POLISCOPE

The public record

DORAL (MIAMI-DADE COUNTY) · LOCALDecisions and attributed speech publishedPartial coverage

COUNCIL ZONING MEETING

Wednesday, June 28, 2023 · Government meeting record

The 30-second read

Recorded outcome

COUNCIL ZONING MEETING

Why it matters

The official meeting record is available below. Item-level plain-language summaries are not available yet.

What happens next

No later meeting or follow-up date is stated in the reviewed record.

An official outcome record and a transcript or captions are published for this meeting.

People and votes

4 recorded votes0 split

Split votes (0)

Every recorded vote passed unanimously.

Unanimous votes (4)

approved

Emergency Debris Removal Services — unanimous

approved

Police Training Center AC Replacement — unanimous

approved

Support for Venezuelan Adjustment Act — unanimous

approved

Tobacco and Vape Shop Distance Requirements — unanimous

Transcript and record text

Closed captionsWhat was said at the meeting, transcribed Aug 3, 2026. Speech is not a decision.
  • No speaker turns were supplied with this transcript.
  • This transcript has no source timestamps.
  • No speaker identities were supplied with this transcript.

This source published text without speaker turns, so speakers and timestamps are not shown.

It's Wednesday, June 28.Today it is now 6:13in the evening.Please call the roll. [ CALLING ROLL ] Please rise for the Pledge of Allegiance. >> I pledge allegiance to the Flag of the United States of America, And to the Republic for which it stands, one Nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. >> And for today's invocation.I will be doing the invocation. We thank you for this day that you have given us a Lord.For its blessing , It's opportunity and its challenges may we appreciate and use each day that comes to us.We pray strength and guidance may we be challenged to give our best always and will be assured with your presence with as always.Amen. Okay.Thank you are much.Agenda order of business.Any changes? >> I do have an emergency item just to due to impact that you have in our community issue of severe traffic Issues safety concerns and it all in our city services including parks. >> Give me, if you give as a just couple minutes for the city attorney to review this and four each of us to review it because we want you to take a vote Or we will need a supermajority to lay this item down.We want to make sure it is life safety at time sensitive. Okay. >> Go ahead Madam city attorney. >> So under section 4.10 of the city Charter, there is an exception to the City Council items being added at last-minute.So As long as there's an informative vote of no less than four members of the City Council.Have the Emergency specifically relates to the public's health safety and welfare emergency.Ultimately this is finding for the council to make it but requires an affirmative 4 An order for that to be added to the agenda. >> Okay.I would hear motion? Motion and seconded.Do need the roll call or All in favor say I?So we will go ahead and do a roll call. Motion to add requested lay down item. [ CALLING ROLL ] Motion passes. >> Madam Mayor.I will add this is a second discussion item.Okay it will be item 7B. >> Any other additions or deletions from the agenda this time? No? Okay. I'm going to open public comment portion of this meeting.Public comment Is now open.If you have any comments on the any item that is on the agenda or not only agenda if you're here to speak on the public hearing item, please hold your comment for that time. You have thing minutes to speak on the item please do so on a respectful mother.So your name and for the record lease make sure you feel that one of this court. So anyone would like to speak? Seeing none will close the public comment portion of this meeting.Madam Clerk no one has chosen to speak And the public comment.To get a motion on the consensus agenda? Motion and seconded, All in favor say I? Thank you very much.Will now move the discussion item's. >> A resolution of the Mayor in the City Council of the city of Doral Florida supporting HR 4048, the Venezuelan adjustment act, or similar legislation that would authorise the Secretary of Homeland Security to adjust the status of a certain Venezuelan national is lawfully admitted permanent residence providing for transmittal for and providing for an effective date. Thank you madam clerk.Councilwoman Porras this is your item. Thank you,Which would authorise certain national is to apply residence.I think it's something that would benefit our community The city with the largestGroup and I think this would be a great show of support to Venezuelan community.And will be celebrating the Independence Day. So I would ask my colleague to support this and that way we could show solidarity and support from our Venezuelan community. Motion and seconded, Madam Clerk call the roll. [ CALLING ROLL ] Motion passes. >> Thank you.Moving on to lay down item. >>This is to read legality So we having voice of our people we have policies represent our consultant and do what is best for our community.I want to acknowledge and thank the hundred of residence in the communities, expressed great concern regarding the project 9741.The concern that all of you have, this is whyAct, Senate Bill 102.I believe that we need to keep our promises and fight over development in our city. I have many concerns about the availability of Senate Bill 102 and the current application being review by our staff. The project presented to staff on behalf ofOf developer wants to bring over 600 units residential living Additional commercial that is already suffers from traffic issue.The memo in front of you request of the city to higher law firm or lawyer that could only review and interpret the bill but look at theFrom a perspective and help us protect our local rights.I also ask for the city contract lobbyist to reach out Miami Dade legal cities. And we simply setback allow this project And what will be the followIn our city clerk in the life of our residents.We must fight to home role And not simply stand by the point by finding others. I also want to ask the city manager of those goals is approve for her at the end of the next week to give us an updateFor the process because this has to be done quickly. >> Thank you, Any other comments? >> Number one, I am a big proponent home rule.And this, what you are proposing here today Councilwoman Cabral is beyond The 600 residential units. I think we have to think beyond that.And I will, it will a build a effect The entire city.It is taken out zoning rights to a body that does not live here.Someone of them live very far away And I do not know the effect that it will have not only on traffic, but in quality-of-life in general, I would like to ask the attorney if we have, if there's any loss at within the state? >> I am not familiar with any lawsuit. That would be against the bill.They are not really familiar with any legal basis.Because it's the Estate statue, they have pre-empted all local government.Both counties and cities. (INAUDIBLE) so it something that is being looked at, Julian has working very diligently in conjunction with our office.And also Miami Dade legue of cities the planners Association, everybody's and some boat. >> If I may, so we were trucking best way back when those committees, I know not only Julian, but I believe Mr (INAUDIBLE) was up in Tallahassee. Lots of cities are extremely upset. I think there areAll up.Protecting our city, when I was in Tallahassee, it's Something that unfortunately run at the legislative body,Second billHeard and signed by governor.The only I can say about thisAnd there's a, we could share somethingWith the Councilwoman,The memo ofIs written, I have worked togetherToGo Tallahassee andGet this amended.She was the one who wrote this bill.A new junior senator, And how this attack on our city zoning and how pre-emption was something that was really unfair to our residents.And they are looking file A bill for next session. The moment we found out about it, along of pre-emptive bills, that I suggest wanted to all look at, So I plan there is a lot of time in Tallahassee,I have spoken to the league of cities membersJoker, I've spoken to several times about it.With the author of this bill, with our development servicesAdministrator Julian has a lot of history and experience, she is going to meet JokerWith myself. She wants to learn more to fix this.And I think that they need to here directly from the resident.And directly from us. So while I support those on the agenda, actually tomorrow's workshop I want to propose having workshop about Senate Bill 102.The virtual world chat saying that we are going to hearing the zoning change for the property that you mention. That is inaccurate.Zoning application coming for us they have filed under this role, this law.And will not have the opportunity to hear it will go administratively is what the city attorney stated it will not give the ability to regulate .Which basically leave us not much to stay. So... >> I do understand.... >> Let me finish and then [ CROSSTALK ] >> My understanding if you're following it (INAUDIBLE) Excuse me, I will defer to city attorney to answer that, [ CROSSTALK ] But I will allow the city attorney to clarify. >> There's nothing precluding Mayor for making her comment. We'll having discussion about this.But I would appreciate you not interrupt me. This is your item, if you want to, that's not a problem. But I did want to let everybody know, top of this our attorney extensive bench in Tallahassee, our completely a brave and there's been a lot of discussion protect city.SoI really appreciate you bringing this forward.It's really a great way to posture your position, but there is, I don't think there is a city attorney that should look at those.And we have a ready work with other municipality we have full report in your office.With all the legalities. >> Thank you.This bill or this law, extremely concerningIt something that are going to bypass the regular process, I do agree started looking at it today, I do agree that we need deep review and an analysis done.Whether it's by our council or, I guess my question as Madam attorney,Doing a deep dive, do you feel comfortable and analysis, providing us with an evolution? >> (INAUDIBLE) >> Thank you.Before give you the floor, Madam city manager can we go ahead and share that analysis. >> Yes, we can work in providing. >> It's very did till and I know you're working with (INAUDIBLE) >> I actually had a meeting tomorrow to discuss this and reviewed at draft. I was going to ask that. I just want to make a comment in regards to, first of all obviously I think we all Agreed that The impact that SB 102 For the series in general, not only here in Doral in general, But time, I think that is important also what we just heard in regards to , There is a lot of misinformation out there going around Since last week. So I know we are all promoting the workshop for tomorrow, which is I think is important for everyone to participate, Because I think raise issue being formed Correctly by the city especially by the city staff. Educational process that I always like to come and about at because I think that, misinformation out there, there are particular organisations to the race .But I'm going to take this chance to see this, I didn't see the same impact or feedback last year in October, when the project off from organization waterproof for 2500 units. So where or without SB 102 , I think that is something that has been going on the city for years. We are not hereTo blame one administration. We are here to respect our staff , Mr Julian Paras,I know I didn't go over his racing, but I did than even have it. ButI blessed to have someone like him over here.So again numbers , You guys can take a look at the numbers of units that has been approved for the last twenty years. And you can make your own conclusions, we are in your administration .We are trying to do everything that we can of issues, were going to do everything at least in my power that I can to make sure that we are notMaking the same mistakes that the administration making the past. >>Additional comments? >>I was going to (INAUDIBLE) that six at later cautioned that I was going to ask the city attorney as well have she felt such incompetent to be able to just review What interpret the bill. >> So I hope that I colleague will be able to support my item which is something that I mentioned before, we are the voice of our residents , Community and even though I know that work has been being on my way, I think that we should putAt a record. >> Other comments? >> I would support this bill but I think that are independent lawyer SB 102 will be necessary. Number three independent lawyers and firms to review the intent wonder to and to higherA necessary lobbyist to review SB 102Act Miami Dade and legal success.They already working against this Florida legal cities as working against it. So I will support at just having number two which is hiring independent lawyers.The validity of the SB 102, before to hire the lawyers to challenge the validity of one or two could one firm to do both.That's what I think the rest some things Like we mention that can be done here and save money and the other one is The organisations that are already support, role. >> I believe that there is to comment. >> I just want to ask a mention.Is it something that we could do in-house? >> Yes. With challenging pre-emption bill, that's notTo say we can evaluate it. [ FAINT AUDIO ] I do not if you recall where the firearm pre-emption.Which is very exhaustive, it's a bunch of cities get together and try to challenge that.This state legislator has to power to pre-empt us in this space. >> I was going to see the same thing, usually I would like(INAUDIBLE) D, city attorney a legal document and sometimes I know that it's outside the capacity. >> Yes.100% could >> Because I know that there are other issues that you prefer. >> Yes, for example, with the pension obviously. >> Okay.That include your comment council woman? >> Okay so that would take care of one. And the validity regarding any project presented to the city, that's also something that it can handle and? >> Yes, we work with planning department to review how certain laws are applied. Thank you so here are the comments that I made based on this.As far as review this, I'll go us for a saying,Eleven run by them putting a moratorium.We talk about putting a moratorium, it could bring, Was advised not to do it that it would immediately be challenged andWe would have to withdraw because unfortunately, it's not something that you would have to study to look and see how you fixed.It as pre-emptive.Which means the law.Self-explanatory us to what they can do with this bill.It as attacking our home role.Extremely pre-emptive, you can absolutely read it.It was look at the city attorney, for analysis, I think one analysis has been in the city.A change which which is I think more active, more successful in going to lobby amendment then we are challenging it.And the city has gotten together, to challenge a because it seems that there will be affects to this Just going to take place in the next session. So meanwhile the application to come forward as our staff Job to make sure that they Cut through the book of our code of them And our conference of plan the do best to Mitigate as much as possible.But this was the will of the state.Unfortunately we can just run it through. Unfortunately called legislator. It is extremely important that we speak with one voice in Tallahassee and let them know That the danger of this types of bill, attacks our government. We will all feel comfortable, think again direct the city, legal opinion based on this I would be comfortable voting On asking our city attorney to put a legal Put together legal opinion, validity on what you can do, give us option Of what a dozen city moving forward, Little to prepare a memo, more affirmative. I will send out the state on behalf of the city, letting them know and like I said, I continue to work with the author of this bill and it is work with a legal City to hopefully have better news in the next legislative. That will be Amended. That is what I am comfortable moving forward with. But once think we can, I'm not going to put in the city position that were not going to enter that's my position on it.I think we can take a vote on that. We are All in favor? and of us in favor I think we are all in this. >>So I do agree, I also just want to mention obviously I would in favor of this as well as the chalice appeal.Eventually at some point it as something that we should consider eventually not at this time.I think we need to find out first what the application and its.And what it says. That's a >> I think our city attorney can look and product and the recommendation.But level immediately (INAUDIBLE) >> Can I suggest that we hold onto this two wait to review. With all due respect,A concurrent for a free. >> This is what I have motion to direct the city attorney to provide a legal opinion on the validity and options that the city has honestly want to. >> Letter from a office today state.We can take a motion, but on that.And after you will all be report if you feel that something else should come up. I think right now what we are doing, it's the most we can do at this time. >> I need emotion. >> Motion and seconded.Madam Clerk please call the roll. [ CALLING ROLL ] Motion passes. >> Thank you madam clerk.Let's move on toThe public hearing portion. >> Yes Madam Mayor . [ SWEARING IN ] First item Resolution of the Mayor in the City Council of the city of Doral Florida of in the site plan for health peak properties Incorporated for the property generally located north of north-west 41 street and west of North West 109 Avenue Doral Florida, pursuant to section 53 " 184F of thecity's land development code and providing for an effective date. Thank you madam clerk. Opening up the public hearing. For item 7A.If anyone wanted speak on this item please come forward. Good afternoon Madam Mayor Council staff. I want clarification and technicality Checked there was a late an item today.I don't think it was open for public comment.Have to make a public comments On the previous item. Well, explain the issue about the moratorium. And the possible implication request is just the consider the appeal because as far as I understand that bill has been used to temporarily stop something I do know if that's same They are expert at I would like to get responsive andAppeal will be also something that should be considered Thank you very much. Anyone else? Now admitted time to come up and speak.Sitting on Madam Clerk this let the record reflect that no one else has chosen to speak. Will now allow for the staff there one come forward. >>Gillian parents are development services administrator. Good evening Mayor, Julian Perez Development service Administrator for the city.Breath sanitation regarding this project.The applicantHealth peak Or the medical office.Project is over here.The request is a safe plan revolved it's indicated by the city attorney. Sorry, city clerk.And basically what they are asking is the approval for three-storey a medical office building. This building will be located at 109150 North West 41 street and its actually to the west of an existing HCA.The general area where this facility is going to be located as on 11.4 acres desires of the building as the approximately plus as on 11.4 acres desires of the building as the approximately +62 160 square-foot. This category for this area is a business, the zoning district. This core to commercial, this development is property is going to be done on three phases. Which is medical office building that is before US considerationWill be phase 2 and then finally fees they will be asked in the future.We don't have a site plan for that or is there any plans associated with that phase 3. The they principal documents associated with this project which is conference of plan.The alarm development code and the Doral Boulevard Masterplan.As you can see, this chart various surrounding the proposed project is pretty much residential to the north land to the west as well as there's the residential commercial to East And then again to the west as that (INAUDIBLE) And to mediate North is the bridge point project your zoning map. Next slide As the surrounding areas.We are all very familiar again, building located and this property Is the freestanding emergency facility. Rest of the area is just open land. Next year as the proposed site plan and some of the rendering is associated with this project.Seconds she From the renderings one of the most important things when we looked at this project, wasTo make sure that they were consistent.Not only where they are just use, which is the HCA facility. But also the consistentWhere the adorable of our masterplan and its from the rendering is.As you can see, They have met all those requirement.And in addition, they went ahead and donated more land than that, they were supposed to. They took out a complete road of parking in order to make sure a more functional project. This project that was review for consistency our requirements for the site plan evolution section 53 " 184 C3.Of the land development code.And number of Malaysia criteria, actually there is Eight of them and the project has met all of them successfully.We first the standard is consistency Where the conference of plan and this project is consistent and further Some of the policy that I'm going to mention.This is something that very important. Because any project of the site plan Starts with consistency with our Conference of plan. It does in many different ways.An acquired sidewalk,Including landscaping and sitting areas,Front industry,Also there's a water component on this project, which is extremely support.This is one of those Activities that within the project that foreigners law impact Development masterplan. And it helps us to retain all of the stone water on site and in a natural way.Integration of the project are more effectively And to their surrounding environment.Obviously, is consistent with the existing facility as well as the other commercial uses around it. And it would also further to our medical services that were going to be providing to the surrounding communities. At enhance the property values, obviously when you have a project not only provides A first quality design, it's also sensitive integrate with the surrounding community. Added value to the surrounding area but I think also the property values.It also (INAUDIBLE) and a relationship on buildings useAnd also that very important to, is not only making sure that we are providing a project that is consistent but it's the one as they will facilitate service. Number six is protect a health safety and welfare of the residents and as indicated, the project environmental relation as well as the promotion of look ability and social interaction and that is done through thisDurable of our masterplan.Requirement are some of the factors that contribute to the creation of the healthy water and that's what we want.That's what, where the stone water retention is going to be locatedAnd then when you look across this thread with a bridge point, the new have a complete quarter towards the Turnpike trick the traffic Analysis through a traffic studyThat was doneAnd a number of recommendations as indicated on the slide usAlso indicated to only conditions and theResolution. There is no issue with this.Very briefly TheStaff recommendation.Again when we are looking at the project, is extremely important that look at the compatibility issue.And we did thatWe ensure that, everything that is designed and done in this projectWe want to make sure that is consistent that what we have here.Again we went back and look at theLunch code to make sure that everything is consistent and met requirement of those at a, Open space and overallStandards of the building code.Again I'm referring to such 3180 4C,The proposed project is consistent Where the city conference of one Specifically passivePolicies 2.1, 2.2, AndThere is a language that fact and your staff report.Proposed project again, they are studied drawBelow Doral Boulevard beautification. And finally staff recommends approval of the proposed site plan subject to the meeting or exceeding the condition requirement set forth and the development agreement twentyWeek propertiesAnd the city of Doral. >>Thank you. >> Tracey,It's nice to see all of you. Thank you JulianThat was a very thorough presentation.So got on of the technical details,I'm going to show you create a picture.So I do haveA brief presentationThe show you the renderings of the buildingAnd talk about our compatibility.SoAs you can see this is the building towards the north-west Russia give you full view of the project And landscaping. As Julian mentioned withThe Doral masterplanned design,Sidewalk,The building is three-storey.It will be located and the central portion of the site.It's accessBut existing driveways, In aNew drivewayWill be added in the not west side.Further to the west of the buildingWill be a lecture so that will beOpen space for the durationOf the project.As Julian mentionedWe are corridor commercial zoning.We complied with all the applicable zoning and designRegulations of the both the code and around Boulevard muster one on the aerial pictures here, the emergency augmentIs located at the South east Corner of the property that will remain and this building is intended to make complementary to that use. This is intended to be a class a medical office building that will serve , service this a 62,000 square- foot Building.We expect the to have numerous doctors office of the various specialties.They have partnered where HCA to build This building and they are experts and out medical healthcare services and construction.So we are very excited about that.Technically on the site plan you can see there is a parking need is more than general topical of office space.In addition to the parking spaces that exist for the emergency department running another 253 spaces.Majority of them to be utilised and just for your Reference the amount of parking that we are providing is fifty spaces above what the code requires.So our goal is to make sure that everyone finds a place to park and can get their doctors if efficiently quickly and safety. The building is located at the center of the site. To ensure us much buffering is possible with Eagle Cove To the north.I took a field trip out there before the meeting and you know, it's heavily Wooded.It's very well screened. We had participation from the members of the community and we had very positive responses from everyone. So we did do line of the site growing is to try to determine as best we could, what someone in Eagle Cove or someone on 114Would CF they were looking towards the property towards the building. There's a lot of distance between the building and residential neighbourhoods in the North and we spent a lot of time designing situating the building in manner that will provide a most privacy to those folks. This is the rendering of the building locations just to give you an idea of the general design it's a matter and -- modern design. But the design of the building does address all four sides of the building .There are, it's hard to tell and decide its actually, I'll take it at the next one but also the building walls for district. So don't have one solid wall across the land of the building and the building has depthAnd character and provides shade walk.(INAUDIBLE) There are sidewalk conducting the building to district and connecting to the parking areas and connecting to the emergency. So that concludes my presentation and happy to answer any question you may have. Thank you very much.Any question from the council at this time? I am okay with the location Of the building, And also the distance from our residence where they need communityOn this side, The concern as the overall site which would and have presentation today.But you guys, I did know if it was required By codeBody have the storm waterTo east of the property.Which means the future phaseWhich says on the site plan it's going to be on the north sideOf the proposedBuilding that we are talking about today.Is there a wayThat future site could be on theEast side for from our neighborsRather than in the back of this building? >>I'm going to pull up the site and again. So the lake platted. And I think address the lowest point of the property.So that was part of why they situated at there. I think that gives a lot of flexibility to whatever a future land may be, That in my mind, buildings would connect because someone coming to a hospital are going to the doctor's office, usually connects through a building. So its possible that where the parking is shown today many building in the future end. Wouldn't know what the phasing is.So don't have a representative here from HCA or I have personally seen a plan, but we'll keep that in mind as we move forward >> Thank you. I actually the same concern with Tracey. I mention that it would be my opinion a better opportunity to years the lake are is , The water retention as a buffer from the residents that the north. I understand the flow of the actualOf the front, first of all I want to thank you guys for pushing the building back that right onto the street.I think that's really important in something, we have heard from our residents that They don't like is to see the building right up on district .So thing that this allows for a really nice landscape, but for which is working on improving As we move forward in updating our masterplan.But there is also no parking in the front which wouldn't see either. We did revise thatAnd still accommodate currently, there is a distilling shown bottom of the slide, we felt that that is important. The idea that you want to get the slowing traffic of41 street as quickly as possible.The Doral Boulevard masterplan improvement we had a set price parking. >> The also isCross (INAUDIBLE) can you come in a little bit aboutThe improvement and intersection? >> Yes,And that land at that we had access to there latest and greatest information and incorporated that into landscape design as well as into the future of places of rest along the lake there will be some furniture and Rob Lee some version of an architectural or install And that will correspond over what the bridge doing this outside. >> Thank you. My final comment is on the upper facing.Upper corner here just about the emergency room.What is that? That's just green space.I would actually a year its trees.And That maybe some dry retention, we'll have to go throughThree removal permitting and determine what it says and what goes, but it's generally going to be open space. >> Okay.Great.Further comments at this time? >>Motion. >> Motion seconded, >> I just wanted to thank the (INAUDIBLE) >> Thank you very much.Madam Clerk this call the roll. [ CALLING ROLL ] Motion passes. >> Madam Clerk moving on to the final item. >>An ordinance of the Mayor in the City Council of the city of Doral Florida approving text amendments to the city of Doral land development code by amending division 4 special development regulations for a certain uses of article 3 special setbacks and uses of chapter 74, miscellaneous and supplementary regulation of the city of the Doral land development code to create distance requirements and other regulations related to tobacco/vape shops.Providing for definitions providing forincorporation into the code, providing for severability, providing for conflict in providing for an effective date. >> Thank you madam clerk.Opening up a publicHearing portion of this item. Where going to open up this item.If you have any comment regarding the item. Item B.Please come forwardIn the podium On stage name and address.You have the minutes to speak. [ SPEAKING SPANISH ] >>Good afternoon, my name is Anna Marie commentsResident of Doral,A divine Saviour Academy,Thank you to the Mayor and allHer team.142 north-west 107 court. Thirty 178. [ SPEAKING SPANISH ] She wanted to thank the Mayor for allowing to participate in this decision to of the city make.Check am representing the family in the parents Of the city of Doral. For your consideration of this item, which is a distant of tobacco shops. They recently found out there will be a tobacco shop opening next to the canyon store. It is located at fifty-eight Avenue Behind the Divine Saviour Academy. A lot of children in local family members attend to that area.Although the creation of this small businesses boast economy for the city and the families. And they are not against them. And they do like the development of this small businesses of the city therefor it. (INAUDIBLE) positive impact in the city to where this business are located. Then years at this tobacco start will be open and close to an education of community and educational facilities such as disco Divine Saviour. It is what worries them as a community members becauseThis could have the potential but influence and impact. Some other recent turn state us to why this as not agreeable for them for the community.The proximity of the store to the school,Expose the children of school to some of this product.This establishment normalise the consumption of tobacco. And they could increase the risk of the years to participate in this and to be involved with this tobacco activities. The presence of this establishment near the school can have an impact on their health and the well-being of the children. Just like second-hand smoke can have long-term healthcare corses And health risk to all of this youth. Lastly our school take time to educate the children entered danger of tobacco use. And they take the time to promote healthy lifestyle. And therefor opening such establishment near the school contradict with the school messages. They reiterate that they are not against Opening small business within our city. They are trying to enhance the legislator so that they could avoid this type of businessOpening closer to disclose in the city of the Doral. This will help enhance the health of our children to be able to Be healthier children in the future. Thank you for your time and I wish you would make some decision for this item in order to help community. There welcome to hear any feedback into assistant anywhere they can.Have a great afternoon thank you for hearing out. >> Thank you anyone else? Please come up to the podium at this time. I had to ask question. I fully support the comments of my neighbors. But more than talking about the smoking Because I evenHad a session to the police Department Thirteen HP rentals, the kids are when they do we being come out which does not produce a Kind of, clear or many, I need to clarify,Because I know that tobaccoBut in my important question especially to the Mayor because she will be the one sponsoring and displace.Because it speaks About someplace aboutEverything about 10% or a small areaSo in my requestThat will cover any place, even dismal portion any vaping devices. Whatever you call it. That I think we would have most effective, (INAUDIBLE) >> Thank you.Any other comments? Sitting on Madam Clerk let the record reflect that there are no 1 to speak. So will take the item.Now that all the public comments have been met with it some research on this item. I want to thank you to city attorney and Julian Perez for helping me put this item together.I of the community come to my attention.As this new establishment is reopening up obviously establishments that are already in process would be grandfathered in the whole Policy of the alcohol store policy that has a distant requirement.We do not have for typical shops in our code and so I asked for this to be draught and put In for your consideration.I would like for the city attorney to place address That we are ask the intent was any tobacco products vaping, it all falls under the same category would not be allowable within the distance actually would like to go stronger thing 2500 feet is enough. I really believe that if you do the distance or we need to be clear from we are a regulated, The door from the school or rather any point of that property, schools property from that distance to The establishment, to the property establishment.That's way I would like to see itInterpreted.So I want to make sure we are black-and-white.Madam city attorney I will turn over the floor to you. >> So first it does Include vape retailers and both retail vape products and dealers.And that means any retail establishment that sells vape generating electronic device, component parts and accessories for such products.So for those requirement that we have in our alcohol ordinance that existing because essentially, the vice or the use of similar in nature and so you can concerned that I shared with also with the planning argument, if you start treating them to spirited. >> Is there anyone can clarify the language.I know had a first and second Reading.But I would really like to come over it to be very clear that it's from any corner of the proper class. >>Yes, if I may have currently how it's drafted, so it goes from the front door of the shop to the nearAs point of the property boundary line of either the place. >> F FS support for that I'm all in. While there is a extremely important for our children well it has a similar years to alcohol, you're talking about eighteen years of age versus twenty-one. That's my personal opinion. If we can fix something in the future I am all in.so that's my recommendation. So if there's a motion on the change. >> Motion to approve. >> Second. Motion in second, >> I am all very much in favor of this proposed item, But we received a letter , I did know if you guys, The mention that the Florida statuteDemonstrate that such a propose local earnings as pre-emptive by the state law. >> Yes, so I did receive the letter and we did have an opportunity to review it. I don't believe that the city is expressly pre-emptive, Pre-emption provides, How they can market and sell it. Having said thatObviously this is under (INAUDIBLE) we have some review and analysis.If we believe that there is an implied pre-emption that would be susceptible To challenge obviously. >> Can you please share that to the meeting. >> Sure. >> Thank you. >> Any other questions or comments? And just for the record we have a conversation with the city attorney. >> Just for clarification, how this applied to the gas station? It would not apply to a gas station. >> Other question? >> Madam Mayor could you please estate your amendment. I drafted to the change,0.5 mile. [ CALLING ROLL ] Motion passes. >> Thank you very much.Appreciated.With that, All in favor say I? [ MEETING ADJOURNED ]

FINAL MINUTES

CITY OF DORAL

COUNCIL ZONING MEETING

WEDNESDAY, JUNE 28, 2023 06:00 P.M.

CITY HALL COUNCIL CHAMBERS

8401 N.W. 53rd TERRACE, 3rd FLOOR

DORAL, FL 33166

1)

Call to Order / Roll Call of Members

Meeting was called to order at 6:13 p.m. All members were present. (00:00:02)

Mayor Christi Fraga

Present

Vice Mayor Rafael Pineyro

Present

Councilwoman Digna Cabral

Present

Councilwoman Maureen Porras

Present

Councilman Oscar Puig-Corve

Present

Also present were:

Barbie Hernandez, City Manager

Connie Diaz, City Clerk

Nabors, Giblin & Nickerson, City Attorney

2)

Pledge of Allegiance (00:00:16)

3)

Invocation (00:00:30)

Mayor Fraga gave the invocation. (00:00:31)

4)

Agenda / Order of Business (00:00:59)

Councilwoman Cabral requested to laydown an item to Defend Home Rule SB102.

Motion to approve the laydown item made by Councilman Puig-Corve and seconded by Councilwoman Porras. Roll call vote - motion passes 4-1 (Vice Mayor Pineyro voted "no"). (00:02:14)

5)

Public Comments (00:04:40)

There were no comments made during public comments. (00:05:09)

6)

Consent Agenda (00:05:22)

Motion to approve items 6A, 6B, 6C, 6D, and 6E on Consent made by Councilman Puig-Corve and seconded by Vice Mayor Pineyro. By consensus, motion passes unanimously. (00:05:27)

A)

Council Zoning Meeting CITY OF DORAL Meeting Agenda - Final (Revised) DORAL GOVERNMENT CENTER 8401 NW 53 TERRACE DORAL, FLORIDA 33166 Mayor Christi Fraga Vice Mayor Rafael Pineyro Councilwoman Digna Cabral Councilwoman Maureen Porras Councilman Oscar Puig-Corve Charter Officials Barbie Hernandez, City Manager Connie Diaz, City Clerk Nabors, Giblin & Nickerson, P.A., City Attorney Council Chambers6:00 PMWednesday, June 28, 2023 Revision Date 6/27/2023 1) Call to Order / Roll Call of Members 2) Pledge of Allegiance 3) Invocation 4) Agenda / Order of Business 5) Public Comments 6) Consent Agenda Page 1CITY OF DORAL

June 28, 2023Council Zoning Meeting Meeting Agenda - Final (Revised) A) 23-5163 A RESOLUTION OF THE MAYOR AND THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF DORAL, FLORIDA, AWARDING INVITATION TO BID #2023-05 “DISASTER DEBRIS REMOVAL AND DISPOSAL SERVICES;” AUTHORIZING THE CITY MANAGER TO ENTER INTO AN AGREEMENT WITH CTC DISASTER RESPONSE, INC., CERES ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES, AND DRC EMERGENCY SERVICES FOR THE PROVISION OF EMERGENCY DEBRIS REMOVAL SERVICES; PROVIDING THAT COST TO THE CITY SHALL ONLY APPLY UPON THE CITY’S AUTHORIZED REQUEST OF SERVICE AFTER AN ACTUAL EMERGENCY; AUTHORIZING THE CITY MANAGER TO EXPEND BUDGETED FUNDS ON BEHALF OF THE CITY WITH RESPECT TO THE AGREEMENTS APPROVED HEREIN; PROVIDING FOR IMPLEMENTATION; AND PROVIDING FOR AN EFFECTIVE DATE Sponsors: Public Works Memo Bid Tabulation 2023-05 RFP CTC Disaster Response Inc - Bid Submittal 2023-05 RFP Ceres Environmental Services - Bid Submittal 2023-05 RFP DRC Emergency Services - Bid Submittal 2023-05 RFP Aftermath Disaster Recovery - Bid Submittal 2023-05 RFP D&J Enterprises - Bid Submittal 2023-05 RFP Phillips and Jordan - Bid Submittal 2023-05 RFP TFR Enterprises - Bid Submittal CTC Disaster Response Inc Agreement Ceres Agreement DRC Agreement Res. No. 23-Award ITB 2023-05 Emergency Debris Removal Svcs Attachments: Page 2CITY OF DORAL

June 28, 2023Council Zoning Meeting Meeting Agenda - Final (Revised) B) 23-5166 A RESOLUTION OF THE MAYOR AND THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF DORAL, FLORIDA, AUTHORIZING THE USE OF TIPS CONTRACT No. 220106 FOR THE PURCHASE OF A REPLACEMENT AC CHILLER UNIT FROM CARRIER CORPORATION FOR THE POLICE TRAINING AND COMMUNITY CENTER; AUTHORIZING THE CITY MANAGER TO ACCEPT THE PROPOSAL FROM CARRIER CORPORATION IN AN AMOUNT NOT TO EXCEED $108,120.00; AUTHORIZING THE CITY MANAGER TO EXPEND BUDGETED FUNDS ON BEHALF OF THE CITY; PROVIDING FOR IMPLEMENTATION; AND PROVIDING FOR AN EFFECTIVE DATE Sponsors: Public Works Memo TIPS Contract HVAC Carrier Proposal Daikin Proposal Trane Proposal Res. No. 23-Police Training Community Center Chiller Replacement Attachments: C) 23-5167 A RESOLUTION OF THE MAYOR AND THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF DORAL, FLORIDA, APPROVING AN AMENDMENT TO THE CONSERVATION EASEMENT BETWEEN THE CITY OF DORAL AND TRUMP ENDEAVOR 12 LLC, PURSUANT TO IRS NOTICE 2023-30; AUTHORIZING AND DIRECTING THE CITY MANAGER TO EXECUTE AND RECORD THE SAME; AND PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE Sponsors: City Attorney Memo Exhibit A - 2022-12-07 Deed of Conservation Easement Trump Doral Blue Monster Golf Course Exhibit B - N-23-30 Exhibit C - Conservation Easement Amendment Res. No. 23-Approving Conservation Easement Amendment Blue Monster Attachments: Page 3CITY OF DORAL

June 28, 2023Council Zoning Meeting Meeting Agenda - Final (Revised) D) 23-5168 A RESOLUTION OF THE MAYOR AND THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF DORAL, FLORIDA, APPROVING THE CITY’S PARTICIPATION IN MIAMI-DADE COUNTY’S ENTITLEMENT JURISDICTION FOR THE PURPOSES OF THE COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT BLOCK GRANT (CDBG), EMERGENCY SHELTER GRANT (ESG), AND HOME INVESTMENT PARTNERSHIPS (HOME) PROGRAMS FOR FISCAL YEARS 2024-2026; AUTHORIZING THE CITY MANAGER TO PROVIDE NOTICE OF THE CITY’S PARTICIPATION WITH MIAMI DADE COUNTY’S ENTITLEMENT JURISIDICTION FOR SAID PROGRAMS, AND IF NECESSARY, AUTHORIZING THE CITY MANAGER TO EXECUTE AN URBAN QUALIFICATION COOPERATION AGREEMENT WITH MIAMI-DADE COUNTY FOR SAID PROGRAMS FOR FISCAL YEARS 2024-2026; PROVIDING FOR IMPLEMENTATION; AND PROVIDING FOR AN EFFECTIVE DATE Sponsors: City Manager Memo Community Development Block Grant Program FY 2018-2020 Res. No. 23-Opting Into Community Development Block Grant FY 2024-2026 Attachments: E) 23-5169 Proclamation for Miguel Cabrera Day Sponsors: Mayor Fraga 2023-07-29 Miguel Cabrera Day Request 2023-07-29 Miguel Cabrera Day Clauses Attachments: 7) Discussion Item A) 23-5170 A RESOLUTION OF THE MAYOR AND THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF DORAL, FLORIDA, SUPPORTING H.R. 4048, THE “VENEZUELAN ADJUSTMENT ACT,” OR SIMILAR LEGISLATION THAT WOULD AUTHORIZE THE SECRETARY OF HOMELAND SECURITY TO ADJUST THE STATUS OF CERTAIN VENEZUELAN NATIONALS TO LAWFULLY ADMITTED PERMANENT RESIDENTS; PROVIDING FOR TRANSMITTAL; AND PROVIDING FOR AN EFFECTIVE DATE Sponsors: Councilwoman Porras Memo HR 4048 Venezuelan Adjustment Act Bill Res. No. 23-Expressing Support for HR4048 Venezuelan Adjustment Act Attachments: Page 4CITY OF DORAL

June 28, 2023Council Zoning Meeting Meeting Agenda - Final (Revised) 8) Public Hearings Any individual(s) testifying in a quasi-judicial proceeding shall be sworn in. A) 23-5165 A RESOLUTION OF THE MAYOR AND THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF DORAL, FLORIDA, APPROVING THE SITE PLAN FOR HEALTHPEAK PROPERTIES INC., FOR THE PROPERTY GENERALLY LOCATED NORTH OF NW 41 STREET AND WEST OF NW 109 AVENUE, DORAL, FLORIDA, PURSUANT TO SECTION 53-184(F) OF THE CITY’S LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE; AND PROVIDING FOR AN EFFECTIVE DATE Sponsors: Planning and Zoning Planning and Zoning Staff Report Attachment A - Legal Advertisement Exhibit A - Application & LOI Exhibit B - Site Plan Exhibit C - DERM Exhibit D - Solid Waste Exhibit E - Traffic Exhibit A - Legal Description Exhibit B - Site Plan Res. No. 23-Healthpeak Site Plan Attachments: First Reading Page 5CITY OF DORAL

June 28, 2023Council Zoning Meeting Meeting Agenda - Final (Revised) B) 23-5164 Ordinance #2023-20 “Distance Requirements Tobacco Shops” AN ORDINANCE OF THE MAYOR AND THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF DORAL, FLORIDA, APPROVING TEXT AMENDMENTS TO THE CITY OF DORAL LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE BY AMENDING DIVISION 4 “SPECIAL DEVELOPMENT REGULATIONS FOR CERTAIN USES” OF ARTICLE III “SPECIAL SETBACKS AND U S E S ” O F C H A P T E R 7 4 , “ M I S C E L L A N E O U S A N D SUPPLEMENTARY REGULATIONS,” OF THE CITY OF DORAL LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE TO CREATE DISTANCE REQUIREMENTS AND OTHER REGULATIONS RELATED TO TOBACCO/VAPE SHOPS; PROVIDING FOR DEFINITIONS; PROVIDING FOR INCORPORATION INTO THE CODE; PROVIDING FOR SEVERABILITY; PROVIDING FOR CONFLICTS; AND PROVIDING FOR AN EFFECTIVE DATE Sponsors: Mayor Fraga Memo Ord. No. 2023-20 Distance Requirements Tobacco Shops Attachments: 9) Adjournment Notice to the Public Any person who acts as a lobbyist pursuant to City of Doral Resolution No. 2007-31 and Section 2-11.1(s) of the Miami-Dade County Conflict of Interest and Code of Ethics Ordinance, must register with the City Clerk prior to engaging in lobbying activities before city staff, boards, committees and/or the City Council. Pursuant to Florida Statute 286.0105, anyone wishing to appeal any decision made by the City Council with respect to any matter considered at this meeting or hearing shall need a record of the proceedings and, for such purpose, may need to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceedings is made, which record includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal is to be based. Any invocation that may be offered before the official start of the Council meeting shall be the voluntary offering of a private citizen/member of the clergy, to and for the benefit of the Council. The views or beliefs expressed by the invocation speaker have not been previously reviewed or approved by the Council, and the Council is not allowed by law to endorse the religious beliefs or views of this, or any other speaker. Page 6CITY OF DORAL

Showing the first 24,000 of 37,781 characters. The full document is at the source.

It's Wednesday, June 28.Today it is now 6:13in the evening.Please call the roll. [ CALLING ROLL ] Please rise for the Pledge of Allegiance. >> I pledge allegiance to the Flag of the United States of America, And to the Republic for which it stands, one Nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. >> And for today's invocation.I will be doing the invocation. We thank you for this day that you have given us a Lord.For its blessing , It's opportunity and its challenges may we appreciate and use each day that comes to us.We pray strength and guidance may we be challenged to give our best always and will be assured with your presence with as always.Amen. Okay.Thank you are much.Agenda order of business.Any changes? >> I do have an emergency item just to due to impact that you have in our community issue of severe traffic Issues safety concerns and it all in our city services including parks. >> Give me, if you give as a just couple minutes for the city attorney to review this and four each of us to review it because we want you to take a vote Or we will need a supermajority to lay this item down.We want to make sure it is life safety at time sensitive. Okay. >> Go ahead Madam city attorney. >> So under section 4.10 of the city Charter, there is an exception to the City Council items being added at last-minute.So As long as there's an informative vote of no less than four members of the City Council.Have the Emergency specifically relates to the public's health safety and welfare emergency.Ultimately this is finding for the council to make it but requires an affirmative 4 An order for that to be added to the agenda. >> Okay.I would hear motion? Motion and seconded.Do need the roll call or All in favor say I?So we will go ahead and do a roll call. Motion to add requested lay down item. [ CALLING ROLL ] Motion passes. >> Madam Mayor.I will add this is a second discussion item.Okay it will be item 7B. >> Any other additions or deletions from the agenda this time? No? Okay. I'm going to open public comment portion of this meeting.Public comment Is now open.If you have any comments on the any item that is on the agenda or not only agenda if you're here to speak on the public hearing item, please hold your comment for that time. You have thing minutes to speak on the item please do so on a respectful mother.So your name and for the record lease make sure you feel that one of this court. So anyone would like to speak? Seeing none will close the public comment portion of this meeting.Madam Clerk no one has chosen to speak And the public comment.To get a motion on the consensus agenda? Motion and seconded, All in favor say I? Thank you very much.Will now move the discussion item's. >> A resolution of the Mayor in the City Council of the city of Doral Florida supporting HR 4048, the Venezuelan adjustment act, or similar legislation that would authorise the Secretary of Homeland Security to adjust the status of a certain Venezuelan national is lawfully admitted permanent residence providing for transmittal for and providing for an effective date. Thank you madam clerk.Councilwoman Porras this is your item. Thank you,Which would authorise certain national is to apply residence.I think it's something that would benefit our community The city with the largestGroup and I think this would be a great show of support to Venezuelan community.And will be celebrating the Independence Day. So I would ask my colleague to support this and that way we could show solidarity and support from our Venezuelan community. Motion and seconded, Madam Clerk call the roll. [ CALLING ROLL ] Motion passes. >> Thank you.Moving on to lay down item. >>This is to read legality So we having voice of our people we have policies represent our consultant and do what is best for our community.I want to acknowledge and thank the hundred of residence in the communities, expressed great concern regarding the project 9741.The concern that all of you have, this is whyAct, Senate Bill 102.I believe that we need to keep our promises and fight over development in our city. I have many concerns about the availability of Senate Bill 102 and the current application being review by our staff. The project presented to staff on behalf ofOf developer wants to bring over 600 units residential living Additional commercial that is already suffers from traffic issue.The memo in front of you request of the city to higher law firm or lawyer that could only review and interpret the bill but look at theFrom a perspective and help us protect our local rights.I also ask for the city contract lobbyist to reach out Miami Dade legal cities. And we simply setback allow this project And what will be the followIn our city clerk in the life of our residents.We must fight to home role And not simply stand by the point by finding others. I also want to ask the city manager of those goals is approve for her at the end of the next week to give us an updateFor the process because this has to be done quickly. >> Thank you, Any other comments? >> Number one, I am a big proponent home rule.And this, what you are proposing here today Councilwoman Cabral is beyond The 600 residential units. I think we have to think beyond that.And I will, it will a build a effect The entire city.It is taken out zoning rights to a body that does not live here.Someone of them live very far away And I do not know the effect that it will have not only on traffic, but in quality-of-life in general, I would like to ask the attorney if we have, if there's any loss at within the state? >> I am not familiar with any lawsuit. That would be against the bill.They are not really familiar with any legal basis.Because it's the Estate statue, they have pre-empted all local government.Both counties and cities. (INAUDIBLE) so it something that is being looked at, Julian has working very diligently in conjunction with our office.And also Miami Dade legue of cities the planners Association, everybody's and some boat. >> If I may, so we were trucking best way back when those committees, I know not only Julian, but I believe Mr (INAUDIBLE) was up in Tallahassee. Lots of cities are extremely upset. I think there areAll up.Protecting our city, when I was in Tallahassee, it's Something that unfortunately run at the legislative body,Second billHeard and signed by governor.The only I can say about thisAnd there's a, we could share somethingWith the Councilwoman,The memo ofIs written, I have worked togetherToGo Tallahassee andGet this amended.She was the one who wrote this bill.A new junior senator, And how this attack on our city zoning and how pre-emption was something that was really unfair to our residents.And they are looking file A bill for next session. The moment we found out about it, along of pre-emptive bills, that I suggest wanted to all look at, So I plan there is a lot of time in Tallahassee,I have spoken to the league of cities membersJoker, I've spoken to several times about it.With the author of this bill, with our development servicesAdministrator Julian has a lot of history and experience, she is going to meet JokerWith myself. She wants to learn more to fix this.And I think that they need to here directly from the resident.And directly from us. So while I support those on the agenda, actually tomorrow's workshop I want to propose having workshop about Senate Bill 102.The virtual world chat saying that we are going to hearing the zoning change for the property that you mention. That is inaccurate.Zoning application coming for us they have filed under this role, this law.And will not have the opportunity to hear it will go administratively is what the city attorney stated it will not give the ability to regulate .Which basically leave us not much to stay. So... >> I do understand.... >> Let me finish and then [ CROSSTALK ] >> My understanding if you're following it (INAUDIBLE) Excuse me, I will defer to city attorney to answer that, [ CROSSTALK ] But I will allow the city attorney to clarify. >> There's nothing precluding Mayor for making her comment. We'll having discussion about this.But I would appreciate you not interrupt me. This is your item, if you want to, that's not a problem. But I did want to let everybody know, top of this our attorney extensive bench in Tallahassee, our completely a brave and there's been a lot of discussion protect city.SoI really appreciate you bringing this forward.It's really a great way to posture your position, but there is, I don't think there is a city attorney that should look at those.And we have a ready work with other municipality we have full report in your office.With all the legalities. >> Thank you.This bill or this law, extremely concerningIt something that are going to bypass the regular process, I do agree started looking at it today, I do agree that we need deep review and an analysis done.Whether it's by our council or, I guess my question as Madam attorney,Doing a deep dive, do you feel comfortable and analysis, providing us with an evolution? >> (INAUDIBLE) >> Thank you.Before give you the floor, Madam city manager can we go ahead and share that analysis. >> Yes, we can work in providing. >> It's very did till and I know you're working with (INAUDIBLE) >> I actually had a meeting tomorrow to discuss this and reviewed at draft. I was going to ask that. I just want to make a comment in regards to, first of all obviously I think we all Agreed that The impact that SB 102 For the series in general, not only here in Doral in general, But time, I think that is important also what we just heard in regards to , There is a lot of misinformation out there going around Since last week. So I know we are all promoting the workshop for tomorrow, which is I think is important for everyone to participate, Because I think raise issue being formed Correctly by the city especially by the city staff. Educational process that I always like to come and about at because I think that, misinformation out there, there are particular organisations to the race .But I'm going to take this chance to see this, I didn't see the same impact or feedback last year in October, when the project off from organization waterproof for 2500 units. So where or without SB 102 , I think that is something that has been going on the city for years. We are not hereTo blame one administration. We are here to respect our staff , Mr Julian Paras,I know I didn't go over his racing, but I did than even have it. ButI blessed to have someone like him over here.So again numbers , You guys can take a look at the numbers of units that has been approved for the last twenty years. And you can make your own conclusions, we are in your administration .We are trying to do everything that we can of issues, were going to do everything at least in my power that I can to make sure that we are notMaking the same mistakes that the administration making the past. >>Additional comments? >>I was going to (INAUDIBLE) that six at later cautioned that I was going to ask the city attorney as well have she felt such incompetent to be able to just review What interpret the bill. >> So I hope that I colleague will be able to support my item which is something that I mentioned before, we are the voice of our residents , Community and even though I know that work has been being on my way, I think that we should putAt a record. >> Other comments? >> I would support this bill but I think that are independent lawyer SB 102 will be necessary. Number three independent lawyers and firms to review the intent wonder to and to higherA necessary lobbyist to review SB 102Act Miami Dade and legal success.They already working against this Florida legal cities as working against it. So I will support at just having number two which is hiring independent lawyers.The validity of the SB 102, before to hire the lawyers to challenge the validity of one or two could one firm to do both.That's what I think the rest some things Like we mention that can be done here and save money and the other one is The organisations that are already support, role. >> I believe that there is to comment. >> I just want to ask a mention.Is it something that we could do in-house? >> Yes. With challenging pre-emption bill, that's notTo say we can evaluate it. [ FAINT AUDIO ] I do not if you recall where the firearm pre-emption.Which is very exhaustive, it's a bunch of cities get together and try to challenge that.This state legislator has to power to pre-empt us in this space. >> I was going to see the same thing, usually I would like(INAUDIBLE) D, city attorney a legal document and sometimes I know that it's outside the capacity. >> Yes.100% could >> Because I know that there are other issues that you prefer. >> Yes, for example, with the pension obviously. >> Okay.That include your comment council woman? >> Okay so that would take care of one. And the validity regarding any project presented to the city, that's also something that it can handle and? >> Yes, we work with planning department to review how certain laws are applied. Thank you so here are the comments that I made based on this.As far as review this, I'll go us for a saying,Eleven run by them putting a moratorium.We talk about putting a moratorium, it could bring, Was advised not to do it that it would immediately be challenged andWe would have to withdraw because unfortunately, it's not something that you would have to study to look and see how you fixed.It as pre-emptive.Which means the law.Self-explanatory us to what they can do with this bill.It as attacking our home role.Extremely pre-emptive, you can absolutely read it.It was look at the city attorney, for analysis, I think one analysis has been in the city.A change which which is I think more active, more successful in going to lobby amendment then we are challenging it.And the city has gotten together, to challenge a because it seems that there will be affects to this Just going to take place in the next session. So meanwhile the application to come forward as our staff Job to make sure that they Cut through the book of our code of them And our conference of plan the do best to Mitigate as much as possible.But this was the will of the state.Unfortunately we can just run it through. Unfortunately called legislator. It is extremely important that we speak with one voice in Tallahassee and let them know That the danger of this types of bill, attacks our government. We will all feel comfortable, think again direct the city, legal opinion based on this I would be comfortable voting On asking our city attorney to put a legal Put together legal opinion, validity on what you can do, give us option Of what a dozen city moving forward, Little to prepare a memo, more affirmative. I will send out the state on behalf of the city, letting them know and like I said, I continue to work with the author of this bill and it is work with a legal City to hopefully have better news in the next legislative. That will be Amended. That is what I am comfortable moving forward with. But once think we can, I'm not going to put in the city position that were not going to enter that's my position on it.I think we can take a vote on that. We are All in favor? and of us in favor I think we are all in this. >>So I do agree, I also just want to mention obviously I would in favor of this as well as the chalice appeal.Eventually at some point it as something that we should consider eventually not at this time.I think we need to find out first what the application and its.And what it says. That's a >> I think our city attorney can look and product and the recommendation.But level immediately (INAUDIBLE) >> Can I suggest that we hold onto this two wait to review. With all due respect,A concurrent for a free. >> This is what I have motion to direct the city attorney to provide a legal opinion on the validity and options that the city has honestly want to. >> Letter from a office today state.We can take a motion, but on that.And after you will all be report if you feel that something else should come up. I think right now what we are doing, it's the most we can do at this time. >> I need emotion. >> Motion and seconded.Madam Clerk please call the roll. [ CALLING ROLL ] Motion passes. >> Thank you madam clerk.Let's move on toThe public hearing portion. >> Yes Madam Mayor . [ SWEARING IN ] First item Resolution of the Mayor in the City Council of the city of Doral Florida of in the site plan for health peak properties Incorporated for the property generally located north of north-west 41 street and west of North West 109 Avenue Doral Florida, pursuant to section 53 " 184F of thecity's land development code and providing for an effective date. Thank you madam clerk. Opening up the public hearing. For item 7A.If anyone wanted speak on this item please come forward. Good afternoon Madam Mayor Council staff. I want clarification and technicality Checked there was a late an item today.I don't think it was open for public comment.Have to make a public comments On the previous item. Well, explain the issue about the moratorium. And the possible implication request is just the consider the appeal because as far as I understand that bill has been used to temporarily stop something I do know if that's same They are expert at I would like to get responsive andAppeal will be also something that should be considered Thank you very much. Anyone else? Now admitted time to come up and speak.Sitting on Madam Clerk this let the record reflect that no one else has chosen to speak. Will now allow for the staff there one come forward. >>Gillian parents are development services administrator. Good evening Mayor, Julian Perez Development service Administrator for the city.Breath sanitation regarding this project.The applicantHealth peak Or the medical office.Project is over here.The request is a safe plan revolved it's indicated by the city attorney. Sorry, city clerk.And basically what they are asking is the approval for three-storey a medical office building. This building will be located at 109150 North West 41 street and its actually to the west of an existing HCA.The general area where this facility is going to be located as on 11.4 acres desires of the building as the approximately plus as on 11.4 acres desires of the building as the approximately +62 160 square-foot. This category for this area is a business, the zoning district. This core to commercial, this development is property is going to be done on three phases. Which is medical office building that is before US considerationWill be phase 2 and then finally fees they will be asked in the future.We don't have a site plan for that or is there any plans associated with that phase 3. The they principal documents associated with this project which is conference of plan.The alarm development code and the Doral Boulevard Masterplan.As you can see, this chart various surrounding the proposed project is pretty much residential to the north land to the west as well as there's the residential commercial to East And then again to the west as that (INAUDIBLE) And to mediate North is the bridge point project your zoning map. Next slide As the surrounding areas.We are all very familiar again, building located and this property Is the freestanding emergency facility. Rest of the area is just open land. Next year as the proposed site plan and some of the rendering is associated with this project.Seconds she From the renderings one of the most important things when we looked at this project, wasTo make sure that they were consistent.Not only where they are just use, which is the HCA facility. But also the consistentWhere the adorable of our masterplan and its from the rendering is.As you can see, They have met all those requirement.And in addition, they went ahead and donated more land than that, they were supposed to. They took out a complete road of parking in order to make sure a more functional project. This project that was review for consistency our requirements for the site plan evolution section 53 " 184 C3.Of the land development code.And number of Malaysia criteria, actually there is Eight of them and the project has met all of them successfully.We first the standard is consistency Where the conference of plan and this project is consistent and further Some of the policy that I'm going to mention.This is something that very important. Because any project of the site plan Starts with consistency with our Conference of plan. It does in many different ways.An acquired sidewalk,Including landscaping and sitting areas,Front industry,Also there's a water component on this project, which is extremely support.This is one of those Activities that within the project that foreigners law impact Development masterplan. And it helps us to retain all of the stone water on site and in a natural way.Integration of the project are more effectively And to their surrounding environment.Obviously, is consistent with the existing facility as well as the other commercial uses around it. And it would also further to our medical services that were going to be providing to the surrounding communities. At enhance the property values, obviously when you have a project not only provides A first quality design, it's also sensitive integrate with the surrounding community. Added value to the surrounding area but I think also the property values.It also (INAUDIBLE) and a relationship on buildings useAnd also that very important to, is not only making sure that we are providing a project that is consistent but it's the one as they will facilitate service. Number six is protect a health safety and welfare of the residents and as indicated, the project environmental relation as well as the promotion of look ability and social interaction and that is done through thisDurable of our masterplan.Requirement are some of the factors that contribute to the creation of the healthy water and that's what we want.That's what, where the stone water retention is going to be locatedAnd then when you look across this thread with a bridge point, the new have a complete quarter towards the Turnpike trick the traffic Analysis through a traffic studyThat was doneAnd a number of recommendations as indicated on the slide usAlso indicated to only conditions and theResolution. There is no issue with this.Very briefly TheStaff recommendation.Again when we are looking at the project, is extremely important that look at the compatibility issue.And we did thatWe ensure that, everything that is designed and done in this projectWe want to make sure that is consistent that what we have here.Again we went back and look at theLunch code to make sure that everything is consistent and met requirement of those at a, Open space and overallStandards of the building code.Again I'm referring to such 3180 4C,The proposed project is consistent Where the city conference of one Specifically passivePolicies 2.1, 2.2, AndThere is a language that fact and your staff report.Proposed project again, they are studied drawBelow Doral Boulevard beautification. And finally staff recommends approval of the proposed site plan subject to the meeting or exceeding the condition requirement set forth and the development agreement twentyWeek propertiesAnd the city of Doral. >>Thank you. >> Tracey,It's nice to see all of you. Thank you JulianThat was a very thorough presentation.So got on of the technical details,I'm going to show you create a picture.So I do haveA brief presentationThe show you the renderings of the buildingAnd talk about our compatibility.SoAs you can see this is the building towards the north-west Russia give you full view of the project And landscaping. As Julian mentioned withThe Doral masterplanned design,Sidewalk,The building is three-storey.It will be located and the central portion of the site.It's accessBut existing driveways, In aNew drivewayWill be added in

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
Agenda packetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Action agendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Transcript or captionsSource recordingread transcript
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Coverage and corrections

Records considered

  • COUNCIL ZONING MEETING — Minutes
  • COUNCIL ZONING MEETING
  • COUNCIL ZONING MEETING — Closed Captions

Not claimed by this page

  • Verified meeting decisions with item-specific public-source evidence
  • Item-level plain-language summaries are not available; this page does not infer individual agenda items.
  • Item-linked, attributed deliberation
  • A source-grounded next meeting date
  • A plain-English overview is not available.
  • Official outcomes have not been published.
  • The available transcript has no reliable timestamps.
  • Transcript coverage is partial.
  • Speakers have not been reliably matched to public profiles.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.
  • An individual roll-call roster is not available.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: 2c5efba02aeb2335ad3c2acf5f22f1e4. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record