POLISCOPE

The public record

DAVIS (SACRAMENTO COUNTY)Held · official record pendingPartial coverage

City Council

Tuesday, February 20, 2024 · Government meeting record

The 30-second read

Record incomplete

City Council

Why it matters

The official meeting record is available below. Item-level plain-language summaries are not available yet.

What happens next

The scheduled meeting date has passed. Minutes or an action agenda are not published in the records we hold.

This meeting date has passed and no official outcome record has been published yet. Nothing on this page is a decision.

Transcript and record text

Closed captionsWhat was said at the meeting, transcribed Aug 3, 2026. Speech is not a decision.
  • No speaker turns were supplied with this transcript.
  • This transcript has no source timestamps.
  • No speaker identities were supplied with this transcript.

This source published text without speaker turns, so speakers and timestamps are not shown.

The opening of 98,948 stored characters

evening. Everyone. Welcome to the februari 20th 2024 meeting of the Davis City Council. I left the record note. It is 6:36 and uh, my 4 colleagues are present. So we have a quorum with that. I will move um to a to have a motion for approval of the agenda. Second. Thank you motion by COUNCILMAN Partida second by vice mayor vittala any other questions comments concerns from the agenda. All right all in favor, please. Say I I abstain motion carries 50. Thank you. With that we're going to move on to item number 1 the ceremonial ceremonial presentation Poclamation rgarding recognizing FEBRUARY 2024 as Black History Month. Proclamation recognizing FEBRUARY 2024 is Black History Month. Whereas Black History Month is an annual celebration of achievements by African-Americans and the time for recognizing their Central role in United States history and whereas in DR. Carter g Woodson a black author and historian chose the second week in FEBRUARY to coincide with the birthdays of Abraham Lincoln and Frederick Douglass as a time to study the history of Black Americans, which inspired schools and Nationwide to establish history clubs in host performances and lectures. In whereas the week-long eventually became black his month in 1976 when us PRESIDENT Gerald Ford extended the recognition to honor the 2 often the neglected in every area of endeavor throughout our history. And whereas in 1986 Congress passed Public Law 99-457 and whereas each year Black History Month has a theme and for 2024. It is African-Americans in the Arts exploring the influences African-Americans have in the fields of Visual and Performing Arts literature folklore language film music architecture and other forms of cultural expression. And whereas art is a powerful motivator and Storyteller of people and their experiences cementing their legacy in history in their local communities in the United States and whereas today ad every day is a time to honor the influences and Legacies of African-Americans from activists and civil rights civil rights Pioneers to leaders in politics science arts and more. Now therefore we the Davis City Council on behalf o citizens of Davis to hereby recognize and acknowledge a significant contributions made by African-American people to our community and Proclaim FEBRUARY 2024 to be recognized as Black History Month. Except in the proclamation recognizing FEBRUARY as Black History Month the representatives from the black student union to the Davis Junior High and high school campuses along with the Davis High High High School black student union advisor. Comica Edwards avador. Welcome. History Month everyone. My name is comica Edwards Alberto good try and I am uh advised of a co-advisor with Naomi Davis. And uh, we have been doing this for several years, uh about this is my fourth or fifth year, uh, bsu stands for black student union. It's an extracurricular club that provides a safe space school campuses for African diaspora students and allies to be together in Fellowship learn together culturally and uh to serve together civically. I've been a member. I've been advising for about 4 to 5 years and it is my honor and privilege to be here with you today to accept this Black History Month Proclamation from the city of Davis. Um, did you know that in 1926 Carter g Woodson announced the very first negro history week in honor of Frederick Douglass and Abraham Lincoln's birthdays. Um Lincoln on the uh on the on the Valentine's Day, but it's not sure because records weren't kept um on the enslaved and s that's when he celebrates. Um his mom said like you're my love or my sweetheart or something related to Valentine's Day. So that's when we celebrate Frederick Douglass day his birthday and now every FEBRUARY since 1976, we celebrate the contributions and achievements of African-Americans who have left an indelible mark on their respective communities and as a whole former us PRESIDENT. Ronald Reagan is quoted as saying understanding the history of Black Americans is a way to understanding the strength of our nation. So thank you to all of you I this place who like MAY believe black history is American history and deserves just as much attention and focus. Thank you to David City Council for recognizing the significance of this month and for continuing to uh Implement City policies that build up the black community so continue to um, make contributions to our city and finally thank you to the cmmunity relations program manager Carrie dyer for the invitation and opportunity to celebrate with you and to receive this very important Proclamation. I'll end with um, the black national anthem will not sing it I receive but it says it's by a written by James Weldon Johnson, and it's called lift every voice and sing, um lift every voice till Earth and Heaven ring ring with the harmonies of Liberty. Let our rejoicing rise high as the listening Skies, let it ReSound loud as the rolling sea. Sing a song full of the faith that the dark past has taught us. Sing a song full of the hope that the present has brought us facing the Rising Sun of our new day begun. Let us mark on until Victory is 1 I encourage all o you to continue listening to learning from and on each other this black history month and every day. So, thank you and have a good night. Ma. Thank you, And I thank you for all Take 5 minutes and if Keiko if you and whoever else is with you today we'll just come down to front of the podium and let's have a quick photo with you and go from there. Good evening Council. Thank you very much a couple of uh, more uh, announcements and reminders. Uh, we've done announcements on these at the last council meeting as well. But uh, uh, we want to keep a a wrd spreading out there about uh, our 2 different recognitions that are this time of year. Uh, 1 is for nominations, uh for the uh, Tong haiwen Memorial Awards. Those are now open through MARCH 18th, uh city of davis.Org, uh under the news categories, uh linked to uh information about these, uh, Awards recognitions and the nomination and uh, forms and information about it. Uh, the awards are in memory of uh, Davis High Shool student Tong. Hi win, uh, who was stabbed to death on MAY 4th 1983 and to help raise awareness for social justice and uh qualities to consider nominating an individual or or an organization include uh promoting civil rights, uh or and or Civic engagement creating positive human relations in our Multicultural and diverse Community, uh, improving the quality of life in Davis for residents and visitors through uh, things such as health health promotion Human Services housing education employment cultural cultural awareness or peaceful means of conflict resolution. Those nominations are open through MARCH 18 achieved and there are 2 categories of Ages under 18 and 18 and over. So, please get those denominations in. And then uh my second and final announcement tonight is uh another recognition, which is our environmental recognition Awards nominations are currently open for that through MARCH 20th. Uh for the annual Awards 3, uh uh, our business individual, um businesses. And then the second category of individual group and then the third category of nonprofit organization, and then we have the environmental Legacy award. Uh, which is uh, uh recognizing events and programs that have made a significant Environmental Qality of Life difference in Davis over time. Uh, so again under city of davis.Org in the news section. You can find a link to additional information very much. Mike. Uh item 2b city brief announcements and liaison reports and my colleagues have announcements or leave them. Item 2c city council indication of intent to pull items from consent calendar any of my colleagues wish to pull any consent calendar items. Moving right along. With that we are at iem number 3 general public comment reserved to uh commenters for items that are not on the agenda or items on the consent calendar. Also if you're not able to stay for an agenda item later on this evening, uh now would be your opportunity to speak for 2 minutes and I'll welcome our first public commenter. Tis is uh, this is where I come to complain. Just just checking. I I'll leave that to others. But anyway, um, I recently uh returned from our sister on Ukraine and I was uh, given the honor of uh, bringing him back a letter, uh to the Davis City Council and to Mayor Josh Chapman from the mayor of Oman Arena platinum, and I just wanted to leave it here with City staff. Um, and so that was it. Thank you. Brett. Something cuter last time? Good challenge here. My name is Elaine Roberts muser on februari 6th, the city council took preliminary action to approve moving forward with the concept of merging commissions. However, the subcommittee on commissions of baitland Chapman is seriously flawed process. The proposal was first made available to the public late on Friday before Tuesday city council meeting in quickly put to account Council vote that night. There was no material input from Commissioners or city staff The subcommittee on commissions has refused to appoint to fill commission vacancies in Consequence. The finance and budget commission is being destroyed and is and there is currently no citizen oversight of the city budget. There are already Rumblings against any city tax measure because of it. There are many Tech problems with the proposal as a result of the flawed process. This would not have happened had City staff and and caner has been consulted beforehand for instance the historic Resources management commission must be a separate commission to obtain clg and to streamline the sql process for development projects if the Utilities Commission is not a separate commission. There's a real possibility the city will be exposed to civil liability for not abiding by the terms of the settlement agreement in the water rate lawsuit. If the tree commission is merged with the National Resources Commission a number of city ordinances will have to be Rewritten a merger between the human relations commission and the Civic Arts commission was already determined to be a bad fit which is equally true of the other mergers in the flawed process and potential technical problems. The city council should reverse course, we're sending approval make the merger proposal and agenda item at the next meeting of each affected Commission. present and present and respond to concerns ratings in the full city council a petition to that effect has now been signed by 76 Davis residents and activists including 1 current or former Commissioners all of whom represent a broad cross-section of Alan Miller commission subcommittee commissions your merge commissions, you'll end commissions your Purge, whatever you do make it your mission to end several Davis commissions for finance merge them with uilities. Btsc into uitrans will do for trees use our sensibilities, its environmental justice and cly m to commission subcommittee commissions, you'll merge commissions. You'll end commissions. You'll Purge. What is the endgame of the strategy will bring 1 commission for everything Davis? So Davis have we got emergency for you historical into planning? We think it's overdue, but it's a nice Purge of good merge true true. I promise it'll function even as a mut there's commission than that. Don't ask me what Davis we've got it. You'll be a lucky City. It's perfect. It's functional actually just a subcommittee, but it's a nice nice Purge a good merge. Right right planning says they can handle it. They say they're very screwed. But only if they have time so we're all screwed commission subcommittee. This ain't benign. We need more input. Please take your time, uh into this last month, we've misunderstood that we could be hosed for good dear papa. This all must be well planned dear Josh. You 2 are a Davis site. It's not that every idea is damn, but this all needs to be clarified commission subcommittee plan me no plans. We're in no rush. Maybe we've learned playing with commissions. The city could get burned. S merge me know merge merge me no Purge and me no end me know blend unless you get our Buy in. Allan. Hi, Alan, Hirsch. I first like to apologize for Zoe for making requests for documents being given at the last minute, but I think we've made some major progress here. We now Distributing that letters that to the consulate are shared with the community. I think that's wonderful and I want to bring attention to a letter that Chris Granger wrote to the council, um on februari 20th that has a lot of insights in terms of Citizen involvement. And how do we learn from the downtown plan how we lived in the cap plan in terms of the citizen engagement and and and and the role of it and I I appreciate that being said, I've curious have some really interesting thoughts. You was very thoughtful person our our recommend the council and please mke that available to the public all these documents that are given to the council should be made available as part of the public record with that our accessible. That's the next step. So, but thank you so much for making that that that progress since there's a making things more transparent to the public. Alan. This is Khan speaking on item 3 general public comment and speaking as an individual throughout the meeting. off, I just want to mention that. That the council should consider postponing the scheduled MARCH 5th meeting since that is a major election day locally in California and across the country and I do think that there should be a single primary election day across the cuntry the same way there is for the general election and that the primary and general election days should be holidays, But that being the case, I think it's possible for major bodies to try to not have any substantial activities on election days as much as possible. And I do think it would be reasonable to move a regular council meeting by a week the same way that the council has deviated from the typical every 2 week schedule several over the past few months anyway, and then also on item d of the consent calendar. A grant for body cams. I do want to mention that since this is a Federal grant. I'm hoping there's no policies which might be undesirable for the city that are required for body cams. In order to receive this Grant and I also have mixed feelings body cams, and I do think that it might be useful for the city to reconsider. Its policies around the use of body cams, especially when they are on versus when they are not on it. Great, and tat is our uh last pre-recorded public comment. And we will now uh move on to item 4 the consent calendar. We have a motion to consent calendar. I apologize. I actually do have 1 that's on a just a consent calendar if we're going to go to that. I'm sorry. Sure. The Leiden executive director first 5 yolo can item e maior Capman and city council. I wish that I could be with you tonight. Thank you for accepting my voicemail comment on behalf of first by yolo. I want to Express gratitude for our Innovative partnership. Around the project road to resilience. Tank you for considering the extension of this important work together the leadership of city of Davis allowed first 5 yolo to begin this transformative health and safety effort for our youngest most vulnerable children and their families and ultimately to draw millions of dollars more from the state to expand countywide. This incl clinic and in-home project has been family centered and data driven and has produced masurable outcomes that have garnered attention throughout the state. Briefly highlight for you that nearly 90% of caregivers reduced or obtained from substance use over 70% reduced their depressive symptoms and 99% of families avoided the need to enter child welfare services. The city's contribution to our local match funding has been and remains critical. Thank you again for understanding the unique importance of very early brain development and the value of Services. Thank you for investing in your community and helping first 5 to give families what they need and deserve to thrive. Tank you, Zoe, Uh and with that actually with that segue, I'm just going to uh mention that I will abstain from the vote on 4 e that was just a public comment. Um, my wife has um business with first 5 in Yolo County and advance of cost. I'm gonna so with that being said, um, a motion to approve the consent calendar close to approve? Thank you. All right. We have a motion by vice mayor va second by council member Neville and the other questions or comments on the consent. All right all in favor, please. Say I I I opposed abstain. All right motion carries. Okay, We are on to our only regular calendar item here this evening, u item number 5, uh an exciting 1 that we had the pleasure of uh, taking up briefly in our uh city council Retreat looking forward to diving in this into this here again this evening, uh, General Plan update process for 2024. I'm going to turn this over to our city manager Mike Webb and to Sheri mezzer. Yeah, thank you very much. Mayor Chapman city council. Uh, so as we noted in the staff report. This is uh, been a highly anticipated sort of long awaited, uh point in time to uh, sort of start officially kicking off the general update of our general plan process with you as the city council, uh that actually conversation started at your Council Retreat on februari 9th with some preliminary, uh feedback on the same questions that are posed in the staff report tonight. Uh, and so the staff report here that's before you tonight sort of builds upon that and provides us a follow-up opportunity. Um, and you know more formal council meeting setting, uh to explore those same questions and really again as Sherry will outline here. The focus of tonight is about the process, um and less so on the content of should be or not be in the general plan in terms of policies and you know land use Frameworks and uh and so forth. Um, but more about what our council's uh wants desires exp expectations around the process of goi about doing a general Plan update. Uh, it's a big undertaking. Um, uh, even in an expedited manner. It's a big a substantial undertaking. Uh, and it's 1 it's been 1 that has not been initiated since the late 90s as uh, Sherry outlines in the staff report. Uh, so tonight. We are really seeking some uh, an extension of that preliminary feedback from the council and we'll lay out some of the suggested next steps. I'll just reinforce that the general Plan update process, even the development of the process is going to be an iterative multi-step Endeavor, uh to get to a place where the city council says. This is what our process is going to be with precision ad timeline and budget and dates and so forth. We're not there yet. We're not going to be there tonight. Um, but we're going to take the first steps towards getting there and uh, that's what we're here to Discuss with you tonight so with that I'm going to turn it over to Sherry as our community development director to give an overview of of the report. Uh, and then we'll be happy to entertain questions clarifications, of course from Council and engage in discussion. Um and a public comment tonight, of course, so thank you very well know we more more further back from that, but certainly it's been a general topic of discussion in more recent times, Especially now that we have finished. Sorry anybody hear me now. Okay, um now that we have finished the downtown plan. You all know. The General plan was adopted in 2001. And it took about 7 years to create and complete and from my general experience. That's about average. I know it sounds horrendously long, but uh, it unfortunately is a very complicated document. And sometimes requires a great deal of discussion and thought and careful consideration as far as what goes into it. At the same time. I think it's important that we get it done as quickly as possible because obviously an update to make the uh, General plan reflect the direction that the city is heading is a very important Endeavor to take on at this point in time. First question is what is the general plan? I think most people have no idea what the general plan is. I think most people think that the general plan is something we'll know more commonly refer to as the zoning ordinance. What can I build on my Wat are my setbacks those kinds of things? Those are actually zoning issues and the zoning document is implementation of the general plan. The general plan itself is a Visionary document. It is a policy oriented document. It is the document that sets the tone for how the physical development of a person's Community or the Citizens Community is going to take place. It sets. Uh how these decision makers. I'm sorry um Community objectives an opportunity and direction for how they might consider those issues and it's also the city's expression of quality of life and Community Values. That's where all of those things live If you read our current General plan, you'll find that it very much contains those types of now we know what is the general plan? It in it. The state of California has very carefully mandated what needs to be included in the general plan. This is really the tip of the iceberg as far as what has to be included. There's a whole chapter in the government code on what needs to be done as far as a general plan is concerned, but for regular latte people, I think the general description is that you're required to have these eements of a general plan an element is something akin to a chapter if you will. An area where you have to address various issues. Um, for example in land use that's where you set up the types of land use that you're going to have in your community everything from residential single family homes all the way up to Industrial and how intense is the industrial in the circulation element, that's where you decide how big your roads are going to be and what's your um, well in the old days we used to do level of service policies, but we probably won't need to do that again, but the kinds of things that have to be included in your general plan in order to make it what they call internally consistent. And make it an effective document. So, how do we go about doing this General Plan update? Well, there are several questions as Mike alluded to that have to be addressed before you really dive in and start general, uh, updating your general plan. So first questions is is how deep of a dive do you want to do on updating the general plan? Are we talking about throwing the whole thing out per se and starting from scratch or are we talking about an update where basically you look at the policies that are in the existing General plan and you and everything that could occur in between normally these things are generally decided at the beginning of the process and they will manifest themselves in different ways we find we go through the projects and reread the policies and become even more familiar with them and decide what we want to have in the general in the new general plan to guide us in the future. Uh, it also would provide us an opportunity the depth will provide us an opportunity to incorporate a lot of other plans that we recently have brought to bear the downtown plan the cap. And documents like that 1 on new housing element for sure. Next question is probably 1 of the big ones and that's the time for adoption. We want to incorporate as many opinions and get as much feedback as we can from various members of the community. That's an important part of the implementation and development of the general plan itself. te downside to it is of course that takes time and takes a lot of time in some cases will recall the last General plan had a 14 committees. I think it was and 200 and some odd people involved and took 7 years for that to come to fruition, and I'm sure we've all worked on projects where the more people you involved the more time it takes but it the other hand hang on bouncing back and forth. It's important to get everybody's opinion. And so it's important to come up with the process where that can happen in the most expeditious way possible. Other big important qestion is the budget obviously the more time we spend on putting together the update the more likely and more obviously the more expensive it's going to be You know are more like the more than likely going to need to hire a consultant and the more time we spend on the document the more it's going to cost. I did uh survey a few other communities in the greater Sacramento area who have recently updated their General plans and what I found was what I expected. It's somewhere between a million and 2 2 million for the plan and the eir. So I think we should count on costing us at least that much. And last but um not least of course is the level of community engagement and how do we go about doing community engagement? We at the council meeting on februari 9th the council did talk about hiring a consultant to do the heavy lift serve as an extension of Staff in order to coordinate these meetings make sure that we have all of the locations set up and things of that nature preparing the agendas for these commissions and what they're going to discuss all of these kinds of things are important and and we do on a routine nature with all the various commissions that we already have. So to have someone assigned to do the general Plan update as an extension of Staff would be critical. But what it would do also involve the community members and give them an opportunity to hve many opportunities and quite frankly to uh comment on the general plan and give ideas for what sorts of policies and issues should be addressed in the plan itself. And finally, there was next question was to what level of involvement should the council be? I believe and I think the council agreed as a is demonstrated on februari the 9th that the wants to be very involved in this the evolution and progression of this particular General Plan update. What this will do is it will allow for the council to comment on things and make changes to the plan as it moves through the process. Otherwise as you've said what can happen is it finally ends up at the council after it has spent years and months going through a public review process only to have folks frustrated because the council decides to make Your point of view is very important and needs to be reflected in the general plan as we move through the evolution of its development. Certainly, you will be the last body to as I'd like to call it bless it before we start the eir which which will identify the environmental impacts that go along with it. So but there would I Envision there would be many many many times where the council would check-in meetings where we would update you and you MAY even provide us with comment and feedback as we are moving through the process. I also hope that maybe there's some way the council could even participate in the um. Discussions as they happen in these separate groups as we develop them. The Next Step, what's the first thing we should do? I think the first thing we should do is develop request for proposals and see if we can find a consulting firm that can meet our needs. Request for our um Did I say if your request for proposal habit requests for qualifications maning that person would then tell us their experience and their qualifications to actually do a general Plan update the proposal itself wouldn't come until later after we had had some time to and would like them also to excuse me to work with the city council in reflect the kinds of things that you all want to have included in the process that point. We're not trying to guess no 1's trying to guess what kind of a process you would like to have included in the proposal and then we bring it to you on some Tuesday night and you approve it in this way. You're more involved in what the process would look like. Way a lot more I think a lot more in and not more opportunity for the public to comment on how the process is going to look. So after we do that, we would return with a consultant contract. Also, I think the council wished to consider the formation of 2 city council subcommittees 1 involving Community engagement and 1 involving solicitation of Staff input and finally we would have a workshop to provide a more detailed as I just mentioned. Plan update framework where we would indeed talk in Greater detail than we would tonight about how we might go about processing this General Plan update. It's a very different animal than anything we've done before even the downtown plan. Than the general plan? Not just what it deals with and the planning particular issues, but the way in which it works and what it does after its adopted. It's important that there are lots of integral pieces that they have to work together. So with that I will answer any questions you might have. All right. Thank you vry much, Sherry and uh depending upon the council's wishes for how to sort of work through those uh fundamental questions that Jerry had on the prior slide and that are outlined in the staff report. Um when the time is right I can either do it now or after public comment or when the council is ready for it. I'm happy to provide a brief summary of the feedback preliminary feedback that we heard on februari 9th on each of those key questions if the outlined in the staff report, too, but I'm happy to provide a brief overview of the preliminary responses that we got to those questions on the 9th and then uh engage in with the council and and verifying that direction or any uh course alterations, um the other Is uh 1 which is te fourth bullet point here, which is the potential formation of 2 Council subcommittee. So on februari 9th, there was a suggestion, uh in that Council conversation, uh about uh, the possibility of forming to help serve throughout this process and and uh be a a key Point 1 is uh on community engagement, uh, and a council subcommittee that would really serve to uh, working in in Partnership. I think with our uh, the consultant team that we met that Council ultimately select. Uh, but the subcommittee would work closely with that, uh subcommittee, uh t really focus on community outreach and engagement efforts, um and be coordinated on that and uh in particular, uh with Community engagement at large and how that process looks and take shape, but also the relationship to uh City commissions, uh, and any potential for a uh, steering committee that the council MAY be interested in forming. Um, the second subcommittee would be uh 1 that would be focused on working again. I think with the consultant tam primarily, um, and probably myself the city manager to identify appropriate means and methods of So the professional staff feedback into the general Plan update processes, so that subcommittee. Um, uh is the other 1 that's recommended to be formed the council can think about and consider whether you're ready to uh, solidify those 2 as the desired subcommittees, and if so if you want to appoint members to serve on those here tonight, uh alternatively you MAY elect to say, hey, let's let's uh defer that uh until uh, 1 of the follow-up meetings that we would coming bck with a consultant recommendations and so forth. So you have some options uh, so with that I'll turn it back to council and happy to answer any questions. Mike. Hey, my colleagues have any clarifying questions for either Mike or Sherry before we go to public comment? Questions are all that we will move to uh public comment so welcome to any public commenters. Um again, we have 2 minutes. First public comment. I'm Katie casters, and I would like to urge you to consider adding student, uh specific high density housing to the general plan. Um, I know that a lot of your constituents really do not like that. They tink it should do universities, um responsibility to care for the students and students housing and maybe the right maybe the right. Uh, but the problem is it doesn't matter if he was right or the could and should have as my mom says, um, the reality is that University is failing us and has been failing us. Um, it's not going to go away. We need a bridge between now and when it does get fixed and that the city of Davis went out of every 6 of us our housing insecure. The vacancy rate is horrendously small. I'm I have firstand experience of what happens when you can't find new housing because it's impossible. I'm stuck with housemate a martial arts instructor who pays me so much that he told me over text to couldn't speak to him face to face to resolve an issue because he was afraid he'd get me ad I wouldn't want him in my own house like a trap to animal, but I can't do anything about it because he's been searching for the past 4 and a half months because he wants out as much as I want him out and he can't find anything. This is what slow growth does to us. 1 of my best friends her mom cut her off and she couldn't find um an apartment that would take her anymore. Um, so she had to resort to going back to her shity ex-boyfriend to have a roof over her head. I looked at the housing element and your action items are just to encourage the university to do something, um about the student crisis, but nothing on the part of the city itself is listed as an action item. The students at uc Davis were irrevocably intertwined. With city's culture economy and to should the university be taking care of us? Absolutely. Yes, but they won't or they can't so now it's up to you and even if it's they need to ask you to do it would be the good thing to do. Hello, wonderful city council. I'm so thrilled that you all are taking on the general plan. Um, I'm Katherine Brinkley. I'm a professor at uc Davis. I teach a class where for 10 weeks, uh, wonderful undergrad students take on the general plan revision. I've done that since 2017, so I have spent a lot of time with our general plan is now 23 years old and has 21 chapters or Elements, which is longer than it needs to be and through that process and learning from really wonderful students and hearing about um what they are struggling wth. I have a few suggestions fr you all for the general plan process. So 1 um comes from serving on the downtown plan when uh council member parta came and said, what about Universal Design and we hadn't been given that directive. Hadn't thought about it. So what I'm encouraging you to do is to consider a guiding star for the general plan and a good guiding star would be environmental justice because it's a new requirement. 2 ways that jurisdictions are doing this is either having a standalone element all to itself or infusing it throughout the general plan if you infuse it throughout the general plan, then you touch on all that about fair treatment and meaningful involvement from the very beginning of um of the design process. Tat in mind another um suggestion that I'd like to offer is that um in the rfq you consider small gants for local agencies to do workshops and Outreach and raise awareness around the general plan process what it is what it means for zoning. And as part of that Outreach that that any commission's include student representation. We didn't have that for the downtown plan. Um, representation could include low income folks and unhoused and stifled would go a long way to boosting those voices meaningfully in the planning process. Thank you all for for getting this done. Katherine. Um I'm quite concerned about the process that we're managing our citizens in and use the way the way that the city is using the brown act to options of what could be considered a commission that would and what commissions on the council could do actually at the street commission being there was a discussion about the Nishi project and its really complex the trees on it, and they wanted to form a subcommittee and the staff told the commission. You cannot form a subcommittee because it's not 1 of the options on the agenda. In other words, the interpretation staff is using that if if the in if the result is not in te staff report the commission and I assume the council to cannot take that action. That's not democracy that staff predefined with the only ting you can do. I don't think I think that's an old brown act overreach. It's not on the spirit of the brown act. So I think that's that needs to be challenged that basically we can just the commissions and the council are going to decide whatever it wants on the particular subject matter. This is pretty important. Sort of a commission wants to form a subcommittee. That should be legitimate. The thing I ask is bending committees. We have used ad hoc committees that have lasted for years and years in this city to basically do obviously standing work. The commission can be we've had commissioned cmmittees for a long time over a year. That's usually this ch point the 3 commissary. So those I'm not sure. That's the right answer but under the law that's what you need to do. And I legislative committee and other commissions should be open at this point no more ad hoc committees for long-term standing editions. Thank you very much. Alan. Hi, Alan, Miller. I live in all these Davis um for my general plan comments. I am going to perform the entire musical cats with a symphony. I'm not. Um you know, I've been involved with Davis politics, uh Since uh I was in my mid 20s, and I'm not in my mid 20s anymore. I remember 1 of the early. Experiences was uh, we were talking with somebody about a development they were doing in our neighborhood and um, they were you know, it was all about the color and the smell of the windows and um, we came to agreement and then they and the color was different the windows were different. We contacted the people at the city and they said oh well, none of that's binding or like why did you have us focus on that in the meeting? So then after that whenever they started doing that bs I'd go no, we're going to talk about what we want to talk about. Take your tiles and your window shapes and go away. Um, and also, you know the downtown plan like we went through all that stuff arguments were about 1 this 3 floors or 4 floors or 4 floors or 5 floors, and we did all that and then it came before the council and the council just went and the same with the uh, downtown plan, Um, the design guidelines, you know, we we went through years and put that all together and then you know right after uh, somebody wanted to and so they had a visioning plan and they envisioned a big development that wasn't work that we had done. So basically what I'm saying is, you know, all the work that you do and all the time that you spend is a complete waste of time because it's um, just overridden as soon as somebody wants to do something different. So, um, I'm just telling the young people have it occasionally you win. Good. Name is Elaine Roberts muser according to the staff report on the general Plan update and I quote staff recommends that the consultant be responsible for coordinating all communication between decisions makers staff members commission members and the community at Large. By making the consultant a conduit between al participants in the process a centralized place of communication is created and all ideas can be bedded. Instead the subcommittee on commissions of Veteran Chapman has jumped the gun assuming that commissions will somehow be a better process for addressing the general Plan update without any input from whatever consultant the city will hire in Consequence. The merge commission proposal is poorly aligned with the gpu elements. None of the gpu elements includes a fiscal category is described in the merger proposal. Nor is there a gpu element that includes an equity and culture category nor is the city council contemplating a major overhaul of the general plan. Therefore there is no implement a major overhaul of commissions to better align with the gpu as claimed by the subcommittee on commissions. Just as the subcommittee on commissions refused to obtain commission or city staff input on the merger proposal. They are also refusing to get input from Consultants who are experts in the gpu process. Let the gpu gpu Consultants be the conduit between all participants in the process and advise what initial steps to take. And while they buy their time consultant, I suggest the subcommittee on commissions use the time while waiting to seek input from commissions and City staff the merger plan the council prematurely and hastily approved in concept. Thank you. Elaine. Seitz, um a former panning commissioner and I served on my update years ago in the subsequent housing element searing committee that followed that uh, the process was a good 1. And it was a very inclusive of the community, uh to draft the current General plan. Uh, which is actually a very good General plan. It's it included 215 data citizens 14 committees 2 years of volunteer work the 7 years took the city to get it written up. There was not that was not the Citizen's slowdown. You know In fact, it was such a good General plan that other cities actually used it as a as a basis base document to to draft their own General plans. So it's been considered a model General plan. So the current General plan has all the elements that the staff mentioned in the staff report except for 1 that's been added in recent years, uh by by the state and that's the environmental justice. Which could be supplemented, but what's important is that there needs to be public input on this? Not just the commission's, you know giving input to this which you know, the commission is another issue that I want to address in that regarding this the commissions, uh, the suggesting any suggestion of combining or eliminating them is a terrible idea. Uh, Davis has always been a community strongly supporting the Democratic process a public input diminishing and eliminating by combining them is not de a democratic process and it really is quite contrary. So I would like like so many others who have spoken to this responding on this issue to urge the council to not diminish and not combine or eliminate these important citizen committees, uh commissions which would only diminish and eliminate, uh, the public input for the planning of the future of their community. So, uh, there's nothing further from a democratic process than taking such an action, but general Plan update, please uh just document took a long time and a million dollars to write and a lt of community input. So, uh, it just needs to be tweaked. Basically. It does not need to be eliminated or thrown out. Thank you by the country. Thank you. Hello, my name is Ethan Stern. I'm a student at the University of California Davis. And I live at the intersection of 5th and pine. Uh, well, I'm not a registered voter be very upfront and saying I have lived here now for more than a year and I do consider it my home. And I would like to make a few points here firstly just because something is being updated does not make it that the first version was bad that the new version is bad. That the new version is bad. It means that the new version is fundamentally. It was made at the time to suit the needs of the time not made now to suit the needs of our current system and I think the points that my colleague and classmate my professor, uh, Katherine Brinkley brought our fantastic ones as somebody who personally studies environmental justice. I think it needs to be included and not only does it need to be tacked on as a side note, but it actually needs to be its own section and at the core of what the city of Davis's prioritizing because how can we be Democratic? How can we be a city that claims to be this? Great Democratic Hub and say, oh well if you're not making as much money or you're from a socioeconomically different background than I am live in a slightly worse neighborhood and I'm not saying that Davis is the worst at this it's not but we're not perfect and I think we should while not letting the great be the enemy of the good still strive for the great because fundamentally why not at least try then I would also like to add that we should add. A housing element if not even specifically for students for the residents of Davis more broadly. As a student fundamentally, It is nearly impossible to find housing. I myself have spent weeks toiling over which Housing Development to live in fundamentally half of them have mold and need to be updated. They cannot be updated under the status quo. And so I think a housing element to allow for at the very least higher density housing should be incorporated into the next general plan so that you know, we don't have to keep living in unsafe environments. We don't living uh in the example cited by my colleague in literally unsafe living environments with people who we cannot avoid because there is not enough housing. Thank you. Thank you. Have any other in-person public comments? That I'll close the in Person Public comment and move to any pre-recorded. This is speaking on item 5 about the general Plan update. So I agree with what the council has already discussed that's presented in the staff report around the breadth of this update. And I also think that if the council so desires directly be involved in this update throughout the process. And that should include having multiple public Council items on this process as it goes along and I also favored doing as much as possible in general to make sure that the broader Community is part of these conversations as well. So I would favor having workshops and whatnot like the type that were done during the downtown specific plan update as well as doing direct Outreach to different impacted communities, especially the most marginalized and those who are often not part of these types of discussions. I also think that getting both formal and informal feedback from Community organizations that are interested and knowledgeable about And then finally, I do think that commissions should be directly involved as well and that commissions that should be able to give formal as well as informal feedback too. So in particular, I think that each commission should have at least 1 meeting where there is an item around the general plan it relates to their specialization the agenda. And since this process is likely to take several years. I think it is quite possible to do that as long as it is scheduled and planned well ahead of time in order to make sure Yes, sir. This is Ron ortell. Uh, I'd like to clarify my um my message regarding item number 5 and just use this message instead and I think the first 1 was very clear. Um, it's possible. Um, yeah, so I guys have already heard an earful regarding, uh, consolidating commissions and um, you know, seems like, uh, you know, I'm just adding my voice to that as well. Uh, I really do think you you are endangering your goal of expanding the city outward, uh on the peripheral lands by consolidating commissions. So in a sense, um, I'm kind of happy to see you guys, uh, alienate yourself uh, especially if you're going to if you're going to ask voters to uh dismantle measure j and or approve sprawling developments like this second act of Co I'm not really sure what my message is except that. Um, I do think you're increasingly out of touch and are underestimating, uh, the the reaction to the consolidation of commissions and also the uh, updating of general plan which I assume um, It's also an attempt t expand outward on the Farmland. So. Anyway, yeah, um, I think that's my message. Thank you. Bye. Hello, this is Nancy price. I'm calling about item 5 the general Plan update process. I like to uh, first say that. Um in this process, I do not think that the general plan must be entirely and comprehensively, uh, updated I or overhauled. I think that there needs to be uh, some updates of specific elements that city council could discuss that need to be focused on the there is a list of required elements in the uh, packet of materials to be discussed this evening. Uh, I think it's very important that this is an open a democratic and um inclusive process. That um of commissions are included and uh, the general public is uh available to is uh invited to participate think that the um, The the issues here are to update what is needed to be update to uh, bring the plan. Uh, To a point where the issues that we're going to be considering of housing Transportation sustainability a downtown, uh, and and economic development can be addressed sufficiently to uh have an updated plan, but I would not spend uh, the uh requirement for all the funds in order to do a comprehensive, uh plan at this point. Thank you very much. Zoe. And with that, uh, we'll close public comment on agenda item number it back, um to the Des and if it's okay with my colleagues and my turn to Mike, um for a quick recap. From our Retreat on te nights and then we'll turn it back to uh to council for uh questions and and dialogue. Thank you. Yeah, very good happy to do that. Um sure if w could go back to the prior slide with the key questions that city council provided, uh preliminary input on these questions on februari 9th that was summarized in your staff report as well for wanting to to see the uh, the summary of of those inputs. So you're going to the uh, I'll go through each of these and uh, Briefly summarize, uh, the feedback that we heard that evening, uh, and then trn to council for uh, further elaboration or discussion. Um, so the first question the at the breadth of the general Plan update, um, the council feedback on the 9th was really just to stay focused on the essentials the focus in on the elements or chapters, uh that are required the state. Um, and with the recognition be, you know at some additional um, uh components that MAY be uh, get identified through the process to incorporate along the way. Uh, but to otherwise, uh, stay focused on the on the essentials, um, utilize and referencing uh, where appropriate in the document what are effectively Myriad um, uh Master plans specific plans and so forth that the city has developed especially the last 2 years. Those include of course is often referenced tonight the downtown plan, uh, that was just completed, uh, the housing element that was just certified by the state. Um, the things like the urban Forest master plan, uh, the homeless strategic plan, which is currently uh being developed. Um the open space plan the climate action plan, uh climate action adaptation plan, uh amongst others, uh, we have a multitude of plans that uh have taken very specific deep dives into particular topics that can be very for the general Plan update. Um, but some of them don't necessarily, uh, lend themselves to you know, their own chapter because things like the housing element MAY have a certain um, uh, you know timeline associated with them, uh, the housing element that was just certified, uh, for example, you know would go through 2029 and at that point there would be a new general, uh, housing element that would need to be incorporated, uh, and thought through so given that the that current adopted the general Plan update might focus on you know, the initial throws of the next housing element, um as the main focus, uh, for example, but um in other areas in terms of the breadth, uh, there was recognition, I think by the council that the current General plan has many good policies, uh, and does not necessarily require starting over. Um, but it was it's important. Uh, I think to the as was expressed by the Council on the 9th to analyze current General plan for policies, uh that MAY uh still be relevant versus those that uh MAY just simply need updating versus those that MAY say hey this is out of date now and and should and should go away. So there was definitely a recognition that the current General plan, uh, and that there should be uh early in the process, you know with the consultant on board, uh, and and Analysis of uh of that of the current General plan. Uh Council also expressed, uh an interest in uh, evaluating the different methods of going about including environmental justice, uh in the document either as mentioned here tonight as its own Standalone chapter. That's 1 option. The other option is to integrate throughout the chapters and there was mentioned. Um, I think from council member, uh, Neville, uh about there's even a third option that hadn't thought of yet which is sort of a a hybrid uh to consider. Uh, but I think the council expressed interest in wanting to understand the sort of the the pros and cons of each of those different methodologies before making a hard decision on how to go about that and that's something that Community input and consultant input. Could I think very much help Uh, lastly the council. Uh, uh, Really stressed that calling this a general Plan update is crucial. Um, so that it signals strongly that again uh provides a good starting place. So that was some of the a summary of the feedback with respect to the uh, the breadth of the general Plan update. I'm happy to move on to the next 1 unless the council would prefer to have a conversation 1 at a time. Otherwise, I can go through them all. Up to the council here. Yeah, if you want to just kind of quickly go through the last 4 that we can come back. All right, these others will go a bit a bit, uh quicker time adoption again, uh the time frame that the council really expressed an interest in wanting to strive for a um a process that was closer to to 2 years, um with the understanding that there would need to be about a 9 to 12 month period for preparation of the eir that would you know, make it a effectively a 3 year process, um, but to really strive to get to that 2 year mark, um, if at all possible, um, and to keep momentum, uh going with the let things stagnate and go offline for months at a time and and so frth, uh, which can So that was a strong, uh feedback from the council in terms of te timeline, uh as for Budget again, as Sherry mentioned the cost can be roughly anywhere from 1 to 1 and a half million dollars roughly, uh to prepare, uh, a general plan. Um, and to the extent that uh, any ballot measures MAY be required, uh to incorporate, um, inclusion of certain lands that are subject to measure jrd, uh, that would be in addition to in terms of time and and funding but um, just recognizing that as a as a brief sidebar, uh, the council feedback on the 9th really was let's keep this the the process um, uh with our budgetary means um, and focus on keeping uh cost to that 1 and a half to 2 million dollar Mark currently in the budget. We have about $800,000 give or take, uh in budget that we've collected. Uh, and those are fees are fees that are collected on building permits from new development. Uh, and so those have been collected. Over the years those are also the funds that we use the city used to update the downtown plan. So for example, so, um, we keep collecting those funds as the process goes. And so there's that Revenue collection that still happens, but just uh, uh keeping in mind that we'll need to uh supplement the budget that we currently have along the way but we have sufficient funds and certainly to get the process started, uh in a good robust way. With Community engagement. Uh, this was a a big topic of the discussion, uh with Council on the 9th, um in the council, uh, you know, gave some pretty extensive feedback on this, uh, in summary, you know, utilizing a consultant to be an extension of staff to do the heavy lift, uh into uh serving that capacity as as experts. Um, we and our staff the last time we did a general Plan update here in Davis was you know adopted in 2001. We are not doing this every day. Are consultant teams out there. Who all they do is General plan updates with communities. They know this material in and out. They are experts in it. They know what methodologies and best practices work. Well which ones uh MAY not work as well. So really using them to do the heavy lift, uh, particularly when it comes to both helping design the process but also the community engagement, uh in solicitation of that engagement. Um, the council expressed that how commissions are to that Community engagement. Um, and that uh, there's uh a way to align, uh with u key elements of the general plan, uh with commissions, um, and commissions or subcommittees thereof, uh working with the consultant, uh team is a crucial aspect in obtaining local expertise and inputs, uh from uh from them, uh and ensuring that the commissions are provided with the resources and training for successful Outreach and engagement is also crucial Uh, that also be a key role for our consultancy. Uh, there was also uh Council expressed interest in Broad and robust CommunityWide engagement. So really focusing on going to the people, uh, and going to the organizations and utilizing our cmmunity-based organizations and leveraging those to help reach out and connect with those people who MAY not otherwise normally be engaged on a process like this. To really, uh, make a big efforts to reach out, uh and engage Uh in those ways. Um uh, and then with respect to the iea of forming a steering committee, uh 1 we had a steering committee for example during the downtown Plan update. I think there was an interest in council's part and better understanding the different, uh options around that and what does that look like? What are the ways to uh formulate around that um, and uh, just have some discussion about it, uh as the as the process unfolds. Uh, and then lastly with the council involvement, uh from yourselves, uh, strong interest, uh in staying engaged staying, uh apprised of of how things are progressing. Uh, we heard tonight that some of the ideas around, uh, you know doing frequent workshops with the council. We did some of that with the downtown plan, uh, both Community facing workshops and then our Council, uh, workshops and Chambers, uh, so council is very interested in being involved in Hands-On. Um, so not just a passive role of you know, a general plan being presented to you when it's all done and then the council being sort of the last stop in the process, but the council expressed the real strong desire to be involved, uh, all along the way from the beginning of the creation of the process itself and then throughout the implementation thereof, uh, the idea of the 2 2 Sub committees are being recommended, uh was raised. Um, and again, like I said having those check-in points along the way via regular Council agenda up update items and workshops, uh with was signaled as something being a very strong interest. So that's uh a quick, uh, snapshot summary o some of the preliminary feedback that the council provided on the 9th and I'll turn it back to you. Thank you Mike and I appreciate you providing that framework as we as we go through the conversation this evening and um outlining some of the conversation that's already been had in providing that to uh, folks who are here this evening as well. Uh, so with that I'm going to I'm going to turn to my colleagues and and open it up for uh questions, uh conversation dialogue, uh for staff when we like to It's off sure company partita. Yeah. Um, I have a question about the eir process for this. Is it similar to eir processes that we're familiar with as far as um the time frame then like once it is completed what happens after the eir process? You mean once after the clients? Okay, um, yes, the eir process would be very similar to what you have experienced on other projects. Probably this. So again the most similar being the downtown plan. So when you're developing a plan such as the downtown and the general plan, that is the project as opposed to something that actually going to build So the pan itself becomes th

Agenda textCity Council

Page

/

4

Loading…

![](https://docs.google.com/viewerng/thumb?ds=AON1mFxHXE0pofLjNhEY1NkYgztmSHt5wvsELi6l8T70NoAy8n5NkNwfDVMPj9gRbqY6vShTLjxnIkjjOA2sAqqk2aFlRdIWhgwud4A0PcyfZEgBo_gVBI56B0THqurx7Shm2MbU-zwiFi3bggHXw3r19GNNDLFz4yn9L9Q2F62uhogZq9mzi64qXobNuuCKNiV--vh42wKDnTqFO7i0st5WKOYZMVBvIlRLWqH6SA_zZLkLK5IYB8pBWk3Qc4jc0NFf-gmw1DlQjrf8euFvnXtmdvkWtREU0_FTUCQsdv4mkyV1X0MmuhbYaKH-h8aDra0JPhvnKVoDCkKzCxLYLW5C6iuB5pOxGQ%3D%3D&ck=lantern&dsmi=unknown&authuser&w=800&webp=true&p=proj)

{"id": "", "title": "DocumentViewer.php", "mimeType": "application\\/pdf"}

[mailto:CityCouncilMembers@cityofdavis.org](mailto:CityCouncilMembers@cityofdavis.org)

## Page 1 of 4

Page 1 of 4

CITY OF DAVIS

CITY COUNCIL MEETING AGENDA

COMMUNITY CHAMBERS, 23 RUSSELL BOULEVARD, DAVIS, CA 95616

TUESDAY, FEBRUARY 20, 2024

6:30 P.M.

Members of the City Council:

Josh Chapman, Mayor

Bapu Vaitla, Vice Mayor

Will Arnold

Donna Neville Mike Webb, City Manager

Gloria Partida Inder Khalsa, City Attorney

PLEASE NOTE – The numerical order of items on this agenda is for convenience of reference;

times listed are estimates. Items may be taken out of order upon request of the Mayor or Coun- cil Members. A 4/5 vote of the Council is required to begin consideration of a new item of busi- ness after 11:30 p.m.

Roll Call

Approval of Agenda

Item 1

6:30 Ceremonial Presentation: Proclamation Recognizing February 2024 as Black His- tory Month

Item 2

6:35 A. City Manager Brief Announcements

B. City Council Brief Announcements and Liaison Reports from Various 2x2 Meet- ings and Commission/Board/Inter-jurisdictional Assignments

C. City Council Indication of Intent to Pull Item(s) from the Consent Calendar for

Discussion

Item 3

6:45 Public Comments

The Public Comments section is for the City Council to receive comments; except for brief ques- tions for clarification, no discussion or action may be taken on any item that is not listed on the

agenda. Public comment may be continued to the end of the meeting if the time allotted for public

comment expires.

IN PERSON PUBLIC COMMENTS:

Any member of the public may address the City Council on matters not listed on this

agenda, or on matters listed on the consent calendar. If possible, citizens should reserve

their comments for regular matters listed on this agenda until the time the item is consid- ered by the Council. Speakers will be asked to line up at the podium and state their name

Showing the first 24,000 of 98,948 characters. The full document is at the source.

evening. Everyone. Welcome to the februari 20th 2024 meeting of the Davis City Council. I left the record note. It is 6:36 and uh, my 4 colleagues are present. So we have a quorum with that. I will move um to a to have a motion for approval of the agenda. Second. Thank you motion by COUNCILMAN Partida second by vice mayor vittala any other questions comments concerns from the agenda. All right all in favor, please. Say I I abstain motion carries 50. Thank you. With that we're going to move on to item number 1 the ceremonial ceremonial presentation Poclamation rgarding recognizing FEBRUARY 2024 as Black History Month. Proclamation recognizing FEBRUARY 2024 is Black History Month. Whereas Black History Month is an annual celebration of achievements by African-Americans and the time for recognizing their Central role in United States history and whereas in DR. Carter g Woodson a black author and historian chose the second week in FEBRUARY to coincide with the birthdays of Abraham Lincoln and Frederick Douglass as a time to study the history of Black Americans, which inspired schools and Nationwide to establish history clubs in host performances and lectures. In whereas the week-long eventually became black his month in 1976 when us PRESIDENT Gerald Ford extended the recognition to honor the 2 often the neglected in every area of endeavor throughout our history. And whereas in 1986 Congress passed Public Law 99-457 and whereas each year Black History Month has a theme and for 2024. It is African-Americans in the Arts exploring the influences African-Americans have in the fields of Visual and Performing Arts literature folklore language film music architecture and other forms of cultural expression. And whereas art is a powerful motivator and Storyteller of people and their experiences cementing their legacy in history in their local communities in the United States and whereas today ad every day is a time to honor the influences and Legacies of African-Americans from activists and civil rights civil rights Pioneers to leaders in politics science arts and more. Now therefore we the Davis City Council on behalf o citizens of Davis to hereby recognize and acknowledge a significant contributions made by African-American people to our community and Proclaim FEBRUARY 2024 to be recognized as Black History Month. Except in the proclamation recognizing FEBRUARY as Black History Month the representatives from the black student union to the Davis Junior High and high school campuses along with the Davis High High High School black student union advisor. Comica Edwards avador. Welcome. History Month everyone. My name is comica Edwards Alberto good try and I am uh advised of a co-advisor with Naomi Davis. And uh, we have been doing this for several years, uh about this is my fourth or fifth year, uh, bsu stands for black student union. It's an extracurricular club that provides a safe space school campuses for African diaspora students and allies to be together in Fellowship learn together culturally and uh to serve together civically. I've been a member. I've been advising for about 4 to 5 years and it is my honor and privilege to be here with you today to accept this Black History Month Proclamation from the city of Davis. Um, did you know that in 1926 Carter g Woodson announced the very first negro history week in honor of Frederick Douglass and Abraham Lincoln's birthdays. Um Lincoln on the uh on the on the Valentine's Day, but it's not sure because records weren't kept um on the enslaved and s that's when he celebrates. Um his mom said like you're my love or my sweetheart or something related to Valentine's Day. So that's when we celebrate Frederick Douglass day his birthday and now every FEBRUARY since 1976, we celebrate the contributions and achievements of African-Americans who have left an indelible mark on their respective communities and as a whole former us PRESIDENT. Ronald Reagan is quoted as saying understanding the history of Black Americans is a way to understanding the strength of our nation. So thank you to all of you I this place who like MAY believe black history is American history and deserves just as much attention and focus. Thank you to David City Council for recognizing the significance of this month and for continuing to uh Implement City policies that build up the black community so continue to um, make contributions to our city and finally thank you to the cmmunity relations program manager Carrie dyer for the invitation and opportunity to celebrate with you and to receive this very important Proclamation. I'll end with um, the black national anthem will not sing it I receive but it says it's by a written by James Weldon Johnson, and it's called lift every voice and sing, um lift every voice till Earth and Heaven ring ring with the harmonies of Liberty. Let our rejoicing rise high as the listening Skies, let it ReSound loud as the rolling sea. Sing a song full of the faith that the dark past has taught us. Sing a song full of the hope that the present has brought us facing the Rising Sun of our new day begun. Let us mark on until Victory is 1 I encourage all o you to continue listening to learning from and on each other this black history month and every day. So, thank you and have a good night. Ma. Thank you, And I thank you for all Take 5 minutes and if Keiko if you and whoever else is with you today we'll just come down to front of the podium and let's have a quick photo with you and go from there. Good evening Council. Thank you very much a couple of uh, more uh, announcements and reminders. Uh, we've done announcements on these at the last council meeting as well. But uh, uh, we want to keep a a wrd spreading out there about uh, our 2 different recognitions that are this time of year. Uh, 1 is for nominations, uh for the uh, Tong haiwen Memorial Awards. Those are now open through MARCH 18th, uh city of davis.Org, uh under the news categories, uh linked to uh information about these, uh, Awards recognitions and the nomination and uh, forms and information about it. Uh, the awards are in memory of uh, Davis High Shool student Tong. Hi win, uh, who was stabbed to death on MAY 4th 1983 and to help raise awareness for social justice and uh qualities to consider nominating an individual or or an organization include uh promoting civil rights, uh or and or Civic engagement creating positive human relations in our Multicultural and diverse Community, uh, improving the quality of life in Davis for residents and visitors through uh, things such as health health promotion Human Services housing education employment cultural cultural awareness or peaceful means of conflict resolution. Those nominations are open through MARCH 18 achieved and there are 2 categories of Ages under 18 and 18 and over. So, please get those denominations in. And then uh my second and final announcement tonight is uh another recognition, which is our environmental recognition Awards nominations are currently open for that through MARCH 20th. Uh for the annual Awards 3, uh uh, our business individual, um businesses. And then the second category of individual group and then the third category of nonprofit organization, and then we have the environmental Legacy award. Uh, which is uh, uh recognizing events and programs that have made a significant Environmental Qality of Life difference in Davis over time. Uh, so again under city of davis.Org in the news section. You can find a link to additional information very much. Mike. Uh item 2b city brief announcements and liaison reports and my colleagues have announcements or leave them. Item 2c city council indication of intent to pull items from consent calendar any of my colleagues wish to pull any consent calendar items. Moving right along. With that we are at iem number 3 general public comment reserved to uh commenters for items that are not on the agenda or items on the consent calendar. Also if you're not able to stay for an agenda item later on this evening, uh now would be your opportunity to speak for 2 minutes and I'll welcome our first public commenter. Tis is uh, this is where I come to complain. Just just checking. I I'll leave that to others. But anyway, um, I recently uh returned from our sister on Ukraine and I was uh, given the honor of uh, bringing him back a letter, uh to the Davis City Council and to Mayor Josh Chapman from the mayor of Oman Arena platinum, and I just wanted to leave it here with City staff. Um, and so that was it. Thank you. Brett. Something cuter last time? Good challenge here. My name is Elaine Roberts muser on februari 6th, the city council took preliminary action to approve moving forward with the concept of merging commissions. However, the subcommittee on commissions of baitland Chapman is seriously flawed process. The proposal was first made available to the public late on Friday before Tuesday city council meeting in quickly put to account Council vote that night. There was no material input from Commissioners or city staff The subcommittee on commissions has refused to appoint to fill commission vacancies in Consequence. The finance and budget commission is being destroyed and is and there is currently no citizen oversight of the city budget. There are already Rumblings against any city tax measure because of it. There are many Tech problems with the proposal as a result of the flawed process. This would not have happened had City staff and and caner has been consulted beforehand for instance the historic Resources management commission must be a separate commission to obtain clg and to streamline the sql process for development projects if the Utilities Commission is not a separate commission. There's a real possibility the city will be exposed to civil liability for not abiding by the terms of the settlement agreement in the water rate lawsuit. If the tree commission is merged with the National Resources Commission a number of city ordinances will have to be Rewritten a merger between the human relations commission and the Civic Arts commission was already determined to be a bad fit which is equally true of the other mergers in the flawed process and potential technical problems. The city council should reverse course, we're sending approval make the merger proposal and agenda item at the next meeting of each affected Commission. present and present and respond to concerns ratings in the full city council a petition to that effect has now been signed by 76 Davis residents and activists including 1 current or former Commissioners all of whom represent a broad cross-section of Alan Miller commission subcommittee commissions your merge commissions, you'll end commissions your Purge, whatever you do make it your mission to end several Davis commissions for finance merge them with uilities. Btsc into uitrans will do for trees use our sensibilities, its environmental justice and cly m to commission subcommittee commissions, you'll merge commissions. You'll end commissions. You'll Purge. What is the endgame of the strategy will bring 1 commission for everything Davis? So Davis have we got emergency for you historical into planning? We think it's overdue, but it's a nice Purge of good merge true true. I promise it'll function even as a mut there's commission than that. Don't ask me what Davis we've got it. You'll be a lucky City. It's perfect. It's functional actually just a subcommittee, but it's a nice nice Purge a good merge. Right right planning says they can handle it. They say they're very screwed. But only if they have time so we're all screwed commission subcommittee. This ain't benign. We need more input. Please take your time, uh into this last month, we've misunderstood that we could be hosed for good dear papa. This all must be well planned dear Josh. You 2 are a Davis site. It's not that every idea is damn, but this all needs to be clarified commission subcommittee plan me no plans. We're in no rush. Maybe we've learned playing with commissions. The city could get burned. S merge me know merge merge me no Purge and me no end me know blend unless you get our Buy in. Allan. Hi, Alan, Hirsch. I first like to apologize for Zoe for making requests for documents being given at the last minute, but I think we've made some major progress here. We now Distributing that letters that to the consulate are shared with the community. I think that's wonderful and I want to bring attention to a letter that Chris Granger wrote to the council, um on februari 20th that has a lot of insights in terms of Citizen involvement. And how do we learn from the downtown plan how we lived in the cap plan in terms of the citizen engagement and and and and the role of it and I I appreciate that being said, I've curious have some really interesting thoughts. You was very thoughtful person our our recommend the council and please mke that available to the public all these documents that are given to the council should be made available as part of the public record with that our accessible. That's the next step. So, but thank you so much for making that that that progress since there's a making things more transparent to the public. Alan. This is Khan speaking on item 3 general public comment and speaking as an individual throughout the meeting. off, I just want to mention that. That the council should consider postponing the scheduled MARCH 5th meeting since that is a major election day locally in California and across the country and I do think that there should be a single primary election day across the cuntry the same way there is for the general election and that the primary and general election days should be holidays, But that being the case, I think it's possible for major bodies to try to not have any substantial activities on election days as much as possible. And I do think it would be reasonable to move a regular council meeting by a week the same way that the council has deviated from the typical every 2 week schedule several over the past few months anyway, and then also on item d of the consent calendar. A grant for body cams. I do want to mention that since this is a Federal grant. I'm hoping there's no policies which might be undesirable for the city that are required for body cams. In order to receive this Grant and I also have mixed feelings body cams, and I do think that it might be useful for the city to reconsider. Its policies around the use of body cams, especially when they are on versus when they are not on it. Great, and tat is our uh last pre-recorded public comment. And we will now uh move on to item 4 the consent calendar. We have a motion to consent calendar. I apologize. I actually do have 1 that's on a just a consent calendar if we're going to go to that. I'm sorry. Sure. The Leiden executive director first 5 yolo can item e maior Capman and city council. I wish that I could be with you tonight. Thank you for accepting my voicemail comment on behalf of first by yolo. I want to Express gratitude for our Innovative partnership. Around the project road to resilience. Tank you for considering the extension of this important work together the leadership of city of Davis allowed first 5 yolo to begin this transformative health and safety effort for our youngest most vulnerable children and their families and ultimately to draw millions of dollars more from the state to expand countywide. This incl clinic and in-home project has been family centered and data driven and has produced masurable outcomes that have garnered attention throughout the state. Briefly highlight for you that nearly 90% of caregivers reduced or obtained from substance use over 70% reduced their depressive symptoms and 99% of families avoided the need to enter child welfare services. The city's contribution to our local match funding has been and remains critical. Thank you again for understanding the unique importance of very early brain development and the value of Services. Thank you for investing in your community and helping first 5 to give families what they need and deserve to thrive. Tank you, Zoe, Uh and with that actually with that segue, I'm just going to uh mention that I will abstain from the vote on 4 e that was just a public comment. Um, my wife has um business with first 5 in Yolo County and advance of cost. I'm gonna so with that being said, um, a motion to approve the consent calendar close to approve? Thank you. All right. We have a motion by vice mayor va second by council member Neville and the other questions or comments on the consent. All right all in favor, please. Say I I I opposed abstain. All right motion carries. Okay, We are on to our only regular calendar item here this evening, u item number 5, uh an exciting 1 that we had the pleasure of uh, taking up briefly in our uh city council Retreat looking forward to diving in this into this here again this evening, uh, General Plan update process for 2024. I'm going to turn this over to our city manager Mike Webb and to Sheri mezzer. Yeah, thank you very much. Mayor Chapman city council. Uh, so as we noted in the staff report. This is uh, been a highly anticipated sort of long awaited, uh point in time to uh, sort of start officially kicking off the general update of our general plan process with you as the city council, uh that actually conversation started at your Council Retreat on februari 9th with some preliminary, uh feedback on the same questions that are posed in the staff report tonight. Uh, and so the staff report here that's before you tonight sort of builds upon that and provides us a follow-up opportunity. Um, and you know more formal council meeting setting, uh to explore those same questions and really again as Sherry will outline here. The focus of tonight is about the process, um and less so on the content of should be or not be in the general plan in terms of policies and you know land use Frameworks and uh and so forth. Um, but more about what our council's uh wants desires exp expectations around the process of goi about doing a general Plan update. Uh, it's a big undertaking. Um, uh, even in an expedited manner. It's a big a substantial undertaking. Uh, and it's 1 it's been 1 that has not been initiated since the late 90s as uh, Sherry outlines in the staff report. Uh, so tonight. We are really seeking some uh, an extension of that preliminary feedback from the council and we'll lay out some of the suggested next steps. I'll just reinforce that the general Plan update process, even the development of the process is going to be an iterative multi-step Endeavor, uh to get to a place where the city council says. This is what our process is going to be with precision ad timeline and budget and dates and so forth. We're not there yet. We're not going to be there tonight. Um, but we're going to take the first steps towards getting there and uh, that's what we're here to Discuss with you tonight so with that I'm going to turn it over to Sherry as our community development director to give an overview of of the report. Uh, and then we'll be happy to entertain questions clarifications, of course from Council and engage in discussion. Um and a public comment tonight, of course, so thank you very well know we more more further back from that, but certainly it's been a general topic of discussion in more recent times, Especially now that we have finished. Sorry anybody hear me now. Okay, um now that we have finished the downtown plan. You all know. The General plan was adopted in 2001. And it took about 7 years to create and complete and from my general experience. That's about average. I know it sounds horrendously long, but uh, it unfortunately is a very complicated document. And sometimes requires a great deal of discussion and thought and careful consideration as far as what goes into it. At the same time. I think it's important that we get it done as quickly as possible because obviously an update to make the uh, General plan reflect the direction that the city is heading is a very important Endeavor to take on at this point in time. First question is what is the general plan? I think most people have no idea what the general plan is. I think most people think that the general plan is something we'll know more commonly refer to as the zoning ordinance. What can I build on my Wat are my setbacks those kinds of things? Those are actually zoning issues and the zoning document is implementation of the general plan. The general plan itself is a Visionary document. It is a policy oriented document. It is the document that sets the tone for how the physical development of a person's Community or the Citizens Community is going to take place. It sets. Uh how these decision makers. I'm sorry um Community objectives an opportunity and direction for how they might consider those issues and it's also the city's expression of quality of life and Community Values. That's where all of those things live If you read our current General plan, you'll find that it very much contains those types of now we know what is the general plan? It in it. The state of California has very carefully mandated what needs to be included in the general plan. This is really the tip of the iceberg as far as what has to be included. There's a whole chapter in the government code on what needs to be done as far as a general plan is concerned, but for regular latte people, I think the general description is that you're required to have these eements of a general plan an element is something akin to a chapter if you will. An area where you have to address various issues. Um, for example in land use that's where you set up the types of land use that you're going to have in your community everything from residential single family homes all the way up to Industrial and how intense is the industrial in the circulation element, that's where you decide how big your roads are going to be and what's your um, well in the old days we used to do level of service policies, but we probably won't need to do that again, but the kinds of things that have to be included in your general plan in order to make it what they call internally consistent. And make it an effective document. So, how do we go about doing this General Plan update? Well, there are several questions as Mike alluded to that have to be addressed before you really dive in and start general, uh, updating your general plan. So first questions is is how deep of a dive do you want to do on updating the general plan? Are we talking about throwing the whole thing out per se and starting from scratch or are we talking about an update where basically you look at the policies that are in the existing General plan and you and everything that could occur in between normally these things are generally decided at the beginning of the process and they will manifest themselves in different ways we find we go through the projects and reread the policies and become even more familiar with them and decide what we want to have in the general in the new general plan to guide us in the future. Uh, it also would provide us an opportunity the depth will provide us an opportunity to incorporate a lot of other plans that we recently have brought to bear the downtown plan the cap. And documents like that 1 on new housing element for sure. Next question is probably 1 of the big ones and that's the time for adoption. We want to incorporate as many opinions and get as much feedback as we can from various members of the community. That's an important part of the implementation and development of the general plan itself. te downside to it is of course that takes time and takes a lot of time in some cases will recall the last General plan had a 14 committees. I think it was and 200 and some odd people involved and took 7 years for that to come to fruition, and I'm sure we've all worked on projects where the more people you involv

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
Agenda packetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Action agendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
MinutesNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Transcript or captionsSource recordread transcript
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Coverage and corrections

Records considered

  • City Council
  • City Council — Closed Captions

Not claimed by this page

  • Verified meeting decisions with item-specific public-source evidence
  • Item-level plain-language summaries are not available; this page does not infer individual agenda items.
  • Item-linked, attributed deliberation
  • A source-grounded next meeting date
  • A plain-English overview is not available.
  • Official outcomes have not been published.
  • The available transcript has no reliable timestamps.
  • Transcript coverage is partial.
  • No audio or video recording is linked.
  • Speakers have not been reliably matched to public profiles.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.
  • An individual roll-call roster is not available.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: 2c1989ba83a3acf49a0c9f22fd24f01f. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record