POLISCOPE
Back to feed
NewsABC Action News (WFTS) — Hillsborough CountyOctober 28, 2026Hillsborough County

Some Tampa Bay families drop health insurance as cash prices occasionally prove cheaper than insurance rates

Photo: ABC Action News (WFTS) — Hillsborough County

A growing number of families and business owners in the Tampa Bay area are dropping traditional health insurance to pay for medical care entirely in cash, discovering that direct-pay options can sometimes cost less than negotiated insurance rates. While cash prices for certain routine services like blood draws or specific imaging can yield substantial savings, medical experts warn that self-paying carries significant financial risk in the event of a major medical emergency.

Read the full story at ABC Action News (WFTS) — Hillsborough County

Why It Matters

Residents facing high insurance premiums and deductibles are navigating whether to drop coverage and self-fund routine care, balancing potential monthly savings against the financial exposure of catastrophic medical emergencies.

Key Facts

  • Some Tampa Bay families are dropping traditional health insurance entirely to rely on direct self-pay arrangements for medical care.
  • Laura Kissak reported paying $2,000 a month in premiums with a $10,000 deductible as a business owner family before switching to a $200 monthly direct primary care membership.
  • A test using Tampa General Hospital's price estimator showed a bilateral mammogram cost $529 with insurance compared to $185 for a self-pay cash price, a difference of $344.
  • Johns Hopkins researchers studied 70 common, shoppable healthcare services across 2,379 hospitals and found that 47% of those hospitals had cash prices lower than or equal to insurance-negotiated prices.
  • Families opting out of insurance often redirect their former premium money into savings accounts and increase their auto insurance bodily injury and liability coverage as a buffer.
  • Experts advise that while cash pricing can work well for routine and preventative care, an unexpected medical emergency or major illness can carry severe financial risks without insurance.
  • Major hospital networks in Florida, including HCA Florida Healthcare, Tampa General Hospital, BayCare, and AdventHealth, provide online price estimator tools to compare cash and insurance rates.

Who's Mentioned