POLISCOPE

The public record

GLENDALE (LOS ANGELES COUNTY)Decisions and attributed speech publishedPartial coverage

Planning Hearing Officer Meeting

Wednesday, January 29, 2020 · Government meeting record

The 30-second read

Recorded outcome

Planning Hearing Officer Meeting

Why it matters

The official meeting record is available below. Item-level plain-language summaries are not available yet.

What happens next

No later meeting or follow-up date is stated in the reviewed record.

An official outcome record and a transcript or captions are published for this meeting.

Transcript and record text

Closed captionsWhat was said at the meeting, transcribed Aug 3, 2026. Speech is not a decision.
  • No speaker turns were supplied with this transcript.
  • This transcript has no source timestamps.
  • No speaker identities were supplied with this transcript.

This source published text without speaker turns, so speakers and timestamps are not shown.

they came them self and saying alternative number one is not good because there is 13. Why you are basing all the time and the money and the city resources, our resources and so forth. I didn' t even touch the issue of the liability because I am involved a lot of big lawsuits. The city by itself [Indiscernible] Have to consider because if you go, I did mention that, let' s go to the page, I will show, page, one of these speaker at the time , by the way I put that on their , that part of 17, speaker 16 person in the hearing of August 6, 2019, opposed to this. 95% of the people -- mayor najarian: that is something different. Those were 5g discussions. This is 4g. How is putting this facility on, which would be an existing or adjacent to an existing like paul, stopping -- light pole, stopping you from your development? You have many more issues of light -- then a light pole to develop a 30 story tower. Tell me how. The only way I can give you your appeal is if you tell me this is going to interfere with your development and the glendale municipal code even takes that into account, that says if in the future you can tell us how it is preventing you from developing, at the cost of the applicant, he has to, or they have to remove that and put it to another place. It May be two years, three years, five years, the plans you gave us are for -- from 2005. Why shouldn' t we let them do it now and if in two years, three years, you are saying I can' t develop it, we shouldn' t let them replace it to another location? >> I am a businessman. Even eventually affect our financial issue because we have to disclose to all of our occupant of apartment or condo or whatever, all of this issue we have. That by itself prevent a lot of sensitive people, especially high and residents, that are coming to this. As you know, in the left six or seven years, 3, 4, 5000, five story was built. They are selling $2000 per square foot. You have opportunity that a developer like us to come to the city and erect something of that magnitude and we are requesting even your own start of the at&t saying -- expert of the at&t saying [Indiscernible] When you put it in that area, you have more open [Indiscernible] And so forth. Mayor najarian: are you going to tell your people that you are 50 feet from a freeway, one of the very busy freeways, and there are fumes and particulate matter? Is that worse than an at&t tower? >> at&t wanted to put it there and we talked with the city council, during the motion, we were -- mayor najarian: you can say excellent phone reception and charge extra for that. Because I don' t have excellent phone reception at my house and it is a problem for me. Thank you. Are there any other questions? Councilmember devine: I would like to have the doctor come up again. I noticed a lot of speakers were at the podium, you were taking copious notes and I would like to hear what you have written down in response to some of their allegations and especially about the nepa. Ok. >> the reference to the cherokee indians, the statement the speaker made was absolutely correct and has no applicability to us. Let me tell you why. The key is the title of the case. The hand of indians, that relates to federal property. Neppa applies to project on federal property, this is not, and projects funded by federal dollars, this is not. It is outside of nepa. Is something we hear a lot. But as to that carveout on federal property, correct, the D.C. Circuit overturned that. But that was a very limited overturning on a very specific set of basically two prongs. The issue of pollution, I tell you, if I was critiquing verizon' s attorney to find every possible carveout to offer an insurance policy and not have to pay off on it, I would probably put something like tooth -- third tuesday of every week too. The issue is that you are facing complete federal preemption. It is not something you consider because we are just not allowed to. It just isn' t possible for us to consider. The only question we have under both state and federal law and regulations is, does the proposed project before you comply with the fcc rules? As your expert, the person who co-authored the fcc' s' s guide to local governments on the subject, I' m telling you it does. That is the end of that exploration. In terms of the landscaping damage question, it ties back again to rf. If it is going to interfere because of rf, again, the question would be if a sell side went in and was going to be proposed within the drip loop of a tree, that would be something we could deal with. Because it is not rf related. But this is just not within your authority to do. I was writing notes everywhere. I believe that was what I have, yes, that is what I' ve got. Questions? Councilmember quintero: rf technology, the cell technology, is only line of sight? It literally has to be lined up with other cell sites? >> at the frequencies that are used, they are not 100% line of sight. For example, we are not line of sight to a cell site in this building. Yet cell phones will still work. There is some building penetration by the signal, not a lot. It normally loses about 90% of the power is lost when you come through a wall. But these are very low power, the cell phones operate on very low power. The practical matter is, the network is designed to penetrate into homes and cars, to serve people walking on the street. Line of sight is important, but at the frequencies we are talking about for the cell site, focusing back to this appeal, which is really important to stay on the facts of this appeal, it is just not a consideration. Line of sight helps, but it is not the defining factor. Mayor najarian: thank you. Councilmember devine: one more question. She mentioned this has never been safety tested and-or post-market tested. Or surveyed. >> again, these relate back exactly to rf safety, which is out of your purview. I' m sorry. That is just the way the federal and state laws work. I will be available. Mayor najarian: Mr. City attorney, if we made a finding discussing rf dangers, would that be grounds for overturning a decision by this council? City attorney garcia: it would be against our recommendation because we are pretty clear we are preempting on the rf. mayor najarian: somebody would take us on a writ? They would consider rf, it is out of their purview, their decision is over? Yes? Councilmember agajanian: who owns the land by that poll -- that pole? Councilmember devine: he does. >> the appellant' s company. Mayor najarian: the vacant land on north maryland. >> that is saying ownership. Councilmember agajanian: they own land? Mayor najarian: yes. They bought it. Councilmember quintero: all right, I' m ready. Mayor najarian: I' m going to give the applicant a chance and the appellant will have last shot, then we can discuss argument. Let me call up the applicant again. You have five minutes if you would like to make any closing comments or rebuttal. You are good? You' re going to stand pat? Sir, you have the last chance to argue before council. For five minutes. >> when I came from pennsylvania in 1977, california, land [Indiscernible] And we have very, I am living in [Indiscernible] Connection with glendale. This item prevent us to come to spend more money and more effort . Currently right now, in process of developing the 17 acre in city of santana, [Indiscernible] Went to the city of santana, become the director, he change our property to new downtown, they are putting 934 apartments there and 200 existing medical facility. All of this negative in glendale push us back to not come here. I am requesting the city council put aside at&t to come to a small people like us that we are trying to do something good for the city and they push us back. I am requesting again that please go to the alternative number one. Doesn' t affect us at all and if you pay for that removal of the tree, whatever location, the city approved, pay for the cost and -- mayor najarian: thank you. Counsel can deliberate and argue. Discuss. Councilmember quintero: I did drive by the site to take a look at it, and I think I will -- I think alternative one is a perfectly logical site. It is off the freeway, with clear visibility east to west, and I repeat once again, north to south along maryland. So I think that is a perfectly logical site. It appears that at&t would have to spend a few more bucks to go across the street to that site, since running along the sidewalk , the representative indicated it is only five or six feet away so this would mean going 30 feet or whatever that distances. I think technically, it absolutely what the -- would be an equal or better site and consequently, give equal or better service. So that would be my motion. City attorney garcia: that is ultimately the direction of the council, it would be a motion to hold appeal, do not the site -- deny the site based on the finding about the alternative and we would ask you direct us to prepare findings consistent with that. Councilmember quintero: then whether the applicant pays to move the tree or not, I guess that is a separate issue at a separate time, whether we hold him to that possibility. But anyway, I think that is a perfectly logical location for it, and there is no question that it can be done. It doesn' t put a tremendous burden on at&t to do that. Let me just comment in terms of our expert, basically the fcc, and this doesn' t have anything to do with the motion or maybe even what we were discussing tonight, but in 1997, the fcc set standards. Do we have some idea of what has transpired since 1997? We are in 2020. It is like multiple, multiple increase in usage and rf waves and everything else that is out in the sky. So the fact that the providers like at&t and verizon and every, everyone else, the fact that they haven' t been sort of forced to do some research, to try to establish what medical consequences might be taking place, I find that, I don' t find it amazing because that is how politics work in washington, D.C. So I am not at all impressed that a few years ago, the fcc said, we will just continue with the standards from 1997. Boy, I sure wish we in fact could get some of the providers to begin to fund organizations that could do some research to see if it is true or not. Maybe as a matter of fact, it is not true, that there are no consequences to all of the different radio waves, but I don' t believe the ssue has been examined the way it should be. Councilmember devine: I would agree with councilmember quintero. I want to thank Dr. Kramer. It seems that this was a really unbiased opinion, and based totally on legal standards and law, and I appreciate that. I think, I can make the findings that alternate number one should be the location. The tree is not an issue. They are willing to take care of the tree. Dr. Kramer says it is the same as the other side except, even if, mayor najarian, with all due respect, I think of the opposite way that you did. Let' s say eventually, you are going to have to move it or you might have to move it, put it here then move it later. I the opinion that put it in the right place first, then nobody has to worry about moving it or changing it or anything. It is, it is in a good location. So I would, I would uphold the appeal and ask for relocation. Agreeing with councilmember quintero. Mayor najarian: are we on the record that you are approving another 30 story tower on north -- this is what this is all about because he is saying this is going to prevent him from developing that 30 story, 300 foot development. Here it is, folks. So I think this development is eons and light years away from ever seeing reality, especially since there is another huge development that is coming through just adjacent to this. So I don' t see this ever being developed in this manner. What' s more, this isn' t about alternative one being better than the current location. That is not what is is about. That is not a basis for denying the current location. Tell me, tell the applicant, why the current location is bad. We have a list of criteria, I haven' t heard one of those criteria being expressed today. Even the appellant himself couldn' t tell me why it is not going to be, why it is interfering with his development. These were just vague answers he was giving. The amount of construction, even if this were to be approved by some development loving counsel a few years from now, the amount of excavation and work and disturbance that that would provide is, factors more than a single light pole with a tower on it. i think we have to have findings. I' m not sure any findings have been enunciated. I think we are going to see a vacant lot there for many, many years to come, and to deny the placement of the facility at that location on the presumption, you guys are saying this will be built. And this will be interfering with the applicant, the appellant' s construction. I don' t know if the news press sees this. This is the new one. We are, on the city council, saying we can' t put the 4g facility there because we are going to disturb his development rights? There are so many issues before this thing gets anywhere close to seeing the light of day than a 4g pole in the public right-of-way that meets each and every one of our requirements under the municipal code. Somebody point out to me what of the six, one of the 10 points of the municipal code is not met by the placement of this. Because we are going to have to make a finding when you deny this, if that is where the vote is going. I don' t like it can be done. I think you are putting our city attorney into the position of making silk out of a spider' s web. I don' t think, because we haven' t heard it, there has been no evidence before us. You are saying alternative one is better, that is not the issue here. It is not whether number one is better, number two is better, what is wrong with the current site? We have rules we have to follow. Even in the future there is an issue with this development, then the at&t company is under the burden of replacing it and putting it in another spot. Councilmember devine: I think I can cite finding number seven, alternative sites analysis. That is what the doctor has done and he has told us the second of the alternative is just as good as the other alternatives. Mayor najarian: is that what you said, Dr.? Alternative one is the same -- councilmember devine: it is right here. Mayor najarian: we heard evidence from at&t that alternative one is not as good and there has been no other evidence on that besides the at&t evidence that came forward. >> my analysis is that the coverage from alternative one would be essentially equal to that of the proposed site. Mayor najarian: but not better. >> I' m going to be very conservative and just stop where I have said and say that it is at least equal based on my experience as an expert in rf transmission. >> based on a commonsense observation of this site, it is way more open than it would be on the site at&t has chosen. i just have a feeling, and this is not scientific, but I have a feeling just like any construction project, if you are five feet from power and five feet from the fiber, let' s go ahead and pick this one, why go across the street and over to the side? It is only going to be more expensive -- certainly going to be more expensive for at&t but I think it makes more sense in terms of location the next to someday what will be a project. It will never be what was proposed in 2005, but it is a nice empty lot. I think in the past, we have considered buying it for a formal housing if I remember -- affordable housing if I remember correctly. One of these days, double b housing built there, two-story or three-story. At any rate, I think this location is more open, clear visibility, direct site, direct line of sight to other towers and I am fine with it. Mayor najarian: ok. City attorney garcia: just to reiterate, it is true that the decision of the council can' t be based on, shouldn' t be based on the proposed, the project that the appellant has spoken to only because it is not a relevant inquiry. There is a mechanism that deals with that and the council does have the authority to consider the alternative site and its analysis -- in its analysis but have -- has to make an affirmative finding that there is a legitimate time, place, manner location it is in. If you find it to be in -- more aesthetically pleasing in the proposed site, that is what I was hearing from you, that would be a proper basis. We will certainly bring those findings back based on your comments and what is in the record if that ends up being, the recommendation still from the staff obviously is to approve it, approve the application, deny the appeal on the basis that the alternative site is equal to, not better than and it is, you are not getting any additional benefit by putting it on another alternative site in a preferred versus nonpreferred location but that is your decision at this point. Mayor najarian: the only problem with that is, the basis for this appeal is that it was interfering with his development rights. This council has gone further than the appellant has gone. Maybe they should hire you for his legal team because those are not the arguments he made. Those are not the arguments he made. Are we ready for a vote councilmember quintero: I am frankly not interested in the proposed development. I am taking a look at this and looking at the two locations. One is right off the freeway with nothing but open space and a clear shot down maryland, and that makes a lot more sense than on a side street. Councilmember devine: you made a motion, I will second it. Mayor najarian: your motion is to -- >> granting the appeal of the director of public works and continue the matter until February 11, 2020 for the city attorney to prepare findings. Mayor najarian: let' s take roll call. We will close the public hearing. Roll call. Councilmember agajanian: no. Councilmember gharpetian: councilmember quintero: yes. Councilmember devine: yes. Mayor najarian: no. So back to one of the first questions I asked for the evening. What do we do? >> you can have further discussion, the motion died. So unless you have further discussion or take a further motion, it will be brought back to next week' s agenda for further discussion. In the interim I will research the ability of Mr. Gharpetian to participate. It would be a recommendation to resolve it tonight. Mayor najarian: is there any argument that has not been made by anyone -- councilmember devine: I would like to hear Mr. Agajanian' s reason. Mayor najarian: I think that is where we will end it for tonight, unresolved. We will see you next week. City attorney garcia: we will ask the matter be continued until next week' s meeting. There will not be full -- for the public comment. Mayor najarian: I encouraged the parties to communicate with each other, and in the event you can seek a resolution outside of counsel -- council' s per view, we recommend that. Don' t we, Mr. Garcia? City attorney garcia: certainly. Councilmember agajanian: I would rather discuss with each other, as they told us, they discussed the matter. Mayor najarian: we have given them a next rate incentive because they will have to be back next week. Please speak with each other and you have heard how the council is laying on this and that will be at. Next item. >> oral communications, discussion is limited to items not a part of this agenda. Each speaker is allowed five minutes. Counsel May question or response to the speaker but there will be no debate or decision. The city manager May refer the matter to the appropriate department for investigation and report. I have one card. Mayor najarian: we have one card. I have a card from rafi. Please keep it down, folks, as you exit the chambers. >> hello again, how are you? So several months ago -- mayor najarian: just a moment, let' s make sure you get the full attention of the council. >> I appreciate that. Thank you. mayor najarian: ok. Thank you. Let' s start the clock. >> several months ago, I addressed the council in regards to the review of current building codes causing adverse effect, surrey, of verse impact on the development of basic small-scale multifamily units in glendale. That day, you voted unanimously to bring the matter to the table and have a full discussion. The items we discussed that you wanted to study was, the restriction of height on the subterranean parking structure, to only three foot above ground. I mentioned that that was causing a great hardship and a great amount of difficulty in porder to produce these small lots with 4, 5 or up to six units. It is very difficult when you have to dig down so deep and have to spend, you know, $250,000 shoring because when you dig deep, you have to shore around the property. So that, these things add up and it becomes almost impossible and people that are building those units are maybe breaking even. There is nothing in it. Restrictions, the second one is, the restriction of overall height to 26 foot. That is also come on small lots, that is not enough height to produce. For example, I have a 7000 square foot lot and with that height limit, I will not be able to produce five units. Currently, there are lots smaller than mine that support six units. this is a 1250, high density zone. The third item was eliminate the requirement of 200 square foot open lots zoned r-1250. In your own description, that is described as high density. So high density, 200 square foot open-space, they don' t really jive. Allow an additional 10 foot canopy to support some -- solar panels. That is something we have discussed as well. Right now, if I were to build the building, if I wanted to put a canopy on the roof I don' think that would be allowed, but I think it should. Instead of laying panels flat on the roof, I am suggesting we allow the canopy, then you can utilize the area on the roof for maybe recreation. Also, allow an additional, lastly, take any other available measures to facilitate and promote this type of lower impact and more affordable development, which is more suitable to the average glendale resident. That is my presentation and I hope I can get some feedback. This was supposed to come back, if somebody could tell me when it is going to come back. Mayor najarian: thank you. Can you give us some idea? >> you give us direction to go look at it and indeed, we have started that task. As I described a little bit, we are combining that with the south glendale community plan tropico. We are on a clock for that, so we put the two together because tropical -- will inform the rest of that. We' re going through the planning exercise. We have also sought a grant that will help us accelerate that time. We should have this no later than the end of the year. As we go all through developing the code, bringing it to the planning commission, bringing it back to you. If we can get the grant, which we believe we well, we can perhaps have that earlier am a maybe late-summer. Mayor najarian: thank you. I have no other cards. Do we have new business? City attorney garcia: we have one item. The council met in closed session to discuss initiation litigation pursuant to government code section 54956.9 d 4, anticipated litigation in the closed session counsel give us the authority or requesting authority to file an amended street of appeal -- administrative appeal with another public agency. At the time the matter is filed and served, we can provide information on that lawsuit to any person interested. So we request that motion. Mayor najarian: would someone like to move that iago >> I will move the item. Councilmember agajanian: yes. Councilmember gharpetian: yes. Councilmember quintero: yes. Councilmember devine: yes. Mayor najarian: yes. That concludes our business is there a motion to adjourn? We are adjourned.

GLENDALE PLANNING HEARING OFFICER GLENDALE COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DEPARTMENT PUBLIC HEARING MINUTES JANUARY 29, 2020 9:30 a.m. Ms. Milca Toledo, Planning Hearing Officer, opened the hearing in Room 105 of the Municipal Services Building. She outlined the requirements of Title 30 for the pertinent cases and described the provisions for appeal in Title 30 of the Glendale Municipal Code as well as the procedures for the conduct of the hearings. Ms. Toledo announced that the agenda for the meeting was posted on January 22, 2020, at the City Hall Entrance. Staff Members Present – Community Development Department 1) Milca Toledo, Planning Hearing Officer 2) Vilia Zemaitaitis, Principal Planner 3) Cassandra Pruett, Planner (1) LOCATION: 2508 SAINT ANDREWS DRIVE  VARIANCE CASE NO. PVAR 1726875 APPLICANT: Kaaren Khoudikian OWNER: Ara Vartanian ZONE: “RIR” (Restricted Residential) Zone, FAR District III LEGAL DESCRIPTION: Lot 3 of Tract No. 9039 PROJECT DESCRIPTION The applicant is requesting the approval of a standards variance to construct a new 2,010 square-foot (SF), three-story single-family residence with an attached two-car garage on a vacant 6,708 SF lot, which is less than the code-required 7,500 SF minimum lot size in the R1R (FAR District III) zone. The lot features an average current slope of 60%. CODE REQUIRES (1) The minimum lot size for purposes of constructing a new dwelling unit on lots divided prior to June 26, 1986 is seven thousand five hundred (7,500) square feet (GMC 30.11.030 and GMC 30.11.060).

Planning Hearing Officer Minutes January 29, 2020 2 APPLICANT’S PROPOSAL (1) To construct a single-family residence on a vacant 6,708 square-foot lot. ENVIRONMENTAL DETERMINATION The project is exempt from CEQA review as a Class 3 “New Construction or Conversion of Small Structures” exemption, pursuant to Section 15303 of the State CEQA Guidelines because it is a new dwelling unit in a residential zone. Staff - Ms. Vilia Zemaitaitis, case planner, stated that this agenda item will be continued to regularly scheduled hearing of February 19, 2020, because the property was not posted by the applicant. (2) LOCATION: 800 NORTH PACIFIC AVENUE  PARKING REDUCTION CASE NO. PPRP 1923119 APPLICANT: Jefferson Choi, Synarc Studio BUSINESS NAME: Mobil Gas ZONE: “C2-II” - (Community Commercial, Height District II) LEGAL DESCRIPTION: Portions of Lot 38 and Lot 45, Oliver’s West Glendale Tract PROJECT DESCRIPTION Application for a Parking Reduction Permit to provide seven parking spaces for a new 1,789 square-foot (SF) retail building and a new 1,790 SF self-service car wash, whereas ten parking spaces are required by Code (seven for the retail building and three for the car wash). CODE REQUIRES For retail buildings, four parking spaces per thousand SF of floor area ([1,789/1,000]*4 = 7 parking spaces) and one parking space per washing module plus two parking spaces for a self-service car wash. APPLICANT’S PROPOSAL To provide seven parking spaces instead of the code-required ten parking spaces. ENVIRONMENTAL DETERMINATION The project is exempt from review under the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) as a Class 32 In-Fill Development Project. Staff - Ms. Cassandra Pruett, case planner, presented the project. She answered questions from the Planning Hearing Officer.

Planning Hearing Officer Minutes January 29, 2020 3 Applicant - Mr. Eric Liwskei, applicant and consultant on the project, and representing the applicant and the owner, presented the case. WRITTEN PUBLIC INPUT In Favor: None In Opposition: None. Interested Party - Letter from a neighbor (no name provided) SPEAKING AT THE HEARING In Favor - S. Lewis - C. Overesaard In Opposition: No one. Interested Party: No one. The case was taken under submission for a decision to be made at a later date. The meeting adjourned at 11:00 a.m. sm

Welcome to the meeting of the Planning Hearing Officer. Meetings are broadcast live on cable channel 6 (GTV6) and rebroadcast throughout the week. Call (818) 548-4013 for program schedules. DVDs of the proceedings are available for purchase in the City Clerk’s Office by calling (818) 548-2090. PLEASE TURN OFF CELLULAR PHONES AND PAGERS WHILE INSIDE THE MUNICIPAL SERVICES BUILDING, ROOM 105. In compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) of 1990, auxiliary hearing aids, sign language translation, and Braille transcripts are available upon request. Assisted listening devices are available same-day upon request. At least 48 hours (or two business days) notice is required for requests regarding sign language translation and Braille transcription services. If you have any question about matters on the agenda, or requests for assistance, please contact the Community Development Department at (818) 548-2115 during regular business hours. JANUARY 29, 2020 9:30 A.M. (1) LOCATION: 2508 SAINT ANDREWS DRIVE  VARIANCE CASE NO. PVAR 1726875 APPLICANT: Kaaren Khoudikian OWNER: Ara Vartanian STAFF: Vilia Zemaitaitis PROJECT DESCRIPTION Application for a Variance to construct a new 2,010 square-foot, three-story single-family residence with an attached two-car garage on a vacant 6,708 square-foot lot, which is less than the code-required 7,500 SF minimum lot size in the R1R (FAR District III) zone. The lot features an average current slope of 60%, and is located in the “RIR” (Restricted Residential) Zone, FAR District III, described as Lot 3 of Tract No. 9039, in the City of Glendale, County of Los Angeles. ENVIRONMENTAL DETERMINATION The project is exempt from CEQA review as a Class 3 “New Construction or Conversion of Small Structures” exemption, pursuant to Section 15303 of the State CEQA Guidelines because it is a new dwelling unit in a residential zone. Continued…page two – A G E N D A – REGULAR MEETING OF THE PLANNING HEARING OFFICER CITY OF GLENDALE, COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DEPARTMENT MSB Room 105, 633 East Broadway, Glendale, CA 91206

A G E N D A REGULAR MEETING OF THE PLANNING HEARING OFFICER January 29, 2020 2 (2) LOCATION: 800 NORTH PACIFIC AVENUE  PARKING REDUCTION PERMIT NO. PPRP 1923119 APPLICANT: Jefferson Choi, Synarc Studio BUSINESS NAME: Mobil Gas STAFF: Cassandra Pruett PROJECT DESCRIPTION Application for a Parking Reduction Permit to provide seven parking spaces for a new 1,789 square-foot retail building and a new 1,790 square-foot self-service car wash, whereas ten parking spaces are required by Code (seven for the retail building and three for the car wash), in the “C2-II” - (Community Commercial, Height District II) Zone, described as Portions of Lot 38 and Lot 45, Oliver’s West Glendale Tract, in the City of Glendale, County of Los Angeles. ENVIRONMENTAL DETERMINATION The project is exempt from review under the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) as a Class 32 In-Fill Development Project. Date Agenda Posted: January 22, 2020 KA:sm

Showing the first 24,000 of 24,010 characters. The full document is at the source.

they came them self and saying alternative number one is not good because there is 13. Why you are basing all the time and the money and the city resources, our resources and so forth. I didn' t even touch the issue of the liability because I am involved a lot of big lawsuits. The city by itself [Indiscernible] Have to consider because if you go, I did mention that, let' s go to the page, I will show, page, one of these speaker at the time , by the way I put that on their , that part of 17, speaker 16 person in the hearing of August 6, 2019, opposed to this. 95% of the people -- mayor najarian: that is something different. Those were 5g discussions. This is 4g. How is putting this facility on, which would be an existing or adjacent to an existing like paul, stopping -- light pole, stopping you from your development? You have many more issues of light -- then a light pole to develop a 30 story tower. Tell me how. The only way I can give you your appeal is if you tell me this is going to interfere with your development and the glendale municipal code even takes that into account, that says if in the future you can tell us how it is preventing you from developing, at the cost of the applicant, he has to, or they have to remove that and put it to another place. It May be two years, three years, five years, the plans you gave us are for -- from 2005. Why shouldn' t we let them do it now and if in two years, three years, you are saying I can' t develop it, we shouldn' t let them replace it to another location? >> I am a businessman. Even eventually affect our financial issue because we have to disclose to all of our occupant of apartment or condo or whatever, all of this issue we have. That by itself prevent a lot of sensitive people, especially high and residents, that are coming to this. As you know, in the left six or seven years, 3, 4, 5000, five story was built. They are selling $2000 per square foot. You have opportunity that a developer like us to come to the city and erect something of that magnitude and we are requesting even your own start of the at&t saying -- expert of the at&t saying [Indiscernible] When you put it in that area, you have more open [Indiscernible] And so forth. Mayor najarian: are you going to tell your people that you are 50 feet from a freeway, one of the very busy freeways, and there are fumes and particulate matter? Is that worse than an at&t tower? >> at&t wanted to put it there and we talked with the city council, during the motion, we were -- mayor najarian: you can say excellent phone reception and charge extra for that. Because I don' t have excellent phone reception at my house and it is a problem for me. Thank you. Are there any other questions? Councilmember devine: I would like to have the doctor come up again. I noticed a lot of speakers were at the podium, you were taking copious notes and I would like to hear what you have written down in response to some of their allegations and especially about the nepa. Ok. >> the reference to the cherokee indians, the statement the speaker made was absolutely correct and has no applicability to us. Let me tell you why. The key is the title of the case. The hand of indians, that relates to federal property. Neppa applies to project on federal property, this is not, and projects funded by federal dollars, this is not. It is outside of nepa. Is something we hear a lot. But as to that carveout on federal property, correct, the D.C. Circuit overturned that. But that was a very limited overturning on a very specific set of basically two prongs. The issue of pollution, I tell you, if I was critiquing verizon' s attorney to find every possible carveout to offer an insurance policy and not have to pay off on it, I would probably put something like tooth -- third tuesday of every week too. The issue is that you are facing complete federal preemption. It is not something you consider because we are just not allowed to. It just isn' t possible for us to consider. The only question we have under both state and federal law and regulations is, does the proposed project before you comply with the fcc rules? As your expert, the person who co-authored the fcc' s' s guide to local governments on the subject, I' m telling you it does. That is the end of that exploration. In terms of the landscaping damage question, it ties back again to rf. If it is going to interfere because of rf, again, the question would be if a sell side went in and was going to be proposed within the drip loop of a tree, that would be something we could deal with. Because it is not rf related. But this is just not within your authority to do. I was writing notes everywhere. I believe that was what I have, yes, that is what I' ve got. Questions? Councilmember quintero: rf technology, the cell technology, is only line of sight? It literally has to be lined up with other cell sites? >> at the frequencies that are used, they are not 100% line of sight. For example, we are not line of sight to a cell site in this building. Yet cell phones will still work. There is some building penetration by the signal, not a lot. It normally loses about 90% of the power is lost when you come through a wall. But these are very low power, the cell phones operate on very low power. The practical matter is, the network is designed to penetrate into homes and cars, to serve people walking on the street. Line of sight is important, but at the frequencies we are talking about for the cell site, focusing back to this appeal, which is really important to stay on the facts of this appeal, it is just not a consideration. Line of sight helps, but it is not the defining factor. Mayor najarian: thank you. Councilmember devine: one more question. She mentioned this has never been safety tested and-or post-market tested. Or surveyed. >> again, these relate back exactly to rf safety, which is out of your purview. I' m sorry. That is just the way the federal and state laws work. I will be available. Mayor najarian: Mr. City attorney, if we made a finding discussing rf dangers, would that be grounds for overturning a decision by this council? City attorney garcia: it would be against our recommendation because we are pretty clear we are preempting on the rf. mayor najarian: somebody would take us on a writ? They would consider rf, it is out of their purview, their decision is over? Yes? Councilmember agajanian: who owns the land by that poll -- that pole? Councilmember devine: he does. >> the appellant' s company. Mayor najarian: the vacant land on north maryland. >> that is saying ownership. Councilmember agajanian: they own land? Mayor najarian: yes. They bought it. Councilmember quintero: all right, I' m ready. Mayor najarian: I' m going to give the applicant a chance and the appellant will have last shot, then we can discuss argument. Let me call up the applicant again. You have five minutes if you would like to make any closing comments or rebuttal. You are good? You' re going to stand pat? Sir, you have the last chance to argue before council. For five minutes. >> when I came from pennsylvania in 1977, california, land [Indiscernible] And we have very, I am living in [Indiscernible] Connection with glendale. This item prevent us to come to spend more money and more effort . Currently right now, in process of developing the 17 acre in city of santana, [Indiscernible] Went to the city of santana, become the director, he change our property to new downtown, they are putting 934 apartments there and 200 existing medical facility. All of this negative in glendale push us back to not come here. I am requesting the city council put aside at&t to come to a small people like us that we are trying to do something good for the city and they push us back. I am requesting again that please go to the alternative number one. Doesn' t affect us at all and if you pay for that removal of the tree, whatever location, the city approved, pay for the cost and -- mayor najarian: thank you. Counsel can deliberate and argue. Discuss. Councilmember quintero: I did drive by the site to take a look at it, and I think I will -- I think alternative one is a perfectly logical site. It is off the freeway, with clear visibility east to west, and I repeat once again, north to south along maryland. So I think that is a perfectly logical site. It appears that at&t would have to spend a few more bucks to go across the street to that site, since running along the sidewalk , the representative indicated it is only five or six feet away so this would mean going 30 feet or whatever that distances. I think technically, it absolutely what the -- would be an equal or better site and consequently, give equal or better service. So that would be my motion. City attorney garcia: that is ultimately the direction of the council, it would be a motion to hold appeal, do not the site -- deny the site based on the finding about the alternative and we would ask you direct us to prepare findings consistent with that. Councilmember quintero: then whether the applicant pays to move the tree or not, I guess that is a separate issue at a separate time, whether we hold him to that possibility. But anyway, I think that is a perfectly logical location for it, and there is no question that it can be done. It doesn' t put a tremendous burden on at&t to do that. Let me just comment in terms of our expert, basically the fcc, and this doesn' t have anything to do with the motion or maybe even what we were discussing tonight, but in 1997, the fcc set standards. Do we have some idea of what has transpired since 1997? We are in 2020. It is like multiple, multiple increase in usage and rf waves and everything else that is out in the sky. So the fact that the providers like at&t and verizon and every, everyone else, the fact that they haven' t been sort of forced to do some research, to try to establish what medical consequences might be taking place, I find that, I don' t find it amazing because that is how politics work in washington, D.C. So I am not at all impressed that a few years ago, the fcc said, we will just continue with the standards from 1997. Boy, I sure wish we in fact could get some of the providers to begin to fund organizations that could do some research to see if it is true or not. Maybe as a matter of fact, it is not true, that there are no consequences to all of the different radio waves, but I don' t believe the ssue has been examined the way it should be. Councilmember devine: I would agree with councilmember quintero. I want to thank Dr. Kramer. It seems that this was a really unbiased opinion, and based totally on legal standards and law, and I appreciate that. I think, I can make the findings that alternate number one should be the location. The tree is not an issue. They are willing to take care of the tree. Dr. Kramer says it is the same as the other side except, even if, mayor najarian, with all due respect, I think of the opposite way that you did. Let' s say eventually, you are going to have to move it or you might have to move it, put it here then move it later. I the opinion that put it in the right place first, then nobody has to worry about moving it or changing it or anything. It is, it is in a good location. So I would, I would uphold the appeal and ask for relocation. Agreeing with councilmember quintero. Mayor najarian: are we on the record that you are approving another 30 story tower on north -- this is what this is all about because he is saying this is going to prevent him from developing that 30 story, 300 foot development. Here it is, folks. So I think this development is eons and light years away from ever seeing reality, especially since there is another huge development that is coming through just adjacent to this. So I don' t see this ever being developed in this manner. What' s more, this isn' t about alternative one being better than the current location. That is not what is is about. That is not a basis for denying the current location. Tell me, tell the applicant, why the current location is bad. We have a list of criteria, I haven' t heard one of those criteria being expressed today. Even the appellant himself couldn' t tell me why it is not going to be, why it is interfering with his development. These were just vague answers he was giving. The amount of construction, even if this were to be approved by some development loving counsel a few years from now, the amount of excavation and work and disturbance that that would provide is, factors more than a single light pole with a tower on it. i think we have to have findings. I' m not sure any findings have been enunciated. I think we are going to see a vacant lot there for many, many years to come, and to deny the placement of the facility at that location on the presumption, you guys are saying this will be built. And this will be interfering with the applicant, the appellant' s construction. I don' t know if the news press sees this. This is the new one. We are, on the city council, saying we can' t put the 4g facility there because we are going to disturb his development rights? There are so many issues before this thing gets anywhere close to seeing the light of day than a 4g pole in the public right-of-way that meets each and every one of our requirements under the municipal code. Somebody point out to me what of the six, one of the 10 points of the municipal code is not met by the placement of this. Because we are going to have to make a finding when you deny this, if that is where the vote is going. I don' t like it can be done. I think you are putting our city attorney into the position of making silk out of a spider' s web. I don' t think, because we haven' t heard it, there has been no evidence before us. You are saying alternative one is better, that is not the issue here. It is not whether number one is better, number two is better, what is wrong with the current site? We have rules we have to follow. Even in the future there is an issue with this development, then the at&t company is under the burden of replacing it and putting it in another spot. Councilmember devine: I think I can cite finding number seven, alternative sites analysis. That is what the doctor has done and he has told us the second of the alternative is just as good as the other alternatives. Mayor najarian: is that what you said, Dr.? Alternative one is the same -- councilmember devine: it is right here. Mayor najarian: we heard evidence from at&t that alternative one is not as good and there has been no other evidence on that besides the at&t evidence that came forward. >> my analysis is that the coverage from alternative one would be essentially equal to that of the proposed site. Mayor najarian: but not better. >> I' m going to be very conservative and just stop where I have said and say that it is at least equal based on my experience as an expert in rf transmission. >> based on a commonsense observation of this site, it is way more open than it would be on the site at&t has chosen. i just have a feeling, and this is not scientific, but I have a feeling just like any construction project, if you are five feet from power and five feet from the fiber, let' s go ahead and pick this one, why go across the street and over to the side? It is only going to be more expensive -- certainly going to be more expensive for at&t but I think it makes more sense in terms of location the next to someday what will be a project. It will never be what was proposed in 2005, but it is a nice empty lot. I think in the past, we have considered buying it for a formal housing if I remember -- affordable housing if I remember correctly. One of these days, double b housing built there, two-story or three-story. At any rate, I think this location is more open, clear visibility, direct site, direct line of sight to other towers and I am fine with it. Mayor najarian: ok. City attorney garcia: just to reiterate, it is true that the decision of the council can' t be based on, shouldn' t be based on the proposed, the project that the appellant has spoken to only because it is not a relevant inquiry. There is a mechanism that deals with that and the council does have the authority to consider the alternative site and its analysis -- in its analysis but have -- has to make an affirmative finding that there is a legitimate time, place, manner location it is in. If you find it to be in -- more aesthetically pleasing in the proposed site, that is what I was hearing from you, that would be a proper basis. We will certainly bring those findings back based on your comments and what is in the record if that ends up being, the recommendation still from the staff obviously is to approve it, approve the application, deny the appeal on the basis that the alternative site is equal to, not better than and it is, you are not getting any additional benefit by putting it on another alternative site in a preferred versus nonpreferred location but that is your decision at this point. Mayor najarian: the only problem with that is, the basis for this appeal is that it was interfering with his development rights. This council has gone further than the appellant has gone. Maybe they should hire you for his legal team because those are not the arguments he made. Those are not the arguments he made. Are we ready for a vote councilmember quintero: I am frankly not interested in the proposed development. I am taking a look at this and looking at the two locations. One is right off the freeway with nothing but open space and a clear shot down maryland, and that makes a lot more sense than on a side street. Councilmember devine: you made a motion, I will second it. Mayor najarian: your motion is to -- >> granting the appeal of the director of public works and continue the matter until February 11, 2020 for the city attorney to prepare findings. Mayor najarian: let' s take roll call. We will close the public hearing. Roll call. Councilmember agajanian: no. Councilmember gharpetian: councilmember quintero: yes. Councilmember devine: yes. Mayor najarian: no. So back to one of the first questions I asked for the evening. What do we do? >> you can have further discussion, the motion died. So unless you have further discussion or take a further motion, it will be brought back to next week' s agenda for further discussion. In the interim I will research the ability of Mr. Gharpetian to participate. It would be a recommendation to resolve it tonight. Mayor najarian: is there any argument that has not been made by anyone -- councilmember devine: I would like to hear Mr. Agajanian' s reason. Mayor najarian: I think that is where we will end it for tonight, unresolved. We will see you next week. City attorney garcia: we will ask the matter be continued until next week' s meeting. There will not be full -- for the public comment. Mayor najarian: I encouraged the parties to communicate with each other, and in the event you can seek a resolution outside of counsel -- council' s per view, we recommend that. Don' t we, Mr. Garcia? City attorney garcia: certainly. Councilmember agajanian: I would rather discuss with each other, as they told us, they discussed the matter. Mayor najarian: we have given them a next rate incentive because they will have to be back next week. Please speak with each other and you have heard how the council is laying on this and that will be at. Next item. >> oral communications, discussion is limited to items not a part of this agenda. Each speaker is allowed five minutes. Counsel May question or response to the speaker but there will be no debate or decision. The city manager May refer the matter to the appropriate department for investigation and report. I have one card. Mayor najarian: we have one card. I have a card from rafi. Please keep it down, folks, as you exit the chambers. >> hello again, how are you? So several months ago -- mayor najarian: just a moment, let' s make sure you get the full attention of the council. >> I appreciate that. Thank you. mayor najarian: ok. Thank you. Let' s start the clock. >> several months ago, I addressed the council in regards to the review of current building codes causing adverse effect, surrey, of verse impact on the development of basic small-scale multifamily units in glendale. That day, you voted unanimously to bring the matter to the table and have a full discussion. The items we discussed that you wanted to study was, the restriction of height on the subterranean parking structure, to only three foot above ground. I mentioned that that was causing a great hardship and a great amount of difficulty in porder to produce these small lots with 4, 5 or up to six units. It is very difficult when you have to dig down so deep and have to spend, you know, $250,000 shoring because when you dig deep, you have to shore around the property. So that, these things add up and it becomes almost impossible and people that are building those units are maybe breaking even. There is nothing in it. Restrictions, the second one is, the restriction of overall height to 26 foot. That is also come on small lots, that is not enough height to produce. For example, I have a 7000 square foot lot and with that height limit, I will not be able to produce five units. Currently, there are lots smaller than mine that support six units. this is a 1250, high density zone. The third item was eliminate the requirement of 200 square foot open lots zoned r-1250. In your own description, that is described as high density. So high density, 200 square foot open-space, they don' t really jive. Allow an additional 10 foot canopy to support some -- solar panels. That is something we have discussed as well. Right now, if I were to build the building, if I wanted to put a canopy on the roof I don' think that would be allowed, but I think it should. Instead of laying panels flat on the roof, I am suggesting we allow the canopy, then you can utilize the area on the roof for maybe recreation. Also, allow an additional, lastly, take any other available measures to facilitate and promote this type of lower impact and more affordable development, which is more suitable to the average glendale resident. That is my presentation and I hope I can get some feedback. This was supposed to come back, if somebody could tell me when it is going to come back. Mayor najarian: thank you. Can you give us some idea? >> you give us direction to go look at it and indeed, we have started that task. As I described a little bit, we are combining that with the south glendale community plan tropico. We are on a clock for that, so we put the two together because tropical -- will inform the rest of that. We' re going through the planning exercise. We have also sought a grant that will help us accelerate that time. We should have this no later than the end of the year. As we go all through developing the code, bringing it to the planning commission, bringing it back to you. If we can get the grant, which we believe we well, we can perhaps have that earlier am a maybe late-summer. Mayor najarian: thank you. I have no other cards. Do we have new business? City attorney garcia: we have one item. The council met in closed session to discuss initiation litigation pursuant to government code section 54956.9 d 4, anticipated litigation in the closed session counsel give us the authority or requesting authority to file an amended street of appeal -- administrative appeal with another public agency. At the time the matter is filed and served, we can provide information on that lawsuit to any person interested. So we request that motion. Mayor najarian: would someone like to move that iago >> I will move the item. Councilmember agajanian: yes. Councilmember gharpetian: yes. Councilmember quintero: yes. Councilmember devine: yes. Mayor najarian: yes. That concludes our business is there a motion to adjourn? We are

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
Agenda packetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Action agendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Transcript or captionsSource recordingread transcript
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Coverage and corrections

Records considered

  • Planning Hearing Officer Meeting — Minutes
  • Planning Hearing Officer Meeting
  • Planning Hearing Officer Meeting — Closed Captions

Not claimed by this page

  • Verified meeting decisions with item-specific public-source evidence
  • Item-level plain-language summaries are not available; this page does not infer individual agenda items.
  • Item-linked, attributed deliberation
  • A source-grounded next meeting date
  • A plain-English overview is not available.
  • Official outcomes have not been published.
  • The available transcript has no reliable timestamps.
  • Transcript coverage is partial.
  • Speakers have not been reliably matched to public profiles.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.
  • An individual roll-call roster is not available.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: 2dd513293ec4853a13a266a644b13a77. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record