POLISCOPE

The public record

WINDERMERE (ORANGE COUNTY) · LOCALHeld · official record pendingPartial coverage

Town Council

Tuesday, April 14, 2026 · Government meeting record

The 30-second read

Record incomplete

This document serves as a placeholder for the Town Council meeting records. It indicates that the official meeting documentation is currently being processed or is unavailable for direct viewing.

Why it matters

Access to council meeting records is essential for residents to stay informed about local government decisions and public spending.

What happens next

The scheduled meeting date has passed. Minutes or an action agenda are not published in the records we hold.

This meeting date has passed and no official outcome record has been published yet. Nothing on this page is a decision.

Record text

No recording or transcript is held for this meeting.

Agenda textTown Council

Page

/

3

Loading…

![](https://docs.google.com/viewerng/thumb?ds=AON1mFzxLqIrssRhDqprXYLnZeLVyEpFX1FoNdpe9cqj1mARoNRKLhOs6y-Zsn4b9FPiXjvTGMTo2II_FMWiFCRboKfiu4KpoP6JvMX3bmIKBJAauTH5oubaLdXNeZZc2dnT9qsCW0HwKydLIVCELPgxO4oQ7gIYZZbNKC2E_nWOd4flQ2Gu631wIW9HybH_QpPkvyfVGJfJ5S2pVMAYNrhd787BUrv-rSCq_xTjxBpfy2GGH9bQDcOIFu9NV0uKkKWlI_4vC-5cqGRXSV-q69cbYd7y03TaviH21Wxco0_awtPewLtOIf7IE8iC70jYWIQaThIsFf340x0rKaTTYRqcfJO2CUhvoQ%3D%3D&ck=lantern&dsmi=unknown&authuser&w=800&webp=true&p=proj)

{"id": "", "title": "23489e4d70afd14dff9663c026a52d150.pdf", "mimeType": "application\\/pdf"}

Loading…

Agenda packet textTown Council — Packet

Showing the first 24,000 of 38,587 characters. The full document is at the source.

MAYOR AND COUNCIL OF THE TOWN OF WINDERMERE Agenda Mayor Andy Williams Council Members CT Allen Mandy David Tony Davit Brandi Haines Tom Stroup Agenda April 14, 2026 6:00 PM WINDERMERE TOWN HALL 520 MAIN STREET WINDERMERE, FL 34786 JOIN ZOOM MEETING: HTTPS://WWW.ZOOM.COM/ MEETING ID: 816 9286 6627 PASSCODE: TOW2024 ONE TAP MOBILE: +1 (305) 224-1968, 81692866627# US PLEASE TURN OFF ALL CELL PHONES 1

PLEASE NOTE: IN ACCORDANCE WITH F.S. 286.26: Person with disabilities needing assistance to participate in any such proceedings should contact the Office of the Clerk at least 48 hours beforehand at (407) 876-2563. Pursuant to Resolution No. 2005-12 adopted on December 13, 2005, the following Civility Code shall govern all procedings before the Town of Windermere Town Council: 1. All electronic devices, including cell phones, shall be either turned off or otherwise silenced. 2. Prolonged conversation shall be conducted outside Council meeting hall. 3. Whistling, heckling, gesturing, loud conversations, or other disruptive behavior is prohibited. 4. Only those individuals who have signed the speaker list and/or/who have been recognized by the Mayor (or Chair) may address comments to the Council. 5. Comments at public hearings shall be limited to the subject being considered by the Council 6. Comments at Open Forums shall be directed to Town issues. 7. All public comments shall avoid personal attacks and abusive language 8. No person attending a Town Council meeting is to harass, annoy, or otherwise disturb any other person in the room. Any member of the public whose behavior is disruptive and violates the Town of Windermere Civility Code is subject to removal from the Town Council meeting by an officer and such other actions as may be appropriate. PLEASE NOTE: IN ACCORDANCE WITH F.S. 286.0105: Any person who desires to appeal any decision at this meeting will need a record of this proceeding. For this, such person may need to ensure that a verbatim record of such proceedings is made, which includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal is to be based. AGENDA THE MEETING IS CALLED TO ORDER BY THE MAYOR FLAG SALUTE 1. OPEN FORUM / PUBLIC COMMENT (3-Minute Limit) 2. SPECIAL PRESENTATION / PROCLAMATIONS / AWARDS a. Check Presentation i. West Orange Chamber of Commerce, will present a check from the West Orange Foundation to the members of the Legacy Fund Board, which will be deposited in the newly established Windermere Legacy Fund. This check is a component of the agreement reached between the original team of WWD and the West Orange Foundation, gifting them the rights to continue the wine and dine event under their name. 3. OLD BUSINESS 4. NEW BUSINESS a. MINUTES (Attachments) i. Town Council Meeting Minutes March 10, 2026 2

ii. Town Council Workshop Minutes (Town Hall Rentals) March 24, 2026 b. Variance Request (Attachments) i. Case Z26-04 – 323 E 4th Avenue, George and Paige Couros, Property Owners - Variance to permit the placement of a sport court in the front yard of a single-family residence where the Land Development Code requires sport courts to be located within the side or rear yard. 5. MAYOR & COUNCIL LIAISON REPORTS 6. STAFF REPORTS 7. ADJOURN 3

TOWN OF WINDERMERE Town Council Meeting Minutes March 10, 2026 Page 1 of 3 CALL TO ORDER: Present were Mayor Jim O’Brien, Town Council Members Tom Stroup, Andy Williams, Mandy David, Tony Davit, and Brandi Haines. Town Manager Robert Smith (arrived 6:32pm), ATM/PWD Elliott-Moore, Attorney Chrisine Epperson, Chief Dave Ogden, and Town Clerk Dorothy Burkhalter were present. Council elected CT Allen was also present. Mayor O’Brien called the meeting to order at 6:01 pm and stated that a quorum was present. He then led everyone to the Pledge of Allegiance. 1. OPEN FORUM/PUBLIC COMMENT (3 Minute Limit) There were no public comments. 2. TIMED ITEMS & PUBLIC HEARING a. Ordinance 2026-01 – Tabled for the April 12th Town Council meeting Mayor O’Brien stated that this item has been tabled to the April 12, 2026, Town Council meeting. 3. OLD BUSINESS a. Windermere Town Hall Rehabilitation – Authorization Preparation of Construction Documents Mayor O’Brien introduced this item and turned the floor over to ATM/PWD Elliott-Moore. ATM/PWD Elliott Moore commented on past discussions regarding Phase two and three, exterior and interior renovations. She explained that approval would allow the move to the construction documents to 40, 60 and 90 which will come back to the Town Council. Member Haines questioned if SHIPO had been contacted. ATM/PWD Elliott-Moore stated yes. Member Davit made a motion to approve. Member Williams seconded the motion. Roll call vote was as follows: Haines – aye, Davit – aye, David – aye, Williams – aye, and Stroup – aye. Motion carried 5-0. b. Town Square Library Restroom Facility – Selection of Preferred Concept Option Mayor O’Brien introduced this item. He then turned the floor over to ATM/PWD Elliott-Moore. ATM/PWD Elliott-Moore gave a brief review of past meetings and options. She stated that option four with added fixture in the men’s and women’s bathrooms. ATM/PWD Elliott-Moore commented that approval for option four is needed. Member David made a motion to approve option four with the additional men’s/women’s fixture. Member Davit seconded the motion. Member Haines questioned the accuracy of the square footage of the bathrooms. She explained that the actual numbers don’t add up and tree protection is needed. Mr. Fitzgibbon commented that conceptual approval is needed. He further stated that the Council will review the 40, 90 and 100 percent plans. Discussion followed regarding total square footage, facility size enough for 300 people, tree impacts, schematics, and specific details later. After discussion was made, roll call vote was as follows: Stroup – aye, Williams – aye, David – aye, Davit -aye, and Haines – aye. Motion carried 5-0. c. Town of Windermere v. Fanelli, Daniel et al., Court Case #2022-CA-006506-O Mayor O’Brien introduced this item. He then turned the floor over to Attorney Rachael Crews. Ms. Crews introduced herself as the Appellant Attorney in this case. She then commented on the mediation process, the proposed settlement and the clarified settlement offer. The proposed settlement as a fee of $500,000.00 paid to those residents for fees and costs, the Town would drop the appeal with no resolution, and the Town would need to execute a release that states that the Town would not contest the ownership of the docks and associated land by the boathouse residents. She then commented on the ownership of the associated land which has been clarified as the boathouse and the underlying land. 4

TOWN OF WINDERMERE Town Council Meeting Minutes March 10, 2026 Page 2 of 3 Discussion followed regarding costs, proposed appeal costs, and fees. Ms. Crews commented on a proposed counter proposal offered by the Town Manager which would need approval by the Town Council. The proposed as “The ownership issues and interest would get legally determined and clarified for the Town and the boathouse residents, obtain actual deeds, and recommend paying $105,000.00 for attorney’s and fees. Ms. Crews then gave an update on the appeal. Mayor O’Brien commented for clarification that the Council has the option to accept the settlement, decline the settlement, or do nothing. Manager Smith stated that he advised the opposing counsel that he would bring the settlement agreement forward and request a vote of either “in favor or against” of their proposed settlement offer. He further stated that he would make the recommendation for the counter offer he has provided to include to the opposing side; a 99-year lease that would automatically renew and pay them $105,000.00. Discussion followed. Member Haines made a motion to decline the proposed settlement offer from the opposing side. Member Davit seconded the motion. Manager Smith explained the process of the motions. Roll call vote was as follows: Stroup – nay, Williams – aye, David – aye, Davit – aye, and Haines – aye. Motin carried 4-1. Mayor O’Brien commented that if option two is not approved, a Shade meeting will be needed. Member Willaims made a motion to approve the counteroffer of clarifying ownership, a ninety-ninety- year lease with automatic renewal, along with the $105,000.00 settlement offer. Member Davit seconded the motion. Discussion followed regarding the offer, defining ownership interest, friendly quite titles, deed restrictions, and shade meetings. Mr. Jerry Fay of 28 Pine Street questioned the ninety-ninety-year lease when the Town does not own the boathouses. Member Williams commented that ownership needs to be cleared up first. Mayor O’Brien reviewed the motion on the table. Roll call vote was as follows: Haines – nay, Davit – aye, David – nay, Williams – aye, and Stroup – nay. Motion fails 3 – against, 2 – for. Mayor O’Brien commented that the next option would be a Shade meeting. 4. NEW BUSINESS a. Swear in Oaths i. Andy Williams – Mayor ii. Brandi Haines – Town Council Member iii. CT Allen – Town Council Member Mayor O’Brien administered the Oath of Office to Ms. Brandi Haines, Ms. CT Allen and Mr. Andy Williams. Ms. Haines will be serving her second two-year term as a Council member. Ms. Allen will be serving her first two-year term as a Council member. Mr. Willaims will be serving his first two-year term as Mayor. All were congratulated. Mayor Willaims presented a Key to the Town to outgoing Mayor O’Brien. Mr. O’Brien thanked the Town and gave a brief farewell speech. b. MINUTES i. Town Council Meeting Minutes: February 10, 2026 ii. Public Information Session Restrooms Minutes: February 18, 2026 iii. Town Council Workshop Restrooms Minutes: February 24, 2026 Mayor Williams introduced this item. Member Haines commented on public comments that needed to be added. Clerk Burkhalter stated that they were added as requested and would verify that it is correct. Member Davit made a motion to approve the minutes as presented. Member David seconded the motion. Roll call vote was as follows: Haines – aye, Davit – aye, Davis – aye, Allen – aye, and Stroup – aye. Motion carried 5-0. c. Historic Preservation Board Committee Member Application: i. Charles R. Hobbs Mayor Williams introduced this item. Member Davit made a motion to appoint Charles R. Hobbs to the Historical Preservation Board. Member Haines seconded the motion. Roll call vote was as follows: 5

TOWN OF WINDERMERE Town Council Meeting Minutes March 10, 2026 Page 3 of 3 Stroup – aye, Allen – aye, David – aye, Davit – aye, and Haines – aye. Motion carried 5-0. 5. MAYOR & COUNCIL LIAISON REPORTS: Mayor Williams opened the floor to the Council members. Member Haines gave a report on the Tree Board. Member Davit gave a report on MetroPlan, which included E-Bikes. Member David reported on Parks and Recreation and WAYS committees. 6. STAFF REPORTS: a. TOWN MANAGER ROBERT SMITH – No report. b. ATM/PWD TONYA ELLIOTT-MOORE – No report. c. ATTORNEY CHRISTINA EPPERSON – Ms. Epperson gave an update on the Sovereign Immunity bill and the Ad Valorem Joint resolutions. She then stated that a full report will be given once the session closes. d. POLICE CHIEF DAVE OGDEN – Chief Ogden reported on St. Augustine and accreditation, March 22nd Robbie German EOW and an upcoming lunch on March 18th. e. TOWN CLERK DOROTHY BURKHALTER – Clerk Burkhalter congratulated the newly sworn in officials. 7. ADJOURN: Mayor Williams adjourned the meeting at 7:11pm. ____________________________ _____________________________ Dorothy Burkhalter, MMC, FCRM Loren “Andy” Williams, Mayor Town Clerk 6

TOWN OF WINDERMERE Town Council Workshop March 24, 2026 Town Hall Rentals 1 Present were Mayor Andy Williams, Council Members Tom Stroup, CT Allen, Mandy David, Tony Davit, and Brandi Haines. Town Manager Robert Smith, ATM/PWD Tonya Ellott- Moore, and Town Clerk Dorothy were also present. 1. PUBLIC WORKSHOP CALLED TO ORDER Mayor Williams opened the workshop at 6:02pm. 2. DISCUSSION ITEMS a. Town Hall Rental Discussion i. Hours of rentals during the week and weekends ii. Rates for resident vs non-residents iii. Violations/Fines iv. Further restrictions/additional input Mayor Williams introduced this item. He then turned the floor over to Member Stroup as he requested this item. Member Stroup commented on noise issues with the rentals, not Town events. He then stated that “quality of life” needed to be considered. Member Stroup stated that he has researched other rental venues and their rules and rental agreements. Discussion began regarding number of rentals, non-profits, rental rates, time for events – 10:00pm ending with an hour clean-up, number of hours for a daily rate/full day, enforcement and stricter guidelines, increased deposit, more regulations, noise/bands/outside, monitor of the events, cannot regulate speech, outsourced party planner, against amplifying of music, and keeping rates reasonable for residents. Mayor Williams stated that the consensus for hours that music must be off is three for off at 9:00pm and two for 10:00pm. Manager Smith questioned if the shutdown times would be different for weekdays than weekends. Discussion followed regarding weekday shutdown at 9:00pm and weekends at 10:00pm. Discussion regarding “out the door” time was made. Consensus was 3- 11:00pm and 2 – no opinions as there will not be any music playing. Discussion began regarding rental rates, resident/non-resident rates, residents renting for others, increasing deposits, holidays which could fall on a weekday, weekend/weekday rates, rates for non-profits, which non- profits utilize Town Hall, deposits and amounts, violations/fines, use of sternos/candles, breaking of rules, accountability, in/out checklists, requiring insurance to allow sternos/candles, back to back events, clean-up/set up/downs, staff, and accountability for rules and regulations, and future public workshops/meetings regarding this item. This item will be placed on the May Town Council meeting. 3. ADJOURN Mayor Williams adjourned the workshop at 7:56pm. __________________________________ ________________________________ Dorothy Burkhalter, Town Clerk Jim O’Brien, Mayor 7

Page 1 of 6 Development Review Board March 17, 2026 Town Council April 14, 2026 Case Number: Z26-04 Property Owners: George and Paige Couros (Property Owners) Requested Action: Variance to permit the placement of a sport court in the front yard of a single-family residence where the Land Development Code requires sport courts to be located within the side or rear yard. Property Address: 323 East 4 th Avenue Legal Description: PLAT OF WINDERMERE G/36 LOT 356 (LESS W 75 FT) & THAT PT OF OCCUPIED PLATTED LAKE Future Land Use: Single Family Residential and Recreation Zoning: Single Family Residential and Recreation Existing Use: Received Permit for New Single-Family Residence Surrounding Future Land Use and Zoning North: Single Family Residential and Recreation/Single Family Residential and Recreation East: Water Bodies (Lake Down) South: East 4 th Avenue Right of Way and Recreation/East 4th Avenue Right of Way and Recreation West: Single Family Residential/Single Family Residential Town of Windermere 614 Main Street Windermere, FL 34786 Office: (407) 876-2563 Fax: (407) 876-0103 Town Manager ROBERT SMITH Mayor ANDY WILLIAMS Clerk DOROTHY BURKHALTER 8

Page 2 of 6 CASE SUMMARY George and Paige Couros, owners of the property located at 323 East 4th Avenue, have requested approval of a variance in accordance with Section 10.02.00 of the Town of Windermere Land Development Code (LDC). The requested variance would permit the construction of a basketball court within the front yard of the subject property, where the Town’s Land Development Code prohibits sport courts from being located forward of a front building line. The aerial map provided below shows the location of the subject property, which has been highlighted in pink. The property is situated east of the intersection of East 4th Avenue and Magnolia Street and has direct waterfront access to Lake Down. Aerial Imagery of 323 E. 4th Avenue (Outlined in Pink) - Source: Orange County Property Appraiser Section 7.02.09 outlines the locational restrictions pertaining to the placement of sport courts: [Sport courts must be] Located behind the front of the principal building, meet the required side yard setbacks, placed no closer than ten feet to a rear property line. If a building permit is required (foundation, electric, plumbing), then for waterfront properties it is placed no closer than 50 feet from the normal high- water elevation. However, if contained within a primary or accessory building, then it shall be located within the building envelope but behind the front of the principal building. The applicant proposes to construct an approximately 1,083-square-foot basketball court in the south front yard of the property, positioned in front of the existing home along East 4th Avenue. However, the Town’s Land Development Code prohibits sport courts from being located forward of a principal building. As a result, the proposed basketball court does not comply with the applicable regulations. The applicant’s proposed sport court would add approximately 1,083 square feet of impervious surface to the property, which is more than the 125 square feet that requires the applicant to provide a grading and drainage plan to display on-site retention for the first inch of stormwater runoff in accordance with the Town’s Land Development Code. The proposed addition of the sport court results in a total impervious 9

Page 3 of 6 surface area of 9,196 square feet, or approximately 44.1% of the total project area, which is less than the 45% permitted for residential properties. These measurements would be reviewed for compliance during the Town’s permitting process. The following review considerations would also be applicable to the proposed sport court at 323 East 4th Avenue, in accordance with Section 7.02.09 of the Town’s Land Development Code: There shall be no direct glare visible from any adjacent property from any unshielded or other sources of lighting. As indicated in the applicant’s provided narrative letter, there will be no lighting proposed to be included as part of the construction of the sport court. If this were to change in the future, any lighting would be reviewed through the permitting process to ensure that it is fully compliant with the standards of the Town’s Land Development Code. The property’s single-family residence, which received a building permit in June of 2025 (permit number 25-05-024), was approved with the following building setbacks: • North (Side Yard) – 15’ • East (Lakefront) – 51’ to pool deck, 58’-9” to residence (distance to normal high-water elevation) • South (Front Yard) – 25’ • West (Side Yard) – 26’-6” In accordance with the locational requirements outlined in Section 7.02.09 of the Land Development Code, sport courts are required to adhere to applicable side yard setbacks and be built no closer than 10 feet from rear property lines. The north side of the single-family residence was approved to utilize the maximum build to line afforded by the property’s required side setbacks (i.e., 15 feet for the side yard), leaving no additional room for the placement of improvements such as a sport court. The western side yard, which abuts the vacant parcel of land located at 335 Magnolia Street, was approved at 26 feet, 6 inches from the property line. Adhering to the minimum required 15-foot side yard setback would leave only 11 feet, 6 inches available for the placement of a sport court. The presence of the residence’s mechanical equipment, the property’s drain field, septic system, and previously approved driveway further restrict the ability for additional improvements to be made to the property’s west side yard without significant revisions being made to the property’s layout. The eastern front yard fronts Lake Down, and as a result, any sport courts must be located at least 50 feet landward of the normal high-water elevation, in accordance with Land Development Code Section 7.02.09. The eastern yard, located behind the front façade of the single‑family residence, meets the required 50-feet setback and has already been approved as the location for the residence’s swimming pool through permit 25-08-024. 10

Page 4 of 6 Consequently, the front yard location shown on the site plan submitted with the variance application is the only area on the property where the proposed sport court it its current size and configuration could practically be placed. However, the Town’s code does not allow sport courts to be located in a front yard. Zoning Map of Surrounding Area - Source: Orange County Property Appraiser Division 10.02.00 of the LDC empowers the Development Review Board to review and make recommendations for approval, approval with conditions or denial to the Town Council on variance requests. Division 10.02.00 of the LDC requires the Town Council to consider the recommendation of the Development Review Board and to take final action to either approve or deny the variance request. CASE ANALYSIS: Section 10.02.02 of the LDC provides the specific standards by which the Development Review Board and Town Council are to review to consider the approval or denial of a variance application. In addition, this Section requires a positive finding, based on substantial competent evidence, for each of the standards. These standards are summarized as follows: 1. The need for the variance arises out of the physical surroundings, shape, topographical condition or other physical or environmental conditions that are unique to the subject property. Variances should be granted for conditions peculiar to the property and not the result of actions of the property owner; 2. There are practical or economic difficulties in carrying out the strict letter of the regulation; 3. The variance request is not based exclusively upon a desire to reduce the cost of developing the site; Single Family Residential Recreation 11

Page 5 of 6 4. The proposed variance will not substantially increase congestion surrounding public streets, the danger of fire or other hazard to the public; 5. The proposed variance will not substantially diminish property values in, nor alter the essential character of, the area surrounding the site; 6. The effect of the proposed variance is in harmony with the general intent of this Land Development Code and the specific intent of the relevant subject areas of this Land Development Code; and 7. The variance will not encourage further requests for changes where such a land use would not be deemed appropriate. It is also important to note that this Section also provides specific standards that are not to be considered in the review of a variance application. These standards are: 1. That the implementation of these regulations would impose an economic hardship on the cost of the building or redevelopment project; 2. That these regulations impose a hardship by decreasing the maximum density of a property in terms of the number of units, square footage of buildings, etc.; and 3. That other adjacent lands, structures or buildings not in conformance with these regulations provide a rationale for a lessening of their application in this specific case. Section 10.02.02(c) of the LDC allows the imposition of conditions and restrictions as may be necessary to allow a positive finding to be made on any of the variance standards to minimize the negative effect of the variance. The conditions and restrictions should further the interest of the LDC. The applicant submitted a site plan and written narrative in support of the variance request. Please see the information provided with the agenda item for the applicant’s submittal. PUBLIC NOTICE Public notices were mailed to property owners within 500 ft of the subject property. As of March 16,

Official record

ArtifactSourceState
BudgetNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Action agendaNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
MinutesNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
Transcript or captionsNot published in the sources we holdunavailable
AttachmentNot published in the sources we holdunavailable

Official pages

Coverage and corrections

Records considered

  • Town Council
  • Town Council — Packet

Not claimed by this page

  • Verified meeting decisions with item-specific public-source evidence
  • Item-level plain-language summaries are not available; this page does not infer individual agenda items.
  • Item-linked, attributed deliberation
  • A source-grounded next meeting date
  • Official outcomes have not been published.
  • A transcript is not available.
  • No audio or video recording is linked.
  • Speakers have not been reliably matched to public profiles.
  • Named people and places have not been reliably resolved.
  • An individual roll-call roster is not available.

No source correction or revision history is recorded for this meeting. A corrected artifact will appear here as a new version rather than replacing what is shown above.

Canonical record: 159ca290d47a60a069ea1391530017da. This page changes as stronger artifacts are published; it never overwrites an agenda with minutes.

Publisher tools

Share or embed this record

POLISCOPE publisher tools

Share or embed this record