
NewsLos Angeles TimesOctober 25, 2026Los Angeles County
9th Circuit Panel Questions Justice Department Request to Block 20,000 California Ballots
Photo: Los Angeles Times
A federal appeals court panel questioned the Trump administration's emergency request to force California officials to set aside 20,000 ballots from voters whose citizenship is questioned. During a Sunday hearing, judges pressed Justice Department attorneys on whether the executive branch has the constitutional authority or court jurisdiction to intervene in state election administration.
Read the full story at Los Angeles TimesWhy It Matters
The outcome of the emergency appeal could determine whether 20,000 flagged ballots are segregated and delayed or counted alongside millions of other votes in the ongoing midterm election.
Key Facts
- A three-judge panel of the U.S. 9th Circuit Court of Appeals held a rare Sunday hearing on an emergency request by the Justice Department to block the tabulation of 20,000 California ballots.
- The Justice Department is demanding that California Secretary of State Shirley Weber and Los Angeles County Registrar-Recorder/County Clerk Dean Logan immediately stop counting ballots from 20,000 flagged voters until citizenship is proven.
- Appellate judges Mark J. Bennett and Gabriel P. Sanchez questioned whether the executive branch has jurisdiction or constitutional authority under the Elections Clause to intervene in state-run elections.
- California officials and attorneys argued that the Justice Department's demands are illegal, unconstitutional, and based on flawed third-party data.
- More than 3 million people have already cast ballots statewide in California, and over 500,000 have voted in Los Angeles County.
- The Justice Department originally sued California, Weber, and Logan on Oct. 15 after giving officials 48 hours to set aside the flagged ballots.
- Federal prosecutors recently charged 28 legal permanent residents in California with election-related crimes, including illegally registering to vote.
- On Friday, the Justice Department sent letters to county election offices statewide threatening criminal punishment if they refuse to segregate ballots from voters the administration believes are noncitizens.
Who's Mentioned
OrganizationUCLA School of Law“Institution housing the Safeguarding Democracy Project”PersonTrent McCotter“Acting Deputy Attorney General”locationLos Angeles County“County handling local voter registration and ballot tabulation”PersonPatrick J. Bumatay“Circuit judge on the 9th Circuit panel”PersonGabriel P. Sanchez“Circuit judge on the 9th Circuit panel”PersonRick Hasen“Director of the Safeguarding Democracy Project at UCLA School of Law”PersonSeth Waxman“Attorney for Dean Logan”PersonMatthew Donnelly“Justice Department attorney”PersonDean Logan“Los Angeles County Registrar-Recorder/County Clerk”OrganizationU.S. 9th Circuit Court of Appeals“Appellate court hearing the emergency case”OrganizationTrump administration“Executive branch seeking to intervene in California elections”PersonBill Essayli“First Assistant U.S. Attorney in Los Angeles”PersonMark J. Bennett“Federal appeals court judge on the 9th Circuit panel”PersonShirley Weber“California Secretary of State”OrganizationJustice Department“Federal agency suing California election officials”locationCalifornia“State whose election administration is subject to the lawsuit”PersonSamuel P. Siegel“California Deputy Solicitor General”
