
NewsWPLG Local 10October 26, 2026Miami-Dade County
9th Circuit questions Justice Department demand to segregate 20,000 California mail ballots
Photo: WPLG Local 10
Federal appellate judges expressed skepticism regarding the Justice Department's emergency request to force California election officials to set aside 20,000 mail ballots from voters flagged as potential noncitizens. During Sunday arguments, the panel questioned the timing, constitutionality, and appellate jurisdiction of the administration's lawsuit, which seeks to halt ballot counting pending citizenship verification.
Read the full story at WPLG Local 10Why It Matters
The outcome of the litigation could alter ballot-processing requirements for California elections and determine whether thousands of mail-in ballots undergo citizenship segregation before being counted.
Key Facts
- The Justice Department demanded that California election officials set aside 20,000 mail ballots from individuals suspected of not being citizens.
- A three-judge panel of the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals held rare weekend arguments to review an appeal by the federal government seeking an expedited decision.
- The Trump administration's lawsuit accuses California of failing to meet a 48-hour deadline to review the flagged names and asks to withhold counting those ballots until immigration status is verified.
- Circuit Judge Mark Bennett questioned whether the appellate court has jurisdiction to hear the case before a lower court ruling.
- Circuit Judge Gabriel Sanchez questioned whether the federal government was violating the Tenth Amendment by commandeering state enforcement of federal law.
- Justice Department attorney Matthew Donnelly argued that allowing noncitizens to vote causes irreversible harm and frustrates federal law.
- Seth Waxman, representing Los Angeles County Clerk Dean Logan, argued that the government's list is unreliable and that manual segregation would take approximately 140,000 man-hours.
- A Los Angeles County review of 200 records from the administration's list found canceled or inactive registrations, individuals with no voting history, and voters born in the U.S.
- Sam Siegel, representing California Secretary of State Shirley Weber, stated that the federal government provided no credible evidence to support its claims.
- Circuit Judge Patrick Bumatay suggested that granting an emergency order could provide clarity on whether ineligible citizens are voting.
Who's Mentioned
PersonPatrick Bumatay“Circuit Judge on the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals”OrganizationJustice Department“Federal agency bringing the lawsuit against California”PersonSeth Waxman“Attorney representing Los Angeles County Clerk Dean Logan”PersonMark Bennett“Circuit Judge on the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals”locationCalifornia“State targeted by the federal voting lawsuit”locationBoise“City in Idaho where reporter Boone reported from”PersonBoone“Reporter reporting from Boise, Idaho”PersonMatthew Donnelly“Justice Department attorney representing the federal government”Organization9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals“Appellate court hearing the emergency appeal”PersonDean Logan“Los Angeles County Clerk”PersonGabriel Sanchez“Circuit Judge on the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals”PersonMonica Flores“Assistant Registrar-Recorder for Los Angeles County”PersonSam Siegel“Attorney representing California Secretary of State Shirley Weber”PersonDonald Trump“President whose administration brought the lawsuit”PersonShirley Weber“California Secretary of State”OrganizationLos Angeles County“County whose election office reviewed a sample of the administration's list”
