POLISCOPE
Back to feed
NewsKPBS Public MediaOctober 26, 2026San Diego County

U.S. Department of Justice Demands Local California Election Officials Impound Alleged Noncitizen Ballots

Photo: KPBS Public Media

Local election officials across California have received urgent Department of Justice letters demanding they secure mail-in ballots cast by individuals federal authorities claim are noncitizens, while setting a 48-hour deadline and threatening legal action. County registrars have largely rejected the demands, stating they will continue counting ballots normally as a federal appeals court prepares to hear arguments on the dispute.

Read the full story at KPBS Public Media

Why It Matters

The conflict directly impacts ballot processing procedures for California's 23 million registered voters and exposes local election workers to potential federal prosecution if they count ballots contested by the Justice Department.

Key Facts

  • Local election officials across California received letters from the Department of Justice demanding they secure ballots believed to have been sent to noncitizens.
  • The federal letters request sensitive information, including Social Security numbers, for approximately 20,000 registered voters.
  • The federal government established a 48-hour deadline for officials to hand over the information and warned of potential legal action against anyone who deliberately counts a noncitizen vote.
  • County registrars, such as Napa County's John Tuteur, stated they are ignoring the federal demands and continuing to count ballots normally.
  • A panel of judges from the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals is scheduled to hear arguments on whether California must comply with the federal requirements.
  • The Justice Department filed a lawsuit on October 15 asking a judge to block California from counting mail-in ballots from individuals identified as likely noncitizens.
  • State officials and county analysts noted errors in federal lists, finding that sample names included individuals who had already cancelled their registration, had no voting history, or were born in the United States.
  • Federal authorities recently charged 28 people out of a 20,000-person list with illegally registering to vote, with some facing charges for illegal voting and lying on naturalization documents.
  • Federal prosecutor Bill Essayli stated that election officials who deliberately process a noncitizen ballot face potential criminal prosecution.

Who's Mentioned