POLISCOPE

The public record

VILLAGE NO 4 CDD (MARION COUNTY) · LOCALDecisions and attributed speech publishedDistrict meetings and recordsPartial coverage

Village Community Development District No. 4

Friday, July 11, 2025 · Community development district meeting record

The 30-second read

Recorded outcome

Village Community Development District No. 4

Why it matters

The official meeting record is available below. Item-level plain-language summaries are not available yet.

What happens next

No later meeting or follow-up date is stated in the reviewed record.

An official outcome record and a transcript or captions are published for this meeting.

Recorded votes

Listen to the meeting The recording is not indexed to individual votes.

5 recorded votes0 split

Split votes (0)

Every recorded vote passed unanimously.

Unanimous votes (5)

Voting yes on all of these (5)

Cliff Wieneryes
Mark Hayesyes
Cary Sternbergyes
Jim Murphyyes
Don Deakinyes

2.A. Approval of the Minutes

Yes
5
No
0

3.A. Review and Approval for Geotechnical Engineering Remediation and Asphalt

Yes
5
No
0
Yes
5
No
0

Consent Agenda

Yes
5
No
0

Public Hearings

Yes
5
No
0

People and votes

Cary Sternberg

5 recorded votes

  1. Recorded vote

    2.A. Approval of the Minutes - Voted yes on the motion “The Board approved the Minutes from the June 13, 2025 meeting”; the record reports passed.

    Official record
  2. Recorded vote

    3.A. Review and Approval for Geotechnical Engineering Remediation and Asphalt - Voted yes on the motion “The Board approved proceeding with the geotechnical remediations and asphalt repairs for the Cameron Villas Roadway Project in the estimated amount of $363,111.99 and adoption of Resolution 2025-10 amending the District’s budget in the amou”; the record reports passed.

    Official record
  3. Recorded vote

    Adjourn - Voted yes on the motion “The Board adjourned the meeting”; the record reports passed.

    Official record
  4. Recorded vote

    Consent Agenda - Voted yes on the motion “The Board took formal action on the following items: 2.B. Approval of Amendment Three to the Agreement for RFP #21P-029 (Group A) with CEPRA Landscape, LLC decreasing the total annual agreement amount to $1,059,508.99 and authorized the Cha”; the record reports passed.

    Official record
  5. Recorded vote

    Public Hearings - Voted yes on the motion “The Board adopted Resolution 2025-09 Amending and Restating Chapter IV of the District’s Rule to include enforcement measures for repeat offenders regarding towing and removal of repeat FIFTH ORDER OF BUSINESS: Supervisor Comments 5.A. Supe”; the record reports passed.

    Official record
See all 5 roll calls with named votes

Transcript and record text

Closed captionsWhat was said at the meeting, transcribed Nov 7, 2026. Speech is not a decision.
  • Some speaker identities remain unresolved.

The opening of 115,095 stored characters

Good afternoon, everybody. It's uh, this is the District four Board of Supervisors July 11th, 2025. Meeting. Not coming through at all. Huh? You're not Coming through at all Time. Could you hear me now? Yeah. Okay. Good afternoon everybody. This is July, the July 11th, 2025, district four Board of Supervisors meeting. Roll call shows that all supervisors are present. First center agendas are standing for the pledge of the flag and remain standing for a moment of silence for our military personnel and first responders. Thank you. I wanna welcome all of our attendees. It's nice to have a full house, even though I think I know why most of you are here. Uh, Next thing I need, the agenda is public comments. If you have a public comment to make, please step to the podium. State your name and address. You will have three minutes. I will tell you that the clock is up there. I will be watching the clock. When your three minutes are up, you're done. We're not going over because there's probably gonna be more than one or two people that wanna speak today. Um, please try not to repeat what people before you have said. We'll hear you the first time and we don't need to hear the same things over and over. And before we get into anything, if you have a cell phone, please shut it off, put it on vibrate, do not disturb or something. Um, and for your information, our meeting is being video recorded. The a a c meeting was the first meeting that was video recorded this week on Wednesday. And we are the second. So our meetings will now be recorded every month. So if you can't come, you can always watch it the next day or later that day once they post it on our website. Okay. With that being said, if somebody has a comment breach. Karen, I saw your hand go first. Karen O'Farrell 17 8 5 1 Southeast 85th Ton Court. My comment is very brief. I just notice every month on the agenda that under supervisors reports there's, um, a liaison designation, designee. You know what I'm saying? And I'm curious as to what the expectation is for the role of liaison. All I have, thank you. Okay. And yes, ma'am. Yes. Good afternoon. My name is Debbie Spoon over. I reside at 1 6 8 3 9 Southeast 91st Crenshaw Terrace in Phillips Village in community Development district number four. I'm here to speak about, of course, the proposed Walmart development located at Mulberry Lane and Phillips Court. The one thing I wanna say before we start is my initial request would be not to put a Walmart there because it definitely severely impacts the neighborhood that was so quiet that we all moved into due to that fact. The location of it being a little outside of the villages and a little outside of, of uh, regular living was perfect for all of us, and that's where we decided to retire. If the project does move forward, I wanna focus today on public safety. Phillips Court. The road directly east of the proposed development is the only entrance and exit into Phillips Villas neighborhood. If Phillips V Court was blocked due to a traffic crash or other incident, how would fire emergency, medical or law enforcement respond to emergencies in our neighborhood? This has been already been an ongoing concern since neighborhood was built. Increases in traffic will lead to increases in traffic crashes, especially considering the lack of traffic controls and signals at both Highway 42 and Phillips Court and Mulberry Lane in Phillips court. The traffic study, the most current one that we saw submitted into Marion County, appears to indicate that no changes need to be made or any of on any of the impacted roadways. That's a concern. Traffic on these roadways will increase dramatically and impact accessibility into our neighborhood by both residents and emergency services. If no changes are made, the entry and exit points from the proposed parking lot onto Phillips Court will cause traffic backups and traffic crashes that will block the only entry into our neighborhood. In addition, Phillips Villas does not have a sidewalk or multimodal path allowing walkers, bicycles or golf carts and alternatives to using the single roadway at Phillips Court entry in and out of the neighborhood. We will need sidewalk along Phillips court and a multimodal path that connects to either Bellmead Circle or Mulberry Lane. These concerns need to be addressed by the elected appointed decision makers at Community Development District four and Marion County before giving approval for the development. Thank you. We appreciate all that you do. Thanks. Thank you. Yes, ma'am. Good afternoon. My name is Lori Pop and I reside at 91 57 Southeast 166 Sprung Lane in Phillips Villas in Community Development District four. I'm here to speak about proposed Walmart, um, development located at Mulberry Lane in Phillips Court. First of all, I would like to say I am not in favor of this project. My focus today, if it goes forward, will be quality of life issues. Quality of life issues such as noise and light pollution, garbage odor, rodent infestation, and increases in suspicious or criminal activity at the development are serious concerns for Phillips fills residence hours of operation for Walmart neighborhood markets do not reflect the neighboring businesses, which all close by 9:00 PM Walmart starts very early in the morning and extends late into the evening every day of the week, 6:00 AM to 11:00 PM Will the gas station be open 24 hours? We don't know. With the future development of the property, east of this proposed Walmart already approved 40 acres consisting of 86 homes just to the east of us. And then the additional housing department, uh, development that is currently being built off 42 just east of St. Mark's Church will consist of over 1500 homes. This is going to bring quite a lot of congestion and traffic into our area off of 42. Were either of these developments in consideration in the traffic study that was done? Lastly, I ask that if you have not been over to Phillips Villa, is that you come and take a look at our entrance and where the Walmart will be located. Our concerns need to be addressed by the elected appointed decision makers at Community Development District four and Marion County before giving approval for this development. Thank you for your time. Yes, ma'am. Good afternoon. My name is Renee Al. I live at 16 8 2 5 Southeast 91st Crenshaw Terrace in Phillips. It's District four for eight years with my husband John. First I want to thank you for taking the time to listen to our concerns. I wanna talk to you today about public safety, especially if the Walmart goes in. According to National Public Radio interview with Shannon Petty Peace, Walmart stores across the US experience a violent crime across daily leading local police being overwhelmed by sheer number of calls they received from these locations. There were over 200 distinct incidences of violence at Walmart stores across the country between January 1st, 2023 and December 31st, 2023. And at least one violent incident at a store was reported every month during this period. Incidents vary in severity, but include 132 Gun violence Incident. Hold on. The mic went on, the microphone went on Off. No, no, no, no, no, no. You just have just me. No, no. It's all Incidents varied in severity, but included 132 gun violence incident, 26 bomb threats, 31 physical assaults, 11 incidents involving the violent use of vehicle and one incident involving the use of arson envo harm. This is reported by the United For Respect Education Fund. They also reported between January 1st, 2020 and March 20th, 2024, there were 473 gun related incidences, which included 104 gun related deaths at Walmart stores. Meaning one out of every 10 Walmart stores in the US experienced a gun related injury or death during this period. Violent crime is particularly rare in the villages with the rate of 0.27 per 1000 residents according to two College Brothers. But in Summerfield, where there's currently a Walmart, the violent crime is 21%. Just under the national average of 22.7, news reports indicate incidents near the villages. Walmarts include shoplifting, arrests, physical altercations, and golf cart thefts. The villages has always been, had an excellent reputation of being a safe place to live. This is one of many reasons we moved here, and I'm sure that's one of the reasons why a lot of other peoples have moved here too. I would prefer that the villages, especially Phillips S, continue being a very safe place. Thank you very much for your time and consideration. Thank you. I can't see whose hand is Yes, sir. Your podiums in the way. Good afternoon. My name is Leroy Val. I reside at 91 56 Southeast, one 66th sprung lane in Phillips Vs. In CDD four. When we first visited the villages 12 years ago, we were amazed at everything that was offered here. Like all of you on the board, it was immediately evident this was the place we wanted to spend our retirement in. The villages life promises a fantastic compromise for retirees, numerous activities and events coupled with peaceful neighborhoods and above all security. The villages was promoted to us as a safe place to live with a tranquil atmosphere. I'm here to speak about the proposed Walmart development located at Mulberry Lane in Phillips Court just off Highway 42 and its potential impact to Phillips Villas. My focus will be on the same quality, safety, and quality of life that everyone here bought into and expects from the villages. The proposed Walmart will be built directly in front of Phillips and also border Summerfield right across the road, as it was mentioned in the crime rate. It's an astonishingly low 0.03 in the village is yet 21% across the road, nearly 800 times higher if you do the math. Looking at these numbers, I am very concerned about safety within our neighborhood. Our neighborhood will become a much more visible target to that 21% demographic with no man gate. There is little to deter this democra, this demographic from entering our neighborhood from a quality of life perspective. Parking lots will be on 24 7 and will be very visible to homes and Phillips, especially those on the front wall where their bedroom window now faces that direction. Store hours at a Walmart were referred to earlier, this will bring constant noise from the store traffic and semi-truck deliveries all week long. Calling the other neighborhood Walmart, they get eight deliveries a day entering and exiting our abilities with a much more difficult and dangerous that's been alluded to. We have one way in and out and now have to share it with that store and that traffic. Golf carts and bicycles will now have to share a road not only with heavy consumer traffic and semi trucks, there is no golf cart or bicycle lane on any of these roads there. From an environmental standpoint, I am also concerned about water runoff and we have a major storm. We are now covering 10 and a half acres with concrete. This area that used to absorb water will now run off either to the retention ponds or into our villas and could potentially cause damage to homes that are on the front side of that. I have much more to say along with facts, but I will wrap this up. Due to the limited speaking time we bought into the village's promise of a tranquil and safe retirement are now faced with losing a great deal of that. Our lives will be subject to noise and light pollution, disruption, and exposure to far more crime than any of us ever expected in the villages. Can any of you on the board honestly say you would welcome a Walmart in front of your home if you were in this situation bordering the outside of the villages? These concerns need to be addressed by the elected appointed decision makers at CDD four and Marion encounter before giving any approval to this project. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Anybody else? Yes, ma'am. Hello, my name is Barb Cher. I live at 92 68 Southeast, 167th Ford Street in the Phillips Villas. While I agree with all the points that have been made, I have kind of a different story. I've been a resident of the villages for almost 27 years. Originally, I lived in Del Soul South at the intersection of Morrise Boulevard and 4 66, where residents almost daily experience the dangers and challenges of cars and trucks sharing the road with golf carts. I believe the Mulberry Lane location has an abundance of safety and logistical issues to prevent approval for this particular commercial business. Thank you. You're welcome. I think it Yes, ma'am. Good afternoon and thank you for this opportunity to speak. My name is Frankie Hutchins and I'm at 90 90 Southeast, 166 Kathy Loop Villages, Florida building a Walmart and gas station in Phillips Village's entrance. Brings, brings and affects three major issues, safety, traffic, and quality of life. A golf cart path for our area was denied approximately eight years ago, leaving one entrance and exit, which could and possibly be insufficient in case of an emergency for 165 homes or families. When large service vehicles are parked near our entrance, this causes congestion for vehicles coming and going. Recently, one of our residents was nearly killed when a semi driving on Mulberry Lane did not see him. Phillips Village will become more vulnerable to questionable predators, such as crooks and homeless folk golf carts on our, in our, um, golf carts on our bike and our bikes will, oh dear. Did I get mixed up? Okay. In a possible rodent population from Walmart, trash and gas station threatens our pets and our safety in our homes. Backyards and neighborhoods fumes from the gas station and increased traffic threatens our health and safety. Increased traffic not only threatens our safety, but quality of life for our vehicles, golf carts and our bikes and walkers. Not to mention the increased volume of noise, which will interrupt our peaceful existence. According to research. Home values decrease in surrounding areas where Walmarts are built. Phillips's residents have put much time and money and planning into the improvement of our homes, making them comfortable for our lives in our later years. Two questions. Since there are no golf cart paths upon entering or exiting Phillips Court, who will be financially liable for golf cart paths on either side of the road to, um, our only entrance and who will be responsible for the wear and chair and upkeep of the roads. Due to the increased amount of traffic from semis and other large vehicles delivering gas and supplies all hours of the day and night, there is a Walmart within two to three mile radius. Why another at five gas stations in a three mile stretch from 3 0 1 to 4 41 possible solutions, a plaza, which includes specialty shops such as high, high-end boutique coffee and beverage shops, or a gym. And I'm in hope this matter can be resolved according to the goals Mr. Schwartz had in mind for seniors. Thank you very much. Thank You. Anybody else? Yes. Not so I can get close enough. Um, Hi everybody. My name is Jeannie Za and I live at 91. Ma'am, Could you get a little closer to the mic so I can hear you? It's a little hard for me. And You, you can move the mic closer to you if That makes it easier like this. Pull it. The whole thing will come closer. Can you repeat your, Well, I have to hold on to something. Microphone. Would you repeat your name for us Again? Okay. My name is Jeannie Zer. I live at 91 37 Southeast, 1 67 Ford Street. I've lived here since 2018 and I've noticed a lot of traffic and most of it is way past the speed limit. It's obvious that we will need new traffic lights in our community going east to west on 42 to turn south onto Phillips Court, but that's awfully close to the one block away set of traffic lights for the VA medical center. With so much traffic, there's more danger to non villages families and school children that are right across the way from our development. They take school buses, they stand on the corner, and this is gonna create so much more danger to those families. And if one child gets killed, that is one child too many. Um, I looked at the plot plan and I'm not sure if this is going to be a neighborhood Walmart or a larger one, but I'm asking the question, do we really need another grocery store, one block away from Publix's grocery store that has shoppers that, that will deliver. And there's a dollar store, so NOCO Station at, with the store and crazy days that are all grocery, gasoline, food and household items. Two blocks away at 42 and 4 41, I counted 130 parking spaces. To me, that's just too many vehicles in that close proximity. And I perceive that the three new roadways are going to it. It's very little dirt and grass left. And so when it rains, it's gonna be a torrent of rain and there won't be any grass or soil soak it up. It's just gonna flood the area because of all the concrete and the painting. I've also noticed the pole lights are so high and so bright at night that they can easily disturb nearby residents sleep. Um, I also noticed too, not only that there's 18 hours that the stores open, but there's about six or eight hours when they will be feeling of the, the tankers come and delivery trucks. So there's gonna be no peace and quiet for 24 hours in our neighborhood. They're gonna be unloading those trucks and stocking the shelves late into the night, making a lot of noise. And personally, I've never driven by a dumpster behind a Walmart store that wasn't dripping with puddles of goo stinky rotten food stuff that should have been picked up days before and in infrequent trash pickups. So that dumpsters are overflowing. Drawing racks. Vernon and Carnivores. Personally, I observed heavy truck deliveries at a local Walmart at night, and in the silence that makes so much noise, it wakes me up. Anyway. Traffic, as you know, is one way in or one way out. And I question a problem. Water and sewer quality and quantity, if that is there. What's gonna happen to the residents quality of water and sewer? Are we gonna get contaminated water or are we gonna get lesser volume of water? Are we gonna get less sewer, uh, uh, uh, Facilities? Ma'am, ma'am, your three minutes are up. You need to wrap it up. Thank You. Thank you. Um, I'm asking the gentlemen and everyone to please consider all of us residents who spent our hard-earned money and savings. Uh, peace and quiet. Thank you. Thank you. Anybody else? I see no other hands. So we, first of all, I will give this board a chance to answer, but I, I have something I want to say. I empathize with every single one of you, but this is not a District four issue. We don't own the property, we don't own the roads. And unfortunately, you need to go to Marion County and present your case. I would help you if I at all could, but there's absolutely nothing this board can do to change Marion County, Walmart or anybody else, the developer or anybody else that wants that property to be used. Um, so with that being said, I will listen to anything else that this board might have to say. Carrie Cliff, thank you. Uh, the, the comments are certainly apropos. I I think a lot of people don't understand what powers the districts have and don't have. Um, we are only a quasi-government agency. Um, we are tasked with effectively operating and maintaining the infrastructure and have an ability to levy assessments. Um, we are a special group with special functions, and those functions include roads, water, and sewer in the areas that affect us. Uh, we oversee the infrastructure and the services. We have absolutely no say at all about who, who buys or owns property. Outside of our jurisdiction. We have absolutely no say at all in regard to roads and, uh, services provided to, uh, Marion County businesses or landowners that are not within our boundaries. So while we, I, I understand your concerns. I understand them completely, and I agree that you are concerned. Uh, but there's really, there's nothing we can do. Uh, you know, if it, if it's a matter of somebody's taking a bus up there and they, they want people to go and pack the, the, the chambers, um, then Marion County, uh, should certainly have to listen to everybody that has an opinion. Uh, there are, there are always things like this to come up. You know, the caveat being that when, uh, when we bought our property, uh, wherever it was that we bought, you know, we take a chance on who's becoming our neighbor. And, you know, that's something that we can't control. Uh, the Phillips Villas, the property there has been advertised as commercial property, uh, since the time that they were developed and opened. And so those people that bought up there, um, you know, should have been aware of what possible things were going to go in. Uh, you know, I'm not saying that promises weren't made. Uh, we all know what, you know, salesmen will do to, to make a sale, but they weren't made by this board. They, they weren't made by, by anybody here in regard to what's coming in. So the, the, the, the vigor by which you, uh, approach this needs to be taken to the proper source, which is Marion County Development. Not us. Thank you. Could I just ask one question? Pardon? No, I'll pass for the moment. Pardon? I will pass for the moment. Don, it's your turn if you want to talk. No. Fine. Otherwise, I would like to give other people a chance to speak first. I, I understand. I, 'cause I get accused of monopolizing it already. Oh, that's okay. It's your turn. Please talk. We're not gonna go go. I will go last here like we do at a, a c. It's your turn. You wanna talk? Say something now. Okay. First of all, I really sympathize with the residents of Phillips Village, and I understand the stress that concerns and the issues that you are going through. I also recognize the fact that you are not going to be the only residents in the villages that are going to be affected by what goes in there. All of us who shop at that plaza are going to be affected. All of us who go and use County Road 42 or 3 0 1 or 4 41 are gonna be affected. The quality of our lives will all be affected in some ways favorably and other ways not. I heard the say, I'm glad that we're getting a Walmart, um, market, neighborhood market there because Publix is too expensive. What if Publix goes outta business or quits competing with us and shuts down at that market sometime in the future? What's gonna happen to the rest of the Mulberry Plaza? There are so many possible unintended consequences that we haven't even begun to look at that are going to affect everybody in the Marion County section of the villages. And so we need to take those things under consideration. We, as a board and as individuals represent the residents who live in District four. And while Mr. Weiner and Mr. Turnberg are correct that our powers and jurisdictions are limited, that doesn't mean that we cannot as a governing body and as individuals express our support for your issues and concerns. It doesn't mean that we can't go and support your cause and express our concerns as a board as to how this will affect our residents, that we represent how it will affect the quality of life and all the things that you've already talked about. I feel that we as a board could share our concerns with the Marion County Commission, That as a board we could ask that the process be slowed down to gain time to gather more facts and information so that the proposal can be fully reviewed by all concerned entities. I feel that we as a board, could hold a special public workshop regarding this issue and invite Marion County representatives, commissioners, and the development, the Marion County Development Board to come and hear what you have to say and what we could contribute to. Because we've all got a stake in this. We all have a dog in this fight. I feel that this board could explore other options and alternatives to what is currently being proposed. I feel that we could say there might be a better use than a neighborhood Walmart and a 20 pump gas station on this property. When we came initially, we asked what do they perceive for this? And the answer that we got, and I know it's not in writing, and I understand that they don't have to honor anything that they say, but we were clearly informed that the expectation was that there would be offices in there. Those offices could be doctor's offices, lawyers offices, accounting offices, chiropractors, medical offices, all kinds of other uses that have a much lower traffic count. And so I think that we should try to support you by getting Marion County and the development review boards should take some of those things in consideration and that we should work together. Karen O'Farrell just asked, what is the purpose of a liaison? What is the expectation of a liaison? Years ago, I recognized that District four was the only villages in Marion County, and that we did not have any kind of relationship with Marion County other than the fact that we lived here and we paid taxes here. And I felt that it would be appropriate for us to have a liaison from this board who could establish a cooperative working relationship with the county commissioners. And those county commissioners have listened to us before. They did respond to the residents who were concerned about what was gonna happen on the 40 acres. And, and we had even less power there because that property was not within the jurisdiction of District four. But Marion County listened to the residents. They considered that, and they made suggestions based on what the residents said to modify the plans that were originally scheduled for the 40 acres, to the point that they would be much more acceptable without being invasive to the residents who do live next to and around that 40 acres. And I think that we have a similar situation here, but we do have a dog in a fight. It does affect our villages. And I heard someone say there's only one way in or out of Phillips Village. There are no sidewalks, there are no pedestrian paths. And who's gonna maintain those roads as they suffer wear and tear? Are there any maintenance and ongoing agreements with the commercial districts there? If not, we, this board is gonna bear the burden of maintaining Phillips Court. And two thirds of that Phillips Court is going to cost us a lot of money. And it's gonna come out of not just the pockets of the residents of Phils village, is it's gonna come out of the pocket of every single resident through our non-ad alarm maintenance assessments. We are going to encounter additional costs and additional expenses as a board. And so we need to consider that as well. This board could ask for a review of the impacts of other projects. As someone already said, there's a lot of stuff coming onto County Road 42. Now, as a liaison to the Marion County, I have tried to keep this board informed of just how much is going to be brought in to County Road 42 that could have an impact on the lives of our residents and us. And that needs to be taken into consideration. And I have seen some traffic studies, but I cannot honestly say I haven't had the opportunity because this just came up on June 30th. We were just informed about it by the developer on the Daily Sun on that date. So very little time has gone by. So I do not know if that those engineering studies include what's already been approved and being constructed on County Road 42 off of, you know, off of 42, not literally honorable. So I think there's a lot that we as a board can do and can participate in and can express active support and active concerns and issues, not just for the residents of Phillips Village, but for all our residents. And that's, that's what I've got so far, Jim. Yeah. Yeah. A few comments, both, um, you know, takeaways and maybe, um, something that this board could take a look at down the road. Uh, first Don talked about, uh, you know, his liaison responsibility that he, he agreed to deal with the county. Uh, there are four liaison, um, committee members from this board that were all approved by the board, uh, to do contact with, um, entities outside of the board meeting. So that is all in place. Uh, a couple comments. Um, the, um, everybody here is aware that there's a 40 acres site, uh, next to Phillip Villas, the front 20 acres being commercial and the back 20 acres, uh, approximately at least that's was the guideline, uh, are gonna be residential type. And as Don indicated, uh, when it was originally set up, those were gonna be like highrise apartments. And as a result of, uh, residents going, uh, to Marion County and talking with the people, uh, those were brought back to units similar to water in the village. So it did have a significant impact on what the residential piece of that property is as far as the commercial, uh, again, uh, whatever the developer's gonna do there, that's approved by the county that's gonna go in there. And one of the big projects, as you see by the sign there is going to be a big storage unit. But what, what impact that has, I'm not quite sure. Uh, again, the comment that was made, uh, Mr. Chairman about the, uh, commercial property being part of the original layout. Anybody that purchased there originally, uh, was certainly aware that the front 20 acres of that site, uh, in front of Phillips Bella was going to be two things on the one side, uh, two retention ponds on the north part. And I, I don't know, is that still called Mulberry Lane? That runs through there? Yeah. Okay. The north part of Mulberry Lane belonging to, uh, CD D four and the southern part belonging to the developer to service the commercial property, which is on the other side of, uh, the Phillips entry. And again, there's, there's a lot of questions of being raised about is that site big enough to handle that kind of a development? And again, we don't have a lot of information yet on that. As far as, uh, we are aware the 40 acres site to the east of, uh, Phillips and the commercial property there, uh, will not have egress or entry into, uh, where the commercial villages property and Phillips Villa is now. At least that's what we're told. So, uh, that property is going to have to have some kind of a entrance right off of 42 into that 40 acres. Uh, as far as the cart path concerns, um, the original plotting of that site, uh, this board did, uh, vigorously go after the developer to, um, develop a cart path that would've exited to the rear, uh, or rear west of that property back by the golf course and down along the trail so that the people wouldn't have to use the current commercial property, um, to, uh, get into the village's, uh, property. Uh, that was denied. And, um, we fought it, but it didn't happen. Um, as I mentioned before, we have very little authority over the commercial property, but, and on a positive note and things this board may have to talk about in the near future, even though the original, uh, assessment that you're all receiving didn't include, uh, any cart pass being built and maintained, uh, we do, uh, c DD four does own the property where the, um, pond is on the north side of Mulberry. And, um, the other thing I'm not not sure is where does CD's four's responsibility on the road that enters Phillips Fellows begin and end and words that become commercial, uh, if that whole road is in fact, um, belongs to CD D four, uh, then we have another issue that we need to be talking to somebody about. Uh, because CDD four, if they in fact paid for that entire road without any taxes being, you know, assessed to Marion County residents to build that road, uh, we need to resolve that issue because then it becomes a point between a private road and a public road or a road that's, that we cannot restrict, um, anybody from using. So that one, uh, I have a note on that we have to take a look at, but the building of cart pass, uh, we do have property there that could be done. The question is always, uh, how do you finance it and support it? Um, for those of you who were there for maybe seven, eight years or so, you may remember, uh, that this board primarily led by Don Deacon, was able to convince a developer based on some, uh, kind of sketchy items that were in the property itself, uh, to build that cart path from the, uh, stop sign along the, um, property that's owned by the Village's Health. At the time, there was no car path there. So, you know, we've been working hard wherever we could to, uh, make that happen. Uh, solely air by the way, we will have the same issue that you have because they got that chunk of property in front of their place. And, uh, that commercial property also, uh, is pretty close to where the residents live. But again, uh, we have some issues to deal with there. Uh, the other question that's come up before this board before, as it relates to private property versus property that, uh, can be, uh, that's paid for by the residents of CDD four, but which we cannot restrict traffic on, uh, raises an issue that we really need to take a look at. Uh, and it has to do with primarily, uh, gate houses and gate passes. Uh, the issue that we may have to look at at Phillips Villas, uh, the villas right behind, um, uh, the Publix's, uh, Mulberry Grove Shopping Center. And so air would be the potential to, uh, turn those units into resident only potential, um, users so that uh, anybody who's in the parking lots or anything go over just can't push a button and go into your property. And that, that is a serious concern, I think, as far as, uh, potential problems within the community, um, we haven't seen enough, as Don has said, uh, I've looked at what I could see, but there's really nothing there. Uh, I don't know what the size of the buffer or the height of the buffer is going to be between the commercial property and your residential property. Uh, so we're not really sure. Uh, you've seen the height of the buffer behind the, uh, Mulberry Grove Plaza and the villas that are there. It's, uh, it's almost 12 foot high, uh, with trees on it and bushes. So we need, we need to find out a little bit more what they're going to do to reduce some of the noise that might be coming there. Um, I, I think that's primarily what I have to say. And I, I guess my point Don, would be that, um, even though we have no control over the commercial property, uh, we do have control over the residential property and potentially the road. And that this board will continue to look at, uh, ways that we might be able to leave whatever we can do for Phillips and Soer. Um, I see the one young lady there pushing her, uh, cart and my wife uses one too, and I see people riding, uh, you know, electric carts up and down that road. Uh, and we have a responsibility to do whatever we can do, uh, to improve the, uh, multimodal type trails, uh, on the CDD four portion of that road. And, um, I think it's fair to say this board's gonna take a very, uh, um, concerning look at being able to address some of those issues quick, just a point, point of information. Okay. Um, I, I am now on the county's website. NextGen owns the road from 42 down to, um, the Mulberry Lane, uh, intersection. Okay. CDD four owns from the Mulberry intersection into Phillip Village. We do not own the property above that. Yeah. But that piece of property that the commercial property extends on the other side of Mulberry Lane. So the question is, is that on our, our property? That road? No, no. That's also owned by NextGen. Okay. Where does the villas road ownership begin? At the gate? No, at Mulberry. At Mulberry and Phillips. So right past, once you come in and you reach the intersection, that road that goes before the gate is ours. That's where our property starts. Okay. Mulberry and Mulberry Lane that goes across is also next Gen. Yes. Understand that, understand that. So that means that that means that, uh, that road could be restricted from the north part one at a time. Okay. Excuse me. Excuse me. Uh, that means that we could take a look at that road being restricted north of the intersection in Correct. We, I, we, we can look at a lot of things. Okay. Okay. Well, it's just, just things that there, just, just so everybody understands, is that a whole lot of information out about this whole thing. Yeah. So it's really kind of hard to even decide how you even want to proceed right now, except that we know we have an issue. Um, and until we get more information, we're really spinning our wheels. But I want to give Mark, 'cause Mark hasn't said, well, I, I just think it's a item that this board is not gonna drop. Yeah, no, I agree. I don't, I don't wanna reiterate anything that's said other than I get a couple points. Um, that property there, for lack of a better term, that entire commercial development there is owned by the developer, yet at his sole discretion, what he puts in there, subject to approval from Marion County. So we really, as, as, as everybody has said, we really have no say. So whether it's right, wrong, or indifferent, I side exactly with you. I would not wanna live there. However, I had a good friend of mine who was an attorney telling me that if you don't like the view because you fear something's gonna happen, you should have bought the view that, that type of say, now that property was out there and it, it was there. The last thing that I'd like to bring up is as far as light transfer, the developer can, can ensure if, if, if, if he's made aware of that, that the light transfer has to be, has blocks on it so it doesn't shine back into the residential area, it shines only forward. And, and that happens all over the place that they do that. So that's, that's not a big deal. That's all I have. Okay. I'm not gonna, like I said, I'm not gonna reiterate everything. Okay. So I just want to say one thing and then we're going to close the subject because we got other things to discuss, um, until we know more, it's really kind of hard to do anything. I think that the idea of a workshop, once we get some more information might be a good way to go and invite Marion County. But until we see, because personally I agree what somebody said, there's no way a neighborhood Walmart and 20 gas pumps are fitting on that piece of property with parking for 120 cars. It doesn't take a genius to figure that out. So I think we might be putting a card ahead of the horse. Let's wait and get more information if that's what's gonna proceed. I'm all for having a workshop and getting our input as a board to Marion County and letting 'em answer these people in a public forum. But we need more information. So Don, Mr. Chairman, um, I am my recollection in going through hundreds of pages of engineering reports and so forth in a very short period of time, and you had to look at all the graphs and charts and everything else along with it. My recollection is that it's a lot more than 120 parking spaces. Wow. Okay. It might be close to double that amount. Um, okay. Secondly, we, Marion County has already booked, and I told this board about it, that they are going to have a Marion State of the county meeting right here in the villages. Um, and I, I think it's at Mulberry Grove Recreation Center. Mulberry, August 17th. I, yeah, uh, 22nd, 17, 22nd. I've got it here. I can confirm it. Um, but it's going to be here and it won't be the whole Marion County Commission board. It'll be the chairman of the board and the staff. And even though they are here to do a presentation about the state of the county. The 20th, the 20th, the 20th. But it is during the day, one o'clock at one o'clock on August 20 when, so it's right around the corner. So Wednesday's, so Wednesday, and even though they're here to do a presentation, it is a great opportunity for our residents, not just from Phillips Villas, but all residents from District four who are part of Marion County to come hear their, what they have to say with their presentation. And for then us to express our concerns about how our lives and quality might change as a result of this proposal. I can say that on the 40 acres, the houses and you, you backed up to that area, you were gonna be one of the ones affected. Marion County, when the residents said, we want the trees along the borders saved. And the developer, not our developer, but an outside developer from somewhere said, okay, I'll save the trees along the border for Buffer resident said, we want a fence. Along that same buffer developer was there with his attorney and said, okay. They said, we don't want a chain link or a sprint, a split rail fence. We want a PVC opaque fence of a certain height. The developer agreed to it. He said, we don't want a two or three story apartment building. We want houses, single story houses. Developer agreed. They said, we don't want tiny little lots and tiny little houses. We want designer type homes, which back up from the village in Woodbury. They backed right up and they got the developer to say he reduced the number of lots and he agreed to design those houses comparable to what was behind him in Woodbury. And on and on the list went and the developer agreed to everything. Then those of us that were around here, the developer himself booked Mulberry Recreation Center and had an open q and a and presentation with any residents that wanted to show up. And he made a wonderful presentation. And he, again, not in front of a county commission board, he agreed to everything that the residents were asking for. Now that's pressure. And the Marion County commissioners and I, I said that the board, as a resident, a dog was in the fight. I said, you know what, that 40 acres would make a wonderful park. Where's the closest Marion County Park? And two board members spoke up immediately and said, yeah, how, where is our closest park? And then they said, they went so far as to say you're right that 40 acres would make a nice Marion County Park. Now that's pressure that two of five commissioners put on that developer. I'm just sharing that information. Okay. The process, the 40 acres isn't the issue. And we I understand that. Okay. I just wanna explain how things can happen. I know. And I have a, something I want to say to staff. I would appreciate if staff and the bulletin boards in district four before the, uh, August 20th meeting would put something notifying of the Marion County meeting. So the residents, no one can come. I would hope the medic could put something in the which she just shook her head. Yes. And I will tell you that the POA will have an article in their bulletin that comes out in August about it. So people will know about it. Now, whether or not they show up, it's up to them. But we can make it so people know it's important. Mr. Chairman, can I make one comment? Yes. Something just dawned on me in lieu of holding a meeting here, wouldn't it be more appropriate to hold the meeting with the, with the, uh, people who have to say the yay or nays and that would be Marion County? Not, not, don't do it here. Have Marion County post that meeting. I don't. They're the ones who are gonna propose it. I don't think they are hosting the meeting. They, they are hosting the meeting. They are hosting the meeting that if you're gonna seriously sit down and discuss the A's and Nays Pro proposal, this, they, Marion County should be the, the ones who are gonna be hearing that. Not us. You we're not, we're not. Guys, we gotta move on. Yeah, we gotta move on. They, the, the 40 acres, they, the resident did go to the Marion County meeting. Yeah, I'm talking, I'm talking about the, the proposal. Okay. Yes. Of Walmart. That's all I'm saying. Okay. We shouldn't waste the time to do that. That should be Marion County. They're the ones who have to make the decision, not us. Okay. Next on the agenda's, the consent agenda, uh, on a motion to approve the consent agenda's, a motion to approve all items on it. There's three items, approval of the minutes amendment three to, uh, between village, community, district and spr. Landscaping and termination of agreement with, uh, cut patch, asphalt repair. Anybody want any of those three pulled? Seeing not, I just have, I have one question I'd like to ask Don. Don, um, in your, in your report that you sent back from, from, uh, the meetings with Marion County and the they can't hear you possibly. Hold on. If, if Okay. If you guys are gonna leave, please talk once you get outside and that, that would be fine. Make sure the door shut please. So should we pull this item and pass the consent without it and then consider this separately? Well we, yeah. Pull, pull the pull a minute. We'll ask the meeting and wait. Okay. Alright. I'll do it. I'll do, I'll do it. Do it under, uh, no, no, no, no. Just pull the item. Okay. Alright. Okay. Can I get a motion to approve B and C? Uh, so moved second two A. You're pulling two A. Can I get a motion? We have a motion to prove to B and C. Can they get a second? Second. All in favor? Aye. Aye. All opposed? Okay. Approved Unanim. Okay. Mark, what's your question on two A? I'm just, I'm just, um, for as a point of clarification, uh, Don had meetings with, based upon letters that he sent to us, he had meetings with the city engineer discussing converting property in the villages from public right of way to private right of way. I don't recall us ever having that discussion, uh, outside of just the entry gates. Is there, is there something that I missed that you had with, uh, Mr. K? We discussed it at our meeting and I simply shared the question that was raised here and he responded and that was it. I, I think what he's referring to Don, and I could be wrong 'cause I had the same question last month. You gave a sh sheet of paper at the meeting. Correct. And we didn't have a show. You, you talked about what was on it, but we didn't get actually a chance to read it. Mm-hmm. And then when I got home and I had time, I read it. So I have some of the same questions because some of the issues that you had on there, I didn't understand what we as a board were involved in such as, such as Rejuvenate or on Buena Vista, which we don't know. I didn't, I didn't ask him about that. He came to me a month or two earlier and said that they wanted to, um, they were scheduling rejuvenation on Buena Vista, a public road that belongs to Marion County. What he wanted to know or what he was asking. And this goes along with a cooperative working relationship. He wanted to have us communicate with the residents that there was going to be some changes in traffic patterns when they rejuvenated those roads. He was, it was a very general statement. He didn't tell me when, he didn't tell me what kind of closures they might experience. And all he said was, uh, we'd like some help in communicating with the residents. That was it. I I'm just, I'm, I I have what you gave us. So yeah, the five things were the rejuvenator, right. The patching on Southeast 40 Highway 42 conversion of currently dedicated public roads to private roads. Uh, that which was our neighborhoods. I i hundred. I know. Okay. I, I didn't understand what the point was of TA discussing that and that, I'm just asking 'cause I don't understand it between Marion County engineer and you because they have no control over our roads, period. Okay. The only road they control is Buena Vista. That's their road. The rest are ours that we pay for 'em. We, and, and no, I'm just, let me finish. And it says SW sweet sweeping and CD four and then the Rejuvenator project. I, I just didn't understand what this was actually referring to. That, that, that's where I'm going. Okay. You gave it to us and then I took it home and I read it, which was fine, but now I don't understand it. So if you could explain why you discussed, thank you, why you discussed those issues, why those issues were discussed with the Marion County engineer. That's the part I don't understand. He approached me first about the rejuvenation and I mentioned those. Oh, the, and years ago we got complaints about the condition of County Road 42 that go, in fact, it goes back probably two years. And in a conversation with, at that time, Tracy Troub, I asked, when is County Road 42 scheduled for mill and overlay or patching or whatever. Just a question. And at first she said to me, oh, your timing is perfect. I reported this to the board. Your timing is perfect. We should be, um, getting ready to do that right away. And then she came back to me later on and she said, because the budget reasons and the road is not as old as I thought it was. Uh, it's not gonna happen as quickly as we thought. And so then the new county engineer, um, and I, while we were talking about rejuvenation, I thought he was talking about rejuvenation of County Road 42. And it turned out that he wasn't. And it wasn't until even, even af long after this letter went out, did I find out that he was specifically talking about Buena Vista? And I thought he was tagging on to a conversation that I had had with Tracy Troub about County Road 42. Okay. I I, I still don't buy it. And one of the things that I would like to see put on the agenda for next month is, is a discussion as to what a liaison can do and can't do because I think this is getting outta hand. Uh, and I understand what Don's trying to do, don't get me wrong. But there are things here that, that I just don't think, I mean, if this board says to you, Don, we need to know about patching on Highway 42, please go to Amer 'cause you go to the meetings, please go and find out. But it, it appears that you are having a different kind of conversation with the engineer above and beyond with this, this board was not, was not aware of any of this until you gave us this letter. And if you hadn't given it to us, I wouldn't have had a clue about any of it. So I, I just think, I just think that we need to have parameters. That's just my opinion. And I, if the rest of the board wants to weigh in, I'm willing to, let me, let me add a couple things then Okay. To respond. Every time I go to a Marion County meeting, I, I'm there early. I stay after the meeting and commissioners who are there early as well, who come back to my seat in the auditorium and they say, well, hi, how are things going? What's, what's happening down there in the villages of Marion County? And what, what are some of the issues and concerns? The idea was to improve communication with these commissioners. Mm-hmm. To, to try and create a good working relationship, a cooperative working relationship. So it was a conversation. We, and we talked about things that have happened in our meeting, which are public record. One of those public record things was the condition of County Road 42. One of those issues has been about patching. One of our conversations was about can we privatize our roads? Are they already privatized or are they classified as public? Those were all things that we discussed publicly in meetings. And so I shared that with a commissioner, not necessarily an engineer. And after the meeting, similar conversations occur. Um, dealing with how things are going down here. They are taking an interest in the residents here, and they are concerned about what's going on and what they can do to help. That relationship would not exist at all if we didn't have a liaison and we're the only district in Marion from the villages and I, because those were public record items, which they may or may not have been aware of. I didn't see any problem in mentioning them to them. I didn't, they understand that I don't represent the board as a whole. They understand that I don't even represent myself as a supervisor because I, they get my newsletter that goes out every month and they see my disclaimer in there. And I also have a disclaimer on their behalf. And so I'm not having what I would consider, you know, inappropriate or improper conversations. I could have been a resident and not, and not a supervisor, and had those same conversations. I sit in the meeting and hear the conversations from other developments all around Marion County and they have similar conversations. The difference is they go up to the podium and they speak for their five minutes or, or whatever. I seldom get up to the podium and speak. I my conversations are one-on-one when we are saying hi or hello or how's life and so on. They're not formal discussions. Uh oh. Speaking of, of, of Marion County, when we had the sinkhole issue and the houses were having problems, especially with inspections on four or five occasions, we had officials from Marion County come here to us. Other than that, we, and once we had a commissioner come and that stopped, it would be nice once in a while if he said to them, why don't you come to the District four board and you can say what you're saying to me, to the board. I just, perception is everything and I understand what you're doing. And, and believe me, from the bottom of my heart, nobody works harder than Don Deacon. And, and I've said that many, many times. You do more things than anybody I know. And I give you credit for that. I am worried about perception. You could, you can put all the disclaimers you want on the bottom of everything you write and say, but people are going to see it their way. And I'm trying to just stop some of that perception. Oh, and I have nothing else to say on this. I just needed clarification on what you gave us. And now I have it, Mr. Chairman. Yes. And this just goes right to the point that I think that you're getting at, in, in the, in here it says, I am reading right from the minutes. Mr. Kon indicated that the prior review he completed previously was that one of the conditions of the original development order was that the roadways and the villages remain public. Now, I don't know what impact that has. Mark on, on, on what, what you and I discussed about, so long as there's a bond, you can't make those roads private. Does that change that by any means? No. No. The, the issue is closing off roads, which we don't intend on doing. Um, limiting traffic when there are bonds that are still due. Okay. Okay. Thank you. Okay. I make a motion to approve the minutes as written board. Second. Second. All in favor? Aye. Aye. All opposed? Okay. Do business, uh, review of, uh, engine? Oh, you said, thank you. Good afternoon. Board Mike Harris, district Property Management. I'm here for your review and approval for geological engineering remediation and asphalt repairs at Cameron Village's Roadway project and approval of budget resolution 2025 dash 10 on April 20th, 2025. Community watch reported a depression next to a stormwater inlet in the center of the road on Crow Field Avenue. And another depression next to the stormwater manhole in the center of the road on Victoria Lane. Stormwater and utility inspections. Two standard penetration tests, subgrade, sample borings, three road cores, followed by hand, auger bos, and a multi-channel analysis of subsurface waves were completed. Recommendations are to stabilize the area with concrete grout injection. Seal, the storm water system with chemical crowd grout injection, and repave the roadway. The project cost for the geological testing has already been completed. And recommendation, recommended geotechnical remediations and subsequent roadway repairs are estimated to be approximately $363,111 and 99 cents. Funding in the amount of $130,699 is currently remaining in the approved CDD four fiscal year 24 25 budget for geological anomaly expenses and stormwater repairs. The final cost for this project may increase or decrease depending on the quantity of grout and material and roadway based replacement if needed. Budget resolution 2025 dash 10 is included in the included for the remaining amount of $199,501, which utilizes available funding from District four Capital Reserve for the amount of the needed to complete this project. Staff request approval to proceed with the geological recommendations and asphalt repairs for the Cameron Villa Roadway Project in the total estimated amount of approximately 363,100, excuse me, and $11 and nine 9 cents, and approval of budget resolution 2025 dash 10 and issuance of all associated purchase orders. And I'm here if you have any questions. I'm sure somebody has questions. No, Don, do you have a question? Yeah, I'm, I'm kind of, uh, shocked by the amount. Yes. So much of, of that bill and, um, I, I just, if, if the finance department could tell us we just last month set a maximum limit of 3% as a possible increase in our non valor maintenance assessment, can they remind us what that 3% would total to? Just the 3%? What, what would that bring us in dollars after the 2% that goes in Marion County, 50 60 Brandy Cook budget. So the additional funding, uh, if the 3% is what's in the final approval, would bring an additional, um, $87,765. 87,000 What? 7 65? 7 65. 7 65. Okay. And we cannot go any higher in September when we finalize it. And this is more than four times that amount. So 3%, 3%, 3% the next four years is still maybe going to cover the cost of that one item. And I want that in a minutes because I think our residents need to understand the kind of pressures that we are under when we face these catastrophic events. And crow field. What we're dealing with here does not look like a catastrophic event. But I know that there's a lot that we can't see and there's a lot that's required for us to remedy this situation. And again, I sympathize with the residents in Cameron Villas because they've had several incidences there, and a straight line from the west, outside the wall from the west of Cameron v's. Wall all the way across to the pond and over to McLaren Avenue. And so I, I really am concerned about that. Now, I, having said all of that, I know that we need to pass this motion. We need to get this thing repaired. Uh, you can't do a circle. You hit a dead end as far away from the entrance as you can get, and then you have to make an awkward turnaround and go back the other way. And someone that goes the other direction hits that same dead end and they have to do the same thing. They have to turn around and come back. I don't know how they do trash collection and other services there, but it is certainly not conducive to the quiet lifestyle that they want either. And, and so I think that we need to act on this as quickly as possible. My concern, Don, is that it took a long time to get these figures that's been like that for months. And had we had this information in June, we could have done differently with the 3%. Now we're locked in. And I agree with you, it's more than four times. So we're gonna raise, we're actually gonna be forced to raise it 3%, even if we didn't want to. 'cause I was hoping we didn't even have to do that, although we might not. There's still other things. I, this is the same issue we had on the same pipe that we just spent lots of money on less than a year ago. I, I, I just, I guess I get frustrated when it's the same thing over and over again. And, and it's like we have really deep pockets and we keep doing this. Gary, Mr. Chairman, I'm, I, I'm confused. $87,000 does not sound like the right amount. No, I'm thinking that too. You know, we're talking about a 3% increase in our budget. 87, something gotta be wrong. Well, we have a $3 million budget. 3% of that is 90, $90,000. Uh, what's, tell me what your, I'm sorry. I do, we have a, uh, we, we generate about 3 million now. So if you raise 3%, three times 3% of three, 3 million, what do you got? I'm not on the 3 million. Hold on, I'm pulling up the packet again. Let us pull up the packet from June. Took that folder out today too. Yeah, that was in the, in the date of our last meeting. Yeah, I just took that folder up. So the additional revenue is 117,000. And then the additional tax collector fees, Lemme find the right line, Is, um, about three and a half thousand

MINUTES OF MEETING VILLAGE COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DISTRICT NO. 4 A meeting of the Board of Supervisors of Village Community Development District No. 4 was held on Friday, July 11, 2025 at 1:30 p.m. in the Ashley Wilkes Room at the Savannah Recreation Center, 1545 Buena Vista Boulevard, The Villages Florida, 32162. Board members present and constituting a quorum: Cliff Wiener Chair Mark Hayes Vice Chair Cary Sternberg Supervisor Jim Murphy Supervisor Don Deakin Supervisor Staff Present: Carrie Duckett Deputy District Manager Mark Brionez District Counsel Bruce Brown Assistant District Manager Jennifer Liunoras Finance Director Brandy Cook Budget Director Emilly Morrison Purchasing Assistant Director Matt Armstrong Community Standards Director Mike Harris District Property Management Director Caitlyn Bessoni Executive Assistant Jennifer Farlow District Clerk Rebecca Johnson Deputy District Clerk FIRST ORDER OF BUSINESS: Call to Order 1.A. Roll Call Chair Wiener called the meeting to order at 1:30 p.m. and stated for the record that all Supervisors were present representing a quorum. 1.B. Pledge of Allegiance The Chair led the Pledge of Allegiance.

VCDD 4 – Meeting Minutes July 11, 2025 Page 2 1.C. Observation of Moment of Silence Chair Wiener led the Board and audience members in attendance in a moment of silence to observe those who have served our Country and community. 1.D. Welcome Meeting Attendees The Board welcomed all those in attendance. 1.E. Public Comments Karen O’Farrell stated that every month under the Committee Updates portion of the agenda there are Liaisons designated for each Committee and requested clarification of the expectations of that role. Residents from Phillips Villas expressed concerns about the proposed construction of a Walmart Marketplace and 20-pump gas station on the commercial property located at Mulberry Lane and Phillips Court along CR 42. The residents’ concerns pertained to the possible negative impact of public safety responses due to increased traffic; increased traffic on the roadways; safety concerns for the residents due to the lack of sidewalks and multi-modal paths which requires walkers, bicyclists and golf carts utilize the roadways; quality-of-life concerns to include increased noise, commercial lighting pollution, garbage odors, increased criminal activity; extended hours of operation; the negative impact to the roadways because of the semi-delivery trucks and the need for additional street lights and/or access to the commercial area. Chair Wiener stated that the Board empathizes with the residents’ concerns but advised that the commercial activities and the roadways do not fall under the purview of this Board. Chair Wiener recommended that the residents also address their concerns with the Marion County Board of County Commissioners (MCBOCC). Supervisor Sternberg advised the residents, for their information, that Village Community Development District (VCDD) No. 4 is a quasi-governmental entity which is tasked with effectively operating and maintaining the infrastructure of the District and levy assessments within the boundaries of the District. Supervisor Deakin stated that the quality of life for all residents who utilize the commercial area and roadways will be impacted, and stated that the Board could request that the MCBOCC consider slowing the approval process for this project to provide the residents with an opportunity to review the

VCDD 4 – Meeting Minutes July 11, 2025 Page 3 proposal and provide alternate commercial entities for this area which would have a reduced impact on the amount of traffic in the area. Supervisor Deakin suggested that the Board hold a joint Workshop with the MCBOCC and Planning Board to provide an opportunity for the Marion County officials to receive resident input. The resident input received by Marion County had a large impact on the type of housing that will be constructed on the 40 acres property adjacent to The Villages. Supervisor Murphy concurred that the resident input received by Marion County did have an impact on the construction of the housing and storage facility on the 40 acres property adjacent to The Villages. Supervisor Murphy advised that when Phillips Villas was being constructed the Board actively requested that the Developer construct a multi-modal path to the rear and west of the villa unit for an extra access point, but that did not occur. The District owns that property and it could be an option if a multi-modal path needs to be constructed. Additionally, the Board may need to consider restricting access to the villa units that are close to commercial properties to resident only gates. Supervisor Sternberg clarified that NextGen, a commercial entity, owns the roadway from CR 42 to the Mulberry Lane intersection and District 4 owns the roadway from the Mulberry intersection into Phillips Villas. Vice Chair Hayes stated that it is the Developer’s sole discretion what to construct on the commercial property, subject to approval by Marion County, and advised that restrictions can be placed on the lighting to ensure that the light transfer does not shine into the residents’ homes. Chair Wiener stated that until additional information is received, it is difficult to proceed, but once additional information is received a public forum should be provided for the residents to address their concerns to Marion County. Supervisor Deakin stated that Marion County will be holding a State of the County Meeting at Mulberry Recreation Center on August 20, 2025 at 1:00 p.m. which could provide the residents with an opportunity to express their concerns about the proposed Walmart Market. Chair Wiener requested that the information about the Marion County State of the County August 20, 2025 meeting be posted at the postal facilities.

VCDD 4 – Meeting Minutes July 11, 2025 Page 4 SECOND ORDER OF BUSINESS: Consent Agenda Chair Wiener advised the Board that a motion to approve the Consent Agenda is a motion to approve all recommended actions. All matters on the Consent Agenda are considered routine and no discussion is required unless desired by a Board Supervisor or a member of the public. Vice Chair Hayes requested that item 2.A. be pulled from the Consent Agenda. On MOTION by Cary Sternberg, seconded by Jim Murphy, with all in favor, the Board took formal action on the following items: 2.B. Approval of Amendment Three to the Agreement for RFP #21P-029 (Group A) with CEPRA Landscape, LLC decreasing the total annual agreement amount to $1,059,508.99 and authorized the Chair/Vice Chair to execute the Amendment. 2.C. Approval of the termination of the Agreement for ITB #24B-024 for Cut/Patch Asphalt repair Services with Tri-State Asphalt Corporation for non- performance. 2.A. Approval of the Minutes Vice Chair Hayes stated that based on comments made at the June 13, 2025 Meeting, Supervisor Deakin advised the Board that he had meetings with the Marion County Engineer to discuss converting the District 4 roadways from public rights-of-way to private rights-of-way, which he does not remember this Board discussing. Chair Wiener stated that Supervisor Deakin handed out a document at the June 13, 2025 meeting that the Board did not have an opportunity to review at that time, but the document included items that this Board had no involvement in, such as an application of rejuvenator to Buena Vista Boulevard. Chair Wiener stated that he did not understand why Supervisor Deakin would discuss the District’s roads with the County Engineer, because the County does not have purview over the District 4 roads. Supervisor Deakin stated that the County Engineer was requesting that the Board forward communication to the residents when the road rejuvenator was scheduled to be completed. Chair Wiener requested that an agenda item be included on the August 8, 2025 agenda for the Board to discuss the roles of a liaison, because it appears that discussions may be occurring beyond what this Board has requested.

VCDD 4 – Meeting Minutes July 11, 2025 Page 5 Supervisor Deakin stated that the purpose of this liaison role was to improve communication with the County Commissioners, and when he attends the MCBOCC meetings the County Commissioners will inquire about items being addressed by the Board, which he communicates. Vice Chair Hayes stated that included in the Minutes was a statement that “Mr. Coon indicated that the prior review he completed previously was that one of the conditions of the original development order was that the roadways in The Villages remain public”, and inquired of Mr. Brionez if that has an impact of his opinion that was provided that stated that the roadways must remain public as long as there is bond debt. Mr. Brionez stated that his opinion has not changed. On MOTION by Mark Hayes, seconded by Jim Murphy, with all in favor, the Board approved the Minutes from the June 13, 2025 meeting. THIRD ORDER OF BUSINESS: New Business 3.A. Review and Approval for Geotechnical Engineering Remediation and Asphalt Repairs for the Cameron Villas Roadway Project and adoption of budget Resolution 2025-10 Mike Harris, District Property Management (DPM) Director, advised that on April 20, 2025 Community Watch reported a depression in the center of the road between 17156 and 17168 SE 78th Crowfield Avenue and another depression occurred next to the stormwater manhole in the center of the road between 7836 and 7840 SE 171st Victoria Lane. Stormwater and utilities inspections, two (2) standard penetration tests (SPT) and a multi-channel analysis of surface waves were completed, which resulted in the Engineer’s recommendation to stabilize the area with concrete grout injection, seal the stormwater system with chemical grout injection and repave the roadway. Mr. Harris advised that the estimate to complete the project is $363,111.99 and to date $33,001.99 has been expended. The necessary funds to fund the project in the amount of $199,501 are included in Working Capital; however, the final cost for the project may increase or decrease depending on the quantity of grout material and roadway base replacement needed. Staff is recommending that the Board approve the geotechnical remediations and asphalt repairs for the Cameron Villas Roadway Project in the estimated amount of $363,111.99 and adopt Resolution 2025-10 amending the District’s budget in the amount of $199,501.

VCDD 4 – Meeting Minutes July 11, 2025 Page 6 Supervisor Deakin expressed concern at the estimated amount to complete the project and stated that at the June 13, 2025 meeting the Board approved a proposed maximum increase of 3% to the maintenance assessment rates and requested that Staff advise the Board what the annual additional revenues would be. Brandy Cook, Budget Director, stated that the 3% increase would result in an additional $108,000 of net revenue. Supervisor Deakin expressed frustration that it would take in excess of three (3) years of collecting the additional maintenance revenue received to offset the cost of this project. Chair Wiener expressed frustration about the amount of time it took for the Board to receive the estimated cost of the project, because if the information had been provided prior to or at the June meeting, the Board could have chosen a different course of action. Chair Wiener further stated that it is frustrating that the District will again have to expend funds for depression repairs in this villa unit. On MOTION by Don Deakin, seconded by Cary Sternberg, with all in favor, the Board approved proceeding with the geotechnical remediations and asphalt repairs for the Cameron Villas Roadway Project in the estimated amount of $363,111.99 and adoption of Resolution 2025-10 amending the District’s budget in the amount of $199,501. 3.B. Financial Statements Jennifer Liunoras, Finance Director, provided an overview of the Financial Statements as of May 31, 2025: • Total budgeted revenues year-to-date are $4,299,000 which includes the receipt of budgeted maintenance assessment revenue in the amount of $3,926,000. As of May, the District has received 99% of the maintenance assessments to be collected. • Investment earnings year-to-date are $129,000, which is 55% of the annual budgeted income. The month of May resulted in $33,000 of investment earnings, which was approximately $10,000 more than received in April. • The expenditures are at $2,092,000, which the District has adequate funds to cover the expenditures. The District’s spending trend is averaging $280,000 monthly. • The District’s Operating Expenditures are at $2,129,00, which is 63% of the budget and the target for this point of the fiscal year is 67%.

VCDD 4 – Meeting Minutes July 11, 2025 Page 7 o Utility Services is at 81% of the budgeted expenses of $457,000. o Building, Landscape and Other Maintenance Expense are at $2,353,000 which is 60% of the budget. o Capital Outlay is budgeted at $974,000, of which includes $692,000 for Unit 54 mill and overlay project. • The District continues to meet the reserve requirement. FOURTH ORDER OF BUSINESS: Public Hearings A. Adoption of Resolution 2025-09 Amendment and Restatement of Chapter IV of the District’s Towing Rule Caitlyn Bessoni, Executive Coordinator, advised that the adoption Resolution 2025-09 will amend and restate Chapter IV of the District’s Rule to include enforcement measures for “Repeat Offenders” relating to the towing of improperly parked vehicles and vessels. The Board adopted Chapter IV of its Rule at the March 14, 2025 meeting and at the April 11, 2025 meeting the Board directed Staff to develop provisions to address repeat violators of the Rule. Ms. Bessoni advised that the proposed amendment to Section 5 states – Repeat Offenders, which establishes that any vehicle or vessel owner who violates this Rule more than once within a 12 month period shall be considered a “Repeat Offender” and provided a review of the provisions. Supervisor Murphy requested confirmation that the District’s process adheres to State Statute. Mark Brionez, District Counsel, advised that the Statute requires that the District provide notice, which will be sent to the person violating the District’s Rule advising that the next time the vehicle is improperly parked it will be towed without notice. Vice Chair Hayes requested clarification of the process that would be followed for the fines and towing costs. Mr. Brionez stated that the individual will have to pay the fine to the District and the towing costs directly to the towing company. A letter will be sent to the individual advising of the cost of the fine, but an Order of Enforcement will not be recorded. Supervisor Murphy inquired if the District could request that the towing company require that the individual show proof that the fine to the District have been paid prior to releasing the vehicle. Mr. Brionez stated that he would have to complete a review of all applicable Statutes to determine if

VCDD 4 – Meeting Minutes July 11, 2025 Page 8 Supervisor Murphy’s suggestion could be required. Mr. Brionez responded to additional Supervisor inquiries. B. Open Public Hearing Chair Wiener opened the Public Hearing at 3:00 p.m. Lee Clark, Soulliere Villas inquired if “No Parking” signage will be installed at the locations where parking is not allowed, advising that a vehicle could be towed. Carrie Duckett, Deputy District Manager, advised that the majority of the Guest Parking Areas have existing signage, and per the District’s Rule, Staff will post the vehicle and send a letter to the vehicle owner. Ms. Duckett stated that vehicles improperly parked on District property can be towed. C. Close Public Hearing Chair Wiener closed the Public Hearing at 3:07 p.m. D. Adoption of Resolution 2025-09 Amending and Restating Chapter IV of the District’s Rule On MOTION by Mark Hayes, seconded by Cary Sternberg, with all in favor, the Board adopted Resolution 2025-09 Amending and Restating Chapter IV of the District’s Rule to include enforcement measures for repeat offenders regarding towing and removal of repeat FIFTH ORDER OF BUSINESS: Supervisor Comments 5.A. Supervisor Murphy: Florida SB 180 – Emergencies Supervisor Murphy stated that the District has submitted requests to the Federal Government for FEMA reimbursement in the past, but FEMS management could change in the future and wanted to ensure that Staff reviewed these types of Bills to ensure that the District adheres to all State guidelines. Ms. Duckett advised that District Management and District Counsel monitor the Bills being brought before the State Legislature to ensure that the Districts adheres to any new legislation. Mr. Brionez does provide updates to the Board of legislation that could or would impact the District. SIXTH ORDER OF BUSINESS: Committee Updates 6.A. Investment Advisory Committee (IAC): Primary – Jim Murphy, Alternate – Mark Hayes

VCDD 4 – Meeting Minutes July 11, 2025 Page 9 Supervisor Murphy advised that the quarterly Investment Advisory Committee (IAC) has not been held. 6.B. Multi-Modal Path Discussion Group (MMPDG): Cliff Wiener Chair Wiener stated that the MMPDG meeting will be held on September 23, 2025 at 2:00 p.m. at the Savannah Recreation Center, and advised that at the District 3 Board meeting held today the Board chose not to proceed with the installation of centerline RPMs but did agree to have a representative attend the next MMPDG meeting. Staff will also extend an invitation to the District 14 and District 15 Boards. Chair Wiener advised that he met with The Villages Public Safety Department (VPSD) who has indicated that they will be able to provide data for daytime and nighttime golf cart accidents. 6.C. Liaison to MCSO and VPSD: Mark Hayes Vice Chair Hayes advised that the Board received a copy of The VPSD Department monthly report. The University of Florida Stroke Unit will be dedicated on July 22, 2025 and will be available for immediate response to stroke victims between the hours of 8:00 a.m. and 5:00 p.m. 6.D. Liaison to MCBOCC: Don Deakin Supervisor Deakin advised that at the recent MCBOCC meeting, the MBOCC reviewed the upcoming road rejuvenation projects. The most recent Q&A update included information about the proposed Walmart Market construction, the Buena Vista Boulevard rejuvenation project and the State of Marion County meeting to be held in August, which the Board previously discussed. SEVENTH ORDER OF BUSINESS: Old Business 7.A. Old Business Status Update Ms. Duckett provided the following Old Business Status Updates: 1. Consider video recording/live streaming meetings: This item is completed. Staff began video recording the District 4 meetings today. 2. SECO Update: Ms. Duckett advised that Staff has no additional updates for this item and inquired if the Board would like the item to remain on the Old Business Status Update. The Board requested that this item remain on the Old Business Status Update until the District 7 review of solar lighting alternatives has been completed. Ms. Duckett advised that the District

VCDD 4 – Meeting Minutes July 11, 2025 Page 10 7 Board will hold a workshop on July 28, 2025 to review the proposals received from the Request for Proposal issued. 3. Update on Drainage Assessment: Ms. Duckett stated that the estimated completion of the study is September 30th. Staff was advised that the extra rainfall that has been received is assisting the engineers with the assessment. Chair Wiener requested clarification as to why the assessment is taking so long to complete. Mr. Harris advised that the Budget Resolution to allocate the funds for the project was adopted by the Board at the June 13, 2025 meeting and the Purchase Orders were then issued. Supervisor Deakin requested that the Old Business Status Update item be revised to identify the location where the drainage assessment is being completed. 4. Review if District 4 can restrict public access behind gates: Mr. Brionez stated it was his understanding that the Board wanted to remove the buttons from the unmanned gates and requested clarification of the Board’s request. Chair Wiener stated he does not believe it was the Board’s intent to restrict access to the roadways; it was more to change the way people access the District 4 roads. Supervisor Murphy stated that the Board’s request is to deactivate the red button at the unmanned gates, to require non-residents access District 4 roadways through a manned gate and receive a visitors pass. Supervisor Murphy inquired if Staff can identify a way to eliminate the cloned gate cards. Ms. Duckett stated that currently the District does not have the ability to deactivate cloned access cards/stickers. Staff anticipates scheduling a joint workshop for the AAC and Project Wide Advisory Committee (PWAC) to review gate reader access and software upgrades. Supervisor Murphy inquired if the District can take legal action against the people selling the cloned access cards/stickers. Ms. Duckett advised that District Counsel for Village Center and Sumter Landing has sent out several cease letters to people who are cloning the cards. Staff will review with the AAC and PWAC what will be needed to deactivate all cloned cards and options for controlled access at some of the neighborhood pools. Ms. Duckett responded to additional inquiries. 5. Depression at Storm Inlet on Crowfield Avenue (Cameron Villa): This item was previously addressed.

VCDD 4 – Meeting Minutes July 11, 2025 Page 11 6. Debris Collection: Staff forwarded an email to the Board on June 23, 2025 which provided the costs for local contractors to complete storm debris cleanup. The District’s current landscape contractor indicated that they do not have the capacity to complete storm debris cleanup. The District would continue to utilize the contractors it has contracted with through the FEMA process for debris hauling and monitoring. The Board requested that this item remain on Old Business so that the Board can hold a future discussion. Non-VCDD No. 4 Items 7. Post Kenny Blocker’s June 9, 2025 Our Place Article at Postal Facilities: This has been completed. The District’s Communication Coordinator is also developing a bullet point overview of the amenity fees, maintenance assessments and bond assessments that will be posted at the postal facilities. 8. Communicate concern about lack of notice to residents re: AMR Meter Change Out: Ms. Duckett stated that Staff has confirmed that postcards have been sent to the residents in advance of the meter changeouts. Staff is surprised of the negative feedback received from District 4 residents because the feedback from other Districts has been very positive. EIGHTH ORDER OF BUSINESS:Informational Items Only 8.A. Supervisor Deakin: Amenity Authority Committee After Agenda Supervisor Deakin advised that the Amenity Authority Committee (AAC) After Agenda from the July 9, 2025 meeting was provided to the Board, as information, and highlighted the following: • The Committee “directed the adoption of a Resolution to establish an amenity fee deferral at $199 to the Village Center Community Development District (VCCDD) Board, requested that the Sumter Landing Board adopt an identical Resolution, if recommended by the PWAC, and to request such action as necessary from other amenity owners to ensure the adoption of this Resolution will not result in residents of The Villages outside the AAC service territory being treated differently than Village Residents inside the AAC service territory”. None of the AAC Members chose to challenge Kevin Stone, District Counsel’s opinion; however, there are other attorneys who have not been consulted with, but have expressed the opinion that the AAC can

VCDD 4 – Meeting Minutes July 11, 2025 Page 12 establish an amenity fee deferral rate, via the Interlocal Agreement. without the other amenity service providers agreeing. • Reflective pavement markers (RPMs) have been added along the middle of the roadway from CR 42 to the First Responders Recreation Center 8.B. Merger of Citizen Frist Bank and Seacoast Bank An update related to the merger of Citizens First Bank and Seacoast Bank was provided to the Board as information. 8.C. DPM Monthly Report The DPM Monthly Report was provided to the Board as information. 8.D. Advanced Meter Reading (AMR) Changed Out Update- April 2025 The (AMR) change out was provided to the Board as information. 8.E. Village Community Development District No. 4 Public Hearing Updates The District 4 Public Hearing Updates were provided as information. NINTH ORDER OF BUSINESS: District Manager Reports 9.A. Save the Date for the Paradise Recreation Center: Walk Down Memory Lane Ms. Duckett advised that an invitation has been provided to the Board for the Paradise Recreation Center Walk Down Memory Lane on July 22, 2025 from 11 a.m. to 1 p.m. The official groundbreaking for the beginning of the demolition of the Paradise Recreation Center will be held in August. Supervisor Murphy inquired if the definition of “neat and clean” has been reviewed. Ms. Duckett stated that per the Board’s direction, Staff is working with Supervisor Sternberg to elaborate on the definition of “neat and clean” in the District’s External Deed Restriction Standards. Staff is also working with Mr. Brionez to determine if a complaint is received for one item under the neat and clean definition if Staff can include all items that fall under that definition. Supervisor Murphy inquired if a picture is submitted with a complaint, would the complainant be able to state that they are submitting a complaint for all violations included in the picture. Ms. Duckett stated that would not be allowed with the current language of the District’s Rule, but Staff is reviewing ways to improve the language of the

VCDD 4 – Meeting Minutes July 11, 2025 Page 13 neat and clean definition, but that would not include other violations, such as a lawn ornaments or landscaping in an easement. TENTH ORDER OF BUSINESS: District Counsel Reports 10.A. Age Restriction Requirement Mr. Brionez stated that if the Board is interested, there is an opportunity for the Board to amend its Rule to enforce any age-related restriction in the Declaration of Restrictions governing the residential properties in the District. If the Board is interested Staff will prepare a presentation to include an overview of how the process would be implemented and function. Vice Chair Hayes stated that he thought internal deed restrictions were the responsibility of the Developer. Mr. Brionez stated that currently the Developer is responsible for enforcing the age restriction, but there is a Florida Statute that would allow the District to also enforce this restriction, by the Developer granting its consent for the District to also enforce age-related restrictions that are in the Declaration of Restrictions. Chair Weiner inquired who is responsible for tracking the 80/20 rule for the 55 and over restriction. Ms. Duckett stated that the tracking falls under the purview of the Developer. Ms. Duckett stated that there are two (2) age-related deed restrictions; one is that member in the home must be 55+ and the other states that no one under the age of 19 can reside in a home for more than 30 days in a calendar year. Typically, the complaints received are for a child under 19 residing in the home. Supervisor Deakin stated that a hardship clause should be included. Ms. Duckett stated that currently there is not a hardship clause in the deed restrictions for children under the age of 19, but Staff could review how these types of items might be addressed. Following discussion, the Board directed Staff to include an agenda item authorizing Staff to advertise on the August agenda. ELEVENTH ORDER OF BUSINESS: Public Comments There were no public comments received. Supervisor Sternberg stated that the Supervisors are mandated to manage the infrastructure of the District but under Florida Statute 190 the Supervisors are not advocates, and this Board may be taking

VCDD 4 – Meeting Minutes July 11, 2025 Page 14 on items that do not fall within the Board’s purview. Supervisor Sternberg stated that the Board spent 20 minutes receiving an overview from the AAC meeting, which does not fall under this Board’s purview. Supervisor Murphy advised that the Board previously adopted a Mission Statement which provides guidance to the Board for the actions it takes to ensure the residents’ safety, well-being and quality of life. ELEVENTH ORDER OF BUSINESS: Adjourn The meeting was adjourned at 3:54 p.m. On MOTION by Cary Sternberg, seconded by Mark Hayes, with all in favor, the Board adjourned the meeting. Kenneth C. Blocker Cliff Wiener Secretary Chair

Showing the first 24,000 of 115,095 characters. The full document is at the source.

Good afternoon, everybody. It's uh, this is the District four Board of Supervisors July 11th, 2025. Meeting. Not coming through at all. Huh? You're not Coming through at all Time. Could you hear me now? Yeah. Okay. Good afternoon everybody. This is July, the July 11th, 2025, district four Board of Supervisors meeting. Roll call shows that all supervisors are present. First center agendas are standing for the pledge of the flag and remain standing for a moment of silence for our military personnel and first responders. Thank you. I wanna welcome all of our attendees. It's nice to have a full house, even though I think I know why most of you are here. Uh, Next thing I need, the agenda is public comments. If you have a public comment to make, please step to the podium. State your name and address. You will have three minutes. I will tell you that the clock is up there. I will be watching the clock. When your three minutes are up, you're done. We're not going over because there's probably gonna be more than one or two people that wanna speak today. Um, please try not to repeat what people before you have said. We'll hear you the first time and we don't need to hear the same things over and over. And before we get into anything, if you have a cell phone, please shut it off, put it on vibrate, do not disturb or something. Um, and for your information, our meeting is being video recorded. The a a c meeting was the first meeting that was video recorded this week on Wednesday. And we are the second. So our meetings will now be recorded every month. So if you can't come, you can always watch it the next day or later that day once they post it on our website. Okay. With that being said, if somebody has a comment breach. Karen, I saw your hand go first. Karen O'Farrell 17 8 5 1 Southeast 85th Ton Court. My comment is very brief. I just notice every month on the agenda that under supervisors reports there's, um, a liaison designation, designee. You know what I'm saying? And I'm curious as to what the expectation is for the role of liaison. All I have, thank you. Okay. And yes, ma'am. Yes. Good afternoon. My name is Debbie Spoon over. I reside at 1 6 8 3 9 Southeast 91st Crenshaw Terrace in Phillips Village in community Development district number four. I'm here to speak about, of course, the proposed Walmart development located at Mulberry Lane and Phillips Court. The one thing I wanna say before we start is my initial request would be not to put a Walmart there because it definitely severely impacts the neighborhood that was so quiet that we all moved into due to that fact. The location of it being a little outside of the villages and a little outside of, of uh, regular living was perfect for all of us, and that's where we decided to retire. If the project does move forward, I wanna focus today on public safety. Phillips Court. The road directly east of the proposed development is the only entrance and exit into Phillips Villas neighborhood. If Phillips V Court was blocked due to a traffic crash or other incident, how would fire emergency, medical or law enforcement respond to emergencies in our neighborhood? This has been already been an ongoing concern since neighborhood was built. Increases in traffic will lead to increases in traffic crashes, especially considering the lack of traffic controls and signals at both Highway 42 and Phillips Court and Mulberry Lane in Phillips court. The traffic study, the most current one that we saw submitted into Marion County, appears to indicate that no changes need to be made or any of on any of the impacted roadways. That's a concern. Traffic on these roadways will increase dramatically and impact accessibility into our neighborhood by both residents and emergency services. If no changes are made, the entry and exit points from the proposed parking lot onto Phillips Court will cause traffic backups and traffic crashes that will block the only entry into our neighborhood. In addition, Phillips Villas does not have a sidewalk or multimodal path allowing walkers, bicycles or golf carts and alternatives to using the single roadway at Phillips Court entry in and out of the neighborhood. We will need sidewalk along Phillips court and a multimodal path that connects to either Bellmead Circle or Mulberry Lane. These concerns need to be addressed by the elected appointed decision makers at Community Development District four and Marion County before giving approval for the development. Thank you. We appreciate all that you do. Thanks. Thank you. Yes, ma'am. Good afternoon. My name is Lori Pop and I reside at 91 57 Southeast 166 Sprung Lane in Phillips Villas in Community Development District four. I'm here to speak about proposed Walmart, um, development located at Mulberry Lane in Phillips Court. First of all, I would like to say I am not in favor of this project. My focus today, if it goes forward, will be quality of life issues. Quality of life issues such as noise and light pollution, garbage odor, rodent infestation, and increases in suspicious or criminal activity at the development are serious concerns for Phillips fills residence hours of operation for Walmart neighborhood markets do not reflect the neighboring businesses, which all close by 9:00 PM Walmart starts very early in the morning and extends late into the evening every day of the week, 6:00 AM to 11:00 PM Will the gas station be open 24 hours? We don't know. With the future development of the property, east of this proposed Walmart already approved 40 acres consisting of 86 homes just to the east of us. And then the additional housing department, uh, development that is currently being built off 42 just east of St. Mark's Church will consist of over 1500 homes. This is going to bring quite a lot of congestion and traffic into our area off of 42. Were either of these developments in consideration in the traffic study that was done? Lastly, I ask that if you have not been over to Phillips Villa, is that you come and take a look at our entrance and where the Walmart will be located. Our concerns need to be addressed by the elected appointed decision makers at Community Development District four and Marion County before giving approval for this development. Thank you for your time. Yes, ma'am. Good afternoon. My name is Renee Al. I live at 16 8 2 5 Southeast 91st Crenshaw Terrace in Phillips. It's District four for eight years with my husband John. First I want to thank you for taking the time to listen to our concerns. I wanna talk to you today about public safety, especially if the Walmart goes in. According to National Public Radio interview with Shannon Petty Peace, Walmart stores across the US experience a violent crime across daily leading local police being overwhelmed by sheer number of calls they received from these locations. There were over 200 distinct incidences of violence at Walmart stores across the country between January 1st, 2023 and December 31st, 2023. And at least one violent incident at a store was reported every month during this period. Incidents vary in severity, but include 132 Gun violence Incident. Hold on. The mic went on, the microphone went on Off. No, no, no, no, no, no. You just have just me. No, no. It's all Incidents varied in severity, but included 132 gun violence incident, 26 bomb threats, 31 physical assaults, 11 incidents involving the violent use of vehicle and one incident involving the use of arson envo harm. This is reported by the United For Respect Education Fund. They also reported between January 1st, 2020 and March 20th, 2024, there were 473 gun related incidences, which included 104 gun related deaths at Walmart stores. Meaning one out of every 10 Walmart stores in the US experienced a gun related injury or death during this period. Violent crime is particularly rare in the villages with the rate of 0.27 per 1000 residents according to two College Brothers. But in Summerfield, where there's currently a Walmart, the violent crime is 21%. Just under the national average of 22.7, news reports indicate incidents near the villages. Walmarts include shoplifting, arrests, physical altercations, and golf cart thefts. The villages has always been, had an excellent reputation of being a safe place to live. This is one of many reasons we moved here, and I'm sure that's one of the reasons why a lot of other peoples have moved here too. I would prefer that the villages, especially Phillips S, continue being a very safe place. Thank you very much for your time and consideration. Thank you. I can't see whose hand is Yes, sir. Your podiums in the way. Good afternoon. My name is Leroy Val. I reside at 91 56 Southeast, one 66th sprung lane in Phillips Vs. In CDD four. When we first visited the villages 12 years ago, we were amazed at everything that was offered here. Like all of you on the board, it was immediately evident this was the place we wanted to spend our retirement in. The villages life promises a fantastic compromise for retirees, numerous activities and events coupled with peaceful neighborhoods and above all security. The villages was promoted to us as a safe place to live with a tranquil atmosphere. I'm here to speak about the proposed Walmart development located at Mulberry Lane in Phillips Court just off Highway 42 and its potential impact to Phillips Villas. My focus will be on the same quality, safety, and quality of life that everyone here bought into and expects from the villages. The proposed Walmart will be built directly in front of Phillips and also border Summerfield right across the road, as it was mentioned in the crime rate. It's an astonishingly low 0.03 in the village is yet 21% across the road, nearly 800 times higher if you do the math. Looking at these numbers, I am very concerned about safety within our neighborhood. Our neighborhood will become a much more visible target to that 21% demographic with no man gate. There is little to deter this democra, this demographic from entering our neighborhood from a quality of life perspective. Parking lots will be on 24 7 and will be very visible to homes and Phillips, especially those on the front wall where their bedroom window now faces that direction. Store hours at a Walmart were referred to earlier, this will bring constant noise from the store traffic and semi-truck deliveries all week long. Calling the other neighborhood Walmart, they get eight deliveries a day entering and exiting our abilities with a much more difficult and dangerous that's been alluded to. We have one way in and out and now have to share it with that store and that traffic. Golf carts and bicycles will now have to share a road not only with heavy consumer traffic and semi trucks, there is no golf cart or bicycle lane on any of these roads there. From an environmental standpoint, I am also concerned about water runoff and we have a major storm. We are now covering 10 and a half acres with concrete. This area that used to absorb water will now run off either to the retention ponds or into our villas and could potentially cause damage to homes that are on the front side of that. I have much more to say along with facts, but I will wrap this up. Due to the limited speaking time we bought into the village's promise of a tranquil and safe retirement are now faced with losing a great deal of that. Our lives will be subject to noise and light pollution, disruption, and exposure to far more crime than any of us ever expected in the villages. Can any of you on the board honestly say you would welcome a Walmart in front of your home if you were in this situation bordering the outside of the villages? These concerns need to be addressed by the elected appointed decision makers at CDD four and Marion encounter before giving any approval to this project. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Anybody else? Yes, ma'am. Hello, my name is Barb Cher. I live at 92 68 Southeast, 167th Ford Street in the Phillips Villas. While I agree with all the points that have been made, I have kind of a different story. I've been a resident of the villages for almost 27 years. Originally, I lived in Del Soul South at the intersection of Morrise Boulevard and 4 66, where residents almost daily experience the dangers and challenges of cars and trucks sharing the road with golf carts. I believe the Mulberry Lane location has an abundance of safety and logistical issues to prevent approval for this particular commercial business. Thank you. You're welcome. I think it Yes, ma'am. Good afternoon and thank you for this opportunity to speak. My name is Frankie Hutchins and I'm at 90 90 Southeast, 166 Kathy Loop Villages, Florida building a Walmart and gas station in Phillips Village's entrance. Brings, brings and affects three major issues, safety, traffic, and quality of life. A golf cart path for our area was denied approximately eight years ago, leaving one entrance and exit, which could and possibly be insufficient in case of an emergency for 165 homes or families. When large service vehicles are parked near our entrance, this causes congestion for vehicles coming and going. Recently, one of our residents was nearly killed when a semi driving on Mulberry Lane did not see him. Phillips Village will become more vulnerable to questionable predators, such as crooks and homeless folk golf carts on our, in our, um, golf carts on our bike and our bikes will, oh dear. Did I get mixed up? Okay. In a possible rodent population from Walmart, trash and gas station threatens our pets and our safety in our homes. Backyards and neighborhoods fumes from the gas station and increased traffic threatens our health and safety. Increased traffic not only threatens our safety, but quality of life for our vehicles, golf carts and our bikes and walkers. Not to mention the increased volume of noise, which will interrupt our peaceful existence. According to research. Home values decrease in surrounding areas where Walmarts are built. Phillips's residents have put much time and money and planning into the improvement of our homes, making them comfortable for our lives in our later years. Two questions. Since there are no golf cart paths upon entering or exiting Phillips Court, who will be financially liable for golf cart paths on either side of the road to, um, our only entrance and who will be responsible for the wear and chair and upkeep of the roads. Due to the increased amount of traffic from semis and other large vehicles delivering gas and supplies all hours of the day and night, there is a Walmart within two to three mile radius. Why another at five gas stations in a three mile stretch from 3 0 1 to 4 41 possible solutions, a plaza, which includes specialty shops such as high, high-end boutique coffee and beverage shops, or a gym. And I'm in hope this matter can be resolved according to the goals Mr. Schwartz had in mind for seniors. Thank you very much. Thank You. Anybody else? Yes. Not so I can get close enough. Um, Hi everybody. My name is Jeannie Za and I live at 91. Ma'am, Could you get a little closer to the mic so I can hear you? It's a little hard for me. And You, you can move the mic closer to you if That makes it easier like this. Pull it. The whole thing will come closer. Can you repeat your, Well, I have to hold on to something. Microphone. Would you repeat your name for us Again? Okay. My name is Jeannie Zer. I live at 91 37 Southeast, 1 67 Ford Street. I've lived here since 2018 and I've noticed a lot of traffic and most of it is way past the speed limit. It's obvious that we will need new traffic lights in our community going east to west on 42 to turn south onto Phillips Court, but that's awfully close to the one block away set of traffic lights for the VA medical center. With so much traffic, there's more danger to non villages families and school children that are right across the way from our development. They take school buses, they stand on the corner, and this is gonna create so much more danger to those families. And if one child gets killed, that is one child too many. Um, I looked at the plot plan and I'm not sure if this is going to be a neighborhood Walmart or a larger one, but I'm asking the question, do we really need another grocery store, one block away from Publix's grocery store that has shoppers that, that will deliver. And there's a dollar store, so NOCO Station at, with the store and crazy days that are all grocery, gasoline, food and household items. Two blocks away at 42 and 4 41, I counted 130 parking spaces. To me, that's just too many vehicles in that close proximity. And I perceive that the three new roadways are going to it. It's very little dirt and grass left. And so when it rains, it's gonna be a torrent of rain and there won't be any grass or soil soak it up. It's just gonna flood the area because of all the concrete and the painting. I've also noticed the pole lights are so high and so bright at night that they can easily disturb nearby residents sleep. Um, I also noticed too, not only that there's 18 hours that the stores open, but there's about six or eight hours when they will be feeling of the, the tankers come and delivery trucks. So there's gonna be no peace and quiet for 24 hours in our neighborhood. They're gonna be unloading those trucks and stocking the shelves late into the night, making a lot of noise. And personally, I've never driven by a dumpster behind a Walmart store that wasn't dripping with puddles of goo stinky rotten food stuff that should have been picked up days before and in infrequent trash pickups. So that dumpsters are overflowing. Drawing racks. Vernon and Carnivores. Personally, I observed heavy truck deliveries at a local Walmart at night, and in the silence that makes so much noise, it wakes me up. Anyway. Traffic, as you know, is one way in or one way out. And I question a problem. Water and sewer quality and quantity, if that is there. What's gonna happen to the residents quality of water and sewer? Are we gonna get contaminated water or are we gonna get lesser volume of water? Are we gonna get less sewer, uh, uh, uh, Facilities? Ma'am, ma'am, your three minutes are up. You need to wrap it up. Thank You. Thank you. Um, I'm asking the gentlemen and everyone to please consider all of us residents who spent our hard-earned money and savings. Uh, peace and quiet. Thank you. Thank you. Anybody else? I see no other hands. So we, first of all, I will give this board a chance to answer, but I, I have something I want to say. I empathize with every single one of you, but this is not a District four issue. We don't own the property, we don't own the roads. And unfortunately, you need to go to Marion County and present your case. I would help you if I at all could, but there's absolutely nothing this board can do to change Marion County, Walmart or anybody else, the developer or anybody else that wants that property to be used. Um, so with that being said, I will listen to anything else that this board might have to say. Carrie Cliff, thank you. Uh, the, the comments are certainly apropos. I I think a lot of people don't understand what powers the districts have and don't have. Um, we are only a quasi-government agency. Um, we are tasked with effectively operating and maintaining the infrastructure and have an ability to levy assessments. Um, we are a special group with special functions, and those functions include roads, water, and sewer in the areas that affect us. Uh, we oversee the infrastructure and the services. We have absolutely no say at all about who, who buys or owns property. Outside of our jurisdiction. We have absolutely no say at all in regard to roads and, uh, services provided to, uh, Marion County businesses or landowners that are not within our boundaries. So while we, I, I understand your concerns. I understand them completely, and I agree that you are concerned. Uh, but there's really, there's nothing we can do. Uh, you know, if it, if it's a matter of somebody's taking a bus up there and they, they want people to go and pack the, the, the chambers, um, then Marion County, uh, should certainly have to listen to everybody that has an opinion. Uh, there are, there are always things like this to come up. You know, the caveat being that when, uh, when we bought our property, uh, wherever it was that we bought, you know, we take a chance on who's becoming our neighbor. And, you know, that's something that we can't control. Uh, the Phillips Villas, the property there has been advertised as commercial property, uh, since the time that they were developed and opened. And so those people that bought up there, um, you know, should have been aware of what possible things were going to go in. Uh, you know, I'm not saying that promises weren't made. Uh, we all know what, you know, salesmen will do to, to make a sale, but they weren't made by this board. They, they weren't made by, by anybody here in regard to what's coming in. So the, the, the, the vigor by which you, uh, approach this needs to be taken to the proper source, which is Marion County Development. Not us. Thank you. Could I just ask one question? Pardon? No, I'll pass for the moment. Pardon? I will pass for the moment. Don, it's your turn if you want to talk. No. Fine. Otherwise, I would like to give other people a chance to speak first. I, I understand. I, 'cause I get accused of monopolizing it already. Oh, that's okay. It's your turn. Please talk. We're not gonna go go. I will go last here like we do at a, a c. It's your turn. You wanna talk? Say something now. Okay. First of all, I really sympathize with the residents of Phillips Village, and I understand the stress that concerns and the issues that you are going through. I also recognize the fact that you are not going to be the only residents in the villages that are going to be affected by what goes in there. All of us who shop at that plaza are going to be affected. All of us who go and use County Road 42 or 3 0 1 or 4 41 are gonna be affected. The quality of our lives will all be affected in some ways favorably and other ways not. I heard the say, I'm glad that we're getting a Walmart, um, market, neighborhood market there because Publix is too expensive. What if Publix goes outta business or quits competing with us and shuts down at that market sometime in the future? What's gonna happen to the rest of the Mulberry Plaza? There are so many possible unintended consequences that we haven't even begun to look at that are going to affect everybody in the Marion County section of the villages. And so we need to take those things under consideration. We, as a board and as individuals represent the residents who live in District four. And while Mr. Weiner and Mr. Turnberg are correct that our powers and jurisdictions are limited, that doesn't mean that we cannot as a governing body and as individuals express our support for your issues and concerns. It doesn't mean that we can't go and support your cause and express our concerns as a board as to how this will affect our residents, that we represent how it will affect the quality of life and all the things that you've already talked about. I feel that we as a board could share our concerns with the Marion County Commission, That as a board we could ask that the process be slowed down to gain time to gather more facts and information so that the proposal can be fully reviewed by all concerned entities. I feel that we as a board, could hold a special public workshop regarding this issue and invite Marion County representatives, commissioners, and the development, the Marion County Development Board to come and hear what you have to say and what we could contribute to. Because we've all got a stake in this. We all have a dog in this fight. I feel that this board could explore other options and alternatives to what is currently being proposed. I feel that we could say there might be a better

Community Development District 4 Seat 1 - Cliff Wiener, Chair Seat 2 - Cary Sternberg, Supervisor Seat 3 - Jim Murphy, Supervisor Seat 4 - Mark Hayes, Vice Chair Seat 5 - Don Deakin, Supervisor July 11, 2025 at 1:30 PM Savannah Regional Recreation Center 1545 Buena Vista Blvd. The Villages, FL 32162 ____________________________________________________________________________________________ AGENDA The District encourages citizen participation in the democratic process and recognizes and protects the right of freedom of speech afforded to all. As the Board conducts the business of the District, rules of civility shall apply. District Board Supervisors, Staff members, and members of the public are to communicate respectfully. It is preferred that persons speak only when recognized by the Board Chair and, at that time, refrain from engaging in personal attacks or derogatory or offensive language. Persons who are deemed to be disruptive and negatively impact the efficient operation of the meeting shall be subject to removal after two verbal warnings. Audience Comments on all issues will be received by the Board. 1. Call to Order 1.A. Roll Call 1.B. Pledge of Allegiance 1.C. Observation of Moment of Silence 1.D. Welcome Meeting Attendees 1.E. Public Comments 2. Consent Agenda 2.A. Approval of Minutes 2.B. Amendment Three to the Agreement between Village Community Development District 4 and Cepra Landscape, LLC for Landscape and Irrigation Maintenance - RFP #21P- 029 (Group A) 2.C. Termination of Agreement ITB 24B-024 for Cut/Patch Asphalt Repair Services with Tri- State Asphalt Corporation 3. New Business 3.A. Review and Approval for Geotechnical Engineering Remediation and Asphalt Repairs for the Cameron Villas Roadway Project and Approval of Budget Resolution 2025-10 3.B. Financial Statements 4. Public Hearings 4.A. Adoption of Resolution 2025-09 Amendment and Restatement of Chapter IV Rule -- VCDD No. 4 Towing Rule A. Overview of Resolution 2025-09 Amendment and Restatement of Chapter IV of the District's Rule B. Open Public Hearing C. Close Public Hearing

D. Adoption of Resolution 2025-09 Amendment and Restatement of Chapter IV of the District's Rule 5. Supervisor Comments 5.A. Supervisor Murphy: Florida SB 180 - Emergencies 6. Committee Updates 6.A. Investment Advisory Committee/Auditor Selection Committee: Primary - Jim Murphy, Alternate - Mark Hayes 6.B. Multi-Modal Path Discussion Group: Cliff Wiener 6.C. Liaison to MCSO & VPSD: Mark Hayes 6.D. Liaison to MCBOCC: Don Deakin 7. Old Business 7.A. Old Business Status Update 8. Informational Items Only 8.A. Supervisor Deakin: Amenity Authority Committee After Agenda 8.B. Merger of Citizens First Bank and Seacoast Bank 8.C. DPM Monthly Report 8.D. AMR Meter Change Out Update - June 8.E. Village Community Development District No. 4 Public Hearing Updates 9. District Manager Reports 9.A. Save the Date for the Paradise Recreation Center: Walk Down Memory Lane 10. District Counsel Reports 10.A. Age Restriction Enforcement 11. Public Comments 12. Adjourn HOSPITALITY STEWARDSHIP INNOVATION & CREATIVITY HARD WORK NOTICE Each person who decides to appeal any action taken at these meetings is advised that person will need a record of the proceedings and that accordingly, the person may need to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceedings is made, incoming the testimony and evidence upon which such appeal is to be based. Audio recordings of Board meetings, workshops or public hearings are available for purchase per Florida Statute 119.07 through the District Clerk for $1.00 per CD requested. Any person requiring special accommodations at this meeting because of disability of physical impairment should contact the District Office at (352) 751-3939 at least five calendar days prior to the meetings.

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
Agenda packetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Action agendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Coverage and corrections

Records considered

  • Village Community Development District No. 4 (2025-07-11) — Minutes
  • Village Community Development District No. 4 (2025-07-11) — Closed Captions
  • Village Community Development District No. 4 (2025-07-11)

Not claimed by this page

  • Verified meeting decisions with item-specific public-source evidence
  • Item-level plain-language summaries are not available; this page does not infer individual agenda items.
  • Item-linked, attributed deliberation
  • A source-grounded next meeting date
  • A plain-English overview is not available.
  • Official outcomes have not been published.
  • Transcript coverage is partial.
  • Speakers have not been reliably matched to public profiles.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: 14e5e51e812bd00f480aff0b45dec2a7. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record