicon Mapue Esmeralda Marcial Viri Mata Yuka Matsuyama Christine Mauer Sean McCullough Debra McCurdy Kathleen McLaughlin Michael Mesker Arianna Messmer Kimberly Ming Rhonda Mitchell Michael Mizgalski Mireya Naranjo Thank Nguyen Michael Noe Kimber Norquest Joanne Nuckols Roxy Ortiz Dean Peterson Denise Philley Hazel Portillo Fiona Purdon Karina Ramirez Erica Rede Sarah Rodman Phoenix Rodman Abraham Romwro Philip Rowland Tess Ryan Loresa Salazar Kim Seltzer Michael Serrano Delaine Shane Genevieve Sigala Laura Sorenson Kristen Swift Nick Taylor Nany Thenard Judith H. Trout Vanessa Valencia Gabriela Valle Melanie Wagner Kate Wilson Camila Zagarra Michael Zahn Priscilla Zaragoza Manuel Zaragoza 9

From: Yvonne LaRose To: City Council Public Comment Subject: Public Comment, Agenda Item 5: Fire and Windstorm Survivor Support Date: Wednesday, January 15, 2025 10:45:27 AM CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the City of South Pasadena. Do not click links or open attachments unless you recognize the sender and know the content is safe. CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the City of South Pasadena. Do not click links or open attachments unless you recognize the sender and know the content is safe. Last week I listened to Nataly Tavidian's (KNX reporter) story of losing her childhood home, as well as several other, similar interviews and realized how much support and cathartic healing needs to be provided to our own citizens and employees. Then going into the public on Thursday and Friday the realization of our need hit me in the face as I shared my thoughts at 3 different stops while also making the time to hear their stories. This made me realize we need some designated disaster recovery mental health empathizers who can LISTEN, provide feedback, simply provide supportive words, or simply be the quiet, supportive presence as the survivor mentally processes their condition. I propose that we provide listening spaces for this purpose where the support team members can be stationed for between 2 to 4 hours per day. The purpose is to genuinely be a supportive, healthy community. It's significant when there is someone available to hear the thoughts, encourage the positive memories of comfort, and create a sense of being a person whose existence has meaning and worth. As the one proposing this opportunity for community wellness, I am available and encourage you to include me in the conversations and considerations of this matter so that we are focused on the right steps to make it a reality. Viva Yvonne LaRose, CAC Organization Development Consultant: Diversity/Title VII, Harassment, Ethics 10

Dear Council, Please take the following into consideration. Arborist Biases Tree removal companies staff arborists specifically to facilitate the removal process. Arborists unaffiliated with removal companies ultimately want to win the contract. These circumstances introduce a clear bias. Certifying bodies allow for ethics violation complaints in order to combat biased reporting but absent a third party review these are difficult to make. City Staff's utilization of our City Arborist has been lackluster and opaque. The initial City Arborist approval was based upon the false premise that this was a development project yet her signature and approval was included in the presentation to the NREC nonetheless. This agenda presents the first mention of an informed interaction with our City Arborist: “Following this report, the City Arborist reviewed the findings and, although acknowledging some concerns, approved the removal based on the arborist's assessment.” From this reading it appears that our City Arborist did not stand before the trees and make an independent assessment. Her concerns remain unknown. I had a master arborist that I know take a look at the applicant's arborist's report and they see nothing unusual about the palms. They don't appear diseased and the frond dieback appears to be of the standard variety for palms. Hazard claims are increasing and staff is asking for heightened ministerial authority while avoiding transparent independent review. It has been nine months since the start of the application process. Why hasn't the city arborist been to the site and why don't we have any kind of report from her? The City of Pasadena utilizes independent arborists for review of all protected tree removal applications. This results in active, practicing arborists providing unbiased opinions and recommendations. Safety Leaving the healthy palms unpruned has actually created a hazardous situation. The applicant has acknowledged this danger of falling fronds and instead of having the trees pruned to mitigate the danger chose to lead in his initial stand at the NREC podium with a threat of lawsuit if something were to happen as a result of injury caused by fallen fronds. Regular strong winds in the area routinely remove deadwood from trees. This is a normal part of a tree's lifecycle in a forest setting. This process should not be relied upon in an urban setting. 11

When fire comes with high winds the hanging deadwood creates an extreme fire hazard. This is true for all trees but especially important with palm frond dieback due to their unique ability to create a large amount of embers. This is even more important with the large size of Canary Island Palm fronds. This is a good reason to remove the palms but an extremely poor precedent to set with regards to upkeep of deadwood removal. Current Status The recent winds have caused the dropping of most of the dead fronds. The canopy is now considerably more visible from street level observation. There is absolutely no indication of Fusarium Wilt and the City Arborist would have a clear view to see that if she were to stand before the trees. Replacement Selection Japanese Maple A commissioner recommended that the Japanese Maple in the back yard be better selected for size and drought tolerance. No acknowledgment has been made to it being incorrectly placed next to the wall of Arborvitae mentioned in my appeal. Not only is there not enough room for the canopy of the miniaturized maple species the applicant has chosen but the tree would be immediately and perpetually in competition with the roots of the established trees well within its dripline. Fruit Trees Fruit trees should not constitute a majority of the replacements. My appeal mentions the inappropriateness of Gala Apples but I'll explain further. Fruit trees are very different than non-fruit trees. They should often be optimized to be small. The apricot and plum trees should be pruned short and with an open center. If done correctly they will not represent any kind of meaningful contribution to our urban canopy– aesthetically or ecologically. The orange tree however could be grown large and significant and would no doubt be culturally appropriate for a property on "Orange Grove Avenue". Front Yard Palo Verde and Crepe Myrtle are probably the most common replacements being planted in South Pasadena. They grow quickly and produce vibrant floral displays. It can be confusing when discussing them because there are different subspecies and hybrids that come in different sizes and shapes. Palo Verde 12

Palo Verde in general are native to the Arizona/Mexico desert. They are not adapted to cycles of torrential rain and drought-fueled fire. The "Desert Museum" Palo Verde is a hybrid palo verde invented in the 70s. Its especially quick growth comes at the expense of branch strength and root/crown balance. There are ample accounts on the internet of branches breaking or the entire tree uprooting in strong winds or heavy saturation from rain. Correct pruning and watering practices are vital to their long term success. I have not seen a single Palo Verde in the city pruned correctly to produce a safe, full canopy capable of standing the test of time. Crepe Myrtle Crepe Myrtle trees are small and insignificant. They have limited ecological value and provide little benefit to our urban canopy. Replacement Plan Details In my most recent appeal I confused the placement of the Crepe Myrtle and Palo Verde. As a result the placement of these trees is not incorrect as I stated. I apologize for the confusion. I believe Staff should expect tree replacement plans to represent the mature canopy size of the species. This would have prevented my mistake and in general provide a much clearer understanding to all parties involved of the canopy before and after removal and replacement. I have raised this issue with Public Works and Planning on several occasions and the response has been that you can't determine the eventual size of the canopy. This is incorrect and represents the lack of foresight being put into the replacement process. On-Site Natives Several times throughout the process natives were asked for by the commission. There are zero native replacements. The applicant stated at one point: “Commissioner Bourke had an issue that these were not native trees. If that is still a concern I'm happy to address that by simply saying that we can also donate whatever the amount is needed to plant native trees somewhere else if that's still a point of contention.” Conclusion Every single tree decision has lasting consequences. Staff speaks of an aging canopy as if it is an inherent problem. This is simply incorrect. Trees will stick around longer than the property owner owns the property. This 13

requires property owners to inherit the decisions made before them and make sound decisions for future owners. This is why we have a tree code. The spirit of our tree code is not being upheld and this is just one of many examples of it. Please consider the future of South Pasadena's canopy one hundred years from now. Recommendations While our climate swings have clearly become more extreme the fundamentals have remained the same–multi year dry seasons leading to wind-fueled fire events and interspersed torrential rains. Native trees

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Action agendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
MinutesNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Transcript or captionsNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Official pages

Coverage and corrections

Records considered

  • Additional Documents
  • Additional Documents — Packet

Not claimed by this page

  • Verified meeting decisions with item-specific public-source evidence
  • Item-level plain-language summaries are not available; this page does not infer individual agenda items.
  • Item-linked, attributed deliberation
  • A source-grounded next meeting date
  • A plain-English overview is not available.
  • Official outcomes have not been published.
  • A transcript is not available.
  • No audio or video recording is linked.
  • Speakers have not been reliably matched to public profiles.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.
  • An individual roll-call roster is not available.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: 2fd89b30fb5048585e7161ad029d0d92. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record