
NewsSuncoast SearchlightNovember 2, 2026Sarasota County
Sarasota City Commission Rejects The Obsidian Luxury Condo Tower for the Third Time
Photo: Suncoast Searchlight
Sarasota city commissioners voted 3-2 to reject the proposed Obsidian high-rise condo tower, defying a special magistrate's recommendation and risking a potential circuit court lawsuit from the developer. The 18-story, 320-foot tower at 1260 North Palm Avenue would have contained just 14 luxury units but faced intense, multi-year opposition from nearby residents over its height and compatibility.
Read the full story at Suncoast SearchlightWhy It Matters
The decision preserves the current downtown streetscape for neighboring residents while exposing the city to potential multi-million-dollar damages in a looming legal battle with the developer.
Key Facts
- The Sarasota City Commission rejected the proposed Obsidian condo tower in a 3-2 vote.
- The 18-story, 320-foot tower was planned for 1260 North Palm Avenue and would have featured only 14 condo units.
- The vote defied a special magistrate's recommendation who had previously sided with the developer under a Florida land-use dispute law.
- Mayor Debbie Trice cast the deciding vote against the project during her final meeting before leaving office.
- Developers and attorneys indicated the project will likely head to a circuit court judge following the denial.
- Opponents packed City Commission chambers wearing red T-shirts to protest the development over compatibility and height concerns.
- Neighboring Bay Plaza residents argued the building would cast shadows, create a wind tunnel, and stand too close to their property.
Who's Mentioned
PersonMatt Kihnke“Project developer”PersonGretchen Cochran“Author”OrganizationBay Plaza“Neighboring 14-story condo building”PersonDerek Gilliam“Suncoast Searchlight reporter and photographer”PersonRobert Lincoln“Attorney for the developer”PersonKyle Battie“City Commissioner”PersonJen Ahearn-Koch“City Commissioner opposed to the development”locationNorth Palm Avenue“Location of the proposed tower at 1260 North Palm Avenue”locationSarasota“City where the development is proposed”PersonChristian Casale“Suncoast Searchlight reporter”PersonJohn Harshman“Candidate for Sarasota City Commission”OrganizationThe Obsidian“Proposed 18-story condo tower development”PersonLiz Alpert“City Commissioner who expressed concern over legal liability”PersonMorgan Bentley“Trial attorney representing project opponents”OrganizationCommunity News Collaborative, Inc.“Parent nonprofit corporation of Suncoast Searchlight”PersonDebbie Trice“Sarasota Mayor”OrganizationMichael Saunders and Co.“Real estate company”PersonMartin Hyde“Independent candidate for state senate”PersonJonathan Abrams“Luxury real estate agent with Michael Saunders and Co.”PersonKathy Kelley Ohlrich“City Commissioner who voted against the project”
