POLISCOPE

The public record

ST. LUCIE COUNTY · LOCALDecisions and attributed speech publishedPartial coverage

Board of County Commissioners- Informal Meeting

Tuesday, September 10, 2024 · County government meeting record

The 30-second read

Recorded outcome

The St. Lucie County Board of Commissioners discussed the future of Blind Creek Beach, the potential continuation of the Property Assessed Clean Energy (PACE) program, and a long-term mobility and climate infrastructure study. The meeting focused on balancing public access, consumer protection, and planning for climate-related growth through the year 2100.

Why it matters

The Board is evaluating policy changes that will impact beach access rules, the availability of energy-efficiency financing for homeowners, and long-term land-use regulations to mitigate future flood risks.

What happens next

No later meeting or follow-up date is stated in the reviewed record.

Official minutes publish outcomes and identify speakers and the topics they addressed.

People and votes

Commissioner Commissioner Dzadovsky

2 statements

  1. Statement

    Commented on the contributions of State Representative, Dana.

    Official record
  2. Statement

    Commented on the historical context of flood zone processes, the.

    Official record

What people said

Attributed speechA separate authority lane. Speech is evidence of what a person said, never of what the board decided.
Show 1 more attributed statements
  • The official minutes identify speakers and topics, but summarize rather than quote their exact words.

Record text

No recording or transcript is held for this meeting.

BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS ST. LUCIE COUNTY, FLORIDA Informal Meeting September 10, 2024 Convened: 9:00 AM Adjourned: 10:57 AM 1. CALL TO ORDER - CATHY TOWNSEND, CHAIR BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS The meeting was called to order at 9:00 AM by Vice-Chair Chris Dzadovsky, District No. 1. Present Commissioner Linda Bartz District 3, Commissioner Chris Dzadovsky District 1, Commissioner Larry Leet District 2, Commissioner Jamie Fowler District 4 Excused Commissioner Cathy Townsend District 5 Also Present Dan McIntyre, County Attorney George Landry, County Administrator Mayte Santamaria, Deputy County Administrator Jason Davis, Deputy County Administrator Matt Baum, Parks & Recreation Director Amy Griffin, Environmental Resources Director Dana Trabulsy, State Representative Benjamin Balcer, Planning & Development Services Director Katrina Slay, Executive Aide to County Administration/Agenda Coordinator Sydney Halleran, Agenda Coordinator Vera Smith, Deputy Clerk Recording Secretary 2. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE 3. DISCUSSION ITEMS A. Blind Creek Beach - Designated Clothing Optional Beach Section Discussion Matt Baum, Parks & Recreation Director, and Amy Griffin, Environmental Resources Director, presented the Board with an update on Blind Creek Beach located just northeast of South Hutchinson Island's Florida Power and Light (FPL) nuclear power plant. The map shows Blind Creek Beach at the south end and Little Mud Creek at the north end, part of a contiguous state preserve leased by the county. The lease with the Board of Trustees of the Internal Improvement Trust

BOCC Informal Meeting Tuesday, September 10, 2024 9:00 AM 2 | P a g e Fund and the state of Florida began on November 17, 1999, for a term of 50 years ending in 2049. From 1999 to the present, multiple departments (Environmental Resources, Mosquito Control, and Parks and Recreation) have collaborated and worked to help operate and maintain the property. Parks and Recreation has maintained and operated the recreational aspects since 2017. On June 2, 2020, the Board approved a resolution recognizing Blind Creek Beach as a clothing- optional beach. On March 3, 2022, signs were placed at Little Mud Creek to clarify that it is not a clothing-optional beach. The clothing-optional beach area is designated from originally1,660 to 820 ft. along the southern portion of the property due to some surveying errors. In 2020, the Board agreed upon a designated area of 2,500 ft. Staff presented a map illustrating the clothing- optional area and other amenities, including a southern entrance, parking area, beach trail, observation tower, and additional beach access trail. An expansion project for Blind Creek Beach restroom is scheduled for the next board meeting, including a new ADA-accessible six-stall restroom, city water and sewer, paved entrance road, improved parking spaces (167), drainage, beach showers, and park security. Improvements will be made to the existing spaces. Mr. Baum mentioned concerns of the naturist group in the area requesting additional signage to keep people off the dunes and prevent lewd behavior. Signs have been ordered and are expected to be installed soon. The naturist group has also requested to increase the designated clothing- optional beach section from 2,500 linear ft., the maximum approved by the Board. The group has also requested law enforcement to enforce laws keeping people off the dunes and preventing lewd and lascivious behavior. Law enforcement is aware of the need to enforce laws and prevent lewd behavior, and the naturist group has also requested an alternative overflow parking area to the north. The naturist group has withdrawn its request for lifeguards and is not interested in charging for parking as previously requested. Staff advised Blind Creek Beach is popular and well- utilized, with hundreds of beachgoers daily, attributed to its clothing-optional designation. The naturist group promotes beach cleanups and discourages inappropriate behavior. Law enforcement has concerns about cars parked along the A1A when the grass parking area is full, which can obstruct views and cause safety issues. The staff has received various complaints over the years since the clothing-optional designation: nudity at Little Mud Creek, sexual acts being performed both on the beach and in the dune at both the Blind Creek Beach and Little Mud locations. Blind Creek Beach is a state-preserved property leased by the County. Any future expansions are regulated and need the approval of the Florida Department of Environmental Protection and the County's Environmental Resources Department, with the state having no opinion on the clothing-optional beach designation leaving it up to the decision-makers of the managing entity to decide. Staff requested the Board's direction. Commissioner Fowler requested confirmation of the parking spaces for the beach and inquired about how many miles of beach space the County has. Staff advised the new parking lot will have 167 spaces, and the County beach ranges from 19 to 21 miles, from the southern tip to the northern tip, including private land. Commissioner Dzadovsky suggested implementing a lifeguard service due to the beach's high usage, estimating the cost at around $90,000 annually. He also mentioned the challenges in hiring lifeguards, advising that many current lifeguards are firefighters working second jobs. He also said that the 2,500 ft. is responsible enough for the beach. He was uncertain of extending it up to Little

BOCC Informal Meeting Tuesday, September 10, 2024 9:00 AM 3 | P a g e Mud Beach and suggested creating a firm path to the beach for easier access. The Board discussed the naturist group, beach clean-up, tourism, lifeguards, improving beach accessibility, alternative parking sites during construction, and larger raccoon-proof garbage cans. The staff mentioned that the nature-society is involved in funding and cleaning efforts, which include providing dumpsters, porta-potties, and raccoon-proof trash cans. They also advised that once the project is approved, it should be under contract and completed by the middle of next summer. B. Pace Funding - September 10, 2024 Informal Meeting - Status Update Dan McIntyre, County Attorney, presented this item to the Board. In 2010, the County was the first to implement Property Assessed Clean Energy (PACE) in the creation of the Sustainability District and validated bonds for that purpose. During that time, the County entered into agreements with SELF, and the lender Inland and currently has outstanding PACE loans as a part of it. The County is currently in a legal dispute with a vendor that began operating within the community without the County’s consent. The County joined in litigation against the vendor with other counties, and it is currently pending in the Florida Supreme Court. There are state attorneys and tax collectors involved. The state attorney general filed a friend of the court brief on behalf of the County’s position. Going forward with operating in the County and other local governments, vendors will need the consent of the Board. Chapter 1024-273, also known as Senate Bill 770, is a comprehensive law providing consumer protection and allowing Home Rule for counties and local governments to decide if they would like to utilize PACE. The goals of PACE are positive and energy efficiency and resiliency are reiterated, with the state laws expanding these goals. The decision is up to the Board whether the County should continue with PACE or opt-out. Options for implementing PACE include full-service activities that handle contractor vetting, financing, loan processing, and disclosure as required by state law. The County could also hire a third-party administrator to manage PACE operations, with multiple vendors available for selection. A vetting process is suggested to ensure transparency and consumer protection, with the County reviewing what other communities have done. The County does not have the staff to manage PACE operations, currently, and hiring staff with experience in PACE management is considered a better option than managing it in-house. Staff will prepare a regular agenda item at a future Board meeting to obtain formal approval based on Board direction. Dana Trabulsy, State Representative, addressed the Board regarding the new PACE financing provisions and highlighted benefits to consumers and protection by offering a menu of services and allowing them to choose to keep their homes. She commented on the vetting process and the need for consumer protection to prevent predatory lending. She also provided a scenario of a homeowner needing a new roof to renew insurance, who could not get a traditional loan but could get a PACE loan. She advised that PACE financing is not suitable for everyone and should be an option for those in need, not a mandatory choice. Commissioner Leet expressed concerns regarding PACE loans being predatory, particularly with solar panels, due to high costs and long-term loans.

BOCC Informal Meeting Tuesday, September 10, 2024 9:00 AM 4 | P a g e Commissioner Dzadovsky commented on the contributions of State Representative, Dana Trabulsy, in assisting the state lead in inmate medical care, highlighting a $2 million savings. He discussed the importance of consumer protection. He mentioned the role of Community Development Financial Institutions (CDFI) in providing low-interest loans to low to moderate- income individuals. And expressed the need for competition and third-party administration to ensure fair and honest practices in PACE financing. He also mentioned his role as president of the solar energy loan fund. Commissioner Fowler commented on the vetting process, third-party administration, disclosure of tax bill additions and penalties, solar energy loan fund, and alternative financing options. Commissioner Bartz commented on the culvert assistance program and loans, debt-to-income ratios, and return on investment considerations for the PACE loans, staffing, and consumer protection. She expressed her full support for the PACE program. The Board discussed the vetting process, the importance of consumer protection in PACE financing, third-party administration, PACE loans, solar energy loan funds, benefits for homeowners needing repairs, vendors, credit, third-party administration, and competition to ensure fair practices. Dan McIntyre, County Attorney, commented on the Board's direction to proceed with the PACE program and the vetting process. He advised staff would evaluate both current and potential new PACE lenders and present the options to the Board for approval. C. St. Lucie County Mobility Infrastructure Study Update Benjamin Balcer, Director of Planning & Development Services, presented this item to the Board. He introduced Mark Alvarez, a Planner and Project Manager of the Corradino Group. In 2021, the County was awarded a $210,000 Community Development Block Grant (CDBG) which was earmarked for mitigation projects and planning. The infrastructure study incorporates land use planning, comprehensive planning, mitigation planning, and resiliency planning, updating the County's right-of-way protection map and drafting policies based on future climate-related impacts and mitigation needs of public infrastructure. Mr. Alvarez presented the County's Sustainability Mobility Infrastructure study to the Board. He advised the CDBG project is a federally funded initiative with a $250,000 budget, including $210,000 from federal funds and $40,000 from County match funding. The project aims to develop a countywide mobility infrastructure plan incorporating land use, comprehensive, regional mitigation, and resiliency planning. The focus is on planning rights of way to address future infrastructure needs, considering resiliency and the time scope to the year 2100 (75 years). The time scope provides several opportunities to set out the needs in terms of right-of-way, technologies, engineering, population, and the growth of the County. The project includes climate projections, such as sea level rise, storm intensity, and hurricane storm surge, as well as growth projections and policies. The National Oceanographic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) has models used to project climate change impacts to the year 2100, with specific steps in 2040, 2070,

BOCC Informal Meeting Tuesday, September 10, 2024 9:00 AM 5 | P a g e and 2100. He advised the human side of growth is influenced by real estate costs, retirement, and investment options, which are difficult to model. He provided a detailed overview of sea level rise projections and highlighted the impact on the County's coastal areas and barrier islands. By 2100, the County is projected to experience a 6-ft. sea level rise, with significant flooding in coastal areas including high tides and storm surges, to identify areas at risk of flooding. The County's policies and growth management are crucial in addressing the projections and planning for future infrastructure needs. The barrier islands and coastal areas of concern for flooding include the City of Fort Pierce, St. Lucie River, and tributaries such as Five-Mile Creek. Mr. Alvarez explained the impacts of a Cat-5 hurricane storm surge and the need for policy change to manage flooding based on the year 2025. The County's population is projected to exceed a million people by 2021, with significant growth in the northwest and southwest areas. The County must plan for evacuation routes and clear main roads, as well as consider the cost and feasibility of raising roads. The study provided recommendations on water management levels and evacuation planning, highlighting the importance of comprehensive planning and land use regulations in managing growth and infrastructure. The study also provided projections for extreme rainfall based on the year 2025, including a 100-year storm rainfall depth and a more severe storm. Several zoning codes are not updated, and several homes need to have their habitable floors higher as reconstructed in the future to base flood elevation plus one foot, but several zoning codes don't allow it. Most zoning codes do not include a provision for freeboard, which allows for a difference between the first habitable floor and the base flood elevation. They have 25 ft. limits and 2 stories. Over the next 75 years, the changes need to be in place and coordinated with other municipalities. The importance of land use regulations in ensuring that habitable floors are above the base flood elevation was advised. He discussed the impact of population growth on infrastructure planning, including the need for increased road capacity and land use regulations. The County's population is projected to exceed a million people by 2100, according to the Bureau of Economic and Business (BEBR) with significant growth in the northwest and southwest areas. The study will examine how transportation options like autonomous vehicles, transit, shared bicycles, and scooters will affect future infrastructure needs. This is outlined in the St. Lucie TPO Automated Connected Electric and Shared (ACES) Transportation Plan. Also, analyze over 200 county road segments to develop recommendations for right-of-way needs based on climate impacts and land use. The study will explore the concept of sustainability hubs, designed to be self-sufficient and provide resources in natural disasters. These hubs would include hospitals, warehouses, and other essential services, creating a resilient infrastructure. Mr. Alvarez advised the study will create a right-of-way protection map, analyzing road segments for flooding and sea level rise. Specific road segments, such as Edwards Road, Selvitz Road, and Midway Road, will be analyzed for their current and future flooding risks. Recommendations will be provided on the amount of right-of-way needed for climate change mitigation and growth management. The importance of raising roadways and planning for future transportation options, such as transit and multi-modal systems. The study will explore six basic ways to acquire the right- of-way: outright purchase, eminent domain, development agreements, and transfer development rights. He discussed the complexities of urban, exurban, and suburban development, in areas with flooding issues, and the challenges of land use changes, especially in single-family residential areas. He explained the outlines of the steps to finalize the mobility infrastructure plan, including a

BOCC Informal Meeting Tuesday, September 10, 2024 9:00 AM 6 | P a g e draft form for review by staff and the Board. The comprehensive plan will include recommendations for changes, with a 75-year scope. The right-of-way map will not be adopted immediately but will be considered for future land use planning. Mr. Alvarez informed about the upcoming public meetings and workshops with the TPO and various advisory committees, including those for bicycles, pedestrians, technical advisory, and citizens advisory. These workshops will aim to gather feedback on land use options and choices, with a focus on the County's geography and its future impact. The topics to be discussed during the workshops include the geography of growth, technological accommodations, mobility technology, and climate mitigation. The draft plan will be presented to staff and the Board for review in November, to complete the plan for potential adoption in December. Commissioner Leet commented on the sea level rise and high tide changes. In response, Mr. Alvarez mentioned the NOAA tidal gauge estimates, with a projected sea level rise by 2040, at 4.5 ft., and its impact on southeast Florida. Commissioner Fowler expressed concern regarding Midway and Edwards Road, moving the density into agricultural areas, improvements to low-lying areas of White City, and the challenges of raising homes to prevent flooding. Commissioner Dzadovsky commented on the historical context of flood zone processes, the challenges of securing grants for flood mitigation, and the need for increased stormwater protection in new developments, beyond the current 25-year storm standards. He also expressed concerns regarding right-of-way protection and the cost of raising roads. Mayte Santamaria, Deputy County Administrator, commented on policy recommendations for addressing sea level rise and flooding, including buyout programs and rolling setbacks. She mentioned in December, when the final report is received, a final decision is not required. These are policy recommendations, and there will be extensive debate. The Board commented on flooding zone areas, rising insurance rates, flood maps, drainage, population growth/decrease, tidal changes, property values, long-term planning, foreclosures, and the long-term economic impact of current development decisions. 4. ADJOURNMENT With no other information to be considered before the Board, the meeting was adjourned at 10:57 AM. Please note: Final minutes are recorded in the official minute books filed with the Clerk of the Circuit Court and available for inspection upon request.

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
AgendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Agenda packetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Action agendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Transcript or captionsNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Coverage and corrections

Records considered

  • Board of County Commissioners- Informal Meeting (2024-09-10)

Not claimed by this page

  • Verified meeting decisions with item-specific public-source evidence
  • Item-level plain-language summaries are not available; this page does not infer individual agenda items.
  • Item-linked, attributed deliberation
  • A source-grounded next meeting date
  • Official outcomes have not been published.
  • A transcript is not available.
  • No audio or video recording is linked.
  • Speakers have not been reliably matched to public profiles.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.
  • An individual roll-call roster is not available.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: 30dad34045ae027050462ae0ab6b30e7. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record