
NewsSuncoast SearchlightNovember 2, 2026Sarasota County
Sarasota City Commission rejects proposed Obsidian luxury condo tower for the third time
Photo: Suncoast Searchlight
Sarasota City Commissioners voted 3-2 to reject a proposed 18-story luxury condo tower known as The Obsidian, overriding a special magistrate's recommendation to approve the project. The decision likely sends a long-running land-use dispute over the downtown skyline to circuit court.
Read the full story at Suncoast SearchlightWhy It Matters
A planned 320-foot high-rise with 14 condo units at 1260 North Palm Avenue is blocked from moving forward, exposing the city to potential litigation from the developer over land-use rules.
Key Facts
- The Sarasota City Commission voted 3-2 to reject The Obsidian, an 18-story condo tower proposed for 1260 North Palm Avenue.
- The project previously received a favorable recommendation from a special magistrate under a Florida law resolving land-use disputes.
- The proposed building would stand 320 feet tall and contain 14 condo units, making it the tallest building in downtown Sarasota.
- Developers met the city's 18-story limit but included extra space between floors to increase overall height.
- Residents of the nearby Bay Plaza condo building organized three years of opposition, citing concerns over shadows, wind tunnels, and building compatibility.
- Mayor Debbie Trice cast the deciding vote against the project during her final commission meeting.
- Developer representatives stated that legal action in circuit court is expected following the rejection.
- Commissioners voting in favor of moving the project forward expressed concern over potential millions of dollars in damages from a lawsuit.
Who's Mentioned
PersonMatt Kihnke“Developer of The Obsidian.”PersonGretchen Cochran“Reporter who co-authored a related article.”OrganizationBay Plaza“Nearby 14-story condo building whose residents opposed the new tower.”PersonDerek Gilliam“Reporter for Suncoast Searchlight.”PersonRobert Lincoln“Attorney for the developer.”PersonKyle Battie“City Commissioner who expressed apprehensions about court risks.”PersonJen Ahearn-Koch“City Commissioner who opposed the development.”locationSarasota“City where the development is proposed.”PersonChristian Casale“Reporter for Suncoast Searchlight.”PersonJohn Harshman“Candidate for Sarasota City Commission who spoke against the project.”OrganizationThe Obsidian“Proposed 18-story condo tower project.”PersonLiz Alpert“City Commissioner who raised concerns about a potential legal battle.”PersonMorgan Bentley“Trial attorney representing project opponents.”OrganizationCommunity News Collaborative, Inc.“Nonprofit corporation operating Suncoast Searchlight.”PersonDebbie Trice“Mayor of Sarasota who cast the deciding vote against the development.”PersonMartin Hyde“Independent candidate for state senate who spoke against the project.”PersonJonathan Abrams“Luxury real estate agent who spoke in favor of the project.”PersonKathy Kelley Ohlrich“City Commissioner who voted against the project.”
